PresentationPDF Available

Caroline Raat, De positie van de klokkenluider

Presentation

Caroline Raat, De positie van de klokkenluider

Abstract

Presentatie van Caroline Raat voor de Vereniging voor de Sociaalwetenschappelijke Bestudering van het Recht over de positie van klokkenluiders en de 'lastige-mensen-aanpak'.
3UHVHQWDWLHELMGH965VWXGLHPLGGDJ
³:LHEHWDDOWEHSDDOW´
GGPDDUW
'HNORNNHQOXLGHULVGRRG
/DQJOHYHGHPHOG,1*
GRRUHHQPHOGHU
&DUROLQH5DDW
,QGHSHQGHQW5HVHDUFKHUYRRU2SHQ*RYHUQPHQW 3DUWQHUVKLS0LQ%=.
2QGHU]RHNHUDGYLVHXULQWHJULWHLWVNZHVWLHV ZRPHOGLQJHQELMGLYHUVHRYHUKHGHQ
$XWHXURYHUNORNNHQOXLGHQRPYRRU-XVWLWLsOHYHUNHQQLQJHQ:2'&
$QQRWDWRURP9DQ5H\ HQ6SLMNHUV
5HFKWVELMVWDQGVYHUOHQHURPDDQPHOGHQGHDPEWHQDUHQ
:DDURPJHHQNORNNHQOXLGHU"
 :RRUGEHGDFKWGRRU%RYHQVMDUHQ¶
 :HWWHOLMNZHUNQHPHU GLHPHOGLQJGRHWHQGLH
EHVFKHUPLQJNULMJW
 'RHWQXPHHUNZDDGGDQJRHG
± ³,HGHUHHQLVNORNNHQOXLGHU´
± 3RVLWLHEHKDQGHOLQJYDQNORNNHQOXLGHULVQLHWXQLHN
± :RRUGLVSRVLWLHIQHJDWLHIEHODGHQ
± :RRUGYHUOHJWRQEHGRHOGGHDDQGDFKWYDQPHOGLQJ
QDDUPHOGHUµDDQNODJHU¶
 'DDURPWLMGYRRUQHXWUDOHUHWHUP
 PHOG,1* GRRUPHOGHU
³,HGHUHHQLVNORNNHQOXLGHU´
 9DDNJHEUXLNWYRRUGRRULHPDQGGLHµOHNW¶
QDDUGHPHGLD
 9HHOPHQVHQPHWHHQKDUGQHNNLJ
HUYDUHQSUREOHHPQRHPHQ]LFK]R
± &OLsQWHQLQGH]RUJ
.ODQWHQYDQJURWHEHGULMYHQ
³,HGHUHHQLVNORNNHQOXLGHU´ 
 ,QZRQHUVPHWSUREOHPHQPHWGHRYHUKHLG
 :HUNQHPHUVPHWHHQSUREOHHPPHWKXQEDDV
$G%RV
 ³=LHNHQGHEXUJHUV´µ'RUGWVHKXLVMHVPHONHU¶
 0HQVHQPHWSDUDQRLDTXHUXODQV
±RRU]DDNJHYROJ""+22)'/(77(56
VDPHQ]ZHULQJVWKHRULHsQZDUULJHRQEHJULMSHOLMNHWHNVWHQ
GUHLJHPHQWHQVFKHUPHQPHWUHODWLHVHQµEHZLM]HQ¶
RRNDQWLVRFLDOHQDUFLVWLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ"
1%HHUVWRQGHU]RHNHQRIKHWSUREOHHPZHOµEHVWDDW¶«
3RVLWLHNORNNHQOXLGHULVQLHWXQLHN
 'RRUGHRUJDQLVDWLHJH]LHQDOVODVWLJ
HYHQDOV
± $XWRQRRPGHQNHQGHZHUNQHPHUV
± $VVHUWLHYHEXUJHUV
± 0RQGLJHFOLsQWHQLQGH]RUJ
± 2QWHYUHGHQNODQWHQYDQHHQEHGULMI
± $FWLYLVWHQ
 =LMNULMJHQGHµODVWLJHPHQVHQDDQSDN¶
.ORNNHQOXLGHULVEHODGHQZRRUG
 3RVLWLHIKHOGµYHUWHOWGHZDDUKHLG¶OR\DDO
VODFKWRIIHU
 1HJDWLHIQHVWEHYXLOHUYHUUDGHUQLHWOR\DDO
SLHWOXWRQJHKRRU]DPHODVWSDNGDGHU
+HWZRRUGYHUOHJWGHDDQGDFKWQDDUGHSHUVRRQYDQGH
PHOGHU
± -HNXQWHUQLHWQHXWUDDOWHJHQRYHUVWDDQ
± +HWORRSWDOWLMGVOHFKWPHWGHPHOGHUDI
7HUZLMOKHWRQGHUZHUSYUDDJWRP]DNHOLMNHQXFKWHUH
REMHFWLHYHDDQSDN
0HOGHUDOVLQIRUPDQW µEHNODDJGH¶ RRNJRHGEHVFKHUPG
:HW+XLVYRRUNORNNHQOXLGHUV
 'RHODPELJX
± 1LHXZHRQGHU]RHNVRUJDQLVDWLH
,QHHQKXLVPHWDGYLHV HQYHUZLMVSXQW
 0HWGDDUWXVVHQFKLQHVHZDOO
± %HWHUEHQDGHOLQJVYHUERGLQ$PEWHQDUHQZHW
± 1LHXZEHQDGHOLQJVYHUERGLQ%:
 *HHQRPJHNHHUGHEHZLMVODVWFRQIRUP
5HVROXWLH5DDGYDQ(XURSDSDUO$VVHPEOHH
± 1LHWYRRU]]S¶HUVYULMZLOOLJHUVEHVWXXUGHUVHWF
 +XLVEHVFKHUPWJHHQPHOGHUV
GDDUYRRUQDDUGHUHFKWHU
 *URWHYUDDJZDWGRHW+XLVZHOHQZDWQLHWDDQ
RQGHU]RHNYROJHQVGHZHW"
3RVLWLHPHOGHQGHDPEWHQDDU
6FHQDULRµODVWLJHPHQVHQDDQSDN¶
 $OVGHPHOGHU]LFKQLHWODDWWHJHQKRXGHQGRRU
SUHNHQGUHLJHPHQWHQ
 2QVFKDGHOLMNPDNHQGRRU
± )UDPLQJQHJDWLHYHRSGHPDQJHULFKWH
NZDOLILFDWLHVLQELMYEHRRUGHOLQJHQSOHLWQRWD¶VHWF
± 6WRU\WHOOLQJRSEDVLVYDQKHWIUDPHHHQHHQYRXGLJ
KDSNODDUYHUKDDOYRRUKRXGHQ
(HQJUHHSXLWHLJHQHQDQGHUHGRVVLHUV
± ;LVQLHWIOH[LEHOHQKHHIWJHHQJHYRHOYRRUEHVWXXUOLMNH
YHUKRXGLQJHQLGHDDOYRRUVOHFKWHEHRRUGHOLQJHQ
± ;LVRQFROOHJLDDOQLHWOR\DDORQJHKRRU]DDP
± ;LV]LHNLQ]LMQKRRIGYE)UHG6SLMNHU
± ;IXQFWLRQHHUWQLHWJRHGVQDSWµLQHHQV¶ ]LMQHLJHQZHUNQLHW
PHHUYE*RWOLHE
± ;SOHHJWVHNVXHOHLQWLPLGDWLHEOHHNPDLOZLVVHOLQJPHW]LMQ
HLJHQSDUWQHUWH]LMQ
± ;LVUHFKWVPLVEUXLNHUYRRUDODOVKLM]DNHQGUHLJWWHZLQQHQRI
EHZLMVGUHLJWWHYHUJDUHQ
± ;LVSURFHV]LHNHQZHHWYDQJHHQRSKRXGHQ
.ZDOLILFDWLHVRUJDQLVDWLHGRRUPHOGHUV
1%PDDNRQGHUVFKHLGWXVVHQLQFLGHQWHQ
VWUXFWXUHOHSUREOHPHQ
 (UKHHUVWHHQDQJVWFXOWXXU
MDDUYHUVODJ$3.
± 5RO+5032
± ,QWLPLGDWLHEHGUHLJLQJSHVWHQ]ZDUWPDNHULM
 (ULVVSUDNHYDQPDFKWVPLVEUXLN
± )UDXGH]HOIYHUULMNLQJYULHQGMHVSROLWLHN
± 7DDNYHUVFKXLYLQJGXVYHUZDDUOR]LQJ
± :HJZHUNHQµWHJHQVWDQGHUV¶ GRRUGH]HWH
EHVFKXOGLJHQYDQYHU]RQQHQQLHWLQWHJHUKDQGHOHQ
.ZDOLILFDWLHVRUJDQLVDWLH
 (ULVVSUDNHYDQSHUPLVVLYLWHLW
± 0DDURQJHOLMNGHHHQPDJDOOHVGHDQGHUQLHWV
± µGRRUJHVFKRWHQJHSROGHU¶ZHNLMNHQZHJHQ
SUREOHPHQORVVHQZHLQIRUPHHORSGRRUµLMVNDVW¶
µUHIUDPHQ¶YHUJRHOLMNHQµRQWNHQQHQ¶
 *HHQFKHFNV DQGEDODQFHVNZDOLWHLWV]RUJ
± 0HQVHQNXQQHQRQJHFRQWUROHHUGKXQJDQJJDDQ
± 'HVNXQGLJHQMXULVWHQZRUGHQSDVLQJHVFKDNHOGDOV
HUSURFHGXUHV]LMQ
± +HWUHFKWLVHHQPLGGHORPHONZHQVHOLMNGRHOWH
EHUHLNHQJHHQZDDUGHRS]LFK]HOI³0LMQMXULVWHQ]LMQ
7RP3RH]HQ]LMYHU]LQQHQHHQOLVW´
1XJDDWKHWGXVRPGHPHOGHU«
³6FHQDULR´
 0HOGHUGDQQRJQDwHIGRHWPHOGLQJYDDNQD
SRJLQJHQRPLQIRUPHHORSWHORVVHQ
0HOGLQJZRUGWQLHWRIµPHUNZDDUGLJ¶ RQGHU]RFKW
± µKHWLVJHHQPLVVWDQGYROJHQVRQ]HGHILQLWLH¶
± 0HOGHULVRQJHORRIZDDUGLJUDQFXQHXV
± ,QWHUQRIVRPV]HOIVH[WHUQRQGHU]RHNGRRURIRQGHU
UHJLHYDQEHWURNNHQHQ
± &RQFOXVLHYHUVWRSWLQGLNNHEHOHLGVVWXNNHQ
 *HKHLPKRXGLQJVEHVOXLWHQRSOHJJLQJ
 0HOGHUµ]LHWGHEXLDOKDQJHQ¶«
0HOGHUZRUGWNDOWJHVWHOOW
 2S]LMQDIGHOLQJZRUGWNDUDNWHUPRRUGJHSOHHJGµ]ZDUW
VFKDDS¶
± µ3HVWHQGRRUGHZLWWHVFKDSHQ¶GLHGDDUYRRUVRPVZRUGHQ
µEHORRQG¶³JDUDQWLHRSSURPRWLH´
± ,QIRUPHHOEXLWHQJHVORWHQ
± XLWGHPDLOJURHS
± QLHWPHHUVDPHQOXQFKHQHWF
± µJUDSSHQ¶ HQµSODJHQ¶
± :HUNSOHNYHUSODDWVW]HOIVLQNHOGHU
± µ6SLRQHUHQHQYHUVODJOHJJHQ¶
± :HUN]DDPKHGHQDIJHQRPHQRIMXLVWWHYHHOZHUNYHUYHOHQG
ZHUNEHQHGHQHLJHQQLYHDX
 0HOGHUJDDWGLVIXQFWLRQHUHQZRUGW]LHN
± 3URWHVWWHJHQJDQJYDQ]DNHQZRUGWJHNZDOLILFHHUGDOVµ]LHMH
ZHOMHEHQWODVWLJHQQLHWIOH[LEHO¶
³'RVVLHURSERXZ´
 1DUHIXQFWLRQHULQJVJHVSUHNNHQURO32
± µ$OVMHGRRUJDDWPHWGLHPHOGLQJKHHIWGDWJHYROJHQ
YRRUMHEHRRUGHOLQJ¶
± *HYROJGGRRUYHUSOLFKWHWZHHZHNHOLMNVH
YRRUWJDQJVJHVSUHNNHQ
± 9HUSOLFKWLQJRPDOOHVYRRU
DNNRRUGWHWHNHQHQµDQGHUV¶«
 6OHFKWHEHRRUGHOLQJ
± 9HUSOLFKWHDVVHVVPHQWV HQWUDLQLQJHQ
 *HHQERQXVSURPRWLH
 5HHNVYDQWLMGHOLMNHWHZHUNVWHOOLQJHQHOGHUVLQGH
RUJDQLVDWLH
6WUDIRQWVODJRIRQWVODJZHJHQVµLPSDVVH¶
 5HFKWVPLGGHOHQZRUGHQµQLHWRSSULMVJHVWHOG¶
± µ=LHMHZHOKLMOHJW]LFKQHUJHQVELMQHHU¶
± µ1XNRPWLH]RPDDUPHWHHQDGYRFDDW¶
± :HUNJHYHUVFKDNHOW]HOIRRNDOYURHJWLMGLJDGYRFDDWLQ
µPDFKWVYHUWRRQ¶
 5HFKWVPLGGHOHQVWDQGDDUGµDIJHZH]HQ¶
± *HVSUHNLVQLHWPRJHOLMN
0HGLDWLRQµJHEUXLNW¶ DOVGUXNPLGGHORPDNNRRUGWHJDDQ
PHWQDGHOLJHRQZHWWLJHUHJHOLQJHQYRRUDO
JHKHLPKRXGLQJRSRQGHUZHUSPHOGLQJ
 0HGLDWLRQODWHQPLVOXNNHQRPGDWZHUNJHYHUQLHWHFKW
EHUHLGLVWRWVFKLNNHQ
 µ$DQVWXUHQRSHVFDODWLH¶VFKXOGPHOGHU
 0HOGHUJDDWRRNHVFDOHUHQUDDNWZDQKRSLJ³,PSDVVH´
3URFHVJHGUDJZHUNJHYHU
=DDNIUDPHQ DOVµJHZRRQDUEHLGVFRQIOLFW¶
± µ8LWHUDDUGEHQDGHOHQZLMJHHQNORNNHQOXLGHUGDWEOLMNWXLWRQ]H
PRWLYHULQJYDQKHWRQWVODJ¶
± µ'H]HPHGHZHUNHUOHYHUWJHZRRQVOHFKWZHUN¶
± +LMOLJWVOHFKWRSGHDIGHOLQJZHKHEEHQ]HOIVVFKULIWHOLMNH
YHUNODULQJHQYDQ]LMQFROOHJD¶V
± µ+LMZLO0HOGHUIUDPHQ DOVµODVWLJ¶QLHWLQWKHUDSLH¶
± µ+LMYHU]LQWGLQJHQKLMEHVFKXOGLJWRQVYDQYDQDOOHVPDDU
EHZLMVWQLHWV¶ GDWKRHIWRRNQLHWYROJHQVGHZHW
± 2YHUGULMYHQYDQDDQWDOOHQSURFHGXUHVJHYRHUGGRRUGHPHOGHU
± µ(UYDOWQLHWPHHWHSUDWHQZLMKHEEHQHUDOOHVDDQJHGDDQRP
]LMQJHGUDJWHYHUEHWHUHQPDDUKLMZLOQLHW«¶
 :HUNJHYHUNDQYROVWDDQPHWHHQYRXGLJGRVVLHU
± /DDWYDDNµODVWLJHGHWDLOV¶ ZHJ
'HEHVWXXUVUHFKWHU
 $PEWHQDUHQUHFKWHULQHHUVWHDDQOHJ
 LVµJHZRQHURXOHUHQGHUHFKWHU¶PHHVWDO
 JHHQVSHFLDOLVWDPEWHQDUHQUHFKW
 PHHVWDOHQNHOYRXGLJHNDPHU
 .LMNWDOOHHQQDDUKHWYRRUOLJJHQGHEHVOXLW
± 1LHWQDDUKHWDFKWHUOLJJHQGHµYHUKDDO¶
± 3DVWEHZLMVUHFKWQLHWDOWLMGJRHGWRH
 :HUNJHYHUPRHWEHZLMVDDQGUDJHQYRRUKHWEHVOXLWPDDU
 0HOGHUPRHWYROOHGLJEHZLMVDDQOHYHUHQYRRUFDXVDDOYHUEDQGPHW
PHOGLQJ
.RPWµXLWSXUHHOOHQGH¶ PHWGLNNHGRVVLHUVHQYHHOGHWDLOV
$OVZHUNJHYHUµGRPZHJRQWNHQW¶ GDW]R¶QYHUEDQGHULV
GDQOXNWKHWQLHWµJHZRRQDUEHLGVFRQIOLFW¶
± 5HFKWHULVRRNHHQPHQVHQJHYRHOLJYRRUIUDPLQJHIIHFW HQ
FRJQLWLYHELDVKHWYHUKDDOYDQGHZHUNJHYHULVDOKDSNODDU
RSJHGLHQG
&RQFOXVLH
'RHKHWQLHW
HQ]HNHUQLHWDOOHHQ
HQSDVDOVMHHHQDQGHUHEDDQKHEW
2QGHU]RHNHUYDQPRJHOLMNHPLVVWDQGHQ
 %OLMIDXWRQRRP
 /DDWMHOHLGHQYHUUDVVHQGRRUGHIHLWHQ
 (pQLQFLGHQWPDDNWQRJJHHQµIRXWHRUJDQLVDWLH¶
 9HUWURXZRRNRSMHLQWXwWLH
 :HHVELMHHQPRJHOLMNQHJDWLHYHXLWNRPVWDOHUWRS
µRQGHUPLMQLQJ¶
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.