ArticlePublisher preview available

A novel group decision making model based on neutrosophic sets for heart disease diagnosis

DOI:10.1007/s11042-019-07742-7
Authors:
Mohamed Abdel-Basset at Zagazig University
Mohamed Abdel-Basset
Abduallah Gamal at Zagazig University
Abduallah Gamal
Gunasekaran Manogaran
Gunasekaran Manogaran
Gunasekaran Manogaran
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Le Hoang Son
Le Hoang Son
Le Hoang Son
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Show all 5 authorsHide
Read publisher preview
Download citation
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

In a developed society, people have more concerned about their health. Thus, improvement of medical field application has been one of the greatest active study areas. Medical statistics show that heart disease is the main reason for morbidity and death in the world. The physician’s job is difficult because of having too many factors to analyze in the diagnosis of heart disease. Besides, data and information gained by the physician for diagnosis are often partial and immersed. Recently, health care applications with the Internet of Things (IoT) have offered different dimensions and other online services. These applications have provided a new platform for millions of people to receive benefits from the regular health tips to live a healthy life. In this paper, we propose a novel framework based on computer supported diagnosis and IoT to detect and monitor heart failure infected patients, where the data are attained from various other sources. The proposed healthcare system aims at obtaining better precision of diagnosis with ambiguous information. We suggest neutrosophic multi criteria decision making (NMCDM) technique to aid patient and physician to know if patient is suffering from heart failure. Furthermore, through dealing with the uncertainty of imprecision and vagueness resulted from the symmetrical priority scales of different symptoms of disease, users know what extent the disease is dangerous in their body. The proposed model is validated by numerical examples on real case studies. The experimental results indicate that the proposed system provides a viable solution that can work at wide range, a new platform to millions of people getting benefit over the decreasing of mortality and cost of clinical treatment related to heart failure.
Figures - available from: Multimedia Tools and Applications
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
  • A preview of this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
  • Learn more
Preview content only
Content available from Multimedia Tools and Applications
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
A novel group decision making model based
on neutrosophic sets for heart disease diagnosis
Mohamed Abdel-Basset
1
&Abduallah Gamal
1
&Gunasekaran Manogaran
2
&
Le Hoang Son
3
&Hoang Viet Long
4,5
Received: 28 February 2019 /Revised: 20 March 2019 /Accepted: 9 May 2019
#Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2019
Abstract
In a developed society, people have more concerned about their health. Thus, improvement of
medical field application has been one of the greatest active study areas. Medical statistics
show that heart disease is the main reason for morbidity and death in the world. The
physician’s job is difficult because of having too many factors to analyze in the diagnosis of
heart disease. Besides, data and information gained by the physician for diagnosis are often
partial and immersed. Recently, health care applications with the Internet of Things (IoT) have
offered different dimensions and other online services. These applications have provided a new
platform for millions of people to receive benefits from the regular health tips to live a healthy
life. In this paper, we propose a novel framework based on computer supported diagnosis and
IoT to detect and monitor heart failure infected patients, where the data are attained from
various other sources. The proposed healthcare system aims at obtaining better precision of
diagnosis with ambiguous information. We suggest neutrosophic multi criteria decision
making (NMCDM) technique to aid patient and physician to know if patient is suffering from
heart failure. Furthermore, through dealing with the uncertainty of imprecision and vagueness
resulted from the symmetrical priority scales of different symptoms of disease, users know
what extent the disease is dangerous in their body. The proposed model is validated by
numerical examples on real case studies. The experimental results indicate that the proposed
system provides a viable solution that can work at wide range, a new platform to millions of
people getting benefit over the decreasing of mortality and cost of clinical treatment related to
heart failure.
Keywords Heart failure .Internet of things (IoT) .Neutrosophic multi criteria decisionmaking .
Biomedical data analysis
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11042-019-07742-7
*Mohamed Abdel-Basset
analyst_mohamed@zu.edu.eg
Extended author information available on the last page of the article
Multimedia Tools and Applications (2020) 79:9977–10002
Published online: 28 May 2019
/
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... The weighted average methodology is utilized to implement the membership function with the fuzzy interference system. More details about fuzzy and deep learning techniques can be found in (Jha et al., 2020;Son et al., 2020a;Abdel-Basset et al., 2020;Dey et al., 2020a;Son et al., 2020b;Son et al., 2020c;Son et al., 2020d;Giang et al., 2020;Dey et al., 2020b;Koo et al., 2020;Ngan et al., 2020;Jha et al., 2019a;Nguyen et al., 2019a;Jha et al., 2019b;Son and Fujita, 2019;Tuan et al., 2019;Long et al., 2019a;Kaur et al., 2019;ThongLuu QuocDat et al., 2019;Dat et al., 2019;Popa et al., 2019;Long et al., 2019b;Harold Robinson et al., 2019;Tey et al., 2019;Gai Quek et al., 2019;Nguyen et al., 2019b;Vo et al., 2019a;Vo et al., 2019b;Long et al., 2019c;Le et al., 2019;Le et al., 2018). ...
Fuzzy Logic based Smart Irrigation System using Internet of Things
Article
Traditional agricultural systems require huge amount of power for field watering. This paper proposes a smart irrigation system that helps farmers water their agricultural fields using Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM). This system provides acknowledgement messages about the job's statuses such as humidity level of soil, temperature of surrounding environment, and status of motor regarding main power supply or solar power. Fuzzy logic controller is used to compute input parameters (e.g. soil moisture, temperature and humidity) and to produce outputs of motor status. In addition, the system also switches off the motor to save the power when there is an availability of rain and also prevents the crop using panels from unconditional rain. The comparison is made between the proposed system, drip irrigation and manual flooding. The comparison results prove that water and power conservation are obtained through the proposed smart irrigation system.
... Currently, doctors must manually diagnose and anticipate the condition based on their knowledge, experience, and observations. It poses a challenge for healthcare practitioners since it results in extremely high rates of mortality and morbidity (Abdel-Basset et al. 2020). Developing healthcare systems based on patient data models and technologies can significantly improve the decision-making process. ...
Quantum K-means clustering method for detecting heart disease using quantum circuit approach
Article
Full-text available
The development of noisy intermediate- scale quantum computers is expected to signify the potential advantages of quantum computing over classical computing. This paper focuses on quantum paradigm usage to speed up unsupervised machine learning algorithms particularly the K-means clustering method. The main approach is to build a quantum circuit that performs the distance calculation required for the clustering process. This proposed technique is a collaboration of data mining techniques with quantum computation. Initially, extracted heart disease dataset is preprocessed and classical K-means clustering performance is evaluated. Later, the quantum concept is applied to the classical approach of the clustering algorithm. The comparative analysis is performed between quantum and classical processing to check performance metrics.
... With the rapid development and popular application of computer and information technology, the industry application data is exploding, and society has stepped into the era of big data and the digital economy. As a strategic asset of the industrial enterprises and the country, big data has been officially listed as an important production factor in the data economy era and plays a key role in the development of the data economy [3]. is study not only is a theoretical discussion but also provides a reasonable implementation mechanism and strategy choice for the change and innovation of school art curriculum based on the theoretical analysis, which will provide a policy basis for the construction and change of school art curriculum in practice, and for redesigning art curriculum, fundamentally ensuring the selection of art education paths, goals, and models under new media in schools and the operation and implementation of specific art curriculum [4]. e average comprehensive index of each management unit is 75.56, 25 are higher than the average index, accounting for 69.44%, 11 are lower than the average index, accounting for 30.56%, ...
Construction of Higher Education Management Data Analysis Model Based on Association Rules
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2022
This paper adopts the analytical method of intelligent programming to conduct in-depth research and analysis on university education management and designs a corresponding university education management model to be applied in actual teaching. Based on the basic theories and methods of big data distributed data mining and machine learning, automated machine learning, and big data programming computational methods, this paper combines the importance and technical challenges of the algorithms themselves and the background of the practical application needs of the industry and firstly selects a series of data mining and machine learning algorithms that are commonly used based on high complexity, outstanding computational efficiency problems, and difficult to design distributed algorithms. The research on efficient large-scale distributed parallelized data mining and machine learning methods and algorithms is carried out. As an innovative teaching model, the experiential teaching model focuses on the cultivation of individual students’ independent learning ability and subjective initiative, which not only can effectively activate the classroom atmosphere and improve the teaching effect but also meet the requirements of classroom teaching for the development of the times. The empirical evidence of the experiential teaching model proposed in this paper is carried out, and the implementation process of the experiential teaching model of high school physics is further improved. In terms of the overall implementation effect, the experiential teaching model proposed in the paper can deepen students’ understanding of concepts and physical laws, thus enabling them to solve physics problems better, and has a positive and active effect on enhancing students’ learning interests and attitudes. In the case of system security, the average comprehensive index of each unit is 61.11, 22 are higher than the average index, accounting for 61.11%, 14 are lower than the average index, accounting for 38.89%, and 23 management departments’ management systems passed the safety monitoring, accounting for 63.89%. At the same time, the proposed model also provides educational practitioners with a more reliable framework for instructional design, which has realistic reference value and significance.
... Basset et al. [48] proposed a robust ranking methodology for managing green supply chains in a neutrosophic setting. Basset et al. [49] developed a neutrosophic multi-criteria decision-making methodology to assist patients and physicians in determining if a patient has heart failure. ...
Entropy and Correlation Coefficients of Neutrosophic and Interval-Valued Neutrosophic Hypersoft Set with application of Multi-Attributive Problems
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2022
In computational intelligence, machine learning, image processing, neural networks, medical diagnostics, and decision analysis, the ideas of correlation coefficients and entropy have practical applications. By applying hypersoft set (HSS) in neutrosophic environment provides a good model for describing and addressing uncertainties. In statistics, the correlation coefficient between two variables is crucial. Furthermore, the accuracy of the correlation assessment is dependent on data from the discourse set. The main focus of this study, is to develop entropy for (NHSS) and generalized correlation coefficient interval-valued neutrosophic hypersoft-set (IVNHSS). We proposed some theorems on entropy along with algorithms based on correlation and weighted correlation coefficients in the context of NHSs and IVNHSS. The validity and superiority are presented along with application and also comparison is made with existing approaches.
A Review on IoT-Driven Technologies for Heart Disease Diagnosis and Prediction
Chapter
  • Jun 2022
People around the world are at risk from chronic diseases like cancer, heart disease, and diabetes. When it comes to sudden cardiac arrest, many people have recently become increasingly concerned. The main cause of death in the world is heart disease. Because it needs both experience and advanced knowledge, predicting heart disease is a difficult assignment. Sensor values are being collected for heart disease detection and prediction using internet of things (IoT), which has recently been implemented in healthcare systems. In order to achieve a continuous remote cardiac monitoring system, IoT and wireless technology have advanced significantly over the past several years. The use of various sensors, such as electrocardiograms (ECGs), thermometers, and blood pressure monitors to collect important body signals and diagnose illnesses has resulted in the creation of a wireless body area network. The diagnosis of cardiac disease findings is low in accuracy. The goal is to highlight IoT-driven technologies that have been used in the literature for diagnosing and forecasting heart disease.
A hybrid GA and PSO optimized approach for heart-disease prediction based on random forest
Article
Full-text available
Nowadays, heart diseases are significantly contributing to deaths all over the world. Thus, heart-disease prediction has garnered considerable attention in the medical domain globally. Accordingly, machine-learning algorithms for the early prediction of heart diseases were developed in several studies to help physicians design medical procedures. In this study, a hybrid genetic algorithm (GA) and particle swarm optimization (PSO) optimized approach based on random forest (RF), called GAPSO-RF, is developed and used to select the optimal features that can increase the accuracy of heart-disease prediction. The proposed GAPSO-RF implements multivariate statistical analysis in the first step to select the most significant features used in the initial population. After that, a discriminate mutation strategy is implemented in GA. GAPSO-RF combines a modified GA for global search and a PSO for local search. Moreover, PSO achieved the concept of rehabbing individuals that had been refused in the selection process. The performance of the proposed GAPSO-RF approach is validated via evaluation metrics, namely, accuracy, specificity, sensitivity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve by using two datasets from the University of California, namely, Cleveland and Statlog. The experimental results confirm that the GAPSO-RF approach attained the high heart-disease-prediction accuracies of 95.6% and 91.4% on the Cleveland and Statlog datasets, respectively. Furthermore, the proposed approach outperformed other state-of-the-art prediction methods.
Modified local binary patterns based feature extraction and hyper parameters tuned attention segmental recurrent neural network classifier using flamingo search optimization algorithm for disease diagnosis model
Article
  • Jul 2022
In this article, the modified local binary patterns based feature extraction and hyper parameters tuned attention segmental recurrent neural network classifier with flamingo search optimization algorithm (MLBPFE‐ASRNNFSOAC‐DDM) is proposed for the disease diagnosis model. Here, breast cancer, diabetic, chronic kidney diseases diagnosis model is implemented. Initially, images are considered as dataset for disease diagnosis, which is given to the altered phase preserving dynamic range compression (APPDRC) scheme for preprocessing process. This APPDRC is used to preserve local features for boundary detection, thus; recovers image quality. Then the morphological, grayscale statistical and Haralick texture features are taken from preprocessed image with the help of modified local binary pattern process. The extracted features are given with attention segmented recurrent neural network (ASRNN) for classification. Then the weight parameters of ASRNN classifier are optimized by flamingo search optimization algorithm (FSOA), which increases the classification accuracy. This simulation process is accomplished at MATLAB platform. The proposed method, during Diabetic Diagnosis Model attains higher accuracy 16.4%, 21.45%, 30.38%, and 21.01% compared with the existing methods like FE‐ResNetV2DNNMSOC‐DDM and CMVHHO‐DKMLC‐DDM, CNN‐CAD‐DDM, and AD‐CFDRI‐SDL, respectively. During breast cancer Diagnosis Model attains higher accuracy 27.3%, 20.56%, 31.34%, and 25.13% compared with the existing methods like CMVHHO‐DKMLC‐BCM and SVMFE‐OPFPSOC‐BCM, MLPNN‐CNN‐BCM, and DCNN‐EL‐BCM, respectively.
Non-contact Methods for Heart Rate Measurement: A Review
Conference Paper
  • Dec 2021
A novel fuzzy knowledge graph pairs approach in decision making
Article
Full-text available
Fuzzy Knowledge Graph (FKG) has recently been emerging as one of the key techniques for supporting classification and decision-making problems. FKG is a novel concept that was firstly introduced in 2020 by integrating approximate reasoning with inference mechanism to find labels of new records, which are impossible for inference by the rule base. However, one of the key limitations of FKG is the use of a single pair to find new records’ label that leads to low performance in approximation. This paper presents a novel approach of using FKG pairs instead of a single pair as in the classical model. A novel FKG-Pairs model including a new representing method and an approximation algorithm is presented. Theoretical analysis of the FKG-Pairs model such as identification of a threshold for the best value (k∗) pairs is also investigated. Finally, to validate the proposed model, a numerical example and the experiments on the UCI datasets are presented. In addition, a two-way ANOVA method is also conducted to validate the model statistically. The novel concept about the FKG-Pairs given in this paper exposes new ideas in the effort to realize the much-anticipated decision-making and classification problems in fuzzy systems
Analysis and risk estimation system for heart attack using EDENN algorithm
Article
  • Apr 2022
Heart related diseases are very common in the present scenario. In the past two decades the number of heart patients have increased to a large extent. Due to this abrupt rise in the number of patients, the death count has also increased. Thus, an efficient and accurate system must be developed for the diagnosis of heart related diseases, as the present methods available are not accurate enough and are insufficient for the Heart Attack (HA) and its Risk Analysis (RA). This paper propounds a system for HA risk estimation by the use of an Enhanced Deep Elman Neural Network (EDENN). In this system a Photoplethysmography (PPG) signal is inputted and pre-processed for noise removal. Further, Signal Decomposition (SD) is done, and the vital signs are estimated like Blood Pressure (BP), Respiratory Rate (RR) and Cardiac Autonomic Nervous System (CANS). For the BP estimation, Modified Maximum Amplitude Algorithm (MMAA) method is used and for the decomposed signal processing the Improved Incremental Merge Segmentation (IIMS) is used. As for features, Variation of amplitude, frequency and intensity are calculated and merged.
Linguistic Approaches to Interval Complex Neutrosophic Sets in Decision Making
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2020
One of the most efficient tools for modeling uncertainty in decision-making problems is the neutrosophic set (NS) and its extensions, such as complex NS (CNS), interval NS (INS), and interval complex NS (ICNS). Linguistic variables have been long recognized as a useful tool in decision-making problems for solving the problem of crisp neutrosophic membership degree. In this paper, we aim to introduce new concepts: single-valued linguistic complex neutrosophic set (SVLCNS-2) and interval linguistic complex neutrosophic set (ILCNS-2) that are more applicable and adjustable to real-world implementation than those of their previous counterparts. Some set-theoretic operations and the operational rules of SVLCNS-2 and ILCNS-2 are designed. Then, gather classifications of the candidate versus criteria, gather the significance weights, gather the weighted rankings of candidates versus criteria and a score function to arrange the candidates are determined. New TOPSIS decision-making procedures in SVLCNS-2 and ICNS-2 are presented and applied to lecturer selection in the case study of the University of Economics and Business, Vietnam National University. The applications demonstrate the usefulness and efficiency of the proposal.
Towards granular calculus of single-valued neutrosophic functions under granular computing
Article
Full-text available
Neutrosophic theory studies objects whose values vary in the sets of elements and are not true or false, but in between, that can be called by neutral, indeterminate, unclear, vague, ambiguous, incomplete or contradictory quantities. In this paper, we firstly introduce preliminaries on granular calculus and analysis related to single-valued neutrosophic functions. Based on horizontal membership functions approach, we establish some basic arithmetic operations of single-valued neutrosophic numbers, that red allow us to directly introduce the terms of neutrosophic function in usual mathematical formulas. Additionally, we build metrics on the space of single-valued neutrosophic numbers induced from Hamming distance. Then, we define some backgrounds on the limit, derivative and integral of single-valued neutrosophic functions. Finally, in order to demonstrate the usable of our theoretical results, we present some applications to well-known problems arising in engineering such as logistic model, the inverted pendulum system, Mass - Spring - Damper model.
Energy efficient fog-assisted IoT system for monitoring diabetic patients with cardiovascular disease
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2019
Blood glucose plays an important role in maintaining body's activities. For example, brain only uses glucose as its energy source. However, when blood glucose level is abnormal, it causes some serious consequences. For instance, low-blood glucose phenomenon referred to as hypoglycemia can cause heart repolarization and induce cardiac arrhythmia causing sudden cardiac deaths. Diabetes, which can be viewed as a high-blood glucose level for a long period of time, is a dangerous disease as it can directly or indirectly cause heart attack, stroke, heart failure, and other vicious diseases. A solution for reducing the serious consequences caused by diabetes and hypoglycemia is to continuously monitor blood glucose level for real-time responses such as adjusting insulin levels from the insulin pump. Nonetheless, it is a misstep when merely monitoring blood glucose without considering other signals or data such as Electrocardiography (ECG) and activity status since they have close relationships. When hypoglycemia occurs, a fall can easily occur especially in case of people over 65 years old. Fall's consequences are more hazardous when a fall is not detected. Therefore, we present a Fog-based system for remote health monitoring and fall detection. Through the system, both e-health signals such as glucose, ECG, body temperature and contextual data such as room temperature, humidity, and air quality can be monitored remotely in real-time. By leveraging Fog computing at the edge of the network, the system offers many advanced services such as ECG feature extraction, security, and local distributed storage. Results show that the system works accurately and the wearable sensor node is energy efficient. Even though the node is equipped with many types of sensors, it can operate in a secure way for up to 157 h per a single charge when applying a 1000 mAh Lithium battery.
Neutrosophic soft set decision making for stock trending analysis
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2019
In this paper, we point out a major issue of stock market regarding trending scenario of trades where data exactness, accuracy of expressing data and uncertainty of values (closing point of the day) are lacked. We use neutrosophic soft sets (NSS) consisting of three factors (True, Uncertainty and False) to deal with exact state of data in several directions. A new approach based on NSS is proposed for stock value prediction based on real data from last 7 years. It calculates the stock price based on the factors like “open”, “high”, “low” and “adjacent close”. The highest score value retrieved from the score function is used to determine which opening price and high price decide the closing price from the above mentioned four factors.
A novel method for solving the fully neutrosophic linear programming problems
Article
Full-text available
The most widely used technique for solving and optimizing a real-life problem is linear programming (LP), due to its simplicity and efficiency. However, in order to handle the impreciseness in the data, the neutrosophic set theory plays a vital role which makes a simulation of the decision-making process of humans by considering all aspects of decision (i.e., agree, not sure and disagree). By keeping the advantages of it, in the present work, we have introduced the neutrosophic LP models where their parameters are represented with a trapezoidal neutrosophic numbers and presented a technique for solving them. The presented approach has been illustrated with some numerical examples and shows their superiority with the state of the art by comparison. Finally, we conclude that proposed approach is simpler, efficient and capable of solving the LP models as compared to other methods.
Systematic Review of Decision Making Algorithms in Extended Neutrosophic Sets
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2018
The Neutrosophic set (NS) has grasped concentration by its ability for handling indeterminate, uncertain, incomplete, and inconsistent information encountered in daily life. Recently, there have been various extensions of the NS, such as single valued neutrosophic sets (SVNSs), Interval neutrosophic sets (INSs), bipolar neutrosophic sets (BNSs), Refined Neutrosophic Sets (RNSs), and triangular fuzzy number neutrosophic set (TFNNs). This paper contains an extended overview of the concept of NS as well as several instances and extensions of this model that have been introduced in the last decade, and have had a significant impact in literature. Theoretical and mathematical properties of NS and their counterparts are discussed in this paper as well. Neutrosophic-set-driven decision making algorithms are also overviewed in detail.
Dynamic interval valued neutrosophic set: Modeling decision making in dynamic environments
Article
Distributed machine learning cloud teleophthalmology IoT for predicting AMD disease progression
Article
The ability to perform screening of potential vision-impairing diseases remotely with an Ophthalmologist-in-the-loop is crucial in serving the Medically Underserved Areas/Population (MUA/P) and in acute medical settings, such as emergency departments. With an estimated 217 million individuals affected by moderate to severe vision-impairing diseases worldwide and an increasing number of new patients with such diseases, the need for access to faster (or real-time) diagnosis on a large scale is imperative. It is evident that early diagnosis of chronic diseases such as diabetic retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration (AMD) could better prevent vision loss. In this paper, a scalable cloud based teleophthalmology architecture via the Internet of Medical Things (IoMT) for diagnosis of AMD is presented. In the proposed architecture, patients wear a head-mounted camera (OphthoAI IoMT headset) to send their retinal fundus images to their secure and private cloud drive storage for personalized disease severity detection and predictive progression analysis. A proposed AMD-ResNet convolution neural network with 152 layers will then analyze the images to identify and determine AMD disease severity. The algorithm is trained with AREDS (age related eye disease study) images from the National Institute of Health (NIH) with over 130,000 fundus images captured over 12 years, and for determining AMD severity, we achieve a sensitivity and specificity of 94.97 ± 0.5% and 98.32 ± 0.1% respectively. A temporal Long–Short Term Memory (LSTM) deep neural network for precision medicine and AMD predictive progression is also proposed. Patient personalization allows better targeted care, lesser side effects, and a greater likelihood of responding to treatments by tailoring healthcare on a per-patient basis.
A novel approach for fuzzy clustering based on neutrosophic association matrix
Article
A novel approach for diagnosing heart disease with hybrid classifier
Article
  • Jan 2018
A Cardiovascular disease which is additionally referred to as heart diseases that have been a common and steady issue in the field of medical research. Nowadays various methods were applied which is not robust for the prediction of human being expenses and disease risks for patients. This paper proposed an Orthogonal Local Preserving Projection (OLPP) method to reduce the function dimension of the input high-dimensional data. The dimension reduction improves the prediction rate with the help of hybrid classifier i.e. Group Search Optimization Algorithm (GSO) combine with the Levenberg-Marquardt (LM) training algorithm in the neural network. The LM training algorithm is used to solve the optimization problem and it determines the best network parameters such as weights and bias that minimizes the error. The final output of the optimization technique is combined with the performance metrics as accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity. From the result, it is observed that hybrid optimization techniques increase the accuracy of the heart disease prediction system.