Conference PaperPDF Available

The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Violent fire-driven convection can manifest as towering cumulus or cumulonimbus clouds, the latter of which are known as firestorms (pyroCb). These extreme fires can have devastating impacts on environment and society, and appear to be a worsening problem. The major concerns surrounding these large pyroconvective events are that their associated fire spread is highly unpredictable and that they're generally not suppressible. Indeed, current methods of fire spread prediction, including the use of empirical and semi-empirical modelling approaches, fall short when attempting to predict fire behaviour associated with these events. In particular, they commonly under-predict the rate of spread in such situations, when broader-scale fire-atmosphere interactions are dominant. To date, research into large pyroconvective events has either focused on the processes involved in normal atmospheric convection, or on surface fire weather and associated fuel conditions. While some investigations have combined the two approaches, a definitive study into both the effects of the surface conditions and the fire-atmosphere interactions is still needed to better understand their respective role in the development of extreme fires. This paper incorporates recent insights into dynamic fire propagation into a coupled fire-atmosphere fire modelling framework to test the combined effects of fire behaviour and atmospheric structure on the occurrence of violent pyroconvective events. In particular, we consider the role of factors such as the spatial expanse and intensity of the fire, and the stability of the atmosphere (both in terms of temperature lapse and moisture profile). The effects of these variables on extreme pyroconvective development are investigated in a systematic way, varying these parameters using the coupled fire-atmosphere WRF-Fire (Weather Research and Forecasting Model (WRF)). In the initial work presented in this paper we focus on the case where the fire is represented by a static heat source of variable dimension and intensity. Analyses were conducted to investigate how (a) the size of the fire (i.e. area of deep flaming) and (b) the intensity of the sensible heat source affects the plume development. Results from preliminary analyses of dry, static fires indicated that the areal expanse of the fire strongly influences the development of the column of deep convection associated with violent pyroconvective events. This supports the hypothesis that plumes above zones of deep flaming are less influenced by entrainment than plumes emanating from typical linear fire fronts. While air is entrained at the plume boundary, the inner core of the plume is less able to entrain air. As a consequence, the areal nature of the heat source driving convection has an influence on the dynamics of the plume-in particular, the heights it can attain. The magnitude of the heat flux produced by the fire is also important for areas of deep flaming up to a minimum of 2 km diameter, but as the size of the heat source increases beyond a 2 km diameter, this appears to be less influential on the way the plume develops. Our findings provide motivation for further investigation into the effect of the fire's attributes on the immediate atmosphere. They also have the potential to significantly improve forecasting of blow up fire events. Indeed, by combining our findings with recent insights into dynamic fire propagation and improved operational information relating to the atmospheric profile (e.g. through enhanced capability to conduct atmospheric soundings) it is feasible to provide fire agency personnel with far more targeted methods and tools that can be used to better distinguish fires that are likely to develop into violent pyroconvective events.
Content may be subject to copyright.
The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
R.L. Badlana, J.J. Sharplesa, J.P. Evansb, R.H.D. McRaec
aApplied and Industrial Mathematics Research Group, School of Physical, Environmental and Mathematical
Sciences, UNSW Canberra, Australia.
bClimate Change Research Centre, Faculty of Science, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia
cAustralian Capital Territory Emergency Services Agency, Canberra, Australia
Email: r.badlan@adfa.edu.au
Abstract: Violent fire-driven convection can manifest as towering cumulus or cumulonimbus clouds, the
latter of which are known as firestorms (pyroCb). These extreme fires can have devastating impacts on
environment and society, and appear to be a worsening problem. The major concerns surrounding these large
pyroconvective events are that their associated fire spread is highly unpredictable and that they’re generally
not suppressible. Indeed, current methods of fire spread prediction, including the use of empirical and semi-
empirical modelling approaches, fall short when attempting to predict fire behaviour associated with these
events. In particular, they commonly under-predict the rate of spread in such situations, when broader-scale
fire-atmosphere interactions are dominant. To date, research into large pyroconvective events has either
focused on the processes involved in normal atmospheric convection, or on surface fire weather and
associated fuel conditions. While some investigations have combined the two approaches, a definitive study
into both the effects of the surface conditions and the fire-atmosphere interactions is still needed to better
understand their respective role in the development of extreme fires.
This paper incorporates recent insights into dynamic fire propagation into a coupled fire-atmosphere fire
modelling framework to test the combined effects of fire behaviour and atmospheric structure on the
occurrence of violent pyroconvective events. In particular, we consider the role of factors such as the spatial
expanse and intensity of the fire, and the stability of the atmosphere (both in terms of temperature lapse and
moisture profile). The effects of these variables on extreme pyroconvective development are investigated in a
systematic way, varying these parameters using the coupled fire-atmosphere WRF-Fire (Weather Research
and Forecasting Model (WRF)). In the initial work presented in this paper we focus on the case where the fire
is represented by a static heat source of variable dimension and intensity.
Analyses were conducted to investigate how (a) the size of the fire (i.e. area of deep flaming) and (b) the
intensity of the sensible heat source affects the plume development. Results from preliminary analyses of dry,
static fires indicated that the areal expanse of the fire strongly influences the development of the column of
deep convection associated with violent pyroconvective events. This supports the hypothesis that plumes
above zones of deep flaming are less influenced by entrainment than plumes emanating from typical linear
fire fronts. While air is entrained at the plume boundary, the inner core of the plume is less able to entrain air.
As a consequence, the areal nature of the heat source driving convection has an influence on the dynamics of
the plume - in particular, the heights it can attain. The magnitude of the heat flux produced by the fire is also
important for areas of deep flaming up to a minimum of 2 km diameter, but as the size of the heat source
increases beyond a 2 km diameter, this appears to be less influential on the way the plume develops.
Our findings provide motivation for further investigation into the effect of the fire’s attributes on the
immediate atmosphere. They also have the potential to significantly improve forecasting of blow up fire
events. Indeed, by combining our findings with recent insights into dynamic fire propagation and improved
operational information relating to the atmospheric profile (e.g. through enhanced capability to conduct
atmospheric soundings) it is feasible to provide fire agency personnel with far more targeted methods and
tools that can be used to better distinguish fires that are likely to develop into violent pyroconvective events.
Keywords: Wildfire simulation, fire-atmosphere interaction, deep flaming, pyroconvection
22nd International Congress on Modelling and Simulation, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia, 3 to 8 December 2017
mssanz.org.au/modsim2017
1090
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
1. INTRODUCTION
Extreme wildfires occur throughout the world and are the most severe category of bushfire (Sharples, et al.
2016). Violent pyroconvective events; that is, towering pyrocumulus (pyroCu) and pyrocumulonimbus
(pyroCb) impact the surface as well as extending their influence into the atmosphere. Extreme wildfires have
a large cost to society through the destruction of buildings and loss of lives, as well as forestry and
agricultural productivity and sites of cultural importance (Sharples et al. 2016). The 2009 Black Saturday
fires in Victoria, for example, resulted in the loss of 173 lives and a total economic cost estimated at $4.4
billion (Teague, et al. 2010). Population growth is also causing expansion of urban areas and increasing the
proportion of the urban margins with the surrounding woodland and forested neighbouring areas. These
demographic changes combined with the increased likelihood of extreme wildfires under climate change,
mean that the risk of extreme wildfires to the community will increase. It is therefore important to improve
our understanding of the drivers of these catastrophic events, and to use that understanding to devise better
ways of predicting their occurrence and to inform better management options that might ameliorate the risk.
These extreme fires manifest as coupled fire-atmosphere events, which can have a significant effect on local
weather patterns. Entrainment into the plume of a violent pyroconvective event can result in highly erratic
and turbulent winds in the vicinity of the fire, while within the fire’s convective plume, organised flows can
be produced - possibly resulting in downbursts, which are problematic to firefighters and planners.
Furthermore, the effect of smoke shading can result in thermal gradients over the land surface, which can
produce buoyancy flows whose influence can extend some distance away from the fire (Clements, et al.
2007). The development of a deep convective column into a pyroCb may also transport smoke into the lower
stratosphere as the enhanced plume overshoots the troposphere, thereby depositing aerosols (e.g. smoke and
ash) high in to the atmosphere where it can then be transported around the globe (Fromm, et al. 2010).
Injection of aerosols into the atmosphere leads to extended lifetime of convective clouds (Lindsey and
Fromm 2008) as well as the pollution of the stratosphere (Fromm, et al. 2005, Fromm, et al. 2008, Fromm, et
al. 2008), with broader climatic consequences.
PyroCbs often produce lightning, which may result in the ignition of additional fires and even spawn
tornadoes (Fromm, et al. 2006, McRae, et al. 2013), both of which were observed in the 2003 Canberra fires.
The spot fires produced by lightning strikes (and/or from embers) may coalesce into a larger fire, which due
to the nature of its formation exhibits sustained and intense flaming over a large spatial expanse. We refer to
these instances as instances of ‘deep flaming’ (McRae, et al. 2015). Thus, deep flaming describes large areas
of the landscape affected by quasi-simultaneous active flaming. Deep flaming events result in large spatial
integrals of instantaneous energy release, and should be considered as quite distinct from the more typical
frontal propagation of a wildfire, which has a more linear structure. Deep flaming events can encompass
several square kilometres, and can arise in a number of ways, for example:
Very strong winds – so the head fire advances more rapidly than the back of the flaming zone;
Change in wind direction – so the long flank of a fire is transformed into a fast running head fire;
Eruptive fire behaviour – where steep slopes can cause a fire to accelerate rapidly;
Vorticity-driven lateral spread – where strong winds and steep terrain interact to rapidly drive a fire
laterally, accompanied by downwind spotting (Sharples, et al. 2012, Simpson, et al. 2013, Simpson,
et al. 2014); and
Fire coalescence – including mass spot fires from embers and lightning or merging of fires
introduced into the landscape by other means such as back-burning.
Deep flaming has also shown itself to be a characteristic of violent pyroconvective events and is conducive to
the development of deep convection, as seen in the 2003 Canberra fires, the 2014 Grampian fires in Victoria
and more recently, the Sir Ivan fire that destroyed Uarbry, NSW in February this year. McRae et al. (2015)
demonstrated a spatiotemporal link between deep flaming events, as identified in multispectral linescans of
the fire, with radar echotop maxima and the strongest radar returns. As entrainment of environmental air
occurs along the perimeter of the plume, it is hypothesised that the larger and more regular-shaped the fire
area, the less mixing of hot air will occur away from the plume boundary, enabling the plume to reach an
adequate height for the latent heat release and atmospheric instability to further influence the convection
(Finney and McAllister 2011). Therefore, further research into how deep flaming may influence
pyroconvection is necessary for better prediction of such events and will increase our understanding of fire-
atmosphere interactions more generally.
A number of models have investigated the interactions of atmosphere and fire and also note how pyrogenic
moisture release plays a role in pyroconvection (Potter 2005, Cunningham and Reeder 2009, Luderer, et al.
2009, Thurston, et al. 2015, Thurston, et al. 2016). The role of released moisture is an active area of research
1091
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
with its relative contribution to pyroconvection still being debated. Although, it is acknowledged that
moisture is a vital component of the fluxes released from the fire to the atmosphere, this work initially
focuses on the effect of a static heat source only. The model used for this stage of research has no pyrogenic
moisture (i.e. fuel or combustion moisture) to allow only the effects of the sensible heat from the fire the
convective plume to be determined. The role of moisture will be considered in later stages of research.
Figure 1. Profiles of (a) potential temperature (K) and (b) mixing ratio (g kg-1) for the lower 15 km of the
atmosphere.
2. METHOD
The numerical simulations were performed using version 3.9 of the Weather Research and Forecasting model
(WRF) (Skamarock, et al. 2008). This is coupled to the WRF-Fire module (Coen, et al. 2013) and is run in
large-eddy simulation (LES) (Moeng, et al. 2007). This configuration explicitly resolves the atmospheric
large-scale eddies whereas the small-scale (subgrid) eddies are modelled using a subfilter-scale stress model.
The WRF model is fully compressible and utilises a mass-based terrain-following coordinate system.
The computational domain extends 21 km in both directions horizontally and 30 km vertically, with vertical
and horizontal resolution of 150 m. The WRF-Fire model grid is set to a 4:1 resolution of the atmospheric
model grid and therefore the fire model is run with 37.5 m horizontal resolution. The effects of subgrid
turbulence are parameterised using a predictive 1.5-order turbulence kinetic energy closure. A Rayleigh
damping layer is used in the top 5 km. The simulations are idealised and have no radiation, physics, planetary
boundary layer, or cumulus parameterisation schemes. The microphysics scheme employed is the Single
Moment 6-class (WSM6) scheme (Hong and Lim 2006) which is a graupel scheme with ice, snow and
graupel processes. It has six categories of hydrometeor, can simulate the process of water vapour, cloud
water, cloud ice rain, snow, and graupel, and is particularly suitable for high resolution simulations. There is
no terrain in the model and no background wind. The timestep is 0.9 s for the three smallest fires and 0.3 s
for the largest fire. The lateral boundaries are open and the simulation runs for 6 hours and 30 minutes, with
the first 4 hours used for spin-up.
Three different fire intensities are investigated (25 kW m-2, 50 kW m-2, and 100 kW m-2) to determine how
the sensible heat from the fire may affect the nature of the resulting plume generated by pyroconvection.
When evaluating the pyroconvective potential of the fire, the plume height is observed. The heat flux is
introduced after boundary layer initialised (i.e., after 4 hours) and is increased linearly over 10 minutes to
avoid instability. The spatial extent of the fire source is varied to represent different sizes of deep flaming.
Four circular fires are compared each with the following radius: 150 m, 500 m, 1 km, and 4 km. These fires
are run to determine whether the areal extent of a zone of deep flaming affects the generation of violent
pyroconvection associated with extreme fires.
The sensitivity of the plume to the horizontal resolution of the grid points is evaluated by producing three
simulations with a horizontal resolution of 50 m, 100 m and 150 m (not shown). There is very little
difference between the plumes produced so for the sake of computational resources, the 150 m horizontal
resolution model was used.
1092
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
The model is initialized with three different soundings, each representing stable, neutral and unstable
atmospheric profiles in the lowest 3 km of the atmosphere (Fig. 1) and a tropopause located at a height of
12 km. The c-Haines value for each sounding was calculated and produced values of 0.5, 6.1, and 9.5
respectively.
Figure 2. Four vertical cross-sections through the plume after 40 minutes for 100 kW m-2 fires with neutral
stability. The fires are circular and have radii of 150 m (top left), 500 m (below left), 1 km (top right), and
4 km (below right). The coloured contours show the cloud mixing ratio (in g kg-1) and the line contours
represent vertical velocity with solid lines representing positive values and dashed lines, negative for every
2 m s-1 for (a)-(c) and 8 m s-1 for (d).
3. RESULTS
3.1. Effect of fire size on plume
Figure 2 shows a vertical cross-section through the centre of the domain for each size of fire each with the
strongest heat flux of 100 kW m-2, with neutral stability, after 40 minutes. It is evident from that the 150 m
radius fire (Fig. 2(a)) that, although it produces a small cloud, does not develop sufficiently to generate any
organisation. The 500 m fire begins to show a substantial core (Fig. 2(b)) and continues to develop organised
circulations, maintaining its structure for at least 2 and a half hours. The plume attains a height around 9 –
10 km not quite reaching the stratosphere at any time during the simulation. The 1 km and 4 km fires both
develop into pyroCbs, which are long-lived and attain plume tops of at least 13 km with strong vertical
motion within the convective core. The 4 km model is producing overly strong vertical velocity as the plume
top reaches a height of approximately 19 km (far into the stratosphere); this may be due to the 100 kW m-2
constant heat flux across the fire area, which is at the limit of heat fluxes that may be introduced to the
model. However, the different fire sizes illustrate the fact that larger fires are conducive to violent
pyroconvection.
3.2. Effect of fire intensity
The 1 km radius fire was then rerun with a constant heat across the fire area of 25 kW m-2 and 50 kW m-2.
Figure 3 shows the same vertical cross- sections previously. Comparing the 100 kW m-2 fire in Fig. 2(c) with
1093
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
Fig. 3, it is evident that for fires of this size, the fire intensity is influential on the strength of the convection,
with a higher intensity fire producing a deeper convective column and a higher cloud top. The 25 kW m-2 fire
produces a weak plume, but the convection only organises into deep convection with a 50 kW m-2 heat
source for a fire with 1 km radius. The 100 kW m-2 fire (Fig. 2(c)) develops the strongest pyroconvective
cloud and also generates more turbulence due to the increased vertical motion. However, for larger fires (~
4 km radius), it is likely that the intensity of the heat source is of less importance, due to the entrainment of
the cooler ambient air, which would not affect the plume to the same extent, with the pyrogenic heat
dominating the background atmospheric stability.
Figure 3. Vertical cross-section through the centre of the plume after 40 minutes, for a 1 km radius fire in a
neutral stability atmospheric environment, for 25 kW m-2 fire source (top) and 50 kW m-2 (below). The
coloured contours show the cloud mixing ratio (in g kg-1) and the line contours represent vertical velocity
with solid lines representing positive values and dashed lines, negative for every 2 m s-1 for (a)-(c) and
8 m s-1 for (d).
4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
Understanding the role that wildfire dynamics and the spatial expanse of a fire’s flaming zone have on the
development of towering pyrocumulus and/or pyrocumulonimbus has a number of important implications for
fire management. Better prediction of the burning characteristics of a fire, which may sometimes be
dominated by dynamic modes of fire propagation and a transition to deep flaming, combined with
information on the vertical atmosphere will assist fire managers to monitor fires in the landscape and better
assess their likelihood of developing into large firestorms.
The 2017 Sir Ivan fire near Dunedoo, NSW, is a case in point. This fire developed into a large pyroCb under
the influence of strong prefrontal winds and the enhanced atmospheric instability associated with a trough
line. The same broad scale meteorological features were experienced over a broad area, yet the White Cedar
fire, only approximately 50 km to the south east of the Sir Ivan fire, did not develop into a pyroCb. It is
hoped that the research presented above, and extensions thereof, can be used to develop an additional level of
‘fire triage’ that will enable fire agency personnel to better distinguish the likelihood of fires like Sir Ivan and
White Cedar developing into large pyroconvective events, or not.
Preliminary analyses of dry, static fires indicated that the areal expanse of the fire strongly influences the
development of the column of deep convection associated with violent pyroconvective events. This supports
the hypothesis that plumes above zones of deep flaming are less influenced by entrainment than plumes
emanating from typical linear fire fronts. The areal nature of the heat source driving convection has an
influence on the dynamics of the plume - in particular, the heights it can attain. The magnitude of the heat
1094
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
flux produced by the fire is also important for areas of deep flaming up to a minimum of 2 km diameter, but
as the size of the heat source increases beyond a 2 km diameter, this appears to be less influential on the way
the plume develops. These results also suggest that care should be taken when choosing a heat source for
idealised models, as the model can be sensitive to the magnitude of the heat flux and may not produce
realistic pyroconvection. The largest fire (4 km radius) also produces strong upward motion within the
column and this results in an overly high plume top. These simplified idealised simulations nevertheless, give
an insight into the relationship between the spatial expanse of a fire’s flaming region and the height of the
plume, and these insights will be informative to improving forecasting of blow up events.
Further work will extend this research by considering the contribution of pyrogenic moisture fluxes (fuel and
combustion moisture) in the development of violent pyroconvection. Further work will also seek to
understand the interaction between deep flaming and atmospheric stability by considering other idealized
atmospheric profiles (stable and unstable) and atmospheric profiles similar to those observed on days when
extreme fire development has taken place. We also note that the results presented here were derived from
circular heat sources, which is not the shape a wildfire usually assumes. As such, the effect of the shape of
the flaming zone on plume development will also be an interesting avenue of research to pursue.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This research was funded under the Australian Research Council’s Discovery Indigenous Scheme
(IN160100029), and undertaken with the assistance of resources provided by the NCI National Facility at the
Australian National University through the National Computational Merit Allocation Scheme supported by
the Australian Government. The authors are grateful to Philip Cunningham and Janice Coen for helpful
discussions.
REFERENCES
Clements, C. B., R. Perna, M. Jang, D. Lee, M. Patel, S. Street, S. Zhong, S. Goodrick, J. Li and B. E. Potter
(2007). Observing the dynamics of wildland grass fires: Fireflux—a field validation experiment. Bulletin
of the American Meteorological Society 88(9): 1369-1382.
Coen, J. L., M. Cameron, J. Michalakes, E. G. Patton, P. J. Riggan and K. M. Yedinak (2013). WRF-Fire:
coupled weather–wildland fire modeling with the weather research and forecasting model. Journal of
Applied Meteorology and Climatology 52(1): 16-38.
Cunningham, P. and M. J. Reeder (2009). Severe convective storms initiated by intense wildfires: Numerical
simulations of pyro-convection and pyro-tornadogenesis. Geophysical Research Letters 36(12): n/a-n/a.
Finney, M. A. and S. S. McAllister (2011). A Review of Fire Interactions and Mass Fires. Journal of
Combustion 2011.
Fromm, M., R. Bevilacqua, R. Servranckx, J. Rosen, J. P. Thayer, J. Herman and D. Larko (2005). Pyro-
cumulonimbus injection of smoke to the stratosphere: Observations and impact of a super blowup in
northwestern Canada on 3–4 August 1998. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 110(D8): 1-16.
Fromm, M., D. T. Lindsey, R. Servranckx, G. Yue, T. Trickl, R. Sica, P. Doucet and S. Godin-Beekmann
(2010). The Untold Story of Pyrocumulonimbus. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 91(9):
1193-1209.
Fromm, M., E. P. Shettle, K. H. Fricke, C. Ritter, T. Trickl, H. Giehl, M. Gerding, J. E. Barnes, M. O'Neill,
S. T. Massie, U. Blum, I. S. McDermid, T. Leblanc and T. Deshler (2008). Stratospheric impact of the
Chisholm pyrocumulonimbus eruption: 2. Vertical profile perspective. Journal of Geophysical Research:
Atmospheres 113(D8): 1-16.
Fromm, M., O. Torres, D. Diner, D. Lindsey, B. Vant Hull, R. Servranckx, E. P. Shettle and Z. Li (2008).
Stratospheric impact of the Chisholm pyrocumulonimbus eruption: 1. Earth-viewing satellite perspective.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 113(D8): 1-16.
Fromm, M., A. Tupper, D. Rosenfeld, R. Servranckx and R. McRae (2006). Violent pyro-convective storm
devastates Australia's capital and pollutes the stratosphere. Geophysical Research Letters 33(5): 1-5.
Hong, S.-Y. and J.-O. J. Lim (2006). The WRF single-moment 6-class microphysics scheme (WSM6).
Journal of the Korean Meteorological Society 42(2): 129-151.
1095
Badlan et al., The role of deep flaming in violent pyroconvection
Lindsey, D. T. and M. Fromm (2008). Evidence of the cloud lifetime effect from wildfire-induced
thunderstorms. Geophysical Research Letters 35(22): 1-5.
Luderer, G., J. Trentmann and M. O. Andreae (2009). A new look at the role of fire-released moisture on the
dynamics of atmospheric pyro-convection. International Journal of Wildland Fire 18(5): 554-562.
McRae, R., J. Sharples, S. Wilkes and A. Walker (2013). An Australian pyro-tornadogenesis event. Natural
Hazards 65(3): 1801-1811.
McRae, R. H. D., J. J. Sharples and M. Fromm (2015). Linking local wildfire dynamics to pyroCb
development. Natural Hazards & Earth System Sciences 15(3): 417-428.
Moeng, C., J. Dudhia, J. Klemp and P. Sullivan (2007). Examining two-way grid nesting for large eddy
simulation of the PBL using the WRF model. Monthly Weather Review 135(6): 2295-2311.
Potter, B. E. (2005). The role of released moisture in the atmospheric dynamics associated with wildland
fires. International Journal of Wildland Fire 14(1): 77-84.
Sharples, J. J., G. J. Cary, P. Fox-Hughes, S. Mooney, J. P. Evans, M.-S. Fletcher, M. Fromm, P. F. Grierson,
R. McRae and P. Baker (2016). Natural hazards in Australia: extreme bushfire. Climatic Change 139: 15.
Sharples, J. J., R. H. D. McRae and S. R. Wilkes (2012). Wind–terrain effects on the propagation of wildfires
in rugged terrain: fire channelling. International Journal of Wildland Fire 21(3): 282-296.
Simpson, C., J. Sharples and J. Evans (2014). Resolving vorticity-driven lateral fire spread using the WRF-
Fire coupled atmosphere–fire numerical model. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 14(9): 2359-
2371.
Simpson, C. C., J. J. Sharples, J. P. Evans and M. F. McCabe (2013). Large eddy simulation of atypical
wildland fire spread on leeward slopes. International Journal of Wildland Fire 22(5): 599-614.
Skamarock, W. C., J. B. Klemp, J. Dudhia, D. O. Gill, D. M. Barker, M. G. Duda, W. Wang and J. G. Powers
(2008). A description of the Advanced Research WRF version 3, Tech Note 475. NCAR.
Teague, B., R. McLeod and S. Pascoe (2010). Final report, 2009 Victorian bushfires Royal Commission.
Parliament of Victoria, Melbourne Victoria, Australia.
Thurston, W., K. J. Tory, R. J. Fawcett and J. D. Kepert (2015). Large-eddy simulations of pyro-convection
and its sensitivity to environmental conditions. Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC & AFAC Conference.
Adelaide 2015.
Thurston, W., K. J. Tory, R. J. Fawcett and J. D. Kepert (2016). The effects of turbulent plume dynamics on
long-range-spotting. AFAC16. Sydney, Bushire and Natural Hazards CRC, 2016.
1096
... The WRF idealized setup is similar those used in other studies of fire (Badlan et al., 2017(Badlan et al., , 2019Cunningham & Reeder, 2009). Cunningham and Reeder (2009) use WRF at the same horizontal resolution (200 m), with similar physics options (microphysics and turbulence closure), and a parameterized fire source to simulate a 2003 Australian wildfire and associated pyroconvection. ...
... These two comparisons to observed fires indicate that the setup of our fire model produces reasonable plume heights. Badlan et al. (2017) completed a sensitivity study to grid resolution using the WRF model with horizontal resolutions of 50, 100, and 150 m for similar fire simulations and noted little difference in the overall plume, therefore we do not investigate resolution in this work. Additional simulation results are presented in section 3examining the sensitivity of the plume height to wind speed, atmospheric moisture, and fuel loading. ...
... The heat and moisture fluxes and size and shape of the fire contribute to plume rise dynamics, as do the atmospheric stability, ambient wind speed and shear, and latent heat released from condensing water vapor (Paugam et al., 2016). Larger fire size and higher heat fluxes have been shown to increase plume height (Badlan et al., 2017;Freitas et al., 2007;Penner et al., 1986), as have areal fires (i.e., circles or squares) in comparison to linear fires covering the same area (Badlan et al., 2019) through reduced entrainment of ambient air into the convective core. Higher ambient wind speeds and shear can enhance entrainment and decrease plume height (Freitas et al., 2010). ...
Article
Full-text available
Recent studies examine the potential for large urban fires ignited in a hypothetical nuclear exchange of one hundred 15 kt weapons between India and Pakistan to alter the climate (e.g., Mills et al., 2014, https://doi.org/10.1002/2013EF000205, and Reisner et al., 2018, https://doi.org/10.1002/2017JD027331). In this study, the global climate forcing and response is predicted by combining two atmospheric models, which together span the micro‐scale to global scale processes involved. Individual fire plumes are modeled using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model, and the climate response is predicted by injecting the WRF‐simulated black carbon (BC) emissions into the Energy Exascale Earth System Model (E3SM) atmosphere model Version 1 (EAMv1). Consistent with previous studies, the radiative forcing depends on smoke quantity and injection height, examined here as functions of fuel loading and atmospheric conditions. If the fuel burned is 1 g cm⁻², BC is quickly removed from the troposphere, causing no global mean climate forcing. If the fuel burned is 16 g cm⁻² and 100 such fires occurred simultaneously with characteristics similar to historical large urban firestorms, BC reaches the stratosphere, reducing solar radiation and causing cooling at the Earth's surface. Uncertainties in smoke composition and aerosol representation cause large uncertainties in the magnitude of the radiative forcing and cooling. The approximately 4 yr duration of the radiative forcing is shorter than the 8 to 15 yr that has previously been simulated. Uncertainties point to the need for further development of potential nuclear exchange scenarios, quantification of fuel loading, and improved understanding of fire propagation and aerosol modeling.
... The pyroconvection grows with very strong winds which change directions and drive with lateral vorticity and vertical wind shear. Badlan et al. [14] performed an idealized numerical simulation to study the role of deep flaming in pyroconvection by using WRF-Fire version 3.9. They repeated the simulation with variations of fire intensities, spatial extensions and horizontal resolutions and three different atmospheric profiles to explore the dynamics of pyroconvection. ...
Article
Full-text available
The accurate prediction of wildfire behavior and spread is possible only when fire and atmosphere simulations are coupled. In this work, we present a mechanism that causes a small fire to intensify by altering the atmosphere. These alterations are caused by fire-related fluxes at the surface. The fire plume and fluxes increase the convective available potential energy (CAPE) and the chance of the development of a strong pyroconvection system. To study this possible mechanism, we used WRF-Fire to capture fire line propagation as the result of interactions between heat and moisture fluxes, pressure perturbations, wind shear development and dry air downdraft. The wind patterns and dynamics of the pyroconvection system are simulated for the Horse River wildfire at Fort McMurray, Canada. The results revealed that the updraft speed reached up to 12 m/s. The entrainment mixed the mid and upper-level dry air and lowered the atmospheric moisture. The mid-level and upper-level dew point temperature changed by 5-10 • C in a short period of time. The buoyant air strengthened the ascent as soon as the nocturnal inversion was eliminated by daytime heating. The 887 J/kg total increase of CAPE in less than 5 h and the high bulk Richardson number (BRN) of 93 were indicators of the growing pyro-cumulus cell. The presented simulation has not improved the original model or supported leading-edge numerical weather prediction (NWP) achievements, except for adapting WRF-Fire for Canadian biomass fuel. However, we were able to present a great deal of improvements in wildfire nowcasting and short-term forecasting to save lives and costs associated with wildfires. The simulation is sufficiently fast and efficient to be considered for a real-time operational model. While the project was designed and succeeded as an NWP application, we are still searching for a solution for the intractable problems associated with political borders and the current liable authorities for the further development of a new generation of national atmosphere-wildfire forecasting systems.
... Firestorms have strong inflowing winds so that they have little spread, extremely tall convection columns or smoke plumes, and burn for long durations until all the fuel within their perimeter is consumed (e.g., Glasstone & Dolan, 1977). Numerous studies of firestorms (e.g., Badlan et al., 2017;Cotton, 1985;Penner et al., 1986;Small et al., 1989;Small & Heikes, 1988) show smoke rising into the stratosphere from simulated firestorms, and explore the dependence of smoke altitude on fire intensity, atmospheric stability, moisture, fire size, wind speed, and other parameters. In a nuclear conflict over a large country involving a large number of weapons many of the fires would be expected to develop into firestorms. ...
Article
Full-text available
Reisner et al. revisited a study we had done modeling the climate impacts of a nuclear war between India and Pakistan, in which fires started by 100 15‐kt atomic bombs would produce 5 Tg of soot injected into the upper troposphere, and subsequently lofted into the lower stratosphere. Their claim that there would be much less smoke than in our results is wrong for several reasons. They chose a target area of suburban Atlanta that includes a golf course, playground, and individual houses with large yards, with little material to burn, which is not representative of densely populated cities in India and Pakistan. The fire they modeled is not typical of the type of mass fire likely to result from a nuclear attack on cities. They used winds that are stronger than typical winds. They did not allow moist convection, which would be important in convective lofting of the smoke. Their claim that if they included convection the resulting rain would wash out the smoke is not supported by observations of pyrocumulonimbus injection of smoke into the stratosphere from forest fires. And they used a fire model that they have not made available for other scientists to try to reproduce their work, and which has not been shown to accurately simulate firestorms observed in Hamburg, Dresden, and Hiroshima during World War II. They significantly underestimate the amount of smoke, and climate and agricultural impacts likely after a nuclear war.
Chapter
Wildland fires are among the most complicated environmental phenomena to model. Fire behavior models are commonly used to predict the direction and rate of spread of wildland fires based on fire history, fuel, and environmental conditions; however, more sophisticated computational fluid dynamic models are now being developed. This quantitative analysis of fire as a fluid dynamic phenomenon embedded in a highly turbulent flow is beginning to reveal the combined interactions of the vegetative structure, combustion-driven convective effects, and atmospheric boundary layer processes. This book provides an overview of the developments in modeling wildland fire dynamics and the key dynamical processes involved. Mathematical and dynamical principles are presented, and the complex phenomena that arise in wildland fire are discussed. Providing a state-of-the-art survey, it is a useful reference for scientists, researchers, and graduate students interested in wildland fire behavior from a broad range of fields.
Chapter
This chapter applies a justice framework to the complex of dilemmas between individual rights and the public good. It uses the case of the Wye River and Separation Creek Christmas Day 2015 bushfire in Victoria, Australia. Analysis of this event reveals the complex interactions of assumed, asserted and contested rights that play out before, during and after major destructive bushfire events, and their justice implications. The chapter suggests that there is a need to acknowledge and treat risks as complex manifestations of ongoing decisions over time; that existing emphases on individual property rights often erode the public good; that there is a need to set minimum standards in settlements; and that there is need to actively integrate individual and collective action to achieve risk justice.
Article
Full-text available
Fire channelling is a form of dynamic fire behaviour, during which a wildland fire spreads rapidly across a steep lee-facing slope in a direction transverse to the background winds, and is often accompanied by a downwind extension of the active flaming region and extreme pyro-convection. Recent work using the WRF-Fire coupled atmosphere-fire model has demonstrated that fire channelling can be characterised as vorticity-driven lateral fire spread (VDLS). In this study, 16 simulations are conducted using WRF-Fire to examine the sensitivity of resolving VDLS to spatial resolution and atmosphere-fire coupling within the WRF-Fire model framework. The horizontal grid spacing is varied between 25 and 90 m, and the two-way atmosphere-fire coupling is either enabled or disabled. At high spatial resolution, the atmosphere-fire coupling increases the peak uphill and lateral spread rate by a factor of up to 2.7 and 9.5. The enhancement of the uphill and lateral spread rate diminishes at coarser spatial resolution, and VDLS is not modelled for a horizontal grid spacing of 90 m. The laterally spreading fire fronts become the dominant contributors of the extreme pyro-convection. The resolved fire-induced vortices responsible for driving the lateral spread in the coupled simulations have non-zero vorticity along each unit vector direction, and develop due to an interaction between the background winds and vertical return circulations generated at the flank of the fire front as part of the pyro-convective updraft. The results presented in this study demonstrate that both high spatial resolution and two-way atmosphere-fire coupling are required to reproduce VDLS within the current WRF-Fire model framework.
Article
Full-text available
Extreme wildfires are global phenomena that consistently result in loss of life and property, and further impact the cultural, economic and political stability of communities. In their most extreme form they cause widespread devastation of environmental assets and are capable of impacting the upper troposphere–lower stratosphere through the formation of a thunderstorm within the plume. Such fires are now often observed by a range of remote sensing technologies, which together allow a greater understanding of a fire's complex dynamics. This paper considers one such fire that burnt in the Blue Mountains region of Australia in late-November 2006, that is known to have generated significant pyrocumulonimbus clouds in a series of blow-up events. Observations of this fire are analysed in detail to investigate the localised processes contributing to extreme fire development. In particular, it has been possible to demonstrate for the first time that the most severe instances of pyroconvection were driven by, and not just associated with, extreme local fire dynamics, especially the fire channelling phenomenon, which arises due to an interaction between an active fire, local terrain attributes and critical fire weather, and causes the fire to rapidly transition from a frontal to an areal burning pattern. The impacts of local variations in fire weather and of the atmospheric profile are also discussed, and the ability to predict extreme fire development with state-of-the-art tools is explored.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Intense heating by a bushfire causes air to ascend, which if deep enough can cause the formation of cumulus or cumulonimbus clouds. This moist pyro-convection can potentially have a significant impact on fire behaviour by amplifying burn and spread rates, enhancing spotting through plume intensification and igniting new fires via pyrocumulonimbus lightning. Here we use large-eddy simulations to investigate the generation of pyro-convection by bushfire plumes and the sensitivity of this pyro-convection to fire intensity and environmental moisture. Moister background atmospheres produce larger, more intense pyro-convective clouds and if the background atmosphere is moist enough, intense fires can produce pyro-convection even in the absence of any moisture from the combustion. Updrafts within the simulated pyro-convection are well in excess of the fall velocities of typical firebrands and exceed those in the cases where pyro-convection does not occur. The formation of precipitation within the most intense pyro-convective clouds leads to the development of downbursts that cause strong and highly variable winds at the surface. These strong updrafts and downbursts can have significant impacts on fire behaviour.
Article
Full-text available
The WRF-Fire coupled atmosphere-fire modelling system was used to investigate atypical wildland fire spread on steep leeward slopes through a series of idealised numerical simulations. The simulations are used to investigate both the leeward flow characteristics, such as flow separation, and the fire spread from an ignition region at the base of the leeward slope. The fire spread was considered under varying fuel type and with atmosphere-fire coupling both enabled and disabled. When atmosphere-fire coupling is enabled and there is a high fuel mass density, the fire spread closely resembles that expected during fire channelling. Specifically, the fire spread is initially dominated by upslope spread to the mountain ridge line at an average rate of 2.0 km h(-1), followed by predominantly lateral spread close to the ridge line at a maximum rate of 3.6 km h(-1). The intermittent rapid lateral spread occurs when updraft-downdraft interfaces, which are associated with strongly circulating horizontal winds at the mid-flame height, move across the fire perimeter close to the ridge line. The updraft-downdraft interfaces are formed due to an interaction between the strong pyro-convection and the terrain-modified winds. Through these results, a new physical explanation of fire channelling is proposed.
Article
Full-text available
The interaction of wind, terrain and a fire burning in a landscape can produce a variety of unusual yet significant effects on fire propagation. One such example, in which a fire exhibits rapid spread in a direction transverse to the synoptic winds as well as in the usual downwind direction, is considered in this paper. This type of fire spread, which is referred to as ‘fire channelling’, is characterised by intense lateral and downwind spotting and production of extensive flaming zones. The dependence of fire channelling on wind and terrain is analysed using wind, terrain and multispectral fire data collected during the January 2003 Alpine fires over south-eastern Australia. As part of the analysis, a simple terrain-filter model is utilised to confirm a quantitative link between instances of fire channelling and parts of the terrain that are sufficiently steep and lee-facing. By appealing to the theory of wind–terrain interaction and the available evidence, several processes that could produce the atypical fire spread are considered and some discounted. Based on the processes that could not be discounted, and a previous analysis of wind regimes in rugged terrain, a likely explanation for the fire channelling phenomenon is hypothesised. Implications of fire channelling for bushfire risk management are also discussed.
Article
Full-text available
The character of a wildland fire can change dramatically in the presence of another nearby fire. Understanding and predicting the changes in behavior due to fire-fire interactions cannot only be life-saving to those on the ground, but also be used to better control a prescribed fire to meet objectives. In discontinuous fuel types, such interactions may elicit fire spread where none otherwise existed. Fire-fire interactions occur naturally when spot fires start ahead of the main fire and when separate fire events converge in one location. Interactions can be created intentionally during prescribed fires by using spatial ignition patterns. Mass fires are among the most extreme examples of interactive behavior. This paper presents a review of the detailed effects of fire-fire interaction in terms of merging or coalescence criteria, burning rates, flame dimensions, flame temperature, indraft velocity, pulsation, and convection column dynamics. Though relevant in many situations, these changes in fire behavior have yet to be included in any operational-fire models or decision support systems.
Article
Spotting can start fires up to tens of kilometres ahead of the primary fire front, causing rapid spread and placing immense pressure on suppression resources. Here, we investigate the dynamics of the buoyant plume generated by the fire and its ability to transport firebrands. We couple large-eddy simulations of bushfire plumes with a firebrand transport model to assess the effects of turbulent plume dynamics on firebrand trajectories. We show that plume dynamics have a marked effect on the maximum spotting distance and determine the amount of lateral and longitudinal spread in firebrand landing position. In-plume turbulence causes much of this spread and can increase the maximum spotting distance by a factor of more than 2 over that in a plume without turbulence in our experiments. The substantial impact of plume dynamics on the spotting process implies that fire spread models should include parametrisations of turbulent plume dynamics to improve their accuracy and physical realism.
Article
On 18 January 2003, fires had a devastating impact on Australia’s capital, Canberra. A series of reviews and scientific studies have examined the events of that day and indicate that the worst impacts were due to a series of violent pyro-convective events and resultant pyro-cumulonmibi. These coupled fire–atmosphere events are much more energetic than normal fires. In one instance, an intense pyro-convective cell developed a tornado. We demonstrate that this was indeed a tornado, the first confirmed pyro-tornadogenesis in Australia, and not a fire whirl. Here, we discuss aspects of the formation, evolution and decay of the tornado, which was estimated to have been of at least F2 intensity, highlighting a process that can significantly increase the damage of a wildfire event.