Content uploaded by John Mayne
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by John Mayne on Feb 17, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
! !
""#! #$
#%&'(
"!!#
! &
""!%)*
!+,!-#
.#!%
/0#/"(!(
1
% %2 !#
#
% !%3!&!#
&
4% "# $!%,5
%
.% %&'%2!!
&# !
("
% #%6!*
!" 1
%&&()""
( "5 !
%
(!! (#&"
(
"7"(
8%
!%&!
"!%
*%&!!
((
&"8%
#"
!%
#%/
"'
!#! %/
##'"
%/#'!&
9!
(#:&;#
""%
#!'
!((!<
%/!# =%
!9 !!%&!
*!#"( "#
"( !%
++,
&!
' &!#%%#'
#(&
!9 "%&&
!%&
("&#
%
! !"
"!!
"<(<%
-
&!
#%"
(!#"!(
%>*
!* !!"#(
( %
Generative causality
/!
!7"!!7
($95*9
%+#!
1 *<!%
&"""!#!
>"*"!
!%&( !
!
!%&&"
(!!9
8%
./&!.!
616'*<5
613! !
"
641?9 !
1
&!
&(8
6.1 #
616(!
6@1+!
6A1+6.
4
Causal factors
&!1
&
!!"(
%+#!! "
> "
> "(
%&#"
B #(
7/C267
5%
& 1
!!
%
&!*!
!"(#
9%,
(!""# ="
9!("
!%,""
%
9!%
Contributory causes
!
!#%%#!"
!(
!(#A.$" D#$#%
!!
"!E<F%
<9!!
F!###
&#/<C
26<<(#A.%6
#1A@/C26%
G("
#H1.%6#1@%
.
%/ #
%/(
(<%&( <
"
!#"<
E""!"!F%
Contribution claims
="!
%#(I
!51D!
<JD!
J
0
!51
D""!
<#J
&!
( "(%D""
! "!<
## J&!
!" #%%#%
6 ##9 "
9 "8#"!
(<%
Demonstrating contribution claims
!#!
&#! &7#
(7"!%0(
1
(
%/!"
!"8%
0
%+#! &
%
"# !.!$!
6&
5%&(
'"5%&
!!5
#%/
#/#
!5 #
9!%&
!!%
!#!
75"7%
/ 51
&"9!=!I
9J
D!<!J
-!J
-"!"!J
9!# #
"9#
%
*!5
"&# %&
5"9
!!%5
H! %
K(5# 7
!71
&!!
7! 7
" #L%
@
(!! (#
The need in CA for robust ToCs
M!#$#
!5 "
# &%
0&%
/! #
& %&
A&1#
#(!%&4
%
.0 !!.!
&1
% /&J"#
(J/
J
% & J
4% /5J
.% /&J3"
5J(*!
.1"# %&!2!
% %-!!#
J
% !.!!%3!(<#%%#
! !J/
#""!J-
!(
J
4% (3%-B "J
.% %&!%-!!
"(J
% .%!J
A
5<J/5
J
% (J
@% 8
(J
&1
A% /& J
H% #(
J-(
!J
% ((!J*(
' !J
% ( "
<J
% /!"
9J
% &"9J
9#&#
#&! #
('# E'F#
"%6
#''%
/(!#
' ( %/
((<#'
" %
6&" "
%&
5 #
&!%
Unpacking complex intervention settings: dierent ToCs for
dierent purposes
&5 !
! "
! &%/! !
"!<
7 7<
#%#&5(!
%/!1/!
H
49#(F!&1#!
%
/!!
%DB1
"#&!!#9"
! "!"(%
$&&!"
!%&""
" "%
/
!%
#%&%&&"9
(!(
I9!&%&&#
9#"#"<
I< %C
&(9! %"
<"&%
&(!
&##&
!% &!
%&
&#%
The need for evaluable ToC models
!!
!&!#
%/!'
!&! !#
!%/!
"! "
#5"!
!#&
"(!%2#(
&'(9
!" !
%
D#"! !
#&79H
%3! E F& #5#
"E"F
9 &""&&
%N
%
Behaviour change ToC models
!!! !
%/! #A$#H
&!
! &#" %&
"(#(-.
!0
1#)!%
D#)*0%
&)*0&!!
&75!
!! 7(
%/9 "
! " %&#)*0
4"( !
$9"(
! %
Inferring Causality: demonstrating contribution claims
!!%'5#"
J
4+!M"
&#A$-#.%
Behaviour
Change
Capacity Change
Figure 1: The COM-B Theory of Change Model
Reach &
Reaction
Activities/
Outputs
Direct
Benets
Improved
Wellbeing
'
"
"
(
"
&(
"
)
"
,9
/B
Capabilit
y
Opportunity
Motivation
)*
/( !&#
##
" "%
"(5"
( %0"
=""
%
#
"%D
! (&#%%#
("+5+%
&"1
% +" +#
% +"+
( (
"("+
+#" "1L%%
/9!"!<
"#""&%#
("9""
!#"%D#
(5"
%9#"*&
!!!#
""!
%
"%
N
7 !=(7"
"6.%
#!*"
"((1
% &!!
7! #
% /" #L%
6" !"
1!( "
< 7"9"
" #!"
( #
%
!
##! !#
("8%0#"
( "(%M
!" #!
%
/#" !"
<#%%#
!"#5 1
( "<#
!!"
( # %
6<" (
&""8%6<
"""( #/""
" &"8 %)
!&%-
3!#4%M14A.
( (
%
G9
&#&4
#
!%
&.!! ! ##"
&%
.4' ! #
!! !%%
Checking that change occurred
%O
"
+&P
"
!'J&
4
-
!
( %
Hoop tests for con#rming plausibility
%G
5
+&P41
3!
+&P.1
G
/!
#
%
*1*
!Q
J
!1/5
J
/
J
4%+
<9
+&P1
!<
3!
/!
<9"!
J
.%,9**
<8
M 1
/<#
!(%0<
!%
Building the causal narrative
%(
<
+&P1
<$
+&P1
(
/
(
<
J
"(
'J
D!
J
Con#rming a causal factor
@%65
<!
M 1
(
+
!%
&!&.
!%! !7
"7""(!
%&9"("($
%
,('!'!'!
5(
%/! (
"95*9
#9=""!
B #4"(
!"9 9
#."
.
"(
%
)"#5
# " ( #5
#4"
!%
" #C%%D%+,-&.
(",/,.,))
0%)92!M%
3!#,%J.%-#(%
-(CR,- %- %
!
1II! %%8I9S'II*
8%%
3!#,%%4%$
.%0,!<("%
N#%% %T2 *0&
) +9
6 %T1,6/
& %
(#%G%A.%-"2
%)92!M%
#%H%T&"2'&%T
,2..I1.*.4@%
#%%1 ,<%
/%+%6"8#N%%#
,%C"0"(#C#&M4*@%
#%%T1 JT
H41A*H%
#%%T2& %T
1,41*.%!
1II!%II'I=*I4**
S%
#%A%T& 10 +
& %T1,
41*A4%!
1II!%II'I=*I4**
%
#%H%$3+(3%!
1II1II"""% %II44H@H@S&
S)0S&S.%
#%H%&#,!
0' C%!
1II1II"""% %II44H@H4AS3!
SS2 S2S&%
#%%($3+(3%
+?%!
1II1II"""% %II44AS&
SS0 SS)O%
#% %+ /
,!1? -U(J/
,.%%M%M #,#&
%
#6%#G%(+%-.%(
)-"/&.%?0#
6!(M %!
1II"""%! "%I
M#%%T28*
%TH414@.*4AA%
M"#+%C%&A%'%6 %
-#%D%%C 1,9
*!!
!%/#
-45
%%M%#%%N#G%0%6%D%
-#,%- #3#&/@*%
-#?%.%'.-".1
G%!
1II"""%% II% %(I'I*I*
*'I4H%%
@