ArticlePDF Available

Theoretical analysis of state capture and its manifestation as a governance problem in South Africa

Authors:

Abstract

State capture became topical in South Africa in March 2016 following the dismissal of the then Minister of Finance, Nhlanhla Nene, on 09 December 2015. ‘Nenegate’ revealed poor understanding of state capture among politicians and the general public. The literature indicates that state capture lacks analytical clarity as there is no clear demarcation between legitimate political lobbying and state capture created by corruption. The research question addressed in this article is: What is state capture and how is it manifested in South Africa? Firstly, it systematically unpacks the phenomenon as a type of business–state relationship distinct from influence, corruption and lobbying and outlines its types, features and essence. Secondly, the article explores state capture in contemporary South Africa. Methodology-wise, a combination of literature study and current research reports is used to illuminate the phenomenon and its manifestation. The article contributes to existing knowledge by not only clarifying a concept conflated with corruption but also analysing the manifestations of state capture in South Africa.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... African governments have employed various methods to repress the press, including the spread of mis-and disinformation, ownership changes, regulatory pressure and the arrest of journalists (Bratich, 2020; Moyo, Mare, & Mabweazara, 2020;Chari & Mabokela, 2021;Essien, Muoghalu, & Sulaimon, 2022). Media capture is also achieved through state contracts, advertising revenue, favourable regulatory decisions and preferential access to state information (Dassah, 2018;Canen & Wantchekon, 2022;Freedom House, 2023b). ...
Article
Adopting a mixed method of interrogative review of literature, secondary data and case study of a digital legislation employed in jailing a TikToker in Uganda, this study critically evaluated the prevalence of digital authoritarian tactics in Africa since 2014. These repressive measures are not limited to digital spaces but are also used against the press. The paper argued that this double attack on both digital and traditional media is a symptom of a deeper problem. Through an analysis of the authoritarian media theory, this paper suggested that the root cause of digital repression lies in the deep-seated tendencies of African governments to control the media. Digital media has changed the political power dynamics in Africa, and governments are determined to bring it under their control. To address this crisis, it is necessary to look beyond the narrow view of digital repression as an isolated phenomenon. It is part of a process that begins with media control and ends with state capture. The ultimate goal is to eliminate the public accountability provided by both digital and mainstream media. The battle has only changed names; authoritarian governments will stop at nothing to suppress democracy.
... En este sentido, se ha postulado la corrupción como central para la comprensión y definición de la captura del Estado, mediante la cual "individuos, instituciones o grupos poderosos… utilizan la corrupción para influenciar las políticas, el entorno legal y la economía de una nación en beneficio de sus propios intereses privados" (Martini, 2014: 2). Mientras que los análisis de clientelismo, patrimonialismo y patrocinio se centran en las instituciones estatales (o el lado de "salida" de la corrupción), la captura del Estado se centra en el lado de "entrada" de las prácticas corruptas que distorsionan las "reglas del juego" (Dassah, 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
Resumen: Este artículo examina la falta de progreso de Paraguay en el cumplimiento de los Objetivos de Desarrollo Sostenible (ODS) de la Organización de las Naciones Unidas (ONU) a través del marco conceptual de la captura del Estado. Analiza varios aspectos de tres ODS interrelacionados: i) acción climática y protección ambiental, ii) desigualdad y iii) paz, justicia e instituciones sólidas, centrándose en la seguridad personal. Estos ejemplos sugieren dos cosas: primero, que el actual modelo de desarrollo paraguayo es insostenible en términos económicos, sociales y ambientales. Afirmamos, en sentido contrario, que se basa casi exclusivamente en los intereses de una pequeña élite y en contra del interés nacional. En segundo lugar, se observa que el progreso en el cumplimiento de los ODS se ve socavado por la captura del Estado y la influencia de estas élites que bloquean, retrasan, y diluyen reformas y políticas que puedan amenazar sus intereses. En este sentido, la captura del Estado socava el desarrollo sostenible, la seguridad nacional y la gobernabilidad democrática.
... Another definition of state capture corruption is the purchase of decrees, laws, and policies made by companies through the handover of money to public officials. (Dassah, 2018) In practice, there are two elements that play a role in state capture corruption, namely, interest groups and law framers. Interest groups are parties that influence the framers of laws so that laws and regulations are made in favor of monopolistic interests so that they can provide as much personal profit as possible (supernormal profit) and maintain market power. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article examines the topic of state capture corruption and how Indonesia's Corruption Law treats the practice. This article also intends to look into the practice of state capture corruption in the Mineral and Coal Mining Law revision. This study was created using normative legal research methods from a statutory and conceptual standpoint. This will be followed by descriptive and qualitative analysis. The findings of this study lead to the conclusion that state capture corruption is a type of compromise between people in positions of power and employers to produce legislation that serves their commercial interests. Due to the limited definition of corruption, the Corruption Law struggles to address this issue. Also, the 2020 Mineral and Coal Mining Law revision exposed some measures that were made specially to advance the financial interests of entrepreneurs while simultaneously deleting provisions that provided such actors control. ABSTRAK Artikel ini bertujuan untuk mendudukan persoalan state capture corruption dan menganalisis bagaimana hukum pidana korupsi Indonesia dalam memandang praktik state capture corruption tersebut. Disamping itu, tujuan selanjutnya dari artikel ini adalah untuk menganalisis ada tidaknya praktik state capture corruption dalam revisi UU Minerba. Penelitian ini disusun menggunakan metode penelitian hukum normatif dengan pendekatan perundang-undangan dan konseptual. Selanjutnya akan dianalisis secara deskriptif kualitatif. Adapun hasil dari kajian ini dapat disimpulkan bahwa state capture corruption merupakan suatu bentuk kompromi antara pengusaha dan pemegang kekuasaan pembentukan UU untuk melahirkan suatu produk hukum yang mengakomodir kepentingan bisnisnya. UU Tipikor mengalami kegagapan dalam menjawab persoalan ini dikarenakan pendefinisian korupsi yang masih sempit. Selanjutnya, dalam revisi UU Minerba pada tahun 2020 telah memperlihatkan beberapa pasal yang sengaja ditujukan hanya sekedar untuk mengakomodir kepentingan ekonomi para pebisnis dan pada saat yang sama menghapus pasal yang memberikan kontrol yang ketat bagi pelaku usaha dalam menjalankan bisnisnya. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license.
... In South Africa, the Gupta brothers' acknowledged friendship with the President and their ownership of lucrative tenders for coal supplies to Eskom, the power utility, has created tension between factions within the African National Congress (ANC), prompting the Deputy President to describe government as waging ‗war with itself', (Georg 2016. Dassah, M.O., 2018. According to Ismail & Richards, 2023, Political Patronage became prominent following widespread allegation that several state-owned enterprises and other agencies were infiltrated by persons close to President Jacob Zuma and that they radically altered the processes and functions of these entities to serve the interests of a few indivi ...
Article
Full-text available
The world in general constantly faces both political and economic upheavals due to unethical behavior of politicians and powerful political power brokers. Political interference is likely to shorten policymakers' horizons leading to suboptimal short term macroeconomic policies. Political patronage manifests itself in politicians manipulating procurement processes in favour of family, friends and relatives; skewed public appointments, judicial, legal and policy frameworks; playing politics of ethnicity and tribal balancing; corruption and impunity in public service; and economic influences of corruption. Procurement related corruption has become a matter of great concern across the globe. The main objective of this study was to find out the impact of political patronage on public procurement ethics in Kenya. The research design employed in this study was descriptive. This study relied heavily on secondary data as is the case with most desktop research study. The study reviewed journal articles, unpublished papers and conference papers on the influence of political patronage on public procurement ethics. The paper employed a desktop approach to provide answers to the research objectives. Specifically, the paper used a descriptive approach to gather information from peer-reviewed publications such as, journal articles, environmental organizations reports and books. The study found that corruption thrives in Africa, chiefly because the legal system is porous and openly manipulated, insufficient for monitoring and punishing offenders who constitute the ruling-elite class. Elites in African countries lack a commitment to the fight against corruption. This is demonstrated by their flagrant abuse of court processes and open manipulation of the legal systems. Elements of political patronage such as Favoritism, Cronyism, State Capture, Neopatrimonialism and Conflict of interest, has the capacity of diverting public resources to serve private interests rather than enlightened interests. The study recommended that, to fight Corruption in public procurement, the country's top leadership must commit to fight corruption using the top down approach, strengthen corruption control mechanisms and see to it that offenders are punished. Moreover, the citizenry needs to be mobilized to demand transparency and accountability from those entrusted with state power.
... The Zondo Commission of Inquiry was formed as a result of this, with various political figures testifying about significant mismanagement, corruption, and personal partisanship during South Africa's so-called "nine squandered years" (Fredericks & Jager, 2021). According to Dassah (2018), President Zuma's associates are accused of selecting cabinet members and key government officials as well as obtaining lucrative state contracts. According to reports, the Gupta brothers have significant ties inside the ANC and considerable influence in its procedures and across the state, and the benefits of their influence reach three provincial premiers (the Free State, North-West, and Mpumalanga). ...
Article
Full-text available
This article explores the impact of African National Congress-led government's dominance on South Africa's public service. On one hand, the African National Congress since the 1994 democratic elections had many achievements in advancing South Africa's democracy and responding to the citizens' needs through countless development and policy initiatives that were designed to cater to the basic needs of the citizens. On the other hand, it has become less responsive to citizen needs and this is evident as citizens have taken to the streets to protest for service provisions throughout the country. Citizens' discontent can be seen in the rapid decline of the African National Congress' political dominance and the formation of political coalitions. South African public service delivery has been marked by a lack of public accountability, corruption, cadre deployment, state capture, and procurement system manipulation as a result of the African National Congress's dominance since the country's first democratic elections. It is important to note that most South African citizens depend on the public sector and the African National Congress's dominance in the public sector has damaged its ability to be responsive to citizens' needs. This article relied on secondary sources, by reviewing current literature on the ramifications of having one political party dominating the country's political space for decades.
Article
Full-text available
The erosion of the South African state and its public services can be understood through various social, political and economic factors. These issues are complex and multifaceted, often intertwined and mutually reinforcing. Several theories and patterns can help explain the erosion of the state and public services in the country. The core objective of this paper is to elucidate the foregoing factors, using purposely selected theories as philosophical lenses through which to understand why service delivery dilemmas prevail, and why state institutions are eroding. This paper is located within a qualitative paradigm, in particular narrative reviews, where secondary sources of information was consulted. This paper makes a conceptual contribution to the notion of the erosion of South African public sector institutions in general, and the field of Public Administration in particular. The paper recognises that addressing the erosion of the South African state and public services requires comprehensive strategies and reforms, including tackling corruption, improving the education and healthcare systems, creating jobs, and addressing economic inequalities. It also necessitates strengthening institutions and promoting good governance to restore public trust and to ensure sustainable development.
Article
This article begins by considering the relationship between textual variants and the canonical text, arguing for a fuller presence of significant variant readings alongside the canonical text, in line with contemporary textual critical scholarship and their associated eclectic critical editions. Alongside such eclectic critical editions and their appropriation within Bible translation, this article suggests that a community-based approach like Contextual Bible Study could be used to return significant and relevant variants to ordinary African readers and hearers of the Bible. The article argues that LXX 3 Reigns 12:24p–t is such a significant and relevant textual variant, offering as it does a remarkable resonance with contemporary South African concerns about state capture. The article analyses 24p–t as a significant textual variant in text critical terms, as significant narrative literature in its own right, as a coherent economic narrative analysis concerning the cause of the division of the united monarchy, and as a potential resource for Contextual Bible Study work within the contemporary South African context of state capture.
Article
Full-text available
The local state capture phenomenon becomes very interesting if it is associated with the macro state capture framework that has begun to develop in the last two decades. A more multifaceted political approach is needed because state erosion is a political problem, not just an economic one. By referring to the political ethnographic tradition, this study describes how the complexity of relations between local economic, political, and ruling elites leads to the emergence of local state capture and the scope of its power. This study concludes that the weathering or weakening of formal government functions is not the source of the emergence of the local capture phenomenon. The growth of local state capture is more owing to the one-of-a-kind interaction between local political and economic actors and the ruling elite since the direct election of regional leaders takes place. This elite collaboration results from the emergence of a local oligarchic pole controlling local resources. The initiation of relations between the economic and political elite and the ruling elite is not only because of economic spheres but because they want to be part of the rulers' closest political circle of power.
Article
Full-text available
The History Ministerial Task Team Report (HMTT) on the proposed compulsory school history in South Africa was made public in February 2018. Ever since, it has generated many debates and concerns among in- and pre-service history educators, History (of) Education scholars as well as the general public. Many of these concerns are premised on the fear that there is an attempt, at least by the state, through the work of the HMTT to (re)capture school history. This (re)capture, some argue, would deliver a school history that is both nationalist and patriotic in its approach, and glorifies only the African National Congress's (ANC) role in history, much in the same way as the apartheid curriculum glorified the role of the National Party (NP), Afrikaner nationalism and white supremacy thinking. However, we are convinced that there might as well be a different reading of the HMTT and its Report; thus, a different form of (re)capture. In this paper, we will explore, theorise and reflect on the HMTT's work and Report, as well as recent scholarly debates regarding the HMTT itself and its Report. This we do by employing the notion of (re)capture as our theoretical framework which is derived from the current 'state capture' discourse in South Africa. We then use this theoretical lens to review literature on the contested epistemic nature of school history, as well as to read and make sense of the HMTT and its Report. We conclude that those who argue that there are indeed attempts to (re)capture the school history for narrow nationalistic aspirations which are nativist in nature, provide us with a different reading of the HMTT and its report. We contend that the form of (re)capture advanced by the HMTT, and its Report is for a greater cause related to current calls for decolonisation and Africanisation of school history in post-apartheid South Africa - where the colonised ways of knowing and being can also take centre stage in the historical literature and where cognitive, epistemic, existential, and ontological justice is realised.
Working Paper
Full-text available
Article
Full-text available
State capture and corruption are widespread phenomena across the globe, but their empirical study still lacks sufficient analytical tools. This paper develops a new conceptual and analytical framework for gauging state capture based on micro-level contractual networks in public procurement. To this end, it establishes a novel measure of corruption risk in government contracting focusing on the behaviour of individual organisations. Then, it identifies clusters of high corruption risk organisations in the full contractual network of procuring authorities and their suppliers using formal social network analysis. Densely connected clusters of high corruption risk organisations are denoted as the domain of state capture. It demonstrates the power of the new analytical framework by exploring how the radical centralisation of the governing elite following the 2010 elections in Hungary impacted on centralisation of state capture. Findings indicate the feasibility and usefulness of such micro-level approach to corruption and state capture. Better understanding the network structure of corruption and state capture opens new avenues for research and policy on anti-corruption, budget deficit, market competition, and quality of democracy. Supporting further empirical studies of corruption, the data is made available at digiwhist.eu/resources/data.
Article
Full-text available
State capture has emerged as a global threat in several countries. The definitions vary from the act of rent-seeking to corruption. Russia, Ukraine, and some countries in Central Asia are several areas where state capture was first observed. Indonesia is not immune from the threat. Several misconducts in the country had already been labeled as state capture. There are some distinctions between state capture and corruption, whereas in a few countries both are considered as the same. Strategies for combating corruption usually involve reducing state capture.
Article
Full-text available
Corruption has recently risen to the top of the development agenda, particularly in the transition economies. However, existing empirical research has been hampered by the lack of detailed and comparative data on the problem. We use the data from the ongoing Business Environment and Enterprise Performance Survey (BEEPS) to unbundle corruption into its specific constituent components and examine their particular causes and consequences. In addition to conventional measures of administrative corruption, we unbundle the measurement of corruption to focus particularly on two corrupt strategies which firms may use in their interactions with the state. First, state capture, defined as the efforts of firms to shape the very institutional environment in which they operate, and, second, public procurement corruption, the payment of kickbacks for securing public contracts. We show that the incidence, costs and benefits to the firm of both types of corruption differ. The evidence suggests that while ‘captor’firms in some environments benefit through higher sales in the short term, such payoff from state capture may not be sustainable. Furthermore, the social costs of state capture are high: firms in an environment characterized by state capture face strong incentives to join the fray, leading to a downward development spiral of increasing
Article
Reorganising Power in Indonesia is a new and distinctive analysis of the dramatic fall of Soeharto, the last of the great Cold War capitalist dictators, and of the struggles that reshape power and wealth in Indonesia. The dramatic events of the past two decades are understood essentially in terms of the rise of a complex politico-business oligarchy and the ongoing reorganisation of its power through successive crises, colonising and expropriating new political and market institutions. With the collapse of authoritarian rule, the authors propose that the way was left open for this oligarchy to reconstitute its power within society and the institutions of newly democratic Indonesia.
Article
The article argues that questions of definition relating to corruption are central to understanding its significance and its prominence in peacekeeping contexts. Definitional issues are discussed and a definition that combines certain universal features while acknowledging the importance of local norms and rules is offered. The definition revolves around actions, decisions and processes that subvert or distort the nature of public office and the political process. The challenge for peacebuilders is to develop and enforce standards for public office that have sufficient linkage with local norms and expectations to command some support, and to do so in a context that, by definition, lacks consensus on norms and principles of legitimacy for public office. The article explores some of the strategies open to those in post-conflict contexts and argues that corruption will frequently be a rational strategy for many, creating a vicious cycle that is hard to break. The article also questions how far corruption should be the major concern of peacekeeping forces, and how the concept might be disaggregated to allow a more targeted approach - one that recognizes that attacking corruption directly may not always be the best strategy, and that sees that corruption may not always be the major priority.
Article
This article demonstrates that most new EU Member States experience serious problems of state capture. It argues that central European states cluster around two dominant modes of party competition. In the first, predominantly ideologically committed elites (Poland, Hungary, Estonia, Slovenia and Estonia) established relatively ‘electoral professional’ party competitions, only to face deepening fiscal constraints on mainstream ideological competition. Following the collapse of the social democratic left, both Hungary and Poland experienced attempts to reassert political monopoly, i.e., ‘party state capture’. In the second group (Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania, Bulgaria and Latvia), more entrepreneurial political elites established ‘brokerage’ party systems, in which public policy remains a side-product of an essentially economic competition. All five states show high levels of ‘corporate state capture’ in which public power is exercised primarily for private gain. These findings contest the more optimistic expectations of the institutionalist literature on state-building and democratic consolidation.
Article
By recognizing the dynamics of state capture, we gain a much clearer understanding of the factors underlying the persistence of corruption in many transition countries. Although corruption has usually been seen as a symptom of weak state institutions, our analysis highlights the powerful forces that have a strong interest in fostering and maintaining these weak institutions. Any reforms to improve the institutional framework, which might undermine these highly concentrated advantages, will be strongly opposed by captor firms that have the political influence to derail such reforms. Consequently, tackling the problem of state capture is a prerequisite for reforms to improve governance and strengthen the legal, judiciary, and regulatory environment. But once the capture economy has become entrenched, how can the country break out of the vicious circle?.
Article
Large-scale systemic state capture, which is the root of widespread corruption, is acquiring such proportions in Serbia that it may undermine the success of its transition. ‘State capture’ is defined as any group or social strata, external to the state, that seizes decisive influence over state institutions and policies for its own interests and against the public good. The appropriation of state institutions and functions by the political party leadership is being carried out at an alarming rate in Serbia, as supported by research data in this paper by Vesna Pesic, an International Policy Research Fellow. The phenomenon of state capture is explored in depth looking at its background, prevalence and variety of mechanisms in Serbia today. The author concludes with policy options and recommendations to help curb corruption, address the deep mistrust expressed by the Serbian people about their political system, and to pave the way for democratic transition.