Content uploaded by Neil Whitehead
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Neil Whitehead on Jan 08, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
!"#!$%&%
'#(%&
From Journal of Human Sexuality 8: 99-125 (2017)
Summary
)!*+,-
+. ,+//,0123+-,
+ #(%&(45,6711+-,+89.(%%:4/,6
(713+-,+.9'&3734/,)!4/#
-1712+-,-#
)!45##
;#+</,-(7!&37%=
!#>#0</
+45,772+-,-//4/
7;7(;
<#4/#!
#?-@#A
;/!#-#0##)
!--. BB-
&
C;#!;
#-. 611(+-,)D-
E*#-
#00;
;-;#
;##0
)-(//0#F
!#%F-(</+/,
#D#-D0;
!#E>#-)-
-#
(D.
Introduction
###-
+ 5#D(%%(1,@
-#A#
-;#+G#9
/!H&3:1,+.G9$D&332,+5#D&33:,+.9
'&373,@)-
#D >#
A+G#9/!H&3:11((,"*-
###)##-
!;#0
(
B-#;#+
&377-,#
1#%F-. ("
#D#!#-#
#!+ID&3:,#!
##(J+J&332,7%F-
1"!!#
-###
0#-#+ #
.J9J&33,D#-
4/#0>##;#
#;#)-
#-!-##
0#)
!!;#
-0*-#
)#-45!4/#-
>#!0
Requirements for good representative surveys
#!##
;#-D#<#
+ #(%&(,J#
##;#
1
;#/###!
*!!-
)#-+ #(%&(,D-!45
&3:&37%J(%%G
#>#B#
-! ##-!
!#
#-D#
C0#+@A,#!*
4-#-##?#!#
!!#
!0
)D!@#A#
#+G
#9J(%%%,B# ###
4-#-#//0
!
!-!##
#)##*#-
!!-##-#
;"!#-##
-#-#!
>#!#-#)
##-###
#--
###)#?##
##0
;#-)K#!#
-45&37%8(%%#
0--#
&)K#D-
#-!-&(1
;-##!-
#!G###
#&
Measures of typical length
K#!;#-
0--#)-
#-#+0#,
#-. 0!##
C#&+8(%%%,
C#&J//0-#+C#!
-+8(%%%,,
#C#&##
--!--!
;D##)-
*--#!C#(2C#
&!#-mean-B
!median!#+%FD,
#!#-
"!!#
#C#&+!,!
!#modeJ#!0
+;&,-!
ID#D-
#D)!
2
-##
###
-
)##!
#D!C#&
#-</!-
#(7)-//C#&
(71F##-#1F
+22F*-I,#
&0F)-(D+/-
</,F
SSA Data from the literature
Lau (2012)
#+(%&(,45#---
#*#:
!-////-8#</
</###
!C#(
7
%&(127:3
%
%(
%
%2
%:
&
&(
Survival Curves UK
//J
//C
</8
</
Years
Fraction surviving
C#(C-#!+ #(%&(,//JLJ
;##+&1:#,M//CLC;##+&(
#,</8M<0;#+&7(&3#,</M
";##+:&7#,</8#
)</8</###//J//C
#B:
##*-#
N8 ;0*-#>#-
!;*#-32033F-+
##*,)-
;#-###
ln+(,O!O##-;>#-
*ln+(,#-(%!%231)
-//J//C</8</123
&(((77+)%F-!
:
!(, #//C
#//J-
<///J<///C77;2;)
!<///0
)>#-##%:F-//J(2F-//C
!(<//#;
-:##-0;
##%-:)
!1F+4/#,-C#&#)
1F#//J//C#
!"!4/#!45#
###E
B</4/#%F"!
!;#!##P7%P:%
%F*#
!B-##!-
!+/9-(%%7,
!#
#-
-0-
45#!#4/-!
-!!4/#
+.9'&373) (Carpenter & Gates, 2008)!
*#-!>###
3
Best USA studies
)#-5#.'+&373,
#-
!!!#;#
#>#!D#0"!D
#!-!
#5=!>#!#>#M
#--!"!##?
#-#?
#!#)#
###
>##-!5##-
#-#!###
-;##?#;!D!
#)!-(7
13-//J//C
)+89.(%%:,!!--#
. ##8--(%%#
-@A!*H(%%:)!
-#>##D#
##E0#
*##->#)!711
-//J//C
&%
)-!#+.9'&373,+89
.(%%:,!1712-//J//C
!##H-45#)
//J#45*##//C*#!
!#!--#
!45#
#E#(7-
)#4///J//C
#D#!#Q1%F
Other Supporting SSA Studies
#;#-#!
*-#;&)H
!C#1###!#
#--#!/
!#--
D!---#;#-C#1!
#;##
###
#"BR##!
!/-;#-
&&
C#1J//0+#,-
H#;&I6GD6
.6#)!!!
#;)H+1:,-;
!#4/#
)C#145)
#;*####
!;)*#!*-
-5+&31:0&37&,+S%%,#-
+. ,E-#0+L%&%,
-0;D*EM//J#
0//C#!#
#-!#@#!*
A
&(
US Heterosexual Data
C4/!</&37%0&376
% &% & (% ( 1%
%
(%
%
2%
:%
&%%
Survival Curve (US)
//J
</
Years
Percentage remaining
C#-</+8(%&%,+G##-8#4/
-8(%%,-//J+8(%%%,
!-#
C#!-4/!. !
!%F-
;#/(
#-(2745*#%-
(77#</#
)</E%F-!
)#*##
#-.
##-!#(
&1
Homosexual/Heterosexual comparisons.
)#-!#-4/
#-45!#:
J// C// ";#
%
&%
&
(%
(
1%
US Relationship-length
Length in Years
C#R#--+4/,
)</7;7(;//J//C
Other ethnic groups
)##-GD++I#89J&337,
JT&CT&2,8++I9&332,JT&,#
++5;&337,JT(+/D&332,JUCT(,
!*#1#)
>#E-</#
&
Longest relationships
/#M#-;#
//!+8!9I#&3:,+I#ID9"&3:(,
-1(M+889I
&3:3,-#T&##-
--#+C//#!10
!#,+9I&33,
-#--;
#</#
Bisexual Data
)-!#;#+.9'&373,-#
0-(1&+-,)#
+D,!+&3311,!-
11(+-,!<;;#
!#!//
</B!E-//
+6S%%,+&33%,-#
;#-:2+-,!
;#!!0;
0;
Implications
Lesbians’ relationships longer?
&
)--!
#);!#
#-
#;#-G#
-!-!+ #(%&(,##=
=
4/;##-4/
Possible explanations for SSA relationship-lengths
8#E!<///D-!
#H--</"!;#
+"D9/(%&%,+(F3F-,//0
#E-;#//!
+:F&22F//J//C,+"D9/(%&%,
--//J//C
---#!
#D#E#
D!-
8#E//;</!D
#"!--!;##
;!//+J6%F(F//JG;#
C6F&7F//CG;#+G!DG"#9J8
(%&,,#-
&2
-//#C#1!
BB-
8#--D--//
-G#;#
;#+"D(%&%,+(3FF-,
B-. #@A!#-
#%F(+-,-
</#+D/90CD?(%%2,
+5#D&33:,##--
*)--
-
8#-C#
2!</#</
#!+C#(,
//J//C8-
+C#2-#
C#(,
&7
% ( 2 : &% &( & &2
%
(%
%
2%
:%
&%%
&(%
Breakups of Marriage and Cohabitation (US)
J
8
Years
Percentage remaining
C#2GD#-C+88(%%(,<0;
*#D#-
-#-E-C#(
<;*E!-//J
//C##>#
E-"!E!//
</D-//J//C.
*-
)-!E
D##-!;
0;!0;
#E-0-!;
;#+G&332,+)?)9
&:
&333,+5#D&33&,)##-+&377,
-!#-//
OSA/SSA contrasts
)###--#E
!)>#E
!</</
0##!;;#;#+#
#&%F#--##+ID(%&%,,B
//+,;#;##
##-!#
+/#/H9/H(%&&,
);#-E
-//J//C-#*#(#
0##
)#@)
!##;-0;#
--#;#
0;#A+"#-G(%&1
(%3,!#E-!-
C-#
!#@V;#
!;##A
Counseling implications
&3
/#F-. G(D
!#%F-</
##//0
)!)##
D#--#
//0##+G9&37:,+8
9$(%&,#!-D
8#0//#D
;#+/<8,-C#
+'9W#(%%7,+'9W#(%&&,/
+#,---;#
-##--!%F
#D!;#
##!*#
0;!(C&0(F-
-#+-,-
0;#//;#</X
-*0-*
(D
B+&33,--;#
;#//#-#20:10
!D-!
#!##7%F#!#*
;&%#!!
(%
--0-#;-0
-!0!</#+GD9&331,G#-
##-!#
K#-#!#?#
0-
)-!#-!
-##-###
"!#
-"BR##!#
#
Conclusions
)! #58#
-0!
-#1!-&3%=
(%%%=)#@A#@#A(7
-</-454/
B!#@A!#D
E!-
#J
#--00;
D##--
;##D
(&
References
;8'+&337,C8#)- 0)
.JJournal of Gay & Lesbian Social Services7+&,&X
&(6&%&1%%'%&%7%&Y%&
.D)/90CD?"+(%%2,)
-0;!/!
Demography43+&,73X3:6&%&11(%%2%%%&
G'J#JI9J.+(%%%,.
Z#;##!
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology78(X12
66;&%&%17%%((01&7:1(
GD 9+&331,B
6I;-)-
JLaw and Human Behavior17+,13X%
6&%&%%7GC%&%177
G5IB9I# +(%%(, 6
#Journal of Lesbian Studies6+&,1X
216&%&1%%'&%2%&Y%2
GI9J/+&37:,Homosexualities. A Study Of Diversity
Among Men And Women!WD6//#
G'+&332,;6-;#
Psychological Review1031(%X11
((
G'9 #I+(%%(,);;-
?#[;[;
Communication Research Reports19+1,(:X(2:
6&%&%:%%::(%3%(%31::
G"#-+(%&1,Working Group on human sexuality 6
8#"#I#
G5 9"+(%%:,I!D#
!00;#;0;Journal
of Social and Personal Relationships25+,723X73&
6&%&&77%(2%7%:%3223
G5 9I#D8C+(%%,Can less be more? Comparing duration vs.
frequency of sexual encounters in same-sex and mixed-sex relationships
in “The Tortoise and the Hare”: Sexual Orientation & Gender Di@erences
in the Duration of Sexual Activity-
6!!!#(17772:Y)Y)YYY"Y/;#Y
<YY.YEYYY#Y-Y/;#YY
!Y/0/;YYJ;0/;Y
G#I9/!HI+&3:1,American Couples!WD6
J!
G!DGG8'"#) G)9J8/+(%&,
;#
#4/The American Journal of Orthopsychiatry
84+&,1X6&%&%17%%3::&
(1
G!'9)+(%&%,/BH"B
C/8/#
.JAmerican Journal of Mens Health4+1,(27X(72
6&%&&77&73::1%31(%%(
G/+&33,8-.
8#6Journal of Gay & Lesbian Social Services1+(,&%&X&&7
6&%&1%%'%&%&%(Y%2
G##-8#4/-8+(%%,/#-
BII+/BII,(%%IB8I/%&70&
J&((%&-
6!!!##!8J#&7
G##DGI9GDDG+&337,8
;;B/IGJournal of Applied Social
Psychology27+&,&(&X&(76&%&&&&?&30
&:&2&337%&:%;
8!J9I# +&3:,)-!
Sex Roles10+7:,(7X%
6&%&%&7/%%1::7&%3%%%&(
8I859I5+&3:3,E-;##
#Psychological Reports64&&27X&&73
85J+(%%%,Relationship characteristics, social support,
masculine ideologies and psychological functioning of gay men in
(
couples. Ph.D. Thesis, California School of Professional Psychology
8-/-I-I
889..'+(%%:,. 6
-8-Demography45+1,71X3%6&%&11%%%&
88+(%%(,8J4
/Vital and Health Statistics; Series 23, No. 22, Hyattsville,
Maryland&(%&-
6!!!Y(1(1Y%((-
8D"E88)G9 +(%&(,-
)-"BRI-/4B"BR0
.J8AIDS and Behavior16+7,
&3X&3:6&%&%%7&%2&0%&(0%&:&02
8" W 9$G+(%&,8#-#
!;!86>##
BMC Public Health15+&,&12X&1:6&%&&:2&(::30%&0&120:
8+(%&%,Pew Research CenterJ
&((%&-6!!!!(%&%%2%000
=#9."+(%%&,#-;#
H;#
#Journal of Interpersonal Violence16&%%:X&%(7
6&%&&77%::2(2%%&%&2%&%%%1
(
8DG#/8)G9"E88
+(%&(,I0#Z#-D
##AIDS and Behavior16+&,&3X
276&%&%%7&%2&0%&%03:2:0:
)R595/8+(%%3,"BR
D"BR#6
-AIDS and Behavior13+(,&:X3
6&%&%%7&%2&0%%:03:%01
/9. +&33%,8--
#Psychology of Women Quarterly14+&,1X2(
6&%&&&&?&7&02%(&33%%%%%;
.<9"J8+(%%(,B-
0;#
Personal Relationships9+&,:3X316&%&&&&&702:&&%%%%2
.J +(%&(,Fusion in lesbian relationships; the relationship between
di@erentiation of self and gay stressorsI)/4-
<D
.I"9'G+&373,The Kinsey Data: Marginal
tabulations of the 1938-1963 interviews conducted by the Institute for
Sex ResearchI6G/#
.'GJ9$D+&332,#-#
#B' 9'.+,Lesbians
(2
and Gays in Couples and Families+&:X(1%,/C6'0
G
"/J+(%%(,//#J.J
8#8!"BRB/Journal of Social and Personal
Relationships19+&,:7X&&&6&%&&77%(2%7%(&3&%%
" "DCJ /8'9#I
+(%%(,First, Service. Relationships, sex and health among lesbian and
bisexual women -
6!!!#D*(%%(-+&(0
J(%&,
"D.J))'9/8 +(%&%,
I/8-/-0B* .
G;##4/I/Sexuality Research and
Social Policy7+1,&72X(%%-(%:11:1
"E889G#/8+(%&%,/;#
#Archives of Sexual Behavior39+1,77X7:7
6&%&%%7&%%:0%%:031310(
'/ 9W#J+(%%7,Ex-Gays? A Longitudinal Study of
Religiously Mediated Change in Sexual Orientation!=.
B6BRI
(7
'/ 9W#J+(%&&,##-
#;#Journal of Sex and
Marital Therapy37+,%X(76&%&%:%%%3(2(1N(%&&2%7%(
5 9/.+(%%,./I/6.
B/#?[GIJournal of
Personality72+,327X336&%&&&&?%%((01%2(%%%%(:7;
5;/'I.8!-'J8G;9
8+&337,/;#B/6-
AIDS11+(,&3&X&37-
6?#!!&337%(%%%/;#Y
YYYB/YYY3;
5#D +&33&,)#-. 8#Journal of
Social and Personal Relationships8+(,(2X(7:
6&%&&77%(2%73&%:(%%2
5#D +&33:,#6#
-#;
#Journal of Marriage and the Family601X2:
6&%(1%711(:
5#D +(%%,!D!##
Current Directions in Psychological Science14+,(&X(
6&%&&&&?%32107(&(%%%%17;
(:
/J8+(%%%,.#6-#
#Journal of Homosexuality39+(,7X7&
6&%&1%%'%:(13%(Y%1
#8\+(%&(,)/-/0/;8E0/;
8JJournal of Marriage and Family74+,371X
3::6&%&&&&?&7&01717(%&(%&%%%;
#<.'"J)9J/+&33,The
Social Organization of Sexuality864-8I
D<98HH+(%&,E-/;/;#<B*
; /;#
B*Journal of Marital and Family Therapy40+&,2:X3&
6&%&&&&?&7(0%2%2(%&(%%11&;
J89C#+(%&&,8-=G/[/;
J6)8E. G;#
B#Journal of Social Issues67+(,((X(216&%&&&&?&%0
2%(%&&%&232;
J+&332,/0;@JAB.D'/<D9'
.+,Journal of Human Sexuality+X2,8);6
!/
JI9JJ+&3:,The Male Couple!8E
!'6I0"
(3
J''9C+(%%2,/;#
>#0;#Personality & Social Psychology
Bulletin32+:,&%:X336&%&&77%&2&27(%2(::(:&
)G8D G#/89"E88
+(%&%,R-/;#B
/R-/;#B
/Journal of Sex Research47+&,(X17
6&%&%:%%%((3%3%(3&2%&7
<JD//9+(%%2,/
>#0;#Journal of Social and Personal Relationships
23+&,:&X336&%&&77%(2%7%2%2%&73
ID+(%&%,);-;##;#
Perspectives on Sex and Reproductive Health42+&,11X
(6&%&121(%11&%
I/9I+&332,J;##"BR
D8BI+,Bisexualities and AIDS+(:,
456)9C-
6DDL9L9L<<&\G'9L&
I# 98/+&3:&,R#B
-.JJournal of Homosexuality6+1,&X(%
6&%&1%%'%:(%2%1Y%&
1%
I# 8/9JRJ+&337,/#-
B-- .BG
.+,Ethnic and cultural diversity among lesbians and gay men
+&&X1:,!#ID86/
I# 8/D59ID8+&37:, !6
#Journal of Social
Issues347X(76&%&&&&?&%02%&37:%(2&&;
I# ID89"J+&3:(,/-
Journal of Homosexuality8+(,(1X1
6&%&1%%'%:(%:%(Y%
IDJ+&3:,J;#0BI]
9G^?+,Western Sexuality - Practice and Precept in the Past
and Present+%X2&,<;-6GGD!
D//9"/.+(%&%,I
!00;#
Journal of Family Psychology24+&,:(X:26&%&%17%%&73(
.B8#"C#59E8+(%%:,#
;-#6
#-0;#!0;
#Developmental Psychology44+&,33X
&%&6&%&%17%%&(0&23&3&
1&
//#I//H C9/H)"
+(%&&,#-#;#-
!;!6#-"BR
G/#BMC Public Health11&:3X&37
6&%&&:2&7&0(:0&&0&:3
/D/+&332,/0;#6Journal of
Family Studies2+(,&7X&2166;&%&7(?-((&7
/J/+&3:2,)-
;##6Psychology of Women Quarterly
10(1X(13
/#D#D'G!.JJD89JDIJ+(%&1,
B8 6)-
.BPosterJ&((%&-
6D##*(%&1%(00(%&1-
/J.'IJ9II+(%%2,B#
##;#
;#J##Sexually Transmitted Infections
82+2,7X776&%&&12(%%2%(%3&7
/G9-'+(%%7,J68
CJournal of Economic Perspectives21+(,(7X(
6&%&(7?(&((7
1(
)?I)98'+&333,8--
-0;0;Violence and
Victims14+,&1X(
)8'G#98+(%&(,
-#Personal Relationships
19+(,(&3X(116&%&&&&?&702:&&(%&&%&13;
J/8'9I+&33,Dual Attraction.
Understanding Bisexuality!WD6<;-4I
'+&377,Homosexuality Reexamined 6#D!
;&
B-*;@TA*#;#!#-
-#)!-#
#-#-
C#1).'-#&370
&37&)8!!
#--!6J132C
&7:##-
(F2F--
I#6+I#8D9ID&37:,+4
,(Gebhard & Johnson, 1979)(13)(M2.7/F3.9y)+I#98
&3:&,(1)(M+F <1.25y), (Peplau et al., 1982)+ ,
11
(Blumstein & Schwartz, 1983)(2)(M<4.4,F<2.8), (Caldwell & Peplau, 1984)
+ ,(McWhirter & Mattison, 1984)(3)(M<5y), (Schneider, 1986)+/
,+9.&33%,+<(U,+G&33,+Weinberg et
al., 1994,(4)(M<4, F<4y), (Green et al., 1996)(5)(M<4, F<3.5y), (Pan &
Aggleton, 1996)+8,+/D&332,+#,, (Alexander, 1997)
+G##D9GDD&337,+5;&337,+#,+I#
&337,+GD,+5#D&33:,+<U,(Campbell, 2000)(6)(M<4.5y),
(LaSala, 2000)(7)(M<4.5y), (D’Augelli & Grossman, 2001)+<S2%,
+GB9I#(%%(,+<,+G9 #(%%(,
+ ,(Gaines & Henderson, 2002)(8)(M+F 4.7)+"(%%(,+/
, (King & Smith, 2004)(9)(M<2.6y), (Henderson et al., 2002)+G9
I#D(%%,(Mohr & Fassinger, 2006)(10)(M+F <4.2y), (Otis, Rostosky, &
Riggle, 2006)+/.I9I(%%2,+G9"
(%%:,(Carpenter & Gates, 2008)(11)(M 4.7y F 3.3y), (Roisman, Clausell,
Holland, Fortuna, & Elie@, 2008)+595(%%3,
+G"BR0,+G!9)(%&%,+"E9G#(%&%,+/
,(Neilands, Chakravarty, Darbes, Beougher, & Ho@, 2010)(12)
(M<4y), (Riggle, Rostosky, & Horne, 2010)+8#,+J9
C#(%&&,+I,+8D"E9
(%&(,+G"BR0,+8DG#9"E
(%&(,+G"BRU,+.(%&(,+ D98HH(%&,+)
G#9(%&(,+/#D#DG!JD9JD(%&1,
+4,
1
