PresentationPDF Available

Supporting migrant origin students to achieve academic success. A critical grounded theory in Italian middle school

Authors:
Giovanna Malusà at Free University of Bozen-Bolzano
Giovanna Malusà
Download file PDF
Read file
Download citation

Abstract

To ensure inclusive and equitable quality education for all was one of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals adopted by the UN in 2015. However, the recent global increase in refugees and the complex needs of “post-migrants” (Zoletto, 2012) are profoundly challenging the official inclusion policies of European societies (Catarci, Gomes, & Siqueira, 2017). National and international surveys (OECD, 2016) show that the school failure rates of migrant origin students (MOS) are higher than those of their native peers. The data underline the urgent need to unite research, practice, and policy to reduce inequality in education (Suárez-Orozco, Yoshikawa, & Tseng, 2015), assuming a critical social justice perspective (Tarozzi & Torres, 2016) to shape a global citizenship education that promotes an equitable global society (Torres, 2017). My study, set in Northern Italy, attempts to identify an effective model to support the inclusion of MOS, exploring the following research question: How can they best be enabled to achieve academic success? The research is part of a complex mixed-method “Sequential explanatory design” (Creswell, 2013) quantQUAL, in which I have adopted a critical, constructivist, grounded theory method (Charmaz, 2014). The simultaneous data collection and analysis (2014-2017) involved open and focused observations (82 hours) in 5 middle schools, 28 recorded semi-structured interviews (19 hours) with principals and teachers, questionnaires and document analysis. All the material was transformed into text, transcribed verbatim and encoded using QSRNVivo10: 2,323 occurrences and 847 codes emerged from the open coding. During the focused and theoretical coding, 99 subcategories were built inductively, then grouped into 11 saturated categories (reduced to 7), before being integrated into an interpretative final model. This functional multi-dimensional model involves relational, methodological, organizational, political, economic and ethical dimensions, and identifies an effective 5-step process, that could contribute to the planning of equitable quality education for all.
Content uploaded by Giovanna Malusà
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Giovanna Malusà on May 12, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
12/05/2019
1
12/05/2019
2
12/05/2019
3
12/05/2019
4
12/05/2019
5
12/05/2019
6
12/05/2019
7
12/05/2019
8
12/05/2019
9
12/05/2019
10
12/05/2019
11
12/05/2019
12
12/05/2019
13
12/05/2019
14
12/05/2019
15
12/05/2019
16
12/05/2019
17
12/05/2019
18
12/05/2019
19
12/05/2019
20
12/05/2019
21
12/05/2019
22
G. Malusà , 2019
Catarci, M. (2015). Interculturalism in Education across Europe. In M. Catarci & M.
Fiorucci (Eds.), Intercultural Education in the European Context: Theories, Experiences,
Challenges (pp. 1-34). Farnham-UK: Routledge-Ashgate.
Catarci, M., Gomes, M. P., & Siqueira, S. (2017). Refugees, interculturalism and education.
Intercultural Education, 28(2), 109-112. doi:10.1080/14675986.2017.1308647
Charmaz, K. (2014). Constructing Grounded Theory (2nd ed.). London: SAGE.
Creswell, J.W. (2013). Qualitative Inquiry & Research Design. Choosing Among Five
Approaches (3rd ed.). Los Angeles: SAGE.
Freire, P. (2002). Pedagogia de la esperanza. Un reencuntro con la pedagogia del
oprimido. Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI editores.
GENE. (2018). Innovation, Values And Policies In Global Education. GENE Retrieved from
https://gene.eu/wp-content/uploads/GENE_InnovationBook_2018.pdf.
Giroux, H. (1988). Teachers as Intellectuals. Towards a Critical Pedagogy of Learning.
Westport, CT-USA: Bergin & Garvey.
Johnson, C.W., & Parry, D.C. (2015). Contextualizing Qualitative Research for Social
Justice. In C.W. Johnson & D.C. Parry (Eds.), Fostering social justice through qualitative
inquiry: a methodological guide (pp. 11-22). NewYork-USA: Routledge.
Malusà, G. (2018). Still Searching for Solutions: a Critical Approach to Academic
Underachievement among Migrant Origin Students in Italy.Encyclopaideia, 22(51), 45-
63. doi:https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.1825-8670/8460
Malusà, G. (2017a). Equity in educational systems and policies: a difficult social justice
choice.Encyclopaideia, 21(47). doi:https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.1825-8670/6953
12/05/2019
23
G. Malusà , 2019
Malusà, G. (2017b). Pianificare percorsi di successo scolastico per studenti di origine
migrante. Un mixed method study nella scuola secondaria in Italia.(Doctoral thesis),
University of Trento (Italy). Retrieved from http://eprints-phd.biblio.unitn.it/1920/.
Malusà, G. (2017c). Planning paths of school success in Italian multicultural secondary
school.Education theory and practice in challenging times: Cultivating an ethos of social
justice, respect and diversity. Book of Abstracts (pp. 60). Angers-F: IAIE & UCO.
Malusà, G., & Tarozzi, M. (2017). Ensuring quality and equity in an Italian multicultural
primary school. In A. Portera, & C. Grant (Eds .), Intercultural Education and Competences:
Challenges and Answers for the Global World (pp. 221-238). Newcastle-UK: Cambridge
Scholars Publishing.
Mayo, P. (2007). Critical Approaches to Education in the Work of Lorenzo Milani and
Paulo Freire.Studies in Philosophy and Education, 26, 525-544.
Mayo, P. (2013). Echoes from Freire for critically engaged pedagogy. New York, London:
Bloomsbury.
MIUR (2018). Gli alunni con cittadinanza non italiana. A.S. 2016/2017. Roma: MIUR -
Ufficio di Statistica.
OECD (2016). PISA 2015 Results (Volume I): Excellence and Equity in Education. Paris:
OECD Publishing.
Suárez-Orozco, C., Yoshikawa, H., & Tseng, V. (2015). Intersecting Inequalities: Research
to Reduce Inequality for Immigrant-Origin Children and Youth. New York, NY: William T.
Grant Foundation.
Tarozzi, M., & Torres, C.A. (2016). Global citizenship education. Beyond the crises of
multiculturalism. London: Bloomsbury.
Torres, C. A. (2017). Theoretical and Empirical Foundations of Critical Global Citizenship
Education. London: Routledge.
G. Malusà , 2019
Thanks for the attention
Giovanna Malusà
malusa.giovanna@gmail.com
Malusà, G. (forthcoming). Riuscire a
farcela. Pianificare percorsi di
successo scolastico per studenti di
origine migrante nella scuola
secondaria in Italia. Milano:
FrancoAngeli
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
View
Still Searching for Solutions: a Critical Approach to Academic Underachievement among Migrant Origin Students in Italy
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2018
This article analyses the most significant legislation so far enacted to protect the right-duty to education and then goes on to present some measures to support the academic success of migrant origin students, highlighting the most critical areas and the urgent need to create a vision of education with a clear political dimension and an effective ius scholae. Nel presente contributo dopo un’analisi dei principali riferimenti normativi che vorrebbero tutelare il diritto-dovere all’istruzione, si presentano alcune misure di supporto al successo scolastico in particolare degli studenti di origine migrante, evidenziandone le principali aree di criticità e la necessità di una visione anche politica dell’educazione, che comprenda un reale ius scholae.
View
Planning paths of school success in Italian multicultural secondary school
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Jun 2017
The present study, Social-Justice-Education oriented, intends to identify meaningful ways in which all students of foreign origin can be supported to achieve academic success. Academic achievement of students of foreign origin is one of the major challenges of contemporary intercultural education. Despite policies of inclusion, international and national surveys show that students from first or second generation immigrant backgrounds tend to perform at lower levels than their native peers. Intercultural education tends to understate the very issue of social equality. However, education could play an important role in promoting effective paths towards equity. A shift from Intercultural Education to a more extensive vision of Social Justice Education becomes a necessary step in this direction. I adopted a two-phase mixed-method design quant->QUAL (QUAL emphasized), consistent with the “Sequential Explanatory design” (Creswell, 2007), in which the quantitative data analysis of the first phase becomes the background for the second qualitative phase, a critical Grounded Theory Method (GTM) in its constructivist approach. The first phase is related to 1,325 students of foreign origin in the second year of secondary school in the Province of Trento, with a post-hoc descriptive reconstruction back to 6 years, highlighting the pedagogical predictors of the pattern of school success. The second phase includes open and focused observations (82 hours) in 5 middle schools, 28 recorded semi-structured interviews (19 hours) to key-informants (principals and teachers), questionnaires and document analysis. According to the GTM procedures, all the material was transformed into text, transcribed verbatim and encoded using QSR NVivo10. Inhomogeneous patterns of the school careers (269) of the students of foreign origin are clearly revealed, as are training channeling and sterile projects which often fail to promote academic success. Among the 7 built categories by GTM, effective strategic planning emerges as core-category, directly related to the congruent local policies, to the suitable evaluation of trajectories and to flexible teaching approaches, with the creation of meaningful relationships with students. In particular, the emerging multidimensional model and the 6 steps of an effective process could be relevant for planning paths of school success for all.
View
PIANIFICARE PERCORSI DI SUCCESSO SCOLASTICO PER STUDENTI DI ORIGINE MIGRANTE. Un mixed-method study nella scuola secondaria in Italia
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Mar 2017
IL VOLUME "RIUSCIRE A FARCELA. PIANIFICARE PERCORSI DI SUCCESSO SCOLASTICO PER STUDENTI DI ORIGINE MIGRANTE" (FrancoAngeli, 2019) SI ISPIRA A QUESTO LAVORO. - Assumendo in modo non neutrale il successo formativo degli studenti di origine migrante come parametro di valutazione dell'efficacia dei percorsi educativi, emergono pesanti criticità e profonde ineguaglianze nel sistema scolastico italiano, relative non solo al fenomeno degli abbandoni scolastici, ma anche a quello della canalizzazione formativa delle ragazze e dei ragazzi cosiddetti "post-migranti" nella scelta della scuola superiore. Dopo un iniziale approfondimento delle policies sottese alle politiche educative europee - con una decostruzione del concetto di insuccesso scolastico in una visione multi-prospettica radicata nella critical pedagogy - si presenta il complesso disegno di ricerca, un Mixed Methods Sequential Explanatory Design quan->QUAL con direzione teorica qualitativa, adottato per poter approfondire alcuni elementi emergenti dalla prima fase esplorativa di studio, che analizza le traiettorie formative di studenti non italiani attraverso sei anni di scuola. La fase intermedia sul prestigio scolastico ha permesso poi di individuare il campione di riferimento della seconda parte qualitativa, una Grounded Theory critica orientata alla giustizia sociale, che indaga i processi di successo e di insuccesso scolastico degli alunni/e di origine non italiana e che ha portato all'elaborazione di un modello teorico finale multidimensionale, testato attraverso un questionario strutturato. Il progetto triennale ha coinvolto – attraverso osservazioni etnografiche ricorsive, interviste focalizzate e in profondità e questionari - dirigenti, docenti, figure genitoriali, studenti e personale esterno di alcuni Istituti secondari di primo grado della provincia di Trento e Torino (Italia), Los Angeles (California) e Odense (Danimarca). Considerando la valenza strategica degli esiti dell'indagine presentata, si forniscono in conclusione alcune linee d'azione per gli stakeholders coinvolti a livello educativo sui percorsi formativi degli studenti di origine migrante, al fine di focalizzare – con uno sguardo pedagogico – alcune linee di intervento efficaci per promuovere il successo scolastico e formativo delle ragazze e dei ragazzi più fragili.
View
Global Citizenship Education and the Crises of Multiculturalism. Comparative Perspectives
Book
Full-text available
  • Jul 2016
The notion of global citizenship education (GCE) has emerged in the international education discourse in the context of the United Nations Education First Initiative that cites developing global citizens as one of its goals. In this book, the authors argue that GCE offers a new educational perspective for making sense of the existing dilemmas of multiculturalism and national citizenship deficits in diverse societies, taking into account equality, human rights and social justice. The authors explore how teaching and research may be implemented relating to the notion of global citizenship and discuss the intersections between the framework of GCE and multiculturalism. They address the three main topics which affect education in multicultural societies and in a globalized world, and which represent unsolved dilemmas: the issue of diversity in relation to creating citizens, the issue of equality and social justice in democratic societies, and the tension between the global and the local in a globalized world. Through a comparative study of the two prevailing approaches – intercultural education within the European Union and multicultural education in the United States – the authors seek what can be learned from each model. Global Citizenship Education and the Crises of Multiculturalism offers not only a unifying theoretical framework but also a set of policy recommendations aiming to link the two approaches. - See more at: http://www.bloomsbury.com/us/global-citizenship-education-and-the-crises-of-multiculturalism-9781474235976/#sthash.oDQnIAZ1.dp
View
Ensuring quality and equity in an Italian multicultural primary school
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Feb 2017
http://www.cambridgescholars.com/intercultural-education-and-competences
View
Theoretical and Empirical Foundations of Critical Global Citizenship Education
Book
  • Apr 2017
In the first volume in the Critical Global Citizenship Education series, Torres combines theoretical and empirical research to present an original perspective on global citizenship education as a vitally important way of learning in a globalized world. In examining the requirements for effective global citizenship education and education reform, he investigates pathways to citizenship-building at the local, national and global levels and urges development of teaching methods, teacher education, and curriculum within a social justice education framework. Taking into account post-colonial perspectives, political realities at play, and practical implications, Torres provides a succinct but comprehensive understanding of how global citizenship education can expand the concept of civic education in a global society and interrupt inequality. This volume considers the ways that global citizenship education has been incorporated and is used by international institutions, governments, and the academy, and provides a clear framework for anyone struggling to make sense of the tensions and complexities of global citizenship education today.
View
View
Critical Approaches to Education in the Work of Lorenzo Milani and Paulo Freire
Article
  • Jan 2007
Paulo Freire and Lorenzo Milani are considered as key figures in a number of Southern European countries for providing signposts for a critical approach to education. In this paper I will view their ideas and biographical trajectories comparatively to glean some important insights for a critical pedagogy. The common theme throughout this comparative analysis is that of education for social justice based on critical literacy. The paper also deals with such themes as the relationship between education and politics, the relationship between education and life, the collective dimension of learning and the ability to read as well as write the word and the world.
View
Interculturalism in Education across Europe
  • Jan 2015
  • 1-34
  • M Catarci
Catarci, M. (2015). Interculturalism in Education across Europe. In M. Catarci & M. Fiorucci (Eds.), Intercultural Education in the European Context: Theories, Experiences, Challenges (pp. 1-34). Farnham-UK: Routledge-Ashgate.