Available via license: CC BY-NC 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 242
Meeng the needs of Mediterranean naons: improving eciency in laboratory medicine
This is a Planum Open Access Journal distributed under the terms of the Creave Commons Aribuon Non-Commercial License which permits unrestricted
non-commercial use, distribuon, and reproducon in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it
and why is it important for patients?
Graham H. Beastall1,2
1 University of Glasgow, Mayeld, Birdston, Glasgow, United Kingdom
2 The Joint Commiee for Traceability in Laboratory Medicine (JCTLM)
ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT
The between method variability of paent results is
a source of uncertainty that can have adverse con-
sequences for paent safety and clinical outcomes.
Globalisaon requires that laboratory medicine results
should be transferable between methods. Traceability
in laboratory medicine aims to reduce between meth-
od variability so that results are independent of me
or locaon. Applicaon of the metrological traceability
chain facilitates a universal approach based around the
preparaon, adopon and use of higher order interna-
onal commutable reference materials and reference
measurement procedures, supported by expert ref-
erence laboratories. Global collaboraon is required,
involving several dierent stakeholder groups ranging
from internaonal experts to laboratory medicine spe-
cialists in roune clinical laboratories.
Corresponding author:
Graham H. Beastall
University of Glasgow
Mayeld, Birdston
Glasgow G66 1RW
United Kingdom
E-mail: gbeastall@googlemail.com
Key words:
metrological traceability,
commutability, stakeholder acon plan
Acknowledgements:
Published on behalf of the Joint Commiee
for Traceability in Laboratory Medicine (JCTLM)
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 243
Graham H. Beastall
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it and why is it important for paents?
INTRODUCTION
Laboratory medicine results inuence a high per-
centage of all clinical decisions. Paents expect
that dierent laboratories, using dierent meth-
ods, will give the same result for an analyte mea-
sured in a clinical sample. Oen this is not the
case and an inappropriate clinical decision for
a paent may be the consequence. Laboratory
medicine specialists have a professional respon-
sibility to provide a high-quality service that is
opmised to the needs of the paent [1].
Traceability in laboratory medicine aims to re-
duce between method variability so that results
are independent of me or locaon [2]. Achieving
traceability is a global mul-stakeholder coop-
erave acvity involving metrologists; interna-
tional standards organisations; scientific and
clinical experts from internaonal professional
bodies; healthcare regulators; and the in-vitro
diagnoscs (IVD) industry that is responsible for
the manufacture and sale of diagnosc tesng
systems [3]. The Joint Commiee for Traceability
in Laboratory Medicine (JCTLM) was established
to co-ordinate the acvity of these stakeholders,
to provide educaonal support for traceability,
and to establish and maintain a database of ref-
erence materials, reference methods and refer-
ence laboratories [4].
THE IMPORTANCE
OF REDUCING BETWEEN-METHOD
AND BETWEEN-LABORATORY VARIABILITY
There are several reasons why efforts should
be made to reduce between-method and be-
tween-laboratory variability [5]. These include:
• Improving paent safety
• Facilitang paent empowerment
• Ensuring public condence
• Enabling consolidaon and networking
• Supporng laboratory accreditaon
• Implemenng evidence-based clinical
guidelines
• Guaranteeing clinical governance
• Adopng common informacs
• Introducing the electronic paent record
TRACEABILITY IN LABORATORY
MEDICINE AND THE METROLOGICAL
TRACEABILITY CHAIN
Metrology is the science of measurement. The
basics of measurement involve:
• A measurable property, known as a quanty
(e.g. concentraon)
• Denion of the measurand – the quanty
that is intended to be measured. The de-
scription of the measurand should include
the matrix (e.g. plasma); the component
(analyte) of interest, and the amount of
substance concentraon
• The units in which the measurement will be
made. Metrological traceability requires the
international system of units (SI) or units
with well-established conversions
• The uncertainty with which the measure-
ment can be made
Metrological traceability is the property of a
measurement result, which can be related to
a reference through a documented unbroken
chain of calibrations. The principles of a ref-
erence measurement system for establishing
metrological traceability are described in the
ISO17511:2003 document [6]. The components
of a reference measurement system comprise
reference materials (calibrators) and measure-
ment procedures (methods), both of which ex-
ist at dierent hierarchical levels.
The inter-relaonship between the components
of a reference measurement system describes
the metrological traceability chain [6]. Figure 1
depicts this traceability chain with higher order
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 244
Graham H. Beastall
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it and why is it important for paents?
reference materials and measurement proce-
dures at the top and lower order towards the
bottom. This hierarchy is depicted by the ris-
ing ‘metrological traceability’ arrow. Descent
through the traceability chain is accompanied
by increasing measurement uncertainty as de-
picted by the downward arrow.
The traceability status of an individual measure-
ment result depends on the existence of an un-
broken chain to higher order materials and/or
measurement procedures. To be eecve the
unbroken chain requires commutable materials
[7] and suciently low imprecision at each step.
In the case of structurally simple molecules,
like many of those measured rounely in clini-
cal chemistry, it is possible to have a complete
unbroken chain to primary reference measure-
ment procedures and primary reference materi-
als. Even for some protein molecules it is possible
to achieve full metrological traceability by using
a unique, signature pepde as the primary refer-
ence material. The measurement of serum cho-
lesterol and blood haemoglobin A1c are examples
of full metrological traceability where the agree-
ment between methods is excellent [3]. Serum
parathyroid hormone and blood haemoglobin A2
are examples where the between-method vari-
ability is unacceptably high, causing clinical risk.
In both these cases method standardisaon/har-
monisaon iniaves have commenced [3].
For many biological materials, including com-
plex proteins and viruses it is not possible to
prepare secondary calibrators. In these circum-
stances internaonal convenonal calibrators
are adopted as being the highest order materi-
als available. The global acceptance of such in-
ternaonal convenonal calibrators can facili-
tate reduced between method variability.
Figure 1 Metrological traceability chain for laboratory medicine
Primary reference material
Primary calibrator
Secondary calibrator
Manufacturer master
calibrator
Product calibrator
Patient result
Primary reference
measurement procedure
Secondary reference
measurement procedure
Manufacturer selected
measurement procedure
Manufacturer standing
measurement procedure
Routine laboratory method
Metrological traceability
Routine
lab
IVD method
manufacturer
Metrology
institute /
Reference lab
Measurement uncertainty
Adapted from EN ISO 17511 2003 [6]
Definition of measurand: concentration in SI units
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 245
Graham H. Beastall
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it and why is it important for paents?
SOURCES OF REFERENCE MATERIALS
AND REFERENCE MEASUREMENT
PROCEDURES
The JCTLM maintains a database of refer-
ence materials, reference measurement pro-
cedures and reference laboratories [8]. Strict
criteria are required for inclusion in the JCTLM
database, including evidence of commutabil-
ity of reference materials and measurement
uncertainty.
The World Health Organizaon Expert Commiee
for Biological Standardizaon (WHO-ECBS) main-
tains a catalogue of internaonal convenonal
calibrators for blood products and biological
stan dards [9].
CHALLENGES IN IMPLEMENTING
TRACEABILITY IN LABORATORY MEDICINE
AT A GLOBAL LEVEL
There are several challenges to implemenng
global traceability [3]. These include:
• Geographical dierences
• Lack of uniformity of units
• Complex analytes
• Global coordinaon
STAKEHOLDERS IN IMPLEMENTING
TRACEABILITY IN LABORATORY MEDICINE
The stakeholders involved in delivering trace-
ability in laboratory medicine into roune prac-
ce are summarised in Figure 2.
Figure 2 Global stakeholders involved in delivering traceability
in laboratory medicine into routine practice
Define clinical decision values
and analytical requirements
Provide reference materials
and reference methods
List available materials and
methods. Promote traceability
Raise analytical and clinical
quality targets
Produce higher-order methods
with commutable calibrators
Use commutable materials to
monitor method performance
Select methods based on
quality performance
Routine
lab
EQA
providers
IVD method
manufacturers
Standards / accreditation /
professional bodies
Global database of reference
materials & methods
National metrology institutes
Professional bodies / societies
Internationally recognised expert
clinical / laboratory committees
Adapted from Beastall et al. [3]
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 246
Graham H. Beastall
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it and why is it important for paents?
The iniave begins at the boom of the trian-
gle with internaonal recognion of the need
for traceability for a specic analyte. Thereaer,
internaonal and naonal standards organisa-
ons and metrology instutes are responsible
for producing and lisng the available reference
materials and measurement procedures. These
are used by the IVD method manufacturers to
produce the methods made available for roune
use with their performance evaluated through
external quality assessment (EQA) schemes
based on commutable control materials.
ACTION PLAN TO IMPLEMENT
TRACEABILITY IN LABORATORY MEDICINE
AT A GLOBAL LEVEL
The implementaon of traceability in laboratory
medicine at a global level requires a coordinated
action plan. This can be derived from Figure 2
by assigning acons to each of the seven stake-
holder groups [3].
1. Internaonally recognised expert clinical/
laboratory commiees:
• Develop internaonal consorum for
communicaon and sharing informa-
on on the need for traceability
• Priorise and agree methods that re-
quire harmonisaon and issue invita-
ons to expert groups to undertake
method harmonisaon projects [10]
2. Naonal metrology instutes/internaonal
professional bodies/sociees:
• Develop commutable reference materi-
als and measurement procedures for
individual analytes to the highest avail-
able order of metrological traceability
• Publish the outcome of harmonisaon
projects in peer-reviewed scienc
literature
3. Global database of reference materials and
methods:
• Using freely available lists and cata-
logues publicise available reference
materials and methods that meet
agreed standards, including informaon
on commutability and measurement
uncertainty
• Provide educaonal support materials
to promote the importance of trace-
ability in laboratory medicine
4. Standards/accreditaon/professional bodies:
• Include traceability in laboratory medi-
cine in the training of laboratory medi-
cine specialists and in the standards
required for laboratory accreditaon
• Provide educaonal support materials
to promote the importance of trace-
ability in laboratory medicine
5. IVD method manufacturers:
• Produce IVD methods that conform
with the highest available order of met-
rological traceability
• Provide details of the traceability status
of methods in the informaon for use
documentaon
6. EQA providers:
• Promote the use of commutable EQA
materials
• Provide educaonal support about
traceability for EQA scheme parcipants
7. Roune laboratory medicine specialists:
• Know the traceability status of the
methods used and understand the
measurement uncertainty involved
• Educate sta about traceability in labo-
ratory medicine and its importance to
healthcare
eJIFCC2018Vol29No4pp242-247
Page 247
Graham H. Beastall
Traceability in laboratory medicine: what is it and why is it important for paents?
Resources for educaonal support are available
from JCTLM [4]. Readers of this arcle are invited
to discuss with their peers how they can contrib-
ute to the coordinated acon plan.
REFERENCES
1. Beastall GH. Adding value to laboratory medicine: a
professional responsibility. Clin Chem Lab Med 2013; 51:
221-228
2. White GH. Metrological traceability in clinical biochem-
istry. Ann Clin Biochem 2011; 48: 393-409
3. Beastall GH, Brouwer N, Quiroga S, Myers GL. Trace-
ability in laboratory medicine: a global driver for accurate
results for paent care. Clin Chem Lab Med 2017; 55:
1100-1108
4. JCTLM: Traceability, educaon and promoon. www.
jctlm.org (accessed 25 July 2018)
5. Plebani M. Harmonizaon in laboratory medicine: the
complete picture. Clin Chem Lab Med 2013; 51: 741-751
6. ISO 17511: 2003 In vitro diagnosc medical devices -
measurement of quanes in biological samples – met-
rological traceability of values assigned to calibrators and
control materials ISO, Geneva, Switzerland; 2003
7. Young IS. The enduring importance and challenge of
commutability. Clin Chem 2018; 64: 421-423
8. JCTLM database of reference materials and measure-
ment procedures www.bipm.org/jctlm/ (accessed 25 July
2018)
9. WHO catalogue of blood products and related biologi-
cals http://www.who.int/bloodproducts/catalogue/en
(accessed 25 July 2018)
10. The Internaonal Consorum for Harmonizaon of
Clinical Laboratory Results. www.harmonizaon.net (ac-
cessed 25 July 2018)