ArticlePDF Available

Development of a Macroinvertebrate - based Index of Biotic Integrity (M-IBI) for Colombo-Sri Jayawardhanapura Canal System (A new approach to assess stream/ wetland health)

Authors:

Figures

Study area map: Colombo -Sri Jayewardenepura canal system 2.2. Data Collection Biological sampling and habitat assessments were made in ten sampling sites on monthly basis during the period of November 2008 to June 2009. After developing the index a new set of samples was obtained for validation test during the period of May to June 2011. It was included with 3 new sites. Macroinvertebrates were sampled using a D-framed kick net with a 400 µm mesh bag. It was dragged along both river banks within a known distance (10 meters). Collected macroinvertebrate samples were sorted and identified at least up to family level by using naked eye, a hand lens or microscope and according to both locally and internationally reputed keys and guides such as Mendis and Fernando (1962), Fernando, (1963, 1964, and 1969), The Waterwatch Australia Steering Committee (2004) and Bartlett (2009), then enumerated and computerized. Some of the physical and-chemical parameters like Temperature, pH value, Conductivity and Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) of the water were measured at the field using potable measuring instrument [Electrical Conductivity Metre (340-set1, WTW Co., Weilheim, Germany)]. For further water quality analysis, additional water samples were collected and brought into the laboratory. Then, other physical and chemical parameters were analyzed in the laboratory as mentioned below; dissolved oxygen (DO): Winkler Method, Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD): standard5-day BOD testing method, Alkalinity and Cl -concentration: Titrimetric.
… 
Content may be subject to copyright.
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
10
Development of a Macroinvertebrate–based Index of Biotic Integrity
(MIBI) for Colombo-Sri Jayewardenepura Canal System
L. G. R. Y. Perera
1
*, J. Wattavidanage
1
, and N. Nilakarawasam
1
1
Department of Zoology, Open University of Sri Lanka, Nawala, Nugegoda, Sri Lanka
Date Received: 10-06-2011 Date Accepted: 22-02-2012
Abstract
Macroinvertebrates have been identified as excellent indicators of stream/ wetland health as they
respond rapidly to environmental changes and provide short to medium term pollution history records.
Current study was aimed to develop a Macroinvertebrate-based Index of Biotic Integrity (M-IBI) which
is a new approach to monitor stream/wetland health of Colombo-Sri Jayewardenepura canal system.
Sixty eight macroinvertebrate samples were obtained using a D-framed kick net from ten stations
namely Kotte, Nawala, OUSL, Kirimandala Mw., Wellawatta, Orugodawatta, St. Sebastian, Beira Lake,
Buthgamuwa and Royal Park representing main branches of the system and marshes covering dissimilar
environmental conditions of the canal system during the period of Nov. 2008 to June 2009 on monthly
basis. Habitat characteristics and some water quality parameters also recorded. For the index
development, those ten stations were grouped into two as ’Reference’ and Degraded’ based on their
environmental conditions. Then ten candidate metrics were selected out of 41 for M-IBI development
after evaluating their sensitivity and appropriateness. Validity of the index was tested with a new
independent data set. Scores acquired were positively correlated with DO values (r = 0.578). That
concluded the potential of using M-IBI developed for biological monitoring and improving biotic
integrity of streams/ wetlands.
Keywords:
Macroinvertebrates, stream health, biotic integrity, Multimetric index, Colombo-Sri
Jayewardenepura canal system
1. Introduction
The canal system which is in and around Colombo-Sri Jayewardenepura area is currently in such
an environmentally deteriorated condition due to rapid development and urbanization of the area. The
quality of water and habitat in most of the areas are influenced by industrial and public effluent
discharge to the canal system. According to the Beira Lake Restoration Study (1993) cited by Fernando
(1994), the data collected by the Central Environmental Authority during a period of 23 months (from
March 1991 to February 1993) has shown that St. Sebastian canal, which is a branch of the Colombo
canal system, had recorded high turbidity, BOD and COD values, richer in nutrients; reduction of nitrate
into nitrite and ammonia (due to eutrophication), high concentrations of metals and faecal coliform.
*
Correspondence: ousl.ruvini@gmail.com
Tel-++ 94 77236 8009
ISSN 2235-9370 Print / ISSN 2235-9362 Online ©2012 University of Sri Jayewardenepura
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
11
These records have already shown an unhealthy condition of the canal system for living beings. Also it
has been severely affected on well being of the community live around the canal system. Aquatic
macroinvertebrates are organisms that are large enough to be seen with the naked eye, lack of a
backbone and inhibit all types of waters including lentic, lotic and muddy habitats (Viklund, 2011).
They are capable of indicating any change in the environment through their responses at different levels
of organization, ranging from the individual animal to the total invertebrate community (Hodkinson and
Jackson, 2005). Since they live in the water for all or most of their life cycle, are exposed directly to the
stress of pollution and the prevailing conditions of the aquatic environment, are easy to collect, differ in
their tolerance to amount and types of pollution, are easy to identify, often live for more than one year
thus well suited to long-term observation of stresses. Their high species diversity which means many
potentially different reactions to many different environmental effects can be used as bioindicators for
assessing and monitoring the state of health of aquatic environments (Invertebrates as indicators, 2008).
The biological integrity of a stream or an aquatic ecosystem means how well the habitat can support
biological communities, including algae, invertebrates, fish, aquatic mammals and birds. For a given
habitat, to have high biological integrity, it should be unimpaired or minimally disturbed by human or
other activities and must contain a diverse assemblage of naturally occurring plants and animals (Jensen,
2007).
Multimetric indices are commonly used for evaluating the biological condition of water bodies.
Most multimetric indices consist of a number of measures or metrics (attributes), describing a specific
assemblage like fish or macroinvertebrates, which are combined into a single ‘multimetric’ value
representing the condition of a water body (Blocksom, 2003). These metrics can represent a wide range
of ecological characteristics, including taxa richness, taxonomic composition, pollution tolerance,
functional feeding groups, and behavioural habits. The Indices of Biotic/Biological Integrity (IBI) are
one form of Multimetric index that focuses on Fish, Periphyton, or Benthic communities. These IBIs are
region-specific due to the variations in communities across a wide range of ecological habitats.
Therefore it is only applicable only for regions that show same environmental conditions (Wittman and
Mundahl, 2002).
This study was aimed to develop a macroinvertebrate-based multimetric index of biological
integrity as an alternative for other conventional methods like chemical and instrumental which are
much expensive and need advance laboratory facilities.
2. Methodology
2.1. Study Area
Colombo-Sri Jayewardenepura (Diyawanna Oya) canal net work is a man made canal system
which is located on the left bank of the lower valley of Kelani Ganga. It is situated in the Western
province, Colombo district of Sri Lanka, latitudes 6 52’ 55” - 6 55’ 45” N and longitudes 79 52’ 35” - 79
55’ 15” E. Main catchment areas of the canal system are the low-lying marshlands known as
Kolonnawa, Heen Ela and Kotte marsh (Figure 1). These are also important as major flood detention
zones in the city of Colombo (Colombo Flood Detention Areas, 1995). Total area of the marsh is around
400ha. The canal system has 3 outfalls to the sea namely Mutwal (underground tunnel system),
Wellawatta and Dehiwala (last two are open drains). The average depth of these canals is about 1.5
meters. It may vary seasonally due to heavy sedimentation of silts and bank erosion in the rainy season
and it was frequently clogged with floating weeds & dumps (polythene, plastics & domestic wastes). It
has been found that 43.5% of the families in the study area dump their household garbage into the marsh
(Colombo Flood Detention Areas, 1995). Present study was carried out covering an extensive area of the
canal network. Ten sites were selected considering human factors (such as density of settlements,
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
12
industries, etc.), habitat characteristics (such as availability of marshlands and riparian vegetation) and
representing significant canals and streams.
Figure 1: Study area map: Colombo - Sri Jayewardenepura canal system
2.2. Data Collection
Biological sampling and habitat assessments were made in ten sampling sites on monthly basis
during the period of November 2008 to June 2009. After developing the index a new set of samples was
obtained for validation test during the period of May to June 2011. It was included with 3 new sites.
Macroinvertebrates were sampled using a D-framed kick net with a 400 µm mesh bag. It was dragged
along both river banks within a known distance (10 meters). Collected macroinvertebrate samples were
sorted and identified at least up to family level by using naked eye, a hand lens or microscope and
according to both locally and internationally reputed
keys and guides such as Mendis and Fernando
(1962), Fernando, (1963, 1964, and 1969), The Waterwatch Australia Steering Committee (2004) and
Bartlett (2009), then enumerated and computerized. Some of the physical and-chemical parameters like
Temperature, pH value, Conductivity and Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) of the water were measured at
the field using potable measuring instrument [Electrical Conductivity Metre (340-set1, WTW Co.,
Weilheim, Germany)]. For further water quality analysis, additional water samples were collected and
brought into the laboratory. Then, other physical and chemical parameters were analyzed in the
laboratory as mentioned below; dissolved oxygen (DO): Winkler Method, Biochemical Oxygen Demand
(BOD): standard5-day BOD testing method, Alkalinity and Cl
-
concentration: Titrimetric.
2.3. Data Analysis
Following steps were used to analyse data collected to develop the Macroinvertebrate-based
Index of Biotic Integrity (M-IBI).
Step 1. Identification of Reference and Degraded sites (sampling stations): Reference and Degraded sites
were identified and designated based on selection criteria (Table 1) that comprise both laboratory and
field survey records (DO value, BOD value, urban land and Forested land use practices of the area).
1
4
2
6
3
5
7
8
10
9
v1 v2
v3
N
Marshlands
Paddy fields
Study area
Flow direction
Main canals
Sampling Sites:
1. Kotte
2. Nawala
3. OUSL
4. Kirimandala Mw.
5. Wellawatta
6. Orugodawatta
7. St. Sebastian
8. Beira Lake
9. Budhgamuwa
10. Royal Park
Extra sites used for
Validation:
V1. Torrington
V2. Kotte Lake
V3. Kotte Bridge
Map of Sri
Lanka
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
13
Table 1: Criteria used for designating reference and degraded sampling sites
Reference site Degraded site Reference
DO value >= 2.5
Urban land use <= 50%
Forested/Marshy land use > 25%
BOD value < 5mg/L
DO value < 2.5
Urban land use > 50%
Forested/ Marshy land use < 25%
BOD value >= 5mg/L
(Stribling et al., 1998)
(Stribling et al., 1998)
(Stribling et al., 1998)
(Chauhan et al., 2011)
Step 2. Compiling and calculating candidate metrics: Candidate metrics for testing and potential
inclusion in the M-IBI were nominated primarily by assessing the previous work done, parallel studies
or documents/ protocols/ guidelines published by varies authors or institutes such as Stribling (1998),
Chirhart (2003), Macroinvertebrates as bio-indicators (2008), Jensen (2007), Calculating and
Interpreting the Genus-Level B-IBI (2001), Bennett and Rysavy (2003), Wittman and Mundahl (2002),
Weigel et al. (2002), Mandaville (2002) and Karr et al. (2002). These Macroinvertebrate based 41
candidate metrics were grouped in to five and listed out with their possible response to environmental
stresses (stream impairment) in Table 2.
Table 2: Candidate metrics and their predicted response to increasing stressors
Candidate Metric Predicted response
1. Taxonomic Richness
(i). Overall Species Richness Decrease
(ii). Tot no of individuals of the sample (Average ) Decrease
(iii). Tot EPT
(Ephemeroptera+Plecoptera+Tricoptera) Decrease
(iv). No of Diptera Taxa Decrease
(v). No of Molluscs Taxa Decrease
(vi). No of Odonata Taxa Decrease
(vii). No of Hemiptera Taxa Decrease
(viii). No of Coleoptera Taxa Decrease
(ix). No of Annelida/Policheata Taxa Decrease
(x). No of Crustacea Taxa Decrease
(xi). No of Chironomidae Taxa Decrease
2. Taxonomic composition & Abundance
(xii). % of Diptera Increase
(xiii). % of EPT Decrease
(xiv). % of Molluscs Decrease
(xv). % of Odonata Decrease
(xvi). % of Hemiptera Decrease
(xvii). % of Coleoptera Decrease
(xviii). % of Annelid/ Polycheats Decrease
(xix). % of Crustacen Decrease
(xx). % of Chironomids Increase
(xxi). Most abundant species and % Decrease
Table 2 continues …
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
14
3. Pollution Tolerance / Intolerance
(xxii) Hilsenhoff family biotic index (FBI) Increase
(xxiii) No of Intolerant Taxa Decrease
(xxiv) No of Intolerant Individuals Decrease
(xxv) % Intolerant Ind of the sample Decrease
(xxvi) No of Tolerant Taxa Increase
(xxvii) No of Tolerant Individuals Increase
(xxviii) % Tolerant Ind of the sample Increase
4. Trophic Structure (Functional Feeding Groups)
(xxix) No of Predator Taxa Decrease
(xxx) No of Collector - Gatherer Taxa Variable
(xxxi) No of Collector - Filter Taxa Variable
(xxxii) No of Scraper Taxa Decrease
(xxxiii) No of Shredder Taxa Decrease
(xxxiv) % Predator Individuals Decrease
(xxxv) % Collector - Gatherer Individuals Decrease
(xxxvi) % Collector - Filter Individuals Decrease
(xxxvii) % Scraper Individuals Decrease
(xxxviii) % Shredder Individuals Decrease
5. Incorporated Diversity
(xxxix) Shannon-Wiener diversity index (H) Decrease
(xxxl) Simpson's Diversity Index (1-D) Decrease
6. Proportional Metrics
(xxxli) Heterogeneity Decrease
Step 3. Selecting Candidate Metrics: The criterion used for the selection of Candidate Metrics was based
on;
1. Their sensitivity to stream impairment/ human influences: Each candidate metrics was tested to
determine its correlation with environmental parameters such as DO, Cl
-
, TDS and Conductivity by
using Pearson’s Product-Moment Correlation method. Metrics showed significant correlation (r >= 0.5
/ -0.5) with those environment parameters were considered further.
2. Their ability to distinguish between Reference and Degraded sites: The distributions of metric values
of Reference and Degraded sites were compared using a non parametric statistical test (t test). Metrics
whose values differed between reference and degraded sites (p < 0.05) were retained for further
analysis, whereas those metrics having similar medians and distributions in reference and degraded
sites were eliminated.
3. Their contribution of non-redundant information to the M-IBI: Many metrics are sensitive to the
same change in conditions of stream habitat. These metrics that are highly correlated with one another
do not contribute much new information to the M-IBI score (Stribling, 1998). Hence the redundancies
among these metrics were calculated using Pearson’s product-movement correlation method.
Redundant metrics (r >= 0.75) were used in index combinations only if inclusion increased the index
classification efficiency.
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
15
Step 4. Index development and scoring: Finalized metrics for the index development were further taken
into consideration and the calculated metric values were converted to metric scores. Quartile statistics
for each of the final metrics were calculated for both reference and degraded data sets. Metric values that
are equal or above 25
th
percentile of reference sites were scored as 5 while metric values equal or lower
than 25th percentile of degraded sites were scored as 0 and those were in between these two boundaries
were scored as 3. To obtain the final M-IBI for a given site, scores obtained for all metrics simply added
together. Metrics those expectations were reversed were scored conversely. Finally the qualitative
ratings and the stream condition that describe the status of the canal assessed were developed for five
rating categories as excellent, good, fair, poor and very poor by dividing the total index score into five
equal classes.
Step 5. M-IBI testing and validation: Once the M-IBI was developed it was tested using a new
independent data set of macroinvertebrates collected from ten sites of Colombo-Sri Jayawardhanpura
Canal system during the period of April-May, 2011. Apart from seven sampling stations used for index
development there were three (3) new sampling sites namely, Torrington, Kotte Lake (near renovation
site) and Kotte Bridge (near Lion’s club). Also to test the validity and to check if any relationship
existed between the M-IBI and habitat parameters used in conventional monitoring, M-IBI scores were
plotted against habitat parameters (DO value) for all ten sites.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Habitat assessment and designation of sampling stations
Based on the criteria developed for designating reference and degraded sites; Kotte, Nawala,
OUSL, Buthgamuawa and Royal Park sites were declared as reference sites whereas the others were as
degraded sites. Evaluation criteria and the scores obtained for sites are given in Table 3.
Table 3: Evaluation and designation of sampling stations base on their DO, BOD values, urban land use
and Forested land use practices of the surrounding area
Sampling Station
DO
value >
2.5
BOD
value <
5mg/L
Urban
Land Use
< 50%
Forested
Land Use
> 25%
Total
Score
Category
(Reference>=3/
Degraded <3)
Kotte 1 1 1 1 4 Reference
Nawala 1 1 0 1 3 Reference
OUSL 1 1 0 1 3 Reference
Kirimandala MW 0 1 0 1 2 Degraded
Wellawatta 0 1 0 0 1 Degraded
Orugodawatta 0 1 0 0 1 Degraded
St. Sebastian 0 1 0 0 1 Degraded
Beira Lake 0 0 0 0 0 Degraded
Buthgamuwa 1 1 1 1 4 Reference
Royal Park 1 1 1 1 4 Reference
3.2. Metric selection and evaluation
Results for the first step of metrics evaluation was obtained by finding the correlation between
41 candidate metrics and DO, Cl-, TDS and Conductivity values, also between reference and degraded
sites. Thirty one candidate metrics resulted Pearson’s correlation coefficient value as (r) >=0.50 or -0.50
and got the conclusion as ‘Positive’. As for the second step, again a t- test was done for all candidate
metrics and out of them 11 metrics resulted as ‘Positive’. Collectively, fifteen candidate metrics
representing five main categories (ecological characteristics) were qualified for the next step which was
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
16
for the redundancy. After considering the redundancy test results, ten metrics that had less occurrence of
obtaining redundancy value (r) >= 0.75 were considered for the index development. However candidate
metrics like; (i) overall species richness, (x) no of crustacean taxa, (xxx) Shannon-wiener index and
(xxxli) Heterogeneity were included to the final list as to increase the classification efficiency.
3.3. Index development and scoring
As the final outcome, ten (10) out of forty one (41) candidate metrics were designated for the M-
IBI development. Then their values were converted to unitless M-IBI scores as in Table 4.
Table 4: Scoring Criteria for the ten metrics used in Macroinvertebrates based Index of Biological
Integrity (M-IBI)
Finally, the status or the narrative ratings of the M-IBI and their score were classed into five
ranges (rating categories) as excellent, good, fair, poor and very poor as given in Table 05.
Table 5: M-IBI score ranges and corresponding narrative ratings
3.4. M-IBI testing and validation
M-IMI scores and stream conditions obtained from the validation test done with the independent
data set (ten sites) are shown in Table 06. The M-IBI scores ranged from 17 to 40 for the tested sites.
According to the test results, none of the sites were ranked as ‘Excellent’. Site named as Royal Park was
ranked as ‘Good’ while others were ‘Fair’ for 6 sites (Nawala, OUSL bridge, Kirimandala Mw.,
Torrington, Kotte Lake & Buthdamuwa), ‘Poor’ for the sites called Senanayake Ground (Kotte) and
Kotte bridge, and “Very Poor” for Wellawatta. These M-IBI scores were positively correlated (r =
0.578) with habitat parameter (DO values) recorded from same tested sites. Additional tests are needed
to be conducted with more sites for further improvements
.
Metrics
Predicted
response to
increasing
stressors
M-IBI Score
5 3 1
Overall Species Richness Decrease >14.67
14.67 - 6.67
<6.67
No of Hemiptera Taxa Decrease >1.75
1.75 - 0.00
<0.00
No of Coleoptera Taxa Decrease >2.67
2.67 - 0.00
<0.00
No of Crustacea Taxa Decrease >2.25
2.25 - 0.25
<0.25
% of Diptera Increase <2.33%
2.33 - 51.79%
>51.79%
% of Odonata Decrease >2.04%
2.04 - 0.52%
<0.52%
No of Intolerant Taxa Decrease >1.25
1.25 - 0.50
<0.50
No of Collector - Gatherer Taxa Decrease >5.50
5.50 - 2.67
<2.67
Shannon-Wiener diversity index (H) Decrease >1.95
1.95 - 1.59
<1.59
Heterogeneity Increase <67.44%
67.44 - 87.77%
> 87.77%
M-IBI Score Stream condition (Narrative rating)
50 – 46 Excellent
38 – 45 Good
28 – 37 Fair
18 – 27 Poor
10 – 17 Very Poor
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
17
Table 06: M-IBI scores and narrative rating (stream condition) of ten tested sites
Tag No Site location
Canal name
M-IBI score
(Narrative rating)
1 Senanayake lane
Kotte canal
20
Poor
2
Nawala Road
Kotte canal
30
Fair
3
Narahenpita Rd
- OUSL bridge
Kotte
canal 36
Fair
4 Kirimandala Mawatha
Heen ela (canal)
32
Fair
5
Near St Peter's College
Wellawatta canal
17
Very Poor
6 Heen Marsh
Torington canal
28
Fair
7 Wetland restoration site
Kotte lake
28
Fair
8 Kotte bridge - near Lion's club
Kotte canal
18
Poor
9 Buthgamuwa - Kolonnawa
Marsh
Kolonnawa canal
36
Fair
10 Heen Marsh - near Royal Park
Heen ela (canal)
40
Good
Figure 2: Overview of the stream condition from the scores obtained for ten sites tested
4. Conclusion
The M-IBI has shown the potential of using it for biomonitoring and improving biotic integrity
of streams/ wetlands. Excluding monitoring the health of a natural freshwater ecosystem, M-IBI can be
used for monitoring the progress of restored or constructed ecosystems particularly for a renovated
wetland like Diyawannawa Oya. It is ready to be introduced to any government authorities institutes,
neighbouring schools, universities, etc. who engaged in stream health monitoring.
Acknowledgements: Authors wish to express their sincere thanks to Asian Development Bank (ADB)
for providing financial aid, to Dean/Faculty of Natural Sciences, The Open University of Sri Lanka
(OUSL), to all academic and non-academic staff of the Department of Zoology, OUSL and also to the
admin staff and the field crew of Research & Development Division, SLLRDC for their immense
support given to make this effort a success.
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
18
References
Bartlett, T., 2009. BugGuide.Net [online]. Hosted by Iowa State University Entomology. Available
from: http://bugguide.net/ [last accessed 30th May,2011].
Bennett, S. and Kieran Rysavy, 2003. A benthic Invertebrate Index of biological Integrity for Stream in
the Bulkley TSA (Filed Session 2002). Biologic Consulting Terrace, BC.
Blocksom, K.A., 2003. A Performance comparison of metric scoring methods for a multimetric index
for Mix-Atlantic Highlands streams. Environmental Management vol. 31, no. 5.pp. 670-682.
Calculating and Interpreting the Genus-Level B-IBI, 2001. adapted from:
http://www.cbr.washington.edu/salmonweb/ [Accessed 1 September 2010].
Chauhan, A., Chauhan,S., Singh,A. P., Chamoli,N. and Pande, K.K., 2011. Evaluation Of Garhwal
Springs Water For Drinking Purpose By Using Water Quality Index. Nature and Science; 9(1):80-
84. [online] http://www.sciencepub.net/nature.
Chirhart, J., 2003. Development of a Macroinvertebrate Index of Biological Integrity (MIBI) for Rivers
and Streams of the St. Croix River Basin in Minnesota. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency,
Biological Monitoring Program.
Colombo Flood Detention Areas, 1995. Wetland sites report. Central Environmental Authority. Wetland
Conservation Project , Sri Lanka.
Fernando, C.H., 1963. A guide to the freshwater fauna of Ceylon. Supplement 1, In: C. H. Fernando.
Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority. 163-
172 p
Fernando, C.H., 1964. A guide to the freshwater fauna of Ceylon. Supplement 2, In: C. H. Fernando.
Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority. 173-
207 p
Fernando, C.H., 1969. A guide to the freshwater fauna of Ceylon. Supplement 3, In: C. H. Fernando.
Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority. 209-
275 p
Fernando, M. S., 1994. Sanitary aspects of canal project. 20th WEDC Conference: Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Available from: http://info.lboro.ac.uk/departments/cv/wedc/papers/ .html [accessed on 10
Feb,2010].
Hodkinson, I.D., and Jackson, J.K., 2005. Terrestrial and Aquatic Invertebrates as Bioindicators for
Environmental Monitoring, with Particular Reference to Mountain Ecosystems. Environmental
Management Vol. 35, No. 5, pp. 649–666.
Invertebrates as indicators, 2008. Indicator species, Biological indicators of watershed health, Available
from: USEPA, http://www.epa.gov/bioindicators/html/invertebrate.html [accessed on 5th Feb,2008].
Jensen, V., 2007. The biological Integrity of Okanagan Streams: Using Benthic Invertebrates to Monitor
Stream Health in the Okanagan. Environmental Protection Program, Ministry of Environment,
Penticton, BC.
Karr, J. R., et al., 2002. Biological Integrity and the Index of Biological Integrity. Salamon Web.
Available from: http://www.cbr.woshington.edu/salamonweb/bibi/ [Accessed 31 March 2010].
Mandaville, S.M., 2002. Benthic Macroinvertebrates in Freshwaters Taxa Tolerance Values, Metrics
and Protocols. (Project H-1), Soil & Water Conservation Society of Metro Halifax. Available from:
http://chebucto.ca/Science/SWCS/SWCS.html [accessed on 12th Feb,2008].
Mendis, A. S. & C. H. Fernando. 1962. A guide to the freshwater fauna of Ceylon. Bulletin of the
Fisheries Research Station Ceylon 12, In: C. H. Fernando. Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri
Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority. 1-160 p.
Stribling, J.B., Benjamin K. Jessup and Jeffrey S. White, 1998. Development of a Benthic Index of
Biotic Integrity for Maryland Streams. Report no. CBWP-EA-98-3. Tetra Tech, Inc. Owings Mills,
Perera et al., /Journal of Tropical Forestry and Environment Vol. 2, No. 01 (2012) 10-19
19
MD 21117 and Daniel Boward & Marty Hurd, Maryland Department of Natural Resources,
Monitoring and Non-Tidal Assessment Division, Annapolis, MD.
Viklund, A., 2011. Aquatic Macroinvertebrates [online]. Krisweb. Available from:
http://www.krisweb.com/aqualife/insect.htm [ Accessed 28 June 2011]
Weigel, B.M., L.J. Henne and Luis M. Martinez-Rivera, 2002. Macroinvertebrate-based index of biotic
integrity for protection of streams in West-Central Mexico. Journal of North American
Benthological Society, 21(4) : 686-700.
Wittman, E. and Mundahl. N., 2002. Development and validation of a benthic index of biotic integrity
(B-IBI) for streams in Southern Minnesota. Winona State University, Winona, MN 55987.
... Although there is an independent canal system and interconnected waterways, the Colombo area is not satisfactorily drained due to malfunctioning of the canal system (Dissanayake et al., 1987;UNCHS and UDA, 1997;Tortajada, 2006;MCUDP, 2011). However, past experiences revealed that Colombo drainage pollution has reached a critical point (Eriyagama and Ratnayake, 2008;Opallage et al., 2019;Perera, 2003;Weerasooriya et al., 1983;Jayaweera and Samarakoon, 2018a;Perera et al., 2012). ...
... Fernando (1994) had observed high turbidity, BOD 5 and COD and richer metal levels in the water of St. Sebastian canal as per the data collected by the Central Environmental Authority (CEA), Sri Lanka for a period of 23 months (from March 1991to February 1993. Moreover, various water quality parameters have been occasionally measured in the St. Sebastian canal (Ali and Kadija, 1991;Opallage et al., 2019;Weerasooriya et al., 1983;Perera et al., 2012;NWSDB, 2013;Lekamge et al., 2015). However, recently, no detailed studies have been conducted concerning heavy metal pollution in the St. Sebastian canal. ...
Article
Anthropogenic pollution plays an important role in deteriorating the water quality of canals worldwide, especially in developing countries like Sri Lanka. The St. Sebastian Canal is one of the main canals in Sri Lanka, which runs through Colombo city that collects massive quantities of domestic, municipal, and industrial waste products. The aim of the present study is to develop water pollution and heavy metal pollution indices to assess the water pollution status of the St. Sebastian canal, Colombo by comparing water quality parameters with ambient water quality standards for aquatic life in Sri Lanka. Water samples were analyzed for physical and chemical parameters and heavy metals. Ultimately, Water Pollution Index (WPI) and Heavy Metal Pollution Index (HPI) were developed for several sites along the canal. WPI ranged from 0.64 to 1.93 with a mean value of 1.12, indicating water of St. Sebastian canal is highly polluted. The mean value of HPI was found to be 50, which is higher than the critical HPI value of 30, thus indicating that water of the canal is critically polluted with heavy metals. Further, sites 1, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 and sites 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 were found to be highly polluted as per the WPI and HPI, respectively. This shows the importance of having both WPI and HPI to assess the level of water pollution as site 4 is being categorized as a highly polluted site by HPI and as a good water quality site by WPI. Therefore, the site-specific assessment of water pollution by WPI and HPI will help the relevant authorities to implement remediation methods with respective to the critical pollutants in a particular location, to identify the polluters and to take measures to prevent the discharges to the water body from different sources.
... In Sri Lanka published research on biotic indices of benthic communities to assess the environmental conditions, is rare. However, diversity indices of benthic macro invertebrate communities have been used in several studies in order to monitor the environmental conditions (Gamlath and Wijeyaratne 1997;Dahanayaka and Wijeyaratne 2006;Perera et al. 2012;Idroos and Manage 2012;Madhushanka et al. 2014). In addition, many studies have concentrated on assessment of physicochemical parameters in the aquatic systems of Sri Lanka in order to identify the source and sink areas of pollutants (Sangakkara and Wijeyaratne 2015;Wijeyaratne 2016). ...
... Studies on the relationships between biotic indices and water quality parameters are not common in the inland waters of Sri Lanka. In a study conducted in the Colombo-Sri Jayewardenepura Canal System, 'Reference' and 'Degraded' sampling sites have been identified based on the environmental conditions and macroinvertebrates and a Macroinvertebrate-based Index of Biotic Integrity (M-IBI) has been developed to monitor stream/wetland health (Perera et al. 2012). In this study, H', EPT, FBI and TR have been found to be significantly correlated with water quality parameters such as dissolved oxygen concentration, Clconcentration, total dissolved solids and conductivity. ...
Article
Full-text available
The biotic indices used in Rapid Bioassessment Protocol II (RBP II) developed by United States Environmental Protection Agency was used to assess the feasibility of using benthic macroinvertebates as bio-indicators for monitoring water and sediment quality in Ja-Ela stream, which is a lotic water body in the western coastal region of Sri Lanka. Five study sites to cover the entire length of the stream, which are in five different fringing land uses (undisturbed site, agricultural site, industrial discharge receiving site, densely populated urban site and a site close to the mouth of the stream) were sampled for water and sediment quality parameters and benthic macroinvertebrates from April to October 2015. Shannon-Weiner diversity index (H`), Hilsenhoff Family Biotic index (FBI), Taxa richness (TRI), and Ehemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera (EPT) index were calculated for each site. Results indicated significant spatial variations in BOD5, COD, visibility, nitrate concentration and total phosphorus concentrations in the water, and total organic carbon content and particle size distribution in sediments. The highest mean values for H' (2.38), TR (13.6) and EPT (6.2) were recorded from the undisturbed site. Significantly higher FBI values are recorded from the industrial discharge receiving site (6.97) and the urban site (6.81), indicating that they are the most polluted sites with higher degree of organic pollution than other sites. These biotic index values showed significant correlations with sediment and water quality characteristics of the study sites (R2 >0.5, p<0.05) The H', EPT, FBI and TR values for benthic macro-invertebrate community showed that the upstream portion of this stream is habitable to pollution sensitive taxa, while the downstream areas close to its opening to Negombo estuary are habitable by pollution tolerant taxa. Results of the present study identified the RBP II as a possible bio monitoring protocol to reflect the water and sediment quality in the Ja-Ela stream.
... Benthic macroinvertebrates are also widely used as ecological indicators in freshwater lakes (Li et al., 2022;Odountan, 2019;Yang et al., 2020), rivers (Balderas et al., 2016;Damanik-Ambarita et al., 2016;Tampo et al., 2021), and canals (Bendary et al., 2023;Blakely et al., 2014;Perera et al., 2012). Most macroinvertebrates reside in or on bottom substrates for extended periods, exhibit regional characteristics, and have limited mobility. ...
... The Kotte marshland is located in Sri JayewardenepuraKotte, the western part of Sri Lanka (see Fig. 1). Colombo metropolitan can be considered a city built on and around wetlands in Sri Lanka (Perera et al., 2012). The growth of Sri JayewardenepuraKotte from 1981 to 1994 has influenced land prices. ...
Article
Full-text available
Freshwater marshlands are a more productive ecosystem that, influenced by anthropogenic activities, causes degradation and loss of wetlands. Kotte marshland has been located in the urban administrative area of the capital city in Sri Lanka, which is threatened by rapid development and population growth. This study aims to explore wetland ecosystem services and the loss of marshes in the Kotte marshland area from 2004 to 2021. Google Earth Pro and Open Street Map were used to identify the loss of marshes. Observation and discussion were used to implement the rapid assessment of the ecosystem services approach to wetlands. Numerical values were assigned to the evaluation sheets of the marshland ecosystem services to achieve the findings. 21 of the 37 ecosystem services listed in the evaluation method were registered a positive contribution to the surrounding environment in the Kotte wetland. However, no negative assistance ecosystem services were found in the Kotte marsh. The decline of the marshland reduces the quality and quantity of the ecosystem services in this area. As an urban wetland, the protection of the Kotte marshland is essential to avoid impacts such as air pollution, flood hazard, local climate regulation and habitat loss. Thus, this finding can be helpful to developing ecosystem services regulations to protect the wetland environment in the future. Finally, this study contributes to Ramsar strategic plan goal 1, which focuses on addressing wetland loss and degradation drivers to achieve the sustainable development goals.
... Examples of MMIs are "Index of Biotic Integrity" and "Benthic Index of Biotic Integrity". In the sense of natural variability, biotic integrity, and associated indices reflects aquatic system's ability to sustain characteristic functional and structural populations, to resist loss of this function and structure due to disturbance, and to recover from such disturbance (Perera et al. 2012). The disadvantages associated with use of such indices are their complexity of calculations in determining the stream health (Fierro et al. 2017). ...
Article
Full-text available
Biological monitoring is the evaluating changes in the environment using the biological responses with the intent of using such information in quality control of the ecosystem. Biomarkers and bioindicators are two main components of the hierarchy of biomonitoring process. Bioindicators can be used to monitor changes of ecosystems and to distinguish alteration of human impact from natural variability. There is a wide range of aquatic taxa such as macroinvertebrates, fish and periphyton, planktons which are successfully used in the biomonitoring process. Among them, macroinvertebrates are an important group of aquatic organisms that involves transferring energy and material through the trophic levels of the aquatic food chain and their sensitivity to environmental changes differs among the species. The main approaches of assessing freshwater ecosystems health using macroinvertebrates include measurement of diversity indices, biotic indices, multimetric approaches, multivariate approaches, Indices of Biological Integrity (IBI), and trait-based approaches. Among these, biotic indices and multimetric approaches are commonly used to evaluate the pesticide impacts on aquatic systems. Recently developed trait-based approaches such as SPEcies At Risk of pesticides (SPEAR) index was successfully applied in temperate regions to monitor the events of pesticide pollution of aquatic ecosystems but with limited use in tropics. This paper reviews the literature on different approaches of biomonitoring of the aquatic environment giving special reference to macroinvertebrates. It also reviews the literature on how biomonitoring could be used to monitor pesticide pollution of the aquatic environment. Thus the review aims to instil the importance of current approaches of biomonitoring for the conservation and management of aquatic ecosystems especially in the regions of the world where such knowledge has not been integrated in ecosystem conservation approaches.
... The index of biotic integrity (IBI) was originally created to assess the condition of riverine fish assemblages in the Illinois River (Karr et al., 1986), and has since become adopted worldwide for both rivers and lakes (Beck and Hatch, 2009;Ruaro and Gubiani, 2013), to assess fish (e.g., Zhu and Chang, 2008;Fayram et al., 2005;Joy and Death, 2004a;Lyons et al., 2000a;Kamdem Toham and Teugels, 1999;Minns et al., 1994), macroinvertebrates (e.g., Lunde and Resh, 2012;Perera et al., 2012;Masese et al., 2009;Raburu et al., 2009;Weigel et al., 2002), macrophytes (e.g., Beck et al., 2010Beck et al., , 2013, and phytoplankton (e.g., Wu et al., 2012;Maulood et al., 2011;Kane et al., 2009). The term "integrity" refers to a condition that has not been anthropogenically altered. ...
Article
Full-text available
Assessment of temporal variation of the water quality is an essential aspect of evaluating temporary changes in a water body caused by natural or artificial contributions. The study aims to assess the water quality temporal variation and the water quality index over the year from 2010 to 2019. Water sampling was carried out near the bridge of the Kotte canal. Water quality parameters such as pH, electrical conductivity (EC), temperature, dissolved oxygen (DO), ammonia, nitrate, phosphate, and chemical oxygen demand (COD) were determined to assess the quality of water at different periods. It has been calculated based on the standard of the central environmental authority of Sri Lanka. The weighted arithmetic index method has been used to calculate the water quality index. The water quality index of the study area was recorded as good (33.60760) in 2010 and poor in 2013 (56.95663), 2016 (52.37269), and 2019 (69.04417). The study revealed that the water temperature in the canal fluctuates with the time and climate of the area. The EC of the water is registered within the reference range. However, pH, COD, DO, and ammonia are the main water parameters deviating from the reference range. It is observed that the leading causes of the deterioration of water quality are human activities, the illegal discharge of sewage and industrial wastewater, the lack of adequate sanitation facilities, and urban runoff.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study is to generate a first global overview of pressures and methods used to assess the environmental quality of rivers and streams using macroinvertebrates. In total, 314 peer-review studies were reviewed, published in the period 1997 – 2018, from developing economies in Africa, South-Central America, Mexico and Southern Asia. To establish a global perspective, the results from the literature review were compared to other compiled datasets, biomonitoring manuals, environmental surveys and literature reviews from Europe, North America and Australasia. The literature review from the developing economies showed that sampling was most usual during baseflow, using kick- or Surber sampling, with taxonomical identification levels mostly to genus or family. Assessments were most often done using metrics (singular and multimetrics; > 70% of the applications) and were based on community attributes related to richness and dominance (58% of studies), sensitivity (40%), diversity by heterogeneity (32%) and functional traits (25%). Within each category, the most used metrics were the richness and dominance of Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera (EPT), Biological Monitoring Working Party scoring systems (BMWP/ASPT), Shannon-Wiener diversity and feeding traits. Overall, 92% of the reviewed studies reported that the use of macroinvertebrates, at least in some of their responses, was successful in detecting degradation of environmental quality in the investigated rivers. Given the many similarities in applied methods worldwide, at present, we consider that a global assessment of riverine environmental quality can be feasible by using family level identifications of macroinvertebrate samples. We propose a global common metric (multimetric), comprising three of the most common river assessment metrics from the reviewed literature, but also elsewhere, namely the BMWP/ASPT, Shannon-Wiener diversity and richness of EPT. Recent concerns regarding the global state of nature and consequences for freshwater communities, as reported by the intergovernmental science-policy platform on biodiversity and ecosystem services (IPBES), emphasize the urgent need for such a synthesis.
Article
Full-text available
Este trabalho contém uma ampla revisão sobre os estudos de macroinvertebrados realizados em águas correntes iranianas ao longo dos últimos 15 anos com o objetivo de fornecer um checklist de invertebrados bentônicos. Ecossistemas de águas correntes são ambientes complexos e conhecidos por sua importância para a biodiversidade. Como parte da análise, nós nos esforçamos para oferecer uma re-identificação crítica das espécies encontradas comparando-as com o banco de dados da Animal Diversity Web (ADW) e com fontes bibliográficas adequadas ou conhecimento especializado. Um total de 126 espécies de 4 filos foram compiladas em 57 publicações. O filo Arthropoda é o que contém o maior número de taxa (n = 104), seguido de Mollusca, Annelida e Platyhelminthes. Os esforços atuais em ambientes aquáticos do Irã estão relacionados ao desenvolvimento de índices de biomonitoramento, testes, refinamento e validação para serem utilizados em córregos e rios. Em uma visão geral, nós sugerimos que estudos futuros sobre macroinvertebrados em águas iranianas devam ser focados em mudanças de longo prazo, na ampliação do conhecimento de espécies-alvo e em fazer fortes esforços para publicar os resultados em revistas científicas na língua inglesa.
Article
Full-text available
A very few studies have been carried out on natural springs of Garhwal Himalayas which is the main source of potable water in Garhwal Himalayas. This paper based on water quality status of these springs, for this purpose parameters like alkalinity, acidity, DO, BOD, free CO 2 , nitrate, chlorides, hardness, pH and coliform number were studied. The study elucidates that the water quality of selected natural water springs is suitable for drinking purpose. [Avnish Chauhan, Suman Chauhan, Amit Pal Singh, Neha Chamoli and Krishna Kumar Pande. Evaluation Of Garhwal Springs Water For Drinking Purpose By Using Water Quality Index. Nature and Science. 2011;9(1):80-84]. (ISSN: 1545-0740). http://www.sciencepub.net/nature.
Article
Full-text available
The water and habitat quality of many streams in west-central Mexico are influenced by municipal and industrial effluent, as well as water diversion for irrigation, livestock, and deforestation. Restoration efforts have been hampered by a lack of clear standards against which to judge the degree and trend in environmental degradation. We describe the development and characteristics of a macroinvertebrate-based index of biotic integrity (IBI) designed to provide such standards. Eight metrics chosen a priori comprised the IBI: catch per unit effort, generic richness, % Ephemeroptera-Plecoptera-Trichoptera genera, % Chironomidae individuais, Hilsenhoff Biotic Index, % depositional individuais, % predator individuais, and % gatherer genera. Each metric distinguished sites with minimum or moderate human influence from sites with severe influence. The IBI was developed with data from 27 sites and validated with 6 others. Values from the development data set correlated well with the measures of human influence based on qualitative assessment of habitat and water quality (Pearson's r = 0.86). IBI values for 7 sites on Río Ayuquila corresponded with a documented longitudinal pattern of human influence and the existing fish-based IBI (Pearson's r = 0.87). This macroinvertebrate IBI shows promise for developing biological standards, facilitating long-term monitoring, and improving ecological integrity of streams in west-central Mexico.
Article
Full-text available
When biological metrics are combined into a multimetric index for bioassessment purposes, individual metrics must be scored as unitless numbers to be combined into a single index value. Among different multimetric indices, methods of scoring metrics may vary widely in the type of scaling used and the way in which metric expectations are established. These differences among scoring methods may influence the performance characteristics of the final index that is created by summing individual metric scores. The Macroinvertebrate Biotic Integrity Index (MBII), a multimetric index, was developed previously for first through third order streams in the Mid-Atlantic highlands of the United States. In this study, six metric scoring methods were evaluated for the MBII using measures related to site condition and index variability, including the degree of overlap between impaired and reference distributions, relationships to a stressor gradient, within-sample index variability, temporal variability, and the minimum detectable difference. Measures of index variability were affected to a greater degree than those of index responsiveness by both the type of scaling (discrete or continuous) and the method of setting expectations. A scoring method using continuous scaling and setting metric expectations using the 95th percentile of the entire distribution of sites performed the best overall for the MBII. These results showed that the method of scoring metrics affects the properties of the final index, particularly variability, and should be examined in developing a multimetric index because these properties can affect the number of condition classes (e.g., unimpaired, impaired) an index can distinguish.
Article
Full-text available
The use of terrestrial and aquatic invertebrates as a management tool for monitoring change in ecosystems is reviewed and critically evaluated. Their suitability and value for assessing a range of environmental problems from pollution impacts, through habitat evaluation for conservation to the long-term degradation and recovery of ecosystems, is critically discussed. Guidelines are provided for the choice of appropriate bioindicators. Examples of the use of a broad spectrum of invertebrates to assess a variety of environmental problems are summarized. The particular potential of invertebrates for monitoring montane ecosystems is highlighted.
Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority
  • C H Fernando
Fernando, C.H., 1964. A guide to the freshwater fauna of Ceylon. Supplement 2, In: C. H. Fernando. Freshwater Fauna and Fisheries of Sri Lanka Natural Resources, Energy & Science Authority. 173-207 p
Sanitary aspects of canal project
  • M S Fernando
Fernando, M. S., 1994. Sanitary aspects of canal project. 20th WEDC Conference: Colombo, Sri Lanka. Available from: http://info.lboro.ac.uk/departments/cv/wedc/papers/.html [accessed on 10
The biological Integrity of Okanagan Streams: Using Benthic Invertebrates to Monitor Stream Health in the Okanagan. Environmental Protection Program, Ministry of Environment
  • V Jensen
Jensen, V., 2007. The biological Integrity of Okanagan Streams: Using Benthic Invertebrates to Monitor Stream Health in the Okanagan. Environmental Protection Program, Ministry of Environment, Penticton, BC.