Content uploaded by Dini Sejko
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dini Sejko on Feb 25, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
!"#
W!EN UNITE"NATIONS SANCTIONS
IMPACT INTERNATIONAL #INANCIAL
$OVERNANCE%LESSONS #ROM T!ELIBYAN
SOVEREI$NWEALT!#UN"
$%&% '()*+,-&$ $-.(/ )0 1%2*(33,,
%0 %&32+$453%+&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000!"#
%%0 36( -''(3 72((8(00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000!9:
-0 36( %&%3%-. .%'3%&;000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000!9<
10 36( =-23%-. (-'%&;00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000!9>
%%%0 36( 32+41.($ .%7( +7 36( .%- 00000000000000000000000000000!9"
-0 36( .%-?'%&5(=3%+&@ '3245342(@-&$ %&A('3B(&3
'32-3(;/ 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000!9"
10 ;++$ ;+A(2&-&5( -&$ 36( '-&3%-;+ =2%&5%=.('000>CD
50 -E;-B( +7 362+&('F-&$ 36( .+&; '6-$+G +7 36(
2(;%B( 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000>::
%A0 2(A%'%3%&; 36( -''(3 72((8( +& 36( .%-00000000><C
A0 5+&5.4'%+&0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000><D
%0 %&32+$453%+&
3HI .JKLMN %NOIPQRINQ -SQHTUJQL V.%-W JP QHI 'TOIUIJXN GIMYQH
7SNZ V'G7W T[ QHI PQMQI T[ .JKLM MNZ JP QHI KJXXIPQ -[UJ\MN 'G70:
, 2IPIMU\HIU@ %NPQJQSQI [TU (RIUXJNX BMU]IQ 'QSZJIP@ 6TNX *TNX 4NJOIUPJQL T[
'\JIN\I MNZ 3I\HNTYTXL^ =H$ 5MNZJZMQI@ 7M\SYQL T[ .M_@ 3HI 5HJNIPI 4NJOIUPJQL
T[ 6TNX *TNX^ 2IPIMU\H -[[JYJMQI@ 'TOIUIJX&(3@ 3HI 7YIQ\HIU '\HTTY@ 3S[QP
4NJOIUPJQL0 (RMJY` PIa]T0ZJNJbXRMJY0\TR0
,, 2IPIMU\H 7IYYT_@ GMU 2IcMUMQJTNP 5INQUI@ -RPQIUZMR 5INQIU [TU %NQIUNMQJTNMY
.M_@ 7M\SYQL T[ .M_@ 4NJOIUPJQL T[ -RPQIUZMR^ 2IPIMU\H -PPT\JMQI@ GMYQHIU
'\Hd\]JNX %NPQJQSQI [TU %NQIUNMQJTNMY .M_@ 7M\SYQL T[ .M_@ 4NJOIUPJQL T[ *JIY0
(RMJY` ZMYIL0KJU]IQQbXRMJY0\TR0
3HI MSQHTUP _JPH QT QHMN] )SYJIN 5HMJPPI@ =MQUJ\] '\HINM@ MNZ (YJTQ *MYQIU [TU
\TRRINQP MNZ ZJP\SPPJTNP TN IMUYJIU OIUPJTNP T[ QHJP MUQJ\YI0 3HI MSQHTUP MUI MYPT
!"" AM.U. INTLL. REV.e!>`<
3HI ;MZZM[J UIXJRI IPQMKYJPHIZ QHI .%- JN <CCf QT PQUIMRYJNI QHI
RMNMXIRINQ T[ .JKLM?P Ig\IPP TJY UIOINSIP MNZ [TUIJXN UIPIUOIP MNZ
QT KIQQIU JNQIXUMQI .JKLM JNQT JNQIUNMQJTNMY RMU]IQP0<3HI cSUcTPI T[
QHI .%- JP INPHUJNIZ JN .JKLMN YM_`
3HI e.%-?P TKaI\QJOIPh PHMYY KI JNOIPQRINQ T[ .JKLMN 7SNZP iBTNJIP
MKUTMZ JN QHI OMUJTSP [JNMN\JMY MNZ I\TNTRJ\ [JIYZP@ TN PTSNZ I\TNTRJ\
KMPJP@ MP _TSYZ \TNQUJKSQI QT development of the national economic
resources MNZ ZJOIUPJ[J\MQJTN QHIUIT[ [TU M\HJIOJNX QHI KIPQ [JNMN\JMY
UIOINSIP [TU PSccTUQJNX QHI Public Treasuryresources@MNZ RJNJRJjJNX
JN\TRI [YS\QSMQJTNP MNZ TQHIU UIOINSIP T[ theState0!
3HI .%- [TURP cMUQ T[ QHI %NQIUNMQJTNMY 7TUSR T[ 'TOIUIJXN GIMYQH
7SNZP V%7'G7W@>M XUTSc T[ 'G7P _HTPI RIRKIUP INZTUPI QHI
'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP0 3HI 'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP MUI MPIUJIP T[ XSJZJNX
cUJN\JcYIP JPPSIZ JN <CC" MP M UIPSYQ T[ \TRcYIg RSYQJYIOIY NIXTQJMQJTNP
XUMQI[SY QT =MNMXJTQJP $IYJRMQPJP MNZ %TMNNJP 'QUJKJP [TU QHIJU \TRRINQP TN MN
MKUJZXIZ OIUPJTN T[ QHJP MUQJ\YI cUIPINQIZ MQ QHI #Q H 5TN[IUIN\I T[ QHI =TPQXUMZSMQI
MNZ (MUYL =UT[IPPJTNMYPi-\MZIRJ\P &IQ_TU] T[ QHI 'T\JIQL T[ %NQIUNMQJTNMY
(\TNTRJ\ .M_ V=(=-i'%(.W@ HIYZ MQ QHI (SUTcIMN 4NJOIUPJQL 5LcUSP JN &J\TPJM TN
:! k:> -cUJY <C :" 0
:0 $J[[IUINQ PTSU\IP IPQJRMQI QHI OMYSMQJTN T[ QHI MPPIQP RMNMXIZ KL QHI .%- QT
KI KIQ_IIN 4'$ fC MNZ #C KJYYJTN0 See, e.g.@Libyan InvestmentAuthority@
'+A(2(%;& G(-.36 74&$' %&'30@ HQQcP`ii___0P_[JNPQJQSQI0TUXiP_[PiYJKLMNl
JNOIPQRINQlMSQHTUJQLi VYMPQ OJPJQIZ 'IcQ0 :<@ <C :" W^ 'MRJ 8McQJM@ UN Libya Experts
Panel Seeking to Establish the True Value of Libyas Frozen Assets@ .%1/- 6(2-.$
VBMU0 :!@ <C:"W@ HQQcP`ii___0YJKLMHIUMYZ0\TRi<C:"iC!i:!iSNlYJKLMlIgcIUQPlcMNIYl
PII]JNXlQTlIPQMKYJPHlQHIlQUSIlOMYSIlT[lYJKLMPl[UTjINlMPPIQPi^ BMQQHI_ 5MRcKIYY m
*JQ 5HIYYIY@ Hot Mess: How GoldmanSachsLost $1.2 Billion of Libyas
Money@ 1.++B1(2; 14'%&(''G((* V+\Q0 :> @ <C :f W @ HQQcP`ii___0KYTTRKIUX0\TRi
[IMQSUIPi<C :f l X TYZRMNlPM\HPlYJKLMi V\TNQUMPQJNX _JQH TQHIU PTSU\IP QHMQ \YMJR QHMQ@
M[QIU RTUI QHMN PIOIN LIMUP T[ QHI MPPIQ [UIIjI@ QHI OMYSI T[ MPPIQP \SUUINQYL RMNMXIZ
KL QHI .%- JP MP YT_ MP 4'$ !> KJYYJTNW0
<.See)SYJIN 5HMJPPI IQ MY0@ Emerging SovereignWealth Funds in the Making:
Assessing theEconomicFeasibilityand RegulatoryStrategies@>D)0 G+2.$ 32-$(
"!#@ "><V<C::W^ %NQ?Y GTU]JNX ;Uc0 T[ 'TOIUIJXN GIMYQH 7SNZP e%G;h@ Generally
Accepted Principles and Practices: Santiago PrinciplesV+\Q0 <C C"W@
HQQc`ii___0I\XJ0TUXi\TZIPiZT\SRINQPiJ_XnPMNQJMXTncUJN\JcYIPnT\Q<C C " n I N0cZ[
eHIUIJNM[QIU Santiago Principlesh0
!0 .JKLMN %NO0 -SQH0 O0 ;TYZRMN 'M\HP %NQ?Y e<C:fh (G65 V5HW <D! C @ e:!h
V(NX0W VIRcHMPJP MZZIZW VoSTQJNX ;INIUMY =ITcYI?P 5TRRJQQII@ &T V:<DW T[ :! #D
=$ V<CC#-0$0WW0
>.SeeOur Members@%7'G7@ HQQc`ii___0J[P_[0TUXiTSUlRIRKIUP VYMPQ OJPJQIZ
'IcQ0 "@ <C :" W ^ see generally SantiagoPrinciples@supra NTQI <0
<C:"h LESSONSFROM THE LIBYAN SOVEREIGNWEALTH FUND !"9
JNOTYOJNX QHI %NQIUNMQJTNMY BTNIQMUL 7SNZ V%B7W JN \TYYMKTUMQJTN
_JQH TQHIU PScUMNMQJTNMY KTZJIP@ M PJXNJ[J\MNQ NSRKIU T[ 'G7P@ MNZ
JNOIPQRINQlUI\JcJINQ 'QMQIP0D3HI MJR T[ QHI 'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP JP QT
HIYc 'G7P JRcUTOI QHIJU XTOIUNMN\I MNZ INHMN\I QHIJU QUMNPcMUIN\L
PQMNZMUZP MNZ@ JN QHJP _ML@ QT PSPQMJN TcIN [YT_P T[ \McJQMY0f
$SUJNX QHI -UMK 'cUJNX@ .JKLM IgcIUJIN\IZ M cTcSYMU ScUJPJNX@
[SIYIZ JN cMUQ KL M EYJNXIUJNX UIPINQRINQF MXMJNPQ .JKLMN YIMZIU
BSMRRMU ;MZZM[J?P UIXJRI0#%N <C::@ JRcYIRINQJNX 4NJQIZ &MQJTNP
'I\SUJQL 5TSN\JY V4&'5W 2IPTYSQJTNP :9#C MNZ :9#!@ PIOIUMY
GIPQIUN \TSNQUJIP [UTjI@ MRTNX TQHIU [JNMN\JMY UIPTSU\IP@ QHI MPPIQP
T[ QHI .%-0"3HJP _MP QHI [JUPQ QJRI MPPIQP T[ M 'G7 _IUI QHI QMUXIQ T[
M4&'5 MPPIQ [UIIjI093HI UIPTYSQJTNP MJRIZ QT cUIOINQ ;MZZM[J [UTR
SPJNX QHI UIPTSU\IP T[ XTOIUNRINQ INQJQJIP MP MPTSU\I T[ [SNZJNX [TU
HJP UIXJRI@ _HJ\H _MP PTTN INXMXIZ JN M KYTTZL \JOJY _MU _JQH UIKIY
[TU\IP0:C BSMRRMU ;MZZM[J?P ZIMQH JN +\QTKIU <C :: YIZ QT QHI
ZT_N[MYY T[ HJP UIXJRI0 6T_IOIU@ PTRI T[ QHI .%-?P MPPIQP UIRMJNIZ
VMNZ PQJYY UIRMJNW [UTjIN0:: 3HI 4&'5 HMP NTQIZ QHMQ QHI [UTjIN MPPIQP
_JYY KI RMZI MOMJYMKYI QT@ MNZ [TU QHI KINI[JQ T[@ QHI .JKLMN cITcYI EMP
D.Santiago Principles@supra NTQI <@ MQ :k <0
f.Seegenerally ($G%& B0 324B-&@ '+A(2(%;& G(-.36 74&$'` 362(-3 +2
'-.A-3%+&pV<C:CW VMNMYLjJNX QHI UTYI T[ OMUJTSP PTOIUIJXN _IMYQH [SNZP JN QHI
XYTKMY I\TNTRLW0
#.See$%2* A-&$(G-..(@ - 6%'3+2/ +7 B+$(2& .%1/- <C > V<Z IZ0 <C :<W
VZJP\SPPJNX QHI UIXJRI?P MKJYJQL QT PSccUIPP TccTPJQJTN TOIU QHI [TSU ZI\MZIP
cUI\IZJNX QHI UIOTYSQJTNW0
".See'050 2IP0 :9 #! @ qq :9 k <: VBMU0 :#@ <C ::W ^ see also '050 2IP0 :9 #C @ qq
:#k<:V7IK0 <f @ <C ::W^ $MOJZ 5SQYIU@ Factbox - Sanctions against Libya@ 2(43(2'
VBMU0 :>@ <C::@ :C`<D -BW@ HQQcP`ii___0UISQIUP0\TRiMUQJ\YIiJZ%&%NZJMlDDDf">
<C ::C ! :> 0
9.SeeBMUJLM ;TUZILIOM m+YjHMP -SLIjTO@ BNY Mellon Freezes $22.6
Billionin Kazakh Oil Fund Assets@ 2(43(2' V$I\0 <:@ <C :#@ :<` > # -BW@
HQQcP`ii___0UISQIUP0\TRiMUQJ\YIiSPl]MjM]HPQMNlKNLlRIYYTNlYM_PSJQiKNLlRIYYTNl
[UIIjIPl<<lflKJYYJTNlJNl]MjM]HlTJYl[SNZlMPPIQPlJZ4'*1&:(7C7<VE3HI [UIIjJNX T[
QHI MPPIQP \TRIP _II]P M[QIU =UIPJZINQ &MjMUKMLIO QHUIMQINIZ QT PM\] HJP \MKJNIQ J[
QHIL [MJYIZ QT RM]I YMUXI PQMQI \TRcMNJIP KUJNX KM\] \MPH HIYZ MKUTMZ0FW0
:C .SeeA-&$(G-..(@supra NTQI #@ MQ <C > VPQMQJNX QHMQ QHI 4NJQIZ &MQJTNP MNZ
(SUTcI QMUXIQIZ ;MZZM[J MNZ HJP [MRJYL _JQH MNSRKIU T[ PMN\QJTNP MP QHI _MU
PcUIMZW0
::.See;JSYJM =MUMOJ\JNJ@ MillionsFlow from GaddafisFrozen Fundsto
UnknownBeneficiaries@ =+.%3%5+ V7IK0 "@ <C :" @ >`C<-BW@ HQQcP`ii___0cTYJQJ\T0ISi
MUQJ\YIiRSMRRMUlXMZZM[Jl[UTjINl[SNZPlKIYXJSRlSN]NT_NlKINI[J\JMUJIPi0
!9C AM.U. INTLL. REV.e!>`<
PTTN MP cUM\QJ\MY0F:< 3HI .%-?P RMNMXIRINQ \YMJRP QHMQ KI\MSPI QHI
MPPIQP UIRMJN [UTjIN@ QHI [SNZ HMP IgcIUJIN\IZ NTQMKYI YTPPIP@ JNPQIMZ
T[ _HMQ _TSYZ HMOI KIIN UIQSUNP TN JQP JNOIPQRINQP J[ JQP MPPIQP HMZ
KIIN cUTcIUYL JNOIPQIZ0:!
3HJP MUQJ\YI IgMRJNIP MPIQ T[ JPPSIP UIYMQIZ QT QHI .%-?P M\QJOJQJIP
MNZ XTOIUNMN\I@ _JQH M cMUQJ\SYMU [T\SP TN QHI JRcM\Q T[ QHI 4&'5
PMN\QJTNP0 3HI MUQJ\YI oSIPQJTNP _HIQHIU JQ JP aSPQJ[JMKYI QT cIUcIQSMQI
QHI PMN\QJTNP TN QHI .%-?P MPPIQP QT QHI ZIQUJRINQ T[ QHI [SNZ?P
M\QJOJQJIP MNZ QHI cITcYI T[ .JKLM@ [TU _HTPI KINI[JQ QHI .%- _MP [JUPQ
IPQMKYJPHIZ0 3HI MUQJ\YI RM]IP [TSU \UJQJ\MY cTJNQP0 7JUPQ@ QHI MUQJ\YI
HJXHYJXHQP QHMQ QHI .%- UIRMJNP PSKaI\Q QT 40&0 PMN\QJTNP@ PIOIN LIMUP
M[QIU ;MZZM[J?P ZIMQH@ _HJ\H HMOI HMZ NIXMQJOI I[[I\QP TN QHI .%-?P
XTOIUNMN\I0:> 'I\TNZ@ QHI MUQJ\YI oSIPQJTNP QHI \TNQJNSIZ OMYJZJQL T[
QHI UIMPTNP cUTOJZIZ KL QHI 40&0 'MN\QJTNP 5TRRJQQII [TU QHI .%-?P
\TNQJNSIZ YJPQJNX0 3T RM]I QHJP MPPIUQJTN@ QHI MUQJ\YI NTQIP QHMQ QHI MPPIQ
[UIIjJNX RIMPSUIP MXMJNPQ QHI .%- _IUI TUZIUIZ PT QHI UIPTSU\IP T[
QHI .%- \TSYZ KI NTQ SPIZ MP M PTSU\I T[ [SNZJNX [TU QHI ;MZZM[J [MRJYL
QT [JNMN\I QHI cIUcIQSMQJTN T[ HJP UIXJRI0 3HI MUQJ\YI cUTcTPIP QHMQ@
[TYYT_JNX ;MZZM[J?P YTPP T[ cT_IU@ QHI KMPJP [TU QHI PMN\QJTNP _MP NT
YTNXIU PSPQMJNMKYI MNZ PHTSYZ HMOI KIIN UIOJPJQIZ KL QHI 4&'5 QT
MOTJZ RIMPSUIP MJRIZ MQ MZOMN\JNX QHI JNQIUIPQP T[ QHI .JKLMN cITcYI
[UTR HMOJNX QHI TccTPJQI I[[I\Q0 3HJUZ@ QHI MUQJ\YI ZIRTNPQUMQIP QHMQ
QHI cMUQJMY PMN\QJTNP UIYJI[ TUZIUIZ KL QHI 4&'5 HMZ YJRJQIZ JRcM\Q
:<.See'050 2IP0 <C >C@ q 9 VBMU0 :<@ <C:<W VEe3hHI 5TRRJQQII PHMYY@ JN
\TNPSYQMQJTN _JQH QHI .JKLMN MSQHTUJQJIP@ YJ[Q QHI ZIPJXNMQJTN T[ QHIPI INQJQJIP MP PTTN
MP cUM\QJ\MY QT INPSUI QHI MPPIQP MUI RMZI MOMJYMKYI QT MNZ [TU QHI KINI[JQ T[ QHI cITcYI
T[ .JKLM0FW0
:! 0 %KUMHJR +0 -0 $MKKMPHJ@ .IQQIU ZMQIZ <: BMU0 <C :f [UTR QHI =IURMNINQ 2Ic0
T[ .JKLM QT QHI 4NJQIZ &MQJTNP MZZUIPPIZ QT QHI =UIPJZINQ T[ QHI 'I\SUJQL 5TSN\JY@
40&0 $T\0 'i<C :f i <#D VBMU0 <! @ <C :f W eHIUIJNM[QIU $MKKMPHJh VE3HI .%- IPQJRMQIP
QHMQ JN <C :> MYTNI@ JNPQIMZ T[ JN\UIMPJNX QHI OMYSI T[ JQP MPPIQP KMPI@ JQ HMZ UIMY YTPPIP
T[ r#<:RJYYJTN0 7SUQHIURTUI@ JQ YTPQ MN MZZJQJTNMY r:0f KJYYJTN QT r<0! KJYYJTN JN _HMQ
_TSYZ HMOI KIIN UIQSUNP TN JNOIPQRINQ J[ JQP MPPIQP HMZ KIIN cUTcIUYL JNOIPQIZ0 0 0 0FW0
:> 0 3HI .%- JP QHI [JUPQ 'G7 QT HMOI KIIN IgcYJ\JQYL YJPQIZ KL QHI 4&'5@ J0I0 QHI
[JUPQ PS\H INQJQL QT HMOI HMZ JQP I\TNTRJ\ UIPTSU\IP [UTjIN MP MUIPSYQ T[ KIJNX NMRIZ
TN M4&'5 PMN\QJTNP YJPQ0 %N \TNQUMPQ@ [TU IgMRcYI@ QHI *S_MJQ %NOIPQRINQ -SQHTUJQL@
QHI 'G7 T[ QHI 'QMQI T[ *S_MJQ@ _MP JRcM\QIZ KL PMN\QJTNP JRcTPIZ KL QHI 4&'5
MXMJNPQ %UMo [TYYT_JNX JQP JNOMPJTN T[ *S_MJQ JN QHI IMUYL :9 9 CP@ KSQ _MP NTQ EYJPQIZF
cIU PI0 See, e.g.@'050 2IP0 ff:@ V-SX0 f@ :9 9 C W VcUTOJZJNX [TU PMN\QJTNP MNZ TQHIU
RIMPSUIP JNQINZIZ QT HIYc UIPQTUI QHI YIXJQJRMQI XTOIUNRINQ T[ *S_MJQW0
<C:"h LESSONSFROM THE LIBYAN SOVEREIGNWEALTH FUND !9:
TN QHI .%-?P XTOIUNMN\I0 7TSUQH@ QHI MUQJ\YI IgMRJNIP QHI .%-?P
XTOIUNMN\I PQUS\QSUI@ JNOIPQRINQ PQUMQIXL@ MNZ QHI 'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP
QT cUTOJZI IgcYMNMQJTNP MP QT _HL QHI [SNZ UIRMJNP PSKaI\Q QT 40&0
PMN\QJTNP _HJYI TQHIU INQJQJIP HMOI KIIN UIRTOIZ [UTR QHI 'MN\QJTNP
.JPQ0 -N MNMYLPJP T[ QHI .%-?P XTOIUNMN\I PQUS\QSUI JP IPPINQJMY QT
\YMUJ[LJNX QHI UIMPTNP KIHJNZ QHI \TNQJNSIZ MccYJ\MQJTN T[ QHI
PMN\QJTNP@ MNZ QT MZZUIPPJNX QHI I[[I\QP T[ QHI MPPIQ [UIIjJNX RIMPSUIP
TN QHI .%-?P JNOIPQRINQ PQUMQIXL MNZ XTOIUNMN\I0 -N IgMRJNMQJTN T[
QHI 'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP MNZ QHI cTQINQJMY \TNPIoSIN\IP T[ QHIJU
MccYJ\MQJTN QT QHI \SUUINQ XTOIUNMN\I T[ QHI .JKLMN 'G7@ YIMZP SP QT
\TN\YSZI QHMQ QT JRcUTOI QHI XTOIUNMN\I@ QUMNPcMUIN\L@ MNZ UJP]
RMNMXIRINQ T[ QHI .%- [SUQHIU MZHIUIN\I QT QHI 'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP
JP NI\IPPMUL0
3T PSccTUQ TSU QHIPJP QHMQ QHI 4&'5?P UIMPTNP [TU QHI \TNQJNSIZ
YJPQJNX T[ QHI .%- MUI TKPTYIQI@ MNZ QHMQ ZIRTNPQUMKYI JRcUTOIRINQP
JN XTOIUNMN\IscUTOIN JN cMUQ QHUTSXH M UI\TRRJQRINQ QT QHI
'MNQJMXT =UJN\JcYIP MNZ QHI %7'G7s_JYY PJXNMY QHI .%- HMP QHI
\McM\JQL QT UIlMPPSRI RMNMXIRINQ T[ JQP MPPIQP@ QHI MUQJ\YI JP ZJOJZIZ
JNQT [TSU cMUQP0 GHJYI 'I\QJTN % cUTOJZIZ M KUJI[ TOIUOJI_ T[ QHI MUQJ\YI
MNZ JQP \TNQIgQ@ 'I\QJTN %% ZJP\SPPIP QHI IOTYOJNX MPPIQ [UIIjJNX
RIMPSUIP MZTcQIZ KL QHI 4&'5 'MN\QJTNP 5TRRJQQII _JQH UIPcI\Q QT
.JKLM0 'I\QJTN %%% \UJQJ\MYYL MPPIPPIP QHI .%-@ P\USQJNJjJNX JQP
JNOIPQRINQ PQUMQIXL MNZ \TRcYJMN\I _JQH JNQIUNMQJTNMY PQMNZMUZP0 3HJP
PI\QJTN MYPT HJXHYJXHQP QHI .%-?P ZJPcSQIZ RMNMXIRINQ MNZ
YIMZIUPHJc@ [T\SPJNX TN QHI cTYJQJ\MY PQUSXXYIP QHMQ PQJYY ZJOJZI QHI PQMQI
MQ QHI QJRI T[ _UJQJNX0 'I\QJTN %A MNMYLjIP QHI cIUcIQSMQJTN T[ MPPIQ
[UIIjJNX RIMPSUIP [TYYT_JNX QHI ZIMQH T[ ;MZZM[J@ ZIPcJQI QHI MUUIPQ TU
ZIMQH T[ MNSRKIU T[ RIRKIUP T[ HJP [MRJYL MNZ HJP [TURIU UIXJRI0
'I\QJTN %A T[ QHI MUQJ\YI PSRRMUJjIP MNZ HJXHYJXHQP QHI \UJQJ\MY cTJNQP
UMJPIZ HIUIJN0
%%0 36( -''(3 72((8(
%N QHJP PI\QJTN _I ZJP\SPP QHI cTYJQJ\MY PJQSMQJTN JN .JKLM JN <C::@
_HJ\H QHI 4&'5 ZIQIURJNIZ QT UIcUIPINQ MQHUIMQ QT JNQIUNMQJTNMY
cIM\I MNZ PI\SUJQL@ MNZ _HJ\H YIZ QHI 4&'5 QT UIoSIPQ QHMQ PQMQIP
[UIIjI .JKLMN MPPIQP PT MP QT cUIOINQ QHI ;MZZM[J [MRJYL [UTR SPJNX
QHIR QT cUTYTNX QHI \JOJY _MU0 3HI [JUPQ PIQ T[ 4&'5 PMN\QJTNP MXMJNPQ
QHI .%-@ _HJ\H TUZIUIZ PQMQIP QT [UIIjI QHI [SNZ?P MPPIQP@ _IUI MZTcQIZ
!9< AM.U. INTLL. REV.e!>`<
JN BMU\H <C ::0 %N 'IcQIRKIU <C ::@ QHIPI PMN\QJTNP _IUI cMUQJMYYL
UIYMgIZ0 GI MNMYLjI QHJP cUT\IPP JN ZIQMJY JN QHI [TYYT_JNX PI\QJTN0
-0 36( %&%3%-. .%'3%&;
3HI .JKLMN ScUJPJNX PQMUQIZ JN 7IKUSMUL <C :: JN QHI IMPQIUN \JQL T[
1INXHMjJ@ QUJXXIUIZ KL cUTQIPQP MXMJNPQ QHI .JKLMN PI\SUJQL [TU\IP?
MUUIPQ T[ 7MQHJ 3MUKJY@ M HSRMN UJXHQP YM_LIU MNZ \UJQJ\ T[ QHI ;MZZM[J
UIXJRI0:D 3HI YT\MY ZIRTNPQUMQJTNP oSJ\]YL QSUNIZ JNQT [JXHQJNX QHMQ
PcUIMZ M\UTPP .JKLM?P NTUQHIUN \TMPQ@:f _JQH UIcTUQP T[ HSNZUIZP T[
ZIMQHP MNZ JNaSUJIP MP UIKIYP \YMPHIZ _JQH cUTlXTOIUNRINQ [TU\IP JN
1INXHMjJ _HJYI MQQIRcQJNX QT QM]I \TNQUTY T[ .JKLM?P PI\TNZ RTPQ
cTcSYTSP \JQL0:# 3HI 4&'5 JNJQJMYYL IgcUIPPIZ UIXUIQ MQ QHI OJTYIN\I
MNZ \JOJYJMN ZIMQHP JN McUIPP PQMQIRINQ@:" MNZ QHIN@ TN 7IKUSMUL <f@
<C::@ JQ UIM\QIZ SNMNJRTSPYL JN MZTcQJNX 2IPTYSQJTN :9 #C 0 :9
=MUMXUMcH :# T[ QHI 2IPTYSQJTN cUTOJZIP`
e-hYY BIRKIU 'QMQIP PHMYY [UIIjI _JQHTSQ ZIYML MYY [SNZP@ TQHIU [JNMN\JMY
MPPIQP MNZ I\TNTRJ\ UIPTSU\IP _HJ\H MUI TN QHIJU QIUUJQTUJIP@ _HJ\H MUI
T_NIZ TU \TNQUTYYIZ@ ZJUI\QYL TU JNZJUI\QYL@ KL QHI JNZJOJZSMYP TU INQJQJIP
YJPQIZ JN -NNIg %% T[ QHJP UIPTYSQJTN TU ZIPJXNMQIZ KL QHI 5TRRJQQII
IPQMKYJPHIZ cSUPSMNQ QT cMUMXUMcH <> KIYT_@ TU KL JNZJOJZSMYP TU INQJQJIP
M\QJNX TN QHIJU KIHMY[ TU MQ QHIJU ZJUI\QJTN@ TU KL INQJQJIP T_NIZ TU \TNQUTYYIZ
KL QHIR@ MNZ ZI\JZIP [SUQHIU QHMQ MYY BIRKIU 'QMQIP PHMYY INPSUI QHMQ MNL
[SNZP@ [JNMN\JMY MPPIQP TU I\TNTRJ\ UIPTSU\IP MUI cUIOINQIZ [UTR KIJNX
RMZI MOMJYMKYI KL QHIJU NMQJTNMYP TU KL MNL JNZJOJZSMYP TU INQJQJIP _JQHJN
QHIJU QIUUJQTUJIP@ QT TU [TU QHI KINI[JQ T[ QHI JNZJOJZSMYP TU INQJQJIP YJPQIZ JN
:D.SeeA-&$(G-..(@supra NTQI #@ MQ <C > VIgcYMJNJNX QHMQ QHIPI cUTQIPQP
oSJ\]YL PcUIMZ QHUTSXH QHI I\TNTRJ\MYYL NIXYI\QIZ IMPQIUN cMUQ T[ QHI NMQJTNW0
:f .Id.
:#.SeeBMUQJN 5HSYTO@ Libyan City Dubbed Free Benghazias Anti-Gaddafi
TroopsTakeControl@ ;4-2$%-& V7IK0 <! @ <C ::@ 9`C" -BW@
HQQcP`ii___0QHIXSMUZJMN0\TRi_TUYZi<C::i [IKi<!iYJKLMl[UIIlKINXHMjJlMNQJlXMZZM[Jl
QUTTcP VZIQMJYJNX QHI _IMcTNP MNZ QM\QJ\P SPIZ KL QHI UIXJRI QT UIRMJN JN \TNQUTY T[
QHI \JQLW0
:" 0 =UIPP 2IYIMPI@ 'I\SUJQL 5TSN\JY@ 'I\SUJQL 5TSN\JY =UIPP 'QMQIRINQ TN .JKLM@
40&0 =UIPP 2IYIMPI '5i:C:"Cl-72i<:<C V7IK0 <<@ <C ::W eHIUIJNM[QIU =UIPP 2IYIMPI@
'I\SUJQL 5TSN\JY =UIPP 'QMQIRINQ TN .JKLMh V\MYYJNX [TU MN JRRIZJMQI INZ QT QHI
OJTYIN\IW0
:9 .Seegenerally '050 2IP0 :9#C@ V7IK0 <f @ <C ::W 0
<C:"h LESSONSFROM THE LIBYAN SOVEREIGNWEALTH FUND !9!
-NNIg %% T[ QHJP UIPTYSQJTN TU JNZJOJZSMYP ZIPJXNMQIZ KL QHI
5TRRJQQII0 0 0 0<C
3HI 4&'5 YJPQIZ PJg JNZJOJZSMYP JN -NNIg %% T[ 2IPTYSQJTN :9 #C`
QHI .JKLMN YIMZIU@ BSMRRMU ;MZZM[J@<: MNZ [JOI T[ HJP \HJYZUIN0<< &T
INQJQJIP _IUI YJPQIZ JN QHJP 2IPTYSQJTN0 6T_IOIU@ [TYYT_JNX MN
IP\MYMQJTN T[ HTPQJYJQJIP JN .JKLM@ QHI 4&'5 MZTcQIZ 2IPTYSQJTN :9 #!
TN BMU\H :#@ <C::@<! _HJ\H IgQINZIZ QHI MPPIQ [UIIjI RIMPSUIP JN
2IPTYSQJTN :9#C0<> %N MZZJQJTN QT QHI JNZJOJZSMYP ZIPJXNMQIZ MP PSKaI\Q
QT MPPIQ [UIIjI RIMPSUIP@<D QHI .%- _MP TNI T[ [JOI INQJQJIP QHI 4&'5
YJPQIZ JN -NNIg %% T[ 2IPTYSQJTN :9 #! MP PSKaI\Q QT RIMPSUIP JRcTPIZ
KL 2IPTYSQJTN :9#C0<f -\\TUZJNX QT QHI 4&'5@ QHI aSPQJ[J\MQJTN [TU
[UIIjJNX QHI .%-?P MPPIQP _MP QHMQ QHI .JKLMN 'G7 _MP EeShNZIU eQHIh
\TNQUTY T[ BSMRRMU ;MZZM[J MNZ HJP [MRJYL@ MNZ eMh cTQINQJMY PTSU\I
T[ [SNZJNX [TU HJP UIXJRI0F<# &TQMKYL@ JN cMUMXUMcH <C T[ 2IPTYSQJTN
:9#!@ QHI 4&'5 MYPT M[[JURIZ EJQP ZIQIURJNMQJTN QT INPSUI QHMQ MPPIQP
[UTjIN cSUPSMNQ QT cMUMXUMcH :# T[ 2IPTYSQJTN :9#C V<C::W PHMYY@ MQ M
YMQIU PQMXI@ MP PTTN MP cTPPJKYI KI RMZI MOMJYMKYI QT MNZ [TU QHI KINI[JQ
T[ QHI cITcYI T[ QHI .JKLMN -UMK )MRMHJUJLM0F<"
4&'5 UIPTYSQJTNP \MYYJNX ScTN 'QMQIP QT [UIIjI MPPIQP MUI@ T[ \TSUPI@
NTQ PIY[lIgI\SQJNX MNZ UIoSJUI JRcYIRINQMQJTN KL 'QMQIP0<9 %N QHJP
<C .Id.q:#0
<:0 ;MZZM[J?P cTPJQJTNP T[ UIPcTNPJKJYJQL@ M\\TUZJNX QT 4&'5 2IP0 :9 #C @
JN\YSZIZ E.IMZIU T[ QHI 2IOTYSQJTNF MNZ E'ScUIRI 5TRRMNZIU T[ -URIZ 7TU\IP0F
Id. MQ -NNIg %%0
<<.Id.
<! 0 '050 2IP0 :9 #! @ VBMU0 :#@ <C ::W 0
<> .Id.q:9 0
<D. See id. MQ -NNIg %%0
<f . See id. q<< VE$I\JZIP 0 0 0 QHMQ QHI JNZJOJZSMYP MNZ INQJQJIP YJPQIZ JN -NNIg %%
PHMYY KI PSKaI\Q QT QHI MPPIQ [UIIjI JRcTPIZ JN 0 0 0 <