ArticlePublisher preview available
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

The current Information Society requires new skills for personal, labor and social inclusion. Among the so-called 21st Century Skills (Care, Griffin & Wilson 2018) is Problem Solving in Technology Rich Environments (PS-TRE), a skill evaluated in PISA and PIAAC tests (OECD 2016). This skill, although currently receiving considerable attention in compulsory education, has not received the same level of thought in adult education. In this article, the presence of the PS-TRE skill among adults of working age (25-65 years) in Europe is analysed in relation to the factors that potentially affect a higher level of PS-TRE proficiency. This analysis is carried out using structural equations modelling, taking into account socio-personal and educational factors, as well as the use of different skills at work and in daily life. The results indicate that educational attainment and the use of different skills (reading, numerical skills, ICTrelated skills) at home and at work, as well as participation in non-formal education activities, decisively relate to a higher level of PS-TRE. This result is positively mediated through risk factors such as being older or being a woman. This study concludes that it is necessary to reinforce these skills, not only in children, but also in the adult population, in order to avoid social and labour exclusion
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Technology, Knowledge and Learning (2020) 25:929–951
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10758-019-09403-y
1 3
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Twenty‑First Century Skills forAll: Adults andProblem
Solving inTechnology Rich Environments
TatianaIñiguez‑Berrozpe1 · EllenBoeren2
Published online: 27 March 2019
© Springer Nature B.V. 2019
Abstract
The current Information Society requires new skills for personal, labor and social inclu-
sion. Among the so-called Twenty-First Century Skills (Care etal. (eds) in Assessment and
teaching of 21st century skills, Springer, New York, 2018) is Problem Solving in Technol-
ogy Rich Environments (PS-TRE) competence evaluated in PISA and PIAAC tests (OECD
in Survey of adult skills (PIAAC). Retrieved from https ://goo.gl/cpb3f Q (2016)). This
skill, although currently receiving considerable attention in compulsory education, has not
received the same level of thought in the case of adult education. In this article, the pres-
ence of the PS-TRE skill among adults of working age (25–65years) in Europe is analysed
in relation to the factors that potentially affect a higher score in this skill. This analysis is
carried out using structural equations modelling, taking into account socio-personal and
educational factors, as well as the use of different skills in work and daily life. The results
indicate that educational level and the use of different skills (reading, numerical, related to
ICT) at home and at work, as well as participation in non-formal education activities, deci-
sively relate to a higher level of PS-TRE. This result is positively mediated through risk
factors such as being older or being a woman. This study concludes that it is necessary to
reinforce these skills, not only in children, but also in the adult population, in order to avoid
social and labour exclusion.
Keywords Problem solving· Adult education· Technology· Twenty-first century skills·
Inclusive education
1 Introduction
In recent years, technological revolution has invaded all domains of public and private life.
This resulted into a new type of society, the Information Society (Castells 2002). Currently,
access to and efficient use of ICT are essential for effective participation in society, both at
* Tatiana Iñiguez-Berrozpe
tatianai@unizar.es
Ellen Boeren
Ellen.Boeren@ed.ac.uk
1 University ofZaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain
2 University ofEdinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... However, the pace of change that continues to occur because of globalization presents its own challenges for vocational education. Especially now that it has entered the 21st century, where the characteristics of work are dominated by solving complex problems [4]. Jobs related to solving complex problems require critical thinking skills, creativity skills supported by collaboration skills, and increasingly high digital literacy skills [5], [6]. ...
... The ability to solve problems at this time is very important for vocational education students to have as a provision to enter the world of work. Disruption of work, competence and technology demands the role of problem-solving abilities to solve job problems [4]. Adaptive to developments that disrupt work and replace with new ones characterizes the workforce having a good ability to solve problems [39]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The 21st century learning requires complex competencies, transformations of technology-based learning and non-cognitive skills need. This situation makes it difficult for teachers of Indonesian vocational education apply 21st century skills. This study aimed to analyze the level of difficulty of teachers and students in vocational education and analyzing the differences in the difficulties faced in vocational education. This research used survey research with a quantitative approach. A total of 178 people participated in the study consisting of two public vocational high schools and two private vocational schools with the distribution of respondents consisting of 155 students and 23 teachers. Collecting data using a questionnaire in the form of a statement of difficulties faced by teachers and students, including creativity skills, critical thinking, problem solving, communication, collaboration, and digital literacy or information and communication technology (ICT) as many as 50 items. The instrument used was a Likert scale with very difficult, difficult, easy, and very easy categories. The findings of the study showed: i) All skills were identified on the "easy" criteria; and ii) There were significant differences between the difficulties faced by teachers and students, especially communication skills. The recommendation in this study is the need to improve 21st century skills to produce competitive graduate candidates in vocational education.
... PSSs in TREs can be labelled as one of the important skills to survive in today's world, given that access and efficient use of ICTs are necessary for successful involvement both at work and in daily life (Care, 2018;Iñiguez-Berrozpe & Boeren, 2020). According to Bocconi et al. (2016), future work skills based on digital technology are now also essential for children and young people since lack of PSSs in TREs can keep people out of the labor market and social activities in the coming years (Iñiguez-Berrozpe & Boeren, 2020;Iñiguez-Berrozpe et al., 2018;Vanek, 2017). ...
... PSSs in TREs can be labelled as one of the important skills to survive in today's world, given that access and efficient use of ICTs are necessary for successful involvement both at work and in daily life (Care, 2018;Iñiguez-Berrozpe & Boeren, 2020). According to Bocconi et al. (2016), future work skills based on digital technology are now also essential for children and young people since lack of PSSs in TREs can keep people out of the labor market and social activities in the coming years (Iñiguez-Berrozpe & Boeren, 2020;Iñiguez-Berrozpe et al., 2018;Vanek, 2017). ...
Article
This study aims to evaluate the level of Turkish higher education graduates' problem-solving skills (PSSs) in technology-rich environments (TREs) at work and daily life as information and communication technologies are increasingly used in economic and social structure. It also investigates the effects of socio-demographic factors including gender, age, the field of study, and higher education attainment level on their PSSs in TREs. In this context, the data concerning Turkish higher education graduates' PSSs released by the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) in 2016 was used. With regard to methodology, we employed descriptive and logistic regression analyses to investigate the data. The descriptive statistics results indicated that the participants use computer at a basic level in TREs and work in small and medium enterprises where technology is not highly demanded at moderate and advanced levels. The logistic regression analysis results revealed that gender and higher education level have significant impacts on their level of PSSs in TREs as opposed to age and the field of study variables. The significant differences are in favor of the female participants and associate and bachelor degree levels. These findings accounted for nearly 4% of their level of problem solving skills. Based on the study findings and the changing expectations of labor market, the policy proposals were discussed to increase the level of Turkish higher education students' PSSs in TREs. The study can contribute to the literature, thereby assisting the development of new practices or policies in Turkey to advance higher education graduates' PSSs in order to meet the needs of TREs at both work and in daily life.
... Obviously, this trend towards automation and the transfer of interactions to the online world in the world of work have an immediate effect on the demands for skills that are required and will be required of workers, especially in terms of digitization and use of technologies (Boeren & Íñiguez-Berrozpe, 2020). As we will see in the section dedicated to this, the changes in educational curricula in Europe are already reflecting these concerns about key skills for the 21st century and the new requirements of the labour market which, as we are analysing, have been accelerated due to the pandemic. ...
... One of the issues for the development of digital skills is that it does not seem to have been included in countries' adult education strategies (Iñiguez-Berrozpe, & Boeren, 2019). This thinking is confirmed by the OECD (2019) who found that in many of the 32 countries' policies they reviewed, 1 Stats NZ (2020). ...
Research
Full-text available
This research reports on how education providers adapted to teaching using digital technology early in the COVID-19 pandemic and how foundation level learners delighted in learning about and through technology.
Article
Using the PIAAC data, we show how exposure to various dimensions of nonformal and informal learning relates to the problem-solving capacity in a technology-rich environment for working adults. The sample included permanent staff from various economic sectors, self-employed individuals, and casual employees doing fixed-term contracts ( n = 1248) between 16 and 65 years, 38% of participants were males. A regression analysis showed that managerial practices such as degree of autonomy, frequency of interaction with coworkers, participation in training and counseling, and handling of routine and complex in-job problems are important factors associated with problem-solving scores for the respondents at every level of educational attainment. Underdevelopment of managerial practices can be connected to the lingering transition to the market system which hinders the flexible transition of skills and training in the workplace and lowers problem-solving scores in Russia compared to OECD countries.
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated how one's problem-solving style impacts his/her problem-solving performance in technology-rich environments. Drawing upon experiential learning theory, we extracted two behavioral indicators (i.e., planning duration for problem solving and human-computer interaction frequency) to model problem-solving styles in technology-rich environments. We employed an existing data set in which 7516 participants responded to 14 technology-based tasks of the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) 2012. Clustering analyses revealed three problem-solving styles: Acting indicates a preference for active explorations; Reflecting represents a tendency to observe; and Shirking shows an inclination toward scarce tryouts and few observations. Explanatory item response modeling analyses disclosed that individuals with the Acting style outperformed those with the Reflecting or the Shirking style, and this superiority persisted across tasks with different difficulties.
Article
Age can lead to stigmatization, which is aggravated in groups that are already at risk of exclusion, such as women. This intersectional bias between age and gender (gendered ageism) affects so-called mature workers (aged 50 and over) in different ways. These can include the prejudices on the part of employers and workers regarding their skills and competencies, as well as regarding their motivation to participate in training. In this article we analyse mature female workers’ level of training, motivation, and use of job-related skills, with the aim of providing evidence that breaks with ageist gender prejudices on this issue. We conducted a descriptive analysis using ANOVA, and we applied structural equation modelling in an analysis of the PIAAC data of the OECD (2016), dividing the entire sample (n.=31,739) into four subsamples (women -50; women 50+; men -50; men 50+). In our descriptive analysis, female older workers achieve the highest scores in almost all the variables. Our proposed model, resulting from multigroup comparisons among the four subsamples, has a more optimal fit and structural coefficients of greater weight in mature female workers than in younger ones, especially regarding the influence of informal learning at work on the level of use of job-related skills.
Article
Full-text available
The field of computational thinking (CT) is developing rapidly, reflecting its importance in the global economy. However, most empirical studies have targeted CT in K-12, thus, little attention has been paid to CT in higher education. The present scoping review identifies and summarizes existing empirical studies on CT assessments in post-secondary education, aiming to reveal the current trends of empirical research in this domain and key features of recent CT assessment instruments. It examines 33 peer-reviewed journal articles published between 2013 and 2019 from six databases. Results show that most assessment tools are designed for computing science and engineering undergraduates or pre-service and in-service teachers in these subjects. Most tools involve in-class interventions to promote CT skills. Several assessment formats were adopted in the selected studies, including selected-response questions, constructed-response questions, Likert scales, interviews, programming artefacts, observations, and interviews. Finally, most assessment instruments attempt to measure skills from a combination of dimensions including CT Concepts, Practices, and Perspectives from a hybrid-competency framework. More specifically, the skills assessed in most studies are algorithmic thinking, problem solving, data, logic and logical thinking, and abstraction. Findings may help instructors to select CT assessments for higher education and researchers to focus on less explored research areas.
Article
This study focuses on the problem solving skills in technology-rich environments of teachers. PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies) data on adults’ (n = 11,294) competencies, is used to investigate how problem solving skills of teachers are associated with sociodemographic, work-related, and everyday-life related background factors. In addition, the problem solving skills in technology-rich environments of teachers are compared with those of other adults with a higher education degree. The main statistical analyses are conducted with logistic regression models under the design-based framework. Our findings illustrate that teachers’ strong or weak skills seem to be associated with sociodemographic factors and work-related factors. When comparing teachers with other professionals, for high problem solving skills numeracy skill use at home was important on top of the sociodemographic factors, while teachers’ weak skills seem to be associated with fewer ICT skill-use at work on top of the sociodemographic factors. Combining our results with earlier research that emphasises the importance of daily activities at work on the one hand, and the lack of room for teachers to actually work and learn together on the other hand, we argue that teachers may benefit from more opportunities to develop professionally at work.
Article
Full-text available
During the last decades, digital competence has become essential at workplace. Nowadays, it is difficult to find a job where no ICT skills are required. At the same time, there is a lack of ecosystems for adult reskilling in digital competence. Moreover, most of them do not use of a common language and terminology, decreasing the possibilities of being used by a wider public. In addition, the assessment of digital competence cannot be done using simple self-assessment tests, but more complex tools such as simulations or other activities based on real scenarios. Considering this, we designed a performance-based evaluation system following a pragmatic approach based on DigComp framework. We carried out a needs analysis based on expert consultation (63 teleworkers and 82 entrepreneurs) to create an assessment syllabus and implement the assessment modules. Then, we conducted an analysis by experts (n = 21) of the relationship between the content of the tests and the construct it was intended to measure. After refinement, the system was piloted by end-users all over Europe (n = 525). Results confirmed that DigComp was the most appropriate reference when considering the transversality of digital competence, providing researchers with well-defined clear criteria.
Article
Full-text available
El llamado Darwinismo Social, provocado por la revolución tecnológica actual, está dando paso a una Sociedad de la Información (SI) más inclusiva, en la que colectivos en riesgo de exclusión se están incorporando a ella de manera activa. En la presente contribución nos centramos en uno de estos grupos sociales, los adultos maduros (AM, mayores de 55), analizando su acceso y uso de las TIC y su competencia tecnológica en la resolución de problemas cotidianos. Para ello hemos empleado los microdatos de la encuesta PIAAC europea. Con ella hemos realizado un estudio estadístico bivariante para caracterizar la muestra, y analizar los coeficientes de correlación entre las variables relacionadas con las habilidades implicadas en el uso de las TIC y las competencias evaluadas en la encuesta. Finalmente hemos implementado una regresión logística binaria, para analizar la relación entre las características sociopersonales y las habilidades tecnológicas de los AM. Los resultados muestran una progresiva inclusión de este grupo social en la SI, siendo relevantes el nivel educativo y la participación en actividades de aprendizaje permanente para el desarrollo de estas competencias. Por otra parte, se evidencia que el dominio de las habilidades tecnológicas está relacionado con una mayor puntuación en las otras habilidades medidas en la escala.
Article
Full-text available
En la actual Sociedad de la Información (SI), donde un cambio cultural, como es el uso masivo de las TIC, ha provocado un cambio social, es necesario repensar la inclusión de la población adulta, especialmente la de mayor edad, en un entorno cada vez más informatizado, que, a priori, puede parecer exclusor. Contrariamente a la idea general, la población adulta de todas las edades se está incorporando de manera activa a esta SI a través de la adquisición progresiva de competencias digitales, hecho al cual contribuyen de manera significativa las actividades de Aprendizaje Permanente (AP). En el presente artículo se analiza, en primer lugar, a través de los microdatos de la muestra europea proporcionados por la encuesta PIAAC (OCDE, 2013), la correlación existente entre el desarrollo de las diversas competencias instrumentales con las habilidades digitales. Seguidamente, mediante una regresión lineal múltiple, se muestra que, más allá de las características sociopersonales de la población adulta, es el factor educativo el que supone un mayor desarrollo de las competencias instrumentales en general y las digitales en particular. De esta forma, se defiende el AP como estrategia fundamental para lograr de manera definitiva la ruptura de la brecha digital entre jóvenes y adultos, así como elemento esencial para que la democratización de la SI sea una realidad.
Article
Full-text available
Research in the social sciences has focused extensively on the relationship between family background, educational attainment and social destination, on the one hand, and on the processes of skills creation and skills use, on the other. This paper brings these two branches of the literature together by examining the correlation between a range of social factors. The methodology we adopt provides a comprehensive approach to the study of the channels through which literacy skills are acquired, taking into account the interrelation of family background, educational attainment, and the use of skills at work and at home. We use the Programme of International Assessment of Adult Competences (PIAAC) dataset and apply a structural equation model (SEM). Our results show that family background and education play an important role in the configuration of adult skills and skill practices. Unequal family access to resources has a strong impact at later stages in life and strongly affects educational attainment and skills outcomes. Additionally, skills use has a positive and direct impact on adult skills.
Article
Full-text available
In the past decade, Computational Thinking (CT) and related concepts (e.g. coding, programing, algorithmic thinking) have received increasing attention in the educational field. This has given rise to a large amount of academic and grey literature, and also numerous public and private implementation initiatives. Despite this widespread interest, successful CT integration in compulsory education still faces unresolved issues and challenges. This report provides a comprehensive overview of CT skills for schoolchildren, encompassing recent research findings and initiatives at grassroots and policy levels. It also offers a better understanding of the core concepts and attributes of CT and its potential for compulsory education. The study adopts a mostly qualitative approach that comprises extensive desk research, a survey of Ministries of Education and semi-structured interviews, which provide insights from experts, practitioners and policy makers. The report discusses the most significant CT developments for compulsory education in Europe and provides a comprehensive synthesis of evidence, including implications for policy and practice.
Book
This book provides a detailed description of research and application outcomes from the Assessment and Teaching of 21st Century Skills project, which explored a framework for understanding the nature of these skills. The major element of this new volume is the presentation of research information from the global assessment of two 21st century skills that are amenable to teaching and learning: collaborative problem solving, and learning in digital networks. The outcomes presented include evidence to support the validity of assessment of 21st century skills and descriptions of consequent pedagogical approaches which can be used both to teach the skills and to use them to enhance key learning goals in secondary education systems. The sections of the volume are connected through a focus on the degree to which innovative assessment tasks measure the constructs of interest. This focus is informed by conceptual and methodological issues associated with affordances of 21st century computer-based assessment. How understanding of the nature of the skills, as derived from these assessments, can guide approaches to the integration of 21st century skills in the classroom, is informed by initiatives adopted by participating countries. The guiding questions in this volume are: "Do the assessment tasks measure the constructs?" and "What are the implications for assessment and teaching in the classroom?" It is the third volume of papers from this project published by Springer.
Chapter
This chapter provides a general introduction to issues and initiatives in the assessment of twenty-first century skills, the implications of assessment for the teacher and teacher training, the role played by technologies not only for demonstration of skills but for their measurement, and a look to the future. Frameworks that have informed a gradual shift in the aspirations of education systems for their students are described, followed by evidence of implementations globally and regionally. The role of the Assessment and Teaching of 21st Century Skills (ATC21S; Griffin et al. (Eds.) (2012), Assessment and teaching of 21st century skills. Springer, Dordrecht) in reflecting and acting on a call by global consortia is outlined. This provides the context for the book contents, with the chapters briefly described within their thematic parts. The chapters provide a clear picture of the complexities of the introduction of teaching and assessment strategies based on skills rather than content.
Article
Purpose Research has shown that the problem-solving skills of adults with a vocational education and training (VET) background in technology-rich environments (TREs) are often inadequate. However, some adults with a VET background do have sound problem-solving skills. The present study aims to provide insight into the socio-demographic, work-related and everyday life factors that are associated with a strong problem-solving performance. Design/methodology/approach The study builds on large-scale data of the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) and gives insight into VET adults ( N = 12,929) with strong problem-solving skills in 11 European countries. Findings This study introduces new knowledge with respect to the socio-demographic, work-related and everyday life background factors that contribute to successful VET adults’ problem-solving skills. The findings of the authors illustrate that a continuous process of development including non-formal and informal activity, as well as learning taking place at work, is associated with strong performance in problem-solving skills in TRE. Research limitations/implications An important implication of this study is that this paper introduces novel knowledge for VET adults’ competences and can be used to support the development of VET adults’ problem-solving skills in TREs. Originality/value The study was conducted to explore new understanding about good problem-solvers in TREs with a VET background. The originality of the study derives from its focus on good problem-solvers in TREs related to a VET background. The findings can be used to create novel ways to enhance the development of VET adults’ problem-solving skills in TREs.
Article
The main aim of this paper is to analyse the evolution of adult skills, as captured by cognitive competencies assessed in the PIAAC, across age cohorts, explicitly taking into account that the quality of schooling might change from one cohort to another. We estimate a model that relates numeracy and literacy competencies to age, schooling, gender and variables related to both family background and labour market performance. The specification allows us to control for changes in the efficiency of the transformation of schooling into competencies when drawing age-skill profiles. Our results show that the effect of ageing on skills, once isolated from cohort effects related to schooling, decreases monotonically across consecutive cohorts. The evolution of the efficiency of the transformation of schooling into both numeracy and literacy skills shows a remarkably similar pattern. Nonetheless, this evolution differs substantially between education levels, with the efficiency of the transformation of schooling into skills showing a steadier profile for intermediate than it does for higher education. Finally, empirical evidence is provided for the decomposition of the differences in the skill levels of the older vs. the prime age generations. The results suggest that the progressive expansion of schooling across younger generations partially offsets the negative effect of the irrepressible ageing of society on skills.