ArticlePDF Available

The Benefits of Reflexology for the Chronic Pain Patient in a Military Pain Clinic

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Background: Chronic pain is a major cause of disability across the military, especially for the combat Soldier. More than twothirds of Americans with chronic pain are now using complementary medicine. Methods: Patients with chronic pain opting for reflexology as part of their treatment plan received bilateral therapy. Alternating pressure was applied to the individual patient's reflex points corresponding to their pain sites. Following a single treatment session, patients were asked to complete a short survey. Discussion: There is evidence that reflexology is therapeutic for many conditions, to include sleep and anxiety, both of which can be comorbidity in the patient with chronic pain. There is a lack of evidence on the use of reflexology with chronic pain patients receiving multidisciplinary pain care. Results: A total of 311 participants completed the survey. Posttreatment pain scored decreased by a median of 2 points (interquartile range [IQR] 1-3) on a 10-point pain scale. This represents a median 43% (IQR 25%-60%) reduction in pain for males and a 41% (IQR 30%-60%) reduction in pain for females. Conclusion: Currently research is limited on effects of reflexology in treating chronic pain, yet, like acupuncture, this is an inexpensive, reliable, teachable, and simple noninvasive treatment. Further studies are warranted.
Content may be subject to copyright.
103
*Correspondence to serene.health.reflexology@gmail.com
The authors are from Womack Army Medical Center, Fort Bragg, NC.
ABSTRACT
Background: Chronic pain is a major cause of disability across
the military, especially for the combat Soldier. More than two-
thirds of Americans with chronic pain are now using comple-
mentary medicine. Methods: Patients with chronic pain opting
for reflexology as part of their treatment plan received bilateral
therapy. Alternating pressure was applied to the individual pa-
tient’s reflex points corresponding to their pain sites. Follow-
ing a single treatment session, patients were asked to complete
a short survey. Discussion: There is evidence that reflexology is
therapeutic for many conditions, to include sleep and anxiety,
both of which can be comorbidity in the patient with chronic
pain. There is a lack of evidence on the use of reflexology with
chronic pain patients receiving multidisciplinary pain care.
Results: A total of 311 participants completed the survey.
Posttreatment pain scored decreased by a median of 2 points
(interquartile range [IQR] 1–3) on a 10-point pain scale. This
represents a median 43% (IQR 25%–60%) reduction in pain
for males and a 41% (IQR 30%–60%) reduction in pain for
females. Conclusion: Currently research is limited on effects of
reflexology in treating chronic pain, yet, like acupuncture, this
is an inexpensive, reliable, teachable, and simple noninvasive
treatment. Further studies are warranted.
Keywords: reflexology; pain; chronic pain; complementary
treatments; alternative treatments
Introduction
Chronic pain is a major cause of disability across the military
but is most common in the Soldier deployed for combat.1 The
Final Report from the Army Surgeon General’s Pain Manage-
ment Task Force recommended the use of complementary al-
ternative medicine (CAM) but specifically stated the lack of
evidence supporting its use.2 More than two-thirds of Ameri-
cans with chronic pain are now using complementary and al-
ternative therapies.
The origins of reflexology reach back to ancient Egypt, with
hieroglyphic evidence as early as 2330 BC in the tombs of
Ankhamor. This evidence demonstrated sophisticated systems
of treatment that are comparable to the “foot maps” available
today. From Egypt, this modality spread throughout the Ro-
man Empire, helping to popularize it long before allopathic
medicine was developed.3
In practice of reflexology, it is believed that there are reflex
points that correspond to every gland, organ, muscle, tissue,
and body system. In addition, through mastery and applica-
tion of reflexology techniques, it is thought that the blood and
lymph circulation to these can be influenced toward homeo-
stasis (Figure 1).4 According to the Reflexology Association
of America, “Reflexology is a non-invasive complementary
practice involving the use of alternating pressure applied to
reflexes within reflex maps of the body, located on the feet,
hands and outer ears.”5
Recently, some therapists practicing reflexology have inte -
grated related forms of therapy such as yoga/stretching,
breath ing exercises, and mindfulness with guided imagery.
One application of this type of integrative therapy is Integra-
tive Method Reflex Therapy (IMRT), in which reflexology is
used in conjunction with a comprehensive medical program in
a clinical setting as a therapeutic tool. When practicing IMRT,
the reflexologist has the advantage of access to clinical data
that is not available in a nonclinical setting.6
Reflexology may improve chronic pain by helping to improve
sleep.7,8 A study analyzing the effects of reflexology on alpha
brain waves in sleep found that the application of reflexology
induced change in the activity of brain waves in correspon-
dence with the appearance of a high degree of sleepiness.8 In
addition, there is evidence that reflexology may impact the
The Benefits of Reflexology
for the Chronic Pain Patient in a Military Pain Clinic
Connie Kern, NBCR, IMRT; Amy McCoart, RN, BSN*;
Thomas Beltranm, MA; Michael Bartoszek, MD
FIGURE 1 Foot massage chart.
Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bf/Foot
-massage-chart.jpg
104|JSOM Volume 18, Edition 4 / Winter 2018
the efficacy of the treatment (P = .78). Posttreatment, both
males and females reported a decrease on the pain scale. For
males, the self-reported median posttreatment pain score was
3 (IQR 1.5–4.5) and the median posttreatment pain score for
females was 3 (IQR 2–4). This represents a 43% (IQR 25%–
60%) reduction in pain for males and a 41% (IQR 30%–60%)
reduction in pain for females (Figure 2).
No differences were observed in self-reported pain type (mus-
culoskeletal, nerve, or both) based on sex (P = .55). Overall,
53 patients (19.9%) reported musculoskeletal pain, 26 (9.7%)
reported nerve pain, and 188 (70.4%) reported experiencing
both musculoskeletal and nerve pain. Posttreatment change in
pain was not related to age (P = .45) or type of pain (P = .30).
When asked about perceived benefit, 96.4% (n = 296) of pa-
tients reported that the treatment helped with their pain; 0.3%
(n = 1) reported that the treatment did not help; and 2.9% (n =
9) of patients reported “Not sure.” Similar responses were ob-
served when asked about repeating the treatment. Ninety-nine
percent (n = 302) of patients reported that they would be in-
terested in further treatment, while 1% (n = 4) responded that
they were not sure.
Discussion
This prospective, nonrandomized, observational study demon-
strated pain reduction with a high degree of tolerability when
reflexology was added to treatments offered in a military mul-
tidisciplinary pain management clinic. These data support ex-
pansion of reflexology services in a military multidisciplinary
pain management clinic and support further academic expan-
sion on the role of reflexology in the management of chronic
pain. Previous studies have shown reflexology to be beneficial
in treating sleep disturbances and stress. Future studies should
seek to integrate outcomes measures considering stress, sleep
quality, and chronic pain using multiple treatments over time.
In addition, future studies on training healthcare providers
and the benefits that may provide could prove beneficial.
Conclusion
Reflexology, when used as part of a multidisciplinary treat-
ment plan, has been shown to have high patient tolerability
with pain reduction. Further studies are warranted.
Disclosure
There was no funding source for this project, and there were
no conflicts of interest. The views expressed herein are those
of the author(s) and do not reflect the official policy of the
stress response.9 A study of cancer patients with anxiety found
that “patients experienced a significant decrease in pain inten-
sity and anxiety” compared with the control group.10,11 Studies
like these have helped to build objective evidence supporting
the use of reflexology in chronic pain patients. There is a lack
of evidence on the use of reflexology with chronic pain pa-
tients receiving multidisciplinary pain care. We sought to de-
termine the feasibility of incorporating the use reflexology for
US Army Soldiers with chronic pain within in an interdisci-
plinary pain clinic.
Methods
The Interdisciplinary Pain Management Center (IPMC) at
Womack Army Medical Center, Fort Bragg, NC, is a fully in-
tegrated clinic offering comprehensive pain management. Pa-
tients with chronic pain receiving treatment at IPMC opting
for reflexology received 25 minutes of therapy using both feet
(unless contraindicated) in addition to their standard of care
pain management therapies, which could include acupuncture,
chiropractic care, massage, exercise therapy, physical therapy,
interventional pain procedures, and prescription medications.
Adhering to the guidelines of the American Reflexology
Certification Board, alternating pressure was applied by a
board-certified reflexologist correlating to the individual pa-
tient’s pain sites and other points based on the reflexologist’s
assessment of the patient’s pain complaint and comorbidities.
Following a single treatment session, patients were then asked
to complete a voluntary survey reporting their sex, age, and
pretreatment pain score using the Defense and Veterans Pain
Rating Scale (DVPRS).12 The survey also included the classi-
fication of pain (musculoskeletal, nerve, or both), immediate
posttreatment pain scores, satisfaction, and self- assessment of
treatment benefit.
Summary statistics are reported as median and IQR for contin-
uous variables. Categorical variables are reported as percent-
ages. Patients’ change in pain was computed using self-reported
assessments of pretreatment and posttreatment pain. Kruskal–
Wallis tests were used to assess the relationship between cat-
egorical variables and age, pretreatment pain, posttreatment
pain, as well as change in pain. Linear regression analysis was
used to examine the relationship between posttreatment pain
reduction, age, and pain type. All statistical tests were per-
formed by using a P < .05 level of significance. Data analyses
were conducted using SPSS v23 (IBM, Armonk, NY).
Results
A total of 311 participants completed the survey. Among the
295 who indicated their sex, 67.5% (n = 199) reported being
male and 32.5% (n = 96) reported being female. The median
age of the participants was 36 years (IQR 28–44). Females
were significantly older than males, with a median age of 42
years (IQR 30–46) compared with a median age of 35 years
(IRQ 38–43) for males (P < .01).
Sex differences were observed in self-reported pain before
treatment. For pretreatment pain, females reported less pain
than males (P = .02). Posttreatment pain did not differ by sex
(P > .05). Females reported a median pretreatment pain of 5
(IQR 3.5–6.5), while males reported a median pretreatment
pain of 6 (IQR 3.5–7.5). There were no differences by sex in
FIGURE 2 Pain reduction of 43% (IQR 25%–60%) for males and
of 41% (IQR 30%–60%) for females.
Reflexology for Chronic Pain in Military Patients
|105
Department of the Army, Department of Defense, or the US
government.All authors approved the final version.
Author Contributions
CK is a board-certified reflexologist who had an interest in
conducting a research study on the effectiveness of reflexology.
She provided the therapy and contributed in writing the manu-
script; AM with CK developed the questionnaire and plan for
the project and initiated the manuscript, TB analyzed the data
and wrote the Results section; and MB reviewed and edited
the final version of the manuscript.
References
1. Cohen SP, Nguyen C, Kapoor SG, et al. Back pain during war an
analysis of factors affecting outcome. Arch Intern Med. 2009;169
(20):1916–1923. doi:10.1001/archinternmed.2009.380
2. https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a523510.pdf. Accessed 21
Sept 2017.
3. Dale C. The subtle body: an encyclopedia of your energetic anat-
omy. Sounds True. 2014.
4. Foot massage chart. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia
/commons/b/bf/Foot-massage-chart.jpg. Accessed 20 Apr 2013.
5. Reflexology Association of America. http://reflexology-usa.org.
Accessed November 2015.
6. Hillinger MG, Wolever RQ, McKernan LC, et al. Integrative
medicine for the treatment of persistent pain. Primary Care Clin
Office Pract. 2017;44(2):247–264.
7. Finan PH, Goodin BR, Smith MT. The association of sleep and
pain: an update and a path forward. J Pain. 2013;14(12), 1539–
1552. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2013.08.007
8. Esmel-Esmel N, Tomás-Esmel E, Tous-Andreu M, et al. Reflex-
ology and polysomnography: Changes in cerebral wave activity
induced by reflexology promote N1 and N2 sleep stages. Com-
plement Therap Clin Pract. 2017.
9. Hebden Bridge Times. Your health with Lucy Wilson of Physio
& Therapies: How reflexology can relieve stress. http://www
.hebdenbridgetimes.co.uk/news/your-health-with-lucy-wilson-of
-physio-therapies-how-reflexology-can-relieve-stress-1-7579462.
Accessed 29 Sep 2017.
10. Stephenson NL, Swanson M, Dalton J, et al. Partner-delivered
reflexology: effects on cancer pain and anxiety. Oncol Nursing
Forum. 2007;34(1).
11. Frambes D, Sikorskii A, Tesnjak I, et al. (2017, September). Care-
giver-reported health out comes: effects of providing reflexology
for symptom manage ment to women with advanced breast can-
cer. Oncol Nursing Forum. 2017;44(5):596–605.
12. Buckenmaier CC III, Galloway KT, Polomano RC, et al. Prelim-
inary validation of the Defense and Veterans Pain Rating Scale
(DVPRS) in a military population. Pain Med. 2013;14(1):110–123.
Available on t he JSOM Online Store at:
www.JSOMonline.org/ATP-P.php
Show your team how much you care.
Subscribe to the JSOM and
inform your thinking.
The
Journal of Special
Operations Medicine
(JSOM) is
the only academic, peer-reviewed
medical journal in the world
dedicated to unconventional
medicine in the unique working
environment of the Tactical Medical
Professional. Take your training
to
the next level
with current,
relevant updates – as they happen.
Chapter
Complementary and integrative health approaches are becoming more widely used by patients with pain in the United States and the rest of the Western world. Growing body of evidence point to potential benefit and complementary roles they can play in managing patient's pain. Further research evaluating efficacy of many of these approaches is indicated.
Article
Reflexology lymph drainage (RLD) for breast cancer-related lymphoedema (BCRL) may have a positive impact on arm swelling and pain. Thermal imaging is a means of tracking temperature change by visual images. This study aimed to explore the use of thermal imaging in treatment for BCRL. The swollen arms of two participants with BCRL were photographed using a thermal imaging camera during a single RLD treatment. Limb Volume Circumferential Measurement (LVCM) of both arms was taken before, after and the next day. The images were examined for visual changes, and temperature data were extracted. Images showed differences in temperature within the affected hand and arm over 45 minutes. LVCM data indicated a loss of limb volume in the affected arm in both cases, which continued to decrease over 24 hours. Thus, thermal imaging may be useful in tracking temperature change during treatment for BCRL.
Article
Background: The neonates of addicted women are at risk for neonatal abstinence syndrome. This study aimed to compare the effects of auricular seed acupressure and foot reflexology on neonatal abstinence syndrome among the neonates of addicted women. Methods: Thirty one neonates of addicted women were purposively recruited and randomly allocated through coin flipping to receive either foot reflexology then seed acupressure or seed acupressure then foot reflexology. Interventions were performed in two successive days with a 12-h washout interval. Foot reflexology was applied for 15 min to the first horizontal zone of the sole while seed acupressure was applied for 24 h through attaching acupuncture-specific ear seeds to the posterior surface of the auricle on the SJ 17 acupoint. The symptoms of abstinence syndrome were assessed using Finnegan Neonatal Abstinence Scoring System before and after foot reflexology, and before, 15 min, and 24 h after the onset of the seed acupressure intervention. Symptom assessment was done by a research assistant who was blind to the study intervention. Findings: The mean score of abstinence symptoms for the foot reflexology intervention significantly reduced from 10.32 ± 2.10 at pretest to 7.87 ± 2.04 at posttest (P < 0.001). Moreover, the mean score of abstinence symptoms for the seed acupressure intervention significantly reduced from 9.70 ± 2.10 to 8.70 ± 1.46 at the first posttest (P = 0.007) and 7.32 ± 1.42 at the second posttest (P < 0.001). The change in the mean score of the foot reflexology intervention was significantly greater than the change in the mean score at the first seed acupressure posttest (P < 0.001) but did not significantly differ from the change in the second seed acupressure posttest (P = 0.880). Conclusion: Both foot reflexology and auricular seed acupressure has significant effects on abstinence symptoms. Of course, 15-min seed acupressure is less effective than 15-min foot reflexology, while 24-h seed acupressure is as effective as 15-min foot reflexology in alleviating abstinence symptoms.
Article
Full-text available
Background Several studies have shown the effectiveness of reflexology in different health problems as well as obtaining a high degree of relaxation during its application. A previous study suggested a possible relation between the relaxation obtained during the reflexology session and the sleep. However, the design of the study did not provide evidence for this hypothesis. In this study, we use a polysomnogram to investigate the effects during its application. Method Prospective experimental study conducted in a sleep laboratory. Twelve healthy adults were enrolled. Two groups were created based on whether or not they had knowledge of reflexology. Reflexology was applied for 35 min and their sleep effects were measured by means of polysomnography. A descriptive and bivariate analysis was performed. A bivariate analysis conducted through chi-square test or ANOVA was considered appropriate. Results After controlling for baseline data, nine of the participants did move toward N1 (p = 0.833) and N2 (p = 0.227) stages, remaining in these states between 4 min and 25.5 min. No significant differences were found between the two groups. Conclusions The application of reflexology induces changes in the activity of brain waves in correspondence with the appearance of a high degree of sleepiness and sleep (N1 and N2 NREM sleep). There is a gradual transition and an orderly progression from wakefulness to sleep, which could explain the effects of relaxation and well being obtained with this method, as well as many other benefits.
Article
Full-text available
Ample evidence suggests that sleep and pain are related. However, many questions remain about the direction of causality in their association, as well as mechanisms that may account for their association. The prevailing view has generally been that they are reciprocally related. The present review critically examines the recent prospective and experimental literature (2005-present) in an attempt to update the field on emergent themes pertaining to the directionality and mechanisms of the association of sleep and pain. A key trend emerging from population-based longitudinal studies is that sleep impairments reliably predict new incidents and exacerbations of chronic pain. Microlongitudinal studies employing deep subjective and objective assessments of pain and sleep support the notion that sleep impairments are a stronger, more reliable predictor of pain than pain is of sleep impairments. Recent experimental studies suggest that sleep disturbance may impair key processes that contribute to the development and maintenance of chronic pain, including endogenous pain inhibition and joint pain. Several biopsychosocial targets for future mechanistic research on sleep and pain are discussed, including dopamine and opioid systems, positive and negative affect, and sociodemographic factors. This critical review examines the recent prospective and experimental research (2005-present) on the association of sleep and pain in an attempt to identify trends suggestive of directionality and potential mechanisms. An update on this literature is needed to guide future clinical efforts to develop and augment treatments for chronic sleep disturbance and chronic pain.
Article
Purpose/Objectives: To determine the effects of delivering a reflexology intervention on health outcomes of informal caregivers, and to explore whether intervention effects are moderated by caregiver characteristics. Design: Two-group, randomized clinical trial. Setting: Eight oncology clinics in urban and rural regions of Michigan and Illinois. Sample: 180 informal caregivers of patients with advanced breast cancer. Methods: Caregivers were randomized to provide reflexology to individuals with cancer during a four-week period or to attention control. Data collection occurred at baseline and at weeks 5 and 11. Linear mixed-effects modeling was used to test intervention effects among all participants and the effects of the number of sessions delivered in the reflexology group. Main Research Variables: Caregiver characteristics; psychological, physical, and social outcomes. Findings: Caregiver fatigue in the reflexology group was reduced compared to controls at weeks 5 (p = 0.02) and 11 (p = 0.05). No differences were found for anxiety, depression, pain, physical function, sleep disturbance, satisfaction with participation in social roles, and pain interference between caregivers who delivered reflexology and those who did not. Conclusions: Informal caregivers who provided reflexology to individuals with cancer did not have negative psychological, physical, or social outcomes. Fatigue levels were lower among caregivers who provided reflexology. Implications for Nursing: Clinicians need to be aware that providing supportive care interventions, such as reflexology, to reduce symptom burden does not increase negative outcomes on informal caregivers who provide this care, and it may even lead to reduced fatigue.
Article
Integrative health modalities can provide useful tools in the management of persistent pain in the primary care setting. These modalities, such as acupuncture, mind-body medicine, diet and herbs, and movement strategies can be safely used and may provide patients with hope and empowerment. It is highly recommended that the patient work alongside trained professionals for a given modality and/or an interprofessional team.
Article
Back pain is the leading cause of disability in the world, but it is even more common in soldiers deployed for combat operations. Aside from battle injuries and psychiatric conditions, spine pain and other musculoskeletal conditions are associated with the lowest return-to-unit rate among service members medically evacuated out of Operations Iraqi and Enduring Freedom. Demographic, military-specific, and outcome data were prospectively collected over a 2-week period at the Deployed Warrior Medical Management Center in Germany on 1410 consecutive soldiers medically evacuated out of theaters of combat operations for a primary diagnosis pertaining to back pain between 2004 and 2007. The 2-week period represents the maximal allowable time an evacuated soldier can spend in treatment before disposition (ie, return to theater or evacuate to United States) is rendered. Electronic medical records were then reviewed to examine the effect a host of demographic and clinical variables had on the categorical outcome measure, return to unit. The overall return-to-unit rate was 13%. Factors associated with a positive outcome included female sex, deployment to Afghanistan, being an officer, and a history of back pain. Trends toward not returning to duty were found for navy and marine service members, coexisting psychiatric morbidity, and not being seen in a pain clinic. The likelihood of a service member medically evacuated out of theater with back pain returning to duty is low irrespective of any intervention(s) or characteristic(s). More research is needed to determine whether concomitant treatment of coexisting psychological factors and early treatment "in theater" can reduce attrition rates.
Article
To compare the effects of partner-delivered foot reflexology and usual care plus attention on patients' perceived pain and anxiety. The experimental pretest/post-test design included patient-partner dyads randomly assigned to an experimental or control group. Four hospitals in the southeastern United States. 42 experimental and 44 control subjects comprised 86 dyads of patients with metastatic cancer and their partners, representing 16 different types of cancer; 23% of patients had lung cancer, followed by breast, colorectal, and head and neck cancer and lymphoma. The subjects had a mean age of 58.3 years, 51% were female, 66% had a high school education or less, and 58% were Caucasian, 40% were African American, and 1% were Filipino. The intervention included a 15- to 30-minute teaching session on foot reflexology to the partner by a certified reflexologist, an optional 15- to 30-minute foot reflexology session for the partner, and a 30-minute, partner-delivered foot reflexology intervention for the patient. The control group received a 30-minute reading session from their partners. Pain and anxiety. Following the initial partner-delivered foot reflexology, patients experienced a significant decrease in pain intensity and anxiety. A nurse reflexologist taught partners how to perform reflexology on patients with metastatic cancer pain in the hospital, resulting in an immediate decrease in pain intensity and anxiety; minimal changes were seen in the control group, who received usual care plus attention. Hospitals could have qualified professionals offer reflexology as a complementary therapy and teach interested partners the modality.
The subtle body: an encyclopedia of your energetic anatomy. Sounds True
  • C Dale
Dale C. The subtle body: an encyclopedia of your energetic anatomy. Sounds True. 2014.
Preliminary validation of the Defense and Veterans Pain Rating Scale (DVPRS) in a military population
  • C C Buckenmaier
  • Iii
  • K T Galloway
  • R C Polomano
Buckenmaier CC III, Galloway KT, Polomano RC, et al. Preliminary validation of the Defense and Veterans Pain Rating Scale (DVPRS) in a military population. Pain Med. 2013;14(1):110-123.