Article

Enrollee Choices after Their Health Plans are Terminated: Default Effects versus Persistent Preferences

January 2016
SSRN Electronic Journal

DOI:10.2139/ssrn.2888968

Authors:

Harvard University

Enrolee outcomes after health insurance plan terminations: a diagnosis of default effects

Article

Jan 2018

Behavioural economic research has established that defaults, one form of nudge, powerfully influence choices. In most policy contexts, all individuals receive the same nudge. We present a model that analyses the optimal universal nudge for a situation in which individuals differ in their preferences and hence should make different choices and may incur a cost for resisting a nudge. Our empirical focus is on terminated choosers (TCs), individuals whose prior choices become no longer available. Specifically, we examine the power of defaults on individuals who had enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage and whose plans were then discontinued. Currently, if these TCs fail to actively choose another Medicare Advantage plan, they are defaulted into traditional fee-for-service Medicare (TM) without drug coverage. Overall, the rate of transition of TCs into TM is low, implying that original preferences and status quo bias overpower the default. Increasing numbers of Americans are choosing plans in health insurance exchange settings such as Medicare, the Affordable Care Act and private exchanges. Plan exits and large numbers of TCs are inevitable, along with other forms of turmoil. Any guidance and defaults provided for TCs should factor in their past revealed preferences.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.

Article

Perspective: Reforming Health Insurance: Realistic Options And Hard Choices

May 2003 · Health Affairs

Joseph Antos

The persistently high number of people reporting that they have no health insurance has precipitated a number of new comprehensive proposals to extend coverage to most Americans. Such proposals must find solutions to fundamental problems that have thus far eluded policymakers, including the role of government regulation, how much to spend, and who should pay. The experience of the 1990s suggests ... [Show full abstract] that an effective policy would offer more choices of health plans through the private market, limit unnecessary government regulation, and provide appropriate subsidies to individuals.

Article

The Effect of Health Insurance on Married Female Labor Supply

December 1999 · The Journal of Human Resources

We investigate the effects of employer-provided health insurance on the labor supply of married women. Because health benefits commonly are restricted to full-time workers, wives who prefer to work short hours but have no alternate source of insurance may work long hours in order to acquire coverage for their families. We use data from the April 1993 Current Population Survey Benefits Supplement, ... [Show full abstract] and we exploit variation in coverage under husbands' health plans to estimate the magnitude of this effect. Our reduced-form labor supply models indicate a strong negative effect of husbands' health insurance on wives' work hours, particularly in families with children. This effect persists when we replace husbands' insurance coverage with husbands' offered insurance, and when we use a multinomial logit model that accounts for unobserved heterogeneity in family labor supply preferences.

Article

Perspectiv e Reforming Health Insurance: Realistic Options And Hard Choices The degree of government...

January 1970

Joseph Antos

The persistently high number of people reporting that they have no health in- surance has precipitated a number of new comprehensive proposals to extend coverage to most Americans. Such proposals must find solutions to fundamental problems that have thus far eluded policymakers, including the role of government regulation, how much to spend, and who should pay. The experience of the 1990s ... [Show full abstract] suggests that an effective policy would offer more choices of health plans through the private market, limit unnecessary gov- ernment regulation, and provide appropriate subsidies to individuals.

Article

A Panel Analysis of the Effects of a Consumer Directed Health Insurance Plan

January 2011 · SSRN Electronic Journal

We investigate the introduction of a Consumer Directed Health Plan (CDHP) in 2005 at a large, self-insured employer. Our relatively long panel enables us to observe utilization and spending for two years prior and four years after the introduction of the CDHP, enabling us to control for unobserved factors that affect both enrollment and utilization. We can also look for evidence of "pent up" ... [Show full abstract] demand or "stocking up" which might bias estimates of the effect of CDHPs in shorter panels. The length of our panel also allows us to determine whether the effects of CDHP enrollment persist over time. The CDHP we study has greater potential to shift spending than those studied in the prior literature because it is associated with an employee-funded health savings account (rather than a pre-Medicare Modernization Act employer-funded reimbursement account). However, we find that CDHP enrollment has little effect on utilization or spending.