ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that costs reduction is no longer a complete indication of performance and should not be attained at the expense of the firm’s sustainable social responsibility and environmental aspects. The question of whether outsourcing is a “blessing” or a “lesson” remains unresolved in the minds of practitioners and researchers alike. The literature is replete with the up- and down-sides of outsourcing, all going in different directions, making it very cumbersome particularly for practitioners to articulate when and what to outsource (if at all) and how to contain or mitigate outsourcing downsides. Design/methodology/approach Outsourcing as a two-edged sword can be value creating strategy or a firm’s soft spot. This paper focusses on the latter through a review of sourcing in two leading multinational companies: Benetton, in the fast fashion industry, and Nestlé, in the food industry. Findings Benetton experienced the biggest catastrophe in the garment industry, the Rana Plaza collapse. Nestlé went through the horse meat scandal, perhaps one of the most complex food crime cases in history. Both cases illustrated the strategic vulnerability that arises from the international outsourcing of production. Research limitations/implications Clearly, production costs are no longer a complete indication of performance as the two cases unveil. Management control systems should be especially vigilant when outsourcing transfers social and environmental responsibility from one contract to another in a global business context. Monitoring costs cannot be outsourced when it comes to sustainable social responsibility and environmental aspects. Practical implications Firms can leverage relationships with stakeholder groups, activists and NGOs to help them to monitor their international operations. Institution-based trust to protect brands, increased integration and control are necessary mechanisms. Originality/value Indeed, global outsourcing in any industry should transfer not only industrial operations but also credible and responsible social and environmental benchmarks.
*** Journal of Business Strategy ***
The ethics of outsourcing: when companies fail at responsibility
Journal of Business Strategy, Vol. 39 Issue: 5, pp.7-13,
https://doi.org/10.1108/JBS-03-2018-0037
Nelson Oly Ndubisi
King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals
College of Industrial Management
Dhahran, Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia
&
Arne Nygaard
Professor of Marketing,
Kristiania University College
Postboks 1155 Sentrum
Kirkegaten 24-26, 0107 Oslo, Norway
Phone 952 43 656
E-mail arne.nygaard@kristiania.no
&
Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)
Teknologivegen 22, 2815 Gjøvik, Norway
December 2016
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The authors contributed equally to the article.
Introduction
Management literature suggests that outsourcing is an effective device to create
incentive collusion, which reduces opportunism, externalizes monitoring costs and
facilitates the competitive organization of supply chains. However, we argue that the
eagerness to outsource operations may cause an avoidable problem, and that ethical
behaviour may be reduced when the aim is to get rid of transaction or production
costs. Outsourcing through offshoring relates to the relocation of business to another
country. According to the Economic Policy Institute (Kimball and Scott, 2014), 3.2
million US jobs were outsourced to China between 2001 and 2013. New business
models and supply chain networks promote the outsourcing of domestic jobs in both
manufacturing and service industries. Some of the emerging market economies have
developed refined and effective systems for acting as offshoring destinations. Lower
international labour rates are financial incentives for outsourcing through offshoring.
An analysis presented by the Wall Street Journal concluded that thirty-five large
multinational US companies created new jobs faster than other US-based companies.
However, although the companies that outsourced jobs globally grew faster, three-
quarters of the jobs were created overseas (Thurm, 2012). In the US, the number of
workers in manufacturing dropped by 8 million over 30 years because many jobs
were outsourced to third world countries. Some large companies have outsourced all
of their manufacturing operations outside the US. For instance, Apple and Nike have
sub-contracted their manufacturing to independent companies and have been
innovators of outsourcing as a business model based on the foreign operation of
manufacturing processes (Roberts, 2016).
The reason behind outsourcing
The increased globalization of outsourcing operations in recent years has been the
modus operandi of textbook models of competitive strategies. The received theory and
empirical evidence have pointed to core business, taxation regimes, regulations, the
costs of production, labour, resources and energy, and transaction costs as
motivations for offshore outsourcing. During the past decade, private equity
investors have put pressure on costs. Consequently, the cost focus is driving
outsourcing strategies. Although the production costs of outsourcing are pretty clear,
the true cost of the environmental and social impact of outsourcing is hidden behind
a complex network of contractual relationships, and arises through cultural,
geographical and system differences.
In the new world of globalism, sustainability should be an integrated platform
for future competitive business models (Porter and Linde, 1995). Steve Jobs and Elon
Musk provide benchmarks for this new wave of open, global and sustainable
strategies. The simplistic approach that only has an eye on production costs does not
only ignore the true costs of unsustainable global operations. It also prohibits firms
from making disruptive technological changes in the new world of zero emissions,
electrification and social evolution. The intertwined effect of these elements is
ultimately a precondition for long-term economic growth.
Fast fashion and the Rana Plaza collapse
In the 1960s about 95% of the clothes made for the American market were made in
the US. Today, about two per cent of the clothes bought in the US are made there –
98% of the production has been outsourced to the third world. Outsourcing as a
business model in the garment industry really took off in the 1980s, when chains like
Gap Inc. and J.C. Penney pioneered the strategy (Cline, 2012). The leading company
in the fast fashion industry, Inditex, now has 6,298 factories located in over 50
countries. The development means that production is outsourced from countries
with strong traditions of controlling social aspects through labour unions, media and
institutions to countries where this control system is not so strong. Outsourcing
production might therefore lead to operations with unintended high social and
environmental costs. In other words, cutting social and environmental costs through
outsourcing operations to the third world might have become an integrated part of
the business model branded as “fast fashion”. The reality is that the reduction of
these social and environmental costs might have led to deflation in product prices in
the market for fashion. This unfortunate development has pushed the costs of cheap
production to the weakest link in the supply chain – the female garment workers in
underdeveloped countries. No case describes the social costs of outsourcing better
than the Rana Plaza accident.
Rana Plaza was a location where clothes and other products for reputable
companies in the west were manufactured. Companies like Benetton, Wal-Mart,
Mango and El Corte Inglés had clothing factories in the building. Benetton proudly
announce that their sustainability label, Dress Safely, reflects:
“the ethical approach of Benetton Group, whose social commitment, concern for the
environment and transparency towards the consumer have for years been the key
values of a responsibility that goes beyond its commercial objectives.”
Nevertheless, the Rana Plaza tragedy in 2013, when 1,129 people were killed,
is the worst accident in modern industrial history. No doubt Benetton is now one of
the serious companies in the garment industry that have sustainability as an
everyday aspect of their operations. However, in the shockwave of the disaster they
denied that their factory supply came from Rana Plaza, and refused to support the
Rana Plaza Donors Trust Fund. Heavy protests in the aftermath of the tragedy
contributed to the closure of the Oxford Street shop in the UK (Butler, 2015). The
background is Benetton’s outsourcing strategy for benefiting from manufacturing in
Asia. Their production in India could reduce their production costs by 20%
(Procurement Leaders, 2007). From its cultural roots and production origins in north
east Italy, the company suddenly faced a complex network of manufacturing systems
that it handled with lower monitoring costs. The Rana Plaza disaster shows how
applying the textbook approach that we teach to our business school students can go
catastrophically wrong. The global supply chain network is seen as a physical
logistical chain, and the people operating it as cheap input factors. Conventional
textbook wisdom applauds the outsourcing of standardized technology and products
whenever zero-specific investments and zero switching costs characterize the
relationship. The market competition itself secures the interests of the principal – the
general and straightforward roadmap for business relationships that has been known
since Berle and Means’ work in 1932. The market as an institution is a disciplinary
device that controls opportunism, but will it fuel the success of globalism through
outsourcing? In the general literature on the strategic choice between markets,
contracts and hierarchy, the theoretical model of the perfect market may or may not
be an open and transparent marketplace. The monitoring of outsourced production is
complex, and observation is costly. Problems of safety, social security or
environmental hazards are typically difficult to discern. Benetton may therefore have
ignored the fact that aspects like geographical distance, cultural differences,
complexity and uncertainty raise the monitoring costs of choosing overseas
outsourcing.
We have long known that ownership and control do, in fact, affect our
options, because of monitoring costs (Jensen and Meckling, 1976). This approach,
though, focuses on the potential observability of the concept of “performance”, so
that the principal company can write outcome-based contracts with the agent who
signs the outsourcing agreement. Today, this is seen as a far-fetched “old school”
strategy because “performance” is no longer only the “bottom line figure” but is
rather a construct of indicators of “sustainability”. As we know, the concept of
sustainability includes financial, social and environmental performance. In the Rana
Plaza case, it is obvious that the brands produced there were measured according to
only one of these dimensions – financial performance – and were motivated by cost
benefits. The companies survived the strategic shock after the disaster by following
the “walk the talk” procedure. They understood that sustainability was not just a few
nice lines on their webpage but was also a real, true, transparent and documentable
process. Their reputation depended on their ability to create credible sustainable
actions. Sustainable outsourcing is a multidimensional strategy that creates
performance ambiguity within the organization. Thus, in relation to monitoring
costs, outsourcing should be a much more integrated business than the markets can
normally offer. A company needs to develop strict control and reporting procedures
to allow continuous monitoring of their businesses and their contract manufacturers
abroad. Eco-brands, Eco certification systems and activists may provide valuable
control information. The Rana Plaza tragedy did not have to happen. The absence of
monitoring, combined with opportunism among the clothing manufacturers, forced
the garment workers into a building that was a death trap. Structural cracks in the
building had even been filmed and documented. The principal companies behind the
luxury brands probably did not know this, or did not wish to monitor the social and
environmental impact of their own production. The market itself did not provide the
information. This is an ethical market failure that could have been avoided through
old school monitoring. Outsourcing, therefore, may in general facilitate unethical
practice if the principal companies do not include their home-grown moral codes in
their foreign strategy. Ethics should not be outsourced to irresponsible
manufacturing in order to lower manufacturing costs. Ethics along the entire product
life cycle, from raw materials to recycling, is a signal part of the brands. Fast fashion
cannot eliminate its responsibilities through outsourcing production.
Food safety and horse meat
Another industry that has recently been studied through the lens of business ethics is
the food industry. Like the fashion industry, the ability of the food industry to access
global sourcing has become a major opportunity for reducing costs, enhancing
quality, innovating and differentiating products. Food safety, however, has been a
concern for a long time. Mad cow disease broke out in the UK in 1986 and caused
Creutzfeldt–Jakob illness, which probably killed 177 people in the United Kingdom
and 52 in other European countries. This disease made it clear how serious this
matter was. The control of all aspects of the entire food chain became critical. On the
other hand, the EU development of a common European market motivated
outsourcing and international supplies through access to fast-growing international
markets. In a new European order of food regulations and free trade, could we trust
the institutions that promoted outsourcing and market transactions in the food
markets? Prior business research has pointed out the essential nature of institutional
trust for emerging European markets if costly business-to-business relations are to be
supported and replaced (Dahlstrom and Nygaard, 1995). Institutional trust manifests
itself in a trustworthy legal system and policing that can safeguard contracts in the
market (Zucker, 1986). Consequently, the food market is essentially vulnerable to
institutional trust. Nestlé, the world’s largest food company, should therefore be
rational and sensitive about regulations affecting the outsourcing of the food supply
in its relationships with 165,000 direct suppliers and 695,000 individual farmers
worldwide. Its sustainability strategy states that: “Working alongside NGO partners,
we map our supply chains, and conduct supplier audits and farm assessments to
ensure the procurement…” (nestle.com). However, even in the largest and probably
the most professional food company in the world, the complexity of monitoring the
supply chain has created the potential for opportunism when taken alongside the
company’s intention to use supplier relationships to build a competitive global
advantage.
The Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) revealed in 2012 that horse meat
was mixed into the beef food chain. In January 2013 it became known that retailers
like Tesco, Dunnes Stores, Aldi and Lidl were selling beef products mixed with horse
meat. As a result of the scandal, Nestlé withdrew the pasta products Buitoni beef
ravioli and beef tortellini from the Italian and Spanish markets, as well as lasagne
produced in France. The complexity of international sourcing created a vacuum for
international opportunism that turned out to be difficult to control. The horse meat
scandal involved more than 7,000 firms. The police found that the complexity
included “post office” firms and dummy companies that further complicated the
investigation. The question raised in Zucker’s classic article is whether we should
trust the regulatory system offered by the EU and the national food control regimes
to produce food safety. Nestlé as a brand signals food quality of a particular standard
to consumers all around the world, but the horse meat case demonstrates that brands
cannot live without a regulatory system to support them. We see, in the
underdeveloped market economies, that “lemons” eliminate trust and in that way
undermine the entire market. Through the lens of Akerlof’s (1970) article, brands
may serve as a signal of quality and thus develop market growth. In the context of
outsourcing in the food market, it is also crucial to understand the institutional trust
that supports the brand signals that are sent to consumers. The nutrition and food
businesses have a strong impact on sustainable development. Nestlé’s marketing of
breast milk substitutes in underdeveloped countries led to boycott actions back in
1977. Today, stakeholder groups and NGOs are integrated into the strategic planning
process to “create shared value”. Sourcing therefore is a defined strategic goal,
manifested in the Nestlé Responsible Sourcing Guideline, where a commitment related
to responsible sourcing is specified in every area (nestle.com):
• Nestlé Supplier Code
• Nestlé Policy on Environmental Sustainability
• Nestlé Commitment on Climate Change
• Nestlé Commitment on Deforestation and Forest Stewardship
• Nestlé Commitment on Child Labour in Agricultural Supply Chains
• Nestlé Commitment on Rural Development
• Nestlé Commitment on Farm Animal Welfare
• Nestlé Commitment on Water Stewardship
• The International Bill of Human Rights
• The 8 ILO Core Conventions
• United Nations Global Compact Principles
However, sustainability is a multidimensional performance construct based on
social, environmental and financial aspects. Sustainability therefore affects the
measurement ambiguity inherent in business-to-business relationships. Although
Nestlé shows professionalism and has experience in the governance of global
relationships, the horse meat scandal illustrates the immense complexity of
multinational sourcing in international markets.
Conclusion
Our review has looked at sourcing in two leading multinational companies:
Benetton, in the fast fashion industry, and Nestlé, in the food industry. Benetton
experienced the biggest catastrophe in the garment industry, the Rana Plaza collapse.
Nestle went through the horse meat scandal, perhaps one of the most complex food
crime cases in history. Both cases illustrated the strategic vulnerability that arises
from the international outsourcing of production. What strategic lessons can we learn
from these cases?
Sustainability contributes to performance ambiguity. Production costs are no
longer a complete indication of performance. Management control systems should be
especially vigilant when outsourcing transfers social and environmental
responsibility from one contract to another in a global business context.
Monitoring costs cannot be outsourced when it comes to sustainable social
responsibility and environmental aspects. Management information systems and
reporting processes might curb opportunism. The problem, though, is that there are
no contracts that can address every aspect of a future uncertain and global world.
That is why stakeholder groups, activists and NGOs might help companies to
monitor their international operations. Business research has for a long time argued
that if there are many managerial tiers, long distances and many cultural contexts,
this might complicate the monitoring of sustainable operations. Transparency might
therefore produce a satisfactory background from which host country stakeholder
groups can follow and control social responsibility and environmental performance.
Contracts in general, and outsourcing in particular, thrive in countries with
institutional trust. A new global business world can only grow when business-to-
business contracts are safeguarded through the legal system and international trade
agreements. The protected development of brands, trademarks and company names
is the best shield against “lemons” contractors (Akerlof, 1970). Without being able to
navigate through institution-based trust to protect brands, it is difficult to make
rational outsourcing decisions.
Global sourcing adds uncertainty to business-to-business relationships.
Management can only confront these complex problems by increased integration and
control. Social, cultural, legal and technological change directly affects potential
inter-organizational uncertainty and opportunism (Achrol et al., 1983). However, we
can sometimes see that norms might affect behaviour. For instance, leading by
example probably also facilitates a culture in which sustainability can be developed.
When top management does not take social responsibility and the environment
seriously, a laissez faire culture that creates opportunism develops easily.
Reversed globalism encourages 3D-printing and the automization and
robotization of production. Thus, technological development might curb these ethical
concerns in the long term. Furthermore, information technology and social media
provide additional transparency in the system. As a conclusion, however, global
outsourcing in any industry should transfer not only industrial operations but also
credible and responsible social and environmental benchmarks.
References
Achrol, R., Reve, T., and Stern, L. (1983), “The environment of marketing channel
dyads: A framework for comparative analysis”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 47 No. 4,
pp. 55-67.
Akerlof, G. A. (1970), “The market for ‘lemons’: Quality, uncertainty and the market
mechanism”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 84, pp. 488-500.
Berle, A.A. and Means, G.C. (1932), The Modern Corporation and Private Property,
Macmillan Publishing Co, New York, NY.
Butler, S. (2015)Rana Plaza disaster marked by Oxford Street demonstration”, The
Guardian, Thursday 24 April.
Cline, E.L. (2012), The Shockingly High Cost of Cheap Fashion, Portfolio/Penguin.
Dahlstrom, R. and Nygaard, A. (1995), “An exploratory investigation of interpersonal
trust in new and mature market economies,” Journal of Retailing, Vol. 71 No. 4, pp.
339-361.
Jensen, M. C. and Meckling, W. H. (1976), “Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior,
agency costs and ownership structure”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 3 No. 4,
pp. 305-360.
Kimball, W. and Scott, R.E. (2014), “China trade, outsourcing and jobs; Growing U.S.
trade deficit with China cost 3.2 million jobs between 2001 and 2013, with job losses
in every state”, Briefing Paper #385, Economic Policy Institute.
http://www.nestle.com/aboutus/suppliers Responsible Sourcing.
Porter, M.E. and Linde, C. van der (1995), “Green and competitive: Ending the
stalemate”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 73, No. 5.
Procurement Leaders (2007),Indian outsourcing helps Benetton lower production
costs” http://www.procurementleaders.com/news-archive/news-archive/indian-
outsourcing-helps-benetton-lower-production-costs
Roberts, P.C. (2016), “The offshore outsourcing of American jobs: A greater threat
than terrorism, Global Research, 13 March.
Thurm S. (2012), “U.S. firms add jobs, but mostly overseas”, The Wall Street Journal,
Business Section, 27 April.
Zucker, L.G. (1986), “Production of trust: Institutional sources of economic structure,
1840-1920”, Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 8, pp. 53-111.
... Monitoring costs are eminent in all the problems related to the delegation of the right to produce services or products throughout the supply chain (Fama and Jensen 1983;Ndubisi and Nygaard 2018). Legal brands or firms that operate under the sustainability regime will have to monitor the agents within the supply chain, otherwise, as Ndubisi and Nygaard (2018) put it 'eagerness to outsource operations may cause an avoidable problem, and ethical behaviour may be reduced when the aim is to get rid of transaction or production costs' (p. ...
... Monitoring costs are eminent in all the problems related to the delegation of the right to produce services or products throughout the supply chain (Fama and Jensen 1983;Ndubisi and Nygaard 2018). Legal brands or firms that operate under the sustainability regime will have to monitor the agents within the supply chain, otherwise, as Ndubisi and Nygaard (2018) put it 'eagerness to outsource operations may cause an avoidable problem, and ethical behaviour may be reduced when the aim is to get rid of transaction or production costs' (p. 7) along with monitoring costs. ...
Article
This paper discusses how problems of eco-opportunism in metals markets escalate due to market failures because of the increasing scarcity of precious metals. Establishing the right sourcing strategy for recycled material, therefore, is crucial for supply chains and for managing corporate sustainability tensions. We analyse the transaction costs in three strategic models of sourcing from ‘make’ inside the supply chain to contract, and ‘buy’ in the grey market for metals. ‘Blood metals’ leak into the grey markets when there is lack of control, information asymmetry in global supply chains and eco-opportunism in recycling of electronic products. Consequently, the need for traceable supply encourages companies to integrate closed-loop recycling of their products. Furthermore, scarcity of valuable metals along with consumer preferences for sustainable products lead to specific investments in product design and robot technology that disassemble end-of-life products. Together, these factors provide an integrated system that reduces transaction costs and increases recycling efficiency. Therefore, specific assets designed to facilitate reuse of scarce metals like the Apple robot Daisy is a key corporate strategy to secure sustainable performance. Specific investments in disassembling technology like robots in the smartphone industry, should, according to transaction cost theory, be organised as a vertically integrated circular economy. The integrated closed-loop model presented here, control eco-opportunism and the unsustainable character of grey markets for recycled material in electronics.
... In some cases, the requirements of the project may strain or exceed the available skills and resources . At such junctures, managers are faced with the task of deciding whether the company should recruit staff with the required skills, or outsource the services of another organization (Ndubisi, and Nygaard, 2018). Such decisions are based on cost and the impact on the quality of the project. ...
... As a sustainable society would give a smaller role for commercial transactions, traditional advertising will diminish. As transition in general, these processes must be supported by changes in norms and voluntary commitment by organizations, such as regarding sustainable supply chain management and ethical codes of conduct (Montabon et al., 2016;Ndubisi and Nygaard, 2018). Labour would be less of a market activity and more an integrated part of community relations. ...
Article
Full-text available
Sustainable development has been an important policy goal for the international community for over three decades. Still, the state of the planet continues to worsen. This conceptual article considers the failure largely a result of structural obstacles and the so-called weak sustainability discourse, popularized by the Brundtland report and manifested today in The 2030 Agenda. The article adopts a strong sustainability perspective for examining structural distances between actors and the consequences of their acts. We argue that these impede responsible action and that policy should aim to reduce or eliminate distances in the four dimensions of space, time, functions and relations. The article concludes by suggesting Strongly Sustainable Development Goals, which could help transitioning humanity towards sustainability, lower the anthropogenic environmental impact on the planet, and enable the continuity of diverse life on Earth.
... In their in-depth analysis of customer reshoring sentiment, Grappi et al. (2018) found that consumers often associate offshoring with the exploitation of foreign workers, environmental pollution and human rights infringement. In fact, offshoring outsourcing is often perceived as a strategy through which firms try to benefit from unethical practices by moving the responsibility for unethical behaviours to their foreign suppliers (Ndubisi and Nygaard, 2018). In this study, we also suggest that customer reactions are more negative when a firm is perceived to have a (pre-offshoring) high level of CSR. ...
Article
Purpose Driven by the disruptive effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, the ongoing debate about the international location of firms' manufacturing activities has increasingly highlighted the specific benefits and costs of near-shoring versus far-shoring. However, the effects of near-shoring versus far-shoring on customer perceived quality and purchase intention have not been examined. Thus, this study aims to develop a conceptual model and provide new evidence to fill this gap. In particular, the study explores the roles of brand familiarity and corporate social responsibility (CSR) to explain the different levels of perceived quality and purchase intention in relation to near-shoring versus far-shoring. Design/methodology/approach This study includes two analyses of data collected from a sample of Italian customers. The first analysis consists of a 2 (high/low brand familiarity) × 3 (domestic insourcing, near-shoring, far-shoring) factorial design, and data are assessed via analyses of variance (ANOVA). The second analysis evaluates the suggested model in the two scenarios (near-shoring and far-shoring) via partial least squares–structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) multigroup analysis. Findings Results showed that customer perceived quality and purchase intention were significantly higher for near-shoring than for far-shoring, but only when brand familiarity was low. No significant difference was found for participants with a high level of brand familiarity. In addition, the level of a brand's pre-offshoring perceived CSR was negatively related to perceived quality, and this was conceptually justified by the CSR-washing effect. Again, this effect was found only when brand familiarity was low. Research limitations/implications The findings contribute to advancing the current understanding of the multiple effects of the offshoring decision and clarify that near-shoring and far-shoring have different effects for customers with low brand familiarity. The findings also emphasise that the far-shoring decision can elicit the perception of decoupling between the firm's CSR claims and CSR actions, thus decreasing perceived quality. Practical implications This study provides managers with additional inputs to make more informed decisions regarding offshoring. While the post-pandemic scenario seems to favour near-reshoring over far-shoring due to agility considerations, this study also provides additional evidence of the superiority of near-reshoring from the customer's perspective. Originality/value This is the first study to examine and prove the differential effects of near-shoring versus far-shoring on the customer's perceptions and behaviours.
... In fact, for a lengthy period, apparel location decisions have been largely based on quantitative cost measures [7,15]. However, the need to contemplate additional factors beyond cost has arisen and companies are often re-evaluating their supply chain design [28,[31][32][33]. In 2013, Fine argued that in the future companies would no longer place so much emphasis on searching for the lowest price locations since they would be increasingly concerned about their reputations and the exposure that they could face in more transparent global supply chains [34]. ...
Article
Full-text available
For decades, apparel companies have profited from moving their manufacturing to low-cost countries and several academic studies have focused on understanding whether low-cost locations could support optimal supply chain configurations. However, the exploitation of resources in foreign sourcing countries often resulted in many environmental and social issues and apparel companies became progressively more concerned about the negative exposure that they could face with a limited supply chain transparency. Therefore, this paper aims at investigating global sourcing strategies of fast fashion retailers in order to understand whether the decision criteria influencing sourcing locations have changed over time to also embrace sustainability considerations. Drawing on a literature review on sustainability in fashion supply chains, offshore outsourcing, and fast fashion global sourcing, a new theoretical framework concerning fast fashion retailers’ sourcing locations is proposed together with a content analysis of their reports. The findings show that fast fashion retailers identify sustainability as a key element to consider in selecting sourcing locations since sustainability issues at suppliers’ factories may represent relevant hidden costs. Moreover, actions aimed at checking and improving sustainable practices in global sourcing policies are proven to support the development of a strategic sourcing reputation for their fast fashion brands.
... Dermed kan man i verste fall risikere at ikke-baerekraftige produkter kan vinne i konkurransen om forbrukerne. Vi har blant annet sett hvordan klesindustrien har ført kunder bak lyset gjennom grønnvasking av sine egne varemerker (Ndubisi & Nygaard, 2018). Utfordringen er derfor å forstå hvilke mekanismer som skaper informasjonsproblemer som lurer forbrukerne. ...
Article
Full-text available
ER DET blitt slik at man er mer opptatt av korrekte holdninger og symboler for å redde klima og baerekraft enn faktisk å gjøre noe med det? Mange er kanskje lei av å lytte til at klima er mer et spørsmål om moral og symboler enn en aktiv handling? I en forskningsar-tikkel fant vi nemlig at den symbolske og nedlatende pekefingermoralismen kan få motsatte effekter enn det vi faktisk ønsker å oppnå (Biong mfl., 2010). Vi ser også at mange sprer dystopier som skaper frykt og frustra-sjon rundt kommende klimaendringer. Dette fører til apati-det motsatte av det entreprenørskapet vi nå trenger for å fikse klimaforandringene. Noen hevder at baerekraft bare er en form for oppor-tunisme for å tilegne seg makt og ressurser. Vi ser stadig at det beste presenteres som det godes verste fiende. Det er en lang prosess å få til et baerekraftig samfunn. Men akkurat som Roma ikke ble bygget på én dag, vil det å skape baerekraftig endring vaere en dynamisk prosess der både teknologisk innovasjon og entreprenørskap kan skape positive endringer som kommer alle for-brukere til gode. Vi ønsker bedre produkter og bedre løsninger. Baerekraft er et Kinder-egg som gir oss dette. I den nye boken Grønn markedsføringsledelse-om baerekraftig entreprenørskap, strategi og markedsføring er mitt mål å gi redskaper til de virkelige aktivistene som har kapasitet og kunnskap til å gjennomføre det grønne skiftet-nemlig ledere i naeringslivet, organisasjoner og forvaltning. Naeringslivets oppgave blir da å skape bedre produkter som forbrukerne vil ha. Grunnen til at Tesla har de mest lojale kundene, er jo nettopp at Tesla-kundene er mer tilfredse enn andre bilkjøpere. Dette er de fordi bilen har en raskere akselerasjon, bedre trygg-het, flottere design, lavere støynivå, mindre utslipp og bedre kjøreegenskaper enn andre biler i samme klasse. Både akselerasjon og forbruk er direkte konsekvenser av en baerekraftig teknologi. Tesla-gründer Elon Musk sier at elektriske biler må se spennende ut, slik at kun-dene virkelig ønsker dem, og ikke bare kjøper dem fordi de må eller bør. For at naeringslivet skal lyktes med det grønne skiftet, trenger moderne ledere å knekke Musks Kinder-egg ved bruk av verktøy som blant annet: • grønne delingsøkonomi-modeller for økt baerekraft • nudging (grønn dulting) for å endre automatisk adferd i retning av baerekraft • blockchain-teknologi for å utkonkurrere ikke-baere-kraftige produkter (såkalte lemons) • grønn SWOT-analyse for strategisk endring i retning av baerekraft • grønn BCG-analyse for å strukturrasjonalisere egen produktportefølje i retning av baerekraft • sirkulaere økonomimodeller for å snu avfallspyra-miden • grønn prisstrategi (insentivsystemer) • grønn produktstrategi (innovasjonsbasert grønt entreprenørskap) • grønn distribusjonsstrategi • grønn kommunikasjonsstrategi (unngå grønnvas-king og treffe LOHAS, grønne segmenter i markeder) • kontroll av økoopportunisme • interessentanalyser og strategier Utfordringene er å snu koplingen mellom økonomisk vekst og økende miljøproblemer (figur 1). Dette er en utvikling som krever kunnskap der en må implementere sirkulaere forretningsmodeller i retning av baerekraftig, økonomisk vekst. Det grønne skiftet er en grunnleg-gende og gjennomgripende (disruptiv) endring som drives frem gjennom både teknologiske og markeds-messige drivkrefter (figur 2) (Christensen & Overdorf, 2000). Bedriftsøkonomisk innsikt i hvordan ledelsen kan møte denne utviklingen, er derfor kritisk viktig. ARNE NYGAARD er professor ved Institutt for markedsføring, økonomi og innovasjon ved Høyskolen Kristiania.
Article
Full-text available
Berkat pengaruhnya yang besar terhadap konsumen di seluruh dunia, fast fashion mungkin adalah istilah yang sangat akrab bagi banyak orang. Meskipun populer, fast fashion juga dikenal sebagai model bisnis yang memiliki rantai pasokan yang sangat rumit. Karena proses rantai pasokan yang kompleks itu, mereka diketahui melakukan praktik yang tidak etis terhadap para pekerjanya dan juga lingkungan. Sayangnya, sebagai satu negara pemasok fast fashion terbesar di dunia, Bangladesh tampaknya tidak keberatan dengan sifat destruktif fast fashion dan menutup mata terhadap dampak yang diciptakan oleh industry tersebut. Oleh karena itu, penelitian ini bertujuan untuk memberikan penjelasan tentang bagaimana dinamika offshore outsourcing dalam rantai pasokan fast fashion menyebabkan penurunan kualitas lingkungan Bangladesh melalui sektor pakaian jadi dan bagaimana pemerintah terlibat dalam kasus ini di bawah pengaruh neoliberal menggunakan metode kualitatif dan pendekatan studi kasus. Hasilnya, peneliti menemukan bahwa strategi offshore outsourcing dalam bisnis fast fashion menyebabkan banyak dampak buruk terhadap lingkungan seperti kontaminasi air, polusi udara, dan penumpukan limbah padat di atas permukaan tanah.
Article
Este ensayo discute sobre algunos de los grupos y roles que se deben considerar en el análisis de los cambios en el valor de las marcas. Se plantean los roles activos y pasivos que tienen: las actividades de la empresa, los grupos de interés de la empresa y los consumidores. Las actividades de las empresas se vinculan con el valor de las marcas directamente a través de sus productos, pero especialmente por la experiencia, identidad y la moral de sus procesos. Los grupos de interés agregan la perspectiva que genera la imagen ética de la empresa en el valor de las marcas, como lo son las responsabilidades medioambientales, su integridad y la creación de valor compartido. Los consumidores son los principales agentes modificadores del valor de la marca. Estos no solo ligan el valor del producto adquirido con la satisfacción de la necesidad, sino agregan constructos sociales que identifican, distinguen y pueden clasificar a las empresas modificando su valor, gracias a la difusión de boca a boca físico y virtual (redes sociales). Este ensayo cobra especial importancia porque en los últimos años sean incrementado las empresas cuyas marcas superan en valor a las de sus activos tradicionales, y se necesita de análisis adicionales para entender este fenómeno.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This paper aims to set out the development, based on the extant literature, an integrated conceptual framework for the emergent field of sustainable global sourcing (GS) that synthesizes its antecedents, GS practices and sustainable performance. Design/methodology/approach Conceptual theory building combined with content analysis is used to develop a framework and propositions representing a middle-range theory of sustainable GS. A literature review of the 89 most influential papers is followed by a further discussion based on the resource orchestration perspective (ROP) to advance an integrated conceptual framework. Findings Three main themes are identified from the literature as antecedents, GS practices and sustainable performance, with each theme being detailed in a variety of constructs. Based on the ROP, the relationships between these constructs are revealed, and therefore, an integrated conceptual framework is advanced via three sets of propositions in recourse orchestration breadth, recourse orchestration depth and resource orchestration evolution, respectively. Eight directions for future research are further proposed. Originality/value First, this study provides a comprehensive framework for future study in the emergent field of sustainable GS. Second, the authors contribute to theory development by proposing a ROP to explore the GS practices towards sustainability. Third, the future research directions we proposed can benefit scholars interested in the overlapping areas of GS and sustainability.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose-This paper aims to set out the development, based on the extant literature, an integrated conceptual framework for the emergent field of sustainable global sourcing (GS) that synthesizes its antecedents, GS practices and sustainable performance. Design/methodology/approach-Conceptual theory building combined with content analysis is used to develop a framework and propositions representing a middle-range theory of sustainable GS. A literature review of the 89 most influential papers is followed by a further discussion based on the resource orchestration perspective (ROP) to advance an integrated conceptual framework. Findings-Three main themes are identified from the literature as antecedents, GS practices and sustainable performance, with each theme being detailed in a variety of constructs. Based on the ROP, the relationships between these constructs are revealed, and therefore, an integrated conceptual framework is advanced via three sets of propositions in recourse orchestration breadth, recourse orchestration depth and resource orchestration evolution, respectively. Eight directions for future research are further proposed. Originality/value-First, this study provides a comprehensive framework for future study in the emergent field of sustainable GS. Second, the authors contribute to theory development by proposing a ROP to explore the GS practices towards sustainability. Third, the future research directions we proposed can benefit scholars interested in the overlapping areas of GS and sustainability.
Article
The political economy framework for the comparative analysis of marketing channel dyads proposed by Stern and Reve (1980) focused mainly on relationships between channel members. This article extends the political economy framework by indicating how environmental factors (i.e., factors external to a dyad) might influence and affect the structure and processes of the dyad. When combined with the original article by Stern and Reve, the resulting overall perspective should provide a comprehensive basis for theory development and research in the marketing channel area.
Article
The study evaluates the positive effect of long-term oriented marketing relationship on ethical conduct from the perspective of the service provider (i.e., the agent-firm), by integrating the relevant literature from relationship marketing, ethics, and long-term orientation domains. The paper proposes that service providers that build relationship quality with their clients will display increased ethical conduct toward them. Specifically, the study examines the positive influence of the dimensions of relationship quality (that are relevant to the offshoring services context) that the service provider firm's employees undertake and their impact on ethical conduct. Overall, the results indicate that the commitment-only full mediation model of relationship marketing variables on ethical conduct is a better representation than both direct-effects model and other competing mediating models examined in this study. Fundamentally, it means that customer service officers should incorporate long-term orientation and commitment in their principal-agent relationships that will provide the impetus for undertaking ethical behavior. The article concludes with a discussion and implications of the findings.
Article
In this paper we draw on recent progress in the theory of (1) property rights, (2) agency, and (3) finance to develop a theory of ownership structure for the firm.1 In addition to tying together elements of the theory of each of these three areas, our analysis casts new light on and has implications for a variety of issues in the professional and popular literature, such as the definition of the firm, the “separation of ownership and control,” the “social responsibility” of business, the definition of a “corporate objective function,” the determination of an optimal capital structure, the specification of the content of credit agreements, the theory of organizations, and the supply side of the completeness-of-markets problem.
Article
This paper relates quality and uncertainty. The existence of goods of many grades poses interesting and important problems for the theory of markets. On the one hand, the interaction of quality differences and uncertainty may explain important institutions of the labor market. On the other hand, this paper presents a struggling attempt to give structure to the statement: “Business in under-developed countries is difficult”; in particular, a structure is given for determining the economic costs of dishonesty. Additional applications of the theory include comments on the structure of money markets, on the notion of “insurability,” on the liquidity of durables, and on brand-name goods.
Article
This study investigates antecedents and consequences of interpersonal trust in new and mature market economies. The authors present a model which suggests that interpersonal trust emerges as a consequence of the legal environment and the extent of interfirm managerial control. The model also suggests that interpersonal trust and managerial controls influence performance. Hypotheses are tested in retail petroleum channels in Poland, (former East) Germany, and Norway. The results indicate that the production of trust and performance varies by country. The paper concludes with a discussion of the implications for franchise management and theory.
Article
The political economy framework for the comparative analysis of marketing channel dyads proposed by Stern and Reve (1980) focused mainly on relationships between channel members. This article extends the political economy framework by indicating how environmental factors (i. e., factors external to a dyad) might influence and affect the structure and processes of the dyad. When combined with the original article by Stern and Reve, the resulting overall perspective should provide a comprehensive basis for theory development and research in the marketing channel area.
Article
This paper integrates elements from the theory of agency, the theory of property rights and the theory of finance to develop a theory of the ownership structure of the firm. We define the concept of agency costs, show its relationship to the ‘separation and control’ issue, investigate the nature of the agency costs generated by the existence of debt and outside equity, demonstrate who bears these costs and why, and investigate the Pareto optimality of their existence. We also provide a new definition of the firm, and show how our analysis of the factors influencing the creation and issuance of debt and equity claims is a special case of the supply side of the completeness of markets problem.The directors of such [joint-stock] companies, however, being the managers rather of other people's money than of their own, it cannot well be expected, that they should watch over it with the same anxious vigilance with which the partners in a private copartnery frequently watch over their own. Like the stewards of a rich man, they are apt to consider attention to small matters as not for their master's honour, and very easily give themselves a dispensation from having it. Negligence and profusion, therefore, must always prevail, more or less, in the management of the affairs of such a company.Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, 1776, Cannan Edition(Modern Library, New York, 1937) p. 700.