ArticlePublisher preview available

Let Us Not Forget: Crypto Means Secret. Cryptocurrencies as Enabler of Unethical and Illegal Business and the Question of Regulation

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

In the following, I concentrate on the nefarious, harmful and unethical dimensions emerging only slowly as the rather new phenomenon of cryptocurrencies and blockchain at large become visible only gradually. For the positive and pro-social use of cryptocurrencies please refer to the article of Claus Dierksmeier in this issue of HMJ. As there are many different dimensions still unknown, I concentrate on the ethical issues emerging from the secretive nature of cryptocurrencies, less on the environmental carbon footprint or economic implications of volatility also discussed in the literature. Among the most critical issues are black market transactions of weapons used in terrorist attacks, drugs, or childpornography. Additionally, cryptocurrencies are more and more found in blackmailing people and as payment for ransom-ware and other computer viruses (Wannacry was a remarkable example). Money laundering also is on the rise via cryptocurrencies. I argue that the nefarious use of cryptocurrencies threatens the prosocial potential of cryptocurrencies and in general makes criminal activity easier for criminals and less likely to track down by legal authorities. In closing, I discuss current debates about emerging regulation presenting an overview of some jurisdictions and the option of regulated central bank issues cryptocurrencies.
FUTURE CHALLENGES
Let Us Not Forget: Crypto Means Secret. Cryptocurrencies
as Enabler of Unethical and Illegal Business
and the Question of Regulation
Peter Seele
1
Received: 22 May 2018 / Accepted: 23 May 2018 / Published online: 30 May 2018
Abstract In the following, I concentrate on the nefarious, harmful and unethical dimen-
sions emerging only slowly as the rather new phenomenon of cryptocurrencies and
blockchain at large become visible only gradually. For the positive and pro-social use
of cryptocurrencies please refer to the article of Claus Dierksmeier in this issue of HMJ.
As there are many different dimensions still unknown, I concentrate on the ethical issues
emerging from the secretive nature of cryptocurrencies, less on the environmental carbon
footprint or economic implications of volatility also discussed in the literature. Among
the most critical issues are black market transactions of weapons used in terrorist attacks,
drugs, or childpornography. Additionally, cryptocurrencies are more and more found in
blackmailing people and as payment for ransom-ware and other computer viruses
(Wannacry was a remarkable example). Money laundering also is on the rise via
cryptocurrencies. I argue that the nefarious use of cryptocurrencies threatens the
prosocial potential of cryptocurrencies and in general makes criminal activity easier for
criminals and less likely to track down by legal authorities. In closing, I discuss current
debates about emerging regulation presenting an overview of some jurisdictions and the
option of regulated central bank issues cryptocurrencies.
Keywords Business ethics .Cryptocurrencies .Dark net .Digitalization .Money laundering .
Secrecy .Switzerland
Humanist Manag J (2018) 3:133139
https://doi.org/10.1007/s41463-018-0038-x
*Peter Seele
peter.seele@usi.ch; http://www.usi.ch
1
Faculty of Communication Sciences, Università della Svizzera italiana (USI), via G. Buffi 13 (R.413),
CH-6900 Lugano, Switzerland
#Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... We grouped these into technology-related, business-related and legal and policy-related barriers. Thus, our paper mainly contribute to the issue of understanding and mitigating the negative use of crypto, by analysing its impact on international business activities (Seele, 2018). More importantly, our paper finally stands out by shedding light on the "often-overlooked" dark side of new technologies: it not only underscores the negative aspects that demand attention in the responsible use of technology but also pioneers a fresh perspective on the technological barriers, emphasizing not just the lack of technology or skills but the indirect repercussions of illicit tech use in target investment countries. ...
... Despite the immense potentialities, some barriers hinder foreign investment in MEA markets (Kammoun et al., 2020;Sedik and Seoudy, 2012), regulatory complexities, political instability and infrastructural challenges are among the commonly cited impediments. However, a notable concern that has emerged in recent times is the unregulated use of cryptocurrencies, introducing new dimensions to investment challenges (Maimbo, 2020;Seele, 2018;Wang and Zhu, 2021). ...
... Despite their positive impact on digital entrepreneurship, cryptocurrencies are not immune to ethical concerns. The pseudonymous nature of transactions raises alarms about potential misuse, including the financing of terrorism and participation in illicit activities (Foley et al., 2019), highlighting a sort of "dark side" of cryptocurrencies (Ali, 2015;Seele, 2018). ...
Article
Purpose This paper aims to unveil the darker side of cryptocurrencies by delving into its role as an obstacle to investments in Middle East and African (MEAs) countries, unravelling the challenges involved. Indeed, despite the rise of blockchain-related technologies, specifically cryptocurrencies, having undeniably unlocked new avenues for business and society, crypto for venture funding purposes may exhibit a “dark side” due to their use for unethical purposes, for example, money laundering or terrorism financing, largely diffused in certain areas of MEA countries. Design/methodology/approach Through an explorative research design, using a mix of techniques based on both qualitative and interpretive methods, we conducted in-depth interviews among 33 European managers of companies engaged in MEA markets or aspiring to invest in such foreign markets, to analyse their thoughts, perceptions and possible strategies concerning the management of the “dark side” of cryptocurrencies in MEAs. Findings Our investigation unearthed seven pivotal issues, which manifest as significant barriers related to the ambivalent use of crypto for funding projects, encompassing seven important consequential elements: (1) lack of knowledge about the technology’s potentialities; (2) perceptions of crypto technology’s ambivalence; (3) reputation and image consequences; (4) uncertainty about the destination of the invested funds; (5) decreased attractiveness of MEAs; (6) competition and market; and (7) lack of control and regulation. We grouped these into technology-related, business-related and legal- and policy-related barriers. Such findings underline the probable decrease in attractiveness of MEAs in terms of investments, together with the triggering factors and potential strategic solutions to mitigate such circumstances. Research limitations/implications Future studies could explore a broader sample of managers since we only considered the perception of European managers operating in companies that invest (or are intending to invest) in MEAs. Moreover, future research may extend the analysis to MEA-native companies or those engaging in reciprocal exchanges with Western countries. Practical implications Practically, our findings suggest several elements in which to intervene to mitigate managers’ negative perception of the unethical use of cryptocurrencies in MEAs and to support CEOs’ and CFOs’ strategies, together with requirements to ensure the unaltered attractiveness of investments in an otherwise thriving region of the world, without overlooking the protection and safeguarding of investments and the health of the market and competition. Furthermore, a call for future research in this domain, along with at least minimal regulatory mechanisms, clearly emerges. Social implications Our findings underline the social challenges associated with the perception and acceptance of cryptocurrencies in these contexts, influencing cultural and social dynamics. Moreover, the identification of these barriers could underscore the significance of awareness of and education on blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies within society, including implications for policymakers. Originality/value Despite prior investigations into the negative effects of cryptocurrencies as a form of venture funding, no studies to date have examined managers’ perceptions by focusing on possible barriers to investment in MEA countries due to the unethical usage of crypto. Importantly, this paper unravels the unexplored complexities of crypto’s impact on ethical investments in MEAs, showcasing an original perspective.
... Cryptocurrencies-relying on blockchain technology-are also used for funding international crime and terrorism [74]-again, ethically unacceptable based on the ethical point of reference of human rights [75,76]. ...
Article
Full-text available
There is no question about the innovation force and the economic potential of blockchain technology. As the basis for new currencies, financial services, and smart contracts, blockchain technology can be seen as the fifth disruptive computing paradigm, after mainframes, personal computers, the Internet, and mobile devices. However, there are questions about its ethical implications, which have the potential to also impact the economic success of blockchain technology. This article aims to provide ethical guidance on blockchain technology. In order to reach this goal, the focus of the ethical analysis will first concentrate on the unique characteristics of blockchain technology compared to other technology-based innovations. The unique nucleus of blockchain technology can be defined as a move from the trust in people to a trust in math, as a move from an internet of information to an internet of value, or—as I would propose—a shift from an intermediated network to an immediate network. Second, the ethical opportunities (e.g., transparency, participation, global access to services) and risks (e.g., ecological impact, lack of legal monitoring and enforcement) associated with this unique nucleus of blockchain technology will be discussed. Third, an outlook on possible concrete solutions will be provided.
... These studies have examined the facilitative factors that enable Bitcoin-related crimes on the Darkweb, such as the anonymity of cryptocurrencies and the lack of regulation in certain jurisdictions [76]. Other studies have explored the ethical implications of using cryptocurrencies for illegal purposes and the potential for regulation to address this issue [77]. Research on currency substitution in the shadow economy, which includes the Darkweb, has also examined the use of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as an alternative to traditional fiat currencies [78]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Darkweb, part of the deep web, can be accessed only through specialized computer software and used for illegal activities such as cybercrime, drug trafficking, and exploitation. Technological advancements like Tor, bitcoin, and cryptocurrencies allow criminals to carry out these activities anonymously, leading to increased use of the Darkweb. At the same time, computers have become an integral part of our daily lives, shaping our behavior, and influencing how we interact with each other and the world. This work carries out the bibliometric study on the research conducted on Darkweb over the last decade. The findings illustrate that most research on Darkweb can be clustered into four areas based on keyword co-occurrence analysis: (i) network security, malware, and cyber-attacks, (ii) cybercrime, data privacy, and cryptography, (iii) machine learning, social media, and artificial intelligence, and (iv) drug trafficking, cryptomarket. National Science Foundation from the United States is the top funder. Darkweb activities interfere with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) laid forth by the United Nations to promote peace and sustainability for current and future generations. SDG 16 (Peace, Justice, and Strong Institutions) has the highest number of publications and citations but has an inverse relationship with Darkweb, as the latter undermines the former. This study highlights the need for further research in bitcoin, blockchain, IoT, NLP, cryptocurrencies, phishing and cybercrime, botnets and malware, digital forensics, and electronic crime countermeasures about the Darkweb. The study further elucidates the multi-dimensional nature of the Darkweb, emphasizing the intricate relationship between technology, psychology, and geopolitics. This comprehensive understanding serves as a cornerstone for evolving effective countermeasures and calls for an interdisciplinary research approach. The study also delves into the psychological motivations driving individuals towards illegal activities on the Darkweb, highlighting the urgency for targeted interventions to promote pro-social online behavior.
Article
This article examines how Chinese Muslim bitcoin entrepreneurs navigate the tensions between tradition and modernity, religion and secularism, as they respond to shifting state policies in China and the dominance of the Western global financial system. Situated at the intersection of Chinese and Islamic civilizations, these entrepreneurs chart alternative paths to economic modernity while grappling with the constraints of traditional Islamic finance. Drawing on in-depth interviews, the analysis reveals how they construct narratives that challenge both European secularity and Sino-centric uniformity, asserting unique ethical and moral standings in the global economy. These entrepreneurs are simultaneously contained and strengthened by their religious traditions, using their faith as a resource to engage with emerging digital technologies and redefine their roles within a secular financial system. By situating their experiences within broader patterns of Islamic reform and global economic shifts, this article highlights the intersection of faith, technology, and economic autonomy, offering a nuanced understanding of contemporary Muslim subjectivities.
Article
Full-text available
Decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) represent a novel organizational form enabling self-governed coordination based on blockchain technology. This study examines the prototypical Bitcoin DAO from an institutional perspective, focusing on how its core features—decentralization and autonomy—interact with the broader institutional framework in which it operates. Specifically, we study how regulative institutional environments (i.e., (il)legalization) shape the growth and development of DAOs while theorizing about the role of both petty and grand corruption (i.e., by higher-level officials) in influencing the effectiveness of these regulative institutions. Our empirical analysis focuses on the global rise of Bitcoin trading and platform establishment across 49 national contexts from 2011 to 2023. Utilizing a unique data set, we find that, although the number of Bitcoin exchange platforms in a country is positively associated with Bitcoin legalization, Bitcoin trading volume is positively associated with Bitcoin illegalization. In countries with higher levels of grand corruption, Bitcoin illegalization becomes even more strongly associated with trading. In contrast, grand corruption dampens the positive association between legalization and the number of Bitcoin exchange platforms. Further, the presence of petty corruption reduces the impact of grand corruption. Our study reveals that it is critical to distinguish between petty and grand corruption as an important factor that influences the interplay between the regulative environment and growth and development of the Bitcoin DAO and the related ecosystem of Bitcoin trading and platform founding.
Article
Full-text available
Place leadership in emerging industries: navigating the controversy and complexities of blockchain technology Abstract. This article explores the critical role of place leadership in advancing blockchain technology, a controversial emerging industry, in the Swiss cantons of Ticino and Zug. It examines how leadership dynamics, actor constellations, and contextual factors shape the growth of such contentious sectors. The study highlights distinct differences in the blockchain industry's development between the two regions, emphasizing the importance of place leadership in navigating the complexities of emerging industries. We argue that while first-mover regions can gain advantages by prioritizing technological experimentation and selectively engaging with criticisms, second-mover regions can also succeed by swiftly focusing on less controversial applications. Across all contexts, robust regulatory frameworks at higher levels are crucial for addressing industry-related controversies.
Chapter
Full-text available
This book discusses digitalization, robotization, and automation of society and of the economy and the use of artificial intelligence from an ethical perspective. After an introduction on the correlation between morality and technology and an assessment of the moral capability of technologies, the book introduces ethical principles serving the evaluation of the digital transformation and the use of artificial intelligence. Subsequently, the digital transformation and its chances and challenges are analyzed from an ethical standpoint. Finally, ethical approaches addressing the challenges are developed. One of the research-focuses of Peter G Kirchschlaeger (Full Professor of Theological Ethics and Director of the Institute of Social Ethics ISE at the Department of Theology of the University of Lucerne; prior Visiting Fellow at Yale University) lies on ethics of digitalization, robotization, automatization, and artificial intelligence.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this research paper is to review and synthesize the role of blockchain technology (BCT) in various types of illegal activities, including but not limited to fraud, money laundering, ransomware attacks, firearms, drug tracking, cyberattacks, identity theft and scams. Design/methodology/approach The authors conducted a review of studies related to illegal activities using blockchain from 2015 to 2023. Next, a thematic review of the literature was performed to see how these illegal activities were conducted using BCT. Findings Through this study, the authors identify the relevant themes that highlight the major illegal activities performed using BCT, its possible steps for prevention and the opportunities for future developments. Finally, the authors provide suggestions for future research using the theory, context and method framework. Originality/value No other research has synthesized the illegal activities using BCT through a thematic approach to the best of the authors’ knowledge. Hence, this study will act as a starting point for future research for academic and technical practitioners in this area.
Article
The authors examine the questions of ensuring national security on the basis of incorporating modern trends of the digitization of society into the classical approach when investigating criminal cases connected with unlawful impact on critical information infrastructure. Using the situational approach, clauses of criminal legislation and the theory of crime qualification, the authors determine the circumstances included in the subject of proof for the criminal cases of unlawful influence on critical information infrastructure, which serves as a foundation for building general and specific criminalistic versions, and is also the basic scheme for making plans during the preliminary investigation. The authors conclude that, in order to obtain a realistic picture, it is necessary and unavoidable that an aggregate of official criminalistic techniques and scientific approaches should be used to study criminal activities in the sphere of information systems. They stress the necessity of studying and incorporating various data of criminal law research into modern investigative practice. The dominant features of the initial stage are identified, which make it possible to formulate its key tasks. The description of the tasks at this stage predetermines its key functions — the search and cognitive work of investigators and the subjects of investigation they interact with, the use of expert knowledge, the leading role of investigative, operative search versions and expert versions. The specific character of information and search for it predetermine the dominance of search, communicative and experimental investigative actions in the structure of the investigation. The analysis of the specific features of carrying out procedural and other actions at the initial stage of investigation allowed the authors to make conclusions about the importance of using tactical complexes in the investigation. They specify a complex of criminalistic recommendations of technical, tactical and methodological character to be implemented in the practice of crime investigation with the purpose of optimizing the counteraction to unlawful impact on critical information infrastructure.
Article
Full-text available
Discover the world’s best science and medicine | Nature.com
Article
Full-text available
Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, SETLcoin, Ether, Solar Coin, or Liberty Reserve exist since 2009. Because of their decentralized control, they are often considered a threat or alternative to the conventional centralized banking system. While the technological implication of some such currencies, especially of Bitcoin, has attracted much attention, so far there is little discussion about the entire field of cryptocurrencies and very little academic literature addressing its ethical significance. In this article, we thus address the impact of “blockchain technology” on the nature of financial transactions from a business ethics perspective. We begin with a survey on relevant literature from neighboring disciplines. Next, we work towards a 3 × 3 framework for current debates on the ethics of cryptocurrencies (see Table 1): we combine the micro, meso, and macro levels of business and society with assessments of the potential ethical impact of cryptocurrencies as morally beneficial, detrimental, and ambiguous. In addition, we highlight possible avenues for future research, such as the changing roles of the miners and regulators, the prosocial use of cryptocurrencies, the antisocial use for shadow banking and transactions in the ‘dark net’ and cryptocurrencies’ effect on inflation and deflation.
Article
Full-text available
Evaluating the evolving controversial digital currency.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose – The purpose of the article is to look closely at the phenomenon of the cryptocurrencies such as and bitcoin to identify their potential vulnerabilities to money laundering and financing of terrorism. It also explores their specific characteristics relevant to ML/FT risks. Design/methodology/approach – Using digicash and bitcoin protocols as primary cases for centralized and decentralized cryptocurrencies we analyse their characteristics against cash and cashless payments. We also draw on “bundle of attributes” that may define their attractiveness for common public or criminals. Findings – Our research shows that characteristics of the cryptocurrencies are unlikely to make them popular among the consumers, as demand for anonymity seems to be overrated. Cryptocurrencies can also be classified as payment instrument rather than private currencies; therefore their embededdness in the financial system minimizes the ML/FT risks. Research limitations/implications – Some decentralized cryptocurrencies operate within informal communities. Therefore, relations within these communities are constantly evolving and need to be monitored further. Practical implications – The paper provides an insight into the mechanics and classification of cryptocurrencies as payment instruments. Place of cryptocurrencies within the broader payment ecosystem defines their potential vulnerabilities to being abused by the criminals. Originality/value – The paper fills the gap in research on cryptocurrencies as payment instruments rather than private currencies and also provides an overview of their relevance for the Anti-money laundering and combating financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) regime.
Book
Die Gedanken sind frei – aber sie sind nicht mehr geheim. Heute werden unsere Daten von Algorithmen automatisch auf der Rückseite der Cloud gespeichert und ausgewertet – dort, wo wir selbst nicht mehr hinschauen können oder gar Kontrolle über unsere Daten hätten. Unsere privatesten und geheimsten Informationen sind dem Internet auf ewig anvertraut und werden mit und ohne unser Einverständnis permanent gesammelt, gestapelt und verknüpft zu unserem digitalen Zwilling. „Privacy is dead“ wie es Mark Zuckerberg formulierte. Aber wie konnte es so weit kommen? Und wenn alle alles wissen: was ist dann heute noch privat, und gibt es dann überhaupt noch persönliche Geheimnisse, wenn die „Götter“ auf der Rückseite der Cloud uns besser kennen als unsere Freunde und Familie? Die zweite Auflage des Buches entwickelt anhand einer Fülle von aktualisierten sowie gänzlich neuen Fallstudien (Krypto-Währungen, Publizistik oder digitale Spuren sexueller Präferenzen) eine ideengeschichtliche Typologie von Privatheit und zeigt, in welchen Lebensbereichen Big Data und Künstliche Intelligenz schon Einzug gehalten hat. Die Autoren Peter Seele ist Professor für Wirtschaftsethik an der Universität der italienischen Schweiz, USI Lugano, ausgebildet als Philosoph und Ökonom. Twitter: @PeterSeele @digital_march Lucas Zapf ist Postdoc, Religionsökonom und interdisziplinärer Geisteswissenschaftler und arbeitet an der Universität Basel. Von den Autoren erscheint bei Springer außerdem das Werk „Der Markt“ existiert nicht. Aufklärung gegen die Marktvergötterung.
Article
So verdienstvoll wie ambitiös diese Wortschöpfung und der dahinter stehende Wille zur Innovation sein mögen, so unglücklich ist das Konzept der „Krypto-Nation“ hinsichtlich seiner Signalwirkung, insbesondere in Richtung USA – und zwar sogar in zweierlei Hinsicht. Zunächst die Chronologie dieser etwas speziellen Wortschöpfung. Die Grundfrage ist, ob man mit dem Organisieren von Geheimnissen auf dem bestmöglichen...
Article
Jede Technologie ist grundsätzlich neutral. Es ist allein der Mensch, der ihren Gebrauch moralisch bewertet, wonach etwas als gut oder schlecht bezeichnet wird. Dies gilt auch und insbesondere für Blockchain- und Kryptowährungen wie Bitcoin, die gegenwärtig fetteste Sau, die gleichzeitig durch das Goldgräber-Bubble-Dorf, durch das Fintec-Dorf, das digitale Disruptions-Dorf oder das Automatisierungs-Job-Verlusts-Dorf getrieben wird. Das Cryptovalley in Zug ist dabei bemüht und erfolgreich, den sich anbahnenden Paradigmenwechsel hin zu dezentral organisierten Digitalwährungen, zu Smart-Contracts und zum Internet der Blockchain-Dinge zu antizipieren. Die Ansiedlung von Etherum ... https://insideparadeplatz.ch/2018/01/02/comeback-des-swiss-nummernkontos-dank-bitcoin-co/
Book
Das vorliegende Buch entwickelt anhand einer Fülle von Fallstudien eine ideengeschichtliche Typologie von Privatheit und zeigt, in welchen Lebensbereichen Big Data schon Einzug gehalten hat. Die Gedanken sind frei – aber sie sind nicht mehr geheim. Heute sind unsere Daten und Gedanken auf der Rückseite der Cloud gespeichert - wohin wir selbst nicht mehr schauen können. Unsere Informationen sind dem Internet auf ewig anvertraut, werden mit und ohne unser Einverständnis gesammelt. „Privacy is dead“ wie es Mark Zuckerberg formulierte. Aber wie konnte es so weit kommen? Und wenn alle alles wissen: Was ist dann heute noch privat, und gibt es dann überhaupt noch Geheimnisse? Mit einem Nachwort zur Privatheit aus juristischer Sicht von Bertil Cottier Die Autoren Peter Seele ist Professor für Corporate Social Responsibility & Business Ethics an der Università della Svizzera italiana in Lugano, ausgebildet als Philosoph und Ökonom. Chr. Lucas Zapf ist Postdoc, Religionsökonom und interdisziplinärer Geisteswissenschaftler und arbeitet an der Universität Basel. Von den Autoren erscheint bei Springer außerdem das Werk „Der Markt“ existiert nicht.
Article
Amid its rapidly increasing usage and immense public interest the subject of Bitcoin has raised profound economic and societal issues. In this paper we undertake economic and econometric modelling of Bitcoin prices. As with many asset classes we show that Bitcoin exhibits speculative bubbles. Further, we find empirical evidence that the fundamental price of Bitcoin is zero.
Article
This paper presents an analysis of the money laundering risks of two virtual currencies, the Linden dollar, the in-world currency of the interactive online environment Second Life, and Bitcoin, an experimental virtual currency that allows for the transfer of value through peer-to-peer software. The paper will demonstrate that although these virtual currencies have money laundering utility, they are currently unsuitable for laundering on a large scale. The paper also considers whether either of these virtual currencies fall under the scope of the Money Laundering Regulations 2007 and draws on similarities with online gambling to suggest a method of incorporating the Linden dollar and Bitcoin within the anti-money laundering framework.