Article

A View on the History of Media Theory from the Global South

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

The generalisation of “media” as a term for all forms of communication technologies occurred in part as a result of Cold War history. The implication was that every medium was in some abstract sense equivalent, whether it was print, radio or television for example. Media acquired emancipatory connotations, as if their growth would bring progress in its wake. Alongside, however, paradigms for research on media proliferated, and became increasingly hard to bridge; one outcome was the increasing marginalisation of media and communication studies from the social sciences and humanities in general, even as media scholars grew in number. This marginalization reflected a historical problem, but, interestingly, the remedies sought for it are often theoretical, drawing for example on science studies or on critical race theory. It is as if the Global South and North that have been set adrift from each other, with scholarly sanction from the academy. But for understanding the forms of contemporary globalisation, an account of Cold War media theory’s historical formation is indispensable.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... The view that global capitalist production is uneven may be the reason why many parts of the world, despite their sovereignty, are vulnerable to new forms of power (Rajagopal, 2019), which may have a cultivating effect. ...
... In essence, the Council laments the gravity of Western imperial influence. The world order is being reorganized by the core states to advance their own interests at the expense of others (Hamelink, 2002, Rajagopal, 2019. The Muslim Judicial Council further added that these narratives are being forced down the throats of a 21st century society that questions the basic existence of all things, or in technical language, "the natural order of things". ...
Article
Full-text available
Global cultures and imperialist Western ways of being and doing pervasively penetrate and influence societies and individuals, overarching the nations at the bottom of development. This globality operates unidirectionally, biased toward the Western gravity of power, excluding, disenfranchising, erasing, and debasing the values of the global South’s peripheries. Consequently, the theory of globalization has focused on how localized groups in subaltern developing countries respond to the weighty forces of globalism. This paper presents a critical analysis that explores the omnipotent ideologicalhegemonic power of the media to cultivate, enculturate, and superimpose values normative to the ethos of global culture. We employ critical discourse analysis to analyze seven selected newspapers that reported on a draft proposal by the Department of Basic Education that envisions the eradication of gender labels through the imposition of genderless toilets in South African schools. Critical reading of the newspaper articles demonstrated clear Afrocentric pushbacks; other counternarratives displayed the societal incongruity of such a vision. The media frames corresponded to audience frames that vehemently rejected the unisex toilet proposition. The frames continue to invite readers to question the redefinition of gender identities and performances that promote global cultural values that supposedly disrupt nature.
... Second, freedom of expression, integral though it is to the history of the ideas of media and communications, is not a politically neutral category. It has acquired new connotations within the political history of the long Cold War, serving as a tool for American propaganda (Rajagopal 2019). The political character of "freedom of expression" is rarely acknowledged by communication scholars who treat this concept narrowly, as an objective, core priority. ...
Article
Research on Western European and North American news media continues to dominate scholarship in the field of journalism studies. The remedies sought to rectify this imbalance notably include comparative studies across non-Western and Western countries using large-scale surveys or content analyses. At an epistemological level, such studies adopt—often inherently—an Enlightenment-inspired normative frame that makes the comparisons and transpositions possible. On the one hand, these normative frames are necessary placeholders to make sense of the global field of journalism considering existing hierarchies of knowledge production. On the other, such frames are untenable because they conveniently force Enlightenment-based assumptions upon non-Western cultures, which fundamentally exist in tension with those normative assumptions. Departing from such comparative studies and approaches, this article proposes the concept of “cultures of restraint” to understand non-Western journalism practices and news values in a more context-sensitive manner. We demonstrate the utility of this concept by applying it to the case of vernacular language migrant journalists in the Middle East. Drawing on fieldwork and interviews, we illuminate the cultural conditions that shape the journalistic task of redefining “normative” news values, in the process challenging conventional interpretations of news and journalism.
Article
The dualistic view of communication as both disease and cure, raised by John Durham Peters in Speaking into the Air, continues to gain traction globally. This view of communication has followed the itineraries of the neoliberal economy and its expectations. Communication today is the site where individual aspirations, market expectations and national interests meet and collide. Taking a cue from Peters of thinking with the past, this essay follows the dualistic narrative in the complex linguistic terrain of India today where the English language and communication serve as a space for defining failure and promoting the remedy of self-development. Engaging with postcolonial examples, the discussion illustrates how narratives of miscommunication are integrated and reinforced in the entrepreneurial space of communication skills training.
Article
Full-text available
This paper examines how the West Berlin communication studies department, for over 40 years, was tied to or “disciplined” by the Cold War, leading to practices of exclusion and hegemony. Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of symbolic power, we analyze how anticommunism as a discourse formed the habitus, capital, and field logic of West Berlin communication studies. Sources are archival material from Freie Universität Berlin (Free University of Berlin), minutes of Abgeordnetenhaus von Berlin (parliament), press from East and West Germany, and autobiographical material and academic publications from West Berlin and West German communication scholars. The paper describes how the anticommunist discourse at first helped Emil Dovifat, professor and department director from 1928 on, to protect himself from attacks regarding his Nazi past and to reestablish his reputation after 1945. For his successor, the interim director Fritz Eberhard, the anticommunist discourse caused problems. Eberhard tried to consolidate the poorly reputed discipline at Freie Universität Berlin during the 1960s; however, this effort was weakened because he had to defend himself against press attacks for being a socialist. Finally, the unique geopolitics of West Berlin, together with the anticommunist discourse, help to explain why the West Berlin department developed after 1968 into a (lonely) center of critical theory indebted to Marx and the Frankfurt School, and how these approaches were marginalized by the rest of the field and by the political system in the 1970s and 1980s.
Article
Full-text available
Why has the field of communication failed to define itself, its intellectual focus, and its mission in a coherent way? This essay explores reasons for this failure, focusing especially on the institutional use of the field's central terms and concepts. Incoherence has been the price of institutional success. What defines communication's unique identity as a field is also what maintains its conceptual confusions. The field is compared to a nation-state. The essay places the field's emergence in the context of the history of the social sciences in order to help illuminate its current crises and to explore how we might find new ways of conceiving the field's intellectual task.
Book
This book was originally published by Macmillan in 1936. It was voted the top Academic Book that Shaped Modern Britain by Academic Book Week (UK) in 2017, and in 2011 was placed on Time Magazine's top 100 non-fiction books written in English since 1923. Reissued with a fresh Introduction by the Nobel-prize winner Paul Krugman and a new Afterword by Keynes’ biographer Robert Skidelsky, this important work is made available to a new generation. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money transformed economics and changed the face of modern macroeconomics. Keynes’ argument is based on the idea that the level of employment is not determined by the price of labour, but by the spending of money. It gave way to an entirely new approach where employment, inflation and the market economy are concerned. Highly provocative at its time of publication, this book and Keynes’ theories continue to remain the subject of much support and praise, criticism and debate. Economists at any stage in their career will enjoy revisiting this treatise and observing the relevance of Keynes’ work in today’s contemporary climate.
Article
This essay aims to show how what is most intimately and essentially human – our ideas, personal purposes, feelings, and dreams – finds space for expression within the autonomous, unfeeling, physical dynamics of the technosphere – the defining system of the Anthropocene. The approach adopted is based on systems science and aims to avoid metaphysical assumptions about the nature and importance of human values. A non-humanistic analysis of human potential shows why the demands of the physical technosphere on human behavior leave space for nominally non-technospheric activities, such as the pursuit of personal purposes. The dynamical perspective also highlights the central role of humanistic pushback against technospheric encroachment on the human domain.
Article
Reflecting on two US-engineered Cold War programs and plans, the author finds how terror, over past decades, has become a normal element in everyday US life. The historic period that saw the Corona satellite and the Single Integrated Operational Plan come to light, the author argues, taught Americans to be committed to total war as a precondition for everyday life - while locating death as exterior to the nation. © The Author(s) 2013 Reprints and permissions: sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav.
Article
Modernization is the unifying principle in this study of the changing Middle East. The characterological transformation that accompanies modernization is psychic mobility, and its mechanism is empathy—the ability of an individual to see himself in the other fellow's situation. A major hypothesis of the study is that high empathic capacity is the predominant style only in modern society, which is distinctively industrial, urban, literate, and participant. The secular evolution of a participant society appears to involve a regular sequence of three phases: urbanization, literacy, and media participation, all of which lead to increased political participation. The degree of modernization present in a society can be measured by indices of these phases. The extent to which these are evolving is determined by the existence of individuals with high empathy. Such transitionals are largely defined in terms of what they want to become; their passage from what they were to what they are to what they are becoming is the passing of traditional society in the Middle East. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
In the international press Nigeria is represented almost exclusively as a state in crisis. Recurrent military coups, ethnic and religious sectionalism, a civil war, a series of bloody riots and local unrest (of which the Niger delta situation is the best-known example), economic turmoil, and the re-imposition of the Islamic criminal code in many northern states have all been used to paint a picture of chaos and collapse. Journalists and government officials alike tend to find the roots of Nigeria's problems in intractable ethnic conflict, the collapse of oil prices in 1983, structural adjustment mandated by the International Monetary Fund in 1986, and hatred between Muslims and Christians. The trouble with Nigeria is also understood to illustrate the trouble with Africa. With 25 percent of the population of sub-Saharan Africa, Nigeria appears as representative of Africa. Potentially wealthy from its oil revenue, it symbolizes Africa's promise denied.
Article
Obra que interpreta el pensamiento de Gilles Deleuze (1925-1995), filósofo francés iconoclasta con raigambre en el postestructuralismo. El autor parte del análisis del devenir deleuziano frente al ser para después articularlo con algunas nociones que han sido tratadas desde Deleuze como el psicoanálisis y el cognitivismo, el cine y la percepción, y la política cultural.
The Role of Criticism in the Management of Mass Communications
  • Paul Lazarsfeld
Communication Revolution: Critical Junctures and the Future of Media
  • Robert W Mcchesney
Negotiations. 1972-1990. Translated by Martin Joughin
  • Gilles Deleuze
Information, Crisis, Catastrophe
  • Mary Doane
  • Ann
The Beginnings of Communication Study in America: A Personal Memoir
  • Wilbur Schramm
Towards a Semiotic Inquiry Into the Television Message.” Translated by Paola Splendore. Working Papers in Cultural Studies
  • Umberto Eco
The Rights of Man Part II. The Principle and the Practice
  • Thomas Paine
The Story of Human Communication: From Cave Painting to Microchip
  • Wilbur Schramm
  • Lerner Daniel