ArticlePDF Available

Problems with Fat, Oil, and Grease (FOG) in Food Industry Wastewaters and Recovered FOG Recycling Methods Using Anaerobic Co-Digestion: A Short Review

Trans Tech Publications Ltd
Key Engineering Materials
Authors:
  • Bio Re Ltd

Abstract and Figures

Food production industry is the main producer of wastewaters with high fat, oil, and grease (FOG) content. FOG waste can be recovered from the wastewater stream by using physicochemical methods and reused considering their high methane potential. Popular method of FOG reuse is anaerobic co-digestion (AcoD) with wastewater treatment sludge and scum from the primary wastewater sedimentation tanks. This short review focuses on understanding the efficiency of FOG reuse possibilities by AcoD and takes a closer look at problems connected to degradation issues, gives an understanding on microbial changes during FOG degradation, and reviews enzymes involved in the degradation process.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Problems with Fat, Oil, and Grease (FOG) in Food Industry Wastewaters
and Recovered FOG Recycling Methods Using Anaerobic Co-Digestion:
a Short Review
Elvis Klaucansa*, Karlis Samsb
AURAVIA LATVIA Ltd., Mukusalas 41B, Riga, Latvia
aelvis.klaucans@auravia.lv, bkarlis.sams@auravia.lv
Keywords: fat, oil, grease, FOG, anaerobic codigestion, enzyme usage in biodegradation, food
processing wastewater
Abstract. Food production industry is the main producer of wastewaters with high fat, oil, and grease
(FOG) content. FOG waste can be recovered from the wastewater stream by using physicochemical
methods and reused considering their high methane potential. Popular method of FOG reuse is
anaerobic co-digestion (AcoD) with wastewater treatment sludge and scum from the primary
wastewater sedimentation tanks. This short review focuses on understanding the efficiency of FOG
reuse possibilities by AcoD and takes a closer look at problems connected to degradation issues, gives
an understanding on microbial changes during FOG degradation, and reviews enzymes involved in
the degradation process.
Introduction
Food production facilities are some of the biggest clean water consumers in municipalities due to
their technological demands. Food production wastewaters (WW) usually contain high organic
content together with increased fat, oil, and grease concentrations. Studies showed that FOG
production per capita in developing countries is increasing, and it was 50 kg/year per citizen in 2015;
whereas, in non-developing countries it reached around 20 kg/year on average per citizen [1]. FOG
suppresses WW treatment systems by clogging the pipelines and eliminating further wastewater
treatment processes [2]. There are various options for FOG recovery from WW stream and for use as
renewable materials in order to replace high quality grade raw materials and materials of fossil origin.
The aim of this short review is to highlight the major sources of FOG, to see how their
physicochemical characteristics influence WW treatment, to estimate suitable recovered FOG reuse
techniques with focus on FOG anaerobic co-digestion process, to understand microbial changes, and
to state enzymes and their role in FOG digestion over biogas formation process.
Characteristics of Food Processing Wastewater
Physicochemical characteristics of food processing WW are varying due to food processing
technologies used [3], but they all has similar problems, e.g., high biological oxygen demand (BOD),
increased total suspended solid (TSS) content, they are rich in protein and total nitrogen (Ntot), and
have high FOG concentration. Fat, oil, and grease emission in WW comes from fish filleting, meat
cutting and primary processing, high and low temperature treatment, and product cooking using deep-
frying methods. Table 1 represents the average WW chemical compositions for seafood and meat
processing plants, which use smoking techniques [4], as well as average restaurant WW effluent in
comparison to typical municipal WW parameters [5].
Table 1. Wastewater chemical composition in meat and seafood processing in comparison to typical
municipal wastewaters
Parameter
See food processing
wastewaters [mg/L]
Meat processing
wastewaters
[mg/L]
Restaurant
wastewaters
[mg/L]
Typical municipal
wastewaters [mg/L]
Total COD
8 00018 700
9 60012 900
12504500
210740
Total BOD
100072 000
2 5008 000
8203000
150350
Total suspended solids
(TSS)
5002000
7903 350
2202700
120450
Total Nitrogen (Ntot)
200 - 300
230260
2080
Total Phosphorus
(P tot)
3050
623
FOG [mg/L]
2505000
1002000
1404100
Physicochemical Characteristics of FOG and Influence on Wastewater Treatment Process
High FOG concentration in WW is discussed as one of the most growing and hard to resolve
problems due to physicochemical characteristics of waste and problems with its handling during cold
seasons. FOG mainly consists of long chain fatty acids (LCFA) that are bonded to glycerol, esters,
waxes, phospholipids, sterols, and sterol esters. Due to the high concentration of LCFA, it has a
slightly acidic pH value. Fatty acid content in FOG varies but generally wastes are rich in oleic acid
(18:1 cis), elaidic acid (C18:1 trans) and palmitic acid (C16:0) which are hard to degrade and cause
toxic effect to microflora. Material is not classified as biohazardous although its biodegradation is
inhibited by its physicochemical abilities. [6]. Chemical composition of FOG in combination with its
nonpolar nature and specific gravity (less than 1.0) makes them float on top of the water surface. At
room temperature and higher FOG is in semi liquid state and is readily mixable with water. However,
the decrease of temperature results in solidification, and at this state it is hardly movable and
completely water immiscible [7]. FOG tends to stick on nonpolar surfaces, such as fermenter walls
and pipe walls, causing pipe clogging and decreases their lifetime due to corrosive anaerobic
processes and hydrogen sulfide gas formation. FOG’s viscosity correlates with concentration of
unsaturated fatty acids in triglyceride ester composition the higher the concentration, the lower the
viscosity of FOG. Ineffectively pretreated food processing WW with high FOG content increases the
organic load rate on the further aerobic treatment process and affects the oxygen mass transfer in
aeration tanks [8] as well as sludge dewatering processes by adhesion on biomass surface [9].
FOG Removal from Wastewater Stream
Most of WW pretreatment systems are able to remove up to 90% of FOG from effluent [3]. FOG
removal has to be considered in small food processing facilities and restaurant business scale sites by
gravity or hydro chemical grease traps. The main waste product of this treatment is grease trap waste
[10] with approximate organic matter content ranged from 50 to 80 w/w% [11]. Advanced removal
techniques, e. g., primary sedimentation, dissolved air flotation units, FOG screens, are applied at
industrial food processing facilities and wastewater treatment plants [12]. Depending on technique
used, waste product is classified as waste scum and can contain form 8-50 w/w% of organic matter
[13].
Utilization and Reuse of Recovered FOG
There are numerous possibilities for FOG reuse because of its high energetic value, e.g., agricultural
sector in land farming applications and composting. However, it can have a bad influence on roots of
plants by disturbing the water uptake during regular fertilizing. Deposition of FOG in municipal
landfills is another disposal method; it is considered to be one of the less favorable from
environmental and economical points of view because of methane production during FOG
decomposition and the unused economic potential [4]. Turning FOG into renewable energy is more
reasonable by using transesterification methods and producing biodiesel as alternative to fossil fuel,
and in such way decreasing high quality oil demand [14, 15]. However, many authors point out
problems of recovered FOG: varying chemical composition and differences between industrial brown
sewer grease, WW scum, and grease trap waste from restaurants that affects esterification reaction
[16, 17]. FOG reuse using biological methods is the most effective because of minor effect of varying
material characteristics. Recovered FOG can be used in WW treatment sludge anaerobic co-digestion
(AcoD) processes as extra carbon source in order to increase methane yield. Nevertheless, there are
still many unresolved technical problems with recovered FOG use due to the tendency of fatty clump
formation in system and grease cap formation on top of digestion mass [18]. Use of enzymes and bio-
surfactants has a high potential to enhance FOG digestion efficiency and total methane yield in
anaerobic digestion [19].
Anaerobic Digestion of High Content FOG Waste
There is an open research on FOG waste usage in AcoD aimed at increasing methane yield. Lipids
have 10 times higher biogas potential than carbohydrates and 2 times higher biogas potential than
proteins [20]. Over load of FOG in codigestion may lead to process inhibition, which is mainly
caused by toxic effect of LCFA accumulation and hydrophobic properties of FOG, such as mass
transfer limitations, sludge flotation and washout, digester foaming, pump and pipe blockages [21].
Many anaerobic digestion plants are not suitable for FOG co-digestion due to technological design.
It is discovered that step feed AcoD methods are more suitable for establishing the optimal organic
loading rate for each individual type of digestion technologies [24]. Technical updates in substrate
dosage combined with bio-surfactant use to improve FOG emulsification can help to achieve even
178 % increase in methane yield for anaerobic digestion plants using grease interceptor waste as co-
digestion substrate for municipal wastewater treatment plant secondary sludge (SS) [22, 23]. Table 2
shows mesophilic semi-continuous AcoD efficiency for FOG containing substrates from different
origin and summarises popular process problems. There is a lack of information about FOG co-
digestion with agro-industrial origin substrates. Agro-industrial biogas production would be able to
benefit from FOG use as alternative source to decrease corn and maize demand, which is manly
subsidized by state governments. Anaerobic reactor techniques, e.g., up-flow anaerobic sludge
blanket reactor and inverse anaerobic sludge blanket reactor process, are promising techniques for
WW treatment with high FOG content [25, 4]. Technology offers to treat WW with high organic
content without separating FOG from WW stream; this would be beneficial for small scale food
factories which are located far from municipal WW treatment plants. Another beneficial aspect of
anaerobic WW treatmet is less activated sludge discharge compared to aerobic treatment technologies
due to methane production. It is possible to turn up to 95% of organic matter into biogas by achieving
up to 600 LCH4/kg VS [26]. The process is sensitive to FOG concentration variance in feed stock
causing sludge flotation. Problem could be solved by use of anaerobic membrane bioreactor
technologies that solve biomass washout problems and increase treatment efficiency [27, 28].
FOG source
FOG
content
FOG
Loaded
from
total
VS*
HRTa
[d]
OLRb
[gVS/L/day]
Methane yield
[LCH4/kgVSadd]
Biogas
increase
[%]
Methane
conc.
[%]
Stated problems
Ref.
Grease interceptor
waste from
municipal waste
water treatment
plant.
10 v/v%
65.5
v/v%
20
133
752
317
66,9
Process inhibition after 84%
addition of FOG from total
VS.
Unstable substrate dosage.
Unstable process
performance.
[23]
FOG collecting
facility waste
2.97 w/w%
64%
15
2.34
598
137
66,8
Process inhibition after 74%
addition of FOG from total
VS.
Long microbial acclimation
time and recovery time.
[29]
Fat waste from veal
cutting
98 w/v%
2.5%
40
1.3
520
219
61
pH drop during incubation
time.
Low organic loading rates
due to LCFA inhibition.
[30]
Extracted FOG from
restaurant food
waste
71.8 w/v%
42%
20
5.2
n. d.c
45.4
n. d.
Process inhibition after 55%
addition of FOG from total
VS.
Unstable digestion process.
LCFA accumulation.
[31]
Grease trap sludge
from meat
processing plant
57%
30%
20
1.15
456
52
67.5
Negative impact of Oleic
acid deposition.
[32]
Grease sludge from
primary clarifier
skimmings in
municipal WW
treatment plant
64%
40%
15
3.1
660d
46
70
Process inhibition and
instability from 60-90% of
FOG addition from total VS.
Foaming effect.
[33]
Microbial Cultures Involved in FOG Digestion
Understanding the changes in microbiome induced by FOG digestion using AcoD is one of the key
factors for successful FOG conversion to biogas. Syntrophic β-oxidizing bacteria work as primary
triglyceride digesters, and their relative abundance increases together with LCFA concentration.
During the changes of microbial consortium, an increase of Proteobacteria - Syntropohomonas sp.
species is detected and it inhibits Methanogenic arhea concentration [34]. LCFA deposition inhibits
acetoclastic and methanogenic arhea growth disrupting their metabolism [35], which slow down
hydrolysate conversion into methane [36, 37]. Lately researchers have found that Gram-negative
facultative anaerobic Proteobacteria Rheinheimera sp. and Bacillus sp. can digest FOG under
anaerobic conditions and decrease LCFA deposition [38]. Well-known Pseudomonas putida strains
can use LCFA as sole carbon sources [39] by help of self-synthesized ramnolipids; therefore, it is
important to enhance abundance of these cultures in anaerobic digestion [40] to decrease toxic effect
of LCFA. There is open discussion about substrate pre-treatment with fungi from Penicillium sp.,
Aspergillus sp. and Rhizopus sp. species [41], but one of the main disadvantages is that FOG substrate
has to be dewatered and made to undergo solid state pre-treatment, which slows down the mass flow
and has unfavourable maintenance [42]. Microbial enzyme dosage could cover the gaps in the biogas
formation process by helping to prepare substrates for the next fermentation steps.
Enzymes Involved in FOG Degradation
Complex triglycerides are broken down into glycerol and LCFA with help of extracellular enzymes
of bacteria and fungi. Degradation process involves complex enzyme content that consists of lipases,
esterases, proteases, and amylases [43]. While lipases are mainly involved in insoluble long chain
triglyceride decomposition, esterase converts partly soluble molecules [44]. There are studies on
recombinant lipase use from E. coli that is capable to keep the hydrolytic ability over broad
temperature and pH ranges and that shows better performance than using wild-type lipase ferments
[45]. Research on immobilized lipase derived from Candida rugosa showed a 65% recovery potential
with only 30% enzyme activity decrease after digestion. These data provide new evidence of
economic potential of immobilized enzymes in FOG co-digestion technologies [46].
Conclusions
Research shows that FOG is one of the top problems in WW treatment both from industrial and
restaurant scale origins due to their physicochemical characteristics and degradation bi-products.
Reuse of recovered FOG by AcoD with SS is one of the most popular methods, but it is still facing
unresolved problems with FOG dosage and toxic effect from LCFA accumulation. Promising tools
for problem solving is use of bio-surfactants and lipolytic enzyme producing bacteria bio-
augmentation. There is also luck of information for FOG usage in Agro-industrial biogas production
which could decrease green mass usage. Further investigation is needed to more understand influence
of LCFA on the process as well as to find the optimum balance between the abundance of bacteria
and methanogenic arhea.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by the European Regional Development Fund
(ERDF) within the framework of “Latvian Food Competence centre”
Ltd. project Nr. 1.2.1.1/16/A/004 “LATVIAN FOOD INDUSTRY
COMPETENCE CENTER” research project Nr.19, conducted by
AURAVIA LATVIA Ltd.
References
[1] European Biomass Industry Association, 2015. Transformation of Used Cooking Oil into
Biodiesel: from Waste to Resource - Position Paper, [online], Promotion of Used Cooking Oil
Recycling for Sustainable Biodiesel Production (RecOil) available at :
http://www.eubren.com/UCO_to_Biodiesel_2030_01.pdf (Accessed 1July 2016).
[2] Xia He, Francis L. de los Reyes III, Michael L. Leming, Lisa O. Dean, Simon E. Lappi, Joel J.
Ducoste, Mechanisms of Fat, Oil and Grease (FOG) deposit formation in sewer lines, Water
Research . 47 (2013) 4451-4459.
[3] William C. Merka, Processing water and wastewater, in: Alan R. Sams (Eds.), Poultry Meat
Processing, New York, Washington D.C., 2001. Pp 301-310.
[4] Neil McPhail, Review of Removal of Fats, Oil and Greases from Effluents from Meat Processing
Plants, Australian Meat Processor Corporation. (2015)
[5] Information on http://www.fao.org/docrep/t0551e/t0551e03.htm
[6] A. J. Cavaleiro, M. A. Pereira, A. P. Guedes, A. J.M. Stams, M. M. Alves, D. Z. Sousa,
Conversion of Cn-unsaturated into Cn-2-saturated LCFA can occur uncoupled from
methanogenesis in anaerobic bioreactors, Ultrasonics Sonochemistry. (2016)
[7] Alireza Serjouie, C.P. Tan. H. Mirhosseini, Y. B.C Man, Effect of Vegetable-Based Oil Blend
on Phisicochemical Properties of Oil During Deep-Fat Frying, American Journal of Food
Technologies 5 (5) (2010) 310-323
[8] A. M. Brooksbank, J. W. Latchford, S. M. Mudge, Degradation and modification of fats, oils,
and grease by commercial microbial supplements, World Journal of Microbiology and
Biotechnology. (2006).
[9] W.Yi, F. Sha, B. Xiaojuan, Z Jingchan, X. Siqing, Scum sludge as a potential feedstock for
biodiesel production from wastewater treatment plants, Waste Manegment. (2015).
[10] G. Estrada, R. Hamers, R. Palomares, S. Deering, J. Cuevas, J. Merid, J. Jenkins, A. Bacani,
Orange country WDR Subcommittee Group, Fats, oil & Grease (FOG) Programme Review.
September 2016.
[11] T. Kobayashi, H. Kuramochi, Kai-Qin Xu,Variable oil properties and biomethane production of
grease trap waste derived from different resources, International Biodeterioration &
Biodegradation. (2016) 1-9.
[12] Hayden, Harding & Buchanan, Walker Process Equipment, Installation profile Scum
Concentration system, City of Manchester, Manchester, New Hampshire, Information on line
www.walker-process.com
[13] C. Kole, C. P. Joshi, D. R. Shonnard, Handbook of Bioenergy Crop Plants, CCR press, Taylor
&Francis group, 2012.
[14] D. C. Panadare, V. K. Rathod, Applications of Waste Cooking Oil Other Than Biodiesel: A
Review, Iranian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 12, (2015) 3.
[15] T. Wallace, D. Gibbon, M. O'Dwyer, T. P. Curran, International evolution of fat, oil and grease
(FOG) waste management - A review, Journal of Environmental Management 187 (2016) 424-
435.
[16] A. Delavari, F. Halek, M. Amini, Continuous biodiesel production in a helicoidal reactor using
ultrasound-assisted transesterification reaction of waste cooking oil, Clean Techn Environ Policy
17 (2015) 273-279.
[17] Qingshi Tu, Diverting FOGs from Wastewater Stream for Biodiesel Production, Ohio WEA-
AWWA 2014 Technical Conference & Expo, Columbus, Ohio August (2014) 26-29.
[18] P. E. Poh1, D. Gouwanda, Y. Mohan, A. A. Gopalai, H. M. Tan1, Optimization of Wastewater
Anaerobic Digestion Using Mechanistic and Meta-heuristic Methods: Current Limitations and
Future Opportunities, Water Conserv Sci Eng. 1 (2016) 1-20.
[19] Arthur, S. & Blanc, J., Management and Recovery of FOG (fats, oils and greases), CREW project
CD2013/6. Available online at: crew.ac.uk/publications. (2013)
[20] M. Madalena Alves, M. A. Pereira, D. Z. Sousa, AJ. Cavaleiro, M. Picavet, H. Smidt, A. J. M.
Stams, Waste lipids to energy: How to optimize methane production from long-chain fatty acids
(LCFA), Microbial Biotechnology. 2(5) (2009) 538-550.
[21] J.H. Laong, T.N. Azizm F. L, de los Reyes III, J.J.Ducoste, Anaerobic co-digestion of fat, oil,
and grease (FOG): A review of gas production and process limitations, Process Safety and
Environmental Protection. 90 (2012) 231-245.
[22] R. M.W. Ferguson, F. Coulon, R. Villa, Organic loading rate: A promising microbial
management tool in anaerobic digestion, Water Research. 100 (2016) 348-356
[23] Tarek Aziz, Sustainable Anaerobic co-digestion of grease interceptor waste, Water Resources
Research Institute of The University of North Carolina, Report No. 449, (November 2014) A.J.
Cavaleiro, M.A. Picavet, D. Z. Sousa, A.J. M. Stams, M.A. Pereira, M.M. Alves, Anaerobic
Digestion of Lipid-Rich Waste, Hydrocarbon and Lipid Microbiology Protocols. (2015) 221-236
[24] http://www.veolianorthamerica.com/sites/g/files/dvc596/f/assets/documents/2015/12/Gresham_
-_Net_Zero_Program_Presentation.pdf
[25] A. J. Cavaleiro, M.A.Picavet, D.Z.Sousa, A.J.M.Stams, M.A.Pereira, M.M.Alves, Anaerobic
Digestion of Lipid-Rich Waste, Hydrocarbon and Lipid Microbiology Protocols. (2015) 221-236.
[26] M. A. Picavet, M. M. Alves, IASB-Inverted Anaerobic Sludge Blanket reactor: background,
history and development, University of Minho, Braga, Portugal, conference paper (2013)
[27] V. Diez, C. Ramos and J. L. Cabezas, Treating wastewater with high oil and grease content using
an Anaerobic Membrane Bioreactor (AnMBR). Filtration and cleaning assays, Waters Science
& Technology. 65 (10) (2012).
[28] P.D. Jensen, S.D. Yap, A. Boyle-Gotla, J. Janoschka, C. Carney, M. Pidou, D.J. Batstone
Anaerobic membrane bioreactors enable high rate treatment of slaughterhouse wastewater,
Biochemical Engineering Journal 97 (2015) 132141.
[29] Caixia Wan, Quancheng Zhou, Guiming Fu, Yebo Li, Semi-continuous anaerobic co-digestion
of tckened activated sludge and fat, oil and grease, Waste Management 31 (2011) 17521758
[30] E. J. Martínez, M. V. Gil, C. Fernandez, J. G. Rosas, X. Gómez, Anaerobic Codigestion of
Sludge: Addition of Butcher’s Fat Waste as a Cosubstrate for Increasing Biogas Production,
PLOS ONE TENTH Anniversary. April 12, 2016.
[31] R. Xu, Z. Yang, T. Chen, L. Zhao, J. Huang, H. X.P. Song, M. Li, Anaerobic co-digestion of
municipal wastewater sludge with food waste under different fat, oil, grease contents: study on
reactor performance and extracellular polymeric substances, RSC Sdvances. 125 (2015).
[32] A. Grosser, E. Neczaj, B.R. Singh, Å.R. Almåsb H. Brattebø, M. Kacprzak, Anaerobic digestion
of sewage sludge with grease trap sludge and municipal solid waste as co-substrates,
Environmental Research. 155 (2017) 249-260
[33] C. Noutsopoulos, D. Mamais, K. Antoniou, C. Avramides, P. Oikonomopoulos, I.Fountoulakis,
Anaerobic co-digestion of grease sludge and sewage sludge: The effect of organic loading and
grease sludge content, Bioresource Technology 131 (2013) 452-459.
[34] R.M. Ziels, D.A.C. Beck, H. D. Stensel, Long-chain fatty acid feeding frequency in anaerobic
co-digestion impacts syntrophic community structure and biokinetics, Water Research. June
2017.
[35] I. H. Franke-Whittle, A. Walter, C. Ebner, H. Insam, Investigation into the effect of high
concentrations of volatile fatty acids in anaerobic digestion on methanogenic communities,
Waste Management. 34 (2014) 2080-2089.
[36] S.A. Silva, A.F. Salvador, A.J. Cavaleiro, M.A. Pereira, A. J. M. Stams, M. M. Alves, D.Z. Sousa,
Toxicity of long chain fatty acids towards acetate conversion by Methanosaeta concili and
Methanosarcina mazei, Microbial Biotechnology. 9 (4) (2016) 514-518.
[37] R. Rodríguez-Méndez, Y. L. Bihan, F. Béline, P. Lessard, Long chain fatty acids (LCFA)
evolution for inhibition forecasting during anaerobic treatment of lipid-rich wastes: Case of milk-
fed veal slaughterhouse waste, Waste Management, (2017)
[38] Ashley Alfred Hendricks, Isolation and Characterisation of Lipolytic Bacteria and Investigation
of their ability to Degrade Fats, Oils and Grease in Grain Distillery Wastewater, Master of
Science in Food Science in the Faculty of Food Science at Stellenbosch University, Supervisor:
Dr G.O. Sigge (March 2015)
[39] P.Fauntaine, R.Mosrati.D.Corroller,Medium chain length polyhydroxyalkanoates biosynthesis in
Pseudomonas putidamt-2 is enhanced by co-metabolism of glycerol/octanoate or fatty acids
mixtures, International Journal of Biological Macromolecules. 98 (2017) 430-435.0
[40] V. Wigneswaran, K.F. Nielsen, C. Sternberg, P.R. Jensen, A. Folkesson, L. Jelsbak, Biofilm as
a production platform for heterologous production of rhamnolipids by the non-pathogenic
strain Pseudomonas putida KT2440, Microbial Cell Factories. 15 (2016) 181.
[41] A. Witharana, J. Manatunge, N. Ratnayake, C.M. Nanayakkara, M. Jayaweera, Rapid
degradation of FOG discharged from food industry wastewater by lipolytic fungi as a
bioaugmentation application, Environmental Technology. 30 June 2017.
[42] Andrea Hom-Diaz, Francesco Baldi, Paqui Bla´nquez, Lidia Lombardi, Lucı´a Martı´n-
Gonzalez Teresa Vicent, Exhausted Fungal Biomass as a Feedstock for Increasing Methane
Production During the Anaerobic Digestion of Organic Wastes, Waste Biomass Valor. 17
November (2015).
[43] P. Kanmani, J. Aravind, K. Kumaresan, Hydrolytic Enzyme Profiling of Bacillus
Subtilis COM6B and Its Application in the Bioremediation of Groundnut Oil Mill Effluent,
Integrated Waste Management in India. (2016) 179-189.
[44] M.C. Cammarota, D.M.G. Freire, A review on hydrolytic enzymes in the treatment of wastewater
with high oil and grease content, Bioresource Technology 97 (2006) 21952210.
[45] Saengsanga Thanakorn, Siripornadulsil Wilailak, Siripornadulsil Surasak.Molecular and
enzymatic characterization of alkaline lipase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens E1PA isolated
from lipid-rich food waste, Enzyme and Microbial Technology. 82 (2016) 23-33.
[46] J. Jeganathan, A. Bassi, G. Nakhla, Pre-treatment of high oil and grease pet food industrial
wastewaters using immobilized lipase hydrolization, Journal of Hazardous Materials. B137
(2006) 121-128.
... Characterization of RWW and its reuse for different purposes like irrigation, curing of concrete, and biogas production was discussed by Parwin and Karar Paul (2020). Klaucans and Sams (2018) studied the characteristics of restaurant wastewater containing FOG and the anaerobic digestion of FOG for the production of biogas. Wallace et al. (2017) gave an insight to the categorization of FOG and the associated problems together with the global waste management and awareness campaigns. ...
... The concentrations of BOD and COD are on the higher side in the samples collected from the GGI because of high organic matter, oil and greases, soaps, detergents, and other chemicals (Klaucans and Sams, 2018). The values of BOD and COD are illustrated in Fig. 5 (a) and (b), respectively. ...
Article
The number of restaurants is increasing day by day in almost all the developing countries, causing the increase in the generation of restaurant wastewaters. Various activities (i.e., cleaning, washing, and cooking) going on in the restaurant kitchen lead to restaurant wastewater (RWW). RWW has high concentrations of chemical oxygen demand (COD), biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), nutrients such as potassium, phosphorus, and nitrogen, and solids. RWW also contains fats, oil, and grease (FOG) in alarmingly high concentration, which after congealing can constrict the sewer lines, leading to blockages, backups, and sanitatry sewer overflows (SSOs). The paper provides an insight to the details of RWW containing FOG collected from a gravity grease interceptor at a specific site in Malaysia, and its expected consequences and the sustainable management plan as prevention, control, and mitigation (PCM) approach. The results showed that the concentrations of pollutants are very high as compared to the discharge standards given by department of environment. Maximum values for COD, BOD and FOG in the restaurant wastewater samples were found to be 9948, 3170, and 1640 mg/l, respectively. FAME and FESEM analysis are done on the RWW containing FOG. In the FOG, palmitic acid (C16:0), stearic acid (C18:0), oleic acid (C18:1n9c), linoleic acid (C18:2n6c) are the dominant lipid acids with a maximum of 41, 8.4, 43.2, and 11.5%, respectively. FESEM analysis showed formation of whitish layers fprmed due to the deposition of calcium salts. Furthermore, a novel design of indoor hydromechanical grease interceptor (HGI) was proposed in the study based on the Malaysian conditions of restaurant. The HGI was designed for a maximum flow rate of 132 L per minute and a maximum FOG capacity of 60 kg.
... Globally, the fishing industry generates large volumes of wastewater (approximately 20-40 m 3 h −1 for a plant with a capacity of 100 t fish h −1 ) [1,2], with COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand) of 2.0-5.0 g L −1 [3,4], TN (Total Nitrogen) of 150-300 mg L −1 [5,6] and TP (Total Phosphorus) of 44-78 mg L −1 [5,7], making them an environmental challenge if not properly treated. In the case of Cuba, fishery wastewater has an average BOD of 539-670 mg L −1 [8,9] and a COD of 1.0-1.2 ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The study aimed to evaluate the growth capacity and nutrient removal efficiency of Chlorella vulgaris in fish wastewater (FWW) and Bold's Basal (BB) medium as a control. The research question was whether C. vulgaris could effectively grow and remove nutrients in FWW. Methods The experiment was conducted under controlled conditions in a climatic chamber. C. vulgaris was grown in FWW and BB medium. Cell counting, optical density, and dry weight were measured daily. The nutrient removal efficiency was determined by analysing total nitrogen (TN) and phosphate (P-PO4³⁻) concentrations. Results The growth of C. vulgaris in both media was gradual, with an exponential phase from day 2 to 10 in BB medium and from day 4 to 10 in FWW. TN removal reached 89.09% in BB and 98.11% in FWW, while P-PO4³⁻ removal was 34.06% in BB and 98.45% in FWW. Conclusion C. vulgaris demonstrated efficient growth and nutrient removal in fish wastewater, making it a promising candidate for wastewater treatment and biomass production in the Cuban agro-industrial sector. Graphical Abstract
... Globally, the fishing industry generates large volumes of wastewater (approximately 20-40 m 3 h -1 for a plant with a capacity of 100 t fish h -1 ) [1,2], with COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand) of 2.0-5.0 g L -1 [3,4], TN (Total Nitrogen) of 150-300 mg L -1 [5,6] and TP (Total Phosphorus) of 44-78 mg L -1 [5,7], making them an environmental challenge if not properly treated. In the case of Cuba, fishery wastewater has an average BOD of 539-670 mg L -1 [8,9] and a COD of 1.0-1.2 ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Purpose The study aimed to evaluate the growth capacity and nutrient removal efficiency of Chlorella vulgaris in fish wastewater (FWW) and Bold's Basal (BB) medium as a control. The research question was whether C. vulgaris could grow and remove nutrients in FWW effectively. Methods The experiment was conducted under controlled conditions in a climatic chamber. C. vulgaris was grown in FWW and BB medium. Cell counting, optical density, and dry weight were measured daily. The nutrient removal efficiency was determined by analysing total nitrogen (TN) and phosphate (P-PO 4 ³⁻ ) concentrations. Results The growth of C. vulgaris in both media was gradual, with an exponential phase from day 2 to 10 in BB medium and from day 4 to 10 in FWW. TN removal reached 89.5% in BB and 92.1% in FWW, while P-PO 4 ³⁻ removal was 78.9% in BB and 84.2% in FWW. Conclusion C. vulgaris demonstrated efficient growth and nutrient removal in fish wastewater, making it a promising candidate for wastewater treatment and biomass production in the Cuban agro-industrial sector.
... Nasr et al. [27] investigated chemical treatment of wastewater from both a chemical and plastic shoe manufacturing factory. anaerobic co-digestion is another method used for treating wastewater with high oil and grease content [28]. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, an efficient industrial wastewater and leachate evaporation method is proposed and tested experimentally. The goal of this study is to investigate whether the addition of a carbon foam (CF) porous layer can lead to energy savings by evaporating more water mass per unit of energy input. The standard boiling evaporator layout was redesigned by placing the heating element in the upper region of the tank and CF underneath the heat source. The CF purposed to localize the energy in an area by the water's surface and minimize conduction heat losses to the rest of the water. A 90.2% reduction in energy lost to regions outside of the CF isolated control volume, specifically during the evaporator preheating process was observed with the addition of 100 Pores Per Inch (PPI) CF. In addition, a reduction in evaporative energy intensity was observed yielding results of 3.344 , 3.441 , and 3.644 for the 100 PPI, 45 PPI, and 10 PPI tests, respectively. This new evaporation design provides a more energy- and cost-efficient method for reducing the volume of various industrial wastewater and leachate concentrations onsite.
Chapter
Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) are promising alternatives to conventional petrochemical-based plastics due to their biodegradability, biocompatibility, and versatility. However, their widespread adoption is limited by high production costs, primarily attributed to the cost of carbon substrate. This chapter introduces the characteristics of PHAs and their production processes, and highlights the challenges at each production stage. The potential of food industrial waste streams as cost-effective and sustainable sources for PHA production is explored. The discussion includes conventional management practices for food waste streams and their associated limitations and pretreatment approaches to enhance the bioavailability of these waste streams for PHA-producing microorganisms. Additionally, this chapter presents the potential of various food waste streams as carbon sources for PHA synthesis. Integrating food waste management with PHA production aligns with the approach of circular economy, promoting sustainable development through resource recovery and utilization, while mitigating environmental impacts.
Article
The meat rendering process transforms waste from the meat industry into valuable materials such as animal feed supplements. During the rendering process, large amounts of condensate and housekeeping wastewater (CWW and HKWW), solids, and greenhouse gases are released into the environment, imposing a huge pollution threat. Rendering condensate wastewater also causes many issues that commonly affect biological treatment processes such as pH inhibition, nutrient deficit, and temperature. Therefore, the main objective of this work was to simulate the nutrient removal from a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) through the differential nitrogen overload of CWW. With the aid of simulation, the results found that the current SBR system does not remove carbon and nitrogen as much as other biological systems. This is due to the low biodegradation of chemical oxygen demand, the high content of inert particulate carbon (XI), identified in the fractionation of HKWW, and the toxic and inhibitory effect of ammonium present in CWW. When the system is overloaded with nitrogen from CWW, there is little removal of biochemical oxygen demand, ordinary heterotrophic organisms outnumber autotrophic nitrifying organisms and ammonium toxicity occurs, all contributing to a failure to remove nutrients.
Article
Full-text available
Waste generated during used cooking oil (UCO) collection poses significant environmental challenges due to its high oil content. This study investigates the efficacy of coagulation and flocculation in separating oil from cooking oil secondary waste (COSW), which typically contains 53% oil. Two additives, aluminum sulfate (Alum—Al2(SO4)3) and polyacrylamide (PAM), were employed to enhance the separation process. Experimental results demonstrate that the combined application of coagulation and flocculation using these additives achieved 82% oil removal efficiency. These findings suggest a promising approach for recovering valuable oil resources from COSW while addressing environmental concerns associated with its improper disposal.
Article
Full-text available
The oily wastewater represents one of the major threats to the environment nowadays and requires innovative water treatment technology. This review provides an overview of polymeric photocatalytic membranes used for oily wastewater treatment, with key focus on the pollution sources and the membrane materials. Moreover, the advantage of coupling the photocatalyst technology into the membrane fabrication for oil removal is explored. This work evaluates the removal performance and anti-fouling properties in oily wastewater treatment of the most recent developed polymeric photocatalytic membranes.
Chapter
Full-text available
Sugarcane is a tropical grass of the Poacea family and Saccharum genus and comprises several species although plants presently cultivated are mostly hybrids derived from S. officinarum, S. spontaneum, S. robustum, S. sinnensis, and S. barberi (Figueiredo 2008). Sugarcane is originated from Asia; the exact center of origin is unknown, but evidence points to Polynesia, New Guinea, India, China, Fiji Islands, and Tahiti. There are reports that S. officinarum was known in 6000 BC in India (Daniels et al. 1975). Sugarcane was already cultivated in the Middle East before the Christian era. Later the Arabs introduced the plant in Europe and from there it spread to America and parts of Africa in the early fifteenth century with the start of colonization (Figueiredo 2008).
Chapter
Full-text available
Industrial effluents rich in oil and grease pose hindrance to the functioning of wastewater treatment units and also affect the quality of receiving water bodies. Pretreatment of such wastewaters to bring about lipid hydrolysis makes them more amenable to conventional biological treatment and hydrolytic enzymes, especially lipases, find promising applications in this sector. In our study, the bacterial strain Bacillus subtilis COM6B isolated from groundnut mill effluent was cultivated in minimal media based on residual oil waste from the extraction process, in which it produced lipase and other extracellular hydrolytic enzymes such as protease and amylase. Applying response surface methodology led to a 1.8-fold increase in oil waste removal by the isolate. As a further study, the effluent discharged from the oil mill was treated in batch mode using pure cultures of the isolate and the effects of incubation time, inoculum size and effluent dilution on the treatment process were investigated. A maximum of 95, 93 and 98 % reduction in biochemical oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand and oil and grease respectively, were achieved after treatment with COM6B. Hence, the isolate could serve as a potential candidate for remediating the fat and oil contaminants and reducing the organic load of wastewaters.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, issues relating to fat, oil and grease (FOG) in sewer systems have intensified. In the media, sewer blockages caused by FOG waste deposits, commonly referred to as ‘fatbergs’, are becoming a reminder of the problems that FOG waste can cause when left untreated. These FOG blockages lead to sanitary sewer overflows, property flooding and contamination of water bodies with sewage. Despite these financial and environmentally detrimental effects, a homogenous FOG waste management method has not been developed internationally. However, some successful enduring FOG management programmes have been established, such as in Dublin city and in Scandinavian countries. The aim of this paper is to carry out a review on existing FOG research and management approaches. FOG management involves comprehending: (1) FOG deposition factors in the sewer, (2) FOG prevention and awareness tactics undertaken internationally and (3) potential utilisation methods for FOG waste. This review will highlight that preventing FOG from entering the sewer is the most common approach, often through simple awareness campaigns. The diverted FOG is rarely valorised to bioenergy or biomaterials, despite its potential. Thus, all facets of the FOG waste lifecycle must be identified and managed. Advancements in processes and techniques must be assessed to best determine the future evolution of FOG waste management to assist in achieving a sustainable urban environment. See more details at http://www.ucd.ie/fog and http://researchrepository.ucd.ie/handle/10197/8257
Article
Full-text available
Background Although a transition toward sustainable production of chemicals is needed, the physiochemical properties of certain biochemicals such as biosurfactants make them challenging to produce in conventional bioreactor systems. Alternative production platforms such as surface-attached biofilm populations could potentially overcome these challenges. Rhamnolipids are a group of biosurfactants highly relevant for industrial applications. However, they are mainly produced by the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa using hydrophobic substrates such as plant oils. As the biosynthesis is tightly regulated in P. aeruginosa a heterologous production of rhamnolipids in a safe organism can relive the production from many of these limitations and alternative substrates could be used. Results In the present study, heterologous production of biosurfactants was investigated using rhamnolipids as the model compound in biofilm encased Pseudomonas putida KT2440. The rhlAB operon from P. aeruginosa was introduced into P. putida to produce mono-rhamnolipids. A synthetic promoter library was used in order to bypass the normal regulation of rhamnolipid synthesis and to provide varying expression levels of the rhlAB operon resulting in different levels of rhamnolipid production. Biosynthesis of rhamnolipids in P. putida decreased bacterial growth rate but stimulated biofilm formation by enhancing cell motility. Continuous rhamnolipid production in a biofilm was achieved using flow cell technology. Quantitative and structural investigations of the produced rhamnolipids were made by ultra performance liquid chromatography combined with high resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) and tandem HRMS. The predominant rhamnolipid congener produced by the heterologous P. putida biofilm was mono-rhamnolipid with two C10 fatty acids. Conclusion This study shows a successful application of synthetic promoter library in P. putida KT2440 and a heterologous biosynthesis of rhamnolipids in biofilm encased cells without hampering biofilm capabilities. These findings expands the possibilities of cultivation setups and paves the way for employing biofilm flow systems as production platforms for biochemicals, which as a consequence of physiochemical properties are troublesome to produce in conventional fermenter setups, or for production of compounds which are inhibitory or toxic to the production organisms. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12934-016-0581-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
Book
As the world’s population is projected to reach 10 billion or more by 2100, devastating fossil fuel shortages loom in the future unless more renewable alternatives to energy are developed. Bioenergy, in the form of cellulosic biomass, starch, sugar, and oils from crop plants, has emerged as one of the cheaper, cleaner, and environmentally sustainable alternatives to traditional forms of energy. Handbook of Bioenergy Crop Plants brings together the work of a panel of global experts who survey the possibilities and challenges involved in biofuel production in the twenty-first century. Section One explores the genetic improvement of bioenergy crops, ecological issues and biodiversity, feedstock logistics and enzymatic cell wall degradation to produce biofuels, and process technologies of liquid transportation fuels production. It also reviews international standards for fuel quality, unique issues of biofuel-powered engines, life-cycle environmental impacts of biofuels compared with fossil fuels, and social concerns. Section Two examines commercialized bioenergy crops, including cassava, Jatropha, forest trees, maize, oil palm, oilseed Brassicas, sorghum, soybean, sugarcane, and switchgrass. Section Three profiles emerging crops such as Brachypodium, diesel trees, minor oilseeds, lower plants, Paulownia, shrub willow, sugarbeet, sunflower, and sweet potato. It also discusses unconventional biomass resources such as vegetable oils, organic waste, and municipal sludge. Highlighting the special requirements, major achievements, and unresolved concerns in bioenergy production from crop plants, the book is destined to lead to future discoveries related to the use of plants for bioenergy production. It will assist in developing innovative ways of ameliorating energy problems on the horizon.
Article
Fats, oils and grease (FOG) congregate in grease trap devices as a result of culinary activities in the food service industry. FOG is considered to be a slowly biodegradable particulate organic matter and may require enzymatic or hydrolytic conversion to form readily biodegradable soluble organic matter. The existing treatment methods are claimed on water based hydrolysis of FOG to form long chain fatty acids. The long fatty acids discharged into wastewater treatment system create functional difficulties, especially the inhibitory effect caused by accumulation of long chain fatty acids. The present study was aimed at finding an effective treatment method for this persistent problem encountered in conventional wastewater treatment system. Solid state degradation by lipolytic fungi was performed in a tray type reactor as a novel approach of bioaugmentation. Grease trap waste samples were dried to have moisture content of 25 - 35% and mixed with coir fiber (1% w/v) for proper aeration. Each 10 mg/g dry weight of substrate was inoculated with 1 ml of spore suspension (1×10⁷ spores/ml) of lipolytic fungi. Thereafter, moisture content in the reactor was increased up to 65%, and incubation was carried out at 30 °C. Within 72 h of post incubation, degradation efficiency of about 50% was recorded by fungal isolates. The degraded residue can be used as an inoculum for the second set of grease trap waste. The feasibility of using developed protocol for FOG degradation was tested with a laboratory scale prototype reactor and it was operated successfully without inoculation.
Article
A detailed study of a solid slaughterhouse waste (SHW) anaerobic treatment is presented. The waste used in this study is rich in lipids and proteins residue. Long chain fatty acids (LCFA), coming from the hydrolysis of lipids were inhibitory to anaerobic processes at different degrees. Acetogenesis and methanogenesis processes were mainly affected by inhibition whereas disintegration and hydrolysis processes did not seem to be affected by high LCFA concentrations. Nevertheless, because of the high energy content, this kind of waste is very suitable for anaerobic digestion but strict control of operating conditions is required to prevent inhibition. For that, two inhibition indicators were identified in this study. Those two indicators, LCFA dynamics and LCFA/VSbiomass ratio proved to be useful to predict and to estimate the process inhibition degree.
Article
This study investigated the impacts of long-chain fatty acid (LCFA) feeding frequencies on microbial community structure, bioconversion kinetics, and process stability during anaerobic codigestion. Parallel laboratory-scale anaerobic codigesters fed with dairy cattle manure were either pulse-fed every two days or continuously-fed daily, respectively, with oleate (C18:1) in incremental step increases over 200 days up to 64% of the influent chemical oxygen demand (COD). The effluent acetate concentration exceeded 3000 mg/L in the continuous-fed codigester at the highest oleate loading rate, but remained below 100 mg/L in the pulse-fed codigester at the end of its 48-hr oleate feed cycle. Maximum substrate conversion rates of oleate (qmax, oleate) and acetate (qmax, acetate) were significantly higher in the pulse-fed codigester compared to the continuous-fed codigester. 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing showed that Bacteria and Archaea community profiles diverged based on the codigester LCFA feeding pattern and loading rate. LCFA-degrading Syntrophomonas bacteria were significantly enriched in both LCFA codigesters relative to the control digester. The pulse-fed codigester had the highest community fraction of Syntrophomonas 16S rRNA genes by the end of the experiment with 43% of Bacteria amplicon sequences. qmax, oleate and qmax, acetate values were both significantly correlated to absolute concentrations of Syntrophomonas and Methanosaeta 16S rRNA genes, respectively. Multiple-linear regression models based on the absolute abundance of Syntrophomonas and Methanosaeta taxa provided improved predictions of oleate and acetate bioconversion kinetics, respectively. These results collectively suggest that pulse feeding rather than continuous feeding LCFA during anaerobic codigestion selected for higher microbial bioconversion kinetics and functional stability, which were related to changes in the physiological diversity and adaptive capacity of syntrophic and methanogenic communities.
Article
The feasibility of simultaneous treatment of multiple wastes via co-digestion was studied in semi-continuous mode at mesophilic conditions. The obtained results indicated that sewage sludge, organic fraction of municipal waste (OFMSW) and grease trap sludge (GTS) possess complementary properties that can be combined for successful anaerobic digestion. During the co-digestion period, methane yield and VS removal were significantly higher in comparison to digestion of sewage sludge alone. Addition of GTS to digesters treating sewage sludge resulted in increased VS removal and methane yield up to 13% (from 50 to 56.4) and 52% (from 300 to 456,547m(3)/Mg VSadd), respectively. While the use of OFMSW as the next co-substrate in the feedstock, can boost methane yield and VS removal up to 82% (300-547m(3)/Mg VSadd) and approximately 29% (from 50% to 64.7%), respectively. Moreover, the results of the present laboratory study revealed that the addition of co-substrates to the feedstock had a significant influence on biogas composition. During the experiment methane content in biogas ranged from 67% to 69%. While, the concentration of LCFAs was increasing with the gradual increase in the share of co-substrates in the mixtures, wherein only the oleic acid was higher than some inhibition concentrations which have been reported in the literature. However, it did not significantly affect the efficiency of the co-digestion process.
Article
The synthesis of medium chain length polyhydroxyalkanoates (mcl-PHAs) by Pseudomonas putida mt-2 was investigated under nitrogen-rich then deficient conditions with glycerol/octanoate or long-chain fatty acids (LCFAs) as carbon sources. When mixed, glycerol and octanoate were co-assimilated regardless of nitrogen availability but provided that glycerol uptake has been already triggered under non-limiting nutrient conditions. This concomitant consumption allowed to enhance mcl-PHAs accumulation (up to 57% of cell dry weight (CDW)) under both non-limiting and nitrogen deficient conditions. Octanoate then mostly drove anabolism of the polyester with 3-hydroxyoctanoate (3HO) synthesized as the main monomer (83%). If the preferred PHA precursor octanoate was supplied, glycerol was mainly involved in cell growth and/or maintenance but very little in PHA production even under nitrogen starvation. P. putida cells accumulated higher amounts of mcl-PHAs when grown on mixtures of LCFAs compared to LCFAs supplied as single substrate (25% and 9% of CDW, respectively). However, only a weak enrichment of the polyester was observed after transfer of cells in a fresh nitrogen-free medium containing the same combination of LCFAs. Some typical units within the polyester were related to the LCFAs ratio supplied in the medium indicating that tailor-made monomers could be synthesized.