ArticlePDF Available

Efficacy of three different steamers for control of bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L.)

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

BACKGROUND Bed bugs, Cimex lectularius L., have become one of the most difficult urban pests to control. Steam treatment is reported to be an effective method to kill bed bugs and is considered to be an important component of bed bug integrated pest management (IPM). We evaluated and compared the efficacy of two affordable consumer‐grade commercial steamers to a commonly used professional‐grade steamer for killing bed bugs. RESULTS In laboratory experiments, the consumer‐grade steamer at an affordable price achieved the same high control efficacy as the professional‐grade steamer for treating bed bugs exposed on mattresses (100% bed bug mortality), located beneath a fabric cover (>89% bed bug mortality), or hiding in cracks (100% bed bug mortality). Bed bugs located behind a leather cover did not suffer significant mortality from steam treatment regardless of the type of steamers used and treatment duration. CONCLUSION Proper use of steamers can kill all life stages of bed bugs. Affordable consumer‐grade steamers are as effective as professional‐grade steam machines for eliminating bed bugs resting on mattresses, hiding behind fabric materials, or in cracks.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Research Article
Received: 25 December 2017 Revised: 19 March 2018 Accepted article published: 15 April 2018 Published online in Wiley Online Library:
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI 10.1002/ps.4933
Efficacy of three different steamers for control
of bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L.)
Desen Wang,a,b Changlu Wang,b* Guohong Wang,cChen Zha,bAmanda L
Eidenband Richard Cooperb
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Bed bugs, Cimex lectularius L., have become one of the most difficult urban pests to control. Steam treatment is
reported to be an effective method to kill bed bugs and is considered to be an important component of bed bug integrated pest
management (IPM). We evaluated and compared the efficacies of two affordable consumer-grade commercial steamers and a
commonly used professional-grade steamer for killing bed bugs.
RESULTS: In laboratory experiments, the consumer-grade steamers at affordable prices achieved the same high control efficacy
as the professional-grade steamer for treating bed bugs exposed on mattresses (100% bed bug mortality for all steamers),
located beneath a fabric cover (>89% bed bug mortality for all steamers), or hiding in cracks (100% bed bug mortality for all
steamers). Bed bugs located behind a leather cover did not suffer significant mortality from steam treatment regardless of the
type of steamers used and the treatment duration.
CONCLUSION: Proper use of steamers can kill all life stages of bed bugs. Affordable consumer-grade steamers are as effective
as professional-grade steam machines for eliminating bed bugs resting on mattresses and hiding behind fabric materials or in
cracks.
© 2018 Society of Chemical Industry
Keywords: bed bug; steam treatment; efficacy; integrated pest management
1 INTRODUCTION
The common bed bug, Cimex lectularius L. (Hemiptera: Cimicidae),
is an obligate blood-sucking insect that feeds upon humans and
other animals.1The recent resurgence of this pest worldwide,
except in Antarctica, has drawn the attention of many researchers.2
A large number of methods for killing or monitoring bed bugs
have been described and developed over the past 10 years.2,3
Because of their widespread resistance to insecticides and cryptic
and secretive behavior, bed bugs are considered to be one of the
most difficult urban pests to control.2,4– 6 Non-chemical treatments
are considered an important component in bed bug management
practices and can provide an effective alternative to insecticides.3,7
As one of the non-chemical control methods, heat treatment
is currently used for control of stored food product pests8,9 as
well as wood-destroying pests.10– 12 Bed bugs are sensitive to
high temperatures; thus, heat treatment has been applied as a
practical and effective means of bed bug control.2Pereira et al.13
reported that mortality of bed bug adults started at 41 Cwith
an exposure time of 100 min, and this time gradually decreased
as the temperature increased, to about 1 min at 49 C. Johnson14
demonstrated that all stages of bed bugs are killed after exposure
to 45 C for 1 h. The target heat treatment temperature used for
killing bed bugs by the professional pest management industry is
between 45 and 52 C.15– 17
Heat can be applied via hot laundering/drying of infested cloth-
ing and bedding,18 and through the use of portable heat chambers
or structural heat treatments.2,19,20 Loudon20 demonstrated that all
bed bugs on the outer surface of luggage would be killed even
if they were only exposed to an air temperature of 70– 75 Cfor
6 min. The use of steam is another effective method, which capi-
talizes on the delivery of lethal temperatures for treatment of bed
bugs.19,21– 24 Puckett et al.22 reported that steam treatment could
effectively kill bed bug eggs, nymphs, and adult males, when the
steam attachment was placed directly on top of them, moving the
steamer at a speed of 10 s per 30.50cm. However, it is still unclear
whether steam treatment is effective at killing bed bugs when they
are hiding beneath fabric surfaces or in cracks and crevices.
Expensive professional-grade steamers have already been
proven to be effective in killing bed bugs, and they are often
used by pest management professionals in bed bug treatment.19
The Amerivap Systems STM-BASIC Steamax Commercial Steam
Cleaner (Amerivap Systems, Inc., Dawsonville, GA, USA), com-
monly used by pest management professionals, retails at $1259
(https://www.amazon.com), and is therefore not affordable to
most consumers. During our visits to bed bug-infested apart-
ments in previous studies, we found that residents had purchased
more affordable steamers, in an effort to get rid of bed bugs
Correspondence to: C Wang, Department of Entomology, Rutgers University,
New Brunswick, NJ 08901, USA. E-mail: changluw@rutgers.edu
aKey Laboratory of Bio-Pesticide Innovation and Application of Guangdong
Province, Department of Entomology, College of Agriculture,South China Agri-
cultural University, Guangzhou, China
bDepartment of Entomology, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, USA
cCollege of Life Science, Fujian Normal University,Fuzhou, China
Pest Manag Sci (2018) www.soci.org © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry
www.soci.org D Wang et al.
in their homes by themselves. Steamers that cost <$100 are
widely available to consumers, and they can be used as an
effective ‘do-it-yourself’ tool by consumers for bed bug control.
However, no data are available on the efficacy of inexpensive
consumer-grade steamers for bed bug control.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the bed bug control
efficacies of three steamers under various scenarios. Our results
provide practical recommendations for the proper use of steamers
in bed bug management.
2 EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
2.1 Bed bugs
Bed bugs were collected in 2009 from multiple infested apart-
ments in Bayonne, New Jersey, USA. They were maintained in
plastic containers (5 cm diameter and 4.7 cm height; Consolidated
Plastics, Stow, OH, USA) with folded papers as harborages [40mm
length (L) and 30 mm width ( W); Universal Stationers Supply Co.,
Deerfield, IL, USA] and kept in an incubator (Percival Scientific, Inc.,
Perry, IA, USA) at a temperature of 26 ±1C, relative humidity of
40 ±10%, and a photoperiod of 12:12 h (light:dark). Bed bugs were
fed weekly on defibrinated rabbit blood (Hemostat Laboratories,
Dixon, CA, USA) using a Hemotek membrane-feeding system (Dis-
covery Workshops, Accrington, UK).
Toobtain bed bug eggs, one piece of blue fabric (L ×W: 8 ×8cm;
65% polyester and 35% cotton; Palencia Broadcloth; Springs Cre-
ative Products Group, LLC, Rock Hill, SC, USA) was exposed to
3040 fed and mated females for 4 days before the experiment,
so that the age of eggs deposited on the fabric was 04 days after
being laid. Bed bugs were only allowed access to one side of the
fabric for the deposition of eggs. To achieve this, the fabric was
placed in a Petri dish (9 cm diameter and 2.5 cm height; Fisher Sci-
entific, Pittston, PA, USA), and a plastic ring (6.5 cm diameter and
2 cm height) was placed on the fabric to confine bed bugs. The
inner wall of the plastic ring was coated with a thin film of fluo-
ropolymer resin (BioQuip Products, Rancho Dominguez, CA, USA)
to prevent bed bugs from escaping.
Adult males (unknown age) and nymphs (4th– 5th instar) used in
all experiments were unfed for 6– 7 days. Female adults were not
used to prevent oviposition in the experimental arenas. All exper-
iments were conducted in a laboratory with a mean temperature
of 24.5 C during the study period.
2.2 Steamers
Three different steam machines were compared. Two were
consumer-grade steamers, the HAAN HS-20R Handheld Steam
Cleaner (HAAN Corporation, Lancaster, PA, USA), henceforth
referred to as ‘HAAN’, and the Steamfast SF-370WH Multi-Purpose
Steam Cleaner (Steamfast, Andover, KS, USA), henceforth ‘Steam-
fast’. The third was the aforementioned professional-grade
machine, the Amerivap Systems STM-BASIC Steamax Commercial
Steam Cleaner, henceforth referred to as ‘Steamax’ (Table 1).
These three steam machines varied significantly in price. They
were selected because we found that homeowners used cheap
steamers for self-control of bed bugs and pest management
professionals typically use expensive/specialized steamers. The
attachment of each steamer used in our study is shown in Fig. 1.
Steamax has three working pressures: low (310 kPa), medium
(379 kPa), and high (448 kPa). In experiment 1, the medium work-
ing pressure (379 kPa) was selected to treat bed bugs on the
surface of the mattress; in experiments 2 and 3, the high working
Figure 1. Steamer attachment used in the experiments.
pressure (448 kpa) was used to treat bed bugs that were hiding
under a fabric cover or in a crack. The HAAN and Steamfast steam-
ers both had a single working pressure (the pressure was not
specified in the manufacturers’ product instructions).
2.3 Experiment 1: treating bed bugs on the mattress surface
A mini mattress [L ×W×height (H): 30 ×30 ×22 cm] was placed
in a plastic tray (L ×W×height: 80 ×75 ×5 cm) (Fig. 2a). For each
treatment, a total of 25 nymphs and 25 adult males were released
onto the mini mattress (three to four males and three to four
nymphs at each of the eight corners) 1 h before treatment; 50 –100
eggs along with the fabric were attached to the mattress surface
immediately before treatment to avoid the possibility of the bed
bugs moving under the fabric prior to treatment.
Two tests were included in this experiment. In the first test, only
the mattress surfaces (including the top, sides, and underside sur-
faces) were steamed; in the second test, both the mattress sur-
faces and the floor of the plastic tray under and around the mat-
tress were steamed. In each test, four treatments (HAAN, Steam-
fast, Steamax, and untreated control) were included. Each treat-
ment was replicated six times; therefore, a total of 24 treatments
were conducted for each test. For each steamer, the moving speed
of the steamer attachment during the first and second tests was
same (3 cm per second), but more time was spent steaming in the
second test, because the tray under and around the mattress was
also steamed.
During treatment, the steamer attachment was kept approxi-
mately 1 cm away from the mattress surface. To minimize the pos-
sibility of escape during the steam treatment, the sequence of
steam treatments was from bottom to top of the mattress. Bed
bugs stayed both along the stitches on the mattress surface and at
the edges, so the whole mattress surface was steamed to ensure
that all bed bugs (eggs, nymphs, and adults) were exposed to
steam. The mini mattress in the control received the same num-
ber of bed bugs with no steam treatment. For each treatment,
the maximum temperature on the surface of the mattress was
recorded during treatment using a thermocouple thermometer
(Cole-Parmer Instrument Company, Vernon Hills, IL, USA), and the
treatment duration was recorded using a digital timer (National
Presto Industries, Inc., Eau Claire, WI, USA).
After treatment, the pieces of fabric with bed bug eggs were
placed in Petri dishes (6 cm diameter and 1.5 cm height; Fisher
Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA, USA) and transferred to an incubator
at 26 ±1C. Each Petri dish lid had a 1.5-cm-diameter screened
area for ventilation. Egg mortality was recorded after 14 days.
Unhatched eggs were considered dead. The nymphs and adult
males in each arena were transferred separately into Petri dishes
(6 cm diameter and 1.5 cm height) and were kept in an incubator
at 26 ±1C. The bottom of each dish had a piece of filter paper
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry Pest Manag Sci (2018)
Efficacy of steamers for control of bed bugs www.soci.org
Table 1. Prices and specifications of the three steamers. Except for the prices, the information was obtained from the manufacturers’ product
instructions. Price information was obtained from http://www.amazon.com
Steamer Price Wattage (W ) Water capacity (mL) Heat-up time (min) Operating time (min)
HAAN $75.11 1000 200 <315
Steamfast $101.94 1500 1420 8 45
Steamax $1259.00 1700 2400 14 90
Figure 2. Experimental set-up for evaluating the efficacy of steamers for killing bed bugs resting in various habitats. (a) Bed bugs on a mini mattress. (b)
Bed bugs under a cover: (b1) fabric cover with a ClimbUp interceptor underneath; (b2) bed bugs in a ClimbUp interceptor with the fabric cover removed.
(c)Bedbugsinacrack.
on it (3.5 cm diameter; Fisher Scientific). Nymph/adult mortality
was recorded after 1 day. Bed bugs that did not move when
probed with featherweight forceps (BioQuip Products, Rancho
Dominguez, CA, USA) were recorded as dead.
2.4 Experiment 2: treating bed bugs hiding under fabric or
leather covers
White ClimbUp®insect interceptors (15.24 cm diameter and
2.3 cm height; Susan McKnight, Inc., Memphis, TN, USA) were used
as experimental arenas for this study (Fig. 2b). The experimental
set -up consisted of an interceptor placed in a white plastic tray
(L ×W×H: 56 ×44 ×8 cm). The inner wall of the interceptor was
coated with a thin film of fluoropolymer resin to prevent bed
bugs from escaping. Filter paper was glued onto the bottom
of the interceptor to provide a climbable substrate for the bed
bugs. For each treatment, a total of 20– 30 eggs on a piece of
fabric, or 15 nymphs and 15 adult males were introduced into
each interceptor. The interceptor was covered with a piece of
bed sheet (L ×W: 27 ×27 cm; 100% polyester microfiber), sofa
fabric (L ×W: 27 ×27 cm; cotton-terylene), or sofa leather (L ×W:
27 ×27 cm; artificial leather) 1 min prior to treatment (Fig. 3). The
distance between the bed bugs and the cover was 2.3 cm (the
height of the interceptor). The bed sheet (a normal bed sheet
made from polyester microfiber) was bought from an internet
vendor (https://www.amazon.com); both sofa fabric and sofa
leather were cut from discarded old sofas. During treatment, the
steamer attachment was held on the surface of the cover and
only the area directly under the cover was steamed. Treatment
durations of 15 and 30 s were tested in this experiment. For each
type of cover (bed sheet, sofa fabric, or sofa leather), nine steam
treatments were tested: HAAN0s (control), HAAN15s, HAAN30s,
Steamfast0s (control), Steamfast15s, Steamfast30s, Steamax0s (con-
trol), Steamax15s, and Steamax30s . Interceptors in the control
contained bed bug eggs, or nymphs and adult males, and were
covered with the three types of cover, but did not receive steam
treatment. During each treatment, the maximum temperature
under the cover was recorded by the thermocouple thermometer.
This experiment was replicated six times; therefore, a total of 162
treatments were conducted.
After treatment, mortality of bed bug eggs, nymphs and
adults was monitored following the same method as that in
experiment 1.
Pest Manag Sci (2018) © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps
www.soci.org D Wang et al.
Figure 3. Covers used in experiment 2.
2.5 Experiment 3: treating bed bugs hiding in a crack
Two pieces of wood board (L ×W×H: 9.7 ×9.7 ×1cm)wereused
to construct a wedge-shaped crack (L ×W×H: 9.7 ×1.3 ×9.7 cm)
(Fig. 2c). One side of the crack was sealed with athletic tape (L ×W:
9.7 ×3.7 cm; Walgreen Co., Deerfield, IL, USA), and the other three
sides were open. Before steaming, the crack was placed with the
sealed side lying on a white plastic tray (L ×W×H: 56 ×44 ×8cm)
and was fixed with two wrenches as shown in Fig. 2c. For each
treatment, 20 bed bug eggs on a piece of fabric were placed at a
depth of 8.5 cm from the upper opening of the crack, or 10 nymphs
and 10 adults on a paper harborage were placed at a depth of
6 cm from the upper opening immediately before treatment. In
our experiments, bed bugs did not move out of the crack after
they were placed in it. Five treatment durations (1, 2, 4, 6 and 8 s)
were tested for each steamer. A control was also included when
testing each steamer. The control cracks received bed bugs, but
did not receive steam treatment. The maximum temperature in
each crack (near the eggs or nymphs/adults) was recorded during
steaming. This experiment was replicated three times; thus, a total
of 54 treatments were conducted.
After treatment, mortality of bed bug eggs, nymphs, and adults
was recorded using the same method as in experiment 1.
2.6 Statistical analysis
In all experiments, the mortality of bed bugs (eggs, nymphs or
adults) was <5% in the control (no steam treatment). Corrected
mortality based on Abbott’s formula is used in this paper.25
One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to compare
the difference among different steamers in experiment 1. When
statistical differences existed among data sets (P<0.05), Tukey’s
honest significant difference (HSD) test was used to separate the
means.
Three-way ANOVA was used for analyzing the temperature and
bed bug mortality data in experiment 2. The three factors were
steamer (HAAN, Steamfast, and Steamax), cover type (bed sheet,
sofa fabric, and sofa leather), and treatment duration (15 and 30 s),
and only their main effects were analyzed. In case of statistical dif-
ferences existing for a factor (P<0.05), the means were separated
using Tukey’s HSD test.
Two-way ANOVA was used to determine the significant of the
difference in temperature in the crack during treatment, and bed
bug mortality data in experiment 3. The two factors were steamer
and treatment duration (1, 2, 4, 6 and 8 s), and only their main
effects were analyzed. In the case of statistical differences existing
among data sets for a factor (P<0.05), the means of this factor
were compared using Tukey’s HSD test.
The percentage data were arcsine square root transformed prior
to analysis, if necessary; other data were normally distributed. All
data analyses were carried out using SPSS version 22.0 (Interna-
tional Business Machines Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).26
3RESULTS
3.1 Treating bed bugs on the mattress surface
There was no significant difference among the three steamers for
percentage of egg mortality, or percentage of nymph and adult
mortality, regardless of the experimental conditions (only mattress
steamed, or both mattress and plastic tray floor steamed). Similarly,
the temperature on the mattress’s surface during treatment and
the treatment duration were similar for all three steamers tested
(Table 2).
During steam treatment in the first test (mattress steamed), the
mean temperatures on the mattress surface were 71.9– 75.4 Cfor
each steamer (Table 2). After treatment, none of the treated eggs
hatched; and 9193% of nymphs and adults were dead. In the
second test (mattress and plastic tray floor steamed), the mean
temperatures on the mattress surface were 81.5– 82.7 Cforeach
steamer (Table 2). After steam treatment, none of the treated eggs
hatched; and all nymphs and adults were dead.
3.2 Treating bed bugs hiding under a fabric or leather cover
In the bed bug egg treatments, the temperature beneath the
cover varied significantly depending upon the type of cover,
which steamer was used, and the treatment duration (Table 3).
When treating different cover types, the temperature under sofa
leather (36.744.6 C) was significantly lower than that under the
bed sheet (64.0 –80.1 C) or sofa fabric (61.379.1 C) (Tukey’s
HSD test, P<0.05). The HAAN steamer (37.7 –80.1 C) produced a
significantly higher temperature under the cover compared with
the Steamfast steamer (36.7 –79.0 C) (Tukey’s HSD test, P<0.05).
The 30-s steam treatment (36.7 –80.1 C) induced a significantly
higher temperature under the cover than the 15-s steam treatment
(36.879.2 C) (Tukey’s HSD test, P<0.05).
In the bed bug nymph and adult treatments, the temper-
ature under the cover was significantly influenced by cover
type and steamer, but not the treatment duration (Table 3).
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry Pest Manag Sci (2018)
Efficacy of steamers for control of bed bugs www.soci.org
Table 2. Mean (±standard error) treatment duration, temperature during steam treatment, and bed bug control efficacy for the different steamers
used to treat bed bugs on mattresses
Treatment duration (s)
Tem per atu re on t h e
mattress surface during treatment (C) % egg mortality % nymph mortality % adult mortality
First test
HAAN 240.5 ±26.5 71.9 ±3.6 100 93 ±295±1
Steamfast 231.3 ±23.4 72.6 ±2.8 100 91 ±393±2
Steamax 197.8 ±20.9 75.4 ±2.6 100 93 ±391±5
Statistics F2,15 =0.9 F2,15 =0.4 F2,15 =0.1 F2,15 =0.5
P=0.429 P=0.696 P=0.879 P=0.600
Second test
HAAN 517.8 ±29.3 82.7 ±1.3 100 100 100
Steamfast 462.5 ±24.6 82.7 ±0.8 100 100 100
Steamax 428.0 ±22.8 81.5 ±1.9 100 100 100
Statistics F2,15 =3.1 F2,15 =0.2 – –
P=0.074 P=0.803
In the first test, only the mattress surface was steamed.
In the second test, the mattress surface and the floor of the plastic tray directly under and around the mini mattress were steamed.
Table 3. Mean (±standard error) temperature under the cover during steam treatment of bed bugs hiding under a fabric or leather cover
Temperature during egg treatment (C)Temperature during nymph and adult treatment (C)
Cover type Steamer 15-s steam treatment 30-s steam treatment 15-s steam treatment 30-s steam treatment
Bed sheet HAAN 79.2 ±3.1 80.1 ±4.1 78.2 ±1.3 72.6 ±3.9
Steamfast 66.7 ±2.7 64.0 ±3.3 65.9 ±1.9 60.4 ±3.9
Steamax 75.7 ±3.2 76.1 ±0.6 73.0 ±1.3 75.2 ±0.6
Sofa fabric HAAN 70.2 ±4.6 79.1 ±2.2 63.5 ±4.6 82.3 ±0.4
Steamfast 67.0 ±4.0 79.0 ±2.4 59.3 ±3.5 72.2 ±2.7
Steamax 61.3 ±2.3 67.0 ±2.4 57.6 ±1.6 63.6 ±1.6
Sofa leather HAAN 39.4 ±0.3 37.7 ±1.6 35.4 ±2.0 31.7 ±0.4
Steamfast 36.8 ±0.7 36.7 ±1.3 32.5 ±2.3 30.7 ±0.5
Steamax 41.0 ±0.6 44.6 ±3.0 39.6 ±3.1 36.7 ±0.3
Three-way ANOVA: Fcover =215.2, df =2102, P<0.001; Fsteamer =5.3, df =2102, P=0.007; Ftreatmentduration =4.0, df =1102, P=0.047.
Three-way ANOVA: Fcover =231.8, df =2102, P<0.001; Fsteamer =7.5, df =2102, P=0.001; Ftreatmentduration =2.3, df =1102, P=0.136.
The temperatures beneath the various covers were: bed
sheet (60.478.2 C) =sofa fabric (57.682.3 C) >sofa leather
(30.739.6 C) (Tukey’s HSD test, P<0.05). The HAAN steamer
(31.782.3 C) produced a significantly higher temperature under
the cover than the Steamfast steamer (30.7– 72.2 C) (Tukey’s HSD
test, P<0.05).
Bed bug mortality was influenced by the cover type (egg mor-
tality: F=368.5, df =2102, P<0.001; nymph mortality: F=320.9,
df =2102, P<0.001; adult mortality: F=429.0, df =2102,
P<0.001), but not by the steamer or treatment duration (Tukey’s
HSD test, P>0.05). Therefore, we combined the data for different
steamers and treatment durations (Fig. 4). The egg mortality
under different cover types was: bed sheet >sofa fabric >sofa
leather. Mortality of nymphs and adults under sofa leather was
significantly lower than that under the bed sheet and sofa fabric.
3.3 Treating bed bugs hiding in a crack
In the bed bug egg treatments, the mean temperature in the cracks
was significantly affected by treatment duration (F=4.6, df =4, 38,
P=0.004), but not by steamer (F=0.6, df =2, 38, P=0.574). The
2-, 4-, 6-, or 8-s steam treatment created a significantly higher tem-
perature than the 1-s steam treatment (Tukey’s HSD test, P<0.05;
Fig. 5). There were no significant differences in the mean temper-
ature among the 2-, 4-, 6-, and 8-s steam treatments (Tukey’s HSD
test, P>0.05; Fig. 5).
During bed bug nymph and adult treatments, the mean temper-
ature in the cracks was significantly influenced by steamer (F=7.0,
df =2, 38, P=0.003) and treatment duration (F=12.6, df =4, 38,
P<0.001). The Steamax treatment induced significantly higher
temperatures in cracks than Steamfast (Tukey’s HSD test, P<0.05);
there was no significant difference in temperature between HAAN
and Steamfast, or between HAAN and Steamax (Tukey’s HSD test,
P>0.05). The 2-, 4-, 6-, and 8-s steam treatment durations induced
significantly higher temperatures in the cracks than the 1-s steam
treatment (Fig. 5). There were no significant differences in temper-
ature among the 2-, 4-, 6-, and 8-s steam treatments (Fig. 5).
Two-way ANOVA showed a significant effect of treatment dura-
tion on the mortality of bed bug eggs and adults, but not
nymphs (egg mortality: F=3.3, df =4, 38, P=0.021; adult mor-
tality: F=3.7, df =4, 38, P=0.012). The steamer type had no
significant effect on bed bug mortality (all P>0.05). Therefore,
we combined the data from different steamers for comparing
treatment durations (Fig. 5). The 4-, 6-, and 8-s treatment dura-
tions caused significantly higher egg and adult mortality than the
Pest Manag Sci (2018) © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps
www.soci.org D Wang et al.
Figure 4. Effect of the cover on the steamer’s bed bug control efficacy.
Data represent combined results for three steamers and two treatment
durations (15 and 30 s). During steam treatment, bed bugs were located
under a fabric or leather cover. Different lowercase letters above the bars
indicated significant differences between treatments (one-way ANOVA;
P<0.05, Tukey’s HSD test).
1-s treatment. All eggs and adults were killed at 4-s and longer
treatment durations; however, 100% mortality of nymphs was only
achieved at 6-s treatment duration.
4 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The boiling point of water at 1 atm of pressure (sea level) is 100 C,
which is much higher than the maximum lethal temperature to
kill bed bugs (52 C).15– 17 Therefore, in theory, exposing bed bugs
to steam produced at a short distance from them will result in
their death immediately. It is important to note that, during steam
treatment, bed bugs (nymphs and adults) may initially be exposed
to a sublethal or non-lethal temperature and may escape the
steam treatment by moving away or dropping onto the floor.
This phenomenon was observed in our preliminary experiments.
Figure 5. Effect of treatment duration on mean temperature in cracks
during steam treatment and steamer’s bed bug control efficacy. During
steam treatment, bed bugs were hiding in a crack. Bars indicate bed bug
control efficacy. The line indicates the temperature in cracks during steam
treatment. Data represent combined results for three steamers. Different
lowercase letters above the bars indicate significant differences in bed bug
control efficacy between treatments; different uppercase letters above the
line indicate significant differences in the temperaturebet weentreatments
(one-way ANOVA; P<0.05, Tukey’s HSD test).
Therefore, caution must be practiced when conducting steam
treatment in naturally infested environments. Steaming both the
infested area and the areas under and/or around the infested area
will be critical to ensure bed bug control efficacy. The sequence
of steam treatments of infested furniture should be from bottom
up to reduce the probability of bed bugs falling off the treated
surfaces. In experiment 1, 100% bed bug mortality was achieved
when both the surface of the mattresses and the arena floor
directly under the mini mattresses were steamed.
In addition, our results verify that bed bugs under a cover can
also be successfully killed by steaming. When treating bed bugs
under a cover, the steam treatment efficacy was affected by cover
type, not by the type of steamer, even though higher temperatures
were produced by the HAAN steamer compared to with Steam-
fast and Steamax. This was because all steamers produced a lethal
temperature under the fabric covers (bed sheet: 60.4– 80.1 C; sofa
fabric: 57.6– 82.3 C). In our study, bed bugs were hiding 2.3 cm
below the cover. However, whether the consumer-grade steamers
can kill 100% of bed bugs hiding much deeper under the cover
remains to be determined. The temperature under sofa leather
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry Pest Manag Sci (2018)
Efficacy of steamers for control of bed bugs www.soci.org
(30.744.6 C) induced by all three steamers was below the mini-
mum lethal temperature (45 C). No significant bed bug mortality
was observed. In fact, homeowners and pest management pro-
fessionals might be reluctant to steam leather furniture coverings.
Similarly, in the experiment treating bed bugs hiding in cracks, the
variations among steamers resulted in a significant difference in
the treatment temperature, but not a significant difference in bed
bug mortality. In experiments with bed bugs under a cover, the
temperatures varied significantly with the treatment duration in
the bed bug egg treatments, but were similar among treatment
durations in the bed bug nymph and adult treatments. These dif-
ferent results suggest that minute differences in application tech-
nique can cause significant differences in the temperature deliv-
ered. However, overall, the temperature measurement results indi-
cate that temperatures lethal to bed bugs under fabric covers are
achieved if sufficient treatment time is used.
During our study, we found that once water vapor had con-
densed over a fabric cover, it became less conducive to steam
passing through. Thus, during indirect exposure treatment (bed
bugs hiding under a fabric cover), moving the steamer attachment
slowly across the surface of the cover is essential to ensure bed
bug control efficacy. Steam treatment failed to cause any mortal-
ity of bed bugs hiding under leather because of the inability of
the steam to pass through leather. In a domestic environment, bed
bugs may hide under many different materials, such as paper, card-
board, plastic, various fabrics and carpets. Studies on additional
types of covers would be beneficial to gain better understanding
of the efficacy of steam treatment.
In practice, a steamer’s effectiveness for killing bed bugs can be
affected by how fast steam is released and the attachment type
being used. The steamer Steamax has three working pressures.
To avoid blowing bed bugs off the mattress surface, we used
the medium pressure to treat bed bugs on the mattress surfaces
(experiment 1) and high pressure for steaming the bed bugs that
were hiding under a cover and in cracks. Commercial steamers
are equipped with different styles of attachments. Larger brush
attachments often work better than smaller tips, because the
smaller ones may release steam too fast, which can blow bed bugs
off the substrate.21
In conclusion, steam treatment can serve as an important com-
ponent of the IPM tool box for bed bug management. In this labo-
ratory study, steamers at affordable prices achieved the same high
control efficacy as the expensive steamer when properly used. This
finding provides evidence that, for home owners, using afford-
able steamers instead of spraying insecticides could achieve high
control efficacy. During steam treatment, it is critical to move the
steamer attachment slowly, and to extend the treatment duration
when treating bed bugs hiding in/under cracks or covers.
Self-treatment for bed bugs is common among people experi-
encing bed bug activity in their homes, and often involves the
purchase and application of insecticides. It is worth noting that
the insecticides purchased are expensive [for example, the Hot
Shot Bed Bug and Flea Killer (17.5 oz; Spectrum Group, St. Louis,
MO, USA) retails at $7.71, and the Pronto Plus Bedbug and Dust
Mite Killer (10 oz; Insight Pharmaceuticals Corp., Langhorne, PA,
USA) retails at $24.27; price information was obtained from https://
www.amazon.com] and are typically ineffective.27 Furthermore,
insecticide misapplication, including over-application, is likely to
cause potential hazards, such as the occurrence of insecticide resis-
tance and threats to human health. Our results demonstrate that
consumer-grade steamers offer an effective and affordable solu-
tion to replace the use of insecticides, which are less effective and
potentially harmful when applied by consumers in a manner that is
inconsistent with label directions for use. Consumer-grade steam-
ers have shorter operating times than the professional steamers;
however, because they are only being used for personal and not
commercial use, this is not a significant limitation. Therefore, this
non-chemical treatment technique is highly effective and advan-
tageous compared with the traditional chemical treatment as it
avoids the potential health risks of insecticide applications. Fur-
ther studies under various field conditions need to be conducted
to confirm its efficacy for eliminating bed bugs hiding in various
habitats.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Qi Zhang for help in rearing bed bugs and Jeff White
for providing mini mattresses. HAAN Corporation and Steamfast
donated steamers. The study was supported by the USDA National
Institute of Food and Agriculture Hatch project 1001098 through
the New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station, Hatch project
NJ08127. The senior author was also supported by the State
Scholarship Fund of China. This is New Jersey Experiment Station
Publication No. D-08-08127-07-17.
REFERENCES
1 Usinger R ed, Monograph of Cimicidae (Hemiptera: Heteroptera).Ento-
mological Society of America, College Park, MA (1966).
2 Doggett SL, Dwyer DE, Penas PF and Russell RC, Bed bugs: clinical
relevance and control options. Clin Microbiol Rev 25:164 –192 (2012).
3 Koganemaru R and Miller DM, The bed bug problem: past, present, and
future control methods. Pestic Biochem Phys 106:177 –189 (2013).
4 Romero A, Potter MF, Potter DA and Haynes KF, Insecticide resistance in
the bed bug: a factor in the pest’s sudden resurgence?JMedEntomol
44:175– 178 (2007).
5 ZhuF,WiggintonJ,RomeroA,MooreA,FergusonK,PalliRet al.,
Widespread distribution of knockdown resistance mutations in the
bed bug, Cimex lectularius (Hemiptera: Cimicidae), populations in
the United States. Arch Insect Biochem 73:245 –257 (2010).
6 Dang K, Doggett SL, Veera Singham G and Lee CY, Insecticide resistance
and resistance mechanisms in bed bugs, Cimex spp. (Hemiptera:
Cimicidae). Parasites Vectors 10:318 (2017).
7 Wang C and Cooper R, Environmentally sound bed bug management
solutions, in Urban Pest Management: An Environmental Perspective,
ed. by Dhang P. CAB International, Wallingford, pp. 44–63 (2011).
8 Tang J, Mitcham E, Wang S and Lurie S eds, HeatTreatments for Posthar-
vest Pest Control: Theory and Practice. CABI, Wallingford (2007).
9 Mahroof R, Subramanyam B and Flinn P, Reproductive performance
of Tribolium castaneum (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae) exposed to the
minimum heat treatment temperature as pupae and adults. JEcon
Entomol 98:626– 633 (2005).
10 Massa R, Panariello G, Pinchera D, Schettino F, Caprio E, Griffo R
et al., Experimental and numerical evaluations on palm microwave
heating for Red Palm Weevil pest control. Sci Rep 7:45299 (2017).
11 Oliver-Villanueva JV, Gascón-Garrido P and Ibiza-Palacios MS, Evalua-
tion of thermally-treated wood of beech (Fagus syl vat ica L.) and ash
(Fraxinus excelsior L.) against Mediterranean termites (Reticulitermes
spp.). Eur J Wood Wood Prod 71:391 –393 (2013).
12 Uzunovic A, Gething B, Coelho A, Dale A, Janowiak JJ, Mack R et al.,
Lethal temperature for pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus
xylophilus, in infested wood using radio frequency (RF) energy. J
Wood Sci 59:160170 (2013).
13 Pereira RM, Koehler PG, Pfiester M and Walker W, Lethal effects of
heat and use of localized heat treatment for control of bed bug
infestations. J Econ Entomol 102:11821188 (2009).
14 Johnson CG, The ecology of the bed-bug, Cimex lectularius L., in Britain.
JHyg41:345 –461 (1941).
15 Kells SA, Nonchemical control of bed bugs. Am Ent 52:109 –110 (2006).
16 Kells SA and Goblirsch MJ, Temperature and time requirements for
controlling bed bugs (Cimex lectularius) under commercial heat
treatment conditions. Insects 2:412– 422 (2011).
Pest Manag Sci (2018) © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps
www.soci.org D Wang et al.
17 Pinto LJ, Cooper R and Kraft SK, Bed Bug Handbook: The Complete Guide
to Bed Bugs and their Control. Pinto & Associates, Inc., Mechanicsville,
VA (2007).
18 Naylor RA and Boase CJ, Practical solutions for treating laundry
infested with Cimex lectularius (Hemiptera: Cimicidae). JEcon
Entomol 103:136– 139 (2010).
19 Cooper R, Chapter 8 - Ectoparasites, part three: bed bugs and kissing
bugs, in Mallis Handbook of Pest Control, 10th edn, ed. by Mallis A,
Hedges S and Moreland D. The Mallis Handbook Company, Richfield,
Ohio, pp. 587– 632 (2011).
20 Loudon C, Rapid killing of bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L.) on sur-
faces using heat: application to luggage. Pest Manag Sci 73:64– 70
(2017).
21 Potter MF, Romero A and Haynes KF, Battling bed bugs in the USA, in
Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Urban Pests,ed.
by Robinson WH and Bajomi D. OOK-Press Kft., Veszprém, Hungary,
pp. 401– 406 (2008).
22 Puckett RT, McDonald DL and Gold RE, Comparison of multiple steam
treatment durations for control of bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L.).
Pest Manag Sci 69:1061 –1065 (2013).
23 Wang C, Gibb T and Bennett GW, Evaluation of two least toxic inte-
grated pest management programs for managing bed bugs (Het-
eroptera: Cimicidae) with discussion of a bed bug intercepting
device. J Med Entomol 46:566 –571 (2009).
24 Wang C, Singh N, Cooper R, Liu C and Buczkowski G, Evaluation of an
insecticide dust band treatment method for controlling bed bugs. J
Econ Entomol 106:347 –352 (2013).
25 Abbott WS, A method of computing the effectiveness of an insecticide.
J Econ Entomol 18:265 –267 (1925).
26 IBM Corporation ed, IBM SPSS Statistics Base 22.IBMCorporation,
Armonk, NY (2013).
27 Wang C, Singh N and Cooper R, Efficacy of an essential oil-based
pesticide for controlling bed bug (Cimex lectularius) infestations in
apartment buildings. Insects 5:849859 (2014).
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ps © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry Pest Manag Sci (2018)
... Steam treatment and diatomaceous earth (DE) dust application have been recommended by many researchers as bed bug control methods to mitigate the risks associated with chemical methods. [16][17][18][19][20][21] Steam treatment kills bed bugs by high temperature steam that exceeds the thermal lethal temperature of bed bugs. 19,21 In a laboratory study, the transient temperature of the treatment arena surface can rise to 73.9°C after treatment by steam equipment at a speed of 10 s per 30.5 cm and caused more than 88% mortality of bed bug nymphs and adults, and no eggs hatched normally. ...
... [16][17][18][19][20][21] Steam treatment kills bed bugs by high temperature steam that exceeds the thermal lethal temperature of bed bugs. 19,21 In a laboratory study, the transient temperature of the treatment arena surface can rise to 73.9°C after treatment by steam equipment at a speed of 10 s per 30.5 cm and caused more than 88% mortality of bed bug nymphs and adults, and no eggs hatched normally. 19 Ramos et al. 20 compared the efficacy of steam treatment and insecticide mixture spray under simulated field conditions and found that both methods could kill bed bugs effectively, and steam treatment was better than insecticide sprays. ...
... In our previous study, steam treatment could easily kill bed bugs if they were exposed to steam directly, but if they are hidden under covers it is difficult for the steam to penetrate the cover, resulting in a much reduced killing effect. 21 Similar results were also found in Experiment II. The superheated dry steam used in this study can provide dry saturated steam heated to 180°C (information from the equipment instructions), which is much higher than the upper lethal temperature of tropical bed bugs. ...
Article
Full-text available
BACKGROUND Over the past two decades, bed bugs (Cimex spp.) have resurged as common urban pests around the world. The search for efficient and safe control measures has become a key interest among researchers, manufacturers, and pest control professionals. In this study, we evaluated and compared the efficacy of steam, diatomaceous earth (DE) dust, and a combination of both against tropical bed bugs (Cimex hemipterus (F.)) under laboratory and field conditions. RESULTS In the laboratory study, the mortality of bed bugs after 2 days of exposure to DE dust was 100%. When bed bugs stayed on the surface of an object or in cracks, a brief steam treatment (1 s) caused 100% mortality. However, when bed bugs were hidden under a fabric cover, steam application for 10 s only caused 89 ± 6% mortality. Bed bugs that survived steam treatment exhibited reduced feeding activity. In a 14‐week long study, there was no significant difference in the reduction rate of bed bugs between steam treatment and DE dust treatment. A 37‐week long control study showed that steam and steam plus DE dust treatments eliminated 97–100% of the infestations. CONCLUSION Applying steam and DE dust are effective strategies for eliminating natural tropical bed bug infestations. Continuous follow‐up monitoring and treatment until no bed bugs are found are crucial in completely eliminating the infestation of tropical bed bugs. © 2024 Society of Chemical Industry.
... Among the hightemperature treatment methods, the steam application is attractive because of the potential for instantons kill and ease of use. Both commercial and consumer-grade steamers (price range US$75-1,259) effectively control bed bugs that are exposed or hiding under fabric or within cracks (Puckett et al. 2013, Wang et al. 2018b). The surface temperature may reach >71 o C, ensuring all bed bugs on the surface, hiding in cracks or under the fabric, will be killed. ...
... Bed bugs often hide in cracks and crevices as well as beneath pleats and folds of furniture items (Cooper 2010). Effective delivery of insecticides into bed bug harborages associated with upholstered furniture is another potential concern since upholstered items may often be treated with stain-resistant materials that repel liquids, therefore, reducing spray penetration (Wang et al. 2018b). This challenge would not be expected for a steam treatment, but this difference was not investigated in this study. ...
... According to the manufacturer's internal study, the steamer used in our study uses patented technology to produce superheated dry steam (at least 15ºC higher than other steamers) and reduced condensation on treated surfaces as compared to the traditional steamer (https://www.poltieradicator.com/superheated-drysteam/). Previous studies evaluated four different steamers under laboratory conditions: HAAN HS-20R Handheld Steam Cleaner (HAAN Corporation, Lancaster, PA), Steamfast SF-370WH Multi-Purpose Steam Cleaner (Steamfast, Andover, KS), Amerivap Systems STM-BASIC Steamax Commercial Steam Cleaner (Amerivap Systems, Inc., Dawsonville, GA), and J-4000DM Jiffy steamer (Jiffy Steamer Company, Union City, TN) (Puckett et al. 2013, Wang et al. 2018b. Although all tested consumer and commercial grade steamers were effective for controlling bed bugs, using a steamer that generates higher temperatures may eliminate bed bug infestations more efficiently (i.e., can move the nozzle faster compared to a traditional steamer) since temperature and mortality are positively correlated (Kells and Goblirsch 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
The common bed bug, Cimex lectularius L., is a difficult urban pest to control. A simulated field study was conducted to compare the efficacy of steam application and an insecticide mixture spray (0.05% acetamiprid and 0.06% bifenthrin mixture) against C. lectularius. Three types of furniture (desk chair, upholstered armchair, and wooden table) were treated in the laboratory. The efficacy of the treatments was evaluated by visual inspection and placement of interceptor traps under the legs of the furniture. One hundred mixed stages of an insecticide-resistant population of C. lectularius were released onto each furniture item. After a 10-day acclimation period, each furniture item received steam treatment, insecticide spray, or no treatment. The second application of treatment was conducted 14 d later. Bed bug counts from interceptors and visual inspections were recorded at 13 d and 28 d after the initial treatment. At 28 d, the mean (± SE) live bed bug count in the steam, spray, and control group was 1 ± 0, 2 ± 1, and 83 ± 10, respectively. Both treatment methods were highly effective in controlling bed bugs on furniture. The mean bed bug count from interceptors in the steam, spray, and control groups were 0.3 ± 0.2, 11 ± 7, and 47 ± 9, respectively. There was no significant difference in the efficacy between steam and spray treatments based on either visual inspection or bed bug counts from interceptors. However, based on interceptor counts, the steam treatment caused faster bed bug population reduction than insecticide sprays.
... Physical contact of bugs with boiling water causes thermal injury which instantly causes death of bed bugs. It is an easy, effective method that does not require any specific instrumentation for its application (Lee et al., 2023;Wang et al., 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
Various researches on bed bugs (Family: Cimicidae) have been performed in the recent past due to their re-activation in the world. These bed bugs primarily infest enclosed and inadequately ventilated spaces. They are more prevalent in densely populated areas where there is minimal movement of household furniture and bedding, particularly during the hot and humid seasons in Pakistan. Bed bugs pose direct effects by bite-associated allergies and blood-sucking; indirectly by affecting mental health. Although many bed bug control strategies are available, in this case heat treatment through boiling water was used as a control strategy. Boiling water causes thermal injury and death of bugs by desiccation. This strategy is an effective and cheap control strategy because no specific instrumentation and chemical are required
... Generally, nonchemical interventions have a more immediate effect in reducing the number of bed bugs and are less hazardous than chemical interventions [4]. Nonchemical interventions include keeping affected areas clean and free of clutter, vacuuming, use of equipment to heat room to a lethal temperature (60°C) for bed bugs, steam treatment of furniture, washing linens with hot water, placing infested items into a freezer (temperature -17°C for at least two hours), caulking wall holes and cracks where bugs can hide, mattress encasements, proper disposal of highly infested items (sealed in plastic), and placement of bed bug traps/interceptors (e.g., the "pitfall" style) at the base of beds and furniture [127][128][129][130][131][132]. Most traps use heat or semiochemicals (e.g., carbon dioxide, kairomones) to attract bed bugs. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the past decade, there has been a global resurgence of bed bug infestations, especially in developed countries. Proper awareness and identification of bed bug infestations are essential to guide treatment and eradication. The purpose of this article is to familiarize physicians with bed bug bites so that they can effectively diagnose, treat, and address questions about bed bug bites and infestations. Bed bug bites are often painless. Typical reactions include pruritic, erythematous maculopapules occurring in clusters or in a linear or curvilinear distribution in exposed areas of the body. A small red punctum may be visualized at the center of the bite mark. Lesions that appear three in a row and papules on the upper eyelid associated with erythema and edema are highly suggestive of bites from bed bugs. Exaggerated local reactions such as vesicles, urticarial wheals, urticarial perilesional plaques, diffuse urticaria, bullae, and nodules may occur in previously sensitized individuals. Reactions to bed bug bites are self-limited. As such, treatment is mainly symptomatic. Topical pramoxine and oral antihistamines can be used to alleviate pruritus. Topical corticosteroids can be used for significant eruptions to control inflammation and pruritus, and to hasten resolution of the lesions. Integrated pest management, an approach for the eradication of bed bugs, includes monitoring devices (active monitors include the use of heat or carbon dioxide attractants and passive monitors include the use of sticky pads for trapping), and judicious use of nonchemical and chemical treatments known to be effective. Nonchemical interventions include keeping affected areas clean and free of clutter, vacuuming, washing linens with hot water, caulking wall holes and cracks where bugs can hide, proper disposal of highly infested items, and placement of bed bug traps/interceptors at the base of beds and furniture. Chemical interventions involve the use of insecticides such as synthetic pyrethroids, silicates, insect growth disruptors, carbamates, organophosphates, neonicotinoids, diethyl-meta-toluamide, chlorfenapyr, fipronil and plant essential oils. Insecticides should be used with caution to prevent over-exposure and toxicity (in particular, cardiovascular and neurologic toxicity), especially if there are young children around. It is important to note that multiple mechanisms of insecticide resistance exist and as such, chemical treatment should only be undertaken by trained professionals who understand the current literature on resistance. Both nonchemical and chemical technologies should be combined for optimal results. Bed bug infestations may cause diverse dermal reactions, stigmatization, poor self-esteem, emotional stress, anxiety, significant adverse effect on quality of life, and substantial socioeconomic burden to society. As such, their rapid detection and eradication are of paramount importance. Consultation with a professional exterminator is recommended to fully eradicate an infestation.
... Today, heat treatments are applied using handheld devices, heating chambers of varying sizes, or whole-room treatments. With handheld steamers, cheap units perform as effectively as expensive steamers for treating under fabric materials or in cracks (144). Infested furniture, mattresses, suitcases, boxes, and other household items can be placed and treated in a heat chamber, insulated tent, utility trailer, cube van, or shipping container, with the heat provided by electricity or propane gas. ...
Article
Full-text available
Bed bugs (Hemiptera: Cimicidae) are an important group of obligate hematophagous urban insect pests. The global resurgence of bed bugs, involving the common bed bug, Cimex lectularius L., and the tropical bed bug, Cimex hemipterus (F.), over the past two decades is believed to be primarily due to the development of insecticide resistance, along with global travel and poor pest management, which have contributed to their spread. This review examines and synthesizes the literature on bed bug origins and their global spread and the literature on historical and contemporary control options. This includes bed bug prevention, detection and monitoring, nonchemical and chemical control methodologies (and their limitations), and potential future control options. Future research needs are highlighted, especially the factors behind the modern resurgence, the necessity of identifying differences between the two bed bug species relevant to control, and the need to improve insecticide test protocols and management strategies. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Entomology, Volume 68 is January 2023. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.
Article
Hot water mound drench treatment has broad application prospects in the control of the red imported fire ant (RIFA), Solenopsis invicta Buren (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). However, much work still needs to be carried out to provide a theoretical basis and technical support for the use of this method against RIFAs under field conditions. In this study, we monitored the temperature changes at different depths within RIFA nests during laboratory-simulated hot water mound drench experiments and evaluated the lethal effect of hot water treatment on RIFAs. Furthermore, the targeted removal effect of hot water mound drench treatment on RIFA nests under field conditions was evaluated. Results indicated that the temperature at depths of 5, 15, and 25 cm inside the simulated ant nests was higher than 51.1 °C within 30 min after treatment, resulting in a 100% mortality rate for RIFAs at all tested depths. Under field conditions, when nests were disturbed, the percentage of RIFAs crawling out of their nests gradually increased with time after disturbance, reached its maximum value at 25 or 30 s after the disturbance, and then gradually decreased. Single hot water mound drench treatment (each ant nest was treated with 17.8–21.6 liter of hot water at a temperature of 97–100 °C) can significantly reduce the RIFA population in ant nests and lead to a 72.7% reduction in the number of surviving ant nests. However, the safety, operability, and timelines of hot water mound drench treatment for RIFA field control still need further investigation.
Article
Full-text available
Bed bugs are an important group of medical and urban insect pests. They are obligate blood-feeders. Their bites may cause skin irritation and allergic reactions and, under some circumstances, may lead to mental and other health issues. Despite numerous discoveries on the biology of these obnoxious pests and progress in control strategies over the last two decades, bed bugs continue to preferentially plague those from low socioeconomic communities because the poor generally could not afford effective control options. As a result, such infestations in poorer communities serve as a reservoir for wider society. This Special Collection of the Perspective on Biology and Management of Bed Bugs presents nine original research papers on bed bug detection , insecticide performance and resistance, nonchemical treatment, fungal biopesticides, and pest management procurement and contracts. We hope that these investigative findings will spur research on safer, more affordable, and effective control options in the future.
Article
Full-text available
This study aimed to review published scientific literature on bed bugs in countries where insecticide resistance has been reported worldwide from 2000 to 2021. Electronic databases, including Scopus, PubMed, and WOS, were searched. Out of 606 articles found in the initial search, we selected 57 articles, of which 40 articles had reported on Cimex lectularius (C. lectularius), and 22 papers had reported on Cimex hemipterus (C. hemipterus). Most studies on insecticide resistance were carried out on C. lectularius in North America (14, 35%) and C. hemipterus in Asia (16, 72.7%). The most common method used to detect bed bug resistance to insecticides was toxicological bioassay with an overall random pooled effect size of 0.38 (95% CI: 0.23–0.53) in C. lectularius and 0.46 (95% CI: 0.27–0.65) in C. hemipterus. Resistance to pyrethroids was reported against C. lectularius with an overall pooled effect size of 0.75 (95% CI: 0.56–0.94) and C. hemipterus with an overall pooled effect size of 0.81 (95% CI: 0.57–0.93) in 33.40 (82.5%) and 19.22 (86.3%) published articles, respectively. A very high resistance level to pyrethroids in both studied species was observed, and resistance ratios at the highest level were 76389.3 and 315.5 in C. lectularius and C. hemipterus, respectively. Resistance mechanisms against pyrethroids were reported from most locations except Iran and Thailand, but these mechanisms were not studied in other insecticide groups. These reports indicate that chemical control options for bed bugs are limited. Therefore, a combination of chemical and non-chemical strategies is recommended for bed bug control.
Article
Full-text available
Numerous bed bug research papers have been published in the past 20 yr as a result of bed bug (Cimex spp.) (Hemiptera: Cimicidae) resurgence in the world. Yet, few of them focused on the management of the tropical bed bug, C. hemipterus (F.). Here, we describe a case of tropical bed bug infestation in two dormitory buildings and effectiveness of a tropical bed bug treatment program. The study site consisted of 125 dormitories in two buildings. An initial building-wide monitoring with ClimbUp interceptors revealed 25 infestations. The spatial distribution of bed bug infested rooms showed a significant aggregated distribution pattern with same infestation status for neighboring units sharing walls. All infested rooms were monitored every 2 wk and treated using a combination of steam and diatomaceous earth (DE) dust application if bed bugs were still found. For the 25 initially identified infested rooms, after 14 wk treatment, 44% of them no longer had bed bugs, and the mean number of bed bugs captured per room decreased by 94.1%. A combination of steam and DE dust treatment is an effective strategy for suppressing tropical bed bug infestations in dormitory environment.
Article
Full-text available
The worldwide resurgence of bed bugs [both Cimex lectularius L. and Cimex hemipterus (F.)] over the past two decades is believed in large part to be due to the development of insecticide resistance. The transcriptomic and genomic studies since 2010, as well as morphological, biochemical and behavioral studies, have helped insecticide resistance research on bed bugs. Multiple resistance mechanisms, including penetration resistance through thickening or remodelling of the cuticle, metabolic resistance by increased activities of detoxification enzymes (e.g. cytochrome P450 monooxygenases and esterases), and knockdown resistance by kdr mutations, have been experimentally identified as conferring insecticide resistance in bed bugs. Other candidate resistance mechanisms, including behavioral resistance, some types of physiological resistance (e.g. increasing activities of esterases by point mutations, glutathione S-transferase, target site insensitivity including altered AChEs, GABA receptor insensitivity and altered nAChRs), symbiont-mediated resistance and other potential, yet undiscovered mechanisms may exist. This article reviews recent studies of resistance mechanisms and the genes governing insecticide resistance, potential candidate resistance mechanisms, and methods of monitoring insecticide resistance in bed bugs. This article provides an insight into the knowledge essential for the development of both insecticide resistance management (IRM) and integrated pest management (IPM) strategies for successful bed bug management.
Article
Full-text available
The invasive Red Palm Weevil is the major pest of palms. Several control methods have been applied, however concern is raised regarding the treatments that can cause significant environmental pollution. In this context the use of microwaves is particularly attractive. Microwave heating applications are increasingly proposed in the management of a wide range of agricultural and wood pests, exploiting the thermal death induced in the insects that have a thermal tolerance lower than that of the host matrices. This paper describes research aiming to combat the Red Palm pest using microwave heating systems. An electromagnetic-thermal model was developed to better control the temperature profile inside the palm tissues. In this process both electromagnetic and thermal parameters are involved, the latter being particularly critical depending on plant physiology. Their evaluation was carried out by fitting experimental data and the thermal model with few free parameters. The results obtained by the simplified model well match with both that of a commercial software 3D model and measurements on treated Phoenix canariensis palms with a ring microwave applicator. This work confirms that microwave heating is a promising, eco-compatible solution to fight the spread of weevil.
Article
Full-text available
Bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L. and Cimex hemipterus F.) are among the most difficult urban pests to manage. Many essential oil-based bed bug control products that are considered reduced risk to mammals compared to synthetic insect neurotoxins have become commercially available, but their effectiveness as a stand-alone control method is unknown. This study assessed the field efficacy of an essential oil-based bed bug control product (EcoRaider; a.i. 1% geraniol + 1% cedar oil + 2% sodium lauryl sulfate) compared to a pyrethroid and neonicotinoid mixture spray (0.075% Temprid SC; a.i. beta-cyfluthrin + imidacloprid). After 12 weeks, the three treatments—EcoRaider, Temprid SC, and EcoRaider + Temprid SC caused 92.5 ± 2.7, 92.9 ± 3.0, and 91.7% ± 2.7% bed bug count reduction, respectively. No significant differences existed in the bed bug reduction among the treatments. Bed bugs were eliminated from only 22% of the treated apartments. Among those still with bed bugs, 76% of the residents did not know bed bugs were present. We documented the residents’ self-control practices and discussed the potential of using essential oil-based insecticides in bed bug management programs to minimize the health risks to building occupants and pets and to slow down the development of insecticide resistance.
Article
Full-text available
Developing effective alternative approaches for disinfesting bed bugs from residential spaces requires a balance between obtaining complete insect mortality, while minimizing costs and energy consumption. One method of disinfestation is the application of lethal high temperatures directly to rooms and contents within a structure (termed whole-room heat treatments). However, temperature and time parameters for efficacy in whole-room heat treatments are unknown given the slower rate of temperature increase and the probable variability of end-point temperatures within a treated room. The objective of these experiments was to explore requirements to produce maximum mortality from heat exposure using conditions that are more characteristic of whole-room heat treatments. Bed bugs were exposed in an acute lethal temperature (LTemp) trial, or time trials at sub-acute lethal temperatures (LTime). The lethal temperature (LTemp 99) for adults was 48.3 °C, while LTemp 99 for eggs was 54.8 °C. Adult bed bugs exposed to 45 °C had a LTime 99 of 94.8 min, while eggs survived 7 h at 45 °C and only 71.5 min at 48 °C. We discuss differences in exposure methodologies, potential reasons why bed bugs can withstand higher temperatures and future directions for research.
Article
Full-text available
Article
Background: The resistance of bed bugs (Cimex lectularius L.) to chemical insecticides has motivated development of non-chemical control methods such as heat treatment. However, because bed bugs tend to hide in cracks or crevices, their behavior incidentally generates a thermally-insulated microenvironment for themselves. Bed bugs located on the outer surface of luggage are less insulated and potentially more vulnerable to brief heat treatment. Results: Soft-sided suitcases with adult male bed bugs on the outside were exposed to an air temperature of 70-75 °C. It took 6 minutes to kill all of the bed bugs, even those that had concealed themselves under zipper flaps or decorative piping. During heating, only one bed bug (out of 250 total) moved into the luggage (through a closed zipper). Over long periods of time (24 hours) at room temperature, adult male bed bugs on the exterior of luggage only infrequently moved inside; only 3% (5/170) had moved inside during 24 hours. Conclusions: Brief exterior heat treatment of luggage is a promising way to decrease the spread of bed bugs being transported on the outer surface of luggage. This treatment will not kill bed bugs inside the luggage, but could be a component of integrated management for this pest.
Chapter
This book, containing 15 chapters, aims to highlight approaches to urban pest (including mosquitoes and termites) prevention and control by the judicious use of pesticides. It discusses key strategies for minimizing pesticide use without compromising quality of pest control; foremost among these are strict adherence to the principles of integrated pest management, the adoption of novel technologies (such as use of growth regulators, baits, pheromones, natural products and encapsulated formulations) and enacting effective regulations.
Article
Bed bugs are wingless hematophagous ectoparasites that have co-existed with humans since they first appeared in the caves of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern regions approximately 65 million years ago. Bed bugs are not known to transmit diseases, most probably due to the lack of sylvatic cycles. Historical control methods include some remedies, but also many useful control methods such as community-wide eradication efforts, insecticidal powders, fumigation, and rigorous cleaning. These intense eradication efforts combined with newly developed synthetic insecticides, such as DDT and malathion, almost eliminated bed bugs during the 1950s. However, there has been a resurgence in bed bug populations during the past 15 years. Recent molecular evidence suggests that bed bugs did not experience a genetic bottle neck, but rather existed in isolated populations. Today, bed bugs are found to have multiple modes of insecticide resistance including reduced cuticular penetration and up-regulation of ABC transporters (ATP-binding cassette protein transporters). Currently available chemical treatments are based on pyrethroid insecticides that are not effective against many insecticide resistant bed bugs, but fumigation and dust formulations have been found to be more effective. Non-chemical control methods are most useful in community-wide integrated pest management. Future bed bug control will most likely to rely on refining the currently available methods and focusing on the research with cooperative efforts.