ArticlePDF Available

Social Inequality and Mental Health in Chile, Ecuador, and Colombia

Authors:

Abstract

The results of a comparative study of social inequality and mental health show that Chile and Colombia, which have enormous social gaps despite their economic growth, are characterized by poor mental health indicators and social discontent, while the better equity indicators in Ecuador are not clearly linked to mental health. The concept of social defeat is suggested as a mediator between social inequality and individual and collective mental health, and participation and empowerment are suggested as ways of improving social well-being. Los resultados de un estudio comparativo de desigualdad social y salud mental muestran que Chile y Colombia, que tienen enormes brechas sociales a pesar de su crecimiento económico, se caracterizan por indicadores de salud mental deficientes y descontento social, mientras que los mejores indicadores de equidad en Ecuador no están claramente vinculados a la salud mental. El concepto de derrota social se sugiere como un mediador entre la desigualdad social y la salud mental individual y colectiva, y la participación y el empoderamiento se sugieren como formas de mejorar el bienestar social.
LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES, Issue XXX, Vol. XX No. XXX, Month 201X, 1–17
DOI: 10.1177/0094582X18803682
© 2018 Latin American Perspectives
1
Social Inequality and Mental Health in Chile,
Ecuador, and Colombia
by
Yanet Quijada, Loreto Villagrán, Pamela Vaccari Jiménez,
Carlos Reyes, and Luz Dary Gallardo
Translated by
Victoria J. Furio
The results of a comparative study of social inequality and mental health show that
Chile and Colombia, which have enormous social gaps despite their economic growth, are
characterized by poor mental health indicators and social discontent, while the better
equity indicators in Ecuador are not clearly linked to mental health. The concept of social
defeat is suggested as a mediator between social inequality and individual and collective
mental health, and participation and empowerment are suggested as ways of improving
social well-being.
Los resultados de un estudio comparativo de desigualdad social y salud mental muestran
que Chile y Colombia, que tienen enormes brechas sociales a pesar de su crecimiento
económico, se caracterizan por indicadores de salud mental deficientes y descontento social,
mientras que los mejores indicadores de equidad en Ecuador no están claramente vincula-
dos a la salud mental. El concepto de derrota social se sugiere como un mediador entre la
desigualdad social y la salud mental individual y colectiva, y la participación y el empodera-
miento se sugieren como formas de mejorar el bienestar social.
Keywords: Mental health, Social well-being, Social inequality, Social defeat, Public
policy
It is recognized worldwide that social variables influence people’s health
(WHO, 2008). In Latin America, however, an increase in macroeconomic indi-
cators has not always translated into improved individual health and/or
well-being, and this may be related to inequality. Most studies of the relation-
ship between health and inequality focus on epidemiological variables
(Kaufman and Mezones-Holguín, 2013; Muntaner etal., 2003) or on power
relations and the control of capital (Domingo-Salvany etal., 2013; Rocha etal.,
2013) rather than on the way people construct and represent the sociopolitical
context in which they live. For this reason, the guiding question for this essay
is what psychosocial processes make it possible for social inequality to affect
mental health.
Yanet Quijada is an associate professor of psychology at the Universidad San Sebastián, Chile.
Pamela Vaccari Jiménez and Loreto Villagrán are professors of psychology at the Universidad de
Concepción. Carlos Reyes is a professor at the Universidad Andina Simón Bolívar, Ecuador and
Luz Dary Gallardo is a professor at the Universidad San Buenaventura, Colombia. Victoria J. Furio
is a translator living in New York City.
803682LAPXXX10.1177/0094582X18803682Latin American PerspectivesQuijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH
research-article2018
2 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
Studies emphasize the social dimension, including aspects such as empa-
thy, the ability to establish interpersonal relations (Jahoda, 1958), satisfying the
need for bonds (Ryan and Deci, 2000) and establishing positive relations with
others (Ryff, 1989), as a basic component of health. The WHO (2002: 2) defines
health as “a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being and not
merely the absence of disease or infirmity,” incorporating the concept of social
well-being originally proposed by Corey Keyes (1998) and including self-
esteem, satisfaction with life, sense of well-being, social sensitivity, and posi-
tive affect (Keyes, 2005; Shapiro etal., 2008). From this we infer that the
inequality and discontent that characterize Latin American countries make it
highly likely that their health will be affected. This is not an assertion of social
determinism but a relational view in which people cannot be separated from
their physical and mental features or from the social and cultural contexts in
which they are imbedded.
The effects of inequality can be explained in terms of the inability of
lower-income groups to acquire the material conditions necessary for good
health (Lynch, Smith, and House, 2000). Another approach suggests that
physical and psychological discomfort develops when people evaluate
themselves as having lower status than a reference group (Hounkpatin
etal., 2015). Empirical studies such as that of Daly, Boyce, and Wood (2015)
show that a low social position based on gross income compared with var-
ious reference groups (gender, age, education, and place of residence) is a
better determinant of various indicators of physical health problems than
gross income per se. The same occurs in predicting psychological distress
(Wood etal., 2012). Low social position has been found a better predictor
than gross income of symptoms of depression (Hounkpatin etal., 2015),
low overall satisfaction (Boyce, Brown, and Moore, 2010), and even sui-
cidal ideation and attempts (Wetherall etal., 2015). These studies use data-
bases with macroeconomic and social indicators, leading some writers to
point to the need for more research into the psychological mechanisms that
link social context with individual malady, with social comparison being
fundamental to their understanding (Hounkpatin etal., 2016; Wilkinson
and Pickett, 2006).
Developmental models of social functioning show that subjects with low or
subordinate social positions will display physiological and behavioral reac-
tions that make them more vulnerable to health problems (Mendelson,
Thurston, and Kubzansky, 2008). When applying this to mental health, the term
“social defeat” surfaces. This concept involves negative behavioral and cogni-
tive reactions to failure to attain status or goals in comparison with others
(Gilbert, 2006). This mechanism, which assumes social comparison, has been
studied empirically only in relation to individual clinical variables. Therefore,
its association with social variables is still unexplored, and we suggest that it
could be useful in understanding mental health in Latin America. Accordingly,
this essay will analyze figures on inequality and studies that relate it to mental
health and well-being in the past 20 years in Latin America and examine the
concept of social defeat as a possibility for explaining the impact of inequality
on mental health.
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 3
The SociopoliTical conTexT of inequaliTy
Latin America has been viewed historically as founded on relations of ine-
quality. This can be traced back to the colonizing enterprise, which set up strict
power relations based on the oppression of the original peoples, imposing
European cultures on the local ones. In the continent’s historical development,
these power relations were reproduced by the establishment of social classes
that concentrated power and resources, supporting forms of government that
perpetuated them. The history of the continent between the 1950s and the
1990s created dictatorial processes for Chile, Colombia, and Ecuador that per-
petuated the asymmetry of power and resources among their citizens, the
basis of the economic models that maintain inequality in these societies today
(Katz, 2015).
chile
The case of Chile is emblematic. During the Pinochet dictatorship of the
1970s, under heavy repression and social control, a Milton Friedman–style neo-
liberal economic model consisting of the imposition of a free market, drastic tax
reductions, privatization of services, cuts in social spending, and general liber-
alization and deregulation was implemented (Klein, 2008). As a result, a domi-
nant elite pursuing free-market business arose, and it was allowed to concentrate
economic resources and power in contrast to a working class that saw its work-
ing conditions become insecure, losing social benefits through the privatization
of public services such as health care, pensions, and education (Espinoza,
Barozet, and Méndez, 2013). The return to democracy in the 1990s did not
improve those conditions; the postdictatorship governments maintained the
economic model despite implementing social policies that allocated economic
resources to the most vulnerable. This led to an improvement in poverty indica-
tors without its translating into a more egalitarian society or an improvement
of well-being.
For example, considering suicide as the extreme of psychological distress,
Moyano and Barría (2006) found a direct relation (r = 0.87) between the growth
curves of the suicide rate and the gross domestic product (GDP) during the
period from 1981 to 2003. Between the 1990s and 2000 Chile had an approxi-
mate annual growth of 5 percent (Espinoza, Barozet, and Méndez, 2013), and
between 2006 and 2013 it reduced poverty rates from 29.1 percent to 14.4 per-
cent (MDS, 2015). At the same time, the Gini coefficient fluctuated between
0.50 and 0.51, above the regional average and one of the most noteworthy
among the OECD countries (MDS, 2015; OECD, 2015a). The average indepen-
dent income of a household in the top 10 percent was 27.6–38.8 times that of a
household in the bottom 10 percent (MDS, 2015). Likewise, reviewing national
stratification and mobility data for the past 10 years Espinoza, Barozet, and
Méndez (2013) concluded that Chile has a relatively mobile and permeable
class structure in its middle sector but a tendency toward polarization at the
extremes, since social distances increase despite economic growth. Health care
reform with explicit health guarantees was implemented in 2005, and in both
4 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
2000 and 2013 people at the highest social levels continued to have a greater
likelihood of obtaining above-average health care than people in the lowest
strata (Cabieses etal., 2015). Chile’s case shows that economic growth indica-
tors can be deceptively optimistic, concealing a highly unequal distribution of
income among the population, and leads us to conclude that the mere fact of
subsidizing the disadvantaged is no guarantee of social mobility or improve-
ments in health.
ecuador
The past 30 years in Ecuador have been marked by abrupt political, eco-
nomic, and social changes reflected in successive presidential overthrows and
an economic crisis that led to a profound imbalance in the country. The 1999
banking crisis, based on economic deregulation reforms (Larrea, 2002), concen-
tration of credit for businesses, and lack of government monitoring or evalua-
tion (Espinosa, 2000), was a landmark event. Added to this were the drop in the
price of oil, the country’s principal resource, and the effects on agriculture of
natural disasters (Fontaine, 2002). Government measures included a freeze on
deposits and widespread bank closures or takeovers by the state, leading to the
dollarization of the system as a means of adjustment and stabilization. As a
result, unemployment rates increased from 8 percent to 17 percent in 1999 and
underemployment to 57 percent, while the minimum wage dropped to US$53
and urban poverty rose from 36 percent to 65 percent (Espinosa, 2000; Fontaine,
2002; Larrea, 2002). Ultimately, some 700,000 Ecuadorians emigrated, mostly to
the United States, Spain, and Italy.
Despite an economic recovery following the crisis, there were frequent
changes of president until Rafael Correa came to power in 2007. His measures
for achieving stability included an economic policy assumed almost com-
pletely by the state, the creation of a new constitution, and the development
of social policies based on the concept of “living well” (buen vivir; Secretaría
Nacional de Planificación y Desarrollo, 2009). These initial policies involved
a distancing from the neoliberal paradigm that garnered massive citizen sup-
port for the “Citizens’ Revolution” in Correa’s first term. In addition, an eco-
nomic bonanza achieved with the rise in oil prices to historic levels allowed
for a strengthening of the state in income distribution and implementation of
measures aimed at development, access to rights, and institutional consolida-
tion (Martínez, 2015: V. Silva, 2016). A significant reduction in poverty was
achieved between 2006 and 2014, from 37.6 percent to 22.5 percent (World
Bank, 2016), along with a reduction in extreme poverty from 16.9 percent to
8.6 percent (INEC, 2014). The Gini coefficient, 0.55 in 2007, dropped to 0.47 in
2015 (INEC, 2014; World Bank, 2016) and was practically identical in urban
and rural areas. By the same token, the inequality index dropped by 1.7 per-
cent (UNDP, 2014). Thus inequality as measured by income level has displayed
a sustained reduction over the past 10 years. A measure that provided monthly
vouchers to almost 2 million people may have influenced the sustained rise in
the human development index, which reached 0.732 (UNDP, 2013). Despite
these advances, 23.7 percent remain at the poverty level, with significant dif-
ferences between the urban (15.6 percent) and rural (39.3 percent) popula-
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 5
tions (INEC, 2014; World Bank, 2016)—figures that call the progress in the
Gini coefficient into question.
In health, coverage in the more vulnerable quintiles increased from 35 per-
cent to 80 percent between 2006 and 2013, and health insurance increased from
17 percent to 34 percent in the same period (INEC, 2014). However, a recent
report from Aldeas Infantiles SOS (2015) noted the lack of psychological and
mental health services for the treatment of addiction and severe mental disor-
ders. Additionally, there are few reports on the epidemiology of specific disor-
ders, and the data currently available on mental health tend to be presented
separately from epidemiological variables. As a result, it is difficult to find an
analysis that promotes a comprehensive explanation of the progress reported
in these areas. For example, issues such as the 3.4 percent increase in suicides
among youth from 2000 to 2012 (WHO, 2014) point to the need to know more
about the social and economic factors involved in this situation.
In recent years, increasing labor flexibilization and privatization in mining
projects have signaled a return to the neoliberal economic policies implemented
during the 1990s (Acosta and Hurtado-Caicedo, 2016). Although the current
administration has not fully recognized it, a crisis exists in the form of economic
recession and deterioration of growth prospects (IMF, 2016), along with discon-
tent among those displaced by the mining industry and an increase in unem-
ployment from 4.2 percent to 5.4 percent (ILO, 2016).
In short, indicators in Ecuadorian society over the past decade demonstrate
economic and social progress tending toward a more equitable society, but
there are no data from national or international organizations that consider the
relationship between social inequality and health variables. Finally, the current
crisis has produced changes in the country’s political and economic stability
that are causing noticeable changes in the reported trend.
colombia
Colombia joined the trend toward the use of the neoliberal economic model
in the 1990s, implementing significant changes in the comprehensive social
security system and prioritizing investment in industry (Observatorio Nacional
de Salud, 2015). These processes redefined the land and its relationships in
terms of production and marketing needs (Bello, 2004), setting the stage for a
widening of the gap between rich and poor. In particular, small farmers and
indigenous populations cannot compete with large agricultural businesses and
struggle against expulsion from their lands to make way for road building and
commercial enterprises. The 2006–2010 National Development Plan was cre-
ated to reduce poverty and improve health care for vulnerable groups, and
when it achieved only meager results new policies with similar objectives for
2012–2021 were implemented. The social and economic policies employed by
the National Planning Department to address inequality have been deemed
successful in light of the decline in the Gini coefficient from 0.53 in 2014 to 0.52
in 2015 (DANE, 2015). However, UN-Habitat (2014) ranked Colombia among
the 10 least equitable countries. Between 2010 and 2015, 4,574,000 people rose
out of extreme poverty because of the United Network and Families in Action
program, focused on support and the provision of housing. The indicators on
6 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
access to basic services such as electricity, sewage systems, and potable water
improved, but those on education, health care, the environment, and the social
system were judged inequitable (Observatorio Nacional de Salud, 2015).
All these changes in economic variables and inequality in Colombia pro-
ceeded in parallel to the so-called internal armed conflict that goes back at least
to the 1950s, pitting the state, the guerrilla groups (the Fuerzas Armadas
Revolucionarios de Colombia and the Ejército de Liberación Nacional, among
others), and the “self-defense” paramilitary groups against each other. The
country has the largest number of internally displaced persons in the world
(IDMC, 2013) and ranks eighth in the number of refugees outside its borders
(UNHCR, 2012). The farmer population is bitter about the consequences of the
introduction of the neoliberal model and the market for illegal crops (Bello,
2004: 21), along with the increase in drug trafficking and the traffickers’ par-
ticipation in the struggle for control of territory (Castillo, 2004).
Colombia has improved its poverty indicators and slightly reduced inequal-
ity in recent years, but government policies are currently failing to provide
services and/or quality resources. Added to this, violence and the displace-
ment of civilians present a challenge to the state to assist various vulnerable
groups by promoting agricultural development and political participation,
solving the problem of illegal drugs, attending to the victims of the armed con-
flict, and ending the war. All of this produces socioeconomic uncertainty
because of the increase in the number of beneficiaries of these policies and the
challenge for coordination between the state, the private sector, and organiza-
tions to guarantee social security, education, health care, and well-being.
aSSeSSing inequaliTy in healTh care
Ortiz-Hernández, López-Moreno, and Borges (2007) point out that a combi-
nation of criteria is employed to analyze the social determinants of health: epi-
demiological (mortality rates, morbidity, or life expectancy), sociological
(educational level, income, and socioeconomic position), and economic (pov-
erty, Gini coefficient). Measures that assess inequality and health tend to use
social stratification, through nominal or ordinal categories, because of practical
considerations or the availability of databases (Galobardes etal., 2006; Muntaner
etal., 2003). They add that in general inequality is considered an expression of
stratification (as in Colombia, where the ranking from 1 to 6 that is applied to
housing ends up being the focal point of discrimination among people). The
effects of this are significant because the social relations resulting from inequal-
ity are not questioned (Muntaner etal., 2003; 2012). Variables that focus on
income level or on consumer goods do not analyze employment situations,
control/authority relations on the job, or power differences between social
classes. Methodological problems in evaluating social class are also evident,
especially with regard to the social strata at the extremes, where people are less
accessible to research efforts (Muntaner etal., 2003). For all of the above, meas-
uring inequality could be improved if other dimensions, such as educational
level in income distribution and purchasing power, were used. When the
UNDP’s human development index is applied to Latin America, it is clear that
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 7
purchasing power sets the conditions for health and education. If this index
were analyzed from the perspective of inequality, it would drop from 0.83 to
0.67 in Chile, from 0.72 to 0.54 in Colombia, and from 0.73 to 0.57 in Ecuador.
From this example and Wilkinson’s (2002) inputs, it is possible to assume that
the countries with better health indicators are those with the smallest gap
between wealth and poverty. Another measure supplementing those currently
used to measure inequality might be the International Index of Social and
Health Problems, which includes, among other things, inquiries into mental
disorders, social mobility, and confidence (Wilkinson and Pickett, 2010).
Instead of considering wealth and/or home furnishings, measures of income
inequality tend to include the financial assets, real estate holdings, and savings
instruments that are usually possessed by the higher-income sectors, reflecting
a position handed down over time that directly influences health (Hounkpatin
etal., 2015). When wealth is included, the description of inequality appears
with a greater gap, and figures such as the global Gini soar to values close to
0.8 (UNICEF, 2012). If current poverty indicators were supplemented with
measures that assessed the relationship between social determinants and
health, policies could be tailored to the design of more equitable communities.
Social defeaT aS a mediaTor beTween
healTh and Social inequaliTy
At the individual level, it has been suggested that mental depression may
explain the way inequality affects health, presenting it as a mediator of this
relationship. Symptoms of depression may be a reaction to contexts such as
dangerous neighborhoods and/or high levels of family conflict (Chen and
Miller, 2013). Following this logic, improving people’s life settings could
improve their mental health. At the same time, theories of depression indicate
that human beings, like other primates, are highly sensitive to social hierarchies
because they provide information on the resources available to them and the
likelihood of obtaining them (Price, 1972). Those who consider themselves of
low social status will have little expectation of obtaining what they need; their
tolerance for frustration will drop and they will avoid conflict with those more
powerful by displaying submissive behavior. All these reactions will have a
physical correlation involving the serotonergic system and the stress regulator,
which are associated with symptoms of depression (Hounkpatin etal., 2015).
In this approach, manifestations of depression are understood as defensive
responses to the perception of low social status and not just reactions to an
adverse condition (Taylor etal., 2011).
We have established that Chile is a highly unequal country, and, consistent
with this, epidemiological studies there show a prevalence of major depressive
disorders of 9.2 percent, very similar to that found in the United States (9.6
percent) and among the highest in the world (D. A. Silva and Valdivia, 2013;
Vicente etal., 2006). Similarly, we have pointed to the country’s sustained eco-
nomic growth and the GES plan for subsidizing health care, both of which
should have had a positive impact on mental health in recent decades.
Instead, while in 2003 (before the GES) 17.5 percent of the population showed
8 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
symptoms of depression, in 2009 (after the GES) the figure had changed only
changed slightly, to 17.2 percent (Errázuriz etal., 2015). These figures show that
provision of resources without a transformation of the social structure does not
produce the desired effect. In fact, while the GES plan improved access for the
disadvantaged sectors, inequality in health care associated with educational
level, income, and type of retirement system increased between 2000 and 2013
(Cabieses etal., 2015), which could explain the sustained figures on depression
and other indicators of poor health. In Colombia, a country with a socioeco-
nomic model and inequality indicators similar to Chile’s, indicators of well-
being for the 18–44-year-old population were between 32.5 percent and 42.2
percent depending on the question and gender. In this regard, Hounkpatin
etal. (2016) suggest that in inequitable settings comparisons can result in phys-
ical and psychological distress.
Not all those who consider themselves of low social status will develop a
depressive disorder; it has been suggested that this will require psychological
characteristics that interact with the setting and the individual’s biological
makeup. The concept of social defeat, defined as a sense of failure associated
with the loss of a valued status or important personal goal (Gilbert and Allan,
1998), has social comparison at its core but adds an individual component in
proposing that human beings develop their own psychological hierarchies of
goals and are conscious of their social positions in relation to those goals. In
nonpathological conditions unfavorable social comparison implies accepting
the defeat—feeling its consequences (submission, low motivation, hormonal
reaction) only temporarily before redirecting motivation and behavior toward
new goals (Sloman, Gilbert, and Hasey, 2003). Nevertheless, when one is inca-
pable of overcoming the defeat, a psychopathological condition—feeling
trapped and chronically suffering its consequences (Taylor etal., 2011)—will
appear. This mechanism has received broad empirical support for explaining
depression, anxiety, and suicide (Siddaway etal., 2015; Taylor etal., 2011).
People in the disadvantaged classes in Chile can be assumed to live with a
chronic sense of defeat and distress over the inability to attain valued goals
because of the lack of the resources to reach them. This constant sense of defeat
may help us to understand why the prevalence of depressive symptomatology
increases as the socioeconomic level declines (Jiménez and Orchard, 2013)
independent of mental health subsidies and of the relation between low social
status and the prevalence of mental disorder or symptoms of comorbidity and
anxiety in general (Vicente etal., 2006). In terms of working conditions, social
class, and mental health the data also support our suggestion, showing that
upper-class people are less likely to display mental health problems than
supervisors and formal and informal workers (Rocha etal., 2014).
With regard to the perception of their social position, qualitative studies
show that Chileans view their society as highly classist and provide many
examples of the advantages of having economic resources or belonging to a
high social class. Worse, they maintain that this situation is inherited by certain
individuals or groups (Garretón and Cumsille, 2002). The inability to overcome
defeat has been put forward as the variable most highly associated with suicide
(Siddaway etal., 2015). The idea of the heritability of class may be related to the
increase in the suicide rate by 54.9 percent between 1995 and 2009, especially
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 9
among youth (OECD, 2015b). In Colombia a measure of socioeconomic strati-
fication in which 1 is extreme poverty and 6 is economic solvency (Alzate, 2006)
has led to a demarcation of classes, conditioning the perception of social posi-
tion and identifying the opportunities of each stratum in terms of certain social
criteria, which makes social mobility difficult for the less favored social classes.
Consequently the 2015 national mental health survey indicates that the adoles-
cents of the lower strata have a higher frequency of depressive, anxious, and
psychotic symptoms and that disorders are more prevalent at the lower levels
of the social scale. In particular, anxiety disorder is more frequent in persons
living in poverty. If we focus on a specific population of “the defeated” in
Colombia such as those displaced by the internal conflict, studies show a
greater frequency of mental disorders than in the nondisplaced population: 47
percent for anxiety disorder, 37 percent for major depression, and 37 percent for
risk of suicide (Londoño etal., 2005). It is striking that, following the Chilean
trend, we have begun to see a rise in adolescent suicide rates from 1.57 per
100,000 in 2008 to 1.75 in 2012 (Instituto Nacional de Medicina Legal y Ciencias
Forenses, 2013).
From a more collective standpoint, the low motivation and submission that
social defeat produces limit individuals’ ability to take advantage of opportu-
nities to improve their situation (Gilbert, 2006). More specifically, remaining
in defeat is a link to fatalism, defined by Martín-Baró (1973: 486) as “an atti-
tude of passive acceptance of a present and a future in which everything is
already predetermined.” This is a maladaptive strategy characterized by inac-
tion despite constant discomfort. In this regard, Vidal etal. (2014) point out
that Chileans with higher incomes demonstrate better social strategies for
dealing with distress. Similarly, members of the disadvantaged classes display
less participation and less confidence in public institutions (INJUV, 2012;
Latinobarómetro, 2015; OECD, 2015a; UNDP, 2012). In Ecuador, a country
with better equality indicators than Chile or Colombia, political participation
in the elections of 2013 and 2014 showed a rate of 83.2 percent, an increase of
22.6 percent (Consejo Nacional Electoral, 2015). In contrast, abstention in Chile
reached 58 percent, the highest in Latin America among nations with non-
obligatory voting, followed by Colombia, with 52.1 percent (International
IDEA, 2016).
The consequences of social defeat can be softened by social support (Williams,
1997, cited in Taylor etal., 2011). Rocha etal. (2014) found that Chileans with
less perceived social support had worse self-perceived physical and mental
health. If support is sought through social media, collective action may result
(Sullivan etal., 1980), and action over time may amount to a social movement
(Turner and Killian, 1987). The formation of social movements has intensified
over the past 10 years and come to cover a variety of issues (Garcés, 2012). In
Chile, the defeated have organized themselves to demand rights that, under
the socioeconomic model, have become acquirable goods according to one’s
purchasing power, leaving aside a large portion of society without the possibil-
ity of attaining education, quality health care, or a dignified retirement. From
another point of view, we could conclude that any country’s measure against the
collective demand serves to maintain the defeated in their state of inaction. For
example, in Ecuador, with the latest government move toward neoliberalism
10 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
communities have been stripped of their territories to the benefit of large-scale
mining (Acosta and Hurtado, 2016; Colectivo de Investigación y Acción
Psicosocial, 2015; 2017) and subjected to the detention of their leaders, militari-
zation, and violence (CONAIE, 2017). These actions seek to break up collective
action, fostering the submission and inaction that stem from the state of defeat.
diScuSSion and concluSionS
Latin America is a region of extreme socioeconomic inequality (UNICEF,
2012). This is apparent, for example, in the concentration of wealth in small
portions of the population as a result of the capitalist and neoliberal model
operating in countries such as Chile and Colombia, where limited and sub-
sidiary states have left supplying goods and services to the population to the
private sector (García-Castro, 2010; Harvey, 2007; Katz, 2015). Although the
model of the state in Ecuador is different, its progress in the area of health care,
as in Chile and Colombia, has been slow because not everyone can afford this
subsidized service (OECD, 2015a; UNDP, 2013). This has led to persistent dis-
content and mistrust of institutions and governments (Baletti, 2016;
Latinobarómetro, 2015). The region has historically been characterized by social
movements, and during the past decade they have become widespread and
their demands wide-ranging. Critiques of the neoliberal model, which, in the
guise of free development, fuels individual growth through capital accumula-
tion and the reproduction of profit, touching aspects of life that in welfare states
are considered rights, are thereby highlighted (Garcés, 2012; Katz, 2015).
Discontent also appears when a state is unable to reduce poverty indicators or
offer a range of basic and varied services to the population. Ecuador is in this
situation, and, although there is less inequality among its citizens, discomfort
and discontent persist.
In the case of Chile, strategies for assessing and taking action on social
inequality since 1990 have had a positive effect on poverty reduction, but indi-
cators of mental disorder, levels of participation, and confidence in institutions
have not improved. Health care continues to vary in quality with the type of
coverage, and there has been little investment in mental health treatment
(Errázuriz etal., 2015). High levels of inequality persist, with extensive segrega-
tion of social classes and little social mobility. Currently, this structure is being
strongly questioned by social movements advocating for equality in education,
health care, and pensions and opposing the assignment of the status of “com-
modity” to these basic rights.
Ecuador has seen significant economic and social progress in the past 10
years, but there is a crisis caused by the decline in the price of petroleum and
excessive state control of the country’s figures on health care. This, along
with punitive actions against those who question the administration, has
provoked changes in political and economic stability. The prearranged agree-
ments for the expected sale of oil and the impact of the 2016 earthquake
forced government budget cuts that created uncertainty about how the
advances of recent years might affect the health and well-being of Ecuadorians
subjected to them.
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 11
In Colombia the state has committed itself to responding with public policies
to improve the quality of life for the most vulnerable, and analysis of social
determinants has served to measure mental health in the population. Because
of the country’s history, this includes identifying the conditions for peace,
whose link to health is a challenge requiring public policies that include all
groups.
In all three countries, better health and greater satisfaction require reducing
the gap between rich and poor. Guaranteeing access to quality services and
promoting citizen participation and empowerment are, however, still pending
items in Latin America because of the tension that exists between civil society
and the state (Astete and Vaccari, 2017). On the one hand, the state needs to
provide guarantees of access to services; on the other, it limits participation in
decision making in the political realm, preventing people from controlling
wage inequalities and the reduction of poverty in a given sector (Katz, 2015).
The Gini coefficients in 2015 were 0.45 in Ecuador, 0.52 in Colombia, and 0.49
in Chile, and no measures have been aimed directly at improving them. The
increase in funding for various programs does not guarantee better health for
the population or any reduction in these coefficients. In Chile and Colombia,
suicide rates, for example, remain largely unchanged (11 per 100,000 inhabit-
ants in Chile and 3.8 in Colombia) (Errázuriz etal., 2015; Instituto Nacional de
Medicina Legal y Ciencias Forenses, 2013). In Ecuador, the increase in social
investment, including the human development voucher paid monthly to a
large portion of the population, has not reduced the poverty rate (currently 23.7
percent). Ecuador has no public figures on the effects of the holistic “living
well” plan, and studies that link the Gini, the human development index, pov-
erty measured by income, and percentage of informal labor with mental health
epidemiology do not exist. However, there are many inconsistencies between
its high human development index (0.732), its 0.45 Gini coefficient, and its pov-
erty level (INEC, 2014; World Bank, 2016). The efforts made in health care do
not specify the issue of social determinants as the point of departure. Therefore,
a more comprehensive analysis will be required to demonstrate the impact of
these changes.
For these reasons, evaluating psychological factors in relation to inequality
and health seems an appropriate way of guiding possible individual or collec-
tive action. People are conscious of their positions in society, and this makes
the social composition of their country a fact that helps define their position in
life. In Chile, where purchasing power conditions the “purchase” of important
personal goals, the feeling of defeat is generalized, explaining the elevated
indicators of mental health problems. Despite this, a culture that promotes
social support persists, demanding equality through collective action. In
Colombian society disadvantaged groups are marked by the subsidy policy
and by a history of displacement and seizure of their lands. While in the for-
mer the perception of defeat predominates, the second has objectively been
“defeated” and will require focused attention on mental health given that the
social divide leaves them with few tools for dealing with the consequences.
Both groups display poor mental health indicators. Reporting on Ecuador’s
social composition has left aside groups such as indigenous populations in
economically coveted areas whose attempts to overcome defeat have been
12 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
heavily repressed. Added to this is the quarter of the population that is steeped
in poverty and job insecurity, an issue that cuts across the three countries
because of the effects of the prevailing economic model. Our analysis suggests
that part of the Ecuadorian population may be at risk of developing psycho-
pathological processes.
Becoming conscious of one’s social position intersects with elements of iden-
tity that shape beliefs about oneself and one’s goals and expectations of their
achievement. Adolescence may be a phase particularly susceptible to the effects
of defeat, since identification of reference groups and future goals and, because
of progress toward more abstract thought, the incorporation of macrosocial
aspects into one’s understanding of society are under way. In this regard, the
idea of the heritability of class and the conditioning factor of money in the per-
sonal goals of Chileans and the identification of class in terms of numbers in
Colombian society could exacerbate the perception of defeat, a mechanism
associated with suicide. Here we may find an explanation of the increase in the
suicide rate in this age-group in these two countries. Reactions to social defeat
may involve passivity and apathy, which may lead to resistance and opposi-
tion. However, we found no studies of the transformation of social defeat into
social movements. The transcultural validation under way in Chile, Colombia,
and Ecuador of the main scale of evaluation of social defeat will allow us to
corroborate our concept of mental health at the individual and collective levels.
Social defeat should be included in the explanation of the effect of inequality
on mental health, and mechanisms for dealing with social defeat should be
promoted. From a clinical standpoint, action can be taken to reinforce the social
support of surrounding networks. Experiments on this exist in the area of
social-communal psychology, where actions are focused on strengthening par-
ticipation and empowerment. Solidifying strategies for collective coping and
community organization, along with the development of leadership and nego-
tiation skills, could provide true alternatives for coping with social defeat,
improving subjective well-being, and contributing to the changes advocated by
social movements.
referenceS
Acosta, Alberto and Francisco Hurtado-Caicedo
2016 “De la violación del Mandato Minero al festín minero del siglo XXI.” Biodiversidad en
América Latina y el Caribe. http://www.biodiversidadla.org/Principal/Secciones/
Documentos/Ecuador_De_la_violacion_del_Mandato_Minero_al_festin_minero_del_siglo_
XXI (accessed March 11, 2017).
Aldeas Infantiles SOS Ecuador
2015 Estado de situación y análisis del ejercicio de derechos de los niños, niñas y adolescentes en el
Ecuador 2014–2015. Quito: Aldeas Infantiles SOS.
Alzate, María Cristina
2006 La estratificación socioeconómica para el cobro de los servicios públicos domiciliarios en Colombia:
¿Solidaridad o focalización? Bogotá: ECLAC, UN.
Astete, Marco and Pamela Vaccari
2017 “Políticas públicas y subjetividades en disputa: implementación de programas sociales
en la Comuna de Lota, Chile.” Psicoperspectivas: Individuo y Sociedad 16: 31–41.
Baletti, Brenda
2016 “Toward the worker state, or working for the state? Reorganization of political antago-
nisms in the Brazilian Amazon.” Latin American Perspectives 43 (2): 22–47.
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 13
Bello, Nuria
2004 “El desplazamiento forzado en Colombia: acumulación de capital y exclusión social,” pp.
19–30 in María Bello (ed.), Desplazamiento forzado: Dinámicas de guerra, exclusión y desarraigo.
Bogotá: Universidad Nacional de Colombia/United Nations High Commission for Refugees.
Boyce, Christopher, Gordon Brown, and Simon Moore
2010 “Money and happiness rank of income, not income, affects life satisfaction.” Psychological
Science 21 (4): 471–475.
Cabieses, Baltica, Richard Cookson, Manuel Espinoza, Gillian Santorelli, and Iris Delgado
2015 “Did socioeconomic inequality in self-reported health in Chile fall after the equity-based
healthcare reform of 2005? A concentration index decomposition analysis.” PloS One 10 (9):
e0138227. doi:10. 1371/journal.pone.0138227.
Castillo, Carolina
2004 “Colombia: violencia y narración.” Espéculo: Revista de Estudios Literarios 27: 47–60.
Chen, Edith and Gregory E. Miller
2013 “Socioeconomic status and health: mediating and moderating factors.” Annual Review of
Clinical Psychology 9: 723–749.
Colectivo de Investigación y Acción Psicosocial
2015 Estrategias de represión y control social del Estado ecuatoriano ¿Dónde quedó la Constitución?
Caso Yasunidos. Quito: Colectivo de Investigación y Acción Psicosocial.
2017 La herida abierta del cóndor. Quito: Colectivo de Investigación y Acción Psicosocial.
CONAIE (Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador)
2017 La voz del líder shuar desde la cárcel. Quito: CONAIE.
Consejo Nacional Electoral
2015 “Transparencia 2015.” http://cne.gob.ec/es/transparencia/2015 (accessed November 6,
2016).
Daly, Michael, Christopher Boyce, and Alex Wood
2015 “A social rank explanation of how money influences health.” Health Psychology 34 (3):
222–230.
DANE (Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estadística)
2015 “Encuesta nacional de calidad de vida.” https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas
-por-tema/salud/calidad-de-vida-ecv/encuesta-nacional-de-calidad-de-vida-ecv-2015 (accessed
November 6, 2016).
Domingo-Salvany, Antonia, Amaia Bacigalupe, José Carrasco, Albert Espelt, Josep Ferrando, and
Carme Borrell
2013 “Propuestas de clase social neoweberiana y neomarxista a partir de la Clasificación
Nacional de Ocupaciones 2011.” Gaceta Sanitaria 27 (3): 263–272.
Errázuriz, Paula, Camila Valdés, Paul Vöhringer, and Esteban Calvo
2015 “Financiamiento de la salud mental en Chile: una deuda pendiente.” Revista Médica de
Chile 143: 1179–1186.
Espinosa, Roque
2000 “La crisis económica financiera ecuatoriana de finales de siglo y la dolarización.”
Programa Andino de Derechos Humanos, Universidad Andina Simón Bolívar. http://www
.memoriacrisisbancaria.com/www/articulos/Roque_Espinosa_Crisis_bancaria.pdf (accessed
November 6, 2016).
Espinoza, Vicente, Emanuelle Barozet, and María Luisa Méndez
2013 “Estratificación y movilidad social bajo un modelo neoliberal: el caso de Chile.”
Lavboratorio 25 (Autumn): 169–191.
Fontaine, Guillaume
2002 “Crisis de la gobernabilidad y dolarización en el Ecuador: una mirada retrospectiva al
golpe de Estado del 21 de enero 2000.” Documentos del Instituto Internacional de Gobernabilidad
97: 1–19.
Galobardes, Bruna, Mary Shaw, Debbie Lawlor, John Lynch, and George Smith
2006 “Indicators of socioeconomic position (part 1).” Journal of Epidemiology and Community
Health 60 (1): 7–12.
Garcés, Mario
2012 El despertar de la sociedad: Los movimientos sociales de América Latina y Chile. Santiago: LOM
Ediciones.
14 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
García-Castro, Juan
2010 “Ideología de la desigualdad: análisis de la investigación empírica en psicología social.”
Revista Electrónica de Psicología Política 24: 67–87.
Garretón, Manuel Antonio and Guillermo Cumsille
2002 “Las percepciones de la desigualdad en Chile.” Revista Proposiciones 34: 1–9.
Gilbert, Paul
2006 “Evolution and depression: issues and implications.” Psychological Medicine 36 (3): 287–297.
Gilbert, Paul and Steven Allan
1998 “The role of defeat and entrapment (arrested flight) in depression: an exploration of an
evolutionary view.” Psychological Medicine 28 (03): 585–598.
Harvey, David
2007 Breve historia del neoliberalismo. Madrid: Ediciones Akal.
Hounkpatin, Hilda, Alex Osafo, Alex Wood, and Graham Dunn
2016 “Does income relate to health due to psychosocial or material factors? Consistent support
for the psychosocial hypothesis requires operationalization with income rank not the Yitzhaki
Index.” Social Science and Medicine 150: 76–84.
Hounkpatin, Hilda, Alex Wood, Gordon Brown, and Graham Dunn
2015 “Why does income relate to depressive symptoms? Testing the income rank hypothesis
longitudinally.” Social Indicators Research 124: 637–655.
IDMC (Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre)
2013 “Colombia: internal displacement in brief.” http://www.internal-displacement.org
/americas/colombia/summary (accessed April 19, 2016).
ILO (International Labour Organization)
2016 “Overview Latin America and the Caribbean.” ILO Regional Office for Latin American
and the Caribbean. http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/—americas/—ro-lima
/documents/publication/wcms_545825.pdf (accessed April 12, 2017).
IMF (International Monetary Fund)
2016 “Purchase under the rapid financing instrument: press release, staff report, and statement
by the executive director for Ecuador.” IMF Country Report no. 16/288. http://www.imf.org
/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/cr16288.pdf (accessed April 12, 2017).
INEC (Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos)
2014 “Desafíos para la medición de los logros educativos: la experiencia de Ecuador.” http://
www.cepal.org/MDG/noticias/seminarios/9/53699/2_Ecuador_INEC_JRosero.pdf
(accessed October 27, 2016).
INJUV (Instituto Nacional de la Juventud)
2012 “Séptima encuesta nacional de juventud.” http://www.injuv.gob.cl/portal/wp-content/
files_mf/septimaencuestanacionaljuventud2.pdf (accessed November 5, 2016).
Instituto Nacional de Medicina Legal y Ciencias Forenses
2013 “Boletín epidemiológico trimestral: quitarse la vida cuando ésta aún comienza— suicidios
en niños, niñas y adolescentes en Colombia en el año 2013.” http://www.medicinalegal.gov.co
/documents/10180/28521/2+suicidios-jovenes.pdf/136d4b84-821a-430f-befc-57b72b17fb6d
(accessed November 6, 2016).
International IDEA (Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance)
2016 “Total vote.” https://www.idea.int/data-tools/question-countries-view/438/19/reg
(accessed April 18, 2016).
Jahoda, Marie
1958 Current Concepts of Positive Mental Health. New York: Basic Books.
Jiménez, Alvaro and Macarena Orchard
2013 “Sobre la distribución desigual de la sintomatología depresiva: Chile, desigualmente dep-
rimido.” Columna de investigadores Universidad de Chile, January 16. http://www.uchile.cl
/noticias/88435/a-jimenez-y-m-orchard-chile-desigualmente-deprimido (accessed November
5, 2016).
Katz, Claudio
2015 “Dualities of Latin America.” Latin American Perspectives 42 (4): 10–42.
Kaufman, J. S. and Edward Mezones-Holguín
2013 “Una epidemiología social para América Latina: una necesidad más allá de la reflexión sobre
las inequidades en salud.” Revista Peruana de Medicina Experimental y Salud Pública 30: 543–546.
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 15
Keyes, Corey
1998 “Social well-being.” Social Psychology Quarterly 61 (2): 121–140.
2005 “Mental illness and/or mental health? Investigating axioms of the complete state model
of health.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73: 539–548.
Klein, Naomi
2008 La doctrina del shock: El auge del capitalismo del desastre. Toronto: Random House of
Canada.
Larrea, Carlos
2002 Pobreza, dolarización y crisis en el Ecuador. Quito: Ediciones Abya-Yala.
Latinobarómetro
2015 “Informe metodológico Latinobarómetro.” http://www.latinobarometro.org/latContents
.jsp (accessed November 6, 2016).
Londoño, Nora, Oscar Muñiz, Jorge Correa, Carlos Patiño, Gerardo Jaramillo, Juliana Raigoza,
Laura Toro, Diego Restrepo, and Carlos Rojas
2005 “Mental health among victims of the armed conflict in Bojayá Chocó, Colombia.” Revista
Colombiana de Psiquiatría 34: 493–505.
Lynch, John, George Smith, George Kaplan, and James House
2000 “Income inequality and mortality: importance to health of individual income, psychoso-
cial environment, or material conditions.” British Medical Journal 320:1200–1204.
Martín-Baró, Ignacio
1973 “Psicología del campesino salvadoreño.” Estudios Centroamericanos 297: 476–495.
Martínez Dalmau, Rubén
2015 “Democratic constitutionalism and constitutional innovation in Ecuador: the 2008
Constitution.” Latin American Perspectives 43 (1): 158–174.
Mendelson, Tamar, Rebecca C. Thurston, and Laura D. Kubzansky
2008 “Affective and cardiovascular effects of experimentally-induced social status.” Health
Psychology 27: 482–489.
MDS (Ministerio de Desarrollo Social, Gobierno de Chile)
2015 “Informe de desarrollo social.” http://www.ministeriodesarrollosocial.gob.cl/pdf
/upload/IDS2.pdf (accessed November 6, 2016).
Moyano, Emilio and Rodolfo Barría
2006 “Suicidio y producto interno bruto (PIB) en Chile: hacia un modelo predictivo.” Revista
Latinoamericana de Psicología 38: 343–359.
Muntaner, Carles, Carme Borrell, Joan Benach, María Isabel Pasarín, and Esteve Fernández
2003 “The associations of social class and social stratification with patterns of general and
mental health in a Spanish population.” International Journal of Epidemiology 32: 950–958.
Muntaner, Carles, Katia B. Rocha, Carme Borrell, Clelia Vallebuona, Ciro Ibáñez, Joan Benach, and
Orielle Sollar
2012 “Clase social y salud en América Latina.” Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 31 (2):
166–175.
Observatorio Nacional de Salud
2015 “Informe técnico: desigualdades sociales en salud en Colombia.” http://www.ins.gov
.co/lineas-de-accion/ons/SiteAssets/Paginas/publicaciones/6to%20informe%20ONS.pdf
(accessed November 6, 2016).
OECD (Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development)
2015a “How’s life? 2015: measuring well-being.” doi:10.1787/how_life-2015-graph87-en.
2015b “Suicide,” pp. 54–57 in Health at a Glance 2015: OECD Indicators. Paris: OECD Publishing.
Ortiz-Hernández, Luis, Sergio López-Moreno, and Guilherme Borges
2007 “Desigualdad socioeconómica y salud mental: revisión de la literatura latinoamericana.”
Cadernos de Saúde Pública 23: 1255–1272.
Price, John
1972 “Genetic and phylogenetic aspects of mood variation.” International Journal of Mental
Health 1 (1–2): 124–144.
Rocha, Katia, Carles Muntaner, María José González, Pamela Bernales, Clelia Vallebuona, Carme
Borrell, and Orielle Solar
2013 “Clase social, desigualdades en salud y conductas relacionadas con la salud de la
población trabajadora en Chile.” Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 33: 340–348.
16 LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
Rocha, Katia, Carles Muntaner, Orielle Solar, Carme Borrell, Pamela Bernales, María José González,
and Clelia Vallebuona
2014 “Clase social, factores de riesgo psicosocial en el trabajo y su asociación con la salud
autopercibida y mental en Chile social.” Cadernos de Saúde Pública 30: 2219–2234.
Ryan, Richard and Edward Deci
2000 “Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development,
and well-being.” American Psychologist 55 (1): 68.
Ryff, Carol
1989 “Happiness is everything, or is it? Explorations on the meaning of psychological well
-being.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 57: 1069.
Secretaría Nacional de Planificación y Desarrollo
2009 “Plan Nacional para el Buen Vivir.” http://www.buenvivir.gob.ec/versiones-plan-nacio
nal;jsessionid=0E7F6ED83EA6667F385EBBEBB2A92284 (accessed November 6, 2016).
Shapiro, Shauna, Doug Oman, Carl Thoresen, Thomas Plante, and Tim Flinders
2008 “Cultivating mindfulness: effects on well-being.” Journal of Clinical Psychology 64: 840–862.
Siddaway, Andy, Peter Taylor, Alex Wood, and Joerg Schulz
2015 “A meta-analysis of perceptions of defeat and entrapment in depression, anxiety prob-
lems, posttraumatic stress disorder, and suicidality.” Journal of Affective Disorders 184: 149–159.
Silva, Daniel A. and Mario Valdivia
2013 “Estudio comparativo de dos escalas de depresión en relación al intento de suicidio en
adolescentes no consultantes.” Revista Chilena de Neuro-psiquiatría 51 (1): 10–15.
Silva, Verónica
2016 “Constructing a state in the face of regional power: the case of Guayaquil.” Latin American
Perspectives 43 (1): 93–108.
Sloman, Leon, Paul Gilbert, and Gary Hasey
2003 “Evolved mechanisms in depression: the role and interaction of attachment and social
rank in depression.” Journal of Affective Disorders 74 (2): 107–121.
Sullivan, Thomas J., Kenrick S. Thompson, Richard D. Wright, George R. Gross, and Dale R. Spady
1980 Social Problems: Divergent Perspectives. New York: Wiley.
Taylor, Peter, Patricia Gooding, Alex M. Wood, and Nicholas Tarrier
2011 “The role of defeat and entrapment in depression, anxiety, and suicide.” Psychological
Bulletin 137: 391.
Turner, Ralph and Lewis Killian
1987 Comportamiento colectivo. Madrid: Prentice-Hall.
UNDP (United Nations Development Program)
2012 “Bienestar subjetivo: el desafío de repensar el desarrollo.” http://desarrollohumano.cl
/idh/informes/2012-bienestar-subjetivo-el-desafio-de-repensar-el-desarrollo/ (accessed
November 6, 2016).
2013 “Desarrollo humanidad dividida: cómo hacer frente a la desigualdad en los países en
desarrollo.” http://www.bibliotecavirtual.info/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Humanidad_
dividida_Spanish.pdf (accessed November 6, 2016).
2014 “Informe sobre desarrollo humano: sostener el progreso humano, reducir vulnerabili-
dades y construir resiliencia.” http://hdr.undp.org/sites/default/files/hdr14-summary-es
.pdf (accessed November 6, 2016).
UN-Habitat
2014 “Brecha urbana: ciudades desiguales.” http://mirror.unhabitat.org/documents
/SOWC10/SP/Unequal_Cities.pdf (accessed April 4, 2016).
UNHCR (United Nations High Commission for Refugees)
2012 “Situación Colombia.” http://www.acnur.org/t3/fileadmin/scripts/doc.php?file=t3
/fileadmin/Documentos/RefugiadosAmericas/Colombia/2012/Situacion_Colombia_-_
Agosto_2012 (accessed April 4, 2016).
UNICEF (United Nations Children’s Fund)
2012 “Global inequality: beyond the bottom billion: a rapid review of income distribution in
141 countries.” http://libguides.williams.edu/citing/chicago-author-date#s-lg-box-12037257
(accessed November 6, 2016).
Vicente, Benjamin, Robert Kohn, Pedro Rioseco, Sandra Saldivia, Itzhak Levav, and Silverio Torres
2006 “Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R disorders in the Chile psychiatric prev-
alence study.” American Journal of Psychiatry 163: 1362–1370.
Quijada et al. / SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH 17
Vidal, Daisy, Isi Chamblas, Mercedes Zavala, Ralph Muller, María Rodriguez, and Alejandra Chavez
2014 “Deteminantes sociales en salud y estilos de vida en población adulta de Concepción,
Chile.” Ciencia y Enfermería 20 (1): 61–74.
Wetherall, Karen, Michael Daly, Kathryn Robb, Alex Wood, and Rory O’Connor
2015 “Explaining the income and suicidality relationship: income rank is more strongly asso-
ciated with suicidal thoughts and attempts than income.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric
Epidemiology 50: 929–937.
WHO (World Health Organization)
2002 “Informe mundial sobre la violencia y la salud.” http://iris.paho.org/xmlui/bitstream
/handle/123456789/725/9275315884.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed November 6,
2016).
2008 “Informe de la OMS y Comisión sobre determinantes sociales de la salud: informe final.”
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/69830/1/WHO_IER_CSDH_08.1_spa.pdf
(accessed November 6, 2016).
2014 “Prevención del suicidio: un imperativo global.” http://www.who.int/mental_health
/suicide-prevention/es/ (accessed March 7, 2017).
Wilkinson, Richard
2002 Unhealthy Societies: The Afflictions of Inequality. Abingdon: Routledge.
Wilkinson, Richard G. and Kate Pickett
2006 “Income inequality and population health: a review and explanation of the evidence.”
Social Science and Medicine 62: 1768–1784.
2010 The Spirit Level: Why Equality Is Better. London: Penguin UK.
Wood, Alex, Christopher Boyce, Simon Moore, and Gordon Brown
2012 “An evolutionary based social rank explanation of why low income predicts mental dis-
tress: A 17-year cohort study of 30,000 people.” Journal of Affective Disorders 136: 882–888.
World Bank
2016 “Ecuador panorama general.” http://www.bancomundial.org/es/country/ecuador
/overview, el 27 de octubre de 2016 (accessed November 6, 2016).
... By capturing feelings linked to unfavorable social comparison, it has been proposed that social defeat could act as a mediator between a context of social inequality and the psychological unrest of the people who inhabit it (Quijada, Villagrán, Vaccari, Reyes, & Gallardo, 2018). Specifically, Chile has presented deterioration in some mental health indicators, e.g., 21.1% of Chilean adults claim having been diagnosed with depression at some point in their lives (Ministerio de Salud de Chile, 2014). ...
... In the present study, SD was associated to lower levels of social well-being. Although SD has been linked to abusive group dynamics such as bullying (Björkqvist, 2001;Meltzer, Vostanis, Ford, Bebbington, & Dennis, 2011), its reverse association with perceptions of integration or communal contribution adds to the discussion about how socio-contextual variables affect psychological well-being and play a role in individual suffering (Quijada et al., 2018;Wood, Boyce, Moore, & Brown, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction Social defeat (SD) is defined as a feeling of having lost the fight leading to a loss of valuable status or of important personal goals, and has been associated to depression and suicidal behavior, among other disorders. Furthermore, it has been proposed as a mediating variable between social and clinical elements. Objective To adapt and validate a Spanish version of the Defeat Scale. Method A back translation into Spanish was carried out. SD, hopelessness, and social well-being were measured in 546 university students (Mean age = 20.93 years, SD = 2.98; 68.7% females). Results An exploratory factor analysis offered a two-dimension structure in the scale made up by the dimension defeat and triumph. A confirmatory factor analysis found good fit indicators for the two-dimension model (df = 89; χ² = 188.96; CFI = .942; RMSEA = .061; IFI = .943). Both dimensions present good internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha > .70). SD was associated to higher levels of hopelessness and lower levels of social well-being. Discussion and conclusion The Spanish version of the Defeat Scale presents good psychometric properties. Its use can help deepen the understanding of psychopathological phenomena and their link to social elements within the context of Spanish speaking countries.
... Thus, higher social status individuals perceive less government corruption and therefore have fewer depressive symptoms. This conclusion extended social rank and relative deprivation theories 56,57 . In a collectivist society, high social status is usually not the result of one's own efforts. ...
Article
Full-text available
Perceived government corruption is an important indicator of depressive symptoms. Recent studies have explored the relationship between perceived government corruption and depressive symptoms in a cross-cultural context, but the underlying mechanisms need further research. This paper examines the impact of perceived government corruption on depressive symptoms in China and the moderating role of social status. Based on the 2018 wave of China Family Panel Studies (CFPS2018), 14,116 respondents aged between 16 and 96 were selected. The results revealed: (1) Perceived government corruption was significantly positively correlated with depressive symptoms. (2) Social class had an inhibitory effect in moderating the relationship between perceived government corruption and depressive symptoms. (3) The moderating effect was only significant for respondents who received education between junior high school and a bachelor’s degree. The findings provide policy implications for developing countries and transitional societies like China. To build a more psychologically healthy society, we need to strengthen anti-corruption, stimulate social mobility, and improve people's sense of gain in the future
... Their research combines control and systems theory with psychology to suggest several psychiatric treatments for dealing with behavioural abnormalities in the lives of individuals. Previous research has found that income inequality in a country does not have an impact on national happiness [13,14]. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents an in-depth study and analysis of the correlation between satisfaction with rural residents’ income and mental health well-being in the context of industrial structure upgrading. Most of the studies on residents’ subjective well-being from the perspective of relative income or income inequality have started from the happiness of rural residents and the satisfaction of rural residents’ life, and few scholars have focused on the psychological health of rural residents. Subjective well-being is significantly related to external and internal goals in desire. Life satisfaction is significantly and positively correlated with external and internal goals, as well as the six dimensions of desire, except for social identity; positive emotions are significantly and positively correlated with internal goals; negative emotions are only negatively correlated with self-acceptance, and there is a significant positive correlation between income level and desire. In vertical income, there is also a process of judging whether the expected income is achieved. If the expected income growth level is achieved, the income satisfaction will increase. Desire mediates the effect of income level on subjective well-being. Income level influences subjective well-being through internal goals; income level influences life satisfaction and positive emotions through external goals. The relationship between income inequality and mental health is influenced by the characteristics of the population, with women and middle-aged people being the most negatively affected. This relationship is also influenced by income level, with the effect of income inequality on mental health showing a negative effect in the lower and middle-income groups but a positive effect in the higher income groups. Income inequality affects residents’ mental health through the mediating effects of a sense of social justice, life stress, and trust in government. Inequality in household wealth can exacerbate the negative effects of income inequality on mental health.
... The Chilean healthcare system has become more equitable and responsive to the population's needs (e.g., the Bono AUGE healthcare reform programme); however, the high relative inequalities in terms of income (OECD, 2018), education level and rural-urban factors are determinants of quality of care, health system barriers and differential access to healthcare (high confidence) (Frenz et al., 2014). Exposure and vulnerability to psychosocial risks in SWS show significant inequalities in times of disasters such as earthquakes according to socioeconomic, geographic and gender factors (high confidence) (Labra, 2002;Vitriol et al., 2014;Quijada et al., 2018), which are increased by the absence of local planning and drills and the lack of coordination (Vitriol et al., 2014). Indigenous Peoples have the highest levels of vulnerability in Chile in terms of income, basic needs and access to services to climate change (low confidence) (Parraguez-Vergara et al., 2016). ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Central and South America are highly exposed, vulnerable and strongly impacted by climate change, a situation amplified by inequality, poverty, population growth and high population density, land use change particularly deforestation with the consequent biodiversity loss, soil degradation, and high dependence of national and local economies on natural resources for production of commodities (high confidence1). Profound economic, ethnic and social inequalities are exacerbated by climate change. High levels of widespread poverty, weak water governance, unequal access to safe water and sanitation services and lack of infrastructure and financing reduce adaptation capacity, increasing and creating new population vulnerabilities (high confidence). {12.1.1, 12.2, 12.3, 12.5.5, 12.5.7, Figure 12.2}
... The same data capture process also excludes reverse causation, unless the presence of high anxiety/depression scores makes workers self-select into more precarious jobs. This interpretation is not supported by the fact that compared with other Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries, Chile's indicators of mental health have worsened at an accelerated rate [32]. We conclude, therefore, that reverse causation and inflated results due to common method bias are unlikely to be serious limitations. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Precarious work is a broad definition for non-standard employment, often including unstable and insecure positions where workers permanently experience uncertainty; these types of jobs are growing steadily around the planet. Since the coup d’état in 1973, Chile has experienced a series of structural economic changes framed by neoliberal ideas cemented in the “Constitution of Pinochet.” Precarious work in Chile is a direct consequence of these ideas. This multidimensional phenomenon has progressively been entering employment areas where it was not previously present. As a result, there has been a rise in work precarization and its full impact on health is not well known. The goal of this study was to estimate the association of work precariousness with mental health outcomes in Chilean workers. Methods Data were obtained from the Chilean Survey of Work and Health 2009–2010 (ENETS). Only valid records of salaried workers (excluding hourly-only or commission-only workers) in the private sector without missing values were included ( n = 1900). After applying appropriate sampling weights, 1,461,727 workers were represented. Mental health was estimated as anxiety/depression levels using the 12-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12). A multilevel multivariate generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) with negative binomial and log link distribution was used to study the association between precariousness and depression/anxiety. Results Looking at the overall precariousness scale (range from zero to four), we observed an increase of approximately 34% in the depression/anxiety score (scale range from 0 to 36) for every unit on the precarious work overall scale (Relative Risk = 1.34, 95% CI = 1.28, 1.42) controlling for age, sex, and occupational group. Conclusion Precarious work was associated with anxiety and depression as measured with the 12-item General Health Questionnaire. Controlling for demographic variables changed neither the direction nor the magnitude of the association.
... En la actualidad, a pesar de los avances en la disponibilidad de servicios de salud mental bajo un modelo comunitario, los hospitales psiquiátricos permanecen vigentes, persisten importantes brechas en la calidad de atención y respeto de derechos de los usuarios (Cea-Madrid, 2019;Minoletti et al., 2015) y se observan crecientes indicadores de descontento social y malestar subjetivo en el conjunto de la ciudadanía (Aceituno Morales; Miranda Hiriart; Jiménez Molina, 2012; Quijada et al., 2018). Junto con ello, organizaciones en primera persona han impulsado acciones colectivas de defensa de derechos, enriqueciendo el debate público en el campo de la salud mental (Cea-Madrid, 2018b). ...
Article
Full-text available
El presente trabajo analiza el gasto público en salud mental en el marco de la implementación del modelo comunitario en Chile. Para ello, examina el mecanismo de financiamiento y la asignación de recursos financieros en salud mental considerando los recursos ejecutados en prestaciones hospitalarias y extrahospitalarias en el sistema público de salud en el período 2014-2018. En general, se observa un aumento del número de prestaciones hospitalarias y extrahospitalarias, así como en el gasto derivado de las mismas. Los mayores incrementos de inversión monetaria refieren a la aplicación de electroshock, programas de rehabilitación tipo 2, día cama integral psiquiátrico diurno y día cama hospitalización integral corta estadía. Se concluye que la vigencia del modelo asilar, el predominio biomédico y la excesiva medicalización de la salud mental sustentan una inequidad en la valoración de las prestaciones, así como una desigual distribución de los recursos públicos, siendo necesario reorientar el gasto estatal hacia servicios comunitarios que garanticen derechos de ciudadanía y la promoción del bienestar.
Book
Mit dem Aufkommen der Coronakrise war aufgrund der Neuartigkeit des Virus und des akuten Handlungsbedarfs von Seiten jedes Einzelnen gerade zu Beginn ein erhöhter Bedarf an Informationen gegeben. Daher war es die Aufgabe der Wissenschaft, Behörden und journalistischen Berichterstattung zu erklären, um welche Art von Virus es sich handelt, welche Symptome auf eine Infektion hindeuten und wie man sich schützen kann. Im Laufe dieser äußerst hartnäckigen Krise kamen immer neue Themen rund um das Virus auf, zu denen sich die Bevölkerung informieren musste; zum Beispiel was unter einem exponentiellen Wachstum zu verstehen ist, wie die verschiedenen Impfstoffe wirken oder welche Maßnahmen derzeit zu befolgen sind. Viele dieser Informationen fußten auf den neuesten Erkenntnissen von Wissenschaftler*innen, die sich bemühten (und dies noch stets tun), komplexe wissenschaftliche Sachverhalte verständlich zu präsentieren. Wie Barbieri et al. (2020) für Italien demonstrieren, ist die Vermittlung wissenschaftlicher Informationen, die das Problem gründlich erklären, eine wichtige Voraussetzung für die langfristige Akzeptanz der Maßnahmen. Bald war allerdings die Presse dominiert von Interviews mit Virolog*innen wie Christian Drosten, Hendrik Streeck oder Melanie Brinkmann sowie von coronabezogenen Informationen alle Art. Durch diesen Information Overload stellte sich bei vielen eine Art Informationsverdrossenheit ein, während das Thema gleichzeitig immer stärker polarisierte. Aus diesem Grund versammelt dieser Band interdisziplinäre Perspektiven auf Informationsverhalten und Informationsvermittlung im Rahmen der Coronapandemie, wobei die Beiträge aus den Feldern Sprachwissenschaft, Informationswissenschaft, Kommunikationswissenschaft und Psychologie stammen. Es handelt sich um einen Konferenzband, der im Anschluss an die Tagung Interdisziplinäre Forschungszugänge zu Wissenschaftskommunikation und Informationsverhalten in der Corona-Pandemie (InFoCoP) entstanden ist, die im Juli 2021 als Online-Veranstaltung der Universität Hildesheim stattfand. Die Tagung wurde im Rahmen des Projektes Wissenschaftsvermittlung in der Informationskrise um die COVID-19-Pandemie (WInCO1) durchgeführt, das von 2021 bis 2022 in der Förderlinie Zukunftsdiskurse vom Ministerium für Wissenschaft und Kultur Niedersachsen finanziert wird.
Article
Background: The processes involved in this study were 2-fold. First, we analyzed the levels of resilience and internalized problems (defined as group of emotional symptoms) in children aged 9 to 12 years. Second, we examined whether the relationship between them varies according to the low or high vulnerability of school communities. Methods: About 1460 students from schools in northern Chile participated. A total of 52.6% were girls, and 47.4% were boys. The scales of internalizing problems of the System of Evaluation of Children and Adolescents (SENA) and the short scale of resilience (CYRM-12) were applied. Correlations in each group and differences between groups were analyzed using a MANOVA. A 2-level path analysis was also performed. Results: Resilience was higher in the context of low vulnerability while depression, social anxiety, and posttraumatic stress symptomatology were greater in the context of high vulnerability. A 2-level path analysis showed that the slope of gender, anxiety, and depression symptomatology varies between schools and an interaction effect between vulnerability and anxiety symptomatology. Conclusion: There are differences in the relationship between internalized problems and resilience according to whether the students belong to low or high vulnerability establishments. This study contributes to a better understanding of the relationship between internalizing problems and resilience.
Chapter
Child and adolescent suicide is a major public health issue in Chile. Although we have seen a decline in child and adolescent suicide statistics over the past few years, suicide is still the leading cause of death in adolescents between 15 and 19 years of age. Suicidal ideation is an important factor in the prevention and early intervention of suicide. However, this factor has great variability, dependent on territory, rurality, gender, and social status in Chilean adolescents. Owing to this distinct inequality, this chapter addresses important questions regarding the effect of social context on the mental health of adolescents and the mediating mechanisms that explain the relationship between a certain social context and suicidal behavior. To address these questions, the chapter describes risk and protection variables in a Chilean context, which are theoretically and empirically grounded, and which shed light on the relationship between context and extreme psychological distress. This chapter identifies findings regarding the relationship between suicidal behavior and sociodemographic variables like rurality, economic vulnerability and gender, among others. Furthermore, this chapter considers related studies that focus on the effects of psychosocial variables such as family functionality, alcohol consumption, drug use, with a clear focus on the construct of social defeat. Finally, this chapter identifies and describes clinical predictors of suicidal behavior. The results of a study completed on an adolescent Chilean population that identifies risk trajectories through the analysis of mediation are discussed in this chapter. These results demonstrate that risk trajectories begin with the contextual, pass through the psychosocial and clinical variables, and finally increase the probability of experiencing suicidal behavior.
Article
Full-text available
This critical and socio constructionist qualitative exploratory study aims to analyze tensions between the implementation of social programs and the subjectivity of those who are intervened. It seeks to contribute to understanding why, after implementation of several social policies in the communes, social problems such as poverty, inequality and unemployment persist. The work was developed out in the commune of Lota, Chile, with 15 local leaders with years of experience in these positions. Life story was used as data collection technique, and data analysis for content analysis with thematic mesh, to coding the construction of relations between subjects, community and State. The discussion shows the need to understand the intervention considering a relevant conjuncture with community organizations and a multidimensional perspective of problems that promote and highlight resources owned by the intervened social groups.
Article
Full-text available
In spite of the high prevalence of mental health disorders in Chile, there is a significant financing deficit in this area when compared to the world’s average. The financing for mental health has not increased in accordance with the objectives proposed in the 2000 Chilean National Mental Health and Psychiatry Plan, and only three of the six mental health priorities proposed by this plan have secure financial coverage. The National Health Strategy for the Fulfilment of Health Objectives for the decade 2011-2020 acknowledges that mental disorders worsen the quality of life, increase the risk of physical illness, and have a substantial economic cost for the country. Thus, this article focuses on the importance of investing in mental health, the cost of not doing so, and the need for local mental health research. The article discusses how the United States is trying to eliminate the financial discrimination suffered by patients with mental health disorders, and concludes with public policy recommendations for Chile.
Article
Full-text available
Research on why income influences health has produced mixed findings. Many, but not all, studies suggest that the relationship between income and health is due to income indicating psychosocial position rather than the associated material benefits. The inconsistent findings may be partly due to the use of the Yitzhaki Index, a function which calculates the accumulated income shortfall for an individual relative to those with higher income, in order to represent the psychosocial position conferred by income. The current study tests whether an alternative specification - income rank - provides more consistent conclusions regarding the psychosocial effect of income on health. We used data from two nationally representative samples: 14,224 observations from 9,404 participants across three waves (2004, 2008, and 2012) of the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA) and 29,237 observations from 8,441 individuals across seven waves (2007-2013) of the Longitudinal Internet Studies for the Social Sciences (LISS). Multilevel regression models indicated that income rank was a stronger and more consistent predictor than both the Yitzhaki Index and actual income of self-rated and objective health. The psychosocial hypothesis is more consistently supported when income rank is used to test it.
Article
Objective: Although several epidemiological studies of the prevalence of psychiatric disorders have been conducted in Latin America, few of them were national studies that could be used to develop region-wide estimates. Data are presented on the prevalence of DSM-III-R disorders, demographic correlates, comorbidity, and service utilization in a nationally representative adult sample from Chile. Method: The Composite International Diagnostic Interview was administered to a stratified random sample of 2,978 individuals from four provinces representative of the country's population age 15 and older. Lifetime and 12-month prevalence rates were estimated. Results: Approximately one-third (31.5%) of the population had a lifetime psychiatric disorder, and 22.2% had a disorder in the past 12 months. The most common lifetime psychiatric disorders were agoraphobia (11.1%), social phobia (10.2%), simple phobia (9.8%), major depressive disorder (9.2%), and alcohol dependence (6.4%). Of those with a 12-month prevalence diagnosis, 30.1% had a comorbid psychiatric disorder. The majority of those with comorbidity had sought out mental health services, in contrast to one-quarter of those with a single disorder. Conclusions: The prevalence rates in Chile are similar to those obtained in other studies conducted in Latin America and Spanish-speaking North American groups. Comorbidity and alcohol use disorders, however, were not as prevalent as in North America.
Article
The institutionalization of the Brazilian Workers’ Party has given rise to new tensions among emerging political actors, historic social movement mediator organizations, and the state. An analysis of the differences in strategies and practices between the Movement in Defense of Renascer and the Prainha Rural Worker’s Movement that emerged during the creation of the Renascer Extractive Reserve in the Lower Amazon highlights the fact that the movement’s emancipatory impulses indicate a break with the politics-as-usual of the union and the Workers’ Party more broadly. An examination of union political discourses and practices that seek to fold these emancipatory impulses back into the dominant logic indicates that the union continues to perform the work of the state—albeit a reconstituted one—both institutionally and effectively. A institucionalização do Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT) no Brasil tem criado novas tensões entre atores políticos emergentes, organizações mediadoras dos movimentos sociais históricos e o Estado. Uma análise das diferenças entre o Movimento em Defesa do Renascer e o Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais da Prainha, na Baixa Amazônia, enfatiza o fato de que os impulsos emancipatórios do movimento indicam um rompimento com os hábitos políticos de sindicatos e do Partido dos Trabalhadores de um modo geral. Um exame dos discursos políticos sindicais e das práticas que buscam a contenção desses impulsos emancipatórios, e tentam restaurá-los à lógica dominante, indica que o sindicato continua a desempenhar o trabalho do Estado—mesmo que reconstituído—tanto institucionalmente quanto efetivamente.
Article
The city of Guayaquil is a territory in which economic actors play a central role in the configuration of subnational power. This has generated a kind of pseudo- or half-finished democracy in which, although elections are held, there is only one actor, the Madera de Guerrero Social Christian Party, representing the local economic elite that has held power since 1992. Following the theory of Edward Gibson, this situation can be viewed as sort of subnational authoritarianism: the parochialization of power, the nationalization of influence, and control of institutional and noninstitutional links have allowed this subnational power to achieve local control and influence in the national arena during various periods. La ciudad de Guayaquil representa un territorio donde los actores económicos juegan un papel central en la configuración del poder subnacional, haciendo de los espacios de representación política su mecanismo legitimador y su fuente de negociación local y nacional. Para algunos investigadores del caso, esto ha generado una suerte de seudodemocracia o democracia a medias en la que, si bien se celebran elecciones, a la vez encontramos un solo actor en escena, el Partido Social Cristiano Madera de Guerrero, representante de la élite económica local en el poder desde 1992. Siguiendo la teoría de Edward Gibson bien se podría hablar de una suerte de autoritarismo subnacional: la parroquialización del poder, la nacionalización de sus influencias y el control de los vínculos institucionales y no institucionales han hecho de este poder subnacional una fuerza que ha logrado un control local y una influencia en la arena nacional durante varios períodos.