Content uploaded by Roger Higgs
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Roger Higgs on Feb 29, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
UNITED'NATIONS'‘INTERGOVERNMENTAL'PANEL'ON'CLIMATE'CHANGE’'(IPCC)'−'INCONVENIENT'TRUTHS'
!"#$%&'"#()&&*+#,'%-./*0-/#123#Technical)Note)2018-2+#4/"-5#6789+#/:';3'3#6<25#='>#6767?#@''#/.*%#A'-5?#B%2'#678<C87#
!"#$%&'"()*+,-..+%/+United'Na>ons'#0+"#1*/+"2')3452+&'#)6$#16)+ #0+ $"")""+ 7308&)*9)+0:+2&';$#)<+=+")$<&)>)&+ ?@AB+ 2($39)C+
D06+)$2(+ 3)8+6)E06#+ ?)>)6/+F<.+ /)$6"BG+6)E6)")3#$4>)"+ 0:+ HIJJ+ ;);%)6+ 90>)63;)3#"+ =+ K0%")6>)6+ 069$3'"$403"L+ )&)2#+ $+
KM16)$1L+0:+"2')34"#"+#0+2(00")+ 6)E06#+ $1#(06"+ ?;0"#&/+ 90>)63;)3#<+ =+13'>)6"'#/+$2$*);'2"B+:60;+90>)63;)3#+30;'3$#<
'03"+?'C)C+;1&4E&)+&)>)&"+0:+E0&'42$&+'3E1#BG+"))7'39+$+E0&'42$&&/+2066)2#+K%$&$32)L+0:+:);$&)G+/0139+=+#('6*<806&*+$1#(06"C+
+
J($'6;$3G+NOON<,FG+PCQC+I$2($16'G+I(R+S06#(+J$60&'3$+@#$#)+T3'>)6"'#/+03G+$();G+:06)2$"439+)&)2#6'2'#/+*);$3*+'3+$+6)9'03+
0:+S06#(+=+@01#(+J$60&'3$+?U'7'BC+V22)E#)*+S0%)&+I)$2)+I6'W)+NOOXG+03+HIJJY"+%)($&:G+8'#(+20<8'33)6G+)6G+V&+Z06)+CCC++++
DE%"#25')"#'F%"2*#2%#>G).3#GH#/;3#3)**':);/2'#&"'/2'"#I;%J.'3&'#/>%G2#:/;C:/3'#-.):/2'#-5/;&'KC+
+
HIJJY"+"1%<6)E06#+[J&';$#)+J($39)+NO,\+]()+I(/"'2$&+@2')32)+M$"'"Y+CCC+]U^+_V`^P+RH@]^P]H^S@+CCC+
,C+ _$3/+ 0:+ #()+ NFF+ $EE0'3#)*+ $1#(06"+ P!Aa+ 03+ E1%&'2+ %)&'):+ '3+ ;$3<;$*)+ 9&0%$&+ 8$6;'39+ ?'C)C+ "$&$6')"G+ 6)")$62(+ 96$3#"G+
E1%&'2$403+('"#06/BC+]('"+E60:013*+>)"#)*+'3#)6)"#+?&$27+0:+';E$64$&'#/B+91$6$3#))"+HIJJ+6)E06#"+$6)+%'$")*+=+$&$6;'"#C++
+
NC+]()+NFF+$1#(06"+'32&1*)+30+9)0&09'"#"+06+$62($)0&09'"#"G+#()+>)6/+"E)2'$&'"#"+;0"#+$8$6)+0:+?,B+E)6'0*'2+6$E'*+8$6;'39"<
200&'39"+=+@A+2($39)+#(6019(01#+!$6#(b"+cCF+%'&&'03+/)$6"G+*1)+#0+"0&$6+d12#1$403"+=+>0&2$3'2+)61E403"+=+?NB+e0&02)3)+?&$"#+
,,GOOO/6"B+21$&+20&&$E")"+=+;$""<;'96$403"+*1)+#0+*6019(#"G+$9$'3+136)&$#)*+#0+J^N+?;/+])2(C+S0#)+NO,-<,,+03+J^NY"+
'3302)32)BC+]()+NFF+'32&1*)+J&';$#)+@2')34"#"f_0*)&&)6"+?:021"+03+#()+&$"#+,FO/6"+"'32)+6)&'$%&)+#);EC+=+@A+;)$"16);)3#"+
%)9$3G+'C)C+$+;)6)+\O<;'&&'03#(+0:+!$6#(+('"#06/gBG+J&';$#0&09'"#"+?:021"+03+#()+&$"#+NGOOO/6"G+#6))+6'39"G+)#2CBG+Z)0E(/"'2'"#"G+
I(/"'2'"#"G+@#$4"42'$3"G+Z&$2'0&09'"#"G+_)#)060&09'"#"G+^2)$3096$E()6"G+Z)0*)"'"#"+CCC+%1#+30+9)0&09'"#"+06+$62($)0&09'"#"C+
+
HIJJY"+&$#)"#+6)E06#+?NO,\f,cB+($"+.\.+$1#(06"+?'32&1*'39+#()+$%0>)+NFFBG+'32&1*'39+)2030;'"#"G+"02'0&09'"#"+=+E1%&'2<()$&#(+
)hE)6#"G+%1#+30+9)0&09'"#"+06+$62($)0&09'"#"+?-+$1#(06"+:60;+!3>'603;)3#+J$3$*$G+O+:60;+#()+Z)0&09'2$&+@16>)/+0:+J$3$*$gBC+
+
HIJJ+[J&';$#)+J($39)+NO,c+@/3#()"'"YG+:06)806*i+j#($37"+#0+#()+>0&13#$6/+8067G+*)*'2$403+$3*+20;;'#;)3#+0:+#(01"$3*"+
0:+)hE)6#"+$3*+"2')34"#"+CCC+6)E6)")3439+$+6$39)+0:+CCC+*'"2'E&'3)"L+CCC+)h2)E#+9)0&09/+=+$62($)0&09/G+#()+;0"#+6)&)>$3#+0:+$&&C+
_06)0>)6G+K>0&13#$6/L+'"+*'"'39)3101"G+$"+$1#(06"+8'3+#(6)):0&*i+,C+9$'3+E6)"49)G+)C9C+K20<8'33)6+CCC+S0%)&+I)$2)+I6'W)L+?03+
2J%+J$3$*'$3"Y+Jk"gBl+NC+2$3+2'#)+#()'6+083+E$E)6"l+\C+;$3/+2$3+86'#)+:06+HIJJ+03+);E&0/)6Y"+4;)G+'C)C+"4&&+E$'*C+
+
NO,c+ @/3#()"'"i+ DLMNN# )*# ;%J# <O# H'"-';2# -'"2/);# 25/2# 5G:/;*# /"'# 25'# :/);# -/G*'# %E# -G""';2# &.%>/.# J/":);&KC+ e08+ dare+
#()")+&$69)&/+")&:<'3#)6)"#)*+E)0E&)G+136)E6)")3#)*+%/+)>)3+,+9)0&09'"#+06+$62($)0&09'"#G+;$7)+"12(+$+*6$"42+=+'&&<'3:06;)*+
2&$';G+ '3*12'39+ 90>)63;)3#"+ #0+ 6)&)3#&)""&/+ 6$'")+ #$h)"+ =+ )3)69/+ E6'2)"+ '3+ 06*)6+ #0+ "m1$3*)6+ nn#6'&&'03"+ 03+ ?,B+ 6)E&$2'39+
:$6;&$3*+8'#(+2(603'2$&&/+'3)o2')3#+"0&$6+KE$67"L+=+8'3*+K:$6;"LG+?NB+*)"#60/'39+3$#16$&+($%'#$#+#0+9608+%'0:1)&"G+)#2CG+)#2C+