ArticlePDF Available

Situating Agency, Embodied Practices and Norm Implementation in Peacekeeping Training

Authors:

Abstract

Applying a Bourdieusian feminist practice theory approach to the study of norm implementation, this article introduces a fourth level of analysis, the embodied subject who is expected to be governed by peacekeeping norms. It does so by examining the training experiences of Rwandan tactical-level female military peacekeepers deployed in mix-gender contingents to UNAMID. It is argued that the pre-deployment training space is a field of norm contestation and negotiation, wherein gendered peacekeeper subject positions and gendered peacekeeping labouring practices are constructed and performed. The research findings suggest that by partially complying with the UN's gender mainstreaming norms, the Rwanda Defence Force strengthens the military's gender protection norms and establishes the sexual division of labour of the mission area. Trained to perform a scripted Rwandan female subject position, some women find they are not adequately prepared for the more challenging situations they find themselves in when working in multi-dimensional peacekeeping operations and devise alternative, informal training practices to better equip themselves prior to deployment. The case study draws on 65 depth-interviews with Rwandan military personnel, trainers and external consultants and non-participatory observations of field exercises.
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=finp20
International Peacekeeping
ISSN: 1353-3312 (Print) 1743-906X (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/finp20
Situating Agency, Embodied Practices and Norm
Implementation in Peacekeeping Training
Georgina Holmes
To cite this article: Georgina Holmes (2018): Situating Agency, Embodied Practices
and Norm Implementation in Peacekeeping Training, International Peacekeeping, DOI:
10.1080/13533312.2018.1503934
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/13533312.2018.1503934
Published online: 02 Aug 2018.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 2
View Crossmark data
Situating Agency, Embodied Practices and Norm
Implementation in Peacekeeping Training
Georgina Holmes
Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Reading, Reading, UK
ABSTRACT
Applying a Bourdieusian feminist practice theory approach to the study of norm
implementation, this article introduces a fourth level of analysis, the embodied
subject who is expected to be governed by peacekeeping norms. It does so by
examining the training experiences of Rwandan tactical-level female military
peacekeepers deployed in mix-gender contingents to UNAMID. It is argued
that the pre-deployment training space is a eld of norm contestation and
negotiation, wherein gendered peacekeeper subject positions and gendered
peacekeeping labouring practices are constructed and performed. The
research ndings suggest that by partially complying with the UNs gender
mainstreaming norms, the Rwanda Defence Force strengthens the militarys
gender protection norms and establishes the sexual division of labour of the
mission area. Trained to perform a scripted Rwandan female subject position,
some women nd they are not adequately prepared for the more challenging
situations they nd themselves in when working in multi-dimensional
peacekeeping operations and devise alternative, informal training practices to
better equip themselves prior to deployment. The case study draws on 65
depth-interviews with Rwandan military personnel, trainers and external
consultants and non-participatory observations of eld exercises.
KEYWORDS Peacekeeping; gender; pre-deployment training; norms; international practice theory
Introduction
How do we conceptualize norm implementation in peacekeeping? How do we
account for the ways in which the implementation of institutionalized peace-
keeping norms
1
can lead to variation of practice on the ground? These are the
overarching research questions posed by scholars that seek to problematize
processes that have largely been overlooked in the norm diusion/circulation
literature.
2
Norm implementation scholars start from the premise that
implementation is a distinct processrunning in parallel to international
© 2018 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Georgina Holmes g.holmes@reading.ac.uk
1
Karlsrud denes peacekeeping norms as norms guiding peacekeeping(Karlsrud, Norm Change in Inter-
national Relations, 8).
2
See Björkdahl, Promoting Norms through Peacekeeping; Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World
Politics; Auteserre, 2014; Paddon, 2014; Paddon, this section; Karlsrud, 2015, Norm Change in Inter-
national Relations; Maertens, this section; Marion Laurence, this section.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING
https://doi.org/10.1080/13533312.2018.1503934
norm institutionalization processes.
3
Betts and Orchard describe norm
implementation as the steps required to introducean international norms
precepts into formal legal and policy mechanisms within the state or organ-
ization in order to routinize compliance, wherein compliance is conceptual-
ized as an act
4
The conceptual distinction facilitates the study of variance in
norm implementation and its eects, even when the act of norm compliance
has occurred at the domestic level within the state and its security institutions
that engage in peacekeeping. This article contributes to recent theorizing of
norm implementation by introducing a fourth level of analysis, the embodied
subject who is expected to be governed by peacekeeping norms. It does so by
examining how UN gender mainstreaming norms are translated into practice
in pre-deployment training programmes for tactical-level peacekeepers in
Rwanda.
Examining norm implementation processes necessitates a dierent set of
research questions to those posed by norm circulation theorists. The focus
shifts away from how norms spreadto who operationalizes norms and
under what conditions?Constructivists dene norms as the collective expec-
tations for the proper behaviour of actors with a given identity in global poli-
tics
5
that serve the purpose of guiding behaviour by providing motivations
for action.
6
Constructivist scholars often distinguish between the level of
the international, regional and the domestic (the state) to structure their
norm diusion/circulation models, and have recognized the inuence episte-
mic communities inside the state have in determining how norms are inter-
nalized at the domestic level.
7
They have advanced understandings of how
international norms are translated, negotiated and contested to challenge
the early norm cascade models, which allocated primacy of power and
agency to western actors.
8
However, these theorists have been criticized for
failing to locate actors as central to diusion and implementation, instead
ascribing agency to the norm itself.
9
They have also been criticized for intro-
ducing an ideational biasinto theorizing norm dynamics which positions
material interests as secondary in determining what motivates actors to
perform, or to change their behaviour.
10
In contrast, norm implementation
theorists acknowledge that ideational, material and institutional factors
3
Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World Politics,4.
4
Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World Politics,2.
5
Katzenstein, The Culture of National Security,5.
6
Björkdahl, Norms in International Relations,15.
7
Risse and Sikkink, The Socialization of International Human Rights Norms into Domestic Practices; Acharya,
How Ideas Spread;Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders; Cardenas, Norm Collision; Betts and
Orchard, Implementation & World Politics.
8
Acharya, How Ideas Spread;Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders; Cardenas, Norm Collision; Bloo-
meld, Norm Antipreneurs and Theorising Resistance to Normative Change.
9
Bucher, Acting Abstractions.
10
See Cardenas, Norm Collision; Bigo, Pierre Bourdieu and International Relations; Adler and Pouliot,
International Practices.
2G. HOLMES
determine how norms are implemented.
11
They infer that acting persons
12
are agentive and embodied subjects who shape norm implementation pro-
cesses. How agentive subjects engage in translating institutionalized norms
into routinized practices therefore demands greater attention. It requires a
conceptual framework that bridges the ideational-material divide, and calls
for a rethinking of what is meant by internalizationand socialization’–
two metaphors
13
commonly used by norm diusion/circulation scholars to
denote the moment when a norm is accepted by a state or state institutions.
Peacekeeping training is recognized as a site wherein the UN institutiona-
lized norms that are intended to govern and discipline peacekeeper subjects
are diused and implemented.
14
Pre-deployment training is conceptualized
frequently in the literature as a mechanism or channel through which
(liberal peace) norms, values and beliefs, as well as technical skills are trans-
ferred to peacekeepers, rather than a eld of social practice wherein norms are
translated and/or negotiated, consciously or unconsciously, by embodied sub-
jects engaged in the training process. Suspending the regional and local socio-
political and economic contexts which shape peacekeeping training and
peacekeeping training spaces, this narrow conceptualization reinforces the
assumption that training trainers, standardizing training materials and
sharing good practice (with the intention of strengthening the ow of knowl-
edge from the core to the periphery) will by default enhance the capabilities of
peacekeepers, establish norm compliance and improve operational eective-
ness. Two underlying concepts in the peacekeeping training literature
norm diusion and peacekeeper socialization support the constructivist
emphasis on the ability of norms to change the behaviourof peacekeeper
subjects, and in doing so reconrm the primacy of the norms agency. As a
result, the agency of the peacekeeper subjects who are participants in the
training process is eclipsed.
15
In this article, I develop a feminist reading of French Sociologist Pierre
Bourdieus theory of social practice to examine how gender mainstreaming
norms embedded in UN DPKO/DFS policy and training discourse are oper-
ationalized by actors during a TCC military-led pre-deployment training pro-
gramme. UN gender mainstreaming norms observe that gender equality
should be systematically integrated in all systems and structures, into all pol-
icies, processes and proceduresof peacekeeping, including the cultures of
institutions engaged in peacekeeping, and into the ways of seeing and
11
Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World Politics, 13.
12
Bucher, Acting Abstractions,748.
13
Bucher, Acting Abstractions,748.
14
Jowell, The Unintended Consequences of Foreign Military Assistance in Africa; Anne Flaspöler, 2014;
Wilén, Examining the Links between Security Sector Reform and Peacekeeping Troop Contribution
in Post-conict States.
15
Bucher, Acting Abstractions,748.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 3
doingpeacekeeping and peacebuilding.
16
Biological sexand culturally con-
structed concepts of gendershould be separated to ensure that all individ-
uals, regardless of their sex, sexuality and gender, are empowered, treated
fairly and equally and provided equal opportunities in peacekeeping
workforces.
17
I use practices as my core unit of analysis
18
to demonstrate how peace-
keepers are trained to perform gendered peacekeeping labouring practices
prior to deployment. Bourdieus theory of social practice and his concepts
eld, habitus and capitals help identify relations of power between inter-
national, regional and domestic actors and structures at play in norm con-
testation. Though Bourdieu has been criticized for overemphasizing
structure and oversimplifying relations between the dominated and the dom-
inating in his theorizing of power,
19
feminist readings of Bourdieu located in
political studies and sociology open his theory up to the possibility of observ-
ing the agency of subordinated actors, who may work with or against the
structures, discourses and practices that govern them. Specically, feminist
theorizing of women as both commodities and capital-accumulating sub-
jects
20
within elds of power, helps us to examine how individual peace-
keepers engage in norm contestation during the implementation process.
Focusing on the training experiences of Rwandan tactical-level female mili-
tary peacekeepers deployed in mix-gender contingents to UNAMID, the
article sets out to answer three interrelated questions: (1) How are DPKO/
DFS-embedded gender mainstreaming norms translated into routinized prac-
tices during pre-deployment training? (2) What kinds of subject positions are
female military personnel trained to enact? (3) How do female peacekeeper
trainees engage in norm implementation during the pre-deployment training
process? It is argued that the pre-deployment training space is a eld of norm
contestation and negotiation, wherein gendered peacekeeper subject positions
are constructed and reproduced through the embodied performances of insti-
tutional practices. The research ndings suggest that a scriptedRwandan
female peacekeeper subject position is constructed which is based on how
RDF senior ocers perceive womens use-value within a given mission.
Trained to perform this scripted subject position, some Rwandan female mili-
tary peacekeepers nd they are not adequately prepared for challenging
working environments and devise alternative, informal training practices to
better equip themselves prior to deployment.
16
Joaquim and Schneiker, ““Changing Discourses, Changing Practices?,530.
17
Zalewski, “‘I Dont Even Know What Gender Is,12; Karim and Beardsley, Equal Opportunity
Peacekeeping.
18
Adler and Pouliot, International Practices,5.
19
Lovell, Thinking Feminism with and against Bourdieu; Skeggs, Introducing Pierre Bourdieus Analysis
of Class, Gender and Sexuality; Moi, Appropriating Bourdieu; Bueger and Gadinger, International Prac-
tice Theory.
20
Lovell, Thinking Feminism with and Against Bourdieu.
4G. HOLMES
Rwanda is an important case study for examining how UN gender main-
streaming norms are operationalized in pre-deployment training pro-
grammes. The small African state is among the ten largest contributors of
peacekeepers globally and is deploying female military peacekeepers to
complex peacekeeping missions including the UN/African Union Mission
in Darfur (UNAMID) and the UN Mission in the Republic of South Sudan
(UNMISS). Rwanda has deployed troops since 2006 and over the past ve
years has contributed some 6,000 troops annually, of which 250 (4 percent)
are women.
21
Supporting international gender equality legislation, Rwanda
has begun mainstreaming gender its national security policies and architec-
ture and is recruiting more female military personnel, as outlined in its
UNSCR 1325 National Action Plan (2009).
22
The article is divided into four parts. The rst part outlines how norms,
norm dynamics and agency are conceptualized in the peacekeeping training
literature. In the second, the article makes the case that the pre-deployment
training space as a eld of norm negotiation and contestation wherein gen-
dered peacekeeper subject positions are constructed and performed through
embodied practices. The article then examines how UN gender mainstream-
ing norms embedded in DPKO/DFS policies and training guidance construct
womens peacekeeping labouring practices, and illustrates how these norms
are operationalized during pre-deployment training. After analysing how a
diversity of female military personnel engage in norm implementation
during pre-deployment training, the article concludes by reecting on the
explanatory power that a Bourdieusian feminist praxiography contributes to
the study of norm implementation processes. In conducting this analysis, I
oer a signicant contribution towards understanding how peacekeeping is
gendered, and a conceptual framework to help link agency to norm
implementation. The case study draws on 65 depth-interviews with
Rwandan military personnel, trainers and external consultants, and non-par-
ticipatory observations of eld exercises.
A feminist praxiography
The research strategy employed is based on the methodological approaches
located in International Practice theory (IPT) and feminist theory. A Bour-
dieusian feminist praxiography the study of gendered logics of embodied
practices
23
enables a dierent kind of analysis of norm implementation to
constructivist approaches. As Bigo argues, constructivism exists only in
relation to the empirical study of practices.
24
Social relations and institutional
21
Statistics provided by RDF Gender Desk, 9 July 2015.
22
Holmes, Gendering the Rwanda Defence Force.
23
Bueger and Gardinger, International Practice Theory, 80.
24
Bigo, Pierre Bourdieu and International Relations,234.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 5
processes are not just imbued in ideas, language and discourse, they are depos-
ited in bodies and things, and practices emergeat their conuence.
25
Practices
are intersubjectively created competentand incompetent performances
26
and socially meaningful patterns of actionwhich are embodied, performed
and enacted by actors (subjects) who occupy social positions within a given
hierarchically structured eld of power.
27
These social positions, or subject
positions, are determined by the elds habitus the naturalized socio-political
environment. Naturalized subject positions are organized through insti-
tutional structures(the military) and intersectional categorisations such as
class, race, gender, religion and dis/ability. Dominant actors may use subject
positions to regulate subordinated actors within the eld.
28
Drawing on
Butlers theory of performativity, feminists contend that gender is a practice,
and embodied practices are gendered.
29
Wilcox observes that Butlers concep-
tualization of gender as a repeated stylization of the bodyand a set of repeated
actsaligns with the practice theorists’‘emphasis on habituated practices of the
body.
30
Subject positions constitute socially accepted, routinized, embodied
practices performed by the subject within an institution.
31
Subjects are embo-
died, and emplaced in a specic material circumstance (the eld and habitus).
However, unlike the Subject, which is fragmented and can never be fully
known, subject positions are observable. Feminist practice theory examines
how gendered, embodied practices are performed by human subjects
(actors) within the eld of international relations and how the eld, and the
embodied practices within this eld, are experienced by these subjects.
International Practice theorists seek to record and constructpractices
(praxi), rather than culture (ethno), and establish a bottom-up analysis
32
of
patterns of actionwithin the eld of practice. Practice theorists argue that
norms are important, but they should not become isolated objects of
research. Instead, they are part of a larger practical repertoire of knowledge,
or background knowledgeacquired by actors in the eld.
33
A feminist theor-
etical perspective suggests that this background knowledge is informed by col-
lective and personal emotions of actors, as well as intersubjectively produced
historical practices, norms and discourses.
To ascertain how UN institutionalized norms were implemented in the
Rwanda case study, a three-fold approach
34
was established to reconstruct
25
Pouliot, 2013, 45.
26
Wilcox, 2016, 801.
27
Adler and Pouliot, International Practices,6.
28
Skeggs, Introducing Pierre Bourdieus Analysis of Class, Gender and Sexuality,24.
29
See Lovell, Thinking Feminism with and Against Bourdieu; Wilcox, 2016.
30
Wilcox, 2016, 795.
31
Skeggs, Formations of Class & Gender, 12.
32
Karlsrud, Norm Change in International Relations,7.
33
Bueger and Gadinger, International Practice Theory, 83.
34
Pouliot, 2013, 48; Bueger and Gadinger, International Practice Theory, 83.
6G. HOLMES
(a) training and gender mainstreaming practices (b) female peacekeeper
subject positions and (c) positions and struggles between actors in the pre-
deployment training eld of practice. A mixed-methods approach was used,
combining participant observation, depth-interviews and content analysis.
Participant observation of eld exercises facilitated the mapping of training
and gender mainstreaming practices in realtime.
35
Semi-structured inter-
views with actors who operate within the pre-deployment training eld
were used to discover womens training experiences; and collect training prac-
tices and background knowledge discussed with the interviewees.
36
These
were coded using Nvivo software and relations between codes and thematic
patterns were established. Content analysis was used to read
37
practices
located in DPKO/DFS and Rwanda Defence Force (RDF) policies and train-
ing materials.
Fieldwork was undertaken at Gako Military Training Academy in Musanze
and the Ministry of Defence (MINEDEF) in Kigali, Rwanda between May
2014 and December 2015. Sixty-ve semi-structured interviews were con-
ducted with male and female Rwandan military personnel, trainers and exter-
nal consultants (see table) in Kinyarwanda, English and French by the author,
two female research assistants and two translators.
Research participant Quantity
Female military personnel
Member of all-female unit in battalion currently being trained 9
Trained, awaiting deployment 15
Returned from deployment 22
RDF Trainers
Male 6
Female 1
External consultants/trainers
Male 2
Female 1
Senior stain RDF/Ministry of Defence
Male 8
Female 1
Total 65
The analysis presented in this article is based on practices observed (ident-
ied) and recorded by the author during participant observations, formal and
informal research encounters in the pre-deployment training eld, and train-
ing materials provided by the RDF. Due to restrictions on freedom of speech
in post-conict Rwanda
38
and the closed institutional structure of the RDF,
self-censorship was evident during interviews. Research participants would
not discuss whether ethnicity aected their training experiences and this
35
Bueger and Gadinger, International Practice Theory, 83.
36
Halperin and Heath, Political Research, 258.
37
Bueger and Gadinger, International Practice Theory, 85.
38
Holmes, Women and War in Rwanda,3640.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 7
variable is excluded from the study. Research participants were selected by
RDF stain MINEDEFs Peace Support Operations division and by the
Oce of the Director of Gako Military Training Academy from a pool of
peacekeepers who may have been screened and briefed in advance to
ensure regularity of performance during research encounters. Several research
participants appeared to perform to an RDF institutional (public) transcript
or provided what were perceived by the author to be socially acceptable
answers for an outsider researcher.
39
Others diverged from formal narratives
and spoke at a more personal and critical level. This discrepancy helped ident-
ify the embodied practices female military personnel were expected to
perform during training vis-à-vis the practices the women chose to
perform, and facilitated reconstruction of the scriptedRwandan female
peacekeeper subject position. Triangulation identied a range of practices
and the repetition and routinization of practices,
40
as did conducting inter-
views over four eld research trips, each lasting 2-3 weeks. To dierentiate
between types of background knowledge and practices acquired during train-
ing, and afterwards during deployment, a comparative analysis of interview
transcripts with female peacekeepers that had not deployed and those that
had was conducted. Interviews were translated into English and transcribed
by three assistants in Rwanda and the UK, although small variations in trans-
lation occurred. Research participants consented to the interviews and are
referred to by a number, rank and role to ensure anonymity.
Norms and agency in peacekeeping training
DPKO/DFS outline three training phrases for peacekeepers: pre-deployment
training; early deployment (induction) training and ongoing training during
deployment.
41
Under General Assembly resolution A/RES/49/37 (1995),
TCCS are responsible for training uniformed personnel and since 2009 are
expected to use core pre-deployment training materials (CPTMs) produced
by DPKO/DFS and the Integrated Training Service (ITS). Theorizing how
UN institutionalized peacekeeping norms are implemented in peacekeeping
training is an emergent area of research. In the existing literature, critical
peacekeeping scholars borrow constructivist denitions of norms and norm
dynamics to explain how the politics of global governance play out in peace-
keeping training.
First generation scholars writing in the 1990s contended that peacekeepers
deployed to multi-dimensional peacekeeping operations require softer
conict resolution skills than the conventional combatant soldier.
39
Halperin and Heath, Political Research, 259.
40
Pouliot, 2013.
41
United Nations, United Nations Peacekeeping Resource Hub.
8G. HOLMES
Transforming the traditional warrior peacekeeper into the cosmopolitan
peacekeeper
42
was the focus, as was improving peacekeeper interactions
with host communities to deliver protection of civilian (POC) tasks and
support mission-specic peacebuilding eorts.
43
Peacekeeping training is
conceptualized as a mechanism or channel through which to transfer UN
institutionalized human rights and protection norms in order to re-socialise
military personnel as UN peacekeepers; or to transfer technical skills to the
peacekeeper. Reecting constructionist denitions, norms change behaviour
and [re-]constitutepeacekeeper subjects.
44
They are institutionalized at the
international level, before cascading to the domestic level once the tipping
point is reached, as described in Finnemore and Sikkinks norm life-cycle
model.
45
Norms have socialization properties and are transferred through
military education and training. Betts Featherston draws on Bourdieus
theory of social practice to demonstrate how training produces eective
peacekeepers.
46
A soldiers behaviours and patterns of action are product
[s] of habitusand social positions learned from within [the] military
47
and may not be appropriate when applied in the peacekeeping mission
area, which is a dierent eld and habitus.
48
Norms therefore set the stan-
dards for appropriate behaviour and action.
49
Where constructivist norm
diusion theories employ the metaphors internalizationand socialization
to explain how norms are accepted at the domestic level, Betts Featherston
introduces a fourth level of analysis, claiming that norms transferred via
peacekeeping training change a peacekeepers mindset. However, he infers
that the TCC military institution (a singular actor) is a norm-taker or
norm-resister, rather than norm-contester of the UNs institutionalized
norms, conceptualized as stable and unambiguous.
Second generation scholars apply postcolonial theorizing of power
relations to foreground the agency of global south TCCs.
50
New peace-
keepers, for example from west and east Africa, require relatively heavy
external assistance and training to deploy troops to peace operations.
51
Military elites (the new peacekeepers) prot politically and economically
42
Curran, More than Fighting for Peace?, 119.
43
Betts Featherston, 1998; Duy, Cultural Issues in Contemporary Peacekeeping.
44
Björkdahl, Norms in International Relations,21.
45
Finnemore and Sikkink, 1998.
46
Betts Featherston, 1998, 167.
47
Betts Featherston, 1998, 167. Kats.
48
Betts Featherston, 1998, 162.
49
Katzenstein, The Culture of National Security,5.
50
Flaspöler, Adding Peacekeepers to the Debates of Critical Liberal Peacebuilding; Jowell, The Unin-
tended Consequences of Foreign Military Assistance in Africa; Wilén, Examining the Links between
Security Sector Reform and Peacekeeping Troop Contribution in Post-conict States.
51
Wilén, Examining the Links between Security Sector Reform and Peacekeeping Troop Contribution in
Post-conict States,4.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 9
from engaging in peacekeeping.
52
Jowell contends that African militaries are
adept at adopting and subvertingUN institutionalized norms, suggesting
that military elites are norm-adapters as well as norm-takers and/or norm-
resisters. Flaspöler questions whether African peacekeepers can be socialized
as international peacekeepers, as Betts Featherston presumes, and suggests
that TCCs deploy hybridizedpeacekeeper subjects.
53
The literature aligns
with Acharyas norm circulation model, who evidences the agency and
power of domestic (local) actors by demonstrating how these actors build
congruence
54
between institutionalized and domestic norms during
implementation.
In parallel to this research, gender scholars are examining how UN institu-
tionalized gender mainstreaming norms are implemented in peacekeeping
training since UN Security Council Resolution 1325 (Women, Peace and
Security) was adopted in 2000. For these scholars, UN gender mainstreaming
norms are adaptive and adaptable
55
constitutive normsthat create new
actors, interests or categories of actionand give meaning to action.
56
UN
gender mainstreaming norms can be broadened or narrowed once operatio-
nalized. When broadened, the norms set policy formation agendas and trans-
form existing organizational structures and practices. When narrowed, they
may be submitted to other goals than that of gender equality,t into existing
policy frames
57
and reproduce existing gendered institutional practices.
58
These scholars acknowledge that training curricular are already gendered
before gendered perspectives are integrated. Most empirical studies examine
how male uniformed personnel are re-socialized as peacekeepers and focus
on preventing male peacekeepers from committing Sexual Exploitation and
Abuse (SEA) by enforcing norm compliance through behavioural change.
59
The studies draw on constructivist norm cascade models to show (1) why
UN institutionalized gender mainstreaming norms should be implemented
through peacekeeping training; (2) the implications for peacekeeping cultures
if TCC military institutions resist norm change. As in Betts Featherstones
analysis, men are products of their domestic military institutions habitus;
are taught to behave as hypermasculine warriors and should be resocialised
52
Beswick, The Risks of African Military Capacity Building; Wilén, Examining the Links between Security
Sector Reform and Peacekeeping Troop Contribution in Post-conict States,4.
53
Flaspöler, Adding Peacekeepers to the Debates of Critical Liberal Peacebuilding.
54
Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World Politics,7.
55
Joachim and Schneiker, 2012, 529; Krook and True, Rethinking the Life Cycles of International Norms.
56
Borkdahl, 2002, 16.
57
Joaquim and Schneiker, Changing Discourses, Changing Practices?,530.
58
Carreiras, Gender and the Military.
59
See Whitworth, Men, Militarism, and UN Peacekeeping; Mackay, Mainstreaming Gender in United
Nations Peacekeeping Training; Lyytikäinen, Gender Training for Peacekeepers; Laplonge, The
Absence of Masculinity in Gender Training for UN Peacekeepers; Carson, Pre-deployment Gender
Training and the Lack Thereof for Australian Peacekeepers.
10 G. HOLMES
as gender sensitive, morally virtuous, goodpeacekeepers.
60
Eective gender
training enlightensmen to the failings of their domestic military habitus.
61
How female peacekeepers are trained to work in mixed-gender contingents
is underexplored, in part due to the prevailing assumption that women natu-
rally possess the softer skills required of the cosmopolitan peacekeeper.
62
Hei-
neken argues that the embodiment of hegemonic masculinitiesand the
hyper-masculine peacekeeping environmentundermine South African
womens ability to function as equals in peacekeeping.
63
Pre-deployment
training provides an opportunity for military elites to resist UN gender main-
streaming norms and reinforce domestic gender protection norms.
64
Women
are the vulnerable sex to be protected by men against other(ed) predatory
men, and are a gendered security risk
65
that weakens a deployed battalions
capacity. Women receive the same training as men, but are considered an
anomaly in peacekeeping because they cannot embody the peacekeeper mas-
culinity expected of military personnel, a conclusion shared by Sion in her
analysis of Dutch pre-deployment training.
66
These structural limitations
prevent women from enhancing operational eectiveness.
Several shared understandings about norm implementation processes may
be deduced from this literature review. First, norm implementation constitu-
tes a dierent process to norm institutionalization, although implementation
and diusion are used interchangeably. Norms are primarily complied with or
rejected, but seldom negotiated. Second, agency and power is assigned to mili-
tary institutions/military elites (the norm-takers, norm-resisters, and norm-
adaptors), but not to subordinate peacekeeper subjects. In Betts Featherstons
analysis, as in the gendered analyses, tactical-level peacekeepers who are
expected to be governed by UN institutionalized norms, or who are under-
stood to be governed by the TCC military institutional norms and practices,
are passive receivers and conveyors of norms, whose mindsets can be manipu-
lated and changed. Linguistically, the metaphors internalization,socializa-
tion, and assimulation
67
suggest that norms have agency,
68
can penetrate
the peacekeeper subject or persuade him/her to behave or think dierently.
If norms are correctly implemented by the TCC military, automatic norm
60
See Higate and Henry, Insecure Spaces; Whitworth, Men, Militarism, and UN Peacekeeping; Duncanson,
Forces for Good?; Bevan and MacKenzie, “‘CowboyPolicing versus the Softer Stu.
61
Laplonge, The Absence of Masculinity in Gender Training for UN Peacekeepers; Carson, Pre-deploy-
ment GenderTraining and the Lack Thereof for Australian Peacekeepers.
62
Carreiras, Gender and the Military; Holmes, Gender, Peacekeeping and the Commonwealth; Karim and
Beardsley, Equal Opportunity Peacekeeping.
63
Heineken, 2015, 241.
64
Karim and Beardsley, Equal Opportunity Peacekeeping.
65
Heineken, 2015, 247.
66
Sion, Peacekeeping and the Gender Regime.
67
Heineken, 2015, 244.
68
Bucher, Acting Abstractions.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 11
adoptionand acceptance
69
(internalization) will occur and change the subor-
dinate peacekeepers subjectivity. This neglects the underlying, everyday
agential processes
70
that determine how subordinate, lower-ranking male
and female military personnel participate in norm implementation.
Third, practices matter in norm implementation. Scholars recognize that a
relationship exists between norms and practices, and infer the centrality of
practices in implementing norms, but there is considerable variety in how
practices are understood and employed in the literature. Carson suggests
that training is a practice.
71
Others foreground institutional practices (rules
and processes) and peacekeeping practices.
72
Gender scholars observe that
gender is a practice, and highlight how naturalized gendered power relations
are reproduced during peacekeeping training.
73
However, institutional (train-
ing) practices are created and controlled by military elites.
Fourth, material factors determining how and why UN institutionalized
norms are implemented is of secondary importance to ideational factors,
even though scholars acknowledge that military elites are self-interested
and seek to accrue, in Bourdieusean terms, social and symbolic capital
which can be converted into material capital. The conviction that ideas
change peacekeeper subjectivities eclipses the lived reality that peacekeepers
are classed, raced and gendered labouring bodies and material resources
(commodities) supplied by the TCC military to the UN. Gender scholars
have long vocalized concern that the instrumentalist argument, which empha-
sises the unique ways women enhance peacekeeping by introducing gender
sensitivity into military tasks and into interactions with host country commu-
nities, has overshadowed the rights-based argument for including women in
peacekeeping workforces.
74
They challenge assumptions that the operational
value of women is dependent on their sex-dierence; caution against counting
women and essentialising women as peaceful and non-threatening.
75
Pruitt
observes that [w]omen are being marketed, and womens abilities are
framed to convince current decision-makers of the utility of their abilities
69
Bucher, Acting Abstractions,749.
70
Bucher, Acting abstractions,749.
71
Carson, Pre-deployment GenderTraining and the Lack Thereof for Australian Peacekeepers.
72
Flaspöler, 2015; Jowell, The Unintended Consequences of Foreign Military Assistance in Africa; Wilén,
Examining the Links between Security Sector Reform and Peacekeeping Troop Contribution in Post-
conict States.
73
MacKay, Mainstreaming Gender in United Nations Peacekeeping Training; Sion, Peacekeeping and the
Gender Regime; Laplonge, 2016; Carson, Pre-deployment GenderTraining and the Lack Thereof for
Australian Peacekeepers.
74
See Bridges and Horsfall, 2008; Jennings, Womens Participation in UN Peacekeeping Operations; Kron-
sell, Gender, Sex and the Postnational Defense; Simic, Increasing Womens Presence in Peacekeeping
Operations; Gizelis and Olsson, Gender, Peace and Security; Karim and Beardsley, Equal Opportunity
Peacekeeping.
75
See Sion, Peacekeeping and the Gender Regime; Heathcote and Otto, Rethinking Peacekeeping, Gender
Equality and Collective Security; Simic, Increasing Womens Presence in Peacekeeping Operations;
Beardsley and Karim, Female Peacekeepers and Gender Balancing; Pruitt, The Women in Blue
Helmets; Karim and Beardsley, Equal Opportunity Peacekeeping.
12 G. HOLMES
and knowledge, or to legitimiseinstitutional practices.
76
Crawford and Mac-
donald suggest that gender mainstreaming is a UN-led demand-driven
response to past mission failures, rather than a supply-driven response of
TCCs.
77
The appropriation of Bourdieus theory of social practice to explain how
domestic norms are supplanted and gendered peacekeeper subjects trans-
formed overlooks how gendered peacekeeping labouring practices are con-
structed during the training encounter. Peacekeepers are not just
commodities, they are also capital accumulating subjects
78
who bring their
own ideational and material interests to peacekeeping missions,
79
as well as
to peacekeeping training. Therefore, the act of norm compliance, non-compli-
ance or partial compliance, which occurs during the norm implementation
process, carries transactional value both for the TCC and the individual
peacekeeper.
Taken together, the ideational bias in the existing peacekeeping training lit-
erature foregrounds structure over socially embedded agency and relations of
power
80
in the material training space, and hinders analysis of how a diversity
of raced, classed, sexed and gendered peacekeeper subjects engage in norm
implementation.
Conceptualizing pre-deployment training
The pre-deployment training space is a eld of practice and a site of norm
contestation, negotiation and implementation. Actors (subjects) that engage
in pre-deployment training are located within a eld and both shape and
are shaped by the elds gendered logic of practice (habitus)
81
The eld is a
hybrid space in which TCC military actors and external actors from training
institutes, other militaries and UN subsidiary bodies (UN Women, DPKO/
DFS) engage in curriculum design and delivery and contribute to operationa-
lizing UN norms. Norms are contested, adapted, rejected or accepted by the
TCC military during frictional encounterswith external agents, as they nego-
tiate training content and practice. Informing norm localization processes,
frictional encounters can be productive and may not necessarily lead to the
outright rejection of a norm.
82
Yet, since dominant control over the operatio-
nalization of norms lies with the TCC military, norm subsidiarity,dened by
Acharya as a process whereby local actors create rules [and practices] to
preserve their autonomy from dominance [and] abuse by more powerful
76
Pruitt, The Women in Blue Helmets, 78.
77
Crawford and Macdonald, Establishing a Marketplace of Women in Peacekeeping.
78
Lovell, Thinking feminism with and against Bourdieu,20.
79
Higate and Henry, 2008.
80
Bucher, Acting Abstractions,754.
81
Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production, 30.
82
Björkdahl and Höglund, Precarious Peace,290.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 13
central actors,
83
may occur concurrently. For instance, TCC senior military
leaders may reject UN gender mainstreaming norms if they perceive that
the military institutions established gender regime is threatened. Thus, UN
institutionalized norms are adapted by TCC-military senior leaders and trai-
ners (internal norm brokers) and external consultants (external norm
brokers) to make them workable and practicalin more than one local
context the TCC military and the peacekeeping operation.
84
Whether a
UN institutionalized norm is accepted and complied with, or adapted and
partially complied with, depends on whether TCC military elites conceive
they will prot symbolically and materially from its implementation.
Constructing gendered peacekeeper subject positions
The pre-deployment training space is a militarized eld of power, as well as an
educational eld of practice wherein subject positions are constructed and
negotiated during transfers of knowledge between educators and learners.
Through military education and training, male and female personnel are
assigned (pre-)constructed subject positions, which they must learn to
perform in accordance with the logic of appropriateness within the elds in
which they will operate.
85
Informed by historical, gendered military practices
and patterns of action, the training curriculum establishes hierarchical
relations between dierent forms of knowledgeand generates a network of
subject positions in relation to these hierarchies.
86
For the TCC military, pre-deployment training does not necessarily aim to
transform the mindset (consciousness)of subordinate peacekeepers if raising
awareness of the military habitus has the potential to disrupt the militarys
existing power relations. Instead, the aim is to ensure that deployed peace-
keeper subjects perform peacekeeping practices to the standardized level of
competence required either by the UN or by the TCC. Accepted norms,
then, do not need to be internalized by the peacekeeper subject, but they do
need to be implemented and incorporatedinto the routinized, embodied
practices that peacekeeper subjects perform.
Subject positions are constructed according to institutionally and socially
recognized (often dialectical) categorisations and sub-categorisations, such
as man/woman,masculine/feminine,heterosexual/homosexual,
black/white. They are performed repetitively overtime according to the
military institutions accepted norms, practices and discourses,
87
leading to
the creation of what I call scriptedpeacekeeper subject positions. How
83
Acharya, Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders.
84
Acharya, Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders,1.
85
Skeggs, Formations of Class & Gender,2.
86
Skeggs, Formations of Class & Gender, 61.
87
Skeggs, Formations of Class & Gender, 12.
14 G. HOLMES
gendered scripted peacekeeper subject positions are constructed is determined
by a peacekeepers perceived use-value. Here, I borrow from the Marxist idea
that labouring bodies carry value within a given labour market
88
and are
bearers of capital value
89
for powerful elites. As gender scholars contend,
the instrumentalist argument for womens integration into peacekeeping
assumes that militarized womens bodies, and the proscribed feminine
subject positions military women are expected to perform when undertaking
gendered labouring practices, have particular functions in peacekeeping oper-
ations and acquire value because they are considered to improve operational
eectiveness. Peacekeepers are resources (assets) and commodities which
TCCs rent out to the UN in exchange for material and symbolic capital
(such as international prestige and military experience). If scripted peace-
keeper subject positions are performed competently, the TCC may accrue
more symbolic and material capital. Therefore, gendered labouring practices
peacekeepers are expected to perform are taught and rehearsed during pre-
deployment training. Routinized embodied practices performed during train-
ing encourage men and women to accept their place within the sexual division
of labour of the pre-deployment training space and within the hierarchical
structures of both the TCC military and the deployed battalion.
90
Once operationalized, an accepted norm may no longer be an ideal model
of behaviour (performance), since a plurality of relational embodied prac-
tices
91
inuence how the norm is implemented during the pedagogic encoun-
ter. This plurality of practices create norms-in-practiceenacted by trainees
during pre-deployment training and once deployed. As Krook and True
contend, constitutive norms are norms in process.
92
Implementing norms
and putting them into practice (incorporating
93
them into embodied prac-
tices) cannot completely stabilize a norm, since how practices are performed
is dependent on the subject, who may perform them competently or incom-
petently. Whether embodied practices are perceived to be competently per-
formed will vary according to the dierent perspectives of the actors within
the eld. An external consultant may judge that a peacekeeper trainer or trai-
neesperformance is incompetent, while a senior military stamember may
presume otherwise, or vice-versa. Bourdieus theory of practice and his sug-
gestion that the habitus of the pre-deployment training eld changes accord-
ing to the actors operating within it reminds us of the temporality of norm
implementation processes. Norms-in-practice, then, are continually nego-
tiated by the subjects engaged in norm implementation. Yet, the repetition
88
Spivak, The Scattered Speculations on the Question of Value,3.
89
Lovell, Thinking Feminism with and against Bourdieu,24.
90
Skeggs, Formations of Class & Gender, 48.
91
Bigo, Pierre Bourdieu and International Relations,233.
92
Krook and True, Rethinking the Life Cycles of International Norms,110.
93
de Sardan, Real Governance and Practical Norms in Sub-Saharan Africa,1.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 15
and routinization of embodied practices stabilizes implemented norms, albeit
precariously.
DPKO/DFS embedded gender mainstreaming norms
The use-value of tactical-level female military peacekeepers is described in
DPKO/DFSsGender Policy for UN Peacekeeping(2010) and the Guide-
lines for Integrating a Gender Perspective into the work of the UN Military
in Peacekeeping Operations(2010). DPKO/DFS adopt an integrationist
(and instrumentalist) approach to gender mainstreaming by emphasising
increasing the proportion of female military personnel to deliver specic
tasks, and incorporating a gender perspective into established workstreams.
This includes applying a gender perspective to tactical-level PoC and law
enforcement activities; disarmament, reintegration and security sector
reform (DDR/SSR) programmes and CivilMilitary (CIMIC) operations
aligned to peacebuilding mission objectives. Female military peacekeepers
are valued for educating and empowering local women and engaging with
perceived vulnerable groups when delivering capacity building projects
(currently Quick Impact projects).
DPKO/DFS also interpret UN gender mainstreaming norms as transfor-
mative and capable of changing the habitus of peacekeeping workforces
and modes of operation (practices) within military, police and civilian com-
ponents and across multidimensional teams, so that female personnel are
equal partners in decision-making at all levels. Within the DPKO/DFS
policy discourse, there exists a contradiction in how gender should be prac-
ticed. Womens labouring peacekeeping practices are dependent on a close
alignment of biological sex and gender, and women are expected to
perform as female peacekeepersto deliver specic mission objectives. Yet,
DPKO/DFS also support the conscious separation of biological sex and
gender to facilitate fair and equal treatment of all sta.
To support implementation of these embedded gender mainstreaming
norms, the UN gender directive stipulates that all pre-deployment training
modules should cover the role and rationale of work for gender equality
and the empowerment of women in peacekeeping contexts.
94
However, the
2009 CPTMs foreground an integrationist approach to gender mainstream-
ing, incorporating gender perspectives into existing mission objectives.
CPTM Unit 3 (Women, Peace and Security), and CPTM Unit 2 (cultural
diversity) only briey conceptualize gender equality in peacekeeping work-
forces.
95
Good practice examples demonstrating how gender mainstreaming
can facilitate gender equality within peacekeeping contingents are absent.
94
United Nations, Core Predeployment Training Materials,16.
95
United Nations, Core Predeployment Training Materials,2, 47.
16 G. HOLMES
This content was extended in the 2017 CPTMS, as Lucile Maertens observes
of the CPTM on environmental issues.
96
Module Two (Women, Peace and
Security) aords greater attention to gendered power structures within peace-
keeping, although how TCCs use these training materials is yet to be
determined.
Pre-deployment training in Rwanda
The proceeding case study illustrates how DPKO/DFS embedded gender
mainstreaming norms become implemented in the Rwandan pre-deployment
training programme for mixed-gender battalions. Overall, the RDF accepts
DPKO/DFS integrationist gender mainstreaming norms and rejects transfor-
mative gender mainstreaming norms.
Norm contestation and negotiation
The RDF trained three battalions concurrently at Gako Military Academy.
Battalions comprised 800 personnel, with one all-female unit of 1020 per-
sonnel.
97
During the three-month pre-deployment training programme, bat-
talions spent two weeks in the classroom and six engaged in eld exercises.
There was ongoing, ad hoc input from external consultants, primarily the
US-funded agency ACOTA and the United States Institute of Peace (USIP)
who provided technical advice on setting up practical exercises or occasional
training for ocers on communication, negotiation and conict resolution.
At the time of the eld research, ACOTA consultants (who were US ex-
military men) did not design or deliver battalion classroom-based training,
but did not regard integrating gender into practical exercises a priority,
98
suggesting there was no conict of interest between ACOTA consultants
and the RDF.
Since RDF trainers delivered classroom-based modules, DPKO/DFS
embedded gender mainstreaming norms were operationalized by internal
norm brokers rather than external norm brokers (consultants). RDF trainers
did not use the CPTM curriculum, nor mainstream gender issues across the
training programme, as recommended by DPKO/DFS. They selected
elements of the older SGMTs,
99
which presented a narrower, integrationist
reading of gender mainstreaming. These older training materials were used
in conjunction with modules developed by the African Union and the RDF
itself. Thus, the training materials informed a hybridized curriculum, where
RDF values and ethics were promoted in the context of teaching military
96
Lucile Maertens, this section.
97
Senior ocer 1, interview with the author, 28 May 2014.
98
Brigadier General, interview with the author, 10 June 2014.
99
I thank Anne Flaspöler for this observation.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 17
personnel UN/AU modes of operation, as well as the RDFs own modes of
operation practiced within Rwandan base camps. According to the male trai-
ners, the hybridized curriculum and relatable domestic examples helped trai-
nees understand theoretical concepts such as gender based violence(GBV).
While this hybridized approach can be seen as productive, the limited content
selection facilitated partial compliance of UN gender mainstreaming norms.
The RDF only incorporated a gender dimension when teaching modules
on preventing SEA, peacekeeper discipline and performance; cultural diver-
sity and PoC. All modules, including the gender module, were taught by
RDF ocers, rather than in-house gender experts. In interviews, these
ocers indicated that the UNs more transformative gender agenda was irre-
levant for preparing peacekeepers for deployment. Modules were taught
didactically as 30-45 minute-long lectures by trainers using powerpoint
slides to all 800 military personnel in the battalion mess. As an RDF
Gender Desk stamember explained, emphasis was placed on ensuring dis-
cipline among male troops.
100
Training objectives specied that the Rwandan
male peacekeeper should understand that gender is socially constructed, know
the concepts SEA and GBVand understand the dierent ways conict aects
men, women and children.
101
Rejection of the UNs transformative gender mainstreaming norms also
took eect through norm subsidiarity and in the subtle operationalization
of the RDFs formal (codied and visible) and informal (invisible) gender
rules that established the gendered logic of practice of Rwandan base camps
within UNAMID and the pre-deployment training space. In Sudan, the
RDFs gender protection norms policing the sexual division of labour repro-
duced stereotypes that portrayed women as incapable of providing protec-
tion.
102
Tactical-level female military peacekeepers who only received
TCC-led pre-deployment training worked solely within the Rwandan military
base camp unless they were told to visit IDP camps. As in Heinecken and
Sions analyses, women were excluded from performing certain security prac-
tices and were conned to safe spacesand safe tasks.
103
They did not join
male Rwandan military peacekeepers on short-duration day patrols unless
it was known in advance that female military peacekeepers were required,
104
and they were not allowed to participate in night patrols or long-duration
patrols. None of the female peacekeepers interviewed engaged in DDR/SSR
programmes, which were not UNAMID priorities. Four women engaged in
intelligence gathering, but most who worked with local populations outside
100
Female major, interview with the author, 4 June 2014.
101
Female peacekeeper 6, interview with author, 9 June 2015.
102
Pruitt, The Women in Blue Helmets, 74.
103
Karim and Beardsley, Equal Opportunity Peacekeeping, 37.
104
Female peacekeeper 18, interview with the author, 13 June 2015; Female peacekeeper 16, interview
with the author, 10 June 2010.
18 G. HOLMES
the base camp supported empowerment and education projects and discussed
human rights, HIV/AIDs awareness and reproductive health with Sudanese
women.
In the 40km² training compound, a simulated mission area incorporating
three base camps was constructed. The gender order of the UNAMID-
Rwandan base camp was reproduced in the simulated mission area: rst, in
the ordering of the peacekeeping training space itself, which was designed
by the RDF, and second in the ordering of training practices in accordance
with mission objectives. According to a former Director of Gako Military
Training Academy, the simulated base camps were organized identically to
Rwandas base camps in the conict zone to ensure RDF military personnel
experienced the closest they could to mission life.
105
RDF policy and practice
dictated that the all-female units tent and bathroom facilities were located
next to the ocersaccommodation.
106
These embodied practices reveal the
subtle ways in which a network of gendered and classed subject positions is
created. Although sexual abuse and harassment should be prevented, the
spatial zoning of the simulated base camp positioned all Rwandan women
as potential victims requiring protection, but also agents who needed to be
vigilant of personal security threats; educated, middle-class Rwandan male
senior ocers were positioned as their protectors, while lower-ranking, (pre-
dominantly) working class Rwandan male soldiers were potential aggressors
and thus subordinate to male senior ocers.
Constructing the Rwandan female peacekeeper subject position
As in most militaries, male and female personnel train together to form a
cohesive team. Though the Rwandan male peacekeeper subject was fore-
grounded in the classroom, women were expected to perform gendered
labouring practices during eld exercises. Task-orientated
107
eld exercises,
designed to test peacekeepers on knowledge learnt in the classroom
108
and
rehearse peacekeeping labouring practices, addressed gender in narrow
terms. During a half-day participant observation, the battalion was presented
with two scenarios. In the rst, warring factions had set up roadblocks, were
conducting ambushes and hindering peacekeepers from reaching IDP camps
and isolated, dehydrated Sudanese women. In the second, the battalion
encountered IDP demonstrations near the Rwandan base camp. Nine out
of the 10 women in the battalion executed basic military tasks within the
base camp and one woman, a captain, was an intelligence analyst. In the
rst scenario, female military personnel performed as the scripted Rwandan
105
Brig. Gen., interview with the author, 29 May 2014.
106
Female peacekeeper 23, interview with the author, 5 June 2014.
107
RDF trainer 2, interview with the author, 5 June 2014.
108
RDF trainer 1, interview with the author, 11 December 2014.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 19
female peacekeeper and tasks were assigned according to their gender.
Process-orientated role-plays included teaching local women and girls
about gender equality; searching a poor womans house, rebuilding houses
and giving IDPs water. In Rwanda, homosexuality is not illegal, though a stra-
tegic silence around LGBT rights in the military and broader society exists.
The scripted Rwandan female peacekeeper subject position RDF women
rehearsed was implicitly heterosexual, while role-plays focused on responding
to women and girl survivors of rape, rather than men and boys. Due to their
low rank, the women did not make decisions about managing convoys and
ambushes. Peacekeepers were not required to negotiate with female comba-
tants during the patrol exercise because, according to senior RDF sta,it
was rare to nd women in ambushes in Darfur.
109
All the women interviewed self-identied as gender-neutral peacekeepers.
Yet, two-thirds spoke of performing a female peacekeepersubject position.
One major remarked,
If I deploy as a female peacekeeper, Im playing two roles because there are
some roles I can play that a men cant play. I interact with female victims,
but [a male peacekeeper] will not be able to gather information [from local
women], so Im both a peacekeeper and a female peacekeeper.
110
Asked whether she was a peacekeeper or a female peacekeeper, a corporal (a
radio operator) responded:
Both. Sometimes I act as a peacekeeper and other times as a female peace-
keeper. For example, like those [issues] of gender. Sometimes we go and
meet women and they ask us to give them things like bread, water, milk
etc. If they see you are a woman, they come to you instead of men. So in
that situation, I act as a female peacekeeper, although I am a peacekeeper
in all other categories.
111
As in the eld exercises, the constructed gendered peacekeeping labouring
practices rehearsed aligned to the instrumentalist approach to integrating
women. One private commented:
The female peacekeeper must console women who have just been raped and
teach gender to the population. She must have empathy to console and to
teach gender in Darfur. I will teach them about the gender factor and teach
them [women] how to protect themselves. And Ill teach them to love the
military.
112
Women interviewed understood being disciplinedas performing as liber-
ated and empowered, modern Rwandan women and Rwanda ambassadors:
109
Senior RDF sta8, interview with author, 7 June 2014.
110
Female peacekeeper 7, interview with the author, 9 June 2015.
111
Female peacekeeper 8, interview with the author, 6 June 2015.
112
Female peacekeeper 27, interview with the author, 6 June 2014.
20 G. HOLMES
The rst value of a peacekeeper is discipline because we follow the guidelines
and rules we are given by our leaders We are there representing our
country so if you fail to perform well, it seems like your country is not dis-
ciplining you eectively, and its [regarded as] a shame [on you and your
country].
113
This construction borrowed from the socially recognizable dialectic category
of male/female peacekeeper, and a second, raced and class-based dialectic
category distinguishing developed, empowered Rwandan women from
underdeveloped, disempowered Sudanese women-victims. Here, the UN
constructed use-value of female military peacekeepers aligned with the
RPF governments constructed use-value of military women as peace-
builders in post-conict Rwanda.
114
Building congruence between domestic
and DPKO/DFS embedded gender mainstreaming norms, the RDF-con-
structed scripted Rwandan female peacekeeper performs as educator (diffu-
ser) of Rwandan norms and practices notably related to conict resolution
and post-conict development. As one trainee remarked, she will take Suda-
nese women out of violence and teach them the benets of unity and
reconciliation, and teach them how to get out of ethnic conict.
115
Women were also required to perform as the bearer of traditional
Rwandan culture. All women interviewed wore traditional dress during cul-
tural exchanges with other military contingents or local populations. One
female peacekeeper returnee managed the dance troupe and organized
rehearsals.
116
Fewer men engaged in these gendered embodied practices.
Within UNAMID, Rwandan female military personnel were expected to
perform two subject positions: the gender-neutral peacekeeper engaged in
tactical-level military tasks within the base-camp; and the disciplined
Rwandan female peacekeeper who promotes (RPF-sanctioned) traditional
Rwandan culture and modern values.
The acceptance of the UNs integrationist gender mainstreaming norms
appeared to more closely align to the RDFs informal gender norms;
helped to stabilize the RDFs gender protection norms, and could be
more easily translated into norms-in-practicein the two local contexts
within which tactical-level military personnel were required to operate:
the UNAMID mission area, and the TCC military. Partially complying
with DPKO/DFS embedded gender mainstreaming norms, the RDF
increased the commodity-value of their female peacekeepers to accrue
more symbolic capital once they deployed, without disrupting the militarys
gender order.
113
Female peacekeeper 29, interview with the author, 7 June 2014.
114
Holmes, Gendering the Rwanda Defence Force; Holmes, Gender and the Military in Post-Genocide
Rwanda.
115
Female peacekeeper 27.
116
Female peacekeeper 11, interview with the author, 10 June 2015.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 21
How female peacekeepers engage in norm implementation
Female military personnel are not just commodities, but capital accumulating
subjects that bring their own ideational and material interests to peacekeeping
training. All the women interviewed regarded pre-deployment training as a
strategic investment. Yet, when asked whether they felt the pre-deployment
training equipped them to perform peacekeeping labouring practices compe-
tently, the women responded in diverse ways, depending on their position
within the military; how much capital they had access to, and the background
knowledge they brought to the training.
Many women notably lower-ranking and younger privates felt
condent they were equipped with the skills required to deploy to
UNAMID, although they often spoke about tactical-level military tasks,
rather than the soft skills required for PoC tasks. It was assumed that the back-
ground knowledge women acquired growing up in post-conict Rwanda
would enable them to engage eectively with traumatized people in the
mission, and many spoke passionately about assisting Sudanese women. A
2nd lieutenant explained,
The RDF, we have experience. For example, the genocide in our country we
saw many things. This made us able to help other countries overcome their war
problems.
117
Women preparing to deploy also presumed they could communicate easily
with Sudanese women, despite their different cultures, religions (all research
participants self-identied as Christian), education, age, ability or personal
circumstance:
Private For example, she has been raped. She cant talk to a man but she
feels free to talk to me.
Interviewer Have you been specically trained on how to talk to a woman
that has experienced conict-related sexual violence?
Private I have not received that training, but as a person I can imagine
what it must be like to speak to her What is happening in
Darfur is almost the same as what happened in Rwanda
because they kill each other and [the women and children] are
left as widows and orphans. So I really pity them because I
know what they are going through and I feel I should counsel
them.
118
For these women, implementing RDF-accepted integrationist gender
mainstreaming norms may have carried enough transactional value and
they did not request changes to existing training practices. Many performed
the scripted Rwanda female peacekeeper subject position in interviews,
117
Female peacekeeper 41, interview with the author, 18 November 2015.
118
Female peacekeeper 29.
22 G. HOLMES
although it was dicult to ascertain whether performing the scripted subject
position was deemed safer than speaking o-script, given their subordinate
positions in the military.
Senior, degree-educated ocers in their late twenties and thirties who had
not deployed demonstrated greater awareness of transformative approaches
to gender mainstreaming perhaps background knowledge acquired
through their military/political elite networks. These middle-class women,
some of whom spoke passionately about the importance of gender equality,
felt the training on gender issues was too short, lacked depth about how
conict aected men and women
119
and focused on good behaviour (norm
compliance), rather than on equal opportunity peacekeeping. One female
captain requested training on how to better implement a gender perspective
into the conduct of operations, in intelligence analysis, and wanted to learn
how gender could be integrated into decision-making. She believed more
complicated scenarios taught in smaller classes would teach peacekeepers
how to handle problems and execute decisions well.
120
These women used their educational and social capital to develop alterna-
tive (informal) training practices to source knowledge about the mission and
peacekeeping labouring practices they would be required to perform. Practices
included talking to previously deployed colleagues; reading training manuals;
undertaking self-directed learning and conducting internet searches. The
captain and leader of the all-female unit from the battalion trained in 2014
who had a BA degree in international politics, in discussion with her subor-
dinates, organized nightly tutorials which took place in their tent, providing
the women space to reect on the days learning. This initiative added to
the captains burden of labour suggesting that some female peacekeepers
second-shift, or additional, voluntary work,
121
commenced prior to
deployment.
Despite these educational investment strategies, which evidence the mili-
tary womens creative agency, the capacity of female peacekeepers to
implement transformative DPKO/DFS embedded gender mainstreaming
norms within the mission area was constrained by the capital value
122
they represented for the RDF. This can be seen in the responses of women
who had returned from UNAMID and their perspectives diered depending
on their deployment. Low-ranking women who worked only in their pro-
fessional military trades within the base camp or mission headquarters con-
sidered the pre-deployment training adequate. Women who worked outside
the Rwandan base camp in multicultural teams observed gender inequalities
within the peacekeeping workforce and talked more about the need for
119
Female peacekeeper 29.
120
Female peacekeeper 23.
121
Pruitt, The Women in Blue Helmets, 12.
122
Lovell, Thinking Feminism with and against Bourdieu,22.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 23
transformative gender mainstreaming initiatives. However, among these
women, pre-deployment training was a site where only integrationist
gender mainstreaming norms should be implemented, and women focused
on discussing how training could better prepare them for mission-specic
tasks. Women who worked directly with the local population in challenging
contexts considered the training inadequate. These women, who engaged in
complex protection duties or worked in isolated teams outside the
Rwandan base camp, rejected the idea that soft skills such as communication,
negotiation and empathy were feminine traits. Dealing with local people who
were traumatized was the primary issue discussed. A degree educated major
who had deployed to UNAMID as a liaison ocer, felt that training peace-
keepers to follow a short protocol for assisting rape survivors did not
prepare them for prolonged engagements with survivors over several hours.
Referring to the pre-deployment training schedule, she remarked:
All these things were helpful. But when I encountered gender based violence it
was not easy When I was on the ground and reached the [IDP] camp, you
nd this person who was raped for two or three hours and the people
[around her] dont want to communicate, they dont care about what hap-
pened. So you take care of her. You dont go alone, you go with military obser-
vers and there must be a female there, the police they must be female. So you
get this person, you put her in touch with the NGOs, you take her to hospital,
but you need to spend three or four hours with her.
123
One private required techniques on having conversations with local
people in order to nd out where the problem is and how they really
live.
124
The Liaison Ocer wanted information on the psychological
impactCRSV has on survivors.
125
In parallel with requests for deeper
context on gender issues and soft skills, several women wanted more
mission-specic scenarios and interactive role-plays for PoC activities. A
2nd lieutenant was critical of the limitations of translating classroom-
taught gender theories (which she believed the women did not always under-
stand) during eld exercises:
We study [gender issues] theoretically, but in the mission area, when we start
putting [theory] into practice there are challenges. In trainings, my mate acts as
a refugee and I act as Im going to help her. But that is like theatre you cant
grasp [the reality] well.
126
Several returned peacekeepers wanted to out-perform the scripted Rwandan
female peacekeeper subject position, believing as one lieutenant explained,
if women perform their tasks well they will give us more challenging and
123
Female peacekeeper 2, interview with the author, 3 June 2014.
124
Female peacekeeper 11.
125
Female peacekeeper 2.
126
Female peacekeeper 4, interview with the author, 11 December 2015.
24 G. HOLMES
good tasks, like the ones of men.
127
Like the junior women who had not
deployed, these women saw implementing RDF-accepted integrationist
gender mainstreaming norms as a strategic investment.
Conclusion
Applying a Bourdieusian feminist praxiography, this article has introduced a
fourth level of analysis to norm implementation, the embodied subject who is
expected to be governed by peacekeeping norms. A feminist reading of Bour-
dieus theory of social practice, with its insistence that subordinated men and
women are capital-bearing objects and capital accumulating subjects,
enhances the study of norm implementation by demonstrating how these sub-
jects are both compelled and choose to engage in norm implementation. In
doing so, the conceptual framework helps to bridge the ideational-material
divide found in the norm diusion/circulation literature. Indeed, Bourdieu
regarded rationalist and constructivist paradigms as incomplete pictures
and sought a synthesis that would not reduce the logic of practice to either
instrumental rationality or structural determinism, nor reify abstract con-
ceptssuch as norms.
128
Bourdieus inference of the eld and habitusmutability depending on the
actors operating within them, reminds us of the temporality of norm
implementation processes. Norms are continually negotiated by the embodied
subjects engaged in norm implementation. Yet, as Betts and Orchard observe,
there has to be some kind of settling process in order for norms to exist.
129
In
Rwanda, settling occurred via the routinization and repetition of embodied
gendered peacekeeping labouring practices performed by peacekeeper trai-
ners and trainees across successive training programmes.
The article also enhances understanding of how through variance in norm
implementation, TCCs contribute to sustaining or transforming the gender
regimes of peacekeeping operations. As has been observed in other peace-
keeping contexts,
130
the RDF partially complied with UN gender mainstream-
ing norms by foregrounding an integrationist approach, rather than a
combined integrationist/transformative approach. This partial compliance
allowed male military elites to strengthen the RDFs institutional gender pro-
tection norms. Explaining how the gendered labouring practices female
peacekeepers are expected to perform in the mission are constructed prior
to their deployment, the present study lls an important gap in the existing
literature. The study demonstrates how militarized gender protection
127
Female peacekeeper 16.
128
Pouliot and Mérand, Bourdieus Concepts,31.
129
Betts and Orchard, Implementation & World Politics, 14.
130
Carreiras, Gender and the Military; Pruitt, The Women in Blue Helmets; Karim and Beardsley, Equal Oppor-
tunity Peacekeeping.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 25
norms are reproduced and stabilized, and how women become relegated to
perceived safe spaces and safe tasks in peacekeeping operations. Female
peacekeepers, like male peacekeepers, require more training and support in
handling dicult situations involving traumatized populations. Senior mili-
tary women with more educational and social capital devised alternative
(informal) training practices to better equip themselves for deployment
and, in one recorded instance, their unit. Yet, women were constrained by
the training elds hierarchical structure and this contributed to their margin-
alization in UNAMID.
In many ways Rwanda presents a unique case, given the authoritarian
governments instrumental use of gender mainstreaming to reconstitute the
post-conict state.
131
However, the case study illustrates how norm
implementation processes in peacekeeping training can take eect. Given
that Bourdieu argues that no one eld is the same, the conceptual framework
developed in this article can facilitate comparative analyses to investigate how
agency is linked to norm implementation processes in dierent peacekeeping
contexts.
Acknowledgements
An earlier version of this paper was presented at the European Workshops in Inter-
national Studies, Norms and Practices of Peace Operations: Evolution and Contesta-
tion, Cardi, 7-9 June 2017. The author would like to thank Dominik Zaum, Corinne
Heaven, Andreas Behnke, Sarah Von Billerbeck, Katia Coleman, Nina Wilén, John
Karlsrud, Kseniya Oksamytna, Lucile Maertens, Emily Paddon Rhoads and Marion
Laurence for their comments on earlier drafts of this article. The author would also
like to thank the British Academy/Leverhulme (Small Research Grant: Ref
SG131357) and the Leverhulme Trust (ECF-2015-418) for funding this research;
Ilaria Buscaglia, RDF personnel who assisted in coordinating the eld research, and
the interviewees who agreed to take part in the project.
Disclosure statement
No potential conict of interest was reported by the author.
Funding
The author would also like to thank the British Academy/Leverhulme (Small Research
Grant: Ref SG131357) and the Leverhulme Trust (ECF-2015-418) for funding this
research; Ilaria Buscaglia, RDF personnel who assisted in coordinating the eld
research, and the interviewees who agreed to take part in the project.
131
Burnet, Genocide Lives within US; Holmes, Gender and the Military in Post-Genocide Rwanda.
26 G. HOLMES
Notes on Contributor
Dr Georgina Holmes is a Leverhulme Early Career Research Fellow in the Department
of Politics and International Relations, University of Reading. Her research explores
the development of gender mainstreaming as a policy frame in global governance and
peacekeeping, norm implementation dynamics, gender and Security Sector Reform,
and the training and deployment of male and female uniformed peacekeepers. She
is the author of Women and War in Rwanda: Genocide, Media and the Represen-
tation of Genocide (2013, I.B. Tauris).
ORCID
Georgina Holmes http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7077-9799
Bibliography
Acharya, Amitav. How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localisation and
Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism.International Organisation 58 (2004):
23975.
Acharya, Amitav. Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders: Sovereignty, Regionalism
and Rule Making in the Third World.International Studies Quarterly 55 (2011):
95123.
Adler, Emmanuel, and Vincent Pouliot, eds. International Practices. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2011.
Adler-Nissen, Rebecca, ed. Boudieu in International Relations. London/New York:
Routledge, 2013.
Beardsley, Kyle, and Sabrina Karim. Female peacekeepers and gender balancing:
Token gestures or informed policymaking?International Interactions 39, no. 4
(2013): 46188.
Betts, Alexander, and Phil Orchard, eds. Implementation & World Politics: How
International Norms Change Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Betts Featherston, A. UN Peacekeepers and Cultures of Violence.Cultural Survival
19, no. 1 (Spring, 1995). https://www.culturalsurvival.org/publications/cultural-
survival-quarterly/un-peacekeepers-and-cultures-violence.
Beswick, Danielle. The Risks of African Military Capacity Building: Lessons from
Rwanda.African Aairs 113, no. 451 (April 2014): 21231.
Bevan, Marianne, and Megan H. MacKenzie. “‘CowboyPolicing versus the Softer
Stu.International Feminist Journal of Politics 14, no. 4 (2012): 50828.
Bigo, Didier. Pierre Bourdieu and International Relations: Power of Practices,
Practices of Power.International Political Sociology 5 (2011): 22558.
Bueger, Christian, and Frank Gadinger. International Practice Theory: New
Perspectives. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Björkdahl, Annika. Norms in International Relations: Some Conceptual and
Methodological Reections.Cambridge Review of International Aairs 15, no. 1
(2002): 923.
Björkdahl, Annika. Promoting Norms through Peacekeeping: UNPREDEP and
Conict Prevention.International Peacekeeping 13, no. 2 (2006): 21428.
Björkdahl, Annika, and Kristine Höglund. Precarious Peacebuilding: Friction in
GlobalLocal Encounters.Peacebuilding 1, no. 3 (2013): 28999.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 27
Bloomeld, Alan. Norm Antipreneurs and Theorising Resistance to Normative
Change.Review of International Studies 42 (2016): 31033.
Bourdieu, Pierre. The Field of Cultural Production. Oxford: Polity Press, 1993.
Bridges, Donna, and Debbie Horsfall. Increasing Operational Eectiveness in UN
Peacekeeping: Toward a Gender-Balanced Force.Armed Forces & Society 36,
no. 1 (October, 2009): 12030.
Bucher, Bernd. Acting Abstractions: Metaphors, Narrative Structures, and the
Eclipse of Agency.European Journal of International Relations 20, no. 3 (2014):
74265.
Burnet, Jennie E. Genocide Lives within US: Women, Memory, and Silence in Rwanda.
Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin, 2012.
Cardenas, Sonia. Norm Collision: Explaining the Eects of International Human
Rights Pressure on State Behavior.International Studies Review 6, no. 2 (Jun,
2004): 21332.
Carreiras, Helena. Gender and the Military: Women in the Armed Forces of Western
Democracies. London: Taylor & Francis, 2006.
Carson, Lisa. Pre-deployment GenderTraining and the Lack Thereof for Australian
Peacekeepers.Australian Journal of International Aairs 70, no. 3 (2016): 27592.
Crawford, Kerry, and Julia MacDonald. Establishing a Marketplace of Women in
Peacekeeping.Air & Space Power Journal Africa and Francophonie 1st Quarter,
(2013): 8096.
Curran, David. More than Fighting for Peace? Conict, Resolution, UN Peacekeeping,
and the Role of Training Military Personnel. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, 2016.
DeGroot, Gerard Jan. A Few Good Women: Gender Stereotypes, the Military and
Peacekeeping.International Peacekeeping 8, no. 2 (2001): 2338.
DPKO/DFS. Guidelines for Integrating a Gender Perspective into the work of the
United Nations Military in Peacekeeping Operations. New York: United Nations,
2010.
Duy, Tamara. Cultural Issues in Contemporary Peacekeeping.International
Peacekeeping 7, no. 1 (2000): 14268.
Duncanson, Claire. Forces for Good? Narratives of Military Masculinity in
Peacekeeping Operations.International Feminist Journal of Politics 11, no. 1
(2009): 6380.
Gizelis, Theodora-Ismene, and Louise Olsson, eds. Gender, Peace and Security:
Implementing UN Security Council Resolution 1325. London/New York: Routledge.
Halperin, Sandra, and Oliver Heath. Political Research: Methods and Practical Skills.
Oxford: Oxfrod University Press, 2012.
Heathcote, Gina, and Diane Otto. Rethinking Peacekeeping, Gender Equality and
Collective Security. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014.
Heinecken, Lindy. Are Women ReallyMaking a Unique Contribution to
Peacekeeping?Journal of International Peacekeeping 19, no. 34 (2015): 22748.
Higate, Paul, and Marsha Henry. Insecure Spaces: Peacekeeping, Power and
Performance in Haiti, Kosovo and Liberia. London/New York: Zed Books, 2009.
Holmes, Georgina. Gender and the Military in Post-Genocide Rwanda.In Women
and Genocide: Survivors, Victims, Perpetrators, eds Elissa Bemporad and Joyce W.
Warren. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2018, 223249.
Holmes, Georgina. The Commonwealth, Gender and Peacekeeping.The Round
Table: The Commonwealth Journal of International Aairs 106, no. 4 (2017):
40319.
28 G. HOLMES
Holmes, Georgina. Gendering the Rwanda Defence Force: A Critical Assessment.
Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 8, no. 4 (2014): 32133.
Holmes, Georgina. Women and War in Rwanda: Gender, Media and the
Representation of Genocide. London/New York: I.B. Tauris, 2013.
Jennings, Kathleen. Womens Participation in UN Peacekeeping Operations: Agents
of Change or Stranded Symbols?NOREF report (September, 2011).
Joaquim, Jutta, and Andrea Schneiker. Changing Discourses, Changing Practices?
Gender Mainstreaming and Security.Comparative European Politics 10, no. 5
(December, 2012): 52863.
Jowell, Marco. The Unintended Consequences of Foreign Military Assistance in
Africa.Journal of Eastern African Studies 12 (January 2017): 102119.
Karim, Sabrina. Reevaluating Peacekeeping Eectiveness: Does Gender Neutrality
Inhibit Progress?International Interactions 43 (September 2016): 822847.
Karim, Sabrina, and Kyle Beardsley. Equal Opportunity Peacekeeping. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 2017.
Karlsrud, John. Norm Change in International Relations: Linked Ecologies in UN
Peacekeeping Operations. London/New York: Routledge, 2016.
Katzenstein, Peter. The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World
Politics. New York: Columbia University Press, 1983.
Krook, Mona L., and Jackie True. Rethinking the Life Cycles of International Norms:
The United Nations and the Global Promotion of Gender Equality.European
Journal of International Relations 18, no. 1 (November, 2010): 10327.
Laplonge, Dean. The Absence of Masculinity in Gender Training for UN
Peacekeepers.Journal of Social Justice 27 (2015): 919.
Lovell, Terry. Thinking Feminism with and against Bourdieu.Feminist Theory 1, no.
1 (2000): 1132.
Mackay, Angela. Mainstreaming Gender in United Nations Peacekeeping Training:
Examples of East Timor, Ethiopia and Eritrea.In Gender, Conict, and
Peacekeeping, eds Dyan Mazurana, Angela Raven Roberts, and Jane Partpart.
Oxford: Rowman and LittleField, 2005, 265279.
Moi, Toril. Appropriating Bourdieu: Feminist Theory and Pierre Bourdieus
Sociology of Culture.New Literary History 4 (Autumn, 1991): 101749.
Olsson, Louise, and Torunn Tryggestad. Women and International Peacekeeping.
London/New York: Routledge, 2001.
Pouliot, Vincent. Methodology.In Bourdieu in International Relations, ed Rebecca
Adler-Nissan. London/New York: Routledge, 2013, 4558.
Pruitt, Lesley J. The Women in Blue Helmets: Gender, Policing, and the UNs First All-
Female Peacekeeping Unit. Oakland, CA: University of California Press, 2016.
Risse, Thomas, and Kathryn Sikkink. The Socialization of International Human Rights
Norms into Domestic Practices. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skeggs, Beverley. Formations of Class & Gender: Becoming Respectable. London: Sage
Press, 1997.
Skeggs, Beverley. Introducing Pierre Bourdieus Analysis of Class, Gender and
Sexuality.In Feminism after Bourdieu, eds Adkins and Skeggs, Oxford:
Blackwell Publishing, 2005.
Sion, Liora. Peacekeeping and the Gender Regime: Dutch Female Peacekeepers in
Bosnia and Kosovo.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 37, no. 5 (2008): 56185.
Simic, Olivera. Increasing Womens Presence in Peacekeeping Operations: The
Rationales and Realities of Gender Balance.In Rethinking Peacekeeping,
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING 29
Gender Equality and Collective Security, eds Gina Heathcote and Diane Otto.
London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014, 185199.
Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. The Scattered Speculations on the Question of Value.
Diacritics 15 (Winter, 1985): 7293.
United Nations. Core Predeployment Training Materials. United Nations, 2010.
http://repository.un.org/bitstream/handle/11176/89573/CPTM_All.pdf?sequence=
1&isAllowed=y.
United Nations. United Nations Peacekeeping Resource Hub. United Nations, 2016.
http://research.un.org/en/peacekeeping-community/Training.
Whitworth, Sandra. Men, Militarism, and UN Peacekeeping: A Gendered Analysis.
Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2004.
Wilcox, Laura. Practising Gender, Queering Theory.Review of International Studies
43, no. 5 (June, 2017): 789808.
Wilén, Nina. Examining the Links between Security Sector Reform and Peacekeeping
Troop Contribution in Post-conict States.Journal of Intervention and
Statebuilding 12 (February 2018): 6479.
Zalewski, Marysia. “‘IDont Even Know What Gender Is: A Discussion of the
Connections between Gender, Gender Mainstreaming and Feminist Theory.
Review of International Studies 36, no. 1 (2010): 327.
30 G. HOLMES
... For "local" knowledge, peacekeeping operations rely on non-white staff, yet such knowledge is not perceived as equally valuable as the expertise of white peacekeepers. 16 Non-white officials, like female peacekeepers, are thus perceived to have a specific but limited "use-value" (Holmes 2019), and it restricts their mobility within the UN as they remain pigeon-holed as experts in particular places and times. This echoes Harper-Shipman's (2021, 2026) observation regarding "a racialized matrix of privilege that locates Blackness as local and whiteness as global." ...
Article
Full-text available
While International Relations scholarship has increasingly addressed questions of race, the literature on international organizations (IOs) has been slower to do so. In particular, it has neglected how race functions within IO workforces. Building on sociological theories of racialized organizations, we develop the concept of racialized IOs. Like domestic organizations, IOs are characterized by enhanced or inhibited agency of racial groups, racialized distribution of resources, credentialing of whiteness, and decoupling of formal rules and informal practices along racial lines. However, IOs display two important differences. First, IOs rely on member states for resources, which requires accommodating powerful white-majority countries (macro-level pressures). Second, since IO workforces are diverse, their employees possess or develop a range of racial stereotypes (micro-level pressures). Using the case of UN peacekeeping, we demonstrate how the four features of racialized organizations operate in light of these macro-and micro-level pressures. We show how locally-hired peacekeeping staff in Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean face constraints on exercising agency; how non-white peacekeepers perform more dangerous jobs than their white counterparts; how whiteness serves as a proxy for desirable skills, while non-white peacekeepers' knowledge is devalued; and how peacekeepers from white-majority countries receive special treatment or deviate from UN-wide procedures.
... Taking into account the positive results of this specialized gender course, it was decided that in the selection of candidates for training for one annual training course, the advantage will be given to female employees, but not excluding male candidates. 7 Thus, already at the pre-deployment training stage, candidates have the opportunity to discuss the UN approaches in the context of the implementation of gender peacekeeping policy 8 and methods of working with vulnerable groups, including women, children and persons with disabilities (Holmes, 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
The peacekeeping became actual agenda of international relations due to increased number of internal conflicts with mass human rights violations in different regions of the world including Africa. The problems of ensuring peace and security have become priority for United Nations (UN) and regional organizations involved in constant search of conflict resolution best practices. Peacekeeping actors admitted the key role of law-enforcement agencies, and first of all the police, in ensuring security in conflict or post-conflict reconstruction. Therefore, the UN actively developing the strategy of police methods usage in peacekeeping operations. Because of this process, the number of member states contributing police contingents to the UN including formed police units increased. Joint activity of police officers from different countries with different education, professional experience and specialization requires high-quality training of candidates for peacekeeping operations. The purpose of this article is to analyze the needs of African police officers in professional development and the capabilities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation in training of African police officers for the UN peacekeeping operations. The study is based on insights from non-participant observation, interviews and analyses of the UN official documents, policies and training materials. Actual Russian and foreign scientific publications were used. Results confirmed that Russian Federation has many years of experience in African policemen training for the UN peacekeeping operations. The promising areas of Russian Federation participation in the development of the peacekeeping potential of African police, along with the provision of standardized pre-deployment training based on the UN certified programs, can be training in the crime investigation methodology and the training of special police units of the UN member states.
Article
Full-text available
In UN peace operations, the special representatives (SRSGs) as heads of mission take on a range of complex, sometimes unfathomable, tasks. This article addresses the question of how individuals influence UN peace operations by focusing on SRSGs who served as heads of two major peace operations and who carried their pre-SRSG experience into their first tenure as SRSG and their experience from that tenure into their second tenure. Thus, the aim is to understand how professional experience influences continuity and change in SRSGs’ leadership practices when leading peace operations. The analysis is grounded in an interview-based approach and informed by a practicecentered approach. The case studies examined here are Alan C. Doss, who served as SRSG of UNMIL and MONUC, and Ellen M. Løj, who served as SRSG of UNMIL and UNMISS. The identified practices of both SRSGs show that certain areas were particularly influenced by experiences from their career paths: (1) mission administration, (2) working with the mission leadership team, (3) interacting with host-state actors, and (4) interactions with UN headquarters. Tracing how practices have been pursued in different contexts provides insights into the influence of individual experiences on UN peace operations and the dynamics of practice internalization.
Article
Full-text available
This article contends that digital technologies are profoundly altering peacekeeping practices as well as peacekeeper consciousness and modes of being. It is proposed that combining postcolonial humanist and posthumanist ontological perspectives when undertaking ethnographic research enrichens investigations into global race and gender power relations in peacekeeping. Drawing on posthumanism and Bourdieusian practice theory, the article examines how 16 British infantry soldiers articulate reconnaissance and civilian protection experiences and construct their militarised masculinities prior to and after deployment to United Nations Multidimensional Integrated Stabilisation Mission in Mali (MINUSMA) in 2020-2021. Findings show that deployment to a high-risk, stressful mission and functioning as 'information processing devices' in an increasingly centralised UN peacekeeping system disempowers and emasculates the men. The peacekeepers respond by engendering and racialising the British Army's 'gender-neutral' cyborg soldier figuration and draw on virtual gaming syntax and framings to create relational distance between themselves, female colleagues and local populations.
Article
Abstracts Over the last twenty years, the international relations literature has sought to understand the conditions in which peacekeeping operations (PKOs) occur and the efficacy of their presence. Much work has focused on PKOs’ relationship to civilians in civil conflict, but less is understood about the influences on peacekeeping missions’ quality. If PKOs commit human rights abuses, how might other actors deter exploitive PKO behavior in the domestic context? We argue international nongovernmental organizations (INGOs) provide a monitoring and socializing effect on PKOs. Using the Peacekeeper Attributes (PKAT) and Transnational Social Movements (TSMO) datasets, we analyze peacekeeping missions from 2007 to 2013. Through zero-inflated negative binomial regression, we found that the presence of general INGOs decreases rates of misconduct, and human rights INGOs decrease rates of misconduct. However, we find that the presence of women’s rights-focused INGOs does not decrease rates of sexual misconduct among PKO troops.
Article
Feminist social theories, especially intersectional and decolonial ones, have been footnotes at best in practice-oriented research in international relations. This disciplinary exclusion of gender studies’ concepts from “international practice theories” (IPTs) or the "practice turn" has marginalized inquiries into power and reflexivity in action. As a result, IPTs have failed to theorize how practitioners’ reflexivity is shaped by local manifestations of systemic lines of difference like race, gender, coloniality, or class. This Theory Note argues that intersectional and decolonial feminist approaches can address this gap. We demonstrate that positionality and privilege condition practical reflexivity by shaping (1) normative interpretations of the world, (2) the content of social critique, and (3) the reception of such critique. Taking feminists as foundational theorists of international practices is critical to addressing some ontological challenges encountered by current IPT scholarship. In this Theory Note, we develop a productive conversation between the two bodies of literature around concepts of background knowledge and competence, which allows for a better understanding of the interplay of structural power and individual reflexivity in everyday interactions.
Chapter
Grave violations of children’s rights during armed conflict, particularly the recruitment and use of children by armed forces and groups, have been an important and growing concern for UN peacekeeping since the mid-1990s. Important advances in these children and armed conflict agenda have included dedicated child protection language in mission mandates, the development of extensive training and policy on child protection, and successful engagement with armed forces and groups to end abuses against children. However, the mandate has gaps in focusing on prevention of grave violations, acknowledging children’s participation in peace and security, and how child protection could contribute to building and sustaining peace. This chapter examines three areas in which future UN peacekeeping missions can improve their approach to the children and armed conflict agenda and complement ongoing initiatives such as Action for Peacekeeping + : better centering children in peace and security efforts, improving early warning and early action to prevent grave violations, and adopting more nuanced understandings of children’s gender and agency.
Article
Full-text available
The cholera outbreak brought to Haiti in 2010 as a consequence of wastewater mismanagement in one of the UN Stabilisation Mission’s camps drew attention to the concrete material footprint of UN peace operations. Since the 2000s, UN peacekeeping missions have been increasingly confronted with environmental challenges. Multiple transformations in terms of norms and practices resulted from these environmental concerns. Drawing on data generated through interviews and participant observation, this article explores how environmental concerns are integrated in UN peacekeeping operations and develops a two-fold argument. First, I argue that the inclusion of environmental concerns in UN peacekeeping relies on the environmentalization of peacekeeping practices. It consists of heterogeneous elements – standards, expertise, training, mainstreaming, equipment management – which focus on the ecological footprint of UN peacekeeping. Second, I show that environmentalizing peacekeeping contributes to the securitization of the environment. By understanding the dynamics of inclusion of environmental concerns, this article sheds light on one of the ways through which emerging issues broaden and widen UN peacekeeping practices.
Article
Full-text available
This article traces the origins, development and implications of Human Rights Up Front (HRuF), a bold and visionary initiative launched by former Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon in 2013. While HRuF is part of a broader continuum of human rights-related reforms, its scope and focus is distinctive. HRuF puts the imperative to protect people from serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law at the core of the UN’s strategy and operational activities, and obliges staff to speak out about abuses and looming crises. Using the case study of South Sudan and drawing on over 150 interviews conducted in-country, this article considers the implications of HRuF for peacekeeping and, specifically, for impartiality, a norm traditionally regarded as the ‘lifeblood’ and ‘heart and soul’ of the UN Secretariat. I identify three challenges that have hindered the UN’s ability to deliver impartially on its protection and human rights mandate and the consequences thereof for the UN’s perceived legitimacy in South Sudan. Further, I examine how the Organization has tried, with mixed success to manage the dilemmas and tensions that have arisen from the privileging of individual, as opposed to state or government, security, and the implications for the broader functioning of the UN.
Chapter
Full-text available
This chapter undertakes a process-oriented study of genocide to consider how the gendered nature of genocide continues to influence security policies in postconflict Rwanda, and informs Rwandan women’s motives for joining state security organs. I argue that while the RDF’s gender program supports once shared national policy goals to mainstream gender equality across politics, economy, and culture, the program has been designed to help improve the reputation of the national armed forces, and in doing so, sets out to strengthen the legitimacy of the authoritarian state. This is achieved in three ways: by supporting the implementation of internal security policy goals; by attempting to improve civil-military relations; and, by transforming societal perceptions of military women.
Article
Full-text available
This article examines the links between post-conflict states’ troop contributions to international peacekeeping missions and security sector reform (SSR). It shows how SSR and troop-contribution preparations are increasingly interwoven and at times perceived as complementary by both external and internal actors. Some of the objectives sought after in SSR, such as the modernization of the military forces and the institutionalization of international norms, overlap with the aim of external partners’ pre-deployment training programmes and formations. Yet, it is argued that there are several unintended consequences with establishing links between SSR and peacekeeping capacity-building that are too strong, including the reinforcement of the troop-contributing government which, in case the government has authoritarian tendencies, undermines democratic reforms and transparency. There is also a risk that donors increasingly prefer to support pre-deployment training that has tangible and rapid results rather than investing funds in SSR, which is politically difficult with few examples of success. Donors and national actors alike are therefore encouraged to reflect on whether post-conflict states should contribute troops in the immediate aftermath of conflict before SSR has been completed. The answer is likely to vary depending on context-specific issues, which makes it difficult to generalize across cases, but the question remains nevertheless essential.
Book
Political Research: Methods and Practical Skills provides a practical and relevant guide to the research process for students. It equips readers with the knowledge and skills needed to evaluate research findings and successfully carry out independent study and research. Taking a helpful step-by-step approach, the chapters guide the reader through the process of asking and answering research questions and the different methods used in political research, providing practical advice on how to be critical and rigorous in both evaluating and conducting research. Topics include research design, surveys, interviewing and focus groups, ethnography and participant observation, textual analysis, quantitative analysis, bivariate analysis, and multivariate analysis. With an emphasis throughout on how research can impact important political questions and policy issues, the book equips readers with the skills to formulate significant questions and develop meaningful and persuasive answers.
Article
Impartiality is a core legitimating norm for United Nations peace operations. Yet beliefs about what that norm requires of UN personnel have shifted dramatically. In 2013, for example, the Security Council created an intervention brigade – composed of infantry battalions, special forces, and an artillery company – to ‘neutralize’ non-state armed groups in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). According to critics, these activities violate core peacekeeping norms, including impartiality. This criticism elicits a puzzling response from many UN officials. They downplay the novelty of new practices, insisting that they are still ‘impartial’. Where does this discursive pattern come from, and what does it tell us about the relationship between day-to-day practices and the norms that ostensibly guide UN peace operations? Drawing on evidence from the DRC, I argue that norms like impartiality may endure – and remain rhetorically powerful – without telling us much about how practices on the ground have evolved. Instead, insisting that new practices are impartial can be a way for UN personnel to stabilize a core part of their identity under conditions of normative ambiguity. It can also be a way of glossing over contestation and pre-empting concerns about partiality in UN peace operations.
Book
The Women in Blue Helmets tells the story of the first all-female police unit deployed by India to the UN peacekeeping mission in Liberia in January 2007. Lesley J. Pruitt investigates how the unit was originated, developed, and implemented, offering an important historical record of this unique initiative. Examining precedents in policing in the troop-contributing country and recent developments in policing in the host country, the book offers contextually rich examination of all-female units, explores the potential benefits of and challenges to women's participation in peacekeeping, and illuminates broader questions about the relationship between gender, peace, and security. © 2016 by The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved.
Article
Peacekeeping training centres in Africa are numerous. These centres are part of broader military assistance programmes provided by bilateral or multilateral donors and are completely funded from outside. The intent is threefold: to improve peacekeeping; to professionalise national defence forces in African states through training and instruction in international norms and to provide areas of socialisation between African militaries in order to foster bonds and forge ties in the hope that the potential for regional conflict will reduce through these elite relationships. This paper argues that few of these intended outcomes are achieved. Using peace support operation training in Kenya and an analysis of organisational functionality it is argued that African militaries reflect the broader socio-political dynamics of the state and are typically patrimonial in nature. By providing patrimonial military institutions with significant external resources such as training centres, foreign donors can actively exacerbate internal patrimonial dynamics. This will, of course, take different forms depending on the nature of the military and the nature of the state. What is common, however, is that foreign military assistance in Africa is subverted for national and usually internal reasons as opposed to the intended and more outward-oriented aims.