ArticlePDF Available

History of microfinance in Bangladesh: A life cycle theory approach

Authors:

Abstract

This study aims to conceptualise and document the historical evolution of microfinance in Bangladesh using the life cycle theory (LCT). Based on the LCT nomenclature, the microfinance sector in Bangladesh shows characteristics broadly consistent with the saturation phase (2006-2015)-which potentially has adverse impacts on both microfinance clients and institutions. The maturity phase (1996-2005) of microfinance has corresponded with competition and several innovations (financial and non-financial). However, the saturation phase sees increasing presence of uncoordinated microfinance institutions and expansion of multiple borrowing, as well as commercialisation and 'mission drift' , which constitute important challenges for the regulatory authority and management of microfinance institutions.
BUSINESS HISTORY, 2017
https://doi.org/10.1080/00076791.2017.1413096
History of micronance in Bangladesh: A life cycle theory
approach
Md AslamMiaa,b, Hwok-AunLeec, VGRChandrana, RajahRasiaha and
MahfuzurRahmand,b
aDepartment of Development Studies, Faculty of Economics and Administration, University of Malaya,
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; bThe Centre for Poverty and Development Studies, Faculty of Economics and
Administration, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; cISEAS Yusuf Ishak Institute, Singapore 119614,
Singapore; dDepartment of Banking and Finance, Faculty of Business and Accountancy, University of Malaya,
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
ABSTRACT
This study aims to conceptualise and document the historical
evolution of micronance in Bangladesh using the life cycle theory
(LCT). Based on the LCT nomenclature, the micronance sector
in Bangladesh shows characteristics broadly consistent with the
saturation phase (2006–2015) – which potentially has adverse impacts
on both micronance clients and institutions. The maturity phase
(1996–2005) of micronance has corresponded with competition
and several innovations (nancial and non-nancial). However,
the saturation phase sees increasing presence of uncoordinated
micronance institutions and expansion of multiple borrowing,
as well as commercialisation and ‘mission drift’, which constitute
important challenges for the regulatory authority and management
of micronance institutions.
1. Introduction
Formal and informal nancial institutions targeted at providing services to the masses have
evolved signicantly over the years. However, most formal nancial instruments are prof-
it-driven. It is for this reason that they tend to neglect the poorest segment of society who
have little means of meeting their collateral requirements. Informal instruments, such as
borrowing from friends, family members and neighbours are quite common. Both formal
and informal moneylending exist, but the poor are either discouraged by exorbitant interest
rates or often become victims of such high and poorly regulated rates. Also, the absence of
commercial banks in the rural areas of poor countries leaves the poor vulnerable to the
activities of lightly regulated moneylenders. In light of these shortcomings, microcredit
became a major breakthrough. Developed by Professor Muhammad Yunus in 1976, micro-
credit oers the poor in Bangladesh a vital means to access credit. The success of microcredit
© 2017 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
KEYWORDS
Microcredit and
microfinance; microfinance
institutions; multiple
borrowing; life cycle theory;
Bangladesh
CONTACT Md Aslam Mia mdaslam.mia@siswa.um.edu.my
Downloaded by [University of Malaya] at 17:57 20 December 2017
... Corresponding author: Muhammad A. Muhammad (m.muhammad@ttu.edu). oppression are well intentioned, prior work suggests that their success will be limited when policies and interventions are grounded in predominant models of entrepreneurial activity (Hulme, 2000;Mia, Lee, Chandran, Rasiah & Rahman, 2019). Arguably, this is because these prevailing models do not fully acknowledge the desire for emancipation (i.e., liberation from the power of another) as a potential motivating factor (Rindova, Barry & Ketchen, 2009). ...
... Due to their marginalized societal position, however, people who have been subjected to systemic oppression are unlikely to possess sufficient levels of the latter resources. As a result, public policies and outreach initiatives focused primarily-if not solely-on providing access to financing are unlikely to achieve their superordinate goal of attenuating systemic oppression by encouraging those living in oppressive conditions to pursue entrepreneurship (see Hulme, 2000;Mia et al., 2019). ...
... The connection between microcredit and usury has been recognised previously: the historical process that led us to the contemporary microfinance tools derives from an attempt to create a form of contrast to usury, which found consensus in Italy (Gatto, 2018;Avallone, 2010). However, microcredit's mission has evolved from charity to entrepreneurship scopes throughout history (Mia et al., 2019). ...
... Microcredit is the most acclaimed microfinance tool and has evolved throughout the centuries . Its charity purpose has been gradually replaced by entrepreneurship goals and targets associated with leading assets for long-term development both in the Global South and North (Mia et al., 2019). Today, microcredit is applied to a number of fields with the objective of promoting socio-economic and environmental goals (Gatto, 2022). ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of microcredit is to offer small loans to people who are not covered by traditional financial channels. It can facilitate entrepreneurship, boosting local socio-economic development and improving environmental and political factors. Design/methodology/approach This paper aims to analyse microcredit in Italy, focusing on a project based in Rione Sanità, Naples. Rione Sanità is one of the poorest areas of Southern Italy, displaying high rates of criminality and unemployment, especially among youth, women, migrants and the vulnerable. The district is renowned for its fine and ancient handicrafts, food, trade and historical heritage – potential drivers for boosting tourism in the area. Qualitative methodologies were used to collect primary data through field visits and interviews with project bankers, local businesses, artisans, associations and religious representatives, project volunteers, as well as participation at local meetings. These data were corroborated by budget analysis based on the project's accounting. Findings The study shows encouraging results for the project and policy prospects. Despite the tiny starting numbers, there emerges a significant potential for microcredit to spread in the district, as in Southern Italy, providing an effective strategy to combat unemployment, usury and criminality, yielding community development and favoring broad societal challenges. Originality/value With this evidence, the paper attempts to shed some light and verify the potential of microfinance projects as a driver of sustainable development and ethical finance in poor areas of developed countries.
... Our study aligns with existing research, demonstrating a positive impact of Ansar-VDP Unnayan Bank's microcredit on income levels and calorie intake, which strengthens the argument for microcredit's role in poverty reduction [22,23]. However, the effects on health awareness and family planning seem less substantial. ...
Article
Introduction: Bangladesh, a pioneer in microfinance since the 1980s, leads the world in microfinance operations aimed at low-income individuals, often women, in informal businesses. Despite its widespread use for development, the full impact of microfinance on socio-economic indicators remains unclear. This study aims to analyze this influence. Research Question: Despite decades of microfinance for development and poverty reduction, the extent of its impact remains unclear. While many researchers acknowledge microcredit as a tool for socio-economic development, others remain sceptical. This study aims to analyze the influence of microcredit on socio-economic development indicators. Methodology: The researcher compiled a comprehensive list of relevant indicators through a literature review. They then investigated which indicators are most impacted by microcredit, aiming to develop practical strategies to maximize the effectiveness of microcredit programs. Ansar-VDP Unnayan Bank, the sole government-owned bank dedicated to poverty alleviation through microcredit, was chosen as the study site. With a target population of 5.6 million, primarily living below the poverty line, Ansar-VDP Bank serves a significant portion of Bangladesh's impoverished population. Data Collection: Data collection involved structured and semi-structured questionnaires administered by trained bank managers. Results: The study found that microcredit impacts all analyzed indicators, with significant effects on calorie intake and income levels. While other indicators may be influenced, the impact was less pronounced. These findings suggest that microfinance practitioners should prioritize key indicators to achieve the desired outcomes, as positive change in these key areas can potentially influence other indicators.
... Inspired by the success of the Grameen Bank model in Bangladesh and other similar initiatives in Asia and Latin America, Nigeria began to see the emergence of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) focused on micro-lending. These NGOs adopted a more bottom-up approach, emphasizing community participation, group lending, and a focus on women (Mia et al., 2019). By the early 2000s, the microfinance landscape in Nigeria had evolved significantly. ...
Article
Full-text available
Microfinance emerges as a transformative beacon in Nigeria's journey towards economic empowerment. This paper dives into the intricate weave of microfinance within Nigeria's bustling economic narrative. Through rigorous literature analysis, we unearth the historical essence of microfinance, measure its tangible socio-economic impacts, and highlight its undeniable role in vanquishing poverty and kindling entrepreneurship. Drawing insights from a curated collection of peer-reviewed articles and empirical studies, our exploration offers a panoramic view of Nigeria's microfinance terrain. The revelations are striking. Microfinance institutions have pioneered avenues of financial inclusion, ignited entrepreneurial ventures, and steadily eroded the bastions of poverty. However, challenges like escalating loan default rates and operational inefficiencies cast long shadows. Yet, the advent of digital innovations signals hope, promising to reshape these challenges into opportunities. In summation, the paper crafts a compelling narrative: for microfinance to etch lasting imprints on Nigeria's economic canvas, it must continually reinvent, adapt, and innovate. Our recommendations are clear-cut—champion regulatory reforms, invest in capacity building, elevate financial literacy, and design financial products that echo Nigeria's diverse ethos. With microfinance as its guiding star, Nigeria's economic horizon gleams with untapped potential and promise Keywords: Microfinance, Economic Empowerment, Nigeria, Financial Landscape, Digital Innovations.
Article
Full-text available
Empowering women requires a multidimensional and holistic approach that encompasses the social, political, and economic aspects of women's development. Economic empowerment is particularly crucial for achieving sustainable development in society. This is especially important in South Asia, where women's poverty levels are high. Microfinancing for South Asian women expands their opportunities in public works, agriculture, finance, and other sectors, thereby accelerating economic growth and helping to mitigate the effects of current and future financial crises, especially at the household level. This study systematically examines evidence of the impact of microfinance initiatives on women in South Asian countries (SAARC countries) using 38 articles. It considers the effects on decision-making; economic gains, such as income, savings, and expenses; freedom and mobility; educational gains; and asset accumulation. The study also assesses the impact on non-financial outcomes like food security, health and nutrition, and social benefits. The results conclude that efficient and effective women's microfinancing can bring significant benefits for women in the region.
Article
Full-text available
This study delves into the pivotal role of directors of microfinance banks in developing countries in implementing governance practices to ensure sustainability. As microfinance institutions (MFIs) strive to balance social impact with financial viability, effective governance emerges as a crucial factor for sustainable operations. The research investigates the strategies and frameworks adopted by MFI directors to establish robust governance structures that promote long-term sustainability. Through comprehensive case studies and interviews with key stakeholders, the study identifies best practices and common challenges faced by microfinance bank directors in governance implementation. Key areas of focus include risk management, transparency, accountability, and stakeholder engagement. The findings highlight the critical importance of strong governance in mitigating risks, enhancing institutional credibility, and ensuring the alignment of financial and social objectives. Moreover, the research underscores the necessity for tailored governance models that consider the unique socioeconomic contexts of developing countries. It reveals that adaptive governance strategies, which incorporate local cultural and regulatory nuances, significantly contribute to the sustainability and resilience of MFIs. By bridging theoretical governance principles with practical implementation, this study provides actionable insights for directors seeking to enhance the sustainability of microfinance institutions. The implications of this research are far-reaching, offering valuable lessons for policymakers, practitioners, and academic scholars. It emphasizes the need for continuous capacity building and the development of governance frameworks that can evolve with the dynamic landscapes of developing economies. Ultimately, the study contributes to the broader discourse on sustainable development by elucidating how effective governance can empower microfinance institutions to drive socioeconomic progress in developing countries.
Article
Full-text available
The main objective of the study is to explore the factors that affect the microfinance industry expansion in Pakistan. To attain the objective of the study we collected the data from the microfinance industry from 2010-2020. Our results show that there is a negative relationship between the previous year's log of the gross loan portfolio and the current year's log of the gross loan portfolio. There is a positive relationship between the loan amount disbursed and the log of the gross loan portfolio. The probability value of the log of loan amount disbursed is 0.2518 which is statistically insignificant. There is a negative relationship between the previous year's log of loan amount disbursed and the current year log of gross loan portfolio There is a positive relationship between the log of several active borrowers and the gross loan portfolio. There is a positive relationship between the previous year’s log of the number of active borrowers and the current year's log of gross loan portfolio. Microfinance is a sort of banking service that is provided to unemployed or low-income persons, and clusters who or else have no other right to use economic services Eventually, microfinance aims to provide low-income groups and circumstances become sovereign by providing a method to save money, the sponge money and obtain insurance.
Article
BACKGROUND: Women entrepreneurship holds a fundamental role in uplifting economies, by providing job opportunities, driving innovations, and alleviating poverty. This study focuses women entrepreneurial intentions in Balochistan Pakistan, where extreme poverty and limited women participation exist. Despite women’s informal, unregistered, and unrecognized status, they possess the potential for productivity and can play a vibrant role in economic activities. OBJECTIVES: This study aims to investigate the impact of microfinancing, risk, and opportunities on women entrepreneurial intentions in Balochistan, Pakistan. Therefore, it seeks to explore the mediating and moderating effects of opportunities and risk attitudes. The emphasis is on identifying women entrepreneurs who are risk-takers, planning to initiate businesses, and require initial funds. METHODS: This is an exploratory and descriptive study; based on primary data collection through survey from 280 women entrepreneurs in district Quetta of Balochistan, Pakistan. Snowball sampling was employed for cross-sectional data gathering, and empirically analyzed by PLS-SEM. RESULTS: The results exhibited positive and significant roles of microfinancing, opportunities, and risk attitudes in influencing women’s entrepreneurial intentions. The findings revealed the absence of financial assistance, which is the primary barrier for business startups and expansions. CONCLUSIONS: Findings recommend microfinancing stimulate women entrepreneurial activities; enhance risk-taking ability to explore more business opportunities. Microfinance institutions (MFIs) are advised to formulate improved strategies tailored for women’s entrepreneurial development in Balochistan, Pakistan.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose Given the growing emphasis among scholars, practitioners and policymakers on financial sustainability, this study aims to explore the applicability of machine learning techniques in predicting the financial performance of microfinance institutions (MFIs). Design/methodology/approach This study gathered 9,059 firm-year observations spanning from 2003 to 2018 from the World Bank's Mix Market database. To predict the financial performance of MFIs, the authors applied a range of machine learning regression approaches to both training and testing data sets. These included linear regression, partial least squares, linear regression with stepwise selection, elastic net, random forest, quantile random forest, Bayesian ridge regression, K-Nearest Neighbors and support vector regression. All models were implemented using Python. Findings The findings revealed the random forest model as the most suitable choice, outperforming the other models considered. The effectiveness of the random forest model varied depending on specific scenarios, particularly the balance between training and testing data set proportions. More importantly, the results identified operational self-sufficiency as the most critical factor influencing the financial performance of MFIs. Research limitations/implications This study leveraged machine learning on a well-defined data set to identify the factors predicting the financial performance of MFIs. These insights offer valuable guidance for MFIs aiming to predict their long-term financial sustainability. Investors and donors can also use these findings to make informed decisions when selecting their potential recipients. Furthermore, practitioners and policymakers can use these findings to identify potential financial performance vulnerabilities. Originality/value This study stands out by using a global data set to investigate the best model for predicting the financial performance of MFIs, a relatively scarce subject in the existing microfinance literature. Moreover, it uses advanced machine learning techniques to gain a deeper understanding of the factors affecting the financial performance of MFIs.
Chapter
This chapter explores MFIs structures and points up areas for further study. The duties and obligations of Bangladeshi microfinance institutions are described. The chapter covers corporate governance in these firms. This section reviews MFIs governance practices. A review of a few of Bangladesh's top MFIs demonstrates the variety of approaches they use to meet the financial needs of their consumers. This comparative analysis aids in identifying the advantages and disadvantages of institutional models, which might result in more efficient and long-lasting microfinance operations.
Article
Full-text available
Many development interventions target transfers to women. However, little evidence directly explores the “fly- paper effects” of whether women retain control over these transfers once within the household and how reallo- cation of the transfers affects women's empowerment. We study these dynamics in the context of BRAC's randomized CFPR-TUP program in Bangladesh, which provides livestock and training to rural women in “ultra poor” households. Our analysis confirms previous findings that CFPR-TUP increased household asset ownership, but shows complex effects on targeted women. Women appear to retain ownership over transferred livestock, but new investments from mobilized resources are largely owned by men. CFPR-TUP also reduces women's movement outside the home and control over income, consistent with transferred livestock requiring mainte- nance at home. However, beneficiary women also report “intangible” benefits such as increased social capital and, even with limited mobility, a preference for work inside the home given a hostile environment outside the home.
Article
Full-text available
This paper analyses data on poverty for 1971-2013 periods and finds that, Bangladesh reduces national poverty by 55.82 percent during these periods. Moreover, nearly 44 percent people are found extremely poor who earn less than 1.25perdayand77percentpeoplearemoderatelypoorwhoearnlessthan1.25 per day and 77 percent people are moderately poor who earn less than 2 per day. Though, absolute income poverty declines but income inequality rises by 30 percent in these periods. However, different international indexes disclose that, Bangladesh also reduces human poverty. Bangladesh is no longer the member of 'alarmingly hunger countries and will become the member of 'Medium human development countries by 2014. Besides, about 58 percent people are found multi-dimensionally poor, who suffer from overlapping deprivations in health, education and standard of living. Finally, this paper makes a comparison between Bangladesh and other south Asian countries and finds that, Bangladesh has the highest level of poverty followed by India in this region.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose-To control exorbitant interest rates, implementation of an interest rate ceiling is a standard practice in microfinance. However, there are pros and cons of such market intervention. Hence, the aim of this short note is to highlight issues and challenges regarding the interest rate cap in microfinance, both from the perspective of clients and institutions. Research design, data, and methodology-While the nature of this short note is explanatory and descriptive, the research methodology used relevant data from the MixMarket and Microcredit Regulatory Authority (MRA) annual reports in Bangladesh. Results-We argue that an interest rate ceiling is detrimental both for the clients and microfinance institutions (MFIs). This market intervention substantially reduces the outreach of MFIs and clients are most likely to pay a higher price in the long-run. Additionally, an interest rate cap also puts severe pressure on newborn and high-cost MFIs to cope with the interest rate ceiling. Conclusions-Although market intervention may be necessary in the short-run, it should not be the ultimate solution to abate high interest in microfinance. Understanding the operational dynamics of MFIs, as well as promoting productivity, efficiency and competition could help to lower the interest rates.
Article
Full-text available
Gender discrimination is a persistent problem faced by women all over the world, which has ledto the need to empower women for uplifting their status as recognized by Millennium Development Goals (2010). The present study focuses on the role of microfinance in empowering women and also acknowledges its’ significance in alleviating poverty. The researcher used qualitative approach and case study method for in depth analysis of the phenomenon in context of Akhuwat, an interest free microfinance organization. It was recognized that microfinance brings about changes in women’s lives: household condition, family wellbeing and social status. It is improved by availing the services of microfinance institution and interest free loans further add to their well-being. Present study focused on four background variables to examine their influence on decision making ability of women in aspects of their domestic and social life. Age, education, marital status and family type are important contributing factors that influence women’s empowerment. It was also observed that women are more inclined to be altruistic and spend most of their income on their families. The present study can be further extended by incorporating more factors and increasing sample size in order to get more significant results.
Book
This book seeks to understand the evolution of Soviet policy towards the countries of South Asia, the regional constraints and policy opportunities which influenced the policy process in Moscow, and the relationship between Soviet perceptions and policy objectives. The author divides Soviet foreign policy into three aspects: a perceptual aspect in which assessment of the regional and international environment occurs; a formulative aspect in which aims and strategies are developed; and an implementation aspect. The book analyses Soviet policy objectives and instruments in distinct historical phases: 1970–1978, which covers the Indo-Pakistani War and bilateral relations; 1979–1985, which covers the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and and its impact on regional politics; and 1985 to the present which examines the Gorbachev era and the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Book
This edited collection presents recent developments, practical innovations, and policy reforms in the realm of microfinance in emerging markets. Microfinance has been hotly debated by ever-colliding camps of ardent supporters, who believe that microfinance addresses credit market failures and provides a durable answer to the problem of the poverty, and staunch critics, who argue that lending by microfinance institutions is wasteful, and the interest rates are too high. To bring further insight into this important debate, this book presents comprehensive historical, political, and economic perspectives on the latest issues in microfinance. An impressive array of scholars and practitioners build a framework for thinking about regulation to drive sustainable, inclusive development. With case studies of programs in India, Ghana, and Bangladesh, and examinations of the effects of gender and religion on financial decision-making, this comprehensive collection offers something valuable to scholars, policymakers, and practitioners—anyone with a vested interest in promoting innovation in microfinance.
Chapter
Microfinance drew attention to itself beginning the day it was born. From day one, its fate was hotly debated by ever-colliding camps of ardent supporters and staunch critics. In this chapter, we provide an in-depth discussion on microfinance revolution and promise. We summarize the highlights of the growing literature on microfinance that have accumulated over the past three decades. The new features of the microfinance sector also are discussed in the chapter.
Article
Location of new products, 191. — The maturing product, 196. — The standardized product, 202.
Article
In recent years, financial interests have increasingly influenced microfinance institutions (MFIs), with financial gain overshadowing service to the poor. This phenomenon, which we can term mission drift, has caused apprehension among academicians as well as policy makers, for its negation of the fundamental social ethos of MFIs and the mandate of sustainable financial inclusion. Hence, this study aims to identify the factors of mission drift, with special emphasis on the role of funding sources. We collect data from a sample of 169 MFIs in Bangladesh from the period of 2009–2014, and deploy static and dynamic panel data estimation techniques. The results suggest that commercial fund is susceptible to mission drift, as average loan size over GNI per capita increases when MFIs use more commercial fund in their operation. The finding also revealed that when MFIs focus more on commercial interest (return on assets and operational sustainability), they tend to depart further from the original aim of serving the poorest of the poor. The findings further suggest that mission drift is influenced by other factors, such as, macroeconomic conditions and regulatory environment. This study underscores the importance for policy to ensure that poor people have viable access to financial services from MFIs, toward promoting long-term sustainable development.
Article
The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) are going to expire at the end of 2015r; and the United Nations are currently negotiating a new development agenda for the coming years. The proposal for ‘Sustainable Development Goals’ submitted by the Open Working Group (OWG) in 2014 serves as a starting point; and the Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN) has recently suggested indicators for its operationalisation. In a joint effort, numerous experts from the German Development Institute/Deutsches Institut fur Entwicklungspolitik (DIE) have prepared detailed comments on each of the goals and targets suggested by the OWG as well as the indicators suggested by the SDSN.