ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Forensic accounting is one of the most effective and efficient ways of reducing and preventing fraudulent activities in Nigeria. Forensic accounting is perceived to have evolved in response to certain emerging fraud related cases of which tax evasion is inclusive. The extent to which tax invasion fraud is perpetrated in Nigeria is quit high and alarming. The menace has resulted into the loss of great fortune that could have enhanced economic development in the country. The study examined the application of forensic accounting in tax evasion in Nigeria. The methodology adopted in this research work is content analysis which involves proper review of books, journals, periodicals, financial reporting standards and relevant laws. The study reviewed the fraud scale theory which revealed that tax fraud is a cog in the wheel of economic development in Nigeria. The study concluded that tax fraud has a strong potential to steal the wealth of a nation and impoverish her people therefore using forensic accounting strategies to prevent and detect this fraud will go to a greater extent in enhancing economic growth and development of the nation. The study recommended that fraud should be seen, especially tax fraud, as retrogressive and be totally condemned by all, ethical culture and appropriate legislation should be put in place to stem effect of personality in committing tax evasion fraud, government should ensure that tax revenue collected is judiciously spent in providing infrastructure in order to ensure tax justice and sensitizing Nigerian population to the cancer of tax evasion fraud and applying all necessary measures to eradicate this cancer using forensic accounting.
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
131
FORENSIC ACCOUNTING AND TAX EVASION IN NIGERIA
Adegbite Samson Adebolu
Department of Accounting and Management Sciences,
Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria.
adebolu2012@gmail.com; 08035540176
Oyebamiji Taofeeq Adewale
Department of Accounting, School of Management Sciences,
Babcock University, Ogun State.
taodewale70@gmail.com, 08033191158
&
Oyedokun Godwin Emmanuel
Senior Lecturer, Department of Accounting,
Nasarawa State University, Keffi, Nigeria.
godwinoye@yahoo.com, +234-80-3373-7184
ABSTRACT
Forensic accounting is one of the most effective and efficient ways of reducing and preventing
fraudulent activities in Nigeria. Forensic accounting is perceived to have evolved in response to
certain emerging fraud related cases of which tax evasion is inclusive. The extent to which tax
invasion fraud is perpetrated in Nigeria is quit high and alarming. The menace has resulted into
the loss of great fortune that could have enhanced economic development in the country. The study
examined the application of forensic accounting in tax evasion in Nigeria. The methodology
adopted in this research work is content analysis which involves proper review of books, journals,
periodicals, financial reporting standards and relevant laws. The study reviewed the fraud scale
theory which revealed that tax fraud is a cog in the wheel of economic development in Nigeria.
The study concluded that tax fraud has a strong potential to steal the wealth of a nation and
impoverish her people therefore using forensic accounting strategies to prevent and detect this
fraud will go to a greater extent in enhancing economic growth and development of the nation.
The study recommended that fraud should be seen, especially tax fraud, as retrogressive and be
totally condemned by all, ethical culture and appropriate legislation should be put in place to stem
effect of personality in committing tax evasion fraud, government should ensure that tax revenue
collected is judiciously spent in providing infrastructure in order to ensure tax justice and
sensitizing Nigerian population to the cancer of tax evasion fraud and applying all necessary
measures to eradicate this cancer using forensic accounting.
Keywords: Forensic accounting, Tax evasion, Nigeria, Fraud, Personality, Ethical culture, Tax
justice.
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Forensic accounting is perceived to have evolved in response to certain emerging fraud related
cases of which tax evasion is inclusive (Modugu & Anyaduba, 2013, Al-Sharaivi, 2018). The
scandals that recently rocked the corporate world with classic examples being the often cited Enron
scandals published in October 2001 and Worldcom scandal in 2002, both in USA (Dibra 2016,
Moncarz, Moncarz, Cabella & Moncarz 2006) and in Nigeria Cadbury Lever Brothers and
integrity of commercial banks (Effiong, 2013) have also brought the field of forensic accounting
to the front burner.
Forensic accounting is the tripartite practice of utilizing accounting, auditing and investigative
skills to assist in legal matters (Aduwo, 2016). It is a specialized field of accounting that describes
engagements that result from actual or anticipated disputes or litigation (Okoye & Gbegi, 2013).
Tax fraud involved tax evasion which is the efforts by individuals, firms, trusts and other entities
to evade taxes by illegal means and this is very prevalent in Nigeria. Fatoki (2014) argued that tax
evasion is a deliberate and willful practice of not disclosing full taxable income in order to pay
less tax. It is a deliberate violation of tax laws which is evident in situations where tax liability is
fraudulently reduced or false claims are filled on the revenue tax forms (Soyode & Kajola, 2006).
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
132
Onyeka and Nwankwo (2016) argued that taxes and tax systems are fundamental components of
government. Onyeka, et al. (2016) went further that taxes undermine the capacity of states to carry
out their goals which form one of the central points for the conduct of state society relations and
they shape the balance between accumulation and distribution that gives state their social character.
These taxes build capacity to provide security, meet basic needs or foster economic development
in any nation of which Nigeria is inclusive. The evasion of these taxes disallowed the government
from getting the necessary revenue for the development activities. This study therefore examined
the application of forensic accounting in tax evasion in Nigeria.
In Nigeria, most of the prosecutions we have seen on tax related offenses are usually for forgery
of tax clearance certificate brought under section 473 of the criminal code Act Cap C28 Laws of
the Federation of Nigeria on forgery and such may not be regarded as tax offenses (Oluwole, 2017).
There is not much involvement of the police and anti-graft agencies on the enforcement of tax
evasion laws, however based on the information of ICPC website (2018), there was an
uncelebrated case in 2014 where the ICPC was able to secure the conviction of an FIRS official
who was bribed to issue a tax clearance certificate to a company without paying the adequate taxes,
both the FIRS official and the company were convicted, though it is not clear if the conviction was
seemed based on the tax evasion laws. Therefore, it appears that there is no documentation of any
criminal prosecution arising from tax evasion in Nigeria.
The study therefore was conducted to see how far forensic accounting techniques can be adopted
to reduce if not totally eliminate tax evasion in Nigeria in the high of the failure of the anti-graft
agencies to do the needful.
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Conceptual Review
2.1.1 Concept of Forensic Accounting
Forensic accounting is seen as homogeneous mixture that links accounting, auditing and judiciary
through a legal point of view to present report that contribute in eventually solving arguments and
disputes (Al-Sharaivi, 2018). Forensic accounting is the tripartite practice of utilizing accounting,
auditing and investigative skills to assist in legal matters (AICPA, 2006; Dada, Adegbite &
Benjamin, 2017).
Adegbie and Fakile (2012) argued that forensic accounting is the application of accounting
concepts and techniques to legal problems which demands reporting, where accountability of the
fraud is established and report is considered as evidence suitable for presentation in a manner that
met the standard required by court of law. Forensic accounting is therefore, a discipline that has
its own models and methodologies of investigative procedures that search for assurance, attestation
and advisory perspective to produce legal evidence in court for the purpose of prosecution.
2.1.2 Concept of Tax Evasion
Soyede, et al. (2006) defined tax evasion as a deliberate and willful practice of not disclosing full
taxable income in order to pay less tax. Soyede, et al. (2006) further see tax evasion as deliberate
violation of tax laws which is evident in situations where tax liability is fraudulently reduced or
false claims are filled on the revenue tax forms.
Fatoki (2014) argued tax evasion is an outright dishonest action whereby the taxpayer endeavours
to reduce his tax liability through the use of illegal means which is achieved by act of omission or
commission which constitutes criminal acts under the tax laws. Olabisi (2010) mentioned some of
these tax evasion behavior which include failure to pay tax, e.g. personal income tax, withholding
tax, income tax, value added tax etc. failure to submit returns, omission of items from returns,
fraudulent claim of relief (in personal income tax) for example: children that do not exist,
understating income, documenting fictitious transactions, overstating expenses, failure to answer
queries etc.
Tax evasion appeared threatening the nation’s economy and drawing back the achievement of her
goals in terms of economic and social benefits.
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
133
2.2 Theoretical Framework
This study is hinged on the fraud scale theory. The fraud scale theory was developed by Albrecht,
Howe, and Romney (2001) as an alternative to the fraud triangle model. The fraud scale is very
similar to the fraud triangle; however, the fraud scale uses an element called “personal integrity”
instead of rationalization and this is often used by tax evaders when considering that they may not
be caught in their fraudulent behaviour. This personal integrity element is associated with each
individual’s personal code of ethical behaviour. Dorminey (2010) also argued that, unlike
rationalization in the fraud triangle theory, personal integrity can be observed in both an
individual’s decisions and the decision-making process, which can help in assessing integrity and
determining the likelihood that an individual will commit fraud. This argument is consistent with
other research. Experts agreed that fraud and other unethical behaviours often occur due to an
individual’s lack of personal integrity or other moral reasoning (Albrecht, et al 2001; Dorminey,
2010).
Rae and Subramaniam (2008) argued that as moral and ethical norms play essential roles in an
individual’s decisions and judgment, ethics relates to determining the rightness or wrongness of a
behaviour in terms of organizational, legal, or societal guidelines. It is important to note that
individuals with low levels of ethical development have been found to be more likely to commit
fraud than those with higher levels; those with higher levels of ethical development were still found
to be capable of committing fraud, but not under the same conditions as those with lower ethical
development (Appelbaum, 2007).
2.3 Empirical Review
Aumeerun, et al. (2016) in their study of the effect of tax evasion on the sub-saharan Africa
concluded that tax evasion, which is a part of tax fraud, is a severe problem in sub-saharan African
region which have negative impact on GDP.
Olabisi, (2010) further observed that the taxpayer indulges in evasion by resorting to various
practices which erode moral values and build up inflationary pressures. Data collected by the study
were analyzed using percentages, the arithmetic mean and standard deviation, the study concluded
that tax evasion and avoidance is a very serious social menace that is causing a major setback on
Nigerian economic development. From all indications it was clear from the study that if
government engages in overhauling the tax administrative machineries, the problems of tax
evasion and avoidance will be reduced to the barest minimum. It is also important for the federal
government to put in place stiff penalty for corrupt tax officials and make frantic efforts aimed at
putting in place adequate enforcement for defaulters. Such penalties and enforcement will help
generate more revenue to the coffers of the government. It is hoped that if the measures prescribed
in this study are implemented, it will go some way in reducing the problem of tax evasion and
avoidance to reasonable dimensions.
Duccio and Matthew (2016) in their own study characterized optimal individual tax evasion and
avoidance when taxpayers “narrow bracket” the joint avoidance/evasion decision by exhausting
all gainful methods for legal avoidance before choosing whether or not also to evade illegally. The
study found that (1) evasion is an increasing function of the audit probability when the latter is low
enough, yet tax avoidance is always decreasing in the probability of audit; and (2) that, holding
constant the expected return to evasion, it is not always the case that the combined loss of reported
income due to avoidance and evasion can be stemmed by increasing the fine rate and decreasing
the audit probability. Fakofuka (2013) in their work on corporate income tax evasion asserted that
theoretical researches on corporate income tax evasion have been disadvantaged far too long by
its incompatibility and limitations. The paper argued that in order to enhance the theoretical
contributions to the problem of corporate income tax evasion, it requires a framework that
bridges the gap between the prediction aspect and the identification aspects of corporate
income tax evasion. Fakofuka (2013) identified four aspects of forensic and audit policies that
will reduce corporate income tax evasion. First, the cut-off policy is recommended over the
standard random audit policy. Second, there should be a reward program to encourage the
capturing of tax evasion and dis-courage it practices. Third, cut-off policy should include
rules to ensure the frequency of tax auditing. Fourth, audit policy should include an
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
134
independence test to ensure that corporations characterized by lack of independence are
subjected to a higher audit probability than those corporations without such characteristics.
Oluwole (2017), in study carried out found that high profile personalities have not been convicted
for tax evasion in Nigeria as we have them convicted in developed countries, not that we do not
have tax evasion laws that are strong enough to prosecute tax illicit wealth and other tax evasion
offences up to supreme court and get them convicted. However, approach of the agencies (EFCC
and ICPC) saddled with prosecuting financial crimes in Nigeria is mild.
In a study carried out by Gordana, Aleksandar, Mirko, Milojo and Milan (2015), it was found that
tax policy and tax administration are the most important part of every tax system reform and that
the fundamental role of the tax administration is to render quality tax-payer services and to
encourage voluntary compliance of tax laws, and also to detect and penalize non-compliance. The
extent of success of the tax administration in its role should be reflected through a high level of
tax compliance and a lower level of tax evasion. Only with collected taxes are governments able
to provide all public services and to implement welfare programmes.
3.0 METHODOLOGY
Content analysis is adopted in this research work. It involved proper review of books, journals,
periodicals, financial reporting standards and relevant laws.
4.0 DISCUSSION
Abata (2014) argued that tax revenue mobilization as a source of financing development activities
in Nigeria has been a difficult issue because of tax fraud that exists in the system which are
primarily exhibited in various form of resistance, such as evasion, avoidance and other forms of
fraudulent practices. These activities are considered as sabotaging the economy and are readily
presented as part of the reasons for present state of underdevelopment in Nigeria. Abata (2014)
went further that government exists to collect taxes from available economic resources and make
use of same to create economic prosperity, gainful employment, provision of infrastructure and
essential public services among others. Tax resistance only makes these laudable programmes
unattainable. Most developed countries of the world such as United Kingdom, USA, Canada,
France, Netherlands etc derive substantial revenue from tax based incomes such as company
income tax, value added tax, import duties which they have used to create prosperities (Oyebamiji,
2018). Onyeka and Nwankwo (2016) supported this claim that though tax frauds are problems
that face every tax system, the Nigerian situation seems unique when viewed against the scale of
corrupt practices in the country. Onyeka, et al. (2016), Oyebamiji, (2018) went further that this
tax fraud has adverse effect on government revenue which is becoming more pronounced now that
the oil revenue has dropped drastically.
Fatoki (2014) citing Nwachukwu (2006) said tax evasion is the general term for efforts by
individuals, firms, trusts and other entities to evade taxes by illegal means. Tax evasion usually
entails taxpayers deliberately misrepresenting or concealing the true state of their affairs to the tax
authorities to reduce their tax liability. It also includes, in particular, dishonest tax reporting such
as declaring less income, profits or gains than actually earned; or overstating deductions. Tax
evasion, apart from being a moral wrong, also amounts to a breach of the tax laws.
According to Soyode, et al. (2006), tax evasion is defined as a deliberate and willful practice of
not disclosing full taxable income in order to pay less tax. It is a deliberate violation of tax laws
and it is evident in situations where tax liability is fraudulently reduced or false claims are filled
on the revenue tax form (Olabisi, 2010; Soyode, et al. 2006). From the comparison of various
definitions given in the literature, it can be seen that paying less tax or not at all than what one is
legally obliged to is described as tax evasion while tax avoidance is an act of doing everything
possible within the confines of the tax law to reduce the tax paid. Therefore, the main difference
between them is the legality of the payer’s action. Tax evasion, according to Uadiale, et al. (2010),
is an outright dishonest action whereby the taxpayer endeavours to reduce his tax liability through
the use of illegal means. Tax evasion is accomplished by a deliberate act of omission or
commission which constitutes criminal acts under the tax laws these acts include: failure to pay
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
135
tax e.g. withholding tax, failure to submit returns, omission of items from returns, claiming relief
(in Personal Income Tax), for example, of children that do not exist, understating income,
documenting fictitious transactions, overstating expenses, Failure to answer queries etc (Olabisi,
2010; Uadiale, et al. 2010).
Other causes of tax evasion and tax avoidance are: fraud in public office, inadequate tax education
and awareness, misappropriation of taxes collected, ignorance of the tax authority, lack of adequate
enforcement for default, proliferation of taxes, loopholes in the tax laws, inequitable distribution
of income, absence of ‘Quid Pro Quo’ i.e. something of value given in return (by the government)
for taxes paid, high level of illiteracy and high tax rates. Tax evasion and tax avoidance has
undoubtedly affected adversely the government revenue generation capability and the economy as
a whole. However, despite the government efforts to bridle the practices of tax evasion and tax
avoidance in Nigeria, the problem still persists. There is no doubt that the due to the federal
government of Nigeria will be reduced by the lack of good governance and unpatriotic act of tax
evaders.
Adegbite (2018) argued that forensic accounting technique such as ethical culture, legislation, risk
management principles, judicial system and forensic skills if properly applied will prevent and
detect fraud of which tax evasion is inclusive.
First, there is need for improvement on ethical culture of organizations in Nigeria. Special
attentions should be paid by concerned authorities to organizations, by instituting good and viable
ethics in work places with special emphasis on reference checks, instituting fraud hotlines and
whistleblowing policies, code of sanctions against erring personalities and organizations, will
bring about the desired effect of tax fraud prevention and detection in Nigeria. In addition, there is
need for periodic training on ethics in order to maintain and improve on the ethical standards of
these organizations and personalities.
Second, Legislation that will strengthen the tax fraud prevention and detection should be enforced
by appropriate authorities. The use of appropriate legislation, as forensic accounting tool, would
influence tax fraud prevention and detection in Nigeria. Enforcement of appropriate Legislation
such as Nigerian 1999 constitution, fiscal responsibility Act 2007, finance Act 1958, procurement
Act 2007, Employee Declaration of Assets Act 1990, criminal code Act 2004, Money Laundering
Act 1995 and other Legislation that deter fraud should be enforced.
Third, management of the risk of any organization is very essential and efforts should be geared
by appropriate authorities to improve on this. Efforts should be made to improve on internal control
system, internal audit department/ unit, security department should be equipped with latest security
skills.
Nigeria needs to improve on her judicial system, court delays and weak litigation support for
prosecution of tax fraud cases should be improved upon. Indiscipline/abuse of power, and lack of
transparency by judicial experts should be looked into. There is need for the appropriate authorities
in Nigeria to thoroughly sanitize Nigerian judicial system to flush out the bad eggs in the system.
By doing this, transparency will be installed back into the system and the better for war against tax
fraud in Nigeria. The reconstitution of tax appeal tribunals in the six geo-political zones as well as
Lagos and Abuja in Nigeria is a welcome development. The aim is to bring back tax payers trust
and confidence in the fairness of the tax system in Nigeria (Ifeanyi, 2018).
Fifth, acquisition of relevant skills on forensic accounting by accountants, auditors and tax
administrators needs to be encouraged by appropriate authorities and this will make positive
impact on war against tax fraud in Nigeria. This can be achieved by the introduction of forensic
accounting to the curriculum of all training institutions, and accounting and auditing professional
bodies across the country. Practical training through attachments of scholars to reputable forensic
accounting firms and capacity buildings for tax administrators; where trainees will be exposed to
quality forensic accounting analysis and state of the earth technologies on forensic accounting can
also be done to achieve this objective.
5.0 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
136
5.1 Conclusion
Fraud has been a cog in the wheel of development and economic and sanity globally. Personality
influence plays a major role in committing fraud of which tax evasion is inclusive. Forensic
accounting has been an antidote in preventing and detecting fraud, especially tax evasion fraud.
Following through with forensic accounting technique which includes code of conduct and
enforcing noted steps and consequences when someone is caught is crucial to preventing fraud. In
conclusion tax fraud has a strong potential to steal the wealth of a nation and impoverish her people
therefore using forensic accounting strategies to prevent and detect this fraud will go a long way
in enhancing economic growth and development of a nation.
5.2 Recommendations
This paper put forward the following recommendations:
First, fraud should be seen, especially tax fraud, as retrogressive to a nation and should be totally
condemned by all, the need to achieve this should be put in place by appropriate authorities.
Secondly, there is need for improvement on ethical culture of organizations in Nigeria. Special
attentions should be paid by concerned authorities to organizations, by instituting good and viable
ethics in work places to stem effect of personality in committing tax evasion fraud.
Third, Legislation that will strengthen the tax fraud prevention and detection should be enforced
by appropriate authorities.
Fourth, management of the risk of any organization is very essential and efforts should be geared
by appropriate authorities to improve on this. Efforts should be made to improve on internal control
system, internal audit department/ unit, security department should be equipped with latest security
skills.
Fifth, Nigeria needs to improve on her judicial system, court delays and weak litigation support
for prosecution of tax fraud cases should be improved upon. Indiscipline/abuse of power and lack
of transparency by judicial experts should be looked into.
Sixth, acquisition of relevant skills on forensic accounting by accountants, tax administrators and
auditors needs to be encouraged by appropriate authorities and this will make positive impact on
war against tax fraud in Nigeria.
Lastly, government should ensure that tax revenue collected is judiciously spent in providing
infrastructure in order to ensure tax justice and this will help in sensitizing Nigerian population to
the cancer of tax evasion fraud and applying all necessary measures to eradicate this cancer using
forensic accounting techniques.
REFERENCES
Abata, M.A. (2014). The impact of tax revenue on the Nigerian Economy. Journal of policy and
development studies, 8(2), 109 - 121.
Adegbie, F. F., & Fakile, A.S. (2012). Economic and financial crime in Nigeria: Forensic
accounting as antidote. British Journal of Arts and Social Sciences ISSN: 2046-9578, 6(1),
37-50.
Adegbite, S. A. (2017). Instituting University -Wide Internal Control System that Guarantees
Accountability and Transparency in Financial Transaction: The Role of Internal Audit.
Uniosun International Journal of Business Administration (UIJBA), 1(2), 155-159.
Adegbite, S.A. (2018). Forensic accounting and fraud prevention and detection in public
universities in South-West Nigeria. A PhD thesis submtted to the Department of
Accounting, School of Management Sciences, Babcock University, Ilishan-Remo, Ogun
State Nigeria.
Aduwo, O. O. (2016). The role of forensic accounting in combacting the menance of corporate
failure. International Journal of Economics Commerce and Management, IV(1), 640-649.
AICPA. (2006). Forensic procedures and specialists: useful tools and techniques: Special Report
by Business Valuation and Forensic and Litigation Service Section of AICPA. AICPA.
Albrecht, W. S., & Romney, M. B. (2001). A red flagging management fraud: A validation.
Advanced Journal in Accounting, 3, 323-333.
Journal of Taxation and Economic Development ISSN 1118-6017 Vol. 17(2) Sept 2018, Pp. 131-140
The Official Publication of the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria
137
Al-Sharaivi, M. E. (2018). The role of forensic accounting in limiting tax evasion in the Jordanian
public individual shareholding companies through the perpective of Jordanian Economics
and Finance. International Journal of Economics and Finance, 10(1), 233-243.
Appelbaum, P. S. (2007). Assessment of patients' competence to consent to treatment. N Engl J
Med, 357(18), 1834-1840.
Aumeerun, B., Jugurnath, B., & Soondum, H. (2016). Tax evasion: Empirical evidence from Sub-
Saharan Africa. Journal of Accounting and Taxation, 8(7), 70-80.
Dada, S. O., Adegbite, S. A., & Benjamin, R. D. (2017). Forensic accounting and fraud prevention
strategies: Panacea to economic development. Babcock Journal of Management and Social
Sciences, 12(1&2), 41-59.
Dibra, R. (2016). Corporate governance failure: the case of Enron and Parmalat. European
Scientific Journal, 12(16), 283-290.
Dorminey, J., Fleming, A., Kranacher, M., & Riley, R. (2010). Beyond the fraud triangle. CPA
Journal, 80(7), 17-23.
Duccio, G., & Mathew, D. R. (2016). Income tax avoidance and evasion: A narrow bracketing
approach. SAGE Journals, Public Finance Review, 8(5), 323-338.
Effiong, E. J. (2013). An exploration of forensic accounting education and practice for fraud
prevention and detection in Nigeria. A doctoral thesis for the award of the degree of doctor
of philosophy at De Montfort University, Leicester.
Fakofuka, P. (2013). The contectual framework of corporate income tax evasion. Journal of
Accounting and Taxation, 5(2), 27 - 37.
Fatoki, J. O. (2014). An empirical study of tax evasion and tax avoidance: A citical issue in Nigeria
economic development. Journal of Economic and Sustainable Development, 5(18), 22-26.
Gordana S.; Aleksandar D.; Mirko V.; Milojko A.; & Milan M. (2015). Impact of the efficiency
of the tax administration on tax evasion. Economic research-Ekonomska Istrazivanja,
28(1), 1138 - 1148.
ICPC. (2018). Retrieved August 28, 2018, from icpc.gov.ng>contact-us.
Ifeanyi, O. (2018, July 13). Retrieved August 28, 2018, from https//punchng.com>fg-
reconstitutes-ta....: Federal government reconstitutes tax appeal tribunals
Modugu & Anyaduba. (2013). Forensic accounting and financial fraud in Nigeria: An empirical
approach. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 4(7), 281-289.
Moncarz E., Moncarz R., Cabella A., & Moncarz B. (2006). The rise and colapse of Envron
financial innovation, errors and lessons. Contaduriay administracion, Universidad
National de Mexico, 17-37.
Okoye, E. I., & Gbegi, D. O. (2013). An evaluation of forensic accountants to planning and
management of fraud risk detection procedures. Global Journal of Management and
Business Research, 13(Version 1, USA), 1-17.
Olabisi, J. (2010). An assessment of tax evasion and tax avoidance in Lagos State. Journal of
Research in National Development, 8(1), 1-4.
Oluwole, O. (2017, April 9). Retrieved August 26, 2018, from
http//www.proshaveng.com/news/taxation/wagesofsin-Tax-Evasion-and-the-Tax-Law:
Tax-Evasion-and-the-Tax-Laws: My Thoughts on the Anti-Corruption Campaign in
Nigeria
Onyeka, V. N; & Nwankwo, C. (2016). The effect of tax evasion and avoidance in Nigeria's
economic growth. European Journal of Business Management, 8(24), 158-166.
Oyebamiji, A.T. (2018). Tax justice, demographic factors and compliance of Nigerian corporate
tax payers. A PhD Doctoral thesis submitted to the Department of Accounting, School of
Management Sciences, Babcock University, Ilishan-Remo, Ogun State, Nigeria.
Rae, K., & Subramaniam, N. (2008). Quality internal control procedures: Antecedents and
moderating effect on organizational justice and employee fraud. Managerial Auditing
Journal, 23(2), 104-124.
Soyode, L., & Kajola, S. O. (2006). Taxation: Principles and Practice in Nigeria (1st ed.). Ibadan:
Silicon.
Uadiale, O. M., Fagbemi, T. O., & Ogunleye, J. O. (2010). An empirical study in the relationship
between culture and personal income tax evasion in Nigeria. European Journal of
Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences, 20(1), 116-126.
... Hence, there is a need for a paradigm shift from traditional tax audits to more sophisticated tax audit practices such as forensic accounting practices. Forensic accounting is one of the most effective and efficient ways of reducing and preventing fraudulent activities in Nigeria (Adegbite, Oyebamiji & Oyedokun, 2018) because it has its models and methodologies of investigative procedures (Nosiri, Uwakwe & Abiahu, 2021). Jafaru (2011) stated that forensic accounting is the application of financial skills and investigative mentality conducted within the context of the rules of evidence to resolve unresolved issues. ...
... The theory of fraud diamond alluded to potential taxpayers who are motivated to engage in tax fraud not only need an opportunity but must also have the capability to explore the existing fraud opportunity (weakness in the tax fraud management techniques) with higher opportunity due to the weaknesses identified in the traditional tax audit technique (Adegbite, Oyebamiji & Oyedokun, 2018;Adekoya, Oyebamiji & Lawal, 2020). It can be further predicted that when a taxpayer has the higher pressure, and can cover up with tax fraud, the mind of committing tax fraud is more likely to occur. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
The thesis examines the forensic accounting techniques, Institutional quality, taxpayers behavior and tax fraud Management in south west, Nigeria. Specifically, the study examines the effect of forensic accounting techniques on tax fraud Management in south west Nigeria, the influence of perceived institutional quality on tax fraud Management in south west Nigeria, taxpayers behavior on tax fraud Management in south west Nigeria and the determine the influence of interaction between perceived institutional quality and taxpayers behavior on tax fraud Management in south west Nigeria.
... We need the data and intelligence which you have to help us track tax evaders and bring them into the tax net. The sharing of data with the FIRS in order to track tax evaders, defaulters and tackle illicit financial flow in Nigeria will enable the government to raise its revenue profile in order to fund development projects (Adebolu, 2018). ...
... Overall, tax evasion is described as the a empt to decrease tax burden using illegal means, and tax avoidance is defined as "lowering taxation through legal means. Adegbite, Oyebamiji, and Oyedokun (2018) distinguished two types of deliberate tax evasion: evasion by commission and evasion by omission. Tax evasion through commission necessitates a taxpayer activity, such as claiming deductions or rebates, which means that if a taxpayer makes a false claim, he will receive a tax break (a commission on top of his evading actions). ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Taxation is the most important and obvious source of funding for governments around the world. Any service that benefits the public will necessitate taxation to cover at least a portion of the costs. Nigeria has a range of alternatives for financing its public expenditures and implementing its fiscal policies. However, tax compliance and remittance have been reported to be relatively low in Nigeria, where tax revenue is the primary source of locally generated revenue. This study then sought to examine the effects of tax system, tax behaviour and tax justice on voluntary compliance. This study reviewed the following theories: Classical Theory of Tax Compliance; Economic Deterrence Theory; Fiscal Exchange Theory; Comparative Treatment Model; Political Legitimacy Theory; Behavioural Economics Theory; and Theory of Planned Behaviour. The primary data was gathered and analysed with Google Forms. From the findings, the study revealed that implications of tax evasion make Nigerians to be tax compliant. However, it can be concluded that the inefficient Nigerian tax system, tax behaviour and tax justice yields low tax compliance. Therefore, this study recommends that Government should continue to provide basic amenities to its citizens and be accountable, as this will convince citizens that tax monies are being utilised; Tax education should be carried out frequently. Tax administrators should administer taxes within the ambit of the law; while the use of technology and professionally trained employees should continue to be encouraged. Tax authorities should endeavour to work with other agencies such as Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC), Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC) and Economic and Financial Crime Commission (EFCC) aid citizens tax compliance; and tax administrators should ensure that updated records of individuals and companies are maintained.
... The contending problems of tax fraud, collusion among tax officials, and diversion of government revenue into private pockets remain a major challenge in developing countries; as such, tax fraud remains one of the greatest problems plaguing revenue from taxes in Nigeria (Baunsguaard & Michael, 2005). Also, Adegbite, Oyebamiji, and Oyedokun (2018) stated that tax fraud has cost the government of Nigeria billions of naira that would have gone into infrastructural development and job creation. In south-west Nigeria, between 2011 and 2017, the region lost about $1.5 trillion as a result of tax fraud (Lagos State N450 billion; Oyo State N261 billion; Ondo State N43 billion; Osun State N281 billion; and Ogun State N387 billion) (Folayan, Dosumu, & Amusa, 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
Tax fraud remains the greatest challenge to the government across the world, but the alarming rate at which it is being perpetrated in Nigeria is of concern to the government. The government has lost billions of naira as a result of this. The involvement of taxpayers in tax fraud depends on the level at which they perceive the institution of governance. Hence, this study examined the influence of interaction between institutional quality and taxpayers’ behaviors on tax fraud management in south-west Nigeria. The study employed a quantitative method to generate data from the total population of 504,263 respondents. The sample size consisted of 400 taxpayers (companies and businesses) registered with the Federal Inland Revenue Service in southwest Nigeria. The data were analyzed using the partial least squares structural equation model (PLS-SEM). The interaction of institutional quality and taxpayer behaviors on tax fraud management was found to have a significant negative relationship (= -0.066, t = -1.763, p = 0.039, 0.05). According to this study, the sets of exogenous latent variables (i.e., institutional quality and taxpayer behaviors) explain 78% of the variance in tax fraud management. The study concluded that the working together of taxpayers’ perceptions of both low institutional quality and taxpayers’ behaviors has a significant influence on the tendency for taxpayers to engage in tax fraud management in south-west Nigeria. It was recommended that the better the morale of a taxpayer, the lower the tax fraud. Therefore, the government is advised to adopt policies and measures that can boost the taxpayers’ morality, which will in turn enable them to see tax fraud as a negative to their principled value system as law-abiding citizens. It is also recommended that tax authorities should be seen as taxpayers' friends by making their interactions with taxpayers less bureaucratic. Article visualizations: </p
... Tax fraud is a global phenomenon and challenges, According to [12] , Fowler highlights that these challenges offer a global response to issues of international tax avoidance; tax evasion; illicit financial flows; money laundering and other harmful tax practices based cooperation and use of advanced technologies to tackle them. [25] subsume that tax fraud is very prevalent in the Nigeria concept, it has cost the government billions of Naira, and the cost of tracking tax fraud has further constitute cost to the government. Tax fraud entails cheating on a tax return in an attempt to avoid paying the entire tax obligation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Deterrent as punishment to tax fraud is an age long tool correcting tax offender and ensuring prompt response to payment of tax levies, as it were from inception tax fraud is astronomically on the increase rather than declining. The aim of this paper was to assess the role of deterrent on tax fraud in Nigeria. The study attempts to review components of tax frauds applicable to deterrent as punishment on tax defaulters or culprits. The paper presents detailed analysis of tax evasion, avoidance and causes of tax fraud with possible reasons responsible for taxpayer declines to file in tax obligations as oppose to willingness to pay. Specifically, it supervene major inherent problems and lukewarm attitudes of government inability to mitigate tax levy into responses and outcomes. Hence, demystifies credible and genuine reasons for or toward tax revenue realizations, responses and outcomes. Moreso, the paper identifies basis for future research, expanded the scope of study and highlighted relevance arguments among reviewed related theoretical issues using a causal factor and conceptual approach thereby involving survey of literature to bring relevance issues to the fore as oppose to the aforementioned nomenclatures. Essentially, various tax penalties ensuring defaulters is punishable relative to the proportion of offenses involved were discussed. Thereafter, pass on to overhaul prior studies, gaps in reviewed prior studies and domesticate the study on relevant deterrent school of thoughts. It therefore, concludes that Tax fraud may not have an end in Nigeria, if those saddled with the responsibility of tax all-encompassing, inclusiveness, delivering tax-welfare to taxpayers are seen not transparent, accountable, sincere, sensitive to the plight of tax payers, and devoid of skirmishes as well as translating taxes revenue into responsibility. However, propose that deterrence is not anylonger the way to go, having tossed both sides of the divide, exigency of time have to take precedence; and allows civility, novelty, automation and all-inclusiveness muster and remediate tax fraud in Nigeria.
Article
Full-text available
This study investigates the impact of forensic accounting on accountability and revenue enhancement in Africa, focusing on Nigeria's public sector. The main objective is to assess how forensic accounting techniques can improve accountability, and increase internally generated revenue (IGR). The study adopts a mixed-methods approach, utilizing quantitative data from questionnaires distributed to public sector employees and qualitative insights from interviews with forensic accounting experts. A sample size of thirty (35) respondents which comprises auditors, accountants, and forensic accounting experts of the State Board of Internal Revenue Service, Abia state, Nigeria was adopted. Descriptive statistics and Analysis of variance, (ANOVA) were used to analyze the data and evaluate the relationship between forensic accounting and key financial outcomes. The findings reveal that forensic accounting significantly contributes to fraud detection, improves accountability, and enhances revenue collection in Nigeria's public sector. Specifically, forensic accounting tools were found effective in identifying anomalies in revenue databases, regulating taxes, fees, fines, and borrowings, and detecting weaknesses in internal controls. The study also highlights the need for specialized forensic accounting units within public institutions to fully realize these benefits. In conclusion, forensic accounting emerges as a critical tool for addressing financial irregularities and boosting public sector revenue in Nigeria, with implications for other African countries. The study recommends the establishment of dedicated forensic accounting units, continuous capacity building, and policy integration to maximize the impact of forensic accounting on public sector accountability and revenue generation.
Thesis
Full-text available
ABSTRACT The main objective of the study was to assess the determinants of occupational fraud amongst SMEs in Edo State. Specifically, the study examined the relationship between owner factor; organizational factor; personal factor; and employee factor on occupational fraud amongst SMEs in Edo State. The study employed primary data with the use of questionnaire to elicit information from population of study using Guilford and Flruchter (1973) formula to determine sample size among SMEs key officials, and introduced path correlation and pooled Ordinary Least Square (OLS) regression to assess which among the determining indicators had positively or negatively influences occupational fraud amongst SMEs. The study revealed that owner factor had significant influence and positive relationship with occupational fraud. This implied that owner factor is a strong influencing factor on occupational frauds amongst SMEs in Edo State, while organizational factor showed a significant effect and positive relationship. The implication of this is that organizational factor is a critical enhancing factor of occupational fraud amongst SMEs in Edo State. Moreso, the study observed that personal factor had significant effect and positive relationship with occupational fraud. The implication of this is also that personal of the employee had strong determining influence, which further revealed that employee factor had no significant effect, but positive relationship. The finding implied that employee factor is a weak enhancing factor of occupational fraud amongst SMEs in Edo State. The study therefore, concludes that the following factors of occupational fraud such as owner, organizational, personal and employee has the ability of lessen occupational fraud amongst small and medium scale enterprise in Edo State if adequate policy is entrenched, rules and procedures are closely monitored and followed to the later. Hence, occupational frauds with emphasis to various factors that enhance them are cankers that could disruption operations and going concern of small businesses in Edo State and Nigeria in general.
Article
Full-text available
The study examined the nexus between forensic accounting and government revenue in Nigeria with the inclusion of domestic debt factor. The study adopts survey research by employing primary data through structured questionnaire and judgmental sampling technique. The target population was 1,500 experienced professionals in Public finance, forensic accounting and other types of audit and practicing and or working in Lagos State, Nigeria. The sample size was 306, determined with the use of Krejcie and Morgan (1970) formula. Data were analysed through logit regression technique. The findings show a positive significant relationship between. This is affirmed as calculated, 1.098 is greater than t-tabulated of 0.273 at 5% level of significance. The empirical investigation also shows that the application of Forensic Accounting skills would reduce the incidences of ineffective management of domestic debt. The study recommended among others for a strong policy for the institutionalization of forensic accounting units in the public sector.
Article
Full-text available
Tax fraud is a longstanding problem that has affected the government's ability to mobilise revenue needed to enhance growth and development. Billions of naira have been reported lost to tax fraud and mitigating this menace has become a high point of call to various tax authorities. Prior researchers have alluded that strategies to deterring tax fraud should be built on factors that influence taxpayers' non-compliant attitudes. On this premise, this study sets out the broad objective of examining the various causal factors of tax fraud in Nigeria. The study adopted the desk research design which involves a review of periodicals on tax fraud in Nigeria, journal articles on the subject of tax fraud, corporate reports and other related documents that address the vexed issue of tax fraud. The study revealed some factors against tax fraud; and these revolve around tax rate, income level, poor tax administration, corruption, low tax penalty, perceived use of tax revenue, tax fairness, and the level of tax payer's education. Each of these factors was found to impinge on tax fraud either separately or through a contribution of a number of factors to the flux of tax fraud in Nigeria. Further, though these factors contribute to the debacle of tax fraud as observed in the literature, they, however, present themselves as factors whose effect in tax fraud are felt in various degrees. In the light of the foregoing, it is suggested that clearly defined strategies and tax policies be required in terms of clear-cut incentives and tax cuts to reduce the burden of tax and to eliminate opportunities that facilitate tax fraud.
Book
Full-text available
The global community is changing and growing at a faster pace. This is as a result of globalization, high digital/information technology investments, and the rapid pace of technological change in combination with escalating costs of research and development. Information technology (IT) concerning computers and peripheral equipment has seen tremendous growth in service industries. Recently, its role has shifted over the last decades to become an important part of how corporate organizations and governments manage and control their resources (Huang, 2005). The digitization of the economy creates benefits and efficiencies as digital technologies drive innovation and fuel job opportunities and economic growth. The digital economy also permeates all aspects of society, influencing the way people interact and bringing about broad sociological changes. Digital technology has revolutionized the way work is carried out, but many smaller businesses and any nation that lack digital skills are being left behind. Technological advances will continue to provide new ways of working. Economy and businesses that embrace those changes will reap the benefits of a highly satisfied workforce and tremendous economic growth and development. In Nigeria, corruption, money laundering, tax evasion, and other related crimes have assumed alarming proportions. Pervasive mismanagement of resources has become the order of the day both in public and private organizations. Financial crime has become pervasive and the likelihood of corporate fraud occurring has also become more severe.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims at identifying the role of forensic accounting in limiting tax evasion in the Jordanian public industrial shareholding companies as well as identifying the most modern methods followed by the Jordanian industrial companies to evade the payment of due taxes. The study also concentrated on clarifying the fields in which forensic accounting is applied and reasons for its appearance. The researcher chose a random sample of external auditors affiliated to the Jordanian association of certified public accountants (JACPA) who had audited the financial statements of the public shareholding industrial companies in Jordan. The study produced a number of important results and recommendations most significantly that there is no statistically significant role of the forensic accounting in limiting the acquisition method of accounting and the misuse of materiality as methods of tax evasion followed in the Jordanian industrial companies, and that there is a statistically significant role of the forensic accounting in limiting the use of accounting estimates and revenue recognition as methods of tax evasion followed byJordanian industrial companies. The researcher also recommends for the competent governmental authorities to activate the role of forensic accounting as a method to limit the cases of tax evasion.
Article
Full-text available
We characterize optimal individual tax evasion and avoidance when taxpayers " narrow bracket " the joint avoidance/evasion decision by exhausting all gainful methods for legal avoidance before choosing whether or not also to evade illegally. We find that (i) evasion is an increasing function of the audit probability when the latter is low enough, yet tax avoidance is always decreasing in the probability of audit; (ii) an analogous finding to the so-called Yitzhaki puzzle for evasion also holds for tax avoidance –an increase in the tax rate decreases the level of avoided income and the level of avoided tax; and (iii) that, holding constant the expected return to evasion, it is not always the case that the combined loss of reported income due to avoidance and evasion can be stemmed by increasing the finene rate and decreasing the audit probability.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we analyse the performance of the tax administration using data envelopment analysis (DEA) and regression analysis in 13 European countries. In the first phase, a DEA input- oriented model with the three input and two output parameters for the efficiency evaluation has been used. The influence of selected independent variables on the grey economy, which represents an approximation of tax evasion and efficiency of tax administration, was conducted by regression analysis in the second phase. The main goal is to investigate the influence of the relative efficiency and number of employees in tax administration as well as country employment rate on the grey economy level.
Article
Corporate governance is the organizational arrangement by which a company represents and serves the interests of its investors. It encompasses anything from a company’s boards to executive compensation schemes to bankruptcy laws. Generally, the definitions of corporate governance which was found in the literature tend to share certain characteristics. One of this characteristic is the notion of accountability. Corporate governance is the process of supervision and control which intends to ensure that the company’s management acts in accordance with the interests of shareholders (Parkinson, 1994). Corporate governance, the internal policies and leadership that guide the actions of corporations, played a major part in the recent global financial crisis. While much blame has been targeted at compensation arrangements that rewarded extreme risk-taking but did not punish failure, the performance of large, supposedly, sophisticated institutional investors in this crisis have not been examined. Corporate governance has come to the forefront of academic research due to the vital role it plays in the overall health of economic systems. Corporate governance was long ignored as a matter of potential importance for the development of a nation’s economy. This paper, however, expresses some cases in the field of corporate governance, regarding the failure of corporate governance. Institutional investors failed to effectively monitor such volatile investments, ignoring relatively well-established corporate governance principles and best practices. Corporate Governance Failures offers nuanced and realistic proposals to mitigate future financial pitfalls.
Article
Tax is the income which is paid to the government in order to fulfill the need of the public. However tax evasion is the act of not paying the tax by use of illegal ways. Allingham and Sandmo being the first researchers studying the tax evasion found a relationship of tax evasion with low penalty fees and a low detection. The tax evasion basically is affected by various factors but it also affects many economic factors. Sub Saharan Africa being a developing region is facing the phenomenon of tax evasion in a crucial way. This study measures the impact of the tax evasion on the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita of Sub Saharan Africa. The relationship between the GDP per capita and tax evasion is tested using the generalized least squared whereby it is found that there is a positive impact of tax evasion on the GDP per capita however the p-value states that the tax evasion is insignificant and is not an important component for the determination of the GDP per capita. Moreover in the presence of tax evasion, this study shows that GDP per capita has also a negative relationship with the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), positive relationship the Gross Domestic Fixed Capital Formation (GDFCF), a favorable connection with the export, a negative relationship with the import, a positive impact on the inflation and a negative relationship with the government expenditure. To fight against tax evasion for the economic benefit of Sub Saharan Africa, it is advised to review the tax system, to implement strict and severe penalties and very high fines for tax evaders. Moreover, the tax authorities of Sub Saharan Africa need to appoint more experts in auditing department to be able to detect the non-compliance tax payers easily and rapidly Key words: Tax evasion, cross sectional regression, tax morale.
Article
The Portfolio Investment Framework, the Principal Agent Framework and the Principal Two Agents Framework of tax evasion, individually or collectively, are inadequate to represent fairly the dynamics of corporate income tax evasion. These behavior based frameworks are for the prediction of tax evasion and their usefulness for identifying tax evasion is limited. To bridge the gap between the prediction and the identification aspects of corporate income tax evasion, this paper presents the Contextual Framework of Corporate Income Tax Evasion, structured with twelve ideas and thirty five dynamics to guide and direct future research. With a simple game theory model, the paper promotes the tax audit cut-off policy that incorporates a reward program for the agent of government, ensures audit frequency and tests independence of the agent from governance.
Article
ABSTRACT The article investigates the reason for and prevention of corporate fraud triangle, the convergence of perceived pressure, perceived opportunity and rationalization to facilitate fraud in the U.S. A study by Donald Cressey is cited, which focused on the circumstances persuading people to initially violate ethical standards and to commit their first fraudulent act. The characteristics of people who commit fraud are mentioned. A summary of fraud triangle and model extensions is also provided.