Éleveurs et territoires pâturés face aux loups : bilan à 25 ans

Full text

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
.%
Éleveurs(et(territoires(pâturés(face(aux(loups(:(bilan(à(25(ans(
%
;<=>"?%;"$4"1.%@%&<"44"8AB$</%'/1C,%
%
.%DE!FG%(;!%H"?2"1G%-I555G%;B*10"??<"4%
,%DE!F%>B*B4J<4"G%KB*/"<?%/=<"*1<L<M$"%N"%?OP*1"*1"%<*1"4NQ0J41"2"*1J?"%KJ$//"/%"1%KQ#"**"/%
%
K"% =>J0<14"% /OJ00$<"% ?J4R"2"*1% /$4% N"/% 14J#J$S% N"/%=>"4=>"$4/% N$% 4Q/"J$% K'FTF&UV% (Coadaptation* entre*
prédateurs* et* humains* dans* leurs* territoires)*W% >110W))XXX7/JN7<*4J7L4)!"=>"4=>"/)KBJNJ01J1<B*804"NJ1"$4/8
>$2J<*/%
%
%
Y"*$/%NOD1J?<"G%<?%C%J%#<*R18=<*M%J*/G%N"/%?B$0/%B*1%<*#"/1<%?"%/$N%N"/%F?0"/%"1%?J%&4B#"*="G%4<=>"/%"*%R<3<"4%
"1%"*%2B$1B*/7%D?/%B*1%"*/$<1"%04BR4"//Q%N"%04B=>"%"*%04B=>"G%"1%0J4LB</%0J4%3B*N/G%NOJ3B4N%#"4/%?"%
*B4NG%0$</%QRJ?"2"*1%#"4/%?OB$"/17%V4"*1"8/"01%NQ0J41"2"*1/%/B*1%J$ZB$4NO>$<%=B*="4*Q/%[L<R$4"%.\7%P*%
/B41<"% NO><#"4% ,5.98.6G% B*1% Q1Q% 4"="*/Q"/% ]6%^B*"/% N"% 04Q/"*="% 0"42J*"*1"%N"% ?B$0/G% NB*1% I,%
1"44<1B<4"/%N"%2"$1"/%['EK_HG%,5.6\7%K"11"%"S0J*/<B*%2J4M$"%?"%/$==`/%N"/%0B?<1<M$"/%2</"/%"*%a$#4"%
/"?B*%?J%KB*#"*1<B*%N"%b"4*"G%"*%#<R$"$4%N"0$</%.cd,G%"1%?J%T<4"=1<#"%UJ3<1J18_J$*"8_?B4"%c,)I-)KPP7%
P*%"LL"1G%?"%?B$0%L<R$4"%"*%3B**"%0?J="%NJ*/%?J%?</1"%N"/%"/0`="/%/14<=1"2"*1%04B1QRQ"/7%
T"%LJ<1G%N"0$</%M$"?M$"/%NQ="**<"/G%*B$/%J004"*B*/%e%J004Q=<"4%LJ$*"/%"1%L?B4"/%4"2J4M$J3?"/7%P??"/%
/B*1%<*#"*1B4<Q"/%"1%?"$4/%>J3<1J1/%NQ?<2<1Q/%"*%#$"%N"%?"/%04B1QR"47%K"%*O"/1%0J/%?"%=J/%N$%?B$07%K"%M$<%
/<R*<L<"%M$O<?%J%/J%0?J="%0J41B$1%NJ*/%?"%0JC/%"*%>J$1%N"%*B/%0C4J2<N"/%Q=B?BR<M$"/G%/"?B*%?J%NBSJ%N"%
2<?<1J*1/%Q=B?BR</1"/%04B=?J2J*1%M$"% ="%/$0"4804QNJ1"$4%"/1% ?"% RJ4J*1% <*N</0"*/J3?"% "1% ?OB0Q4J1"$4%
04<#<?QR<Q%N"%?J%/J*1Q%N"%*B/%Q=B/C/1`2"/%1"44"/14"/7%
AJ%4QLQ4"*="%2JZ"$4"G%0J/%1B$ZB$4/%"S0?<=<1"G%#<"*1%N$%0J4=%*J1<B*J?%N"%f"??BX/1B*"G%J$S%g1J1/8(*</7%'4G%
N"0$</%?J%L<*%N$%hDh"%/<`=?"G%="%0J4=%<22"*/"%:%M$J/<2"*1%?J%/$4LJ="%N"%N"$S%NQ0J41"2"*1/%:%J%Q1Q%#<NQ%
N"/%F2Q4<*N<"*/G%0$</%N"%1B$1"%J$14"%J=1<#<1Q%JR4<=B?"%"1%N"%=>J//"7%D?%*B$44<1%3"J$=B$0%N"%3</B*/%"1%N"%
="4L/G%2J</%J$//<%N<#"4/%04QNJ1"$4/G% NB*1%N"/% ?B$0/%<20B41Q/% N$%KJ*JNJ% "*%.cc]8c97% A"$4% 4"1B$4%J$%
f"??BX/1B*"G%N"%?OJ#</%NO"S0"41/%<20?<M$Q/%NJ*/%?OB0Q4J1<B*G%*O"/1%0J/%LB4=Q2"*1%e%?OB4<R<*"%N"/%"LL"1/%
Q=B?BR<M$"/%"*%=J/=JN"%M$OB*%C%=Q?`34"%14B0%LJ=<?"2"*1G%"1%Z$/M$"%NJ*/%?"%?<1%N"/%4<#<`4"/%[;"=>G%,5.,\7%
H$41B$1G%="/%"LL"1/%*OB*1%4<"*%NOQ#<N"*1%NJ*/%N"/%0JC/JR"/%3<"*%0?$/%>J3<1Q/%"1%RQ4Q/%0J4%?"/%>$2J<*/G%
1"?/%="$S%NOP$4B0"%N"%?OB$"/17%
P*% _4J*="G% ?"/% 2B/JiM$"/% #J4<Q"/% N"% 04J<4<"/G% 0"?B$/"/G% ?J*N"/% "1% 04Q/83B</% /B*1% /14$=1$4Q"/% "1%
"*14"1"*$"/% 0J4%?"% 0j1$4JR"G% ?J% LJ$=>"% "1% ?"/% /B<*/% N$% 3Q1J<?7% AJ% 04Q/"*="% N"%="*1J<*"/%NO"/0`="/%
/J$#JR"/%4"2J4M$J3?"/%C%J11"/1"%N"/%<*1"4J=1<B*/%0B/<1<#"/%"*14"%="/% 04J1<M$"/%"1%?J%3<BN<#"4/<1Q%/$4%
?JM$"??"%?"/% 0B?<1<M$"/% "*#<4B**"2"*1J?"/%LB=J?</"*1%?OJ11"*1<B*7%;J</% ?OJ44<#Q"%N"/% ?B$0/G%=B22"%?"%
/B$?<R*J<1%NQZe%T"#"44"%[.ccc\G%J%RQ*Q4Q%$*%0J4JNBS"%2JZ"$4%0B$4%?"/%Q?"#"$4/7%D*=<1Q/%e%4"NQ0?BC"4%?"%
0j1$4JR"% J$8N"?e% N"/% 04J<4<"/% =$?1<#Q"/% "*% #$"% N"% RQ4"4% ?"/% 0JC/JR"/% 2"*J=Q/% 0J4% ?O"S=`/%
NO"234B$//J<??"2"*1G% <?/% B*1G% ="% LJ</J*1G% N<4"=1"2"*1% "S0B/Q% ?"$4/% 14B$0"J$S% e% ?J% 04QNJ1<B*G% ?"/%
1"44<1B<4"/%"*%2B/JiM$"%N"#"*J*1%="%M$"%?OQ=B?BR<"%N"/%R4J*N/%=J4*<#B4"/%M$J?<L<"%N"%k%0JC/JR"/%N"%?J%
0"$4%l% [AJ$*N4Q% et* al,%,5.5\7% m% 0J41<4% N"% .cc6G% N"/%2"/$4"/%N"% 04B1"=1<B*% N"/% 14B$0"J$S% B*1%Q1Q%
<*/1<1$Q"/7% D?% LJ$1%"SJ2<*"4% ="/% 2"/$4"/%0B$4% Q#J?$"4%?"$4/% ?<2<1"/G% ="% M$"% NQ2B*14"% ?O"S0J*/<B*%
=B*1<*$"%N"/%=Bn1/%04<#Q/%"1%0$3?<=/%N"%?J%04QNJ1<B*%"1%/J*/%*QR?<R"4%?J%4Q"??"%NQ14"//"%N"/%Q?"#"$4/.7%
%
Les(mesures(de(protection(des(troupeaux(
%
A"% N</0B/<1<L% =B*/</1"% "*% $*% =B*14J1G% J//B41<% N"% /$3#"*1<B*/G% M$<% J//B=<"%$*"%04Q/"*="% >$2J<*"%
4"*LB4=Q"G%N"%R4B/%=><"*/%N"%04B1"=1<B*%"1%$*%0J4=JR"%*B=1$4*"%/Q=$4</Q7%T"0$</%,55IG%="%N</0B/<1<L%J%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
.%TQ14"//"%e%04B0B/%N"%?JM$"??"%$*%=>J0<14"%"*1<"4%/"4J<1%*Q="//J<4"7%KO"/1%0B$4M$B<%*B$/%*"%?OJ3B4N"4B*/%0J/%<=<7%EB$/%
4"=B22J*NB*/%="11"%#<NQB%N"%?J%;HF%F4N`=>"%T4o2"%AB<4"G%T7%A"%p?J*<=%[,5.,\%W%
>110W))XXX7NJ<?C2B1<B*7=B2)#<N"B)SXR*.]q"?"#"$4/8?"/82B4/$4"/8<*#</<3?"/q*"X/%

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
,%
Q1Q%2J//<#"2"*1%JNB01Q%NJ*/%?"%/$N8"/1%N$%0JC/7%A"%*B234"%NOQ?"#"$4/%=B*14J=1J*1/G%"*#<4B*%,]55G%C%
=B44"/0B*N%J$ZB$4NO>$<%e%="?$<%N"/%0?J="/%N"%0j1$4JR"%[TB34"2"^%et*alG%,5.9\7%
%
AJ%04Q/"*="%>$2J<*"%4"*LB4=Q"*0J//"% 0J4% ?O"23J$=>"% NO$*%"20?BCQG% N<1% k%J<N"83"4R"4%lG%0B$4%?"/%
1j=>"/%/$00?Q2"*1J<4"/%?<Q"/%e%?J%04B1"=1<B*7% H<1$Q"/%?"%0?$/%/B$#"*1%"*%NQ3$1%N"%2J1<*Q"G%/B<4Q"%"1%
NQ3$1%N"%*$<1G%"??"/%B*1%Q1Q%Q#J?$Q"/%e%,55%>"$4"/%0J4%2B</%0B$4%$*%R4B/%14B$0"J$%NOB#<*/%"*%J?0JR"%
"1%e% J$%2B<*/%.55%>"$4"/%0J4%2B</%0B$4%$*%14B$0"J$%NOB#<*/%B$%=J04<*/%>B4/%J?0JR"%[pJ4N"G%,556\7%
b<"*%M$"%/$3#"*1<B**Q"/%["??"/%4"04Q/"*1"*1%0?$/%N"%65%r%N"/%LB*N/%0$3?<=/%J??B$Q/%J$S%2"/$4"/%N"%
04B1"=1<B*\G% ="/% "23J$=>"/% /B*1% =Bn1"$/"/% "1% 0J/% LJ=<?"/%W% JLLJ<4"% N"% =B*N<1<B*/% N"% 14J#J<?G% N"%
04B2</=$<1Q%NJ*/%N"/%0"1<1/%?BR"2"*1/G% NO>B4J<4"/%Q=?J1Q/7% T$%LJ<1%N"/%>B4J<4"/%M$O<20B/"%?OQ?"#JR"G%
?O"20?B<%4Q0J41<%NJ*/%$*%=B??"=1<L%NO"20?BC"$4/G%2s2"%e%04BS<2<1QG%*O"/1%0J/%04J1<=J3?"7*
%
T"/%=><"*/%N"%04B1"=1<B*G%J3/"*1/%N"%_4J*="G%/J$L%NJ*/%?"/%&C4Q*Q"/G%N"0$</%0?$/%NO$*%/<`=?"G%B*1%Q1Q%
4Q<*14BN$<1/%NJ*/%?"/%14B$0"J$S%B#<*/%"1%=J04<*/7%P*%,5.9G%<?/%/B*1%"*#<4B*%-555%NJ*/%?"%/$N8"/1%N"%?J%
_4J*="7% A"$4% <*1"4#"*1<B*%0"$1%NB**"4%N"/% 4Q/$?1J1/% 04B3J*1/G% *B*%/J*/%N"% /Q4<"$/"/% N<LL<=$?1Q/%
[Y<*="*1G%,5..\7%T"%?J%/Q?"=1<B*%"1%N$%N4"//JR"%N"%="/%=><"*/G%B*%J11"*N%M$"%/"%/"*1J*1%0J41<"%<*1QR4J*1"%
N$%14B$0"J$G%<?/%/B<"*1%#<R<?J*1/G%4QJ=1<L/%"1%JR4"//<L/%LJ="%J$S%?B$0/7%;J</%<?/%NB<#"*1%J$//<%1B?Q4"4%?"/%
>$2J<*/%M$<G%"*%#B</<*/%B$%4J*NB**"$4/G%0J4LB</%*B234"$SG%L4QM$"*1"*1%?"/%2s2"/%?<"$S7%;J?R4Q%?"/%
J#"41<//"2"*1/% "1%?"/% 04Q=J$1<B*/G% ?"/% <*=<N"*1/%/"% 2$?1<0?<"*1G% J2"*J*1% N"/%Q?"#"$4/% N"#J*1% ?"/%
14<3$*J$SG%"1%?"/%2J<4"/%/B*1%N"%0?$/%"*%0?$/%*B234"$S%e%/O<*M$<Q1"4%N"%="%M$<%N"#<"*1%$*%04B3?`2"%N"%
/Q=$4<1Q%0$3?<M$"7%AO"*Z"$%/B=<J?%"1%Q=B*B2<M$"%0B$4%?"/%2$?1<8$/JR"/%N"%?O"/0J="%4$4J?G%C%=B204</%J$%
/"<*%N"/%#<??JR"/G%N"#<"*1%2JZ"$47%
&B$4%?"/%Q?"#"$4/%"$S82s2"/G%?"%=J><"4%N"/%=>J4R"/%N"/%=><"*/%"/1%=B*/QM$"*17%F#"=%J$%2<*<2$2%N"$S%
=><"*/% 0J4% ?B1% NOJ*<2J$S%J$% 0j1$4JR"G% M$"% 0"$1% LJ<4"% ?OQ?"#"$4% /B<R*"$S% M$<% =B*N$<1% <=<% /"/% 34"3</%
J??J<1J*1"/%B$%14J<1"/G%?e%?"/%#<N"/%B$%R"/1J*1"/G%J<??"$4/%?"/%Z"$*"/%0B$4%?"%4"*B$#"??"2"*1%t%_J="%e%$*"%
2"$1"G%=O"/1%0<4"%W%NOJ04`/%?O"S0Q4<"*="%N"/%Q?"#"$4/%N"/%F34$^^"/G%"*%D1J?<"G%=O"/1%$*"%2"$1"%N"%=><"*/G%
N"%]%e%.]%0J4%14B$0"J$G%M$O<?%LJ$1%2B3<?</"4G%"*%RJ4NJ*1%$*%=B??"=1<L%/1J3?"%"1%*B*%N<#</<3?"%[pJ4N"G%,5.9\7%
%
A"%4"R4B$0"2"*1%*B=1$4*"%/C/1Q2J1<M$"%"*%0J4=%Q?"=14<L<QG%e%NB$3?"%"*="<*1"G%e%04BS<2<1Q%N"/%>$2J<*/%
M$"%?"/%=><"*/%0"$#"*1%J?"41"4G%0"$1%/OJ#Q4"4%"LL<=J="%?B4/M$O<?%"/1%4QJ?</J3?"%[KP!&F;%et*al,*,5.,\7%;J</%
=B20J4Q%e%?J%04J1<M$"%B4N<*J<4"G%="%N</0B/<1<L%=B20B41"%N"%R4B/%<*=B*#Q*<"*1/7%P*%"/1<#"G%<?%"/1%NO$/JR"%
M$"%?"%14B$0"J$%J<1%?O<*<1<J1<#"%N$%/<1"%"1%N"%?O>"$4"%N"%/J%k%=B$=>JN"%l%u%J<??"$4/G%/$41B$1%"*%0Q4<BN"%
=>J$N"G%<?%J004Q=<"%N"%RQ4"4%/B*%1"20/%ZB$4%"1%*$<1G%"*%=B*1<*$7%AOB3?<RJ1<B*G%"*%L<*%N"%ZB$4*Q"G%N"%?"%
4J//"23?"4%"1%N"%RJR*"4%?"%0J4=%N"%*$<1%0B?J4</"%"S="//<#"2"*1%?O$/JR"%N$%1"44<1B<4"%0j1$4QG%RQ*Q4J*1%
N"%LB41"/%>Q1Q4BRQ*Q<1Q/7%P??"%N<2<*$"%?J%N$4Q"%$1<?"%N"%0j1$4JR"%"1%NB*=%?"/%0B//<3<?<1Q/%NOJZ$/1"2"*1%
J$S%4"//B$4="/7%P??"%J=="*1$"%?"/%0<Q1<*"2"*1/%?B=J?</Q/%"1%?"/%4</M$"/%NOQ4B/<B*7%TJ*/%?"%0J4=%N"%*$<1%
?$<82s2"G%?O"*1J//"2"*1G%?J%NQR4JNJ1<B*%N$%/B?%"1%?OJ3B*NJ*="%N"/%NQZ"=1<B*/%=B204B2"11"*1%?OQ1J1%
/J*<1J<4"%N"/%J*<2J$S7%TJ*/%?"/%0>J/"/%/"*/<3?"/%N"%?J%#<"%N$%14B$0"J$G%/B*%Q1J1%"1%/"/%0"4LB42J*="/%
/B*1%e%=B$0%/n4%0Q*J?</Q/7%
%
Progression(et(diversification(de(la(prédation(
%
T"%,55d%e% ,5.9G% /"?B*% ?O'EK_HG%?O"LL"=1<L% 2BC"*% "/1<2Q% N"% ?B$0/% 14<0?"% [N"% ..c% e% -]6\% "1%="11"%
=4B<//J*="%"/1%N"%1"*NJ*="%?<*QJ<4"%[L<R$4"%,\7%P??"%"/1%0?$/%2J4M$Q"%0B$4%?"%*B234"%J**$"?%N"%#<=1<2"/G%
2$?1<0?<Q%0J4%04`/%N"%M$J14"%[N"%,96]%e%cc]c\7%K"11"%04BR4"//<B*G%?O"S1"*/<B*%N"/%1"44<1B<4"/%Bv%?"/%?B$0/%
/B*1%04Q/"*1/%*O"*%4"*N%0J/%=B201"7%P*%"LL"1%?"/%Q?"#JR"/%N"/%/"01%NQ0J41"2"*1/%<*#"/1</%"*%04"2<"4G%
04B#"*wJ$S%"1% J?0<*/G%/$3<//"*1%"*=B4"%c5%r%N"/%0"41"/%1B1J?"/%[L<R$4"%-\G%NB*1% $*% 1<"4/G%"*%,5.]%"1%
,5.9G%NJ*/%?"/%F?0"/%;J4<1<2"/G%NQ0J41"2"*1%k%NOJ44<#Q"%l%N"/%?B$0/7%
P*% 0?$/% N"/%#<=1<2"/%Nn2"*1% 4Q0"41B4<Q"/% [L<R$4"% ,%"1% -\G% <?% LJ$1% =B*/<NQ4"4%?J% 0"41"%N"/% J*<2J$S%
N</0J4$/%B$% *B*%<*N"2*</J3?"/%W%0J/%4"14B$#Q/%"*%4J</B*%N$% 1"44J<*% 14`/% J==<N"*1QG% B$% 4"14B$#Q/%"*%
14B0%2J$#J</%Q1J1G%N$%LJ<1%N"/%=>J4BR*J4N/G%0B$4%s14"%4"=B**$/%#<=1<2"/%N"/% ?B$0/7% TJ*/%?"/% F?0"/G%
bJ=>J%et*al.%[,556\%B*1%"/1<2Q%M$O$*"%3s1"%"/1%2J*M$J*1"%0B$4%N"$S%<*N"2*</Q"/7%P*L<*G%*"%/B*1%0J/%

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
-%
Q#J?$Q"/% ?"/% =B*/QM$"*="/% N<1"/% x<*N<4"=1"/O% N"/% J11JM$"/%W% /14"//% e% "LL"1% N$4J3?"G% J#B41"2"*1/G%
3?"//$4"/%"S1"4*"/%B$%<*1"4*"/%0J4LB</%?Q1J?"/7%
%
VB$1"/%?"/%"/0`="/G%B#<*/G%=J04<*/G%3B#<*/G%QM$<*/G%j*"/%"1%?J2J/G%=B*14<3$"*1%J$S%0"41"/7%P*%"LL"1G%?"/%
B#<*/%*"%/B*1%0J/%?"/%/"$?"/%#<=1<2"/7%A"/%=>`#4"/%"*%B*1%LJ<1%0J41<"%N"0$</%?OB4<R<*"%"1%J$ZB$4NO>$<%-55%
e%]55%/B*1%1$Q"/%=>JM$"%J**Q"7%A"/%0"41"/%N"%3B#<*/G%04<*=<0J?"2"*1%N"/%#"J$S%"1%RQ*<//"/G%4"/1"*1%
?<2<1Q"/%e%$*"%="*1J<*"%0J4%J*G%"*%4"?J1<B*%J#"=%?J%LB41"%04QNB2<*J*="%N"/%0"1<1/%4$2<*J*1/%?e%Bv%?"/%
?B$0/%/B*1% J$ZB$4NO>$<% 04Q/"*1/7% ;J</%?"/% 0"41"/%N"% 3B#<*/%B*1%NB$3?Q%J$% =B$4/% N"/%14B</%N"4*<`4"/%
J**Q"/%"1%/<%?"/%?B$0/%=B?B*</"*1%*B1J22"*1%?"%="*14"%N$%;J//<L%K"*14J?G%?"%1J3?"J$%Q#B?$"4J7%F$=$*%
JZ$/1"2"*1%N"/%2"/$4"/%N"%04B1"=1<B*%*O"/1%=B*w$%e%="1%QRJ4N7%AO<*M$<Q1$N"%RJR*"%J$//<%?"/%Q?"#"$4/%
N"%=>"#J$SG%j*"/%"1%?J2J/G%/B$#"*1%"*%0"1<1/%?B1/%[0J4LB</%N"$S%B$%14B</%<*N<#<N$/\G%NJ*/%N"%0"1<1/%0J4=/%
N<//Q2<*Q/7%
%
Impasse(technique,(mais(pas(seulement...(
(
A"/%NQRj1/%N"/%?B$0/%"S0?B/"*17%VB$/%?"/%Q?"#"$4/%N"%0?"<*%J<4%0"$#"*1%/"%#B<4%L4J00Q/%NO$*"%/"4#<1$N"%
<20J4J3?"%M$<%NQ14$<1%?"$4%2Q1<"4%"1%=B204B2"1%?"%L$1$4%N"/%=B??"=1<#<1Q/%Bv%<?/%#<#"*17%AJ%/<1$J1<B*%"/1%
2J*<L"/1"2"*1%>B4/%N"%=B*14o?"7%
K"%*O"/1% 0J/% LJ$1"% NO<*<1<J1<#"/% "1% NO"LLB41/%N"% ?J% 0J41% N"/% Q?"#"$4/7% P*% 1Q2B<R*"*1% ?"% 4"=B$4/% J$S%
2"/$4"/%N"%04B1"=1<B*7%AOg1J1G%0B$4%/J%0J41G%C%JLL"=1"%N"/%/B22"/%=B*/<NQ4J3?"/7%P*%,5.]G%=OQ1J<1%.dG6%
2<??<B*/% NO"$4B/% e% ?OJ00$<% N"%?J% 0J41% N"/% Q?"#"$4/% "/1<2Q"% e%-G]% 2<??<B*/G% 0?$/%,Gc% 2<??<B*/% 0B$4%
?O<*N"2*</J1<B*%N"/%0"41"/G%M$"%?OB*%/J<1%<*=B20?`1"7%
H"?B*%?"/%/1J1</1<M$"/%N</0B*<3?"/%e%?O<*1"4*J1<B*J?G%4J4"/%"1%N"%L<J3<?<1Q%#J4<J3?"%/"?B*%?"/%0JC/G%?J%_4J*="%
/"23?"%s14"%?"%0JC/%J$%2B*N"%M$<%/$3<1%?"%0?$/%N"%0"41"/%N$"/%e%?J%04QNJ1<B*%N"/%?B$0/7%P??"/%/B*1G%0J4%
"S"20?"G%-5% LB</%/$0Q4<"$4"/% e% ="??"/% N"/% 14B</% Q1J1/%N$% *B4N%N"/%!B=>"$/"/% J$S% g1J1/8(*</% [DNJ>BG%
yCB2<*R%"1%;B*1J*J\G%Bv% ?OQ?"#JR"%3B#<*%"1%B#<*%"/1%3<"*%04Q/"*1G% C% =B204</% /$4%?"/%"/1<#"/G% "1%?"/%
?B$0/%J$%*B234"%NO"*#<4B*%.655%[(H%_</>%J*N%y<?N?<L"%H"4#<="G%,5.9\7%
%
P*%_4J*="G%e% *B14"%J#</G% ?"/%2"/$4"/% N"% 04B1"=1<B*%N"/% 14B$0"J$SG% LJ$1"%N"%04"*N4"%"*% =B201"%?"/%
=J0J=<1Q/%NOJNJ01J1<B*%N"/%?B$0/G%?"$4%B*1%?J<//Q%?"%=>J20%?<34"G%e%?OJ34<%N"%?"$4%/1J1$1%?QRJ?%04<#<?QR<Q7%
P*%1B$1"/%/B41"/%N"%/<1$J1<B*/G%="/%04QNJ1"$4/%<*1"??<R"*1/%0J4#<"**"*1G%N"%LJwB*%/B$#"*1%<204Q#</<3?"G%
e%/"%*B$44<4%"1% /"% 4"04BN$<4"% [A"/=$4"$S% "1%A<**"??G%,5.5\%u% ?"$4%B4RJ*</J1<B*%"*%2"$1"/%LJ#B4</"%N"/%
J004"*1<//JR"/G%N"/%"S0?B4J1<B*/G%"1%0"42"1%N"/%3B*N/%NQ2BR4J0><M$"/%[;"=>%"1%bB<1J*<G%,55-\7%K"/%
=J0J=<1Q/G%0J41B$1%3<"*%4"0Q4Q"/G%/"%2J*<L"/1"*1%"*%_4J*="%W%0J4%"S"20?"G%?"/%?B$0/%J11JM$"*1%"*%0?"<*%
ZB$4%N"/%14B$0"J$S%NQ/B42J</%0J4M$Q/%?J%*$<1%/B$/%3B**"%RJ4N"%[L<R$4"%I\7%T"0$</%0?$/%N"%,5%J*/G%<?/%
B*1%0$%/J*/%=4J<*1"%=4B</"4%N"%*B234"$S%>$2J<*/G%/=4$1"4%"1%J004B=>"4%?"$4/%J*<2J$S%J$%0j1$4JR"7%'*%
*"%0"$1%0J/%/xQ1B**"4%M$O<?/%J<??"*1%Z$/M$Oe%2"*"4%?"$4%=>J//"%"*%3B4N%N"%4B$1"G%B$%2s2"%e%?OB4Q"%NO$*%
#<??JR"%[0>B1B% .\7% AJ% 1Q2Q4<1Q% N"/% ?B$0/G% #B<4"% ?"$4/% J01<1$N"/% 1J=1<M$"/G% 0"$#"*1% /OJ#Q4"4% 0J4LB</%
"S="01<B**"??"/%[pJ4N"%"1%;"$4"1G%,5.6\7%
%
Pistes(de(solution(…(tardives(
%
AJ%T<4"=1<#"%UJ3<1J1/%J$1B4</"G%e%=B*N<1<B*%N"%*"%0J/%2"114"%"*%0Q4<?%?"%2J<*1<"*%N"%?J%0B0$?J1<B*%NJ*/%
k% $*% Q1J1%N"% =B*/"4#J1<B*%LJ#B4J3?"%lG%N"/% 04Q?`#"2"*1/%NQ4BRJ1B<4"/%N"%?B$0/G% "*14"% J$14"/%0B$4%
k%04Q#"*<4%N"/%NB22JR"/%<20B41J*1/%e%?zQ?"#JR"%lG%k%"*%?zJ3/"*="%N"%/B?$1<B*/%J?1"4*J1<#"/%l7%
H<%?"/%"S0"41/%B*1%"*=B4"%N$%2J?%e%/"%04B*B*="4%/$4%?OQ1J1%N"%=B*/"4#J1<B*%LJ#B4J3?"%[T$=>J20%et*alG%
,5.6\G% ?"/% NB22JR"/% <20B41J*1/%e% ?OQ?"#JR"%/B*1% Q#<N"*1/% "1% #B*1% =4B<//J*1%[L<R$4"% ,\G% 1J*N</%
M$"%?OJ3/"*="%N"%/B?$1<B*/%J?1"4*J1<#"/%"/1%0J1"*1"7%A"/%1"=>*<M$"/%N"%N<//$J/<B*%0J//<#"G%"1%2s2"%?"/%
=?o1$4"/%N"%0J4=%N"%0j1$4JR"%/$4Q?"#Q"/%"1%Q?"=14<L<Q"/G%*OJ00J4J<//"*1%"*%L<*%N"%=B201"%M$"%/1<2$?"4%
?O<*#"*1<#<1Q%NO$*%04QNJ1"$4%1"*J="7%{$J*1%e%=?B</B**"4%?"/%0j1$4JR"/G%*<%?J%LJ$*"%*<%?"/%$/JR"4/%>$2J<*/%
*OC%14B$#"4J<"*1%?"$4%=B201"7%D?%"*%"/1%N"%2s2"%N"%?J%2$?1<0?<=J1<B*%N"/%=><"*/%N"%04B1"=1<B*G%J$1B$4%
NO$*"%N<^J<*"%0J4%Q?"#JR"G%=B22"%J$ZB$4NO>$<%"*%D1J?<"%"1%0J4LB</%"*%P/0JR*"7%

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
I%
%
A"%0B/1$?J1%M$"%?"/%?B$0/%4"/1"*1%e%N</1J*="%NO$*"%04Q/"*="%>$2J<*"%#<R<?J*1"%"1%=B*1<*$"%*"%1<"*1%M$"%
/<%="11"%N"4*<`4"%"/1%QM$<0Q"%0B$4%4"0B$//"4%J=1<#"2"*1%$*"%J11JM$"7%P*%N<#"4/%0JC/G%B*%/J<1%3<"*%M$"%
?"/%?B$0/%<N"*1<L<"*1%?"%34$<1%NO$*%L$/<?%M$OB*%=>J4R"%"1%2s2"%?OBN"$4%N"%?J%0B$N4"%/<%B*%?"$4%4J00"??"%
N"%1"20/% e%J$14"%?J%2"*J="% M$<%?OJ==B20JR*"%[A"/=$4"$SG%,556\7%K"0"*NJ*1G%/<% ?"% 3"4R"4%B$%#J=>"4%
*O"/1%M$"% #<R<?"G%$*"% 04J1<M$"%=B22$*"%0J4%"S"20?"%J$S%g1J1/8(*</G%<?%*"%0<?B1"%0?$/%?OJ?<2"*1J1<B*%
M$B1<N<"**"%N"/%J*<2J$S% $*"% LB</%/B41</%N$% 0J4=% N"%*$<1% 0B$4% ?J%ZB$4*Q"G% *<% ?"%4"*B$#"??"2"*1%N"/%
4"//B$4="/%0j1$4Q"/7%;J11%bJ4*"/G%B0Q4J*1%J$S%g1J1/8(*</%0B$4%?O'Ep%People*and*Carnivores%e%04B1QR"4%
?"/%R4J*N/%=J4*<#B4"/%1B$1%"*%2<*<2</J*1%?"/%=B*L?<1/%J#"=%?"/%Q?"#"$4/G%"/1%LB42"?%W%k%A"/%?B$0/%NB<#"*1%
J//B=<"4%?"%3Q1J<?%J#"=%?"/%>$2J<*/G%"1%?"/%>$2J<*/%J#"=%?"%NJ*R"4%u%?"/%>$2J<*/%0"$#"*1%4"0B$//"4%?"/%
?B$0/G%2J</%<?/%NB<#"*1%s14"%e%?J%LB</%=B*#J<*=J*1/%"1%1"*J="/%u%?B4/M$O$*%?B$0%J%NQZe%B31"*$%$*%04BL<1%
J?<2"*1J<4"%/$4%N$%3Q1J<?G%<?%N"#<"*1%*"11"2"*1%0?$/%N<LL<=<?"%e%4"0B$//"4%l%[bJ4*"/G%comm.*pers.%,5.]\7%%
%
D?%4"/1"4J<1%NB*=G%NJ*/%*B/%=B*N<1<B*/G%e%4"=4$1"4G%LB42"4%"1%QM$<0"4%N"/%RJ4N"/%J42Q/G%/$4#"<??J*1%ZB$4%
"1% *$<1G% =>JM$"% 14B$0"J$% t% Y$% ="% M$"% /B*1% *B/% 1"44<1B<4"/% 4$4J$SG% ?"$4% /14$=1$4"% NO>J3<1J1% "1% ?"$4%
L4QM$"*1J1<B*G%<?%*OC%J%0J/%M$"%?"/%Q?$/%?B=J$S%M$<%/O<*M$<`1"4J<"*1%N"%="11"%0"4/0"=1<#"%|%!Q8<*=$?M$"4%
J$S%?B$0/%?J%=4J<*1"%N"/%>$2J<*/%*O"/1%=B*="#J3?"%M$"%NJ*/%?"%=JN4"%NOJ=1<B*/%=B*="41Q"/%e%2"*"4%e%
?OQ=>"??"%N"/%1"44<1B<4"/%?B=J$S7%'*%0"$1%"*%#B<4%$*"%04Q2<//"%NJ*/%?J%=4QJ1<B*G%/B$/%?J%4"/0B*/J3<?<1Q%
N"%?O'EK_HG%NO$*"%k%34<RJN"%?B$0%l%3J/Q"%NJ*/%?"/%F?0"/%N"0$</%,5.]7%HB*%<*1"4#"*1<B*G%/$4%=B22J*N"%
04QL"=1B4J?"G%"/1%=<3?Q"%/$4%N"/%?B$0/%JCJ*1%J11JM$Q%N"/%14B$0"J$SG%"*%4"*LB41%N"/%1<4/%N"%NQL"*/"%NQZe%
J$1B4</Q/%J$S%Q?"#"$4/%=B*="4*Q/7%
AB<*%NOQ?<2<*"4%N"/%?B$0/%J$%>J/J4N%N"/%4"*=B*14"/%"*%J=1<B*%N"%=>J//"G%<?%*"%/OJR<1%0J/%NJ#J*1JR"%N"%
04Q1"*N4"%RQ4"4%?"$4%0B0$?J1<B*7%AJ%2<//<B*%e%NQ0?BC"4%"/1%NOQ?<2<*"4%J$%0?$/%#<1"%?"/%4Q=<N<#</1"/%N"%
?OJ11JM$"%N"%14B$0"J$S%<N"*1<L<Q/G%="$S%M$<G%0J4%"S"20?"%J$S%(HF%"1%J$%KJ*JNJG%/B*1%M$J?<L<Q/%N"%k%?B$0/%
e%04B3?`2"%l7% K"0"*NJ*1G%<?%"/1% =?J<4%M$"% ?J%_4J*="% J%04</% 3"J$=B$0%N"%4"1J4N%0B$4% "S"4="4% NJ*/%?J%
N$4Q"%$*"%04"//<B*%N"%/Q?"=1<B*%N"/%?B$0/G%*B*B3/1J*1%?"$4%/1J1$1%NO"/0`="%/14<=1"2"*1%04B1QRQ"7%
%
Conclusion(
%
_B*NJ2"*1J?"2"*1G%"/18<?%0"41<*"*1%N"%LB=J?</"4%/$4%?"%?B$0%?J%04B1"=1<B*%N"%?J%3<BN<#"4/<1Q%"1%?J%/J*1Q%
N"%*B/%Q=B/C/1`2"/%1"44"/14"/%t%A"/%J4R$2"*1/%LB*1%NQLJ$1G%2J</%?"/%NQRj1/%/B*1%J#Q4Q/%"1%?OJ#"*<4%"/1%
"*=B4"%0?$/%04QB==$0J*17%A"/%?B$0/%2"*J="*1%N<4"=1"2"*1%?OQ?"#JR"%=B*N$<1%"*%0?"<*%J<4G%/$4%0j1$4JR"/%
*J1$4"?/%2J</%J$//<%"*%04J<4<"/%=$?1<#Q"/7%UB42</%?"/%R4J*N/%14B$0"J$S%B#<*/%RJ4NQ/%N$4J*1%-%e%]%2B</%
NO"/1<#JR"% "*% 2B*1JR*"G% ?OQ*B42"% 2JZB4<1Q% N"/% Q?"#JR"/% N"% _4J*="% 04B=`N"% 0J4% ?B1/% NOJ*<2J$S%
N</14<3$Q/%NJ*/%N"/%0j1$4JR"/%=?o1$4Q/7%_J="%J$S%?B$0/G%=B22"*1%0"$18B*%=B*="#B<4%M$"%1B$/%="/%04Q/8
3B</G%?J*N"/%"1%04J<4<"/%N"%3B=JR"%/B<"*1% e% QM$<0"4% N"%>J$1"/% =?o1$4"/%Q?"=14<L<Q"/G%"1%N"%=><"*/% N"%
04B1"=1<B*%t%HJ*/% B$3?<"4% ?J% /$4#"<??J*="% >$2 J<*"G% J$04`/%N"% =>JM$"% ?B17% b4"LG% e% LB4="%N"% 2"/$4"/%
<204J1<=J3?"/%"1%NOJ/14"<*1"/%<*1"*J3?"/G%="%/"4J<1%W%>B4/%N"%?OQ?"#JR"%4"0?<Q%"*%3j1<2"*1%/Q=$4</QG%>B4/%
N"%k%?O$/<*"%e%3Q1J<?%lG%0B<*1%N"%/J?$1%t%
AOQ?"#JR"%N"%0?"<*%J<4%"/1%?O$*"%N"%*B/%JR4<=$?1$4"/%?"/%0?$/%=?J<4"2"*1%"*RJRQ"/%NJ*/%?"/%0B?<1<M$"/%N"%
?OJR4B"*#<4B**"2"*17%b<"*%M$"%0"$%4Q2$*Q4J1"$4G%<?%2B1<#"%N"/%=J*N<NJ1/%0B$4%?"/%J=1<#<1Q/%NOJ==$"<?%
"1%?OBLL4"%N"% 04BN$<1/%?B=J$S% B4<R<*J$S%"1% N"%0?$/% "*%0?$/% J004Q=<Q/7%g?"#"$4/% "1% 3"4R"4/%R`4"*1% ="/%
J//"23?JR"/% B4<R<*J$S% N"% 3<BN<#"4/<1Q/% /J$#JR"% "1% NB2"/1<M$"7% &"$18B*% 0J//"4% ="/% 2Q1<"4/% "1% ="/%
/"4#<="/%0J4%0"41"/%"1%04BL<1/%t%TQZe%"*%,55,G%$*%R"/1<B**J<4"%N"%/<1"/%EJ1$4J%,555%NJ*/%?"/%F?0"/%*B$/%
NQ=?J4J<1%W%«*Le*loup*va*nous*faire*perdre*les*bénéfices*de*dix*ans*de*dialogue*et*négociations*avec*les*
éleveurs…*Une*espèce*s’impose*au*détriment*de*plein*d’autres.*C’est*sûr,*on*va*perdre*en*capacité*de*
gestion*des*habitats*».*D?%"/1%0?$/%M$"%1"20/%N"%/<R*<L<"4%J$%04QNJ1"$4%M$"%?"%M$J/<%?<34"8/"4#<="%NJ*/%
?"/%14B$0"J$S%"/1%J3B?<%u%N"%/B*%=o1QG%<?%/OJNJ01"4J7%
*
TB**"4%M$J41<"4%?<34"%J$%4"1B$4%N"/%?B$0/%N"0$</%0?$/%N"%,5%J*/%J%Q1Q%$*"%NQ=</<B*%0B?<1<M$"%?B$4N"7%
&?$1o1%M$"% NO"*% =J*1B**"4% ?"/% =B*/QM$"*="/%e% N"/%k%=B*L?<1/% 04QNJ1"$483Q1J<?%l% B$%?"/% /$3?<2"4%"*%

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
]%
k% 4J00B41/% >B22"8*J1$4"%lG% 0B$4M$B<% *"% 0J/% J//$2"4% M$O<?% /OJR<1G% "*14"% >$2J<*/G% N"% NQ3J114"% N$%
k%#<#4"%"*/"23?"%l%*B/%1"44<1B<4"/%4$4J$S%t%
%
Bibliographie(
%
bJ=>J%H7G%bJ1J<??"%}8_7G%pJ4N"%A7G%,5567%Indemnisation*des*pertes*et*évaluation*des*coûts*réels.*In*:*Loup–
Élevage*:*s’ouvrir*à*la*complexité.*Actes*du*séminaire*des*15*et*16*juin*20067%pJ4N"%A7%[=BB4N7\%PN/7%
KP!&F;G%;J*B/M$"G%.]58.9.7%
KP!&F;G%'DP!8H$J22"G%FN"2G%TTV[;\%5I85]8598-d86-G%DN"?"G%,5.,7%Protection*des*troupeaux*contre*
la*prédation.*KBQN<1<B*%KP!&F;%@%KJ4N`4"G%KB??7%V"=>*<M$"/%0J/1B4J?"/%W%-.,%07%
T"#"44"%K7G%.ccc7%A"%?B$0%[?"%4"1B$4\%"1%?OJR*"J$%[?"%NQ0J41%t\7%Le*Courrier*Environnement*de*l’INRAG%-9%W%
9689d7%
TB34"2"^%A7G%b4JC%_7G%bB4R%T7G%,5.97%Principaux* résultats*de*l’Enquête*Pastorale* 2012/2014* dans*le*
massif*des*Alpes7%D!HVPFG%KP!&F;G%!Q/"J$%&J/1B4J?%!>o*"8F?0"/G%FTP;G%_FDG%HPF%6-G%HPF%6IG%H$J=<%
;B*1JR*OF?0"/G%Z$<??"1%,5.9G%d.%07%~%J**"S"/7%
T$=>J20%K7G% K>J04B*%p7G% p<2"*"^%'7G% !B3"41%F7G% HJ44J^<*%_7G%b"$N"?/8}J2J4% !7G% A"% ; J>B% f7G% ,5.67%
Expertise*collective*scientifique*sur*la*viabilité*et*le*devenir*de*la*population*de*loups*en*France*à*
long*terme%/B$/%?J%=BB4N<*J1<B*%'EK_H8;EUE%W%c-%07%%
pJ4N"%A7%[=BB4N7\G%,5567%Loup*–*Elevage*:*s’ouvrir*à*la*complexité.%F=1"/%N$%/Q2<*J<4"%N"/%.]%"1%.9%Z$<*%
,5597%PN/7%KP!&F;G%;J*B/M$"%W%.]58.9.%@%.998.6d7%
pJ4N"%A7G%,5.97%;B?</"%"1%F34$^^"/%W%N"/%34"3</G%N"/%=><"*/G%N"/%?B$0/%•"1%N"/%UB22"/7%PastumG%.59G%
,58,-7%
pJ4N"%;7G%;"$4"1%;7G%,5.67%Quand*les*loups*franchissent*la*lisière*:*expériences*d’éleveurs,*chasseurs*
et*autres*résidents*de*Seyne-les-Alpes*confrontés*aux*loups7%!J007%"*M$s1"%KP!&F;%;J*B/M$"%@%
DE!F%(;!%H"?2"1%;B*10"??<"4G%..9%07%
AJ$*N4Q%}7y7G%U"4*€*N"^%A7G%!<00?"%y7}7G%,5.57%V>"%?J*N/=J0"%BL%L"J4W%"=B?BR<=J?%<20?<=J1<B*/%BL%3"<*R%
JL4J<N7%The*Open*Ecology*JournalG%-%W%.867%
A"/=$4"$S%E7G%,5567%Maintenir*la*réciprocité*pour*mieux*coexister*?*Ethnographie*du*récit*Kirghiz*des*
relations*dynamiques*entre*les*Hommes*et*les*loups.%V>`/"%N"%NB=1B4J1%;$/Q$2%EJ1<B*J?%NOU</1B<4"%
EJ1$4"??"G%&J4</%W%I5]07%~%J**"S"/7%
A"/=$4"$S% E7G% A<**"??% }7T7K7G% ,5.57% A"/% 2B*1JR*"/% /B*18"??"/% ?"/% N"4*<"4/% 4"L$R"/% N"/% R4J*N/%
04QNJ1"$4/%t%Histoire*des*Alpes*-*Storia*delle*Alpi*-*Geschichte*der*AlpenG%.]%W%.c]8,.57%
;"=>%A7T7G%,5.,7%D/%H=<"*="%<*%NJ*R"4%BL%/J*=1<LC<*R%1>"%XB?Lt%Biological*ConservationG%.]5%W%.I-8.Ic7%
;"=>%A7T7G%bB<1J*<%A7G%,55-7%Wolves:*behavior,*ecology,*and*conservation7%V>"%(*<#"4/<1C%BL%K><=JRB%
&4"//G%K><=JRBG%(HFG%IId%07%
;"$4"1%;7G%'/1C%&78A7G%,5.]7%A"/%?B$0/%N"/%!B=>"$/"/%N$%*B4N W%=>4B*<M$"%NO$*"%<=o*"%/B$/%=B*14o?"/7%
PastumG%.5I%W%-.8-c7%
'EK_HG%,5.67%b<?J*%N$%/$<#<%><#"4*J?%N"%?J%0B0$?J1<B*%N"%?B$0/%[><#"4%,5.98,5.6\7%Bulletin*d’information*
du*réseau*Loup-lynxG%_?J/>%<*LB%.]%2J<%,5.6%W%,%07%
(7H7% _</>% J*N% y<?N?<L"% H"4#<="G% ,5.97% Northern* Rocky* Mountain* Wolf* Recovery* Program* 2015*
Interagency*Annual*Report*–*Executive*summary*and*tables7%U"?"*JG%;B*1J*JG%(HF%W%.,07%
Y<*="*1%;7G%,5..7%Les*alpages* à* l’épreuve*des*loups7%PN/%{$J"%@% ;J</B*%N"/%H=<"*="/%N"%?OUB22"G%
KB??7%EJ1$4"/%/B=<J?"/G%-],%07%
% %

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
9%
%
%
%
Figure(1.%&4Q/"*="%N"%?B$0[/\%NQ1"=1Q"%4QR$?<`4"2"*1%B$%<44QR$?<`4"2"*1%"*%,5.]G%e%0J41<4%NO$*%=4<1`4"%
N"% M$J*1<1Q% Nz<*N<="/G% C% =B204</% ?"/%J11JM$"/% /$4% 14B$0"J$SG% "1% N"% ?J% 4"NB*NJ*="% N"/% NQ1"=1<B*/%
/0J1<J?"/%J$%=B$4/%N$%1"20/%[données*communiquées*par*le*réseau*Loup-Lynx*de*l’ONCFS)7%
% %

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
6%
%
%
Figure(2.%P/1<2J1<B*/%N$%*B234"%2BC"*%N"%?B$0/%[B4NB**Q"%N"%RJ$=>"%:%source%W%'EK_H\%"1%*B234"%
N"%#<=1<2"/%NOQ?"#JR"%4"=B**$"/% 04QNJ1Q"/%0J4%N"/% ?B$0/% [B4NB**Q"%N"% N4B<1"% :% sources%W% TTV[;\8
T4"J?%F$#"4R*"8!>o*"8F?0"/%"1%TTV[;\%N"/%F?0"/8;J4<1<2"/%0B$4%J=1$J?</J1<B*%,5.9\7%
% %
5
.555
,555
-555
I555
]555
9555
6555
d555
c555
.5555
5
]5
.55
.]5
,55
,]5
-55
-]5
Nombre(de(victimes(d'élevage(retrouvées(et(indemnisées
Nombre(de(loups(estimé(moyen
F**Q"/

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
d%
%
%
Figure(3.%&J4%NQ0J41"2"*1G%"*%,5.9G%*B234"%N"%#<=1<2"/%NOQ?"#JR"%4"14B$#Q"/%"1%<*N"2*</Q"/%/$<1"%e%
N"/%J11JM$"/%N"%?B$0[/\%[source*:%TTV[;\8T4"J?%F$#"4R*"8!>o*"8F?0"/\7%
% %

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
c%
%
%
Figure(4.%EB234"%N"%#<=1<2"/%NJ*/%?"/%NQ0J41"2"*1/%J?0<*/%"*%,5.5%"1%,5.]G%/"?B*%M$"%?"/%J11JM$"/%
B*1%"$%?<"$%N"%*$<1%B$%N"%ZB$4%[source*:%bJ/"%pQBAB$0G%T4"J?%F$#"4R*"8!>o*"8F?0"/%u%traitement*des*
données*:%KP!&F;\7%
% %
5
]55
.555
.]55
,555
,]55
-555
-]55
I555
I]55
,5.5 ,5.]
EB234"%N"%#<=1<2"/%4"14B$#Q"/
F11JM$"%N"%*$<1 F11JM$"%N"%ZB$4

!"#$"%&'(!%)%*+%,-.%)%/"01"234"%,5.6%)%007%..68.,9%:%VERSION(ACCEPTEE(AUTEURS%
%
.5%
%
%
Photo(1.%Y<=1<2"/%/$<1"%e%$*"%J11JM$"%N"%?B$0[/\%?"%I%2J<%,5.6%/$4%$*%?B1%N"%34"3</%"1%JR*"J$S%0J4M$Q%
"*14"%?OQR?</"%"1%?"%=<2"1<`4"%N"%HJ<*18KB?B23J*8N"/8Y<??J4N/%[HJ#B<"\%8%Cliché*:%•%}$?<"*%;B4?B1%