Available via license: CC BY 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
genes
G C A T
T A C G
G C A T
Article
Origin and Evolution of Deleterious Mutations
in Horses
Ludovic Orlando 1,2 and Pablo Librado 1, 2, *
1Laboratoire d’Anthropobiologie Moléculaire et d’Imagerie de Synthèse, CNRS UMR 5288, Universitéde
Toulouse, UniversitéPaul Sabatier, 31000 Toulouse, France
2Globe Institute, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Copenhagen,
1350K Copenhagen, Denmark
*Correspondence: plibradosanz@gmail.com; Tel.: +33-0561145505
Received: 23 July 2019; Accepted: 26 August 2019; Published: 28 August 2019
Abstract:
Domestication has changed the natural evolutionary trajectory of horses by favoring the
reproduction of a limited number of animals showing traits of interest. Reduced breeding stocks
hampered the elimination of deleterious variants by means of negative selection, ultimately inflating
mutational loads. However, ancient genomics revealed that mutational loads remained steady during
most of the domestication history until a sudden burst took place some 250 years ago. To identify
the factors underlying this trajectory, we gather an extensive dataset consisting of 175 modern and
153 ancient genomes previously published, and carry out the most comprehensive characterization of
deleterious mutations in horses. We confirm that deleterious variants segregated at low frequencies
during the last 3500 years, and only spread and incremented their occurrence in the homozygous
state during modern times, owing to inbreeding. This independently happened in multiple breeds,
following both the development of closed studs and purebred lines, and the deprecation of horsepower
in the 20th century, which brought many draft breeds close to extinction. Our work illustrates the
paradoxical effect of some conservation and improvement programs, which reduced the overall
genomic fitness and viability.
Keywords: horse; genomics; deleterious variants; mutational loads; negative selection
1. Introduction
The domestication of the horse deeply impacted human history, enhancing the mobility of people,
trade, and culture. For example, the diffusion of Indo-European languages has been associated with
migration waves of horseback riders [
1
,
2
]. Following the incorporation of chariotry and cavalry into
warfare, domestic horses have played a crucial role in the rise and fall of entire past civilizations. It was
only with the onset of motor vehicles in the early 20th century that the horse remained consigned
to farming and transportation in developing countries, and to recreation in Westernized societies.
The equine industry remains instrumental today, with a census population size of 58.5 million horses,
and a yearly market worth 300 billion US dollars [3].
Breeders have reshaped the horse evolutionary trajectory by controlling its reproduction
for hundreds of generations [
4
]. Artificial selection has engendered several hundred breeds,
showing striking phenotypic differences in a range of traits, including morphology, coat coloration,
working capacities, and speed. However, developing such a broad array of breed-associated phenotypes
has entailed profound genomic changes as demonstrated by Fages et al., who recently generated an
extensive genome time-series spanning the last five millennia [
5
]. The authors found heterozygosity
levels remaining relatively steady until they dropped by ~16% some 200 years ago. This clearly
Genes 2019,10, 649; doi:10.3390/genes10090649 www.mdpi.com/journal/genes
Genes 2019,10, 649 2 of 16
revealed that modern reproductive strategies have considerably reduced horse genetic diversity,
possibly through the incorporation of only a limited number of influential stallions [5–7].
Reducing the size of the breeding stock holds the potential to also limit the power of negative
selection against deleterious mutations. Consistent with this prediction, Fages et al. estimated that
horses that lived after the 18th century evolved under weaker selection, which led to a ~4% increment
in homozygous deleterious variants within their protein-coding regions [
5
]. Although convincingly
confirming that modern practices were responsible for the mutational burst, this analysis only included
23 present-day horses. This number was not sufficient to contrast the multiple breeding practices
implemented in modern times, and their potential impact on shaping present-day loads.
Understanding such causes has important implications for the equine industry, as deleterious
variants can reduce the individual fitness and viability, even in the heterozygous state [
8
,
9
].
Developing monitoring tools for harmful variants could improve the sustainability of breeding
practices. However, the list of known deleterious variants is extremely limited, with only 90 causative
variants catalogued thus far in the OMIA database (Online Mendelian Inheritance in Animals) [
10
].
Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) are indeed often underpowered for deleterious variant
discovery, due to the complex architecture of the phenotypic traits investigated and the underlying
pleiotropic interactions masking the exact contribution of each individual allele [
11
]. Therefore, one of
the most feasible approaches to identify sustainable breeding practices, ensuring the long-term viability
of breeds, is to investigate their impact on the accumulation of deleterious mutations [12–14].
The relation between breeding strategies and mutational burdens can be more complex than
simply limiting the efficacy of natural selection in filtering out deleterious mutations. The most
obvious mechanism decoupling the expected positive relation between inbreeding and load is genetic
purging [
15
]. In this process, recessive mutations that were hidden in the heterozygous state are
brought to the homozygous state through inbreeding, and thus phenotypically exposed to negative
selection. Whether genetic purging and other mechanisms have contributed to shape present-day
mutational loads also remains to be elucidated.
In this study, we performed the most extensive characterization of deleterious mutations in horses.
We collected the genome sequences of 161 horses from 36 domestic breeds, 14 Przewalski horses, as well
as one domestic donkey, all sequenced to an average depth-of-coverage of 5–39
×
. We extended the
genomic load estimator applied in previous studies to also cover non-coding regions, and leveraged the
extensive data from Fages et al. [
5
] to investigate the temporal origins and evolutionary trajectories of
deleterious variants. This work provides new insights into the genomic impact of recent reproductive
breeding and conservation techniques.
2. Materials and Methods
Sequencing data from modern horses were retrieved from ENA and NCBI repositories. Raw reads
were processed and mapped against EquCab2 using PALEOMIX with default parameters [
16
].
Horse IDs, breed assignments, accession codes, and the resulting average depth-of-coverage per
genome are reported in Table S1.
Evolutionary conservation is known to represent an excellent predictor of fitness effects,
because mutations at sites that remained highly constrained during evolution are likely to be deleterious.
We thus used phyloP conservation scores to estimate the potential impact of mutations. These scores
summarize the evolutionary constraint position-wise, across a genome-wide alignment of 46 vertebrate
species [
17
,
18
], including EquCab2 as reference assembly for the horse genome [
19
]. We considered as
harmful all mutations at positions showing a minimum phyloP score of 1.5, which is a threshold that
accurately discriminates fourfold and zerofold degenerate sites [
20
], i.e. synonymous (nearly-neutral)
and non-synonymous (functional) variants, respectively. To calculate mutational loads per individual
genome, we first estimated the genotype probabilities at each site, using ANGSD v0.917 [
21
] with the
GATK likelihood model (-GL 2), and the following filtering parameters: -Uniqueonly 1 -remove_bads
1 -C 50 -baq 1 -minMapQ 30 -minQ 30 -only_proper_pairs 1. The most likely genotype was called
Genes 2019,10, 649 3 of 16
and considered further, provided that its likelihood exceeded 0.99 and that it was homozygous (the
phenotypic effect of deleterious variants at heterozygous sites depends on their unknown recessive,
dominant, or co-dominant mode of inheritance). Sites were masked otherwise. Given both phyloP
scores and genotype calls, we estimated the genetic load for each horse genome as:
load =PiphyloPi
#homozygous
where iiterates over all the homozygous positions carrying a deleterious allele, and phyloP
i
is the
phyloP score at the genomic position i. We assigned as deleterious the less frequent (or absent) allele in
the 46-way alignment, provided that at most two variants were segregated.
Two approaches were applied to characterize the historical periods yielding inflated mutational
loads. First, we retrieved all the previously published and radiocarbon-dated ancient genomes from
ENA (PRJEB31613). After excluding mules, donkeys, and specimens belonging to other non-caballine
lineages (i.e., not ancestral to modern horse breeds), we retained genomic data from 153 ancient horses
(Table S2). These mostly lived during the last 3500 years. Then, we binned them within temporal
windows of 1000 years, sliding every 250 years. For each time period, we estimated the frequency fof
each deleterious allele from read count data using Maximum Likelihood (ML), where:
f=argmaxp
n_ind_t
Y
i=1
Binomial(rdi,di,p)
where n_ind_t is the number of samples within each time interval, d
i
is the sequencing depth at
that given position, and r
di
is the number of reads supporting the deleterious allele in individual i.
We only considered those time bins showing at least 10 ancient horses genotyped, to minimize the
variance associated with the estimation of f. By applying the same approach to the joint panel of
161 present-day domesticates (Table S1), we finally reconstructed the full temporal trajectory of each
individual deleterious variant. Analyses were repeated considering transversions only, to limit the
impact of post-mortem DNA misincorporations [22].
As a second approach to identify time periods of increasing loads, we calculated pairwise genetic
distances with plink v2 [
23
] from a matrix that included the 161 modern domesticates, 14 Przewalski
horses, and a donkey. We conditioned on 1,839,707,069 neutral positions (phyloP <1.5), with one
missing genotype at most. From these pairwise distances, we constructed a neighbor-joining (NJ) tree
with subsequent topology refinement (-n option) [
24
]. Since low sequencing depths distort phylogenetic
distances, all the genomes were pseudo-haploidized following a standard procedure in ancient DNA
research. This consists in the random selection of one high-quality read at a given site as representative
for the homozygous genotype. The tree branch lengths were used as proxies for neutral substitution
rates, potentially revealing past episodes of elevated drift such as demographic collapses.
Pseudo-haploidized data were also used to characterize genetic purging, which involves selection
against recessive mutations that are phenotypically exposed, such as those found at the homozygous
state, both within and without Runs of Homozygosity (ROHs) resulting from inbreeding [
25
].
We approximated the strength selection by calculating the average genetic divergence of one given
horse individual to the domestic donkey at constrained (dN; phyloP >1.5) and neutral sites (dS;
phyloP <1.5). Strong negative selection purges out mutations at constrained sites, reducing dN and
leading to negative dN-dS values. Conversely, deleterious variants are not efficiently removed under
relaxed negative selection. Thus, dN behaves more neutrally, and effectively approaches dS, leading to
dN-dS values closer to 0.
Finally, we estimated inbreeding coefficients, proceeding independently for Przewalski horses
and modern domesticates. Specifically and for each group, we calculated the genotype posterior
probabilities with ANGSD [
21
], and retained sites showing at most 10% missingness, provided that
they segregated in approximate linkage equilibrium. The latter condition was satisfied through LD
Genes 2019,10, 649 4 of 16
pruning and the calculation of r
2
[
26
] for Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) pairs located less
than 50 Kb away in ngsLD [
27
]. We next clustered these SNP pairs into larger groups of linked variants
using mcl [
28
], and selected the most central SNP as representative of each block. This yielded a
total of 1,249,153 and 6,244,327 high-quality SNPs for Przewalski horses and modern domesticates,
respectively. Inbreeding coefficients and IBD tracts were then co-estimated on these sites applying
ngsF-HMM with a strict convergence criterion (min-epsilon =1e−7) [29].
3. Results
3.1. Levels and Patterns of Mutational Loads, Across Site Categories and Breed Types
The Przewalski horse represents an excellent starting model for understanding the biological
significance of mutational loads, owing to the population collapse experienced the 20th century,
which led to their extinction in the wild in 1969. The now ~2100 animals living on the planet descend
from a foundational captive stock of only 12–15 animals [
30
]. We first estimated individual loads
within protein-coding regions, for comparison with previous work [
5
,
20
,
31
,
32
]. Averaging over 13
Przewalski horse genomes, and one Przewalski
×
Domestic F1 hybrid, we identified an average
number of 1703.43 deleterious mutations out of 6,201,743 protein-coding sites. This corresponded to a
mean load of approximately 3.698
×
10
−4
. As expected, most of the investigated breeds showed lower
protein-coding loads than Przewalski horses, except for Shetland and Welsh ponies, as well as Marwari,
Noriker, and Akhal Teke horses. Many of these breeds are presently represented by only one or two
horse genomes; hence, we caution that the full range of possible load values present in these breeds
remains to be explored. Other breeds such as Haflingers show highly variable loads, with some horses
reaching values similar to those found in Przewalski horses. It is noteworthy that Haflingers and
Norikers are draft breeds that are traditionally used as farm and pack animals. While only five major
sire lines are described for Norikers, all modern purebred Haflingers can trace their ancestry back to
one sire, Folie 249. Outbreeding was strictly prohibited in both breeds until recently, which limited
founding stocks over multiple generations, leading to high load values (4.292
×
10
−4
and 4.294
×
10
−4
,
respectively; Figure 1A). Shetland ponies also ranked high, which was probably due to long periods of
isolation and genetic drift in a small British island, and to the selective crossing policy developed since
the creation of their breeding society in 1890 [33].
As they represent only a limited fraction of the genome, protein-coding regions might provide
partial and potentially biased estimates for the mutational load. Thus, we expanded the calculation
to also cover non-coding regions, including the 2 Kb flanking gene bodies, introns and intergenic
regions. This increased the number of positions considered ~14-fold, representing approximately
67.6 million homozygous sites per genome. This also helped recover slightly and mildly constrained
sites, which remained under-represented in protein-coding regions. This was so because protein-coding
sites show increased evolutionary constraint relative to other regions, even at positions with phyloP
scores greater than 1.5 (average phyloP scores, protein-coding =2.316, 2 Kb upstream =2.096, 2 Kb
downstream =2.097, intergenic =1.964).
In general, the load estimates showed moderate correlation between the different regions
considered (Spearman correlation;
ρ
<0.586; p-value <0.019), except for the protein-coding and
2 Kb upstream regions, where the correlation was non-significant (p-value =0.949). We also found
substantial differences on absolute scales, with loads within non-coding regions one order of magnitude
greater (intergenic =4.405
×
10
−3
, 2 Kb upstream =4.034
×
10
−3
and
2 Kb downstream =3.972 ×10−3
)
than in protein-coding regions (3.476
×
10
−4
). Considering that most of the horse genome is non-coding,
and that selection seems to be more efficient in purging strongly deleterious mutations within
gene bodies, we concluded that, in horses, loads predominantly accumulate at non-coding sites,
through multiple mutations of small fitness effect.
Genes 2019,10, 649 5 of 16
We next estimated genome-wide mutational loads, aiming at obtaining a fully representative set of
positions, and potentially providing finer resolution for assessing the genomic consequences of different
breed management practices. Results indeed revealed two major groups of breeds, each reflecting a
major determinant of the current mutational burdens.
The top half of the load distribution is clearly dominated by traditional working breeds,
including coldblood draft horses, as well as other farm and pack breeds (Figure 1B). We suggest that this
owes to most working breeds being abandoned since the mechanization of locomotion. Their recent
population collapse likely limited the efficacy of negative selection and inflated loads. Such is the
case of South Korean Jeju horses, which collapsed after industrialization, and accumulated an excess
of deleterious mutations (load =4.301
×
10
−3
), and other draft and farm horses, such Lipizzans
(
4.297 ×10−3
), Haflingers (4.292
×
10
−3
), and Norikers (4.294
×
10
−3
). Shetland ponies also show high
genomic loads (4.310
×
10
−3
), which are even larger than those of the closely related Icelandic horses
(4.294
×
10
−3
) (Figure 2). Both consisted originally of draft and farm animals, but have now been
reconverted for leisure activities, and their census population size is limited. Likewise, the Marwari
horse was endangered during the first half of the 20th century, until a series of conservation initiatives
were started. The only Marwari representative analyzed in this study showed a genomic load of
4.312 ×10−3
. This estimate was greater than that of Sorraia horses (4.283
×
10
−3
), which is a breed once
thought to be extinct, until a relict population was discovered and recovered, albeit incorporating some
farm specimens of uncertain genetic backgrounds [
34
]. It is noteworthy that the genomic burden was
particularly pronounced for Friesian horses (4.428
×
10
−3
), the only breed exceeding the Przewalski
mutational load genome-wide (4.310
×
10
−3
). However, two Friesian horses (SAMEA3951222 and
SAMEA3951223) had much lower loads than the other three breed members. These two genomes were
found to be more homozygous (37.1 versus 46.3 millions homozygous sites), despite being sequenced
at comparable depths-of-coverage (~ 8–9
×
, Table S1). The bimodal pattern found for Friesian horses
could be compatible with genetic purging [25], as further investigated and discussed below.
The bottom half of the full-genome load distribution is enriched in breeds that were originally
engendered for sport and leisure. This mostly consisted of hotblood and warmblood lines, which show
comparable loads despite being subject to different breeding strategies. On the one hand, hotblood lines
such as Arabian (4.245
×
10
−3
) and Akhal-Teke (4.249
×
10
−3
) horses trace their origins deep in the past,
possibly hundreds of years before the raise of modern breeding practices. The only exception pertains,
precisely, to the more recently founded Thoroughbreds, for which studbook registration started in
1791, and loads are inflated (4.268
×
10
−3
). On the other hand, warmblood lines are more recent, but
follow open stud guidelines that tolerate introgression from exogenous alleles, hence minimizing
the deleterious effects of inbreeding (4.211–4.277
×
10
−3
, Figure 1B). Trakehners are worth a special
mention, because unlike most warmblood horses, they are managed through nearly closed studbook
practices, and expectedly show more elevated loads (4.281
×
10
−3
). The benefit of admixture is also
evident in a series of breeds that incorporated ancient Arabian lines, such the Connemara, Welsh,
Miniature, and Reit ponies, as well as the Percheron horse [
35
], which exhibit only moderated loads
(Figure 1B). Finally, the Yakutian horse had the lowest loads (Figure 1B), with an average of 301,007
harmful alleles in the homozygous state, corresponding to a mean genomic load of 4.171
×
10
−3
. Their
lowest genomic loads are in line with the incorporation of multiple reproductive stallions within the
Yakutian genetic pool, as illustrated by their high Y-chromosomal diversity [36].
Overall, it appears that the incentive underlying the development of horse breeds, especially their
main specialization as working or transport animals, has contributed to the mutational landscapes
observed, with working breeds and coldblood lines showing greater genomic loads than hotblood
and warmblood lines. To further assess this, we grouped horses according to the following
categories (excluding breeds with uncertain assignation): (i) working horses (Jeju, Shetland, Icelandic,
Haflinger, Percheron, Noriker, Friesian, Marwari, Sorraia, Lipizzan, and Franches Montagnes);
(ii) hotblood (Akhal-Teke, Arabian, and Thoroughbreds); and (iii) warmblood horses (Bavarian,
Oldenburger, Wurtemberg, Dutch, Hanoverian, Holsteiner, Morgan, American Paint, American Quarter,
Genes 2019,10, 649 6 of 16
Standardbred, Trakehner, and Swiss Warmblood). We found significant statistical support for working
horses carrying greater genomic loads than both hotblood (Wilcoxon test; p-value =3.344
×
10
−3
) and
the more admixed warmblood lines (Wilcoxon test; p-value =6.256 ×10−5).
Genes 2019, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 of 16
Figure 1. Mutational loads per breed, based on positions with a phyloP score greater than 1.5: (a)
Loads were estimated from protein-coding sites (a) or genome-wide (b). Names are color-coded for
working horses (red), leisure horses (blue), and hotblood lines (green). Breeds considered of uncertain
assignation are shown in grey. The red circle shows the F1 hybrid between a Przewalski and a
domestic horse.
Overall, it appears that the incentive underlying the development of horse breeds, especially
their main specialization as working or transport animals, has contributed to the mutational
landscapes observed, with working breeds and coldblood lines showing greater genomic loads than
hotblood and warmblood lines. To further assess this, we grouped horses according to the following
categories (excluding breeds with uncertain assignation): (i) working horses (Jeju, Shetland, Icelandic,
Haflinger, Percheron, Noriker, Friesian, Marwari, Sorraia, Lipizzan, and Franches Montagnes); (ii)
hotblood (Akhal-Teke, Arabian, and Thoroughbreds); and (iii) warmblood horses (Bavarian,
Oldenburger, Wurtemberg, Dutch, Hanoverian, Holsteiner, Morgan, American Paint, American
Quarter, Standardbred, Trakehner, and Swiss Warmblood). We found significant statistical support
for working horses carrying greater genomic loads than both hotblood (Wilcoxon test; p-value = 3.344
× 10˗3) and the more admixed warmblood lines (Wilcoxon test; p-value = 6.256 × 10˗5).
However, these groups showed no difference in their protein-coding loads (Figure 1A; Wilcoxon
test; p-value > 0.1428). In addition to relying on a more limited number of positions, protein-coding
loads represent regions evolving under stronger functional constraint, as reflected by their greater
Figure 1.
Mutational loads per breed, based on positions with a phyloP score greater than 1.5: (
a
) Loads
were estimated from protein-coding sites (
a
) or genome-wide (
b
). Names are color-coded for working
horses (red), leisure horses (blue), and hotblood lines (green). Breeds considered of uncertain assignation
are shown in grey. The red circle shows the F1 hybrid between a Przewalski and a domestic horse.
However, these groups showed no difference in their protein-coding loads (Figure 1A; Wilcoxon test;
p-value >0.1428). In addition to relying on a more limited number of positions, protein-coding loads
represent regions evolving under stronger functional constraint, as reflected by their greater average
phyloP scores. Computer simulations conducted by Fages et al. clearly indicated that, after a population
collapse, load bursts are almost undetectable from strongly constrained sites as selection remains
sufficiently effective, but can be detected at slightly deleterious variation (Figure S2 in [
5
]). Given that
protein-coding loads seem far less sensitive to population collapses, it is thus not surprising that they
fail to recover significant differences caused by the recent history of working, leisure, and hotblood lines.
Genes 2019,10, 649 7 of 16
3.2. Phylogenetic Reconstruction Supports Recent Population Decays in Working Breeds
To investigate population collapses, we built an NJ tree, which recovered strong bootstrap support
for known phylogenetic relationships (Figure 2). In particular, Przewalski horses formed a sister
group to all modern domesticates, with the F1 hybrid occupying the most basal position in this clade
(Figure 2). Within domesticates, Mongolian, Jeju, and Yakutian horses split first, followed by a clade of
Icelandic, Miniature, and Shetland ponies. Hotblooded Akhal-Tekke and Arabian horses clustered
jointly, with a Reitpony specimen, which is a breed that is known to have been influenced by hotblood
lines. However, Thoroughbreds formed their own cluster that was well separated from other hotblood
lines. Coldblooded draft horses were also monophyletic, including Percherons, Friesians, Norikers,
and Haflingers. Finally, warmblood horses were grouped per breed, but showed a more complex
pattern of diversification, reflecting their more admixed nature and introgression from influential
breeds, which were either cold or hotblooded.
Genes 2019, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 16
average phyloP scores. Computer simulations conducted by Fages et al. clearly indicated that, after
a population collapse, load bursts are almost undetectable from strongly constrained sites as selection
remains sufficiently effective, but can be detected at slightly deleterious variation (Figure S2 in [5]).
Given that protein-coding loads seem far less sensitive to population collapses, it is thus not
surprising that they fail to recover significant differences caused by the recent history of working,
leisure, and hotblood lines.
3.2. Phylogenetic Reconstruction Supports Recent Population Decays in Working Breeds
To investigate population collapses, we built an NJ tree, which recovered strong bootstrap
support for known phylogenetic relationships (Figure 2). In particular, Przewalski horses formed a
sister group to all modern domesticates, with the F1 hybrid occupying the most basal position in this
clade (Figure 2). Within domesticates, Mongolian, Jeju, and Yakutian horses split first, followed by a
clade of Icelandic, Miniature, and Shetland ponies. Hotblooded Akhal-Tekke and Arabian horses
clustered jointly, with a Reitpony specimen, which is a breed that is known to have been influenced
by hotblood lines. However, Thoroughbreds formed their own cluster that was well separated from
other hotblood lines. Coldblooded draft horses were also monophyletic, including Percherons,
Friesians, Norikers, and Haflingers. Finally, warmblood horses were grouped per breed, but showed
a more complex pattern of diversification, reflecting their more admixed nature and introgression
from influential breeds, which were either cold or hotblooded.
Figure 2.
Neighbor-joining (NJ) cladogram depicting the horse phylogenetic relationships,
mid-point rooted using the donkey as the outgroup. Color ranges highlight monophyletic lineages,
including Przewalski horses (green), Mongolian-derived (brown) and Nordic (orange) breeds,
as well as coldblooded (blue) and hotblooded (red) lines. Most of the non-colored taxa correspond
to admixed warmblood lines, whose phylogenetic placement depends on the relative contribution of
other influential breeds. Long internal branches are highlighted in red, as possibly reflecting episodes of
elevated drift. Only bootstrap support values lower than 95% are displayed to avoid overloading the tree.
Genes 2019,10, 649 8 of 16
We further scrutinized the length of internal branch lengths to potentially reveal past episodes
of increased genetic drift. The longest internal branches led to Sorraia horses (7
×
10
−5
substitutions
per nearly-neutral site), Przewalski horses (6
×
10
−5
), Haflingers (5
×
10
−5
), Friesians (5
×
10
−5
),
and Lipizzans (2.6
×
10
−5
) (Figure 2). The foundational branches of Icelandic (1.7
×
10
−5
),
Shetland (
1.7 ×10−5
), and Jeju (1.5
×
10
−5
) ponies were slightly shorter, on par with those leading
to Akhal-Teke (1.9
×
10
−5
) and Arabian (1.2
×
10
−5
) horses. These long internal branches echoed
the mutational loads carried by working horses, suggesting independent demographic bottlenecks
reducing the efficacy of negative selection and inflating their mutational loads. It is noteworthy that
the branch length leading to all domesticates was only 1.7
×
10
−5
substitutions per nearly-neutral site,
despite encompassing the ~45,000 years of divergence with Przewalski horses [
5
]. This suggests that
the genomic signature left by the domestication bottleneck was mild, and relative to that observed in
some modern breeds. This mild bottleneck is consistent with the large mitochondrial diversity found
in horses, which was interpreted as a pervasive restocking of wild mares during the initial spread of
horse husbandry [37,38].
3.3. Deleterious Mutations Segregated at Low Frequencies Until the Last ~250 Years
We next aimed at reconstructing the past historical dynamics leading to present-day mutational
loads. To achieve this, we first exploited genome-scale data from 153 ancient domestic horses and
tracked the trajectories of all the deleterious alleles segregating in modern breeds over the last
~3500 years (n=1,313,308). Figure 3A–C provide illustrative examples of the temporal trajectories of a
selection of alleles known to be associated with diseases [
39
–
41
], including increasing and decreasing
trends as well as cases where variation does not follow simple temporal changes. Overall, we detected
that ~11.3% of the deleterious mutations were nearly fixed over time across all the periods, including
in present-day domesticates (ML frequency
≥
0.99). Thus, these harmful mutations spread prior to
3500 years ago, and probably prior to domestication. However, the vast majority of deleterious variants
(~76.6%) remained nearly absent at all time periods (ML frequency <0.01). This proportion increased
to ~84.2% and ~86.9% when conditioning on more constrained positions (phyloP scores
≥
2 and 2.5,
respectively). This suggests that negative selection successfully maintained most of the deleterious
variants at low frequencies during recent horse evolution.
We observed that the remaining fraction of deleterious variants (~12.0%, n=158,448) followed a
dynamic temporal trajectory, which is defined as detectable changes in frequency across successive
time periods (
∆
). To further quantify
∆
, we conditioned on non-overlapping time bins of 1000 years,
centered at 250, 1250, 2250, and 3250 years ago. This was done to ensure no redundancy across adjacent
intervals, and hence to avoid underestimating
∆
, since overlapping windows comprised of almost
the same horses would provide nearly identical allele frequencies. We found that the most recent
time interval tested, representing the last 250 years, experienced the largest shift in allele frequency
(Figure 3D). Its median change over the 158,448 deleterious alleles was
∆
=0.02399, while it was 0.02048
or less for older time periods (Wilcoxon test; p-value <2.2
−16
). These changes entailed increases or
decreases in frequencies at equal proportions, except for the last 250 years, where 71% of deleterious
variants became more common than in the previous time interval. This holds true when disregarding
transitions, suggesting that the temporal trend was robust to the possible presence of post-mortem
DNA misincorporations in the sequence data (although these were likely limited due to the treatment
of most ancient DNA extracts with USER prior to DNA library preparation; Figure 3D).
As the results above supported those by Fages et al. [
5
], in which mutational loads were steady
during millennia prior to the industrial revolution, we jointly considered all ancient specimens.
This provided an approximately even number of 161 modern and 153 ancient horses to confidently
estimate the frequencies of all the deleterious alleles (n=1,313,308). On average, we detected that
deleterious mutations are more common in modern horses, compared to their ancient relatives,
by 0.3% according to transitions and by 0.8% to transversions (Figure 3E). Note that transitions are
more spread than transversions also in modern horses, suggesting that their greater frequency is
Genes 2019,10, 649 9 of 16
not due to post-mortem damage, but to sequencing biases and/or biological processes, such as CpG
hypermutability and selection against transversions [
42
,
43
]. Taken together, these findings confirm that
current deleterious mutations segregated in the past, but that it was only recently that they significantly
rose in frequency.
Genes 2019, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 16
As the results above supported those by Fages et al. [5], in which mutational loads were steady
during millennia prior to the industrial revolution, we jointly considered all ancient specimens. This
provided an approximately even number of 161 modern and 153 ancient horses to confidently
estimate the frequencies of all the deleterious alleles (n = 1,313,308). On average, we detected that
deleterious mutations are more common in modern horses, compared to their ancient relatives, by
0.3% according to transitions and by 0.8% to transversions (Figure 3E). Note that transitions are more
spread than transversions also in modern horses, suggesting that their greater frequency is not due
to post-mortem damage, but to sequencing biases and/or biological processes, such as CpG
hypermutability and selection against transversions [42,43]. Taken together, these findings confirm
that current deleterious mutations segregated in the past, but that it was only recently that they
significantly rose in frequency.
Figure 3. Temporal distribution of harmful variants: changes in frequency for alleles associated with
(a) cerebellar abiotrophy, (b) hydrocephalus, and (c) congenital liver fibrosis; (d) Absolute differences
in allele frequencies between time intervals (Δ). For example, point 2250 represents Δ from 3250 to
2250; (e) Frequency of deleterious mutations in ancient and modern horses, as estimated by ML. Ti
and tv stand for nucleotide transitions and transversions, respectively.
3.4. Inbreeding Depression and Genetic Purging Shaped Loads in Modern Domesticates
Understanding the evolutionary mechanisms that forged current mutational loads is paramount
to identifying (un)desirable breeding practices and designing more sustainable strategies. Given the
recent time-scale delimited within the last 250 years, inbreeding depression represents the most likely
mechanism underlying the recent increase of mutational loads in the horse genome [44,45].
Inbreeding depression is caused by recessive mutations that are phenotypically hidden in the
heterozygous state, until they become effective once located within the runs of homozygosity (ROHs)
Figure 3.
Temporal distribution of harmful variants: changes in frequency for alleles associated with
(
a
) cerebellar abiotrophy, (
b
) hydrocephalus, and (
c
) congenital liver fibrosis; (
d
) Absolute differences
in allele frequencies between time intervals (
∆
). For example, point 2250 represents
∆
from 3250 to
2250; (
e
) Frequency of deleterious mutations in ancient and modern horses, as estimated by ML. Ti and
tv stand for nucleotide transitions and transversions, respectively.
3.4. Inbreeding Depression and Genetic Purging Shaped Loads in Modern Domesticates
Understanding the evolutionary mechanisms that forged current mutational loads is paramount
to identifying (un)desirable breeding practices and designing more sustainable strategies. Given the
recent time-scale delimited within the last 250 years, inbreeding depression represents the most
likely mechanism underlying the recent increase of mutational loads in the horse genome
[44,45]
.
Inbreeding depression is caused by recessive mutations that are phenotypically hidden in the
heterozygous state, until they become effective once located within the runs of homozygosity (ROHs)
introduced by inbreeding. Assuming that inbreeding depression was the main driver of the mutational
load patterns observed in this study, we should expect that: (1) recessive mutations segregated in
the ancestral population, and (2) negative selection was not sufficiently strong to remove recessive
mutations exposed within ROHs [25].
The first assertion was proved in the section above. In order to test the second, we characterized
inbreeding and identified ROHs in each individual modern horse genome using ngsF-HMM [
29
].
Genes 2019,10, 649 10 of 16
Our inbreeding estimates replicated previous work for the 14 Przewalski horses [
46
], showing an
average inbreeding coefficient of F=18.5%, corresponding to ~18.5% of the genome being
identical-by-descendant (IBD) (Figure 4A). The Przewalski x Domestic F1 hybrid analyzed (KB7903)
showed no inbreeding, and also had the lowest mutational load in the group (Figure 1B). This suggests
that the inbreeding estimates that were recovered are genuine. We found that inbreeding coefficients
and mutational loads were strongly correlated in Przewalski horses (Spearman correlation;
ρ
=0.903;
p-value =9.740
×
10
−6
), which was as expected if negative selection was not sufficiently strong to
eliminate the deleterious variants exposed in ROHs.
Genes 2019, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 16
Figure 4. Inbreeding depression and genetic purging: (a) Inbreeding per breed; (b) Box plot
summarizing the length of ROHs in a given individual horse. The ROH length is represented in log
2
scale to avoid excessive distortion caused by outliers. In this scale, a value of 18 corresponds to 2
18
=
262 Kb, while a value of 24 corresponds to 2
24
= 16 Mb; (c) Non-synonymous (dN)˗synonymous (dS)
substitution rates, for Przewalski horses and modern domesticates. More negative dN˗dS values
reflect more efficient selection. The specimen highlighted with a red circle corresponds to sample
KB7903 in Der Sarkissian et al. 2015, and represents an F1 hybrid between a Przewalski horse and a
domestic horse.
4. Discussion
Recent work from Fages et al. revealed that the last few centuries have been accompanied by a
~16% drop in the horse heterozygosity genome-wide, and a ~4% raise in the mutational load within
protein-coding regions [5]. However, the underlying drivers of these shifts remained unclear. To
address this gap, we carried out an extensive characterization of mutational loads in horses,
leveraging previously published genome data from a total of 175 modern horses spanning 37 breeds
and/or populations, and 153 ancient horses. We expanded the calculation of mutational loads outside
protein-coding regions, which enhanced both resolution and accuracy.
Our findings support inbreeding depression as the main mechanism driving the load burst in
domesticates and Przewalski horses. It is important to keep in mind that the last ~250 years cannot
Figure 4.
Inbreeding depression and genetic purging: (
a
) Inbreeding per breed; (
b
) Box plot summarizing
the length of ROHs in a given individual horse. The ROH length is represented in log
2
scale to avoid
excessive distortion caused by outliers. In this scale, a value of 18 corresponds to 2
18
=262 Kb, while a
value of 24 corresponds to 2
24
=16 Mb; (
c
) Non-synonymous (dN)-synonymous (dS) substitution rates,
for Przewalski horses and modern domesticates. More negative dN-dS values reflect more efficient
selection. The specimen highlighted with a red circle corresponds to sample KB7903 in Der Sarkissian
et al. 2015, and represents an F1 hybrid between a Przewalski horse and a domestic horse.
Genes 2019,10, 649 11 of 16
Modern domesticates returned slightly lower inbreeding coefficients (on average, F=15.9%).
This estimate is greater than the 8.8% recently estimated across nine breeds, based on 65,157 SNPs
only [
47
], suggesting strong ascertainment bias within this SNP set. Ranking per breed revealed that
Shetland, Sorraia, and Thoroughbreds were extremely inbred, with values approaching and even
exceeding F=30% (Figure 4A). Their longest IBD tracts spanned 20 Mb, 10 Mb, and 11 Mb, respectively
(Figure 4B). Interestingly, and in contrast to Przewalski horses, inbreeding did not necessarily entail
increased loads, as the correlation was weaker, albeit significant (
ρ
=0.222; p-value =4.708
×
10
−3
).
Limiting the calculations to those 53 domesticates sequenced above 15
×
strengthened the correlation
coefficient (
ρ
=0.4754); however, it remained inferior to that inferred for Przewalski horses. A similar
trend was found conditioning load estimates on protein-coding sites. This suggests that additional
mechanisms, beyond inbreeding depression, have contributed to shape the mutational load present in
modern breeds.
As genetic purging involves strong selection against recessive mutations exposed within ROHs,
we propose that this mechanism could have reduced the mutational loads in the most inbred horses.
This mechanism may have been inefficient in Przewalski horses due to the extremely limited reproductive
stock available for the conservation program and/or to the favorable environmental conditions offered in
captivity and reintroduction reserves. To further validate whether selection was stronger in modern
domesticates than in Przewalski horses, we quantified the difference between non-synonymous and
synonymous mutation rates, dN–dS, in each individual genome (see methods). All the horses had
negative dN–dS values, as expected under negative selection (Figure 4C). Yet, Przewalski horses
appeared at the higher end of the dN–dS distribution (
mean dN–dS =−3.328 ×10−3
), confirming more
relaxed negative selection in this lineage relative to domestic horses. Amongst modern domesticates,
the highly isolated Shetland ponies represent the only breed showing lower negative selection than
Przewalski horses (
−
3.306
×
10
−3
). Interestingly, Thoroughbreds were found to be at the tail of the
dN–dS distribution (
−
3.366
×
10
−3
). The correlation between load and dN–dS, which was calculated
across the 19 Thoroughbreds investigated, was non-significant (
ρ
=0.178; p-value =0.467), supporting
ongoing genetic purging in this breed.
4. Discussion
Recent work from Fages et al. revealed that the last few centuries have been accompanied
by a ~16% drop in the horse heterozygosity genome-wide, and a ~4% raise in the mutational load
within protein-coding regions [
5
]. However, the underlying drivers of these shifts remained unclear.
To address this gap, we carried out an extensive characterization of mutational loads in horses,
leveraging previously published genome data from a total of 175 modern horses spanning 37 breeds
and/or populations, and 153 ancient horses. We expanded the calculation of mutational loads outside
protein-coding regions, which enhanced both resolution and accuracy.
Our findings support inbreeding depression as the main mechanism driving the load burst in
domesticates and Przewalski horses. It is important to keep in mind that the last ~250 years cannot
generate sufficient amounts of de novo variants to explain the observed increment in load, given the
low mutation rate inferred for horses [
48
]. Therefore, the excess of mutational load was almost entirely
driven by standing variation; it was also likely located in non-coding regions, and associated with
slightly deleterious and recessive inheritance (i.e., dominant deleterious mutations are less frequent,
because they are phenotypically exposed to negative selection at the heterozygous state, and thus
efficiently eliminated). We indeed confirm that deleterious variation segregated in the past, at very low
frequencies, until rising recently. Nevertheless, their increments of only ~0.3% (transitions) and 0.8%
(transversions) is lower than the 4% raise in protein-coding loads [
5
]. Hence, the load burst cannot
be only explained by a higher frequency of deleterious mutations, but requires that they increasingly
became exposed at the homozygous state, owing to inbreeding. The significant correlation between
inbreeding and the mutational load identified here further corroborates the role of inbreeding in
causing a fitness depression.
Genes 2019,10, 649 12 of 16
Inbreeding was caused by two main historical shifts. The ubiquity of steam and combustion
vehicles relegated breeds traditionally used for farming and transport to almost oblivion, resulting in fast
population collapses (and even extinction in some cases) [
49
]. Although inbreeding exposes recessive
deleterious variants to negative selection within ROHs, the reduced effective sizes considerably limited
the efficacy of negative selection. For example, this increased mutational loads in Sorraia, Haflingers,
Norikers, and especially Friesian horses, which show larger mutational loads than the endangered
Przewalski horses (Figure 1B). One exception to this pattern pertains to one single Percheron horse
present in our genome dataset. This breed consisted of large, draft horses, and is known to have been
extremely influenced by Arabian bloodlines while being founded in France, before becoming extremely
popular worldwide, especially in the U.S., in the 19th century [
50
]. As a result, its geographic range
was exceptionally large for a draft breed, which may have helped preserve sufficient genetic diversity,
until conservation programs started in the 1960s.
Conservation programs often rely on closed stud practices to maintain un-admixed populations
that are better adapted to native environments. For endangered breeds, this implies that foals can
only be registered if descending from purebred studbook-registered parents. Similar rules govern
selection programs to improve specific breeds, such as Thoroughbreds, for which a studbook was
established well before Darwin formalized the concept of evolution through natural selection in
1859 [
51
]. Closed studs, and the preferential reproduction of influential stallions, increased inbreeding
and the probability of exposing deleterious alleles in the homozygous state. In extremely large studs
such as Thoroughbreds, which are intensively selected for performance, this may have provided
sufficient strength to purge deleterious mutations. However, in other breeds, which are either less
intensively selected or restricted to extremely low effective sizes, mutational loads could spread.
The abandonment of working breeds and the emergence of closed studbooks clearly post-date
the onset of domestication by at least five millennia [
32
,
52
,
53
]. This has deep implications for the
cost-of-domestication hypothesis [
54
], which posits that there was an increase in mutational load due
to the repeated bottlenecks presumably experienced during the early domestication stages [
31
,
55
–
57
].
In agreement with previous work in horses [
20
] and crops [
58
], we find that this is not necessarily the
case, and highlight that two forces with opposing effects could have also contributed to shape mutational
loads. On the one hand, the impact of recent events seems unprecedented in the horse evolutionary
history, and appears to have eroded the horse genome more than the domestication bottleneck itself
(Figures 2and 3). On the other hand, restocking from the wild and cross-breeding during hundreds of
generations could have counteracted the deleterious consequences of early population declines, e.g.,
through heterosis, which is a phenomenon involving greater vigor and fertility in hybrids than in their
parental inbreed stocks [13].
A number of mathematical models for inbreeding depression, heterosis, and genetic
purging
[14,25,59,60]
have predicted that populations with reproductive stocks that are comparable
to what are found in many domestic breeds undergo a strong risk of extinction. For example,
Caballero et al. recently used simulations to estimate that populations limited to approximately
70 reproductive individuals are under substantial risk of extinction, as defined by a >10% reduction
in viability after 50 generations of evolution [
61
]. Note that a breeding stock of N
m
=20 stallions
and
Nf=5000 mares
corresponds to a population size of only N
e
=4N
m
N
f
/(N
m
+N
f
)
≈
80 individuals.
In line with this, and according to the Domestic Animal Diversity Information System (DAD-IS;
accessed 19 July 2019 from the FAO website [
49
]), more than 200 horse breeds would thus be
endangered or at the brink of extinction, while 88 are already extinct.
Encouragingly, the relation between inbreeding and mutational loads was found to be impacted
by genetic purging in modern domesticates (Figure 4). Thus, genetic purging adds an extra layer of
complexity to the interplay of forces that forged genomic loads, not only helping to improve fitness,
but also to optimize traits that are paramount to the equine industry. For example, in Thoroughbreds,
genetic purging has been associated with improved racing performance [
62
]. This means that breeders
Genes 2019,10, 649 13 of 16
can leverage genomic information to design mating strategies favoring the purging of deleterious
mutations from the breeding stock, improving animal welfare and mitigating extinction risks.
Supplementary Materials:
The following are available online at http://www.mdpi.com/2073-4425/10/9/649/s1,
Table S1: Metadata for 175 modern horses investigated in this study. Table S2: Metadata for 153 ancient horses
investigated in this study.
Author Contributions:
Conceptualization, L.O. and P.L.; methodology, P.L.; formal analysis, P.L.; resources,
L.O.; writing—Original draft preparation, P.L.; writing—Review and editing, L.O.; visualization, P.L.;
funding acquisition, L.O.
Funding:
This research was funded by the Danish National Research Foundation (DNRF94), the Initiative
d’Excellence Chaires d’attractivit
é
, Universit
é
de Toulouse (OURASI), and the Villum Fonden miGENEPI.
This project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon
2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement No. 681605).
Acknowledgments: We would like to thank the AGES research group for support.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
1.
Anthony, D.W. The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the
Modern World, Reprint ed.; Princeton University Press: Princeton, NJ, USA, 2010; ISBN 978-0-691-14818-2.
2. Kelekna, P. The Horse in Human History; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 2009.
3.
Equine Industry Statistics Overview l Equine Business Association. Available online: https://www.
equinebusinessassociation.com/equine-industry-statistics/(accessed on 7 June 2019).
4.
Librado, P.; Fages, A.; Gaunitz, C.; Leonardi, M.; Wagner, S.; Khan, N.; Hanghøj, K.; Alquraishi, S.A.;
Alfarhan, A.H.; Al-Rasheid, K.A.; et al. The Evolutionary Origin and Genetic Makeup of Domestic Horses.
Genetics 2016,204, 423–434. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
5.
Fages, A.; Hanghøj, K.; Khan, N.; Gaunitz, C.; Seguin-Orlando, A.; Leonardi, M.; McCrory Constantz, C.;
Gamba, C.; Al-Rasheid, K.A.S.; Albizuri, S.; et al. Tracking Five Millennia of Horse Management with
Extensive Ancient Genome Time Series. Cell 2019,177, 1419–1435.e31. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
6.
Wallner, B.; Vogl, C.; Shukla, P.; Burgstaller, J.P.; Druml, T.; Brem, G. Identification of Genetic Variation on
the Horse Y Chromosome and the Tracing of Male Founder Lineages in Modern Breeds. PLoS ONE
2013
,
8, e60015. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
7.
Felkel, S.; Vogl, C.; Rigler, D.; Dobretsberger, V.; Chowdhary, B.P.; Distl, O.; Fries, R.; Jagannathan, V.;
Janeˇcka, J.E.; Leeb, T.; et al. The horse Y chromosome as an informative marker for tracing sire lines. Sci. Rep.
2019,9, 6095. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
8.
Bosse, M.; Megens, H.; Derks, M.F.L.; de Cara,
Á
.M.R.; Groenen, M.A.M. Deleterious alleles in the context of
domestication, inbreeding, and selection. Evol. Appl. 2018,12, 6–17. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
9.
Szpiech, Z.A.; Xu, J.; Pemberton, T.J.; Peng, W.; Zöllner, S.; Rosenberg, N.A.; Li, J.Z. Long Runs of
Homozygosity Are Enriched for Deleterious Variation. Am. J. Hum. Genet.
2013
,93, 90–102. [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
10.
Nicholas, F.W. Online Mendelian Inheritance in Animals (OMIA): A comparative knowledgebase of genetic
disorders and other familial traits in non-laboratory animals. Nucleic Acids Res.
2003
,31, 275–277. [CrossRef]
11.
Korte, A.; Farlow, A. The advantages and limitations of trait analysis with GWAS: A review. Plant. Methods
2013,9, 29. [CrossRef]
12.
Charlesworth, B. Effective population size and patterns of molecular evolution and variation. Nat. Rev.
Genet. 2009,10, 195–205. [CrossRef]
13.
Charlesworth, D.; Willis, J.H. The genetics of inbreeding depression. Nat. Rev. Genet.
2009
,10, 783–796.
[CrossRef]
14.
Lynch, M.; Conery, J.; Burger, R. Mutation Accumulation and the Extinction of Small Populations. Am. Nat.
1995,146, 489–518. [CrossRef]
15.
Understanding and Predicting the Fitness Decline of Shrunk Populations: Inbreeding, Purging, Mutation,
and Standard Selection|Genetics. Available online: https://www.genetics.org/content/190/4/1461.long (accessed
on 20 August 2019).
Genes 2019,10, 649 14 of 16
16.
Schubert, M.; Ermini, L.; Der Sarkissian, C.; J
ó
nsson, H.; Ginolhac, A.; Schaefer, R.; Martin, M.D.; Fern
á
ndez, R.;
Kircher, M.; McCue, M.; et al. Characterization of ancient and modern genomes by SNP detection and
phylogenomic and metagenomic analysis using PALEOMIX. Nat. Protoc.
2014
,9, 1056–1082. [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
17.
Siepel, A.; Pollard, K.S.; Haussler, D. New Methods for Detecting Lineage-Specific Selection. In Proceedings
of the Research in Computational Molecular Biology; Apostolico, A., Guerra, C., Istrail, S., Pevzner, P.A.,
Waterman, M., Eds.; Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany, 2006; pp. 190–205.
18.
Pollard, K.S.; Hubisz, M.J.; Rosenbloom, K.R.; Siepel, A. Detection of nonneutral substitution rates on
mammalian phylogenies. Genome Res. 2010,20, 110–121. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
19.
Wade, C.M.; Giulotto, E.; Sigurdsson, S.; Zoli, M.; Gnerre, S.; Imsland, F.; Lear, T.L.; Adelson, D.L.; Bailey, E.;
Bellone, R.R.; et al. Genome sequence, comparative analysis, and population genetics of the domestic horse.
Science 2009,326, 865–867. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
20.
Librado, P.; Gamba, C.; Gaunitz, C.; Sarkissian, C.D.; Pruvost, M.; Albrechtsen, A.; Fages, A.; Khan, N.;
Schubert, M.; Jagannathan, V.; et al. Ancient genomic changes associated with domestication of the horse.
Science 2017,356, 442–445. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
21.
Korneliussen, T.S.; Albrechtsen, A.; Nielsen, R. ANGSD: Analysis of Next Generation Sequencing Data.
BMC Bioinform. 2014,15, 356. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
22.
Dabney, J.; Meyer, M.; Pääbo, S. Ancient DNA Damage. Cold Spring Harb. Perspect. Biol.
2013
,5. [CrossRef]
23.
Purcell, S.; Neale, B.; Todd-Brown, K.; Thomas, L.; Ferreira, M.A.R.; Bender, D.; Maller, J.; Sklar, P.;
de Bakker, P.I.W.; Daly, M.J.; et al. PLINK: A tool set for whole-genome association and population-based
linkage analyses. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 2007,81, 559–575. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
24.
Lefort, V.; Desper, R.; Gascuel, O. FastME 2.0: A Comprehensive, Accurate, and Fast Distance-Based
Phylogeny Inference Program. Mol. Biol. Evol. 2015,32, 2798–2800. [CrossRef]
25.
Hedrick, P.W.; Garcia-Dorado, A. Understanding Inbreeding Depression, Purging, and Genetic Rescue.
Trends Ecol. Evol. 2016,31, 940–952. [CrossRef]
26.
Hill, W.G.; Robertson, A. Linkage disequilibrium in finite populations. Theor. Appl. Genet.
1968
,38, 226–231.
[CrossRef] [PubMed]
27.
Fox, E.A.; Wright, A.E.; Fumagalli, M.; Vieira, F.G. ngsLD: Evaluating linkage disequilibrium using genotype
likelihoods. Bioinformatics 2019. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
28.
Van Dongen, S. Graph Clustering Via a Discrete Uncoupling Process. SIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl.
2008
,30,
121–141. [CrossRef]
29.
Vieira, F.G.; Albrechtsen, A.; Nielsen, R. Estimating IBD tracts from low coverage NGS data. Bioinformatics
2016,32, 2096–2102. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
30.
The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Available online: https://www.iucnredlist.org/en (accessed on 7
June 2019).
31.
Schubert, M.; J
ó
nsson, H.; Chang, D.; Der Sarkissian, C.; Ermini, L.; Ginolhac, A.; Albrechtsen, A.;
Dupanloup, I.; Foucal, A.; Petersen, B.; et al. Prehistoric genomes reveal the genetic foundation and cost of
horse domestication. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2014,111, E5661–E5669. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
32.
Gaunitz, C.; Fages, A.; Hanghøj, K.; Albrechtsen, A.; Khan, N.; Schubert, M.; Seguin-Orlando, A.; Owens, I.J.;
Felkel, S.; Bignon-Lau, O.; et al. Ancient genomes revisit the ancestry of domestic and Przewalski’s horses.
Science 2018,360, 111–114. [CrossRef]
33.
Shetland Ponies, about Shetland Ponies—The Breed and Stud-Book. Available online: http://www.
shetlandponystudbooksociety.co.uk/about-the-breed (accessed on 7 June 2019).
34.
Lu
í
s, C.; Cothran, E.G.; Oom, M.d.M. Inbreeding and Genetic Structure in the Endangered Sorraia Horse
Breed: Implications for its Conservation and Management. J. Hered. 2007,98, 232–237. [CrossRef]
35.
Horses—Breeds of Livestock, Department of Animal Science. Available online: http://afs.okstate.edu/breeds/
horses/horses-w.html#r (accessed on 9 June 2019).
36.
Librado, P.; Sarkissian, C.D.; Ermini, L.; Schubert, M.; J
ó
nsson, H.; Albrechtsen, A.; Fumagalli, M.; Yang, M.A.;
Gamba, C.; Seguin-Orlando, A.; et al. Tracking the origins of Yakutian horses and the genetic basis for their
fast adaptation to subarctic environments. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2015,112, E6889–E6897. [CrossRef]
37.
Achilli, A.; Olivieri, A.; Soares, P.; Lancioni, H.; Hooshiar Kashani, B.; Perego, U.A.; Nergadze, S.G.; Carossa, V.;
Santagostino, M.; Capomaccio, S.; et al. Mitochondrial genomes from modern horses reveal the major
haplogroups that underwent domestication. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2012,109, 2449–2454. [CrossRef]
Genes 2019,10, 649 15 of 16
38.
Jansen, T.; Forster, P.; Levine, M.A.; Oelke, H.; Hurles, M.; Renfrew, C.; Weber, J.; Olek, K. Mitochondrial
DNA and the origins of the domestic horse. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2002,99, 10905–10910. [CrossRef]
39.
Drögemüller, M.; Jagannathan, V.; Welle, M.M.; Graubner, C.; Straub, R.; Gerber, V.; Burger, D.;
Signer-Hasler, H.; Poncet, P.-A.; Klopfenstein, S.; et al. Congenital Hepatic Fibrosis in the Franches-Montagnes
Horse Is Associated with the Polycystic Kidney and Hepatic Disease 1 (PKHD1) Gene. PLoS ONE
2014
,
9, e110125. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
40.
Brault, L.S.; Cooper, C.A.; Famula, T.R.; Murray, J.D.; Penedo, M.C.T. Mapping of equine cerebellar abiotrophy
to ECA2 and identification of a potential causative mutation affecting expression of MUTYH. Genomics
2011
,
97, 121–129. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
41.
Ducro, B.J.; Schurink, A.; Bastiaansen, J.W.M.; Boegheim, I.J.M.; van Steenbeek, F.G.; Vos-Loohuis, M.;
Nijman, I.J.; Monroe, G.R.; Hellinga, I.; Dibbits, B.W.; et al. A nonsense mutation in B3GALNT2 is concordant
with hydrocephalus in Friesian horses. BMC Genomics 2015,16, 761. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
42.
Zhang, J. Rates of conservative and radical nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions in mammalian nuclear
genes. J. Mol. Evol. 2000,50, 56–68. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
43.
Lyons, D.M.; Lauring, A.S. Evidence for the Selective Basis of Transition-to-Transversion Substitution Bias in
Two RNA Viruses. Mol. Biol. Evol. 2017,34, 3205–3215. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
44.
O’Grady, J.J.; Brook, B.W.; Reed, D.H.; Ballou, J.D.; Tonkyn, D.W.; Frankham, R. Realistic levels of inbreeding
depression strongly affect extinction risk in wild populations. Biol. Conserv. 2006,133, 42–51. [CrossRef]
45.
Ebert, D.; Haag, C.; Kirkpatrick, M.; Riek, M.; Hottinger, J.W.; Pajunen, V.I. A selective advantage to immigrant
genes in a Daphnia metapopulation. Science 2002,295, 485–488. [CrossRef]
46.
Der Sarkissian, C.; Ermini, L.; Schubert, M.; Yang, M.A.; Librado, P.; Fumagalli, M.; J
ó
nsson, H.; Bar-Gal, G.K.;
Albrechtsen, A.; Vieira, F.G.; et al. Evolutionary Genomics and Conservation of the Endangered Przewalski’s
Horse. Curr. Biol. 2015,25, 2577–2583. [CrossRef]
47.
Genes|Free Full-Text|The Genomic Makeup of Nine Horse Populations Sampled in the Netherlands.
Available online: https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4425/10/6/480 (accessed on 2 July 2019).
48.
Orlando, L.; Ginolhac, A.; Zhang, G.; Froese, D.; Albrechtsen, A.; Stiller, M.; Schubert, M.; Cappellini, E.;
Petersen, B.; Moltke, I.; et al. Recalibrating Equus evolution using the genome sequence of an early Middle
Pleistocene horse. Nature 2013,499, 74–78. [CrossRef]
49.
Data export|Domestic Animal Diversity Information System (DAD-IS)|Food and Agriculture Organization of
the United Nations. Available online: http://www.fao.org/dad-is/dataexport/en/(accessed on 11 June 2019).
50.
Mischka, J. The Percheron Horse in America; Mischka Press/Heart Prairie: Walworth, WI, USA, 1991;
ISBN 978-0-9622663-5-5.
51. Montgomery, E.S. The Thoroughbred; Arco Pub: New York, NY, USA, 1972; ISBN 978-0-668-02824-0.
52.
Outram, A.K.; Stear, N.A.; Bendrey, R.; Olsen, S.; Kasparov, A.; Zaibert, V.; Thorpe, N.; Evershed, R.P.
The Earliest Horse Harnessing and Milking. Science 2009,323, 1332–1335. [CrossRef]
53.
Ludwig, A.; Pruvost, M.; Reissmann, M.; Benecke, N.; Brockmann, G.A.; Castaños, P.; Cieslak, M.; Lippold, S.;
Llorente, L.; Malaspinas, A.-S.; et al. Coat Color Variation at the Beginning of Horse Domestication. Science
2009,324, 485. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
54.
Lu, J.; Tang, T.; Tang, H.; Huang, J.; Shi, S.; Wu, C.-I. The accumulation of deleterious mutations in rice
genomes: A hypothesis on the cost of domestication. Trends Genet.
2006
,22, 126–131. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
55.
Marsden, C.D.; Vecchyo, D.O.-D.; O’Brien, D.P.; Taylor, J.F.; Ramirez, O.; Vil
à
, C.; Marques-Bonet, T.;
Schnabel, R.D.; Wayne, R.K.; Lohmueller, K.E. Bottlenecks and selective sweeps during domestication have
increased deleterious genetic variation in dogs. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
2016
,113, 152–157. [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
56.
Koenig, D.; Jim
é
nez-G
ó
mez, J.M.; Kimura, S.; Fulop, D.; Chitwood, D.H.; Headland, L.R.; Kumar, R.;
Covington, M.F.; Devisetty, U.K.; Tat, A.V.; et al. Comparative transcriptomics reveals patterns of selection in
domesticated and wild tomato. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2013,110, E2655–E2662. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
57.
Moyers, B.T.; Morrell, P.L.; McKay, J.K. Genetic Costs of Domestication and Improvement. J. Hered.
2018
,109,
103–116. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
58.
Allaby, R.G.; Ware, R.L.; Kistler, L. A re-evaluation of the domestication bottleneck from archaeogenomic
evidence. Evol. Appl. 2018,12, 29–37. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Genes 2019,10, 649 16 of 16
59.
Wang, J.; Hill, W.G.; Charlesworth, D.; Charlesworth, B. Dynamics of inbreeding depression due to deleterious
mutations in small populations: Mutation parameters and inbreeding rate. Genet. Res.
1999
,74, 165–178.
[CrossRef] [PubMed]
60.
Charlesworth, B. Mutational load, inbreeding depression and heterosis in subdivided populations. Mol. Ecol.
2018,27, 4991–5003. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
61.
Caballero, A.; Bravo, I.; Wang, J. Inbreeding load and purging: Implications for the short-term survival and
the conservation management of small populations. Heredity 2017,118, 177–185. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
62.
Todd, E.T.; Ho, S.Y.W.; Thomson, P.C.; Ang, R.A.; Velie, B.D.; Hamilton, N.A. Founder-specific inbreeding
depression affects racing performance in Thoroughbred horses. Sci. Rep.
2018
,8, 6167. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
©
2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
