ArticlePDF Available

Review of measures for improved energy efficiency in production-related processes in the aluminium industry – From electrolysis to recycling

DOI:10.1016/j.rser.2018.05.043
Authors:
Joakim Haraldsson at Lund University
Joakim Haraldsson
Maria Johansson at Linköping University
Maria Johansson
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The aluminium industry is facing a challenge in meeting the goal of halved greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, while the demand for aluminium is estimated to increase 2–3 times by the same year. Energy efficiency will play an important part in achieving the goal. The paper's aim was to investigate possible production-related energy efficiency measures in the aluminium industry. Mining of bauxite and production of alumina from bauxite are not included in the study. In total, 52 measures were identified through a literature review. Electrolysis in primary aluminium production, recycling and general measures constituted the majority of the 52 measures. This can be explained by the high energy intensity of electrolysis, the relatively wide applicability of the general measures and the fact that all aluminium passes through either electrolysis or recycling. Electrolysis shows a higher number of emerging/novel measures compared to the other processes, which can also be explained by its high energy intensity. Processing aluminium with extrusion, rolling, casting (shape-casting and casting of ingots, slabs and billets), heat treatment and anodising will also benefit from energy efficiency. However, these processes showed relatively fewer measures, which might be explained by the fact that to some extent, these processes are not as energy demanding compared, for example, to electrolysis. In many cases, the presented measures can be combined, which implies that the best practice should be to combine the measures. There may also be a future prospect of achieving carbon-neutral and coal-independent electrolysis. Secondary aluminium production will be increasingly important for meeting the increasing demand for aluminium with respect to environmental and economic concerns and strengthened competitiveness. Focusing on increased production capacity, recovery yields and energy efficiency in secondary production will be pivotal. Further research and development will be required for those measures designated as novel or emerging.
Content uploaded by Maria Johansson
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Maria Johansson on Feb 19, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
Review of measures for improved energy
efficiency in production-related processes in the
aluminium industry – From electrolysis to
recycling
Joakim Haraldsson and Maria Johansson
The self-archived postprint version of this journal article is available at Linköping
University Institutional Repository (DiVA):
http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:liu:diva-148404
N.B.: When citing this work, cite the original publication.
Haraldsson, J., Johansson, M., (2018), Review of measures for improved energy efficiency in
production-related processes in the aluminium industry – From electrolysis to recycling, Renewable &
sustainable energy reviews, 93, 525-548. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2018.05.043
Original publication available at:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2018.05.043
Copyright: Elsevier
http://www.elsevier.com/
... The key role in improving economic performance, energy security, and environmental sustainability, as well as mitigating climate change, is played by energy efficiency (Fawcett and Killip, 2019;Foggia, 2018;Ingrao et al., 2018;Dadzie et al., 2018). There is a considerable body developed on energy efficiency of industry in general and in particular industrial enterprises (Malinauskaite et al., 2019;Zheng and Lin, 2018;Pusnik, 2017;Paulo de Lima, et al., 2018;Bhat et al., 2018;Lin and Zheng, 2017;Yanez et al., 2018;Xiong et al., 2019;Quiceno et al., 2019;Zuberia et al., 2017;Haraldsson and Johansson, 2018;Tanaka, 2011;Kohler, 2014;Hea and Wang, 2017). One of the most important factors contributing to energy efficiency is energy and recourse saving (Çay, 2018;Matraeva, et al., 2019;Feng, et al., 2018;Yang et al., 2018;Trotta, 2018). ...
View
... Finally, another proposed solution is iron ore electrolysis, which has a TRL of 6. This technique is already used on a large scale for the manufacture of aluminium, so the technology has been proven on an industrial scale (Haraldsson and Johansson, 2018). Optimisation of the electrodes and electrolyte are needed for the efficient reduction of iron. ...
Cost effective decarbonisation of blast furnace – Basic oxygen furnace steel production through thermochemical sector coupling
Article
We present here a first-principles study of the sector coupling between a thermochemical carbon dioxide (CO2) splitting cycle and existing blast furnace – basic oxygen furnace (BF-BOF) steel making for cost-effective decarbonisation. A double perovskite, Ba2Ca0.66Nb0.34FeO6, is proposed for the thermochemical splitting of CO2, a viable candidate due to its low reaction temperatures, high carbon monoxide (CO) yields, and 100% selectivity towards CO. The CO produced by the TC cycle replaces expensive metallurgical coke for the reduction of iron ore to metallic iron in the blast furnace (BF). The CO2 produced from the BF is used in the TC cycle to produce more CO, therefore creating a closed carbon loop, allowing for the decoupling of steel production from greenhouse gas emissions. Techno-economic analysis of the implementation of this system in UK BF-BOFs could reduce steel sector emissions by 88% while increasing the cost-competitiveness of UK steel on the global market through cost reduction. After five years, this system would save the UK steel industry £1.28 billion while reducing UK-wide emissions by 2.9%. Implementation of this system in the world's BF-BOFs could allow the steel sector to decarbonise in line with the Paris Climate Agreement to limit warming to 1.5 °C.
View
... Optimizing the electrolytic cell for lithium production using molten salts involves finding a solution to chlorine bubble production at the anode surface. These bubbles create a resistance to mass transfer, resulting in high energy consumption [11]- [14]. Previous studies have shown the importance to simulate the effect of mass transfer across the anodic boundary layer, where bubbles of Cl2 are produced, which must be improved to optimize lithium production. ...
Effect of Bubbles and Liquid Drops Fluid Dynamics on the Lithium Recombination and Energy Consumed inside a Lithium Electrolytic Cell with Diaphragm
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Metallic lithium is a critical and strategic metal for the world’s production of energy storage devices, and it is produced mainly from molten salt electrolysis processes. To increase the efficiency of such processes, it is of utmost importance to prevent lithium recombination to avoid energy waste. To optimize the lithium electrolytic processes and obtain a high purity metal with the least amount of energy, the recombination of lithium has been studied as a consequence of the lithium drops fluid dynamics. This research studies the behavior of the main variables involved in the reaction inside a Li-production experimental cell from the mass transfer, electrochemical and fluid dynamics standpoints. The behavior of an experimental electrochemical cell was simulated for 600 s time period using a turbulent (k-ε) approach to solve the two-phase flow. In order to analyze the influence of the cathode fluid dynamics in relation with the amount of recombined lithium, two configurations of the non-porous diaphragm were evaluated, including the incorporation of a baffle at the bottom of the cell. The baffle reduced the amount of recombined lithium by 7 %, and the non-porous diaphragm with an inclination of 87° reduced the total recombined mass by 77 %, although it increased the energy consumption by 10 % with respect to the base case of a vertical diaphragm. A grooved diaphragm and rotating electrodes were also used to reduce the energy consumed. The inclination angle of the diaphragm with grooves has been evaluated for three different configurations, while the rotating electrode condition was studied for five different angular velocities without a diaphragm. The anodic film resistance was also added in the numerical model through an empirical equation of gas volume fractions as a function of the time. It allowed for a better combination between fluid dynamics and the electrochemical field. The vertical diaphragm with grooves produced a reduction of 26.7 % in energy consumption in comparison with the vertical non-porous design but increased by four times the amount of recombined lithium in the process. The grooved diaphragm was inclined toward the anode to decrease the lithium recombination. A vertical angle of 85° also helped to reduce the energy consumed by 23.5 % with approximately the same recombined lithium mass compared to the vertical non-porous design. Using a rotating cathode with an angular velocity of 0.25 rad/s resulted in a 40 % reduction in energy consumption; in addition, it decreased by 87.4 % the metallic Li reconversion in comparison with the vertical non-porous diaphragm design.
View
... Burners are used in a multitude of unit operations in pyrometallurgy: they provide the energy to calcine concentrate in kilns, 235 to melt scrap in reverberatory furnaces, 236 and to bring extra energy in cold spots of electric arc furnaces 237 among others. Many different types of fuels have been used throughout history: from heavy oils 238 and exhaust gases coming from pyrometallurgical reactors (such as blast furnace exhaust gases 239 ), up to clean natural gas, 240 all available and cheap fuels have been burnt. ...
Greener reactants, renewable energies and environmental impact mitigation strategies in pyrometallurgical processes: A review
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2022
Metals and alloys are among the most technologically important materials for our industrialized societies. They are the most common structural materials used in cars, airplanes and buildings, and constitute the technological core of most electronic devices. They allow the transportation of energy over great distances and are exploited in critical parts of renewable energy technologies. Even though primary metal production industries are mature and operate optimized pyrometallurgical processes, they extensively rely on cheap and abundant carbonaceous reactants (fossil fuels, coke), require high power heating units (which are also typically powered by fossil fuels) to calcine, roast, smelt and refine, and they generate many output streams with high residual energy content. Many unit operations also generate hazardous gaseous species on top of large CO 2 emissions which require gas-scrubbing and capture strategies for the future. Therefore, there are still many opportunities to lower the environmental footprint of key pyrometallurgical operations. This paper explores the possibility to use greener reactants such as bio-fuels, bio-char, hydrogen and ammonia in different pyrometallurgical units. It also identifies all recycled streams that are available (such as steel and aluminum scraps, electronic waste and Li-ion batteries) as well as the technological challenges associated with their integration in primary metal processes. A complete discussion about the alternatives to carbon-based reduction is constructed around the use of hydrogen, metallo-reduction as well as inert anode electrometallurgy. The review work is completed with an overview of the different approaches to use renewable energies and valorize residual heat in pyrometallurgical units. Finally, strategies to mitigate environmental impacts of pyrometallurgical operations such as CO 2 capture utilization and storage as well as gas scrubbing technologies are detailed. This original review paper brings together for the first time all potential strategies and efforts that could be deployed in the future to decrease the environmental footprint of the pyrometallurgical industry. It is primarily intended to favour collaborative work and establish synergies between academia, the pyrometallurgical industry, decision-makers and equipment providers. Graphical abstract Highlights A more sustainable production of metals using greener reactants, green electricity or carbon capture is possible and sometimes already underway. More investments and pressure are required to hasten change. Discussion Is there enough pressure on the aluminum and steel industries to meet the set climate targets? The greenhouse gas emissions of existing facilities can often be partly mitigated by retrofitting them with green technologies, should we close plants prematurely to build new plants using greener technologies? Since green or renewable resources presently have limited availability, in which sector should we use them to maximize their benefits?
View
... The bubbles are present in many industrial processes, as is the case of separation or recovery processes in bubble columns (Ali, 2014;Musa et al., 2017). It also represents a problem for mass transfer in metal production industries (Ariana et al., 2014;Haraldsson and Johansson, 2018;H. Liu et al., 2015;Oliaii et al., 2017;Zhang et al., 2014), and in the wastewater treatment industry with electro-flotation processes (Martinez Huitle et al., 2018). ...
Numerical simulation of bubble behavior in electrolytic reactor
Research Proposal
Full-text available
  • May 2019
In order to optimize electrolytic processes to obtain a high purity metal with the least amount of energy and the lowest pollution to the environment, a numerical method can be developed to represent the electrolytic phenomena including the behaviour of a set of bubbles with heterogeneous nucleation, growth, detachment, coalescence and breakup in several active catalytic sites. Simulating the behavior and properties of bubbles with respect to time using a Lagrangian-Eulerian (L-E) and Eulerian-Eulerian (E-E) approaches requires the use of stochastic numerical methods, such as the Monte Carlo Method (MCM) coupled with the Classical Theory of Nucleation (CNT) and the Population Mass Balance (PMB) equations. The CNT is used to develop L-E interactions and to represent a heterogeneous nucleus on the electrolysis surface where bubbles can form. The random function of MCM is used to analyse a set of bubbles with the same features and to represent the active sites on the catalytic surface. The growth is simulated using the mass conservation equation coupled to Faraday’s law. Finally, the detachment stages are simulated with the momentum transfer equation representing an external force balance on the bubbles. The gas flow is supplied through the mass transfer equation during the electrochemical reaction. In this case, the bubble radius in the growth phase depends of the nuclei position as defined by MCM due to the effect of hydrostatic pressure. The numerical method is mainly validated by comparing the current density obtained from the simulation (i_S) with the value or behavior of the experimental current density (i_E) produced in the lithium or water electrolytic cell. The proposed iterative solution process is based on using the MCM with PMB equation to represent the E-E interactions, bubble stages are represented in each term of the PMB equation as functions of the physics properties; finally, i_S is compared to i_E to complete the iteration. The originality of this research work comes from the development of a new numerical method where each stage of the bubble formation in electrolytic cells is represented. Moreover, the position of active sites on the catalytic surface is defined by MCM, while Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) is simulated by the PMB equation for E-E interaction and momentum equation and with the CNT equation for L-E description.
View
... 236 -253 , julio 2022 www.concienciadigital.org La fundición como proceso de manufactura es necesaria altos consumos de energía por lo cual para que la fundición de estos elementos sea viable económicamente es necesario tener en cuenta la eficiencia energética del proceso (Haraldsson & Johansson, 2018). Tomando en consideración debemos enfocarnos a que este proceso sea amigable con el medio ambiente, es por ellos que la manufactura aditiva nos ayuda a optimizar procesos y ahorrar energía en el proceso de la fundición (Sivarupan et al., 2019). ...
Optimización del proceso de fundición mediante el proceso de ingeniería inversa y aditiva de un cabezote de un motor de bajo cilindraje
Article
  • Jul 2022
Introducción: En la industria manufactura de piezas y partes en la industria automotriz se ha visto escasamente desarrollada en nuestro país, es por ello por lo que se ha creado políticas gubernamentales como el acuerdo ministerial N 14 264, el cual busca ampliar la gama de productos de fabricación nacional para la industria automotriz. Objetivos: El objetivo se enfoca en la obtención del modelo y los parámetros del proceso de manufactura para obtener un modelo mediante la ingeniería inversa; para conseguir un prototipo de alta calidad y económicamente viable. Metodología: El proceso de manufactura elegido es la fundición en arena el cual es un proceso que nos permite obtener figuras complejas con alta calidad y coste asequible, para ello es necesario realizar el elemento, el procedimiento aplicado es un proceso de escaneo, que el resultado es una nube de punto, para luego transformar a una malla y obtener un elemento sólido obteniendo las características iniciales del proceso. Resultados: Con las características del proceso de moldeo, mediante iteraciones teniendo un error de 0.39 % para un caudal de 0.17285433 ; Y el canal del bebedero tiene una forma tronco cónica teniendo diámetro superior de bebedero de 16,73 mm, y un diámetro inferior del bebedero de 10.21 mm. Conclusiones: Utilizamos manufactura aditiva para el proceso de fundición fue una vez obtenido los valores antes descritos para que la fundición sea óptima, obteniendo un cálculo económico para que nuestro proceso sea competitivo en relación calidad vs costo.
View
View
Material requirements for future low-carbon electricity projections in Africa
Article
  • Nov 2022
Deploying low-carbon electricity systems in developing countries is critical for meeting climate targets while increasing wellbeing. Direct emissions from operating electricity generation are well-understood, however, materials required to construct technologies and their emissions - embodied emissions-are frequently overlooked. This paper quantifies the material implications of proposed electricity systems in 47 African countries from 2015 to 2065, involving a reference scenario, and two Paris-Agreement scenarios (1.5 °C and 2.0 °C of warming). A purpose-built model, called Mat-dp (Material Demand Projections) is used for scenario assessment. Mat-dp integrates electricity generation projections with material requirements by technology, estimating material budgets, embodied emissions, and jobs. The resulting construction material mass grows 20-fold from 2015 to 2065, with the highest growth in the reference scenario. As low-carbon electricity capacity grows, embodied emissions from materials increase, reaching 47 MtCO2 in the 2.0 °C scenario by 2065. Three bulk materials, concrete, steel, and aluminium, make up 64–66% of the total materials required by 2065, and 59–61% of the total embodied emissions. The Paris Agreement scenarios show lower material demand, particularly bulk materials, but higher specialised material demand. Increasing low-carbon electricity generation while decarbonising industry offers a higher emission reduction potential compared to solely switching to low-carbon electricity. Estimated new jobs are 1.6 million per year, mostly from solar.
View
View
Decarbonisation Pathways for Industries
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
The decarbonisation pathways for the industry sectors are derived. The energy-intensive chemical industry, the steel and aluminium industries, and the cement industry are briefly outlined. The assumptions for future market development used for the scenario calculations are documented, and the assumed development of the energy intensities for product manufacture is presented. An overview of the calculated energy consumption and the resulting CO 2 intensities is given, with the assumed generation mix. The textile and leather industry is also included in this chapter because of its strong ties to the chemical industry and meat production (part of the service sector).
View
In Depth Analysis of Energy-Saving and Current Efficiency Improvement of Aluminum Reduction Cells
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jan 2003
In view of the existing aluminum overcapacity and lower aluminum price in China, many companies took measures to reduce the production cost and the energy consumption, but there has been no normalized theory and method defined as yet.
View
View
Reduction of Energy Consumption and GHGs Emission in Investment Casting Process by Application of a New Casting Method
Chapter
  • May 2012
In conventional investment casting process of aluminium alloys for the application of the aerospace industry, to assure the quality of the final casting, usually the foundry uses large runner system which results in low yield, high energy consumption and high GHGs emission. In one case of this investigation, the yield is between 5 ~ 10% which means that the current casting process wastes large amount of energy and generates lots of scraps. By applying a new casting method, the bulky runner system and the melting/holding time are significantly reduced, the quality of the casting is improved, and in the meantime the related energy consumption and GHGs emission are significantly decreased. In the investigation, the energy efficiencies and GHGs emission between the current and traditional processes are calculated and compared. © 2012 The Minerals, Metals, & Materials Society. All rights reserved.
View
Reduced Ventilation of Upper Part of Aluminum Smelting Pot: Potential Benefits, Drawbacks, and Design Modifications
Chapter
  • Jan 2016
Maintaining current draft conditions in the upper part of Al smelting cell requires important electricity consumption for the fans. A reduction of the ventilation rate could significantly diminish the total power requirement at the blowers. However, adverse changes in operating conditions due to this ventilation reduction may disrupt the pot thermal equilibrium. A CFD model was created to investigate the influence of ventilation reduction on pot thermal balance. With the objective of maintaining normal heat losses by the top of the cell, several modifications are simulated, such as using plate fins on the anode assembly, changing hood gap geometry and modifying anode cover thickness. Heat transfer rates are determined for these modified designs, and compared to those currently achieved.
View
Industry Test of Perforation Anode in Aluminium Electrolysis Technology
Chapter
  • Jan 2003
In recent years aluminum industry in China has been developed rapidly. In 2011 China’s electrolytic aluminum output reached 18.06 million tons and has topped the list in the world for 11 consecutive years. However, the energy and environmental issues restrain development of aluminum industry. So it is necessary to promote the use of energy saving technology in the aluminum industry. The composition of the cell voltage is analyzed in this paper. It is reasonable that the cell voltage of ordinary flat cathode cell is about 4.05V. The approximate linear relationships between the bubble layer thickness and the anode width is analyzed. Changing the structure of the anode and adding two rows of the vent on the common anode can reduce the gas running distance below carbon anode, anodal bubble voltage and the work voltage of aluminum reduction cells under the same current efficiency of aluminum reduction cells. Perforated anode technology was tested in small-scale and large-scale industrial cells and the experimental results show that average current efficiency of the test cell is 91.447%, the direct current consumption reaches 12337kwh/T-Al. The anode effect coefficient of the test cell with good thermal balance reduces to an average of 0.185 time /cell–day. The results are consistent with the theory and a comprehensive promotion goal is achieved.
View
Aluminum Smelter Waste Heat Recovery Plant (Heat Exchangers Fouling and Corrosion-A Detailed Investigation)
Chapter
  • May 2012
The main bottleneck for primary aluminum production industry is dealing with a huge amount of input energy. The fact is that part of provided energy to aluminum production smelters will be lost as waste heat and it never used for aluminum production. One part of waste heat is escaping from the potroom exhaust gases, which was studied for possible recovery in a desalination plant to produce distilled water and the paper was presented in 2011 TMS Annual Meeting. However, it was shown that waste heat recovery plant to produce distilled water is highly profitable but the main fact is that the exhaust gases from potroom are highly corrosive, abrasive and dusty. The main challenge for desalination plant construction, which is using aluminum smelter exhaust gases as the main heat source, is the highly corrosive environment that makes the situation difficult and complicated for equipments design and plant construction. In this paper, we are trying to study a detailed investigation regarding the heat exchangers fouling, corrosion in heat exchangers including heat exchangers' material, how often we need to shut down the plant for maintenance or cleaning, and plant thermal efficiency with considering fouling. © 2012 The Minerals, Metals, & Materials Society. All rights reserved.
View
Noise Classification in the Aluminum Reduction Process
Chapter
  • Jan 2016
Cell “noise” is monitored by virtually all reduction cell control systems, and is generally used as one of the control variables for anode movement. High noise levels are thought to reduce cell current efficiency and are generally combated by increasing anode-cathode distance. However, exactly what constitutes “noise” and how noise is measured varies from controller to controller. Cell control algorithms are universally proprietary and little has been published on the correlation between voltage noise and current efficiency. In this study, three types of frequently observed cell noise are presented, and corresponding noise metrics are proposed. The characteristics and possible causes of the three types of noise are discussed. We show that not all types respond to anode movement, and posit that a better understanding of noise type is necessary for effective control of the cell.
View
Innovative Solutions to Sustainability in Hydro
Chapter
  • Jan 2016
Sustainability represents challenges for the Aluminium Industry and also opportunities. Innovation is essential in meeting these challenges. By being innovative and by having a sustainability approach to the whole value chain, there are large potential for improvements both environmentally as well as financially. For Hydro this approach embodies the value chain from power production to the end user of aluminium products. Our aim is to improve Hydro’s environmental footprint as well as generating value for the company Hydro. The two main challenges, the world as well as the industry, is facing today is climate change and energy consumption. In this paper we will show how Hydro systematically works to reduce energy consumption as well as share with you our main topics for future improvements.
View
A Nonlinear Model Based Control Strategy for the Aluminium Electrolysis Process
Chapter
  • Jan 2016
Important factors for the aluminium industry for succeeding in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and increase energy efficiency is not only the speed in which the organization is able to utilize new knowledge, but also the development and use of new advanced process control systems. New advanced process control systems imply utilizing state of the art process control systems as e.g. Nonlinear Model Predictive Control (NMPC). Although the conventional control structures are dominating the aluminium industry, several authors have addressed advanced process control structures for controlling the Hall-Heroult process. This includes the adaptive control of alumina addition, 9 -Box Matrix Control, LQG Control, Model Predictive Control and control structures involving the Neural network approach. Recently Hydro has been active in developing an NMPC control structure for controlling the Hall-Heroult process. The Hydro NMPC control structure and results from operational practice on Hydro’s HAL275 and Hal4e cells are presented.
View
Solid State Carbothermal Reduction of Alumina
Chapter
  • Jan 2016
The Hall-Héroult process, the only commercial technology for aluminum production requires high energy and is a major origin of perfluorocarbons and green house gases. A promising alternative process, carbothermal reduction of alumina to metallic aluminum has advantages of lower capital cost, less energy consumption, and lower emission of green house gases. Carbothermal reduction processes under development are based on formation of aluminum carbide-alumina melts at high temperatures. Solid state carbothermal reduction of alumina is possible at reduced CO partial pressure. This paper presents results of experimental study of carbothermal reduction of alumina into aluminum carbide in Ar, He and H2 atmospheres at 1500–1700°C. The reduction rate of alumina increases with increasing temperature, and is significantly faster in He and H2 than in Ar. Increasing gas flow rate and decreasing pressure favors the reduction.
View