Content uploaded by Fabio Santos
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Fabio Santos on Dec 05, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DO ESTADO DO RIO DE JANEIRO
CENTRO DE CIÊNCIAS EXATAS E TECNOLOGIA
Relatórios Técnicos
do Departamento de Informática Aplicada
da UNIRIO
n° 0005/2017
Network of Ontologies – A Systematic
Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
Fábio Santos
Kate Revoredo
Fernanda Baião
Departamento de Informática Aplicada
UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DO ESTADO DO RIO DE JANEIRO
Av. Pasteur, 458, Urca - CEP 22290-240
RIO DE JANEIRO – BRASIL
!
Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study
and Challenges Comparison *
Fábio Santos1 Kate Revoredo1
Fernanda Baião1
1Depto de Informática Aplicada – Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (UNIRIO)
{fabiomarcos.santos, katerevoredo, fernanda.baiao}@uniriotec.br
Abstract. "#$%&'#($)*' )((+
$'))! ,-%**!,(( %)
%%-%.'-))$ () *,
#'%))$, )$%*
*! &)$()**(,)$**(
'# ( $ * ) ) / 0$ )$ ($,
)$1.2345467)8%&179)))
)$('#($:179))**('#(
$:;)&9<0%, **$-'*
*, **$-'$,)-%*
%%&%()=-%))8%
() *)$!%,(%***>%&
9< (% ')$ ) ') )$) )$ *+
1.2345467
Keywords&$,$,$ '#($, ;* +
*$%,
___________________
?))*,(%!,>@8>@4"A$$% !BB+=
ii
!(>
1Introduction 4
2Background 4
2.1 Networks of Ontologies 4
2.2 Ontology Matching Challenges 5
3 Systematic Mapping Planning 7
4 Systematic Mapping Execution 8
4.1 Results 9
4.2 Threats to Validity 11
4.3 Further Works and Remarks 12
5 Final Considerations 12
References 13
iii
1 Introduction
(,()'#)$,<(($(+
!$) (%'-*)( )!
0$!))$!'$8%
(*%**%)8%,'$1C454
7')% !($() -%+
$, )$, '-*' *-$)*($$
'$*' )<($,;)$--$<+
,D, )$ )$)$)1.23454
67E)%-- )$(%)'%*
#'$ *- )$
9) )- )$ )8% '# %% %,
*!,)(-$ )*-$)
')'#%%$') ((#***%$
,! ,)'#- !$'#)'+
,')''$')$*($F%, ,
)--)!1(!7',$$
')$ %*%,!#*)*
* %!* )'))!0+
*)'#($*! ,%)'))
)$*! ', **$%, *))$
')-(%')))$*1.2345467
)**%%('&)!#$%!%'#(+
$$, )$)$, **$*$
6, **$%B<
2 Background
$,0**<(*%A1G"47(
** -')')) (#'$%
1G"4/7;,**%)'$
*,!#'$'))!% *!!,'
$$), $8%%**$ '!-+
) *', *)* $)', +
, !$$*%**% 1C4547
)*$, )$')) -0*+
* !' ( (( $ 1;4C>34 71.23
45467)(*-!''+
$$ $ %!H%%)
)-!!,#*),1C;">.CC47)%
)$, )$1*'7*! +)$+ ,)$-
')$ ,)%%! *0'#(
$
2.1 Network of Ontologies
9%'#($!*-)$!%)
'#($($')($ !')+
$14547()#!,((#(14+
5471C;">.CC47'#($$
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
4
<, !%, ')') *1$$7
$ *$ $) 1C;" >.CC4 7
)!%, ) -- ,!((),*& +
$ *!,)'#D* '))'#
)*$, * ))D)$,)' !%
*$)'##'$15;;4;=7
)'#')$$!%(-
!%%(%,)%$)-*%$%,!')
$$*!,% (, %$(($1454+
.2367
E ,$(('$$147'(,
($$,% $)*!!,'%% !+
$4$,.'- $$$, ,%+
-**$*1>C4=7)**)!%
' *$$,(4( ))"%$1I45+
EG47!$ )$%(%
)%$*!
@!!,)!*!%'#($#*$
$* !, %! ), *, -- 1I45+
EG47.'-*$ ')%*!%+
%)$)$$ ,! * '))*+
()#),)%)*-14547)('#
($, ,!%))(-%)$
*!')-')#*$() $
!$$)'#
)('#($' *')$$*
!,157),(()%(%$ $$)
%') )') '# ( ) )))',
1GJ;45+@K45I45+EG4L7)')!) ,!%
!%'#)**) )$,$'#(+
$
*')$** ,)
) ! * # $ !' $ ) !$
'#)$$A'#)-! ')%**+
$)* ( )'#(<--
(%-!$ * (%$%*)*+
! 8%)*'$, )$*1.23454+
67:
)%!%'))*! ,)$)'
)!%'( %)8%*6.'+
-!($))$(%%%,'-'))+
$**!,4%A1.2345467()#(),
'#0
2.2 Ontology Matching Challenges
)-#4%A ,*)$()6 )$+
)8%1.2345467-$')'!$+
)), --'-$ )$)8%'#
)*)(%%'#)**(%)8%&M)<
#$*$:)*$$<%$)*%%(%)):(
'))*%,* $:M
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
5
)***',))8%)* $
'))$!$()-#4%A<)$
$))'))'*!
0*!'1.2345467&
C$+ )$ -% !% )' -% )$ *
') --$ )- ) ( ;%,
)#$)* %(!8%$ %$!+
) # )$,"**)'! $ +
!' )A( * *+
)%)**) % )$1.23
45467
4(<,( )$)8%!%%N% *') +
)$%$!)8%,*( )$)('$
,!%(%)*(<,&*A( )$#$% *%+
$D!%( )$#-*')-! *%%D
**0 ( )$%'))- ! ! *D
%A($,$ $ )$#D* A+
(0$ *,*-+!+%(% )$ )1.23
45467
;)$')!#$%#'$!%$') 0+
( !)( *<')),!%.*!
)'$%()* )$, () ,)--+
%!( *-%!%) (%%
<$%-%- %8%,(#'$
%$$1.2345467
-;) !%$!%)')! )
()( )$ !))*< (
!% % ', * )*!!,'
!!% '**%$!0%*
')%$ %+$)8%( '# ) +
$$) )*-) )$( )*+
A)8%**1.2345467
--- !%%$)% 0*)* ))
0* ,!-!) !%() )$
* ,!**-, 8%0*G%!,$+
$* %!%$('!0**+
)%)$!%)'$%)(')(<,
%)0*(<,1.2345467
- 40* ( )$ % !% 0 (% --
)'$*( !%$ (% )$*)+
(-( #$ -%% +
A'$!,,)*%')0 *'A.+
%!, $$ A , )* ) *$ ') ) %
1.2345467
-!- )$!%%$A$%*0
')') )*%!,'#) +
)$ * >)$% )' ( - % ** !
$ ) !% * -$) %-,
$ ( %$) %,#'$)%((+
%1.2345467
-$ $ !%*-$(%%%**
- ')$)%(, $%
))'#)- !!#$%,(
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
6
-%( )!%**# 4(-*
'(($-)()-!! +
)#$, )$(-*$ +
$$1.2345467
Table 1.$,;)$>)$)% A1.2345467
>)$ )
17C$+ )$-% ;% )$
174(<,( )$)8% @A!%**+
0 %A*+
A.
17;)$')!#$%#'$ 3'$8%,$%
1-7;) !%+
$ $* A
1-7-- !,
1-740*( )$% !,A
1-7!- )$ %')
1-7$ $ &(%%
%** A
3 Systematic Mapping Planning
)$(, **$*%-%!%*%+
*')%!$!!,))',('#*)
!<* )))%-(,!,) -)%
%)'#13>.4.;>.47)0(),
**$ )$ ** ') )$ (<% $,
'#
%**, **$,'<))8%!
'))$%@%!')*E&+
)$0%%$%$&!()*%+
!)<*')<%$
)%1>70%14>71)'!67)&*%!+
)*'<,-(,(),, )<
Table 2.)F%
O ;)F% O ,)F%
F
9)))$
'#($
)-!(%)+
%:
F
9)),*()$ ,
'#($01 )
*$!+
)7 *')
$,*$:
F )$'#($
0) !
1.2345467:
F6 9)'))-)%!
*%!):
FB 9))) )$)-
!(':
F .-'#(+
$!%%+
,***: F ')'#($
!$**:
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
7
Table 3.%1>740%14>7>
> )*%!<**!)$!% '#(
$
4> )*%!)-!,!'
4$),-(',%'%
)*%!
4>6 )*%!-( *-'(H%
4>B )*%!)'%$('#($ %
4> )*%!!#)*%!H*+-'1%)
$( (**7)+<*%!1%)
')**7
E!)$))$'(( $
! $ ) 9 !) ('$ ) $&1 M$,
'#M M$,'#M M$'#M M$
'#M M$,$ '#M M'#($M
M'#($,MM'#($MM'#($,M7
CC1)$(<%*(*(*
%,0*M%,MM)M)
#M)MM)M, #(7
*%1'''*% 7)$'%!*!
%%0 **
4 Systematic Mapping Execution
P%))0*'0%*%)$%$=
*%!)*%B6*%!())* +
9<,-%')0%$))$*%!+
%**,0!,*%$!B**%!
)*-(%!H'-!,)-,(-')**
'*%!)
Table 4.**( *$
O %)@%!Q%
C !)3M> *!%'#($ +
$& >$, )**)MAxiomathes6 **/+6
17
4%A P M- '# ( $MArticial intelligence-/
**L+=17
64%A P ME 0* %% $ * 10
-7MEuropean Semantic Web Conference*$@%!)$
**+61B7
BC !0@F$CM!%$$$) $+%%')0+
'# !, * ($ MData & Knowledge Enginee-
ring-/=**L+167
C%>C ;5 >%M&!% +
($$MORE**/+/=167
6) 4' ME *< ( $, '#MThe Semantic
Web: Research and Applications**//+/17
RA $ ;A 4' ) M;#$ $, +
)*0*$,'#MAMW-BL17
/)4'$;AA M;$'!8%,+
! , MInternational Journal of Web Information Sys -
tems-B**6L=+B17
93%A - % ;#'#M>)')*
$ MProceedings of the 5th International Conference on On-
tology Matching. -=/L**+6=17
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
8
PF%MS*$$,'#M The seman-
tic web: research and applications**/=6+/=1L7
8%,%*%)0*, **$,A
*')**(%0% $
*%!-H%$ (%!H-,)8%1!)* ,
,7--%$%,@!B,T
)9-%)***!$$)-+
8%,%)%$))*, *)!,**,$0%+
14>7)$%**'*+-'',
)**%)** )$*'**
E,)('))#***, **$*
)(*1!67( **'-%+
()*'% A>)$'-%+
$)0* **$;**,% +
A))$%$'',!$')
,A)**),)A +*%***)'
) )$
4.1 Results
E )**%$( ), **$'<B')+
$*<,'#($ 9))$
**%((%%'# )**(%%$'#($
')('$ &)) '! ,+
!% '!#( ) *) )
'()%()'#-**
9*'FF!)'$)$**
'))),9)-(%(%)$&'#,
'#-*$'# $ +'#
)$) < ) ' ))
)()'(!, )'# ($ <*
1I45+EG47'* )$,!%+
$ $(,.'-<-
'#($ %$%$) $+
'#%!)$),*-'#-
)%$))$, )$*! ', !,)
%)')) )$'#0%,$-,
'#,*( '#$ *-
*$'#(,9),*#-
'#%)$)!$,')'#-$*+
( )$*)*! '-1.23454+
67
Table 5.<>)$**
@*O
1(
!B7
'#(
$
< >)$ **
'# , +
'# -*+
$
6'# -*+
$
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
9
B'# - *+
$
'#,+
))
='#,+
'!
'# -*+
$ '!))
/'#,+
'! +
,
L'# -*+
$
'# -*+
$
!=')#')1*% (!
7)(%U'V)$'(%(), **$ )+
$ ))E'$' *)'#(
$)$1)U'V7'))U)V<,
U'V)$')UV1!7
Table 6.)'>)$
New Challenges
Research Areas
'#
>
;$
'#>+
,+
+'#
)$
'#+
-+
*$
;%
;)$
@A
!%
**0
;%A
* A
3'$
8%,$
%
$
!,
A
%')
#!=-A* $+
)%((%)$'(%9,) !%%')+
%!,;% )$*A!%**0+
%A* A$')')$
!**%) $,'#%))#'$
8%,$'),)$% ,!)*! *+
<, **
$MM')M'M)$*%!9 ,((
))%( %-- (% ) ,! %
'#,+'# )$'#-*+
$))!') )'!=
))8%-*)%!,8%,*%*
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
10
!$ 8%,0*'#'),$) )$* ,!
*'))0*(,-)($+
*%'#($)%)!%)
)*$
Table 7.0'>)$
Old Challenges /
New Challenges
'#>+
;+
$
'#>+
,+
+'#
)$
'#+
-+
*$
17C$+ +
)$-%
174(<,( +
)$)8%
17;)$')
!#$%#'+
$
1-7;)+
!
%$
1-7--
1-740*(
)$%
1-7+
!- )$
1-7$ +
$ &(%+
%%**
9'!T,* %!%, **$,8%+
$$FF'*!!=)$
**!((<-'!%')(%,#$'%)
')%$((-(!U)V$$F6'
(%) ()***%!)(1%$),'=*+
*7')$)$)),(')***+
-,;*%!)'U>49#)*@$V')**UC+
%> *%V')=**$$FB-)%$))
)%0* ') % ))'$)
)$)-() > *%)$$F#$+
!%$*%!,'% A)** ,(
), **!,('#($%,!%),
, .'-')U '!V
%!H')** ,
4.2 Threats to Validity
), **$)%%))T%)
-,()%19.C7
>%)&'#($)$**'))(+
%()%,-,))!%) )+
%))*'$)( **% A%$)0*+
#'$( )%).)*%!H -(
*) ,-,$')0**(-'"%(
))%)*! )*!')$
)$)-**$')
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
11
9 % , **') 0* - !% **
)$**%$ A))'*+
**--()$$%,+
%- *)-*%)!')
))%.'-*% ,)- **) ,
%)$)%-)%$)**'*)<
)-$))'%(%%'#*0*$)+
*!($'))8%')-(%
>%)&(**,$0%,=LW()
**!,))$ *(, **$*)
(%0(,('**'-!($-* % +
%))'#() )!')%
))*)*$'%)$
))*' ),)' %
)' %(**!%)) ')(%( ))%
' ,))%- ***)
)')'**'!$)8%9,(
- $ * ( .'-** ( ' - !,
'!$>$%+((,=**'(%;-
)) A!%() !(**!()
(), ,! %,-)('!-)) *( $
**')%,N%
4.3 Further Work and Remarks
",,A$<)$$) #')%$))+
- ( ! ' ), % %$ ( )8%
'#($0')%')('*) ,!
-')'#(')$')-*%
)***($$)(%%'#'*0), +
**$))!;-'*)$
#-)**$**%(')9*
%0* %$ )8%'(%(,$)'#
*()**) $$*%$(%%%
90*)()$)'*)*'%+
%) '#($**% (
)$),%( )$)*
)')<(%$(($'))*(
)0()$'%)) )!(
( !%)#'$)8%%!,%+
)*$ ')),)%+
*) '*#'$, *<
**)%!,%)!,)8%$%$)
5 Systematic Mapping Execution
)*** **$%, $(,)$'#(+
$)9')=**,<,
9(%)$,)$*!,1.23
45467'))'(% )$%'))'#''
!%$,*$ $)'#
0)'# )$*! ' **
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
12
,8% -$-(,()$, $+
($, )$)(%)$'(%,
)$) ! 1.23454 67 !% %$ )
( ))$'%< !')M'MMM
(!(%)((( M'M)$)
%%( MM
References
>C4>5EX@;=U$(('$$
(')$,V*$X"%;
5;5X.44M;#$$,)*0*
$,'#M;9BL
454PM'#($$ M9YC%
454PM-'#($M<$-/
**L+=
454P.23@6U$, )$V.!$*$-/
GJ;45+@K45XI45+EG4;>LM(!%$+
$,'# ') ) )$,M@$( ))
(3'$*%**/6+/B
G"4.;M'**()$($%(
#'$)$:MH%()% + *%%B6+=**L+
L
G"4;CG C45 ; /M$, <M
174,*(!, Z,[*$2$
3>.4.;">.4G%(*( $, +
%-'('$$)*4"4++3-,
C;"X>.CC43M> *!%'#(
$$& >$,)**)M0 )-6**/+
6
C454;M$&)**-M@$()
',+<>; G;+G>+G , *% @* ( !
, **66+B=
;4C>34>U$ )$, )$V-\
;) ;#>).%#)
.23@454P6M$, )$&()(%%) +
$M444#'$$$**/+=
I45+EG4;>GJ;45+@K45;4XGG4;
U$,$$'#'V*$X"%;
9.C>4@.];4G4CC"94CKV40* +
('4$$V*$"&L/+6=BLB6
5;;4;3]5>.;454PX.5C4@=ME +
A$$,$ *')$,),M@B)+
(E $,( , 1E7@
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
RelaTe-DIA: Network of Ontologies– A Systematic Mapping Study and Challenges Comparison
13
