ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

When bunionette deformities are not responding to conservative treatment, several surgical procedures are available. Recently, minimal invasive techniques have been proposed with good results. We present our results of a strictly percutaneous 5th metatarsal osteotomy to correct the deformity with bandage after care. We present a retrospective review on 20 percutaneous distal oblique 5th metatarsal osteotomies for correction of bunionette deformity. Aftercare consisted of 5-6 weeks of corrective taping with full weight bearing using a post-op shoe. Patients were evaluated radiographically and clinically by the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Lesser Toe Metatarsophalangeal-Interphalangeal scale, Visual Analogue scale (VAS) and Coughlin classification. At a mean follow-up of 27.05 months, the AOFAS improved from a mean of 51 points to 91.6 points (max 100). 90% of patients had good or excellent clinical result and a mean pain score on the visual analog scale was 0.7 out of 10. Radiographic evaluation showed a good correction of the intermetatarsal and metatarsophalangeal angle. We did not encounter any complications such as infections, wound breakdown, neurovascular problems, non-union or recurrence. The percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy is an effective, reliable and safe procedure concerning the treatment of bunionette deformity. The results are comparable with previously published outcomes of open and minimal invasive procedures with considerable less soft tissue damage, shorter operating time and the lack of internal fixation.
284
b. molenaers, j. vanlommel, p. deprez
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
When bunionette deformities are not responding to
conservative treatment, several surgical procedures
are available. Recently, minimal invasive techniques
have been proposed with good results. We present
our results of a strictly percutaneous 5th metatarsal
osteotomy to correct the deformity with bandage
after care. We present a retrospective review on 20
percutaneous distal oblique 5th metatarsal osteotomies
for correction of bunionette deformity. Aftercare
consisted of 5-6 weeks of corrective taping with
full weight bearing using a post-op shoe. Patients
were evaluated radiographically and clinically by
the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society
(AOFAS) Lesser Toe Metatarsophalangeal-Inter-
phalangeal scale, Visual Analogue scale (VAS) and
Coughlin classication. At a mean follow-up of
27.05 months, the AOFAS improved from a mean of
51 points to 91.6 points (max 100). 90% of patients
had good or excellent clinical result and a mean pain
score on the visual analog scale was 0.7 out of 10.
Radiographic evaluation showed a good correction
of the intermetatarsal and metatarsophalangeal
angle. We did not encounter any complications such
as infections, wound breakdown, neurovascular
problems, non-union or recurrence. The percutaneous
hardware free corrective osteotomy is an effective,
reliable and safe procedure concerning the treatment
of bunionette deformity. The results are comparable
with previously published outcomes of open and
minimal invasive procedures with considerable less
soft tissue damage, shorter operating time and the
lack of internal xation.
Keywords : foot, bunionette, percutaneous surgery
INTRODUCTION
A Tailor’s bunion is a painful deformity on the
lateral aspect of the 5th metatarsal. (6, 7, 21). It’s name
is derived from tailors who sustained these lesions
frequently due to their typical sitting position with
the legs crossed (29). Several retrospective studies
indicate that it is between 3 and 10 times more
frequent in women than men and has a peak incidence
between the fourth and fth decade of life (29). The
bunionnette is often seen in splayfoot disorders
and many times accompanied with a hallux valgus.
An enlarged fth metatarsal head (congenital or
traumatic) or a lateral angulated metatarsal shaft
do give a more prominent metatarsal head. (29)
Typically, these patients complain of pain on the
lateral side of the foot, more pronounced when
narrow shoes are worn. Often there is some callus
or inammation notable. In severe cases a bursa can
develop due to the chronic irritation, and over time
this can evolve into an ulceration.
According to Du Vries and Coughlin there are
3 different deformity types, based on weight-
No benefits or funds were received in support of this study.
The authors report no conflict of interests.
Acta Orthop. Belg., 2015, 83, 284-291
Percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy for bunionnette deformity.
Ben
molenaers,
Jan
vanlommel,
Patrick
deprez
From AZ St-Lucas, Brugge, Belgium
ORIGINAL STUDY
n Ben Molenaers1, MD
n Jan Vanlommel2, MD
n Patrick Deprez2, MD
1Orthopaedics-Traumatology, UZ Leuven and ZOL, Genk,
Belgium
2Orthopaedics-Traumatology Orthoclinic, AZ St-Lucas,
Brugge, Belgium.
Corresponding author: Ben Molenaers
E-Mail : Ben.Molenaers@uzleuven.be
© 2017, Acta Orthopædica Belgica.
11-Molenaers.indd 284 11/10/17 16:03
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy for bunionnette deformity.
285
bearing dorsoplantar radiographs (gure 1). Type 1
is an enlargement of the head of the 5th metatarsal,
type 2 is characterized by a lateral bowing of the
5th metatarsal and type 3 is noted by an increased
intermetatarsal angle between the 4th and 5th
metatarsals (>8°). (1, 4, 6, 10, 15).
cases, percutaneous distal osteotomies have gained
popularity and recently several studies showed
good clinical en radiographic outcomes. (22, 24)
The possible advantage of percutaneous hardware
free surgery is the reduced risk of wound healing
problems and symptomatic hardware, as well as
improved cosmetics.
We present our short-term data in the ongoing
discussion about percutaneous hardware free distal
osteotomy in case of tailor’s bunion.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
We retrospectively reviewed the patients operated
between December 2009 and January 2013. The
percutaneous hardware free distal subcapital
osteotomy was performed on 20 feet (16 patients).
Mean age at surgery was 36.65 years (range 17-66)
and 80% of these patients were women (Table 1).
All medical records were reviewed, all patients were
contacted and information concerning the study was
provided. Informed consent was obtained. Patients
were reviewed one year after surgery or longer at
the time of this investigation. The study protocol
was approved by the ethical committee of our
institution. One skilled ankle and foot surgeon (P.D)
performed all the interventions using the below
described method.
The Indication for surgery was a tailor’s bunion
resistant to conservative treatment, including shoe
wear adaptation and oral anti-inammatory drugs.
In 1 patient a classical hallux valgus correction was
performed simultaneously (Patient 6). All patients
were followed for at least 1 year (average 27, 05
months) (Table 1).
We refer to the technique described by De Prado
and the Grecmip (group of research and study into
minimally invasive surgery of the foot and ankle)
(24). Though without performing a condylectomy.
Adequate percutaneous surgical instruments
are essential and the surgeon should be trained in
percutaneous operation techniques.
Surgery was performed under general anesthesia
or a locoregional popliteal block without tourniquet.
The patient was positioned in dorsal decubitus
distal on the table. After draping, the foot is placed
directly on the mini c-arm.
Fig. 1. — Pre-op Tailor’s bunion bilateraal (Type 1).
Conservative treatment such as oral anti-
inammatories, topical keratolytics, shoe wear
changes or orthoses can solve most of the complaints
though often will not produce long lasting relief
(29). When these are found to be insufcient,
operative possibilities are developed to address the
complaints and anatomy. There are a great variety
of different techniques available though most
include osteotomies to correct the bony deformity.
The purpose of surgery is to decrease the width
of the forefoot as well as the prominence of the
bunionette. (29) Lonely soft tissue procedures do
have high recurrence rates especially when dealing
with type 2 and 3 bunionette’s. In these specic
11-Molenaers.indd 285 11/10/17 16:03
286
b. molenaers, j. vanlommel, p. deprez
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
Tabel I. — Patient characteristics
Patient Gender Age Type Side IM angle
4-5
MTP
angle
AOFAS VAS FU
(months)
pre post pre post Pre Post pre post
1 M 31 1 re 7 5 9 0 37 90 4 4 18
2 F 21 3 re 13 6 21 10 63 100 1 0 20
21 3 li 14 8 28 14 63 100 1 0 20
3 F 66 2 re 7 1 21 9 73 78 1,5 0,5 28
4 M 52 3 li 13 7 25 18 32 93 6 0 26
52 3 re 10 3 23 12 32 100 6 0 26
5 M 65 3 re 14 8 20 9 62 93 4 0 32
6 F 34 2 re 9 6 17 3 70 70 5 3 19
7 F 25 2 li 9 5 19 8 37 100 6,5 0 16
8 F 38 2 li 8 1 22 8 29 100 5 0 28
38 2 re 8 5 16 8 60 100 3 0 26
9 F 64 2 re 9 3 23 11 52 90 5 3 26
10 F 18 2 li 9 7 19 10 62 100 6 0 20
11 F 17 3 re 13 6 23 10 70 100 4 0 16
*12 F 21 3 li 13 6 26 9 37 95 7 0 32
22 3 re 10 7 22 6 37 68 7 3 29
13 F 30 3 re 11 6 23 12 42 100 8 0 42
**14 F 64 1 re 6 6 14 8 25 70 10 0 53
15 F 22 1 re 6 4 13 9 80 100 6 0 44
16 F 32 2 li 7 1 30 8 57 85 4 0 20
Average 36,65 9,8 5,05 20,7 9,1 51 91,6 5 0,675 27,05
OAFAS : American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society Lesser Toe Metatarso-phalangeal-Interphalangeal
score.
In most cases the osteotomy is made just proximal
to the metatarsal head at the metaphysis. In type
3 we go slightly more proximal to obtain more
correction. The osteotomy was always complete
(no closing wedge) with a medial translation of the
metatarsal head and was always conducted under
direct uoroscopic guidance.
With a small beaver blade, a dorsal step wound
(2mm) was made under uoroscopic guidance
lateral to the extensor tendons at the level where
the osteotomy should be performed. The osteotomy
was performed uently by placing the percutaneous
burr directly lateral to the bone in a 45 ° direction
(preventing dorsal displacement), making a small
groove while going plantarly and changing the burr
from a vertical oblique position into a horizontal
position. Still in the same movement, the osteotomy
is completed by pulling the rotating burr from plantar
proximal to distal dorsal in a oblique 45°plane. The
metatarsal head spontaneously moves medially
(gure 2 and 3). With a small percutaneous rasp the
bone debris can be removed.
In all cases a burr of 2mm diameter and 15mm
long (Integra, Newdeal) was used. Burr speed was
maximal 9000 rpm to avoid skin burns. The skin is
closed with a single stitch (gure 4).
A splint dressing was applied post-operatively
to hold the correct position of the fth metatarsal
head after the osteotomy (gure 5). This bandage is
essential for the success of the procedure. It holds
the medial translated fth metatarsal head in the
right position. Therefore it’s important the taping
11-Molenaers.indd 286 11/10/17 16:03
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy for bunionnette deformity.
287
weight bearing for 1 or 2 weeks was allowed with a
hard soled shoe. Early forefoot weight bearing was
allowed if tolerated. The bandage was rst changed
after 1 and 2 weeks and removed after 4 weeks.
Afterwards a simple taping around the forefoot was
advised for 2-3 weeks (gure 6).
Clinically the patients were evaluated using
the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society
(AOFAS) Lesser Toe Metatarsophalangeal-
Interphalangeal Scale. It provides a subscore
counting for subjective and objective outcomes like
pain sensation, functional capacity and radiographic
alignment. Even so patient satisfaction was classied
Fig. 2. — Post-op X-ray AP view left
Fig. 3. — Post-op Lateral view left
is performed by the surgeon himself. Fluoroscopic
check is necessary after the application in the
operation theatre and radiographs are made at 1 and
four weeks.
The rst week rest, elevation and ice applications
are recommended. Immediately after surgery, heel
Fig. 4. — Clinical view post-op wound left
Fig. 5. — Clinical view post-op bandage post-operatively
11-Molenaers.indd 287 11/10/17 16:03
288
b. molenaers, j. vanlommel, p. deprez
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
of pain or a pain free operation site at nal follow-up
(pain score pre-op 13, post-op 37, max 40, P < 0.05).
Function subscores increased from 31.6 towards
42.1 post-operatively with a maximum of 45 points
(P < 0.05) (Table 2). Clinically union occurred at 6
weeks (no pain when walking). No complications
like infection, wound breakdown, nerve or vascular
injuries were noted during the follow-up visits.
According to the Coughlin classication the
subjective satisfaction was in 15 feet excellent,
3 feet good and 2 feet fair. The Visual Analogue
Scale (VAS) improved from mean number 5 pre-
operatively to 0.7 post-operatively (P < 0.05)(Table
1, 2). One patient, known with bromyalgia, was
slightly dissatised with the result though a great
reduction in pain was achieved. She had a little
callous development more distally on the fth toe but
she refused any other surgery. All patients returned
to their pre-operative activity level and those who
were unable to perform sports before surgery could
resume their sport activities after surgery.
The intermetatarsal angle (normal < 8°) decreased
from 9.8° to 5° and the fth metatarsophalangeal
angle (normal < 10°) decreased from 20, 7° to 9,
1° both at the time of latest follow-up (Table 1). In
nearly all patients a limited bone remoddeling was
seen after 4 weeks and all united at nal follow-up
(last visit) (gure 7, 10). No major complications
as non-union, osteonecrosis or late displacement
occurred.
DISCUSSION
Even though a tailor’s bunion seems to be a small
problem, it can have a great inuence on quality
of life, cause frustrations and work problems. If
conservative treatment is not sufcient, operative
correction will be mandatory. Several procedures are
described and proposed depending on the deformity.
(7, 17, 23, 33). As shown by Kitaoka et al (17) partial
metatarsal head resection can be performed with a
Type 1 deformity. A metatarsal head resection can be
performed, mostly as a salvage procedure as it will
induce joint instability and transfer metatarsalgia.
(9, 12, 16)
As for rst ray deformities, several osteotomies
have been described for the fth metatarsal
with the Coughlin Score as excellent, good, fair and
poor. The Visual Analogue Scale was recorded pre-
and post-operatively.
Radiographic assessment consisted of anteropos-
terior and lateral weight bearing x-rays of the foot
pre-operatively and post-operatively at week 4 and
at nal follow-up. The metatarsophalangeal angle
and intermetatarsal angle were compared to evalu-
ate the correction as well to assess consolidation.
RESULTS
In all cases, wound healing occurred without any
problems. Oedema was present for several weeks
but did not interfere with daily live and was not seen
as a problem by most of the patients. One patient
was known to have bromyalgia and one patient
sustained severe burning wounds (including the
foot), these inuenced the outcomes negatively
(Table 2). The mean OAFAS Lesser Toe Metatarso-
phalangeal-Interphalangeal score improved from 51
points to 91.6 points at nal follow-up. (max 100,
P < 0.05). All patients mentioned a great reduction
Fig. 6. — Clinical view post-op bandage after 4 weeks
Tabel II. — Results
Pre-op Post-op P-value
Mean OAFAS
(Max 100)
51 91,6 P<0,05
Pain OAFAS
(Max 40)
13 37 P<0,05
Function OAFAS
(Max 45)
31,6 42,1 P<0,05
VAS scale 5 0,7 P<0,05
OAFAS : American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society Lesser
Toe Metatarso-phalangeal-Interphalangeal score.
VAS: Visual analogue scale
11-Molenaers.indd 288 11/10/17 16:03
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy for bunionnette deformity.
289
Fig. 7. — Post-op 4 weeks AP view left
Fig. 8. Post-op week 12 AP left
Fig. 9. Post-op week 12 lateral
ray including proximal, diaphyseal and distal
osteotomies. (5, 6, 8, 11, 18, 19, 25, 30, 31, 32, 33).
The goal of these procedures is to narrow the
forefoot resulting in less compression at the fth
metatarsal head. (19) All osteotomies do have their
specic indications and complications. Proximal
osteotomies are indicated when the intermetatarsal
angle is greater than 9° and the deformity is
located over the entire metatarsal. Though there is
a greater risk of non-union caused by interruption
of the vascularity (3, 8, 26, 31). The same goes
for the diaphyseal osteotomies, although less
correction can be achieved compared to proximal
osteotomies. Still higher rates of non- and delayed
union are noted.(5, 30, 31) Distal osteotomies are
most commonly performed due to the higher rates
of union reported but with a limited potential for
correction. Therefore these are ideal in type II-III
deformities (5, 6, 18, 19, 25).
11-Molenaers.indd 289 11/10/17 16:03
290
b. molenaers, j. vanlommel, p. deprez
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
post-operative rehabilitation regimen was more
or less identical. Both studies present comparable
results and this on all investigated outcomes like the
clinical, functional and radiographic parameters.
By avoiding a condylectomy we could reduce the
operating time and we may cause less soft tissue
damage leading to a faster recovery. These potential
advantages did not make any difference in the
outcome scores. General satisfaction of the patients
are both high. When pronounced deformity is
encountered the percutaneous metatarsal osteotomy
can slightly be proximised to allow greater
correction possibilities.
As mentioned in the studies (23, 24) radiographic
bone healing is delayed with respect to clinical
healing (gure 8, 9). It is important to know that
the early success is not directly related to the
radiological outcome, but rather the clinical and
pain free experience. In general, clinical healing can
be expected after 6 weeks, allowing normal shoes
to be worn securely starting at 4 to 6 weeks. Bony
healing can take up to 3 months or sometimes even
longer. Limitation of heavy physical activities is
recommended during this time frame (Figure 6, 7,
8, 9).
This study has some limitations as the retro-
spective character and relatively small sample size.
There wasn’t a control group either. On the other
hand this study has some potential strengths as it
focused on all indications of bunionette deformities.
All patients were treated by the same surgeon
using one and the same procedure. Evaluation was
performed by an independent observer using several
standard evaluation scores (AOFAS Lesser Toe
Metatarsophalangeal-Interphalangeal scale, Visual
Analogue scale (VAS) and radiographic evaluation).
CONCLUSIONS
Our study conrms the good outcome of a
percutaneous hardware free distal osteotomy in
tailor’s bunion deformities. The procedure is suited
for the 3 different types of deformities with small
alterations on the surgical procedure. Patients
satisfaction is high, quick recovery can be expected
without malunions and very low complication rates,
such as infection and absent hardware friction. As
Common complications of forefoot surgeries
are loss of alignment, delayed-/non-union, transfer
metatarsalgia, infections, soft tissue irritation due
the xation techniques, fractures and recurrence of
deformity. (13, 14, 19, 20, 24, 28, 31, 33).
Recently there have been several studies
published who presented new minimally invasive
distal osteotomy techniques with good results.(15,
22, 23) Some of the studies used stabilization in order
to maintain reduction. (15, 22). Michels et al showed
the possibility to adapt the osteotomy according to
the deformity and correct the intermetatarsal angle
in minimal invasive procedures (24) Even without
in situ stabilization there was no higher rate of
recurrence (24).
Our technique differs from Michels et al. because
we performed a metatarsal osteotomy without
adjacent condylectomy of the metatarsal head. The
Fig. 10. — Post-op 1 year left
11-Molenaers.indd 290 11/10/17 16:03
Acta Orthopædica Belgica, Vol. 83 - 2 - 2017
percutaneous hardware free corrective osteotomy for bunionnette deformity.
291
16. Kitaoka HB, Holiday AD. Metatarsal head resection
for bunionette : long-term follow-up. Foot and Ankle
1991 ; 11 : 345–9.
17. Kitaoka HB, Holiday AD Jr. Lateral condylar resection
for bunionette. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1992 ; 278 : 183-92.
18. Kitaoka HB, Leventen EO. Medial displacement
metatarsal osteotomy for treatment of painful bunionette.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989 ; 243 : 172-9.
19. Koti M, Maffulli N. Current concepts review bunionette. J
Bone Joint Surg 2001 ; 83 : 1076–82.
20. Legenstein R, Bonomo J, Huber W, Boesch P.
Correction of tailor’s bunion with the Boesch technique : a
retrospective study. Foot Ankle Int. 2007 ; 28 : 799-803.
21. Louwerens JW, Valderrabano V, Wintson I. Minimally
invasive surgery(MIS) in foot and ankle surgery. Editorial.
J Foot Ankle Surg 2011 ; 17 : 51.
22. Magnan B, Samaila E, Merlini M, Bondi M, Mezzari
S, Bartolozzi P. Percutaneous distal osteotomy of the fth
metatarsal for correction of bunionete. J Bone Joint Surg
2011 ; 93 : 2116–22.
23. Martinelli B, Valentini. Correction of valgus of fth
metatarsal and varus of the fth toes by percutaneous distal
osteotomy. Foot and Ankle Surgery 2007 ; 13 : 136–9.
24. Michels F, Van Der Bauwhede J, Guillo S, Oosterlinck
D, de Lavigne C. Percutaneous bunionette correction.
Foot Ankle Surg. 2013 Mar ; 19 : 9-14
25. Moran MM, Claridge RJ. Chevron osteotomy for
bunionette. Foot Ankle Int 1994 ; 11 : 684–8.
26. Okuda R, Kinoshita M, Morikawa J, Jotoku T, Abe
M. Proximal dome-shaped osteotomy for symptomatic
bunionette. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
2002 ; 396 : 173–8.
27. Petersen WJ, Lankes JM, Paulsen F, Hassenpug
J. The arterial supply of the lesser metatarsal heads : a
vascular injection study in human cadavers. Foot Ankle Int.
2002 ; 23 : 491-5.
28. Radl R, Leithner A, Koehler W, Scheipl S, Windhager
R. The modied distal horizontal metatarsal osteotomy
for correction of bunionette deformity. Foot Ankle Int.
2005 ; 26 : 454-7.
29. Roukis TS. The tailor’s bunionette deformity : a eld
guide to surgical correction. Clin Podiatr Med Surg.
2005 ; 22 : 223-45.
30. Shereff MJ, Yang QM, Kummer FJ. Extraosseous and
intraosseous arterial supply to the rst metatarsal and
metatarsophalangeal joint. Foot Ankle. 1987 ; 8 : 81-3.
31. Shereff MJ, Yang QM, Kummer FJ, Frey CC, Greenidge
N. Vascular anatomy of the fth metatarsal. Foot Ankle.
1991 ; 11 : 350-3.
32. Shrum DG, Sprandel DC, Marshall H. Triplanar closing
base wedge osteotomy for tailor’s bunion. Journal of the
American Podiatric Medical Association 1989 ; 79 : 124–
7.
33. Weitzel S, Trnka H, Petroutsas J. Transverse medial slide
osteotomy for bunionette deformity : long-term results.
Foot Ankle Int 2007 ; 28 : 794–8.
reported in previous articles and shown in our study,
clinical healing precedes radiological union.
This study conrms this procedure to be useful as
a standard technique for the percutaneous interested
foot- and ankle surgeon treating a tailors bunion.
REFERENCES
1. Alvarez F, Viladot R, Pons M, Viladot A. Pathology of
the fth toe. Quintus varus. Surgical treatment. J Foot
Ankle Surg. 2005 : 11 : 25-8.
2. Bauer T, Laffenêtre O. Complications de la chirurgie
percutane´e de l’avantpied. In : Cazeau C, editor.
Chirurgie mini-invasive et percutanée du pied. Mont-
pellier : Sauramps Medical ; 2009. p. 183–201.
3. Buchbinder IJ. DRATO procedure for tailor’s bunion. J
Foot Surg. 1982 ; 21 : 177-80.
4. Coughlin MJ. Treatment of bunionette deformity with
longitudinal diaphysealosteotomy with distal soft tissue
repair. Foot and Ankle 1991 ; 11 : 195–203.
5. Coughlin MJ. Treatment of bunionette deformity with
longitudinal diaphysealosteotomy with distal soft tissue
repair. Foot Ankle. 1991 ; 11 : 195-203.
6. Coughlin MJ. Bunionettes. In : Coughlin MJ, Mann RA,
Salzman CL. editors. Surgery of the foot and ankle. 8th ed.
Philadelphia : Elsevier ; 2007. p 491-529.
7. Davies H. Metatarsus quintus valgus. British Medical
Journal 1949 ; 1 : 664–5.
8. Diebold PF, Bejjani FJ. Basal osteotomy of the fth
metatarsal with intermetatarsal pinning : a new approach
to tailor’s bunion. Foot and Ankle 1987 ; 8 : 40–5.
9. Dorris M, Mandel M. Fifth metatarsal head resection
for correction of tailor’sbunions and sub-fth metatarsal
head keratoma. A retrospective analysis. J Foot Surg
1991 ; 30 : 345–9.
10. Du Vries HL. Surgery of the foot, 2nd ed., St Louis : CV
Mosby ; 1965. p. 456–62.
11. Estersohn HS, Scherer PR, Bogdan R. A preliminary
report on open wedge osteotomy of the fth metatarsal.
Archives of Podiatric Medicine and Foot Surgery
1974 ; 1 : 317–27.
12. Fallat LM. Pathology of the fth ray, including the tailor’s
bunion deformity. Clin Podiatr Med Surg. 1990 ; 7 : 689-
715.
13. Frankel JP, Turf RM, King BA. Tailor’s bunion : clinical
evaluation and correction by distal metaphyseal osteotomy
with cortical screw xation. J Foot Surg. 198.9 ; 28 : 237-
49.
14. Friend G, Grace K, Stone HA. L-osteotomy with
absorbable xation for correctionof tailor’s bunion. J Foot
Ankle Surg. 1993 ; 32 : 14-9.
15. Giannini S, Faldini C, Vannini F, Digennaro V, Bevoni
R, Luciani D. The minimally invasive osteotomy SERI
(Simple, Effective, Rapid, Inexpensive) for correction of
bunionette deformity. Foot Ankle Int 2008 ; 29 : 282–6.
11-Molenaers.indd 291 11/10/17 16:03
... The first percutaneous techniques have been described by De Prado and Isham [3]. Further studies, assessing the clinical results, found similar results as the open techniques but a lower risk of complications [4][5][6]. Especially the hardware free percutaneous technique offers this major advantage as complications are very often related to hardware [7]. The advent of these new techniques offers new opportunities, but several questions remain unanswered. ...
... The advent of these new techniques offers new opportunities, but several questions remain unanswered. Between the percutaneous techniques some variations have been described: condylectomy or not, double or single osteotomy, complete or incomplete osteotomy, location of the osteotomy [3][4][5][6]8,9]. There are also some differences in the perioperative protocol. ...
... In the publications of the recent years two groups of minimally invasive corrections can be distinguished: the mini-open techniques using a percutaneous K-wire [14][15][16][17][18][19] and the percutaneous techniques using no additional hardware [3][4][5][6][8][9][10]13,20]. Our study was limited to the surgeons using this second technique. ...
Article
Introduction Il a été démontré que le traitement percutané d’une déformation de type bunionette était une technique fiable et satisfaisante avec un faible risque de complications. Cependant, il existe des variations évidentes dans la technique chirurgicale et le protocole périopératoire. Le but de cette étude était d’analyser les techniques actuellement utilisées traiter une bunionette et d’en rechercher les points communs. Hypothèse Il existe des points consensuels dans la technique chirurgicale et le protocole periopératoire lors de l’utilisation d’une technique percutanée pour traiter une déformation de type bunionette. Méthodes Un questionnaire été envoyé à 50 chirurgiens orthopédistes avec une expérience spécifique des techniques percutanées. Les questions portaient sur les différents aspects de la procédure chirurgicale de la bunionette et du protocole périopératoire. Résultats Un taux de réponse de 92,0 % a été obtenu. Plusieurs points d’accord ont été trouvés. Une condylectomie est rarement utilisée tandis qu’une ostéotomie est réalisée dans presque toutes les procédures. Cette ostéotomie est unique (95,7 %), complète (66,2-72,7 %) et réalisée avec une fraise type Shannon longue (73,9 %). L’emplacement de l’ostéotomie dépend de la déformation (63,0 %). Discussion Cette étude démontre un certain consensus dans l’utilisation de la technique chirurgicale et du protocole périopératoire. L’ostéotomie percutanée oblique est la technique privilégiée alors qu’une condylectomie n’est que rarement utilisée. Niveau de preuve V, Opinions d’experts.
... To our knowledge, only one study has evaluated changes on the lateral radiograph and no study has evaluated changes in rotation of the fifth metatarsal head postoperatively (5). Recently, there has been a rise in number of studies on percutaneous deformity correction, also known as minimally invasive surgery (MIS) (8)(9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20)(21). Although it is unclear whether it relates to clinical outcomes, shortening of the fifth metatarsal and elevation of the metatarsal head are inevitable, especially in percutaneous surgery using a burr for osteotomy. ...
... Interest in using MIS for the treatment of bunionette deformity has been growing recently (6)(7)(8)(9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20)(21). The minimal soft tissue disruption with MIS preserves blood supply, which may improve postoperative pain and recovery outcomes and achieve a good cosmetic result. ...
... In addition, mini-open distal osteotomy with K-wire fixation was limited in correcting severe bunionette deformities (7). Therefore, percutaneous bunionette correction, without fixation, has become increasingly preferred (11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20)(21)33). We began performing percutaneous bunionette surgery in 2012, initially adding K-wire fixation. ...
Article
Bunionette deformities have been treated as an analog of hallux valgus, and the surgical techniques are similar. Most commonly anteroposterior image is evaluated pre- and postoperatively. To our knowledge, only one study has evaluated changes on the lateral radiograph and no study has evaluated changes in rotation of the fifth metatarsal head postoperatively. In percutaneous bunionette correction using a burr for osteotomy, shortening of the fifth metatarsal and elevation of the metatarsal head are inevitable. Without fixation, there is also a possibility of rotational change to the metatarsal head. We measured parameters on anteroposterior and lateral weight-bearing radiographs in 18 feet pre- and postoperatively. Rotation of the fifth metatarsal head was graded according to the medial tubercle location. We also evaluated angular change of the fifth metatarsal on weight-bearing lateral radiographs. Percutaneous bunionette correction without fixation could achieve satisfactory clinical and radiographic results, with less complication, when compared with previously published outcomes of open and percutaneous surgery with fixation. In this surgical method, bunionette is corrected in three dimensions. To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate rotation of the metatarsal head and change in the sagittal angle of the fifth metatarsal after bunionette correction.
... The first percutaneous techniques have been described by De Prado and Isham [3]. Further studies, assessing the clinical results, found similar results as the open techniques but a lower risk of complications [4][5][6]. Especially the hardware free percutaneous technique offers this major advantage as complications are very often related to hardware [7]. The advent of these new techniques offers new opportunities, but several questions remain unanswered. ...
... The advent of these new techniques offers new opportunities, but several questions remain unanswered. Between the percutaneous techniques some variations have been described: condylectomy or not, double or single osteotomy, complete or incomplete osteotomy, location of the osteotomy [3][4][5][6]8,9]. There are also some differences in the perioperative protocol. ...
... In the publications of the recent years two groups of minimally invasive corrections can be distinguished: the mini-open techniques using a percutaneous K-wire [14][15][16][17][18][19] and the percutaneous techniques using no additional hardware [3][4][5][6][8][9][10]13,20]. Our study was limited to the surgeons using this second technique. ...
Article
Purpose The percutaneous treatment of bunionette deformity has been demonstrated as a reliable and satisfying technique with low risk of complications. However, there are some obvious variations in the surgical technique and perioperative protocol. The purpose of this study is to analyze the currently used techniques and to look for some agreements. Hypothesis There are some points of agreement in surgical technique and perioperative protocol when using a percutaneous technique to treat bunionette deformity. Methods A survey was sent to 50 orthopedic surgeons with specific experience in percutaneous techniques. The questions were related to different aspects of the surgical bunionette procedure and the perioperative protocol. Results A response rate of 92.0% was obtained. Several points of agreement were found. A condylectomy is rarely used while an osteotomy is performed in almost all procedures. This osteotomy is single (95.7%), complete (66.2–72.7%) and performed with a Shannon long burr (73.9%). The location of the osteotomy depends of the deformity (63.0%). Discussion This study demonstrates some consensus in the use of the surgical technique and the perioperative protocol. The percutaneous oblique osteotomy is the preferred technique while a condylectomy is only rarely used. Level of evidence V, Survey study.
... Type I is defined by the size of the fifth metatarsal head and its lateral projection, type II is identified by a marked lateral concavity of the fifth metatarsal metaphysis, and type III is characterized by an increase in the intermetatarsal angle between the fourth and fifth metatarsals. Several open surgical techniques have been proposed for treating symptomatic bunionette 15 ; however, since the development of minimally invasive surgery described by de Prado, 23 many surgeons have opted for percutaneous surgery owing to its lower number of complications, 2,5,8,9,12,[14][15][16][17] in addition to maintaining the same satisfactory results. Hence, this retrospective study aimed to analyze the clinical and radiologic results of a new minimally invasive surgical treatment in patients with symptomatic bunionette in order to find an effective technique with fewer complications. ...
... Our clinical outcomes showed a significant increase in the AOFAS score, reaching a mean of 95 points on 28 patients (31 feet), these results were superior to those reported by Molenaers et al 17 Table 4. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Bunionette is a common forefoot deformity that usually leads to significant discomfort. Multiple surgical techniques have been described for correcting bunionette. The purpose of this study is to analyze the clinical and radiologic outcomes of a new surgical technique via minimally invasive distal Chevron osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal without fixation, trying to find an effective technique with fewer complications. Methods We retrospectively analyzed the data of 28 patients (31 feet) who presented with symptomatic bunionette that was resistant to conservative treatment and who underwent surgery at our center from February 2018 to February 2020. A minimum follow-up of 20 months was obtained (mean follow-up 26 months, range 20–37). Clinical results were evaluated using the visual analog scale (VAS) and the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score; 5 different radiologic parameters were analyzed. Results After surgery, the mean AOFAS score increased by 29 points ( P < .001) and the mean VAS scores decreased by 6 points ( P < .001). An adequate radiologic correction was observed with a decrease in the M4–M5 intermetatarsal angle from 10.3 to 4.8 degrees ( P < .001), metatarsophalangeal angle by a mean of 16.05 degrees ( P < .001), and lateral deviation angle of the fifth metatarsal from 8.5 to 0.97 degrees ( P < .001). Moreover, the length of the fifth metatarsal and the forefoot width was reduced ( P < .001). The only complication was an asymptomatic delay in bone healing, but a complete bone consolidation was achieved after therapy. Conclusion The proposed surgical technique shows a good correction capacity with excellent clinical and radiologic results and low complication rates. Level of Evidence: Level IV, retrospective case series.
... MIS enthusiasts claim that they can deliver comparable outcomes to open techniques with less complications, regardless of deformity classification. 28 The unstable nature of 'through and through' percutaneous osteotomies enable powerful triplanar correction with minimal insult to the soft tissue envelope arguably maintaining vascular integrity and a degree of natural constraint with the metatarsal head migrating 'to its ideal position'. Traditional distal osteotomy is limited by a short lever arm, with research demonstrating modest reduction in IM angle despite capital fragment rotation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Scarf osteotomy is established for correcting bunionette deformities. Popularity of MIS has challenged whether percutaneous osteotomy has comparable outcomes with fewer complications although head-to-head trials are lacking. Materials and Methods: All studies demonstrating buniontte reduction via scarf or percutaneous osteotomy between 2000-2023 were collated. Systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical and patient reported outcomes was performed. Methodological quality assessment and risk of bias was reviewed. Mean statistical analyses of outcomes and complications were calculated. Results: 11 small cases series met inclusion: 115 scarf osteotomy vs 170 MIS surgical episodes. All studies demonstrated statistically significant and comparable outcomes. Complications varied between procedures. All studies demonstrated high risk of bias. Conclusion: Both techniques adequately correct deformity delivering high patient satisfaction. Complication rates are similar although they manifest differently. The results of this study can be used to aid patient selection when considering open scarf or percutaneous 5t h metatarsal osteotomy.
... 6,8,9 However, according to the more recent publications this step is rarely necessary. [10][11][12] As in open techniques, a condylectomy without osteotomy offers only limited correction. A condylectomy should not be performed if open growth plates are still present. ...
Article
A bunionette deformity is a painful prominence on the lateral aspect of the fifth metatarsal head. Surgical treatment can be considered if conservative treatment has failed to relieve the symptoms. The percutaneous approach consists of 2 steps: a condylectomy and an osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal. The learning curve is small and the final results are similar to the open techniques. The main advantages are the hardware-free technique and the minimally invasive approach. This percutaneous approach avoids complications related to hardware and soft tissue healing. Because of this low complication rate, the percutaneous technique may become the new gold standard.
Preprint
Full-text available
Purpose This study aimed to compare soft and hard outcome measures after minimally invasive (MIS) versus open surgical treatment (OS) of lesser toe deformities. We hypothesized that minimally invasive treatment would be associated with fewer complications alongside comparable subjective and objective results. Methods A prospective randomized controlled study was designed. 100 patients were included and randomized into two groups. The patients were evaluated clinically, functionally and radiologically prior to surgery and in a follow up of 1.5 years, resp. Additionally, they were asked about their personal satisfaction via patient-reported outcome measures. Results As anticipated, we found significantly more wound complications including infections in the open surgery group (p = 0.029). K-wire issues were distributed equally between the groups but differed in their clinical appearance (p = 0.03). Hospital stay was significantly reduced in the MIS group (p = 0.004). Only 7 out of the finally examined 95 patients were dissatisfied with their long-term results equally distributed between both groups (4 MIS vs. 3 OS, p = 0.914). The clinical and radiological corrections of the lesser toes were comparably good in both groups, but the open surgery group showed significantly more non-unions (p = 0.0013). The functional evaluation via FFI-D (Foot Function Index Germany), a validated reliable and internationally used standardized questionnaire to assess the correlation between foot deformity and function, also demonstrated a relevant improvement of all patients’ abilities postoperatively without any difference between the two technical approaches (p = 0.460). Conclusion Lesser toe surgery is a low-risk treatment with good overall results. Minimally invasive surgery offers equivalent clinical outcomes with lower risk of complications in soft tissue and bone healing. Level of evidence Level 1 prospective randomized controlled study. TRN DKRS00034137, 25.04.2024
Article
Full-text available
Background: There has been increasing interest in the use of percutaneous or minimally invasive osteotomy techniques for bunionette correction. The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the clinical and radiographic outcomes following percutaneous or minimally invasive surgery for bunionette deformity correction. Methods: A systematic review following PRISMA guidelines was undertaken. All clinical studies published in MEDLINE, Embase, PubMed, and the Cochrane Library Database from inception until December 2023 reporting on the use of percutaneous or minimally invasive osteotomy techniques for bunionette deformity correction were included. The primary outcome was radiographic deformity correction. A meta-analysis of clinical and radiographic outcomes was performed to assess the mean difference following surgery. Risk of bias was assessed using the ROBINS-I tool. Results: A total of 942 potential studies were identified, of which 18 were included encompassing 714 feet in 580 patients. There were no comparative studies identified. The majority of studies (n = 14/18) used an unfixed distal osteotomy technique. All studies showed a statistically significant improvement in clinical outcomes (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society ankle-hindfoot score and visual analog scale for pain) and radiologic outcomes (fourth-fifth intermetatarsal angle and fifth metatarsophalangeal angle). Complication rates ranged from 0% to 21.4%. The nonunion rate was 0% to 5.6%. Overall risk of bias was low to moderate. The most common complication was development of a hypertrophic callus that tended to resorb over time without needing further surgical intervention. Conclusion: The results of this systematic review must be considered in light of the methodologic limitations of the studies analyzed—including additional procedures performed at the same time as the bunionette correction, lack of comparative studies, and heterogeneity of the case series included. Despite these limitations, our review suggests that percutaneous techniques for bunionette deformity correction are generally clinically safe and associated with improvement in radiographic alignment and patient-reported outcome measures.
Article
Full-text available
Treatment of tailor's bunion is largely conservative. For severe or refractory cases surgical intervention is necessary. The aim of this study is to evaluate a percutaneous technique for correcting such bunionette deformities. Twenty-one procedures were performed on 20 patients using a percutaneous technique. Patients were scored using the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Lesser Toe Metatarsophalangeal-Interphalangeal Scale. No wound healing problems, infections, non-unions or mal-unions occurred. Functional assessments revealed very good results. Radiographic evaluation confirmed good average correction of the fourth-fifth intermetatarsal angle and metatarsophalangeal angle. This percutaneous technique is a reliable and effective approach for the treatment of bunionette deformity. The results obtained were comparable to those reported using traditional open techniques, but major complications due to soft tissue damage were averted. This technique can be adapted depending on the type of deformity, and does not require internal fixation.
Article
In this paper, the Authors suggest the performance of percutaneous distal osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal neck by a rapid, mini-invasive technique, without joint capsule procedures for the correction of fifth ray deformities with a valgus fifth metatarsal and a varus fifth toe. The procedure was carried out in 25 foots who underwent surgery between January 2002 and May 2005, with an 8-month to 4-year follow-up. The clinical results were evaluated by the AOFAS score which identified an improvement of the obtained score, with over 90% of the results classified between excellent and good.
Article
Distal osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal is indicated in the surgical treatment of bunionette and varus deformities of the fifth toe in patients with a valgus deviation of the fifth metatarsal. The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of a subcapital percutaneous osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal in the treatment of this disorder. From 1996 to 2006, thirty consecutive percutaneous distal osteotomies of the fifth metatarsal were performed in twenty-one patients for the treatment of a painful prominence of the head of the fifth metatarsal. Combined procedures were performed, including a first metatarsal osteotomy in sixteen feet for hallux valgus treatment and a distal open osteotomy of the second metatarsal for painful dorsal dislocation of the second metatarsophalangeal joint in eight feet. The patients were assessed at a mean of ninety-six months with a radiographic and clinical protocol that made use of the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Lesser Toe Metatarsophalangeal-Interphalangeal Scale. The AOFAS score improved from a mean and standard deviation of 51.9 ± 10.2 points preoperatively to 98.4 ± 2.6 points at the time of final follow-up. In 73% of feet there was complete resolution of pain at the fifth metatarsophalangeal joint without any functional limitation (AOFAS score of 100). In 20% of the cases the AOFAS score was 95 points with some decrease in function and a need to use comfortable shoes. In the remaining 7% of patients the AOFAS score was 93 points with mildly asymptomatic malalignment. No nonunions or recurrences were observed. The percutaneous procedure described here is a reliable technique to perform a distal transverse osteotomy of the fifth metatarsal to correct a painful varus fifth-toe deformity with prominence of the fifth metatarsal head. The clinical results are comparable with those reported with traditional open techniques, with the advantages of a minimally invasive surgical procedure, substantially shorter operating time, and a reduced risk of complications.
Article
Lateral condylar resection operations were performed in 21 feet in 16 patients with painful bunionettes. The mean follow-up period (examination and roentgenography) was 6.4 years (range, 2.3-12.4 years). The average forefoot score improved from 40.3 +/- 13.5 points to 68.3 +/- 11.7 points of a possible 75 points. The overall results were considered good in 15 feet, fair in three, and poor in three. The causes of failure were inadequate amount of resection, metatarsophalangeal joint subluxation, and severe forefoot splaying. Complications were infection, toe hypesthesia, and metatarsophalangeal joint subluxation. One patient required reoperation. Lateral condylar resection is simple and effective for most patients with bunionette, but limitations are recognized.
Article
Twenty patients (30 feet) with symptomatic bunionettes refractory to conservative care underwent longitudinal diaphyseal osteotomy, lateral condylectomy, and distal metatarsophalangeal realignment. At an average of 31 months followup, 93% (28 feet) noted good or excellent results. This technique was found to be useful and predictable in correcting the bunionette deformity.
Article
A variety of surgical procedures traditionally have been employed in the treatment of tailor's bunions and sub-fifth metatarsal head keratomas. The overwhelming majority of literature on this subject evaluates the advantages and disadvantages of various fifth metatarsal osteotomies. The authors have initiated a preliminary investigative study to evaluate the effectiveness of fifth metatarsal head resection and to compare these results with those of other studies that have focused on osteotomy techniques. Subjective and objective analyses of 50 procedures (34 patients) were performed retrospectively. Patients were either satisfied or very satisfied in 84% of the cases reviewed. Symptomatic transfer lesions occurred in only 3% of all feet examined. The most frequent postoperative complication was that of fifth digital malalignment, which presented in nearly 60% of the cases. The procedure possesses advantages and disadvantages, which prior to this study, have been discussed in anecdotal fashion only.
Article
The extraosseous and intraosseous vascular anatomy to the fifth metatarsal as visualized in a group of below-the-knee amputation specimens has been described. The extrinsic circulation to the area is provided by the dorsal metatarsal artery, the plantar metatarsal arteries, and the fibular plantar marginal artery. These three source arteries supply branches to the metatarsal and adjacent joints. The intraosseous vascularity consists of a periosteal plexus, a nutrient artery, and a system of metaphyseal and capital vessels.