ArticlePDF Available

Tebeu's Pronostic Classifi cation of Obstetric Fistula According to Anatomopathologic Variables from the University Teaching Hospital, Yaounde Cameroon-International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology SCIRES Literature-Volume 3 Issue 2-www.scireslit.com

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

INTRODUCTION WHO proposes the successful closure rate for fi rst repair at 85% in each facility with the continence achievement among the closed cases at 90 % [1]. Failure of obstetric fi stula repair is associated with severe psychological and social implications [2]. Several experts published their closed rate of obstetric Vesicovaginal Fistulas (VVF) ranging from 63 to 100% [3-7]. In spite of closure, residual incontinence varies from 5 to 30% [8,9]. A report from Kenya showed that among women regularly seen at postoperative follow-up, 54% were still leaking [10]. Th ey found that, this condition was associated with having had previous failed repairs, and greater fi stula size (> 2cm). Similar fi ndings were reported in Uganda, where unsuccessful fi stula closure was signifi cantly associated with large fi stula size (> 3 cm), circumferential defect and fi brosis [11]. Th ey found that, independent predictors for residual stress incontinence aft er successful fi stula closure were urethral involvement and previous unsuccessful fi stula repair. In Democratic Republic of Congo, the satisfactory rate in terms of closure with continence was weak for fi stula size at 4 cm and above (65.2% vs. 83.7%) [12].Th e same authors reported that the satisfaction was respectively 87.1%, 67.7% and 37.9% if no fi brosis, moderate or severe fi brosis [12]. An Egyptian study revealed that, previous repair, long duration of VVF until treatment, surgical approach and the location of the VVF had a signifi cant eff ect on surgical outcome [13]. We previously compared 22 patients presenting closure with good continence to 10 others with failure/incontinence. We found that the later had fi stula more likely to be localized at the bladder neck region (80% vs. 50%); with size more than 5 cm (30% vs. 9%); vaginal scaring (80% vs. 64%), and fi brosis (80% vs 55%) [14]. Th e evidence from previous studies is that fi stula surgical outcome is strongly associated anatomical patterns including location, size and quality of tissue [15,16]. Th ese anatomical features could be used for proper prognostic classifi cation of VVF. Several classifi cations have been proposed for predicting the surgical diffi culties. Th us, Falandry in 1992, proposed a prognostic classifi cation in 3 groups, as group I, also called simple, group II also called diffi cult, and group III, also called complicated considering bladder neck involvement, associated rectovaginal fi stula, fi brosis and previous operation as independent factors for poor prognosis [8]. Th e prognostic implications of previous operations have been supported by several studies, In Ghana, Elkins revealed that the success rate aft er surgery was 85% at fi rst attempt , 50% at second attempt and 33% at third one [17]. In a Zambian's study, the total satisfaction aft er fi stula repair was respectively 70%, 18% and 11% at fi rst, second and third attempts [18]. We recently reported similar trend in Cameroon [19]. Th e number of previous operations is associated with poor surgical outcome, and this could be attributed to the fi brosis of the tissue and merging resection formerly used and that could have increase the fi stula size. Classifi cation proposed by Falandry was later modifi ed by Camey who distinguished three prognostic classes as simple, complex, and complicated fistulas, but did not specify the role of the fibrosis as prognostic factor [20]. Many other classifications have been proposed, like that from Goh, which consider the site, the size and the fibrosis but does not combined those factors to address the prognostic classes [21]. In 1995, another classification proposed by Waaldijk, consider the site, but did not consider the size and fibrosis as prognostic factors [22]. In 2007, WHO proposed this classification, but while expressing two groups of fistulas, those of good prognosis/simple and those of bad prognosis/ complicated [1]. WHO classifi cation suff ers from the impact of the skill of the surgeon, as what appears simple for one surgeon could be complicated for another one depending on their competency. WHO classifi cation suffers from the lack of fibrosis as a prognostic factor, and also, it considers the previous operation and associated recto-vaginal fistula as independent poor prognostic factors. Based on the review on available classification systems, authors revealed that, a standardized classification system with accepted ABSTRACT Introduction: Several studies revealed the prognostic value of the fistula location, size and the vaginal fibrosis on surgical result.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Research Article
Tebeu’s Pronostic Classi cation of Obstetric
Fistula According to Anatomopathologic
Variables from the University Teaching
Hospital, Yaounde Cameroon -
Pierre Marie Tebeu1*, Georges Didier Ngassa Meutchi2, Claude Cyrille
Noa Ndoua3, Yvette Nkene Mawamba4, Gregory Halle Ekane5 and
Charles Henry Rochat6
1Ligue d’Initiative et de Recherche Active pour la Santé et l’Education de la Femme (LIRASEF)
2Department of Obstetric Gynecology, High Institute of Medical Technologies, Yaoundé-Cameroon
3Departement of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University Teaching Hospital, Yaounde, Cameroon
4Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University Teaching Hospital, Yaoundé, Cameroon
5Departement of Obstetrics and Gynecology, General Hospital, Douala, Cameroon
6Geneva Foundation for Medical Education and Research, Switzerland
*Address for Correspondence: Tebeu Pierre Marie, Obstetric Gynecology service, University
Teaching Hospital, Yaoundé, Cameroon, Tel: ++237 6 77 67 55 33; E-mail:
Submitted: 19 August 2017; Approved: 20 September 2017; Published: 22 September 2017
Cite this article: Tebeu PM, Ngassa Meutchi GD, Noa Ndoua CC, Mawamba YN, Ekane GH, et al.
Tebeu s Prognostic classi cation of obstetric stula according to anatomopathologic variables at
the University Teaching Hospital, Yaounde, Cameroon. Int J Reprod Med Gynecol. 2017;3(1): 029-
033.
Copyright: © 2017 Tebeu PM, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative
Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
International Journal of
Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
SCIRES Literature - Volume 3 Issue 2  www.scireslit.com
Page - 030
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
INTRODUCTION
WHO proposes the successful closure rate for  rst repair at 85% in
each facility with the continence achievement among the closed cases
at 90 % [1]. Failure of obstetric  stula repair is associated with severe
psychological and social implications [2]. Several experts published
their closed rate of obstetric Vesicovaginal Fistulas (VVF) ranging
from 63 to 100% [3-7]. In spite of closure, residual incontinence
varies from 5 to 30% [8,9]. A report from Kenya showed that among
women regularly seen at postoperative follow-up, 54% were still
leaking [10].  ey found that, this condition was associated with
having had previous failed repairs, and greater  stula size (> 2cm).
Similar  ndings were reported in Uganda, where unsuccessful
stula closure was signi cantly associated with large  stula size
(> 3 cm), circumferential defect and  brosis [11].  ey found
that, independent predictors for residual stress incontinence a er
successful  stula closure were urethral involvement and previous
unsuccessful  stula repair.
In Democratic Republic of Congo, the satisfactory rate in terms
of closure with continence was weak for  stula size at 4 cm and above
(65.2% vs. 83.7%) [12]. e same authors reported that the satisfaction
was respectively 87.1%, 67.7% and 37.9% if no  brosis, moderate or
severe  brosis [12]. An Egyptian study revealed that, previous repair,
long duration of VVF until treatment, surgical approach and the
location of the VVF had a signi cant e ect on surgical outcome [13].
We previously compared 22 patients presenting closure with good
continence to 10 others with failure/incontinence. We found that the
later had  stula more likely to be localized at the bladder neck region
(80% vs. 50%); with size more than 5 cm (30% vs. 9%); vaginal scaring
(80% vs. 64%), and  brosis (80% vs 55%) [14].
e evidence from previous studies is that  stula surgical outcome
is strongly associated anatomical patterns including location, size and
quality of tissue [15,16].  ese anatomical features could be used for
proper prognostic classi cation of VVF. Several classi cations have
been proposed for predicting the surgical di culties.  us, Falandry
in 1992, proposed a prognostic classi cation in 3 groups, as group I,
also called simple, group II also called di cult, and group III, also
called complicated considering bladder neck involvement, associated
rectovaginal  stula,  brosis and previous operation as independent
factors for poor prognosis [8].
e prognostic implications of previous operations have been
supported by several studies, In Ghana, Elkins revealed that the
success rate a er surgery was 85% at  rst attempt , 50% at second
attempt and 33% at third one [17]. In a Zambian’s study, the total
satisfaction a er  stula repair was respectively 70%, 18% and 11% at
rst, second and third attempts [18]. We recently reported similar
trend in Cameroon [19].  e number of previous operations is
associated with poor surgical outcome, and this could be attributed
to the  brosis of the tissue and merging resection formerly used
and that could have increase the  stula size. Classi cation proposed
by Falandry was later modi ed by Camey who distinguished three
prognostic classes as simple, complex, and complicated  stulas, but
did not specify the role of the  brosis as prognostic factor [20].
Many other classi cations have been proposed, like that from
Goh, which consider the site, the size and the  brosis but does not
combined those factors to address the prognostic classes [21]. In 1995,
another classi cation proposed by Waaldijk, consider the site, but did
not consider the size and  brosis as prognostic factors [22]. In 2007,
WHO proposed this classi cation, but while expressing two groups of
stulas, those of good prognosis/simple and those of bad prognosis/
complicated [1]. WHO classi cation su ers from the impact of the
skill of the surgeon, as what appears simple for one surgeon could be
complicated for another one depending on their competency. WHO
classi cation su ers from the lack of  brosis as a prognostic factor,
and also, it considers the previous operation and associated recto-
vaginal  stula as independent poor prognostic factors.
Based on the review on available classi cation systems, authors
revealed that, a standardized classi cation system with accepted
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Several studies revealed the prognostic value of the fi stula location, size and the vaginal fi brosis on surgical result.
Objective: We conducted this study in order to evaluate a surgical outcome of Obstetric vesicovaginal stula focusing on three
leading prognostic factors combination including size, location and softening of surrounding tissue.
Methods: This was a retrospective case series study from 69 patients at the University Teaching Hospital, Yaounde, Cameroon
involving patients operated from March 2009 to March 2015.
We collected data from registers, patient’s folders and by phone call. We defi ned criteria of good prognosis based on the 3 prognostic
factors (retrotrigonal location, size < 2 cm, soft vagina tissue); minor criteria of poor prognosis (bladder wall other than retrotrigonal, size
between 2-4 cm, vagina less scaring); and major criteria of poor prognosis (Complete circumferential defect, size > 4 cm, major scaring/
stenosis).
The combination of the above variables helped in defi ning prognostic classes as, class-I (3 criteria of good prognosis); class-II (1
minor criteria of bad prognosis); class-III (2 minor criteria of bad prognosis); class-IVA (3 minor criteria of bad prognosis, or 1 major criteria
of poor prognosis), and class-IVB ( at least 2 major criteria of bad prognosis ). Closure with continence rate was assessed at discharge,
and at 3 months after surgery.
Results: Obstetric stula frequency was respectively class I (18.8%), class II 53.7%), class III (18.8%) and class IV (8.8%). The
satisfactory result decreased from class I to IV as closure with continence rate were, respectively for class I (92.3%), class II (94.6%),
class III (77%) and class IV (16.7%).
Conclusion: Fistula location, size and softening of surrounding tissue provide a promising prognostic classifi cation of obstetric stula
in four entities. While waiting for additional researches this appears as a good fi eld option.
Keywords: Fistula; Prognosis; Classifi cation; Surgery; Result
SCIRES Literature - Volume 3 Issue 2  www.scireslit.com
Page - 031
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
terminology is urgently needed while avoiding physiological
terminologies as simple [23].  ese observations called for the
development prognostics classes of VVF depending on morphologic
variables commonly reported as independent prognostic variables
for surgical outcome (so ening of the vagina, localization of  stula,
and it size) that could better be reproducible [15,16]. In Niger,
60% cases were the sizes of the  stula greater than 4 cm, and 78.4%
presented  brous tissue [24]. Authors highlighted the need for
prognostic classi cation and concluded that “A simple, reproducible
and universally accepted scienti c classi cation or staging system for
OF dealing with outcomes rather than anatomic landmarks should
replace the present proposed classi cation systems for prognostic and
ethical purposes”.
As each of the three anatomical prognostic variables is not
always presented as an isolated feature, the challenge in prognostic
classi cation will be to combine all the three variables to de ne the
prognosis classes. If this is done it will help in distribution case among
the teams, better organize competency based training and compared
di erent results from  stula units over the world.
OBJECTIVE
We conducted this study intending to de ne a prognostic
classi cation of vesicovaginal  stula based on three leading prognostic
factors including site, size and  brosis on the daily practice.
METHODS
Type, setting and duration of the survey
is was a retrospective cases series study at the University
Centre Hospital, Yaounde Cameroon focusing on patients operated
from March 03, 2009 to March 03, 2015 (six years).
Population
e study population included obstetric vesico-vaginal  stulas.
Patients with  stula involving urethra, uterus, and ureter were
excluded.
Variables
We collected data from registers, patient’s folders and by phone call.
Variables of interest included, sociodemographic and reproductive
health characteristics (name and  rst name, age, nationality,
profession, residence, marital status, education, occupation, religion),
pregnancy and delivery (antenatal care, duration of labor, place of
childbirth, mode of delivery, neonatal status). Past medical features
of the patients (laparotomy, dystocia, Caesarean, hysterectomy,
instrumental delivery, smelling as urine or stools, vulva dermatitis,
urines leaking, presence of stools on the vulva, speculum examination
ndings. Surgical outcome related information’s were also collected
as presence or absence of leaking).
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Data were collected using a pre-established individual
questionnaire, introduced in a Microso le Excel 2010, then to
transfer to EPI-7.1. For classi cation purpose, we de ned criteria
of good prognosis based on the 3 prognostic factors (retrotrigonal
location, size < 2 cm, so vagina tissue); minor criteria of poor
prognosis (Wall other than retrotrigonal, 2-4 cm, vagina less  brotic);
and major criteria of poor prognosis (Complete circumferential defect,
size > 4 cm, major  brosis/stenosis).  e combination of the above
variables helped in de ning prognostic classes as, class-I (3 criteria of
good prognosis); class-II (1 minor criteria of bad prognosis); class-III
(2 minor criteria of bad prognosis); class-IVA (3 minor criteria of bad
prognosis, or 1 major criteria of poor prognosis), and class-IVB (at
least 2 major criteria of bad prognosis). Closure with continence rate
was assessed at discharge, and at 3 months a er surgery.
RESULTS
e mean age of patients was 29 (SD: 9.03) years. Many patients
were teenagers at surgery (26%), with primary educational level
(55.1%), single (65.2) and housewives (81.2%) (Table I). Fistula was
mostly trigonal (46.4%) and juxtacervical (20.3%). Many  stulas had
small size less than 2 cm (67%), without vaginal  brotic tissue (Table
2). Considering the frequency, obstetric  stula were respectively
class I (18.8%), class II 53.7%), class III (18.8%) and class IV (8.8%)
(Table 2).  ree months follow up a er surgery, revealed similar
outcome among patients reported as Class I and II. Satisfactory result
decreased with the severity of  stula class from I to IV. Closure with
continence rate was, respectively for class I (92.3%), class II (94.6%),
class III (77%) and class IV (16.7%) (Table 3).
DISCUSSION
We found that, many patients were teenagers at surgery (26%).
Teenage condition is found in a wide range in obstetric  stula
Table 1: Socio-demographic characteristics of fi stula patients.
Characteristics
Overall fi stulas
N = 69
n%
Age mean (SD) 29 (SD: 9.03)
Age (classes) (Years)
15-19 18 26.0
20-34 41 59.5
35-45 10 14.5
Educational level
Primary 38 55.1
Secondary 28 40.6
High 3 4.3
Marital status
Married 21 30.4
Single 45 65.3
Widow 3 4.3
Occupation
Civil servant 2 2.9
Private sector 3 4.3
Housewife 56 81.2
Student 8 11.6
Ethnic group
Bantou 40 58.0
Semi-bantou 24 34.8
Sudanese 5 7.2
Residency
Urban 30 43.5
Rural 39 56.5
Religion
Muslim 5 7.2
Christian 63 91.3
Animist 1 1.5
N: Study population, % percentage many patients were teenagers at surgery,
with primary educational level, single and housewives.
SCIRES Literature - Volume 3 Issue 2  www.scireslit.com
Page - 032
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
patients ranging from 8.9 to 86 % [25-27].  e increase obstetrical
risk in teenagers can be explained by anatomic immaturity.  ere
is a need to struggle against teenager’s pregnancies in Cameroon.
Patients had primary educational level (55.1%). Poor educational
level among the obstetric  stula patients had been reported in several
studies as ranging from 78 to 96% [28,29].  is can be due to the fact
that many of the teenagers could not continue their education due to
the medical and social condition.
Most of the patients were single (65.2%); this is high compared
to 38% of patients previously reported as single at the time of surgery
in the northern Cameroon [26].  is can also be the fact that, in the
northern Cameroon, many women will still be in the compound, but
without real contact with the husband and are wrongly considered
as married. However among 11 divorced patients, (n = 10) having
divorced a er the occurrence of the  stula. Almost all of our patients
did not have an occupation (81.2%). Women with obstetric  stula are
o en solitary [30]. In the Far North Cameroon, 15% of patients were
thinking about suicide as solution to their condition. Higher  gure
(38%) was reported in Ethiopia [31].
Fistula had moderate/severe  brosis in 18%, lower than 64.9%
reported in Uganda [11]. We found  stula with a size of more than
4 cm only in 18.4%; similar to 18% reported `in Uganda, lower than
25.3% reported in Niger for size of more than 3 cm [11,32]. Moderate
to severe at 70.4%  brosis was reported in Nigeria [33]. Fibrosis
associated with  stula was similar to the report from DRC, where
20.5% of  stula was associated with vaginal  brosis during surgical
treatment [34].
We found that many  stulas were located at the trigon (46.4%)
and at the juxtacervical area (20.3%). In a previous study in Far North
Cameroon, we found that  stula was located on the bladder wall
(15.6%), on the trigon (28.1%), on the bladder neck (31.3) and on the
urethra (25.0%) [14].
Obstetric  stulas were mostly class-II with respectively class-I
(18.8%), class-II 53.7%), class-III (18.8%) and class-IV (8.8%).  is
observation was in agreement with the report from Falandry who
suggested a prognostic classi cation in three entities including
respectively group-I (37.6%), group-II (41.7%) and group-III (20.7%)
[8] and by Goh [21].
e stula grouped as class I-II (72.5%) suggests that, if this
classi cation is used, it will be rational to gathering class-I / class-II in
basic training and class-III / class-IV as advanced training.
We reported the result initially at discharge, but  nally at 3
months.  ree months follow up a er surgery, revealed similar
outcome among patients reported as Class I and II. In overall,
satisfactory results decreased with the severity of class from I to IV.
Close with continence rate were, respectively for class I (92.3%), class
II (94.6%), class III (77%) and class IV (16.7%).
ere is a great discrepancy for the time of result report; some
are still presenting their results at discharge, as this was recently
published from Ethiopia, with closure and continence of 84.5% at
discharge [35]. Among our patients,  ve of class III-IV who had
closure with continence at discharge didn’t at 3 months meaning the
results should not be concluded before 3 months.
Decreasing satisfaction with the increasing in  stula prognosis
class is in agreement with  nding by Falandry who organized VVF in
three groups (simple, di cult and complicated) and reported a result
of 96.92% for group-I, 76.16% for group-II and 16.6% for group-
III [8]. But this classi cation from Falandry had the weakness of
misconsideration of some prognostic variables. Results as presented
in the present study were at 3 months for a set of patient, therefore
the repeated surgery was not considered and the censured result was
the combination of closure and continence. Some studies present the
result of obstetric VVF repair including repeating operations for the
same patient [8]. Other studies present the result only as successful
closure without taking into consideration the continence status [36].
Classi cation de ned and highlighted by  eld result, can be
considered in the training programs by organizing surgical trainees
in 2 groups of competency Based Training. Yet, consider basic
training (class I and II), and advanced training (class III and IV).
is classi cation could also be possible used while distributing the
surgical task among the sta .
CONCLUSIONS
We have de ned a prognostic classi cation system for
vesicovaginal  stula in four classes. We found that, the surgical
outcome diminish gradually with the prognostic class.  is
classi cation must be used while organizing training sessions and
while allocating the task among the surgical team.
Table 2: Anatomic characteristics of the fi stula.
Characteristics Overall fi stulas
N = 69
n%
Location
Uretro-vaginal 0 0.0
Cervico-vaginal 10 14.5
Trigono-vaginal 32 46.4
Retro trigonal 13 18.8
Juxtacervical 14 20.3
Size
< 2Cm 46 67.0
2-4 Cm 16 23.0
> 4 Cm 7 10.0
Surrounding tissue
Soft 56 81.0
Moderate Fibrosis 11 16.0
Severe fi brosis 2 3.0
Prognostic class
Class I 13 18.8
Class II 37 53.7
Class III 13 18.8
Class IV 6 8.7
N: Study population, % percentage
Fistula were mostly trigonal and juxtacervical. Many fi stulas had small size less
than 2 cm without vaginal fi brotic tissue.
Table 3: Obstetric fi stula outcome for each prognostic class.
Close and
continent
Class I
N = 13(%)
Class II
N = 37(%)
Class III
N = 13(%)
Class IV
N = 6(%)
At discharge
Yes 12(92.3) 35(94.6) 12(92.3) 4(66.7)
No 1(7.7) 2(5.4) 1(7.7) 2(33.3)
At 3 months
Yes 12(92.3) 35(94.6) 10(77.0) 1(16.7)
No 1(7.7) 2(5.4) 3(23.0) 5(83.3)
N: Study population, % percentage
In overall, satisfactory results after surgery decreased with the severity of class
from I to IV.
SCIRES Literature - Volume 3 Issue 2  www.scireslit.com
Page - 033
International Journal of Reproductive Medicine & Gynecology
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We wish to thank the sta of the Department of Obstetrics
and Gynecology at the University Teaching Hospital, Yaounde,
Cameroon.
REFERENCES
1. de Bernis L. Obstetric fi stula: guiding principles for clinical management and
programme development, a new WHO guideline. Int J Gynaecol Obstet.
2007; 99: 117-21. https://goo.gl/5fCw2t
2. Martin SS, Adogaye SB, Rodrigue MB, Maurice D, Vivaldi TT, Amede SF,
et al. [Study of knowledge, attitudes and practices in social reintegration of
women victims of obstetric fi stula: region of the far-North, Cameroon]. Pan Afr
Med J. 2015; 20: 172. https://goo.gl/kgJfzh
3. Nafi ou I, Idrissa A, Ghaichatou AK, Roenneburg ML, Wheeless CR, Genadry
RR. Obstetric vesico-vaginal stulas at the National Hospital of Niamey,
Niger. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2007; 99: 71-74. https://goo.gl/eNKa1f
4. Ahmad S, Nishtar A, Hafeez GA, Khan Z. Management of vesico-
vaginal stulas in women. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2005; 88: 71-75.
https://goo.gl/We2txz
5. Waaldijk K. The immediate management of fresh obstetric fi stulas. Am J
Obstet Gynecol. 2004; 191: 795-799. https://goo.gl/easR6o
6. Wall LL, Karshima JA, Kirschner C, Arrowsmith SD. The obstetric
vesicovaginal fi stula: characteristics of 899 patients from Jos, Nigeria. Am J
Obstet Gynecol. 2004; 190: 1011-1019. https://goo.gl/TMDgkj
7. Qi Li Ya, Ouattara Z, Ouattara K. Traitement des fi stules vesico-vaginales
à l’hôpital de Kati, à propos de 34 cas. Med Afr Noire. 2000; 47: 167-169.
https://goo.gl/44nysB
8. Falandry L. Traitement des fi stules uro-génitales postpartum en Afrique, 261
cas observés en dix ans. Prog Urol. 1992; 2: 861-873. https://goo.gl/sWKguE
9. Sjoveian S, Vangen S, Mukwege D, Onsrud M. Surgical outcome of obstetric
stula: a retrospective analysis of 595 patients. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand.
2011; 90: 753-760. https://goo.gl/K7QDBw
10. McFadden E, Taleski SJ, Bocking A, Spitzer RF, Mabeya H. Retrospective
review of predisposing factors and surgical outcomes in obstetric fi stula
patients at a single teaching hospital in Western Kenya. J Obstet Gynaecol
Can. 2011; 33: 30-35. https://goo.gl/KnbzZV
11. Kayondo M, Wasswa S, Kabakyenga J, Mukiibi N, Senkungu J, Stenson
A, et al. Predictors and outcome of surgical repair of obstetric fi stula at a
regional referral hospital, Mbarara, western Uganda. BMC Urol. 2011; 11: 23.
https://goo.gl/d7eFBb
12. Wadie BS, Kamal MM. Repair of vesicovaginal stula: Single-centre
experience and analysis of outcome predictors. Arab J Urol. 2011; 9: 135-
138. https://goo.gl/uoooTv
13. Tebeu PM, Fomulu JN, Mbassi AA, Tcheliebou JM, Doh AS, Rochat CH.
Quality care in vesico-vaginal obstetric stula: case series report from
the regional hospital of Maroua-Cameroon. Pan Afr Med J. 2010; 5: 6.
https://goo.gl/NAK6eZ
14. Roenneburg ML, Genadry R, Wheeless CR, Jr. Repair of obstetric
vesicovaginal fi stulas in Africa. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2006; 195: 1748-1752.
https://goo.gl/9Yuv2N
15. Elkins TE. Surgery for the obstetric vesicovaginal fi stula: a review of 100
operations in 82 patients. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1994; 170: 1108-1118.
https://goo.gl/bSBcPb
16. Wadhawan S, Wacha DS. A review of urinary fi stulae in a university teaching
hospital. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 1983; 21: 381-385. https://goo.gl/XqtNNw
17. Tebeu PM. Impact of the recurrence on the surgical outcome of women
operated for obstetric vesico-vaginal fi stula: a Cameroonian experience.
2012; 25.
18. Camey M. Les fi stules obstetricales. 1ere edn. Paris: 1998.
19. Goh JT. A new classifi cation for female genital tract fi stula. Aust N Z J Obstet
Gynaecol. 2004; 44: 502-504. https://goo.gl/awW8Rk
20. Waaldijk K. Surgical classifi cation of obstetric fi stulas. Int J Gynaecol Obstet.
1995; 49: 161-163. https://goo.gl/mNx5aL
21. Goh J, Stanford EJ, Genadry R. Classifi cation of female genito-urinary tract
stula: a comprehensive review. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct.
2009; 20: 605-610. https://goo.gl/9QKEHU
22. Karateke A, Cam C, Ozdemir A, Guney B, Vatansever D, Celik C.
Characteristics of obstetric fi stulas and the need for a prognostic classifi cation
system. Arch Med Sci. 2010; 6: 253-256.
23. Tebeu PM, Fomulu JN, Khaddaj S, de BL, Delvaux T, Rochat CH. Risk
factors for obstetric fi stula: a clinical review. Int Urogynecol J. 2012; 23: 387-
94. https://goo.gl/orTKGX
24. Tebeu PM, de BL, Doh AS, Rochat CH, Delvaux T. Risk factors for obstetric
stula in the Far North Province of Cameroon. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2009;
107: 12-15.
25. Maheu-Giroux M, Filippi V, Maulet N, Samadoulougou S, Castro MC, Meda
N, et al. Risk factors for vaginal fi stula symptoms in Sub-Saharan Africa:
a pooled analysis of national household survey data. BMC Pregnancy
Childbirth. 2016. https://goo.gl/s5LFP3
26. Meyer L, Ascher-Walsh CJ, Norman R, Idrissa A, Herbert H, Kimso O, et al.
Commonalities among women who experienced vesicovaginal fi stulae as a
result of obstetric trauma in Niger: results from a survey given at the National
Hospital Fistula Center, Niamey, Niger. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2007; 97: 1-4.
https://goo.gl/9JMPc8
27. Muleta M. Obstetric stulae: a retrospective study of 1210 cases at
the Addis Ababa Fistula Hospital. J Obstet Gynaecol. 1997; 17: 68-70.
https://goo.gl/T7V7TJ
28. WHO [homepage on the Internet]. Geneva: Obstetric stula: guiding principles
for clinical management and programme development. [Updated 2006, cited
2009 January]. 2006; https://goo.gl/BF1pT4
29. Goh JTW, Sloane KM, Krause HG, Browning A, Akhter S. Mental health
screening in women with genital tract fi stulae. B J O G 2005; 112: 1328-1330.
https://goo.gl/gxkJgS
30. Harouna YD, Seidou A, Maikano S, Djabeidou J, Sangare A, Bilane SS, et
al. La fi stule vésico-vaginale de cause obstétricale:enquête aupres de 52
femmes admises au village des fi stuleuses. Med Afr Noire. 2001; 48: 55-59.
https://goo.gl/5JbKjn
31. Kirschner CV, Yost KJ, Du H, Karshima JA, Arrowsmith SD, Wall LL. Obstetric
stula: the ECWA Evangel VVF Center surgical experience from Jos, Nigeria.
Int Urogynecol J. 2010; 21: 1525-1533. https://goo.gl/8TWaoe
32. Loposso M, Hakim L, Ndundu J, Lufuma S, Punga A, De RD. Predictors of
Recurrence and Successful Treatment Following Obstetric Fistula Surgery.
Urology. 2016; 97: 80-85 https://goo.gl/d44zD7
33. Sori DA, Azale AW, Gemeda DH. Characteristics and repair outcome of
patients with Vesicovaginal fi stula managed in Jimma University teaching
Hospital, Ethiopia. BMC Urol. 2016; 16: 41. https://goo.gl/HRkXgK
34. Ramsey K, Iliyasu Z, Idoko L. Fistula Fortnight: innovative partnership brings
mass treatment and public awareness towards ending obstetric stula. Int J
Gynaecol Obstet. 2007; 99: 130-136. https://goo.gl/UQ2QpX
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Background In Ethiopia, about 9000 fistula cases are estimated to occur every year with an incidence of 2.2/1000 women. This study was aimed to determine obstetric fistula characteristics and surgical repair outcomes among patients with fistula surgical repair. Methods A Hospital based cross sectional study design was conducted on all patients with Obstetric vesicovaginal Fistula, who were admitted to Gynecology ward, and had surgical repair from January 2011 to December 2014. Data was collected from patients’ chart, operation logbook and discharge logbook which were filled up from the entry of the patient to the hospital till her discharge. At discharge, a dye test was done to determine the outcome of repair. Results One hundred sixty eight patients with obstetric vesicovaginal fistula were repaired during the study period. The age of the women ranged from 12 to 45 years with mean of 25 (±6) years and 10.1 % were younger than 18 years. Eighty percent of patients were laboring for two or more days, 46.4 % delivered abdominally (cesarean section 24.4 %, hysterectomy for uterine rupture 22 %), and 85.7 % ended up in stillbirth. Most patients (56 %) had mid-vaginal vesicovaginal fistula. Route of repair was vaginal among 95.8 % of patients, and spinal anesthesia was applied among 70.8 % of patients. Out of 93.4 % patients who had successful closure of their fistula, 84.5 % of patients had their fistula healed and continent, 8.9 % of them developed urinary incontinence while 6.5 % of fistula repair had failed at the time of discharge. Conclusions Most fistula patients in this study are older than 18 years, referred from health centers either for cephalopelvic disproportion or obstructed labor after prolonged labor at home. In this study, Spinal anesthesia as well as vaginal route was widely employed and high success rates were achieved with surgical repair. Therefore, increasing access to comprehensive emergency obstetric and new born care is essential to minimize the delay contributing to perinatal mortality and obstetric fistula. In addition use of spinal anesthesia and vaginal route of repair is essential for the high success of repair outcome and low postoperative morbidities. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12894-016-0152-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
Article
Full-text available
Vaginal fistula (VF) is one of the most severe maternal morbidities with the immediate consequence of chronic urinary and/or fecal incontinence. The epidemiological evidence regarding risk factors for VF is dominated by facility-based studies. Our aim is to estimate the effect size of selected risk factors for VF using population-based survey data. We pooled all available Demographic and Health Surveys and Multiple Indicators Cluster Surveys carried out in sub-Saharan Africa that collected information on VF symptoms. Bayesian matched logistic regression models that accounted for the imperfect sensitivity and specificity of self-reports of VF symptoms were used for effect size estimation. Up to 27 surveys were pooled, including responses from 332,889 women. Being able to read decreased the odds of VF by 13 % (95 % Credible Intervals (CrI): 1 % to 23 %), while higher odds of VF symptoms were observed for women of short stature (<150 cm) (Odds Ratio (OR) = 1.31; 95 % CrI: 1.02-1.68), those that had experienced intimate partner sexual violence (OR = 2.13; 95 % CrI: 1.60-2.86), those that reported sexual debut before the age of 14 (OR = 1.41; 95 % CrI: 1.16-1.71), and those that reported a first birth before the age of 14 (OR = 1.39; 95 % CrI: 1.04-1.82). The effect of post-primary education, female genital mutilation, and having problems obtaining permission to seek health care were not statistically significant. Increasing literacy, delaying age at first sex/birth, and preventing sexual violence could contribute to the elimination of obstetric fistula. Concomitant improvements in access to quality sexual and reproductive healthcare are, however, required to end fistula in sub-Saharan Africa.
Article
Full-text available
To evaluate the need for a prognostic classification system for obstetric fistula (OF) with the data obtained by a voluntarily action for OF repair in a regional hospital and Niger, Africa. Obstetric fistula (OF) characteristics of 51 women with vesicovaginal fistula in a fistula campaign in Maradi Regional Hospital, Niger were evaluated. Initial basic gynecological examination, methylene blue (MBT) test and direct cystoscopy were used to describe the characteristics of the lesions. Demographic and clinical data were compared with the existing literature. In 31 (60%) cases were the sizes of the fistula greater than 4 cm. The urethra was circumferentially lost in 8 (15.7%) women. In 18 (35.3%) women the trigone was involved. Extensive fibrosis was present in 10 (19.6%) patients. Only in 11 (21.6%) patients without any obliterating scarring, neither the trigone nor urethra were damaged. Five (9.8%) patients had severe infection. Five (9.8%) had multiple lesions. Thirty-four (66.6%) had a history of at least one previous attempt for fistula repair. A significant proportion of women were divorced or abandoned from their husband, and socially isolated. A simple, reproducible and universally accepted scientific classification or staging system for OF dealing with outcomes rather than anatomic landmarks should replace the present proposed classification systems for prognostic and ethical purposes.
Article
Full-text available
Objectives: Data from 80 patients with a vesicovaginal fistula (VVF) were collected and analysed, to define the probable factors affecting the outcome of surgery. Patients and methods: In a retrospective study, the records of 80 women with a mean (SD) age of 35.8 (9) year were assessed; 40% of the VVF occurred after abdominal hysterectomy, 30% after Caesarean section, 15% after difficult vaginal delivery and 11.25% after forceps vaginal delivery. Fifteen women (18%) had a previous failed repair. The median duration of the VVF was 11.5 months. Results: Of the 80 VVF, 41 were high, 30 were low, four combined high and low and five were at the bladder neck. Nine cases had multiple openings on pan-endoscopy. An abdominal approach was used in 54 patients, vaginal in 20 and a combined approach in six. The median (SD) catheter duration was 14 (3.9) days. Ureteric stents were left in 59 patients. At a mean (SD) follow-up of 33.02 (65.7) months, the VVF was cured in 65 (81%) patients. Univariate analysis of variables possibly affecting the success of surgery showed that the duration of VVF, surgical approach, previous repair and position of the VVF were significant factors. Only previous intervention and surgical approach maintained significance in multivariate analysis. Conclusion: An abdominal approach seems to give superior results. Previous failed repair had a significant negative effect on success. An earlier repair (<6 months) is associated with higher success rates.
Article
Full-text available
Obstetric fistula although virtually eliminated in high income countries, still remains a prevalent and debilitating condition in many parts of the developing world. It occurs in areas where access to care at childbirth is limited, or of poor quality and where few hospitals offer the necessary corrective surgery. This was a prospective observational study where all women who attended Mbarara Regional Referral Hospital in western Uganda with obstetric fistula during the study period were assessed pre-operatively for social demographics, fistula characteristics, classification and outcomes after surgery. Assessment for fistula closure and stress incontinence after surgery was done using a dye test before discharge Of the 77 women who were recruited in this study, 60 (77.9%) had successful closure of their fistulae. Unsuccessful fistula closure was significantly associated with large fistula size (Odds Ratio 6 95% Confidential interval 1.46-24.63), circumferential fistulae (Odds ratio 9.33 95% Confidential interval 2.23-39.12) and moderate to severe vaginal scarring (Odds ratio 12.24 95% Confidential interval 1.52-98.30). Vaginal scarring was the only factor independently associated with unsuccessful fistula repair (Odds ratio 10 95% confidential interval 1.12-100.57). Residual stress incontinence after successful fistula closure was associated with type IIb fistulae (Odds ratio 5.56 95% Confidential interval 1.34-23.02), circumferential fistulae (Odds ratio 10.5 95% Confidential interval 1.39-79.13) and previous unsuccessful fistula repair (Odds ratio 4.8 95% Confidential interval 1.27-18.11). Independent predictors for residual stress incontinence after successful fistula closure were urethral involvement (Odds Ratio 4.024 95% Confidential interval 2.77-5.83) and previous unsuccessful fistula repair (Odds ratio 38.69 95% Confidential interval 2.13-703.88). This study demonstrated that large fistula size, circumferential fistulae and marked vaginal scarring are predictors for unsuccessful fistula repair while predictors for residual stress incontinence after successful fistula closure were urethral involvement, circumferential fistulae and previous unsuccessful fistula repair.
Article
Objectives: To determine factors contributing to recurrence and successful treatment of obstetric fistula (OF). Methods: Data were collected from OF patients in Saint Luc Hospital Kisantu (DR of Congo) between 2007 and 2013. Patients underwent surgical treatment and were evaluated after a follow-up period of 3 months. Successful treatment was defined as no or dry pads while recurrence was defined as the persisting need for wearing incontinence pads immediately after the surgery or after a period of dryness. Fistula classification was done according to Waaldijk. Univariate and multivariate analysis was performed using logistic regression, corrected for pre-operative and intra-operative OF characteristics. Results: Median age of 166 OF patients was 29.11 ± 9. 6 years (range 5-61). The majority of OF was type I (57.2%) followed by type III (20.5 %). 20.5% showed vaginal fibrosis during surgical treatment. Most common location of fistula was peri-cervical (39.8%). The global recurrence rate at 3 months was 28.3% with type IIBb (100%) as most common recurred, followed by IIAb (66.67%) and IIAa (41.18%). 71.7%, 15.7%, 12% and 0.6% patients were considered completely cured, partially cured (down-staged), persistent and up-staged, respectively. OF patients with fibrosis were 68% less likely (OR 0.32, 95%CI 0,14-0.73; p=0.0065) to be dry in comparison to those without fibrosis. Patients with urethral fistula were 73% less likely (OR 0.27, 95%CI0.11-0.63, p=0.0024) to be dry compared to other locations. Conclusions: This study showed that fibrosis and urethral location are independent risk factors for fistula recurrence or persistence following surgical fistula repair.
Article
The results of surgery in new patients presenting with a vesico-vaginal fistula are presented to relate the outcome to age, parity and aetiology of the fistula. Of the 1435 patients admitted to the hospital from January 1991 to December 1992, 1210 had had no previous attempt to repair the fistula and are included in the study. The data were collected from the patients records and a specially designed admission and treatment form. Of the 1210 cases analysed, the fistula was caused by obstructed labour in 96% (1160), and in the majority of these, labour was obstructed for more than 3 days. Half of the patients (598) were aged between 13 and 20 years on admission to hospital. Fifty-five per cent (649) developed a fistula during their first delivery and in 93% the fetal outcome was a still-birth. Of the operated 1210 cases, 1120 (92.6%) were successfully repaired. Five hundred and thirty patients were divorced by their husbands following development of the fistula. Illiteracy as common among the patients. Improvements in maternity services, development of communication networks and eradication of illiteracy are essential for the prevention of obstetric fistula. The role of reconstructive vaginal fistula surgery and the further training in this field is also emphasised.
Article
The aim of the study was to investigate obstetric fistula in terms of patient demographics, fistula characteristics and predictors of surgical outcome. Retrospective cross-sectional study. Fistula referral hospital in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Population. Five hundred and ninety-five women receiving fistula repair from November 2005 to November 2007. Review of patient records for information on patient demographics, obstetric history, clinical data for index pregnancy, fistula characteristics and surgical information. Cross-tabulations and multivariate logistic regression models were used to predict surgical outcome. Fistula closure and incontinence despite fistula closure. Results. 82.9% had developed fistula following obstructed labor, 17.1% after medical interventions of which 71.1% involved cesarean section or peripartum hysterectomy. Median age at fistula development was 23 years; 40.8% were primiparous and 43.2% were parity three or more. Women took a median of two years to seek treatment. Closure rate was 87.1%, with 15.6% remaining incontinent. Failure to close the fistula was significantly associated with previous repairs, amount of fibrosis and fistula size. Compared with primary repairs, the odds ratio of failure was almost five times greater for three or more repairs (odds ratio 4.7, 95% confidence interval 2.2-10.0). Incontinence was significantly associated with previous repairs, amount of fibrosis and fistula location. Compared with fistulas with a high location, the odds ratio of incontinence for low, circumferential fistulas was 6.3 (95% confidence interval 2.5-16.4). Fistula in Democratic Republic of Congo was found in both primiparous and multiparous women, indicating a need for increased access to obstetric care for all pregnant women. Fistulas repaired for the first time, with no fibrosis and size <2 cm, had the best surgical outcome.