ArticlePDF Available

How group singing facilitates recovery from the symptoms of postnatal depression: A comparative qualitative study

DOI:10.1186/s40359-018-0253-0
Authors:
Rosie Perkins at Royal College of Music | Imperial College London
Rosie Perkins
  • Royal College of Music | Imperial College London
Sarah Yorke at Queen Mary, University of London
Sarah Yorke
Daisy Fancourt at University College London
Daisy Fancourt
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

Background: Previous research has demonstrated that making music can enhance positive emotions as well as support positive psychological functioning. However, studies tend to be limited by lack of comparison with other psychosocial interventions. This study builds on a three-arm randomised controlled trial (RCT) that demonstrated that group singing for mothers and babies, but not group creative play, can lead to faster recovery from moderate-severe symptoms of postnatal depression than usual care. The aim was to elucidate the mechanisms of the group singing intervention in order to account for its recovery properties. Methods: Qualitative research was conducted with 54 mothers who had experienced symptoms of postnatal depression. Mothers completed a 10-week programme of either group singing or group creative play as part of the wider RCT study. Data were collected via a series of 10 semi-structured focus groups conducted at the end of each 10-week programme. These were designed to elicit subjective and constructed experiences of the singing and play interventions and were analysed inductively for emergent themes. Results: Five distinctive features of the group singing emerged: (i) providing an authentic, social and multicultural creative experience, (ii) ability to calm babies; (iii) providing immersive 'me time' for mothers; (iv) facilitating a sense of achievement and identity; (v) enhancing mother-infant bond. Conclusions: Community group singing interventions may reduce symptoms of postnatal depression through facilitating a functional emotional response rooted in the needs of new motherhood. These features are of relevance to others seeking to implement creative interventions for maternal mental health. Trial registration: NCT02526407 . Registered 18 August 2015.
Figures - available via license: CC BY
Content may be subject to copyright.
  • Access to this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
  • Learn more
Download available
Content available from BMC Psychology
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
A preview of the PDF is not available
Available via license: CC BY
Content may be subject to copyright.
... Fourth, previous research has demonstrated that in-person group singing can speed up recovery from PND 22 as well as support connections with other mothers and enhance motherebaby closeness. 23,24 While the COVID-19 pandemic catalysed research into the efficacy of online singing groups for PND, 25 evidence in this field remains in its infancy, and further studies are required. Songwriting has been previously investigated in a variety of clinical settings, including for addressing emotional or psychological challenges and facilitating the telling or sharing of stories. ...
Online songwriting reduces loneliness and postnatal depression and enhances social connectedness in women with young babies: randomised controlled trial
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2023
Objective: Loneliness is a public health challenge associated with postnatal depression (PND). This study developed and tested an online songwriting intervention, with the aim of reducing loneliness and symptoms of PND and enhancing social connectedness among women with young babies. Study design: This was a two-armed non-blinded randomised controlled trial (RCT, ISRCTN17647261). Methods: Randomisation was conducted in Excel using a 1:1 allocation, with participants (N = 89) allocated to an online 6-week songwriting intervention (Songs from Home) or to waitlist control. Inclusion criteria were women aged ≥18 years, with a baby ≤9 months old, reporting loneliness (4+ on UCLA 3-Item Loneliness Scale) and symptoms of PND (10+ on Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale [EPDS]). Loneliness (UCLA-3) was measured at baseline, after each intervention session and at 4-week follow-up. The secondary measures of PND (EPDS) and social connectedness (Social Connectedness Revised 15-item Scale [SC-15]) were measured at baseline, postintervention and at 4-week follow-up (Week 10). Factorial mixed analyses of variance with planned custom contrasts were conducted for each outcome variable comparing the intervention and control groups over time and across baseline, Weeks 1-6 and the follow-up at Week 10 for each outcome variable. Results: Compared with waitlist control, the intervention group reported significantly lower scores postintervention and at follow-up for loneliness (P < 0.001, η2P = 0.098) and PND (P < 0.001, η2P = 0.174) and significantly higher scores at follow-up for social connectedness (P < 0.001, η2P = 0.173). Conclusions: A 6-week online songwriting intervention for women with young babies can reduce loneliness and symptoms of PND and increase social connectedness.
View
... distraction from stress, worry and rumination; facilitate problem solving, foster self-esteem and positive emotions) (Cotter & Pawelski, 2022;Crone et al., 2018;Fancourt & Williamon, 2016;Hoffmann & Russ, 2012;Ivcevic & Brackett, 2015;McCrary et al., 2022), provide health promoting cognitive and intellectual stimulation (e.g. facilitating reflective thought or contemplative states, feelings of being immersed or absorbed in an artwork) (Bone & Fancourt, 2022;Camic & Chatterjee, 2013;Fancourt & Steptoe, 2018a;Wang & Blazer, 2015), build resilience and enhance coping mechanisms (Bolwerk et al., 2014;Fancourt & Steptoe, 2018b;Hutchinson et al., 2003;Perkins et al., 2018), provide opportunities for social interaction (conducive to social support and the buffering of stress) (Cohen, 2006;Cotter & Pawelski, 2022;Pearce et al., 2015Pearce et al., , 2016Vogelpoel & Jarrold, 2014;Wilson et al., 2017), reduce sedentary behaviours and promote health behaviours and interaction with the outside world (in contrast to the social withdrawal and isolation associated with depression) (Clift et al., n.d.;Clift et al., 2008;Løkken et al., 2020;Teychenne et al., 2010). Furthermore, a recent meta-analysis across 26 studies of music-interventions found that engaging with music -whether actively (music making) or receptively (music listening) -has similar effects on mental health (albeit at the low end of the range) as other established non-pharmaceutical and medical interventions (e.g. ...
Engagement with arts and culture activities in the Danish general population: Longitudinal associations with new onset or persistent depression and mental wellbeing
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
Objectives: International literature suggests that arts and culture activities may benefit mental health, however, such survey studies conducted in the Danish population are scarce. Further, studies have investigated the associated risk for incident depression, but not for persistent depression. The objective of the current prospective study was to assess associations of engagement in arts and culture activities with incident/persistent depression and also mental wellbeing among Danish adults in the general population. Design: Observational prospective study. Methods: Data stem from a Danish nationally representative panel study of 5000 adults (aged 15+ years) conducted in 2019 and 2020, which was linked to Danish register data. An exposure variable was constructed for frequency of attending concerts, theatres, museums, and cinemas. Validated scales were used to assess the presence of depression (PHQ-8) and levels of mental wellbeing (SWEMWBS). Binary logistic regression analyses were conducted to assess the risk of incident depression (among participants free of depression at baseline), as well as the risk of persistent depression (among participants with depression at baseline), while multinomial logistic regression was used to assess odds for moderate and high mental wellbeing (low as base outcome) while adjusting for baseline values. Result: In terms of incident depression, quarterly engagement in arts and culture activities (compared to never) was associated with an OR of .43 (95%CI .23-.80), while 8 times or more was associated with an OR of .53 (.29-.97). In terms of persistent depression, quarterly engagement was associated with an OR of .30 (.10-.90), while 8 times per year or more was associated with an OR of .26 (.07-.92). Similar to the patterns for incident/persistent depression, associations with moderate mental wellbeing showed higher odds for quarterly engagement and 8 times per year or more. Quarterly engagement was also associated with higher odds for high mental wellbeing but did not reach statistical significance. Conclusions: The results support the involvement of the cultural and creative sectors in health strategies. Mental health promotion initiatives as well as arts and culture sectors may encourage the general public to engage in arts and culture activities with frequencies of at least once per quarter.
View
... Of note, it has been theorised that leisure engagement (which includes creative and community activities) can support health and wellbeing through underlying social mechanisms, such as reducing loneliness and improving social networks and community cohesion (10). Examples include Men's Sheds (community-based organisations that provide meaningful spaces for older men) reducing social isolation to improve wellbeing, group creative writing fostering belonging to support mental health (11,12), and community singing groups facilitating social cohesion to reduce symptoms of post-natal depression (13). #KindnessByPost (KbP) is a national "kindness exchange" that has the potential to improve participants' wellbeing by increasing their sense of connectedness to others and reduce feelings of social isolation and loneliness. ...
KindnessbyPost: An Economic and Clinical Evaluation of a Participatory Public Mental Health Intervention
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Background #KindnessbyPost (KbP) is a “national kindness exchange”. Participants send and receive a card by post to different, unknown people containing messages of good will. Previous evidence suggests participation in KbP may improve loneliness and wellbeing. We evaluated the outcomes and associated costs of KbP and explored the feasibility of collecting health economic measures for future research. Methods We used a pre-post, observational study design. Participants in two KbP exchanges in 2021 were invited to complete an online questionnaire. It included self-reported measures of psychological wellbeing and loneliness, capability, and healthcare service use. Data were collected at three time-points: exchange start (baseline), exchange-end (2 weeks), and 3-months post-exchange. Additional cost data were obtained from the KbP programme organisers. Results Across exchanges, baseline data were obtained for 1,285 participants (from 1,142 individuals). In total, 623 (48%) of participants were followed up at exchange-end, and 414 (32%) at 3-months. 70% of participants were aged between 31 and 60 (n = 789). 94% of participants were female (1,075) and 95% of white ethnicity (1,078). Compared to baseline, loneliness and wellbeing improved at exchange end (‑0.21, 95% CI: -0.29 to -0.12; 0.68, 0.47 to 0.88 respectively) and at 3 months follow up (-0.40, -0.50 to -0.30; 1.01, 0.77 to 1.25 respectively). We observed no difference from baseline in capability at both follow up points (mean (SD) at baseline: 0.52(0.22); exchange-end: 0.53(0.22); 3-months: 0.53(0.22)). The average cost of delivering the intervention was £0.67–0.87 per participant. Conclusions We observed a small, sustained improvement to people’s wellbeing and loneliness following participation in a KbP exchange. Given the study design, causal attribution to KbP is uncertain. However, our results are consistent with previous evaluations and offer preliminary evidence that KbP may be an effective mental wellbeing intervention. Given its cheap cost (estimated at £0.67-£0.87 per participant) and highly scalable design, KbP could be an effective and cost-effective intervention for improving public mental health, which warrants definitive evaluation of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness in future. Our study also demonstrates the feasibility of collecting the wellbeing and health economic outcome measures needed for this research.
View
... As part of the same trial, qualitative research also supported these findings, showing that reduced symptoms were facilitated through fostering a functional emotional response rooted in the needs of new motherhood, including providing 'me time' for mothers and 'tools' for calming and bonding with babies. 23 Music and Motherhood and the SHAPER Study The 'Music and Motherhood' trial comparing the effects of singing and play interventions for PPD was led from 2015 to 2017 by the Centre for Performance Science (a joint research centre that sits between the Royal College of Music and Imperial College, London) with support from University College London (UCL) in the United Kingdom. 24 Following the research, the programme was developed into practice for the first time and expanded from 2017 onwards by an organisation called Breathe Arts Health Research as part of their 'Melodies for Mums' Programme. ...
Scalability of a singing-based intervention for postpartum depression in Denmark and Romania: protocol for a single-arm feasibility study
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Introduction Postpartum depression (PPD) affects around one in seven women globally, with these women in need of non-pharmaceutical treatment strategies. There is a long history of the benefits of singing for maternal mental health, and promising research exists showing the clinical effectiveness of group singing. Group singing interventions are being scaled up to support new mothers in the United Kingdom, but we do not know if such an intervention may benefit women in different cultural contexts. This protocol focuses on exploring the feasibility of implementation and perceived impact of a 10-week group singing intervention for new mothers in Romania and Denmark eliciting signs of PPD. Methods and analysis Data will be collected from up to 48 women with a score ≥10 on the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) participating in a 10-week group singing intervention in Denmark or Romania, as well as a range of project stakeholders. The singing classes will take place in person and be facilitated by professional singing leaders. Feasibility of implementation will be analysed through qualitative data (eg, focus groups, interviews) and quantitative data (eg, the Feasibility of Intervention Measure). Perceived impact will be explored via surveys that include mental health measures (EPDS, Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support, WHO Five Well-Being Index) from singing intervention participants (at weeks 1, 6, 10) and focus groups. Descriptive statistics, repeated measures analysis of variance and analysis of covariance will be used to analyse quantitative data. Framework method and thematic analysis will be used to analyse qualitative data. Ethics and dissemination The national ethics committees in Romania (IRB-PH Protocol #2021-211217-012) and Denmark (case number 1-10-72-274-21) have approved the study, as has the Ethics Review Committee at the World Health Organization (ERC.0003714). All participants will be required to provide informed consent. Results will be disseminated by reports published by the WHO Regional Office for Europe, peer-reviewed publications and at conferences.
View
Blaženka Bačlija Sušić Promjene u RPOO
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
Provođenje glazbenih aktivnosti s djecom rane i predškolske dobi u kontekstu pandemije Covid-19 novi je izazov koji je postavljen pred odgojno-obrazovne djelatnike. Dok je nastava tijekom lockdown-a bila moguća samo u virtualnom obliku uz suradnju s roditeljima/skrbnicima (Vilacheva i sur., 2021), nastavak provođenja glazbenih aktivnosti u neposrednoj odgojno-obrazovnoj praksi zahtijevalo od učitelja poštivanje određenih epidemioloških mjera. Prikazane su brojne dobrobiti glazbe na cjeloviti razvoj djeteta, među kojima se osobito ističe razvoj meta-glazbene svijesti djece, obogaćivanje meta-kognitivnih vještina i njihov transfer na druga područja. Cilj rada je prikazati relevantna i recentna istraživanja vezana uz provođenje glazbenih aktivnosti s djecom rane i predškolske dobi u vrijeme lockdown-a i pandemije Covid-19. Ističući pravo djece na glazbu u djetinjstvu, National Association for Music Education (NAfME) ukazuje da provođenje glazbenih aktivnosti s djecom treba biti imperativ bez obzira na način provođenja. Zaključeno je da unatoč nedostatcima online načina provođenja glazbenih aktivnosti takav način provođenja ima i neke prednosti. Aktivnim sudjelovanjem roditelja u glazbenim aktivnostima dolazi do razvoja njihovih glazbenih kompetencija te bolje povezanosti i suradnje s djecom. To nadalje rezultira većom učestalošću provođenja glazbenih aktivnosti u obiteljskom okruženju što ujedno doprinosi regulaciji emocija i mentalnom zdravlju kako kod djece tako i kod roditelja. Ključne riječi: djeca rane i predškolske dobi;glazbene aktivnosti;lockdown;odgojitelji i glazbeni pedagozi; pandemija Covid-19
View
Four psychological processes navigated by patients during their journey of healing and recovering from depression: a grounded theory study
Article
This study explored the psychological processes that patients navigated when healing and recovering from depression. A grounded theory approach was used. Twenty patients who had recovered from depression participated. Four categories emerged depicting the psychological processes navigated by the participants during the recovery process: (1) acceptance: acceptance of depression and agreement to treatment; (2) transformation: change of mindsets and behaviours; (3) adaptation: stress regulation and change of focus; (4) integration: progress of depressive symptoms and moving on with 'regular' life. Each phase is related to the other phases, mental health professionals could assist patients with depression achieve the integration phase.
View
View
“Unplug to recharge”: accessing respite through song in a culturally and linguistically diverse perinatal context
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Background This original, qualitative study examines the ways in which the concept of respite is expressed and experienced through the activity of singing in refugee mothers, new and expectant, in a perinatal healthcare setting in Logan, Queensland. Methods Data were collected using a multi-method approach using field notes, yarning circles, and semi-structured interviews. Reflexive Thematic Analysis (TA) yielded themes influenced also by literature on singing, wellbeing, health inequities, and the conceptual lens of respite. Results The research found that singing afforded respite for mothers across four dimensions, allowing for safe spaces, me time, new direction, and immersion. Respite and singing are identified here as strength-based and cultural solutions to wellbeing. No negative effects were reported. Conclusions The article discusses implications for socially-mediated healthcare in culturally diverse contexts. The idea of “song” enables access to a space of sanctuary wherein health inequities can be tackled in meaningful and decolonising ways.
View
Twórczość i zdrowie - perspektywa psychologiczna
Book
Full-text available
  • Aug 2022
Książka zawiera przegląd badań na temat znaczenia twórczości dla kształtowania, utrzymywania oraz powracania do zdrowia oraz dobrostanu. Ukazuje również model wyjaśniający mechanizm „prozdrowotnego” oddziaływania twórczości, na podstawie dotychczasowych ustaleń teoretycznych oraz najnowszych wyników badań empirycznych. Dla uzyskania pełnego obrazu tego zjawiska uwzględnione zostały zarówno procesy pozytywnie oddziałujące na zdrowie, jak i czynniki ryzyka towarzyszące twórczości, które mogą być dla niego pewnym zagrożeniem. Ukazane zostały także najważniejsze kierunki rozwoju i wyzwania w zakresie badań naukowych i praktyki w obszarze związków między twórczością a funkcjonowaniem zdrowotnym.
View
Integrated parent–child music classes for preschoolers with and without autism: Parent expectations and experiences
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2022
Integrated recreational programs designed to support neurodiverse children and their families are important vehicles for community participation. In this mixed‐methods study, we investigated the mechanisms by which parent–child music classes for autistic and neurotypical children can support community participation. Parents of autistic (n = 33) and typically developing (TD; n = 28) preschoolers were interviewed about their expectations for and experiences of participating in a 12‐week psychoeducational parent–child music program. Parents completed ratings of momentary affect and social connection, and researchers coded children's behavioral engagement during classes at multiple time points throughout the program. Primary motivations for enrolling in an integrated music class included children's interest in music and opportunities for child socialization. Parent‐focused reasons were less frequently endorsed as primary motivations for participation. Yet, momentary ratings indicated that music classes supported parents’ affect regulation and social connection with other parents at the level of individual classes and across the program. These in‐class experiences were echoed by interviews following program completion, which additionally highlighted the use of new parenting strategies through the musical activities. Since parental emotional experiences of activities, supportive community relationships, and parenting confidence are all linked with increased community participation, integrated music classes may support participation and satisfaction with community experiences. In this mixed‐methods study, we investigated the mechanisms by which parent‐child music classes for autistic and neurotypical children can support community participation.
View
The effects of mother–infant singing on emotional closeness, affect, anxiety, and stress hormones
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2018
Among mammals who invest in the production of a relatively small number of offspring, bonding is a critical strategy for survival. Mother–infant bonding among humans is not only linked with the infant’s survival but also with a range of protective psychological, biological, and behavioral responses in both mothers and infants in the post-birth period and across the life span. Anthropological theories suggest that one behavior that may have evolved with the aim of enhancing mother–infant bonding is infant-directed singing. However, to date, despite mother–infant singing being practiced across cultures, there remains little quantitative demonstration of any effects on mothers or their perceived closeness to their infants. This within-subjects study, comparing the effects of mother–infant singing with other mother–infant interactions among 43 mothers and their infants, shows that singing is associated with greater increases in maternal perceptions of emotional closeness in comparison to social interactions. Mother–infant singing is also associated with greater increases in positive affect and greater decreases in negative affect as well as greater decreases in both psychological and biological markers of anxiety. This supports previous findings about the effects of singing on closeness and social bonding in other populations. Furthermore, associations between changes in closeness and both affect and anxiety support previous research suggesting associations between closeness, bonding, and wider mental health.
View
The Impact of Perinatal Depression on Children’s Social-Emotional Development: A Longitudinal Study
Article
Full-text available
Objectives This longitudinal population study aimed to investigate if maternal depression at different time points during the perinatal period impacts children’s social-emotional development at 2 years of age. Methods Participants were women (n = 1235) who gave birth at Akershus University Hospital in Norway. Maternal depressive symptoms were assessed by using the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale at pregnancy week 32 and at 8 weeks and 2 years postpartum, whereas children’s social-emotional development at the age of 2 years was assessed by using the Ages and Stages Questionnaire: Social-Emotional. Bi- and multivariate logistic regression analyses were conducted to examine the linkage between maternal perinatal depression and children’s early social-emotional development. Results Multivariate analyses showed that social-emotional problems in the child 2 years after birth were strongly associated with maternal depression at pregnancy week 32 (adjusted odds ratio (aOR) 3.4; 95 % CI 1.4–8.0), depression at 8 weeks postpartum (aOR 3.8; 95 % CI 1.7–8.6), and with depression at both time points (aOR 3.7; 95 % CI 1.5–10.1). Conclusion Findings indicate pre- and postnatal depression each bears an independent, adverse impact on children’s social-emotional development.
View
Does Singing Facilitate Social Bonding?
Article
  • Oct 2014
Psychobiological effects of amateur choral singing were studied in a naturalistic controlled within-subjects trial. A mixed group of novice and experienced singers (N = 21) filled out brief ad hoc questionnaires of psychological wellbeing and gave samples of saliva for measuring levels of salivary oxytocin, cortisol, and dehydroepiandrosteron (DHEA) at the beginning of 2 rehearsal sessions and 30 minutes later. The singing condition included warm-up vocal exercises and repertoire pieces. In the chatting condition, dyads of participants talked to each other about recent positive life experiences. Within-subjects, repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) on self-reported and physiological measures revealed significant Time X Condition interactions for psychological wellbeing and oxytocin. Comparisons of mean scores showed patterns of changes favouring singing over chatting. There were no significant interactions for cortisol, DHEA as well as for the cortisol-DHEA-ratio. These results suggest that singing enhances individual psychological wellbeing as well as induces a socio-biological bonding response.
View
Creative interventions for symptoms of postnatal depression: A process evaluation of implementation
Article
  • Jan 2018
Background This article is a process evaluation of a three-arm randomised controlled trial (RCT) comparing the effects of creative interventions on symptoms of postnatal depression (PND) in new mothers. Methods Analyses of quantitative evaluation data from 91 participants and qualitative interviews and focus groups with 80 participants and 3 members of staff. Results Key assumptions of the RCT, including how the delivery of the intervention was achieved and what the intervention involved, are explored. Data suggest that the intervention was delivered as planned with a high level of fidelity. Key uncertainties surrounding the project, in particular unanticipated challenges that had to be overcome during the RCT, are also discussed and simple recommendations for improvement are made. Conclusion This process evaluation aims to illuminate the outcome and mechanisms data from the RCT and enable organisations or individuals to ascertain the feasibility of establishing their own creative classes for women with symptoms of PND.
View
Effect of singing interventions on symptoms of postnatal depression: Three-arm randomised controlled trial
Article
  • Jan 2018
This study assessed whether a novel psychosocial intervention could reduce symptoms of postnatal depression (PND) in the first 40 weeks post-birth. Analyses were carried out of 134 mothers with symptoms of PND randomised into 10 weeks of group singing workshops or group play workshops for them and their babies, or usual care (trial registration: NCT02526407). Overall, among all mothers with symptoms of PND, there was a non-significant faster improvement in symptoms in the singing group ( F4,262 = 1.66, P = 0.16, η² = 0.012). When isolating mothers with moderate–severe symptoms of PND, this result became significant, with a faster improvement in symptoms in the singing group ( F3.9,139.8 = 2.74, P = 0.033, η² = 0.028). Declaration of interest None.
View
View
View
Women's experiences of parenting toddlers following postnatal depression: Experiences of parenting following PND
Article
Objective The aim of this study was to gain an in‐depth understanding of the experience of women parenting toddlers and babies older than 6 months after taking part in a therapeutic support group for postnatal depression (PND). Method Thematic analysis was conducted following individual semi‐structured interviews conducted in 2014 with eight women whose children were aged between 6.5 months and 2.5 years. Results Three overarching themes and six subthemes reflecting how PND can affect parenting experiences beyond the immediate postpartum period were identified: (1) parental self‐perception; both positive: strength gained and unbroken bonds, and negative: high expectations, comparison to others and concerns about judgement; (2) parenting behaviour including difficulties regaining and managing control, and anger attributed to PND directed at siblings; and, (3) mixed feelings around partner support. Conclusion PND can impact parenting of children into toddlerhood, including parenting of an older sibling even when PND was not experienced at their birth. The importance of support in enhancing parenting skills following PND was highlighted.
View
View
View