ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Ahmed Body is a standard and simplified shape of a road vehicle that's rear part has an important role in flow structure and it's drag force. In this paper flow control around the Ahmed body with the rear slant angle of 25 • studied by using the plasma actuator system situated in middle of the rear slant surface. Experiments conducted in a wind tunnel in two free stream velocities of U = 10 m/s and U = 20 m/s using steady and unsteady excitations. Pressure distribution and total drag force was measured and smoke flow visualization carried out in this study. The results showed that at U = 10 m/s using plasma actuator suppress the separated flow over the rear slant slightly and be effective on pressure distribution. Also total drag force reduces in steady and unsteady excitations for 3.65% and 2.44%, respectively. At U = 20 m/s, using plasma actuator had no serious effect on the pressure distribution and total drag force.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Mechanics and Mechanical Engineering
Vol. 22, No. 1 (2018) 239–251
c
Lodz University of Technology
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body Using
Plasma Actuator
S. Shadmani
S. M. Mousavi Nainiyan
R. Ghasemiasl
Department of Mechanical Engineering
West Tehran Branch
Islamic Azad University, Tehran
Iranmousavi.mojtaba@wtiau.ac.ir
M. Mirzaei
S. G. Pouryoussefi
Department of Aerospace Engineering
K. N. Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
Received (18 September 2017)
Revised (14 October 2017)
Accepted (18 November 2017)
Ahmed Body is a standard and simplified shape of a road vehicle that’s rear part has an
important role in flow structure and it’s drag force. In this paper flow control around
the Ahmed body with the rear slant angle of 25studied by using the plasma actuator
system situated in middle of the rear slant surface. Experiments conducted in a wind
tunnel in two free stream velocities of U = 10 m/s and U = 20 m/s using steady and
unsteady excitations. Pressure distribution and total drag force was measured and smoke
flow visualization carried out in this study. The results showed that at U = 10 m/s using
plasma actuator suppress the separated flow over the rear slant slightly and be effective
on pressure distribution. Also total drag force reduces in steady and unsteady excitations
for 3.65% and 2.44%, respectively. At U = 20 m/s, using plasma actuator had no serious
effect on the pressure distribution and total drag force.
Keywords: automotive, aerodynamics, wind tunnel, plasma actuator, Ahmed body.
1. Introduction
Increasing growth of the number of road transportation vehicles and hence fossil
fuel consumption have raised air pollution level to alert status in many cities [1]. In
this regard, considering international policies for reducing the consumption of fuels
and greenhouse gases generated by motor vehicles, researchers in the field of car
aerodynamics have tried to minimize the resisting force generated as air flow hits
the vehicles. The lower amount of this force (known as drag force), the lower will be
240 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
its fuel consumption and pollutant emission [2]. This force can only be controlled
by accurate characterization of the flow pattern.
Since experimental study of flow control accurately and comprehensively is an
expensive and time-intensive practice due to differences in their apparent structures,
and the fact that, it is not reasonable to generalize the results of such studies to
other cases, it will be a useful practice to present a simple and standard model of
a vehicle with similar flow pattern to that of an actual car [3]. Therefore, a model
known as Ahmed body model [3] is referred to which resembles three-dimensional
flow pattern of an actual car due to the rear slant angle behind that (Fig. 1).
Figure 1 Flow pattern behind the Ahmed body model at rear slant angle of 25[3]
In research works, active and passive flow controls were adopted in the tailing
section of the model in an attempt to modify the flow in this region and reduce the
drag force applied to the model. Installation of various types of deflectors [4, 5] is
the passive flow control method which require no external energy [4]. Uncontrollable
performance is a disadvantage of this method [6]. Active control methods such as
mixed jets [6], pulse jets [7] and fluidic oscillators [8] are paid attention because of
their controllable nature which allows them to be turned on/off on demand. Results
of these methods in terms of reducing the drag force applied to Ahmed model are
given in Table 1.
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 241
Table 1 Results of the research on the reduction of drag force
Drag Reduction (%) Reynolds Number Studies
9.3-10.7 8.7×105Hanfeng et al. [4]
9 3.1-7.7×105Fourrie et al. [5]
6.5-8.5 1.2×106Kourtaa et al. [6]
6-8 1.4×106Joseph et al. [7]
7.5 1.4×106Metka et al. [8]
Dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma actuator is another modern tool for
active flow control which is used in aviation applications. As can be observed in
Figure 2, a plasma actuator is composed of two electrodes separated by a dielectric
barrier, whereby air molecules above the insulated electrode is ionized by establish-
ing a strong electric field. Known as plasma, this ionized gas extends from the edge
of the upper exposed electrode to the tailing edge of the lower insulated electrode,
and adds up local momentum to the flow passing above the region by colliding
moving charged particles to other neutral particles of the background gas [9].
Figure 2 DBD plasma actuator mechanism
These actuators have found many applications in separation control on airfoils
[10-12], and flow control on bluff bodies [13-17].
In automobile aerodynamics, Khalighi et al. 2016 [18] installed plasma actuators
on the four edges of an Ahmed body at rear slant angle of 0to analyze passing
flow from the tailing part of a model and showed that drag force decreases by 21.4%
at 10m/s velocity, while the reduction at 20m/s velocity is 2.8%.
In the present research, flow control around an Ahmed body is experimentally
studied by using plasma actuator system that located on the middle of rear slant
surface. For this aim, investigating pressure distribution, drag force and observing
flow pattern was performed for the first time. Experiments carried out at Reynolds
numbers of Re = 4.5×105and Re = 9×105. In order to have the most complete
three-dimensional flow pattern and highest drag force [3], angle of rear slant selected
25(Fig. 3).
242 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
Figure 3 Plot of drag coefficient vs. slant angle (Ahmed et al. 1984)
2. Experimental details
Experiments were performed in the open circuit wind tunnel at K. N. Toosi Uni-
versity (Iran) with a cross sectional area of 1×1.2 m2and length of 3 m (Fig. 4).
Turbulence intensity of the flow was below 0.2% and non-uniformity of the flow
along the test section was about ±5%.
Figure 4 Used wind tunnel in this research
3. Model description
The model was constructed from 6mm-thick Plexiglas at 0.64 scale with respect to
the original model. As was mentioned before, in order to establish three-dimensional
flow behind the model and maximize the drag force obtained from flow separation,
the rear slant angle was considered to be 25. The model dimension was 671 ×250
×18.5 mm3(length ×width ×height), based on which one could calculate wind
tunnel section blockage ratio as 3.8%.
In order to eliminate the effects of boundary conditions on the bottom of the
wind tunnel, according to Fig. 5, the model was placed on a rectangular surface at
given spacing. The distance between surface and tunnel floor was 16×102m, with
the model connected to the surface via four cylindrical supports of the diameter
2×102m and height 32×102m. Moreover, leading edge of the surface was de-
signed sharply to minimize the thickness of the developed boundary layer on that.
Thickness of the boundary layer formed on the surface at flow velocities of 10 to
50 m/s was about 1.5×102m [6], so that the boundary layer on the surface has no
effect on the model.
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 243
Figure 5 Position of the model on the surface
4. Instruments and measurement techniques
Pressure distribution was obtained using 52 pressure sensors (pressure transducers)
installed on half of the slant and vertical surfaces of the model due to symmetry.
Arrangement of the sensors is demonstrated on Fig. 6. Each sensor was composed of
a tube of inner diameters of 2 mm, connected to a 28-channel pressure transducer
(Honeywell-DC005NDC4). The results were monitored on a computer using an
A/D (PCI6224) board, Lab view software, and Farasanjesh pressure distribution
software. Sampling interval was set to 5s and pressure coefficients were calculated
with the help of the Eq. 1:
Cp=PP
0.5×ρ×U2(1)
where Pis static pressure at any point on the model, Pis static pressure of
free flow, Uis the velocity of free flow, and ρis air density. Uncertainty of the
measurement device is about ±0.01.
The applied drag force to the model, which is exerted to the model along the
air flow, was determined using Load Cell.
Input voltage to the plasma actuator was supplied by a High-Voltage Altering
Current (A.C.) with sinusoidal carrier wave and maximum output electrical power
of 1000 W. Two digital multimeter sets were used to calculate actuation and carrier
frequencies, with the duty cycle and applied voltage been monitored by a (GW
INSTEK GDS-1072-U) oscilloscope. Furthermore, a digital multimeter (True RMS
MS8226T) was used to measure mean electrical current.
According to Fig. 7, the plasma actuator position is in such a way that, the
exposed and covered electrode are installed on the middle of slant, in an edge-to-
edge arrangement. The electrodes were made of copper, with their thickness being
50 microns. In terms of length, the electrodes were equal to the model width 25 cm,
with the widths of the open and covered electrodes being 5 and 15 mm, respectively.
In all arrangements, plasma actuator dielectric was composed of six layers of Capton
adhesive at breakdown voltage of 7 kV/mm and dielectric constant of 3.4.
244 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
Figure 6 Position of pressure sensors
Figure 7 Position of plasma electrodes
In static flow, installing a plasma actuator on flat surface, a digital manometer
(Testo 0560 5126) along with a silicon micro-tube were applied to determine maxi-
mum induced velocity based on the applied voltage, with the corresponding voltage
applied in all experiments identically. In Table 2, input electrical parameters of the
plasma actuator, which are used in all experiments on the model are presented.
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 245
Table 2 Input electrical parameters of plasma actuator
Duty cycle
(%)
Carrier fre-
quency (kHz)
Excitation fre-
quency (Hz)
Voltage
(kV)
Type Velocity
(m/s)
No.
100 10 - 6 Steady 10 1
50 10 20 6 Unsteady 10 2
100 10 - 6 Steady 20 3
50 10 40 6 Unsteady 20 4
5. Results and discussion
5.1. Pressure distribution
Three dimensional flow pattern and pressure difference between the regions in front
of and behind the model develop some compressive drag force on the model. Kra-
jnovic and Davidson [19] showed that, contribution of compressive drag force (Form
drag) into total drag is about 80%. This necessitates obtaining the pattern of pres-
sure variations across two end surfaces of the model to investigate the effect of flow
across the region.
Figure 8 Contours of pressure distribution on the rear slant of an Ahmed body in plasma off
mode at velocities of a) 10 m/s and b) 20 m/s
Fig. 8 shows contours of pressure coefficients distribution on the slant surface
behind the model prior to the installation of the plasma actuator at U = 10 m/s
(Re = 4.5×105) and U = 20 m/s (Re = 9×105), exhibiting agreement with the
results reported by Joseph et al. [7], Lienhart et al. [20] and Keogh et al. 2016 [21]
(Fig. 9).
According to Fig. 8, low-pressure regions of the flow extend along leading edge
of the slant, so that one can stipulate that, separation bubble and flow jump over
246 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
the leading edge of slant have resulted in the development of such regions. As one
moves toward central areas, the low-pressure zones are gradually replaced by zones
of more pressure, i.e. the pressure is recovered. Of the other regions where low-
pressure zones are developed on the surface, one may refer to lateral edges of the
surface, indicating the isolation of longitudinal vortices from the top corner of the
surface along the surface length (see Fig. 1).
Figure 9 Contours of pressure distribution on the rear slant of the Ahmed model in velocity of
20m/s and no actuation condition in the studies of: a) Keogh et al. [21]; b) Lienhart et al. [20];
c) Joseph et al. [7] and; d) Present study
Figure 10 Contours of pressure coefficient distribution on the rear slant of Ahmed body at the
velocity of 10 m/s in: a) Plasma Off, b) Steady actuation, and c) Unsteady actuation
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 247
As can be observed on Fig. 10, applying plasma actuation at the velocity of
U = 10 m/s, volume of the low-pressure zones on the leading edge of the surface
reduced, so that the region was much disappeared in steady state. This indicates
that, actuating the plasma, the developed vortex in this zone is degraded and the
separated flow tends to stick to the surface. This will be further observed in vi-
sualization tests. Moreover, a little reduction of low-pressure zones in the lateral
edges of the surface is indicative of reduced effect of longitudinal vortexes behind
the model. The effect of steady actuation was seen to be more significant than that
of unsteady actuation. Based on Fig. 11, at the velocity of U = 20 m/s, plasma
actuation imposed no significant effect on the reduction of low-pressure regions.
Figure 11 Contours of pressure coefficient distribution on the rear slant of Ahmed body at the
velocity of 20 m/s in a) Plasma Off, b) Steady actuation, and c) Unsteady actuation
Figure 12 Plot of pressure coefficient distribution on the centerline of the model at U = 10 m/s
and U = 20 m/s
248 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
Figs. 12 and 13 illustrate the plot of pressure distribution in no-actuation, steady
actuation, and unsteady actuation cases on the centerline and lateral edge of the
model at velocities 10 m/s and 20 m/s, respectively. Fig. 12 shows at the velocity
of 10 m/s, plasma actuation increased pressure coefficients, particularly across the
regions related to slant. This is while the effect of plasma actuator is insignificant at
the velocity of 20 m/s. Fig. 13 indicate that at velocity of 10 m/s, plasma actuator
modified and enhanced pressure coefficient diagram considerably. But as expected
at velocity of 20 m/s no significant effect occurred in diagram.
Figure 13 Plot of pressure coefficient distribution on the lateral edge of the model at velocities
of U = 10 m/s and U = 20 m/s
5.2. Drag measurement
Total drag force applied to the model is made up of compressive and frictional drag
forces applied to different regions of the model. Based on the pressure distribution
pattern on the tailing surfaces of the model (described in Section 3.3), negative
pressure gradient behind the model results in the formation of pressure difference
between the leading and tailing zones, ending up exerting compressive drag force
onto the model. The frictional force is a result of the friction and direct collision of
the air flow with lateral, lower, and upper surfaces of the model. Proposing some
relationships, Thacker et al. [11] specified the contribution from each of the two
forces into the overall force applied to model.
In the present research, total drag force applied to the model was measured
using Load cell. Prior to applying plasma actuation, the drag force applied to the
model was found to be equal to 0.8 N at Re = 4.5×105(U=10m/s) and 3.22 N at
Re = 9×105(U = 20m/s). Since drag force is directly proportional to the velocity
squared, it can be observed that, doubling the velocity applies a force of four times
as large to the model. Considering the relationship for drag force base on Eq. 2,
drag coefficient of the model was found to be 0.29, which is in agreement with the
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 249
results reported in Ahmed et al. [4] (see Fig. 3).
Cd=FD
0.5×ρ×A×U2(2)
where U is free flow velocity, Ais effective cross-sectional area in front view, and ρ
is air density in experimental conditions
Base on Fig. 14, applying plasma actuation at the velocity of 10 m/s, the values
of drag force reduced by about 3.65% and 2.44% in steady and unsteady actuations,
respectively. This is while, at the velocity of 20 m/s, the reduction of drag force in
steady and unsteady actuations reached 0.91%. The results indicate that, at lower
velocities, particularly in steady actuation, the plasma actuator can reduce overall
drag force applied to the model more considerably. Considering the fact that the
dominant drag force in the Ahmed model is pressure drag, the results obtained from
drag force measurement using Load cell exhibit good agreement with the pressure
measurement results.
Figure 14 Plot of drag reduction
5.3. Flow visualization
Considering the results obtained in previous sections indicating proper performance
of plasma actuator at lower velocities, in this section, the smoke flow visualization at
velocity of U = 10 m/s across tailing section of the model was visualized. According
to Fig. 15a, in Plasma off mode, the air flow separates from the surface as it passes
over the leading edge of the rear slant, developing a vortex on the slant surface.
Moreover, with the help of the flow passing through the lower part of the model,
a larger vortex is formed behind the vertical surface of the model. As can be
observed in Figs 15b and 15c, the plasma actuator somewhat suppresses the flow
passing over the surface edge by actuating shear layer, and the separated flow from
the slant surface gets closer to the surface. It is more sensible in steady actuation.
250 Shadmani, S., Mousavi Nainiyan, S. M., Ghasemiasl, R., Mirzaei, M. ...
Figure 15 Pattern of the flow passing through the region behind the model at U = 10 m/s in
different actuations: a) Plasma off, b) Steady actuation, and c) Unsteady actuation
6. Conclusion
In the present research, a plasma actuator was used to study flow control around
an Ahmed body with a rear slant angle of 25. Plasma actuator electrodes were
installed on the middle of the rear slant surface and actuations were performed in
steady and unsteady actuations at different Reynolds numbers and flow velocities
of U = 10 m/s and U = 20 m/s.
Visualization results indicate that, at U = 10 m/s the plasma actuator is capable
of suppressing the flow separated from the leading edge of rear slant and sticking it
back to the surface by actuating the shear layer. In this case, volume of longitudinal
vortexes behind the model is reduced while increasing pressure coefficient on the
slant at the same time. With reducing the pressure difference between leading and
tailing sections of the model, compressive drag force and hence total drag force
decrease, so that the reduction of drag force in steady and unsteady actuations was
3.65% and 2.44%, respectively. At the velocity of U = 20 m/s, the results indicated
that, the plasma actuator may not significantly affect pressure enhancement on
ending surfaces of the model, with the reduction of drag force in both steady and
unsteady state actuations being about 1%. Therefore, application of the plasma
actuator at low velocities, particularly in steady actuation, can serve as an effective
tool for flow control and suppression of the drag force applied to the model.
References
[1] International Energy Agency (IEA) World energy outlook 2007—China and India
insights (execut. summary), International Energy Agency, ISBN:978-92-64-02730-5,
2007.
[2] Hucho, W.H.: Aerodynamic of road vehicles, Cambridge University Press., Cam-
bridge, 1998.
Experimental Study of Flow Control Over an Ahmed Body ... 251
[3] Ahmed, S.R., Ramm, G., Faitin, G.: Some salient features of the time-averaged
ground vehicle wake, SAE Technical Paper, No. 840300, 1984.
[4] Hanfeng, W., Yu, Z., Chao, Z., Xuhui, H.: Aerodynamic drag reduction of an
Ahmed body based on deflectors, J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn, 148, 34–44, 2016.
[5] Fourrie, G., Keirsbulck, L., Labraga, L., Gillieron, P.: Bluff-body drag reduc-
tion using a deflector, Exp Fluids, 50, 2, 2011, 385–395.
[6] Kourta, A., Leclerc, C.: Characterization of synthetic jet actuation with applica-
tion to Ahmed body wake, Sensors and Actuators A. 192, 13–26, 2012.
[7] Joseph, P., Amandolese, X., Aider, J.: Drag reduction on the 25slant angle
Ahmed reference body using pulsed jets, Exp. Fluids, 52, 2012, 1169–1185.
[8] Metka, M., Gregory, J. W.: Drag Reduction on the 25-deg Ahmed Model Using
Fluidic Oscillators, Journal of Fluids Engineering, ASME, 137, 051108-1, 2015.
[9] He, C., Corke, T.C., Patel, M.P.: Numerical and Experimental Analysis of
Plasma Flow Control Over a Hump Model, 45th Aerospace Sciences Meeting. AIAA
paper, 2007-0935, 2007.
[10] Post, M.L., Corke, T.C.: Separation Control on a High Angle of Attack Airfoil
Using Plasma Actuators, AIAA Journal, 42, 2177–2184, 2004.
[11] Benard, N., Braud, P., Jolibois, J.: Airflow Reattachment Along a NACA 0015
Airfoil by Surface SDBD Actuator-Time Resolved PIV Investigation, AIAA Paper,
2008-4202, 2008.
[12] Puoryoussefi, S.G., Mirzaei, M., Alinejad, F., Puoryoussefi, S.M.: Exper-
imental investigation of separation bubble control on an iced airfoil using plasma
actuator, Applied Thermal Engineering. 100, 1334-1341, 2016.
[13] Do, H., Kim, W., Mungal, M.O., Cappelli, M.A.: Bluff Body Flow Separation
Control Using Surface Dielectric Barrier Discharges. AIAA Paper, 2007-939, 2007.
[14] Thomas, F.O., Kozlov, A., Corke, T.C.: Plasma Actuators for Cylinder Flow
Control and Noise Reduction, AIAA Journal, 46, 1921-1931, 2008.
[15] Thomas, F.O., Kozlov, A., Corke, T.C.: Plasma Actuators for Landing Gear
Noise Control, AIAA Paper, 2005-3010, 2005.
[16] Rizzetta, D., Visbal, M.: Large-Eddy Simulation of Plasma-Based Control Strate-
gies for Bluff Body Flow, AIAA Paper, 2008-4197, 2008.
[17] Gregory, J., Porter, C., Sherman, D., McLaughlin, T.: Circular Cylinder Wake
Control Using Spatially Distributed Plasma Forcing, AIAA Paper, 2008-4198, 2008.
[18] Khalighi, B., Ho, J., Cooney, J., Neiswander, B., Han, T.: Aerodynamic
Drag Reduction Investigation for A Simplified Road Vehicle Using Plasma Flow Con-
trol, Proceedings of the ASME 2016 Fluids Engineering Division Summer Meeting,
FEDSM2016-7927, 2016.
[19] Krajnovic, S., Davidson, L.: Flow around a simplified car, Part 2: understanding
the Flow, J. Fluids Eng., 127, 919–928, 2005.
[20] Lienhart, H., Becker, S.: Flow and Turbulence Structure in The Wake of a Sim-
plified Car Model, SAE Technical Paper, 2003-1-0656, 2003.
[21] Keogh, J., Barber, T., Diasinos, S., Doig, G.: The aerodynamic effects on
a cornering Ahmed body, J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn., 154, 34–46, 2016.
[22] Thacker, A., Aubrun, S., Leroy, A., Devinant, P.: Effects of suppressing the
3D separation on the rear slant on the flow structures around an Ahmed body, J.
Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn., 107-108, 237–243, 2012.
... European motor industry has set a target to reduce actively the aerodynamic drag of vehicles by at least 30% without compromising the comfort, storage, or safety of passengers [8]. As a matter of fact, active control has attracted more and more attention in the past decades, with a variety of approaches studied, including steady blowing [9,10], spanwise alternately arranged steady suction and blowing [11,12], suction and oscillatory blowing [13], pulsed blowing combined with the Coanda effect [14,15], synthetic jet [16,17], and plasma actuator [18,19]. ...
... Joseph et al. [95] applied a spanwise array of pulsed have also been shown to be capable to eliminate the flow separation over the slanted surface [16,98,99], producing the drag reduction of 5-8%. Shadmani et al. [19] investigated both steady and unsteady dielectric barrier discharge plasma actuators placed near the upper edge of slanted surface (Fig. 16(i)) for Re ¼ (1.5-2.9)  10 5 and achieved the drag reductions by 7% and 5% for f à J ¼ 0 (steady) and 0.43, respectively. ...
Article
This is a compendium of recent progresses in the development of wake dynamics and active drag reduction of three-dimensional simple automotive models, largely focused on the generic Ahmed body. It covers our new understanding of involved instabilities, predominant frequencies, pressure distribution and unsteady flow structures in the high- (12.5° < f < 30°) and low-drag (f > 30°) bodies and the square-back body (f = 0°), where f is the rear slant angle of the body. Various drag reduction methods and their performances are reviewed, including open- and closed-loop controls along with machine-learning control. The involving drag reduction mechanisms, net saving and efficiencies are discussed. Comments are made for the areas that deserve more attention and future investigation.
... Even in idealize version, there are a lot of aerodynamic drag that will cause more consumption of energy and money. Pressure drag contribute up to 85% of the total drag on a basic Ahmed Body while the other remainder is friction drag med [1].Few flow patterns acting on Ahmed body are forebody separation bubble, c-pillar vortex, backlight, rear spanwise recirculation and lower vortex, these flow pattern can be seen in Figure 1(a) [2]. Finding few ways to decrease the drag force effect will be very beneficial. ...
Article
This study evaluates the drag reduction strategy of suction and blowing on idealize automotive vehicle, Ahmed Body. Optimization approach is adapted in order to analyse the effect of slot location, momentum coefficient and slot angle on the vehicle which experiencing drag. Despite all the efforts that have been done to reduce the Ahmed body drag using various active flow control system, most of the drag reduction were only less than 15%. A 25° Ahmed body with build in co-flow jet is modelled using a CAD software. The flow around the Ahmed body is simulated at Reynolds number based on length Re = 4.29 × 106. The governing equation were solve using an open source software package, which has been validated against experimental data. Pressure Implicit with Splitting of Operator (PISO) algorithm is applied to solve the equation. The outcome of the simulation are varies depending on the variables. Some show a decrease in drag while there are also that actually increase the drag of the system. This are caused by the suction and blowing slots that effect the surrounding air flow whether it is reducing or increasing the wake size downstream of the body. The result shows the momentum coefficient and location of both suction and blowing jet played an important role of manipulating the flow around the body and reducing the drag. The velocity contours indicated that the key to drag reduction is by using 40 m/s jet velocity, placement of suction and blowing away from each other.
... Generally, the voltage required to produce the same effect (body force) scales as the square of the free-stream velocity (momentum). These studies usually use Ahmed model and low airspeed is used such as by Shadmani et al., [12] that tested at 20 m/s. Besides car, plasma actuator also been tested for truck as reported by Vernet et al., [13] and they achieved similar result as Khalighi et al., [10] due to similar flatback configuration. ...
Article
Full-text available
Reducing aerodynamic drag in automobiles has been one of the focuses in automotive industry as it will increase vehicles performance and reduce power consumption which subsequently save the environment. Drag is a force that tend to pull the vehicle backwards. Pressure drag is the major contributor to drag of vehicle which caused by lower pressure in the rear area compared to front of vehicle. When vehicle moves forward, the stagnation point occurs in the front part of vehicle. The airflow then goes over the vehicle and separate at the back due to adverse pressure gradient. Thus, flow separation is created in the rear area of vehicle as indicated by the wake. Wake is a low-pressure region that need to be reduced so that the pressure between the front and rear could be reduced to minimize the drag. Flow control is introduced to delay this flow separation and it has been categorized as active and passive. Active flow controls require power input while passive flow controls do not need power input. This review article will explore those studies on flow controls applied in automobiles and investigate their working mechanisms along with research gaps detected. Relative comparison of effectiveness for each flow control is unfeasible as the parameters used differs but this problem can be resolved. Standard parameters need to be used in future researches in order address the discrepancy of results obtained from numerous studies around the globe. A current flow control technique is proposed to be conducted in UTM Aerolab to further investigate this interesting flow field.
... The second part has a rectangular shape in order to stabilise the flow in front of the inclined angle. The last part is a sloping wall where the boundary layer tear-off zone is located (Bello-millán et al. 2016, Shadmani 2018. ...
Article
Full-text available
The work presents an experimental designation of the aerodynamic drag coefficient for two configurations of the Ahmed body model, with slant angle of 25o and with the inactive synthetic jet generator. When analyzing the aerodynamic drag of vehicles, most authors focus on higher Reynolds numbers, describing lower values only by designated trend lines. Which is why the main contribution of this experimental work was to designate the Ahmed’s body drag coefficient for low Reynolds numbers and to verify the obtained results with other authors experiments especially with the trend lines for Reynolds number in the range 0,35x105 – 1,8x105. For data taken from the literature, it can be seen that the value of the drag coefficient for the Ahmed body model decreases when the Reynolds number increases. The results obtained during the experiment show the opposite tendency.
... Shankar and Devaradjane [17] observed that the car drag and lift coefficients reduced by 4.53% and 2.55% respectively by vortex generators with leading edges toward back end and the middle plane of the vehicle. Shadmani, et al. [18] experimentally demonstrated that drag force of Ahmed body with plasma actuator system situated in the center of the rear slant surface can be decreased by 3.65% and 2.44% in steady and un steady actuations respectively. Additionally, the impact of ground clearance had been studied a lot as in [19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26] The impact of car modification on reducing the drag had been investigated a lot in terms of changing the shape of the geometries utilizing different turbulence model. ...
Article
Full-text available
In overall car performance and ride stability, external car aerodynamic study is of great importance, making it a key element in effective automobile design. In this study, the effect of the vehicle's length on the drag coefficient was numerically investigated. For this purpose, a CFD analysis based on RANS turbulence models was carried out for six configurations for the Ahmed body model with different length in addition to the baseline model. Tetrahedral cells were adopted throughout air enclosure except some prism cells around the vehicle's surfaces. Good agreement for the benchmark model was obtained by comparing current numerical results with experimental related data. The numerical results demonstrate that 1244mm is the optimal length of the Ahmed body. Increasing the overall length of the Ahmed body by about 19.15% leads to decreasing drag coefficient by 8.95%.
...  The rectangular vanes themselves produce more drag because of their larger frontal area so the delta shaped vanes appear to be a better choice [9]  Same experiments can be conducted by using delta shaped vanes to see how the drag of the body is further reduced to make the vehicle more aerodynamic ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Aerodynamic drag is the force that opposes the direction of momentum of a car and is not a profitable amount of force, as it reduces the mechanical efficiency of the car. One of the main causes of aerodynamic drag is boundary layer separation at the trailing end of the car. To minimize the effect of drag produced, Vortex Generators are placed at the rear end of the car. Ahmed Body is a simplified vehicle model which has got some important features matching the real ground vehicles. The CFD method was applied for testing the Ahmed model with a slant angle of 35 degrees and the reduction in drag was noted down for the Ahmed body after the installation of vortex generators. The results show that there is indeed slight decrease in the drag formed. Subsequently, CFD simulations are used to carry out flow analysis around the car, and the post-processing tool is used to enhance the results obtained Vortex generators of geometrical ratios λ/H=1, λ/H=3, and λ/H=5 was studied to see how the width between two rectangular vanes and the height of the vane affect the drag formed by the vehicle body. All tests were done for the Reynold's number Re= 2.8*10 6 Also, the Fuel consumption and power required to overcome the drag force created are calculated and compared how Vortex Generators make the Vehicle body more aerodynamic and improve its overall performance.
Article
This work proposes a machine-learning or artificial intelligence (AI) control of a low-drag Ahmed body with a rear slant angle φ = 35° with a view to finding strategies for efficient drag reduction ( DR ). The Reynolds number Re investigated is 1.7 × 10 ⁵ based on the square root of the body cross-sectional area. The control system comprises of five independently operated arrays of steady microjets blowing along the edges of the rear window and vertical base, twenty-six pressure taps on the rear end of the body and a controller based on an ant colony algorithm for unsupervised learning of a near-optimal control law. The cost function is designed such that both DR and control power input are considered. The learning process of the AI control discovers forcing that produces a DR up to 18 %, corresponding to a drag coefficient reduction of 0.06, greatly exceeding any previously reported DR for this body. Furthermore, the discovered forcings may provide alternative solutions, i.e. a tremendously increased control efficiency given a small sacrifice in DR . Extensive flow measurements performed with and without control indicate significant alterations in the flow structure around the body, such as flow separation over the rear window, recirculation bubbles and C-pillar vortices, which are linked to the pressure rise on the window and base. The physical mechanism for DR is unveiled, along with a conceptual model for the altered flow structure under the optimum control or biggest DR . This mechanism is further compared with that under the highest control efficiency.
Chapter
Dielectric Barrier Discharge (DBD) plasma actuator has become the well-known tools in the aerodynamics flow control applications. DBD plasma actuator have no moving parts as it only involves in ionization of flow stream, fast reaction, flexible and amazingly low in mass making it good alternative to hydraulic based control system. In this study, numerical simulations of airflow on vehicle spoiler with plasma actuator were performed. The results in terms of aerodynamic performance such as coefficient of drag (CD) and lift coefficient (CL) are presented in this paper. The vehicle spoiler is designed based on NACA 4418 airfoil while the DBD plasma is modeled as the source term in ANSYS-Fluent software. The results suggest that, by having plasma actuator on the top part of the spoiler, there is approximately 3.4% decrease in the value coefficient of drag. As such, DBD plasma actuator can be considered as the flow controller that can be installed in automotive spoiler for better performance.KeywordsDBD plasma actuatorAerodynamics flow control
Article
In the past numerical simulation of plasma and fluid coupling, the usually used Suzen numerical simulation model has the defect that the error increases with the increase in excitation voltage. The static test of the ionic wind is used to modify the parameters of the Suzen simulation model, and it applied the modified Suzen model to the flow control of the automobile external flow field, which shows good consistency with the wind tunnel test results. Results show that the Suzen model modified by the static test results of the ionic wind is suitable for different excitation voltage conditions. The corrected body force and charge density distribution conform to the change trend of plasma discharge, and the error between the maximum ionic wind velocity obtained by simulation and the test result is within 4%; the modified Suzen model is successfully applied to the plasma flow control of automobile aerodynamic drag reduction. The results show that the exciter suppresses the generation of periodic separation vortices in the tail of the model, which makes the vorticity in the wake significantly decrease, thereby reducing the energy dissipation and the aerodynamic drag of the model. Through the research in this paper, the modified Suzen model reduces the simulation error. Plasma flow control technology is applied to the field of automobile aerodynamic drag reduction, which has accumulated important experience methods and data foundation for the engineering application of this technology. It also provides new methods for improving vehicle aerodynamic performance and fuel economy.
Article
Full-text available
This review investigates the nature-inspired techniques for the optimization of the aerodynamic forces on bluff bodies. To provide a rich understanding of these nature-inspired phenomena, three distinct zones of the species fishes (nektons), birds (avians) and the fast running land animals are considered. This allows contextualizing different capabilities of the species in different environmental necessities. The review follows a trend in which drag reduction capabilities of individual parts of these species, including body shape & size, tails, fins, surface structure, wings, and wingtips, have been explored in detail. By focusing on specific parts, the review examined the methods and physics involved, which provides space to narrate the development of ideas and our current understanding of the nature-inspired drag reduction and their application to bluff body aerodynamics. Consequently, nature-inspired promising areas for future endeavor related to the bluff body has been discussed in detail. It was found that, though, aerospace field has found several bird inspired application but the bluff body flow modification have only few. Similar is the case with fishes and land animals which have not been explored yet for aerodynamic use on the bluff bodies. The crucial importance of passive devices are also highlighted along with the review of their application on the bluff bodies inspired by nature. Furthermore, several of nature-inspired techniques are proposed and compared to facilitate the research in this direction. It provides a fundamental method to develop nature-inspired flow control devices for the bluff bodies.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The effect of plasma flow control on reducing aerodynamic drag for ground vehicles is investigated. The experiments were carried out for a simplified ground vehicle using single dielectric barrier discharge (SDBD) plasma actuators. The plasma actuators were designed to alter the flow structure in the wake region behind the vehicle. The Ahmed body was modified to allow eight different vehicle geometries (with backlight or slant angles of 0° and 35°). Each of these were further modified by rounding the edges with different radii. Flow visualizations such as particle streams and surface oil were used to quantify features of the local flow field. The drag on the models was measured using a force balance as well as by integrating the mean velocity profiles in the model wakes. The results indicated that flow modifications needed to be applied symmetrically (upper to lower and/or side to side). This was demonstrated with the 0° backlight angle (square-back) that had all four side-corners rounded. Plasma actuators were applied to all four of the rounded edges to enhance the ability to direct the flow into the wake. Wake measurements showed that steady actuation at a fixed actuator voltage reduced the drag by an average of 20% at the lower velocities (below 15 m/s) and by 3% at the highest velocity tested (20 m/s). Model constraints prevented increasing the plasma actuator voltage that was needed to maintain the higher drag reduction observed at the lower speeds. Copyright © 2016 by ASME and General Motors Country-Specific Mortality and Growth Failure in Infancy and Yound Children and Association With Material Stature Use interactive graphics and maps to view and sort country-specific infant and early dhildhood mortality and growth failure data and their association with maternal
Article
Full-text available
The aim of the “Models for Vehicle Aerodynamics” (MOVA) Project is to develop, refine, and validate the latest generation of turbulence models for selected examples encountered in vehicle aerodynamics. The validation of turbulence models requires the availability of detailed experimental data. These quantitative data should cover the most critical flow regions around a bluff car-shaped body and they should give physical quantities that can directly be correlated to the results of numerical simulations. Such experimental data were measured in the LSTM low speed wind tunnel using a 2-component laser-Doppler anemometer (LDA) mounted on a traversing system and a simplified model of a car (Ahmed model). Measurements were made for two rear vehicle body slant angles (25° and 35°) at a bulk air velocity of 40 m/s. This paper serves as a synopsis of the major results of this experimental investigation.
Article
As a vehicle travels through a corner, the flowfield observed from the vehicle׳s frame of reference becomes curved. This condition results in the relative flow angle and freestream velocity changing both across the width and along the length of the body. Wall-resolved Large Eddy Simulations were used to simulate a simple vehicle shape through three different radii corners. The variable flow angle and acceleration affected the pressure distribution along either side of the body and caused an increase in the size of the outboard C-pillar vortex, and an inboard decrease. Furthermore, an outboard extension of the separation bubble at the bluff trailing face resulted in a gentler downwash angle off the backlight surface, with the opposite occurring inboard. At a Reynolds number of 1.7×106, a 19.2% increase in aerodynamic drag occurred for a five car-length radius corner when compared to the straight-line condition. In addition, a yawing moment acted against the rotation of the body through the corner, and a side force acted towards the centre of the corner. An exponential trend related the curvature of a vehicle׳s path to the increase in aerodynamic drag, with a linearity exhibited for the increase in yawing moment and side force.
Article
Transportation of goods and people involves moving objects through air, which leads to a force opposing motion. This drag force can account for more than 60% of power consumed by a ground vehicle, such as a car or truck, at highway speeds. This paper studies drag reduction on the 25-deg Ahmed generic vehicle model with quasi-steady blowing at the roof-slant interface using a spanwise array of fluidic oscillators. A fluidic oscillator is a simple device that converts a steady pressure input into a spatially oscillating jet. Drag reduction near 7% was attributed to separation control on the rear slant surface. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) and pressure taps were used to characterize the flow structure changes behind the model. Oil flow visualization was used to understand the mechanism behind oscillator effectiveness. An energy analysis suggests that this method may be viable from a flow energy perspective.
Conference Paper
Surface dielectric barrier discharges (DBDs) are used to delay flow separation behind a bluff body in atmospheric pressure air. The bluff body is made by connecting a flat plate to a half cylinder tangentially as a round-cornered trailing edge. Four DBD plasma actuators are attached along the surface of the half cylinder. Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) is utilized for studying the velocity field of the flow. In the first part of the study, flow alteration effects of two different discharge sources - a conventional alternating current (AC) discharge and an ultra short repetitively pulsed plasma discharge (USRD) - are compared for identical surface DBD configurations. It is found that, at an identical discharge power (∼ 25 W), the AC discharge shows higher ability for flow alteration than the USRD. In the second part, the flow alteration effect of the AC DBD is investigated for varying free stream flow speeds, surface roughness, Reynolds number (Rex), and electrode configuration. The flow speed ranges from 10 m/s to 25 m/s and the corresponding Rex are from 5 × 104 - 5 × 105. In this flow regime, the separation point behind the bluff body can be moved downstream in the presence of the AC DBD. However, it is found that, as the flow speed increases, the separation delay effect decreases. The flow alteration effect also decreases with rougher surfaces and higher Rex. Finally, skewed electrodes and reversed electrodes relative to the flow direction are utilized as two different electrode configurations. It is seen that the skewed electrode provides a positive effect on separation delay while the reversed electrode induces earlier flow separation.
Conference Paper
This work investigates the use of spatially-distributed open-loop forcing for three-dimensional control of vortex shedding from a circular cylinder. Force-shaped plasma actuators were used to control the flow, with the aim of reducing drag on a circular cylinder at a Reynolds number of 6500. Traditional approaches to cylinder drag reduction have typically involved two-dimensional forcing of the flow field. Spatially-distributed forcing, however, involves a spanwise modulation of the forcing on the flow. A new configuration of the dielectric-barrier discharge plasma actuator was implemented where the momentum addition could be directed either normal or tangential to the surface, as well as spatially tailored in a spanwise fashion to optimize control efficacy. The actuator configuration enables targeted manipulation of the wake-vortex structure shed from a bluff body. The goal of the flow control blowing profile is to break up the spanwise coherency in the vortex street, thereby promoting phase cancellation between spanwise portions of the wake structure. Wake profile measurements were made at several spanwise locations to evaluate the resulting drag reduction and modification of the wake.
Conference Paper
By manipulating the stall regime occurring above the airfoil of aircrafts at high angle of attack, the taking-off and landing phase might be timely reduced, avoiding extensive fuel consumption and noise radiation. Plasma actuators are suitable and effective active control devices to control such separation of low velocity airflows. However, these control devices require new investigations to be used at velocity corresponding to real flight conditions. The first step consists of better understanding the dynamic of the flow control to identify the parameters which can be enhanced. The present study proposes a time-resolved analysis of the flow over a NACA 0015 airfoil by a high-speed PIV system. The airfoil is placed in post-stall regime, at an angle of attack of 16°, and a freestream velocity set to 20 m/s (Re=2.6×105). An actuator based on a dielectric barrier discharge is mounted at the leading edge and quasi-steady or unsteady actuations are studied. The effects of the quasi-steady actuation, the excitation frequency and the duty-cycle of the unsteady actuation on the time-averaged and the instantaneous velocity fields are presented. The natural vortex street issuing from the flow separation is described and the interactive mechanism between the natural vortices and the electric wind produced by the plasma actuator is proposed and commented. The results demonstrate that the effectiveness of the DBD actuation depends on the used frequency and duty-cycle. The high repetition rate of the acquisition system allows to propose a scenario of the control of the separated flow by a plasma actuation. It appears that the flow reattachment results from a vortex dynamic enhanced by the local airflow produced by the DBD actuator. Copyright © 2008 by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc.