ArticlePDF Available

USING ACTION RESEARCH IN A GRADUATE LITERACY CLASS TO CONNECT THEORY TO PRACTICE: A REPLICATION STUDY

Authors:

Abstract

Herein, we use action research as a means for graduate students to develop and grow in their professional expertise as literacy teachers/coaches/specialists. In short, this manuscript aims to document Ernie Stringer's Look, Think, Act routines of seven students as they inquire about one particular situation in their own settings, to improve their own practices, and the outcomes of their students. This process allowed students and the faculty leading this effort to become active participants and thoughtful as they considered the educational theories they were learning in class.
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
57(
USING&ACTION&RESEARCH"IN#A#GRADUATE#
LITERACY)CLASS)TO)CONNECT%THEORY%TO%
PRACTICE:))A)REPLICATION%STUDY!
Juan!Araujo!!!!!!!Joel!Blaylock!
Texas!A&M!UniversityCommerce!!!!Bonham!ISD!!
Pearl!Garden!!!!!!!Sandra!Hogg!
Dallas!ISD!!!!!!!!A!Plus!Elementary!
Liza!Larue!!!!!!!!Deborah!Murillo!
Dallas!ISD!!!!!!!!Dallas!ISD!
Bonnie!Still!!!!!!!Angela!Venters!
Boles!Middle!School!!!!!!Region!7!ESC!
Leslie!Patterson!
Human!Systems!Dynamics!
!
!
Abstract!G+$+0%6(H+(#2+(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(&2(&(4+&%2()"$(F$&I#&/+(2/#I+%/2(/"(I+J+'"=(&%I(F$"H(0%(/-+0$(
=$")+220"%&'(+K=+$/02+(&2('0/+$&,L(/+&,-+$2M,"&,-+2M2=+,0&'02/2>((7%(2-"$/6(/-02(4&%#2,$0=/(&042(/"(I",#4+%/(N$%0+(
@/$0%F+$O2(P""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/($"#/0%+2(")(2+J+%(2/#I+%/2(&2(/-+L(0%R#0$+(&S"#/("%+(=&$/0,#'&$(20/#&/0"%(0%(/-+0$("H%(
2+//0%F26(/"(04=$"J+(/-+0$("H%(=$&,/0,+26(&%I(/-+("#/,"4+2(")(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2>((*-02(=$",+22(&''"H+I(2/#I+%/2(&%I(
/-+()&,#'/L('+&I0%F(/-02(+))"$/(/"(S+,"4+(&,/0J+(=&$/0,0=&%/2(&%I(/-"#F-/)#'(&2(/-+L(,"%20I+$+I(/-+(+I#,&/0"%&'(
/-+"$0+2(/-+L(H+$+('+&$%0%F(0%(,'&22>(
!
Keywords:!/+&,-+$(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-6(,"%%+,/0%F(/-+"$L(/"(=$&,/0,+6($+&I0%F(+I#,&/0"%6('""QD/-0%QD&,/(,L,'+!
!
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
58(
Introduction!
*-+$+(7(&'H&L2()+'/('0Q+(&(/$&=+T+(&$/02/(=+$)"$40%F(H0/-"#/(&(%+/(H-+%(7()0$2/(2/+==+I(0%(
)$"%/(")(&%(&#I0+%,+UP#,Q0'L6(7(4&%&F+I(/"(4&2Q(4L(/$+=0I&/0"%(0%()$"%/(")(&%(&#I0+%,+(
&2(&(,'&22$""4(/+&,-+$>>>(VW$#H+''6(9::X6(=>(9Y;Z((
7%(2=$0%F(9:8X6(&(I",/"$&'(,'&22(+4S&$Q+I("%(&(=$"[+,/(/"(=#/(0%/"(&,/0"%(H-&/(/-+L(H+$+(
'+&$%0%F(&S"#/('0/+$&,L(&%I(0/2(0%2/$#,/0"%>((*"F+/-+$(H+(I+,0I+I(/"(=#/(&''()+&$(&%I(/$+=0I&/0"%(
&20I+(&%I(0%2/+&I(/+&,-(H0/-("#$(-+&$/2(VW$#H+''6(9::XZ>((.2(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/2(+%F&F+I(H0/-(/-+(
&%,-"$(/+K/(Theoretical+Models+and+Processes+of+Reading,+Sixth+Edition+V.'J+$4&%%6(\%$&#6(](
1#II+''6(9:8CZ("%+(")(/-+0$(,-&$F+2(H&2(/"(=#/(/-+2+(0I+&2(0%(=$&,/0,+(0%(/-+0$(=$")+220"%&'(
2+//0%F2(&2(+'+4+%/&$L(,'&22$""4(/+&,-+$26(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2=+,0&'02/26(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2#=+$J02"$26(
,&4=#2(N%F'02-('&%F#&F+(&$/2(,""$I0%&/"$26(&%I(2,-""'(,"#%2+'"$2(#20%F(N$%0+(@/$0%F+$O2(P""Q6(
*-0%Q6(.,/(4"I+'(V^&//+$2"%(+/(&'6(9:8:_(@/$0%F+$6(8``a_(@/$0%F+$6(9::X_(@/$0%F+$(+/(&'6(9::`Z(
'0%Q0%F(/-+"$L(&%I(=$&,/0,+>((*"F+/-+$6(/-+(2/#I+%/2(&%I()&,#'/L($+&I6(2="Q+(&S"#/6(&%I(
I",#4+%/+I(H-&/(/-+L(H+$+('+&$%0%F()$"4(/-+(/+K/>((*-+(,"%J+$2&/0"%2('+I(/-+(2/#I+%/2(&%I(
)&,#'/L(/"(,"4+(/"(&%(&F$++4+%/(/"(I",#4+%/(&%I($+="$/(/-+0$(0%I0J0I#&'(+K=+$0+%,+2(#20%F(
&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(&2(/-+0$(=$04&$L(4+/-"I"'"F0,&'(&==$"&,->((
(
Literature!Review!
Action+Research.++.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(VP+H0%6(8`YaZ(02(&(4+/-"I"'"F0,&'(&==$"&,-(#2+I(SL(/+&,-+$2(
&%I("/-+$(=$&,/0/0"%+$2(/"('""Q(H0/-0%6(,"''+,/(I&/&(&S"#/(&(=&$/0,#'&$(0%R#0$L6("$F&%0T+(&%I(
&%&'LT+(/-+(I&/&6(I+J+'"=(&(='&%(/"(&II$+22(&(=&$/0,#'&$(R#+2/0"%6(04='+4+%/(&(=&$/0,#'&$(='&%6(
+J&'#&/+(/-+($+2#'/2(")(/-+(0%R#0$L6(&%I(,"%/0%#+(/"($+=+&/(/-+(=$",+22(#%/0'(2&/02)&,/"$L($+2#'/2(
&$+(4+/>((.2(/+&,-+$2(&%I(2,-""'(&I40%02/$&/"$2(2++Q()"$(&%2H+$2(/"(/-+0$(0%R#0$L(R#+2/0"%2(/-+L(
")/+%()0%I(/-&/(4"$+(R#+2/0"%2(+4+$F+(/-&/('+&I(/"(2#S2+R#+%/($+2+&$,-(,L,'+2(2040'&$(/"(N$%0+(
@/$0%F+$O2('""Q6(/-0%Q6(&,/(,L,'+2(&2(2++%(0%(b0F#$+(8(Vc+$/'+$6(9::`6(=>(8CZ>(+
(
Figure+1:++Stringer’s+Look+Think+Act+Cycle+
(
(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
59(
7%(@/$0%F+$O2(4"I+'6(/+&,-+$2M&,/0"%($+2+&$,-+$2(,"%/0%#"#2'L(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(&%I(.,/e("%(&(
=&$/0,#'&$(&$+&("%(0%/+$+2/(0%(2+&$,-(")(/-+(04=$"J+4+%/(")(/-+0$("H%(/+&,-0%F6("$()0%I0%F(
2"'#/0"%2(/"(&(R#+2/0"%(/-+L(&$+()&,0%F6("$(/$L0%F(/"(&II$+22(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2O(%++I2>((c+$/'+$(
V9::`Z(2#FF+2/2(/-&/("%+(&,/0"%('+&I2(/"("/-+$(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+2(&2(2++%(0%(b0F#$+(8(V=>(
8CZ>((*-02(d204='+6(L+/(="H+$)#'()$&4+H"$Q(V@/$0%F+$6(9::X6(=>(;Ze(0%J0/+2(/+&,-+$2(/"(2++6(/-0%Q6(
&%I(I"(2"4+/-0%F(/"(&II$+22(&(=&$/0,#'&$(0%R#0$L>((7%(/-02(2/#IL6(/-+()&,#'/L(&%I(/-+(2/#I+%/2(
,-"2+(/"(#2+(/-02(&==$"&,-(S+,&#2+(0/(&''"H+I()"$(2/#I+%/2(/"(4"%0/"$(&(,#$$+%/(=$&,/0,+(/-+L(
H+$+(,"%,+$%+I(&S"#/6(,"''+,/(&%I(&%&'LT+(/-+(&==$"=$0&/+(I&/&6(&%I(/-+%(,"%20I+$M=#/(0%(
=$&,/0,+(&(='&%(")(&,/0"%(/"(&II$+22(/-+0$(0%R#0$L>((
(
Professional+Development.++f0&%+(1&J0/,-(V9:8:Z(2#FF+2/2(/-&/(H-&/(4&Q+2(2"4+(I02/$0,/2(&%I(
0%I+=+%I+%/(2,-""'(I02/$0,/2(2#,,+22)#'(02(&g+
dU$+'+%/'+22()",#2("%(0%2/$#,/0"%(&%I(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/_(0/2(,#'/0J&/0"%(")(
/+&,-+$(&%I(=$0%,0=&'(2#=="$/_(0/2(+K=+$04+%/&/0"%(H0/-(%+H(&==$"&,-+2_(&%I(/-+(
,"%2,0"#2(")(d,"''+F0&'0/L6(,&$0%F(&%I($+2=+,/e(&4"%F(&''(2/&))(4+4S+$2>((74=$"J+4+%/(
$+'0+I("%(=$")+220"%&'2(H-"(H+$+(H0''0%F(/"(/&Q+(/-+(0%0/0&/0J+(/"(/&Q+($02Q26(&%I(/"(/&Q+(
$+2="%20S0'0/L()"$(/-+42+'J+26()"$(/-+0$(2/#I+%/26(&%I()"$(+&,-("/-+$(V=>(YCZ>e(((((
*-+(&S"J+(R#"/+(=$+,02+'L(&$/0,#'&/+2("#$(&04()"$(+%F&F0%F(0%(/-02(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(
&,/0J0/Lh/"()"$4(&(,"44#%0/L(")(=$&,/0,+(VP&J+(](i+%F+$6(8``8Z6(/"(/&Q+($02Q26(&%I(/"(S+(/-+$+(
)"$("%+(&%"/-+$(&2(H+(&//+4=/(/"(04='+4+%/(/-+2+(=$&,/0,+2(/"("#$(,'&22$""4($"#/0%+2>((((
!
Methodology(
Purpose.++*-02($+2+&$,-(02(/-+(=$"I#,/(")(/-"2+(+K=+$0+%,+2(&2(2/#I+%/2(&%I(/-+0$(=$")+22"$(
+%F&F+I(0%(&(2+4+2/+$('"%F(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(=$"[+,/(/"(&II$+22(/-+(R#+2/0"%g(i-&/(-&==+%2(
H-+%(2+J+%(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/2(/&Q+(&%(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(2/&%,+(/"(=#/(0%/"(=$&,/0,+(H-&/(/-+L(&$+(
'+&$%0%F(0%(&(F$&I#&/+('0/+$&,L(,'&22j(+
(
7%(2#46(/-+(2+J+%(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/2g(8Z(2/#I0+I(&%I(/-"#F-/(&S"#/(/-+0$(,'&22$""4(=$&,/0,+26(9Z(
I+J+'"=+I(&(S#$%0%F(R#+2/0"%(,"%%+,/+I(/"(&('0/+$&,L(/"=0,(/-+L(H+$+(2/#IL0%F6(CZ(,"%I#,/+I(
$+2+&$,-(=+$/&0%0%F(/"(/-+0$(0%R#0$L6(YZ(='&%%+I(&%I(04='+4+%/+I(="220S'+(2"'#/0"%26(&%I(5Z(
$+="$/+I(/-"2+(0%R#0$0+2(0%(&(,&2+(2/#IL()"$4&/>((
(
*-02(2/#IL()",#2+I("%(/-+(H&L2(2+J+%(F$&I#&/+(2/#I+%/2()"''"H+I(/-$"#F-(@/$0%F+$O2(+%/0$+(
&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(,L,'+(&2(/-+L(=#/(0%/"(=$&,/0,+(H-&/(/-+L(H+$+('+&$%0%F(0%(&(F$&I#&/+('0/+$&,L(
,'&22(/"(2"'J+(&(=$+220%F(022#+(/-+L(H+$+(+%,"#%/+$0%F(0%(/-+0$(=&$/0,#'&$(2+//0%F2>((
!
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
60(
Case+Study.++i+(#2+(,&2+(2/#I0+2(/"(2L%/-+20T+(&%I($+="$/(/-+(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+2(")(/-+(
=&$/0,0=&%/2(S+,&#2+(/-02(4+/-"I"'"FL(-+'=2(/"(&%2H+$(/-+(R#+2/0"%(/-&/(&$+(/&$F+/+I(/"(&(
'040/+I(%#4S+$(")(+J+%/26(/+%("$('+226(&%I(-"H(/-+L($+'&/+(/"(+&,-("/-+$>((k0%(V8``YZ(2&L2(d,&2+(
2/#IL(I+20F%(02(+))+,/0J+(H-+%(0/(02(#2+I(/"(0%J+2/0F&/+(&(,"%/+4="$&$L(=-+%"4+%"%(H0/-0%(0/2(
$+&'D'0)+(,"%/+K/6(H-+%(/-+(S"#%I&$L(S+/H++%(/-+(=-+%"4+%"%(S+0%F(2/#I0+I(&%I(/-+(,"%/+K/(
&$+(%"/(,'+&$'L(I+)0%+I6(&%I(H-+%(4#'/0='+2(2"#$,+2(")(+J0I+%,+(&$+(#2+I(/"(2/#IL(/-+(
=-+%"4+%"%(&/(-&%I(V=>(;YZ>e+
!
Setting.++*-+(#%0J+$20/L(02('",&/+I(0%(/-+($#$&'(2"#/-H+2/(")(/-+(\%0/+I(@/&/+2>((7/(+%$"''2(8C6:::(
#%I+$F$&I#&/+(&%I(F$&I#&/+(2/#I+%/26(&%I(02(,"%20I+$+I(&(-0F-+$($+2+&$,-(&,/0J0/L(I",/"$&'(
F$&%/0%F(#%0J+$20/L(SL(/-+(l&$%+F0+(l'&220)0,&/0"%(")(7%2/0/#/0"%2(")(G0F-+$(NI#,&/0"%(V9:8CZ>(+
(
*-+(=#$="2+(")(/-+(,"#$2+(H&2()"$(F$&I#&/+(2/#I+%/2(=#$2#0%F(&(I",/"$&'(I+F$++(0%(,#$$0,#'#4(
&%I(0%2/$#,/0"%(H0/-(&(,"%,+%/$&/0"%(0%($+&I0%F(/"(+%F&F+(0%(&%(0%DI+=/-(&%&'L202(")(J&$0+I(
I+)0%0/0"%2(&%I(/-+"$0+2(")($+&I0%F(0%,'#I0%F(/-+(+K&40%&/0"%(")(04='0,&/0"%2()"$($+&I0%F(
0%2/$#,/0"%>((f#$0%F(/-+(2+4+2/+$(/-+(F$&I#&/+(2/#I+%/2(0I+%/0)0+I(&%I(&%&'LT+I(-02/"$0,&'(
,-&%F+2(0%(/-+(,"%,+=/0"%(")($+&I0%F(&%I('0/+$&,L_(/-+L(0I+%/0)0+I6(&%&'LT+I6(&%I(,"4=&$+I(
J&$0"#2(=$",+22+2(")($+&I0%F_(/-+L(0I+%/0)0+I6(&%&'LT+I6(&%I(,"4=&$+I(J&$0"#2(/-+"$+/0,&'(
4"I+'2(")($+&I0%F_(&%I()0%&''L6(/-+L(S+,&4+(0%I+=+%I+%/($+2+&$,-+$2(&2(/-+L(=#/(0%/"(&,/0"%6(
/-+(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e($+2+&$,-(,L,'+()"$("%+(")(/-+(/"=0,2(/-+L('+&$%+I(&S"#/(0%(/-+(,"#$2+(0%(
/-+0$(=$")+220"%&'(2+//0%F2(V0>+>6(,'&22$""46(/+&,-+$(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/6(/$&0%0%F(2+220"%26(
"$($+&I0%F(2=+,0&'02/Z>((*-02(d204='+e(L+/(,"4='+K()$&4+H"$Q(2++4+I(4+/-"I"'"F0,&''L(
&==$"=$0&/+(F0J+%(/-+(=#$="2+(")(/-+(&220F%4+%/6(/-+(I+20$+I("#/,"4+26(&%I(/04+(,"%2/$&0%/2>((
!
Participants.++*-+$+(H+$+(2+J+%(2/#I+%/2(&%I("%+()&,#'/L(4+4S+$(0%(/-02(2/#IL>((*H"(2/#I+%/2(
H+$+(&/(/-+(S+F0%%0%F(")(/-+0$(I",/"$&'(,"#$2+H"$Q6("%+(2/#I+%/(H&2(&/(/-+(+%I(")(-+$(
,"#$2+H"$Q6(&%I()"#$(2/#I+%/2(H+$+(0%(/-+(40II'+(")(/-+0$(=$"F$&4>((.''(2+J+%(2/#I+%/2(
0%/+%I+I(/"(+&$%(&(I",/"$(")(+I#,&/0"%(H0/-(&(,"%,+%/$&/0"%(0%($+&I0%F(+I#,&/0"%>((*-+()&,#'/L(
4+4S+$(H&2(0%(-02(/+%/-(L+&$(")(#%0J+$20/L(/+&,-0%F>((@0K(2/#I+%/2(/&#F-/("$(H"$Q+I()"$(#$S&%(
2,-""'26(&%I("%+(2/#I+%/(/&#F-/(0%(&(24&''D/"H%($#$&'(2,-""'>((+
!
Data+Collection.++.2(/-+2+(2/#I+%/2(/$&%2&,/+I(H0/-(/-+(/+K/(V1"2+%S'&//6(8`X;Z(/-+L(2="Q+(
&S"#/(/-+(I0))+$+%/(,-&''+%F+2(/-+L(H+$+()&,0%F(H0/-(/-+0$(2/#I+%/26(/+&,-+$26(&%I(,"''+&F#+2>((
c#'/0='+(2"#$,+2(")(I&/&(H+$+(,"''+,/+I(/"(2/#IL(/-+(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+>((*-+(2"#$,+2(
,"''+,/+I(0%,'#I+I(,'&22(%"/+26(,'&22('+,/#$+26(,'&22(I02,#220"%6(0%)"$4&'(,"%J+$2&/0"%26('+22"%(
='&%26(&%I("/-+$(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(&$/0)&,/2>(*-+L('""Q+I(H0/-0%(/"(0I+%/0)L(&('0/+$&,L(/"=0,(/-&/(
%++I+I(044+I0&/+(&//+%/0"%>(((
!
Data+Analysis.++G&')H&L(/-$"#F-(/-+(2+4+2/+$(/-+(2/#I+%/2(S+F&%(/"(I+J+'"=(&%I(04='+4+%/(&(
='&%(")(&,/0"%(#20%F(/-+(4#'/0='+(2"#$,+2(")(I&/&(H0/-(0%=#/()$"4(/-+0$(,$0/0,&'()$0+%I2(V^0%+6(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
61(
9::`Z(0%,'#I0%F("/-+$(2/#I+%/2(&%I()&,#'/L(0%(&II0/0"%(/"(/-+(4#'/0='+(2"#$,+2(")(I&/&(/-+L(-&I(
,"''+,/+I(&'"%F(/-+(H&L>((b$"4(/-&/(="0%/()"$H&$I6(/-+(F$"#=(2=+%/(2"4+(/04+(&/(/-+(S+F0%%0%F(
")(+&,-(,'&22(I02,#220%F(/-+(,-&''+%F+2(/-+L()&,+I(&2(/-+L(04='+4+%/+I(/-+0$(='&%(=&L0%F(,'"2+(
&//+%/0"%(&%I(4&Q0%F(,"%%+,/0"%2(/"(/-+('0/+$&/#$+(/-+L(H+$+($+&I0%F>+
(
*-+(2+J+%(2/#I+%/2(/-+%(#2+I(["#$%&'0%F(/"(I",#4+%/(/-+0$(&,/0"%2(&2(/-+L(='&%6(&%I(I+'0J+$+I(
0%2/$#,/0"%>((@-&$0%F(&%I(,"44#%0,&/0%F(/-+($+2#'/2(H&2(&(,-&''+%F+(&/()0$2/(S+,&#2+()"$(4&%L(")(
/-+(2/#I+%/2(/-02(H&2(/-+()0$2/(/04+(/-+L(H+$+(/&2Q+I(/"('""Q(H0/-0%6($+="$/(/-+0$()0%I0%F2(/"(
"/-+$(2/#I+%/26(&%I(H$0/+(0/(#=(/-+0$(+K=+$0+%,+()"$(=#S'0,&/0"%>((7%I0J0I#&''L6(H+(,"I+I(/-+(
+4+$F0%F(%"/+26(/-+%(H+(2+/(&20I+(/04+(0%(,'&22(/"(I02,#22("#$(,"I+2(&2(&(,'&22(S+,&#2+("#$(
,"-"$/(H&2(24&''6(&)/+$(,"I0%F(H+(I0J0I+I("#$()0%I0%F2(0%/"(/-$++(F$"#=2(V0>+>6('""Q6(/-0%Q6(&,/Z>((
N&,-(&#/-"$(/-+%(,$&)/+I(&(I$&)/(")(/-+0$(%&$$&/0J+(&%I(S$"#F-/(0/(H0/-(/-+4(/-+(%+K/(,'&22>(
P#,Q0'L6(/-+(="220S0'0/L(")(I022+40%&/0"%(/"(&('&$F+$(&#I0+%,+(/-$"#F-(&(%&/0"%&'(=$+2+%/&/0"%6("$(
&(="220S'+(=#S'0,&/0"%(4&I+(/-+(/&2Q(&==+&'0%F>((*"H&$I(/-+(+%I(")(/-+(2+4+2/+$6(/-+(F$"#=(
=$+2+%/+I(/-+0$(I&/&(/"(+&,-("/-+$(0%(&%("=+%()"$#46(/-+L(I02,#22+I(/-+0$()0%I0%F26(&%I(/-+%(
H"$Q+I(/"F+/-+$(#20%F(&(H$0/0%F(H"$Q2-"=(&==$"&,-(/"(=$"J0I+(,"%2/$#,/0J+()++IS&,Q(&2(/-+L(
H$"/+(/-+0$(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+2(H-0,-()"''"H>((
!
Results(
Seven+Cases.++*-+()"''"H0%F(2+J+%(,&2+2(&04(/"(I+4"%2/$&/+(-"H(/+&,-+$2M'0/+$&,L(
'+&I+$2M'0/+$&,L(&I40%02/$&/"$2(#2+(/-+('""Q6(/-0%Q6(&,/(,L,'+(0%(/-+0$(=&$/0,#'&$(20/#&/0"%2(/"(=#/(
0%(=$&,/0,+(H-&/(/-+L(&$+('+&$%0%F(0%(F$&I#&/+($+&I0%F(,'&22>(+
!
m"%%0+(
.2(&()0)/-(F$&I+(NP.1(/+&,-+$6(7()"#%I(0/(04="$/&%/(/"(#%I+$2/&%I(/-+(4"2/(=$"I#,/0J+(H&L2(/"(
&==$"&,-(J",&S#'&$L(0%2/$#,/0"%>((7(Q%+H(4L(2/#I+%/2(H+$+('&,Q0%F(0%($0,-(J",&S#'&$L(&%I()+'/(
/-&/(=#//0%F(0%/"(=$&,/0,+(/-+(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+(H"#'I(S+(/-+(=+$)+,/("=="$/#%0/L(/"(H"$Q(
/"H&$I(S#0'I0%F(/-"2+(2Q0''2>((A&FL(&%I(@,"//(V9:8CZ(2&L6(d3",&S#'&$L(Q%"H'+IF+(2/$"%F'L(
0%)'#+%,+2($+&I0%F(,"4=$+-+%20"%e(V=>(Y5;Z6(2"(&2(&($+&I0%F(/+&,-+$(/-02(0I+&(02(J+$L(04="$/&%/(
/"(4+>((cL(F#0I0%F(R#+2/0"%(H&26(di-&/(,&%(7(,-&%F+("$(&II(/"(4L(J",&S#'&$L(0%2/$#,/0"%(/"(
,$+&/+(&%(&/4"2=-+$+($0,-(0%(J",&S#'&$L(H-+$+(2/#I+%/2(&$+(+%F&F+I(0%(/-+(=$",+22(")(
+%-&%,0%F(J",&S#'&$L(Q%"H'+IF+(&%I(2Q0''2je(
(
Look.!!.)/+$($+&I0%F(&S"#/(J",&S#'&$L(=$",+22+2(0%("#$(/+K/6(7(S+F&%(/"(#%I+$2/&%I(/-+(
04="$/&%,+(")(/+&,-0%F(J",&S#'&$L(0%(I0))+$+%/(H&L26("))+$0%F(4#'/0='+("=="$/#%0/0+26(&%I(
0%J"'J0%F(2/#I+%/2(0%(/-+(=$",+22>((A&FL(&%I(@,"//(V9:8CZ(2&L6(d/-+$+(2-"#'I(S+(&%(+4=-&202("%(
0%2/$#,/0"%(/-&/(02(&#/-+%/0,6(4+&%0%F)#'6(&%I(0%/+F$&/+Ie(V=>(Y5;Z>((i0/-(/-02(0%(40%I6(7(4&I+(
/-+(I+,020"%(/"(0%J"'J+(2/#I+%/2(4"$+(SL(-&J0%F(/-+4(2+&$,-("#/(&%I(0I+%/0)L(#%)&40'0&$(H"$I2(
/"(I02,#22(&%I($+2+&$,-(0%(,'&22(&2(H+''(&2("))+$(,-"0,+2(")(I0))+$+%/(F&4+2(&%I(&,/0J0/0+2(/"(-+'=(
/-+4(S+,"4+(4"$+(&,R#&0%/+I(&%I(,"4)"$/&S'+(H0/-(/-+(H"$I2(/-+L(-&I(,-"2+%>((
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
62(
Think.((W0J0%F(2/#I+%/2(4#'/0='+("=="$/#%0/0+2(/"(4&Q+(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(I+,020"%2(F&J+(/-+4(
"H%+$2-0=(")(/-+(%+H(J",&S#'&$L(H"$I2(&%I(&,/0J0/0+2(S+,&#2+(/-+L()+'/(&(I++=(2+%2+(")(
"H%+$2-0=>((b"2/+$0%F(/-+0$(0%J"'J+4+%/(0%(/-+(='&%%0%F6('+22"%(I+'0J+$L6(&%I(0%2/$#,/0"%(
+%-&%,+I(/-+(2/#I+%/2O(0%/+$+2/26(2"(H-+%(/-+(&,/0J0/0+2(/""Q(='&,+(/-+L()+'/(4"$+(+&F+$(/"(
+%F&F+(H0/-(/-+4>((@/#I+%/2(2-"H+I(4"$+(+K,0/+4+%/(I#$0%F(,'&22(I02,#220"%26(F$"#=(&,/0J0/0+26(
&%I(F&4+2>(!
!
Act.!!A&FL(&%I(@,"//(V9:8CZ(2&L(/-&/(J",&S#'&$L(0%2/$#,/0"%(2-"#'I(=$"J0I+(4#'/0='+(&%I(J&$0+I(
+%,"#%/+$26('+&I(/"(/-+(&S0'0/L(/"(+K='&0%(4+&%0%F6(&%I(=$"4"/+(/-+(#2+(")(/-+(H"$I(V=>(Ya9D
YaCZ>((n%,+(2/#I+%/2(-&I(+&,-(,-"2+%(&(H"$I(/"(,"%/$0S#/+(/"(/-+('02/6(/-+L(I02,#22+I(/-+0$(
H"$I2(&%I(="220S'+(4+&%0%F2(H0/-("%+(&%"/-+$(&)/+$($+&I0%F(&'"#I(/-+(="$/0"%(")(/-+(/+K/(0%(
H-0,-(/-+L(-&I()"#%I(/-+4>((A+K/6(2/#I+%/2(H+$+(F0J+%(,-"0,+2(")(-"H(/"(+K='&0%(&%I(=$+2+%/(
/-+0$(H"$I(&%I(0/2(/$#+(4+&%0%F(/"(/-+(,'&22(2#,-(&2(I0))+$+%/()"$4&/2(")(b$&L+$(4"I+'26(
)'0=,-&$/26("$(="2/+$2>((b"$(+K&4='+6("%+(2/#I+%/(,-"2+(/"(,$+&/+(&(="2/+$(S"&$I(I02='&L0%F(-+$(
H"$I6(I+)0%0/0"%6(+K&4='+26(&%I(0''#2/$&/0"%2>((*-02(2/#I+%/(H&2(2"(+K,0/+I(/"(2-&$+(-+$(=$"[+,/(
H0/-(/-+(,'&22(2-+()0%02-+I(0/(+&$'L>((*-+(="2/+$(H&2(0%)"$4&/0J+6(I+2,$0=/0J+6(&%I(J02#&''L(
&==+&'0%F>((.)/+$(/-+(=$+2+%/&/0"%6(7("S2+$J+I("/-+$(2/#I+%/2(,-&%F0%F(&%I(&II0%F(
04=$"J+4+%/2(/"(/-+0$(H"$Q(S+)"$+(2-&$0%F>((@/#I+%/2(H+$+(&'2"(F0J+%(,-"0,+2(")(F&4+2(/"(F0J+(
/-+4()#$/-+$(=$&,/0,+(H0/-(/-+(H"$I2>((@"4+(+K&4='+2()$"4(/-+0$(,-"0,+('02/(H+$+(
,"%,+%/$&/0"%(,&$I26(S"&$I(F&4+26(&%I(I0,+(F&4+2>((G"H+J+$6(/-+0$()&J"$0/+(H&2(J",&S#'&$L(
4#20,&'(,-&0$2>((
(
*-$"#F-"#/(/-02(=$",+226(H-&/(7()"#%I(4"2/(+%,"#$&F0%F()"$(4+(H&2(/-&/(2/#I+%/2()"#%I(/-02(
H"$Q(+%["L&S'+(&%I(0/(2-"H+I(I#$0%F(/-+('+&$%0%F(=$",+22(&%I(0%(/-+(,"44+%/2(/-+L(4&I+(/"(
4+(&%I(/"(+&,-("/-+$(&2(/-+L(H+$+(+%F&F0%F(H0/-(/-+(H"$I2>((@/#I+%/2(S+F&%(4&Q0%F(/-+0$("H%(
)'&2-,&$I2(/"(S+,"4+(4"$+()&40'0&$(H0/-(/-+(H"$I26()0%I0%F(/-+4(0%(I0))+$+%/(2+//0%F2("#/20I+(")(
/-+(,'&22$""4(&%I($+="$/0%F(0/(/"(/-+(,'&226(&%I(4&%L(I0I(+K/$&(&,/0J0/0+2($&/-+$(/-&%([#2/(=0,Q0%F(
"%+(")(/-+(,-"0,+2(=$"J0I+I>((*-+(&/4"2=-+$+(02(2"(4#,-(4"$+(0%J0/0%F(&%I(+K,0/0%F(H-+%(
2/#I+%/2(&,/0J+'L(/&Q+(=&$/(0%(/-+(0%2/$#,/0"%>((7()++'(,"%)0I+%/(/-+(,'&22(H0''(+K,+'("%(/-+0$(
#=,"40%F(J",&S#'&$L(&22+224+%/(I#+(/"(0%J"'J+4+%/6(+%F&F+4+%/6(&%I(+'+J&/+I(0%/+$+2/(
'+J+'2>((*-+2+('+22"%2(&%I(&,/0J0/0+2(-&J+(,-&%F+I(4L(=$&,/0,+(&%I("J+$&''("#/'""Q("%(
0%2/$#,/0"%>((cL()#/#$+(=$&,/0,+2(H0''(0%J"'J+(2/#I+%/2(0%(='&%%0%F6(0%2/$#,/0"%6(&%I("))+$(
2/#I+%/2(,-"0,+2>(
!
.%F+'&(
7(&4(&%(N'+4+%/&$L(N%F'02-(P&%F#&F+(.$/2(@=+,0&'02/(&%I(fL2'+K0&(+K=+$/(&/(&($+F0"%&'(2+$J0,+(
,+%/+$(0%(%"$/-(*+K&2>((7(&4(,-&$F+I(H0/-(2#=="$/0%F(/+&,-+$2(0%(F$&I+2(Q0%I+$F&$/+%(/-$"#F-(
)0)/-(F$&I+2(0%(8:a(2,-""'2>((
!
Look.!!.(,&4=#2(&I40%02/$&/"$(,"%/&,/+I(4+(&/(/-+(40II'+(")(/-+(L+&$(&S"#/(-+'=0%F(,'&22$""4(
/+&,-+$2(#/0'0T+($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(&2(&(4+&%2(")(I+/+$40%0%F('0/+$&,L('+J+'2(V0>+>6()$#2/$&/0"%6(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
63(
0%I+=+%I+%/6(0%2/$#,/0"%&'('+J+'2Z(&%I(/-+%(-+'=0%F(/-+4(0I+%/0)L(&%I(I+J+'"=(2/$&/+F0+2(/"(
/&$F+/(/-"2+(%++I2(I#$0%F(24&''(F$"#=(0%2/$#,/0"%>((*-+(&I40%02/$&/"$($+="$/+I(/-&/(/-+(
/+&,-+$2(4+/(H0/-(2/#I+%/2(0%(24&''DF#0I+I($+&I0%F(F$"#=26(S#/(/-+L(H+$+(%"/(4&Q0%F(
20F%0)0,&%/(=$"F$+22(0%(/-+($+&I0%F(&S0'0/0+2(")(/-+(2/#I+%/2(&%I(H"%I+$+I(0)(/-+$+(H&2(&%L/-0%F(7(
,"#'I(I"(/"(-+'=>((*-+(&I40%02/$&/"$(H&%/+I(/"(4&Q+(2#$+(/-&/(/-+L(Q%+H(-"H(/"(/&Q+($#%%0%F(
$+,"$I26(S#/(4"2/(04="$/&%/'L6(&%&'LT+($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(2"(/-&/(/-+L(,"#'I(='&%(/&$F+/+I(
0%2/$#,/0"%>((.)/+$(2=+&Q0%F(H0/-(/-+(,&4=#2(&I40%02/$&/"$6(H+(I+,0I+I(/"(2,-+I#'+(&(,&4=#2(
2/&))(I+J+'"=4+%/(&S"#/($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(&%I(/-+0$(#2+()"$(='&%%0%F('0/+$&,L(0%2/$#,/0"%>(
!
Think.!!7%(/-0%Q0%F(&S"#/(/-02(,-&''+%F+(&%I(/-+(='&%%0%F(")(/-02(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/6(7(
H&%/+I(/"(&II$+22(/-+(%++I2(/-&/(-&I(S++%(+K=$+22+I(/"(4+(SL(/-+(,&4=#2(&I40%02/$&/"$>(7(
/-"#F-/(S&,Q(/"(H-+%(7(H&2(0%(/-+(,'&22$""46(&%I(H-&/(4&I+(/-+(I0))+$+%,+()"$(4+(&2(&(
=$04&$L(/+&,-+$>((cL(,&4=#2(+4=-&20T+I(F#0I+I($+&I0%F(&2(/-+()"#%I&/0"%()"$($+&I0%F(
0%2/$#,/0"%6(&%I(/-+(#2+(")($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(/"(F#0I+(4L(I+,020"%2(&S"#/(H-+%(/"(4"I0)L(/-+(
F#0I+I($+&I0%F(F$"#=2>((*-+(04=&,/(")(/-+2+(/H"(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(,"4="%+%/2(4&I+(&(H"$'I(")(
I0))+$+%,+()"$(4+(&2(&(/+&,-+$(2"(7(Q%+H(0/(H"#'I(S+(&%(&22+/()"$(/-"2+(/+&,-+$2(&2(H+''>((
b"#%/&2(&%I(^0%%+''(V9:89Z(2/&/+(/-&/(/-+$+(02(&%(04="$/&%/(I0))+$+%,+(S+/H++%(04='+4+%/0%F(
=&$/2(")(&(F#0I+I($+&I0%F('+22"%(&%I(#20%F(F#0I+I($+&I0%F(/"(S$0%F($+&I+$2()$"4(H-+$+(/-+L(&$+6(
/"(&2()&$(&2(/-+(/+&,-0%F(,&%(/&Q+(/-+4(0%(&(F0J+%(2,-""'(L+&$>((7)(/+&,-+$2(&$+("%'L(F"0%F(
/-$"#F-(/-+(4"/0"%2(")(F#0I+I($+&I0%F6(/-+L(&$+(/$#'L(40220%F("#/("%(/-+(0%/+%I+I(=#$="2+>((
W$"#%I+I(0%()"#%I&/0"%&'($+2+&$,-()$"4(c&$0+(l'&L(V8`;9Z6(F#0I+I($+&I0%F(02("%'L(+))+,/0J+(
H-+%(/-+(/+&,-+$(Q%"H2(-"H(/"(I0$+,/(2/#I+%/2O(0%(/-+0$($+&I0%F(I+J+'"=4+%/>((f#$0%F(F#0I+I(
$+&I0%F6(/-+(/+&,-+$O2($"'+(02(/"(Q%"H(H-+%(&%I(-"H(/"(/+&,-6(=$"4=/6(&%I($+0%)"$,+(/-+(
=$",+220%F(2/$&/+F0+2()"$(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2(0%(0%,$+&20%F'L(,-&''+%F0%F(/+K/2>((b"#%/&2(&%I(^0%%+''(
V9:89Z(2/&/+(/-&/(/+&,-+$2(&$+('+&$%0%F(/-&/(&,,#$&/+(H"$I($+&I0%F(02(%"/(/-+("%'L(F"&'_(+))0,0+%/6(
0%I+=+%I+%/(2+')D4"%0/"$0%F(S+-&J0"$(&%I(/-+(&S0'0/L(/"(2+&$,-()"$(&%I(#2+(&(J&$0+/L(")(2"#$,+2(
")(0%)"$4&/0"%(0%(/-+(/+K/(02(Q+L(/"(=$")0,0+%,L>((*-02(=$")0,0+%,L(,&%("%'L(S+,"4+(&($+&'0/L(H-+%(
/+&,-+$2(#/0'0T+(F#0I+I($+&I0%F(/-+(H&L(/-&/(0/(H&2(/$#'L(4+&%/(/"(S+(#2+I(0%(/-+(,'&22$""46(&2(&(
2#=="$/0J+()$&4+H"$Q(&2(2/#I+%/2(S+,"4+(4"$+(=$")0,0+%/(H0/-(,"%/0%#"#2(/+K/>(((
(
7(&'2"(,-"2+($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(S+,&#2+(/-+L(,"4='+4+%/(F#0I+I($+&I0%F>((7(&2Q+I(4L2+')6(0)(
/+&,-+$2(I"(%"/(/&Q+($#%%0%F($+,"$I2("%(/-+0$(2/#I+%/26(-"H(H0''(/-+L(Q%"H(H-&/(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2(
%++Ij(*-02(,&4=#2(H&2("%'L(/&Q0%F($#%%0%F($+,"$I2(/-$++(/04+2(&(L+&$6(2"(/-+$+)"$+(/-+L(I0I(
%"/(Q%"H(H-&/(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2(%++I+I("%(&(4"$+(,"%202/+%/(S&202>((o+%(&%I(k+//&(W""I4&%(
#2+I(/-+(/+$4(402,#+(&%&'L202(0%(='&,+(")(+$$"$g(/-02(H&2(S+,&#2+(")(/-+(%+F&/0J0/L(&22",0&/+I(
H0/-(/-+(H"$I(+$$"$>((.,,"$I0%F(/"(W""I4&%(](W""I4&%(V9:8CZ6(402,#+($+)+$2(/"(/-+(
#%+K=+,/+I($+2="%2+2(/-&/($+&I+$2(4&Q+(I#$0%F("$&'($+&I0%F>((*-+2+(402,#+2(,&%(&2202/(
/+&,-+$2(&2(/-+L(&$+(&%&'LT0%F($#%%0%F($+,"$I2>!!*+&,-+$2(4#2/(-&J+(&%(0%(I+=/-(#%I+$2/&%I0%F(
")(/-+(4+&%0%F(VcZ6(2/$#,/#$+(V@Z6(&%I(J02#&'(V3Z(,#+0%F(2L2/+42(H-+%(/-+L(&%&'LT+(/-+($#%%0%F(
$+,"$I2>((W""I4&%(](W""I4&%(V9:8CZ(&'2"(2/&/+(/-&/(402,#+(&%&'L202(=$"J0I+2(+J0I+%,+(/-&/(
$+&I+$2(0%/+F$&/+(,#+0%F(2L2/+42()$"4(/-+(+&$'0+2/(0%0/0&'(&//+4=/2(&/($+&I0%F>((.(/+&,-+$(,&%(
'+&$%(&('"/()$"4(/&Q0%F(&($#%%0%F($+,"$I6(S#/("%'L(0)(-+("$(2-+(-&2(S++%(/$&0%+I(0%(-"H(/"(2+&$,-(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
64(
&%I(0I+%/0)L(=&//+$%2(H0/-0%(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2O($+&I0%F(S+,&#2+("%'L(/-+%(,&%(&,/0"%(S+(&=='0+I(/"(
-+'=(I0$+,/(/-+(2/#I+%/(&2(/-+L(=$"F$+22(0%(/-+0$($+&I0%F(I+J+'"=4+%/>(
!
Act.!!i-+%(7(H+%/(S&,Q(/"(/-+(,&4=#26(&()+H(I&L2('&/+$(7(H&2(4+/(SL(&(/+&,-+$(H-"(2&0I6(d7(-&J+(
/&Q+%(&($#%%0%F($+,"$I("%(&()+H(")(4L(2/#I+%/2>e((@-+(&%&'LT+I(/-+($+,"$I6(&%I(H&2(&S'+(/"(2++(
/-+(2/$+%F/-2(&%I(%++I2(")(/-+(2/#I+%/2>((@-+(%"/0,+I(/-&/("%+(2/#I+%/(H&2(2"'+'L($+'L0%F("%(
J02#&'(0%)"$4&/0"%6(%&4+'L(/-+(S+F0%%0%F(2"#%I(")(H"$I2>((G+(H&2(%"/(&//+%I0%F(/"(4+&%0%F_(
/-+$+)"$+6([#2/(,&''0%F(&(H"$I(/-&/(-&I(/-+(2&4+(S+F0%%0%F(2"#%I>((.2(&($+2#'/(")(/-+(/+&,-+$(
%"/0,0%F(/-+(=&//+$%6(2-+(H&2(&S'+(/"(/&$F+/(/-02(H+&Q%+22(0%(-+$(F#0I+I($+&I0%F(F$"#=>((@-+(
=$"J0I+I(&(40%0(/+&,-(="0%/(&/(/-+(S+F0%%0%F(")(/-+('+22"%(/-&/(4"I+'+I()"$(2/#I+%/2(-"H(/"(
'""Q(&,$"22(&(H"$I(/"(,"%)0$4(H-&/(0/(026(H-0'+(&2Q0%F("%+2+')6(df"+2(0/('""Q($0F-/je(&%I(df"+2(0/(
4&Q+(2+%2+je((*-+(2/#I+%/2(/-+%(H+%/(0%/"(/-+(/+K/(&%I(&2(/-+(/+&,-+$('02/+%+I(0%("%(/-+4(
$+&I0%F6(2-+(=$"J0I+I(=$"4=/0%F(&%I($+0%)"$,+4+%/>((./(/-+(,"%,'#20"%(")(/-+('+22"%6(2-+(
R#+2/0"%+I(/-+(2/#I+%/2(0%(/-+(F$"#=(&S"#/(=&$/0,#'&$(%"/+2(/-&/(2-+(-&I(/&Q+%(0%($+)+$+%,+(/"(
/-+4(#20%F(/-+(2/$&/+FL(&%I(-"H(0/(-+'=+I(/-+4>((*-+(2/#I+%/2(2++4+I(/"(S+(4"$+(&H&$+6(S#/(
/-+(/+&,-+$(H0''(,"%/0%#+(/"($+0%)"$,+(&2(/-+L(S+,"4+(4"$+(0%I+=+%I+%/(H0/-(/-02(2/$&/+FL>(((
(
*-+(,&4=#2(&I40%02/$&/"$(02(%"H(=+$)"$40%F(H&'Q(/-$"#F-(S&2+I("%(/-+(/$&0%0%F(&%I(-"'I0%F(&''(
/+&,-+$2(/"(/-+(2&4+(2/&%I&$I2>((b"''"H(#=(02(Q+L(0%(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/>((*-+(%+K/(2/+=(
)"$(/-02(,&4=#2(02()"$(4+(/"(=$"J0I+(2040'&$(/$&0%0%F2(/"(%+H(/+&,-+$2>(((
!
P0T&((
7(/+&,-(2+,"%I(F$&I+$2(0%(&($#$&'(,"44#%0/L(0%(A"$/-(*+K&2>((c&%L(")(/-+(2/#I+%/2(0%(4L(
,'&22$""4(&$+(/$&%20/0"%&'($+&I+$2>((*"(-+'=(/-+4(4"J+(/"()'#+%/($+&I+$2(7(/$L(/"()0%I(,$+&/0J+(
H&L2(/"(0%,"$="$&/+()'#+%,L(&,/0J0/0+2(/-$"#F-"#/(/-+(I&L(0%(4L(,'&22$""4>((@"6(H-+%("%+(")(/-+(
/"=0,2(0%(/-+(,"#$2+(&II$+22+I()'#+%,L6(7(H&2(+&F+$(/"($+2+&$,-(/-+(/"=0,>((.2(7(S+F&%(/"($+2+&$,-(
4L(/"=0,6(7()"#%I(/-&/(1&20%2Q0(V9:8:Z(,"%I#,/+I(&('"/(")($+2+&$,-("%(/-+(/"=0,>((*+&,-0%F(
,-0'I$+%(/"($+&I(02(&(,"4='+K(#%I+$/&Q0%F>((1+&I0%F(0%J"'J+2(J&$0"#2(=$",+22+2(/"(S+,"4+()'#+%/(
$+&I+$2(V1"2+%S'&//6(8`X;_(.'J+$4&%%6(\%$&#6(](1#I+''6(9:8C_(1#44+'-&$/6(8``YZ(b'#+%,L(02(
H-+%(&($+&I+$(-&2(4&2/+$+I(/-+(/+K/(H0/-(&#/"4&/0,0/L(H0/-(H"$I($+,"F%0/0"%(&%I(I+,"I0%F(
2Q0''26(&2(H+''(&2($+&I0%F(H0/-(=$"2"IL(V1&20%2Q06(9:8:Z>((7%("$I+$()"$(&(2/#I+%/(/"(S+,"4+()'#+%/6(
/-+L(-&J+(/"(=$&,/0,+>(
!
Look.!!7(#2+(4#20,(0%(4L(,'&22$""4(/"(/$&%20/0"%(2/#I+%/2()$"4("%+(&,/0J0/L(/"(&%"/-+$>((.2(/-+(
2/#I+%/2(H+$+(/$&%20/0"%0%F("%+(I&L6(7($+&'0T+I(/-&/(/-+(J0I+"2(7(H&2(#20%F("%(k"#*#S+(H+$+(
,'"2+ID,&=/0"%+I>((7(I+,0I+I(/"(="2/(/-+(J0I+"2(I#$0%F(/$&%20/0"%2(&%I(+%,"#$&F+(/-+(2/#I+%/2(/"(
$+&I(/-+('L$0,2(/"(04=$"J+()'#+%,L>((7/(H&2(&(204='+(&,/0J0/L(/-&/(,"#'I(S+(+&20'L(0%/+F$&/+I(
/-$"#F-"#/(/-+(I&L>((7("S2+$J+I(/-+0$($+&,/0"%2(/"(/-+('L$0,2(&%I(-"H(/-+L(0%/+$&,/+I(H0/-(/-+(
/+K/2>((7/(H&2(0%/+$+2/0%F()"$(4+(/"(2++(/-+0$(+%F&F+4+%/(0%($+&I0%F>((*"(#%I+$2/&%I(4"$+(&S"#/(
/-02(=$&,/0,+6(7($+&I(&$/0,'+2(&%I(S""Q2(H$0//+%(SL(1&20%2Q0(V9:8:_(9:89Z>((7(&'2"(S+F&%(/"('02/+%(/"(
2+J+$&'(")(1&20%2Q0O2(="I,&2/2(&%I(J0I+"(,'0=2("%(k"#*#S+(/"('+&$%(4"$+(&S"#/(-02($+2+&$,->((
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
65(
i-0'+('02/+%0%F(/"("%+(")(-02(=$+2+%/&/0"%2("%(k"#*#S+6(-+(I02,#22+I(/-+(H&L2(4#20,&'('L$0,2(
-+'=(2/#I+%/2(H0/-()'#+%,L>((
+
Think.++7(I+,0I+I(/"(0%/$"I#,+()0J+(2"%F2(I#$0%F(/-+()0$2/(H++Q>(*-+(2"%F2(H+$+()$"4(/-+(o0IT(
m"=(,"''+,/0"%>((7(Q%+H(7(-&I(/"(p-""QO(/-+(2/#I+%/2(H0/-(2"%F2(/-&/(/-+L(H"#'I(+%["L>((.2(
2/#I+%/2(F"/(4"$+()&40'0&$(H0/-(/-+('L$0,26(7(H"#'I(&II(&(%+H(2"%F>((7/(H&2(0%/+$+2/0%F(/"(2++(/-+(
2/#I+%/2(&,/0J+'L(+%F&F+I(H-+%(7(H"#'I(="2/(/-+('L$0,2("%(/-+(S"&$I>(c&%L(2/#I+%/2(H"#'I(
,"$$+,/(/-+42+'J+2(H-+%('""Q0%F(&/(/-+(H"$I2>((.%(&I40%02/$&/"$(-&I("S2+$J+I(/-+(0%/+$&,/0"%(
/-+(2/#I+%/2(-&I(H0/-(/-+(/+K/>((@-+(2/&/+I6(d7(H&2(2#$=$02+I(-"H(/-+(2/#I+%/2(H"#'I(,-+,Q(/"(
2++(0)(/-+L(-&I(F"//+%(/-+('L$0,2($0F-/(H-+%(/-+L(H+$+%O/(%+,+22&$0'L('""Q0%F(&/(/-+(/+K/>e((.2(/-+(
L+&$(=$"F$+22+I6(7(&II+I(4"$+(2"%F2>((7(0%,'#I+I(2"%F2(/-&/(-&I('L$0,2(&%I(=+$/&0%+I(/"(I0))+$+%/(
,"%/+%/(&$+&2>((A"H6(/-&/(/-+(2,-""'(L+&$(02(&'4"2/("J+$6(7(-&J+(%"/0,+I(&%(0%,$+&2+(0%(2/#I+%/O2(
)'#+%,L(/-&%(7(-&J+(0%(=$+J0"#2(L+&$2>((b"$(+K&4='+6(7(-&J+(&(2/#I+%/(0%(4L(,'&22(/-&/(H&2(
H"$Q0%F(2'0F-/'L(S+'"H(F$&I+('+J+'>((@-+(2/$#FF'+I(H0/-()'#+%,L(&%I(,"4=$+-+%20"%>((f#$0%F("#$(
+%I(")(L+&$(&22+224+%/26(/-+(2/#I+%/2(2-"H+I(F&0%2(0%()'#+%,L(&%I(,"4=$+-+%20"%(2Q0''2>(@-+(02(
%"H($+&I0%F(&S"J+(F$&I+>((
+
Act.!!^$"J0I0%F(2/#I+%/2(&%("=="$/#%0/L(/"(=$&,/0,+()'#+%,L(H0/-(/-+(#2+(")(4#20,&'('L$0,2(,&%(S+(
+%F&F0%F(/"(2/#I+%/2>((nS2+$J0%F(2/#I+%/2(/$L0%F(/"(F+/(/-+(H"$I2(&,,#$&/+'L(H-0'+(20%F0%F(
&''"H+I(/-+4(/"(/&Q+("H%+$2-0=(")(/-+0$('+&$%0%F>((*-+L(H&%/+I(/"(F+/(/-+(H"$I2($0F-/>((mL(
0%,'#I0%F(2"%F2(H0/-('L$0,2(H&2(&(204='+(H&L(/"(F+/(2/#I+%/2(/"(=$&,/0,+(/-+0$()'#+%,L(H0/-('0//'+(
='&%%0%F("%(4L(=&$/>((7(I0I(%"/(-&J+(/"(,$+&/+(2=+,0&'(&,/0J0/0+2(+J+$LI&L(/"(=$&,/0,+()'#+%,L>((7(
#2+I(/+,-%"'"FL6(2/#I+%/2O(0%/+$+2/6(&%I(&%("=="$/#%+(/04+(0%(4L(I&L(/"(=$"J0I+(&()#%(H&L(/"(
=$&,/0,+(/-+0$()'#+%,L>((.''(0/(/""Q(H&2(&('0//'+(,$+&/0J0/Lq((
(
c"J0%F()"$H&$I6(7(H0''(0%,"$="$&/+(J0I+"2(H0/-(4#20,&'('L$0,2(0%("/-+$(,"%/+%/(&$+&2(4"$+(")/+%6(
+2=+,0&''L(H0/-(4&/-(,"%/+%/>((7(I0I(#2+('L$0,&'(4#20,(0%(2,0+%,+(&%I(2",0&'(2/#I+%/26(S#/(7(/-0%Q(
4"$+(#2+(0%(4&/-(H0''(-"=+)#''L(I+J+'"=(2/#I+%/2O(J",&S#'&$L(2Q0''2>((*-+$+(&$+(&(J&$0+/L(")(
$+&2"%2(/-02(2/$&/+FL(,&%(-+'=(2/#I+%/2(0%(/-+(,'&22$""4>((
!
@&%I$&(
*-+(I+20$+(/"($+&,-(2/#I+%/2(H0/-($+&I0%F(I0))0,#'/0+2(-&2(S++%(4L(F"&'(20%,+(7(2/&$/+I(/+&,-0%F(
8X(L+&$2(&F">((7(-&J+(H"$Q+I(H0/-(#%I+$(=$0J0'+F+I(2/#I+%/2()$"4(&''(H&'Q2(")('0)+(&%I(2/$+22(/"(
/-+4(/-+(04="$/&%,+(")($+&I0%F(&%I(/-+(Q%"H'+IF+(0/($+J+&'2(H-+%(/-+L("=+%(/-+(=&F+2(")(
"=="$/#%0/L>(((
!
!
Look.!(b"$(4L(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(=$"[+,/6(7(I+,0I+I(/"(H"$Q(H0/-(2/#I+%/2(H-"(H+$+($+&I0%F(H+''(
S+'"H(/-+(%&/0"%&'(&J+$&F+()"$(Y/-(F$&I+$2>((*-+2+(2/#I+%/2(H+$+(#%&S'+(/"(I+,"I+(H"$I26(
2"#%I("#/(H"$I26("$(,"%%+,/(,"$$+2="%I0%F('+//+$(2L4S"'2(/"(2"#%I2>((.)/+$($+&I0%F(/-+(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
66(
Theoretical+Models(V.'J+$4&%%6(\%$&#6(](1#I+''6(9:8CZ(/+K/(7(H&2(0%/+$+2/+I(0%(0%0/0&/0%F(&(
'0/+$&,L()$&4+H"$Q(/-&/(H0''(&''"H(/-+4(/"(&%&'L/0,&''L(&==$"&,-(&(H"$I(&%I(4&Q+(&('+//+$D
2"#%I(,"%%+,/0"%>((.,,"$I0%F(/"(l'&LO2(V8`;9Z('0/+$&,L(=$",+220%F(/-+"$L6(2-+()"#%I(d*-&/(/-+(
S+F0%%0%F6(=$")0,0+%/($+&I+$(#2+2('&%F#&F+(&%I(J02#&'(&%I(4"/"$(0%)"$4&/0"%(2"(H-&/("%(/-+(
2#$)&,+('""Q2('0Q+(204='+(H"$IDSLDH"$I($+&I0%F6(S#/(0%J"'J+2(,-0'I$+%('0%Q0%F(4&%L(/-0%F2(/-+L(
Q%"H()$"4(I0))+$+%/(2"#$,+2(VJ02#&'6(&#I0/"$L6(=-"%"'"F0,&'6(4"J+4+%/6(2=+&Q0%FM&$/0,#'&/0%F6(
&%I(Q%"H'+IF+(")(/-+('&%F#&F+(V=>(9;Z>e(
!
Think.!(7/(H&2(4L(0%0/0&'(&22+224+%/(/-&/(/-+2+(2/#I+%/2(-&I(0%&I+R#&/+(I+,"I0%F(2Q0''2(&%I(-&I(
4022+I(/-+()"#%I&/0"%&'(2Q0''2(%++I+I(/"($+&I(/+K/2>((.)/+$('""Q0%F(&/(/-+0$(,#4#'&/0J+()"'I+$2(7(
)"#%I(/-&/(/H"(")(/-+(2/#I+%/2(-&I(S++%(I0&F%"2+I(H0/-(IL2'+K0&6(&%I("%+(-&I(S++%(0I+%/0)0+I(
H0/-(&('+&$%0%F(I02&S0'0/L>((.''(/-$++(2/#I+%/2(-&I(F""I(J+$S&'(,"44#%0,&/0"%(2Q0''2>((7%0/0&''L6(7(
-&I(+&,-(2/#I+%/(/&Q+(&(=$+D&22+224+%/(=+$)"$4+I("%(/-+(2,-""'(&I"=/+I($+&I0%F(4"%0/"$0%F(
=$"F$&4(V7@7^Z>((*-02(4"%0/"$0%F(/""'(I0&F%"2+I(/-+($+&I0%F(2Q0''2(/-+(2/#I+%/2(-&I(4&2/+$+I(
&%I(/-"2+(/-&/(%++I+I()#$/-+$(I+J+'"=4+%/>((*-+()0%I0%F2()$"4(/-+(&22+224+%/(&''"H+I(4+(/"(
&I[#2/(/-+(=-"%0,2(0%2/$#,/0"%(7(04='+4+%/+I(H0/-(/-+2+(2/#I+%/2>(7(I+,0I+I(/"(F"("J+$(2"#%I2(
=&//+$%26(H"$I(=&//+$%26(&%I("/-+$(=-"%+40,(&H&$+%+22(2Q0''2()"$(9:(40%#/+2(I&0'L>((.)/+$(I0$+,/(
+K='0,0/(=-"%0,2(0%2/$#,/0"%6(2/#I+%/2(,"4='+/+I(&%(0%I+=+%I+%/(&220F%4+%/(/-&/()",#2+2("%(&(
F#0I+I(0%/+$&,/0J+('+22"%>((i-+%(2/#I+%/2(4&2/+$+I(/-"2+(2Q0''26(&%(&IJ&%,+I('+22"%(=$"J0I+I(
&II0/0"%&'(0%2/$#,/0"%2("$("/-+$(2Q0''2(/-+(2/#I+%/('&,Q>((!
!
Act.((NJ+%(/-"#F-('0/+$&,L(+%,"4=&22+2(4&%L(&$+&2(")(I+J+'"=4+%/6(4&2/+$0%F(/-+(
)"#%I&/0"%&'(2Q0''26(&''"H2(/-+($+&I+$(/"(F&0%(/-+(&S0'0/L(/"(,"F%0/0J+'L(=$",+22(&(H"$I(H0/-('0//'+(
+))"$/(0%(&(H"$Q0%F(2L2/+4(/-&/(,"%%+,/2(/-+($+&I+$(&%I(/-+(/+K/(Vl'&L6(9::8Z>((.,,"$I0%F(/"(
@0%F+$(V8``YZ6(d1+&I+$2(H-"(-&J+(&,R#0$+I(/-+(%+,+22&$L(H"$Q0%F(2L2/+42(&$+(&S'+(/"(4"S0'0T+(
$&=0I'L(&%I()'+K0S'L(&(-0+$&$,-0,&'("$F&%0T&/0"%(")(2#S2L2/+42(0%(H-0,-(&(40%04#4(")(4+%/&'(
+%+$FL(&%I(&//+%/0"%(&$+(I+J"/+I(/"(/-+(0%=#/(2L2/+42>e((7(='&%(/"(,"%/0%#+(H"$Q0%F(H0/-(/-+2+(
2/#I+%/2(#20%F(/-+('0/+$&,L(=$",+220%F(/-+"$L(0%(H-0,-(J02#&'26(=-"%"'"F0,&'(/+&,-0%F6(&%I(H"$I(
&//&,Q(2Q0''2(&$+(/-+()",#2>((1+&I0%F(4"J0%F()"$H&$I(-&2(S+,"4+(&%(&,-0+J&S'+(F"&'()"$(/-+4(
&%I(=$0%/(02(4"$+(/-&%(&%("S[+,/("%(=&=+$>((7(&4(2#$+(/-&/(H0/-(,"%/0%#+I(+K='0,0/(2#=="$/(&%I(
=$&,/0,+6($+&I0%F(H0''(S+(&('0)+D'"%F(2Q0''(/-&/(H0''("=+%(#=(4&%L(I""$2(")("=="$/#%0/0+2()"$(/-+4>(
!
!"+'((
7(&4(&%(0%/+$4+I0&/+(2,-""'(,"#%2+'"$(0%($#$&'(I02/$0,/(0%(/-+(@"#/-H+2/>(.2(&(/+&,-+$6(7(-+'=(
2/#I+%/2(4&Q+(2+%2+(")(,-&''+%F0%F(H"$I(=$"S'+42(&2(/-+L(=$+=&$+(/"(/&Q+(2/&%I&$I0T+I(/+2/2>((
@"4+(")(4L(,"H"$Q+$2(2&L(/-&/(4L(["S(0%,'#I+2(-+'=0%F(2/#I+%/2('+&$%(+))+,/0J+(/+2/(/&Q0%F(
2/$&/+F0+2>(
!
Look.!!b"$(/-02(=$"[+,/6(7('""Q(&/(/-+(H"$Q(")(*&%S+6(&(2/#I+%/(H-"(-&2(I0))0,#'/L(&=='L0%F(
S&,QF$"#%I(4&/-(Q%"H'+IF+(/"(/-+(=&22&F+2(2-+($+&I2(&%I(/-+$+)"$+(")/+%/04+2(-&2(I0))0,#'/L(
&%2H+$0%F(,"4=$+-+%20"%(R#+2/0"%2>(7%(4L(+K=+$0+%,+6(/-02(I0))0,#'/L(,&#2+2(2/#I+%/2('0Q+(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
67(
*&%S+(/"(I"(%"/(I"(H+''("%(2/&/+(2/&%I&$I0T+I(/+2/2(S+,&#2+(/-+L($#2-(,&#20%F(
402#%I+$2/&%I0%F2(S+/H++%(/-+(/+K/(&%I(/-+($+&I+$>((m+'"H(0%(b0F#$+(96()0%I(&%(0%/+$&,/0"%(
S+/H++%(*&%S+(&%I(4L2+')(H-+$+(2-+(,"%)#2+2(&(4&/-+4&/0,&'()0F#$+>((
(
Figure+2:++A+Conversation+with+Tanbe+
(
(
Think.((.2(&(,"#%2+'"$6(7(S+'0+J+(/-&/(2/$&/+FL(0%2/$#,/0"%(=$"="2+I(SL(^&'0%+2&$(&%I(m$"H%(
V8`;YZ6(&%I6(H0''(F0J+(2/#I+%/2(0%,$+&2+I(/+K/(,"4=$+-+%20"%(&%I(S+//+$(=+$)"$4&%,+("%(
2/&%I&$I0T+I(/+2/2(SL(&''"H0%F(/-+4(/04+(/"($+$+&I(&%I(S#0'I(2+')D4"%0/"$0%F(2Q0''2>((@"6(0%(/-+(
,&2+(")(*&%S+(7(2#FF+2/+I(&(2/$&/+FL(/"(&II$+22(/-+(402,#+2(2-+(+%,"#%/+$+I(H-+%(2-+()&,+I(
4#'/0='+(2L''&S'+(H"$I2>((b0$2/6(7(/"'I(-+$(/"(2/"=(H-+%+J+$(2-+(+%,"#%/+$2(I0))0,#'/(J",&S#'&$L>((
@+,"%I6(7(/"'I(-+$(/"(H$0/+(H-&/(2-+(/-0%Q2(/-+(H"$I(4+&%2(I0$+,/'L(&S"J+(/-+(H"$I>((*-0$I6(7(
/"'I(-+$(/"(2++(0)(/-+(S&,QF$"#%I(H"$I()0/(0%/"(/-+(+K02/0%F(=&//+$%>(^&$0S&Q-/(&%I(i+2,-+(
V8``XZ(2&L(/-&/(/-02(2/$&/+FL(-+'=2(2/#I+%/2(I+/+$40%+(="220S'+(H"$I(4+&%0%F()$"4(/-+(,"%/+K/(
/-&/(,&%(S+(&=='0+I(/"(/-+(/+K/>(
!
Act.!!*-02(4+/-"I(&''"H2(2/#I+%/2(/"(#2+(I+,"I0%F(2Q0''2(&%I(0%,$+&2+(,"4=$+-+%20"%(SL(
+K&40%0%F(&%I(+K='&0%0%F(/-+(H"$I2(#20%F(H-&/(/-+L(&'$+&IL(Q%"H(&S"#/(/-+(H"$I(&2(&(
2,&))"'I0%F(/""'>((c"J0%F()"$H&$I6(7(='&%(/"(&2Q(2/#I+%/2(/"(H$0/+(H-&/(/-+L(Q%"H(&S"#/(
#%)&40'0&$(H"$I2(I0$+,/'L(&S"J+(/-+(I0))0,#'/(H"$I2(/-+L(+%,"#%/+$(/-+%(#2+(/-+0$(S&,QF$"#%I(
Q%"H'+IF+(&2(&(/+4="$&$L(2,&))"'I0%F(/""'>(((
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
68(
(
f+S"$&-(
!7(&4(&%(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2=+,0&'02/(4&%&F+$(V^oD9Z()"$(&%(#$S&%(I02/$0,/>((cL($"'+(02(/"(-+'=(=$+=&$+(
2=+,0&'02/2(/"(2#=="$/(/+&,-+$2O('0/+$&,L(=$&,/0,+2>((*"(I"(2"6(/-+(2=+,0&'02/2(&//+%I(H++Q'L(
/$&0%0%F2(/"(2/&L(&S$+&2/(")(S+2/(=$&,/0,+2>(f#$0%F(/-02(2+4+2/+$6(7(-&J+(,"4+(/"(/-+($+&'0T&/0"%(
/-&/($+&I0%F(&%I(0/2(0%2/$#,/0"%(02(,"4='+K(&%I($+R#0$+2(&(2L2/+4&/0,(&==$"&,-(/"(/-+(H&L(7(
=$+=&$+(4L($+&I0%F(2=+,0&'02/2>((7%(2-"$/6(/-+(R#+2/0"%(S+,"4+26(-"H(I"(7(,$+&/+(&(2/$#,/#$+I(
2#=="$/(2L2/+4(/"(=$+=&$+('0/+$&,L(2=+,0&'02/2(/"(I+'0J+$(-0F-(R#&'0/L(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(
/"(/-+(/+&,-+$2(0%(/-+0$(=&$/0,#'&$(2,-""'2j(!
!
Look.!!*-02(2=$0%F6(7(-&J+($+)'+,/+I(&S"#/(/-+(,"&,-0%F(,L,'+(H+(#2+(/"(/$&0%(2=+,0&'02/2(&%I(/-+(
2#=="$/(/-+2+(2=+,0&'02/2(F0J+(/"(/+&,-+$2>((b$"4(4L(="0%/(")(J0+H6("#$(2=+,0&'02/2(-&J+(/"(H+&$(
4&%L(-&/2(&%I(2+$J0,+(&%(&$$&L(")(%++I2>((m+,&#2+(")(/-026(7(,"%,'#I+(/-&/(4L(2=+,0&'02/2(%++I(
&%(+K/$&('&L+$(")(2#=="$/(&%I(&(%&$$"H+$(/&$F+/(")(4+&2#$&S'+("S[+,/0J+2>(7/(02(4L(S+'0+)(/-&/(
4&Q0%F(/-02(,-&%F+(H0''(+%-&%,+(/-+(=$+=&$+I%+22(")(/-+(2=+,0&'02/2(/-&/(H0''(0%(/#$%(&0I(0%(/-+(
I+'0J+$L(")(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/()"$(/+&,-+$2>((
(
Think.++@"6(/-02(2=$0%F(7(S+F&%(/"(&II(&('&L+$(")(2#=="$/(H0/-(/-+(,$+&/0"%(")(&(I",#4+%/(/"(&0I(0%(
/-+(/$&,Q0%F(&%I(4"%0/"$0%F(")(0%I0J0I#&'(2=+,0&'02/2(/$&0%0%F(&%I(/-+(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(
/-+L(I+'0J+$+I(S&2+I("%(/-02(/$&0%0%F>(f#$0%F(/-+(&%&'L2026(7($+&'0T+I(/-&/(/-+('+&$%0%F(-&==+%0%F(
)"$(/-+('0/+$&,L(2=+,0&'02/2(H&2(H0I+(0%2/+&I(")(I++=>((*-&/(02(/"(2&L6(/-+L(Q%+H(&('0//'+(&S"#/(
4&%L(/"=0,2(S#/("%'L(&()+H(H+$+(+K=+$/2(0%(/-+(=&$/0,#'&$(/"=0,2(/-+L(/&#F-/>(7%(2#46(&)/+$(
$+&I0%F(V.'J+$4&%%6(\%$&#6(](1#I+''6(9:8CZ(&%I(,"%2#'/0%F(H0/-(4L(/+&4(4+4S+$2(&%I(
2=+,0&'02/2(7(I+,0I+I(/"()",#2("#$(/$&0%0%F2(4"J0%F()"$H&$I("%(/-+(S&'&%,+I('0/+$&,L(&==$"&,-(
&%I(&220F%+I('+&I(2=+,0&'02/2(/"(H$0/+(/-+(,#$$0,#'#4(&%I(I+20F%(/$&0%0%F2()"$(/-+(2=+,0&'02/2(/"(
4++/(/-"2+(=#$="2+2>((
! !
Act.!!.(,"44"%(F"&'(0%("#$(I02/$0,/(02(/"(-&J+(&''(2/#I+%/2($+&I0%F("%(F$&I+('+J+'(SL(/-0$I(F$&I+>((
^&$/(")(/-&/(,&%(S+(&,,"4='02-+I(SL(-&J0%F(-0F-'L(/$&0%+I(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2=+,0&'02/2(H-"(&$+(
Q%"H'+IF+&S'+(")(S&2+I(S&'&%,+I('0/+$&,L(&==$"&,-+2(/-&/(0%,"$="$&/+(H-"'+('&%F#&F+(&%I(
=-"%0,2(VW""I4&%(](W""I4&%6(9:8CZ>((7%(4L(J0+H6(2=+,0&'02/2(%++I(&(2/$"%F()"#%I&/0"%(")(
S&'&%,+I('0/+$&,L(&==$"&,-+2(&'"%F(H0/-(&(,"44&%I(")(/-+(,"&,-0%F(,L,'+>((cL($"'+(4"J0%F(
)"$H&$I(02(/"(,$+&/+(&(4&%&F+I(&==$"&,-()"$('+&I2(&%I(2=+,0&'02/2(2"(/-&/(/-+L(,&%(S+//+$(
=$+=&$+(/+&,-+$2(/"(04=$"J+(/-+('0/+$&,L(2Q0''2(")(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2()$"4(F$&I+2(oD89>(b"$(%"H6(
-"H+J+$(7(H0''(,-&$F+(4L('0/+$&,L(2=+,0&'02/2(/"()",#2(/-+0$(0%2/$#,/0"%(")(F$&I+2(Q0%I+$F&$/+%(
/-$"#F-(2+,"%I(F$&I+2(&2(&(H&L(/"($+4&0%(24&''>(((
(
*-+('&L+$+I(2#=="$/(2L2/+4(&'"%F(H0/-(/&$F+/+I(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(H0''(-+'=(2=+,0&'02/2(
-&J+(&(,'+&$(#%I+$2/&%I0%F(")(/-+0$($"'+(&%I($+2="%20S0'0/0+2>((*-+(H"$Q(4"J0%F()"$H&$I(H0''(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
69(
+R#0=(/-+(I02/$0,/(H0/-(2#=="$/(2L2/+42(/-&/(&$+(2/$#,/#$+I(&$"#%I(,"44"%('0/+$&,L(=$&,/0,+2>((
7%(/-+()#/#$+6("/-+$(,"%20I+$&/0"%2(H0''(%++I(/"(S+(4&I+(/"(+%2#$+(=$"F$&4()0I+'0/L>(!
!
^+&$'(
7(&4(&(Q0%I+$F&$/+%(r(2+,"%I(F$&I+(7%2/$#,/0"%&'(@=+,0&'02/()"$(&('&$F+(#$S&%(I02/$0,/(&%I(H"$Q(
)"$(f+SS0+>((7(H"$Q(H0/-(/+&,-+$2(&/(C('"H(=+$)"$40%F(+'+4+%/&$L(2,-""'2>((cL($"'+(&2(&(
2=+,0&'02/(02(/"(,"&,-6(4+%/"$6(&%I(/$&0%(/-+(QD9(/+&,-+$2(&/(/-"2+(,&4=#2+2>(7(&4(&(,+$/0)0+I(
$+&I0%F(2=+,0&'02/(S#/(7(&'2"(H"$Q(H0/-(,"$+(2#S[+,/2>((7(-&J+(S++%(0%(+I#,&/0"%()"$(8`(L+&$2(&%I(
-&J+(/&#F-/(2=+,0&'(+I#,&/0"%(&%I(NlD5>((7(-&J+(S++%(0%(4L(,#$$+%/($"'+(&2(&%(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(
2=+,0&'02/()"$(9(L+&$2>(!
!
Look.!!.2(&%(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2=+,0&'02/6(7(/$&0%+I(#%I+$(=$")+220"%&'2(H-"(H+$+(&(=&$/(")(/-+(
1+&I0%F(b0$2/(4"J+4+%/>((.2($+2#'/(")(/-&/(/$&0%0%F(4L('"J+()"$(/-+(#2+(")(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(H&2(
$+J0J+I>((7%(4L(H"$Q(H0/-(/+&,-+$26(7(-&J+(%"/0,+I(/-&/(/-+L(2+'I"4(#2+(/-+($+&ID&'"#I6(+J+%(
)"$(/-+(204='+(+%["L4+%/(")($+&I0%F>((f#$0%F(/-02(2+4+2/+$6(7(H&2($+40%I+I(&S"#/(/-+(="H+$(")(
$+&I(&'"#I(&%I(0/2(04='0,&/0"%2()"$()#/#$+('0/+$&,L(2#,,+22>((7(H&%/(/"($+0%/$"I#,+(/-+(#2+(")(/-+(
$+&ID&'"#I(/"(/+&,-+$2>((.2(&(,'&22$""4(/+&,-+$6(7(#2+I(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(S+,&#2+(0/(02(&(H0I+'L(
&,,+=/+I(&2(&(4+&%2(")(I+J+'"=0%F(J",&S#'&$L(VA+H/"%6(^&I&Q6(](1&20%2Q06(9::;Z>(7%(/-02(,'&226(7(
-&J+(S++%($+&I0%F(&%I(2/#IL0%F(/-+(H"$Q(")(A&FL(&%I(@,"//(V9:8CZ(&%I(-&J+(&'2"($+&I(o0%I'+O2(
V9::`Z(2/#IL("%(,-0'I$+%O2(J",&S#'&$L(F$"H/-(/"(0%)"$4(4+("%(H&L2(7(,&%(&IJ",&/+()"$($+&I(
&'"#I>(7%(2#46(7(H&%/(/"(/$&0%(/+&,-+$2("%(J",&S#'&$L(=$",+22+2(#20%F($+&ID&'"#I(&2(&(/""'(/"(
0%/$"I#,+(&%I(4"I+'(/-02(J+$L(,$0/0,&'(,"4=$+-+%20"%(2Q0''>((
!
Think.!!7(-&J+(,$+&/+I(2"4+(40%0('+22"%2(/-&/(7(#2+(/"(4"I+'(H&L2(/-&/(/+&,-+$2(,&%(/+&,-(
J",&S#'&$L(2Q0''2(/"(/-+0$(2/#I+%/2>(7(-&J+(&'2"(F&/-+$+I($+2"#$,+2('0Q+(F$&=-0,("$F&%0T+$26(
&%,-"$(,-&$/26(&%I($+&I0%F(2/$&/+F0+2(F#0I+2(/-&/(/+&,-+$2(,&%(#2+(/"(='&%(/-+0$("H%(40%0('+22"%(
#20%F(&(S""Q(")(/-+0$(,-"0,+>((7(H&%/(/"(2-"H(/-+4(/-&/(/-+$+(&$+(J&$0"#2(H&L2(/-+L(,&%(-+'=(
2/#I+%/2(0%,$+&2+(/-+0$(H"$I(Q%"H'+IF+>((7(&4(I"0%F(=$&,/0/0"%+$($+2+&$,-("%(/-+(/"=0,(")(#20%F(
$+&ID&'"#I(/"(/+&,-(J",&S#'&$L(&,R#020/0"%>(7(#%I+$2/&%I(/-&/(/-+(=$",+22+2(/-&/(2/#I+%/2(%++I(
/"($+,"F%0T+(/-+(,"4='+K0/L(")(H"$I(Q%"H'+IF+(&$+(04="$/&%/(0%(/-+0$(J",&S#'&$L(&,R#020/0"%(
2"6(H-&/(7(H&%/(/"(I"(02(H"$Q(H0/-(4L(/+&,-+$2(/"(4"I+'(&%I(/$&0%(/-+4("%(H&L2(/-+L(,&%(
4&K040T+(/-+0$(#2+(")(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(&2(&(S+2/(=$&,/0,+(0%($+&I0%F(0%2/$#,/0"%(&%I(J",&S#'&$L(
&,R#020/0"%>((7(H&%/(/"(I"(&(2/#IL(/-&/(&%2H+$2(/-+(R#+2/0"%g(df"+2(#20%F(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(/"(
0%/$"I#,+6(4"I+'6(&%I(/+&,-+$(J",&S#'&$L(-+'=(2/#I+%/2(0%,$+&2+(H"$I(Q%"H'+IF+j((7(H"#'I('0Q+(
/"(#2+(/+&,-+$2(/-&/(&$+(H0''0%F(&%I(H-"(&$+(&'$+&IL(#20%F(/-02(=$&,/0,+(&%I(,"4=&$+(/-+4(/"(
/+&,-+$2(H-"(&$+(%"/(V)"$(H-&/+J+$($+&2"%Z>(7(S+'0+J+(/-&/(#20%F(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(H0''(-+'=(
2/#I+%/2(0%,$+&2+(/-+0$(H"$I(Q%"H'+IF+(&/(&($&/+(/-&/(02()&2/+$(/-&%(/-+(2/#I+%/(H-"2+(/+&,-+$2(
&$+(%"/(&'$+&IL(#20%F(/-02(=$&,/0,+>(
!
Act.!!.(=&$/(")(4L($"'+(")(7%2/$#,/0"%&'(@=+,0&'02/6(7(&4($+2="%20S'+()"$(,$+&/0%F(&%I(=$+2+%/0%F(
=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/>((7(-&J+(&'$+&IL(,$+&/+I(&(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(2+220"%(/-&/(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
70(
I+/&0'2(H&L2(/-&/(/+&,-+$2(,&%(#2+(/-+($+&ID&'"#I(/"(/+&,-(S&20,($+&I0%F(2Q0''2>((7(H0''(,$+&/+(&(
=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(/-&/(/$&0%2(/+&,-+$2("%(+K='0,0/(J",&S#'&$L(0%2/$#,/0"%6(H-0,-(02(2"(
,$0/0,&'()"$(/-+(2/#I+%/2(H+(2+$J+>((d@/#I+%/2(H-"(%++I(-+'=(4"2/(0%(/-+(&$+&(")(J",&S#'&$L(h(
/-"2+(H-"2+(-"4+(+K=+$0+%,+(-&2(%"/(F0J+%(/-+4(&(2#S2/&%/0&'()"#%I&/0"%(0%(/-+(J",&S#'&$L(")(
'0/+$&/+(&%I(&,&I+40,(N%F'02-(h(%++I(/"(&,R#0$+(H"$I2(&/(&(=&,+(+J+%()&2/+$(/-&%(/-&/(")(/-+0$(
=++$2e(VA&FL(](@,"//(9:8CZ>((7(H0''(&'2"(,"%/0%#+(/"(,"&,-6(4+%/"$6(&%I(='&%(H0/-(/-+(/+&,-+$2(
/-&/(7(2+$J+(/"(04='+4+%/(/-+(2/$&/+F0+2(&%I(2Q0''2(0%(J",&S#'&$L(&,R#020/0"%(/-&/(7(-&J+(/$&0%+I(
/-+4("%(/-$"#F-"#/(/-+(%+K/(2,-""'(L+&$>((*-+(#'/04&/+(F"&'(02($+&I0%F(,"4=$+-+%20"%(H-0,-(
$+2+&$,-(I+4"%2/$&/+2(VA&FL(](@,"//6(9:8CZ(02(2/$"%F'L(0%)'#+%,+I(SL(J",&S#'&$L(Q%"H'+IF+>((
(
Discussion!
m"%%0+6(&()0)/-DF$&I+(/+&,-+$6($+="$/+I(/-&/(-+$(2/#I+%/2(-&I('040/+I(J",&S#'&$L>((.%F+'&6(&(
$+&I0%F(2=+,0&'02/6(2&0I(/-&/(/-+(/+&,-+$2(2-+(H&2(H"$Q0%F(H0/-(0%(-+$(,+%/+$(%++I+I(-+'=(H0/-(
0%)"$4&'($+&I0%F(0%J+%/"$0+2(&%I(F#0I+I($+&I0%F>((P0T&6(&(2+,"%IDF$&I+(/+&,-+$6($+="$/+I(/-&/(
2-+(H"%I+$+I(&S"#/(0%,$+&20%F(/-+()'#+%,L('+J+'2(")(-+$(2+,"%I(F$&I+$2>((@&%I$&6(&%(NP.(
,""$I0%&/"$6()"#%I(/-&/(2"4+(")(-+$()"#$/-D(F$&I+(2/#I+%/2(H+$+(#%)&40'0&$(H0/-(=-"%0,2(&%I(
2/0''(2/$#FF'+I(/"(4&Q+(,"%%+,/0"%2(S+/H++%('+//+$2(&%I(2"#%I2>((!"+'6(&%(+'+4+%/&$L(,"#%2+'"$6(
%"/0,+I(/-&/(-02(2/#I+%/2(-&I(/$"#S'+(=&220%F(2/&%I&$I0T+I(/+2/2>((f+SS0+6(&%(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(
2#=+$J02"$6(2&0I(/-&/(2-+(H&%/+I(/-+($+&I0%F(2=+,0&'02/2(/"(S+(+K=+$/2>((^+&$'6(&(Q0%I+$F&$/+%(
/-$"#F-(2+,"%I(F$&I+(0%2/$#,/0"%&'(2=+,0&'02/6()"#%I(/-&/(-+$(/+&,-+$2(%++I+I(4"$+(0%2/$#,/0"%(
&S"#/(/-+(S+%+)0/2(")($+&I(&'"#I>((.'/"F+/-+$6(/-+2+(,L,'+2(2#FF+2/(/-&/(H+(I+J+'"=+I(S+,&#2+(
H+(H+$+(&S'+(/"(=#/(0%/"(=$&,/0,+(H-&/(H+('+&$%+I(&S"#/($+&I0%F(&%I(0/2(0%2/$#,/0"%(&%I(&'2"(/"(
)0%I(H&L2(/"(=#/(H-&/(H+(&$+('+&$%0%F(0%(/-+('&$F+$(,"%/+K/(")(/-+('0/+$&,L(=$")+220"%>((
(
c"$+"J+$6(/-02("=="$/#%0/L(/"(I+J+'"=(&2(&(,"44#%0/L(")(2,-"'&$2(=$"J0I+I(#2(H0/-(&(S+//+$(
H&L(/"(,"%%+,/(H-&/(H+(&$+('+&$%0%F(0%(/-+(F$&I#&/+(,'&22(/"("#$(=+$2"%&'6(=$")+220"%&'(
&2=0$&/0"%2(&%I(H"$Q(,"440/4+%/2(H0/-($+2=+,/(/"('0/+$&,L>((*-&/(02(/"(2&L6('+&$%0%F('0/+$&,L(
/-+"$L(I#$0%F("#$(,"#$2+(")(2/#IL(H&2(&%(04="$/&%/(&2=+,/(/"(H-&/(H+(I0I6(S#/(&I&=/0%F(/-+(
dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e($+2+&$,-(,L,'+(/"("#$("H%(0%I0J0I#&'(20/#&/0"%2(&''"H+I(#2(/"(S$0%F(/-+2+(
&S2/$&,/(0I+&2(0%/"("#$(real+20/#&/0"%2>((m"L+$(V8``:6(==>(XXDX;Z(&=/'L(2/&/+26(d*-+(&04(")(
+I#,&/0"%(02(%"/(/"("%'L(=$+=&$+(2/#I+%/2()"$(=$"I#,/0J+(V-0F-+$(+I#,&/0"%Z(,&$++$26(S#/(&'2"(/"(
+%&S'+(/-+4(/"('0J+('0J+2(")(I0F%0/L(&%I(=#$="2+_(%"/("%'L(/"(F+%+$&/+(%+H(Q%"H'+IF+6(S#/(/"(
,-&%%+'(/-&/(Q%"H'+IF+(/"(-#4&%+(+%I2>e(*&Q0%F("%(&(=$&,/0/0"%+$D2,-"'&$(V9::XZ($"'+(H&2(/-+(
I0))+$+%,+(/-&/(4&I+(/-+(I0))+$+%,+(/"(-"H(H+(2&H("#$(20/#&/0"%6(/-+(H&L2(H+(/-"#F-/(&S"#/(
/-+46(&%I(H-&/(H+(I0I(&S"#/(0/>(((
(
Conclusion!(
n#$(0/+$&/0"%(")(/-+(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+(0%("#$(F$&I#&/+(,'&22($+40%I+I(#2(/-&/(/+&,-+$(
I+,020"%2(&$+(0%)"$4+I(SL(&(4#'/0/#I+(")()&,/"$2(0%,'#I0%Fg(,#$$0,#'&$(4&%I&/+2(0%(/-+0$('",&'(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
71(
20/#&/0"%26(="'0/0,&'(,'04&/+(&%I(&))0'0&/0"%2(")(/-+(/04+6(2/#I+%/2O(&%I(/+&,-+$2O(%++I26(&%I(/-+(
=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(+K=+$0+%,+2(")(/-"2+(H-"(&$+(+%F&F+I(0%(/-+(I+,020"%2(V.$&#["6(
9:88Z>(((*-&/(02(/"(2&L6(/-&/(/-+(I+,020"%2(/+&,-+$2(4&Q+(&S"#/(H-&/(H+(/+&,-(&%I(-"H(H+(/+&,-(
0/(02(&(,"4='+K(#%I+$/&Q0%F(&%I($+R#0$+(#2(/"(4&Q+(0/(&(-&S0/(/"(&'H&L2('""Q6(/-0%Q6(&%I(&,/(/"(
+%2#$+(/-&/(H+(&$+(=$"J0I0%F(&I+R#&/+(0%2/$#,/0"%(/"("#$(2/#I+%/2(/-&/(02(2+%20/0J+(/"(/-+0$(
044+I0&/+(%++I2>((\'/04&/+'L6(/-+(2/#I+%/2($+="$/+I(/-&/(/&Q0%F(=&$/(0%(/-02(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-(
,L,'+($+0%J0F"$&/+I(/-+0$(S+'0+)2(&S"#/(/-+(&S0'0/L(/"(,"%%+,/(/-+"$L(/"(=$&,/0,+(&%I(/-+0$(=#$2#0/(
")(&(I",/"$&/+(0%($+&I0%F(+I#,&/0"%>(((
(
i0''0&4(m"H+%6(2&0I6(2,-"'&$'L($+2+&$,-(d$+)'+,/2("#$(=$+220%F6(0$$+=$+220S'+(%++I(&2(-#4&%(
S+0%F2(/"(,"%)$"%/(/-+(#%Q%"H%(&%I(/"(2++Q(#%I+$2/&%I0%F()"$(0/2("H%(2&Q+>((7/(02(/0+I(
0%+K/$0,&S'L(/"(/-+()$++I"4(/"(/-0%Q()$+2-'L6(/"(2++(=$"="20/0"%2(")(+J+$L(Q0%I(0%(+J+$L(,-&%F0%F(
'0F-/>((.%I(0/(,+'+S$&/+2(/-+(2=+,0&'(+K-0'&$&/0"%(/-&/(,"4+2()$"4(+J+$L(%+H(0I+&(Vm"L+$6(8``:6(
=>(8XZ>e((7/(H&2(/-+(0%/+%/(/"(I"([#2/(/-&/(H0/-("#$(dP""Q6(*-0%Q6(.,/e(,L,'+2hH+(Q%"H("#$(
)0%I0%F2(H0/-(/-+2+(0%0/0&'(&//+4=/2(H0''('+&I(#2(/"()#/#$+(H"$Q(&%I(I02,"J+$0+2>((((
(
.2(&,/0"%($+2+&$,-+$26(H+(+K=+$0+%,+I()0$2/D-&%I(/-&/(0/(02(="220S'+(/"(0%%"J&/+("%(/-+($#%h/"(
=&$&''+'(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/(](,#$$0,#'#4(I+J+'"=4+%/(&2(H+(/$0+I(/"(4++/(/-+(%++I2(")(
/-+(2/#I+%/2>(( ((
(
(
(
!
About!the!Authors!!
!
Juan!Araujo(02(&%(.22",0&/+(^$")+22"$(&%I(.2202/&%/(f+=&$/4+%/(G+&I(H0/-(l#$$0,#'#4(&%I(
7%2/$#,/0"%(&/(*+K&2(.]c(\%0J+$20/L(l"44+$,+>((G+(/+&,-+2(,"#$2+2(&/(/-+(#%I+$F$&I#&/+(&%I(
F$&I#&/+('+J+'(=+$/&0%0%F(/"('&%F#&F+(&%I('0/+$&,L>((G02($+2+&$,-(0%/+$+2/2(I+'J+(0%/"(=$+2+$J0,+(
/+&,-+$(=$+=&$&/0"%6(0%2+$J0,+(=$")+220"%&'(I+J+'"=4+%/6(&%I(H$0/0%F(&%I(0/2(0%2/$#,/0"%>((N4&0'g((
[#&%>&$&#["s/&4#,>+I#>(
(
Joel!Blaylock!02(&%(#==+$(+'+4+%/&$L(,"#%2+'"$(&/(m"%-&4(7@f>((G+(02(R#0,Q'L(&==$"&,-0%F(/-+(
+%I(")(-02(I",/"$&'(,"#$2+H"$Q>((G02($+2+&$,-(0%/+$+2/2(0%,'#I+(/-+(2/#IL(")(2/$#FF'0%F($+&I+$2(
H0/-('+&$%0%F(,-&''+%F+2>((!N4&0'g(!S'&L'",Qs'+"4&0'>/&4#,>+I#>(
!
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
72(
Pearl!Garden!02(&(oD9(7%2/$#,/0"%&'(@=+,0&'02/(0%(f&''&2(7@f>(@-+(-&2(S++%(&%(+I#,&/"$()"$(9:(
L+&$2>(^+&$'(02(&(C$I(L+&$(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/(&/(*+K&2(.]c(\%0J+$20/L(l"44+$,+>(N4&0'g((
=F&$I+%s'+"4&0'>/&4#,>+I#>(
!
Sandra!Hogg!02(&(%&/0J+(")(*+K&2(H0/-(8;(L+&$2(")(+I#,&/0"%&'(+K=+$0+%,+>((@-+(02(/-+(f+&%(")(
7%2/$#,/0"%()"$(&(,-&$/+$(2,-""'('",&/+I(0%(2"#/-+&2/(f&''&2>((@-+(-&2(S++%(&(/+&,-+$6('0/+$&,L(
0%/+$J+%/0"%02/(&%I(,"&,->((@-+(02(,#$$+%/'L(&(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/(&/(*+K&2(.]chl"44+$,+(
H-+$+(2-+(02(=#$2#0%F(&(I+F$++(0%(l#$$0,#'#4(&%I(7%2/$#,/0"%>((@-+(02(4&$$0+I(&%I(&(4"/-+$(")(C(
H"%I+$)#'(L"#%F(&I#'/2>((G+$(CDL+&$D"'I(F$&%I2"%(02(/-+('0F-/(")(-+$('0)+(&%I(+%["L2(2=+%I0%F(
/04+(H0/-()&40'L(&%I()$0+%I2>(N4&0'g((2-"FFs'+"4&0'>/&4#,>+I#>(
!
Liza!Larue!02(&(oD9(7%2/$#,/0"%&'(@=+,0&'02/()"$(f&''&2(7@f>((@-+(H&2(&(,'&22$""4(+'+4+%/&$L(
/+&,-+$()"$(89(L+&$2>(P0T&(02(,#$$+%/'L(&(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/(&/(*+K&2(.]c(l"44+$,+>((G+$(
$+2+&$,-(0%/+$+2/2(0%,'#I+(/-+(04='+4+%/&/0"%(")('0/+$&,L(=$&,/0,+2(&%I(/-+(2/#IL(")(4#'/0D
'0/+$&,0+2(0%(+'+4+%/&$L(,'&22$""42>((N4&0'g((Q'Q[$9C98sF4&0'>,"4>(
!
Deborah!Murillo!02(&%(7%2/$#,/0"%&'(@=+,0&'02/(c&%&F+$(V^oD9Z()"$(f&''&2(7%I+=+%I+%/(@,-""'(
f02/$0,/>((@-+(02(&(C$I(L+&$(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/(&/(*+K&2(.]c(\%0J+$20/L(l"44+$,+>((N4&0'g(
I4#$0''"8s'+"4&0'>/&4#,>+I#>(
!
Bonnie!Still!02(,#$$+%/'L(&(5/-(&%I(a/-(F$&I+(NP.(&%I(@",0&'(@/#I0+2(/+&,-+$(&/(m"'+2(c0II'+(
@,-""'>((*-02(02(-+$(8C/-(L+&$(0%(+I#,&/0"%>((c2>(@/0''(-&2(/&#F-/(9%I6(5/-6(&%I(a/-(F$&I+("J+$(/-+(
L+&$2>((m"%%0+t2(=-0'"2"=-L(")(+I#,&/0"%(0%,'#I+2(/-+(04="$/&%,+(0%(F$"H0%F(/-$"#F-($+2+&$,-(
&%I(+K=+$0+%,+(&2(H+''(&2(S#0'I0%F($+'&/0"%2-0=2(H0/-(2/#I+%/2(&%I()&40'0+2>(N4&0'g((
S2/0''s'+"4&0'>/&4#,>+I#>(
!
Angela!Venters(02(&(oD5(N'+4+%/&$L(NP.(&%I(fL2'+K0&(@=+,0&'02/(0%(N&2/(*+K&2>((.%F+'&(02(&(Y/-D
L+&$(I",/"$&'(2/#I+%/(&/(*+K&2(.]chl"44+$,+>((G+$($+2+&$,-(0%/+$+2/(02(2/$#FF'0%F($+&I+$26(
=&$/0,#'&$'L(/-"2+(/-&/(&$+(0I+%/0)0+I(&2(IL2'+K0,>(.%F+'&(-&2(S++%(0%(+I#,&/0"%()"$(8;(L+&$26(
2+$J0%F(0%(4#'/0='+(,&=&,0/0+2>((N4&0'g((4$+2J+%/+$2sF4&0'>,"4>(
!
Leslie!Patterson!/&#F-/(N%F'02-(&%I('&%F#&F+(&$/2(0%(*+K&2(40II'+(&%I(-0F-(2,-""'2()"$(/+%(L+&$2(
S+)"$+(S+,"40%F(&(/+&,-+$(+I#,&/"$>((A"H($+/0$+I()$"4(#%0J+$20/L(H"$Q6(2-+(02(&(l"Df0$+,/"$(")(
/-+(A"$/-(@/&$(")(*+K&2(i$0/0%F(^$"[+,/6(&(A&/0"%&'(i$0/0%F(^$"[+,/(20/+6(&%I(&(,"%2#'/&%/(H0/-(
G#4&%(@L2/+42(fL%&40,2(7%2/0/#/+6(H-0,-()",#2+2("%(F+%+$&/0J+(H"$Q(0%(,"4='+K(
2L2/+42>((N4&0'g(('+2'0+>=&//+$2"%s#%/>+I#>(
!
!
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
73(
References(
(
.'J+$4&%%6(f>(N>6(\%$&#6(A>(!>6(](1#II+''6(1>(VNI2Z>(V9:8CZ>(Theoretical+models+and+processes+of+reading(Va/-(
(+I0/0"%Z>(A+H&$Q>(fNg(7%/+$%&/0"%&'(1+&I0%F(.22",0&/0"%>((
(
.$&#["6(!>(!>(V9:88Z>(*+&,-+$(I+,020"%D4&Q0%Fg(l#'/#$&'(4+I0&/0"%(0%(/H"(-0F-(2,-""'(N%F'02-('&%F#&F+(&$/2(
(,'&22$""42>(\%=#S'02-+I(f022+$/&/0"%>(f+%/"%6(*ug(\%0J+$20/L(")(A"$/-(*+K&2>(((
(
.22",0&/0"%6(.4+$0,&%(V9::XZ>(Getting+in>(i&2-0%F/"%g(.4+$0,&%(^2L,-"'"F0,&'(.22",0&/0"%>(
m"L+$6(N>(P>(V9::`Z>(Scholarship+reconsidered:+Priorities+of+the+professorate>(@&%(b$&%,02,"6(l.g(*-+(l&$%+F0+(
(b"#%I&/0"%()"$(/-+(.IJ&%,+4+%/(")(*+&,-0%F>((
(
l&$%+F0+(b"#%I&/0"%(V9:8CZ>((*-+(l&$%+F0+(b"#%I&/0"%(")(0%2/0/#/0"%2(")(-0F-+$(+I#,&/0"%>((f"H%'"&I+I("%(
(c&L(C86(9:8X()$"4(
(-//=gMM,&$%+F0+,'&220)0,&/0"%2>0#>+I#M'""Q#=MJ0+Hv0%2/0/#/0"%>=-=j#%0/v0Iw99Y55Y]2/&$/v=&F+w'""Q#
(=>=-=],'RwxXmx99)0$2/v'+//+$x99xC.x99*x99xXf(
(
l'&L6(c>(V8`;9Z>(Observing+young+readers:+Selected+papers>(NK+/+$6(AGg(G+0%+4&%%>((
(
l'&L6(c>(V9::8Z>(Change+over+time+in+children’s+literacy+development>(^"$/24"#/-6(AGg(G+0%+4&%%>(
(
b"#%/&26(7>(l>6(](^0%%+''6(W>(@>(V9:89Z>(W#0I+I($+&I0%Fg(*-+($"4&%,+(&%I(/-+($+&'0/L>(The+Reading+Teacher6(66VYZ6(
(9a;D9;Y>(I"0g8:>8::9M/$/$>:889C(
(
W""I4&%6(k>(c>6(](W""I4&%6(o>(@>(V9:8CZ>(*"(+$$(02(-#4&%g(P+&$%0%F(&S"#/('&%F#&F+(=$",+22+2(SL(&%&'LT0%F(
(402,#+2>(7%(Theoretical+models+and+processes+of+reading(Va/-(+I>6(==>(595D5YCZ>(A+H&$Q6(fNg(
(7%/+$%&/0"%&'(1+&I0%F(.22",0&/0"%>((
(
W$#H+''6(N>(V9::XZ>(Teach+with+your+heart:+Lessons+I+learned+from+the+freedom+writers>(Akg(m$"&IH&L(m""Q2>((
(
o0%I'+6(o>(!>(V9::`6(A"J+4S+$Z>(3",&S#'&$L(I+J+'"=4+%/(I#$0%F($+&ID&'"#I2g(=$04&$L(=$&,/0,+2>(The+Reading+
+Teacher,+63VCZ6(9:9D988>(
(
P&J+6(!>6(](i+%F+$6(N>(V8``8Z>(@0/#&/+I('+&$%0%Fg(P+F0/04&/+(=+$0=-+$&'(=&$/0,0=&/0"%>((l&4S$0IF+6(\og(
(l&4S$0IF+(\%0J+$20/L(^$+22>(
(
P+H0%6(o>(V8`YaZ>(.,/0"%($+2+&$,-(&%I(40%"$0/L(=$"S'+42>(7%(W>(i>(P+H0%(VNI>Z(Resolving+social+conflicts.(A+H(
(k"$Q6(Akg(G&$=+$(&%I(1"H>((
(
c+$/'+$6(l>(.>(V9::`Z>(Action+research:+Teachers+as+researchers+in+the+classroom+(2nd+edition).+P"2(.%F+'+26(l.g(
(@&F+(^#S'0,&/0"%2>((
(
A&FL6(i>(N>6(](@,"//6(!>(V9:8CZ>(3",&S#'&$L(=$",+22+2>(7%(f>(N>(.'J+$4&%%6(A>(!>(\%$&#6(](1>(m>(1#II+''(VNI2>Z(
(Theoretical+models+and+processes+of+reading(V5/-(+I>6(==>(Y5;DYXCZ>(A+H&$Q6(fNg(7%/+$%&/0"%&'(1+&I0%F(
(.22",0&/0"%>(
(
^&'0%,2&$6(.>6(](m$"H%6(.>(V8`;YZ>(1+,0=$",&'(/+&,-0%F(")(,"4=$+-+%20"%D)"2/+$0%F(&%I(,"4=$+-+%20"%D4"%0/"$0%F(
&,/0J0/0+2>(Cognition+and+Instruction,+16(88XD8X5>(
Journal(of(Teacher(Action(Research((
!"#$%&'(")(*+&,-+$(.,/0"%(1+2+&$,-(- 3"'#4+(56(722#+(86(9:8;6(<=$&,/0,&'/+&,-+$$+2+&$,->,"4?6(7@@A(B(9CC9D99CC(E(!*.1>(.''(10F-/2(
74(
^&$0S&Q-/6(*>(@>6(](i+2,-+6(c>(V8``XZ>(3",&S#'&$L(+%-&%,+4+%/(&,/0J0/0+2(&%I($+&I0%F()"$(4+&%0%F(0%(2+,"%I(
('&%F#&F+(J",&S#'&$L(&,R#020/0"%>(Second+language+vocabulary+acquisition:+A+rationale+for+pedagogy6(
(55VYZ6(8XYD9::>(
(
^&//+$2"%6(P>6(m&'IH0%6(@>6(.$&#["6(!>6(@-+&$+$6(1>6(](@/+H&$/6(c>(V9:8:Z>(P""Q6(/-0%Q6(&,/g(\20%F(,$0/0,&'(&,/0"%(
($+2+&$,-(/"(2#2/&0%($+)"$4(0%(,"4='+K(/+&,-0%FM'+&$%0%F(+,"'"F0+2>(Journal+of+Inquiry+and+Action+in+
+Education,+3(3),(8C`D85X>(
(
^0%+6(W>(V9::`Z>(Teacher+action+research:+Building+knowledge+democracies>(*-"#2&%I(n&Q26(l.g(@&F+(
(^#S'0,&/0"%2>((
(
1&20%2Q06(*>(V9:8:Z>(The+fluent+reader:+Oral+and+silent+reading+strategies+for+building+fluency,+word+recognition,+
+and+comprehension>(Akg(@,-"'&2/0,(l"$="$&/0"%>((
(
1&20%2Q06(*>(3>6(](^&I&Q6(A>(f>(V9:89Z>(From+phonics+to+fluency:+Effective+teaching+of+decoding+and+reading++fluency+
+in+the+elementary+school>(^+&$2"%(^#S'0,&/0"%2>((
(
1&J0/,-6(f>(V9:8:Z>(The+death+and+life+of+the+great+American+school+system:+How+testing+and+choice+are+
+undermining+education>(Akg(m&20,(m""Q2>(((
(
1"2+%S'&//6(P>(c>(V8`X;Z>(The+reader,+the+text,+and+the+poem:+The+transactional+theory+of+literacy+work>(
(l&$S"%I&'+6(7Pg(@"#/-+$%(7''0%"02(^$+22>((
(
1#44+'-&$/6(f>(N>(V8``YZ>(*"H&$I(&%(0%/+$&,/0J+(4"I+'(")($+&I0%F>(7%(1>(m>(1#II+''6(c>(1>(1#II+''6(](m>(@0%F+$(VNI2>Z(
Theoretical+models+and+processes+of+reading(VY/-(+I>6(==(;aYD;;YZ>(A+H&$Q6(fNg(7%/+$%&/0"%&'(1+&I0%F(
.22",0&/0"%>(
(
@0%F+$6(G>(V8``YZ>(*-+(2#S2/$&/&D)&,/"$(/-+"$L(")($+&I0%F>((7%(1>(m>(1#II+''6(c>(1>(1#II+''6(](G>(@0%F+$(VNI2>Z+
Theoretical+models+and+processes+of+reading+VY/-(+I>6(==>(;`5D`9XZ>(A+H&$Q6(fNg(7%/+$%&/0"%&'(1+&I0%F(
.22",0&/0"%>((
(
@/$0%F+$6(N>(*>(V8``aZ>(Action+research:+A+handbook+for+practitioners>(*-"#2&%I(n&Q26(l.g(@&F+(^#S'0,&/0"%2>(
(
@/$0%F+$6(N>(*>(V9::XZ>(Action+research>(VC$I(+I0/0"%Z>(P"2(.%F+'+26(l.g(@&F+>(
(
@/$0%F+$6(N>(*>6(l-$02/+%2+%6(P>(c>(](m&'IH0%6(@>(l>(V9::`Z>(Integrating+teaching,+learning,+and+action+research:+
+ Enhancing+instruction+in+the+K-12+classroom>(*-"#2&%I(n&Q26(l.g((@&F+>(
(
k0%6(1>(V8`;YZ>(Case+study+research:+Design+and+methods(V9%I(NI>Z>(m+J+$'L(G0''26(l.g(@&F+(^#S'0,&/0"%2>(((
!!
(
(
!
( (
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
This paper argues that educators interested in sustainability should look to complexity science for guiding principles. When we view our classrooms and campuses as living, dynamic ecologies, we can, as insiders, make sense of what might otherwise seem chaotic or meaningless. This perspective enables us not only to describe and explain what is happening around us, but also to use our findings to influence emerging patterns across our classrooms, campuses, or our larger communities. We suggest that educators use a Look, Think, Act cycle recommended by Ernie Stringer to encourage and support sustainable school reform.
Chapter
Among ordinary language learners, the acquisition of vocabulary has long been felt to be a crucial component of learning a foreign language. Second Language Vocabularly Acquisition has the goal of comparing the effectiveness of the direct learning of vocabulary (through memorization) and the indirect learning of vocabulary (through context); it encourages an appropriate balance between direct and indirect teaching of vocabulary in second language classrooms. The authors of these original articles present theoretical background, empirical research, and case studies focusing on a variety of modes of vocabulary acquisition. There is also an exploration of relevant pedagogical issues, including a description of practical strategies and techniques for teaching vocabulary.
Book
"This is a wonderful book with deep insight into the relationship between teachers’ action and result of student learning. It discusses from different angles impact of action research on student learning in the classroom. Writing samples provided at the back are wonderful examples."-Kejing Liu, Shawnee State University Teacher Action Research: Building Knowledge Democracies focuses on helping schools build knowledge democracies through a process of action research in which teachers, students, and parents collaborate in conducting participatory and caring inquiry in the classroom, school, and community. Author Gerald J. Pine examines historical origins, the rationale for practice-based research, related theoretical and philosophical perspectives, and action research as a paradigm rather than a method. Key Features: Discusses how to build a school research culture through collaborative teacher research; Delineates the role of the professional development school as a venue for constructing a knowledge democracy; Focuses on how teacher action research can empower the active and ongoing inclusion of nontraditional voices (those of students and parents) in the research process; Includes chapters addressing the concrete practices of observation, reflection, dialogue, writing, and the conduct of action research, as well as examples of teacher action research studies.
Book
Integrating Teaching, Learning, and Action Research: Enhancing Instruction in the K–12 Classroom: Helping teachers engage K–12 students as participatory researchers to accomplish highly effective learning outcomes Integrating Teaching, Learning, and Action Research: Enhancing Instruction in the K–12 Classroom demonstrates how teachers can use action research as an integral component of teaching and learning. The text uses examples and lesson plans to demonstrate how student research processes can be incorporated into classroom lessons that are linked to standards. Key Features Guides teachers through systematic steps of planning, instruction, assessment, and evaluation, taking into account the diverse abilities and characteristics of their students, the complex body of knowledge and skills they must acquire, and the wide array of learning activities that can be engaged in the process; Demonstrates how teacher action research and student action learning—working in tandem—create a dynamic, engaging learning community that enables students to achieve desired learning outcomes; Provides clear directions and examples of how to apply action research to core classroom activities: lesson planning, instructional processes, student learning activities, assessment, and evaluation.
Article
The authors examine the growth and impact of guided reading, small group teaching for differentiated instruction in reading that was stimulated by their early publications. Many changes in literacy education have been observed as a result—almost as if educators had a “romance” with guided reading and leveled books. While changes have been positive, the “reality” is that there is much more work to be done to bring guided reading to its full potential for helping children become effective and joyful users of literacy. The authors call for a deeper understanding of the reading process and of the text characteristics of leveled books. They discuss misconceptions regarding fluency and describe the strategic use of assessment and the role of facilitative talk. Regarding guided reading instruction, we are at the end of the beginning and need to forge new understandings for the future.
Article
Reading aloud is a common practice in primary classrooms and is viewed as an important vehicle for vocabulary development. Research indicates that interactive read-aloud styles and adult mediation of word learning are effective in enhancing word learning, but less is known about the actual practices of primary teachers. Read-alouds are complex instructional interactions in which teachers choose texts, identify words for instruction, and select the appropriate strategies to facilitate word learning.