ArticlePublisher preview available

Forty-Five Years of LIS Research Evolution, 1971–2015: An Informetrics Study of the Author-Supplied Keywords

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract and Figures

This article sought to investigate the evolution of library and information science by tracking the author-supplied keywords in the research articles published in the domain between 1971 and 2015. Data was extracted from Thomson Reuters’ citation mainstream indexes and analysed using the VosViewer computer-aided software to obtain author-supplied keyword frequencies in each decade since 1971. We identified the most salient and common research themes in LIS and how the themes have evolved, by delving into the author-supplied keywords to proxy research themes in the field domain. Results indicate that the field of LIS has evolved in terms of its subject focus from information systems design and management in the 1970s to scientific communication, information storage and retrieval, information access, information and knowledge management, and user education in 2015. The application of ICTs in LIS practice and education, too, has emerged as a prominent topic in the field. These issues have the potential of shaping or have shaped the LIS curriculum in some LIS schools in the continent.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol:.(1234567890)
Publishing Research Quarterly (2018) 34:456–470
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12109-018-9590-3
1 3
Forty‑Five Years ofLIS Research Evolution, 1971–2015:
AnInformetrics Study oftheAuthor‑Supplied Keywords
OmwoyoBosireOnyancha1
Published online: 21 June 2018
© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2018
Abstract
This article sought to investigate the evolution of library and information science
by tracking the author-supplied keywords in the research articles published in the
domain between 1971 and 2015. Data was extracted from Thomson Reuters’ citation
mainstream indexes and analysed using the VosViewer computer-aided software to
obtain author-supplied keyword frequencies in each decade since 1971. We identi-
fied the most salient and common research themes in LIS and how the themes have
evolved, by delving into the author-supplied keywords to proxy research themes in
the field domain. Results indicate that the field of LIS has evolved in terms of its
subject focus from information systems design and management in the 1970s to sci-
entific communication, information storage and retrieval, information access, infor-
mation and knowledge management, and user education in 2015. The application
of ICTs in LIS practice and education, too, has emerged as a prominent topic in the
field. These issues have the potential of shaping or have shaped the LIS curriculum
in some LIS schools in the continent.
Keywords Library and information science· Research· Social network analysis·
Co-occurrence analysis· Informetrics, keywords
Introduction
Ke etal. [19] have observed that there is an increase in interest to understand the
dynamics and characteristics of scientific production and the evolution of science.
To that end, Chang etal. [5] opine that exploring research trends in a discipline
facilitates a deeper understanding of the development of the discipline. On their part,
Goldfinch and Yamamoto [13, 8] offer the basis of such an exploration by stating
that “disciplines themselves are unstable and change over time”. Similar sentiments
* Omwoyo Bosire Onyancha
onyanob@unisa.ac.za
1 Department ofInformation Science, University ofSouth Africa, Unisa, PO Box392,
Pretoria0003, SouthAfrica
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... • Subject specialization index, mostly used to assess the concentration of research in given topics, fields, or disciplines (e.g. UNESCO, 2015;Davis, 1983;Pouris and Pouris, 2009;Onyancha, 2018). ...
... The trend of research on ICTs has accelerated in the recent past, and more particularly in the latter part of the 2011-2020 decade. For instance, a study conducted by Onyancha (2018) noted that ICTs has emerged as one of the leading topics of research in the library and information science field. Onyancha's (2018) study revealed that research on different ICTs has continued to dominate LIS research. ...
... For instance, a study conducted by Onyancha (2018) noted that ICTs has emerged as one of the leading topics of research in the library and information science field. Onyancha's (2018) study revealed that research on different ICTs has continued to dominate LIS research. Knowledge management, too, has emerged as a hot research topic having emerged from nowhere so to speak to rank the 2nd in the top 20 author supplied keywords in 2011-2015 (see Onyancha 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
The application of information and communication technologies (ICTs) in information and knowledge management (IKM) has attracted the attention of library and information Science (LIS) scholars in the recent past. The multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary nature of ICTs means that the ICT literature is published in several fields of knowledge. Although Bradford’s law of dispersion is commonly used to determine the core journals in a given field or discipline or topic of study, this study attempts to use the principles of the law to determine the core concepts of ICTs within the information and knowledge management literature. Data was obtained from EBSCO Discovery’s Library, Information Science and Technology Abstracts (LISTA) and the Library and Information Science Source (LISS) databases using a variety of keywords as search terms. The procedures of conducting a Bradford analysis were followed to determine the core subject terms in ICTs as reflected in the IKM group of articles published between 1998 and 2017. The results indicate that the application of ICTs in IKM largely occurs in the fields medicine, business and commerce, education and training (higher education and training), decision sciences, and industrial management. It was also noted that the core subjects varied from one study period to another; technology-associated subject terms were largely visible; and the dispersion of subject terms fits the Bradford’s dispersion. We however noted that the dispersion of articles according to Bradford’s zones is not accurately representative of the principles of the Law. The study has implications for collection development, searching and retrieval practices, and the application of Bradford’s law beyond the analysis of core journals or publications in not only IKM but also in the field of library and information science.
... Similarly, Li et al. (2019) noted a shift in LIS research from the ordering of information to the digging and application of information value. Other areas that were highly researched as observed in many existing studies (Dora and Kumar, 2020;Garg and Sharma, 2017;Li et al., 2019;Onyancha, 2018;Sa and Dora, 2019;Ukwoma and Ngulube, 2023) include information storage and retrieval, social media, information systems, information behavior, bibliometric and webometrics, scientific evaluation, and knowledge management. Other areas that received the attention of many LIS researchers include information technology, management of library and information centers, and library and information service activities (Naseer and Mahmood, 2014). ...
... The study shows that despite the increasing attention given to scientific and professional communication, as well as the growing interest in LIS context, LIS Studies, LIS service activities, and information storage and retrieval, there has been a noticeable decline in research interest concerning the information-seeking research domain. The growing interest in the aforementioned research domains has also been noticed in previous research (Dora and Kumar, 2020;Onyancha, 2018;Sa and Dora, 2019). The diminishing interest in information-seeking research indicates a noteworthy change in the research focus of researchers in LIS field in Tanzania, as they increasingly explore other research domains. ...
Article
This study aimed to analyze the trends in library and information science (LIS) research in Tanzania from 1990 to 2023. A descriptive research design utilizing a content analysis approach was employed to analyze data sourced from Google Scholar during the specified period. The study identified an overall fluctuating trend in LIS research, with a shift in research focus from information-seeking to other areas within the LIS domain. The predominant methodologies observed in most LIS studies were descriptive research design and a mixed methods approach. The study further highlighted a dynamic pattern in research collaboration, albeit with limited international collaboration. Additionally, there was a noticeable underrepresentation of female researchers in the LIS field, as evidenced by the scarcity of publications authored solely by women. The University of Dar es Salaam, Sokoine University of Agriculture, and Mzumbe University emerged as the top three institutions contributing to LIS research. While most LIS researchers published their work in the University of Dar es Salaam Library journal, there was a growing tendency to also publish in other similar international journals. Overall, this study contributes to the existing literature on LIS research trends, emphasizing the evolving nature of LIS research in Tanzania. It also underscores the importance of Tanzanian LIS researchers to actively seek international collaborations to enhance the impact of their research and further advance the field on a global scale.
... La evolución temática dentro de un campo se puede abordar desde dos enfoques principales: modelos bibliométricos y modelización de temas (Song et al. 2014). A su vez, los modelos bibliométricos se basan en diversos elementos como las palabras, los autores, las revistas o las citas en un corpus de textos (Han 2020;Onyancha 2018;Chang et al. 2015). ...
... Cuando se opta por las palabras como los elementos de los documentos que permiten dar a conocer los temas presentes en un corpus y su evolución temporal, se emplean diversas técnicas, desde las palabras clave más frecuentes hasta su aparición simultánea o su distribución por temas o en ciertos ciclos de tiempo (Onyancha 2018;Peset et al. 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
El campo de las redes sociales ha sufrido importantes transformaciones en los últimos veinticinco años, en particular con la introducción de aplicaciones y plataformas digitales, así como la incorporación de estudios de otros campos del conocimiento que adoptan el enfoque de redes sociales en sus análisis. Este artículo ofrece una visión general de la evolución de los tópicos de investigación en este ámbito entre 1997 y 2021 a partir de la modelización de temas. El estudio parte de la producción académica que se recupera de la base de datos Scopus, considerando ventanas temporales de un año y utilizando el software Mallet. Se obtienen siete temas, cuya evolución en el tiempo se describe. Se concluye que los temas relacionados con los medios de comunicación social, así como las redes sociales en línea son estudiados con especial intensidad en los últimos años.
... Infometrics has generally gained increased attention among scholars from a variety of disciplines as a common scientific research design in education, research and trend analysis (Qiu et al., 2017;4). Its uptake in the recent past has propelled informetrics to rank among the top-ranking topics in library and information science (LIS) research (see Chang et al., 2015;Onyancha and Majanja, 2017;Onyancha, 2018;White, 2010). Apart from its use to resolve some methodological issues in the research process and improve the scientific accuracy of quantitative analysis of information from a theoretical point of view (Qiu et al., 2017), informetrics informs policies and decisions across a broad range of fields, from economy to politics and to social issues that influence the flow and use patterns of information (Maluleka and Onyancha, 2016). ...
Article
Purpose The ranking of universities and other research-intensive institutions in global ranking systems is based on numerous indicators, including number of articles with external collaboration, number of articles with international collaboration, number of articles with industry collaboration as well as co-patents with industry. The purpose of this paper is to examine university–industry research collaboration in Ghana, with the aim of exploring the relationship between the research output collaborations in the top four universities in Ghana and industry across different geographical scales. Design/methodology/approach This study’s data was obtained from the SciVal database, which drawn its data from the Scopus bibliographic and citation database. The bibliographic and citation data were extracted using a search of the publications affiliated to the University of Ghana, for the period 2011–2020. Findings Key findings demonstrate a constant rise in the number of research publications by the selected universities over time. Research collaboration intensity in the selected universities in terms of co-authored publications was higher as compared to single-authored publications. University–industry research co-authorships were, however, lower when compared to university–university research co-authorships. The university–industry research co-authorships occurred mostly with Europe, Asia-Pacific and North American-based institutions as opposed to African-based institutions. In Ghana, four industry-based institutions were engaged in intensive research with the selected universities. Originality/value This study demonstrates that, for each selected university, it is possible to measure the performance of individual universities in both intra-regional and international collaboration. Such results may be useful in informing policy as well as merit-based public funding of universities in Ghana.
... It was found that 61.24% of documents included author-supplied keywords, indicating that their provision has not consistently been a requirement in published applied linguistics research, mirroring other disciplines (Mao et al. 2018;Onyancha 2018). As can be seen from Table 2 outlines the frequencies and distributions of the retrieved research documents that included various quantities of author-supplied keywords. ...
Book
This volume explains how scientometrics can be used in understanding the research studies in applied linguistics and will assist applied linguists to examine different aspects of the research performed in their field. The book covers a diachronic and synchronic empirical analysis of research practices, concepts, and phenomena in applied linguistics. It builds upon the ideas and experience of international researchers and provides the reader with creative methods to apply the scientometric principles in their applied research. Aimed at emerging applied linguistics researchers, researcher-practitioners, and MA and PhD students, this book provides a wealth of research ideas for further analysis, to strengthen the knowledge of the field, and to help digest research practices, research publications, research trends, research policies, and research methods. The book will also be useful for the well-established applied linguistics researchers who are interested in a reconceptualization of the field.
... Since keywords are not limited to predetermined categories, as they can be freely selected by the authors, they permit readers to make certain that the research article is relevant and support editors and research databases in enhancing the relatedness of articles on a specific topic (Hartley & Kostoff, 2003). Furthermore, keywords selected by authors have been shown to be useful for understanding a discipline (Li, 2018;Onyancha, 2018;Xu et al., 2018), even though Tsai et al. (2011) have shown that expert authors tend to select keywords that better represent the content of their article compared to those chosen by novices. ...
Article
Full-text available
Since the borders of disciplines change over time and vary across communities and geographies, they can be expressed at different levels of granularity, making it challenging to find a broad consensus about the measurement of interdisciplinarity. This study contributes to this debate by proposing a journal specialization index based on the level of repetitiveness of keywords appearing in their articles. Keywords represent one of the most essential items for filtering the vast amount of research available. If chosen correctly, they can help to identify the central concept of the paper and, consequently, to couple it with manuscripts related to the same field or subfield of research. Based on these universally recognized features of article keywords, the study proposes measuring the specialization of a journal by counting the number of times that a keyword is Queryrepeated in a journal on average ( Sj ). The basic assumption underlying the proposal of a journal specialization index is that the keywords may approximate the article’s topic and that the higher the number of papers in a journal based on a topic, the higher the level of specialization of that journal. The proposed specialization metric is not invulnerable to a set of limitations, among which the most relevant seems to be the lack of a standard practice regarding the number and consistency of keywords appearing in each article.
... Nine main topics were identified: bibliometrics, scientometrics and informetrics, citation analysis, IR, information behavior, libraries, user studies, social network analysis, information visualization and webometrics. Onyancha (2016) explored the evolution of LIS using author-supplied keywords in research articles between 1971 and 2015. Data were collected from Web of Science in the research area "Information Science Library Science". ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This paper analyses the research in Library and Information Science (LIS) and reports on (1) the status of LIS research in 2015 and (2) on the evolution of LIS research longitudinally from 1965 to 2015. Design/methodology/approach The study employs a quantitative intellectual content analysis of articles published in 30+ scholarly LIS journals, following the design by Tuomaala et al. (2014). In the content analysis, we classify articles along eight dimensions covering topical content and methodology. Findings The topical findings indicate that the earlier strong LIS emphasis on L&I services has declined notably, while scientific and professional communication has become the most popular topic. Information storage and retrieval has given up its earlier strong position towards the end of the years analyzed. Individuals are increasingly the units of observation. End-user's and developer's viewpoints have strengthened at the cost of intermediaries' viewpoint. LIS research is methodologically increasingly scattered since survey, scientometric methods, experiment, case studies and qualitative studies have all gained in popularity. Consequently, LIS may have become more versatile in the analysis of its research objects during the years analyzed. Originality/value Among quantitative intellectual content analyses of LIS research, the study is unique in its scope: length of analysis period (50 years), width (8 dimensions covering topical content and methodology) and depth (the annual batch of 30+ scholarly journals).
Chapter
Applied linguists are increasingly looking to bibliometric analyses for top-down insights into the rapidly expanding and diversifying body of literature and to stay abreast of research trends in order to make informed decisions about what issues to research. Authors’ choices of keywords play an important role in conveying the topic of a research article, yet recent applied linguistics bibliometric analyses have largely ignored them. This study examines the author-provided keywords of 23,481 research articles across 42 high-ranking applied linguistics publications during three intervals between 2001 and 2021. It identifies (1) the prevalence of author-supplied keywords, (2) their lengths (measured in words), (3) syntactic structural patterns (e.g., noun + noun), (4) constituent word classes (e.g., noun, adjective, preposition), and, (5) the most frequent research topics as measured by keywords from authors and abstracts. The study found increasing standardisation in the provision of author keywords across research articles, especially combinations of four to six keywords that heavily featured nouns and adjectives in one to three-word phrases. The study identified several themes among topics of enduring, rising, and falling prevalence, although a notable divergence was exhibited between keywords from authors and abstracts. The implications for future bibliometric analyses that investigate research topics and other meta-research that utilises author-assigned keywords are discussed.
Article
Previous investigations into trends in Library and Information Science literature have revealed changes in the topics librarians publish on over time, with older studies highlighting classification and indexing, and information retrieval and more recent studies highlighting keywords such as Internet, information technology, digital libraries, and again, information retrieval. No similar investigation has been conducted on current publication trends by health sciences librarians. This study analyzes the top themes on which health sciences librarians published from 2016 to 2020 by examining the frequency of keywords. Keywords and subject headings were analyzed from The Journal of the Medical Library Association, Medical References Services Quarterly, The Journal of Hospital Librarianship, and The Journal of Electronic Resources in Medical Libraries. A total of 8,806 keywords were downloaded for analysis and organized into 292 categories during taxonomy creation. The ten most frequent themes were: libraries, information, education, humans, demography, librarian, geographical locations, research, electronic resources, and technology. The study also found that data, psychiatry and psychology, informatics, and publishing were other key themes, indicating that health sciences librarians are publishing on a wide range of topics. Some keywords that appeared only once, such as telecommuting and flexible staffing, suggest emerging areas of research for librarians.
Article
The study assessed the research pattern of postgraduate students in the field of Library and Information Science (LIS) in Tanzania. Covering a span of 17 years, the study used content analysis to study and identify research areas postgraduate students studied. In all, 269 dissertations were evaluated for the 2000–2017 period. Most of the dissertations (n = 247; 92%) were for the Master's degree and the least (n = 22; 8%) for doctoral studies, with the majority of LIS graduates being male. The study findings show that user studies accounted for the most researched upon (n = 67; 24.9%) area by postgraduate students in Tanzania followed by information industry economics and management (n = 45;16.7%), information/learning society (n = 37;13.7%), diffusion studies (n = 36;13.3%) and finally, information technology (n = 32; 11.9%). The least covered research areas were methodology, information ethics and law. Implicitly, the students preferred user-studies centred research followed by technology. The study concludes no direct association between gender, level of education, year of study and students’ choice of research themes except for information technology. It is recommended that students ought to be exposed to new LIS global research trends for enhanced and broadened research areas to materialise.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The present study aims to examine the obsolescence of literature in Library and Information Science. It is based on the citations of LIS theses submitted to Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha Library Punjabi University Patiala during the period 2000-2014. The half-life period of documents including journals and books has been calculated separately. It is concluded that the researchers use more of current periodical literature than books and other forms of documents. This study is useful for librarians and information scientists to manage their collection.
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents an empirical study of the evolutionary patterns of national disciplinary profiles in research using a dataset extracted from Scopus covering publications from 45 nations for the period 1996–2015. Measures of disciplinary specializations and statistical models are employed to examine the distribution of disciplinary specializations across nations, the patterns of structural changes in the world’s disciplinary profiles, and the evolutionary patterns of research profiles in individual nations. It is found that, while there has been a continuous process of convergence in national research profiles, nations differ greatly in their evolutionary patterns. Changes in national disciplinary profiles are decomposed into the regression effect and the mobility effect and both effects are analyzed for individual nations. The G7 and the BRICs countries are used as cases for the in-depth scrutiny. Policy implications based on the findings and directions for future research are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
We introduce the author keyword coupling analysis (AKCA) method to visualize the field of information science (2006-2015). We then compare the AKCA method with the author bibliographic coupling analysis (ABCA) method in terms of first- and all-author citation counts. We obtain the following findings: (1) The AKCA method is a new and feasible method for visualizing a discipline's structure, and the ABCA and AKCA methods have their respective strengths and emphases. The relation within the ABCA method is based on the same references (knowledge base), whereas that within the AKCA method is based on the same keywords (lexical linguistic). The AKCA method appears to provide a less detailed picture, and more uneven sub-areas of a discipline structure. The relationships between authors are narrow and direct and feature multiple levels in AKCA. (2) All-author coupling provides a comprehensive picture; thus, a complete view of a discipline structure may require both first- and all-author coupling analyses. (3) Information science evolved continuously during the second decade of the World Wide Web. The KDA (knowledge domain analysis) camp became remarkably prominent, while the IR camp (information retrieval) experienced a further decline in hard IR research, and became significantly smaller; Patent analysis and Open Access emerged during this period. Mapping of Science and Bibliometric evaluation also experienced substantial growth.
Book
An essential resource for LIS master's and doctoral students, new LIS faculty, and academic librarians, this book provides expert guidance and practical examples based on current research about quantitative and qualitative research methods and design. Conducting research and successfully publishing the findings is a goal of many professionals and students in library and information science (LIS). Using the best methodology maximizes the likelihood of a successful outcome. This outstanding book broadly covers the principles, data collection techniques, and analyses of quantitative and qualitative methods as well as the advantages and limitations of each method to research design. It addresses these research methods and design by discussing the scientific method, sampling techniques, validity, reliability, and ethical concerns along with additional topics such as experimental research design, ethnographic methods, and usability testing. The book presents comprehensive information in a logical, easy-to-follow format, covering topics such as research strategies for library and information science doctoral students; planning for research; defining the problem, forming a theory, and testing the theory; the scientific method of inquiry and data collection techniques; survey research methods and questionnaires; analyzing quantitative data; interview-based research; writing research proposals; and even time management skills. LIS students and professionals can consult the text for instruction on conducting research using this array of tools as well as for guidance in critically reading and evaluating research publications, proposals, and reports. The explanations and current research examples supplied by discipline experts offer advice and strategies for completing research projects, dissertations, and theses as well as for writing grants, overcoming writer's block, collaborating with colleagues, and working with outside consultants. The answer to nearly any question posed by novice researchers is provided in this book.
Article
This study provides an overview of the knowledge management literature from 1980 through 2014. We employ bibliometric and text mining analyses on a sample of 500 most cited articles to examine the impact of factors such as number of authors, references, pages, and keywords on the number of citations that they received. We also investigate major trends in knowledge management literature including the contribution of different countries, variations across publication years, and identifying active research areas and major journal outlets. Our study serves as a resource for future studies by shedding light on how trends in knowledge management research have evolved over time and demonstrating the characteristics of the most cited articles in this literature. Specifically, our results reveal that the most cited articles are from United States and United Kingdom. The most prolific year in terms of the number of published articles is 2009 and in terms of the number of citations is 2012. We also found a positive relationship between the number of publications’ keywords, references, and pages and the number of citations that they have received. Finally, the Journal of Knowledge Management has the largest share in publishing the most cited articles in this field.
Article
Through psychotherapy manuals, Short Term Psychotherapy has introduced psychodynamic techniques into those currently used in Public-Health Services, although important factors to do with patient-therapist interaction and therapeutic expertise have, until now, not been brought to light. However government subventioned research programs must, in accordance with professional and scientific principles, take into account social, economic and political priorities in seeking mainly to promote effectiveness of results among the majority of patients. The author develops these topics, exposing related methodology, and outlines future perspectives.
Article
This book examines the problems, pitfalls and opportunities of different models of assessing research quality, drawing on studies from around the world. Aimed at academics, education officials and public servants, key features include an overview of the argument of whether research should be assessed and how research quality should be determined. Prometheus Assessed? offers a survey of research assessment models in the US, UK, Japan and New Zealand and includes an examination of citation analysis and comparison between the different models.