Content uploaded by Youssef K. Hamidi
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Youssef K. Hamidi on Apr 17, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
Paper G06-229 1
34th International Conference of the Polymer Processing Society, Taipei, Taiwan, May 21st-25th 2018
Manufacturing Silk/Epoxy Composite Laminates:
Challenges and Opportunities
Youssef K. Hamidi a,b,*, M. Akif Yalcinkaya a, Gorkem E. Guloglu a,
Maya Pishvar a, Mehrad Amirkhosravi a, M. Cengiz Altan a
a School of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Oklahoma, USA
b Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Mines de Rabat, Morocco
Email: hamidi@ou.edu
Abstract: Application of natural fibers in polymer composites has been gaining popularity in several industries pursuing
environmentally friendly products. Among the natural fibers with proven potential applications, silk fibers have recently
received considerable attention from researchers. Silk fibers provide higher mechanical properties compared to other
commonly used natural fibers such as sisal, jute, and hemp. Silk may also exhibit comparable specific mechanical
properties to glass fibers. However, silk composite laminates are rarely used in commercial products due to a number of
fabrication challenges. This paper investigates such challenges for silk/epoxy laminates, especially issues related to
manufacturing and preform architecture. First, challenges arising from preform architecture (i.e., random and woven
preforms) are presented. Unlike glass fibers for which random mats are easier to manipulate, handling random silk
preform proves to be more challenging, particularly compared to woven silk fabrics. The random silk/epoxy laminates
show higher thickness variation and lower compaction, yielding lower fiber content. Second, fabrication of laminates by
vacuum bag/wet lay-up and vacuum assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM) processes are presented. VARTM is found
to be more appropriate for silk/epoxy laminate fabrication, as it allows a uniform impregnation of the silk preform,
yielding higher part quality and limited void formation. Moreover, applying 0.21 MPa (30 psi) external pressure to the
VARTM laminates allows to increase the fiber content of both random and woven silk/epoxy laminates from ~17 and
~30% to ~21 and ~33%, respectively. In contrast, wetting of silk preform during wet lay-up process, which is operator
dependent, is difficult to achieve; and the produced laminates have high void content. Furthermore, SEM images show a
weak silk/epoxy adhesion in laminates fabricated without external pressure. Finally, the mechanical performance of these
laminates is assessed. The woven silk/epoxy laminates fabricated by pressurized VARTM exhibits the highest
improvement in the specific flexural strength and modulus over pristine epoxy with 30 and 65% increase, respectively.
Keywords: Silk fibers, natural fiber composites, fabrication, mechanical properties.
PACS: 81.05.Qk, 81.20.Hy, 81.70.Bt
INTRODUCTION
Over the past few years, environmental awareness and stricter environmental policies have forced industries,
including automotive and construction, to pursue alternative eco-friendly materials, thus leading to increased interest
in natural materials [1-3]. Driven by their promising biodegradability, natural fiber reinforced composites have
attracted wide attention. For instance, the low cost, low density, and sustainable nature of plant fibers, such as sisal,
jute, and hemp, made them attractive in comparison to the commonly used reinforcing fiber, E-glass, despite their
lower properties. Therefore, a significant growth in the commercial use of plant fiber reinforced composites has
been recently observed, mainly in the automotive industry [4].
In contrast, silk fibers have received limited scientific interest as a reinforcement for composites. Yet, silk
filaments exhibit higher mechanical performance than plant fibers and offer naturally continuous length. In addition
to a considerably higher toughness, its lower density makes silk a potential reinforcement to produce composites
with specific mechanical properties comparable to those reinforced with glass fibers, as suggested in recent studies
[4-5]. For example, Yang et al. [5] fabricated woven silk/epoxy composites using a wet lay-up process followed by
vacuum bagging and hot pressing at high pressure levels, yielding laminates with fiber volume fractions as high as
70%. The authors investigated the tensile, flexural, interlaminar shear, impact, dynamic and thermal properties of
the silk/epoxy composites and reported a linear increase of almost all properties with increasing fiber content
between 30 and 60%. The reported specific mechanical properties compared well with those of glass/epoxy
composites [5]. Similarly, Shah et al. [4] prepared nonwoven and woven silk/epoxy composites using vacuum
assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM), with fiber volume fractions of 36 and 45%, respectively. The authors
reported the tensile and flexural specific strengths (~90 MPa/g cm-3 and ~170 MPa/g cm-3) to be comparable,
although not necessarily superior, to those of glass/epoxy laminates. These findings propose silk fibers as potential
sustainable alternative reinforcement materials to glass fibers in structural applications.
Paper G06-229 5
34th International Conference of the Polymer Processing Society, Taipei, Taiwan, May 21st-25th 2018
Random silk/epoxy laminates showed no improvement in flexural strength over the neat epoxy. While practically
no change is observed for in absolute numbers for both laminates fabricated with wet lay-up and VARTM without
external pressure, a slight decrease is registered for the specific flexural strength as the density of the laminates
increases. A net increase of 26-48% in flexural modulus is observed over neat epoxy, with a concurrent decrease
(~50%) in strain to failure. These results are attributed to the observed weak silk/epoxy interface (Figure 4), as well
as excessive voidage [9]. Applying a 0.21 MPa external pressure, however, yields a significant increase in
mechanical performance. For instance, flexural strength increases by 26% to reach 150.7 MPa. Woven silk
fabric/epoxy laminates, on the other hand, showed improved mechanical performance, which is expected given their
higher fiber content. At 30% fiber content, the woven silk/epoxy laminate fabricated using VARTM without
external pressure displayed a 23% increase over neat epoxy, reaching a comparable performance to the pressurized
random silk/epoxy laminate. The woven silk/epoxy laminates fabricated by pressurized VARTM exhibited the
highest improvement in the specific flexural strength and modulus over pristine epoxy with 30 and 65% increase,
respectively. Comparing the obtained properties of both silk preforms further confirms the superiority of woven silk
as a reinforcement for epoxy composites. Furthermore, the fractured surfaces of these laminates, depicted in Figure
5, show mostly pulled silk fibers, which implies that an appropriate surface of silk fibers may significantly improve
silk/epoxy adhesion, yielding further improvement of the composite performance.
FIGURE 5. Representative SEM images obtained at 500X magnification from fractured surfaces of silk/epoxy laminates
manufactured with: (a) random silk mats without external pressure and (b) woven silk fabric pressurized at 30 psi.
CONCLUSION
This paper investigated fabrication challenges for silk/epoxy laminates, especially issues related to
manufacturing and preform architecture. Woven preform architecture was observed to be more convenient for
structural silk composites, as handling random silk preform proved to be more challenging. The random silk/epoxy
laminates showed higher thickness variation and lower compaction, yielding lower fiber content. Furthermore,
vacuum assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM) is found to be more appropriate for silk/epoxy laminate
fabrication, as it allows a uniform impregnation of the silk preform, yielding higher part quality and limited void
formation. Silk preform wetting in wet lay-up, on the other hand, is difficult to achieve; and the produced laminates
contain excessive voids. In addition, applying an external pressure as low as 0.21 MPa (30 psi) to the VARTM
laminates yielded an increase in the fiber content of both random and woven silk/epoxy laminates from ~17 and
~30% to ~21 and ~33%, respectively. Furthermore, SEM images showed weak silk/epoxy adhesion in laminates
fabricated without external pressure. Regarding the mechanical performance, the woven silk/epoxy laminates
fabricated by pressurized VARTM exhibited the highest improvement in the specific flexural strength and modulus
over pristine epoxy with 30 and 65% increase, respectively. These performances can be further enhanced using a
suitable surface treatment or a sizing applied to silk fibers at higher fiber contents.
REFERENCES
1. N. Saba, M. Jawaid, O. Y. Alothman, M. T. Paridah and A. Hassan, J. Reinf. Plastics & Compos. 35, 447-470 (2016)
2. M. Ho, H. Wang, J.-H. Lee, C. Ho, K. Lau, J. Leng and D. Hui, Compos: Part B 43, 3549–3562 (2012).
3. H. Cheung, M. Ho, K. Lau, F. Cardona and D. Hui, Compos: Part B 40, 655–663 (2009).
4. D. U. Shah, D. Porter and F. Vollrath, Compos. Sci. & Tech. 101, 173-183 (2014).
5. K. Yang, S. Wu, J. Guan, Z. Shao and R. O. Ritchie, Scientific Reports 7: 11939, 1-9 (2017)
6. Q. T. H. Shubhra, A. K. M. Alam, M. A. Khan, M. Saha, D. Saha, J. A. Khan and M. A. Quaiyyum, Polymer-Plastics Tech.
& Engr. 49, 983-990 (2010)
7. R. A. Eshkoor, S. A. Oshkovr, A. B. Sulong, R. Zulkifli, A. K. Ariffin and C. H. Azhari, Materials and Design 47, 248-257
(2013)
8. M. B. Reddy, V. M. Y. Reddy and C. M. B. Reddy, Materials Today: Proc. 4, 3116-3121 (2017).
9. Y. K. Hamidi and M. C. Altan, International Polymer Processing, 32, 1-18, 2017.
(a)
(b)
20 μm
20 μm