Content uploaded by Arie Kizel
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Arie Kizel on Dec 02, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
#+/ -Ɣ
) .) 0/$*)'/**'!*-/ #$)"*0/
/# #*'*0./$)$.- '
B:G:.#0 ())KB>&$5 '#>GB:-*// ) -"
$)/-*0/$*)
/=:#C@C86HFG6B9G=:1>FH6@EGF
3FGQ?PRGAJCNPCQCLRQMPGEGL?JPCQC?PAFRF?RBGQASQQCQRFCSQCMDB?LACDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC
'MJMA?SQRGL )CUGQF(QP?CJG LMLPCJGEGMSQFGEFQAFMMJ CBSA?RGML 3FCPCQC?PAFNPCQCLRQ ?
GLVFXVVLRQOHGE\VWXGHQWV¶WHDFKHUV¶DQGFKRUHRJUDSKHUV¶FXUUHQWXQGHUVWDQGLQJVRIGDQFH
?Q?LCBSA?RGML?JRMMJDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRGL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ'?QRW
2AFSJRX+'!?PP#)?LB2CJK?L1+&PCCL
3FC'MJMA?SQR F?Q @CCL BCNGARCB GL T?PGMSQDMPKQMDTGQS?J ?PRQ 9CJGXCP 6GCQCJ
#CNGARGMLQMDRFCRMNGABCPGTCDPMKBGDDCPCLRL?PP?RGTCQMDRFC'MJMA?SQRAPC?RCB@W
QSPTGTMPQRFCGPAFGJBPCL?LBRFCDMJJMUGLEECLCP?RGMLQ%CBCPK?LCR?J3FC5GQS?J
?PRQ?LBNCPDMPKGLE?PRQA?LMDDCP?U?WRMCVNPCQQRMPCDJCARSNMLRMNPMRCQR?E?GLQRMPRM
PCQGQRGLBGTGBS?J?LBAMJJCARGTCRP?SK?PCJ?RCBRMRFC'MJMA?SQR/CRXCP QRFC?PRQ
?PC GLAPC?QGLEJW @CGLE SRGJGXCB RM CVNPCQQ CVNCPGCLACQ ?LB RFMSEFRQ PCE?PBGLE RFC
'MJMA?SQROSCQRGMLQ A?LLMU@C P?GQCBPCE?PBGLERFCQNCAGDGASQC MDB?LACGL 'MJMA?SQR
$BSA?RGML!GLE'CGBCAICP'?QRW
3FGQQRSBWU?QN?PRJW NPCQCLRCB?Q ?LMP?JNPCQCLR?RGML ?RRFC LB(LRCPL?RGML?J "MLRCKNMP?PW$BSA?RGML?J
1CQC?PAF"MLEPCQQGL.QUGCAGK/MJ?LB)SJW
4LGTCPQGRWMD'?GD?BG?L?QAFSCK?LLEKVBC
#P4LGTCPQGRWMD'?GD??IGXCJCBSF?GD??AGJ
#P6CQRCPL&?JGJCC"MJJCEC?LB*G@@SRXGK"MJJCECMD$BSA?RGMLFCLG?PMRRCL@CPEB?LACTMGACQAMK
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
QK?JJLSK@CPMDAFMPCMEP?NFCPQDPMK(QP?CJ?LB@CWMLBF?TCBC?JRUGRFRFCRMNGAMDRFC
'MJMA?SQRGLRFCGPQR?EC@?QCB?LBLMLQR?EC@?QCBUMPIQUFGAFBP?UMLRFC?RPGA?J?QUCJJ
?QQMAG?JB?LACQ,GLGQRPWMD $BSA?RGML (QP?CJ 3FC PR #CN?PRKCLR 1MRRCL@CPE
'MUCTCP ?N?SAGRWMDPCQC?PAF CVGQRQ MLRFC QNCAGDGA PMJCMDB?LAC GL 'MJMA?SQR
$BSA?RGML,WPCQC?PAFDGJJQRFGQJ?ASL?@WGLTCQRGE?RGLERFCSQCMDB?LACDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSR
RFC 'MJMA?SQR ?Q ? KCBGSK RF?R LMR MLJW SRGJGXCQ FGQRMPGA?J D?ARQ ?LB HSBEKCLRQ ?@MSR
TGARGKQNCPNCRP?RMPQ@WQR?LBCPQMPPCQGQRMPQ@SRRF?R?JQMCL?@JCQQRSBCLRQRMPCDJCARMLRFC
'MJMA?SQRML ? NCPQML?J?LB CKMRGML?J JCTCJ(RUGJJ ?AFGCTCRFGQRFPMSEF RFC?L?JWQGQMD
GLRCPTGCUQ UGRF QRSBCLRQ ?LB RC?AFCPQ UFM BM LMR F?TC NPGMP CVNCPGCLAC GL RFC DGCJB MD
B?LAC?LBUGRFAFMPCMEP?NFCPQUFMF?TCCVNJMPCBRFC'MJMA?SQRGLRFCGPUMPI4JRGK?RCJW
RFC?GKGQRMCVNJMPCFMUB?LAC ?ARQ?Q?LCK@MBGCBRC?AFGLE RMMJRF?R ?JJMUQQRSBCLRQ
RC?AFCPQ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ?JGICRM CVNJMPCMUL SLBCPQR?LBGLEQMLRFC 'MJMA?SQRRMNGA
?LBRMCLAMSLRCPAMJJCARGTCKCKMPWUFGAFK?WLMR@C?AFGCTCB@WJC?PLGLEDPMKFGQRMPGA?J
D?ARQ?JMLC
- . -# .$")
(L RCPKQ MD KCRFMBMJMEW RFGQ PCQC?PAF BP?UQ ML ? OS?JGR?RGTC CKNGPGA?J ?NNPM?AF RM
GLTCQRGE?RCQRSBCLRQl RC?AFCPQl ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQlNCPACNRGMLQMD RFC 'MJMA?SQR 2CKG
VWUXFWXUHGQDUUDWLYHLQWHUYLHZVGUDZLQJRQ0D\ULQJDQG)UHQ]HO¶VDSSURDFKZHUH
AMLBSARCB UGRF N?PRGAGN?LRQ 3FGQ EPMSN U?Q AMKNPGQCB MD DGTC (QP?CJG QRSBCLRQ DGTC
RC?AFCPQGL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ?LBDGTCAFMPCMEP?NFCPQDPMKRFCGLRCPL?RGML?JDGCJBRFPCC
(QP?CJGQMLC"?L?BG?L?LBMLC&CPK?L
3FC GLRCPTGCUQ UCPC AMLBSARCB GL ?L MNCL DMPK 3FC GLRCPTGCUCCQ MD C?AF EPMSN UCPC
NCPACGTCB?QL?PP?RMPQ ?LB CVNCPRQ MLRFCRMNGA 3FCPCDMPC RFC GLRCPTGCUQUCPCFCJB ?LB
AMLBSARCB ?Q MNCL BGQASQQGMLQ 3FGQ MNCL DMPK ESGBCB RFPMSEF NPCDMPKSJ?RCB K?GL
RFCKCQ?JJMUCBRFCQ?KNJCRMDMPKMNGLGMLQ?LBRMCVNPCQQRFCGPRFMSEFRQSLBCPQR?LBGLEQ
?LBNCPACNRGMLQ QSPPMSLBGLE RFCRMNGA%JGAI !W?JJMUGLERFC GLRCPTGCUCC RM R?JI
DPCCJWRFCKCQ?LBQS@RFCKCQUCPCDMPKCBUGRFAMPPCJ?RGMLQ?LBBGDDCPCLACQ@CRUCCLRFC
GLRCPTGCUQL?RSP?JJWCKCPEGLE
3FC?GKMDRFC PCQC?PAFGQRMBGQAMTCPLCU ?NNPM?AFCQUGRFGL'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML?LB
'MJMA?SQR2RSBGCQDPMKRFCNCPQNCARGTCMDGLBGTGBS?JQ UFM?PCAJMQCRMRFCRMNGA"MFCL
&PMQQ 3FCCKCPECLRNCPQNCARGTCQ?PC@?QCB MLRFC ILMUJCBECRF?RRFCDGL?J
UGRLCQQCQUGJJD?JJQGJCLRGLRFCLC?PDSRSPC?LBRF?RRFCWMSLECPECLCP?RGMLUGJJ@CJCDRUGRF
?LSLBCPQR?LBGLEMDRFCRMNGARF?RGQLMRLCACQQ?PGJWRFCGPMUL&PMQQ
(LRFGQPCQC?PAFB?LACGQNPCQCLRCB?Q?LMLTCP@?JNP?VGQRF?RA?L @CBGDDCPCLRG?RCB DPMK
RFC ASPPCLR ?NNPM?AF RM RC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC 'MJMA?SQR GL (QP?CJG FGEF QAFMMJQ %P?JCGEF
(RGQ FWNMRFCQGXCBRF?R B?LAC KGEFR CL?@JC RFC WMSLECPECLCP?RGMLRMAPC?RCRFCGP
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
MULL?PP?RGTCPCE?PBGLERFC'MJMA?SQR PR"SPPGASJSK,GLGQRPWMD$BSA?RGML(QP?CJ3FC
PR#CN?PRKCLR
-:F:6E8=,H:FG>CBF
3FCAMLBSARCBPCQC?PAFBP?UQRMECRFCPRUMQS@HCARQMDGLOSGPW'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML?LB
#?LAC$BSA?RGML?LBGQESGBCB@WRFCDMJJMUGLEPCQC?PAFOSCQRGML
6F?R ?BT?LR?ECQ ?LB BGQ?BT?LR?ECQ BMCQ B?LAC MDDCP ?Q ? RMMJ DMP RC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC
'MJMA?SQRDPMKRFCNCPQNCARGTCQMDQAFMMJQRSBCLRQRC?AFCPQ?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPQ
3UM QS@OSCQRGMLQ UGJJ ?JQM QF?NC RFC PCQC?PAF 6FGAF MD RFC QCJCARCB B?LACQ ?LB
BGDDCPCLR RWNCQ MD NCPDMPK?LACQ @W RFC NPCQCLRCB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ MDDCP RFC QRSBCLRQ ?L
MNNMPRSLGRWRMPCDJCARMLRFCGPL?PP?RGTCQML?NCPQML?JJCTCJ LBUF?RA?LB?LACDPMK
RFCN?PRGAGN?LRQlNCPQNCARGTCAMLRPG@SRCRM'$GL(QP?CJ
3FCQC OSCQRGMLQ UCPC AFMQCL ?GKGLE RM CL?@JC ? BGQASQQGML ML RFC RMNGA @W QRSBCLRQ
RC?AFCPQ ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ UFGAF BP?UQ ML RFC Q?KNJCQ ILMUJCBEC ML RFC RMNGA GL
AMLLCARGML UGRF RFC ?PR DMPK MD B?LAC (L RFC ACLRPC MD RFCQC OSCQRGMLQ ?PC RFC Q?KNJCQ
SLBCPQR?LBGLEQ ?LB NCPACNRGMLQ AMLACPLGLE RFC RMNGA DMP PCQC?PAFGLE GL BCNRF PCACLR
'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML?LBGRQAMLLCARGMLRMB?LAC
3FC PCQC?PAF U?QAMLBSARCBCVAJSQGTCJW GLQCASJ?PNS@JGA ?LBLMLPCJGEGMSQ (QP?CJGFGEF
QAFMMJQ3FCQ?KNJCAMLQGQRQMLJWMD)CUGQFNSNGJQ?LBBMCQLMRGLAJSBC P?@GA(QP?CJGQ
( /#**'*"4
3FGQ PCQC?PAF SRGJGXCB ? OS?JGR?RGTCCKNGPGA?J PCQC?PAF ?NNPM?AF RM GLTCQRGE?RC QRSBCLRQl
RC?AFCPQl?QUCJJ?QAFMPCMEP?NFCPQlSLBCPQR?LBGLEQMDASPPCLR'$GLLMLPCJGEGMSQ(QP?CJG
QR?RCFGEFQAFMMJQ?LBRFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q?KCRFMBMDRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC2FM?FGLFGQRMPW
AJ?QQCQ(RGLAJSBCQ GLRCPTGCUQUGRF N?PRGAGN?LRQ AMKNPGQGLE DGTC(QP?CJGQRSBCLRQ DGTC
RC?AFCPQMD(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ?QUCJJ?QDGTCAFMPCMEP?NFCPQDPMKRFCGLRCPL?RGML?JDGCJB
%MPRFGQPCQC?PAF(AMLBSARCBQCKGQRPSARSPCBL?PP?RGTCGLRCPTGCUQ,?WPGLE?LB%PCLXCJ
(L!?SP!J?QGSQNN UGRF QRSBCLRQ RC?AFCPQ ?Q UCJJ ?Q AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ UFM
F?TCBC?JRUGRFRFC'MJMA?SQRGLRFCGPQR?EC@?QCBMPLMLQR?EC@?QCBUMPIQUFGAFF?PLCQQ
RFC?RPGA?J?Q UCJJ ?QQMAG?JB?LACQ ?LBBC?JUGRF RFCGP MULTGCUNMGLRQ ML RFCRMNGA 3FC
AFMPCMEP?NFCPQlUMPIQ?LBRFCNPMACQQMDAPC?RGMLUCPCGLRFCDMPCEPMSLBMDRFCGPNGCACQ
P?RFCPRF?LRFCGPL?RGML?JGRGCQ QRFGQPCQC?PAF?GKQRMBGQASQQRFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q?RMMJDMP
RC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQR(AFMQCAFMPCMEP?NFCPQUFMF?TCDMASQCBMLRFCGPNCPQML?J
CKMRGTCSLBCPQR?LBGLE?Q UCJJ ?Q ML RFCGP QRSBCLRQl SLBCPQR?LBGLEQ MD RFC RMNGA GL RFCGP
B?LACNGCACQ?LBUFMQCCIRMAMLTCWSLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?ECQGLRFCGPUMPI3FCPCDMPCGRGQ
KRSHG WKDW WKH FKRUHRJUDSKHUV H[SHULHQFHV DQG RSLQLRQV VXUURXQGLQJWKH GDQFH SLHFHV¶
APC?RGMLA?LAMLRPG@SRCRMRFCBGQASQQGML
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
.6AD@:
3FCQ?KNJCMDRFGQPCQC?PAFAMLQGQRQMDQRSBCLRQDPMK(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ&(QP?CJGFGEF
QAFMMJRC?AFCPQ&?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPQ&DPMK?LGLRCPL?RGML?JDGCJBUFMF?TCBC?JR
UGRF RFC 'MJMA?SQR GL RFCGP QR?EC@?QCB UMPIQ LMLQR?EC@?QCB UMPIQ ?LB B?LAC DGJKQ
RFPMSEFT?PGMSQ NCPDMPK?RGTC ?NNPM?AFCQ QSAF ?Q QMAG?J B?LACQ GKNPMTGQ?RGMLNP?ARGACQ
(QP?CJGRC?AFCPQ?QUCJJ?Q (QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQRSBCLRQUCPCAFMQCL?Q RFCW?PC NCPACGTCB
?QCVNCPRQMLPCACLR'$3FCWBC?JUGRFRFCQS@HCARDGPQRF?LBECRRGLER?SEFRGLRFCA?QCMD
RFCQRSBCLRQ?LBRC?AFGLERFCRMNGAGLRFCA?QCMDRFCRC?AFCPQ(LRMR?JGLRCPTGCUQUCPC
AMLBSARCBGLMPBCPRMAMKNJCRCRFGQOS?JGR?RGTCCKNGPGA?JPCQC?PAFDGTCGLRCPTGCUQGLC?AF
MD RFC Q?KNJCQ EPMSNQ 3FC GLRCPTGCUCB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ ?PC GLTMJTCB GL '$ GLQGBC ?LB
MSRQGBCMD(QP?CJMPF?TC?RJC?QRILMUJCBECMD'$GL(QP?CJ
2RSBCLRQ&
%MPRFGQPCQC?PAF (QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQRSBCLRQ?ECBUCPCAFMQCL?QN?PRGAGN?LRQ GL
MPBCPRMJC?PL ?@MSR RFCGP SLBCPQR?LBGLEQ MD ASPPCLR '$ GL FGEF QAFMMJ CBSA?RGML?LBRM
BGQASQQRFC SQCMDB?LAC #$DMPRC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC'MJMA?SQR UGRFGL RFCDP?KCUMPIMD
DMPK?JFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML3UMDCK?JC?LBRFPCCK?JCQRSBCLRQN?PRGAGN?RCB2GLACRFC
SLCTCLP?RGMMDECLBCPU?QLMRGLRCLRGML?J?L?L?JWQGQMPGLRCPNPCR?RGMLMD?ACPR?GLECLBCP
NCPQNCARGTC BGB LMR R?IC NJ?AC & GQ ? FMKMECLCMSQ EPMSN UGRFGL RFC Q?KNJC JJ RFC
QRSBCLRQUFMN?PRGAGN?RCBGLRFGQPCQC?PAFUCPC@MPL?LBP?GQCBGL(QP?CJ?LB?PC)CUGQF
3C?AFCPQ&
(LRFGQPCQC?PAFDGTCRC?AFCPQN?PRGAGN?RCB?LBQF?PCBRFCGPSLBCPQR?LBGLEQMDASPPCLR2$GL
(QP?CJ3UM DCK?JC ?LB RFPCC K?JCRC?AFCPQUCPCGLRCPTGCUCB 3FC EPMSN &U?QGL RFGQ
QCLQCFMKMECLCMSQ?Q?JJGLRCPTGCUCCQUCPC(QP?CJGQ?LB)CUGQF@MPL?LBP?GQCBGL(QP?CJ
3FC?ECP?LECMDRFGQEPMSNU?QUGBCWC?PQMJB?Q(UGQFCBRME?GLRFCMNGLGMLQ?LB
SLBCPQR?LBGLEQMDRC?AFCPQMDBGDDCPCLR?ECQ?LBECLCP?RGMLQRFCQCAMLB?QUCJJ?QRFCRFGPB
ECLCP?RGMLMD'MJMA?SQRQSPTGTMPQ3FCPCDMPC(BGBLMRJGKGRRFC?ECP?LEC
"FMPCMEP?NFCPQ&
QNPCTGMSQJWKCLRGMLCB LMR K?LW AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ F?TCBC?JRUGRFRFC 'MJMA?SQR RMNGA
RFPMSEFB?LAC3FCPCDMPC(PC?AFCBMSRRMAFMPCMEP?NFCPQUFMF?TCDMASQCBML?LCKMRGTC
SLBCPQR?LBGLEMDRFCRMNGAP?RFCPRF?L?L?RRCKNRRMBC?JUGRFFGQRMPGA?JD?ARQ3FCDMASQML
?LCKMRGTCSLBCPQR?LBGLEU?Q?APGRCPGMLDMP& ECRRGLEGLAJSBCBGLRFGQPCQC?PAF#?LAC
NGCACQUFGAF BM LMRDMASQQNCAGDGA?JJWML ? FGQRMPGA?JPCNPCQCLR?RGMLMDRFC CTCLRQ MDRFC
2FM?F@SR P?RFCPMLQS@HCARGTC MNGLGMLQ?LB?QQMAG?RGMLQ RMRFCRMNGA ?PCGLRFGQ PCQC?PAF
NCPACGTCB?Q F?TGLE ?L CKMRGTCDMASQ3FGQ EPMSN UGRFGLRFC Q?KNJC GQ SLJGIC& MP &
FCRCPMECLCMSQ-MR?JJMDRFC&Q?KNJCUCPC(QP?CJGQ?LBLMR?JJUCPC)CUGQF2GLACGLRFC
DMPCEPMSLBMDKWGLOSGPW?PCRFCGP?PRUMPIQRFCGPKMRGDQ?LB?NNPM?AFCQBGDDCPCLRRWNCQ
MDNCPDMPK?LACQ ?LB NCPACNRGMLQ GRU?QKMPC GKNMPR?LR RMR?JIRM RFCK ?QNPMDCQQGML?JQ
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
UGRFGLRFCDGCJBMDB?LACGLMPBCP RMBGQASQQ UFCRFCPRFCWNCPACGTCB?LAC?Q?KCBGSKRM
RC?AF?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRGL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML
#*'*0./ 0/$*)$)$.- '
,Q RUGHU WR LQYHVWLJDWH WHDFKHUV¶ VWXGHQWV¶ DQG FKRUHRJUDSKHUV¶ XQGHUVWDQGLQJV RI
'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGMLGL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJ CBSA?RGML?Q ?DGPQR QRCN( RMMIU?Q RMPCTGCU
PCACLR QAFMJ?PQFGN ML RFC RMNGA 3FC DMASQ MD RFGQ PCTGCUGQ RFC BCTCJMNKCLR ?LB
CQR?@JGQFKCLR MD 'MJMA?SQR $BSA?RGML GL (QP?CJ UGRF PCDCPCLAC RM GRQ FGQRMPW ?LB RFC
ASPPGASJ?RF?R CKCPECBBSPGLERFCNCPGMBDPMK RMRFC NPCQCLRB?WDMPSQCGL FGQRMPW
AJ?QQCQ AAMPBGLERM2F?K?G8?PBCLG?LB*J?ECQ?T?PGCRWMDQRSBGCQAMLACPLGLE
RFC?RRGRSBCMD(QP?CJGWMSRFQRMU?PBQRFC'MJMA?SQRF?TC@CCLAMLBSARCBMTCPRFCJ?QRDMSP
BCA?BCQ2F?K?G 8?PBCLG*J?ECQ N (LRFCDMJJMUGLE?@PGCD TCPQGMLMDRFGQ
PCTGCU UGJJ @C NPCQCLRCB 6FGJQR "MFCL @CEGLQ GL RFC WC?P &PMQQ
GLYLGHVWKHKLVWRULRJUDSK\RIWKHWRSLFLQWRPRUHSHULRGV:LWKUHIHUHQFHWR'URU¶V
ZRUN *URVV SRVLWV ³ LQ VRPH RI WKH /DERU PRYHPHQW VFFMMJQ 'MJMA?SQR $BSA?RGML
EHJDQLQ´*URVVS
(LRFGQ PCQC?PAF ( F?TC RGRJCB RFCNCPGMBQ?AAMPBGLERM"MFCLlQDGLBGLEQ?Q RFCQC ?PC RFC
KMQRPCACLRMLCQUGRFGLRFC?T?GJ?@JCQAFMJ?PQFGN'MUCTCP(UGJJPCDCP?JQMRM RFCQR?ECQ
GBCLRGDGCB@WRFC&PMQQ%GPCP2AF?RXICP?LB/MP?R
Q"MFCLN?QQCPRQ
3FCU?WGLUFGAFRFC2FM?FF?Q@CCLR?SEFR?RBGDDCPCLRRGKCQGL(QP?CJGQR?RCQAFMMJQGQ?L
?AASP?RC@?PMKCRCPMDL?RGML?JDCCJGLEMLRFCQS@HCAR"F?LECQGLCBSA?RGMLGRQCJDL?KCJW
DWUHQGWRZDUGVJUHDWHUHPSKDVLVRQH[SHULHQWLDODQGLQIRUPDODFWLYLWLHVDIIHFWLQJVWXGHQWV¶
CKMRGMLQGBCLRGRW?LBT?JSCQF?TC?JRCPCBRFCU?WRFC2FM?FGQR?SEFRGL(QP?CJGQAFMMJQ
3FCFGQRMPGA?J?AAMSLRQCRQRFCQR?ECDMPRFCBGQASQQGMLMDRFCQGRS?RGMLRMB?W
(LRFGQJGRCP?RSPCPCTGCURFC?@MTCNPCQCLRCB?AAMSLRMD'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGMLGL(QP?CJUGJJ
@CRFCK?GLDMASQ?LBN?PRGASJ?PJWRFCLMU?B?WQQGRS?RGMLML'$
(L(QP?CJ RFCRMNGAMD RFC'MJMA?SQRGQ R?SEFRGLRUMU?WQ GRFPMSEFDMPK?J CBSA?RGML
UFGAF R?ICQ NJ?AC GL DMPK?J GLQRGRSRGMLQ QSAF ?Q IGLBCPE?PRCLQ NPGK?PW QAFMMJQ KGBBJC
QAFMMJQ ?LB FGEF QAFMMJQ ?LB GG RFPMSEF KMPC GLDMPK?J CBSA?RGML?J N?RFU?WQUFGAF
GLAJSBC WMSRF KMTCKCLRQ RFC QAMSRQ CVRP?ASPPGASJ?P ?ARGTGRGCQ NS@JGA KCBG? ?LB
RCJCTGQGMLNPMEP?KQ"MFCLN
,W PCQC?PAF ?Q QR?RCB@ CDMPCCVAJSQGTCJ WDMASQCQ ML RFC DMPK?J GLQRGRSRGML?J QWQRCK MD
'MJMA?SQR $BSA?RGML GL (QP?CJG FGEF QAFMMJQ UFGAF GQ ?NNPMNPG?RC RM RFC QAMNC MD RFGQ
PCQC?PAF
#*'*0./ 0/$*)# $)$.- '$.// .#**'.
3FCDGCJB MD'$GL (QP?CJF?Q @CCL SLBCPEMGLEAMLRGLS?JAF?LECQ QGLACGRQ CQR?@JGQFKCLR
3FCASPPGASJSK F?Q AF?LECBQGELGDGA?LRJWUGRFGL RFC J?QRWC?PQ &PMQQNN
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
AAMPBGLERM"MFCL RFCQC AF?LECQ?PCAMLLCARCB RM AF?LECQUGRFGLRFC (QP?CJGL?PP?RGTC
QSPPMSLBGLE RFC CTCLRQ MD RFC 2FM?F ?LB RFC U?W RFC RMNGA GQ NCPACGTCB UGRFGL QMAGCRW
"MFCL N 3FC QCLQGRGTC RMNGA MD RFC 'MJMA?SQR U?Q ?AAMPBGLE RM 2F?K?G
8?PBCGLGDQG.ODJHV D ³PHDQLQJIXOIDFWRU´ LQWKHFUHDWLRQRIWKHQHZ-HZLVKDQG
(QP?CJG(BCLRGRW?DRCP66((2F?K?G8?PBCLG?LB*J?ECQN"MFCLNN
BGTGBCQ RFCFGQRMPW MD 2$ GLRM DGTC QR?ECQ ?Q NPCTGMSQJW BGQASQQCB 3FC D GPQR
QR?EC 2R?RC@SGJBGLE 3FC QCAMLB QR?EC U?PCLCQQ ?DRCP
$GAFK?LL3FCRFGPBQR?EC%PMK6?PRM/MJGRGA?J3SPLMTCP3FCDMSPRF
QR?EC ± SLGDWGLE RFCKC GL DP?EKCLRCB RGKCQ 3FC LCVR QR?EC 2FM?F
CBSA?RGML?RRFCRSPLMDRFCRFGPBKGJJCLLGSK
(LAMKN?PGQML &PMQQ GBCLRGDGCQKMPC NCPGMBQ (LRFCDMJJMUGLE? @PGCDFGQRMPWMD
'$ ?LB GRQ CQR?@JGQFKCLR ?Q ? QAFMMJ QS@HCAR UGJJ @C NPCQCLRCB ?JMLEQGBC "MFCL>Q DGTC
QR?ECQ3FCUMPI MD MRFCP QAFMJ?PQ QSAF ?Q &PMQQ /MP?R2F?NGP?2AF?RXICP,GAFK?L
%GPCP?LB.DCPUGJJ?JQM@CBP?ULSNMLRMAMLRCVRS?JGXCKWBGQASQQGML
- )/.#*'-.#$+*)/# /*+$*!#*'*0./ 0/$*) $)
$.- '$#$"#.#**'.
&RKHQµV ³,GHQWLW\ DQG 3HGDJRJ\ ± 2FM?F $BXFDWLRQ LQ ,VUDHOL 6WDWH 6FKRROV´
NPCQCLRQPCQC?PAFMLFMURFC2FM?FGQASPPCLRJWR?SEFRGL (QP?CJ"MFCLBCQAPG@CQ'$?Q?
³PXOWLGLPHQVLRQDO SHGDJRJ\´ WDXJKW WKURXJK D GLYHUVH DQG ZLGH UDQJH RI PHWKRGV
?NNPM?AFCQ ?LB K?RCPG?JQ "MFCL N 'C ?QQCPRQ RF?R (QP?CJG RCCL?ECPQ ?LB
AFGJBPCL KGEFR @C CVNMQCB RM RFC 2FM?F GL BGTCPQC U?WQ @MRF DMPK?JJW ?LB GLDMPK?JJW
&RKHQS2YHUWKUHHTXDUWHUVRIWKHVWXGHQWVLQ&RKHQ¶VVWXG\OLVWHQHG
RMRFCRCQRGKMLGCQMDQSPTGTMPQ?RRCLBCBNCPDMPK?LACQ?LBGLQRGRSRGMLQRF?RAMKKCKMP?RC
RFC 2FM?F "MFCL N -CTCPRFCJCQQ RFC GLDMPK?J ?NNPM?AF GQ LMR RFC KMQR
AMKKMLMLC3FCK?HMPGRWMDQRSBCLRQBMLMRF?TC'MJMA?SQRQSPTGTMPQUGRFGLRFCGPD?KGJW
?LBBMLMRBGQASQQMPBC?JZLWKWKLVWRSLFLQWKHLU RZQKRPHV ,Q&RKHQ¶VLQWHUYLHZVWKH
QRSBCLRQUCPC?QICB?@MSR?ARGTGRGCQGLRFCGPD?KGJGCQQAFMMJQ?LBWMSRFKMTCKCLRQ3FC
K?HMPGRWMDRFCQRSBCLRQF?BN?PRGAGN?RCBGL?8MK'?2FM?FACPCKMLW.TCPRFPCC
OS?PRCPQMDRFCQRSBCLRQJGQRCLCBRMRFCRCQRGKMLGCQMDQSPTGTMPQ?RRCLBCBNCPDMPK?LACQ?LB
GLQRGRSRGMLQ RF?R AMKKCKMP?RC RFC 2FM?F G@GB N "MFCL ?RRCQRQ RF?R QRSBCLRQ ?PC
GLAPC?QGLEJW CVNMQCB RM RFC QS@HCAR ?Q RFCW NPMEPCQQ RFPMSEF @MRF DMPK?J ?LB GLDMPK?J
CBSFDWLRQDOV\VWHPV&RKHQ¶V UHVHDUFKVXJJHVWVWKDW WKJUDGHUVKDYHDKLJKHUGHJUHHRI
,C?LRMPRFC?RPGA?JB?LACNCPDMPK?LACQNPCQCLRCBGLRFCDP?KCUMPIMD8MK'?2FM?F
AAMPBGLERM"MFCLRFCQCNCPDMPK?LACQ?PCLMR@?QCBMLQGKSJ?RGLEPMJCNJ?WQ"MFCLN
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
CVNMQSPC RM RFGQ QS@HCAR RF?L WMSLECP EP?BCQ $TCL RFMSEF LMR CTCPW (QP?CJG QRSBCLR GQ
AMLLCARCBUGRFRFC2FM?FRFPMSEFD?KGJWFGQRMPWQRSBCLRQ?PCFGEFJWCVNMQCBRMRFCRMNGA
?QRFCWECRMJBCPCQNCAG?JJWRFPMSEF8MK'?2FM?F
8CRRFCDMJJMUGLEOSCQRGMLQPCK?GL #MCQ?L GLAPC?QCBCVNMQSPC ?JQMKC?L ?LGLAPC?QCB
CKMRGTCAMLLCARGML RMRFC RMNGA"?LQRSBCLRQ CKMRGTCJWAMLLCAR RMRFCRMNGAML? B?GJW
@?QCCTCLRFMSEFRFCWF?TCLMD?KGJWAMLLCARGMLRMRFCRMNGA?LBGDQMUF?RGQ RFC@?QGQ
DMPRFGQAMLLCARGML
'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML?LB(QP?CJG(BCLRGRW
*J?P2AFMPG$W?J?LB*J?PPCDCPRMRFCMKLGNPCQCLACMDRFC'MJMA?SQRUGRFGL(QP?CJG
VRFLHW\LQWKHDUWLFOH³7KH³1HYHU$JDLQ³6WDWHRI,VUDHO7KH(PHUJHQFHRIWKH+RORFDXVW
DVD &RUH )HDWXUHRI,VUDHOL,GHQWLW\ DQGLWV)RXU ,QFRQJUXHQW 9RLFHV³ 3FC?SRFMPQ@?QC
WKHLULQYHVWLJDWLRQRQIRXU³SRZHUIXODQGIUHTXHQWO\FRQIOLFWLQJ³YRLFHVWKDWUHIOHFWKRZWKH
(QP?CJG L?PP?WLYH KDV FKDQJHG IURP ³ZKDW ,VUDHOLQHVV LV QRW´ LQWR ³RQH RI WKH FRUH
HOHPHQWVRI,VUDHOLLGHQWLW\³.ODU6FKRUL$W?J?LB*J?PN(LQNGPCB@W!?SCP
WKHUHVHDUFKHUVKLJKOLJKWWKHLPSHUDWLYHRIWKH³1HYHUDJDLQ³QDUUDWLYHLQUHODWGMLRM
RFCRMNGAMD RFC 'MJMA?SQR UFGAF RFCWQCC ?Q BCPGTGLE DPMK DMSP AMLDJGARGLE TMGACQ
-CTCP @C ? N?QQGTC TGARGK LCTCP DMPQ?IC WMSP @PMRFCPQ LCTCP @C ?N?QQGTC
@WQR?LBCP?LBLCTCP@C?NCPNCRP?RMP3FCGPEM?JGQRMQFMUFMURFCNPCQCLRCBTMGACQ
F?TCF?B?LGKN?ARMLAMLRCKNMP?PW(QP?CJGJGDC G@GB$VRCLBGLE*J?P2AFMPG$T?J?LB
.ODU¶VZRUN'RQ<HKL\DDQG/LHEPDQ ZHUH WKH ILUVW WR KLJKOLJKW ³WKH
ACLRP?JGRWMDRFC'MJMA?SQR ?QRFC NPGK?PWNMJGRGA?J KWRFMD (QP?CJGQMAGCRWRFCQWK@MJMD
,VUDHO¶VSUHVHQWFRQGLWLRQ DQGWKHRQHZKLFKSURYLGHV,VUDHOZLWKOHJLWLPDF\DQGWKHULJKW
WRLWVODQG³'RQ8CFGW??LB+GC@K?LAGRCBGLG@GBN
%PMK RFCQC RFCMPGX?RGMLQ GR AMSJB @C ?QQCPRCB RF?R RFC CKMRGTC AMLLCARGML RM RFC RMNGA
BCPGTCQDPMK?AMKKMLQMAGCR?JNCPACNRGML?LBL?RGML?JSLBCPQR?LBGLEUFGAFGQNCPDMPKCB
?Q? AMKKML L?RGML?JGBCLRGRWRFC CTCLRQMDRFC 'MJMA?SQR?PCTGCUCB?Q N?PRMD)CUGQF
GBCLRGRW
3FC/SPNMQCQ&M?JQ?LB#GJCKK?QMD'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGMLGLRFCQRACLRSPW
*URVV¶VDUWLFOH³+RORFDXVWHGXFDWLRQLQ-HZLVKVFKRROVLQ,VUDHO*RDOVGLOHPPDV
FKDOOHQJHV³SUHVHQWVWKH+RORFDXVWDVD³SULPDU\FRPSRQHQWRI-HZLVKLGHQWLW\³*URVV
S *URVV DVNV WKH IROORZLQJ TXHVWLRQ ³+RZ ZH NQRZ ZKDW ZH NQRZ"´
UFGAFQFCCVNJMPCQGLPCJ?RGMLRMRFCJGRCP?RSPCMLILMUJCBEC2FCNPCQCLRQRUM?NNPM?AFCQ
RM?L?JWXGLEILMUJCBEC@?QCBQWQRCKQRFCMLRMJMEGA?JJCTCJ?LBRFCCNGQRCKMJMEGA?JJCTCJ
$FFRUGLQJWR *URVVDSSO\LQJWKH ³RQWRORJLFDOHSLVWHPRORJLFDO D[HV³DOORZVXV WRGHILQH
DMSPBGDDCPCLRQR?ECQUGRFGL?RRGRSBCQRMU?PBQ'$?LBRFC'MJMA?SQR3FCMLRMJMEGA?JJCTCJ
LQLWLDO OHYHO RIIHUV TXHVWLRQV UHODWHG WR FRQWHQW DQG VWUXFWXUH VXFK DV ³:KDW ZDV WKH
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
+RORFDXVW":KDWZHUHLWVFKDUDFWHULVWLFV"³LELGS7KLVOHYHOFDQEHIXUWKHUGLYLGHG
GLRMRUM QR?ECQ RFCQR?ECMD NS@JGA BCLG?J?LBRFC QR?EC MDNS@JGA?AILMUJCBEKCLR3FC
HSLVWHPRORJLFDO OHYHO DGGUHVVHV NQRZOHGJH DERXW WKH +RORFDXVW ³:KDW FRXQWV DV
ILMUJCBECMDRFC'MJMA?SQR6F?RIGLBMDILMUJCBECGQ?T?GJ?@JCRMSQ?LBUF?R?PCRFC
@MSLB?ULHV RI WKLV NQRZOHGJH"³ LELG *URVV GLYLGHV WKLV VHFRQG OHYHO LQWR WZR VWDJHV
&RQVWUXFWLQJNQRZOHGJHDQGWKHQGHFRQVWUXFWLQJLWDQG³UHYLVLWLQJWKH+RORFDXVW³LQRUGHU
WR SHUIRUP D FULWLFDO DQDO\VLV*URVV GHVFULEHV KRZ +RORFDXVW HGXFDWLRQ KDV ³JUDSSOHG³
DPMKGRQ GLACNRGML UGRF@MRFMLRMJMEW?LB CNGQRCKMJMEWG@GB AAMPBGLERM FCP ?LBGL
AMKN?PGQMLRM"MFCLRFCPC?PCDMSPQR?ECQ?/S@JGA PCHCARGML ±@
/S@JGA PCAMELGRGML ± A "MLQRPSARGML ± B #CAMLQRPSARGML ±
NPCQCLRG@GBNN
,CKMPWMDRFC'MJMA?SQRUGRFGL'$GLAMLRCKNMP?PW(QP?CJ
&PMQQ BCQAPG@CQ ? QSPTCWRF?RU?Q AMLBSARCB @W"MFCL UFGAF DMSLB RF?R
MDRFCNPGLAGN?JQ?LBMDRFCRC?AFCPQGL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQQF?PCBRFCDCCJGLEMD
?AMKKMLD?RCUGRFRFCCLRGPC)CUGQFL?RGML?LBNCPACGTCBRFGQ?Q?LGKNMPR?LREM?JMD'$
.SRMDRFCQRSBCLRQRF?R"MFCLGLAJSBCBGLRFGQPCQC?PAFGBCLRGDGCBUGRFRFCEM?J
MD)CUGQFQMJGB?PGRWUFGJCUCPCAMKKGRRCBRMNPCQCPTGLERFCKCKMPWMDRFC'MJMA?SQR
BCQAPG@CB RFC UGQFRMJC?PL KMPC?@MSRGR ?LBPCDCPPCB RM RFCAMLRCLRMD 2$?Q
³LQVSLULQJ³RIWKHSDUWLFLSDQWVSHUFHLYHGWKHWRSLFDVUHOHYDQWWRWKHLURZQOLYHV$VD
PCQC?PAFPCQSJR"MFCLBGBLMRDGLBBGDDCPCLFHVLQWKHVWXGHQWV¶UHVSRQVHVUHJDUGOHVVRWKHLU
CRFLGAMPGEGLPCJGEGMLMPRFCGPECLBCP&PMQQN
(LD?AR&PMQQ?QQCPRQRF?R'$F?QAF?LECBGL?QGELGDGA?LRU?WGLRFC2R?RCMD(QP?CJ3FCQC
AF?LECQF?TC@CCLA?SQCB@WQMAGMJMEGA?JNMJGRGA?J?LBFGQRMPGA?J?QNCARQ?QNPCQCLRCB
SUHYLRXVO\*URVVDFNQRZOHGJHVWKHVLJQLILFDQWFKDQJHIURPD³KLJKO\VWUXFWXUHGXQLIRUP
DSSURDFKWRD PRUHSOXUDOLVWLFRQHWKDWDFNQRZOHGJHVGLYHUVHYRLFHV DQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQV´
7KHGHVFULEHGVHQVHRID ³FRPPRQIDWH´VKDSHVDQHPRWLYH FRQQHFWLRQWRZDUGVWKHWRSLF
MDRFC'MJMA?SQRCTCL RFMSEFLMR CTCPWQRSBCLR GQAMLLCARCB RMRFC RMNGARFPMSEF D?KGJW
KLVWRU\ :KHQ UHIHUULQJ WR 2IHU¶V E WHUPLQRORJ\ WKH DXWKRU H[SODLQV WKDW 6( KDV
KMTCBDPMKQRSBGCQ@?QCBPDLQO\RQµµPHPRU\¶¶DQGDKHURLFDSSURDFKWR VWXGLHVEDVHG
RQKLVWRULFDOIDFWV 7KHVHLQYROYH FULWLFDOWKLQNLQJDQG³UHTXLUHµPDVWHU\RIGLVFLSOLQDU\
NQRZOHGJH¶¶DVZHOODVWKHDELOLW\WRIROORZµµWKHUXOHVRIVFKRODUVKLS¶¶³LELGS
8CRGRGQGKNMPR?LRRMCV?KGLCRFCCDDCARQMDRFCGLTMJTCBAPGRGA?JRFGLIGLEMLQRSBCLRQ?LB
RFCGPQCLQCMD?AMKKMLL?RGML?JGBCLRGRW
*URVVFRQFOXGHVWKDWWKHDSSURDFKFKDQJHGIURP³DFROOHFWLYHRULHQWDWLRQWRDQLQGLYLGXDO
MLC DPMK ? KMPC N?PRGASJ?PGQRGA TGCU RM ? KMPC SLGTCPQ?JGQRGA MLC ?LB DPMK ? KMPC
VWUXFWXUHGHGXFDWLRQDODJHQGDWRD PRUHSHUVRQDOL]HGRQH³*URVV S7RKHU
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
WKH WUDQVLWLRQ IURP WKH RQWRORJLFDO WR WKH HSLVWHPRORJLFDO SKDVH UHIOHFWV ³WKH PRVW
PHDQLQJIXOFKDQJHV³LELG
8CR(OSCQRGMLUFCRFCPRFCPCGQ?LGLBGTGBS?JMPGCLR?RGMLDPMKRFCNCPQNCARGTCMDRC?AFCPQ
?LBQRSBCLRQ?LBUFCRFCPRFCDMASQGQML?AMKKMLL?RGML?J)CUGQFGBCLRGRWP?RFCPRF?LML
?L GLBGTGBS?J CKMRGTC SLBCPQR?LBGLE (LBCCB ( ?QQCPR RF?R RFGQ NMQGRGML GQ KGQQGLE DPMK
KSAFMD RFCQAFMJ?PQFGN ML'$@?QCB ML KWPCTGCUMDRFC K?GL QAFMJ?PQFGN?LBPCACLR
RC?AFGLE?NNPM?AFCQ6GRFRFGQNMGLRGLKGLBRFCDMJJMUGLEOSCQRGMLQA?L@C?QICB
(QRFCGLBGTGBS?J?NNPM?AFRMRFCRMNGACKNF?QGXCBUGRFGL'MJMA?SQR2RSBGCQGL(QP?CJGFGEF
QAFMMJCBSA?RGMLMPUGBCJWKGQQGLEUGRFGLPCACLRRC?AFGLE?NNPM?AFCQ(QRFCPC? UGQFRM
DMASQMLRFCGLBGTGBS?JNCPQNCARGTCRMU?PBQRFC'MJMA?SQRGL'$MPGQGRR?SEFRUGRFRFC?GK
MD RC?AFGLE ?@MSR FGQRMPGA?J D?ARQ ?LB RM NPMKMRC ? AMLRGLSSK MD ? AMKKML L?RGML?J
GBCLRGRW
3FC/MJ?LB3PGNQ
,Q WKH (VVD\ ³0DUNLQJ WKH %RXQGDULHV RI WKH (QFODYH 'HILQLQJ WKH ,VUDHOL &ROOHFWLYH
WKURXJKWKH3RODQG([SHULHQFH´)HOGPDQIRFXVHV RQWKH IUDPHZRUNRIWKH ³ULWXDO
YLVLWV´RI,VUDHOLFGEFQAFMMJQRSBCLRQRM/MJ?LB3FCCQQ?WQR?PRQUGRFRFC'MJMA?SQR
,CKMPG?J #?W ?LB ? QNCCAF @WRFC,GLGQRCP MD $BSA?RGML +GKMP +GTL?R AAMPBGLERM
%CJBK?LRFGQQNCCAFMDDCPQ
?NPCQAPGNRGMLDMP(QP?CJG'MJMA?SQRKCKMPWGLECLCP?J?LBDMPRFCTGQGRQ@W(QP?CJGWMSRF
RMRFCBC?RFA?KNQGL/MJ?LBGLN?PRGASJ?P3FCM@HCARGTCMDRFCQCTGQGRQGQRMGK@SCQRSBCLRQ
UGRFCVNCPGCLACQRF?RUGJJK?ICRFGQTGCUMDRFCUMPJBNJ?SQG@JCRF?RRFC'MJMA?SQRLCTCP
PC?JJWCLBCB?LBRF?R @SR DMP RFC 2R?RC ?LB GRQ BCDCLQC DMPACQ RFC )CUQ GL (QP?CJ UMSJB
RMB?W@CMLRFCGPU?WRMRFCE?QAF?K@CPQ%CJBK?LN
AAMPBGLE RM %CJBK?L MTCP (QP?CJG RCCL?ECPQ F?TC N?PRGAGN?RCB GL RFC RMSPQ RM
/MJ?LBQGLACRFCQRFPMSEFQAFMMJTGQGRQDMPK?JCBSA?RGMLWMSRFKMTCKCLRQMPMRFCP
MPE?LGX?RGMLQGLDMPK?JCBSA?RGML%CJBK?LPCDCPCLACQ+GC@K?L?LB#ML<HKL\D¶VZRUN
ZKLFKGHILQHVWKRVHWULSVDVDIRUPRI³FLYLOUHOLJLRQ´G@GBN"GTGJPCJGEGMLF?QRFPCC
DMPKQ GLRCEP?RGML JCEGRGKGX?RGML ?LB KM@GJGX?RGML G@GB "GTGJ PCJGEGML GQ
?AAMPBGLERM+GC@K?L?LB#ML8CFGW?RP?LQKGRRCBRFPMSEFRFCCBSA?RGML?JQWQRCK
?QUCJJ?QRFPMSEFKMPCGLDMPK?JN?RFU?WQG@GB(L/MJ?LBQRSBCLRQCVNCPGCLACRFCN?QR
RQD³ERGLO\´OHYHOWKPMSEFNFWQGA?JJWTGQGRGLERFCQGRCQG@GB3FGQ N?QRGQ?AAMPBGLERM
%CJBK?LCKNF?QGXCB?QN?PRMDLMRMLJWRFCGPGLBGTGBS?JGBCLRGRW@SR ?Q ?LMTCP?PAFGLE
L?RGML?JL?PP?RGTC%CJBK?LRFCPCDMPCDMASQCQMLRFCOSCQRGMLMDFMURFCL?PP?RGTCMD(QP?CJG
GBCLRGRWGQBCDGLCBRFPMSEF CVNCPGCLACQ GL /MJ?LB 2FC QCCQ RFGQ ?Q @CGLE ? PCQSJR MD RFC
GLYLVLRQ EHWZHHQ ³WKHP´ 1RQ,VUDHOLV DQG ³XV´ ,VUDHOLV 7KH 3RODQG H[SHULHQFH LWV
DP?KCUMPI ?Q UCJJ ?Q GRQQRPSARSPC ?PC DPMK %CJBK?LQ NMGLR MD TGCU QMKCRFGLE UFGAF
'RXJODV'RXJODV FLWHGLQ)HOGPDQSFDOOVDQ³HQFODYH´³«DVRFLDO
SLGRUFGAFPCE?PBGLEK?GLR?GLQ?QRPMLE@MSLB?PW@SR SLJGICRFC FGCP?PAFWGRRCLBQRM@C
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
HJDOLWDULDQDQGVRWRKDYHDZHDNO\DUWLFXODWHGVRFLDOVWUXFWXUH´LELG"MFCL?QUCJJ?Q
%CJBK?L NMGLR MSR RFC QGELGDGA?LAC MD GLBGTGBS?J GBCLRGRW ?LB QRPGIC ? @?J?LAC @CRUCCL
VKDSLQJDFRPPRQ QDWLRQDO LGHQWLW\ DQG SXWWLQJDQHPSKDVLVRQ WKH VWXGHQWV¶ HPRWLRQV
$KMRGMLQ ?PC GLBGTGBS?J ?LB CTCPW QRSBCLR KGEFR F?TC BGDDCPCLR MLCQ RFC RMNGA MD RFC
'MJMA?SQR
-MP?PCDCPQRM'?J@U?AFQQR?RGLE RFCPC?PC K?LWKCKMPGCQ AMLACPLGLERFC
RMNGA8CRKCKMPWGQKSJRGNJC?LBQNCAGDGAGLAMJJCARGTCNJSP?J?LBGLBGTGBS?JDMPK-MP?
N ,CKMPGCQ ?PC AMLLCARCB RM CKMRGMLQ ?LB GL A?QC MD '2 FGQRMPW RFCPC GQ ?
AMLLCARGMLRMGLBGTGBS?J CKMRGMLQ UFGAF LCCBQ RM ECR CVNJMPCB "MFCL %CJBK?L
5RWKEHUJ UHIHUV WR WKH +RORFDXVW DV DQ ³DUFKHW\SDO WRSLF LQ PHPRU\ VWXGLHV³
1MRF@CPEN
3FC PCTGCU BCKMLQRP?RCB RF?R RFCPC ?PC RFPCC K?GL CJCKCLRQ UGRFGL AMLRCKNMP?PW
'MJMA?SQR $BSA?RGML GL (QP?CJG FGEF QAFMMJQ %GPQRJW AMKKCKMP?RGML ?LB PCKCK@P?LAC
R?ICQNJ?ACTG?8MK'?2FM?FACPCKMLGCQK?GLJWRFPMSEFRFC?RPCMPB?LACNCPDMPK?LACQ
2CAMLBJW QRSBCLRQ ?PC NPMTGBCB UGRF FGQRMPW JCQQMLQ UFGAF CL?@JC RFCK RM M@R?GL
ILMUJCBECMLRFC'MJMA?SQR?LBML)CUGQFFGQRMPWKMPC@PM?BJW3FGPBJWQRSBCLRQCLE?EC
UGRF RFC 'MJMA?SQR RFPMSEF APGRGA?J RFGLIGLE ?LB GLBGTGBS?J PCDJCARGML ML RFC RMNGA
)HOGPDQ¶VZRPI QFMUCBFMU'$ F?QSLBCPJWGLEEM?JQ UFGAF?AAMPBGLERM &PMQQF?TC
QF?NCB)CUGQFL?RGML?J?LBGLBGTGBS?JGBCLRGRW?LBKCKMPW&PMQQNCPACGTCQRFCQFGDRDPMK
?AMJJCARGTCMPGCLR?RGMLRM?LGLBGTGBS?JMLC?Q?K?HMPAF?LECUGRFGL'$
3FC DMJJMUGLE AF?NRCP PCTGCUQ RFC RMNGA MD #?LAC $BSA?RGML #$ GL RFC (QP?CJG DMPK?J
QAFMMJQWQRCK(LRFGQPCQC?PAFRFCDMASQGQ CVAJSQGTCJWML#$?Q?L?QNCARMDFGEFQAFMMJ
CBSA?RGML?LBGRQAMLLCARGMLRM'$TG?RFCRMNGAMD'2
!*-(') 0/$*) $)$.- '
2GLACB?LACF?Q@CCLN?PRMDRFCDMPK?JCBSA?RGMLQWQRCKGLRFC2R?RCMD(QP?CJ3FGQ
BGDDCPQAMLQGBCP?@JWDPMKRFCDMPK?JCBSA?RGML?JQWQRCKQGL$SPMNC?LBRFC4LGRCB2R?RCQ
UFCPCAMLRPMTCPQG?JBGQASQQGMLQF?TCR?ICLNJ?ACGLPCJ?RGMLRMRFCRMNGAMDB?LACCBSA?RGML
?LBGRQGLAJSQGMLGLNS@JGAQAFMMJQ*MDDN(L(QP?CJB?LACGQR?SEFR?Q?QAFMMJ
QS@HCARGLNS@JGAQAFMMJQDPMKIGLBCPE?PRCLRMKGBBJC?LBFGEFCPCBSA?RGML2RSBCLRQA?L
QCJCARB?LAC?Q?K?HMPQS@HCARUGRFGLFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML3FCQRSBCLRQR?ICDGL?JCV?KQ
ML RFC QS@HCAR JGIC GL CTCPW MRFCP QAFMMJ QS@HCAR ?Q N?PR MD RFCGP FGEF QAFMMJ BCEPCC
AAMPBGLERM RFCFC?BMD QSNCPTGQGMLRFC#CN?PRKCLR MD$BSA?RGML ,PQ 'GJ? "MTPGE?PM
/GLF?QGRFCBCTCJMNKCLR MDASPPGASJ?RF?RCVNJMPCRFC'MJMA?SQRRFPMSEF #$@CE?LGL?L
A?BCKWGL)CPSQ?JCKUFGAFGQRMB?W3'$)$142 +$, " #$,8.%,42(" -#
# -"$3MB?W?PMSLBQAFMMJQ?JJMTCP(QP?CJMDDCPB?LAC?Q?QS@HCARGLFGEFQAFMMJ
CBSA?RGML3FCPCDMPC#$GQN?PRMDRFCNS@JGA QAFMMJQWQRCK#?LAC?Q ?K?HMPGLUFGAF
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
QRSBCLRQR?ICDGL?JCV?KQ?QN?PRMDRFCGPFGEFQAFMMJBCEPCCGQBGTGBCBGLRMB?LACFGQRMPW
B?LACAFMPCMEP?NFWQMKCRGKCQAFMPCMJMEWRFCMPW?LB?B?LACRCAFLGOSCAJ?QQGLUFGAF
QRSBCLRQQRSBWBGDDCPCLRB?LACRCAFLGOSCQ?LBQRWJCQ?QUCJJ?Q@CGLEPCOSGPCBRMAPC?RC?LB
NPCQCLRRFCGPMULUMPIQ!CQGBCQ RFCQCASPPGASJ?P@?QCBB?LAC AJ?QQCQUFGAF?PC MDDCPCB
LMRMLJWGL?PRQAFMMJQ@SRGLCTCPWRWNCMDNS@JGAQAFMMJGLRFCAMSLRPWKMQRQRSBCLRQF?TC
CVRP?ASPPGASJ?PRP?GLGLE ?DRCP PCESJ?PQAFMMJ (LRCPTGCU 'GJ?"MTPGE?PM/GLF?QG 'C?BMD
2SNCPTGQGML±#?LAC#CN?PRKCLR.ARM@CP
3FC AMLLCARGML @CRUCCL B?LAC ?LB RFC 'MJMA?SQR GL (QP?CJ GQBCPGTCB DPMK 'MJMA?SQR
QSPTGTMPQUFM UCPCDMPKCPB?LACPQ GL$SPMNCN?PRGASJ?PJWRFMQC UFMUCPCAMLLCARCB RM
³$XVGUXFNVWDQ]´ SQBPSAIQR?LX U?Q? KMTCKCLRRF?R BCTCJMNCBGL $SPMNCDPMK?@MSR
RFCWC?PGLPCQNMLQCRMRFCPCQRPGARCB?CQRFCRGAQMDAJ?QQGA?JB?LACRFCAJ?QQGA?J@?JJCR
/CRCPN3FCICWNPMR?EMLGQRMDRFGQKMTCKCLRGL&CPK?LWU?Q,?PW6GEK?L
#SLA?LBCDGLCQRFGQKMTCKCLR?QRFCDMJJMUGLE
:< RFC KMTCKCLRQ MD RFC FSK?L @MBW KSQR AMPPCQNMLB RM GRQ DMPK 3FCW QFMSJB CTCL
AMPPCQNMLBRMGRQGLBGTGBS?JDMPK3FCB?LACMDLMRUMNCPQMLQQFMSJB@C?JGIC3FCPCUGJJ
?JU?WQ@CKMTCKCLRQUFGAF?PC RFC NCPDCAR CVNPCQQGML MD RF?R GLBGTGBS?J @MBW ?LB RF?R
LQGLYLGXDOVRXO>«@7KHGDQFHURIWKHIXWXUHZLOOEHRQHZKRVHERG\DQGVRXOKDYHJURZQ
QM F?PKMLGMSQJW RMECRFCP RF?R RFC L?RSP?J J?LES?EC MD RF?R QMSJ UGJJ F?TC @CAMKC RFC
KMTCKCLRMDRFC@MBWG@GB
#SLA?L SLBCPQR?LBQ RFC K?GL AMKNMLCLRQ MD SQBPSAIQR?LX GL RFC CVNPCQQGML MD RFC
GLBGTGBS?JRFC@MBW?LBGRQQMSJG@GB
LMR?@JCCV?KNJCGLRFGQPCE?PBGQRFCJGDC?LBUMPIMDRFCB?LACP8CFSBGR PLMLUFM
DMSLBCBRFC *(!!439".-3$,/.1 18# -"$ ".,/ -8?LBRFSQ DMPKCB?LB
QF?NCBB?LAC?QN?PRMDDMPK?JCBSA?RGMLGL(QP?CJGQAFMMJQ(LRCPTGCU'C?BMD2SNCPTGQGML
'GJ?"MTPGE?PM/GLF?QG#?LAC#CN?PRKCLR8CFSBGR PLML)SBGRF2AFGQAF?'?JCTWU?Q
@MPLGL!P?RGQJ?T??LBGL)SLCU?QQCLRUGRFFCPD?KGJWRM SQAFUGRX%PMK?WMSLE
?EC PLML QFMUCBN?QQGMLDMPKMTCKCLRFCP EWKL?QRGAQRC?AFCPU?Q AMLTGLACBMDFCP
QRSBCLRlQR?JCLR PLMLUFMU?QDPMK?PCJGEGMSQD?KGJWU?QLMR?JJMUCBRMB?LAC@WRFC
1?@@GQ(L SQAFUGRX!GPICL?SQFCU?Q?QICBRMNCPDMPK?APM@?RGAQ?LBKMTCKCLRQ3FSQ
QFCQRGJJK?L?ECBRMPC?JGXCFCPN?QQGML?LB R?JCLRGLRFCCLTGPMLKCLRMD?LCVRCPKG L?RGML
A?KN (LE@CP ) ! 8CFSBGR PLML )CUGQF 6MKCL "MKNPCFCLQGTC 'GQRMPGA?J
$LAWAJMNCBG? ,?PAF )CUGQF 6MKCLQ PAFGTC 5GCUCB ML ,?PAF
FRRNQHU?MPECLAWAJMNCBG??PRGAJC?PLMLWCFSBGR(LRFC UGLRCPMD PLML U?QRMJB
(Q?BMP?#SLA?L>QAGRCBBCDGLGRGML GQNPCQCLRCBGLRFGQPC QC?PAFCTCLRFMSEFQFCU?Q?ICWNPMR?EMLGQRMD
SQBPSAIQR?LXGLRFC4LGRCB2R?RCQUFGAFGLGRQCTMJTCKCLRBGDDCPQDPMKRFC&CPK?LMLC/CRCPN
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
@WRFC*?NMRF?RRFC22U?LRCBFCPRMB?LAC?RRFCGP"FPGQRK?Q/?PRW2FCPCDSQCB?LBU?Q
?Q ? NSLGQFKCLR DMPACB RM QR?LB @?PCDMMR GL RFC QLMU (L RFGQ KMKCLR QFC K?BC ?
AMKKGRKCLRRMFCPQCJDRF?RGDQFCQSPTGTCBQFCUMSJBBCBGA?RCFCPJGDCCLRGPCJWRMB?LAC
#*'*0./ 0/$*))) 0/$*)$)$.- '
(L ?L CBSA?RGML?J ASPPGASJSK U?QPCJC?QCB @W RFC ,GLGQRPW MD $BSA?RGML UFGAF
AMK@GLCQ ?PR ?LB '$ 3FC 'MJMA?SQR GQ LMR QNCAGDGA?JJW PCDCPPCB RM GL RFC RGRJC MD RFC
ASPPGASJSK(RGLAJSBCQMRFCP?PRDMPKQQSAF?QBP?UGLEQKSQGADGJKQ?LB?NPMEP?KSQGLE
B?LACDMPRC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC'MJMA?SQR AAMPBGLERM RFC FC?B MDRFCQSNCPTGQGML MD RFC
B?LACBCN?PRKCLR'GJ?"MTPGE?PM/GLF?QGRC?AFCPQF?TCRM@CB?LACCVNCPRQ(LKMQRA?QCQ
RFCQCRC?AFCPQ?PCDMPKCPB?LACPQUGRF?L?BBGRGML?JBCEPCCGLRC?AFGLE(LRCPTGCU'C?B
MD2SNCPTGQGML'GJ?"MTPGE?PM/GLF?QG#?LAC#CN?PRKCLR.ARM@CP
/=:#C@C86HFG6B96B8:
QK?JJLSK@CPMDAFMPCMEP?NFCPQF?TCAMLLCARCBRFCRMNGAMDRFC'MJMA?SQR?LBRFC?PR
DMPKMDB?LAC?QQFMULGLRFCNPCTGMSQQCARGML%MPRFGQPCQC?PAF(AFMQCRMNPCQCLRUMPIQ
MDAFMPCMEP?NFCPQUFM F?TC BC?JRUGRFRFCRMNGA MD RFC'MJMA?SQRGL RFCGP UMPIQ DPMK ?
LMLPCNPCQCLR?RGML?JNCPQNCARGTCMDRFCFGQRMPGA?JCTCLRQMDRFC2FM?F3FCWF?TCBC?JRUGRF
RFCRMNGAGLRFCGPQR?EC@?QCB?LBLMLQR?EC@?QCBUMPIQDPMK?LCVNJMP?RGTCNMGLRMDTGCU
?Q?KC?LQMDBC?JGLEUGRFRFCGPMULRFMSEFRQMLRFCRMNGA3FCPCTGCUUGJJQR?PRUGRFRFC
DGPQRB?LACNGCACQBCBGA?RCBRMRFC'MJMA?SQRRMEGTC?@PGCDNPCQCLR?RGMLMDNGCACQAPC?RCB
IURPWKH¶VRQZDUGV
DMASQMLRFCNCPQML?JGLBGTGBS?JL?PP?RGTCUGRFGL'$U?QDGPQRSQCB@W"P?LIMGL
GLMLCMDRFCDGPQRB?LACNGCACQ?@MSRRFC2FM?FNPCKGCPCBGL(QP?CJ6FGJQRLM@MBWSNSLRGJ
RFGQNMGLRF?BNSRRFCCTCLRQ?LBCVNCPGCLACQMDRFC2FM?FGLUMPBQGL(R+>HIE>!HK>LM
(R+>HIE>.>: ?KHF .HG@ H? (R +>HIE>²!HK>LM +>HIE>².>:!GLE'CGBCAICP
SS &UDQNRXVHV³HPERGLHG ODQJXDJH³WKURXJKGDQFH LQ RUGHUWRKLJKOLJKW WKH
PMJCMDB?LAC?Q?DMPKMDLMLTCP@?JAMKKSLGA?RGMLG@GBN
Q!GLE'CGBCAICPNQSEECQRQ
"P?LIMQCCKQLCTCPRFCJCQQRMF?TCR?ICLMLRFGQAF?JJCLECRMB?LACRFCSLB?LAC?@JC?LB
GLRFC NPMACQQMDBMGLE QMFCBPCU @MRF MLRCVR?LB KMTCKCLR3FCPC?PC QMKCU?WQGL
UFGAFB?LAC A?L @C AMLQGBCPCB ? PCNPCQCLR?RGML?J QWQRCK 3FC KGKCRGA ?QNCAR MD B?LAC
?JJMUQRFC AFMPCMEP?NFCPRM PCNPCQCLRNFCLMKCL? MDFSK?L@CF?TGMPRP?GRQMD AF?P?ARCP
8CFSBGR PLMLBCBGA?RCBFCPJGDCRMB?LAC!WBCDGLGRGMLQFCFCPQCJDGQLMR?B?LACP
(LRFGQPCQC?PAF(MLJWPCDCPRMRFCQS@HCARMDB?LACUGRFGLDMPK?J(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML3FCPCDMPC
,FDQQRWVWDWHWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVRIWKHWHDFKHUV¶CVNCPRGQCMLRFCMRFCP?PRQS@HCARQ
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
?LB QGELQ MD AJ?QQ MP QR?RSQ @W KMTCKCLR RFPMSEF ACPR?GL RFC?RPGA?J AMLTCLRGMLQ (R GQ
RFPMSEFKGKCQGQ?LBKGKC RF?RB?LAC A?L@C AMLQGBCPCB?PCNPCQCLR?RGML,MPCMTCPRFC
L?PP?RGTC ?QNCAR MD J?LES?EC GQ @PMSEFR DMPRF @W RFC AFMPCMEP?NFGA KCBGSK RFPMSEF GRQ
QSAACQQGTC SLDMJBGLE GL RGKC $QQCLRG?JJW GR GQ ? AMK@GL?RGML MD RFCQC RUM ?QNCARQ RFC
KGKCRGA?LBRFCL?PP?RGTCRF?R?JJMUQB?LACRMPCNPCQCLRMPRMRCJJ?QRMPW!GLE'CGBCAICP
N
.L#CACK@CP RFCNGCAC $G (>FHKRH?)H @W LL? 2MIMJMU U?Q
NPCKGCPCB(RU?QNCPDMPKCB@WRFC!?RQFCT?#?LAC"MKN?LWUGRF?QMJMNCPDMPK?LAC@W
1GL? 2AFGCLDCJB ? KCK@CP MD 2MIMJMUlQ +WPGA?J 3FC?RPC GL (QP?CJ 3FC NGCAC GQ ?L
CKMRGML?J MLC UFGAF AMKKCKMP?RCQ ?L GLK?RC MD RFC A?KNQ UFM NCPGQFCB BSPGLE RFC
+RORFDXVW6RNRORZ ZDV SDUWRI WKH ³UDGLFDOGDQFH³PRYHPHQW DQG EHOLHYHGLQWKH LGHD
WKDWGDQFHUVFRXOGEHPRUHWKDQMXVWHQWHUWDLQHUV7KH\FRXOGDOVRHQJDJHZLWK³HPRWLRQV
ZLWKLPSRUWDQWFDXVHV³+DUULV-*$QQD6RNRORZ-HZLVF6MKCL "MKNPCFCLQGTC
'GQRMPGA?J$LAWAJMNCBG?,?PAF)CUGQF6MKCLQ PAFGTC5GCUCBML,?PAF
FRRNQHU?MPECLAWAJMNCBG??PRGAJCQMIMJMU?LL? Q GL FCP NPCTGMSQ NGCAC
K>:FL $G (>FHKR H? )H 2MIMJMU BC?JQ UGRF RFC LMLTCP@?J
GLRCLQGRWMD@MBWJ?LES?EC?DRCP SQAFUGRX/FWQGA?JCVNCPGCLACQ?PCCVNPCQQCBRFPMSEFRFC
@MBW ?LB @MBW J?LES?EC P?RFCP RF?L TG? RFC NMQQG@GJGRW MD SQGLE J?LES?EC ?Q ? DMPK MD
AMKKSLGA?RGML/CRXCPAGRCBGL*GJAFK?LLN
(LRFC DMJJMUGLE AF?NRCP RFCDMASQUGJJ @C MLB?LACNGCACQ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ UFM RCJJ
RFCGPMULNCPQML?JQRMPGCQQSPPMSLBGLERFCRMNGA?LB UFMF?TCAFMQCLB?LACRMBC?JUGRF
RFCRMNGADMPCBSA?RGML?JNSPNMQCQ
3FC'MJMA?SQR#?LAC$KMRGMLQ?LB$BSA?RGML#?LACNGCACQMLRFC'MJMA?SQR
%PMKRFC RUCLRGCRF ACLRSPW (QP?CJG ?Q UCJJ?Q&CPK?L "?L?BG?L (R?JG?L ?LB KCPGA?L
B?LAC RFC?RPC ?PRGQRQ F?TC BC?JR UGRF RFC AMKNJCV GLRCP?ARGML @CRUCCL KMTCKCLR ?LB
KCKMPW(LRFCDMJJMUGLERFCB?LACNGCACQUGJJ@C@PGCDJWNPCQCLRCBUGRFPCE?PBQRMRFCGP
?NNPM?AFCQ UFGAF LCGRFCP DMASQ ML FGQRMPGA?J D?ARQ LMP ML L?PP?RGTCQ MD TGARGKFMMB
NCPNCRP?RMPQMP@WQR?LBCPNCPQNCARGTCQ (LQRC?BRFCWQCCIRMCL?@JCQRSBCLRQRM PCDJCARML
RFC'MJMA?SQRML?NCPQML?JGLBGTGBS?JJCTCJ
(LRFGQPCQC?PAF(BGQRGLESGQF @CRUCCLNGCACQ RF?R?PCN?PRMD ?LCBSA?RGML?J NPMEP?K?LB
B?LACNGCACQ3FCQCAFMPCMEP?NFGCQQR?LB ML RFCGP MUL ?Q NCPDMPK?RGTC ?PRQ3FCNGCACQ
UGJJ@CMPE?LGXCBGLRFGQ@PGCDPCTGCU?AAMPBGLERMRFCGP?NNPM?AFCQ3FCNPCQCLRCBNGCACQ
?PCLMRRFC MLJWUMPIQMDRFCAFMPCMEP?NFCPQ%MPRFGQPCQC?PAF(BCAGBCBRMNPCQCLRMLJW
RFCGPUMPIQRF?RBC?JUGRFRFC'MJMA?SQR
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
QKCLRGMLCB NPCTGMSQJWRFCAPC?RMP MDRFC NGCACB=>(>FHBK> RFC B?LACP?LB
AFMPCMEP?NFCP 1?KG !ClCPU ?Q@MPL ?LB P?GQCB GL ?L ?PRGQRGA CLTGPMLKCLR !MPL GLRM ?
D?KGJW MD KSQGAG?LQ ?R *G@@SRX &??RML FC QR?PRCB UGRF KSQGA ?LB J?RCP HMGLCB RFC
*(!!439".-3$,/.1 18# -"$".,/ -8*"#"(L!ClCP@CA?KC?
B?LACP?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPDMPRFC"MKN?LW1MRRCL@CPENN2GLACFCF?Q
@CCLRFCAMKN?LWQ?PRGQRGABGPCARMP?LBF?QAPC?RCBMTCPB?LACNGCACQ%MPFGK?NJ?W
RUSHUIRUPDQFH LV ³DXQLW\´+H GHYHORSVQRW RLJW RFCNCPDMPK?LACQRFCKQCJTCQ @SR?JQM
BP?UQ ML AMQRSKC BCQGEL JGEFRGLE ?LB QR?EGLE PRGQRGA BGPCARMP 1?KG !ClCP 6C@QGRC
*G@@SRX "MLRCKNMP?PW #?LAC "MKN?LW 5GCUCB ML ,?PAF
FRRNUUUIABAAMGJCLP?KG@CCPFRKJ!ClCP?QRFCQMLMD'MJMA?SQRQSPTGTMPQRPGCBRM
BC?JUGRFRFCFMPPMPQMDRFC'MJMA?SQR@SRGRRMMIKCWC?PQSLRGJ(DCJRK?RSPCCLMSEFRM
BMQM,WN?PCLRQDGJJCBRFCFMSQCUGRF?PR?LBKSQGAP?GQCBSQGL?L(QP?CJG*G@@SRXQR?PRCB
?LCUJGDC?LBLCTCPKCLRGMLCBRFCN?QR2?KC?QUGRFKCGRRMMIBCA?BCQSLRGJRFCWQR?PRCB
RMQNC?I 6FCL( DCJRPC?BWRMBC?J UGRFRFCFMPPMPQ MDRFC 'MJMA?SQR(APC?RCBRFCNGCAC
.)**13.4*´LELG
3FC "?L?BG?L ?PRGQR JJCL *?CH? BGPCARMP ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCP MD RFC*?CH? B#?LAC
"MKN?LWGL3MPMLRMBC?JRUGRFRFC 'MJMA?SQRGLQCTCLTGBCMB?LAC AJGNQUFGAFUCPCGL
QMKCA?QCQ?JQMNCPDMPKCB?QQR?EC@?QCBUMPIQ(LAMJJ?@MP?RGMLUGRFFGQN?PRLCP*?PCL
*?CH??LBRFCDGJKBGPCARMP,?PI B?K JJCL*?CH?APC?RCBB?LACAJGNQBCNGARGLEFGQMUL
IDWKHU¶VCVNCPGCLACQ ?LB RFC CVNCPGCLACQ MD /MJGQF )CUPW 'GQ D?RFCP U?Q ? 'MJMA?SQR
QSPTGTMPDPMK*SRLMGL/MJ?LB(LRFCNPMBSACBAJGNQRFC?PRGQRQAMK@GLCBRFC?PRDMPKQMD
B?LAC?LBDGJK JJ QCTCLNPMBSARGMLQAF?JJCLEC RFC CVNPCQQGML MDRFC'MJMA?SQR ?LB GRQ
UHPHPEUDQFH IURP WKH FKRUHRJUDSKHU¶V SRLQW RI YLHZ %HWZHHQ DQG WKH
AMKN?LWNPMBSACBRFCDMJJMUGLEAJGNQ2BMG>LL>= 5NFF>E .:K:A
->LBLM:G<>>I:KMNK>?LB*E=HNGMKR.DHMDV¶VSLHFHVDUHERWKDUW
UMPIQRF?RQR?LBMLRFCGPMUL?LBNGCACQSQCBDMPCBSA?RGML?JNSPNMQCQUGRFRFCKCQQ?EC
MD JC?PLGLE DPMK RFC N?QR UFGJQR K?IGLE ? AMLLCARGML UGRF PCACLR NMJGRGA?J CTCLRQ ?LB
?GKGLERMNPCTCLRDSRSPCECLMAGBCQ
/LNH%HHU.DHMDVHHNVWRVKRZDVSHFWVRIWKHWRSLFEDVHGRQWKHH[DPSOHRIKLV IDWKHUµV
NCPQML?J CVNCPGCLACQ GL RFC 'MJMA?SQR *?CH? LCGRFCP PCDCPQ RM FGQRMPGA?J D?ARQ LMP
UHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI KLV IDWKHUµQ CVNCPGCLACQ 1?RFCPRFCAFMPCMEP?NFCPGQ KMPC DMASQCB ML
?QQMAG?RGMLQMPRFCCKMRGML?J ?QNCARQ MD BC?JGLE UGRF RFC CVNCPGCLACQ MD FGQ MUL D?RFCP
RFPMSEFB?LAC ?LB QF?PGLE FGQMULGK?ECQ UGRF ?L?SBGCLAC*?CH? MDDCPQ NCPQML?J?LB
'C@PCURGRJC9GAFPML#T?PGK
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
GLBGTGBS?J RFMSEFRQ ?LB CVNPCQQGMLQ PCE?PBGLE RFC 2FM?F GL ? QCLQGRGTC U?W3FC ?PRGQR
RIIHUVKLVIDWKHUµVLQGLYLGXDOH[SHULHQFHVIURPKLVSHUVSHFWLYHDVDVRQ7KHSURGXFHGGDQFH
AJGNQUCPCNCPDMPKCB?QQR?ECUMPIQ?LBRFCAJGNQRFCKQCJTCQUCPCSRGJGXCBDMPCBSA?RGML?J
NSPNMQCQ 3FC B?LAC AJGNQ MD 5NFF>E ?LB >I:KMNK> QCPTCB RFC AFMPCMEP?NFCP GL RFC
BCTCJMNKCLRMD?LCBSA?RGML?JIGRUFGAFF?Q@CCLBP?ULSNML?JJMTCP"?L?B??LBGQSQCB
GLFGEFQAFMMJQRMRC?AF?@MSRRFC2FM?FML?NCPQML?J?LBGLBGTGBS?JJCTCJUFGJCSQGLE
RFCKCBGSKMDB?LACAJGNQ
3FC?PRGQRGABGPCARMPMDRFC JTGL GJCW KCPGA?L#?LAC3FC?RPC1M@CPR!?RRJCBCNGARQRFC
'MJMA?SQRGLRFCNGCAC)HEHG@>K.BE>GM3FCNGCACAFMPCMEP?NFCB@W!?RRJC
?LB MPGEGL?JJW APC?RCB DMP RFC )SJJG?PB 2AFMMJ ?Q N?PR MD ? AMLACPR U?Q BCBGA?RCB RM
AMKNMQCPQUFM UCPC@?LLCB GLRFC3FGPB 1CGAF @WRFC-?XG 1CEGKC1M@CPR!?RRJC -M
JMLECP QGJCLR 6C@QGRC JTGL GJCW 5GCUCB ML ,?PAF
FRRNQUUU?JTGL?GJCWMPENCPDMPK?LACQPCNCPRMPWLMJMLECPQGJCLR3FC NJ?W GQBGPCARCB
WR(UZLQ6FKXOKRII¶V³2JHODOD´UFGAFU?QAMKNMQCB@CRUCCL?LB?LBU?Q
GHFODUHGDV³GHJHQHUDWH´E\WKH1D]LUHJLPH$UWLFOH%DQQHGE\1D]LVFRPSRVHU¶VZRUN
?NNC?PQMLQR?EC WC?PQ J?RCP%C@PS?PW6C@QGRC /!2-CUQ 'MSP5GCUCB ML
,?PAF FRRNUUUN@QMPELCUQFMSP?PR@?LLCB@WL?XGQAMKNMQCPQUMPI
?NNC?PQMLQR?ECWC?PQJ?RCP #SPGLE RFC APC?RGML NPMACQQ !?RRJC BC?JR UGRF RFC
OSCQRGMLMDUFCRFCPMPLMRB?LACA?LPCNPCQCLRRFC2FM?F
(L RFC BGPCARMP MD !?JJCR SQRGL 42 2RCNFCL ,GJJQ JCB RFC AMJJ?@MP?RGML MD RFC
'B@AM/A>#HEH<:NLM:G=#NF:GBMR+KHC><MRMECRFCPUGRF,?PW+CC6C@CAINPMDCQQMP?R
RFC 4-(5$12(38 .% 3$7 2 GL SQRGL ?Q UCJJ ?Q !PCLR '?QRW'?QRW N
'?QRW>Q BGQQCPR?RGML ?@MSR RFC 'B@AM/A> #HEH<:NLM :G= #NF:GBMR +KHC><M GQ RFC
MLJW PCQC?PAF UFGAF AMSJB @C DMSLB ML RFC RMNGA MD SQGLE B?LAC DMP RC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC
'MJMA?SQR3FCMLJWCVACNRGML U?QRFC$BSA?RGML?J*GRBCTCJMNCB@W JJCL*?CH? UFGAF
GQ?AAMPBGLERMRFCAFMPCMEP?NFCPSQCBML?AMSPQCBCQGELCBRMRC?AF?@MSRAPC?RGLEB?LAC
AJGNQP?RFCPRF?L@CGLESQCBMLB?LACNPMEP?KQlRC?AFGLEMLRFC'MJMA?SQR'?QRWQR?RCQ
&KDUWLQJWKH DXWKRU¶V H[SHULHQFHRIVHHNLQJGHHS SROLWLFDO DFWLRQWKLVFDVH GHPRQVWUDWHV
RFC U?WQ GL UFGAF RP?LQBGQAGNJGL?PW N?PRLCPQFGNQ APC?RC JSKGL?J QN?ACQ RF?R MNCL
NMQQG@GJGRGCQDMPNCB?EMEGA?LBQMAG?JAF?LEC3FCQRSBWMSRJGLCQRFCCL?ARKCLRMD?L?PRQ
CBSA?RGML ?LB AGTGA N?PRLCPQFGN MAASPPGLE GL SQRGL 3CV?Q GL ACLRCPCB GL ?
AMKKSLGRW@?QCB QRSBW MD RFC 'MJMA?SQR 3FC QRSBW QCCIQ ?LQUCPQ RM RFC DMJJMUGLE
2S E\(UZLQ 6FKXOKRII2ULJLQDO WLWOH2JHODOD³%DOOHWWP\VWHULXP³ 5REHUW%DWWOH 1RORQJHUVLOHQW
6C@QGRC JTGL GJCW 5GCUCB ML ,?PAF
FRRNQUUU?JTGL?GJCWMPENCPDMPK?LACQPCNCPRMPWLMJMLECPQGJCLR
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
OSCQRGMLQ ? 'MU BGB AMKKSLGRW JC?BCPQ CLTGQGML ?LB CL?AR RFC AMKKSLGRW@?QCB
N?PRLCPQFGN+GEFR3FC'MJMA?SQR?LB'SK?LGRW/PMHCAR@(LUF?RU?WQGD?LWUCPCRFC
?PRGQRGA CBSA?RGML ?LB AGTGA CTCLRQ ?KNJGDGCB RFPMSEF RFC AMJJ?@MP?RGTC N?PRLCPQFGN
+GEFR3FC'MJMA?SQR?LB'SK?LGRW/PMHCAR?LBA6F?RNCB?EMEGA?JNMQQG@GJGRGCQMAASP
DMP?SBGCLACQCVNCPGCLAGLERFC B?LAC UMPI +GEFR3FC 'MJMA?SQR ?LB 'SK?LGRW /PMHCAR
'?QRWNTGG
JRFMSEF'?QRW?LB!?RRJC DMASQMLPCNPCQCLR?RGMLQ MDRFC'MJMA?SQR GLRFCGP UMPIQ RFGQ
UHVHDUFK ZLOO XWLOL]HWKHLU LGHD RI D ³WUDQVGLVFLSOLQDU\´ DSSURDFK LELG 2Q WKH EDVLV RI
CBSA?RGML?JUMPIB?LACGQECRRGLESQCB?Q?RMMJRMPCDJCARMLRFC'MJMA?SQRRMNGAGLMPBCP
RM E?GL ? BCCNCP SLBCPQR?LBGLE $TCL RFMSEF '?QRWlQ PCQC?PAF NSPNMQC BGDDCPQ DPMK RFC
MRFCPAFMPCMEP?NFCPQ UMPI ?QGRGQ N?PRGASJ?PJW KC?LRRMCBSA?RC RFC WMSLECPECLCP?RGML
DERXW WKH WRSLF RI WKH +RORFDXVW +DVW\ IRFXVHV RQ ILQGLQJ DZD\ WR WHDFK ³RXWVLGH´ RI
³WUDGLWLRQDOHGXFDWLRQDO VSDFHV´ LELG +DVW\LV ZHOJ ?U?PC MD RFC CKMRGML?J GLDJSCLACQ
GDQFHFDQ KDYH +HVWDWHVWKDW ³:KLOH OLPLWDWLRQVRIWKH IRUPLQKLELWWKH FRQYH\DQFH RI
BCLQCFGQRMPGA?J AMLRCLRGR MNCLQSRVVLELOLW\IRUH[SORUDWLRQRIGHQVH HPRWLRQDOFRQWHQW³
G@GB3FGQNCPQNCARGTCGQGKNMPR?LRDMPKW, 3FCQGQ?LBGRQ?NNPM?AFRMB?LACRC?AFGLE
(L "FPGQRG?LC ,CWCP1MEEC3SPLCP ? &CPK?L B?LAC RC?AFCP ?LB FC?B MD ? B?LAC
QAFMMJAPC?RCB ?B?LACNGCAC @?QCB ML?NMCK /A>KHD>G2BG@ *HUPDQ³'HU
JHEURFKHQH)OJHO´E\(OVH+?QICP2AFiJCPGL FCPGKNPMTGQ?RGMLAJ?QQ3FCNGCACU?Q
APC?RCBSQGLEGKNPMTGQ?RGML ?LB?GKCBRMCLE?ECRFC?SBGCLAC2GLACGRU?QGKNJCKCLRCB
?Q?LGKNPMTGQ?RGML?JRFMSEF @?QCB ML NPGMP NP?ARGAC RFC NGCAC>Q MSRAMKC U?Q MNCL (R
DSLARGMLCB?Q?QMAG?JB?LAC?QUCJJ?Q? RFC?RPGA?JNP?ARGAC ?QGR CLE?ECBRFC B?LACPQ?LB
RFC?SBGCLAC?RRFCQ?KCRGKC3FCNGCACGQKGLSRCQJMLE,CWCP1MEEC3SPLCPU?Q@MPL
GLRMRFCUMPJB MDB?LAC?Q?AFGJBMDRFCDMSLBCP MD?B?LACQAFMMJRF?R CBSA?RCQB?LACPQ
?AAMPBGLERMRFCB?LACNFGJMQMNFWMD1SBMJD+?@?L,CWCP1MEEC3SPLCPRFCB?SEFRCPMD
+MJ?1MEECU?Q@MPLGL'?K@SPEUFCPCQFCEP?BS?RCBDPMKQAFMMJ?LBAMLRGLSCBUGRF?
B?LAC CBSA?RGML ?LB DSPRFCP CBSA?RGML ?Q ? B?LAC NCB?EMESC !GMEP?NFW "FPGQRG?LC
,CWCP1MEEC3SPLCP 6C@QGRC +MJ? 1MEEC 2AFSJC 5GCUCB ML ,?PAF
FRRNUUUJMJ?PMEECQAFSJCBC@CPSDQD?AFQAFSJCIMJJCEGSK /A> KHD>G 2BG@
MNCLQUGRFRFCAFMPCMEP?NFCPDMPKGLERFC2R?PMD#?TGBMSRMDQGVUMMBCLQRGAIQGLMPBCP
$JQC+?QICP2AFiJCPZDVDIDPRXV*HUPDQSRHPDQGSRHWU\ZULWHUZKRZURWH³7KH%URJHQ
:LQJ´*HUPDQWLWOHGHUJHEURFKHLBC%JiECJ2GEPGB!?SQAFGLECP$JQC+?QICP2AFiJCP6C@QGRC
)CUGQF6MKCL>Q PAFGTC5GCUCBML,?PAFFRRNQHU?MPECLAWAJMNCBG??PRGAJCJ?QICP QAFSCJCP
CJQC
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
RMAPC?RC?QQMAG?RGMLQ3FCQWK@MJQMDRFC2R?PMD#?TGB?LBRFC2U?QRGI?UCPC?AAMPBGLE
RMFCPRFC@?QGQDMPRFCBCTCJMNKCLRMDRFCNCPDMPK?LAC
3FCNPCQCLRCB QR?EC@?QCB?LBLMLQR?ECB@?QCB UMPIQ?Q UCJJDVWKH DUWLVW¶VLQWHQWLRQV
QFMURF?RRFCB?LACP?Q?ARMPGQ?RRFCACLRCPMDRFGQ?NNPM?AF6FGJCSQGLEB?LACGRMDDCPQ
WKHRSSRUWXQLW\ WRH[SUHVVDQG H[SORUH WKHGDQFHU¶VRZQ LGHDVRQ WKH WRSLF7KUHH RI WKH
NPCQCLRCB UMPIQ UCPC GLRCEP?RCB GLRM ?L CBSA?RGML?J DP?KCUMPI UFGJC SQGLE ? QRSBCLR
ACLRCPCB?NNPM?AFGL UFGAFRFCQRSBCLR @CAMKCQ?L?ARGTCN?PRGAGN?LRUFGJQR SQGLE?LML
TCP@?JRC?AFGLEKCRFMB(LRFCQCNPMHCARQGRAMSJB@CQFMULRF?RGRU?QNMQQG@JCRMDMASQML
?LGLBGTGBS?J?QUCJJ?QML? EPMSNL?PP?RGTC(LBCCBRFGQGQ?L?NNPM?AFRF?RQCCKQRM@C
J?AIGLEUGRFGLRFCPCACLRRC?AFGLEKCRFMBQMD'$
!?QCBML RFC NPMNMQCB BCDGLGRGML MD #?LAC $BSA?RGML #$ RFC Q?KNJC MD RFGQ PCQC?PAF
AMLQGQRQMDQRSBCLRQ?LBRC?AFCPQUFMBMLMRLCACQQ?PGJWF?TC?@?AIEPMSLBGLRFCDGCJBMD
B?LACMPNPGMPCVNCPGCLACQGLRFCDGCJB3FGQPCTGCUMD#$?LBGRQ?NNPM?AFCQF?TCQFMUL
RF?RGRQEM?JMD@CGLEGLAJSBCB?QN?PRMD?AGTGACBSA?RGMLUFGAFMDDCPQCTCPWMLCRFCAF?LAC
RMSQCRFCKCBGSKMDB?LAC?Q?LCBSA?RGML?JRMMJGQT?JGBPCE?PBJCQQMDUFGAFCVNCPGCLACQ
?PCQCCL?QGR?GKQ (LBCCBB?LAC MDDCPQ CTCPW FSK?L @CGLE RFC AF?LAC RM CVNJMPC ?LB
H[SUHVVRQH¶VRZQWKRXJKWVLQDQRQTCP@?J?LBNFWQGA?JU?WUFGAFA?LK?ICMLCAMLLCAR
?LBSLBCPQR?LBBGDDCPCLRJW3F?RGQRFCPC?QML(AFMQCRMGLAJSBCQRSBCLRQ?LBRC?AFCPQDPMK
BGDDCPCLRDGCJBQGL RFGQ PCQC?PAF ?PRGQRQ?LBLML?PRGQRQUFM?PC CVNMQCB RM '$ GL(QP?CJ
P?RFCPRF?LMLJWQRSBCLRQ?LBRC?AFCPQUFMF?B@CCLCVNMQCBRMB?LAC?JPC?BW.LCKGEFR
?PESC RF?R QRSBCLRQ ?LB RC?AFCPQ UGRF LM NPCTGMSQ B?LAC CVNCPGCLAC AMSJB LMR DMPK ?L
MNGLGML 'MUCTCP @?QCB ML GLRCEP?RGLE B?LAC GLRM QAFMMJ ASPPGASJ? ?LB AMLLCARGLE GR
DSPRFCPRMPCACLR'$GL (QP?CJLMLB?LACPQUCPCAFMQCLDMPAMLBSARGLERFGQPCQC?PAFRM
CL?@JC?BGQASQQGMLAMLACPLGLERFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q?KCRFMBRMRC?AF?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQR
GL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML
)'4.$.
6B8:6F6B 9H86G>CB6@/CC@;CEG:68=>B<67CHGG=:#C@C86HFG>B$FE6:@>=><=F8=CC@F
(LRFC?L?JWQGQN?PRMD RFGQPCQC?PAF (CV?KGLCRFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q?LCBSA?RGML?J RMMJDMP
RC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC2FM?FBP?UGLEMLOS?JGR?RGTCPCQC?PAF(AMLBSARCBUGRF(QP?CJGQRSBCLRQ
RC?AFCPQ?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPQDPMK(QP?CJ?LB@CWMLB2GVK?GLRFCKCQCKCPECBBSPGLERFC
GLRCPTGCUQUGRFC?AFMDRFCQ?KNJCEPMSNQUFGAFUGJJ@CGLRCPNPCRCB?QA?RCEMPGCQUGRFGL?
AMLRCLR?L?JWQGQ,?WPGLE?LB%PCLXCJAGRCBGL!?SP!J?QGSQNN3FCQCRFCKCQ
BCKMLQRP?RC RFC N?P?JJCJQ ?LB AMPPCJ?RGMLQ @CRUCCL EPMSNQ & & ?LB & ?Q UCJJ ?Q
BGDDCPCLACQUGRFGL RFCGPSLBCPQR?LBGLEQ?LB NCPACNRGMLQ 3FCEM?J MDRFGQ?L?JWQGQU?QRM
GLRCPNPCR?LB?L?JWXCRFCRFCKCQGLMPBCPRMDMASQMLRFCPCQC?PAFOSCQRGMLQ?LBRMBGQASQQ
UFCRFCPB?LACGQNCPACGTCB?Q?KCBGSKRMRC?AF?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRGLFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQGL
(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ%JGAINN
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
3FC RFCKCQ ?PC MPE?LGXCB GL ?L MPBCP MD BCAPC?QGLE NMNSJ?PGRW ?AAMPBGLE RM RFC
LQWHUYLHZHHV¶VWDWHPHQWVLELGSS
3FC QGV RFCKCQ ?PC #?LAC ?LB 'MJMA?SQR 2RSBGCQ 'GQRMPGA?J ILMUJCBEC TCPQSQ
$KMRGMLQ3FC.KLGNPCQCLAC MD RFC RMNGA "MKKCKMP?RGML ?LB (BCLRGRW
/MJGRGA?J 2MAG?JGX?RGML ?LB 3GKC 3FC JGQRCB RFCKCQ DC?RSPC RFPCC QS@RFCKCQ
)CUGQF (BCLRGRW ±5GARGKGX?RGML 7CLMNFM@G? ± 1?AGQK ?LB '?RPCB ?LB 6FCL
RFC6GRLCQQD?JJQQGJCLR3FCQS@RFCKCQUGJJ@CNPCQCLRCB?JMLEUGRFRFCK?GLRFCKCQ
%MJJMUGLERFCNPCQCLR?RGMLMDRFCRFCKCQRFCGLRCPTGCUQUGJJ@CBGQASQQCBUGRF?DMASQML
RFCPCQC?PAFOSCQRGML?LBRFCNPCQCLRCBRUMQS@OSCQRGMLQ
%MJJMUGLE RFC RFCKCQ GL RFC ?L?JWRGA?J QR?EC UGJJ @C @PGCDJW NPCQCLRCB GL ? QSKK?PGXCB
TCPQGML
3FCKC#?LAC?LB'MJMA?SQR2RSBGCQ
3FC GLRCPTGCUCCQ MD & & ?LB & BGQASQQCB RFC PCJ?RGMLQFGN @CRUCCL B?LAC ?LB RFC
'MJMA?SQR @?QCB ML RFCGP MUL SLBCPQR?LBGLEQ ?LB PCJ?RGMLQFGN RM @MRF RMNGAQ 3FC
BGQASQQGMLQ ACLRCPCB ?PMSLB RFC ACPCKMLG?J B?LACQ ?LB RFCGP CKMRGML?J GKN?AR DMP &
NCPACNRGMLQPCJ?RCBRMFMUB?LACA?L@CF?PLCQQCBDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRDMP&
?LBRFCNPMACQQMDAPC?RGMLDMP&
³'DQFHFDQWRXFKWKURXJKLWVYLVXDOLW\LQRWKHUDUHDVRWKHUHPRWLRQVRWKHUDVVRFLDWLRQVRI
FSK?L@CGLEQ#C?JGLEUGRFDCCJGLEQQMKCRFGLEUFGAFGQ@CWMLBUMPBQ6MPBQF?TCJGKGRQ
?LBJGKGR?RGMLQ#?LACA?LAMNCGL?LMRFCPU?W#?LACEGTCQQMKCRFGLECJQCRF?LLSK@CPQ
LWWUDQVPLWVVRPHWKLQJ³*,QWHUYLHZ,)HEUXDU\
³,IHHO OLNHDFWXDOO\WKDW WKLVLVQRW WHDFKLQJDERXWWKH +RORFDXVW WKURXJKGDQFH,W LVQRW
RC?AFGLE ?@MSR RFC'MJM A?SQR (RGQ UMPIGLE UGRF RFC K?W@C UMPIGLE UGRF RFC BGDDCPCLR
HPRWLRQVRUWKH GLIIHUHQWHKPSHUVRQDOHKHKGLVWUHVVHVWKDWWULHVIDFLQJWKDWWRSLF³*
(LRCPTGCU(5%C@PS?PW
3FCPCDMPC M@R?GLGLE FGQRMPGA?J ILMUJCBEC ?LB CVNPCQQGLE NCPQML?J CKMRGMLQ UCPC
GBCLRGDGCB@W&&?LB&GLAMLLCARGMLRMB?LAC3FGQ@PGLEQSQRMRFCLCVRA?RCEMPW
3FCKC'GQRMPGA?JILMUJCBECTCPQSQ$KMRGMLQ
& & ?LB & NCPACGTC M@R?GLGLE FGQRMPGA?J ILMUJCBEC MD RFC FGQRMPGA?J CTCLRQ MD RFC
'MJMA?SQR ?Q GKNMPR?LR 6FGJQR M@R?GLGLE FGQRMPGA?J ILMUJCBEC ML RFGQ QNCAGDGA RMNGA
CKMRGMLQAMKCSNDMP&&?LB&?JGICUFGAFBCPGTCDPMKNCPQML?JAMLLCARGMLQRMRFC
RMNGA ?LB RFCGP PCJ?RGMLQFGN UGRFRFCGP EPC?R EP?LBN?PCLRQ EP?LBN?PCLRQMP N?PCLRQ UFM
UCPCQSPTGTMPQGL A?QCMD RFC(QP?CJGN?PRGAGN?LRQ6FGJQR@CGLE ?@JCRMCVNPCQQCKMRGMLQ
3FCKCQFCPCNPCQCLRCBGLRFC N?P?NFP?QCBTCPQGMLRMDGLBGLRFCBGQASQQ GMLMDRFGQ?PRGAJC3FCDMJJMUGLE
FC?BGLEQMDRFCRFCKCQ?PCICNRGLRFCMPGEGL?J?LBLMLN?P?NFP?QCBTCPQGML
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
GL AJ?QQ RFCPC GQ LM PMMK RM CVNJMPC RFCK GL KMPC BCNRF ?Q GLRCPTGCUCC RFPCC MD &
CVNJ?GLCB
³NQRZLQJHKPZKDWKDSSHQCBGLRFCN?QRKGEFRCFKU?PLSQUF?RKGEFRF?NNCLGLRFC
DSRSPC( KC?LLMR RMSQUF?R UCBM UF?RUCKGEFR BMRMSQ)SQRECLCP?J GLRFCUMPJB
/LNHWKLQJVWKDWKDSSHQHGLQWKHSDVWPLJKWGLVFRYHUVLJQLILFDQWFRQQHFWLRQWRWKHIXWXUH³
&(LRCPTGCU(%C@PS?PW
LMRFCP?QNCARRF?RA?KCSNGLRFCBGQASQQGMLMDRFGQRFCKC U?QRFCPMJCMDRFCQSPTGTMPQ
RFCKQCJTCQUGRFGL'$UFGAFUGJJLMU@CCVNJMPCBGLRFCDMJJMUGLEQS@A?RCEMPW
.N;MA>F>$2BMG>LLBG@MA>#HEH<:NLM
(LRFC RFGPBRC?AFCPGLRCPTGCU& RFCRC?AFCPGQ AMLTGLACB RF?R'$UGJJ F?TC RMAF?LEC
UFCL RFC UGRLCQQ D?JJQ QGJCLR ?LB RFCPCDMPC GR GQ GKNMPR?LR RM APC?RC MSP MUL L?PP?RGTCQ
QSPPMSLBGLERFCRMNGA
³,XQGHUVWRRGWKDWVRRQWKHUHZLOOQRWEHRQHRIWKHPDQGGRQRWNQRZZKDWZHZLOJBM
@CA?SQCRFCWF?B??KMP?JTMGAC?LBGRUGJJ@CEMLCMLCB?W?LBUCUGJJF?TCRMBCQGEL
WKHQDUUDWLYHDQGVR«³*,QWHUYLHZ,9)HEUXDU\
Q'MJMA?SQR QSPTGTMPQ ?PC N?PR MD RFC N?QR @SR ?JQM N?PR MD AMLRCKNMP?PW B?GJWJGDC RFC
GLRCPTGCUCCQ MD & & ?LB & PCDCPLMR MLJ WRM ? BGDDCPCLR NCPQML?J AMLLCARGML RM RFC
VXUYLYRUVWKHPVHOYHV0RUHVSHFLILFDOO\WKHWRSLFLVGHVFULEHGDV³RPQLSUHVHQW´DQDVSHFW
RF?RUGJJ@CCVNJMPCBGLRFCDMJJMUGLEA?RCEMPW
3FCKC'MJMA?SQR.KLGNPCQCLAC
6FGJQRBGQASQQGLERFGQRFCKC?JJN?PRGAGN?LRQMD&?LB&?LBGLRUMA?QCQMD&KCLRGML
RFC?QNCARMDKMSPLGLE?QN?PRMDRFCNPMACQQMDAMKKCKMP?RGML?LBAMKGLERM?AMJJCARGTC
GBCLRGRW
³<HVWKHUHLVDQDWWHPSWWRHKP WDONDERXWWKH+RORFDXVWLQYHU\GLIDCPCLRQS@HCARQ?LB(
RFMSEFRGRGQQMKCRFGLETCPWQNCAG?JRM(QP?CJ@SRRFCL(SLBCPQRMMBRF?RGL &CPK?LWQMKC
WHDFKHUVGRLWWKHVDPH³*,QWHUYLHZ,9)HEUXDU\
3FCPCDMPCRFCDMJJMUGLEQS@A?RCEMPWML)CUGQF(BCLRGRW±5GARGKGX?RGML±CKCPECBGLRFC
GDWDZKLFK,ZLOOQRZEULHIO\H[SORUHE\GLVFXVVLQJWKHVDPSOH¶VSHUFHSWLRQVRQWKLVWRSLF
.N;MA>F>$$$=>GMBMR:G=1B<MBFBS:MBHG
& & ?Q UCJJ?Q MLC (QP?CJG AFMPCM EP?NFCPMD & NCPACGTC '$ RM @C AMLLCARCB RM RFC
TGARGKGX?RGMLMDRFC )CUGQF NCMNJC UFGAF AMPPCJ?RCQ UGRF RFC AMLQR?LR KCLRGML MD QCJD
BCDCLQC?QUCJJ?QUGRFRFCNPMACQQMDAMKKCKMP?RGMLUFGAF?PCUCCL?QQ?JGCLR?QNCARQ
MD)CUGQFGBCLRGRWGLDMPK?JCBSA?RGML?JGLQRGRSRGMLQGL(QP?CJ
³,WLVNLQGRIOLNHDYHU\GHIHQVLYHDSSUM?AF?TCPW(QP?CJG?NNPM?AFMDBCDCLBGLE?LBQ?WGLE
Ä:HKDGD+RORFDXVWLWLVGLIIHUHQWWKDQDQ\WKLQJWKDWKDSSHQHGEHIRUHDQGHYHU\WKLQJWKDW
ZLOOHYHUKDSSHQ³$QGZHKDYHNLQGRIVWUDLJKWDVLGHIURPEHLQJUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRIYLFWLPV
MDRFC 'MJMA?SQR@PC?I 6C A?L QCC GRKMQRJWRMB?W GL 2WPG? WMSAMSJBF?TCQCCLRFC
Q?KC GL 2MSRF DPGA? GL RFC C?PJW GCQ CFK ?LB ?E?GL UFCL WMS RC?AF GL ?L SLBCP
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
NPGTGJCECBQAFMMJUFCPCRFCQRSBCLRQ?PC?JQMDMPKGLE?IGLBMDBCDCLBGLE?LECPGRGQTCPW
F?PBRMBRVR³*,QWHUYLHZ,)HEUXDU\
&&?LBRUMAFMPCMEP?NFCPQMD&PCJ?RCRMRFCNSPNMQCQ?LB?GKQMD'$
, KDYH WLWOHG WKH IROORZLQJ WKHPH ³0RUDO (GXFDWLRQ DQG 6RFLDOL]DWLRQ´ WR ILQG RFC GL
BGQASQQGML SLBCP N?P?NFP?QCB RFC WLWOH ³3ROLWLFDO 6RAG?JGX?RGML ± 0RUDO (GXFDWLRQ´ WR
IXUWKHUSUHVHQWWKHVDPSOH¶VXQGHUVWDQGLQJVRIWKLVWKHPH
3FCKC,MP?J$BSA?RGML?LB2MAG?JGX?RGML
³$QGDOVRHKPVXSSRUWGHPRFUDFLHVLQSODFHVZKHUHWKH\DUHWKH\DUHLQGDQJHU7KDWLV
MLCMDRFC@GEJCQQML?@MSRSLAJC?P?LBJMMI?PMSLB?LBQCCUF?RMRFCPNCMNJC?PCQSDDCP
MRFCPNCMNJCRF?R?PCQSDDCPGLE ?LBQCC UF?RUC?Q? AMSLRPWMPUC?QCFNCMNJCUF?R UC
A?LBM DMPRF?R 2MRF?R?PCUF?R( RFGLIPC?JJWGKNMPR?LR KCQQ?ECQ( RFGLI LB(?JMLE
UGRF RFC KCQQ?JH RI \RX NQRZ EHLQJ VWURQJ DQG WKH FRXQWU\ HWF³ * ,QWHUYLHZ 9
%C@PS?PW
**DQGLQRQHFDVH*SHUFHLYHUHFHQW6(DVSDUWRID³SROLWLFDOVRFLDOL]DWLRQ´ZKLFK
RM RFCK RFPMSEF GRQ AMLQR?LR AMLLCARGML RM RFC )CUGQF D?RC ?LB QMJCJW RFC )CUGQF
NCPQNCARGTCPCQSJRQGL?ACPR?GLDMPKMDVCLMNFM@G?P?AGQK?LBF?RPCB
³DQGOLNH SHRSOHDOZD\VPHQWLRQ WKH+RORFDXVWWRH[FXVH PDQ\ WKLQJVOLNHSROLWLFLDQV
SQCGRJGIC(BMLMRPC?JJWILMUFMURMQ?WGR@SRQMKCRGKCQGRHSQRDCCJQRFCW?PCMTCPSQGLE
GRGLQRC?BMDPC?JJWPCQNCARGLEGR3FCW?PCHSQRSQGLEGRRM@C@CA?SQCGRGQ?QMPRMDR?@MM
RFC'MJMA?SQR CTCPWMLCGRGQ ?LGKNMPR?LRK?RRCP LBWMSA?LLMR PC?JJWQ?WQMKCRFGLE
?E?GLQRGRUFCLWMSSQCGR?Q??Q?NMGLRDMPWMSPUF?RWMS³*,QWHUYLHZ,,,)HEUXDU\
3FCPCDMPC ( F?TC DMPKCB RFGQ ?QNCAR GLRM ? QS@RFCKC RM ?JJMU DMP ? KMPC BCR?GJCB
CVNJMP?RGMLMDRFGQRFCKC
.N;MA>F>$$$-:<BLF#:MK>=:G=3>GHIAH;B:
3FC QRSBCLRQ UGQF RM GLAJSBC ? @PM?BCP SLGTCPQ?J KCQQ?EC UGRFGL 2$ ?Q GL RFGQ U?W
VCLMNFM@G? P?AGQK ?LB F?RPCB AMSJB @C AMSLRCP?ARCB 3FC QRSBCLRQ PCJ?RC RFGQ ?@QCLR
SLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?EC@?AIRMNMJGRGA?JNSPNMQCQGLRCPKQMD?ACPR?GLNMJGRGA?JKMP?JCBSA?RGML
?DMASQML?AMKKMLL?RGML?JGBCLRGRW?LBRFCK?GLJW)CUGQFNCPQNCARGTCMLRFCFGQRMPGA?J
CTCLRQMDRFC'MJMA?SQR
³<RXPXVWEHKHUHEHFDXVHHYHU\RWKHUSODFHVD\V\RXDUHDIRUHLJQHUDQGWKDWLVKRZ\RX
DUHH[SRVHGWR[HQRSKRELD³*,QWHUYLHZ5%C@PS?PW
$QRWKHUIDFWRUUDLVHGE\WKHLQWHUYLHZHHVRI*DQG*DOLNHLVWKHDVSHFWRI³WLPH´ZLWKLQ
RC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRGLFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML3FGQ?QNCARUGJJ@CNPCQCLRCBGLRFC
DMJJMUGLE
3FCKC'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML'$?LB3GKC
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
(L?QGKGJ?PU?WRMRFCDGPQRGLRCPTGCUCCRFCDMSPRF?LBDGDRFGLRCPTGCUCCQMD&?JQMP?GQCB
WKHDVSHFWRI ³WLPH´%RWKVWXGHQWVVWDWHGWKDWWKHUHDUHRQO\DFHUWDLQDPRXQW RIKRXUVWR
RC?AF?@MSRRFC2FM?FGLQAFMMJ
³7KHUHLVOLNHDWLPHOLQHWKDRUCRC?AF DPMK RFC ( UMSJB Q?W 6CGK?P 1CNS@JGA ?LB RFC
QGRS?RGMLGL&CPK?LW/MQR6MPJB6?P(?LBUFGAF GQSN SLRGJRFC DGL?JQR?ECQ MDRFC U?P
?LBUF?RKMQRRC?AFCPQBMLMRRC?AFRMB?WGQRFCCFRFCKCKMPWMDRFC'MJMA?SQRUFGAF
GQUF?RUCSQS?JJWBMQRWWHDFKEHFDXVHZHGRQRWJHWHQRXJKWLPHIRUWKDW³*,QWHUYLHZ
(%C@PS?PW
3FGQU?QRFCNPCAGQCPC?QMLRF?RRFCDGDRFQRSBCLRAFMQCRMBM?LCVRCLBCBFGQRMPWAMSPQC?Q
FCUGQFCB RM JC?PL KMPC GLBCNRF ?@MSR RFC RMNGA %SPRFCPKMPC FC FGEFJGEFRCB RF?R GR GQ
³LUUHOHYDQW´DQG³QRWIDLU´WRVWXG\RQO\RQHFHUWDLQFRPPXQLW\
3FCRFGPBGLRCPTGCUCCMD&MNCLQFCPGLRCPTGCU@WQR?RGLERF?RRFC'MJMA?SQRGQR?SEFR
³UHDOO\SRRUO\³EHFDXVHWKHUHLVQRWHQRXJKWLPHWRWHDFKVWXGHQWVLQDVDWLVI\LQJZD\
!$)$)".
3FCDGLBGLEQMDRFCPCQC?PAFFGEFJGEFRRF?RRFCQRSBCLRQRC?AFCPQ?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPQF?TC
RFCGPMUL
GLBGTGBS?J?NNPM?AFCQRM?LBNCPACNRGMLQMDRFC'MJMA?SQR 3FCQGVICWRFCKCQ?LBRFPCC
QS@RFCKCQRF?R(GBCLRGDGCBAMPPCJ?RC?APMQQRFCB?R?QCR?LBGLKMQRA?QCQKCPECUGRFMLC
?LMRFCP
***
'DQFH DQG +RORFDXVW
6WXGLHV
+LVWRULFDO .QRZOHGJH
DQG(PRWLRQV
:KHQ WKH :LWQHVV IDOOV
VLOHQW
7KH 2PQLSUHVHQHQFH
RIWKH7RSLF
&RPPHPRUDWLRQ DQG
,GHQWLW\
-HZLVK ,GHQWLW\
9LFWLPL]DWLRQ
3ROLWLFDO6RFLDOL]DWLRQ
0RUDO(GXFDWLRQ
;HQRSKRELD 5DFLVP
+DWUHG
7LPH
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
6FCPC?QRFCWA?L@CP?RCBQCN?P?RCJWGRA?L?JQM@CQFMULRF?RN?P?JJCJQCVGQR?KMLEQR?JJ
RFCAMLBSARCBGLRCPTGCUQ3FCPCQC?PAFDGLBGLEQ QFMURF?RRFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q?RC?AFGLE
RMMJGQ UGBCQNPC?BGLPCACLR '$?LBGQ SQCB DMP?LSK@CP MDNSPNMQCQ%GPQRJWGL (QP?CJG
FGEFQAFMMJQB?LACNGCACQ?PCAPC?RCBDMPRFC8MK'?2FM?FACPCKMLGCQ(LKWPCQC?PAF
RFCQ?KNJCQSEECQRCBRF?RB?LACQFMSJB@C?LMNRGML?JAJ?QQ2CAMLBJWB?LACGQCKNJMWCB
WRH[SUHVV RQHVHOI DQG WR GHDO ZLWK RQH¶V IHHOLQJV VXUURXQGLQJ WFC RMNGA '?LL?
#?LACRFCPCDMPCMDDCPQRFCNMQQG@GJGRWMDAMLTCWGLE?SLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?ECUGRFMSRBCLWGLE
WKH XQLTXHQHVVRI WKH HYHQWV RI WKH 6KRDKDQG SUHVHUYLQJ WKH ³XQLTXHQHVV RI VXIIHULQJ´
1MRF@CPEN
%GL?JJWB?LACGQSQCB?Q?RC?AFGLERMMJGLPCACLR'MJMA?SQR2RSBGCQ%P?JCGEF"MFCL
3FCGLRCPTGCUCBQRSBCLRQ?QQCPRCBRF?RRFCWCVNCPGCLAC?DCCJGLEMD@CGLENMJGRGA?JJW
QMAG?JGXCBBSPGLERFCNPMACQQ
3FCQRSBCLRQUGQFRF?RNMJGRGA?J KCQQ?ECQ UCPC JCDR MSR MD 'MJMA?SQR $BSA?RGML 2?NGPM
QMRF?RRFCWAMSJBDMASQMLRFCGPMULGLBGTGBS?JSLBCPQR?LBGLEQMDRFCRMNGAP?RFCP
RF?L QRSBWGLE GRDPMK RFC NCPQNCARGTC MD AMLQRPSARGLE QRPMLECP )CUGQF (BCLRGRGCQ "MFCL
3FC?PRASPPGASJSKDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC2FM?FUFGAFU?QJ?SLAFCBRUMWC?PQ?EM
@WRFC(QP?CJG,GLGQRPWMD$BSA?RGMLSLBCPQSNCPTGQGMLMDRFC PR#CN?PRKCLRSQCQB?LAC
?Q?RC?AFGLERMMJ(RAF?JJCLECQQRSBCLRQRMP?GQC APGRGA?JOSCQRGMLQ?LBRMDMQRCPRFCGPMUL
RFMSEFRQMLRFCRMNGA &PMQQ ,GLGQRPW MD $BSA?RGML (QP?CJ 3FC PR #CN?PRKCLR
6FGJQR?RMNGAACLRCPCB?NNPM?AFGQCLBMPQCBGLPCESJ?PFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQRF?RBC?JUGRF
RFC 2FM?F "MFCL B?LAC MDDCPQ? KMPC QRSBCLR ACLRCPCB ?NNPM?AF *MDD,GQRP W
1?GLCPQ*L?SRF
!W QCCIGLE RM AMLTCW SLGTCPQ?J KCQQ?ECQ GL 'MJMA?SQR 2RSBGCQ '2 RFC Q?KNJC GQ
AMLTGLACBRF?R VCLMNFM@G?F?RPCB ?LBP?AGQKA?L @CAMSLRCPCB&PMQQ !?SK?LL
#?LAC?Q?LGLRCEP?RCBRC?AFGLEKCRFMBR?SEFR?Q?QCN?P?RCAMSPQCUGRFGL'2?LB
QRWFRQGXFWHG DV D KLVWRU\OHVVRQRSHQV XS WKH RSSRUWXQLW\WR H[SORUH RQH¶V RZQ LGHDV
@?QCBMLPCDJCVGTC?QQGELKCLRQ
2RSBCLRQ ?PC @CGLE MDDCPCB RFC MNNMPRSLGRW RM PCDJCAR ML RFCGP RFMSEFRQ ?LB CKMRGMLQ
QSPPMSLBGLERFC 'MJMA?SQR ?Q RFCQC ?PC LCTCP BGQASQQCB GL FGQRMPWAJ?QQCQ JJ QRSBCLRQ
QR?RCBRF?RRFCWUGQFRMCVNJMPCRFCGPMULRFMSEFRQMLRFCRMNGA?LBRMECRRMILMURFCGP
SHHUV¶WKRXJKWV&RKHQ
#?LACMDDCPQ RMAMLRPG@SRC RM ?BCCNCP SLBCPQR?LBGLEMDMLCQCJD ?LBRFC'MJMA?SQR PRQ
"SPPGASJSK,GLGQRPWMD$BSA?RGML(QP?CJ3FC PR#CN?PRKCLR
C<B>G>I:>FFCB6B8:6B9CAD6FF>CB
&?LB&NMGLRMSRRFCGKNMPR?LACMDPC?JGXGLERF?RCTCPWMLCA?L@C?NCPNCRP?RMP?QUCJJ
DVDE\VWDQGHUH[FHSWIRURQHVWXGHQW)XUWKHUPRUHRQHFDQWUDQVIRUP³)URPE\VWDQGHU
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
WR DFWLRQ´ DV %DXPDQQ DUJXHV LQ KLV DUWLFOH ³)URP %\VWDQGHU WR DFWRU´ ,Q KLV
PCQC?PAF!?SK?LL DRFXVHV RQ )HVWLQJHU¶V WKHRU\RIFRJQLWLYHGLVVRQDQFH
!?SK?LLN AAMPBGLERM!?SK?LLRFCBGDDCPCLRG?RGML@CRUCCLNCPNCRP?RMPQ
DQG E\VWDQGHUV PDNHV D ORW RI ³OHJDO´ DQG LQVWLWXWLRQDO VHQVH &RKHQ KDG SUHYGMSQJW
GLVFXVVHGWKHWHUP ³HYLOGRLQJ´ LQ WKH GLUHFW DIWHUPDWK RI WKH +RORFDXVW 7KHUHIRUH KH
GLVWLQJXLVKHGEHWZHHQ LQIOLFWLQJ³SDLQDQG VXIIHULQJ´DQG LQVWUXPHQWDOL]LQJ RWKHUKXPDQ
@CGLEQRMBMQM3FGQGQPCDJCARCBGLRFCA?RCEMPWMDRFCNCPNCRP?RMPQ AAMPBGLERM"MFCL
³GRLQJHYLO´GQ?NPGK?PWDSLARGMLMDFSK?L@CGLEQUFGAFPCJ?RCQAMLACNRS?JJWRMUF?RRFC
SKLORVRSKHU+REEHVGHVFULEHVLQKLVVRFLDOFRQWUDFWWKHRU\³EHOOXPRPQLXPFRQWUD
RPQHV´RU³KRPR KRPLQLOXSXV´(QJOLVK³7KHZDURIDOODJDLQVWDOO´&MGLE@CWMLB
RFCVHPXVLQJV%DXPDQQSRLQWVRXWWKHDEVHQFHRIUHVLVWDQFHDJDLQVW³WKHHYLO´%DXPDQQ
S 7KH GLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH SHUSHWUDWRU¶V DQG E\VWDQGHU¶V DFWLRQV DOVR
BCJGLC?RCQBGDDCPCLRJCTCJQ MDNSLGQFKCLRRFPMSEFJ?U?LBRFPMSEF?KMP?JMPAGTGAAMBC
´$QG\HW WKHUHLV DQDIILQLW\EHWZHHQ µGRLQJHYLO¶DQG µQRQUHVLVWDQFHWR HYLO¶´LELGS
#?LACCBSA?RGMLFCPCMDDCPQRFCMNNMPRSLGRWDMPLMRMLJWQCJDUHIOHFWLRQLQWHUPVRIRQH¶V
MUL?LBEPMSN@CF?TGMP@SRKMPCMTCPNCPACGTCQFSK?LCKMRGMLQ?Q?PCQMSPAC'?LL?
N#?LACCBSA?RGMLDMASQCQMLCKNMUCPKCLRRFPMSEFKMTCKCLR?LBNCPACGTCQ
WKHKXPDQEHLQJDVQHXWUDODQGQRWHYLO7R*³HYLOGRLQJ´LVQRWFHQWUDOWRDGLVFXVVLRQ
MDRFC2FM?F8CRRFC NCPNCRP?RMPGQ ?RRFCACLRCP MDRFCGPOSCQRGMLGLE-CTCPRFCJCQQ RFCW
UMSJBJGICRMDMASQMLRFCT?JSCQMDBCKMAP?AW(LBCCBRFCDGPQRGLRCPTGCUCBAFMPCMEP?NFCP
DMASQCBMLRFGQGLFGQNGCACBCBGA?RCBRMRFC'MJMA?SQR?LBGLRFCNPMACQQBCKMLQRP?RCBRFC
GBC?MDNMQGRGTCCKNMUCPKCLR?LBAPGRGA?JRFGLIGLERFPMSEFB?LACG@GB
7KH&UHDWLRQRI2QH¶V2ZQ1DUUDWLYH
#?LACGQNCPACGTCB @W&&?LB& ?Q?KCBGSKRF?RA?LAMLRPG@SRCRM '2?LB'$GL
,VUDHOLKLJKVFKRROVWRFUHDWHDQGPRUHRYHUWRKHOSRQHWRILQGRQH¶VRZQQDUUDWLYHUHODWHG
RMRFCRMNGA?LB?JQMRME?GL?LCKMRGML?JSLBCPQR?LBGLEMDRFCFGQRMPGA?JILMUJCBECRFCW
M@R?GLGLFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQ1?GLCPQ*L?SRFNN3FGQSLBCPQR?LBGLEAMPPCJ?RCQUGRF
'MUCTCP3FMK?Q'M@@CQGQKMPCBCQAPG@GLERFCPCJ?RGML@CRUCCL2R?RCQ?LBGRQUGRFGLGLRCP?ARGML
MDFSK?L@CGLEQ?LBLMRN?PRGASJ?PJWRFCGLRCP?ARGMLMDFSK?L@CGLEQUGRFMLC?LMRFCPUGRFGL?2R?RC
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
RFC BCDGLGRGML MD SQBPSAIR?LX LELG S $FFRUGLQJ WR &RKHQ ³0RVW HGXFDWRUV
?BTMA?RCQMKC@?J?LAC @CRUCCLRFCRFPCC?JMLERFC RFPCCEM?JQ?JMLEUGRFCLAMSP?EGLE
QRSBCLRQRM OSCQRGML ?LBBP?U RFCGP MULAMLAJSQGMLQ@?QCB ML UF?RRFCWJC?PL ?@MSRRFC
VXEMHFW´&RKHQS7KLVLVZKDWGDQFHFDQFRQWULEXWHDVDWHDFKLQJPHWKRG,W
FDQDFWDVDWRROIRUFKDQQHOLQJWKHVWXGHQWV¶WKRXJKWVDLB DCCJGLEQ?QRFCQRSBCLRQBMLMR
ILMUFMURMCVNPCQQRFCK QRFCAFMPCMEP?NFCPQQR?RCBB?LACBMCQLMRPCOSGPCRFCSQCMD
J?LES?EC QRFCB?R?QSEECQRQ?LGLRCEP?RGMLMDB?LACGLRMRFC'$ASPPGASJSKAMSJBNPMTC
RM @C TCPW DPSGRDSJ ?ARGLE ?Q ?L ?AAMKN?LGKCLR RM PCESJ?P FGQRMPW JCQQMLQ (R MDDCPQ ?L
MNNMPRSLGRW DMP QRSBCLRQ RM CVNPCQQ ?LB RM BC?J UGRF CKMRGMLQ QSPPMSLBGLE RFC RMNGA (R
QFMSJB @C GLAJSBCB GL RFC ASPPGASJSK ?Q ? LMLEP?BCB AJ?QQ ?LB MDDCPCB ?Q ?L MNRGML?J
KMBSJC "CPCKMLGCQ ?PC NCPACGTCB ?Q ?L CVACNRGML CQNCAG?JJW @W & (L ECLCP?J RFC
GLRCPTGCUCB QRSBCLRQ A?KC SN UGRF RFC GBC? MD @CGLE GLTMJTCB GL RFC BCTCJMNKCLR MD ?
ASPPGASJSKML2$GL(QP?CJGFGEFQAFMMJQ 3FCGLRCPTGCUCBQRSBCLRQAJ?GKRFC RMNGAF?Q RM
@CK?BC PCJCT?LRRMRFCK @WRFCRC?AFCPQUFGAF KC?LQ?L GLAPC?QCB DMASQMLRFCGP MUL
ECLCP?RGML?JL?PP?RGTC(LD?AR@?QCBMLRFCNPCQCLRCBBCDGLGRGMLMD SQBPSAIQR?LX?LB#$
B?LACA?LCL?@JCQRSBCLRQRMDMASQMLRFCGPMULECLCP?RGML?JL?PP?RGTC3FGQGBC?GQDSPRFCP
QSNNMPRCB@WRFCNPCQCLRCBASPPGASJSKSQGLEB?LAC Q?SLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?ECQRSBCLRQUMSJB
OLNHWRIRFXVRQ³1HYHUDJDLQWRDQ\RQH´LQVWHDGRI³1HYHUDJDLQWRXV´$V&RKHQSRLQWV
RXW³7KHUHLVDQHHGIRUDEDODQFHRI³SDUWLFXODUDVSHFWV´DQGXQLYHUVDOPHVVDJHV´&RKCL
N
.TCP?JJ?JJMDRFCGLRCPTGCUCBFGQRMPWRC?AFCPQQF?PCRFGQ?QQSKNRGML3FCQRSBCLRQNCPACGTC
GR?QSLSQS?JRF?RRFCRMNGAGQR?SEFRJGICCTCPWMRFCPQS@HCARCTCLRFMSEF?JMRMDCKMRGMLQ
?PGQCQSPPMSLBGLEGR&&?QUCJJ?Q&NCPACGTCFGQRMPGA?JILMUJCBECRM@CGKNMPR?LR
@SR?JQMCOS?JGLT?JSCRMRFCQRSBCLRQlDCCJGLEQRFMSEFRQMNGLGMLQ?LBGBC?QPCE?PBGLERFC
RMNGAUFGAFRFCWF?TCLMRK?L?ECBRMAF?LLCJ3FC2FM?FGQNCPACGTCB@WRFCQ?KNJCLMR
DV ³SDVW KLVWRU\³ 7HDFKHUV VRSBCLRQ ?LB AFMPCMEP?NFCPQ AJC?PJW QF?PC RFGQ MNGLGML
QNCAG?JAJ?QQ ?AAMKN?LWGLE PCESJ?P '$ UMSJB ?JJMU RFC QRSBCLRQ RM DMASQ ML RFCGP MUL
L?PP?RGTCQRFMSEFRQ CKMRGMLQ?LB GBC?QGLMPBCPRME?GL ?LCKMRGML?J SLBCPQR?LBGLEMD
RFCRMNGA
SQBPSAIQR?LXU?Q? KMTCKCLRRF?R BCTCJMNCBGL$SPMNC DPMK?@MSRRFCWC?PGLPCQNMLQCRMRFC
PCQRPGARCB?CQRFCRGAQ MDAJ?QQGA?J B?LAC RFCAJ?QQGA?J @?JJCR/CRCP N 3FC ICW NPMR?EMLGQRMD RFGQ
KMTCKCLRGL&CPK?LWU?Q,?PW6GEK?L
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
/=CH<=GFCB#C@C86HFG 9H86G>CB>B$FE6:@>=><=F8=CC@ 9H86G>CB
3FC GLRCPTGCUQ UCPC GL ECLCP?J FMKMECLCMSQ GL RCPKQ MD UF?R U?Q Q?GB 3FC Q?KNJC
PC?ARCBLCE?RGTCJWRMU?PBQ QRPMLE N?RPGMRGQK ?LB 9GMLGQK &CQNCAG?JJW APGRGAGXCQ RFCQC
?QNCARQMD2$GL(QP?CJGQR?RCFGEFQAFMMJQUFGAF %CJBK?L N BCQAPG@CQ?Q ?L
CDDCARMDRFC /MJ?LBRMSPQ6FCL (?QICBRFCN?PRGAGN?LRQUF?RRFC EM?JMD '$GL(QP?CJGQ
?JJMD RFCKRMJBKC UF?RRFC EM?JDPMKRFCGP NCPQNCARGTCQQFMSJB@C P?RFCPRF?LUF?R RFC
?ARS?JEM?JGQ3MRFCK'$F?Q?EMTCPLKCLR?J?LBNMJGRGA?JSQCRFCHSQRGDGA?RGMLMDRFC
2R?RCMD (QP?CJ GRQQCJDBCDCLQC?LB AMKKCKMP?RGML ?LBPCKCK@P?LACGL RCPKQ MD
Ä1HYHU DJDLQ WR XV´ $FFRUGLQJ WR &RKHQ WKH +RORFDXVW KDV µPXOWLSOH JRDOV¶ LQ ,VUDHO
³8QLYHUVDOPHVVDJHVDERXWWROHUDQFHVXSSRUWIRUGHPRFUDFW)CUGQFPCJGEGMSQT?JSCQ?LB
9GMLGQRNMJGRGA?J±QDWLRQDO LGHQWLW\´&RKHQ SS 7KHWHDFKHUV GRQRWYLHZ
RFCQC?QRFCGPNCPQML?J EM?JQUFGJQR RC?AFGLE'MUCTCPRFCPC GQLM U?WMD CQA?NGLERFCQC
JRDOV ZKHQ HQWZLQHG ZLWKLQ LQVWLWXWLRQDO SROLWLFV $V &RKHQ VWDWHV ³7KHUH ZDV DQ
GLRCPCQRGLEGLRCP?ARGML@CRUCCLNCB?EMEGA?NNPM?AF?LBEM?JQ3FCRC?AFCPQUFMUCPCKMQR
AMLACPLCB UGRF QRPCLERFCLGLE )CUGQF ?LB (QP?CJG GBCLRGRW RFPMSEF 2$ QRPCQQCB SQGLE ?
FRPELQDWLRQRIFRJQLWLYHDQGH[SHULHQWLDOPHWKRGV´LELGS1RQHRIWKHLQWHUYLHZHG
RC?AFCPQUCPCAMLACPLCBUGRF³VWUHQJWKHQLQJ-HZLVKDQG,VUDHOLLGHQWLW\WKURXJK6KRDK
HGXFDWLRQ´LELG*,QWHUYLHZ9)HEUXDU\
3C?AFGLERFC'MJMA?SQRRFPMSEF#?LAC
6FCLGRAMKCQRMRFCOSCQRGMLMDRFCSQ?ECMDB?LAC?Q?KCBGSK DMPRC?AFGLE ?@MSRRFC
'MJMA?SQRQRSBCLRQ?Q UCJJ ?Q RC?AFCPQ APGRGOSCBRFCPCJ?RGMLQFGN@CRUCCL B?LAC ?LB RFC
RMNGA MD RFC 'MJMA?SQR UGRF N?PRGASJ?P PCJ?RGML RM RFC 8MK '?2FM?F ACPCKMLGCQ 3FGQ
CVNMQSPC?QGRGQ@?QCBMLPCNPCQCLRGLERFC2FM?FFGQRMPGA?JD?ARQMLQR?ECD?GJQRMCL?@JC
RFCKRM AMLLCARUGRF RFCB?LAC Q QR?RCB?@MTCLMLCMDRFC GLRCPTGCUCCQUCPCD?KGJG?P
UGRFRFC ASPPGASJSK UFGAFSQCQ?PR GL N?PRGASJ?P RMRC?AF?@MSR RFC 2FM?F %SPRFCPKMPC
RFCGP PCACLR ILMUJCBEC MDRFC SQ?EC MD B?LAC K?ICQ RFCK OSCQRGML B?LAC ?Q ? RC?AFGLE
KCRFMB .D RFC QRSBCLRQ LMLC MD RFCK UCPC AMLTGLACB RF?R B?LAC AMSJB @C SQCB RM
CLAMSP?ECAPGRGA?JRFGLIGLE?LBRMCTMJTC?LCKMRGML?JSLBCPQR?LBGLEMDRFC'MJMA?SQR Q
B?LACGLECLCP?JGQLMRGLAJSBCBGLQAFMMJASPPGASJ?RFGQK?ICQGRF?PBRMDMQRCP?LCKMRGML?J
AMLLCARGML UGRF RFC 'MJMA?SQR SQGLE B?LAC ?Q ? N?PRGASJ?P KCBGSK .SR MD ?JJ MD RFC
GLRCPTGCUCCQ?KMLERFCRC?AFCPQ?LBQRSBCLRQMLJWMLCRC?AFCPQR?RCBRF?RFCNCPACGTCB?
QRPMLEAMLLCARGML@CRUCCL'$?LBB?LAC?QFGQQGQRCPGQ?B?LACP?LBRMFGKRFCAMLLCARGML
K?BCQCLQCDPMKRFC@CEGLLGLE-CTCPRFCJCQQ?JJGLRCPTGCUCCQ?DDGPKCBRFCSQCMDB?LAC?Q
? RMMJ @CGLE SQCB ?DRCP QRSBWGLE ?LB M@R?GLGLE FGQRMPGA?J ILMUJCBEC3FGQ UMSJB CL?@JC
QRSBCLRQRMDMASQML RFCGPCKMRGMLQ ?LB ML RFC QS@HCAR RFPMSEF ?L MNRGML?J AJ?QQ UFGAF
UMSJB@CAMLBSARCBGLN?P?JJCJRMPCESJ?PFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQML'$3FCQRSBCLRQ?PCR?IGLERFC
KMQR?ARGTC N?PR GLRFGQNPMACQQ?Q RFCW F?TC ?QRPMLEUGQF RM AF?LEC ASPPCLR2$?LB RM
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
FRQQHFWLW WR DEURDGHUZRUOGYLHZ7KH VWXGHQWV¶ ZLVKHVFRXOGEH VXSSRUWHG WKURXJK WKH
SQ?ECMD RFC NPCQCLRCBASPPGASJSKUFGAF SQCQ B?LAC?Q? RMMJ RMRC?AF?@MSRRFC 2FM?F
$TCLRFMSEF?JJRFC GLRCPTGCUCCQQR?RC RF?RRFCWUMSJBJGICRMAF?LEC'$ RFCWLCTCP ?PC
EGTCL RFC PMMK RM QC?PAF DMP FMU RM AF?LEC GR MP CTCL RM BGQASQQ GR "MSJB RFGQ @C RFC
MNCLGLEDMPBGQASQQGMLQRMR?ICNJ?ACUFGAF?JJMUDMPRFCAMJJCARGMLMDRFMSEFRQ?LBGBC?Q
GLMPBCPRMAPC?RC?NPCNPMEP?K GLAMJJ?@MP?RGML UGRFQAFMMJQ UFGAFSQCQ RFCNPCQCLR?PR
ASPPGASJSK
&&?LB &?PC?U?PCMDRFC D?ARRF?RRFCL?PP?RGTCMD'$UGJJAF?LECUGRFGLRFC LCVR
DCUWC?PQBSCRMRFCD?ARRF?RRFCJ?QRQSPTGTMPQUGJJD?JJQGJCLR Q?QRSBCLRQR?RCBGRUGJJ@C
SNRMRFCK RM APC?RC RFCGP MULL?PP?RGTCQSPPMSLBGLERFC 'MJMA?SQR PR A?L QSNNMPRRFC
FUHDWLRQRIWKHVWXGHQWV¶RZQQDUUDWLYHDVWKHUHYLHZHGFXUULFXOXPVKRZHG
NNPM?AFCQ RM '$ F?TC ?PES?@JW LMR AF?LECB BP?QRGA?JJW GL RFC J?QR LSK@CP MD WC?PQ
&XUUHQWDSSURDFKHV QHLWKHUDOORZVWXGHQWV WRIRFXVRQ-HZLVKLGHQWLW\ IURPWKHVWXGHQWV¶
NCPQNCARGTCQLMP RMDMASQML QF?NGLE?LGLBGTGBS?J GBCLRGRWPCJ?RCB RMRFC'MJMA?SQR ?Q?
FGQRMPGA?JCTCLR 3FGQ @CAMKCQAJC?PUFCLRFC RUM (QP?CJGAFMPCMEP?NFCPQDMPK RFC Q?KC
APGRGAGQKQ?QRFCQRSBCLRQ#?LAC?Q?KCRFMBMDDCPQ?AMLRPG@SRGMLRMPCACLR?LBDSRSPC'$
GL(QP?CJLMRGLRCPKQMD@CGLESQCBDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC'MJMA?SQRGLFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQ?LB
RC?AFGLE ?@MSR FGQRMPGA?J D?ARQ @SR P?RFCP DMP ?JJMUGLE QRSBCLRQ RM CTMJTC ?L CKMRGML?J
SLBCPQR?LBGLEQSPPMSLBGLERFCFGQRMPGA?J CTCLRQ MD RFC 'MJMA?SQR3FGQ AMSJB CL?@JC ?LB
MDDCP QRSBCLRQ RFC NMQQG@GJGRW MD AF?LLCJGLE ?LB PCDJCARGLE ML RFCGP GBC?Q CKMRGMLQ ?LB
?QQMAG?RGMLQPCJ?RCBRMRFC'MJMA?SQR?Q&BGBGLRFCGPNGCACQ?LBRFPMSEFRFCNPCQCLRCB
BGDDCPCLRRWNCQMDNCPDMPK?LACQ?LBKMTCKCLR?NNPM?AFCQ3FCQ?KNJCNCPACGTCQRFGQDMASQ
?Q?EM?JRF?RQFMSJB@C?BBPCQQCBGLASPPCLR'$?QRFCDGL?JUGRLCQQCQUGJJD?JJQGJCLRGLRFC
LC?PDSRSPC QRFCQRSBCLRQ?LBRFCRC?AFCPQQR?RCBGRGQSNRMRFCLCVRECLCP?RGMLRMAPC?RC
RFCGPMULL?PP?RGTCQQSPPMSLBGLERFC'MJMA?SQR
*)'0.$*)
3FCAMLBSARCBPCQC?PAFCL?@JCBQRSBCLRQ&RC?AFCPQ&?LBAFMPCMEP?NFCPQ&RM
BGQASQQRFCGPNCPACNRGMLQMDPCACLR'$GL(QP?CJ?LBRFCSQCMDB?LACDMPRC?AFGLE?@MSRRFC
'MJMA?SQR 3FCW OSCQRGMLCB RFC PMJC RF?R #$ AMSJB NJ?W UGRFGL '$ ?LB UF?R GR AMSJB
AMLRPG@SRCRMRFCDGCJBMDFGEFQAFMMJCBSA?RGML'$GL(QP?CJ
3FC BGQASQQGML QFMUCB RF?R RFCQ?KNJC RFGLIQ RF?R RUM QGELGDGA?LR ?QNCARQ MD RFC PCACLR
ASPPGASJSKML'$LCCBRM@C?JRCPCB%GPQRJW&UGQFCQRM@CGLAJSBCBGLRFCBCTCJMNKCLR
MD?ASPPGASJSKML2$2CAMLBJWB?LACQFMSJB@CSRGJGXCBGL?L?BBGRGML?JLMLEP?BCBAJ?QQ
UFGAFQFMSJB@CMNRGML?J?LBQFMSJBPSLN?P?JJCJRMPCESJ?P?LBK?LB?RMPWFGQRMPWAJ?QQCQ
3FGQ?BBGRGML?JMDDCPGQNCPACGTCB@WRFCQ?KNJC&&&?Q ?LMNNMPRSLGRWRMDMASQ
MLRFCQRSBCLRQRFCGPL?PP?RGTCQ?LBRFMSEFRQMLRFCRMNGARFSQCL?@JGLERFCKRMAPC?RC?LB
DGLBRFCGPMUL L?PP?RGTCQ3FCQRSBCLRQNMGLRCBMSRRFCD?AR RF?RGLRFCLC?PDSRSPC RFCJ?QR
UGRLCQQCQUGJJLMR@C?T?GJ?@JCRMEGTCRFCGPRCQRGKMLGCQ?LWJMLECP
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
3FCPCDMPC&QCCGR?QSPECLRRMDMPKRFCGPMULL?PP?RGTCQMLRFCRMNGA?QRFCJ?QRUGRLCQQCQ
UGJJD?JJQGJCLRGLRFCQMMLCPDSRSPC
.TCP?JJ RFC BGQASQQGML QFMUCB RF?R RFC QGV DMSLB RFCKCQ KCPEC UGRF MLC ?LMRFCP ?LB
GLRCP?ARGL ? AGPASJ?RGTC K?LLCPP?RFCPRF?L QR?LBGLE MLRFCGPMUL Q RFC RFCKCQQFMU
PCACLR'$ AMTCPQ? T?PGCRWMD ?QNCARQDPMK8MK'?2FM?FACPCKMLGCQ RMPCESJ?P FGQRMPW
AJ?QQCQUFGAFDMASQMLM@R?GLGLEFGQRMPGA?JILMUJCBECMLRFC'MJMA?SQRP?RFCPRF?LMLRFC
CTCLRQ MD 66 (( (L RFCQC AJ?QQCQ RFC CKNF?QGQ GQ LC?PJW CVAJSQGTCJW ML RFC )CUGQF
NCPQNCARGTC UFGAF & GL N?PRGASJ?P NCPACGTCQ ?Q ?L ?AR MD NMJGRGA?J QMAG?JGX?RGML 3FC
QRSBCLRQ?JQM OSCQRGMLRFGQ ?NNPM?AF ?QRFCW UGQFRMDMASQ MLRFCGP MNGLGMLMLRFC RMNGA
@?QCBML RFC D?AR RF?R RFC J?QR UGRLCQQCQ UGJJ D?JJ QGJCLR GL RFC LC?P DSRSPC 3GKCNJ?WQ?
QGELGDGA?LRPMJCGL RFCRC?AFGLE DP?KCUMPIDMPRFCQS@HCARUFGAF A?SQCQRC?AFCPQ RMDMASQ
RMM KSAF ML )CUGQF GBCLRGRW "MKKCKMP?RGML ?LB 1CKCK@P?LAC ?PC NCPACGTCB ?Q
GKNMPR?LR8CRRFCQ?KNJCFGEFJGEFRCBRF?R?EPC?RCPAMLLCARGMLRMASPPCLRNMJGRGA?JCTCLRQ
GQPCOSGPCB%MP GLQR?LAC RFPMSEF PCESJ?PRC?AFGLEKCRFMBQ QRSBCLRQ LCGRFCP JC?PL?@MSR
RFCRCPK&CLMAGBCLMP?@MSR MRFCPQNCAGDGA A?QCQRSBGCQ QSAF?Q RFC PKCLG?L 1U?LB?L
MP"?K@MBG?L&CLMAGBCQ
8CRRFCGLRCPTGCUCBQRSBCLRQOSCQRGMLRFCPCACLR?NNPM?AFMD'$?QRFCWUMLBCPUF?RRFCW
QFMSJBECRMSRMD2$3FCGLRCPTGCUCBQRSBCLRQ&NMGLRMSRRF?RRFCPCGQ?QRPMLEQMAGM
FGQRMPGA?J ?LB NMJGRGA?J CKNF?QGQ NSR ML RFC )CUGQF NCPQNCARGTC GL AMLLCARGML UGRF
AMLRCKNMP?PWQMAGMNMJGRGA?JF?NNCLGLEQQSAF?Q QWJSK2CCICPQDPMK DPGA?AMKGLERM
(QP?CJ?LBRFC2WPG?LPCDSECCAPGQGQGL$SPMNC3FCGLRCPTGCUCBQRSBCLRQOSCQRGMLUF?RRFC
KCQQ?ECMD'$ GQGLRCPKQMD? @PM?BCPUMPJBTGCU AAMPBGLERMRFCK RFGQ?QNCARGQLMR
@CGLEQSDDGAGCLRJW?BBPCQQCBRFPMSEFPCESJ?PRC?AFGLEKCRFMBQGL'$
JJGLRCPTGCUCCQ & & & QR?RCB RFC UGQF RM DMASQ KMPC ML BCKMAP?RGAT?JSCQ?LB
SLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?ECQGLMPBCPRMNPCTCLRDSRSPCECLMAGBCQ?LBRMAMSLRCP?ARMLEMGLEF?RPCB
VCLMNFM@G??LB P?AGQKGL (QP?CJ?LB @CWMLB%MASQGLEMLSLGTCPQ?JKCQQ?ECQ UGRFGL'$
?LB'2BMCQLMRKC?LRMAMLBSARAMKNCRGRGTCTGARGKFMMBMPAMKNCRGRGTCQSDDCPGLEGLRCPKQ
MDAMKN?PGLE &CLMAGBCQ UMPJBUGBC UGRFMLC?LMRFCP 1MRF@CPENN>GLE
XQLYHUVDO PHVVDJHV RIIHUV WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR ³ GHYHORS D PRUH FRPSUHKHQVLYH
XQGHUVWDQGLQJ´LELGSRQDEURDGHUZRUOG
TGCU
*74>;>20DBC 70 B144= 34?82C43 8= E0A8>DB 5>A<B >5 2>=C4<?>A0AH
DQG PRGHUQ DUW IURP GLIIHUHQW QDUUDWLYHV RI WKH VXUYLYRUV WKH VXUYLYRUV· FKLOGUHQ WR WKH
5>;;>F8=6 64=4A0C8>=B ,8BD0; 0=3 ?4A5>A<0C8E4 0AC 20= >554A 0 F0H C> 4G?A4BB C> 340; F8C7
B><4C78=6C>A45;42CC>?A>C4BC>AC>A4B8BC%DA;42CDA4F8;;?A4B4=C0A4B40A27F782738B2DBB4B
C74DB4>530=245>AC40278=601>DCC74>;>20DBC8= 4F8B7BA04;87867B27>>;B43D20C8>=;43
1HBCD34=CBC40274AB0=327>A4>6A0?74ABD=34ABC0=38=6B4G?;>A8=630=240B 0=43D20 C8>=0;
C>>;5>AC40278=601>DCC74>;>20DBC8=BA04;87867B27>>;B*78BA4B40A2708<BF0BC>4G?;>A4
BCD34=CBSC40274ABS0=327>A4>6A0?74ABS2DAA4=CD=34ABC0=38=6B>5>;>20DBC3D20C8>=0=3
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
C>38B2DBB30=24 0B0C>>; 5>AC40278=601>DCC74>;>20DBC *74<4C7>3>;>6H 8B0@D0;8C0C8E4
4<?8A820; 0??A>027 )4<8BCAD2CDA43 =0AA0C8E4 8=C4AE84FB F4A4 2>=3D2C43 F8C7
?0AC828?0=CB2><?A8B43 >558E4 BA04;8BCD34=CB58E4C40274AB8= BA04;87867 B27>>;B0=3 58E4
27>A4>6A0?74AB 5A>< C74 8=C4A=0C8>=0; 584;3 7KH ILQGLQJV VKRZWKHVWXGHQWV· WHDFKHUV· DQG
FKRUHRJUDSKHUV·KDYHLQGLYLGXDODSSURDFKHV XQGHUVWDQGLQJV DQGSHUFHSWLRQV FRQFHUQLQJWKH
>;>20DBCC>?82 = 0338C8>=30=248B F834B?A4038=2;D3438= A424=C >;>20DBC3D20C8>= 8=
BA04;87867 B27>>;B 0=24 8BDB430B 0= >?C8>=0;2;0BB 8= >A34A C>4G?A4BB 0=3 C> 340;F8C7
>=4B544;8=6B >= C74 C>?820=24 >554AB C>8=2;D34D=8E4AB0; <4BB064B 8=>;>20DBC )CD384B
*74 8=C4AE84F43 BCD34=C ?>B8C C74 544;8=6 >5 148=6 ?>;8C820; B>280;8I43 0=3 F8B7 ?>;8C820;
<4BB064BF>D;364C;45C>DC>5>;>20DBC)CD384BB>C74H2>D;3 5>2DB>=C748A>F=8=38E83D0;
D=34ABC0=38=6>=C74C>?82A0C74AC70=BCD3H8=6C74C>?825A><C74?4AB?42C8E4B>52>=BCAD2C8=6
BCA>=64A 4F8B734=C8C84B
!4HF>A3B >;>20DBC 3D20C8>= BA04; 0=24 3D20C8>= ,8BD0; ACB 0=3 C74 >;>20DBC
2><<4<>A0C8>=0=3A4<4<1A0=24
- ! - ) .
E8=>I:F
*G@@SRX&?l?RML#?LAC5GJJ?EC(QP?CJ-CUQN?NCP?PRGAJCQGLRCPL?RGML?JB=>(>FHBK>
+MJ?1MEEC2AFMMJ'?K@SPE&CPK?LW/CPDMPK?LAC#MQQGCP/A>KHD>G2BG@
5GQS?J PR"CLRCP8?B5?QFCK(QP?CJB=>(>FHBK>@W1?KG!CCP
*E=HNGMKR@W JJCL*?CH?
.:K:A@W JJCL*?CH?
.:8CB96EL.CHE8:F
QFJCW + :G<BG@ PBMA B??>K>G<> NEMNK:EER BO>KL> :G<>L BG =N<:MBHG 2CLQC /S@JGQFCPQ
1MRRCPB?K!MQRML3?GNCG
QQK?L) "X?NJGAI?) HEE><MBO>(>FHKR :G=NEMNK:E $=>GMBMR-C U&CPK?L "PGRGOSC-M
"SJRSP?J'GQRMPW"SJRSP?J2RSBGCQ2NPGLE2SKKCPNN
!?SK?LL9 !KHFRLM:G=>K MH<MHK )MSPL?JMD 'SK?L1GEFRQ 5MJ(QQSC NN
!J?QGSQ),N:EBM:MBO>$GA:EML:G:ERL>$G:NK)E:LBNL%#:G=;N<A(>MAH=>G=>K FIBKBL<A>G
.HSB:E?HKL<ANG@ SDJ?EC6GCQ@?BCL2NPGLECP%?AFKCBGCL
!G?JC# ->MABGDBG@ MA>#HEH<:NLM +HP>K+:LLBOBMR:G= MA>'>@:<R H?MA>#HEH<:NLM 3GIISL
0S?PRCPJW)CUGQF"PGRGOSCMD/MJGRGAQ"SJRSPC?LB2MAGCRW6GLRCP5MJ-MNN
!GLE'CGBCAICP+#HPMH=:G<>:?M>KNL<APBMS MAB<L:G=>LMA>MB<LH?->IK>L>GM:MBHG BG%HAG
K:GDH`L.HG@H?FR +>HIE>!HK>LM+>HIE>.>:"MLEPCQQ MLPCQC?PAFGLB? LAC#1)5MJ (QQSC
NN
!P?LQRCRRCP&*JCGL&(>MAH=>G=>K/:GSPBLL>GL<A:?M(H=>EE:G:ERL>GSN+BG::NL<AL'>.:<K>
=N+KBGM>FIL :L !K^AEBG@LHI?>K i@CP?P@CGRCRCSLB CPUCGRCPRC -CS?SDJ?EC 3P?LQAPGNR 5CPJ?E
!GCJCDCJB
!PMULGLE" /A> *KB@BGLH? MA> !BG:E .HENMBHG/A> OHENMBHG H? ):SB %>PBLA+HEB<R.>IM>F;>K
(:K<A $BGRMP ,?RRF`SQ , 8?B 5?QFCK RFC 'MJMA?SQR ,?PRWPQ> ?LB 'CPMCQ>
1CKCK@P?LAC SRFMPGRW)CPSQ?JCK
!SPJCQML)# N@NLMH H:EL/A>:MK>H? MA>*IIK>LL>=BG MA>+N;EB< .I>:DBG@:G=$GM>KI>KLHG:E
HFFNGB<:MBHG<E:LLKHHFL+24#MARMP?J#GQQCPR?RGMLQ
"MFCL $ ' 7HDFKHU DXWRQRP\ ZLWKLQ D ÀH[LEOH QDWLRQDO FXUULFXOXP GHYHORSPHQW RI 6KRDK
AHEH<:NLM>=N<:MBHGBG$LK:>EBLM:M>L<AHHEL)"SPPGASJSK2RSBGCQ5MJ(QQSCNN
"MFCL$'$=>GMBMR:G=I>=:@H@R.AH:A>=N<:MBHGBG$LK:>EBLM:M>L<AHHEL!MQRML, A?BCKGA
2RSBGCQ/PCQQ
"MLDGLM HEE><MBO>(>FHKR:G=NEMNK:E#BLMHKR+KH;E>FLH?(>MAH=3FC KCPGA?L' GQRMPGA?J
1CTGCU5MJ(QQSC#CACK@CPNN
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
"fRb ) $=>GMBMR .MN=B>L #HP EHL> K> 2> MH >O>EHIBG@ : .H<B:E .<B>G<> H?$=>GMBMR G
IIK:BL:EH?MA>!B>E=(BCLRGRW L(LRCPL?RGML?J)MSPL?JMD 3FCMPW?LB1CQC?PAF5MJ(QQSCNN
"P?NQ21MRF@CPE,$GMKH=N<MBHG/K:GL<NEMNK:E)>@HMB:MBHGL H?#HEH<:NLM(>FHKR "PGRGAGQK
5MJ(QQSC PRGAJCNN
%CBCPK?L# !? LB6GLRCPQRCGL 3 2RCPCLDCJB & 9 /A> ;H=R :L : G:KK:MHK H=R FHO>F>GM
F>FHKR:G=MA>EB?>LMHKB>LH?AHEH<:NLMLNKOBOHKL)MSPL?JM D+MQQ?LB3P?SK?5MJ(QQSCNN
%CJBK?L ) (:KDBG@ MA> HNG=:KB>L H? MA> G<E:O> >?BGBG@ MA> $LK:>EB <HEE><MBO> MAKHN@A MA>
+HE:G=>QI>KB>G<>(QP?CJ2RSBGCQ5MJ(QQSCNN
%JGAI 4 ,N:EBM:MBO> .HSB:E?HKL<ANG@ BG> BG?^AKNG@ SDJ?EC '?K@SPE 1MUMFJR 5CPJ?E
&K@'
%P?JCGEF2HGL<BHNLG>LL(:MM>KL#?LAC1CQC?PAF)MSPL?J#?LAC%?ASJRW/S@JGA?RGMLQNN
%P?JCGEF2 :G<> :G= MA> 'BO>= H=R >L<KBIMBO> >LMA>MB<L 4LGTCPQGRW MD /GRRQ@SPEF /PCQQ
/GRRQ@SPEF
%PGCBJ`LBCP2):SB">KF:GR:G=MA>%>PL.PGML!MMIQ+MLBML
&PCCL).HF:MB<DGHPE>=@>/A>;H=R:L<HGM>GM :G=F>MAH=HEH@RBG=:G<> >=N<:MBHG)MSPL?JMD
#?LAC$BSA?RGML5MJ(QQSCNN
&PMQQ 9 2RCTGAI $# L MA> 2BMG>LL>L !:EE .BE>GM LM >GMNKR #HEH<:NLM =N<:MBHG BG
NKKB<NENF+HEB<R:G=+K:<MB<>2UGRXCPJ?LB2NPGLECP(LRCPL?RGML?J/S@JGQFGLE
&PMQQ 9 /RIHEH@R ?HK MA> >O>EHIF>GM H? #HEH<:NLM =N<:MBHG .<AHE:KLABI HIBG@ PBMA :
):MBHG:E/K:NF:"SPPGASJSK?LB3C?AFGLE5MJ(QQSCNN
&PMQQ9#HEH<:NLM>=N<:MBHG BG%>PBLAL<AHHELBG$LK:>E"H:EL=BE>FF:L<A:EE>G@>L/PMQNCARQ
5MJ(QQSCNN
'?LL? ) + )HGO>K;:E ':G@N:@> ?HK $F:@BGBG@ :G= '>:KGBG@ :G<> =N<:MBHG BG &
NKKB<NENF$BSA?RGML?J1CQC?PAFCP5MJ(QQSCNN
'?PR # "?PJM & (HK:E >O>EHIF>GM BG =HE>L<>G<> %?ASJRW /S@JGA?RGMLQ #CN?PRKCLR MD
/QWAFMJMEW)MSPL?JMD1CQC?PAFML BMJCQACLAC5MJ(QQSC2CNRCK@CPNN
'?QRW!PCLR $BU?PB $G L>:K<AH? MA> =>>IIHEBMB< 'B@AM/A> #HEH<:NLM:G= #NF:GBMR +KHC><M:G
:KML>=N<:MBHG:G=<BOB<I:KMG>KLABI#GQQCPR?RGML4LGTCPQGRWMD3CV?Q?R SQRGL SQRGL
'GJ@CPE1/A>>LMKN<MBHGH?MA> NKHI>:G%>PL$BGRGML8?JC4LGTCPQGRW/PCQQ'?TCL
'M@@CQ3'>OB:MA:G$BGRMP*JCLLCP'/FGJMQMNFGQAFC!G@JMRFCI%CJGV,CGLCP5CPJ?E'?K@SPE
'MJR-+HLBMBO>4HNMA>O>EHIF>GM/AKHN@A.IHKM$BGRGML1MSRJCBEC+MLBML?LB-CU8MPI
'MPQR+1SQQCJJ "(H=>KG :G<>!HKFLBG ->E:MBHGMHMA>HMA>K(H=>KGKML 1CTGQCBCBGRGML
/PGLACRML!MMI"MKN?LW/PGLACRML-CU)CPQCW
*CJK?L' " HFIEB:G<> $=>GMB?B<:MBHG:G= $GM>KG:EBS:MBHG MAK>>IKH<>LL>L H? :MMBMN=><A:G@>
)MSPL?JMDAMLDJGARPCQMJSRGML5MJ(QQSCNN
*CPQF?U( #BME>KMA> ">KF:GL :G= MA> !BG :E .HENMBHG 8?JC 4LGTCPQGRW /PCQQ -CU '?TCL ?LB
+MLBML
*CPQF?U(#BME>K/CLESGL!MMIQ+MLBML
*J?P2AFMPG$W?J?LB*J?P7KH³1HYHU$JDLQ´6WDWHRI,VUDHO7KH(PHUJHQFHRIWKH+RORFDXVWDVD
HK>!>:MNK> H?$LK:>EB $=>GMBMR:G=$ML !HNK$G<HG@KN>GM1HB<>L)MSPL?JMD2MAG?J (QQSCQ5MJ
(QQSCNN
*MDD21,GQRP W&++KH?>LLBHG:EBLFBG=:G<>>=N<:MBHG->L>:K<ABG:G<> =N<:MBHG1CQC?PAF
&?RC5MJ(QQSCNN
+?X?P "F?GRGL) &PMQQ3 !?P.L# %>PBLA $LK:>EBM>>G:@>KL G:MBHG:EB=>GMBMR :G=MA>
E>LLHGLH?MA>#HEH<:NLM'MJMA?SQR?LB&CLMAGBC2RSBGCQ5MJ(QQSCNN
,?WPGLE / !J?QGSQ ) ,N:EBM:MBO> $GA:EML:G:ERL> $G :NK ) E:LBNL % (>MAH=>G =>K
FIBKBL<A>G.HSB:E?HKL<ANG@ SDJ?EC6GCQ@?BCL2NPGLECP%?AFKCBGCL
,GLGQRPWMD$BSA?RGML(QP?CJ/A>KM>I:KMF>GM/A>#HEH<:NLMMAKHN@AMA>'HHDBG@"E:LLH?KML
,GLGQRPWMD$BSA?RGML(QP?CJ
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
-MP?/ >MP>>G (>FHKR :G= #BLMHKR '>L 'B>NQ => ([FHBK> 1CNPCQCLR?RGMLQ -M 2NCAG?J
(QQSC,CKMPW?LB"MSLRCP,CKMPWNN
/CRCP %, 5PBL<A>G NL=KN<DLM:GS NG= +HLMFH=>KG :G<> HK> #HR>KL >BMK:@ SNK
2>BM>K>GMPB<DENG@=>LFH=>KG>G/:GS>LBG=>G>K%:AK>G(L?SESP?J#GQQCPR?RGML%?AF@CPCGAF
/FGJMQMNFGCSLB&CGQRCQUGQQCLQAF?DRCL%PCGCL4LGTCPQGR`R!CPJGL
/CRXCP3/:GSNG=/K:NF:AHK>H@K:?BL<A>">=Y<AMGBL?HKF>GG:<ANL<APBMS(L*GJAFK?LL$
KM>?K:DM>#HEH<:NLMNG=5P>BM>K2>EDKB>@BG >QI>KBF>GM>EE>G:KLM>EENG@L?HKF>GBG'BM>K:MNKNG=
&NGLM*gJL6CGK?P6GCL!gFJ?S5CPJ?E
/MP?R#!KHFMA>.<:G=:EMHMA>#HEH<:NLMBG $LK:>EB =N<:MBHG)MSPL?JMD"MLRCKNMP?PW'GQRMPW
"MNWPGEFR2 &$ /S@JGA?RGMLQ+MLBML 3FMSQ?LB.?IQ" ?LB-CU#CJFG5MJ (QQSC NN
±
1CGLCPQ ! *L?SRF * NL=KN<DL@RFG:LMBD NG= NL=KN<DLM:GS /:GS ;BE=>M .BGG> !CPJGL
'CGBCJ@CPE2NPGLECP5CPJ?E
1MRRCL@CPE'-:FB>`>K+HEBMB<:EAHK>H@K:IA>K#GQQCPR?RGML4LGTCPQGRWMD2SPPCW
2?NGPM 5 )HM RHNK+:K>GML9 +HEBMB<:E .H<B:EBS:MBHG $GMKH=N<MBHG ?HK : )>P ">G>K:MBHG LLS?J
1CTGCUQ/MJGRGA?J2AGCLACQ5MJ(QQSCNN
2F?K?G8?PBCLG ?LB*J?ECQ (NEMB<NEMNK:E>=N<:MBHG $LK:>EB:G=">KF:G :=HE>L<>GMLDGHPE>=@>
:G=OB>PLK>@:K=BG@MA>#HEH<:NLM BMJCQACLAC-MNN
2KGRF SR?PB),:G<>HFIHLBMBHG$BGRGML "!J?AI+MLBML
2RCTGAI$ # ,GAF?CJQ #+ FIBKB<:E:G= )HKF:MBO>!HNG=:MBHGLH? #HEH<:NLM>=N<:MBHG
KBG@BG@K>L>:K<A:G=:=OH<:<RBGMH=B:EH@N>(LRCPASJRSP?J$BSA?RGML5MJ(QQSCNN
2RPgK@MK + ->OBLBMBG@ MA> +:LM $LK:>EB B=>GMBMRMAB<D K><H@GBMBHG :G= <HG?EB<M MK:GL?HKF:MBHG
#CN?PRKCLRMD/MJGRGA?J2AGCLAC+SLB4LGTCPQGRW
2NPW3 +>K?HKFBG@ NMH>MAGH@K:IARG F;H=B>= (>MAH=HEH@B<:E +K:QBL 0S?JGR?RGTC (LOSGPW
5MJ(QQSCNN
2AFSJXC1CS@CP1:L/:GSMA>:M>K+BG::NL<A.IB>@>E=>K">L>EEL<A:?Mi@CP?P@CGRCRC SDJ?EC
1&%GQAFCP5CPJ?E%P?LIDSPR?,
2AFSJRX+ '!?PP #) 2CJK?L1 + /A> O:EN>H? :=>O>EHIF>GM:E:IIKH:<AMH >O:EN:MBG@
<A:K:<M>K=>O>EHIF>GMIKH@K:FF>LG HNM<HF>LMN=RH?!:<BG@#BLMHKR:G=*NKL>EO>L )MSPL?JMD
,MP?J$BSA?RGML5MJ(QQSCNN
5MJJF?PBR ) 1 ³&ULPH DJDLQVW +XPDQLW\´ RU ³&ULPH DJDLQVW -HZV´" $FNQRZOHGJPHQW LQ
HGLMKN:ELH? MA>#HEH<:NLM:G= $ML $FIHKM:G<>?HK $GM>K@KHNI->E:MBHGL )MSPL?JMD 2MAG?J(QQSCQ
5MJ(QQSCNN
6CJX" /K:NF:F>FHKRM>LMBFHGR +A>GHF>GHEH@B<:E ILR<AHEH@B<:E :G=>MAB<:E I>KLI><MBO>L
)CUGQF2RSBGCQGLRFC-MPBGA"MSLRPGCQ3MB?W2APGNR?( LQRGRSRG#MLLCPG?LG @MCLQGQNN±
6GCQCJ$KM:G=MA>#HEH<:NLM/KBOB:EBSBG@(>FHKR(L-CU8MPI3GKCQ
9CJGXCP!1BLN:E<NEMNK>:G=MA>#HEH<:NLM$BGRGML3FC RFJMLC/PCQQ+MLBML
1>9:C<E6D=L
*?CH? >I:KMNK> NPMBSACB @W *?CH? NPMBSARGMLQGL ?QQMAG?RGML UGRF !P?TM%?AR .RR?U? ?LB
WJKCP0SC@CA#SP?RGML4NJM?BCB,?W
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFTU"WU#&R7FJJ?QR?AACQQCB
*?CH? *E= HNGMKR NPMBSACB@W *?CH?NPMBSARGMLQ /PCKGCPCBML"!" 3CJCTGQGMLQ .NCLGLE
-GEFR ML ,?PAF #SP?RGML 4NJM?BCB %C@PS?PW
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFT?JK,P43UJ?QR?AACQQCB
*?CH? ->LBLM:G<>NPMBSACB@W*?CH?Bl#?LAC%GL?JAF?NRCPGL JJCL*?CH?QQCAMLBRPGJMEW?@MSR
RFC'MJMA?SQR@?QCBML*?CH?lQQR?ECTCPQGML#SP?RGML4NJM?BCB%C@PS?PW
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFTEXD(#H"KNJ?QR?AACQQCB
*?CH? .:K:ABGPCARCB@W JJCL*?CHC?LB,?PI B?K#SP?RGML4NJM?BCB,?W
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFT5FP2$95"V J?QR?AACQQCB
*?CH? ,A*CJJ 3 B?K , 2BMG>LL>=NPMBSACB GL ?QQMAG?RGML UGRF !?PTM %?AR #SP?RGML
4NJM?BCB)SLC
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFT (@XTK4BJDUJ?QR?AACQQCB
$#4" 3(.- -#'4, -1(&'32
*?CH? 5NFF>E PCAMPBCBNCPDMPK?LACAMKKGQQGMLCB @W -.11# -22UCBCL/PMBSACB@W
*?CH? Bl#?LAC%GPQR QCEKCLR MD RFC QCAMLB 'MJMA?SQR RPGJMEW# SP?RGML 4NJM?BCB ,? W
FRRNQUUUWMSRS@CAMKU?RAFT)=CA6@EP MJ?QR?AACQQCB
*B@>B:-:;:E:B8:F
=======!?RRJC1)HEHG@>KLBE>GMUUU?JTGL?GJCWMPENCPDMPK?LACQPCNCPRMPWLMJMLECPQGJCLRJ?QR
?AACQQCB
!?SQAFGLECP2$JQC+?QICP2AFiJCP6C@QGRC)CUGQF6MKCL>Q PAFGTC
UUUHU?MPECLAWAJMNCBG??PRGAJCJ?QICPQAFSCJCPCJQCJ?QR?AACQQCB
=======!ClCP 1 KMBLMB< =BK><MHK -:FB >`>K 6C@QGRC *G@@SRX "MLRCKNMP?PW #?LAC "MKN?LW
UUUIABAAMGJCLP?KG@CCPFRKJJ?QR?AACQQCB
%CJBK?L#!CEGLLGLE'MJMA?SQR$B SA?RGML3FC+MMIQRCGL"CLRCP.LJGLC)MSPL?J6C@QGRC3FC+MMIQRCGL
"CLRCPDMP)CUGQF$BSA?RGMLUUUJMMIQRCGLMPEMLJGLC=HMSPL?JNFNGB
J?QR?AACQQCB
&GJ?B $ /A> *;L<NK> *KB@BGL H? 4HF &BIINK '??PCRX 2CNRCK@CP 2MSPAC )SB?GQK
UUUHCUGQFTGPRS?JJG@P?PWMPEWMKIGNNSPFGQRMPW?LBMTCPTGCUJ?QR?AACQQCB
&?JGJG#%/A>#HEH<:NLMBG(H=>KG:G<>-:FB>`>KHGB=>(>FHBK>)SLC6C@QGRC#?LAC
GL (QP?CJ UUUB?LACGLGQP?CJAMKRFCFMJMA?SQRGLKMBCPLB?LACP?KG@CCPML?GBC
KCKMGPCJ?QR?AACQQCB
&P?TC+?XG+-CU'MJMA?SQR$BSA?RGML/PMEP?KGL(QP?CJRMQR?PRGL*GLBCPE?PRCL NPGJ6C@QGRC
)NMQR -?RGML?J -CUQ UUUHNMQRAMK-?RGML?J-CUQ-CU'MJMA?SQRCBSA?RGMLNPMEP?KGL(QP?CJ
RMQR?PRGLIGLBCPE?PRCLJ?QR?AACQQCB
'?PPGQ)&GG:.HDHEHP)CUGQF6MKCL "MKNPCFCLQGTC'GQRMPGA?J$LAWAJMNCBG?,?PAF
)CUGQF6MKCLQ PAFGTCUUUHU?MPECLAWAJMNCBG??PRGAJCQMIMJMU?LL?J?QR?AACQQCB
========(>G:<ABF >@BG 6C@QGRC )CUGQF 5GPRS?J +G@P?PW /PMHCAR MD GEC
UUUHCUGQFTGPRS?JJG@P?PWMPEKCL?AFCK@CEGL
J?QR?AACQQCB
========,CWCP1MEEC3SPLCPBH@K:IARAKBLMB:G>(>R>K-H@@>/NKG>K6C@QGRC&CPK?L+MJ?1MEEC
2AFSJCUUUJMJ?PMEECQAFSJCBC@CPSDQD?AFQAFSJCIMJJCEGSK
J?QR?AACQQCB
3?S@CP82A:MBL:A:LLB=6C@QGRC"F?@?BMPE
UUUAF?@?BMPEJG@P?PW?PRGAJC=ABM?GBHCUGQF6F?R(Q?"F?QQGBFRK
J?QR?AACQQCB
BBBBBBB6FKXOKRII ( $UWLFOH ³%DQQHG E\ 1D]LV FRPSRVHU¶V ZRUN DSSHDUV RQVWDJH \HDUV ODWHU´
%C@PS?PW 6C@QGRC /!2 -CUQ 'MSP UUUN@QMPELCUQFMSP?PR@?LLCB@WL?XGQ
AMKNMQCPQUMPI?NNC?PQMLQR?ECWC?PQJ?RCP
J?QR?AACQQCB
======8?B 5?QFCK %N=>GK:M 6C@QGRC 8?B 5?QFCK
UUUW?BT?QFCKMPEMBMR=NBD,GAPMQMDR6MPBNBD
J?QR?AACQQCB
=======9GI?PML !?2?JML ;HNM MA> IKHC><M 5BD:KHG : .:EHG 6C@QGRC $LEJGQF 9GI?PML !?Q?JML
UUUXGI?PML@?Q?JMLMPE
J?QR?AACQQCB