ThesisPDF Available

Simultaneous optimisation of the nutritional quality and environmental sustainability of diets

Authors:
  • WWF Netherlands

Abstract

Simultaneous optimisation of the nutritional quality and environmental sustainability of diets The purpose of this thesis was to explore how the nutritional quality and environmental sustainability of diets can be optimised simultaneously. This work operationalised and quantified the concept of sustainable diets, as defined by the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO), by using examples from the Netherlands. Given the need to redefine dietary guidelines to include health, food security and sustainability issues, quantitative ways of combining and optimising nutritional quality and environmental sustainability were developed. Such approaches increase the concreteness of dietary advice, thus enabling consumers to make dietary choices that satisfy both nutritional and sustainability requirements. Indicators Achieving simultaneous optimisation necessitates methods of measuring the nutritional quality and the environmental sustainability. Greenhouse gas emissions (GHGE) and land use (LU) appeared to be applicable and representative indicators of the environmental sustainability of diets. In evaluating nutritional quality, the current focus is usually on negative health effects, especially those caused by sodium, saturated fats and added sugars. This thesis expanded this approach by demonstrating how positive effects can also be incorporated into measurements. Accordingly, plant proteins, essential fatty acids and dietary fibre were selected as indicators of high nutritional quality. Application The indicators were applied to evaluate and compare the current average Dutch diet with existing predefined dietary regimens, namely, adherence to dietary guidelines and flexitarian, vegetarian, vegan and Mediterranean diets. The composition of these dietary approaches were confirmed as ensuring high nutritional quality whilst simultaneously resulting in high environmental sustainability. Optimisation of diets through linear programming Subsequently, the thesis demonstrated that linear programming is an effective tool for simultaneously optimising the nutritional quality and environmental sustainability of diets. Linear programming was applied to two sample diets, after which an explanation was provided as to how elements of the FAO definition of sustainable diets can be quantified. Such quantification not only covers the optimisation of natural and human resources but also the guarantee of nutritional adequacy, thus resulting in diets with only half of the environmental impacts exerted by current diets. On the basis of the FAO definition, additional constraints were added to the quantification, thereby enabling the design of low-impact diets that are culturally acceptable and affordable. The linear programming approach generated three main findings: • An optimised, traditional Low Lands diet is as healthy as a traditional Mediterranean diet, but is more sustainable. • A sustainable diet is not necessarily more expensive. A healthy, sustainable weekly shopping basket for a two-person household can be filled for less than € 40 per week. • Linear programming enables the modelling of domains of nutritional quality, economic effects (price) and environmental sustainability across disciplines, thus paving the way for the creation of dietary programmes that are more sustainable, cheaper and more culturally acceptable than predefined dietary regimens. Synergy at product level The in-depth analysis of the predefined dietary regimens and optimised diet models revealed a synergy between nutritional quality and environmental impact at the product level. Environmental quality (especially impacts on climate change and land use) could be connected to nutritional quality at diet and product levels. This synergy is described by an index that was developed in this thesis on the basis of seven nutritional quality indicators. The index is called the Sustainable Nutrient-Rich Foods (SNRF) index. With the SNRF index as a reference, consumers and practitioners can categorise food into the following four groups, which are identifiable by colour: 1. Products rich in sodium, saturated fats and/or added sugars (red; SNRF < –1) 2. Moderately nutrient-dense animal products (white; SNFR = –1 to 0) 3. Energy-dense, moderately nutrient-dense plant products (brown; SNFR = 0 to 1) 4. Low energy-dense, high nutrient-dense plant products (green; SNFR > 1) The SNRF index can also assist in the rating of food products. For consumers, such rating helps in adhering to diets that are both healthy and sustainable; for public health organisations, SNRF-assisted rating can help them formulate well-founded recommendations for healthy and sustainable diets. In general, healthy and sustainable diets (i.e. Low Lands, Mediterranean, New Nordic and pesco-vegetarian diets) contain few products from the red group, moderate quantities of products from the white group and a high proportion of products from the brown and green groups in equal proportions (average SNRF = 1, i.e. all essential macronutrients that cover energy requirements are included in the diets). New functional unit describing nutrient density This thesis also developed a new functional unit called the Nutrient Density Unit (NDU). A functional unit is a measure of the function of a studied system —the life cycle analysis of a product or diet— providing a reference to which environmental impacts can be related. From the perspective of a healthy diet, comparing the environmental impacts of products by using metabolic energy content (kilocalorie), or even more accurately, nutrient density (defined as NDU) as a functional unit is a more practicable approach than using weight (kilogram). For example, cereals and other carbohydrate-rich products from the brown group exert the lowest environmental impact per kilocalorie, whereas vegetables, fruits, pulses and mushrooms from the green group pose the lowest environmental impact per NDU. In the end, the function, and there with the choice of the functional unit, dictates the ranking of the environmental impact of products. Opportunities for improving diet practices The final step was to test the practical applicability of the preceding results through a consumer questionnaire. The aim was to identify changes in actual food group consumption that may improve both Health and Sustainability Scores of different Dutch population subgroups (described by gender, age, education, work, income, socio-economic status, and social milieus). Opportunities for improving both scores of different population subgroups lie primarily in the reduction of meat consumption and total metabolic energy consumption. With the quantitative analysis of the diets followed by the different subgroups as a reference, four strategies were formulated: I) Replacing snacks with fruit, especially between meals II) Replacing cheese with vegetables at lunch and dinner III) Partly replacing meat with fish IV) Decreasing the consumption of alcoholic drinks and increasing the consumption of water, which reduces energy intake. These strategies can support different population subgroups in efforts to eat both healthy and sustainable diets. If deriving the highest environmental gain is the purpose of dietary adjustment, a fifth strategy is applicable: V) Halving the portions of consumed meat. Actual unsustainable diet practices of specific subgroups require dedicated transition strategies. Consumer target groups If institutions would promote more healthy and simultaneously more sustainable diets, effective strategies will be necessarily context bound and depend on current dietary patterns of specific target groups. A quintile (20%) of the Dutch population already consumes a healthy and sustainable diet. This percentage predominantly consists of older, unemployed or retired women, including groups of post-materialists and traditionals. The opposite quintile (having a relative unhealthy and unsustainable diet) comprise mainly (young) employed men, who have been determined in this thesis as the appropriate main target group for improvements to overall diet. Applying the optimised diet models and strategies to high-impact groups (high greenhouse gas emissions) can elevate nutritional quality at the population level whilst simultaneously reducing the environmental impacts of the Dutch diet. Next steps The insights derived in this research can help individual consumers make informed food choices and, at the same time, contribute to the development of baseline consumer education and future dietary guidelines that consider both nutritional quality and environmental sustainability. The first step is to recommend the consumption of more plant-based foods and less meat and the selection of products that pose the least environmental within each product group. Halving the environmental impacts of food consumption can be accomplished primarily by a combination of four actions: reducing metabolic energy intake, transitioning from an animal-based diet to a more plant-based one and replacing snacks and drinks produced with high GHGEs with healthier alternatives.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The most common suggestion for dietary intake is to lower meat consumption, especially from ruminants, and increase plant-based foods (Hallstrom et al. 2015;R€ o€ os et al. 2015). Previous research suggests diets based on theoretical calculations of how more climate-friendly diets can be achieved (Dooren 2018;R€ o€ os et al. 2015;Willett et al. 2019). It is essential to recognise and highlight how different social groups are affected by dietary changes and how they can contribute to a positive solution. ...
... The findings of links and connections to meaning (importance and attitude towards food, performance, and climate consideration) lead to a compelling argument that even high-energy consumers can reduce their climate impact from food while still performing at the desired level. This way of eating, which can be both sufficient for performance and climate consciousness, is in line with suggestions from the EAT-Lancet report (Willett et al. 2019) and other research on how to move towards climate-friendly food consumption (Dooren 2018;R€ o€ os et al. 2015). An outline of a potential climate-conscious athletic performance-centred food consumption practice is shown in Figure 5. ...
... Hence, they focus on the nutritional value and how it supports performance rather than the climate impact of whey protein. If protein intake from animal-based sources could be lowered or replaced by plant-based protein sources (Dooren 2018;R€ o€ os et al. 2015), our participants could substantially reduce their CO 2 e. Previous research on vegetarian diets' effect on physical performance showed comparable results to omnivore diets (Craddock et al. 2016;Hevia-Larra ın et al. 2021), encouraging a transition to more plant-based protein sources. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract A high food intake can contribute to increased greenhouse-gas emissions, and therefore consumers with a high energy intake are important to include when exploring sustainable foodways. In this paper, semi-structured interviews and a seven-day food record were used to understand the climate impact of food, analyse mundane food practices, and identify sustainable routines among high-energy consumers represented by a group of recreational athletes. Social practice theory and the interdependent relationship between competence, material, and meaning unfold an Athletic performance-related food practice with a focus on performance, time-saving strategies, structured eating, and a possible Climate-conscious athletic performance-related food practice where the food practice also includes important sustainability aspects. The results indicate a high carbon footprint from high energy and dairy and whey protein intake. Some recreational athletes demonstrate an awareness of the climate impact of food, but they need to be convinced that more sustainable ways are possible without jeopardising athletic performance.
... Other studies report very high LU of beef, e.g. 78.5 m 2 /kg beef in Dooren (2018), due to more extensive systems and higher proportion of low yielding permanent pastures. In future studies, LU should be differentiated into different types of land. ...
Article
The potential to reduce GHG emissions and land use of the diet by replacing animal-based protein sources with foods containing oat protein concentrate (OPC) was analysed by life cycle assessment (LCA) of six different scenarios of daily food intake of one adult. The OPC was used in the preparation of bread and pasta and as a substitute for milk in yoghurt resulting in a higher protein content of these foods. The present study showed, that dietary-related GHG emissions and land use can be reduced by substituting animal-based proteins by foods containing oat protein. If the oat protein (OPC) enriched food items substitute animal based protein sources in the diet proportionally, GHG emission from the diet could be reduced by 8% and land use by 14%. However, if the OPC enriched food items are used specifically to replace intake of all beef and some pork, GHG emissions from the diet could be reduced by 13% and land use by 26%. Thereby, use of new plant-based protein ingredients in diets has a considerable potential to mitigate climate change and reduce land use. Even though the presented scenarios are extreme, they clearly demonstrate the potential that OPC food products made it possible to replace some of the animal-based protein with this plant-based protein source.
Article
Full-text available
Recently, it has been suggested that a shift towards diets with a lower carbon footprints, especially ones that emphasize the consumption of plants, is necessary to keep global heating below 2 °C. To address demand for animal-based products, we analyze if the effectiveness of anthropomorphic food labeling as a strategy for promoting plant-based diets is contingent on strong animal ethical beliefs. To this end, we conduct a stated choice experiment with Chilean university students (N = 1538). We manipulate the visual display of the main component of the dish attribute of the choice tasks, using anthropomorphic and non-anthropomorphic icons to frame the choice of meal options. Our results, which are based on a mixed logit model of the choice data and a linear regression analysis of its individual random parameters, suggest that displaying anthropomorphic icons reduces the likelihood of choosing beef or chicken over vegetables. However, the data provides insufficient evidence to claim an influence on the choice of fish over vegetables. The ethical intuitions that anthropomorphic animals evoke are related to a reduction in the consumption of beef and chicken but do not appear to affect preferences for fish. Our findings support the hypothesis that strong ethical concerns reinforce the effect of anthropomorphic nudges on beef consumption. The results for chicken and fish were inconclusive.
Article
Full-text available
In recent decades, the theory of robust optimization has been introduced as a powerful tool for optimizing uncertain processes. Regarding the Uncertainty of the glycemic load of consumed food, the main purpose of this article is to provide an optimal Iranian diet using a robust optimization to adjust the glycemic load in patients with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes type 2 is a devastating disease, in addition to cardiovascular disease, infectious and kidney diseases, causes insulin resistance and cancer and drugs of cholesterol-lowering have an increased risk of cardiovascular complications and incidence of cancer. Indeed, adjustment of nutrition is important to prevent and control or reduce the complications of diabetes. In this paper, due to the uncertainty of the glycemic load of foods, with collecting necessary nutritional information, the Iranian diet model is determined and analyzed by a robust optimization method. According to this, 75 cases of food (42 Iranian food, 10 Foodstuffs for breakfast, 20 types of fruits and fruit juices and 3 types of dairy products) have been studied locally. The benefits of this model are the ability to adapt according to the person's tastes and opinion of the nutritionist with minimizing changes for the current diet of the individual.
Chapter
Eten volgens de Schijf van Vijf levert naast gezondheidswinst, ook winst voor het milieu op. Wanneer daarnaast binnen de vijf vakken van de schijf meer duurzame keuzes gemaakt worden, is extra duurzaamheidswinst te realiseren. Denk aan minder of geen vlees eten en vaker kiezen voor seizoensproducten. Dit hoofdstuk gaat over waarom het belangrijk is om rekening te houden met duurzaamheid, hoe milieu-impact van voedingspatronen te meten is en hoe gezond en duurzaam samen kunnen gaan. Er komen ook praktische hulpmiddelen aan bod, zoals de Voedselafdruk, de Eetmeter, keurmerken en een handige index. Ten slotte worden zeven adviesregels gegeven om duurzamere keuzes te maken.
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To model dietary changes required to shift the UK population to diets that meet dietary recommendations for health, have lower greenhouse gas emissions (GHGE) and are affordable for different income groups. Design: Linear programming was used to create diets that meet dietary requirements for health and reduced GHGE (57% and 80% targets) by income quintile, taking into account food budgets and foods currently purchased, thereby keeping dietary change to a minimum. Subjects: Nutrient composition, GHGE and price data were mapped to 101 food groups in household food purchase data (UK Living Cost and Food Survey (2013), n=5144 households). Results: Current diets of all income quintiles had similar total GHGE, but the source of GHGE differed by types of meat, and amount of fruit and vegetables. It was possible to create diets with a 57% reduction in GHGE that met dietary and cost restraints in all income groups. In the optimised diets, the food sources of GHGE differed by income group due to the cost and keeping the level of deviation from current diets to a minimum. Broadly, the changes needed were similar across all groups; reducing animal-based products and increasing plant-based foods but varied by specific foods. Conclusions: Healthy and lower GHGE diets could be created in all income quintiles but tailoring changes to income groups to minimise deviation may make dietary changes more achievable. Specific attention must be given to interventions and policies to be appropriate for all income groups.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.