ArticlePDF Available

Amazon Tipping Point

DOI:10.1126/sciadv.aat2340
Authors:
Thomas Lovejoy at George Mason University
Thomas Lovejoy
Carlos A. Nobre
Carlos A. Nobre
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation
Available via license: CC BY-NC 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
Lovejoy and Nobre, Sci. Adv. 2018; 4 : eaat2340 21 February 2018
SCIENCE ADVANCES | EDITORIAL
1 of 1
Copyright © 2018
The Authors, some
rights reserved;
exclusive licensee
American Association
for the Advancement
of Science. No claim to
original U.S.
Government
Works. Distributed
under a Creative
Commons Attribution
NonCommercial
License 4.0 (CC BY-NC).
Amazon Tipping Point
In the 1970s, Brazilian scientist Eneas Salati shattered
the long held dogma that vegetation is simply the
consequence of climate and has no influence on cli-
mate whatsoever (1). Using isotopic ratios of oxygen
in rainwater samples collected from the Atlantic to
the Peruvian border, he was able to demonstrate un-
equivocally that the Amazon generates approximately
half of its own rainfall by recycling moisture 5 to 6 times
as airmasses move from the Atlantic across the basin to
the west.
From the start, the demonstration of the hydrological
cycle of the Amazon raised the question of how much
deforestation would be required to cause the cycle to de-
grade to the point of being unable to support rain forest
ecosystems.
High levels of evaporation and transpiration that forests
produce throughout the year contribute to a wetter at-
mospheric boundary layer than would be the case with
non-forest.This surface-atmosphere coupling is more im-
portant where large-scale factors for rainfall formation
are weaker, such as in central and eastern Amazonia. Near
the Andes, the impact of at least modest deforestation is
less dramatic because the general ascending motion of
airmasses in this area induces high levels of rainfall in
addition to that expected from local evaporation and
transpiration.
Where might the tipping point be for deforestation-
generated degradation of the hydrological cycle? The
very first model to examine this question (2) showed that
at about 40% deforestation, central, southern and eastern
Amazonia would experience diminished rainfall and a
lengthier dry season, predicting a shift to savanna vegeta-
tion to the east.
Moisture from the Amazon is important to rainfall and
human wellbeing because it contributes to winter rainfall
for parts of the La Plata basin, especially southern Paraguay,
southern Brazil, Uruguay and central-eastern Argentina;
in other regions, the moisture passes over the area, but does
not precipitate out. Although the amount contributing
to rainfall in southeastern Brazil is smaller than in other
areas, even small amounts can be a welcome addition to
urban reservoirs.
The importance of Amazon moisture for Brazilian ag-
riculture south of the Amazon is complex but not trivial.
Perhaps most important is the partial contribution of dry
season Amazon evapotranspiration to rainfall in south-
eastern South America. Forests maintain an evapotranspira-
tion rate year-round, whereas evapotranspiration in pastures
is dramatically lower in the dry season. As a consequence,
models suggest a longer dry season after deforestation.
In recent decades, new forcing factors have impinged
on the hydrological cycle: climate change and widespread
use of fire to eliminate felled trees and clear weedy veg-
etation. Many studies show that in the absence of other
contributing factors, 4 degrees Celsius of global warming
would be the tipping point to degraded savannas in most
of the central, southern, and eastern Amazon. Widespread
use of fire leads to drying of surrounding forest and greater
vulnerability to fire in the subsequent year.
We believe that negative synergies between deforesta-
tion, climate change, and widespread use of fire indicate
a tipping point for the Amazon system to flip to non-
forest ecosystems in eastern, southern and central Amazonia
at 20-25% deforestation.
The severity of the droughts of 2005, 2010 and 2015-16
could well represent the first flickers of this ecological
tipping point. These events, together with the severe floods
of 2009, 2012 (and 2014 over SW Amazonia), suggest that
the whole system is oscillating. For the last two decades
the dry season over the southern and eastern Amazon
has been increasing. Large scale factors such as warmer
sea surface temperatures over the tropical North Atlantic
also seem to be associated with the changes on land.
We believe that the sensible course is not only to strictly
curb further deforestation, but also to build back a margin
of safety against the Amazon tipping point, by reducing
the deforested area to less than 20%, for the commonsense
reason that there is no point in discovering the precise
tipping point by tipping it. At the 2015 Paris Conference
of the Parties, Brazil committed to 12 million ha of re-
forestation by 2030. Much or most of this reforestation
should be in southern and eastern Amazonia. The hydro-
logical cycle of the Amazon is fundamental to human well-
being in Brazil and adjacent South America.
– Thomas E. Lovejoy and Carlos Nobre
REFERENCES
1. E. Salati, A. Dall ‘Ollio, E. Matsui, J. R. Gat, Recycling of Water in the Amazon,
Brazil: an isotopic study. Water Resour. Res. 15, 1250–1258 (1979).
2. G. Sampaio,C. A. Nobre, M. H. Costa, P. Satyamurty, B. S. Soares-Filho,
M. Cardoso, Regional climate change over eastern Amazonia caused by pasture
and soybean cropland expansion. Geophys. Res. Lett. 34, L17709 (2007).
10.1126/sciadv.aat2340
Citation: T. E. Lovejoy, C. Nobre, Amazon Tipping Point. Sci. Adv. 4, eaat2340 (2018).
Thomas E. Lovejoy is
University Professor
in the Department of
Environmental Science
and Policy at George
Mason University. Email:
tlovejoy@unfoundation.org
Carlos Nobre is a Member
of the Brazilian Academy
of Sciences and Senior
Fellow of World Resources
Institute Brazil.
on February 22, 2018http://advances.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from
Amazon Tipping Point
Thomas E. Lovejoy and Carlos Nobre
DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aat2340
(2), eaat2340.4Sci Adv
ARTICLE TOOLS http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/4/2/eaat2340
REFERENCES http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/4/2/eaat2340#BIBL
This article cites 2 articles, 0 of which you can access for free
PERMISSIONS http://www.sciencemag.org/help/reprints-and-permissions
Terms of ServiceUse of this article is subject to the
registered trademark of AAAS. is aScience Advances Association for the Advancement of Science. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. The title
York Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20005. 2017 © The Authors, some rights reserved; exclusive licensee American
(ISSN 2375-2548) is published by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1200 NewScience Advances
on February 22, 2018http://advances.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from
... This imagined story draws on news reports regarding the 2017-18 drought (e.g., AP 2018) and Lovejoy and Nobre (2018). ...
... Just a few years ago, it was thought that this tipping point would be reached at a deforestation level of 40 percent of the Amazon Rainforest. n However, in light of the "negative synergies between deforestation, climate change, and widespread use of fire," scientists warn that the tipping point is likely closer to the loss of 20-25 percent of total forest area (Lovejoy and Nobre 2018). o The region has already been 18 percent deforested, p and 2021 saw the highest annual rate of deforestation in a decade in the Brazilian Amazon. ...
Not Just Carbon: Capturing All the Benefits of Forests for Stabilizing the Climate from Local to Global Scales
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2022
This report summarizes the science on the biophysical effects of deforestation on climate stability and explores the policy implications of the resulting impacts at three scales: global climate policy, regional cooperation on precipitation management, and national policies related to agriculture and public health. For each of these policy arenas, there are promising entry points to address current gaps through innovations in policies and institutions.
... ureia). Além disso, a mudança no uso da terra causada pela conversão de florestas em agricultura ou pecuária afeta as propriedades físicas e biológicas da superfície terrestre, com impacto potencial no clima regional e global (Lovejoy;Nobre, 2018). ...
... ureia). Além disso, a mudança no uso da terra causada pela conversão de florestas em agricultura ou pecuária afeta as propriedades físicas e biológicas da superfície terrestre, com impacto potencial no clima regional e global (Lovejoy;Nobre, 2018). ...
Mudança do clima e a agropecuária brasileira Noções, mitigação e adaptação
Technical Report
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
O documento busca contribuir para o entendimento de tópicos relacionados à mudança climática e à agricultura para nivelar os diversos públicos nas discussões sobre o tema. Trata-se de ampla revisão bibliográfica, visando oferecer informações essenciais corroboradas por publicações científicas relacionadas à produção agropecuária predominante nos biomas Cerrado e Mata Atlântica. Justifica-se a publicação apoiando-se em três argumentos: a) há vasta literatura contendo estudos aprofundados sobre mudança do clima, segurança alimentar, manejo sustentável, fluxos de gases de efeito estufa nos ecossistemas terrestres e políticas públicas para agricultura de baixa emissão de carbono, mas destinada a especialistas; b) apesar da agricultura ser altamente vulnerável à mudança do clima, com alta relevância para a riqueza de muitos países em desenvolvimento, relata que o setor de agropecuária demorou anos para ser inserido na agenda de negociações da política ambiental global e; c) há um desconhecimento básico das expressões relacionadas à interação da mudança do clima com a agricultura. Ao final, espera-se que o leitor tenha uma clara compreensão de que o setor de agropecuária, além de contribuir de maneira sustentável para a segurança alimentar, pode ter papel de destaque na mitigação e adaptação à mudança do clima.
... The tipping point percentage has trended down over time due to the anticipated impacts of increasing thermal stress and reduced resilience (Boulton, Lenton, and Boers 2021;IPCC 2014;Lenton et al. 2008). A recent estimate puts it as low as 20 percent, worrisome given 16 percent of the Amazonian forest has already given way to fields and pastures, or 20 percent of Brazil's portion (Lovejoy and Nobre 2018;Walker et al. 2019). Recent analyses suggest that regional climate changes already underway will independently trigger extensive forest loss just past mid-century (Walker 2020). ...
Tapajós
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
“Tapajós” narrates the field campaign of two researchers studying forest fragmentation in the Brazilian Amazon. It addresses a contemporary conflict in the region, where an Indigenous people, the Munduruku, are resisting efforts by the Brazilian State to channelize the Tapajós River and exploit its hydropower potential. Development here represents an existential threat to the Munduruku, whose homeland resides in the river valley. It also represents an ecological threat to the global community. Although the rate of deforestation dropped after the turn of the millennium, it has begun to climb again and would no doubt accelerate with development in the Tapajós watershed and the opening of Central Amazonia to colonization and resource extraction. This would push the forest past its tipping point, a magnitude of deforestation capable of compromising rainfall recycling, and thus precipitating the transformation of the Amazonian forest into a patchwork of fireadapted shrubs and grasses. “Tapajós” describes how such an ecological catastrophe would occur. It also argues that the assertion of Indigenous territorial rights is key to the conservation of Amazonian biodiversity. The account unfolds against a background of conflict between Amazonia’s Indigenous peoples and the Brazilian State. In so doing, it brings to life the realities of frontier violence involving both land conflict and the unrestrained behaviors of individuals living outside the institutional constraints of law. Such violence complicates the execution of field research in the region and contributes to its gathering ecological crisis.
... If they are reduced sufficiently, remaining forests may become drier and more prone to fire and disease. In the Amazon, this process is expected to become irreversible once 20-40 percent of its forests have been cleared [136][137][138]. The lower end of this threshold range has already been crossed, and deforestation is accelerating [139]. ...
Implications of Earth system tipping pathways for climate change mitigation investment
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
Complex Earth systems under stress from global heating can resist change for only so long before tipping into transitional chaos. Convergent trajectories of change in Arctic, Amazon and other systems suggest a biosphere tipping point (BTP) in this mid-century. The BTP must be prevented and therefore offers a hard deadline against which to plan, implement, monitor, adjust and accelerate climate change mitigation efforts. These should be judged by their performance against this deadline, requiring mitigation investments to be compared and selected according to the unit cost of their dated mitigation value (tCO2edmv) outcomes. This unit of strategic effectiveness is created by exponentially discounting annual GHG savings in tCO2e against a dated BTP. Three proof of concept cases are described using a BTP in 2050 and a 10% discount rate, highlighting three key ways to prevent the BTP. The most reliably cost-effective for mitigation, and richest in environmental co-benefits, involves protecting high carbon-density natural ecosystems. Restored and regenerating natural ecosystems also yield abundant environmental co-benefits but slower mitigation gains. Improving choice awareness and building capacity to promote decarbonisation in all economic sectors is cost-effective and essential to meeting national net zero emission goals. Public mitigation portfolios should emphasise these three strategic elements, while private ones continue to focus on renewable energy and linked opportunities. Further research should prioritise: (1) consequences of an Arctic Ocean imminently free of summer sea ice; (2) testing the tCO2edmv metric with various assumptions in multiple contexts; and (3) integrating diverse co-benefit values into mitigation investment decisions.
... Negative synergies between deforestation, widespread use of fire, and climate change suggest that Amazonia is heading toward irreversible ecosystem change (Lovejoy and Nobre, 2018;Boulton et al., 2022). Amazonia is losing globally important ecosystem services (Levis et al., 2020), directly affecting human communities that depend on forest resources. ...
Local forest specialists maintain traditional ecological knowledge in the face of environmental threats to Brazilian Amazonian protected areas
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2022
There is a concern that environmental threats that result in local biodiversity loss compromise traditional peoples’ livelihoods and their traditional ecological knowledge (TEK). Nonetheless, studies usually only analyze how people’s characteristics influence TEK. Here, we investigated both: how the personal characteristics of local specialists (forest experience, gender, and origin) and environmental threats (deforestation, mining, and fires) influence some components of TEK associated with forests. From 2015 to 2019, we conducted free-listing interviews with 208 specialists from 27 communities in and near 10 protected areas (PAs) in Brazilian Amazonia. We recorded forest trees and palms that the specialists mentioned as used, managed, and traded. Plant knowledge was variable, since 44% of the 795 ethnospecies were mentioned only once. Using Mixed-Effects Models, we identified that people with longer forest experience and men tended to cite more used and traded ethnospecies. Women knew more about human food, while men knew more about construction and animal food. Specialists with greater forest experience knew more about protective management and planting. Specialists living in communities influenced by mining cited fewer used ethnospecies, and those in more deforested communities cited proportionally more planting. Environmental threats had smaller effects on TEK than personal characteristics. The components of TEK that we assessed highlight the forest’s great utility and the importance of management of PAs to maintain biodiversity and traditional people’s livelihoods. The communities’ stocks of TEK persisted in the face of environmental threats to PAs, highlighting the resistance of traditional peoples in the face of adversities. This quantitative approach did not show the trends that are generally imagined, i.e., loss of forest TEK, but demonstrates that if we want to change the Amazonian development model to keep the forest standing, knowledge exists and resists.
... Deforestation can accentuate the environmental temperature increase in the Amazon. According to Lovejoy and Nobre (2018), when the level of deforestation reaches between 20% and 40% (17% is the current level) forest systems will be able to recover (tipping point) which will cause a significant increase in the biome temperature and therefore drive many organisms to the limit of their thermal tolerance. And of course, the current high rates of deforestation ( Jaff e et al., 2021) cause a loss of carbon sinking capacity which results in a vicious circle making the whole system even hotter. ...
Environmental stressors in Amazonian riverine systems
Chapter
The Amazon has a rich history of tectonic and climatic effects that have given rise to vast, complex and dynamic interconnected landscapes. The dynamics of the system can be observed today by the oscillation of river water levels, variations in oxygen levels, pH and temperature, and the biological diversity that exists in the different systems throughout the year. This continuous environmental diversity has contributed to the emergence of a rich ichthyofauna that has developed a vast set of adaptations at all levels of biological organization to cope with the continuous environmental challenges of the biome. However, the environmental structure that was formed over some 65 million years, i.e., since the beginning of the Andes uplift, is today confronted with many challenges of a, shall we say, new era—the Anthropocene. These challenges include metal pollution, urban pollution, pesticides, oil, hydroelectric construction, and, most importantly, the effects of climate change. Many of the evolutionary adaptations incorporated by fish are not sufficient to neutralize the effects of these new challenges, many of which have synergistic effects with each other or with the natural challenges that occur in the Amazon (hypoxia, low pH, low ionic availability, naturally warmer waters). Thus, it is important that we can anticipate the responses of Amazonian fishes to the challenges imposed by their environments in order to better manage the Amazon rainforest.
... The thresholds that could lead the BGI to its tipping point are not known (REYER et al., 2015). For the Amazon, for example, Lovejoy and Nobre (2018) affirm that 20 to 25% of deforestation would destabilize the Biome. All of Piauí's municipalities already have a higher rate than 25% of other land covers besides the BGI, which should be a point of concern for the territorial and environmental planning of the state. ...
BLUE-GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE DISTRIBUTION IN PIAUÍ, BRAZIL
Article
  • Oct 2022
Effects of Amazonian flying rivers on frog biodiversity and populations in the Atlantic Rainforest
Article
  • Nov 2022
Our planet faces its sixth largest species extinction due to anthropogenic climate change and habitat destruction. This leads us to question whether, given the speed at which we are changing the climate, species with high degrees of endemism would have time to adapt before going extinct. Here, we investigate through teleconnection analysis the origin of rainfall that determines the phylogenetic diversity of rainforest frogs and the effects of microclimate differences in shaping the morphological traits of isolated populations (which contribute to greater phylogenetic diversity and speciation). We also investigate through teleconnection analysis how deforestation in Amazonia can affect ecosystem services that are fundamental to maintaining the climate of the Atlantic Rainforest biodiversity hotspot. Seasonal winds known as “flying rivers” carry water vapor from Amazonia to the Atlantic Forest, and the breaking of this ecosystem service could lead Atlantic Forest species to population decline and extinction in the short term. Our results suggest that the selection of morphological traits that shape Atlantic Forest frog diversity and their population dynamics are influenced by the Amazonian flying rivers. Our results also suggest that the increases of temperature anomalies in the Atlantic Ocean due to global warming and in the Amazon Forest due to deforestation are already breaking this cycle and threaten the biodiversity of the Atlantic Forest hotspot. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
Climate change: food safety challenges in the near future
Chapter
  • Jan 2023
Exponential increases in various human activities in the Anthropocene era are indicated to have led to rapid alteration in the environment such as climate change and ecosystem impairment. Scientists are seriously discussing the planetary health and threshold for climate stabilization and for safe human life. Food system including agriculture is one of major drivers to climate change, and at the same time, climate change has significant impacts on human health through food system. This chapter discusses various impacts of climate change as most pressing food safety challenges at present and in the near future. Temperature rise is increasing chance of people to be exposed to foodborne hazards, and multiple pathways are demonstrated to mediate climate change and increasing adverse health impact through food safety. Evidence-based food safety risk management is necessary, and inter- and trans-disciplinary researches with cross-sectorial collaboration should be promoted to address these challenges.
Capítulo 25: Una Visión del Desarrollo Sostenible Panamazónico
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jun 2022
This Report provides a comprehensive, objective, open, transparent, systematic, and rigorous scientific assessment of the state of the Amazon’s ecosystems, current trends, and their implications for the long-term well-being of the region, as well as opportunities and policy relevant options for conservation and sustainable development.
Regional climate change over eastern Amazonia caused by pasture and soybean cropland expansion
Article
Full-text available
Received 7 May 2007; revised 7 August 2007; accepted 9 August 2007; published 13 September 2007. (1) Field observations and numerical studies revealed that large scale deforestation in Amazonia could alter the regional climate significantly, projecting a warmer and somewhat drier post-deforestation climate. In this study we employed the CPTEC-INPE AGCM to assess the effects of Amazonian deforestation on the regional climate, using simulated land cover maps from a business-as-usual scenario of future deforestation in which the rainforest was gradually replaced by degraded pasture or by soybean cropland. The results for eastern Amazonia, where changes in land cover are expected to be larger, show increase in near-surface air temperature, and decrease in evapotranspiration and precipitation, which occurs mainly during the dry season. The relationship between precipitation and deforestation shows an accelerating decrease of rainfall for increasing deforestation for both classes of land use conversions. Continued expansion of cropland in Amazonia is possible and may have important consequences for the sustainability of the region's remaining natural vegetation. Citation: Sampaio, G., C. Nobre, M. H. Costa, P. Satyamurty, B. S. Soares-Filho, and M. Cardoso (2007), Regional climate change over eastern Amazonia caused by pasture and soybean cropland expansion, Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, L17709,
Recycling of water in the Amazon Basin: an isotopic study
Article
  • Jan 1978
  • Jan 2018
  • 2340
  • T E Lovejoy
  • C Nobre
Citation: T. E. Lovejoy, C. Nobre, Amazon Tipping Point. Sci. Adv. 4, eaat2340 (2018).
Recycling of Water in the Amazon, Brazil: an isotopic study
  • Jan 1979
  • 1250
  • E Salati
  • A Ollio
  • E Matsui
  • J R Gat
  • Salati E.