ArticlePDF Available

Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes

Authors:

Abstract

This article deals with mediation in language teaching, focusing on how the practice of mediation – as a specific language skill – can be incorporated in the syllabus. The chapter defines the skill of mediation as an emerging concept in language education, and discusses its potential for effective teaching of English for Specific Purposes in general and English for Legal Purposes in particular. The first part of the text seeks to answer several questions, aiming to determine whether mediation is relevant in the context of legal practice and whether it has a place in an English for Law syllabus. The second part addresses a more practical concern of how the skill of mediation can be practiced by students. The article makes a case for assigning mediation a much more central place in the classroom, giving a number of specific examples of how this soft skill can be developed in the teaching of ESP and ELP.
STUDIES IN LOGIC, GRAMMAR
AND RHETORIC 53 (66) 2018
DOI: 10.2478/slgr-2018-0003
Barbora Chovancov´a
Masaryk University, Czech Republic
PRACTICING THE SKILL OF MEDIATION IN ENGLISH
FOR LEGAL PURPOSES
Abstract. This article deals with mediation in language teaching, focusing on
how the practice of mediation – as a specific language skill – can be incorpo-
rated in the syllabus. The chapter defines the skill of mediation as an emerging
concept in language education, and discusses its potential for effective teaching
of English for Specific Purposes in general and English for Legal Purposes in
particular. The first part of the text seeks to answer several questions, aiming
to determine whether mediation is relevant in the context of legal practice and
whether it has a place in an English for Law syllabus. The second part addresses
a more practical concern of how the skill of mediation can be practiced by stu-
dents. The article makes a case for assigning mediation a much more central
place in the classroom, giving a number of specific examples of how this soft
skill can be developed in the teaching of ESP and ELP.
Keywords: legal English, ESP, ELP, mediation, communicative skills, CEFR.
1. Introduction
The field of English for Specific Purposes (ESP) has had a long tra-
dition of paying a close attention to the needs of language students. First
established as a discipline in the 1980s (Hutchinson and Waters 1987), is
was further developed by numerous scholars (e.g. Dudley-Evans 1998; Hard-
ing 2007) who have emphasized the learner-centred approach, typically bas-
ing their frameworks on careful needs analysis (Basturkmen 2006, 2013).
The field of legal ESP, also known as English for Legal Purposes (ELP),
has also received significant input from genre analysis (Swales 1990; Bha-
tia 2004). The concentration on “specialized discourse” (Gotti 2003) has
allowed ELP scholars to benefit from many findings on the genre charac-
teristics of legal texts and the peculiarities of typically written legal texts
and various legal discourses (Bhatia 1987; Bhatia et al. 2008; Gotti and
Williams 2010). Some of this research has been turned into practical advice
on how to design teaching materials (see, for instance, Bhatia 2002).
ISBN 978-83-7431-548-7 ISSN 0860-150X 49
Barbora Chovancov´a
Traditionally, some of the practical considerations of ELP have con-
centrated on language skills that have to do with legal stylistics (e.g. the
drafting of contracts and legislative texts), language reception (e.g. extrac-
tion of information from texts, particularly in view of the specific genre
characteristics of legal texts in view of their syntactic complexity and den-
sity of terminology, cf. Bhatia 1987) and language production (e.g. drafting
documents in a foreign language, which is a skill increasingly needed in
a globalized economy that involves multinational legal teams).
Increasingly apparent, however, is a shift in ELP teaching towards soft
skills. For instance, many recent textbooks of ELP have started to empha-
size soft skills, in addition to teaching the traditional legal English content
(Krois-Lindner and Translegal 2006; Krois-Lindner and Firth 2008). That
is only natural in view of modern patterns of international communication,
particularly among highly educated professionals, such as law school grad-
uates. In a globalized economy and integrated Europe, such professionals
not only increasingly work in multinational teams, but also need to mediate
texts and information originating in different linguistic environments.
The skill of mediation, thus, is highly relevant in the legal context. The
interaction with clients – in both spoken and written form – represents
a substantial part of the workload of many lawyers. This communication is
marked by shifting levels of expertise, where legal professionals should be
able to explain complex legal concepts in ways that are intelligible to clients,
thereby enabling them to make relevant choices on the basis of such medi-
ated knowledge. Importantly, this concerns mediation both within a single
language and across various language (see below).
As such, the soft skill of mediation should come to the focus of ELP
teachers and be practiced in legal English classrooms in more systematic
ways. In some cases, this will include the modification of existing or the
preparation of new materials that can be used in Legal English classrooms
to practice various aspects of mediation. As I show in the second part of
this text, such self-developed materials can be meaningfully included in
the Legal English syllabus, in order to teach students the main mediation
strategies as explained in detail in CEFR ID (90). Arguably, mediation as
a soft skill that is fundamental not just for inter-language communication
(as originally proposed in CEFR) but also for intra-language communication
across different levels of expertise. As such, skill is of paramount importance
in language-learning situations that involve the teaching of languages for
specific purposes (Chovancov´a 2016).
50
Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes
2. Mediation and ESP
In its linguistic sense, the concept of “mediation”1 emerged in the 1990s
in connection with the Common European Framework of Reference for Lan-
guages (CEFR, 2001). This document distinguishes between four types of
language activities that should be in the focus when assessing the proficiency
levels of foreign language users. Mediation was thus aligned with three other
forms of language activities, namely reception, production, and interaction.
In the concept offered by CEFR, mediation consists of the skills of translat-
ing and interpreting and, thus, does not concern language behaviour that
has been seen as central under the earlier dominance of the communicative
approach to language learning, even though CEFR lists such activities as
summarising and paraphrasing texts and hints at the possibility of intra-
language mediation, cf.:
In mediating activities, the language user is not concerned to express his/her
own meanings but simply to act as an intermediary between interlocutors who
are unable to understand each other directly, normally (but not exclusively)
speakers of different languages. (CEFR 2001: 87, Section 4.4)
In its original form, however, CEFR did not provide an entirely adequate
definition of mediation, which was thus left without any elaboration in the
form of more detailed descriptors. For that reason, the notion of media-
tion has not enjoyed the attention it would deserve and has – until quite
recently – remained on the periphery of the interest of educational policy
makers and language learning professionals (for some exceptions in the field
of ESP, see Dendrinos 2006; Chovancoa 2016). Nevertheless, the initial con-
ceptual inadequacy contained in CEFR, which appeared to place too much
emphasis on the “intermediary” role of mediators and the mere “transfer”
of meanings (see criticism in Byram and Hu 2013) has now been addressed
by a project of the Council of Europe’s Language Policy Unit (North and
Piccardo 2016a, b). Completed in April 2016, the project amended the defi-
nition, thus putting language professionals in a much better position to deal
with this phenomenon.
In this paper, I adopt the analytical framework of mediation proposed
by North and Piccardo (2016a) in the above-mentioned document. They
develop the descriptive scheme and illustrative descriptors for mediation
within CEFR by elaborating the various aspects of this skill and setting the
target competencies of learners. The rationale for developing this scheme
was to assess – more adequately – the linguistic competence of L2 speakers
according to the official “Common Reference levels” (i.e., A1, A2, B1, B2,
51
Barbora Chovancov´a
C1, C2) that are used to measure the communicative competencies of foreign
language users. In this way, the proficiency levels can be more adequately
linked to learners’ actual communicative behaviour.
Mediation is seen as including two key notions: (1) the co-construction
of meaning in interaction and (2) the movement between the individual and
social levels in language learning (North and Piccardo 2016a: 4). This ap-
proach acknowledges the fact that the construction of meaning is a dynamic
process that depends on the cooperation between all the parties involved
in a given act of communication – a fundamental premise of various in-
teractional approaches to human interpersonal communication (Locher and
Graham 2010) as well as in language pedagogy (cf. the notion of collabo-
rative learning; Gibbons 2003). In addition, this view holds that language
learning is concerned with the interface between the individual and the so-
cial. Thus, for instance, where an individual strives to produce a successful
act of communication, he or she inevitably does so within the broader so-
cial and discursive context manifested through the various discourse types,
genre conventions, as well as pragmatic competencies that language users
need to navigate (cf. Bhatia 2017).
The new CEFR sees the social aspects as having a central role in the
process of mediation. In this version, the new CEFR goes beyond the tra-
ditional view of mediation: it is no longer seen merely as a synonym for
“translation or interpreting” (as in the previous version). Instead, the term
has attained a considerably wider scope. Indeed, mediation is now recog-
nized as being comprised of four different types, namely linguistic, cultural,
social, and pedagogic (North and Piccardo 2016a: 8–12). This systemati-
zation acknowledges the multi-dimensional role that the skill of mediation
plays in diverse communicative contexts.
3. Mediation in legal English
So far, little has been written about mediation in language teaching,
perhaps with the notable exception of Dendrinos (2006), who deals with
the aspects of both teaching and testing. Similarly, the application of medi-
ation in the field of English for Specific purposes (ESP) has yet to be fully
explored. First attempts have, however, been made, e.g. concerning medi-
ation in Legal English classes (Chovancoa 2016). More specifically, this
concerns the designing of mediation activities in both printed and self-made
materials for students of law, aimed at addressing the information gap cre-
ated by a necessity to mediate information across different languages, e.g.
52
Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes
processing in a source text (e.g. a law or some other legal text) in one lan-
guage and rendering the information in another language. Clearly, this goes
beyond translation and interpreting because critical thinking and specific
cognitive skills are required (cf. the illustrative descriptors in CEFR).
However, mediation also applies to individuals working in one and the
same language. Such intra-language mediation (Chovancoa 2016: 23) ac-
tually constitutes a quite common everyday communitive skill, though it is
particularly necessary in some professional contexts. In this type of media-
tion, an individual needs to communicate across different levels of expertise,
producing “alternative textualizations” (Cornelius 2010).
In the following, initially intra-language mediation is illustrated with
a concrete activity developed for first year law students (section 3.1), and
then sample tasks are provided that deal with the various dimensions of me-
diation: linguistic (section 3.2), cultural (section 3.3), social (section 3.4),
and pedagogical (section 3.4), which can be designed around the main ac-
tivity shown below.
3.1. Mediation and role play
Firstly a sample activity to see how an aspect of mediation can be
introduced through role play can be considered. While one of the traditional
tasks involves inter-language awareness (terminology translation), the role
play task extends the learning situation to intra-language mediation since
it involves communication in English only.
Example 1
Background: a lesson on property law for first year students in the sec-
ond term of their study. Language level B2. The topic is the law of
probate. The task is to become familiar with the textual and struc-
tural template of last wills and testaments (as well as some of the legal
background to this issue).
First, students are presented with an authentic template of a last will and
testament (offered by legal practitioners free of charge to the general public
in Florida, USA). The initial task is to become familiar with the material.
This is done by means of a translation activity, with students being asked
to translate key terms from or into their mother tongues. This quite simple
and straightforward task ensures that the students go through the docu-
ment carefully, making themselves aware of the technical vocabulary and,
more generally, the overall content (structure, customary content, typical
formulations, etc.).
53
Barbora Chovancov´a
However, despite having “gone” through the document when perform-
ing the above-described task (i.e., skimming through the document, and
translating the highlighted terms), their reading can be very superficial.
A follow-up task was therefore designed with the intention to make the stu-
dents study the document in depth, a task that could come under the term
of “mediation”.
In a role play format activity, one student is assigned the role of a lawyer
while another acts out the role of a client – an elderly citizen. The “lawyer”
is asked to give advice to the “client”, who wants to dispose of his or her
property by will. The “lawyer” is to guide the prospective testator through
the template, explaining all relevant information, adapting the language so
that the client can fully understand the content.
In this way, students practice multiple skills. The task involves not only
the transmission and mediation of information, but also other important
soft skills such as reformulation and explanation. Students playing the role
of the lawyer need to be aware that their counterpart, the client, is a non-
lawyer. Moreover, because in this particular task (in order to emphasize the
point), the client is also an elderly person, it is not just that the information
needs to be given in an understandable way but also the communication
partner is to be treated with care and respect.
3.2. Linguistic mediation
A prominent place among the various aspects of mediation is held by
the linguistic aspect of mediation. As North and Piccardo (2016a: 8) point
out, students need to know “how to translate and interpret, more formally
or less formally, or transforming one kind of text into another”.
In any communicative act, the two key factors that will determine the
choice of linguistic means and the level of formality in a given situation are
the context of situation and the recipient of the utterance. For law students,
this means that they have to be linguistically sensitive, being able to adapt
their style according to the speaker and the situation. Upon assessing these
contextual variables, they have to be able to opt for legal terms and other
features of legalese when talking to another professional, and automatically
add explanations for the sake of clarity when talking to a client, adjusting
the level of formality accordingly.
Relevance for the sample activity
In the sample activity above, there are several instances of possible lin-
guistic mediation that can be used by students/teachers to develop aware-
ness of the right degree of formality and the extent to which professional
54
Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes
language needs to be changed. The text, even though a relatively simple
but potentially legally binding document, can be filled in by an informed
laymen, provides ample opportunities to practice this type of mediation.
Particularly relevant in the context of the above-described activity is
intra-language mediation. It is realized through the necessity to summarise
an L2 text in L2. This concerns, for instance, the way terminology is han-
dled by students when mediating the text for their colleagues. Since the
template of the last will is rich in legal terms, it is therefore ideal for prac-
tice of linguistic mediation. Thus, students need to learn to assess which
terms are key to the understanding of the text and which are likely to be
difficult for their client. For instance, the student “lawyer” may seek to
explain the phrase “simultaneous death of spouse” as “this means if you
and your wife/husband die at the same time”. Alternatively, the practic-
ing of reformulation and explication of terminology may be initiated by the
“clients”, who can ask the “lawyers” to clarify certain terms of phrases.
Linguistic mediation is a core skill that any lawyer dealing with the
general public needs to acquire and internalize. It can be somewhat difficult
for first-year students of law, who strain to “speak like lawyers” in order to
show that they have actually grasped the concept. In other words, instead
of proudly using the newly acquired legal terms and phrases, the students
are guided in this activity to reduce the level of expertise and make their
utterances and explanations simpler, both as regards specific formulations
and terminology.
3.3. Cultural mediation
Linguistic mediation is very closely connected with cultural mediation,
which, however, extends beyond the language as such. While language use
is inextricably linked to culture, the situation becomes even more com-
plex when two different languages are used. Culturally-related issues then
inevitably emerge, requiring the attention of the person involved in the pro-
cess of mediation. This kind of mediation could be treated within the scope
of inter-language mediation.
As lawyer-client consultation is essentially about bringing about an un-
derstanding of the relevant legal issue, it also goes under the heading of “cul-
tural mediation”. As North and Piccardo (2016a: 8) observe, “it is a ques-
tion of working at a level sophisticated enough to preserve the integrity
of the source and to get across the essence of the meaning intended”. This
goes beyond paraphrasing the text and explaining terminology to lay people
(as in linguistic mediation), since the real issue is often a different legal cul-
ture, notably the differences between the Civil and Common law countries
55
Barbora Chovancov´a
which the lawyers need to be aware of. Needless to say, this is sometimes
challenging for undergraduate students of law because, particularly at the
beginning of their studies, they may lack the knowledge of the relevant legal
culture (including their own).
Being familiar (at least to a certain extent) with the history and the
development of Legal English in common law countries will help students
when dealing with UK or US legal documents, such as the one used in
the sample activity. For instance, they will be familiar with various multi-
nominal phrases and doublets/triplets. Used to ensure precision, or in some
instances just for the aesthetic value of alliteration, such stylistic features are
a common occurrence in modern legal texts; yet despite the efforts of the
Plain English movement to eliminate some of them, that has led to the
situation that civil law countries are nowadays less prone to use strings of
words to denote a simple concept in their newly drafted legislation.
Relevance for the sample activity
It is therefore important for a lawyer to be able to address this issue
when assisting a client to understand a document, such as the one the
illustrated task. For instance, the student “lawyer” may feel it appropriate
to explain that the term “Last Will and Testament”, which – even though
comprising of two separate terms – refers to a single concept and a single
document.
Even though the main aim of this activity is to practice speaking skills in
English, particularly that of mediation, this is a good instance of “translan-
guaging” (Garc´ıa and Wei 2014), where additional knowledge resources need
to be drawn on in order to ensure successful communication. It would be
appropriate for the “lawyer” to explain that in his or her mother tongue,
i.e. Czech in this case, the “Last Will and Testament” can be translated
either as the general “posledn´ı v˚ule” (the equivalent of “last will”) or, more
officially, as “avˇet’ ” (i.e. “testament”), but not as a combination of both. In
some cases, other expressions are possible, e.g. the umbrella term “pr´ızen´ı
pro pˇr´ıpad smrti”. Some other culture-dictated and language-related pecu-
liarities include, for instance, the capitalisation of key terms in English.
There is also a possibility for some follow-up tasks that may reveal some
striking differences in the law between countries. In the Czech Republic, for
example, if the last will is written by hand, there is no requirement for the
signatures of the two witnesses to be attached. Interestingly enough, the
same is true about Kentucky, but that is an exception to the law in most
other US states.
56
Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes
3.4 Social mediation
The third aspect of mediation is social mediation, which is closely con-
nected to the above-mentioned cultural mediation. This is acknowledged by
North and Piccardo (2016a: 9), who suggest that “[c]ultural awareness, of
course, applies within a language as well as across languages and cultures,
with consideration of idiolects, sociolects and the links between styles and
textual genres. It also concerns relating different sub-cultures: social and
professional, within the umbrella culture of a society”. This aspect is thus
related to various pragmatic competencies that language users draw on in
their everyday interactions with each other as well as the various interac-
tional norms that constitute their professional culture(s). It is thus hardly
surprising that “...the comprehension difficulty may not be due to language;
it may well be due to lack of knowledge or experience, to a lack of familiarity
with the area or field concerned” (North and Piccardo 2016a: 9).
Clearly, this is the area where the legal aspects of the lawyer-client
interaction come into play. After all, the difference between the level of
expertise and knowledge between the lawyer and the client forms the very
essence of legal consultation: the client comes to see the lawyer to obtain
legal advice; and much of the service provided by a lawyer to a client is
embedded in their social interaction.
Relevance for the sample activity
How is the social dimension of mediation applicable with respect to
the activity at hand? The individual involved in mediation acts as an “in-
termediary” who helps to “bridge gaps and overcome misunderstandings”
(North and Piccardo 2017: 85) also between various discourse communities.
In the case of the template of the last will – as well as other types of sample
legal texts found on the Internet – there is a disclaimer warning the user not
to rely on such generic texts entirely and to consult a lawyer. The full word-
ing of the template could be used as an example of useful phrases for social
mediation. A different example consists of the legal style that is typical of
the professional community of lawyers. Thus, the quote from the template
I am married to Mary Smith, and all references in this Will to my wife
are references to her”, with all its specificity may illustrate the point. It is
an example of discourse used by the sub-group of professional lawyers, and
no other professional would put the same information quite like this.
Having discussed the linguistic, cultural and social mediation, which –
as has been shown – are quite closely intertwined and equally relevant to
the task, attention needs to be turned to the last type of mediation, namely
the pedagogic one.
57
Barbora Chovancov´a
3.5. Pedagogic mediation
Pedagogic mediation offers a somewhat different perspective from the
other types of mediation in that it aims to develop the mental skills of the
recipient rather than impart relevant information across linguistic bound-
aries, cultural differences and social norms.
North and Piccardo see successful teaching as a form or mediation,
because “teachers and parents try to mediate knowledge, experiences and
above all the ability to think critically for oneself”, which, in their view
constitutes “cognitive mediation” (2016a: 10).
It may be argued that in lawyer-client interaction, knowledge is facili-
tated through “scaffolded cognitive mediation”. However, it is not the job
of the lawyer to help to develop their clients’ thinking but, rather, to think
on their behalf and offer them alternatives. Thus, in my opinion, pedagogic
mediation is not quite relevant to this particular context. Nevertheless, it is
directly applicable to Legal English teachers and teaching on a more general
level, which is an issue that deserves a more detailed attention in the future.
4. Conclusion
As shown in this article, mediation is an important soft skill that has,
so far, been largely overlooked in the teaching of foreign languages. How-
ever, with the most recent update of the CEFR, this situation is gradually
changing and the practice of mediation is coming to be seen as much more
central to effective language instruction than previously. With mediation,
a speaker acts as an intermediary, helping others to understand information
that is linguistically outside their reach. In this way, mediation bridges dif-
ferences in knowledge and requires the speaker to negotiate meanings across
different communicative styles, discourse norms and cultural contexts, both
within a single language and across different languages.
In the area of English for Specific Purposes in general and Legal English
in particular, the changed orientation calls for the need to modify existing
syllabi that tend to focus on precision (particularly in the area of terminol-
ogy) and learners’ self-expression, while mediation requires the speakers to
actively and consciously modify their linguistic output so that it becomes
maximally accessible to the recipients. Attention thus needs to be turned
to such communicative strategies as language choice, information selection
and processing in order to arrive at an optimally comprehensible message.
In this process, various aspects of mediation are involved: linguistic, cultural,
social, as well as pedagogic.
58
Practicing the Skill of Mediation in English for Legal Purposes
As regards the practice of the skill of mediation in the ELP classroom,
a particularly suitable activity involves interaction with clients. Students can
be taught various mediation strategies (as explained in detail in CEFR ID),
which are extremely relevant for the practice of law. By roleplaying lawyer-
client interactions, students can engage in a communicative practice that
will be quite central to their future careers in legal consultancy, advisory,
etc. Indeed, this is one of the most important soft skills needed by legal
professionals in their interactions with the lay public, i.e. individuals lacking
knowledge of legal issues.
N O T E
1This is different from the legal term “mediation”, which refers to a form of alternative
dispute resolution (ADR).
R E F E R E N C E S
Basturkmen, H. 2006. Ideas and Options in English for Specific Purposes. New
York: Routledge.
Basturkmen, H. 2013. ‘Needs analysis and syllabus design for language for specific
purposes’ In C.A. Chapelle (ed.) The Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics.
Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
Bhatia, V.K. 1987. ‘Textual-mapping in British legislative writing.’ World En-
glishes 6 (1), 1–10.
Bhatia, V.K. 2002. ‘Developing legal writing materials for English second language
learners: Problems and perspectives.’ English for Specific Purposes 21, 299–
320.
Bhatia, V.K. 2004. Words of Written Discourse: A Genre-Based View. London:
Continuum.
Bhatia, V.K. 2017. Critical Genre Analysis: Investigating interdiscursive perfor-
mance in professional practice. London and New York: Routledge.
Bhatia, V.K., C.N. Candlin, and J. Engberg, eds. 2008. Legal Discourse across
Cultures and Systems. Vol. 1. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.
Byram, M. and A. Hu, eds. 2013. Routledge Encyclopedia of Language Teaching
and Learning. London and New York: Routledge.
Chovancov´a, B. 2016. ‘Mediation in Legal English Teaching.’ Studies in Logic,
Grammar and Rhetoric 45 (1), 21–35.
Cornelius, E. 2010. ‘Plain language as alternative textualisation.’ Southern African
Linguistics and Applied Language Studies 28 (2), 171–183.
Dendrinos, B. 2006. ‘Mediation in communication, language teaching and testing.’
JAL 22, 9–35. http://rcel.enl.uoa.gr/KPGnew/texts/Dendrinos mediation%
20JAL.pdf
59
Barbora Chovancov´a
Dudley-Evans, T. and M. Jo St John. 1998. Developments in English for Specific
Purposes: A Multi-disciplinary Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Garc´ıa, O. and L. Wei. 2014. ‘Translanguaging and Education’ in Translanguag-
ing: Language, Bilingualism and Education. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmil-
lan UK, 63–77.
Gibbons, P. 2003. ‘Mediating language learning: Teacher interactions with ESL
students in a content-based classroom.’ TESOL Quarterly 37 (2), 247–273.
Gotti, M. 2003. Specialized Discourse: Linguistic Features and Changing Conven-
tions. Bern: Peter Lang.
Gotti, M. and C.Williams, eds. 2010. Legal Discourse across Languages and Cul-
tures. Bern: Peter Lang.
Harding, K. 2007. English for Specific Purposes: Resource Books for Teachers. Ox-
ford: Oxford University Press.
Hutchinson T. and A. Waters. 1987. English for Specific Purposes: A Learning-
centred Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Krois-Lindner, A. and TransLegal. 2006. International Legal English. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Krois-Lindner, A., M. Firth and Translegal. 2008. Introduction to International
Legal English. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lewis, G., B. Jones and C. Baker. 2012. ‘Translanguaging: developing its con-
ceptualisation and contextualisation.’ Educational Research and Evaluation,
18 (7), 655–670, https://doi.org/10.1080/13803611.2012.718490
Locher, M.A. and S.L. Graham, eds. 2010. Interpersonal Pragmatics. Berlin:
De Gruyter Mouton.
North, B. and E. Piccardo. 2016a. ‘Developing illustrative descriptors of aspects
of mediation for the Common European Framework of Reference (CEFR).’
Available online at https://rm.coe.int/developing-illustrative-descriptors-of-
aspects-of-mediation-for-the-co/1680713e2c. Accessed 25 June 2017.
North, B. and E. Piccardo. 2016b. ‘Developing illustrative descriptors of aspects
of mediation for the Common European Framework of Reference (CEFR):
A Council of Europe project.’ Language Teaching 49 (3), 455–459. doi:
10.1017/S0261444816000100
North, B. and E. Piccardo. 2017. ‘Mediation and the social and linguistic in-
tegration of migrants: updating the CEFR descriptors.’ In: Beacco, J.-C.,
H.-J. Krumm, D. Little and P. Thalgott. (eds.) The Linguistic Integration
of Adult Migrants /L’int´egration linguistique des migrants adultes: Some
lessons from research /Les enseignements de la recherch´e. Berlin and Boston:
De Gruyter Mouton, 83–89.
Swales, J. M. 1990. Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research Settings.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
60
... To this end, the present article seeks to address the gap existing in ELP pedagogy by considering (1) some of the ways in which the practice of such professional communicative skills can be effectively incorporated into the ELP/ESP classroom, (2) how such practice is perceived and reflected on by the students themselves and (3) what implications this holds for the teaching of ELP. The paper is structured as follows: In the theoretical part, it outlines some of the communicative skills crucial for future lawyers and focuses on the linguistic skill of language mediation that has recently been added by language pedagogistsas suggested in the latest version of CEFRamong the key language proficiency skills (Dendrinos 2006;Chovancová 2016Chovancová , 2018Stathopoulou 2015;2019;Piccardo et al. 2019). Then, based on a sample of actual teaching materials developed by the author and her team, it is shown how the skill of mediation can be effectively taught, and what the students' views on the tasks were, based on an informal survey carried out among law students after working on the sample activity. ...
... One of the key soft skills that are relevant for any professional situation where communication occurs between specialists and non-specialists is mediation, which has previously been largely ignored by ESP practitioners (but see, for instance, Dendrinos 2006;Chovancová 2016, Stathopoulou 20152018). While the concept of mediation has a very specific meaning for the legal profession (i.e. ...
... Clearly, the former is a soft skill relevant for any professional (as well as non-professional) interaction where the lay vs. expert dimensions are involved. In the latter, another complication is added to such information transfer, namely the communication across different languages, which makes this skill ideal for inclusion in the ESP/ELP syllabus (Chovancová 2018). Arguably, within the field of ESP, the shift to the skill of mediation can be understood as a paradigm shift that is starting to affect the development of a new generation of teaching materials and a new approach to course design, as well as the training of a new wave of ESP practitioners. ...
Article
Full-text available
A general trend in adult education across the disciplines has been the gradual shift from teaching specialized knowledge to developing various skills. The inclusion of professional skills in the area of Languages for Specific Purposes (LSP) is often based on the results of complex needs analyses of the target situation that leads to effective course design both for in-service and pre-service learners. While major law schools have recently started putting a greater emphasis on the training of legal skills, the present article suggests that some of those legal skills can be effectively developed in the ELP (English for Legal Purposes) classroom as well, i.e. among L2 learners of specialist language. That holds particularly for the soft skill of linguistic mediation. Promoted by CEFR, mediation is characterized by the situation when an expert speaker needs to overcome a communicative gap arising from a difference in the technical or linguistic knowledge of the interlocutors.The present article shows how a sample activity can be used for teaching linguistic mediation in the ELP classroom and how it can serve as an opportunity for enhancing students’ critical self-reflection. It describes a custom-made activity – a role-played lawyer-client interview – and analyses students’ subsequent comments on the activity. The paper suggests that self-reflection is deeper if the theory is supplied after the task and that such a practice enhances students’ learning process. It is suggested that the findings are applicable not only to teachers’ syllabus design and classroom activities design but also more generally to pedagogic theory, e.g. the field of LSP teacher training.
... Additionally, fluency is a key component while mediating and interacting as it refers to language users' capacity to speak appropriately and accurately (Kurniati, 2015). For online communication mediation is important in facilitating interlocutors' message exchanging, making communication clearer and more intelligible (Chovancová, 2018). As a result, we believe thatthe teaching of mediation and the development of fluency when learning a foreign language can have a significant impact on making the online communication process effective. ...
Article
Full-text available
Technology has been incorporated as a valuable tool in education, especially in foreign language teaching. It has also transformed how individuals communicate because they are constantly engaged in face-to-face or online interactions. However, there are situations where the message is not effectively transmitted. In this context of information processing, Mediation emerges. It was incorporated as one of the four modes of communication in the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) in 2018. The European Framework for the Digital Competence of Educators and the CEFR were the primary basis for this research. This study aimed to develop a methodological proposal based on technology to work and assess the components of Mediation. In this arena, this study focuses on fluency. It was conducted in Ecuador, in Riobamba, at Universidad Nacional de Chimborazo. The population consisted of 63 students enrolled in their training to become English teachers. The research utilized a combination of qualitative and quantitative methodologies. The Shapiro-Wilk and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests were applied to analyze the data. The non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test was also selected as the hypothesis contrast statistic. Semi-structured interviews were implemented to elicit participant’s perceptions. The findings of this research show an improvement in language fluency in Mediation in virtual environments. In conclusion, learners enhanced their ability to use the language fluently and naturally to convey the meaning being transmitted and to boost understanding among interlocutors.
... Within this strand of research, the studies also emphasize the need to develop the plurilingual and pluricultural competencies of learners enabling them to act as cultural mediators in modern societies [2,47,48]. Besides that, when investigating the concept of mediation for professional language training, researchers raise questions about the necessity of designing and incorporating multilingual practices into translating and interpreting training programs, as well as into language training for specific purposes (law students) [49,50]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Cultural diffusion and a paradigm shift from a "skill-based" approach to an "action-ori-ented" approach in language pedagogy transform the functions of an educator in a foreign language classroom. A language instructor accepts an intermediatory role in learners' interactions with the environment, using language as a primary mediation tool. Thus, by being involved in varied social contexts and activities, a language educator mediates learning, communication, and sociocultural environments. This study relies on a structural analysis to investigate the mediating role of a language educator. It suggests that pedagogic mediation should be viewed as a specific form of language educators' activity and described through three dimensions: mediating learning, mediating communication, and mediating sociocultural space. In the teaching and learning context, these dimensions manifest themselves as skills to adapt to the instructional and linguistic complexity of texts, manage interaction, facilitate communication in sensitive situations, etc. Drawing upon a phe-nomenological research design and qualitative methods, the study develops illustrative descriptors that can be used in a foreign language classroom to assess the patterns of social, instructional, and communicative behavior of educators. The developed descriptors allowed for exploring the self-perceptions of pre-service language teachers towards their abilities for pedagogic mediation in a foreign language classroom. The results of the study identified the learning gaps among novice language teachers that can be further addressed as learning objectives while designing a curriculum for professional training in language education.
... Therefore, this study analyzed which tasks in the textbook could be related to mediation and lead to teaching and learning. Chovancová (2018) has stressed the significance of English language mediation skills in legal settings and highlighted the essential role of language mediation as a crucial soft skill for both English for Specific Purposes (ESP) and English for Legal Purposes (ELP). ...
Article
Full-text available
Jeon, Ji-hye. (2024). A textbook task analysis based on the CEFR mediation scale of basic user. Primary English Education, 30(1), 91-115. The Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) establishes four macro functions: reception, production, interaction, and mediation, to aid learners in enhancing their communicative competence by reflecting on various aspects of real-life communication. Mediation, the comprehensive function encompassing all other functions, describes the learner's communication process as co-constructing meaning. This study aimed to analyze how a textbook integrates the function of mediation into tasks that serve as teaching and learning materials. The study analyzed textbook tasks and classified the mediation format into six types using basic user descriptors. By analyzing the mediation scale and formats reflected in the textbook's functional integration tasks, this study sought to activate learners' communication in various ways. The analysis revealed numerous tasks related to mediating a text, where learners find information in a given passage and solve problems through it. The textbook emphasized cooperation over leadership in task resolution and did not specify group members' roles, allowing the mediation format to diversify based on the teacher's classroom approach. Effectively implementing mediation activities and strategies requires conducting follow-up research on real-life classroom learning scenarios.
Article
Full-text available
Este artículo presenta los resultados de una intervención pedagógica realizada en la asignatura de Inglés Científico para el Grado en Enfermería en la Universidad San Jorge (Zaragoza, España). La intervención integra actividades de mediación lingüística, un enfoque promovido por el Marco Común Europeo de Referencia para las Lenguas, para mejorar las habilidades comunicativas inclusivas en el alumnado. Esta intervención se abordó a través de ejercicios prácticos diseñados para fomentar la accesibilidad en contextos sanitarios. Los estudiantes participaron en interacciones simuladas con pacientes que presentaban diferentes necesidades comunicativas, adaptando su discurso y estrategias comunicativas en función de los perfiles. Los resultados del estudio demuestran una mejora significativa en la conciencia y habilidades comunicativas del alumnado, además de resaltar la viabilidad y efectividad de incorporar la mediación lingüística en la enseñanza de lenguas para fines específicos. Esta intervención subraya la importancia de la mediación para promover una comunicación equitativa en ámbitos sanitarios.
Article
Full-text available
Mediation has become a fundamental concept in foreign language teaching, encompassing diverse fields from diplomacy to law. Its essence lies in resolving conflicts between differing perspectives by building bridges, facilitating understanding, and enhancing communication. The Common European Framework of Recommendations for Languages (CEFR, 2001), mediation was linked to language skills and introduced as a fourth mode of communication. In the 2018 CEFR, n addition to reception, production and interaction, which cover the basic language skills of listening , speaking, reading, and writing, mediation was formally introduced as the fourth form of communication. In the 2020 CEFR, the concept of mediation is given under the headings of mediation activities and mediation strategies, along with descriptive descriptors according to levels. This study investigates the conceptual domain of mediation skills, a vital component in language education, within a wider framework. The objective is to emphasize the connection between language instruction and mediation. Within this context, the scope of mediation skills is explained and analyzed within the study. The findings highlight mediation as a pivotal tool for effective learning. Accordingly, the study proposes recommendations to foster further exploration of mediation through practical and stakeholder-oriented approaches.
Article
Full-text available
This short paper aims to highlight and concisely explore – but not address in depth -some aspects related to translating and teaching English for specific purposes (mainly English for Legal Purposes) The following questions will be briefly considered: What is the impact of comparative law on legal translation? How can tricky terms in legal translation be taught effectively? How can mediation activities and student self-reflection be utilised to train legal skills? How can teaching plain English to PhD students improve their writing in a scientific context? The paper starts with a brief introduction to the concept of language and communication for specific purposes, with a particular emphasis put on English for Legal Purposes. The second section of the essay refers to issues connected with legal translation; its specificity and the role of comparative law in the quality of translation and interpretation. The third and last part of the paper is dedicated to the issue of instructing languages for specific purposes. It mainly tackles the problem of equipping students with such linguistic competencies, skills, and knowledge which are most valuable for their study and work.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to determine the place of mediation skills in teaching Turkish as a foreign language in accordance with the opinions of the instructors. The research is a content analysis study made with the interview technique, one of the qualitative research methods. The study group for the research consists of 14 instructors who worked in Turkish Teaching Research and Application Centers. The data for the study were obtained from the Teaching Staff Interview Form on Mediation Skills in Teaching Turkish as a Foreign Language, which was created by the researchers and contains structured and semi-structured questions. At the end of the research, it was concluded that the instructors included mediation skills in the teaching of Turkish as a foreign language, but there was no standard and systematic teaching of mediation skills.
Article
This article addresses the issue of foreign language testing in the online mode and proposes a strategy to reduce the possibility of academic misconduct, specifically cheating, by designing tasks that assess the language skill of mediation in Legal English exams. Such tasks require test-takers to generate original answers, which can significantly reduce the risk of copying and pasting. Additionally, mastering the skill of mediation is a valuable asset for future lawyers. The authors introduce two original distinct intra-language mediation tasks that they developed for assessing English for Legal Purposes. One is aimed at first-year students with limited Legal English experience, while the other is intended for more advanced and experienced students. The article analyses student responses and evaluates their performance. The authors follow the action research approach, which involves a circle of observing, reflecting and acting, and raise questions concerning the originality of answers, production of a measurable sample of the target language, objectivity of assessment, and whether the practice in class impacts the success rate. The article also discusses challenges encountered during the process and how they were addressed. It can be concluded that mediation tasks are practical for online testing but could be used equally well for traditional classroom assessment.
Chapter
Full-text available
The notion of mediation has been studied in psychology, pedagogy and the social sciences. The emerging vision of language acquisition as socialization into communities of practice through the mediation of material signs and its implications in the field of language education informed a Council of Europe project that has produced CEFR illustrative descriptors for mediation. The team conducted a three-phase developmental, mixed methods research. The paper concludes by pointing out the relevance of mediation to the integration of migrants.
Article
Full-text available
Mediation is a language activity that has been unjustly neglected when preparing law students for their future professional careers. When trained in a professional context, students need to develop and improve complex communicative skills. These include not only the traditional language skills such as reading, writing, listening and speaking, but also more advanced skills such as summarizing, providing definitions, changing registers etc. All these are involved in the students’ acquisition of ‘soft skills’ that are particularly important for students of law since much of their future work involves interpersonal lawyer-client interaction. This article argues that mediation is a crucial (though previously underestimated) skill and that law-oriented ESP instruction should provide training aimed at developing this skill. Showing a practical application of this approach, the paper demonstrates that mediation can be successfully integrated in the legal English syllabus and make the learning of legal English more effective.
Article
Full-text available
The notion of mediation has been the object of growing interest in second language education in recent years. The increasing awareness of the complex nature of the process of learning – and teaching – stretches our collective reflection towards less explored areas. In mediation, the immediate focus is on the role of language in processes like creating the space and conditions for communication and/or learning, constructing and co-constructing new meaning, and/or passing on information, whilst simplifying, elaborating, illustrating or otherwise adapting input in order to facilitate the process concerned. At a deeper level though, the notion of mediation embraces a broader spectrum of dimensions and connotations. Mediation has been defined as a ‘nomadic notion’ (Lenoir 1996) insomuch as it is at the core of a variety of scientific disciplines and the term ‘mediation’ is used in different senses in different contexts.
Book
This handbook focuses on the interpersonal aspects of language in use, exploring key concepts such as face, im/politeness, identity, or gender, as well as mitigation, respect/deference, and humour in a variety of settings. The volume includes theoretical overviews as well as empirical studies from experts in a range of disciplines within linguistics and communication studies and provides a multifaceted perspective on both theoretical and applied approaches to the role of language in relational work.
Book
Genre theory has focused primarily on the analysis of generic constructs, with increasing attention to and emphasis on the contexts in which such genres are produced, interpreted, and used to achieve objectives, often giving the impression as if producing genres is an end in itself, rather than a means to an end. The result of this focus is that there has been very little attention paid to the ultimate outcomes of these genre-based discursive activities, which are more appropriately viewed as academic, institutional, organizational, and professional actions and practices, which are invariably non-discursive, though often achieved through discursive means. It was this objective in mind that the book develops an approach to a more critical and deeper understanding of interdiscursive professional voices and actions.
Chapter
Language for specific purposes (LSP) courses are designed to meet the specific needs of learners (Dudley-Evans & St John, 1998, p. 4). Keywords: language teaching; language for academic purposes; language for specific purposes
Chapter
This chapter traces the development of a theory of translanguaging in education, from its Welsh beginnings, and its relationship to the important educational concepts of creativity and criticality. The chapter explicitly states why it is important to go from bilingualism in education to translanguaging in education, and the impact of this shift to transform monolingual, foreign/second language education and bilingual education structures.
Article
This volume presents a range of views about language, learning, and teaching in English for Specific Purposes (ESP). Its purpose is to go beyond individual cases and practices to examine the approaches and ideas on which they are based. The aim is for readers to adopt an analytical stance toward the field and to identify current perspectives in ESP and the ideas driving them. Ideas and Options in English for Specific Purposes does not promote any one approach, but rather identifies and illustrates those in evidence today. The main emphasis is on the links between theory and ESP teaching and research. Ideas from linguistics, sociolinguistics, education, SLA, and social theories are described. Links are then made between these ideas and ESP course designs, instructional materials, and research projects. Thus the book moves back and forth between descriptions of theories, teaching practice, and research. Part I introduces the book's approach to description of ESP and the framework used to investigate it. Part II examines ideas of language, learning, and teaching in ESP. Recognizing that ESP is taught in many different countries and contexts, the author draws on a wide range of examples of teaching practice and research from around the world and from different branches of ESP, including English for Academic Purposes, English for Professional Purposes, and English for Vocational Purposes. From Chapter 3 onward, each chapter includes Questions for Discussion and Projects, to encourage readers to research and analyze the practices of ESP in their own contexts and to consider the ideas they draw on in their own teaching. This text is geared toward graduate-level TESOL education courses. © 2006 by Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc. All rights reserved.