ArticlePublisher preview available

Factors Controlling the Fractionation and Seasonal Mobility Variations of Ga and In in Systems Impacted by Acidic Thermal Waters: Effects of Thermodynamics and Bacterial Activity

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

This work assessed both the fractionation and the seasonal mobility variations of Ga and In in systems impacted by acidic thermal waters. This was accomplished by performing thermodynamic calculations using the PHREEQC algorithm and by assessing the activity of acidophilic iron-oxidizing bacteria. The pH of the Kusatsu thermal waters in Gunma Prefecture, central Japan, is rapidly increased following the addition of a lime suspension. After an abrupt pH increase, under which conditions free ions of Ga and In and their complexes with Cl⁻ and SO4²⁻ exist only in negligible quantities, the majority of dissolved Ga and In is removed by sorption onto suspended hydrous ferric oxides (HFOs). These HFOs are then transported to an artificial lake without significant sedimentation along the river. Subsequently, the suspended HFOs settle out and are added to sediments without significant fractionation between Ga and In. The Tamagawa thermal waters in Akita Prefecture, northeast Japan, are also treated with lime. However, complete neutralization requires mixing with some tributary streams, leading to a gradual downstream increase in pH. Dissolved Ga is, in general, sorbed by HFOs in upstream areas, leading to wide dispersal of Ga across the entire watershed. In comparison, In is transported to the lake inlet predominantly as a Cl⁻ complex species without significant removal along the river, with the majority being precipitated in an artificial lake, where Cl⁻ concentrations are too low to form stable complex species with In, and thus, dissolved In is sorbed by HFOs. As a result, In is effectively concentrated within downstream lakebed sediments, whereas Ga is dispersed along the river. Seasonal variations in Ga mobility within the Tamagawa field between snowmelt and low-flow seasons are primarily controlled by pH, because hydrolysis reactions of these metals, which are related to sorption reactions, tend to occur in the upstream regions in the snowmelt season. However, under warmer conditions, HFO formation preferably occurs due to the activity of acidophilic iron-oxidizing bacteria. Thus, under similar pH variations, dissolved Ga is more effectively removed by HFOs during warmer seasons. On the contrary, because HFOs are abundantly formed in low-flow season, even under colder conditions, before In hydrolysis reaction starts to occur, In mobility is less affected by water temperature and then bacterial activity.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Factors Controlling the Fractionation and Seasonal
Mobility Variations of Ga and In in Systems Impacted
by Acidic Thermal Waters: Effects of Thermodynamics
and Bacterial Activity
Yasumasa Ogawa
1
Daizo Ishiyama
1
Naotatsu Shikazono
2
Koichi Suto
3
Chihiro Inoue
3
Noriyoshi Tsuchiya
3
Bernhardt Saini-
Eidukat
4
Scott A. Wood
4
Received: 6 August 2017 / Accepted: 20 January 2018 / Published online: 30 January 2018
ÓSpringer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2018
Abstract This work assessed both the fractionation and the seasonal mobility variations of
Ga and In in systems impacted by acidic thermal waters. This was accomplished by
performing thermodynamic calculations using the PHREEQC algorithm and by assessing
the activity of acidophilic iron-oxidizing bacteria. The pH of the Kusatsu thermal waters in
Gunma Prefecture, central Japan, is rapidly increased following the addition of a lime
suspension. After an abrupt pH increase, under which conditions free ions of Ga and In and
their complexes with Cl
-
and SO
4
2-
exist only in negligible quantities, the majority of
dissolved Ga and In is removed by sorption onto suspended hydrous ferric oxides (HFOs).
These HFOs are then transported to an artificial lake without significant sedimentation
along the river. Subsequently, the suspended HFOs settle out and are added to sediments
without significant fractionation between Ga and In. The Tamagawa thermal waters in
Akita Prefecture, northeast Japan, are also treated with lime. However, complete neu-
tralization requires mixing with some tributary streams, leading to a gradual downstream
increase in pH. Dissolved Ga is, in general, sorbed by HFOs in upstream areas, leading to
wide dispersal of Ga across the entire watershed. In comparison, In is transported to the
lake inlet predominantly as a Cl
-
complex species without significant removal along the
river, with the majority being precipitated in an artificial lake, where Cl
-
concentrations
are too low to form stable complex species with In, and thus, dissolved In is sorbed by
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (https://doi.org/10.1007/s10498-018-
9328-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
&Yasumasa Ogawa
y_ogawa@gipc.akita-u.ac.jp
1
Faculty of International Resource Sciences, Akita University, Tegatagakuen-machi 1-1, Akita,
Akita Prefecture 010-8502, Japan
2
Department of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Technology, Keio University, Hiyoshi
3-14-1, Kohoku-ku, Yokohama, Kanagawa Prefecture 223-8522, Japan
3
Graduate School of Environmental Studies, Tohoku University, Aoba 6-6-20, Aoba-ku, Aramaki,
Sendai 980-8579, Japan
4
Department of Geosciences, North Dakota State University (NDSU), Fargo, ND 58108, USA
123
Aquat Geochem (2018) 24:5–25
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10498-018-9328-z
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Sorption onto hydrous Al or Fe oxy-hydroxides (HAO or HFO) is an important process for natural attenuation of many elements in acidified aquatic systems (e.g., Gammons et al., 2005aGammons et al., , 2005bGammons et al., , 2005cWood et al., 2006;Schemel et al., 2007;McCleskey et al., 2009;Ogawa et al., 2014;Carrero et al., 2015;Ayora et al., 2016). Sorption onto HAO and HFO is largely dependent on pH and thus aqueous speciation of target metals and their fractionation (Ogawa et al., 2018(Ogawa et al., , 2019. It is also reported that REE fractionation are also caused by differences in the stability of aqueous REE complex with various anions (e.g., Grawunder et al., 2014;Olías et al., 2018;Lozano et al., 2019Lozano et al., , 2020aMunemoto et al., 2020). ...
... The Yukawa River was examined during three sampling periods (December 2015, and March and September 2019). The geochemical behavior of As and rare metals, such as Ga and In, in this area in February 2009 have been reported previously (Ogawa et al., 2013(Ogawa et al., , 2018. ...
... Thorium was transported to the reservoir (site K-5) without significant precipitation on the riverbed, and then about 80% of Th originating from the thermal waters settled onto the reservoir bed. This mobility is quite similar to those for As, Ga and In (Ogawa et al., 2013(Ogawa et al., , 2018, meaning that the reservoir acts as an effective sink for these elements. ...
Article
Acidic thermal water originating from the Kusatsu geothermal area of Gunma Prefecture, Japan is introduced into rivers, where there are many anthropogenicobjects such as a neutralization plant, a dam and water channels for hydroelectric power plants. We have investigated changes in the physico-chemical nature and fractionation mechanisms of rare earth elements (REEs) including Y and actinides (Th and U) by artificial and natural neutralization processes during river transport. The geochemical behavior of these elements and fractionation among them are mainly controlled by pH-dependent sorption and/or precipitation, once the pH increases up to 5.5. Dissolved Th is nearly completely removed, and hydrous Fe and Al oxides (HFO and HAO) sorbing Th or Th(SO4)2s settle onto the reservoir's bed. On the other hand, REEs and U remain as dissolved species. The effect of temperature on removal of these metals is limited. At pH values of ~5.5, REEs and U are removed by HFO and/or HAO, resulting in less fractionation among them. As pH increases to greater than 6.5, dissolved REEs continue to be removed by HFO and/or HAO, whereas U largely remains as a dissolved species in river water. Formation of UO2‑carbonate complex species prevents removal of dissolved U. When pH approaches 8, U is desorbed from suspended materials. Fractionation of REEs including Y occurs during sorption onto suspended materials and is strongly pH-dependent. REEs are less fractionated, when sorption occurs under pH less than ~6.2. As pH increases, heavier REEs tend to be removed by sorption onto suspended materials, and lighter REEs tend to remain in river water. Compared to fractionation between MREE and HREE, fractionation between LREE and MREE is larger. Yttrium is sorbed more effectively than LREE but less effectively than HREE. REE fractionation may occur significantly under pH 6.2–7.5.
... Recent studies of the mobility of Ga and In in rivers acidified by thermal waters reveal that physico-chemical speciation changes (chemical state of target elements such as dissolved species and sorbate on HAO and HFO) are strongly influenced by aqueous speciation changes (such as free ions or complex species with some anions) (Ogawa et al., 2013), and thermodynamic calculation can accurately predict the sites (or times) at which sorption reactions onto HFO begin, as well as the semi-quantitative amounts sorbed onto HFOs (Ogawa et al., 2018). However, although there are many reports of REE and U sorption experiments involving aqueous REE species (e.g., Walter et al., 2003;Davranche et al., 2004), research on clarifying the relationship between physico-chemical and aqueous speciation of REEs and actinides in natural aquatic systems is very rare. ...
... (3) Dissolved Th is nearly completely removed and dissolved U also decreased, under the conditions at which hydroxyl species are predicted to become significant. So, aqueous speciation changes of actinides are important for their sorption reaction, similar to Ga and In (Ogawa et al., 2018). On the other hand, geochemical behaviors of REEs are simply controlled by pH. ...
Article
In the Tamagawa geothermal area of Akita Prefecture, northern Japan, Obuki spring discharges a large amount of thermal water (∼9000 L/min), which is chloride-rich and acidic (pH 1.2). We have investigated changes in the physico-chemical nature and fractionation mechanisms of rare earth elements (REEs) including Y and actinides (Th and U) in the Shibukuro and Tama rivers into which acid thermal water from the Obuki spring discharges. The geochemical behavior of these elements is shown to be mainly controlled by pH-dependent sorption onto ferric and/or aluminum oxy-hydroxides (HFO and HAO). HFO is formed around pH > 3. In the upstream region, where pH is less than 4, dissolved Th is removed due to precipitation of Th(SO 4 ) 2(s) . Whereas, under pH condition greater than 4, remaining dissolved Th is nearly completely sorbed onto suspended HFO, where hydroxyl species of Th are thermodynamically significant. Then, the Th(SO 4 ) 2(s) and HFO-sorbed Th are nearly completely removed in an upstream man-made lake. Dissolved U is also removed mainly by sorption onto HFO, where hydroxyl species of UO 2 are predominant. A considerable portion of U is also trapped in the sediments of this lake. On the other hand, removal of REEs is nearly negligible until the lake. This is the first fractionation among REEs and actinides caused by pH-dependent sorption, and the order of removal from river water is Th > U ≫ REEs. The remaining dissolved U and REEs in the river waters are transported farther downstream. At pH values of >6, suspended HAO is effectively formed, and the second fractionation among REEs and U occurs. During the second fractionation, REEs are removed by HAO, whereas U largely remains as a dissolved species in river water under higher pH conditions. Lighter REEs, such as La and Ce, tend to remain in the river waters compared to the other REEs including Y. The predominant chemical species for UO 2 during the second fractionation are carbonate complex species, and relative proportions of hydroxyl species drastically decreases, resulting in prevention of U sorption onto HAO.
Article
Full-text available
III-V materials such as indium arsenide (InAs) and gallium arsenide (GaAs) are increasingly used in electronic and photovoltaic devices. The extensive application of these materials may lead to release of III-V ionic species during semiconductor manufacturing or disposal of decommissioned devices into the environment. Although arsenic is recognized as an important contaminant due to its high toxicity, there is a lack of information about the toxic effects of indium and gallium ions. In this study, acute toxicity of As(III), As(V), In(III) and Ga(III) species was evaluated using two microbial assays testing for methanogenic activity and O2 uptake, as well as two bioassays targeting aquatic organisms, including the marine bacterium Aliivibrio fischeri (bioluminescence inhibition) and the crustacean Daphnia magna (mortality). The most noteworthy finding was that the toxicity is mostly impacted by the element tested. Secondarily, the toxicity of these species also depended on the bioassay target. In(III) and Ga(III) were not or only mildly toxic in the experiments. D. magna was the most sensitive organism for In(III) and Ga(III) with 50% lethal concentrations of 0.5 and 3.4mM, respectively. On the other hand, As(III) and As(V) caused clear inhibitory effects, particularly in the methanogenic toxicity bioassay. The 50% inhibitory concentrations of both arsenic species towards methanogens were about 0.02mM, which is lower than the regulated maximum allowable daily effluent discharge concentration (2.09mg/L or 0.03mM) for facilities manufacturing electronic components in the US. Overall, the results indicate that the ecotoxicity of In(III) and Ga(III) is much lower than that of the As species tested. This finding is important in filling the knowledge gap regarding the ecotoxicology of In and Ga.
Article
Full-text available
The Shozu-gawa River, located in Aomori Prefecture, northern Japan, is affected by volcanic activities and acid thermal waters. The river is unique because both solid arsenic (As; as orpiment, As2S3) and dissolved As are supplied to the river from the uppermost caldera lake (Usori-ko Lake) and thermal ponds. The watershed is an excellent site for investigating the fates of different As species in a fluvial system. Upstream sediments near the caldera lake and geothermal ponds are highly contaminated by orpiment. This solid phase is transported as far as the mouth of the river. On the other hand, dissolved As is removed from the river system by hydrous ferric oxides (HFOs); however, HFO formation and removal of dissolved As do not occur in the uppermost area of the watershed, resulting in further downstream transport of dissolved As. Consequently, upstream river sediments are enriched in orpiment, whereas As(V), which is associated with HFOs in river sediments, increases downstream. Furthermore, orpiment particles are larger, and possibly heavier, than those of HFO with sorbed As. Fractionation between different chemical states of As during transport in the Shozu-gawa River is facilitated not only by chemical processes (i.e., sorption of dissolved As by HFOs), but also by physical factors (i.e., gravity). In contrast to acid mine drainage (AMD), in some areas of the Shozu-gawa River, both solid forms of As (as sulfide minerals) and dissolved As are introduced into the aquatic system. Considering that the stabilities of sulfide minerals are rather different from those of oxides and hydroxides, river sediments contacted with thermal waters possibly act as sources of As under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions.
Article
Limited information is available on the effects of gallium (Ga) and indium (In) on the growth of paddy rice. The Ga and In are emerging contaminants and widely used in high-tech industries nowadays. Understanding the toxicity and accumulation of Ga and In by rice plants is important for reducing the effect on rice production and exposure risk to human by rice consumption. Therefore, this study investigates the effect of Ga and In on the growth of rice seedlings and examines the accumulation and distribution of those elements in plant tissues. Hydroponic cultures were conducted in phytotron glasshouse with controlled temperature and relative humidity conditions, and the rice seedlings were treated with different levels of Ga and In in the nutrient solutions. The growth index and the concentrations of Ga and In in roots and shoots of rice seedlings were measured after harvesting. A significant increase in growth index with increasing Ga concentrations in culture solutions (
Article
Indium is an increasingly important metal in semiconductors and electronics and has uses in important energy technologies such as photovoltaic cells and light-emitting diodes (LEDs). One significant flux of indium to the environment is from lead, zinc, copper, and tin mining and smelting, but little is known about its aqueous behavior after it is mobilized. In this study, we use Mineral Creek, a headwater stream in southwestern Colorado severely affected by heavy metal contamination as a result of acid mine drainage, as a natural laboratory to study the aqueous behavior of indium. At the existing pH of ~ 3, indium concentrations are 6–29 μg/L (10,000 × those found in natural rivers), and are completely filterable through a 0.45 μm filter. During a pH modification experiment, the pH of the system was raised to > 8, and > 99% of the indium became associated with the suspended solid phase (i.e. does not pass through a 0.45 μm filter). To determine the mechanism of removal of indium from the filterable and likely primarily dissolved phase, we conducted laboratory experiments to determine an upper bound for a sorption constant to iron oxides, and used this, along with other published thermodynamic constants, to model the partitioning of indium in Mineral Creek. Modeling results suggest that the removal of indium from the filterable phase is consistent with precipitation of indium hydroxide from a dissolved phase. This work demonstrates that nonferrous mining processes can be a significant source of indium to the environment, and provides critical information about the aqueous behavior of indium.
Article
Palinpinon geothermal field, Negros Island, Philippines, is a high-temperature, liquid-dominated geothermal system in an active volcanic island-arc setting. Parallels have been drawn between the geologic setting and hydrothermal alteration styles recognized at Palinpinon with those that characterize several types of magmatichydrothermal ore deposits (e.g., porphyry, skarn, and high and intermediate sulfidation epithermal systems). The neutral chloride Palinpinon reservoir water chemistry is affected by boiling, mixing, and conductive cooling. The occurrence of base and precious metal scale deposits in several geothermal wells demonstrates that the deep reservoir fluid is capable of transporting and depositing base and precious metals. However, trace metal analysis of the deep reservoir fluids shows they are undersaturated with respect to gold (1-4 μg/kg). Chemical modeling of Palinpinon geothermal water predicts that boiling should be the most effective mechanism for base and precious metal deposition, producing sulfide assemblages similar to those present in well scale deposits. Mixing with acid-bearing sulfate waters can also produce these sulfide assemblages, but less efficiently and with gold and silver deposition occurring at lower temperatures (i.e., <110°C). Despite indications that modern hydrothermal fluids are capable of metal transportation, base and precious metal deposition is not strongly developed at Palinpinon. Base and precious metal concentrations in drill core and drill cuttings are one to two orders of magnitude below ore grade (<0.02 wt % Cu, <0.03 wt % Pb, <0.01 wt % Zn, <0.01 wt % Mo, <8 g/t Ag, and <0.05 g/t Au), and important features that characterize high-grade ore zones of porphyry (i.e., quartz stockwork veining) and epithermal deposits (i.e., residual vuggy quartz, massive crustiform veins, and/or hydrothermal breccia complexes) are apparently absent at Palinpinon. Such features intimate that high-grade ore deposition is promoted by large volumes of fluid and highly permeable wall rock. Their absence at Palinpinon indicates that permeability, fluid flux, and/or metal transport have been insufficient to form significant zones of base or precious metal enrichment.
Article
The Kusatsu and Tamagawa hot springs contain both toxic elements and rare metals used in high-technology industries. High acidity and significant discharge of these springs have led to the construction of dams and neutralization of spring waters by lime addition. However, the same neutralization process causes differing effects in the Kusatsu and Tamagawa areas. This study focuses on the effects of neutralization on fractionation between arsenic (As) and indium (In) during river transport and precipitation of these elements on the lake beds. The Yubatake thermal waters in the Kusatsu area are rapidly neutralized after addition of a lime suspension. After this neutralization, the dissolved As and In are nearly completely removed by sorption onto suspended hydrous ferric oxides (HFO), which then settle out and are added to sediments within a man-made lake without significant fractionation. In contrast, the Obuki thermal waters in the Tamagawa area are neutralized by both addition of lime and by mixing with tributary streams, leading to a gradual downstream increase in pH. Arsenic tends to be sorbed by HFO in upstream areas, leading to wide dispersal of As across the entire watershed. In comparison, In is transported to the lake inlet as stable chloride and/or sulfate complexes without significant removal, with considerable portions being precipitated in a man-made lake. As a result, In is effectively concentrated within downstream lake sediments.
Article
The adsorption mechanism of trivalent Ga and In onto γ-Al2O3was investigated using a triple-layer model simulation and pressure-jump technique. Bidentate Ga3+and In3+and monodentate GaOH2+/InOH2+are the most likely surface species responsible for Ga(III)/In(III) adsorption. Sorption of Ga(III) and In(III) can be interpreted as an associative process. The adsorption pathway is a two-step mechanism: proton release from surface hydroxyl group(s) followed by coordination of Ga(III)/In(III) species to the depronated site(s). Intrinsic adsorption rate constants cannot be estimated with a liner free-energy relationship between the adsorption rate constant and the rate of water exchange, which is developed solely based on the dissociative sorption mechanism of divalent ions.