PresentationPDF Available

WYSIWYG - Also for Big Data?

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The documents gathered here had been compiled in preparation of a presentation at the Max Planck Institute for Social Law and Social Policy, February 21st, 2018. While occasionally reference had been to documents reproduced here, most of the documents should be understood as background-information. Abstract of the presentation: WYSIWYG, the supposed revolutionary concept that once opened a new world for computer quarter-literates is not necessarily applicable if we look at the supposed recent revolution: Big Data. More likely we find the emergence of a WYSID – What You See Is Delusion. The presentation aims on contributing from the perspective of political economy to an understanding of some systemic developments that are hidden behind a blurred understanding of Big Data and Digitisation.
No caption available
… 
No caption available
… 
No caption available
… 
No caption available
… 
No caption available
… 
Content may be subject to copyright.
Peter Herrmann
WYSIWYG1'–'Also'for'Big'Data?'
!
!
!"#$%&'()#*+,$-.+"#/#%$"#/#$".%$0##*$'&)123#%$2*$1/#1./.+2&*$&4$.$1/#,#*+.+2&*$
.+$+"#$5.6$73.*'8$9*,+2+(+#$4&/$:&'2.3$;.<$.*%$:&'2.3$7&32'=>$?#0/(./=$@A,+>$@BACD$
E"23#$&''.,2&*.33=$/#4#/#*'#$".%$0##*$+&$%&'()#*+,$/#1/&%('#%$"#/#>$)&,+$&4$+"#$
%&'()#*+,$,"&(3%$0#$(*%#/,+&&%$.,$0.'8-/&(*%F2*4&/).+2&*D$
Abstract of the presentation:
"#$%"#&'!()*!+,--.+*/!0*1.2,(3.4506!7.47*-(!()5(!.47*!.-*4*/!5!4*8!8.02/!
9.0!7.:-,(*0!;,50(*0<23(*05(*+!3+!4.(!4*7*++50326!5--2375=2*!39!8*!2..>!5(!()*!
+,--.+*/!0*7*4(!0*1.2,(3.4?!@3A!B5(5C!D.0*!23>*26!8*!934/!()*!*:*0A*47*!.9!5!
"#$%B!E!")5(!#.,!$**!%+!B*2,+3.4C!
F)*!-0*+*4(5(3.4!53:+!.4!7.4(03=,(34A!90.:!()*!-*0+-*7(31*!.9!-.23(3752!*7.4.:6!
(.!54!,4/*0+(54/34A!.9!+.:*!+6+(*:37!/*1*2.-:*4(+!()5(!50*!)3//*4!=*)34/!5!
=2,00*/!,4/*0+(54/34A!.9!@3A!B5(5!54/!B3A3(3+5(3.4C!F)*!9.22.834A!3+!A,3/34A!()*!
/*1*2.-:*4(!.9!()*!50A,:*4(?!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
G!! ")5(!6.,!+**!3+!8)5(!6.,!A*(!
!
H!
%C D.134A!90.:!I/1*4(,0*+!34!".4/*0254/!(.!+**34A!()*!".02/!F)0.,A)!
()*!J..>34A<&25++!E!$.:*!F*0:34.2.A3752!K*:50>+!!
%%C L0.:!&.2/!$(54/50/!(.!$-50>234A!B35:.4/+!E!F)*!M7.4.:6!.9!()*!
B3A3(52!54/!%49.0:5(3.452!K*1.2,(3.4!
%%%C F)*!J.4*26!N0.8/!1*0+,+!N0.8/*/!J.4*234*++!E!I=.,(!%4/313/,52'!
$.7352'!O,=237!54/!O0315(*!D5((*0+!
%PC JQR(5(!7Q*+(!:.3!E!2ST(5('!7S*+(<U</30*!4.,+V!E!$.73.<M7.<J*A52!%++,*+!
50.,4/!O,=237!54/!$.7352!K*+-.4+3=323(6!
!
!
W!
!
I.'ALL'NEW?! 5!
Logarithms' 5!
The'Ultimate'Solution:'42' 6!
Leibniz’'Binary'Code'Calculating'Machine' 9!
Hobbes’'Robot'10!
Hobbes''Computable'Rationality'10!
II.'POLITICAL'ECONOMY'AND'ECONOMICS!11!
Revolutions' 11!
Technology''Subsidiary'Industries'12!
Property''Appropriateneasss'and'Appropriation'13!
Demand'and'Supply'Effects'16!
Theory'of'Regulation'17!
Economy'and'Society'18!
système'anthroponymique'19!
Standard'Parameters'in'Economics''Presumptions,'Functions'and'Requirements'20!
%C!O0*+,:-(3.4+!HX!
%%C!"*2950*!9,47(3.4?!HX!
%%%C!O0./,7(3.4!L,47(3.4!HG!
%PC!.--.0(,43(6!7.+(!HG!
PC!O0./,7(3.4!O.++3=323(6!L0.4(3*0!E!M99373*476!K*;,30*:*4(!HH!
Exchange'of'Equivalents''Individual'and'Societal'Work'23!
Theory'of'value'24!
Accumulation'25!
Investment'and'Capital'26!
Self_Alienation'of'Capitalism'27!
Money'versus'Capital'28!
Money'or'Finance?'29!
III.'‘CONCENTRALISATION’'–'ECONOMIC'SOCIO_LEGAL'ISSUES!30!
Worlds'of'Capitalist'Welfare'Systems'30!
Challenges'Then'and'Now'31!
!
Y!
@*1*03/A*Z[*64*+354!E!F)*!931*!:5\.0!/3+*5+*+!WG!
]N,=54!L31*Q! WG!
The'Distributive'Era'32!
UBER'criticism'33!
Modularised'labour'law'–'Modularisierung'des'Arbeitsrechts'34!
[Re_]Defining'entrepreneurial'reference'frameworks'35!
Data''Privacy'–'volonté'générale''volonté'de'tous'36!
^P.2>+_`)2,4A+,0(*32Q!Wa!
Neue'Freiheit?' 38!
New'Freedom?'40!
Licensed'Openness'42!
IV.'ANNEX!43!
Some'general'contemporary'socio_economic'processes'43!
Tulip'Mania'45!
Sixty'Seconds'Online'46!
@*1*03/A*Z[*64*+354!E!F)*!931*!:5\.0!/3+*5+*+!bY!
B%$FK%@cF%de!bY!
]N,=54!L31*Q!bY!
OKdBcNF%de!bY!
Modularised'labour'law'–'Modularisierung'des'Arbeitsrechts'_'32'61!
Tulip'Mania'63!
!
!
!
b!
I.'All'New?'
Logarithms'
N.4+*;,*4(26'!()*+*!258+!.9!45(,0*!4**/!.426!=*!/3+7.1*0*/'!54/!()*4!:54!8322!
4.!2.4A*0!=*!54+8*05=2*!9.0!)3+!57(3.4+'!54/!)3+!239*!8322!=*7.:*!*f(0*:*26!*5+6C!
e**/2*++!(.!+56'!522!),:54!57(3.4+!8322!()*4!=*!7527,25(*/!577.0/34A!(.!()*+*!
258+'!:5()*:5(375226'!23>*!5!(5=2*!.9!2.A503():+'!,-!(.!GXg'XXX'!54/!*4(*0*/!34(.!5!
752*4/50h!.0'!=*((*0!+(322'!+.:*!8*22<:*5434A!-,=2375(3.4+!8322!5--*50'!23>*!()*!
-0*+*4(</56!*47672.-5*/37!/37(3.4503*+'!34!8)37)!*1*06()34A!8322!=*!+.!-0*73+*26!
7527,25(*/!54/!/*+3A45(*/!()5(!()*0*!8322!4.!2.4A*0!=*!546!57(3.4+!.0!5/1*4(,0*+!
34!()*!8.02/C!!
GH&,+&#I,8=>$?=&%&/>$ACJKL$M&+#,$4/&)$N*%#/-/&(*%O$PI#/=).*Q,$;20/./=L$@RS$
!
!
E#33>$+"#$*#<$4&/)$,##),$+&$0#$+"#$#6+#*,2&*>$/#43#'+2*-$.$,'#*./2&$<"#/#$.33$.*%$
#I#/=+"2*-$2,$.0&(+$3&-./2+"),D$
!
!
a!
'
The'Ultimate'Solution:'42'
id!B**-!F).,A)(!N.:-,(*0'j!)*!+53/'!i()*!(5+>!8*!)51*!/*+3A4*/!6.,!(.!-*09.0:!
3+!()3+C!"*!854(!6.,!(.!(*22!,+CCCj!)*!-5,+*/'!iCCC!()*!I4+8*0kj!
iF)*!54+8*0Vj!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!iF)*!54+8*0!(.!8)5(Vj!iJ39*kj!,0A*/!L..>C!
iF)*!c431*0+*kj!+53/!J,4>8322C!
iM1*06()34Akj!()*6!+53/!34!7).0,+C!
B**-!F).,A)(!-5,+*/!9.0!5!:.:*4(Q+!0*92*7(3.4C!iF037>6'j!)*!+53/!9345226C!
i@,(!754!6.,!/.!3(Vj!
IA534'!5!+3A4393754(!-5,+*C!
i#*+'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)('!i%!754!/.!3(Cj!
iF)*0*!3+!54!54+8*0Vj!+53/!L..>!83()!=0*5()2*++!*f73(*:*4(Cj!
iI!+3:-2*!54+8*0Vj!5//*/!J,4>8322C!
i#*+'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!iJ39*'!()*!c431*0+*'!54/!M1*06()34AC!F)*0*!3+!54!54+8*0C!
@,('j!)*!5//*/'!i%Q22!)51*!(.!()34>!5=.,(!3(Cj!
llll!
F)*0*!85+!5!:.:*4(Q+!*f-*7(54(!-5,+*!8)32+(!-54*2+!+2.826!75:*!(.!239*!.4!()*!
90.4(!.9!()*!7.4+.2*C!J3A)(+!925+)*/!.4!54/!.99!*f-*03:*4(5226!54/!+*((2*/!/.84!
34(.!5!=,+34*++23>*!-5((*04C!I!+.9(!2.8!),:!75:*!90.:!()*!7.::,4375(3.4!
7)544*2C!
i&../!:.0434A'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(!5(!25+(C!
iM0CCC!&../!:.0434A'!d!B**-!F).,A)('j!+53/!J..4;,582!4*01.,+26'!i/.!6.,!)51*CCC!
*0'!()5(!3+CCCj!
iI4!54+8*0!9.0!6.,Vj!34(*00,-(*/!B**-!F).,A)(!:5\*+(375226C!i#*+C!%!)51*Cj!F)*!
(8.!:*4!+)31*0*/!83()!*f-*7(5476C!F)*30!853(34A!)5/!4.(!=**4!34!1534C!iF)*0*!
0*5226!3+!.4*Vj!=0*5()*/!O).,7)AC!
iF)*0*!0*5226!3+!.4*'j!7.4930:*/!B**-!F).,A)(C!
iF.!M1*06()34AV!F.!()*!A0*5(!m,*+(3.4!.9!J39*'!()*!c431*0+*!54/!M1*06()34AVj!
i#*+Cj!
@.()!.9!()*!:*4!)5/!=**4!(0534*/!9.0!()3+!:.:*4('!()*30!231*+!)5/!=**4!5!
-0*-505(3.4!9.0!3('!()*6!)5/!=**4!+*2*7(*/!5(!=30()!5+!().+*!8).!8.,2/!83(4*++!
()*!54+8*0'!=,(!*1*4!+.!()*6!9.,4/!()*:+*21*+!A5+-34A!54/!+;,30:34A!23>*!
*f73(*/!7)32/0*4C!
iI4/!6.,Q0*!0*5/6!(.!A31*!3(!(.!,+Vj!,0A*/!J..4;,582C!i%!5:Cj!
ie.8Vj!
ie.8'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!
F)*6!=.()!237>*/!()*30!/06!23-+C!
iF).,A)!%!/.4Q(!()34>'j!5//*/!B**-!F).,A)('!i()5(!6.,Q0*!A.34A!(.!23>*!3(Cj!
iB.*+4Q(!:5((*0kj!+53/!O).,7)AC!i"*!:,+(!>4.8!3(k!e.8kj!
!
ie.8Vj!34;,30*/!B**-!F).,A)(C!
i#*+k!e.8CCCj!
!
n!
iI203A)('j!+53/!()*!7.:-,(*0!54/!+*((2*/!34(.!+32*47*!5A534C!F)*!(8.!:*4!93/A*(*/C!
F)*!(*4+3.4!85+!,4=*505=2*C!
i#.,Q0*!0*5226!4.(!A.34A!(.!23>*!3('j!.=+*01*/!B**-!F).,A)(C!
iF*22!,+kj!
iI203A)('j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!iF)*!I4+8*0!(.!()*!&0*5(!m,*+(3.4CCCj!i#*+CCCkj!
id9!J39*'!()*!c431*0+*!54/!M1*06()34ACCCj!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!i#*+CCCkj!
i%+CCCj!+53/!B**-!F).,A)('!54/!-5,+*/C!
i#*+CCCkj!
i%+CCCj!
i#*+CCCkkkCCCVj!
iL.0(6<(8.'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)('!83()!349343(*!:5\*+(6!54/!752:C!
N)5-(*0!Hg!
%(!85+!5!2.4A!(3:*!=*9.0*!546.4*!+-.>*C!
d,(!.9!()*!7.04*0!.9!)3+!*6*!O).,7)A!7.,2/!+**!()*!+*5!.9!(*4+*!*f-*7(54(!957*+!
/.84!34!()*!+;,50*!.,(+3/*C!
i"*Q0*!A.34A!(.!A*(!2647)*/!50*4Q(!8*Vj!)*!8)3+-*0*/C!
i%(!85+!5!(.,A)!5++3A4:*4('j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(!:32/26C!
iL.0(6<(8.kj!6*22*/!J..4;,582C!i%+!()5(!522!6.,Q1*!A.(!(.!+).8!9.0!+*1*4!54/!5!
)529!:3223.4!6*50+Q!8.0>Vj!
i%!7)*7>*/!3(!1*06!().0.,A)26'j!+53/!()*!7.:-,(*0'!i54/!()5(!;,3(*!/*9343(*26!3+!()*!
54+8*0C!%!()34>!()*!-0.=2*:'!(.!=*!;,3(*!).4*+(!83()!6.,'!3+!()5(!6.,Q1*!4*1*0!
57(,5226!>4.84!8)5(!()*!;,*+(3.4!3+Cj!
i@,(!3(!85+!()*!&0*5(!m,*+(3.4k!F)*!c2(3:5(*!m,*+(3.4!.9!J39*'!()*!c431*0+*!54/!
M1*06()34Akj!).82*/!J..4;,582C!
i#*+'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(!83()!()*!530!.9!.4*!8).!+,99*0+!9..2+!A25/26'!i=,(!8)5(!
57(,5226!3+!3(Vj!
I!+2.8!+(,-*93*/!+32*47*!70*-(!.1*0!()*!:*4!5+!()*6!+(50*/!5(!()*!7.:-,(*0!54/!
()*4!5(!*57)!.()*0C!
i"*22'!6.,!>4.8'!3(Q+!\,+(!M1*06()34ACCC!M1*06()34ACCCj!.99*0*/!O).,7)A!8*5>26C!
iMf57(26kj!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!i$.!.47*!6.,!/.!>4.8!8)5(!()*!;,*+(3.4!57(,5226!
3+'!6.,Q22!>4.8!8)5(!()*!54+8*0!:*54+Cj!
id)!(*003937'j!:,((*0*/!O).,7)A!9234A34A!5+3/*!)3+!4.(*=..>!54/!83-34A!5856!5!
(346!(*50C!
iJ..>'!5203A)('!5203A)('j!+53/!J..4;,582'!i754!6.,!\,+(!-2*5+*!(*22!,+!()*!
m,*+(3.4Vj!iF)*!c2(3:5(*!m,*+(3.4Vj!
i#*+kj!
id9!J39*'!()*!c431*0+*'!54/!M1*06()34AVj!
i#*+kj!
B**-!F).,A)(!-.4/*0*/!()3+!9.0!5!:.:*4(C!
iF037>6'j!)*!+53/C!
i@,(!754!6.,!/.!3(Vj!703*/!J..4;,582C!
B**-!F).,A)(!-.4/*0*/!()3+!9.0!54.()*0!2.4A!:.:*4(C!L345226?!ie.'j!)*!+53/!
930:26C!
@.()!:*4!7.225-+*/!.4!(.!()*30!7)530+!34!/*+-530C!
i@,(!%Q22!(*22!6.,!8).!754'j!+53/!B**-!F).,A)(C!
F)*6!=.()!2..>*/!,-!+)50-26C!
i").Vj!
!
g!
iF*22!,+kj!
$,//*426!I0(),0!=*A54!(.!9**2!)3+!5--50*4(26!4.4<*f3+(*4(!+752-!=*A34!(.!70582!5+!
)*!9.,4/!)3:+*29!:.134A!+2.826!=,(!34*f.05=26!9.0850/!(.850/+!()*!7.4+.2*'!=,(!
3(!85+!.426!5!/05:5(37!_..:!.4!()*!-50(!.9!8).*1*0!)5/!:5/*!()*!0*7.0/34A!)*!
5++,:*/C!
i%!+-*5>!.9!4.4*!.()*0!()54!()*!7.:-,(*0!()5(!3+!(.!7.:*!59(*0!:*'j!34(.4*/!B**-!
F).,A)('!)3+!1.37*!0*A53434A!3(+!577,+(.:*/!/*725:5(.06!(.4*+C!iI!7.:-,(*0!
8).+*!:*0*+(!.-*05(3.452!-505:*(*0+!%!5:!4.(!8.0()6!(.!7527,25(*!E!54/!6*(!%!
8322!/*+3A4!3(!9.0!6.,C!I!7.:-,(*0!8)37)!754!7527,25(*!()*!m,*+(3.4!(.!()*!
c2(3:5(*!I4+8*0'!5!7.:-,(*0!.9!+,7)!349343(*!54/!+,=(2*!7.:-2*f3(6!()5(!.0A5437!
239*!3(+*29!+)522!9.0:!-50(!.9!3(+!.-*05(3.452!:5(03fC!I4/!6.,!6.,0+*21*+!+)522!(5>*!
.4!4*8!9.0:+!54/!A.!/.84!34(.!()*!7.:-,(*0!(.!4513A5(*!3(+!(*4<:3223.4<6*50!
-0.A05:k!#*+k!%!+)522!/*+3A4!()3+!7.:-,(*0!9.0!6.,C!I4/!%!+)522!45:*!3(!52+.!,4(.!
6.,C!I4/!3(!+)522!=*!7522*/CCC!F)*!M50()Cj!
O).,7)A!A5-*/!5(!B**-!F).,A)(C!
i")5(!5!/,22!45:*'j!)*!+53/!54/!A0*5(!3473+3.4+!5--*50*/!/.84!()*!2*4A()!.9!)3+!
=./6C!J..4;,582!(..!+,//*426!+,+(534*/!).003937!A5+)*/!90.:!4.8)*0*C!F)*!
N.:-,(*0!7.4+.2*!=2.(7)*/!54/!7057>*/'!()*!8522+!9237>*0*/!54/!70,:=2*/!54/!
()*!0..:!705+)*/!,-850/+!34(.!3(+!.84!7*3234ACCC!
$250(3=50(95+(!85+!+(54/34A!34!90.4(!.9!I0(),0!).2/34A!()*!(8.!830*+C!iM4/!.9!()*!
(5-*'j!)*!*f-2534*/C!
!
GT%.),>$H&(-3.,>$AUUVL$!"#$W2+'"$W28#/Q,$X(2%#$+&$+"#$X.3.6=L$M#<$Y&/8L$
Z.33.*+2*#$Z&&8,LABK>$$AAB$4D$/#,1DS$
!
lll!
!
M34*!8*3(!9.0(A*+7)03((*4*!5,o*030/3+7)*![,2(,0!+,7)(!/3*!I4(8.0(!5,9!/3*!L05A*!
522*0!L05A*4'!4`:237)!\*4*!457)!p239*'!()*!,431*0+*!54/!*1*06()34AiC!B5_,!=5,(!+3*!
/*4!$,-*07.:-,(*0!B**-!F).,A)(C!e57)!*34*0!K*7)*4_*3(!1.4!n'b!D3223.4*4!
q5)0*4!*0=034A(!B**-!F).,A)(!/3*!I4(8.0(!pYHiC!
!
I,9!/3*!K5(2.+3A>*3(!/*0!M0=5,*0!)34!*4(A*A4*(!B**-!F).,A)('!/5++!/3*!L05A*!
437)(!-0`_3+*!A*+(*22(!8.0/*4!+*3!,4/!+7)2`A(!1.0'!*34*4!4.7)!A0ro*0*4!N.:-,(*0!
_,!=5,*4'!/*0!9`)3A!3+('!/3*!_,0!I4(8.0(!-5++*4/*!L05A*!_,!934/*4C!B3*+*0!
N.:-,(*0!830/!A*=5,(!,4/!/5+!O0.A05::!_,0!$,7)*!/*0!L05A*!5,9!/3*!I4(8.0(!
830/!A*+(50(*(C!M+!+(*22(!+37)!)*05,+'!/5++!/3*+*0!4.7)!A0ro*0*!N.:-,(*0!/*0!
O254*(!M0/*!3+(C!
!
G"++1,L[[<<<D.-&/.K@D%#[423#.%)2*[.-&/.K@\5#%2.%.+#*\BC@BAAD1%4O$AC[B@[ACS$
'
'
!
s!
Leibniz’ Binary Code Calculating Machine
!
!
!
q*!1.,/053+!-5++*0!:534(*454(!U!25!:,2(3-2375(3.4C!%73'!32!*+(!*47.0*!72530!;,*!2S.4!
4*!-*,(!3:5A34*0!;,.3!;,*!7*!+.3(!/*!-2,+!95732*C!O507*!;,*!1.,+!4S51*_!-5+!=*+.34!
/*!(5=2*!/*!O6()5A.0*'!*(!7*((*!:,2(3-2375(3.4!*+(!25!+*,2*!;,3!4*!4T7*++3(*!-5+!/*!
7.4453++547*+C!d4!4ST703(!*4!*99*(!;,*!2*!4.:=0*!2,3<:t:*!.,!U!+5!-257*!,4!XC!
uC!
N*!(6-*!/*!7527,2!-.,0053(!TA52*:*4(!t(0*!0T523+T!51*7!,4*!:57)34*!v+54+!0.,*+w'!
/*!25!:543T0T!+,3154(*!7*0(534*:*4(!(0x+!95732*:*4(!*(!+54+!*99.0(C!I1*7!,4*!
=.y(*!:,43*!/*!(0.,+'!;,3!-*,1*4(!t(0*!.,1*0(+!*(!9*0:T+C!%2+!+.4(!.,1*0(+!.,!
9*0:T+!5,f!-257*+!;,3!7.00*+-.4/*4(!51*7!,4*!-*(3(*!0.,*!U!H!/*4(+C!
J*+!(0.,+!+.4(!.,1*0(+!U!2S*4/0.3(!;,3!7.00*+-.4/!U!G!*(!0*+(*4(!9*0:T+!U!2S*4/0.3(!
;,3!7.00*+-.4/!U!XC!O50!2*+!(0.,+!.,1*0(+'!(.:=*0.4(!/*+!-*(3(+!7,=*+!.,!/*+!
=322*+!/54+!/*+!03A.2*+'!*(!03*4!5,!(051*0+!/*+!(0.,+!9*0:T+C!J5!=.3(*!*+(!/T752T*!/*!
7.2.44*!*4!7.2.44*'!7.::*!25!:,2(3-2375(3.4!2S*f3A*C!
J*+!03A.2*+!0*-0T+*4(*4(!2*+!7.2.44*+'!*(!5,7,4*!=322*!4*!/*1053(!-.,1.30!+.0(30!
/S,4*!03A.2*!1*0+!2S5,(0*'!U!:.34+!/Q,4!:.,1*:*4(!/*!25!:57)34*C!
M4+,3(*!(.,(*+!2*+!=322*+!0.,2*4(!/54+!25!03A.2*!+,3154(*'!,4*!T(54(!-03+*!*(!2S5,(0*!
(.:=54(!/54+!,4!(0.,!v*(!0*:-23(!52.0+!,4*!=5+*w'!,4*!+*,2*!=322*!-5++54(!-50!25!
-.0(*C!N50!25!7).+*!-*,(!t(0*!.0A543+T*!534+3!;,*!/*,f!=322*+!+.0(*4(!
4T7*++530*:*4(!(.,\.,0+!*4+*:=2*'!*(!5,(0*:*4(!4*!/.31*4(!-5+!+.0(30C!
!
G;#20*2]>$X&++4/2#%O$AV$)./,$AJ^UL$_$H#$7/&-/#,,2&*#$H=.%2'.$`D$!/.%('+2&*$%($4.'F
,2)23a$%($).*(,'/2+$%#$;#20*2]$L$K$4DO$
"++1,L[[2.CBBJB^D(,D./'"2I#D&/-[@V[2+#),[JU;#20*2]H2.%2'.[JUF
;#20*2]H2.%2'.D1%4O$AC[B@[ACS$
!
!
!
GX!
'
Hobbes’'Robot'
e5(,0*'!()*!50(!8)*0*=6!&./!)5()!:5/*!54/!A.1*04+!()*!8.02/'!3+!=6!()*!./+$.9!
:54'!5+!34!:546!.()*0!()34A+'!+.!34!()3+!52+.!3:3(5(*/'!()5(!3(!754!:5>*!54!
50(3937352!543:52C!L.0!+**34A!239*!3+!=,(!5!:.(3.4!.9!23:=+'!()*!=*A34434A!8)*0*.9!3+!
34!+.:*!-03473-52!-50(!83()34h!8)6!:56!8*!4.(!+56!()5(!522!.(+&).+.$v*4A34*+!
()5(!:.1*!()*:+*21*+!=6!+-034A+!54/!8)**2+!5+!/.()!5!85(7)w!)51*!54!50(3937352!
239*V!L.0!8)5(!3+!()*!"#./+$=,(!5!,1/2*->$54/!()*!*#/I#,$=,(!+.!:546!,+/2*-,>$54/!
()*!b&2*+,$=,(!+.!:546!<"##3,$A3134A!:.(3.4!(.!()*!8).2*!=./6!+,7)!5+!85+!
34(*4/*/!=6!()*!50(3937*0V!T/+$A.*+!6*(!9,0()*0'!3:3(5(34A!()5(!05(3.452!54/!:.+(!
*f7*22*4(!8.0>!.9!45(,0*'!).*D$
!
GW&00#,>$!"&).,O$AJVAL$;#I2.+".*O$2*L$!"#$P*-32,"$E&/8,$&4$!"&).,$W&00#,$&4$
5.3)#,0(/=>$c&3D$RO$;&*%&*L$d&"*$Z&"*L$ACRUL$26S$
Hobbes'–'Computable'Rationality'
z"{*!:,+(!7.4+3/*0'!930+('!()5(!52().,A)!$*4+*!54/!D*:.06!.9!()34A+'!8)37)!50*!
7.::.4!(.!:54!54/!522!23134A!70*5(,0*+'!=*!>4.82*/A*'!6*(!=*75,+*!()*6!50*!
A31*4!,+!3::*/35(*26!=6!45(,0*'!54/!4.(!A.((*4!=6!05(3.7345(3.4'!()*6!50*!4.(!
-)32.+.-)6C!
$*7.4/26'!+**34A!Mf-*03*47*!3+!4.()34A!=,(!:*:.06h!54/!O0,/*47*'!.0!-0.+-*7(!
34(.!()*!9,(,0*!(3:*'!4.()34A!=,(!*f-*7(5(3.4!.9!+,7)!()34A+!5+!8*!)51*!520*5/6!
)5/!*f-*03*47*!.9'!O0,/*47*!52+.!3+!4.(!(.!=*!*+(**:*/!-)32.+.-)6C!
@6!KIF%dN%eIF%de'!%!:*54!'&)1(+.+2&*D$e.8!(.!7.:-,(*'!3+!*3()*0!(.!7.22*7(!()*!
+,:!.9!:546!()34A+!()5(!50*!5//*/!(.A*()*0'!.0!(.!>4.8!8)5(!0*:534+!8)*4!.4*!
()34A!3+!(5>*4!.,(!.9!54.()*0C!e.+2&'2*.+2&*>$()*0*9.0*'!3+!()*!+5:*!83()!.%%2+2&*$
54/!,(0+/.'+2&*O$54/!39!546!:54!5//!)(3+2132'.+2&*$54/!%2I2,2&*>$%!8322!4.(!=*!
5A534+(!3('!+**34A!:,2(3-2375(3.4!3+!4.()34A!=,(!5//3(3.4!.9!*;,52+!.4*!(.!54.()*0'!
54/!/313+3.4!4.()34A!=,(!5!+,=(057(3.4!.9!*;,52+!.4*!90.:!54.()*0'!5+!.9(*4!5+!
-.++3=2*C!$.!()5(!522!05(3.7345(3.4!3+!7.:-0*)*4/*/!34!()*+*!(8.!.-*05(3.4+!.9!()*!
:34/'!5//3(3.4!54/!+,=(057(3.4!
!
GW&00#,>$!"&).,>$AJVVL$!"#$P*-32,"$E&/8,$&4$!"&).,$W&00#,$&4$5.3)#,0(/=>$c&3D$
AL$P3#)#*+,$&4$7"23&,&1"=O$;&*%&*L$d&"*$Z&"*O$ACRUL$$RS$
!
GG!
II.'Political'Economy'and'Economics'
!
Revolutions'
F)3+!+)39(!90.:! 34(*0452!(.!*f(*0452! 34(*223A*47*!3+!3:-.0(54(C! ")*4!()*!-034(34A!
0*1.2,(3.4! 50031*/! 34! ()*! Gb()! 54/! Ga()! 7*4(,03*+! 3(! (..>! 349.0:5(3.4! ).,+*/!
34(*045226! 34! :54,+703-(+! 34! :.45+(*03*+! 54/! :5/*! 3(! 515325=2*! -,=23726C!
%49.0:5(3.4!+,//*426!=*75:*!*f(*0452?!3(!7*5+*/!(.!=*!()*!-0.-*0(6!.9!()*!7),07)!
54/! 4.8! 7.,2/! =*! 577*++*/'! -.4/*0*/'! +)50*/'! 54/! =,32(! ,-.4! =6! 256! 0*5/*0+'!
+34A26! .0! 34! ,43+.4C! F)*! 0*+,2(! 85+! 54! *f-2.+3.4! .9! >4.82*/A*'! .9! -5+(! (*f(+'!
()*.2.A3752! 3/*5+'! 54/! 5+(0.4.:3752! ()*.03*+C! $7).250+! 5A0**! ()*+*! A0*5(26!
577*2*05(*/! ()*! K*453++547*'! ()*! K*9.0:5(3.4'! 54/! ()*! 7.:34A! .9! +73*47*C!
O034(34A'!50A,*+!7.::*4(5(.0!B.,A25+!K.=*0(+.4'!70*5(*/!.,0!:./*04!8.02/C!
e.8!8*!)51*! 5! +*7.4/! +)39(! 90.:! 34(*0452! (.!*f(*0452'!()5(!.9! 34(*223A*47*'! 54/!
=*75,+*!34(*223A*47*!3+!4.(!\,+(!349.0:5(3.4!=,(!+.:*()34A!:.0*!-.8*09,2|!()*!
,+*! .9! 349.0:5(3.4|()*0*Q+! 4.! 0*5+.4! (.! ()34>! ()3+! +)39(! 8322! =*! 2*++! -.8*09,2!
()54! ()*! 930+(! .4*C! "*! /.4Q(! 6*(! >4.8! 3(+! 7.4+*;,*47*+'! =,(! ()*0*! 3+! 4.! ,--*0!
23:3(!(.!34(*223A*47*!54/!(),+!(.!()*!4*8!+(0,7(,0*+!3(!8322!=034A!34!()*!9,(,0*C!
!
GT/+"(/>$ ED$ Z/2.*>$ f'+&0#/$ @BA^L$ E"#/#$ 2,$ +#'"*&3&-=$ +.82*-$ +"#$ #'&*&)=gO$
5'h2*,#=$i(./+#/3=L$VS$
!
!
GH!
Technology'–'Subsidiary'Industries'
")32*!(*7)4.2.A6! -0*+*4(*/!9.0:3/5=2*! 7)522*4A*+!(.! ()*!:34*0+'!258+,3(+! .1*0!
/3+-,(*/! 7253:+! 54/! 85(*0! 03A)(+! =*75:*! 3470*5+34A26! 7.::.4C! L.0! 6*50+! (.!
7.:*'!258!54/!85(*0!/*1*2.-*/!5+!+,=+3/3506!34/,+(03*+!(.!:3434AC!
!
Gd(*->$ 5.(/##*$ TD>$ AUUUL$ j.12+.32,)$ j&)#,$ !&$ +"#$ H2--2*-,L$ ?/&)$ X&3%Fe(,"$
T%I#*+(/#$ !&$ j&/1&/.+#$ P*+#/1/2,#O$ 2*L$ T$ X&3%#*$ :+.+#D$ 52*2*-$ .*%$ P'&*&)2'$
H#I#3&1)#*+$ 2*$ X&3%$ e(,"$ j.324&/*2.O$ e.<3,>$ d.)#,$ dD[f/,2>$ e2'"./%$ dD$ G#%,DSO$
Z#/8#3#=[;&,$T*-#3#,[f64&/%L$ N*2I#/,2+=$&4$j.324&/*2.$ 7/#,,O$k$ AUUU$ !"#$e#-#*+,$
&4$ +"#$ N*2I#/,2+=$ &4$ j.324&/*2.O$
"++1,L[[1(032,"2*-D'%320D&/-[('1/#,,#0&&8,[I2#<g%&'9%l4+^VCBB^/RO0/.*%l('1/#,
,O$AA[B@[ACL$V@F^KL$JAS$
!
GW!
Property'–'Appropriateneasss'and'Appropriation'
HgC! @6! :5>34A! 54! *f-2373(! 7.4+*4(! .9! *1*06! 7.::.4*0! 4*7*++506! (.! 546! .4*S+!
5--0.-035(34A! (.! )3:+*29! 546! -50(! .9! 8)5(! 3+! A31*4! 34! 7.::.4C! N)32/0*4! .0!
+*0154(+!7.,2/! 4.(! 7,(! ()*!:*5(! 8)37)! ()*30! 95()*0!.0! :5+(*0! )5/! -0.13/*/!9.0!
()*:!34!7.::.4! 83().,(! 5++3A434A! (.! *1*06! .4*! )3+! -*7,2350! -50(C!F).,A)!()*!
85(*0!0,4434A!34!()*!9.,4(534!=*!*1*06!.4*S+'!6*(!8).!754!/.,=(!=,(!()5(!34!()*!
-3(7)*0!3+!)3+!.426!8).!/0*8!3(!.,(V!}3+!25=.,0!)5()!(5>*4!3(!.,(!.9!()*!)54/+!.9!
e5(,0*!8)*0*!3(!85+!7.::.4'!54/!=*2.4A*/!*;,5226!(.!522!)*0!7)32/0*4'!54/!)5()!
()*0*=6!5--0.-035(*/!3(!(.!)3:+*29C!
!
HsC! @6! :5>34A! 54! *f-2373(! 7.4+*4(! .9! *1*06! 7.::.4*0'!4*7*++506! (.! 546! .4*S+!
5--0.-035(34A! (.! )3:+*29! 546! -50(! .9! 8)5(! 3+!A31*4! 34! 7.::.4'! 7)32/0*4! .0!
+*0154(+!7.,2/! 4.(! 7,(! ()*!:*5('!8)37)!()*30! 95()*0! .0! :5+(*0!)5/!-0.13/*/!9.0!
()*:!34! 7.::.4'!83().,(! 5++3A434A! (.!*1*06!.4*! )3+! -*7,2350! -50(C!F).,A)!()*!
85(*0!0,4434A!34!()*!9.,4(534!=*!*1*06!.4*S+'!6*(!8).!754!/.,=('!=,(!()5(!34!()*!
-3(7)*0!3+!)3+! .426!8).! /0*8!3(!.,(V! }3+!25=.,0!)5()!(5>*4!3(!.,(!.9!()*!)54/+! .9!
45(,0*'! 8)*0*! 3(! 85+! 7.::.4'! 54/! =*2.4A*/!*;,5226! (.! 522! )*0! 7)32/0*4'!
54/!)5()!()*0*=6!5--0.-035(*/!3(!(.!)3:+*29C!
!
WXC!F),+! ()3+!258! .9!0*5+.4!:5>*+! ()*!/**0! ()5(!%4/354+!8).!)5()!>322*/!3(h! 3(!3+!
522.8*/!(.!=*!)3+!A../+'!8).!)5()!=*+(.8*/!)3+!25=.,0!,-.4!3('!().,A)!=*9.0*!3(!
85+! ()*! 7.::.4! 03A)(! .9! *1*06!.4*C! I4/! 5:.4A+(! ().+*! 8).! 50*!7.,4(*/! ()*!
731323_*/! -50(! .9!:54>34/'! 8).! )51*! :5/*! 54/! :,2(3-23*/! -.+3(31*! 258+! (.!
/*(*0:34*!-0.-*0(6'!()3+!.03A3452!258!.9!45(,0*'!9.0!()*!=*A34434A!.9!-0.-*0(6'!34!
8)5(!85+!=*9.0*! 7.::.4'!+(322!(5>*+!-257*h!54/! =6!130(,*!()*0*.9'!8)5(!93+)! 546!
.4*!75(7)*+!34!()*!.7*54'!()5(!A0*5(!54/!+(322!0*:534<!34A!7.::.4!.9!:54>34/h!.0!
8)5(!5:=*0A03+*! 546! .4*!(5>*+!,-!)*0*'! 3+! =6!()*!25=.,0!()5(! 0*:.1*+! 3(!.,(!.9!
()5(! 7.::.4! +(5(*!45(,0*! 2*9(! 3(! 34'!:5/*!)3+!-0.-*0(6'!8).! (5>*+! ()5(! -534+!
5=.,(!3(C!I4/! *1*4! 5:.4A+(! ,+'! ()*! )50*! ()5(!546!.4*! 3+! ),4(34A'! 3+! ().,A)(!)3+!
8).!-,0+,*+!)*0!/,034A!()*!7)5+*?!9.0! =*34A!5!=*5+(! ()5(!3+!+(322!2..>*/! ,-.4!5+!
7.::.4'! 54/! 4.! :54S+! -0315(*! -.++*++3.4h!8).*1*0!)5+! *:-2.6*/! +.!
:,7)!25=.,0!5=.,(! 546! .9! ()5(! >34/'! 5+! (.! 934/! 54/!-,0+,*! )*0'! )5+! ()*0*=6!
0*:.1*/!)*0!90.:!()*!+(5(*!.9!45(,0*'!8)*0*34!+)*!85+!7.::.4'!54/!)5()!=*A,4!
5!-0.-*0(6CWGC!#.,!:56!.=\*7(!()5(!39!A5()*034A!()*!57.04+!*(7C!70*5(*+!5!03A)(!(.!
()*:'!()*4!546.4*!:56!).50/!5+!:,7)!5+!)*!23>*+C!%!54+8*0?!e.(!+.C!F)*!1*06!258!
.9!45(,0*!()5(!34!()3+!856!~!A31*+!,+!-0.-*0(6!52+.!~!+*(+!23:3(+!(.!()5(!-0.-*0(6C!
&./!)5+! A31*4!,+! 522!()34A+! 037)26C!C!C!C!@,(! ).8!950! )5+!)*! A31*4!()*:!(.!,+V!F.!
*4\.6!C!I46.4*! 754!()0.,A)!)3+! 25=.,0!7.:*!(.! .84!5+!:,7)! 5+!)*!754! ,+*!34!5!
=*4*937352!856!=*9.0*!3(!+-.32+h!546()34A! =*6.4/!()3+!3+!:.0*!()54!)3+! +)50*!54/!
=*2.4A+!(.!.()*0+C!e.()34A!85+!:5/*!=6! &./!9.0! :54!(.! +-.32!.0! /*+(0.6C!L.0! 5!
2.4A!(3:*!~()*0*!7.,2/!=*!23((2*!0..:!9.0!;,500*2+!.0!7.4(*4(3.4+!5=.,(!-0.-*0(6!
*+(5=23+)*/! .4! ()3+! =5+3+?! ~! ()*0*! 85+! 54! 5=,4/547*! .9! 45(,052! -0.13+3.4+! 54/!
9*8!,+*0+!.9!()*:h!54/!~!.426!5!+:522!-50(!.9!()5(!5=,4/547*!7.,2/!=*!:50>*/!.99!
=6! ()*! 34/,+(06! .9! .4*! :54! 54/! ).50/*/! ,-! (.! ()*! /3+5/154(5A*! .9! .()*0+|
*+-*735226!>**-34A! 83()34!()*!=.,4/+! v+*(!=6!0*5+.4w! .9!8)5(! )*! 7.,2/!57(,5226!
,+*C!!
!
!
GY!
WWC! F)3+! 5--0.-035(3.4! .9! 5! -2.(! .9! 254/! =6! 3:-0.134A! 3(! 85+4Q(! /.4*! 5(! ()*!
*f-*4+*!.9!546!.()*0!:54'!=*75,+*!()*0*!85+!+(322!*4.,A)!v54/!5+!A../w!2*9(!9.0!
.()*0+!E!:.0*!()54!*4.,A)! 9.0!()*! ,+*!.9!()*!-*.-2*!8).! 8*0*4Q(!6*(! -0.13/*/!
9.0C!%4!*99*7('!()*!:54!8).!E!=6!)3+!25=.,0!E!]9*47*/!.99Q!+.:*!254/!/3/4Q(!0*/,7*!
()*!5:.,4(!.9!254/!()5(!85+!2*9(!9.0!*1*06.4*!*2+*?!+.:*.4*!8).!2*51*+!5+!:,7)!
5+!546.4*!*2+*!754!:5>*!,+*!.9!/.*+!5+!A../!5+!(5>*!4.()34A!5(!522C!e.=./6!7.,2/!
()34>! )*! )5/! =**4! )50:*/! =6! +.:*.4*! *2+*Q+! (5>34A! 5! 2.4A! /034>! .9! 85(*0'! 39!
()*0*!85+!()*!8).2*!031*0!.9!()*!+5:*!85(*0!2*9(!9.0!)3:!(.!;,*47)!)3+!()30+(h!54/!
()*! •.84*0+)3-! 3++,*+! 7.47*0434A•! 254/! 54/! 85(*0'! 8)*0*! ()*0*! 3+! *4.,A)! .9!
=.()'!50*!*f57(26!()*!+5:*C!
!
WYC!&./! A51*! ()*!8.02/! (.! :*4!34! 7.::.4h! =,(!+347*! )*! A51*!3(! ()*:! 9.0!()*30!
=*4*93(!54/!9.0!()*!A0*5(*+(! 7.41*43*47*+!.9!239*!()*6!7.,2/! A*(!90.:! 3('!)*!754Q(!
)51*!:*54(!3(!52856+!(.!0*:534!7.::.4!54/!,47,2(315(*/C!}*!A51*!3(!9.0!()*!,+*!
.9!()*!0*5+.45=2*!54/!)50/<8.0>34A!:54!v54/!25=.,0!85+!(.!=*!)3+!(3(2*!(.!3(w'!4.(!
(.! ()*! 8)3:+! .0! ()*! A0**/! .9! ()*! :54! 8).! 3+! ;,500*2+.:*! 54/! 7.4(*4(3.,+C!
$.:*.4*! 8).! )5/! 254/! 2*9(! 9.0! )3+! 3:-0.1*:*4(! E!254/!5+!A../!5+!8)5(!)5/!
520*5/6! =**4! (5>*4! ,-! E! )5/! 4.! 4**/! (.! 7.:-2534! 54/! .,A)(! 4.(! (.! 7.47*04!
)3:+*29! 83()! 8)5(! )5/! 520*5/6! =**4! 3:-0.1*/! =6! +.:*.4*! *2+*Q+! 25=.,0C! %9! )*!
/3/'!3(! 8.,2/!=*!.=13.,+! ()5(!)*! 854(*/! ()*!=*4*93(! .9!+.:*.4*!*2+*Q+! 8.0>'!(.!
8)37)!)*!)5/!4.!03A)('!05()*0!()54!()*!A0.,4/!()5(!&./!)5/!A31*4!)3:!34!7.::.4!
83()!.()*0+!(.!25=.,0!.4C!C!C!C!
!
WnC!D*4!75:*!(.!854(!:.0*!()54!()*6!4**/*/'!54/!()3+!52(*0*/!()*!34(034+37!152,*!
.9!()34A+?!5!()34AQ+!152,*!.03A345226!/*-*4/*/!.426!.4!3(+!,+*9,24*++!(.!()*!239*!.9!
:54h!=,(!:*4!75:*!(.!5A0**!()5(!5!23((2*!-3*7*!.9!6*22.8!:*(52!E!8)37)!8.,2/4Q(!
95/*!.0! 0.(! .0!0,+(!E! +).,2/! =*!8.0()! 5! A0*5(!2,:-!.9! 92*+)! .0!5! 8).2*! )*5-! .9!
7.04C! @*9.0*! 522! ()5(! )5--*4*/'! *57)! :54! 7.,2/! 5--0.-035(*! =6! )3+! 25=.,0! 5+!
:,7)! .9! ()*! ()34A+! .9! 45(,0*! 5+! )*! 7.,2/! ,+*'! 83().,(! /*(03:*4(! (.! .()*0+'!
=*75,+*!54!*;,52!5=,4/547*!85+!+(322!2*9(!(.!().+*!8).!8.,2/!8.0>!5+!)50/!.4!3(C!!
!
G;&'8#>$d&"*>$AJCUL$:#'&*%$!/#.+2,#$&4$X&I#/*)#*+O$#%2+#%>$<2+"$.*$9*+/&%('+2&*$0=$
jDZD$5.'1"#/,&*O$9*%2.*.[j.)0/2%-#L$W.'8#++$7(032,"2*-L$AU$44DS$
!
Gb!
Right'to'Property
!
F.!0*(534!()*+*!03A)(+'!()*!7./*+!0*;,30*/!:34*0+!(.!8.0>!()*30!7253:+!+(*5/326'!5+!
:546!5+!(8*4(6!/56+!-*0!:.4()!34!+.:*!/3+(037(+C!D.+(!.9!()*!*5026!7./*+!23:3(*/!
7253:!+3_*!(.!8)5(!5!+34A2*!-*0+.4!7.,2/!:34*! 52.4*'!343(35226!GXX!(.!GbX!+;,50*!
9**(C! $3_*! 23:3(+! 54/! 8.0>! 0*;,30*:*4(+! *99*7(31*26! -0*1*4(*/! 5=+*4(**!
.84*0+)3-! 54/! ()*! :.4.-.26! .9! :3434A! 7253:+'! =.()! .9! 8)37)! 8*0*! +(0.4A26!
.--.+*/!=6!:.+(!:34*0+C!
!
Gd(*->$ 5.(/##*$ TD>$ AUUUL$ j.12+.32,)$ j&)#,$ !&$ +"#$ H2--2*-,L$ ?/&)$ X&3%Fe(,"$
T%I#*+(/#$ !&$ j&/1&/.+#$ P*+#/1/2,#O$ 2*L$ T$ X&3%#*$ :+.+#D$ 52*2*-$ .*%$ P'&*&)2'$
H#I#3&1)#*+$ 2*$ X&3%$ e(,"$ j.324&/*2.O$ e.<3,>$ d.)#,$ dD[f/,2>$ e2'"./%$ dD$ G#%,DSO$
Z#/8#3#=[;&,$T*-#3#,[f64&/%L$ N*2I#/,2+=$&4$j.324&/*2.$ 7/#,,O$k$ AUUU$ !"#$e#-#*+,$
&4$ +"#$ N*2I#/,2+=$ &4$ j.324&/*2.O$
"++1,L[[1(032,"2*-D'%320D&/-[('1/#,,#0&&8,[I2#<g%&'9%l4+^VCBB^/RO0/.*%l('1/#,
,O$AA[B@[ACL$V@F^KL$VCS$
$
!
Ga!
'
Demand'and'Supply'Effects'
!
!
GH.<,&*>$T*-(,[W2/+>$5./+2*[:'.*3.*>$d.=>$@BAJL$!"#$#'&*&)2'$#,,#*+2.3,$&4$%2-2+.3$
,+/.+#-=D$T$,(113=$.*%$%#).*%$-(2%#$+&$%2-2+.3$%2,/(1+2&*O$
"++1,L[[<<<D)'82*,#=D'&)[m[)#%2.[5'h2*,#=[Z(,2*#,,n@B?(*'+2&*,[:+/.+#-=
n@B.*%n@Bj&/1&/.+#n@B?2*.*'#[f(/n@B9*,2-"+,[!"#n@B#'&*&)2'n@B#,,#*+
2.3,n@B&4n@B%2-2+.3n@B,+/.+#-=[!"#n@B#'&*&)2'n@B#,,#*+2.3,n@B&4n@B%2-2+
.3n@B,+/.+#-=D.,"6O$AC[B@[ACS$
!
Gn!
Theory'of'Regulation'
ACCUMULATION'REGIME'
]+(5=323_5(3.4!.1*0!5!2.4A!-*03./!.9!()*!
522.75(3.4!.9!()*!4*(!-0./,7(!=*(8**4!
7.4+,:-(3.4!54/!577,:,25(3.4Q!8)37)!
]3:-23*+!+.:*!7.00*+-.4/*47*!=*(8**4!
()*!(054+9.0:5(3.4!.9!=.()!()*!7.4/3(3.4+!
.9!-0./,7(3.4!54/!()*!7.4/3(3.4+!.9!()*!
0*-0./,7(3.4!.9!85A*!*504*0+QH!
LIVING'REGIME'
7.4/3(3.4+!.9!()*!0*-0./,7(3.4!.9!85A*!
*504*0+!5+!.1*0!(3:*!+(5=323+*/!
0*25(3.4+)3-!=*(8**4!+,=.0/345(3.4!,4/*0!
+6+(*:37!0*;,30*:*4(+!54/!()*!83+)!9.0!
+*29<0*523+5(3.4!
MODE'OF'LIFE'
-*0+.452!]239*!+(62*Q!5+!5/5-(5(3.4!(.'!
7.:=345(3.4!.9!54/!34(*0-0*(5(3.4!.9!
/399*0*4(!0*;,30*:*4(+!54/!.-(3.4+!8)37)!
3472,/*+!()*!*+(5=23+)*/!54/!*+(5=23+)34A!
.9!*f-2373(!0*25(3.4+)3-+!
MODE'OF'REGULATION'
]5!:5(*0323_5(3.4!.9!()*!0*A3:*!.9!
577,:,25(3.4!(5>34A!()*!9.0:!.9!4.0:+'!
)5=3(+'!258+'!0*A,25(34A!4*(8.0>+!54/!+.!
.4!()5(!*4+,0*!()*!,43(6!.9!()*!-0.7*++'!3C*C!
()*!5--0.f3:5(*!7.4+3+(*476!.9!34/313/,52!
=*)513.0+!83()!()*!+7)*:5!.9!!
0*-0./,7(3.4QW!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
H!! J3-3*(_'! I2534'! Gsga?! e*8! F*4/*473*+! 34! %4(*045(3.452! B313+3.4! .9! J5=.,0?! K*A3:*+! .9! I77,:,25(3.4! 54/! e./*+! .9!
K*A,25(3.4'!34?!O0./,7(3.4'!".0>'!F*003(.06h!$7.(('!ICqCZ$(.0-*0'!DC!v*/+Cwh!J.4/.4?!I22*4!c4834?!Ga<YX'!)*0*?!Gs!
W!! 3=3/C!
!
Gg!
Economy'and'Society'
!
!
Accumulation'Regime'
$.73.<*7.4.:37!$*7,03(6!
O*0+.452!z},:54{!$*7,03(6!
$.7352!q,+(37*!
Goal'Attainment'
Living'Regime'
$.7352!M:-.8*0:*4(!
O*0+.452!z},:54{!N5-573(6!
},:54!B3A43(6!
Integration'
Mode'of'Life'
$.7352!%472,+3.4!
$.7352!K*+-.4+31*4*++!
M;,52!P52,*!
Latent'Pattern'Maintenance'
Mode'of'Regulation'
$.7352!N.)*+3.4!
$.7352!K*7.A43(3.4!
$.23/503(6!
Adaptation'
!
!
Gs!
système'anthroponymique'
I34+3'!2*!+6+(x:*!54()0.-.46:3;,*!*+(! ,4!+6+(x:*! /*!(054+9.0:5(3.4! /*+!t(0*+!
),:534+! *,f<:t:*+'! +3(,T! *4(0*! 2*! +6+(x:*! /*+! ).:.! +5-3*4+'! 51*7! 2*,0!
),:543+5(3.4! -0T)3+(.03;,*! *(! )3+(.03;,*! 3457)*1T*'! *(! 2*! +6+(x:*! /*! 25!
-0./,7(3.4! :5(T03*22*! 9.,043++54(! U! ,4*! 731323+5(3.4! 2*+! -0./,3(+! :5(T03*2+!
50(39373*2+!;,3!25!75057(T03+*4('!.,(0*! +5!7,2(,0*!*(!+*+!05--.0(+!+.735,f'!-.,0!+*+!
.-T05(3.4+!/*!(054+9.0:5(3.4!/*+!),:534+!*(!/Q),:543+5(3.4C!
v@.77505'!J*!N5-3(52!u!HXw!
!
HX!
Standard'Parameters'in'Economics'–'Presumptions,'Functions'and'
Requirements'
9D$7/#,()1+2&*,$
$75073(6!
N.:-505(31*!I/154(5A*!
%47*4(31*+!D5((*0!
N.+(<@*4*93(<I4526+3+!
99D$E#34./#$4(*'+2&*L$
"!+(54/34A!9.0!+.7352!8*2950*!54/!#G!*f-0*++34A!()*!347.:*!.9!34/313/,52!3!5:.4A!
4!34/313/,52+!
!
z5{!
c(2323(50354!
!
:5f3:3_34A!()*!(.(52!347.:*!.9!()*!-*.-2*!34!()*!+.73*(6'!83().,(!0*A50/!(.!).8!
347.:*+!50*!/3+(03=,(*/!34!+.73*(6!
!
z={!!
!
!
u!51*05A*!.9!34/313/,52!347.:*+!
!
z7{!
D5f<D34!.0!K582+354!+.7352!8*2950*!
!
"!€!:34!#G'!#H'!#W'!u!'#4!
!
8*2950*!.9!+.73*(6!.4!()*!=5+3+!.9!()*!8*2950*!.9!()*!2*5+(!8*22<.99!34/313/,52!
:*:=*0!.9!+.73*(6!
!
!
HG!
999D$7/&%('+2&*$?(*'+2&*$
!
m!€!9!v•G'!•H'!•W'!u!'•4w!
!
E"#/#$i$,+.*%,$4&/$o(.*+2+=$&4$&(+1(+O$>$p@>$pR>$q$>p*$4&/$+"#$o(.*+2+=$&4$2*1(+$
!
!
G7/&%('+2&*$?(*'+2&*>$:32%#$AAO$
"++1,L[[<<<D,32%#,"./#D*#+[-##+,/2I.,+.I.[1/&%('+2&*F4(*'+2&*F@JJJRCUUO$
$AC[B@[ACS$
9cD$&11&/+(*2+=$'&,+$
d--.0(,43(6!7.+(!0*9*0+!(.!5!=*4*93(!()5(!5!-*0+.4!7.,2/!)51*!0*7*31*/'!=,(!A51*!
,-'!(.!(5>*!54.()*0!7.,0+*!.9!57(3.4C!$(5(*/!/399*0*4(26'!54!.--.0(,43(6!7.+(!
0*-0*+*4(+!54!52(*045(31*!A31*4!,-!8)*4!5!/*73+3.4!3+!:5/*C!F)3+!7.+(!3+'!
()*0*9.0*'!:.+(!0*2*154(!9.0!(8.!:,(,5226!*f72,+31*!*1*4(+C!%4!341*+(34A'!3(!3+!()*!
/399*0*47*!34!0*(,04!=*(8**4!5!7).+*4!341*+(:*4(!54/!.4*!()5(!3+!4*7*++50326!
-5++*/!,-C!
G"++1,L[[<<<D2*I#,+&1#%2.D'&)[+#/),[&[&11&/+(*2+='&,+D.,1O$AC[B@[ACS$
!
!
!
HH!
"++1,L[[<<<D)(''23#./*2*-D'&)['&)1./.+2I#F.%I.*+.-#O$
@C[BA[AC$
cD$7/&%('+2&*$7&,,20232+=$?/&*+2#/$r$P442'2#*'=$e#o(2/#)#*+$
F)*!-0./,7(3.4!-.++3=323(6!90.4(3*0!vOOLw!3+!5!7,01*!/*-37(34A!522!:5f3:,:!
.,(-,(!-.++3=323(3*+!9.0!(8.!A../+'!A31*4!5!+*(!.9!34-,(+!7.4+3+(34A!.9!0*+.,07*+!
54/!.()*0!957(.0+C!F)*!OOL!5++,:*+!()5(!522!34-,(+!50*!,+*/!*99373*4(26C!
!
G"++1,L[[<<<D2*I#,+&1#%2.D'&)[+#/),[1[1/&%('+2&*1&,,20232+=4/&*+2#/D.,1O$
RB[BA[ACS$
$
$
T113#,$
$
$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$,+/.<0#//2#,$
!
!
HW!
!
Exchange'of'Equivalents'–'Individual'and'Societal'Work'
!
34/313/,52'!-0315(*!8.0>!
!
A*4*052!+.73*(52!8.0>!
8.0>!.9!()*!3+.25(*/!
34/313/,52!
*f7)54A*!152,*'!
7.41*634A!()*!*f7)54A*!
.9!*;,3152*4(+!
(.(52!5:.,4(!.9!8.0>!34!
+.73*(6!
34/313/,52!8.0>34A!(3:*!
!
A*4*052!+.73*(52!8.0>34A!
(3:*!
!
!
HY!
Theory'of'value'
!
m,*2;,*+!-0T73+3.4+!7.47*0454(!2Q54526+*!/*!D50f!
!
O0*:3x0*:*4('! ,4*! -0T73+3.4! :T()./.2.A3;,*! .4! 5! (30T! /*! +*+! (0515,f! ,4*!
()T.03*! /*! 25! 152*,0'! :53+! 2,3<:t:*! -502*! /*! 2.3! /*! 25! 152*,0! *(! 32! 25! (30*! /*!
2Q54526+*!/*!25!:507)54/3+*C!NQ*+(!*4!*99*(!25!:507)54/3+*!;,3!*+(!-0*:3x0*!-.,0!
2,3'!*(!7Q*+(!U!-50(30!/Q*22*!;,Q32!*99*7(,*!2Q54526+*'!7.4(0530*:*4(!U!25!9.0:,25(3.4!
/*! 4.:=0*! /*! +*+! 7.::*4(5(*,0+C! NQ*+(! /30*! +3! /*+! T1.2,(3.4+! /*! 25! 9.0:*!
:507)54/3+*! *(! /*+! 7.4/3(3.4+! /*! :507)54/3+5(3.4! +.4(! /.47! /T(*0:3454(*+!
-.,0!2,3C!
!
B*,f3x:*:*4('! .4! 5! 2Q)5=3(,/*! /*! /30*! ;,*! -.,0! D50f! +*,2! 2*! (051532! *+(!
-0./,7(*,0C!NQ*+(!,4*! 5--0.f3:5(3.4!347.:-2x(*C! O.,0!2,3!2*!(051532!*(! 25!45(,0*!
+.4(! -0./,7(*,0+! /*! 152*,0+! /Q,+5A*'! *(! 7Q*+(! /*! 152*,0! ;,*! 2*! (051532! *+(! +*,2!
-0./,7(*,0C!D50f!/3+(34A,*!*4!*99*(!/54+!,4*!,43(T!/352*7(3;,*!*(!7.4(05/37(.30*!
25! 152*,0! /Q,+5A*! v/T(*0:34T*! -50! 2Q,(323+5(3.4! ;,*! 2Q.4! -*,(! 9530*! /Q,4*!
:507)54/3+*!*(! 23T*! U!+*+!-0.-03T(T+! 7.470x(*+w! *(!25! 152*,0! v/T(*0:34T*! -50!2*!
(*:-+!/*!(051532!+.7352*:*4(!4T7*++530*!-.,0!-0./,30*!25!:507)54/3+*!/54+!,4*!
9.0:5(3.4!+.7352*!*(!U!,4!:.:*4(!/.44Tw'! 25! 152*,0! /QT7)54AT! *+(! 2*! (0.3+3x:*!
(*0:*!v+.,1*4(!7.49.4/,!51*7!25!152*,0!‚!(.,(!7.,0(!ƒw!T(54(!2Q*f-0*++3.4!/*!7*((*!
7.4(05/37(3.4'!7Q*+(!,4!05--.0(!/QT7)54A*C!M4934'!2*+!152*,0+!7.00*+-.4/*4(!U!,4*!
0T523(T! ‚! *++*4(3*22*! ƒ'! ,4*! +.0(*! /*! ‚! :.6*44*! 3/T52*! ƒ! 7.::*! 32! /3('! ;,Q32!
/3+(34A,*!/*+!*f-0*++3.4+!*4!-03f!v-03f!/*!:507)T'!-03f!/*!-0./,7(3.4'!*(7Cw'!;,3!
7.00*+-.4/*4(!U!25!0T523(T!/3(*!‚!-)T4.:T452*!ƒ'!7Q*+(<U</30*!-0.7)*!/*!25!0T523(T!
/30*7(*:*4(!5--0T)*4/T*C!
!
F0.3+3x:*:*4('!+3! ,4*!7).+*!v-0./,3('! +*0137*'!=3*4! 45(,0*2! 4.4!-0./,3('! *(7Cw!5!
,4!-03f'!7*!-03f!/T(*0:34*!+.4!‚!-.,1.30!/QT7)54A*!ƒ'!:t:*!+3!7*((*!7).+*!4Q5!-5+!
/*!152*,0!v7Q*+(<U</30*!4Q*+(!-5+!,4!-0./,3(!/,!(051532wC!NQ*+(<U</30*!;,*!25!0T523(T!
-)T4.:T452*!*+(!-0*:3x0*!*('!/Q,4*!7*0(534*!95„.4!75,+52*'!2*!-03f!*+(!,4*!0T523(T!
;,3!+Q3:-.+*'!:t:*!+Q32!4*! 7.00*+-.4/!-5+! (.,\.,0+!U! ,4*!152*,0GaC! I34+3'!-.,0!
,(323+*0!,4*!9.0:,25(3.4!-2,+!:./*04*!*(!>*64T+3*44*'!25!:.4453*!*+(!-.,0!2,3!‚!
57(31*!ƒC!
!
m,5(03x:*:*4('!*(!*4!7.4+T;,*47*'!2*!-03f!+-T7,25(39!/Q,4*!:5(3x0*!-0*:3x0*!v.,!
/Q,4!(3(0*!9345473*0'!.,!/Q,4!=3*4!45(,0*2!7.::*!,4!(*00534!4,'!,4*!7),(*!/Q*5,'!
*(7Cw!+Q3:-.+*!*(!\.,*!‚!0T*22*:*4(!ƒ'!:t:*!+3!7*!-03f!7.00*+-.4/!U!,4*!152*,0!;,3!
*+(!-.,0! -50(3*!‚!/,! 1*4(!ƒC!B54+! 2*!:t:*! (*:-+'! 25!152*,0! (.(52*! /*!7*! ;,3!*+(!
-0./,3(! 7.:-(*! 5,++3! ?! 2*! -.,1.30! /QT7)54A*! /*! 7*! -03f! 15! /.47! /*1.30! t(0*!
-0T2*1T!+,0!2*!-0./,3(!(.(52'!A2.=52!/*!25!+.73T(TC!D53+!7*73!4*!\.,*!;,Q*4!:.6*44*!
*(!/54+!25!/,0T*'!*(!7*25!/.47!4*!+Q*f*07*!-5+!/54+!2*+!23:3(*+!/Q,4*!544T*!/.44T*!
?! .4! -*,(! 51.30! -*4/54(! ,4! 7*0(534! (*:-+! v/54+! 25! 0T523(T! -)T4.:T452*w! ,4*!
/T-*4+*! -2,+! T2*1T*! ;,*! 2*! (.(52! /*+! 152*,0+! v34925(3.4w! -,3+! 32! 95,/05! ,4*! ‚!
7.00*7(3.4!ƒ!-2,+!.,!:.34+!75(5+(0.-)3;,*u!
!
G;#,$%&,,2#/,$%sa'&*&)2#$#+$1&32+2o(#>$).2Fb(2*$@BAJF^K@[^KRL$@@S$
!
Hb!
Accumulation'
!
!
!
Ha!
Investment'and'Capital'
!
!
!
Hn!
Self_Alienation'of'Capitalism'
J*! 23=T0523+:*! *(! +5! 70T5(313(T! +.4(! 75057(T03+*+! -50! 2*+! 05--.0(+! 7.4(057(,*2+!
*4(0*! 34/313/,+! 23=0*+! *(! TA5,f! *4! /0.3(+'! :53+! 34TA5,f! /,! -.34(! /*! 1,*! /*! 25!
/3+-.+3(3.4!/*+!:.6*4+! :5(T03*2+! *(! 7,2(,0*2+C! J*! 23=T0523+:*!*+(!9.4/T!+,0!/*+!
0*25(3.4+!/*!/T2TA5(3.4+! 0*-0T+*4(5(31*+C!N*+!/T2TA5(3.4+!+*!0*(0.,1*4(! /54+!2*+!
;,5(0*!:.:*4(+!/*!2Q54()0.-.4.:3*!?!/T2TA5(3.4!5,f!7)*9+!/*!95:322*+'!5,f!7)*9+!
/Q*4(0*-03+*+'!5,f!T2,+!/*+!5++*:=2T*+!*(!5,f!7)*9+!/*!A.,1*04*:*4(+!*(!/QR(5(+'!
5,f!5,(*,0+!-.,0!25!7,2(,0*C!J*+!05--.0(+!/*!/T2TA5(3.4!/*!-.,1.30!+Q5--,3*4(!+,0!
/*+!0*-0T+*4(5(3.4+!.=\*7(31T*+'!/.:34T*+!-50!2*+!/T2xA,*+'!*4!0*25(3.4!51*7!2*+!
:.6*4+!/*!2Q3:-03:*03*C!
B54+! 7*+! 7.4/3(3.4+'! 5,f! 703+*+! +6+(T:3;,*+! /*! +,0577,:,25(3.4! /,05=2*! /*+!
75-3(5,f! 7.00*+-.4/053*4(! /*+! 703+*+! /*! ‚! +,=/T2TA5(3.4+! 0*-0T+*4(5(31*+! ƒ'!
7Q*+(<U</30*!/Q*f7x+!/*!/T2TA5(3.4!*(!/*!0*-0T+*4(5(3.4'!0*25(31*:*4(!7.,-T*+!/*+!
0T523(T+!+.7352*+!(054+9.0:T*+C!
!
GZ&''./.$7.(3>$@BA@$L$;#$j.12+.3$%#$5./6>$,&*$.11&/+>$,&*$%a1.,,#)#*+$.(F%#3t$%#$
3Qa'&*&)2#$O$7./2,$L$;#,$!P57:$%#,$j#e9:P:$L$AK@SK$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Y!! m,.(*/!90.:!()*!-0..9!-034(!
!
Hg!
Money'versus'Capital'
")*0*!()*0*!+).,2/!=*!,431*0+52!-0.+-*03(6!54/!)5--34*++'!()*0*!3+!83/*+-0*5/!
-.1*0(6! 54/! +,99*034AC! F).,+54/+! .9! 7.:9.0(5=2*! ).:*+'! 54/! :546! :3223.4+! .9!
/.2250+'! *504*/! =6! ()*! -5(3*4(! (.32! .9! ()*! 34/,+(03.,+! :5++*+'! )51*! =**4! +8*-(!
5856!=6!/3+5+(0.,+!341*+(:*4(+!34!:3434A!+)50*+C!c4/.,=(*/26!()*!+(.7>!:50>*(!
)5+! =**4! 5! 7)3*9! 957(.0! 34! -0./,734A! ()*! -0*+*4(! /*+(3(,(3.4! .9! ()*! -*.-2*C! %(+!
=54*9,2!*99*7(+!)51*!=**4!9*2(!34!*1*06!4*3A)=.0)../!54/!52:.+(!*1*06!95:326!34!
()*! $(5(*C! N5-3(52'! 8)37)! 3+! 5AA0*++31*! 34! 522! *4(*0-03+*+'! 3+! .:43-.(*4(! 34! ()3+C!
N.4(0.2234A!()*!51*4,*+!.9!349.0:5(3.4!90.:!()*!:34*+'!54/!)5134A!-.8*0!(.!2*16!
5++*++:*4(+!83().,(!0*+-.4+3=323(6!(.!546!7.:-*(*4(!5,().03(6'!()*!.426!23:3(!(.!
()*!5:.,4(! .9!:.4*6! 8)37)!:56! =*!*f(.0(*/! 90.:!3(+! 137(3:+!3+! ()*30!5=323(6! (.!
-56C! I+! 95+(! 5+! ()*6! 577,:,25(*'! 3(! 5=+.0=+C! %(! 3+! 5! -*09*7(! :57)34*! 9.0!
7.47*4(05(34A!8*52()C!%(!)5+!:5/*!5!9*8!:3223.4530*+!54/!5!).+(!.9!-5,-*0+C!
!
GT,,#)03=$j&))2++##$&*$j&/1&/.+2&*,>$u5.b&/2+=$e#1&/+>u$2*$j.324&/*2.$;#-2,3.+(/#>$
T11#*%26$+&$+"#$d&(/*.3,$&4$+"#$:#*.+#$.*%$T,,#)03=>$I&3D$K$G:.'/.)#*+&L$:+.+#$
7/2*+2*-$f442'#>$AC^CS>$CDO$
"++1,L[[./'"2I#D&/-[,+/#.)[.11#*%26+&b&(/*.AC^CK'.32[.11#*%26+&b&(/*.AC^CK'
.32\%bI(D+6+O$AA[B@[ACS$
!
Hs!
'
Money'or'Finance?'
!
!
!
!
WX!
!
III.'‘Concentralisation’'–'Economic'Socio_Legal'Issues'
Worlds'of'Capitalist'Welfare'Systems'
!
[M#eM$%Ie!"MJLIKM!eIF%deIJ!$FIFM!
!
!
$N}cDOMFMK%Ie!"dK[LIKM!Od$F<eIF%deIJ!$FIFM!KM&%DM!
!
Gd#,,&1>$ Z&0>$ @BBBL$ ?/&)$ +"#$ h5M:$ +&$ +"#$ :E7eO$ 2*L$ ;#<2,>$ X.23[X#<2/+]>$
:"./&*[j3./8#>$d&"*$G#%,DSO$e#+"2*82*-$:&'2.3$ 7&32'=O$;&*%&*$ #+$.3+#/.L$:.-#L$ A^AF
ACK>$"#/#$A^R$.*%$A^V$/#,1#'+2I#3=S$
!
!
WG!
Challenges'Then'and'Now'
!
Z#I#/2%-#[h#=*#,2.*$r$!"#$42I#$).b&/$%2,#.,#,$
854(!
/3+*5+*!
3A4.0514*!
+;,52.0!
3/2*4*++!
!
Z#I#/2%-#>$E2332.)>$AUK@L$:&'2.3$9*,(/.*'#$.*%$T332#%$:#/I2'#,D$7/#,#*+#%$+&$
7./32.)#*+$0=$j&)).*%$&4$W2,$5.b#,+=O$;&*%&*L$7(032,"#%$0=$W2,$5.b#,+=Q,$
:+.+2&*./=$f442'#O$"++1L[[<<<D,&'"#.3+"D'&D(8[*.+2&*.3F"#.3+"F,#/I2'#[1(032'F
"#.3+"F.*%F<#330#2*-[0#I#/2%-#F/#1&/+[0#I#/2%-#F+"/##F-(2%2*-F1/2*'213#,F
/#'&))#*%.+2&*,[O$@J[BJ[AJ$
vj(0.*$?2I#Q$
!
.1*0-0./,7(3.4!.9!A../+!54/!()*!(,04!.9!A../+!34(.!]=5/+Q!
+.73*(52!5=,4/547*!1*0+,+!34*;,523(6!.9!577*++!
5=,4/547*!.9!>4.82*/A*!54/!3(+!:3+/30*7(3.4!(.850/+!+>322!
()*!34/313/,523+5(3.4!.9!-0.=2*:+!54/!()*30!*:*0A*47*!5+!+.73*(52!()0*5(!
7.:-2*f3(6!.9!A.1*04:*4(!54/!()*!23:3(*/!+7.-*!.9!A.1*04547*C!
!
G,##$W#//).**>$7#+#/>$@BAVO$j/2,2,$.*%$*&$#*%g$e#F#)0#%%2*-$P'&*&)=$2*+&$324#$
.*%$*.+(/#O$2*L$P*I2/&*)#*+$.*%$:&'2.3$7,='"&3&-=$G@BAVSrc&3()#$A>$9,,(#$AL$AFAAO$
"++1L[[#,1D<"2&'#D'&)[2*%#6D1"1[P:7[./+2'3#[%&<*3&.%[BABBR[1%4\RO$AJ[BA[AJO$
W#//).**>$7#+#/>$@BAJL$?/&)$V$-2.*+$#I23,$+&$V$-2.*+$+#*,2&*,$F$+"#$'(//#*+$'/2,2,$&4$
'.12+.32,)$.,$,##%0#%$4&/$2+,$&I#/+(/*$F$&/L$W&<$).*=$-2-.0=+#,$".,$.$"&/,#$gO$
:#)2*./$sj&*+2*(2%.%$=$j.)02&,$#*$3.$/#3.'2&*#,$9*+#/*.'2&*.3#,s$.+$9:e9$G9*,+2+(+&$
:(1#/2&/$%#$e#3.'2&*#,$9*+#/*.'2&*.3#,$e.w3$e&.,$X./'x.S>$W.I.*.$y$
"++1,L[[<<<D/#,#./'"-.+#D*#+[1(032'.+2&*[RBACAVBAV\?/&)\V\-2.*+\#I23,\+&\V\-
2.*+\+#*,2&*,\F\+"#\'(//#*+\'/2,2,\&4\'.12+.32,)\.,\,##%0#%\4&/\2+,\&I#/+(/*\F
\&/\W&<\5.*=\X2-.0=+#\".,\.\W&/,#$z$O$X/&<+"$.*%$H#I#3&1)#*+$F$j&)13#)#*+$
&/$j&*+/.%2'+2&*g$j".33#*-#,$4&/$.$X3&0.3$T-#*%.O$:".*-".2$?&/()>$j"2*.$.*%$
;.+2*$T)#/2'.D$!"#$H#I#3&1)#*+$7./+*#/,"21$&4$+"#$!/.*,F7.'242'$:#'+2&*$
y"++1,L[[<<<D/#,#./'"-.+#D*#+[1(032'.+2&*[RBRVKU@UA\X/&<+"\.*%\H#I#3&1)#*
+\F\j&)13#)#*+\&/\j&*+/.%2'+2&*\j".33#*-#,\4&/\.\X3&0.3\T-#*%.zS$
!
!
WH!
The'Distributive'Era'
GC!F)*!703(*035!9.0!5++*++34A!-.2373*+!8322!7)54A*C!F)*!.2/!-0./,7(3.4<!
=5+*/!*7.4.:6!-03_*/!546()34A!()5(!)*2-*/!*7.4.:37!A0.8()C!%4!()*!/3+(03=,(31*!
*7.4.:6'!8)*0*!\.=+!.0!577*++!(.!A../+!50*!()*!.1*08)*2:34A!703(*035'!*7.4.:37!
A0.8()!2..>+!/*+305=2*!5+!2.4A!5+!3(!70*5(*+!\.=+C!I20*5/6'!,4-.-,250!57(313(3*+!
+,7)!5+!9057>34A!50*!\,+(393*/!.4!()3+!703(*03.4C!
F)*!703(*035!9.0!:*5+,034A!()*!*7.4.:6!8322!52+.!7)54A*C!&BO!54/!-0./,7(313(6!
5--26!=*+(!(.!()*!-)6+3752!*7.4.:6!54/!/.!4.(!7.,4(!130(,52!5/1547*+!-0.-*026!
v+**!+3/*=50'!iO0./,7(313(6!54/!&BO!A0.8()?!e.!2.4A*0!A../!:*5+,0*+VjwC!
HC!L0**<:50>*(!-)32.+.-)6!8322!=*!:.0*!/39937,2(!(.!+,--.0(!34!()*!4*8!
5(:.+-)*0*C!%(!3+!=5+*/!.4!()*!-.-,250!4.(3.4!()5(!,40*A,25(*/!:50>*(!=*)513.0!
2*5/+!(.!*7.4.:37!A0.8()C!%Q1*!+.:*!+6:-5()6!83()!()3+C!I7(,52!*7.4.:37!()*.06!
)5+!(8.!-0.-.+3(3.4+C!%9!5!:50>*(!E!()*!530234*!:50>*('!+56!E!3+!:5/*!90**!54/!
.-*05(*+!577.0/34A!(.!5!).+(!.9!+:522<-034(!*7.4.:37!7.4/3(3.4+'!3(!8322!.-*05(*!
+.!()5(!4.!0*+.,07*+!50*!85+(*/C!F)5(Q+!*99373*476C!$*7.4/'!()*0*!8322!=*!8344*0+!
54/!2.+*0+'!+.!39!8*!854(!(.!:5>*!*1*06.4*!=*((*0!.99'!()*!8344*0+!v=3A<),=!
530234*+'!34!()3+!75+*w!4**/!(.!7.:-*4+5(*!()*!2.+*0+?!+:522!530234*+!54/!-*.-2*!
8).!231*!34!0*:.(*!-257*+C!F)5(Q+!/3+(03=,(3.4'!54/!.1*0522!*1*06.4*!3+!=*((*0!.99C!
%4!-057(37*'!8)*()*0!83()!34(*045(3.452!(05/*!5A0**:*4(+!.0!/*0*A,25(3.4!.0!
90**34A!,-!:50>*(+'!()*!*99373*476!-50(!).2/+!5(!=*+(!+.0(!.9h!.9(*4!,40*A,25(*/!
=*)513.0!2*5/+!(.!7.47*4(05(3.4!5+!7.:-543*+!()5(!A*(!5)*5/!2.7>!34!()*30!
5/154(5A*C!I4/!34!-057(37*'!34!()*!c43(*/!$(5(*+!54/!@03(534'!().+*!8).!2.+*!)51*!
050*26!=**4!7.:-*4+5(*/C!%4!*5023*0!(3:*+!()*6!7.,2/!934/!/399*0*4(!\.=+'!=,(!4.8!
()5(!)5+!=*7.:*!-0.=2*:5(37C!%4!()*!/3+(03=,(31*!*05!90**<:50>*(!*99373*476!8322!
4.!2.4A*0!=*!\,+(3935=2*!39!3(!70*5(*+!8).2*!725++*+!.9!-*.-2*!8).!2.+*C!
WC!F)*!4*8!*05!8322!4.(!=*!54!*7.4.:37!.4*!=,(!5!-.23(3752!.4*C!"*Q1*!+**4!()*!
)50+)!=*A34434A+!.9!()3+!34!()*!c43(*/!$(5(*+!54/!M,0.-*C!".0>*0+!8).!)51*!
+(*5/326!2.+(!577*++!(.!()*!*7.4.:6!5+!/3A3(52!-0.7*++*+!0*-257*!()*:!)51*!5!
+*4+*!.9!()34A+!952234A!5-50('!54/!5!;,3*(!54A*0!5=.,(!3::3A05(3.4'!34*;,523(6'!54/!
500.A54(!*23(*+C!
%Q/!23>*!(.!()34>!()*!-.23(3752!,-)*5152!3+!(*:-.0506'!=,(!()*0*Q+!5!9,4/5:*4(52!
0*5+.4!3(Q+!4.(C!O0./,7(3.4'!()*!-,0+,3(!.9!:.0*!A../+'!3+!54!*7.4.:37!54/!
*4A34**034A!-0.=2*:h!/3+(03=,(3.4'!*4+,034A!()5(!-*.-2*!)51*!577*++!(.!8)5(Q+!
-0./,7*/'!3+!5!-.23(3752!-0.=2*:C!$.!,4(32!8*Q1*!0*+.21*/!577*++!8*Q0*!34!9.0!5!
2*4A()6!-*03./!.9!*f-*03:*4(5(3.4'!83()!0*15:-*/!-.23(3752!3/*5+!54/!-.-,23+(!
-50(3*+!-0.:3+34A!=*((*0!577*++!(.!()*!*7.4.:6C!
$
GT/+"(/>$ED$Z/2.*>$f'+&0#/$@BA^L$E"#/#$2,$+#'"*&3&-=$+.82*-$+"#$#'&*&)=gO$
5'h2*,#=$i(./+#/3=L$C$4DS$
$
!
WW!
UBER'criticism'
!
I(!()*!+5:*! (3:*'! c=*0! )5+! 957*/! 703(373+:! 52.4A!5(!2*5+(! +3f! /3:*4+3.4+?! L30+('!
()5(!3(! 3+!,4953026! 7.:-*(34A!83()! (5f3!/031*0+! =6!*4(*034A! ()*30!:50>*(! 83().,(!
9.22.834A! 0*A,25(3.4+! .0! 950*! +7)*/,2*+h! +*7.4/'! ()5(! 3(! 5+-30*+! (.! =*7.:*! 5!
:.4.-.26h!()30/'!()5(!3(+!750+!.0!/031*0+!50*!,4+59*!.0!,4/*034+,0*/h!9.,0()'!()5(!
3(!:56!3415/*!7,+(.:*0+Q!-031576h!939()'!()5(!3(!*45=2*+!/3+703:345(3.4!=6!/031*0+!
54/! -5++*4A*0+h! 54/! +3f()'! ()5(! 3(! 3+! ,4/*0:3434A! 8.0>34A! +(54/50/+! 9.0! (5f3!
/031*0+!54/!7.:-*4+5(34A!3(+!.84!/031*0+!-..026C!
!
Ge&-#/,>$ Z/2,"#*>$ @BA^L$ !"#$ :&'2.3$ j&,+,$ &4$ N0#/O$ 2*L$ N*2I#/,2+=$ &4$ j"2'.-&$ ;.<$
e#I2#<$ f*32*#>$ c&3D$ C@$ y@BA^z>$ 9,,D$ A>$ T/+D$ JL$ CVFAB@O$ "#/#L$ UAO$
++1L[['"2'.-&(*0&(*%D('"2'.-&D#%([('3/#I\&*32*#[I&3C@[2,,A[JS$
!
!
!
WY!
!
Modularised'labour'law'–'Modularisierung'des'Arbeitsrechts'
M+! 8`0*! *(85! 54! *34! I0=*3(+0*7)(! _,! /*4>*4'! /5++! /399*0*4_3*0*4/! 457)! /*:!
&0,4/! /*0! $7),(_=*/…09(3A>*3(! /*0! @*(0.99*4*4! \*8*32+! *34_*24*!
$7),(_34+(0,:*4(*! )*054_3*)('! `)4237)! 83*! *+! )*,(*! +7).4! =*3!
I0=*3(4*):*0`)4237)*4!/*0!L522!3+(!
llll!
d4*!:56!()34>!.9!5!25=.,0!258'!()5(!3+!/399*0*4(35(34A!+*2*7(*/!-0.(*7(31*!
34+(0,:*4(+!=5+*/!.4!()*!/*A0**!.9!()*!4**/!.9!-0.(*7(3.4!.9!()*!7.47*04*/'!
7.:-505=2*!83()!()*!+3(,5(3.4!()5(!*f3+(+!520*5/6!(./56!34!()*!75+*+!.9!;,5+3<
*:-2.6**+C!
!
GW.*.(>$W.*,>$@BAJL$:'"{*#$H2-2+.3#$T/0#2+,<#3+g$2*L$MdE$RJ[AJO$@JARF@JA^O$"#/#L$
@JAJ$r$&<*$+/.*,3.+2&*S$
!
!
T*%$<".+$%&#,$+".+$/#.33=$)#.*g$!"#$42*.3$+(/*$+".+$+"#$&*#$<"&$1/&I2%#,$<&/8$2,$
2*%##%$*&+$+"#$#)13&=#/$2+$+"#$<&/8#/$r$/#4#//2*-$+&$+"#$X#/).*$+#/),$&4$
T/0#2+-#0#/>$+"#$&*#$<"&$v1/&I2%#,Q[Q-2I#,Q$<&/8$r$#)13&=#/$.*%$T/0#2+*#")#/>$+"#$
&*#$<"&$v+.8#,Q$<&/8$
!
Wb!
[Re_]Defining'entrepreneurial'reference'frameworks'
Gs!
%4!().+*!7307,:+(547*+'!()*!P*0A5=*>5::*0!=*3!/*0!@*_30>+0*A3*0,4A!I04+=*0A!
/*73/*/!(.!+(56!()*!-0.7**/34A+!54/!(.!0*9*0!()*!9.22.834A!;,*+(3.4!(.!()*!N.,0(!
.9!q,+(37*!9.0!5!-0*23:34506!0,234A?!
]B.!I0(372*!ba!FLMc!54/!I0(372*!WvGw!.9!B30*7(31*!saZnGZMN!-0*72,/*!45(3.452!
2*A3+25(3.4!54/Z.0!5!-0.7,0*:*4(!7.4/3(3.4!.9!5!-,=237!7.4(057(34A!5,().03(6!
577.0/34A!(.!8)37)!5!(*4/*0*0!8).!854(+!(.!.=(534!5'!.0!()*'!5/1*0(3+*/!-,=237!
7.4(057(!:,+(!vGw!,4/*0(5>*!(.!-56!()*!+(599!5--.34(*/!(.!75006!.,(!()*!7.4(057(!5!
+(54/50/!.0!:343:,:!85A*!93f*/!34!()*!2*A3+25(3.4'!54/!vHw!3:-.+*!()*!+5:*!
.=23A5(3.4!.4!54!5--.34(*/!.0!-0.+-*7(31*!+,=7.4(057(.0!54/!+,=:3(!5!
7.00*+-.4/34A!,4/*0(5>34A!.9!()*!+,=7.4(057(.0!(.!()*!7.4(057(34A!5,().03(6'!
8)*0*!v5w!()*!2*A3+25(3.4!-0.13/*+!9.0!+,7)!54!.=23A5(3.4!.426!9.0!()*!
-0.7,0*:*4(!.9!-,=237!7.4(057(+!=,(!4.(!52+.!9.0!()*!5850/!.9!-0315(*!7.4(057(+'!
54/!v=w!()*!+,=7.4(057(.0!3+!*+(5=23+)*/!34!54.()*0!Mc!D*:=*0!$(5(*!54/!()*!
*:-2.6**+!.9!()*!+,=7.4(057(.0!75006!.,(!()*!+*0137*+!7.1*0*/!=6!()*!7.4(057(!
*f72,+31*26!34!()*!+,=7.4(057(.0Q+!).:*!7.,4(06VQ!
!
HY!99!
"3()!0*A50/!(.!()*!+7.-*!.9!()*!;,*+(3.4!0*9*00*/!9.0!5!-0*23:34506!0,234A'!3(!:,+(!
=*!4.(*/!()5('!,423>*!34!()*!+3(,5(3.4!8)37)!85+!5(!3++,*!34!.()*0!75+*+'!+,7)!5+!
()5(!8)37)!A51*!03+*!(.!()*!\,/A:*4(!34!K…99*0('!Mc?N?HXXg?Ggs'!B30*7(31*!saZnG!
3+!4.(!5--2375=2*!(.!()*!:534!-0.7**/34A+C!
%(!3+!7.::.4!A0.,4/!()5(!()*!(*4/*0*0!8)37)!=0.,A)(!()*!57(3.4!34!()*!:534!
-0.7**/34A+!/.*+!4.(!34(*4/!(.!-*09.0:!()*!-,=237!7.4(057(!=6!-.+(34A'!34!
&*0:54!(*003(.06'!*:-2.6**+!.9!3(+!+,=7.4(057(.0'!8)37)!3+!5!8).226<.84*/!
+,=+3/3506!*+(5=23+)*/!34!O.254/C!
d4!()*!7.4(0506'!577.0/34A!(.!()*!57(,52!8.0/34A!.9!()*!;,*+(3.4!0*9*00*/!9.0!5!
-0*23:34506!0,234A'!()5(!;,*+(3.4!7.47*04+!5!+3(,5(3.4!34!8)37)!]()*!
+,=7.4(057(.0!3+!*+(5=23+)*/!34!54.()*0!Mc!D*:=*0!$(5(*!54/!()*!*:-2.6**+!.9!
()*!+,=7.4(057(.0!75006!.,(!()*!+*0137*+!7.1*0*/!=6!()*!7.4(057(!*f72,+31*26!34!
()*!+,=7.4(057(.0Q+!).:*!7.,4(06QC!
$,7)!5!+3(,5(3.4!3+!4.(!7.1*0*/!=6!.4*!.9!()*!()0**!(054+45(3.452!:*5+,0*+!
0*9*00*/!(.!34!I0(372*!GvWw!.9!B30*7(31*!saZnG'!83()!()*!0*+,2(!()5(!()5(!/30*7(31*!3+!
4.(!5--2375=2*!(.!()*!/3+-,(*!34!()*!:534!-0.7**/34A+C!
!
d(%-#)#*+$&4$+"#$j&(/+$GM2*+"$j".)0#/S>$AC$:#1+#)0#/$@BAKL$|e#4#/#*'#$4&/$.$
1/#32)2*./=$/(32*-$}$T/+2'3#$VJ$!?PN$}$?/##%&)$+&$1/&I2%#$,#/I2'#,$}$
e#,+/2'+2&*,$}$H2/#'+2I#$UJ[^A[Pj$}$7/&'#%(/#,$4&/$+"#$.<./%$&4$1(032'$,#/I2'#$
'&*+/.'+,$}$M.+2&*.3$3#-2,3.+2&*$/#o(2/2*-$+#*%#/#/,$.*%$+"#2/$,(0'&*+/.'+&/,$+&$
(*%#/+.8#$+&$1.=$.$)2*2)()$<.-#$+&$,+.44$1#/4&/)2*-$+"#$,#/I2'#,$/#3.+2*-$+&$+"#$
1(032'$'&*+/.'+$}$:(0'&*+/.'+&/$#,+.032,"#%$2*$.*&+"#/$5#)0#/$:+.+#Q$F$j.,#$
j
VKU[ARO$"++1L[[#(/F3#6D#(/&1.D#([3#-.3F
'&*+#*+[PM[!p![W!5;[g(/2ljP;PpLJ@BARjdBVKU~4/&)lPMO$AU[B@[AC$
!
!
Wa!
'
Data''Privacy'–'volonté'générale'–'volonté'de'tous'
•c&38,]€"3(*-,(/+#23Q$
†399*0!GnW?!
}3*05,+! 9.2A(?! L0*3*! M4(952(,4A! /*0! O*0+r4237)>*3(! +*(_(! ,4(*0! /*4! :./*04*4!
@*/34A,4A*4! /*0! B5(*41*050=*3(,4A! /*4! $7),(_! /*+! M34_*24*4! A*A*4!
,4=*A0*4_(*! M0)*=,4A'! $-*37)*0,4A'! P*08*4/,4A! ,4/! "*3(*0A5=*! +*34*0!
-*0+r4237)*4!B5(*4!1.05,+C!B3*+*0!$7),(_!3+(!/5)*0!1.4!/*:!&0,4/0*7)(!/*+!I0(!
H!I=+C!G!34!P*0=34/,4A!:3(!I0(!G!I=+C!G!&&!,:95o(C!B5+!&0,4/0*7)(!A*8`)02*3+(*(!
34+.8*3(!/3*!@*9,A43+!/*+!M34_*24*4'!A0,4/+`(_237)!+*2=+(!…=*0!/3*!O0*3+A5=*!,4/!
P*08*4/,4A!+*34*0!-*0+r4237)*4!B5(*4!_,!=*+(3::*4C!
†399*0!GnY?!
=w! B3*+*+! K*7)(! 5,9! ‡349.0:5(3.4*22*! $*2=+(=*+(3::,4A‡! 3+(! 437)(! +7)054>*42.+!
A*8`)02*3+(*(C! B*0! M34_*24*! )5(! 437)(! *34! K*7)(! 3:! $344*! *34*0! 5=+.2,(*4'!
,4*34+7)0`4>=50*4! }*00+7)59(! …=*0! ‡+*34*‡! B5(*4h! *0! 3+(! 13*2:*)0! *34*! +37)!
344*0)52=! /*0! +._352*4! &*:*34+7)59(! *4(952(*4/*'! 5,9! [.::,43>5(3.4!
54A*83*+*4*!O*0+r4237)>*3(C!%49.0:5(3.4'! 5,7)! +.8*3(! +3*! -*0+.4*4=*_.A*4! 3+('!
+(*22(!*34! I==32/!+._352*0!K*523(`(! /50'!/5+!437)(! 5,++7)23*o237)!/*:! @*(0.99*4*4!
522*34!_,A*.0/4*(!8*0/*4!>544C!B5+!&0,4/A*+*(_!)5('!83*!34!/*0!K*7)(+-0*7),4A!
/*+! @,4/*+1*095++,4A+A*037)(+! :*)0957)! )*01.0A*).=*4! 3+('! /3*! $-544,4A!
%4/313/,,:! <! &*:*34+7)59(! 3:! $344*! /*0! &*:*34+7)59(+=*_.A*4)*3(! ,4/!
&*:*34+7)59(+A*=,4/*4)*3(!/*0! O*0+.4! *4(+7)3*/*4!v@P*09&M!Y'! n! zGb{h!g'!HnY!
zWHs{h! Hn'! G! zn{h! Hn'! WYY! zWbG! 9C{h! WW'! WXW! zWWY{h! bX'! HsX! zWbW{h! ba'! WnzYs{wC!
&0,4/+`(_237)! :,o! /5)*0! /*0! M34_*24*! M34+7)0`4>,4A*4! +*34*+! K*7)(+! 5,9!
349.0:5(3.4*22*! $*2=+(=*+(3::,4A! 3:! …=*083*A*4/*4! I22A*:*3434(*0*++*!
)344*):*4C!
†399*0!Gnn?!
"3*8*3(! %49.0:5(3.4*4! +*4+3=*2! +34/'! >544! )3*0457)! 437)(! 522*34! /51.4!
5=)`4A*4'!.=!+3*!34(3:*!P.0A`4A*!=*(0*99*4C!P3*2:*)0!=*/509!*+!_,0!L*+(+(*22,4A!
/*0! -*0+r4237)>*3(+0*7)(237)*4! @*/*,(,4A! *34*+! B5(,:+! /*0! [*44(43+! +*34*+!
P*08*4/,4A+_,+5::*4)54A+?!M0+(!8*44![250)*3(!/50…=*0!=*+(*)('!_,!8*27)*:!
†8*7>! I4A5=*4! 1*0254A(! 8*0/*4! ,4/! 8*27)*! P*0>4…-9,4A+:rA237)>*3(*4! ,4/!
P*08*4/,4A+:rA237)>*3(*4! =*+(*)*4'! 2`o(! +37)! /3*! L05A*! *34*0! _,2`++3A*4!
@*+7)0`4>,4A! /*+! K*7)(+! 5,9! 349.0:5(3.4*22*! $*2=+(=*+(3::,4A! =*54(8.0(*4C!
B5=*3! 3+(! _,! ,4(*0+7)*3/*4! _83+7)*4! -*0+.4*4=*_.A*4*4! B5(*4'! /3*! 34!
34/313/,523+3*0(*0'! 437)(! 54.46:3+3*0(*0! L.0:! *0).=*4! ,4/! 1*050=*3(*(! 8*0/*4!
!
Wn!
v/5_,! ,4(*0! 5w'! ,4/! +.27)*4'! /3*! 9…0! +(5(3+(3+7)*! †8*7>*! =*+(3::(! +34/! v/5_,!
,4(*0!=wC!
GZc#/4X>$AVD$ H#]#)0#/$ AUCRL$A$ ZIe$ @BU[CR>$A$ ZIe$ KCK[CR>$A$ZIe$ K@B[CR>$ A$ZIe$
RJ@[CR>$ A$ ZIe$ @JU[CR>$ A$ ZIe$ KKB[CR$ Gc&38,]€"3(*-,(/+#23SO$
"++1,L[[&1#*b(/D%#[([@JCKKBD"+)3O$AJ[B@[ACS$
!
Wg!
Neue Freiheit?
!
!
Die nichtkommerzielle Initiative für den Aufbau freier (Funk-)Netzwerke in München
Mitmachen
"*0!>544!=*3!L0*39,4>!:3(:57)*4V!
I22*!?w!
@*4r(3A*!37)!30A*4/*34*!L.0:!/*0!D3(A23*/+7)59(V!
e*34'!*+!3+(!>*34*!L.0:!/*0!D3(A23*/+7)59(!4r(3AC!
"3*!(*,*0!3+(!L0*39,4>!9…0!:37)!52+!@*4,(_*0V!
B3*!e,(_,4A! 1.4! L0*39,4>!3+(!1r223A! >.+(*42.+! ,4/!,4>.:-23_3*0(C!$3*)+(! B,! *34!
"JIe<e*(_!:3(!/*:! e5:*4! i:,*47)*4C90*39,4>C4*(j! >544+(! B,! *+!.)4*!I4A+(!
1.0! 1*0+(*7>(*4! [.+(*4! 4,(_*4! ,4/! :,++(! /37)! 437)(! 1.0)*0!>.:-23_3*0(! :3(!
B*34*4!-*0+r4237)*4!B5(*4!54:*2/*4C!
Rechtliches
"5+!)*3o(!i90*3j!=*3!L0*39,4>V!
L0*3! 3:! $344*! 1.4! 90*3*0! K*/*C! †*4+,090*3C! L0*3! 3:! $344*! 1.4! ]d)4*! 8*3(*0*!
[.+(*4QC!L0*3!3:!$344*!1.4!i>.:-2*((!.)4*!M34+7)0`4>,4A*4jC!"30!1*0+(*)*4!90*3!
52+! r99*4(237)! _,A`4A237)'! 437)(! >.::*0_3*22'! 3:! @*+3(_! /*0! &*:*34+7)59(! ,4/!
,4_*4+3*0(C!
"5+!3+(!:3(!/*0!$(r0*0)59(,4AV!
"30!=*(0*3=*4!_*4(052*!†,A54A+-,4>(*!34!B*,(+7)254/'!/3*! /*4!%4(*04*(1*0>*)0!
34+!I,+254/!,:2*3(*4C! B5/,07)!+34/!/3*! @*(0*3=*0%44*4!*34*+![4.(*4+! /3*!3)0*4!
%4(*04*(_,A54A! (*32*4! 437)(! 3/*4(393_3*0=50C! B5:3(! L0*39,4>! 9,4>(3.43*0*4! >544'!
:…++*4!+37)!5=*0!522*!@*4,(_*0%44*4!54!/3*!e,(_,4A+=*/34A,4A*4!)52(*4C!
!
%+(!L0*39,4>!/544!437)(!/3*!DrA237)>*3(!,:!*+!9…0!322*A52*!†8*7>*!_,!1*08*4/*4V!
&0,4/+`(_237)!)5=*4!+37)! *0+(! *34:52! 522*! @*4,(_*0%44*4! 54!A*83++*!K*A*24! _,!
)52(*4'! /3*! ,4(*0! /*:! O37.! O**034A! IA0**:*4(! 5,9A*9…)0(! +34/C! e5(…0237)! +34/!
+.27)*! K*A*24! >*34*! &5054(3*! 9…0! *34! 1.0=32/237)*+! P*0)52(*4! 522*0!
I48*4/*0%44*4'! 5=*0! *+! A3=(! *34! -550! O,4>(*'! /3*! A*A*4! *34*! 322*A52*! e,(_,4A!
+-0*7)*4?!
!
B5+!L0*39,4>4*(_!*0:rA237)(!,4(*0!54/*0*:!†,A54A!_,:!%4(*04*(C!B3*+*0!†,A54A!
3+(!437)(!/59…0!A*/57)('!,:!A0.o*!B5(*4:*4A*4!v_C@C!B.842.5/+!1.4!L32:*4w!_,!
*0:rA237)*4'! +.4/*04! /3*4(! )5,-(+`7)237)! /*0! %49.0:5(3.4+=*+7)599,4AC!
!
Ws!
B*:*4(+-0*7)*4/! 3+(! /*0! I4+7)2,++! 437)(! +.! +7)4*22! 83*! *34! )*3:3+7)*0! B$J<
I4+7)2,++C! c4+*0! B3*4+(2*3+(*0! 9…0! /3*! I4.46:3+3*0,4A! >.+(*(! >45--! GX! ˆ! -0.!
D.45(! ,4/! 3+(! 8*+*4(237)! +7)4*22*0C! &0,4/+`(_237)! +.22(*4! 830! /5:3(! 5,9)r0*4!
*34*! F*7)4.2.A3*! 54! /*:! A0ro(! :rA237)*4! $7)5/*4! _,! :*++*4C! L0*39,4>! =3*(*(!
,4+! 13*2*! (.22*! DrA237)>*3(*4'! /3*! 830! 4,(_*4! +.22(*4C! B,07)! /*4! 54.46:*4!
†,A54A!_,:!%4(*04*(!830/!/3*!P*09.2A,4A!1.4!$(059(5(*4!*0+7)8*0(k!
!
L32*+)5034A!830/!>25++3+7)!437)(!34!.99*4*4!"JIe+!=*(03*=*4C!I4!/*:!)*3:3+7)*4!
%4(*04*(54+7)2,++! 8*0/*4! +*)0! 13*2! )r)*0*! @54/=0*3(*4! *0_3*2('! 8./,07)! *34!
.99*4*+! "JIe<e*(_'! 5,9A0,4/! /*0! O*09.0:547*'! ,434(*0*++54(! 830/C! "*3(*0)34!
+34/! K*7)(+1*02*(_,4A*4! 34! .99*4*4! "JIe<e*(_*4! =3+)*0! 437)(! 34!
4*44*4+8*0(*:! c:954A! =*>544(! A*8.0/*4C! †,+`(_237)! A*)*4! /3*! &*+*(_A*=*0!
5,7)!/51.4!5,+'!/5++!/*0!†,A54A!_,:!%4(*04*(!A0,4/+`(_237)!54.46:!1*08*4/*(!
8*0/*4!>544C!
$
"++1,L[[44)('D*#+[4.o[O$@B[B@[AC$
$
!
YX!
New Freedom?
!
!
$
!/.*,3.+#%$<2+"$<<<DH##1;D'&)[!/.*,3.+&/$
$
The non-commercial initiative for the establishment of free (radio) networks in
Munich
taking part
").!754!-50(373-5(*!34!L0*39,4>V!
I22?w!
B.!%!4**/!546!9.0:!.9!:*:=*0+)3-V!
e.'!()*0*!3+!4.!9.0:!.9!:*:=*0+)3-!0*;,30*/C!
}.8!*f-*4+31*!3+!90**!05/3.!9.0!:*!5+!5!,+*0V!
F)*! ,+*! .9! L0*39,4>! 3+! 7.:-2*(*26! 90**! 54/! ,47.:-2375(*/C! %9! 6.,! +**! 5! "JIe!
4*(8.0>!83()!()*!45:*!‡:,*47)*4C!90*39,4>C!4*(‡!6.,!754!,+*!3(!83().,(!9*50!.9!
)3//*4! 7.+(+! 54/! /.! 4.(! )51*! (.! 2.A! 34! 7.:-2375(*/! 83()! 6.,0! -*0+.452! /5(5!
=*9.0*)54/C!
Legal matters
")5(!/.*+!‡90**‡!:*54!5(!L0*39,4>V!
L0**!34!()*!+*4+*!.9!90**!+-**7)C!N*4+.0+)3-<90**C!L0**!34!()*!+*4+*!.9S!e.!9,0()*0!
7.+(+SC! L0**! 34! ()*! +*4+*! .9! ‡7.:-2*(*26! 83().,(! 0*+(037(3.4+‡C! "*! ,4/*0+(54/!
.,0+*21*+! 5+! .-*4! (.! ()*! -,=237'! 4.4<7.::*07352'! 7.::,43(6<.84*/! 54/!
,47*4+.0*/C!
")5(!5=.,(!()*!34(*09*0*47*!235=323(6V!
"*!.-*05(*!7*4(052!577*++!-.34(+!34!&*0:546!()5(!/31*0(!%4(*04*(!(059937!5=0.5/C!
F)3+! :*54+! ()5(! ()*! .-*05(.0+! .9! 5! 4./*! +)5034A! ()*30! %4(*04*(! 577*++! 50*! 4.(!
3/*4(3935=2*C!%4!.0/*0!9.0!L0*39,4>!(.!8.0>'!522!,+*0+!:,+(!7.:-26!83()!()*!(*0:+!
.9!,+*C!
!
%+4S(!90**!05/3.!()*4!()*!-.++3=323(6!(.!,+*!3(!9.0!322*A52!-,0-.+*+V!
@5+375226'! 522! ,+*0+! )51*! (.! 5=3/*! =6! 7*0(534! 0,2*+! 23+(*/! 34! ()*! O37.! O**034A!
IA0**:*4(C!d9!7.,0+*'!+,7)!0,2*+!50*!4.!A,5054(**!9.0!()*!*f*:-2506!=*)513.,0!
.9!522!,+*0+'!=,(!()*0*!50*!5!9*8!-.34(+!()5(!+-*5>!5A534+(!322*A52!,+*?!
!
!
YG!
F)*!90**!05/3.!4*(8.0>!-0.13/*+!577*++!(.!()*!%4(*04*('!5:.4A!.()*0!()34A+C!F)3+!
577*++!3+!4.(! 34(*4/*/!(.!522.8! 250A*!5:.,4(+!.9! /5(5!v*C!AC!/.842.5/+!.9!932:+w!
=,(! 3+! :53426! 9.0! ()*! -,0-.+*! .9! .=(53434A! 349.0:5(3.4C! I77.0/34A26'! ()*!
7.44*7(3.4!3+!4.(!5+!95+(!5+!5!/.:*+(37!B$J!7.44*7(3.4C!d,0!+*0137*!-0.13/*0!9.0!
54.46:3_5(3.4! 7.+(+! \,+(! ,4/*0! GX! ˆ! -*0! :.4()! 54/! 3+! 7.4+3/*05=26! 95+(*0C!
@5+375226'! 8*! +).,2/! +(.-! :*5+,034A! (*7)4.2.A6! 5A534+(! ()*! A0*5(*+(! -.++3=2*!
/5:5A*C! L0**! 05/3.! .99*0+! ,+! :546! A0*5(! .--.0(,43(3*+! ()5(! 8*! +).,2/! ,+*C!
I4.46:.,+!577*++!(.!()*!%4(*04*(!:5>*+!3(!/39937,2(!(.!-0.+*7,(*!703:*+k!
!
L32*! +)5034A! 3+! 4.(! (05/3(3.45226! .-*05(*/! 34! .-*4! "JIe+C! I(! ()*! /.:*+(37!
%4(*04*(! 7.44*7(3.4! :,7)! )3A)*0! =54/83/()+! 50*! 57)3*1*/'! 8)*0*=6! 54! .-*4!
"JIe! 4*(8.0>! =*7.:*+! ,434(*0*+(34A! /,*! (.! ()*! -*09.0:547*C! L,0()*0:.0*'!
349034A*:*4(+!.9!03A)(+!34!.-*4!"JIe!4*(8.0>+!)51*!4.(!6*(!=*7.:*!>4.84!(.!
546!+3A4393754(!*f(*4(C!%4!5//3(3.4'!2*A3+25(.0+!5++,:*!()5(!577*++!(.!()*!%4(*04*(!
754!=*!,+*/!54.46:.,+26C!
$
"++1,L[[44)('D*#+[4.o[O$@B[B@[AC$
$
!
YH!
Licensed Openness
$
$
$
"++1,L[[<<<D-*(D&/-[32'#*,#,[O$@BDB@DAC$
!
YW!
$
IV.'Annex'
Some'general'contemporary'socio_economic'processes'
GC /*<930:3+5(3.4! E!()*!(*4/*476!.9!()*!725++3752!*4(*0-03+*!(.!2..+*!3(+!
7.:-2*f!+.73.<*7.4.:37!:*5434A!
HC /*<+-573523+5(3.4!E!()*!=2,0034A!54/!7)54A*/!34(*0:34A234A!.9!()*!/399*0*4(!
/3:*4+3.4+!.9!]:*5434AS!.9!+-57*!
WC /*<725++39375(3.4!5+!:5((*0!.9!+)39(34A!54/!;,*+(3.434A!.9!+.7352!725++*+!54/!
+(05(5!
YC /*<9.0:5(3.4!E!()*!(*4/*476!.9!>4.84!-5((*04+!.9!S*/,75(3.452!9.0:5(3.4Q!
2..+34A!9.,4/5(3.4!54/!:*5434A!
bC /*<2*A3+25(3.4! E! ()*! /*70*5+34A! :*5434A! .9! 72*50! 54/! /,05=2*! 2*A52!
905:*8.0>+!54/!7.4/3(3.4+'!3472,/34A!()*!]7)503(3=23+5(3.4!.9!+.7352!03A)(+Q!
aC /*<3/*4(39375(3.4!E!.77,0034A!52+.!5+!]=3A<=0.()*03+5(3.4Q!
nC /*<-*0+.4523+5(3.4! E! -505/.f375226! .77,0034A! 5+! .1*0*:-)5+3+! .9!
34/313/,523+:'! (5>34A! 9.0:+! 5+! ()*6! 50*! 34! +.73.2.A6! /3+7,++*/! 5+!
%4954(323+5(3.4'!@,04<d,(!$.73*(6'!*f-*03*47*! +.73*(6'!2*3+,0*!(3:*!+.73*(6'!
54/!()*!23>*b!
gC /*<-.23(3+5(3.4! E!5+!-50(!.9!5!83/*0!-0.7*++!()5(!/*52+!83()!239*<+(62*!
7).37*+! 5+! ()*! 0*52! 7).37*'! +,AA*+(34A! 34! ()*! *f(0*:*! 75+*! ()5(! ()*! 0*52!
7).37*!3+!5=.,(!83()/05834A!90.:!-.23(37+'!+,AA*+(34A!()5(!3(!3+!IJB%<45(31<!
2.+?!@…0A*0!*4(25+(*4C!"30!+*4>*4!/3*!O0*3+*CQ!E!I!-,4?!=0.5/26!(054+25(*/!
5+!]()*0*!3+!4.!52(*045(31*!(.!IJB%!5+!3(!3+!IJB%!()5(!0*23*1*+!-0*++,0*!90.:!
73(3_*4+!=6!2.8*034A!()*!-037*+QCa!N.4(34,34A!()*!-,4!34!M4A23+)!254A,5A*'!
8*! +**! ()5(! ()*! +64.46:! 9.0! (*0:+! 23>*! ]0*23*1*! -0*++,0*! 9.0:Q'!
],4=,0/*4Q'! ]0*23*134AQ! 3+! v%2,#*-.-2*-QD!$.!E!*1*4!39!4.(!4*7*++50326!
34(*4/*/'!3(!3+!957(,5226!()*!.03*4(5(3.4!.4!34/313/,52+'!4.(!=.()*034A!5=.,(!
-.23(37+! 54/! -.2373*+! 5+! ()3+! 3+! /*7250*/! (.! =*! (5+>! .9! ()*! ]*4(0*-0*4*,0Q'!
52+.! )3A)26! 34/313/,523+(! 54/! +(623+*/! 5+! 7)503+:5(37! -*0+.4523(6C! $).,2/!
8*! +56! ()5(! 3(! +,AA*+(+! ()*! *4(0*-0*4*,0! 5+! 4*8! ]95()*0! 93A,0*! .9! ()*!
7.,4(06QVn!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
b!! $**!*CAC! $(3*A2*0'! @*04)50/'!HXGG?!%4954(323+5(3.4h!O503+! ?! q@†!‰!N3*'!h! $7),2_*'!&*0)50/'!HXXb?!()*!Mf-*03*47*!$.73*(6h!
J.4/.4?!$5A*h!}54'!@6,4A<N),2'!HXGb?!F)*!@,04<d,(!$.73*(6h!$(549.0/?!$(549.0/!c431*0+3(6!O0*++!
a!! .()*0+!50*!*CAC !h!
)((-?ZZ888C).03_.4(C4*(Z:50>*(34AZ457)037)(*4ZI2/3<$,*/<$.<8322</*0<B3+7.,4(*0<:3(<+*34*:<L03+7)*<O0.A05::<
/*4<"5)2>5:-9<5,9:3+7)*4<GaXaaWh!WXZGXZGnh!52+.!)((-+?ZZ888C52/345(312.+C/*ZŠZh!WXZGXZGn!
n!! I!/*(532'!5+!(346!5+!3(!3+'!3+!*;,5226!(*2234A!8)*4!3(!7.:*+!(.!()*!)*A*:.437!+6+(*:!54/!2..>34A!9.0!547).034A!-.34(+!9.0!
-.-,23+(+C! %(! ,4/*0234*+! ()*! :*5434A! .9! ]*4(0*-0*4*,0352! 5((3(,/*Q! 54/! 7.47*04+! ()*! +(623+5(3.4! .9! 34/313/,523+(!
*4(0*-0*4*,0352! +-303(?! -0*+,:5=26! ()*! 0*-0*+*4(5(3.4! .9! ).4*+(6! 54/! 7.4(0.2C! $.! *1*4! *4(*0-03+*+! 83()! 5! 2.4A!
(05/3(3.4!5+!:*/3,:<!(.!250A*<+*3_*/!-*09.0:547*!5/1*0(3+*!()*:+*21*+!5+!]-0315(*Z95:326!*4(*0-03+*Q!
!
YY!
sC N)5057(*03+(375226! 522! .9! ()*:! 50*! 9,4/5:*4(5226! 7.47*0434A! ()*! 0*<
+)5-34A!.9!()*!*7.4.:37!9.0:5(3.4!54/!()*6!50*!9,4/5:*4(5226!0*<+)5-34A!
()*!9.,0!/3:*4+3.4+!-0*+*4(*/!5+!*f(*4/*/!0*A,25(3.43+(!5--0.57)C!E!$(322'!
5((*4(3.4! 3+! 5(! -0*+*4(! *+-*735226! /30*7(*/! (.850/+! 7)54A*+! .9! ()*!
577,:,25(3.4! 0*A3:*! ()5(! 754! =*! +**4! 5+! 7*4(052! 957(.0+! =*)34/! ()*!
*:*0A*47*!.9!-.-,23+:C!IA534'!8*!50*!:53426!2..>34A!5(!()*!]522.75(3.4!.9!
()*! 4*(! -0./,7(! =*(8**4! 7.4+,:-(3.4! 54/! 577,:,25(3.4Q! 54/! *1*4!
4500.8*0!5(!()*!-0.7*++!.9!577,:,25(3.4!3(+*29C!
!
!
Yb!
Tulip'Mania'
!
F)*!95:.,+!(,23-:5435'!8)37)!+58!()*!0*-.0(*/!-037*+!.9!+*1*052!=0**/+!.9!(,23-!
=,2=+!03+*!(.!5=.1*!()*!152,*!.9!5!9,043+)*/!2,f,06!).,+*!34!Gn()!7*4(,06!
I:+(*0/5:'!85+!54!50(3957(!70*5(*/!=6!54!3:-2373(!7.41*0+3.4!.9!.0/34506!9,(,0*+!
7.4(057(+!34(.!.-(3.4!7.4(057(+!34!54!3:-*09*7(26!+,77*++9,2!5((*:-(!=6!B,(7)!
9,(,0*+!=,6*0+!54/!-,=237!.9937352+!(.!=532!()*:+*21*+!.,(!.9!-0*13.,+26!347,00*/!
+-*7,25(31*!2.++*+!34!()*!3:-0*++31*26!-037*<*99373*4('!9,4/5:*4(5226!/031*4'!
:50>*(!9.0!B,(7)!(,23-!7.4(057(+C!F)*0*!85+!(),+!4.()34A!:5435752!5=.,(!-037*+!
34!()3+!-*03./C!B*+-3(*!.,(850/!5--*50547*+'!()*!(,23-:5435!85+!4.(!5!=,==2*!
=*75,+*!=,==2*+!0*;,30*!()*!*f3+(*47*!.9!:,(,5226<5A0**/<,-.4!-037*+!()5(!
*f7**/!9,4/5:*4(52!152,*+C!F)*!i(,23-:5435j!85+!+3:-26!5!-*03./!/,034A!8)37)!
()*!-037*+!34!9,(,0*+!7.4(057(+!)5/!=**4!2*A5226'!52=*3(!(*:-.050326'!7.41*0(*/!
34(.!.-(3.4+!*f*073+*!-037*+C!
!
G!"&)1,&*>$P./3$TD>$@BBJL$!"#$+(321).*2.L$?.'+$&/$./+24.'+gO$2*L$7(032'$j"&2'#$
G@BBJS$ARBL$UUrAAKO$"#/#L$UUO$$Hf9$ABDABB^[,AAA@^FBBJFUB^KFKS$
!
llll!
!
%4!-50(37,250'!()*6!(*22!,+!()5('!.4!L*=0,506!HY'!GaWn'!5!250A*!.0A543_5(3.4!.9!
B,(7)!92.03+(+!54/!-254(*0+'!34!5!/*73+3.4!()5(!85+!25(*0!05(393*/!=6!B,(7)!
2*A3+25(,0*+!54/!7.,0(+'!544.,47*/!()5(!522!7.4(057(+!803((*4!59(*0!e.1*:=*0!
WX'GaWa!54/!=*9.0*!()*!0*<.-*434A!.9!()*!75+)!:50>*(!34!()*!$-034A!-.++*++*/!
-0.13+3.4+!()5(!8*0*!4.(!34!()*!.03A3452!7.4(057(+C!F)*!4*8!-0.13+3.4+!0*23*1*/!
()*30!7,+(.:*0+!.9!()*30!.03A3452!,47.4/3(3.452!7.4(057(,52!.=23A5(3.4+!(.!=,6!()*!
9,(,0*!(,23-+!5(!()*!+-*7393*/!7.4(057(!-037*!=,(!/*:54/*/!()5(!()*6!7.:-*4+5(*!
()*!-254(*0+!83()!5!93f*/!-*07*4(5A*!.9!()*30!7.4(057(!-037*+!F)*!-0.13+3.4+'!34!
*99*7('!7.41*0(*/!()*!9,(,0*+!-037*+!34!()*!.03A3452!7.4(057(+!(.!*f*073+*!-037*+!34!
.-(3.4+!7.4(057(+C!
G902%DL$ABAS$
!
Ya!
Sixty'Seconds'Online'
!
!
!
G"++1,L[[<<<D,)./+2*,2-"+,D'&)[2*+#/*#+F)./8#+2*-F,+.+2,+2',[".11#*,F&*32*#F
JBF,#'&*%,[.++.'")#*+[<".+F".11#*,F&*32*#F2*FJBF,#'&*%,[O$AU[B@[ACS$
!
!
!
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
There is no end of the crisis in sight. Even more, the long nightmare of forcing Greece onto its knees during the first half of 2015, using banks instead of tanks, shows the contempt for mankind by established superior powers when it comes to defending their interest in a Hobbesian war, irrespective of subsequent human tragedies. A more detailed and radical analysis is needed, allowing a change of the structures underlying the current situation. One point in question is that the European tragedy was and is part of a global drama. The discussion of main paradigms as growth, nationality, statehood and the like have to be at the heart of any debates, questioning their validity. A radical shift is needed, aiming at a proactive and provocative re-interpretation of the future.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This presentation approaches general issues of development, suggesting huge potentials for alternative development strategies. They are discussed about an understanding of eco-technological conditions – the eco referring to ecological and economic aspects of the antroponomic system.
Presented to Parliament by Command of His Majesty; London: Published by His Majesty's Stationary Office
  • William Beveridge
Beveridge, William, 1942: Social Insurance and Allied Services. Presented to Parliament by Command of His Majesty; London: Published by His Majesty's Stationary Office; http://www.sochealth.co.uk/national--health--service/public--health--and--wellbeing/beveridge--report/beveridge--three--guiding--principles--