Using Social Marketing To Change Winter Holiday Gift Giving Behavior And Improve Well-Being

Thesis · May 2018with 84 Reads
Cite this publication
Abstract
Research has shown that not only does decreasing consumption support the environment; it is also good for our health and well-being. New Dream’s mission, as a national non-profit organization, is to empower individuals, communities and organizations to transform their consumption habits to improve well-being for people and the planet. In collaboration with New Dream, the overall goal of this research was to use social marketing to learn how best to motivate individuals to shift some purchases from material gifts to experiential gifts during the winter holidays. Specifically, the purpose of this study was to explore the attitudes, awareness, barriers, benefits, and any existing behavior around the topic of giving experiential gifts, along with current happiness levels. Respondents were segmented into six groups – participate in outdoor activities, greenminded, happiness level, millennial, income level, and race/ethnicity. Overall, study findings support that those with less material things are happier. In addition, significant differences between segments were found, so it is recommended that multiple messages, graphics and interventions be used to appeal to different priority groups. Although cost was not a top challenge, creating and sharing inexpensive experiential gift ideas would be useful as those with a high income were more likely to give an experiential gift than lower income individuals. Also, messaging around both top benefits associated with experiential gifts (e.g., lasting memories and uniqueness) would be important as they varied between whites and non-whites. Millennials were willing to use an online wish-list to share their gift requests with family. Promoting this ability on various digital channels would be useful. Additional research could include: 1) barriers to giving an outdoor experiential gift, 2) the role of social norms, 3) testing a public health messaging frame, and 4) how to decease consumption as income increases. The results of this research support the social marketing body of knowledge for use with waste reduction and its effect on the environment and health. These results will be provided to the public on New Dream’s website and will inform the development of a 2018 Simplify the Holidays social marketing campaign.

Do you want to read the rest of this thesis?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
This research hasn't been cited in any other publications.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    New technologies are creating possibilities for making household energy consumption visible. With these technologies come opportunities for harnessing the power of social norms (viewed here as rules that are socially enforced) to affect energy consumption. But will those norms favor reductions in energy use? To answer this question, we conduct three online experiments with U.S. participants to assess individual values and normative expectations regarding household carbon emissions. We find that participants both value reducing carbon emissions and expect that others support reductions. The results have implications for non-monetary strategies for affecting household energy consumption. In particular, they suggest that it may be possible to harness the power of social norms not only to directly affect household electricity consumption, but also to shift time of use in ways that facilitate increased incorporation of renewable sources of electricity generation, and therefore a reduced carbon footprint for the grid.
  • Marketing Social Change. Jossey Bass
    • A Andreasen
    Andreasen, A. (1995). Marketing Social Change. Jossey Bass. San Francisco, CA.
  • Why You Should Spend Your Money on Experiences, Not Things. Huffington Post
    • T Bradberry
    Bradberry, T. (2017). Why You Should Spend Your Money on Experiences, Not Things. Huffington Post. March 20, 2017. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-travisbradberry/why-you-should-spend-your_b_9490244.html.
  • How many people can the earth support? The New York Review
    • J E Cohen
    Cohen, J.E. (1995). How many people can the earth support? The New York Review. New York, Norton.
  • Overconsumption Is Costing Us The Earth and Human Happiness. The Guardian
    • C Cole
    Cole, C. (2010). Overconsumption Is Costing Us The Earth and Human Happiness. The Guardian. June 21, 1010. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/jun/21/overconsumption-environmentrelationships-annie-leonard.
  • New Dream Focus Group results
    • K Dennings
    Dennings, K. (2017). New Dream Focus Group results. Internal memo.
  • Our Brains Love New Stuff, and it's Killing the Planet
    • A C Duhaime
    Duhaime, A.C. (2017). Our Brains Love New Stuff, and it's Killing the Planet. Harvard Business Review. March 17, 2017. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at https://hbr.org/2017/03/our-brains-love-new-stuffand-its-killing-the-planet.
  • World happiness report. The Earth Institute
    • J Helliwell
    • R Layard
    • J Sachs
    Helliwell, J. & Layard, R. and Sachs, J. (2017). World happiness report. The Earth Institute, Columbia University, New York.
  • Green Partners Behavior Change Survey
    • M N Hennepin County
    Hennepin County, MN. (2017). Green Partners Behavior Change Survey. Retrieved on 9/28/2017 at http://www.hennepin.us/business/work-with-henn-co/green-partners-enviro-ed-prog
  • Do We Need $75,000 a Year to Be Happy? Time
    • B Luscombe
    Luscombe, B. (2010). Do We Need $75,000 a Year to Be Happy? Time. September 6, 2010. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2019628,00.html
  • Are We Happy Yet? Published online at pewsocialtrends.org. Retrieved on 9
    • Pew Research
    • Center
    Pew Research Center. (2006). Are We Happy Yet? Published online at pewsocialtrends.org. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2006/02/13/are-we-happy-yet/.
  • Principles of the Ethical Practice of Public Health
    Public Health Leadership Society. (2002). Principles of the Ethical Practice of Public Health.
  • Material Values Scale, Happiness subscale, Question 15 & 17
    • M Richins
    • S Dawson
    Richins, M. & Dawson, S. (1992). Material Values Scale, Happiness subscale, Question 15 & 17. Retrieved on 9/28/2017 at http://digital.lib.hkbu.edu.hk/materialism/studies.php
  • Consumed: Why More Stuff Does Not Mean More Happiness. The Conversation
    • J Stark
    Stark, J. (2017). Consumed: Why More Stuff Does Not Mean More Happiness. The Conversation. April 13, 2017. Retrieved on 9/9/2017 at http://theconversation.com/consumed-why-more-stuffdoes-not-mean-more-happiness-39220.
  • Quick Facts: North Carolina
    • U S Bureau
    U.S. Census Bureau. (2017). Quick Facts: North Carolina. Retrieved on 9/9/17 at https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/NC.
  • Waste Reduction Questionnaire
    • Ireland Birdhill
    Birdhill, Ireland. (2017). Waste Reduction Questionnaire. Retrieved on 9/28/2017 at http://www.birdhilltidytowns.ie/waste_reduction_.html
  • Article
    Does environmentally-friendly behavior necessarily imply sacrifice? In the metric of subjective well-being, research has shown that green behavior and sustainable consumption are positively related to life satisfaction. We extend this research analyzing UKHLS household panel data for Great Britain, showing that this boost in life satisfaction is mostly due to self-image (i.e. one's own assessment of how environmentally-friendly one's behavior is) but not due to concrete pro-environmental behaviors such as conserving water, recycling and so on. We further show that green self-image increases the extent and intensity of green behavior yet even the greenest (self-identified) individuals do not consistently exhibit all pro-environmental behaviors. By this, our data can be used to assess the varying extent of a value-action gap for different pro-environmental behaviors for our sample. (126 words)
  • Article
    Consumers prefer locally grown food products. One source that provides local food is urban agriculture, the farming in and around cities. A number of urban farmers are selling their products directly to consumers. In addition, consumers have the option to grow their own food on certain urban farms. Given this, we investigate how likely consumers are to purchase or grow their own food at urban farms and what determines this likelihood. Given that millennials are a key stakeholder of sustainable consumption and those with the greatest increase in numbers of food gardeners, we conducted an online survey with over 300 Generation Y respondents. We investigate whether young consumers perceive the health impacts and environmental benefits provided by urban agriculture, and what attitudes they hold towards this source of produce. Empirical results show that both psychological and personal factors affect consumer intentions to participate in urban agriculture. Among others, subjective knowledge regarding urban agriculture and a generally favorable attitude towards urban farms increases the likelihood to buy and grow produce at urban farms. Female and older consumers are more likely to grow their own produce. These findings can be used by stakeholders in urban agriculture to design target-oriented marketing activities.
  • Article
    During the last decade, the purchase of organic food within a sustainable consumption context has gained momentum. Consequently, the amount of research in the field has increased, leading in some cases to discrepancies regarding both methods and results. The present review examines those works that applied the theory of planned behavior (TPB; Ajzen, 1991) as a theoretical framework in order to understand and predict consumers’ motivation to buy organic food. A meta-analysis has been conducted to assess the strength of the relationships between attitude, subjective norms, perceived behavioral control, and intention, as well as between intention and behavior. Results confirm the major role played by individual attitude in shaping buying intention, followed by subjective norms and perceived behavioral control. Intention-behavior shows a large effect size, few studies however explicitly reported such an association. Furthermore, starting from a pooled correlation matrix, a meta-analytic structural equation model has been applied to jointly evaluate the strength of the relationships among the factors of the original model. Results suggest the robustness of the TPB model. In addition, mediation analysis indicates a potential direct effect from subjective norms to individual attitude in the present context. Finally, some issues regarding methodological aspects of the application of the TPB within the context of organic food are discussed for further research developments.
  • Article
    Water shortages are an increasingly significant social and economic issue in many countries. Increasing the supply of water is one solution (e.g. desalination plants, new dams), but such measures are expensive. Using price to manage household water demand may be viewed as socially unequitable and politically contentious. Social marketing campaigns, where voluntary behaviour change is the goal, provide the potential to foster sustainable consumption of an increasingly scarce yet essential resource. This paper details a case study of successful water demand management in a drought affected region of South-Eastern Australia. In this region, water consumption was reduced to more sustainable levels through a targeted and successful social marketing campaign. This case is of significant relevance to the field of Social Marketing where there are increasing calls for research into environmental issues in general and water consumption in particular (Kotler, 2011). The extant research literature and this case study are integrated to form several propositions about household water consumption behaviour. Consequently, this paper contributes to the literature by providing a conceptualisation of how residents respond to water conservation related social marketing campaigns. Key issues include the potential for reciprocal behaviour by consumers when a water authority is perceived to manage the water problem effectively, and linking behaviour change through structural approaches (e.g. subsidies and restrictions) and voluntarist approaches (e.g. attitudinal change). Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
  • Article
    The relationship between money and happiness is surprisingly weak, which may stem in part from the way people spend it. Drawing on empirical research, we propose eight principles designed to help consumers get more happiness for their money. Specifically, we suggest that consumers should (1) buy more experiences and fewer material goods; (2) use their money to benefit others rather than themselves; (3) buy many small pleasures rather than fewer large ones; (4) eschew extended warranties and other forms of overpriced insurance; (5) delay consumption; (6) consider how peripheral features of their purchases may affect their day-to-day lives; (7) beware of comparison shopping; and (8) pay close attention to the happiness of others.
  • Article
    This book provides an in-depth psychological analysis of consumerism that draws from a wide range of theoretical, clinical, and methodological approaches. The contributors to this edited book demonstrate that consumerism and the culture that surround it exert profound and often undesirable effects both on people's individual lives and on society as a whole. Far from being different influences, advertising, consumption, materialism, and the capitalistic economic system affect personal, social, and ecological well-being as well as childhood development. The book makes a strong case that despite psychology's past reticence to investigate issues related to consumerism, such topics are crucial to understanding human life in the contemporary age. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
  • Article
    Full-text available
    When do people feel as if they are rich in time? Not often, research and daily experience suggest. However, three experiments showed that participants who felt awe, relative to other emotions, felt they had more time available (Experiments 1 and 3) and were less impatient (Experiment 2). Participants who experienced awe also were more willing to volunteer their time to help other people (Experiment 2), more strongly preferred experiences over material products (Experiment 3), and experienced greater life satisfaction (Experiment 3). Mediation analyses revealed that these changes in decision making and well-being were due to awe's ability to alter the subjective experience of time. Experiences of awe bring people into the present moment, and being in the present moment underlies awe's capacity to adjust time perception, influence decisions, and make life feel more satisfying than it would otherwise.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Happiness and ecological well-being are often portrayed as conflictual pursuits, but they may actually be complementary. In samples of adolescents (Study 1) and adults (Study 2), we tested this proposition and examined the role of three factors in promoting both subjective well-being (SWB) and ecologically responsible behavior (ERB). In both studies, individuals higher in SWB reported more ERB. An intrinsic value orientation (Studies 1 and 2) and dispositional mindfulness (Study 2) related to higher SWB and ERB, while a lifestyle of voluntary simplicity (Study 2) related to higher ERB. Further analyses showed that the compatibility of SWB and ERB was explained by intrinsic values and mindfulness. These findings offer clues to a sustainable way of life that enhances both personal and collective well-being.
  • Article
    The visible landscape is believed to affect human beings in many ways, including aesthetic appreciation and health and well-being. The aim of this paper is to analyse the range of landscapes used in environmental psychology studies, and the evidence of health effects related to viewing these landscapes. A literature review of publications linking landscapes and health effects was conducted. This reported evidence of health and well-being effects related to exposure to visual landscapes. The results of the review include an overview of the types of landscape used in the studies, the evidence on health effects, the methods and measures applied and the different groups of respondents. The analysis reveals a predominance of studies using only coarse categories of landscapes. Most landscape representations have been classed as “natural” or “urban”. Few studies were found to use subcategories within these groups. Generally, the natural landscapes gave a stronger positive health effect compared to urban landscapes. Urban landscapes were found to have a less positive and in some cases negative effect on health. Three main kinds of health effects have been identified in the study; short-term recovery from stress or mental fatigue, faster physical recovery from illness and long-term overall improvement on people's health and well-being.The study provides an overview of the relationships between health and landscapes arranged in an accessible format, identifying gaps in our knowledge requiring further research. The identification of quantifiable landscape attributes that affect health is seen as an important factor in enabling future landscape design to be of benefit to human health.
  • Article
    Extending resistance theories, this article examines multi-method data spanning over seven years of events related to a holiday market. In the context of Valentine's Day, the authors present findings and develop knowledge on anti-consumption and alternative consumption. Specifically, this article introduces the recurring events of gift-resistance, retail-resistance, and market-resistance. Such consumer resistance often coexists with movements towards individualism and creation of more unique alternative consumption traditions.
  • Article
    This article considers the potential of the discipline of marketing to contribute to consumption reduction from a social marketing perspective. The authors review the difficulties of applying conventional marketing theory and practice in pursuit of more sustainable consumption, and the logic of applying an adapted form of social marketing to promote more sustainable lifestyles and reductions in consumption. This study also uses a health-oriented social marketing campaign to demonstrate the potential of a social marketing approach to address ingrained forms of consumer behavior and to successfully ‘de-market’ products.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Whilst urban-dwelling individuals who seek out parks and gardens appear to intuitively understand the personal health and well-being benefits arising from 'contact with nature', public health strategies are yet to maximize the untapped resource nature provides, including the benefits of nature contact as an upstream health promotion intervention for populations. This paper presents a summary of empirical, theoretical and anecdotal evidence drawn from a literature review of the human health benefits of contact with nature. Initial findings indicate that nature plays a vital role in human health and well-being, and that parks and nature reserves play a significant role by providing access to nature for individuals. Implications suggest contact with nature may provide an effective population-wide strategy in prevention of mental ill health, with potential application for sub-populations, communities and individuals at higher risk of ill health. Recommendations include further investigation of 'contact with nature' in population health, and examination of the benefits of nature-based interventions. To maximize use of 'contact with nature' in the health promotion of populations, collaborative strategies between researchers and primary health, social services, urban planning and environmental management sectors are required. This approach offers not only an augmentation of existing health promotion and prevention activities, but provides the basis for a socio-ecological approach to public health that incorporates environmental sustainability.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Do experiences make people happier than material possessions? In two surveys, respondents from various demographic groups indicated that experiential purchases-those made with the primary intention of acquiring a life experience--made them happier than material purchases. In a follow-up laboratory experiment, participants experienced more positive feelings after pondering an experiential purchase than after pondering a material purchase. In another experiment, participants were more likely to anticipate that experiences would make them happier than material possessions after adopting a temporally distant, versus a temporally proximate, perspective. The discussion focuses on evidence that experiences make people happier because they are more open to positive reinterpretations, are a more meaningful part of one's identity, and contribute more to successful social relationships.