ArticlePDF Available

Neurodevelopmental disorders in children exposed in utero to synthetic progestins: analysis from the national cohort of the Hhorages Association*

Authors:

Abstract

The medical and scientific communities have not yet fully acknowledged the undesirable effects of the synthetic hormones that have been administered to pregnant women for decades. The somatic effects of in utero exposure to diethylstilbestrol (DES), such as genital malformations, infertility, and cancer, have long been recognized but this has not been the case concerning psychiatric disorders. The progestins used in contraception and hormone replacement therapy are known to affect the adult brain, but no data exist on their effects due to in utero exposure of children. The Hhorages Association, a national patient support group, has assembled a cohort of 1200 women who took synthetic hormones during pregnancy. These women had a combined 1934 children. We obtained full questionnaire responses from 46 women treated with progestins only – and not an estrogenic cocktail – who gave birth to 115 children. Three groups were observed: Group 1 (n = 18): firstborn unexposed children, Group 2 (n = 62): children exposed in utero to synthetic progestins, and Group 3 (n = 35): children born after a previous pregnancy treated with progestins. No psychiatric disorders were reported in Group 1 and the incidence of psychiatric disorders was drastically elevated in Group 2. Our work shows a striking increase in psychiatric disorders among children exposed in utero to progestins and strongly suggests that prenatal exposure is associated with a high risk of psychiatric disorders in adolescence and adulthood, whether accompanied or not by disorders of sex development.
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=igye20
Gynecological Endocrinology
ISSN: 0951-3590 (Print) 1473-0766 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/igye20
Neurodevelopmental disorders in children
exposed in utero to synthetic progestins: analysis
from the national cohort of the Hhorages
Association*
Marie-Odile Soyer-Gobillard, Laura Gaspari, Philippe Courtet, Mauricette
Puillandre, Françoise Paris & Charles Sultan
To cite this article: Marie-Odile Soyer-Gobillard, Laura Gaspari, Philippe Courtet, Mauricette
Puillandre, Françoise Paris & Charles Sultan (2019): Neurodevelopmental disorders in children
exposed in�utero to synthetic progestins: analysis from the national cohort of the Hhorages
Association*, Gynecological Endocrinology, DOI: 10.1080/09513590.2018.1512968
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/09513590.2018.1512968
Published online: 09 Jan 2019.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 4
View Crossmark data
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Neurodevelopmental disorders in children exposed in utero to synthetic
progestins: analysis from the national cohort of the Hhorages Association
Marie-Odile Soyer-Gobillard
a,b
, Laura Gaspari
c
, Philippe Courtet
d
, Mauricette Puillandre
b
, Franc¸oise Paris
c
and
Charles Sultan
c
a
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Sorbonne University, Universit
e P. et M. Curie (Paris 6), France;
b
Association HHORAGES-France
(Halte aux HORmones Artificielles pour les GrossessES), Asni
eres sur Oise, France;
c
Service de P
ediatrie I, Unit
edendocrinologie et gyn
ecologie
p
ediatrique, Universit
e de Montpellier, France;
d
D
epartement durgence et Post urgence Psychiatrique, CHU Montpellier and Universit
ede
Montpellier, Montpellier, France
ABSTRACT
The medical and scientific communities have not yet fully acknowledged the undesirable effects of the
synthetic hormones that have been administered to pregnant women for decades. The somatic effects of
in utero exposure to diethylstilbestrol (DES), such as genital malformations, infertility, and cancer, have
long been recognized but this has not been the case concerning psychiatric disorders. The progestins
used in contraception and hormone replacement therapy are known to affect the adult brain, but no
data exist on their effects due to in utero exposure of children. The Hhorages Association, a national
patient support group, has assembled a cohort of 1200 women who took synthetic hormones during
pregnancy. These women had a combined 1934 children. We obtained full questionnaire responses from
46 women treated with progestins only and not an estrogenic cocktail who gave birth to 115 chil-
dren. Three groups were observed: Group 1 (n¼18): firstborn unexposed children, Group 2 (n¼62): chil-
dren exposed in utero to synthetic progestins, and Group 3 (n¼35): children born after a previous
pregnancy treated with progestins. No psychiatric disorders were reported in Group 1 and the incidence
of psychiatric disorders was drastically elevated in Group 2. Our work shows a striking increase in psychi-
atric disorders among children exposed in utero to progestins and strongly suggests that prenatal expos-
ure is associated with a high risk of psychiatric disorders in adolescence and adulthood, whether
accompanied or not by disorders of sex development.
ARTICLE HISTORY
Received 11 July 2018
Accepted 13 August 2018
Published online 10 January
2019
KEYWORDS
Adolescence; adulthood;
prenatal progestin
exposure; psychi-
atric disorders
Introduction
Neuroactive steroids like progesterone play an important role in
shaping the CNS structure and function (neurodevelopment,
neurogenesis, and cognition) throughout the lifespan. Progesterone
exerts powerful effects on the brain, such as regulation of neuro-
genesis and astroglial and synaptic plasticity. Moreover, it regulates
the development of neuronal types like Purkinje cells and oligoden-
drocytes, as well as the myelinization process. Progesterone exerts a
significant influence on the activity of several neurotransmitters
involved to the pathophysiology of psychosis, including the dopa-
minergic, glutamatergic and GABAergic systems. In addition to
progesterone itself, it can be converted to dehydroprogesterone and
then allopregnanolone (or iso-pregnanolone) [1], potent ligands of
the GABA-A receptor. Progesterone elicits its effects by gene tran-
scription, mediated by nuclear progesterone receptors, as well as by
non-genomic mechanisms through the activation of a signal trans-
duction pathway. Preclinical studies have provided hints that neu-
rosteroids might be involved in the pathophysiology of psychosis.
Severe psychiatric disorders were recently documented in chil-
dren exposed in utero to synthetic estrogens like diethylstilbestrol
(Distilbene
V
R
, DES) and ethinyl estradiol (EE) [24]. The actions
of these estrogens involve epigenetic mechanisms [5] and espe-
cially differential specific methylations, which were found on the
genes ZPF57 and ADAMTS9 in young psychotic patients
exposed in utero to DES [6]. In this recent work, the authors
suggested that in exposed individuals, ZFP57 gene methylation
may be associated with psychosis. The ADAMTS9 gene is impli-
cated in the control of organ shape, especially the development
and function of the uterus and reproductive organs [7], which
are often abnormal after in utero DES exposure, as well as in the
control of CNS development [8] and several kinds of cancer [9].
Synthetic progestins, widely used for contraception or hormo-
nal replacement therapy, are known to impact the adult brain
[1011], but no data exist on the postnatal effects after in utero
exposure. The aim of this work was to determine whether pre-
natal exposure to synthetic progestins is a risk factor for psychi-
atric disorders in adolescence or adulthood.
Material and methods
Our clinical data were collected from 1200 families (1934 chil-
dren) involved in the French Hhorages Association (Halt to
CONTACT Marie Odile Soyer-Gobillard mog66@orange.fr Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Universit
e Paris 6 and Association HHORAGES-France,
95270 Asni
eres sur Oise, France, Asni
eres sur Oise 95270, France
Association Registered on the Epidemiological Portal of French Health Databases INSERM (French National Institute for Medical Research) and AVIESAN (National
Alliance for Life Sciences and Health) (epidemiologie-france.aviesan.fr).
This work was presented as an oral communication during the European Congress of Gynaecology, Barcelona, 2017.
ß2019 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
GYNECOLOGICAL ENDOCRINOLOGY
https://doi.org/10.1080/09513590.2018.1512968
Synthetic Hormones for Pregnancies), a patient support group,
using a detailed questionnaire drawn up by practitioners and
researchers as described in previous papers [2,3]. We included
questions on patient sex, rank among siblings, exposure during
gestation, and somatic and psychiatric disorders of the descend-
ants. Most families had children exposed to either estrogens
alone or cocktails of estrogens and progestins, but only 46 fami-
lies (115 children) had at least one child exposed to one or more
progestins prescribed alone, without estrogens. In the extensive
questionnaires (Registration number to French National
Commission of Computer Science and Freedom, CNIL
n1006460), we obtained the family history, including the moth-
ers hormone treatment before and during pregnancy, and the
medical records of the childrens health problems, including
diagnoses, prescriptions and treatments and/or hospitalizations.
The psychiatric disorders reported in the questionnaires were
classified as schizophrenia, bipolar disorders (maniac-depressive
psychosis), severe depression, behavior disorders, aggressiveness,
and eating disorders. The diagnoses had been made by experi-
enced psychiatrists and the patients received appropriate drugs
and psychotherapy with or without hospitalization in specialized
institutions. When suicides or suicide attempts were reported, a
second questionnaire validated by members of the Research
Group on Suicide (CHU Lapeyronie Montpellier) was sent to
the families.
From the questionnaires completed by the families and
returned to the Hhorages Association, it appears that one or sev-
eral progestins were prescribed and administered to pregnant
mothers as shown in the numerous conserved medical prescrip-
tions. The prescribed pharmaceuticals were: 17a-hydroxyproges-
terone caproate (synthetic progestin, SP): 32 (Note: withdrawn in
2000 but re-authorized in 2011), 17a-hydroxyprogesterone hepta-
noate (SP): 10 (Note: withdrawn in 2002), chlormadinone acetate
(SP derived from hydroxyprogesterone): 11 (Note: withdrawn on
1970), dydrogesterone (6-dehydroprogesterone, synthetic isomer
of progesterone): 4 (Note: against total indication for pregnant
women; not withdrawn), natural progesterone(derived from
soybean, micronized): 4 (Note: not withdrawn), Norethisterone
Base (SP): 1 (Note: against total indication for pregnant women;
withdrawn in 1998). Total: 62.
Results
In the entire national Hhorages cohort of 1934 children, we
detected 46 families in which at least one child had been exposed
to one or several synthetic progestins.
As shown in Table 1, among the 115 children born from
these 46 mothers, we observed three well-differentiated groups:
Group 1: 18 firstborn unexposed children (9 boys þ9 girls) free
of disorders, Group 2: 62 children exposed to synthetic proges-
tins (40 boys þ22 girls), and Group 3: 35 children (21 boys þ14
girls) born after a previous exposure, free of disorders except 1.
Group 1 þGroup 3 (18 þ35 ¼53 children) served as intra-famil-
ial controls. Among the 62 children exposed to synthetic proges-
tins (see the list of medications in Material and methods), 49
presented psychiatric disorders (79.03%), whereas only 6 (4 boys
þ2 girls) presented somatic disorders alone (9.67%) and 7 (5
boys þ2 girls) presented no disorder (11.29%).
In Group 2, among the 49 patients affected by psychiatric dis-
orders, 10 suffered from both somatic and psychiatric disorders
and 39 from psychiatric disorders alone. Among the psychiatric
disorders, we noted: schizophrenia: 29 (25 boys þ4 girls); severe
depression, bipolar disorder: 16 (6 boys þ10 girls); and behavior
disorders, aggressiveness, eating disorders: 4 (0 boys þ4 girls)
(Table 2). It should be noted that boys mostly suffered from
schizophrenic psychosis (25 boys versus 4 girls), whereas girls
mostly suffered from bipolar disorder (10 girls versus 6 boys).
The questionnaires completed by the families and returned to
the Hhorages Association revealed that one or several progestins
were prescribed and administered to the pregnant mothers, with
the most frequently prescribed drugs being hydroxyprogesterone
caproate, heptanoate alone, or heptanoate in a cocktail with
other progestins.
In Group 3, among the 35 post-exposed children that is,
born after a previous exposed pregnancy only one presented a
psychiatric disorder as severe depression.
In Group 2, composed of children exposed to progestins,
schizophrenia (n¼29), and bipolar disorder and severe depres-
sion (n¼16) made up most of the psychiatric disorders, whereas
eating disorders (n¼2) and behavior disorders (n¼2) were less
numerous. Seven series of suicide attempts (a series comprising
between 2 and 15 suicide attempts per person) were also counted
and one death, as shown in Table 3, which presents the psychi-
atric disorders along with their prevalence in the general popula-
tion [12,13].
Discussion
Although selection biases (familypatient association) may some-
what affect the impact of our data, the high prevalence of psychi-
atric disorders in the exposed subjects is quite striking. It should
be noted that the intra-familial controls (18 firstborn unexposed
versus 62 exposed) presented no disease and among the 35 post-
exposed (born after a previous treated pregnancy) only one psy-
chiatric disorder was observed. Among the 115 children born
from 46 families of the Hhorages cohort, 42 unexposed children
had no psychiatric disorders, while of the 62 exposed children,
only 7 were without psychiatric disorders (55 with a disorder).
Table 1. Classification of the three groups of Hhorages children born from 46
families in which at less one child per family has been exposed in utero
to progestins.
115 children
Group 1 Group 2 Group 3
Firstborn unexposed Exposed to synthetic progestins Post-exposed
(n=18) (n=62)n=
35
Psychiatric disorders
0 disorder n=49 (79.03%) n=1
0 disorder n=7 (11.29%)
Somatic disorders only:
n=
6
(9.67%)
Table 2. Total number of psychiatric disorders among the 62 children exposed
to progestins.
Schizophrenia (25 boys, 4 girls) 29
Maniac-depressive psychosis (bipolar disorder), severe
depression (6 boys, 10 girls)
16
Behavior disorders, aggressiveness, eating disorders (0 boys, 4 girls) 4
Somatic disorders only (4 boys, 2 girls) 6
With no disorder (5 boys, 2 girls) 7
Total number of exposed children 62
2 M.-O. SOYER-GOBILLARD ET AL.
As shown in Table 3, our data demonstrate that the prevalence
of psychiatric disorders in patients who were exposed in utero to
progestins was significantly different from the prevalence of the
same disorders in the general population: schizophrenia:
29 ¼46.77% versus 1% in the general population, behavior disor-
ders: 2 ¼3.22% versus 3% in the general population, bipolar dis-
order and severe depression: 16 ¼25.80% versus 6.3% in the
general population, eating disorders: 2 ¼3.22% versus 1.6%, sui-
cides or suicide attempts: 7 ¼11.29% versus 0.3% in the general
population, and death: 1 ¼1.6% versus 0.02% in the general
population. Seven in utero exposed patients (11.29%) presented
no disorder.
We compared our data with the recent results [4] obtained
from the Hhorages cohort in which we analyzed 1002 patients
who were exposed in utero to the synthetic estrogens diethylstil-
bestrol and ethinyl estradiol. Of the 720 patients exposed in
utero, 250 boys and 353 girls showed severe psychiatric disor-
ders: schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, severe depression, behavior
disorders, eating disorders, suicide attempt series (612 ¼85%)
and death (32 ¼4.4%). Psychiatric disorders were the same in
the groups exposed to estrogens or progestins, with minor differ-
ences: for boys, the number of cases of bipolar disorder seemed
less high in patients exposed to progestins than in patients
exposed to synthetic estrogens, with behavior disorders more
prevalent in the latter category. In both categories, schizophrenia
was the most prevalent disorder for boys. For girls, however, the
proportions of psychiatric cases were nearly the same in the two
categories. Bipolar disorder and severe depression were the most
abundant disorders in the two categories.
Cumulative evidence from experimental, hormonal, genetic,
and epidemiological studies suggests a neurodevelopmental ori-
gin of most psychiatric disorders. Environmental disturbances
are known to increase brain disorder risk, interacting with a gen-
etic predisposition. During fetal life, neuronal differentiation,
migration, and interaction are managed by molecular processes,
regulating the dopaminergic, glutamatergic, and GABAergic sys-
tems. While the GABA system is the major inhibitory neuro-
transmitter in postnatal life, GABA-A receptor activation is
excitatory during fetal life. In addition to progesterone itself, pro-
gesterone is converted to dehydroprogesterone and then to allo-
pregnanolone (or iso-pregnanolone), potent ligands of the
GABA-A receptor. These neurosteroids are known to be involved
in neuronal and glial development and plasticity, and the regula-
tion of mood and affection. Any neurodevelopmental disruption
of this system can induce a dysfunction of cell migration and
synaptic integration and may have marked consequences leading
to chronic disability.
The data regarding the impact of synthetic progestins on the
developing brain are currently conflicting. In adults, progestins
have been suggested to exert neuroprotective effects in several
animal models of neurological disease [14]. After two years of
treatment with progestogen via a COC combination (Oral
Contraceptive Combination), impaired social behavior was
observed in female rats [15]. This combination was also able to
alter GABA receptor exposure, increasing the exposure of the
gamma2-subunit in the cerebral cortex and thus affecting anxiety
behavior. According to this group, progestin may alter brain
function in animal models. In 2016, Willing and Wagner [16]
showed that exposure to synthetic progestins during develop-
ment could impair brain function later in life. These authors
noted that many regions of the developing brain are sensitive to
progestins, including the mesocortical dopamine pathway, a
neural circuit important in rats for complex cognitive behavior
later in life. They found that rats exposed to synthetic progestins
during development expressed impaired cognitive flexibility with
increased perseveration later in life. Although this data cannot be
extrapolated to humans, these authors pointed out the risk of
developmental-behavioral effects of synthetics progestins pre-
scribed for pregnant women.
Negative mood symptoms have been reported by Andreen
et al. [17] in women as a result of progesterone during the luteal
phase of the menstrual cycle or progestin in COC. The symp-
toms are believed to be mediated via the action of allopregnano-
lone on the GABA-A system. In male patients with early
psychosis, Belvederi Murri et al. [18] reported a lower level of
progesterone and suggested that this hormone is involved in the
pathophysiology of psychotic disorders. This hypothesis is sup-
ported by the antipsychotic-like effects observed in animal mod-
els of schizophrenia. Recently Slopien et al. [19] reported a
reduction in circulating allopregnanolone levels that correlate
with depressive symptoms. Conversely, healthy women reported
increased anxiety and mood disorders after long-acting subder-
mal implant of progestogens.
In 2011, Guest et al. [20] reported an elevated concentration
of progesterone in a group of 236 first and recent onset of
schizophrenia patients and suggested that steroid hormones
influence brain function, underlying schizophrenia, and major
depressive disorders. Moreover, Buoli et al. found high DHAS
levels in patients with a history of psychotic symptoms, suggest-
ing a role of steroids in the etiology of psychosis and mood dis-
orders [21].
Lastly, citing the French National Agency of Medicine [22],
the independent medical journal Prescrire, reported that 2714
adverse effects were signaled in the last year by women using
Mirena
V
R
, an intrauterine device containing levonorgestrel, a well-
known progestin [23]. In 85% of the cases, the side effects were
mainly related to psychiatric disorders, such as anxiety
and depression.
Although a direct relationship cannot be formulated, a link
between progestin treatment during fetal life and later psychiatric
disorders in offspring should be considered. Since progestins are
known to induce GABA receptor activity/neural activation before
Table 3. Prevalence of psychiatric disorders and comparison with the general population.
Group 1 Group 2 Group 3
Firstborn unexposed Progestin exposed Post-exposure General population
(n¼18) (n¼62) (n¼35)
Schizophrenia (0%) (n¼29) (46.77%) (0%) (1%)
Behavioural disorders (0%) (n¼2) (3.22%) (0%) (3%)
Bipolar disorder, depression (0%) (n¼16) (25.80%) (n¼1) (2.8%) (6.3%)
Eating disorders (0%) (n¼2) (3.22%) (0%) (1.6%)
Suicides (0%)
Attempts (n¼7) (0%) (n¼7) (11.29%) (0%) (0.3%)
Death (n¼1) (0%) (n¼1) (1.6%) (0%) (0.02%)
With no disorder (n¼7) (11.29%)
GYNECOLOGICAL ENDOCRINOLOGY 3
birth, it is likely that the GABAergic system contributes to
schizophrenia, anxiety, depression, panic disorders, epilepsy, aut-
ism, and other disorders [24]. Disruption of GABA signaling in
early development alters cell migration and cortical architecture,
which then may lead to chronic disability in postnatal life. Our
results point out the postnatal consequences of synthetic proges-
tin treatment during fetal life and highlight the potential impact
of synthetic progestin. They highlight the need for reevaluation
of the potential outcome of progestin administration dur-
ing gestation.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge Professor M. Dolan (University of
Massachusetts, Amherst, USA) for critical reading of the manuscript
as well as the Hhorages board for its ongoing support and precious
collaboration concerning the files and relations with families. The
authors also warmly acknowledge the patient families of the
Hhorages Association for their ongoing support and participation
via their testimonies.
Disclosure statement
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest concerning
this work, the Hhorages Association being exclusively financed by
memberships and donations.
References
[1] Schumacher M, Mattern C, Ghoumari A, et al. Revisiting the role of
progesterone and allopregnanolone in the nervous system: resurgence
of the progesterone receptors. Prog Neurobiol. 2014;113:639.
[2] Soyer-Gobillard MO. Perturbateurs endocriniens et troubles du com-
portement: non, nous navons pas encore tir
e toutes les lec¸ons de
lhistoire du DES. M
edecine et Long
evit
e (Elsevier). 2011;3:6774.
[3] Soyer-Gobillard MO, Sultan C. Behavioral and somatic disorders in
children exposed in utero to synthetic hormones: a testimony case
study in a French family troop. State Art Ther Endocrinol. 2012;
6786. ISBN 978-953-51-0772-9; http://dx.doi.org/10.5772/2906
[4] Soyer-Gobillard MO, Paris F, Gaspari L, et al. Association between
fetal DES-exposure and psychiatric disorders in adolescence/adult-
hood: evidence from a French cohort of 1002 prenatally exposed chil-
dren. Gynecol Endocrinol. 2016;32:2529.
[5] Harlid S, Xu Z, Panduri V, et al. In utero exposure to diethylstilbes-
trol and blood DNA methylation in women ages 4059 years from
the sister study. PloS One. 2015;10:e0118757.
[6] Rivollier F, Chaumette B, Bendjemaa N, et al. Methylomic changes in
individuals with psychosis, prenatally exposed to endocrine disrupting
compounds: lessons from diethylstilbestrol. PLoS One. 2017;12:
e0174783.
[7] Mittaz L, Russell DL, Wilson T, et al. Adamts-1 is essential for the
development and function of the urogenital system. Biol Reprod.
2004;70:10961105.
[8] Lemarchant S, Pruvost M, Montaner J, et al. ADAMTS proteoglyca-
nases in the physiological and pathological central nervous system.
J Neuroinflammation. 2013;10:113. https://doi.org/10.1186/1742-
2094-10-133.
[9] Zhang C, Shao Y, Zhang W, et al. High-resolution melting analysis of
ADAMTS9 methylation levels in gastric, colorectal, and pancreatic
cancers. Cancer Genet Cytogenet. 2010;196:3844.
[10] Dub A. Hormones sexuelles et troubles psychiques. La Lettre du
Gyn
ecologue. 1998;234:2026.
[11] Muye Zhu, Brinton R. How Progestin, a synthetic female hormone
could affect the brain. Atlantic. 2012;116. https://www.theatlantic.
com/health/archive/2012/01/how-progestin-a-synthetic-female-hor-
mone-could-affect-the-brain/251299.
[12] Nicoli M, Bouchez I, Nieto I, et al. Ideation et conduites suicidaires
en France: pr
evalence sur la vie et facteurs de risques dans l
etude
ESEMeD. LEnc
ephale. 2012;38:296303.
[13] L
epine JP, Gasquet V, Kovess V, et al. Pr
evalence et comorbidit
e des
troubles psychiatriques dans la population g
en
erale franc
¸aise: r
esultats
de l
etude
epid
emiologique ESEMeD/MHEDEA 2000/(ESEMeD).
LEnc
ephale 2005;31:182194.
[14] Melcangi RC, Giatti S, Calabrese D, et al. Levels and actions of pro-
gesterone and its metabolites in the nervous system during physio-
logical and pathological conditions. Prog Neurobiol. 2014;113:5669.
[15] Giatti S, Melcangi RC, Pesaresi M. The other side of preogestins:
effects in the brain. J Mol Endocrinol. 2016;57:109126.
[16] Willing J, Wagner CK. Exposure to the synthetic progestin, 17a-
Hydroxyprogesterone caproate during development impairs cognitive
flexibility in adulthood. Endocrinol. 2016;157:7782.
[17] Andreen L, Nyberg S, Turkmen S, et al. Sex steroid induced negative
mood may be explained by the paradoxical effect mediated by
GABAA modulators. Psychoneuroendocrinol. 2009;34:11211132.
[18] Belvederi Murri M, Fanelli F, Pagotto U, et al. Neuroactive steroids
in first-episode psychosis: a role for progesterone? Schizophr Res
Treatment. 2016;2016:114.
[19] Slopien R, Pluchino N, Warenik-Szymankiewicz A, et al. Correlation
between allopregnanolone levels and depressive symptoms during late
menopausal transition and early postmenopause. Gynecol Endocrinol.
2018;34:144147.
[20] Guest PC, Schwarz E, Krishnamurthy D, et al. Altered levels of circu-
lating insulin and other neuroendocrine hormones associated with
the onset of schizophrenia. Psychoneuroendocrinol. 2011;36:
10921096.
[21] Buoli M, Caldiroli A, Serati M, et al. Sex steroids and major psycho-
ses: which role for DHEA-S and progesterone? Neuropsychobiol.
2016;73:178183.
[22] ANSM. Rapport dexpertise-Mirena, Jaydess. DIU au L
evonorgestrel.
2017;121:158.
[23] R
edaction Prescrire. Dispositif intra-ut
erin au l
evonorgestrel: un
afflux de notifications en 2017 en France. Prescrire Mai. 2018;38:
351352.
[24] Schmidt MJ, Mirnics K. Neurodevelopment, GABA system dysfunc-
tion and schizophrenia. Neuropsychopharmacol Rev, 2014;40(1):117.
4 M.-O. SOYER-GOBILLARD ET AL.
... They found that the occurrence of major depressive and anxiety disorders was significantly increased (by a factor of 1.47) in exposed women. Two other studies reported psychiatric effects, particularly schizophrenia, bipolar disorders, depression, eating disorders, suicide attempts, and suicide, in adolescent/adults who were in-utero exposed to DES (5,6) and to progestins (7). ...
... The database of the families of the French patient association Hhorages-France allowed assessing the causal link between inutero exposure to synthetic hormones, particularly DES, and the occurrence of severe psychotic disorders after adolescence in exposed children. This database is based on the responses to a detailed questionnaire written by physicians and researchers and approved by the French national commission for data protection and freedom (CNIL) (7). In 2016, we analyzed data on 1,182 pregnancies from 529 mothers from the Hhorages-France cohort ( Table 1). ...
Article
Full-text available
It is acknowledged that diethylstilbestrol (DES), a synthetic diphenol with powerful estrogenic properties, causes structural anomalies of the reproductive tract and increases the risk of cancer and genital malformations in children and grandchildren of mothers treated during pregnancy. Conversely, data on DES effects on neurodevelopment and psychiatric disorders in in-utero exposed children and their descendants are rare, especially concerning Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD). Recent studies presented in this review strengthen the hypothesis that in-utero exposure to DES and also other synthetic estrogens and progestogens, which all are endocrine disruptors, contributes to the pathogenesis of psychiatric disorders, especially ASD. A large epidemiological study in the USA in 2010 reported severe depression in in-utero exposed children (n=1,612), and a French cohort study (n=1,002 in-utero DES exposed children) in 2016 found mainly bipolar disorders, schizophrenia, major depression, suicide attempts, and suicide. Few publications described ASD in in-utero exposed children, mainly a Danish cohort study and a large Chinese epidemiological study. Molecular studies on endocrine disruptors demonstrated the transgenerational induction of diseases and DES epigenetic impact (DNA methylation changes) at two genes implicated in neurodevelopment (ZFP57 and ADAM TS9). We recently described in an informative family, somatic and psychiatric disorders in four generations, particularly ASD in boys of the third and fourth generation. These data show that the principle of precaution must be retained for the protection of future generations: women (pregnant or not) should be extremely vigilant about synthetic hormones.
... Increases in psychiatric disorders have been shown among children exposed to progesterone in utero. 22 Other studies have associated vaginal progesterone treatment with a risk of gravidic cholestasis. 23,24 Therefore, we should be mindful not to overprescribe progesterone. ...
Article
Purpose: The aim of this study was to describe trends in reimbursed medication prescriptions dispensed during pregnancy in Belgium using administrative healthcare database records from a representative sample of the Belgian population. Methods: Pregnant women were identified with reimbursement codes associated with the delivery of a baby. Data were extracted for three study periods, each over three years: 2003-2005, 2009-2011, and 2015-2017. The age-standardized prevalence of reimbursed medications during pregnancy were computed and logistic regression models were used to evaluate the trends in prevalence across the study periods. The most frequently dispensed medications were listed for each study period. Results: The study included 23,912 pregnancies. The age-standardized prevalence of pregnant women with at least one dispensed medication increased across the three study periods from 81.8.% to 89.3%. The median number and interquartile range of the different medications dispensed during pregnancy rose from 2 (1-6) to 3 (1-7) between the first and last study periods. In the 2015-2017 period, the most frequently dispensed medications during pregnancy included progesterone (25.5%), paracetamol (17.8%), and amoxicillin (17.1%). The data also showed an increasing trend for the dispensation of ibuprofen and ketorolac during pregnancy across the three study periods. Conclusions: The prevalence of reimbursed medications dispensed during pregnancy increased in Belgium from 2003 to 2017 with high proportion for Progesterone and Antibiotics. Utilization of certain nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) increased between 2003 and 2017, despite recommendations to avoid them.
... Currently, there is no research on this these effects of in utero exposure of children to progestins given alone during pregnancy. Our recent observations (24,25) were collected from 1200 families of the Hhorages cohort i.e.1934 children using always the same detailed questionnaire (13). As previously shown, most families of our cohort had children exposed to estrogens or to estro-progestins, but only 46 families (115 children) had at least one child exposed to one or more progestins prescribed alone and representing 62 in utero-exposed children. ...
... Currently, there is no research on these effects of in utero exposure of children to progestins given alone during pregnancy. Our recent observations [24,25] were collected from 1200 families of the HHORAGES cohort, that is, 1934 children using always the same detailed questionnaire [13]. As previously shown, most families of our cohort had children exposed to estrogens or to estro-progestins, but only 46 families (115 children) had at least 1 child exposed to 1 or more progestins prescribed alone and representing 62 in utero-exposed children. ...
Article
Autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are associated with the contribution of many prenatal risk factors; in particular, the sex hormone progestin and vitamin D receptor (VDR) are associated with gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms in ASD development, although the related mechanism remains unclear. We investigated the possible role and mechanism of progestin 17-hydroxyprogesterone caproate (17-OHPC) exposure-induced GI dysfunction and autism-like behaviors (ALB) in mouse offspring. An intestine-specific VDR deficient mouse model was established for prenatal treatment, while transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCT) with related gene manipulation were used for postnatal treatment for 17-OHPC exposure-induced GI dysfunction and ALB in mouse offspring. The in vivo mouse experiments found that VDR deficiency mimics prenatal 17-OHPC exposure-mediated GI dysfunction, but has no effect on 17-OHPC-mediated autism-like behaviors (ALB) in mouse offspring. Furthermore, prenatal 17-OHPC exposure induces CLDN1 suppression in intestine epithelial cells, and transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCT) with CLDN1 expression ameliorates prenatal 17-OHPC exposure-mediated GI dysfunction, but has no effect on 17-OHPC-mediated ALB in offspring. In conclusion, prenatal 17-OHPC exposure triggers GI dysfunction in autism-like mouse offspring via CLDN1 suppression, providing a possible explanation for the involvement of CLDN1 and VDR in prenatal 17-OHPC exposure-mediated GI dysfunction with ASD.
Chapter
Studies of psychiatric effects of progestins on in utero exposed children’s central nervous system (CNS) are scarce. Psychoses such as schizophrenia and bipolarity were described for in utero exposed children to progestins in a French cohort. Psychiatric disorders observed in these patients were compared with CNS disorders that appeared after in utero exposure to synthetic estrogens (DES, EE): no difference was noted. Molecular genomic and epigenomic studies of the estrogen mechanism of action demonstrated that psychosis is in close correlation with specific methylomic modifications that could impact neurodevelopment and neuroplasticity, an epigenetic mechanism. Evidence of psychic disorders on DES daughters analyzed from another French cohort confirms these results. Progestin may also induce autism spectrum disorders by means of an epigenetic mechanism: after animal (rat) study showing a hypermethylation (an epigenetic alteration) of the ERβ receptor genes, an epidemiological study on a large Chinese population confirmed these works. Moreover, a physicochemical study of the amniotic fluid in a male Danish cohort demonstrated that prenatal excess of estrogens contributes to autism to a greater degree than do other prenatal sex steroïds. For the protection of future generations, pregnant or not, women should be extremely vigilant about any kind of synthetic hormone therapy.
Article
Full-text available
Background In the Western world, between 1940 and 1970, more than 2 million people were exposed in utero to diethylstilbestrol (DES). In exposed individuals, and in their descendants, adverse outcomes have been linked to such exposure, including cancers, genital malformations, and less consistently, psychiatric disorders. We aimed to explore whether prenatal DES exposure would be associated with DNA methylation changes, and whether these epigenetic modifications would be associated with increased risk of psychosis. Methods From 247 individuals born from mothers exposed to DES, we selected 69 siblings from 30 families. In each family, at least one sibling was exposed in utero to DES. We performed a methylome-wide association study using HumanMethylation450 DNA Analysis BeadChip® in peripheral blood. We analyzed methylation changes at individual CpGs or regions in exposed (n = 37) versus unexposed individuals (n = 32). We also compared exposed individuals with (n = 7) and without psychosis (n = 30). Results There were more individuals with schizophrenia in the DES-exposed group. We found no significant differences between exposed and unexposed individuals with respect to differentially methylated CpGs or regions. The largest difference was in a region near the promoter of an ADAMTS proteoglycanase gene (ADAMTS9). Compared to exposed individuals without psychosis, exposed individuals with psychosis had differential methylation in the region encompassing the gene encoding the zinc finger protein 57 (ZFP57). Conclusions In utero exposure to DES was not associated with methylation changes at specific CpG or regions. In exposed individuals, however, psychosis was associated with specific methylomic modifications that could impact neurodevelopment and neuroplasticity.
Article
Full-text available
Neuroactive steroids may play a role in the pathophysiology of psychotic disorders, but few studies examined this issue. We compared serum levels of cortisol, testosterone, dehydroepiandrosterone, and progesterone between a representative sample of first-episode psychosis (FEP) patients and age- and gender-matched healthy subjects. Furthermore, we analyzed the associations between neuroactive steroids levels and the severity of psychotic symptom dimensions. Male patients had lower levels of progesterone than controls ( p = 0.03 ). Progesterone levels were inversely associated with the severity of positive symptoms ( p = 0.007 ). Consistent with preclinical findings, results suggest that progesterone might have a role in the pathophysiology of psychotic disorders.
Article
Full-text available
In utero diethylstilbestrol (DES) exposure has been demonstrated to be associated with somatic abnormalities in adult men and women. Conversely, the data are contradictory regarding the association with psychological or psychiatric disorders during adolescence and adulthood. This work was designed to determine whether prenatal exposure to DES affects brain development and whether it is associated with psychiatric disorders in male and female adolescents and young adults. HHORAGES Association, a national patient support group, has assembled a cohort of 1280 women who took DES during pregnancy. We obtained questionnaire responses from 529 families, corresponding to 1182 children divided into three groups: Group 1 (n = 180): firstborn children without DES treatment, Group 2 (n = 740): exposed children, and Group 3 (n = 262): children born after a previous pregnancy treated by DES. No psychiatric disorders were reported in Group 1. In Group 2, the incidence of disorders was drastically elevated (83.8%), and in Group 3, the incidence was still elevated (6.1%) compared with the general population. This work demonstrates that prenatal exposure to DES is associated with a high risk of psychiatric disorders in adolescence and adulthood.
Article
Full-text available
In utero exposure to diethylstilbestrol (DES) has been associated with increased risk of adverse health outcomes such as fertility problems and vaginal as well as breast cancer. Animal studies have linked prenatal DES exposure to lasting DNA methylation changes. We investigated genome-wide DNA methylation and in utero DES exposure in a sample of non-Hispanic white women aged 40-59 years from the Sister Study, a large United States cohort study of women with a family history of breast cancer. Using questionnaire information from women and their mothers, we selected 100 women whose mothers reported taking DES while pregnant and 100 control women whose mothers had not taken DES. DNA methylation in blood was measured at 485,577 CpG sites using the Illumina HumanMethylation450 BeadChip. Associations between CpG methylation and DES exposure status were analyzed using robust linear regression with adjustment for blood cell composition and multiple comparisons. Although four CpGs had p<105, after accounting for multiple comparisons using the false discovery rate (FDR), none reached genome-wide significance. In conclusion, adult women exposed to DES in utero had no evidence of large persistent changes in blood DNA methylation.
Article
Full-text available
The origins of schizophrenia have eluded clinicians and researchers since Kraepelin and Bleuler began documenting their findings. However, large clinical research efforts in recent decades have identified numerous genetic and environmental risk factors for schizophrenia. The combined data strongly support the neurodevelopmental hypothesis of schizophrenia and underscore the importance of the common converging effects of diverse insults. In this review, we discuss the evidence that genetic and environmental risk factors that predispose to schizophrenia disrupt the development and normal functioning of the GABA-ergic system.Neuropsychopharmacology Reviews accepted article peview online, 24 April 2014. doi:10.1038/npp.2014.95.
Article
Full-text available
ADAMTS-1, -4, -5 and -9 belong to 'a disintegrin and metalloproteinase with thrombospondin motifs (ADAMTS)' family and more precisely to the proteoglycanases subgroup based on their common ability to degrade chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans. They have been extensively investigated for their involvement in inflammation-induced osteoarthritis, and a growing body of evidence indicates that they may be of key importance in the physiological and pathological central nervous system (CNS). In this review, we discuss the deregulated expression of ADAMTS proteoglycanases during acute CNS injuries, such as stroke and spinal cord injury. Then, we provide new insights on ADAMTS proteoglycanases mediating synaptic plasticity, neurorepair, angiogenesis and inflammation mechanisms. Altogether, this review allows us to propose that ADAMTS proteoglycanases may be original therapeutic targets for CNS injuries.
Article
Objectives: This observational, cross-sectional study included 140 women with climacteric symptoms. The aim of the study was to evaluate the correlation between the presence and severity of depressive symptoms and allopregnanolone levels in women during late menopausal transition and early postmenopause. Methods: The study group was divided into two groups: 45 women in late menopausal transition and 95 early postmenopausal women. We evaluated Kupperman index, Hamilton scale and serum follicle-stimulating hormone, luteinizing hormone, 17β-estradiol, prolactin, total testosterone, dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate and allopregnanolone levels. Results: We found that serum allopregnanolone concentration was lower in early postmenopausal women compared to women in late menopausal transition; that there was a correlation between serum allopregnanolone levels in early postmenopausal women and time since last menstruation, intensity of climacteric symptoms, and intensity of depression symptoms and that there was a correlation between serum allopregnanolone levels and several depression symptoms presence (shallow sleep and symptoms of the digestive tract in women during late menopause transition; feelings of guilt, sleep disorders and general somatic symptoms in early postmenopausal women). Conclusion: We concluded that reproductive aging is characterized by a reduction of allopregnanolone circulating levels that correlate to Hamilton depression index in early postmenopause and presence of specific depressive symptoms during late menopausal transition and early postmenopause.
Article
Progestins are a broad class of progestational agents widely differing in their chemical structures and pharmacological properties. Despite emerging data suggest that progestins, besides their action as endometrial protection, can also have multiple non-reproductive functions, much remains to be discovered regarding the actions exerted by these molecules in the nervous system. Here, we report the state of the art of the role exerted by different progestins, currently used for contraception or in postmenopausal hormone replacement therapies, in regulating cognitive functions as well as social behavior and mood. We provide evidence that the effects and mechanisms underlying their actions are still confusing due to the use of different estrogens and progestins as well as different doses, duration of exposure, route of administration, baseline hormonal status and age of treated women. We also discuss the emerging issue concerning the relevant increase of these substances in the environment, able to deeply affect aquatic wildlife as well as to exert a possible influence in humans, which may be exposed to these compounds via contaminated drinking water and seafood. Finally, we report literature data showing the neurobiological action of progestins and in particular their importance during neurodegenerative events. This is extremely interesting, since some of the progestins currently used in clinical practice exert neuroprotective and anti-inflammatory effects in the nervous system, opening new promising opportunities for the use of these molecules as therapeutic agents for trauma and neurodegenerative disorders.
Article
Objective: Endocrine pathways seem to play a role in the etiology of major psychoses. The identification of biomarkers associated with psychotic symptoms in schizophrenia (SKZ) and mood disorders would allow the identification of high-risk subjects for delusions and hallucinations. The aim of this study was to evaluate dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEA-S) and progesterone plasma levels in drug-free patients with major psychoses and their relation with the diagnosis and history of psychotic symptoms. Methods: Eighty-nine consecutive drug-free male inpatients with SKZ or mood disorders were recruited, and DHEA-S and progesterone plasma levels were measured. The groups, divided according to pathological/normal-range hormone levels, were compared in terms of clinical variables using x03C7;2 tests with Bonferroni's corrections or multivariate analyses of variance. The same analyses were performed for groups divided according to the presence/absence of lifetime psychotic symptoms. Binary logistic regression analysis was performed using hormone levels as independent variables and history of lifetime psychotic symptoms as a dependent one. Results: A higher number of patients with abnormal DHEA-S levels was found to have a family history of major depressive disorder (p < 0.05). Higher DHEA-S levels (F = 8.31; p = 0.005) were found in patients with a history of psychotic symptoms. In addition, binary logistic regression confirmed that DHEA-S levels were associated with a higher probability of lifetime psychotic symptoms (p = 0.037). Conclusions: Our results confirm previous data about the role of endocrine factors in the etiology of major psychoses. A high DHEA-S level might be a risk factor for psychotic symptoms. Studies with larger samples are needed to confirm these data.
Article
The synthetic progestin, 17α-hydroxyprogesterone caproate (17-OHPC) is increasingly used for the prevention of premature birth in at-risk women, despite little understanding of the potential effects on the developing brain. Rodent models suggest that many regions of the developing brain are sensitive to progestins, including the mesocortical dopamine pathway, a neural circuit important for complex cognitive behaviors later in life. Nuclear progesterone receptor (PR) is expressed during perinatal development in dopaminergic cells of the ventral tegmental area that project to the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). PR is also expressed in the subplate and in pyramidal cell layers II/III of mPFC during periods of dopaminergic synaptogenesis. In the present study, exposure to 17-OHPC during development of the mesocortical dopamine pathway in rats altered dopaminergic innervation of the prelimbic prefrontal cortex and impaired cognitive flexibility with increased perseveration later in life, perhaps to a greater extent in males. These studies provide evidence for developmental neurobehavioral effects of a drug in widespread clinical use and highlight the need for a re-evaluation of the benefits and potential outcomes of prophylactic progestin administration for prevention of premature delivery.