Content uploaded by Gizem Hatipoglu
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Gizem Hatipoglu on Jul 04, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
International
Journal of Human
Sciences
Volume 15 Issue 2 Year: 2018
A content analysis
towards article in
educational
administration in
Turkey
Türkiye'de eğitim
yönetimi alanındaki
makalelere yönelik
bir içerik analizi
Gizem Hatipoğlu1
Yeliz Özkan Hıdıroğlu2
Türkay Nuri Tok3
Abstract
!
"
#$%
&
'( '() $
*$ * +
, - ./$
* 0$ , 123
./$ * 0$
, 4"5 *
6 , 7
./$ * 0$
, 85 ./$ *
0$ ,
, 7 %
Özet
*9 $2
:/":"
$$::; "
3"9 ::
$ "$: / "
;" :
<:: 2 9
3;33"# = ;:%
.>4?=1-@ 1"29
+A -B/
*9 0"3 A 123
B/ *9 0"3
A 4"5 *9
4;:: A 7
B/ *9 0"3
A 85 B/ *9
0"3 A .:
1 = A '('()
$:: : $$:
" $:: 9 $2$
( A"C9"" B/ *9 0"3 *9= =233
*9D2=2334=A 5# E##
A"C9"" B/ *9 0"3 *9= =233
*9D2=2334=A$55"'E #
FA<#A#15A"B/*90"3*9==233*9
D2=2334=A"$"E #
'('(''('G'
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
ML
N 5
5
$ O
# I $
& O/
/&M
/$#4
$
FN
$%
PP% O/
% &" &
'(''%
& $ %
/$L
% / $ JQ R
K&$
O%
&
$-*=&#
Keywords *%
%
%/&#
J*N * $
K
" $:: "L<
$5: <:;:9: " $2
$2 <:": 2"
3$3"393 2" " /
: / 5
""$5$::":
<:;:#
4;:: /
;:$2"3
$$ :;
/ <" 5
;# 45
F "
9 $2
: / "$
% " <"%
S"T " <:;::9:%
$2 "::9:% '
('' :"2" $
<:;::9:% <:; "
29 " 9%
/ : "
"L2<""::9:%/5
"9"5JR
K$::9:%$5$::"
$5:: 9 /
$5: 9 "
5:-*=<:;::9
;#
Anahtar Kelimeler*9%9
;::% 9 $2
;::%"#
GİRİŞ
= /"$" 35;"< 35$
"""3:;::3$3"
2/ 3;"# 1$ ;::: $ 25"
3::9:":$:"5""$
$ J* '((K#U/ 7 J(K
" ;" $" / : 5 35
$"< 3 ::2 9 / ":#
=$359 9$2:$:;::
(F)F
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
" 3 ::"" ;" $:::2
93;33"#
B"9 ;;" 2
;:::# $ " 9 ;::
;:"2#I:""::
": 9 $ : 9 $ : < 9
;:: 2 2/ 3;" JV / ?3<3" ''K#
-@J'''K 29;::9:";:
3< "$<;$2 / "
" "$ 5 9 / $$::9: 3<# *9
;::5::9:;"5::
33 25 <" 2 $::; ;::
3/9$ "$":#I3 ;:: :9
9/$ 9:"9:/;::
"":":J?9''K#
-@ J'''K 2 $:; <"; 9
;::: : < " 3" "
;:: : "9 9 $2" "" $
"$":#I3"$@'''@29;::: $::5
%('$:$::3$3":; 23"J?9
'('% 82"; 7< W:;9 4"<$ =$" = / 25
'(K# *9 ;::: 9 / 9$
:9 <:;:: " $": <::
2 <" J=" A9 ?9 /
?9'((K# *9 $2 :$: ;:
":9::5 <" $ :;: $ <:":; "/: </
":: / $: :;: 3; ": 35 <:;::
23"# I / X;J'(FK "/: "/
$2:/"$2/ $"
2 3 /;:" "5 $ " " $2
29 $" $::: 3 ; "
5"""#
I3"$@ L $$::9: "
;"":<:;";:;:":#<"?:/
A3 J'(K *9 / = A @" " 9
;#?$0:;":/J'(FK<:;:$
A @ '')'(' $:: : $$::; GG "$
" : $" / <" 5$ ;#
82";/"#J'(KU/.>4?=1-/:I3"
9 ""$2":/<:
/ 5 "" / 2" 3$3"393 2 9
;#V;83/25J'(K<:;:I3"$@
" 9 : $::; <:;: <" 5 $$
;# *J'((K I3"$@ '''') $:::9
: $$: " 5 $$
;#D<:=?5/D<:J''K7B/
(F)
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
*9 0"3 A @ $$::; " <" 5$
;# 4:"/ I3" J''K I3"$@ $$: / U@
9 " " " / " 2
;# 1" J''K-/A9U9$ "
<:;: ; / / / 9 $
<:;:;:#83/4J''KI"+,*
I" $ JI+,*IK ''F''G $:: :" 9
"M$ " ;# 25 / ?J''K
I3"$@"9 " (F "$$2 / ":
::/9":$;#
9$2"<:;"::9:""
<:;: ::: $: 9 23"# = <:;
I?9=";/ D<:J'(K? / .$ *9
D2 A @ ''F'(F $:: : $$: "%
"M"/"<253""$5"
<:;:# 4$: *9 / : J'('K 9 $2 :
I3"$@/ ;;23"J4"4/$1 ?K
'''' $:: : $$::; "% " $2 /
<: 2";:;::"9;#V:":@:J'()K
I3"$@ ('()$:: :9$2 /
:$:59<:;:$":#4$:9
$2::" 5 ":# D<: J'(K /
A@: J'(K <:;: "" <:;:# I
=";D<:#/49J'()K9$2" 35
9 $:;:# " <:;: "
D:5@:J'(K<:;:9$2::"
<:; ;# 1 <:; $ <:""
9 $2 :: I3"$@" ;"
9$::;:#
D:;:9%<:;:":$2/
<: 2/<"5"
;:: 9 $ <:;::9: 23"#
0" / 6/ J(K <" 5 $$: $:9:::
L9 ": $2 9
"# *9 ;:: <" 5 "::9:
<:; "":$2 ":" #
1 $2 " "" < 5 :
"";:;::5$::9:<:;:#A9$2
"" L <" " " 2
5$::9:<:;:#B<33$2""
<" " 3 2" <" 5 $::9:
<:;:# 0": " <" 5 $: <:;: "
$::9:<:;/:J?$/"#'(FK#
< " <:; $::: 5:9: 5
$ <:"":# 4;:: <:;: ;"
5" $ ;" < <" 5 ":# = 3
(F)
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
<:;: ;:: 5 "5:: ;"
3 9: ;$: "$;:: <:: 2
93;33"# = ;: <:: :5: /
9 " ;:: ":# = $35 9 :"
9 ;"":: 2#4" 9
"":" :; / "# V3"3 "
"< ";"$2/" $":;: J4:"/
I3" ''K# -" .>4?=1-@
$$: < 9 : / ;:
"9: ""#=;:I6A5
.>4?=1-@ 1"29 + A - B/
*9 0"3 A 123 B/ *9 0"3 A
4"5 *9 4;:: A 7 B/ *9
0"3 A 85 *9 0"3 A .: 1
= A ::;:#= '('() $:::
$$: toplam makale sayısı, eğitim yönetimiyle ilgili makale sayısı,
konu/amaç, yazarın çalıştığı kurum, yöntem, yöntem açıklaması, örneklem
büyüklüğü, örneklem kitlesi, veri toplama aracı, veri analiz teknikleri,
yazar sayısı ":::Y::" / /
<"5$; ":/333"::
9;/;::/;#
=;:::.>4?=1-@GJ$K '('()
$:::*9D2I;:/*"J*DI*K
: $$: " " M" / "
<253""<::9$"/
" "$:"""<:;:;:"":#=
9;9:"/:;:#
A $$:%
(# *9:""$::
# *DI* "$::
F# -"":
# D5:<:;:9:"
# 4;:
)# C""/2"3$3"393
G# 4;:":///5$2
# 4;:":$5$::<:: :9::
2"Z
YÖNTEM
4;: ;:$2"::;:# 4;:/
;: $2"3 $$ :;:#
A"3 ;::: Y "":
< $5:: $ 5 "": JD::: / X;"
'()K#
Çalışma Grubu
(F))
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
V:; .>4?=1- : 5 85 B/
*90"3A 7B/ *9=A
4"5 *9 4;:: A 1"29 + A 123
B/*90"3A -B/*90"3
A .: 1 = A / *5 B/
*9 0"3 A '('() $:: : $$::;
"#.>4?=1-:5 '($::'()
$:::$$::;F"":#="
@*DI*:$$::;"#=;::/
'( $:: '() $:: : 9$2 ; " /
:: $$::; ";":#V:;
2"< ;/<:;/:;::;:#
I (@ $$: 3 " / "
< *DI* : $$: " $: 2 $:
9::: 23"#
Tablo 1. I3-"/*DI*4:D$:-"
D:82A9:::
Yıl / n 20
12
20
13
20
14
20
15
20
16 Toplam
Tüm Makaleler F
G
(
'
F
EYTPE Alanında Yayınlanan
Makaleler G G G ' )
Veri Toplama Aracı
4;: ": : " 5 $" < SD$:
::Y0T"::;:#=25?/D;@:J'(K
<:;: ;:: : 9 $:;:# *DI*
:$:;::::"$";"35
35 ":9;"" $::;:# D$:::Y0%
makalelerin konusu, araştırma modelleri, araştırmanın örneklemi, veri
toplama ve veri analiz yöntemleri, yazar sayıları, dergide yayın yapan
yazarların bağlı oldukları kurumları $ <:"" ;" "5 JK
;:":;#
Verilerin Analizi
=<:;/5<"5
5 "9"::;:# 1<"5 /
<:"$" "/ / ;" ;" Y"#
I/2"/;:::$<:"
(F)G
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
"/ 2 :": ;" 35 / /$<:"$
: : ""# = 5 25
$/<"5;
"/$";:"$"//
5 $<:":" JD::: /X;" '()K#
= $35 ;: 5 <" 5 "
":: ;:: : $ 233;3# =
5 2 / 2 2
::Y:/$:JD:::/X;"'()K#A %
"L<$5:<:;:9:"$2$2<:":2"
3$3"393 2" " / : / 5 ""
$5 $:: : "5 $ $ ;:: :
2;/95::;:#A "
" 5 / $: 3% J(K Adlandırma,
kodlama ve çıkarma aşamasıJKkategori geliştirme aşamasıJFKgeçerlik
ve güvenirlik sağlama aşaması JK raporlaştırma aşaması " 35
2; <";;#
Adlandırma, kodlama ve çıkarma aşaması: '('()$:::
$$::; F " " *DI* :
":::;:"";/ $"":;:#7
"$*DI*(*DI**DI*F;"";;#
=":;:::*DI*:
"%";:9:2523 2523"
;#
Kategori geliştirme aşaması: = ; "
"" ; / makalelerin konu alanı, araştırma modelleri,
araştırmanın örneklem büyüklüğü ve kitlesi, veri toplama ve veri analiz
yöntemleri, yazar sayıları, dergilerde yayın yapan yazarların bağlı oldukları
kurumlar ;" "5 " : ::;:# 4;: "
2":" 2::Y:$
;#=< <" " "
$::9: $ <:"::;:#?: liderlik, iş doyumu, örgütsel
adalet : ::Y:;:# =5: " 5
" 35 9 < " " $:: " $::
$3""#1" "::9::"
:;:33/";"$::;:#
V:; ": " ;:: $::9:
2"3$3"3"((''('(''[ (("::":;/
<" 2" "$ <:;::9: J29 29$2
K $";# -" ": / $2
$:" :::;:#=" "/$
:: 2< < S2<"T : : :
;;# -" / 5 ": "
$2 ::Y:::;:# =5: " /5"
5"$2"::;:#="$::
2 " " 5 $2 $:: 5:#
V:;":"""<$5:$5::9: $:
(F)
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
" ::;:# " $5: 2/ $:":
" 2::Y$ ;#=" $2
29 ; 333 $5 S- *9 =":9:T J-*=K
: : 3/ :;: 2/ $ $5 SA9T :
:::Y::;:#
Geçerlik ve güvenirlik sağlama aşaması: 4;:
$:::;";/:;::;:#=
;: 3<;:::" <";;#1"2
" $2 <" 5 9: ;"
" ;;#=$2"""5" :
" :" ;#8" "
" : ;:: : $: $:
<";;# = " / ";:;:::;
";:;: 3$3" 5 < ;::;:#
4;5:93;33<;:::;""9
9$ <:;:; $ $ ;::: 23;
9" /;"/;#
Raporlaştırma aşaması: 4;:": : *DI* :"
"" /95;%
;: : $: 9:: ;" ;:::;:#
= : : :: 3 / ::
3"3 $9: $: " 3< :"
" ;"<:" $ /$<:;::;:# 4;:
$5:" / "" :"
$:;:#
BULGULAR ve YORUM
V:;: 233 *DI* : $$:
" konu alanı, araştırma modelleri, araştırmanın örneklem
büyüklüğü ve kitlesi, veri toplama ve veri analiz yöntemleri, yazar sayıları,
dergilerde yayın yapan yazarların bağlı oldukları kurumlar ;"
" / " <" 95
$::;:# 4;: : " <: ;"
;:::;:#
I @ $$: " *DI*
: $$: " " : 9::: 2"#
= 2$$:"":9::: 9
5 <:;::S"TJ\K 9 23"#
::$ SAT / S:: D2T <" <:;: "
::#
Tablo 2. -"?4:82A9:::
Konu Alanı Frekans(n)
(F)
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
>"
A
::D2
1;A$
+"D2C5"
D2C5"
1;
C 3?333
C 3=9::"
D2
C 34
I3";"
C 31"
C 3W;:"
1;D:;
C 3C9
C 383/
C9D;
1?$":D2
C 35
A$ =9::"
A9;L8;
V:;
?4
+"=9::9:
C 3A9
C 3C5;;
D:::C9
C 3$;
C 34]"
*9
C 34:;:"
C9:
"
C5$"
6$
C 35
C 3A"
-/$
A9
Toplam
'
(
(
((
)
)
)
F
F
F
F
F
)F
291
IF@ $$: *DI* : $$:"
;: 2 9::: $ /"# = 2
$$:"9:::9;:
$2 5 9 J\()FK :
(FG'
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
J\K/:"3;::9J\((K
23"#
Tablo 3. -"4;:-82A9:::
Araştırma Modeli Frekans (n)
?
Toplam
()F
((
259
I @ $$: *DI* : $$::;
"" 2" 3$3"3" " 9 ;#
I 23393 ;: "" 2"
3$3"3"(("::":;:#A $$:"
2"3$3"393<::9<"":2"
3$3"3933(('':9:9J\FGK:'(F''
J\FFK9 23"#
Tablo 4. -"C"=3$3"39382A9:::
Örneklem Büyüklüğü Frekans(n)
((''
('(''
'(F''
F'(''
'(''
'()''
)'(G''
G'(''
'(''
'(('''
('''35
Toplam
FG
()
FF
()
('
G
G
F
G
142
I @ $$: *DI* : $$::;
" 2" " 9::: ;# -"
2" " " <" 29 J\(K 9
23"#:$2 J\K/29 J\K<:;::9:
23"#
Tablo 5. -"C"?82A9:::
Örneklem Kitlesi Frekans(n)
C9
C9
D2
(
(FG(
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
A
C9*:
A9
Toplam
(G
F
259
I )@ $$: *DI* : $$::;
" ": / $2 " 9:::
;# I ) 9 *DI* : $$:
"/:"5"L2<"J\()FK
::$ 23;J\)GK/"3J\(K"::9: 23"#
Tablo 6. -"?:WID282A9::
Veri Toplama Yöntemleri Frekans(n)
4"LC<"
823;
A"3
0M
A9
Toplam
()F
)G
(
G
263
I G@ $$: *DI* : $$::;
"": /5 "" 9:::;#
= 2*DI*:$$:"5":"
3</5"9::$%J\('KJ\G'K4+W4
J\K9 23"# =5: "5"
$2 "::9: ;# A$::$ " "
5$2$::"$::$3""#
Tablo 7. -"?:W45I""82A9::
Teknik Frekans(n)
(FG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
=^QR_
4+W4
1<"45
=^_45
6 $
0"245
?$
-`$.
?$?$::
>A
?"`7
??
]I
I"$
-4+W4
? //
-5
A9
Toplam
('
G'
F
'
FG
F
FF
'
(
(G
(G
G
)
)
(
564
I @ $$: *DI* : $$::;
" $5 $::: 9::: ;# *DI* :
$$: " $5 $:: <:: 9 " $5:
"5J\((K9:$5:J\)(K/F
$5:J\FK"9 23"#
Tablo 8. -"D5$::82A9:::
Yazar Sayısı Frekans(n)
($5:
$5:
F$5:
$5:
/35
Toplam
)(
((
F
254
A $$:*DI*:<"$$:$$5:
9:9"-*=J\K9 23"#-*=@
5$$:$3/::$123B/J\GK/
U$B/J\K9I@ 23"#
Tablo 9.A D$:DD5:=9:+9?
(FGF
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
Üniversiteler Frekans(n)
-*=
123
U$
7
85
-
A"5*$3
""
D::5I""
4155=$
V""+"5-
85
?
*";+ 5
43"
=<;
4"5
-4"*$
.;"
D":A9
4:$
*"
?"
*5
I*A
8
4/V
I"$
A:
a/
?5I""
+"5-$:
85;
=5"
-4"
-9:":?<
0:
V"::?"
?;3<31
A
7
"$
-835
A35
1a
0-
G
(
'
(
(
(F
(F
(F
(F
(
(
((
G
)
)
)
)
)
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
(FG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
+"
83
?
-U=$
-;4
-
14$:
0-
6I$$*9
V"/
=$"
+AIB
,$/"$
=;"
A1b*6
TOPLAM
)
SONUÇ, TARTIŞMA VE ÖNERİLER
= <:;I6 A5 .>4?=1-@ 1"29+ A
- B/ *9 0"3 A 123 B/ *9
0"3 A 4"5 *9 4;:: A 7
B/ *9 0"3 A 85 B/ *9 0"3
A *5 B/ *9 0"3 A / .:
1 = A @ '('() $:: : $$:
"% " $:: 9 $2$ " $::
"L<$5:<:;:9:"$22"3$3"393
2""/:/5""/$5$:::
<" 5$$ "$" <:;:# = 23/ 5
;: 9 < :;::; /
2$/;#
? ":: " " <" <:;:
"S"T9;#835/D/5J'()K=/
U&J'(K C33 / X;" J'((K 7 J'(FK/ 1;<@
J'(FK <:;: ;:: ": "
"<"<:;:"S"T9/ ":#
D:5J'(K/I/";:J'()K$:<:;:
2":::""$3""$ ::$::9::$
<" 3 " $9;::9:: "# >"
3 " : $:# 7 < 3 9
5"""" ":"
333 $ <:":$: " 3""
": / ;: $::$ : " # C33 /
X;" J'((K <:;: ": " <; $ :9:
"$"$;%29"JI'(%7 '(K
23;3"J=*/*'(K9:::;"J=
/ 8/ '(K 9"J- '(% = '(K2 3
(FG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
" J," / - '(K 5:::# +"
332 3"333<"" 2
: $:;: " " <" <:;: "
:/33 ""3"
";": 29:: 3;33 < 3
": " $";::: / 3 $<:": "
":$:<:; $::;#
D2":: ""<"":
$2;:$2;#82";/"#J'(K
?94"::/9 J'(K $J'(KV9/4$:
J''K4:"/I3"J''K.;/.5J''KU&J(K
J'('K4$:/.$J'(K<:;:<:;
<" $2 "::9:: "# 1
" " " ;:: $::: "< :::
":9: ;:: ;: 2 5 $:
9 23"# ?<:; / /"
<:; :: ": / "$":: 23;333
9:9: <:; JU& ''FK : 9 I3"$@
:::$:"<:;$::9: 23"#?<:;:
$::: 5:9:: % $2
5 $ : "% /
/5":::55: "
9 3;33"# ;: <:;: 9
: $$:: < / " $
333 " <";"# 4$: ;:: <:
<";"/""5":":JU&''FK#
;:: 5:9:: $ "$:: 5
/:/$ 9;";"$::
"2"93;33"#
1 ""2"3$3"393 "
5((''";"2" :9:" <"<:;::9:
23"# C" 3$3"3933 (('' "; :9:
<:;:::5 $: "/
<":/;$93;33#82";/
"#J'(K/1;<J'(FK<:;:2" "5
F(('' ('(F'' "; : 9; 2" <
<:;::9::"#
1 " 29 29 $2 ":
"$" / :;:% " <" <:;: 2"
"299 23"#=;:<"
$: 29 : ;::: "$ : / 9
$2 : / " ":
" 29 " "3333 < :
$::$"9::5"" "2
" 9 3;33"# =; / C5 9::@: J'(GK%
82";/";::J'(K%J'('K%1;<J'(FK;::
(FG)
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
; ": " 5 29 $:$
<:;::9:: 23"#
-" ": / <: 9% 5
": / <:: 2<"L" / 23; 9
23"#<"/J'(K82"<"/J'(FK/J'(KV;
J'(KB39 J'(FK 4 / 83 J''K X;"/ J''K
82"; / J'(K 1;< J'(FK 4$: / .$ J'(K $333"
<:; <" 2<" / 23; "::9::
;#C<" $ :% 23;$ 5 $
:":53/M"<:"$
/":3//$$$;::
:<"92$J<":?
/A3'(K#
4;:$$:<:;":/5$2
9;#-"<"":/5$2
5/4+W4""9;#X;"
/J''K4:"/I3"J''KW:;9/J'(FKD<:/J''K
=";/J'(FKA9/J'('KJ'('K1;<J'(FK4$:/
.$J'(K/55""JQ/#K
"::9:: ;# = <:;: :: $
9 / : <:;:: $ "9
23"#C<"$ :5:5
"" :: 5 : " <# C<"
5 $" 5"""::$:5
::#
D$:"9"$5$:::(
:9;"#1"$5:""<((
# 4 / 83 J''K +5 / ?2 J'(K
;::$"$5:$5:"9::":"
";:;: 9 ;# = " <9
:;:$/293$"$::9:
#1"$5:$"$""$5:5$"$:"/
:5"::#
-" 9 " $ $5: "
-*=9::":9 23"# *DI* 233 $3"" /
" $ "; " -*=@ <:; < 9
$2/29;93;33"#A$::$-*=
"2"$5:5:"#
V:; < I3"$@ .>4?=1-@ 5
*DI* : $$: "% " " ;:
;::2"///5$2
$5 $:: $$:$ $5: 9: ": "
$<:"";";# =<:;:<::*DI*
: ;:::: $ ;:: <$ 2 9:
3;33"# = 9 "$ " $:"
(FGG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
5 /$ ;" <:; < ;:: $2" 2
;:
(K *DI*:5<:;::;$<<:;::;"
<:;$:#
K A":2<3<"$2<:;$::/
<;9 #
FK V:; < "3329 /
": 35<:;$:#
K D:"<:; ;/ :#
K C<"/ 23;:;:":/<:$<:;
<";#
)K 1;"<:;:2<:":9:3;33393"$5:
<" $5: <:; $ 3$3" 2<" $ "
<:;:9::"/#
KAYNAKÇA
4 4# / 83 D# J''K# I
4 /& I+,*I#TOJET: The
Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology8JK#
4:"6##/I3"-#J''K#*9:$$:
$ " #Uluslararası
Türkiye Eğitim Araştırmaları Kongresi, Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart
Üniversitesi, Antalya#
4$:4#/.$X#J'(K#I3"$c9$2;:
/":""5#Abant İzzet
Baysal Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi14J(K#
4$: 4# *9 U# / : D# J'('K# *9 $2 :
$$: " " $2 / < <::
";:;:::# Eurasian Journal of Educational Research39FGd
#
="4#A9#?9#/?9+#
J'((K# * $$: 9 " D2
5#I3"0*9A J(K(((F#
=:4#/4$:V#J''K#I3"$@9$2;:::
? / $ 9 $2 29#
Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim Yönetimi15JKFFF#
=";-#A37#U$4#J'(FK#.::2999
5$ J.+K <; 9;" <::
#Uşak Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi. 6(2)'()#
=>#*,#/*># U# J'(K# U
> *> # International Journal of
Educational Management26JKF('#
= W# J'(K# - / &% $
8 4 $# International Journal of
Educational Management26JK(G((#
(FG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
= I# / U& -# J'(K# - / ' $ 4
7 6/&# Educational Management Administration &
Leadership40JKFGdF#
=I# /8/A# J'(K#A >
* # School
leadership & management32J(K(F)#
U7#/7 >#W#J(K# The handbook of research synthesis#
0#
U& =#4# J(K# N /
O$ Z# Journal of Science Teacher
Education35((F#
U& ,# `# J''FK# Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and
mixed methods approachesJ*#K#U4 #
V # / ?3<3" -# J''K# 0 29 9
;:: "":" 3;3# V. Ulusal Fen Bilimleri ve
Matematik Eğitimi Kongresi ()(*$3+AIB ?33 / ?
-"54"#
V:": X# J'()K# I3"$@ 9$2 / :
$: 5 ;" # Prof. Dr. Ziya Bursalıoğlu’na
armağan J* 4# =: / 1# 4$:K# 4" 4" B/
*9=0"3D$::##F'FFF)#
V:": X# J'()K# I3"$@ 9$2 / :
$: 5 ;" # # A# a$ =:9@
9 J* 4# =: / 1# 4$:K# 4" 4" B/
*9=0"3D$::##F'FFF)#
V; 4#J'(K# '''(' $::: "9 :
I3"$@$:$3""/"5<:;::<"
5 The Journal of Academic Social Science Studies, 5(7), ((
#
V;4#838#/25-#J'(K#-
I"$4$$#Educational Sciences: Theory &
Practice12J(KG'#
A 8# J'(K# I3"$@ 9 $2 : ;:
9 / : 233 9:
9#D$::;A"I5#*";+ 5
B/*9=*33*";#
A9-#8<I#4":4##/X"0#J'(K#0
9<:;:$3""/"55#I3"
Fen Eğitimi Dergisi, 9(1),)#
*A#J'((K#I3"$@''d'')$:::$$:9
" " 5: 25" <::
= 5# Eğitimde ve Psikolojide Ölçme ve
Değerlendirme Dergisi2J(K('(G#
0" >#I#/6/6#J(K#UN4$IO
4$ 6 0 4 >
- 6A>/#JK
G('#
(FG
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
82"<"I#=0#a#? *#V":#/?3D#J'(FK#''F'(
$:: : I3"$@ " ;: $2$ $:
9<:;::5#International Journal of Social Science
F)
82";D#7<0#W:;9=#4"<$4#=$"#=-#/
25-# J'(K# I3"$@" 9 ;:: 9
=<"5#Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim Bilimleri12J(KF
)'#
82";D#?3<3"#4$-#I*#4:" C#D:::8#/
691#J'(K#I3"$@9"M;::"
9'''''2"<"5#Kuram ve
Uygulamada Eğitim Bilimleri Dergisi12(1),(GG(#
83 D# / 4 4# J''K# C9 "M : $:
;:"<"5#Ankara Üniversitesi Eğitim
Bilimleri Fakültesi Dergisi42JKF(((#
835A#/D/5-#J'()K#*99/$2":
'( $:: $$::; " < / $2
"::9#İlköğretim Online15JKF(F#
7 # J'(FK# 4 &" $ /&
# Journal of
Educational Administration51JK()(#
7 -# # J'(K# A ]
7&]@/
# Educational Administration Quarterly
48JKGFFdG#
1"#J''K#.:9$9;::/
I3"$@ 2" -/ / " $2# Doğu
Coğrafya Dergisi21(F(F)#
1;< # J'(FK#I3"$@ 9 $2 : $::; 33
5 " M" / " <:
(Master's thesis, ESOGÜ, Eğitim Bilimleri Enstitüsü).
," ?#-#/ - U# J'(K#I
Y
5O$# Educational Administration Quarterly 48JK
F'#
?9 *# J'('K# *9 " 5 ":
;:"35$/"#Kuram
ve Uygulamada Eğitim Yönetimi16J(KG(#
- ># J'(K# * /
Z# International Journal of Educational
Management26JK)()#
- # J'''K# A Z British
Educational Research Journal26J(K#
+5U# /?2 *# J'(K# *9 : /29 :"
;: 9#Sakarya University Journal of Education4J(K
(()(F)#
(F'
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
C33 A#/ X;"7# J'((K# 4"$ 253 I3"$@
9 $2 "" 5# Kuram ve
Uygulamada Eğitim Yönetimi17JK()G(G#
$ +# J'(K# */ 4
/& J''('('K# Studies in Educatinal Evaluation
38GFF#
8#J'('K#*9 $2/ : $::;
33 5 <:;:: #Maltepe Üniversitesi,
İstanbul#
<"a#:-#?-#/A37#J'(K#*9/
$$:;::91<"5#Eğitim
ve Bilim39J(GFK#
8#?9-#4"::4#/9##J'(K#C9
"M"::$;:":;
<" 5 <:;:# 4"" =; (F X '( L.;"
B/.;"#
25 -# / ? 7# J''K# A/ U
*6I"$#Essays in Education,(#
X;"4# C5#=8#?::<?#4" D#/D:::D#
J''K# I3"$@" 9 "M ;:: 3
9#Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 19,F#
X;" 4# C5 # .$ C# ?" ?# =" U# ?::< I# /
V97#J''K#1"$:I3"$@"9"M
;:: 25 9# Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim
Bilimleri,())#
I U# D# J'(K# I& N
"& #School Leadership & Management32JK
(F(#
I#/X;-#J'(FK#*9$2:3
/::;5::; ;# Kuram ve Uygulamada
Eğitim Yönetimi [Educational Administration: Theory and Practice]
19JK'(#
I#?9*#=";0#/D<:-#J'(K#I3"$@9
$2 3? /.$ *9D2
A ''F'(F$$:::#Kuram ve Uygulamada
Eğitim Yönetimi [Educational Administration: Theory and Practice]
20J(KF((#
I#=";0#D<:-#/49D#J'()K#*9$2
: 33*9$2" 3/
3/35 9# Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim
Yönetimi, 22J(K(('#
.; 0# / .5 =# J''K# -" 9 ;: /
9 ''''')$:: :# İlköğretim Online 7JFK )(
))#
B39 A# 4# J'(FK# I3"$! $ / 29 "M
9 :" $3"" 5 ;:
9#Eğitim Teknolojisi Kuram ve Uygulama3(1),G(#
(F(
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
W:;9 =# X 4# / 82"; D# J'(FK# I3"< 9
;:: 9#Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim
Bilimleri13(3),(G)G(G(#
D<:-#J'(K#=:"$": I3"""3*9
$2 :: 9# D$::; A" I5#
*"; + 5 B/ *9 = *33
*";#
D<:#=#?50#/D<:C#J''K#73/
9 "3 $$: " 9 1<"
5# The First International Congress of Educational Research,
Çanakkale, )#
D::: 4# / X;" 7# J'()K# $ ;:
$2J('#=":K4"<"D$:::"#
D:5?#J'(K#I3"$@"9$2: <:;
; ":;# Journal of Human Sciences, 15J(K (F(#
('#()GLM#/((#FF
Extended English Summary
Introduction
+ / $
#*
#*
/$
JV?3<3"''K#4
- J'''K &
$/
$$$5#`
/
" $ /
#I
$ O$$
J?9 ''K# M I"$ &
] $ L J<"
?:A3'(I?9=";D<:
'(?$0:;":'(F82";'(V;83
25*9 :'('D<:=?5D<:''
4:" I" '' " '' 83 4 ''
25?''K#
4
# 6 / ]$
$$ #/
"
/ /
# M O"$
(F
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
$#I
/M#7&/
O$M#=
M J4:"
I"''K#M
.>4?=1- $/ O
/ #
M I6 A$ .>4?=1-% *$ *
, - ./$ * 0$ , 123 ./$
*0$,4"5*6,7
./$ *0$, 85./$ * 0$
, , 7 N#
M&'(
'()
ML N
5 $ 5
$O&$5$
/$#IM.>4?=1-/
//
#/$&
/ /
M.>4?=1-&'('()#
Method
e/&#I
& /&# 4 /&
//$5 &
/ / JD:::X;"'()K#
.>4?=1-% 85 ./$
* 0$ , 7 ./$ * 0$
, 4"5* 6, $* +
, 123 ./$ * 0$ , - ./$
* 0$ , 7 ,
*5 ./$ * 0$ , '( '()
F
&N#PU0P/$
25?D;J'(K&#I
& $5 $ / $#
*DI*(*DI* *DI*F /#* &
$N N
$ O
& M ]# 0
&&&M
$#0 /
$ / # =
&$$#
(FF
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
I &
& / # /$
/#
Results
M
.>4?=1-&$5
&NO$
#
` N M
* -
*$ M
J \ (#(QK# 4 4 J \ ' )#QK
J \ ( #QK &# `
&N
&J\()F)FQK&
$O/J\F#QKN$J\
((#QK#` M N
55&
((''J\FG)#(QK&$'(F''J\FFF#(QK#
I J \ ( #GQK #
4&&" & J\Q'#K
J \ Q ('#K # I O$
& /$L J \ ()F)QK/&J\ )G
#QK J \ ( )#QK# I $
ON%J\('(#(QKJ\
G'(#QK4+W4J\('#QK#
#I
$ #
J\((#QK&&
N&$(&J\)(#(QKF&
J\F(QK#&&
]-*=J\)((#)QK#123./$J\G#)QK
U$ ./$ J \ #QK &
/-*=/$#
Conclusion, Discussion and Recommendations
$ $5& $
I6 A$ .>4?=1-% 1"29 + ,
-./$*0$,123./$*
0$,4"5*6,7./$
* 0$ , 85 ./$ * 0$ ,
*5./$*0$,,
7 '('() % $
5 5 $
O#
(F
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
M
MNPP#
835D/5J'()K=U&J'(KC33X;"
J'((K7 J'(FK5M
PPN#I
&
5 /
$&
]/%&"
#&"
/ M *
#
$$
MNO/#
82";#J'(K?94"::9J'(K
$ J'(K V9 4$: J''K 4:" I" J''K
.; .5J''K O/
#IMN
&N/$O/
&O/#I"
N%/$/
$ $5 O/$ O/$
$ " # e/ "
/$
&$#O/
JU&''FK#I"
O/ & /
/ O&$
$]/#0/
/ $N
/$/$#
M N
5& &5
N((''#I&$5&
((''
O"$# 82"; # J'(K /$
NF((''('(F''
# &"
& #
N&]
/ %&/
#%
/$
$$
/ &
(F
79 8# C5" 7::9 D# H I" # I# J'(K# I3"$! 9 $2
:""$2"<"5#Journal of Human Sciences15JK
(F)(F'#('#()GLM#/(#()
$ /
#=; C5 9::J'(GK% 82"; #
J'(K/&/$
/N#
] $
/&" #
`$5 $
$J)QK/&J#QK&$
#<"#J'(K82"<"#J'(FK
#J'(KV;J'(KB39J'(FK483J''K
X;"#J''K82";#J'(K
/&#
$
$" M/
$ /& $ J<"
:?A3'(K#
/]/&#
$$
& /# I $ $
& / $ J(#(QK J(#QK 4+W4
J('#QK#X;"#J''K4:"I3"J''KW:;9#
J'(FKD<:#J''K=";J'(FKA9J'('K
/OJQ#K
$#
#
N/$O
&N #I
/$O$5 $
#
` N
&(#I&&
#Q# 4 83J''K +5
?2 J'(K &
$#-
& / &#
/ &&&"#0/
&"& & &
#
` N
$-+*J((#)QK#
& / !
$
&" -+*#
(F)
