Content uploaded by James Konopasek
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by James Konopasek on Apr 11, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
Konopasek and Nelson 2015 Sexual History Disclosure and Sex Offender Recidivism
Abstract
This research shows that sexual history disclosure sufficient to produce a No Significant Response (NSR) polygraph examination result within 6 months of treatment onset is correlated with treatment outcome and reduced odds of sexual recidivism.
... In relation to recidivism, Cook et al (2014) found that those who did not receive a polygraph, reoff ended signifi cantly more over a 5 year follow up period, compared with those who did undertake a polygraph. Other 5 year follow-up studies have shown similar results with low recidivism when comparing matched polygraphed with non-polygraphed sex off enders (McGrath et al., 2007;Konopasek & Nelson, 2015). ...
Polygraph examinations are commonly used to monitor individuals following conviction for a sexual offense. The objective of polygraph use is to elicit risk-relevant disclosures to inform and improve management of people who have offended sexually, with the ultimate aim of reducing the likelihood of reoffending. However, by synthesizing and evaluating the existing recidivism literature relating to post-conviction sexual offense-related testing (PCSOT), this narrative analysis demonstrates that use of PCSOT lacks robust empirical support beyond the fact that examinations facilitate increased disclosures and can be used as a surveillance tool. This review proposes mechanisms through which polygraphs would be expected to impact offending behavior and explores potential explanations for why PCSOT has not been found to reduce recidivism. It is suggested that polygraphs may undermine a trusting relationship and may be over-relied upon as a tool to tackle denial or determine risk categorization, instead of translating disclosures into individualized management. It is clear from this review that there is an urgent need for more rigorous research to assess the effectiveness of PCSOT in terms of treatment and recidivism outcomes, to inform policies that facilitate empirically driven clinical practice.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.