A preview of this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
Content available from Nature Physics
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
ARTICLES
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 6 NOVEMBER 2017 | DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS4305
How drops start sliding over solid surfaces
Nan Gao1,2*, Florian Geyer1, Dominik W. Pilat1, Sanghyuk Wooh1†, Doris Vollmer1, Hans-Jürgen Butt1
and Rüdiger Berger1*
It has been known for more than 200 years that the maximum static friction force between two solid surfaces is usually
greater than the kinetic friction force—the force that is required to maintain the relative motion of the surfaces once the
static force has been overcome. But the forces that impede the lateral motion of a drop of liquid on a solid surface are not as
well characterized, and there is a lack of understanding about liquid–solid friction in general. Here, we report that the lateral
adhesion force between a liquid drop and a solid can also be divided into a static and a kinetic regime. This striking analogy
with solid–solid friction is a generic phenomenon that holds for liquids of dierent polarities and surface tensions on smooth,
rough and structured surfaces.
When two solid objects are brought into contact, a
threshold force FTHRD must be overcome in order for
one of the objects to slide1–3. This phenomenon can be
visualized in a typical classroom experiment where a solid block
attached to a spring is pulled over a solid surface (Fig. 1a). The static
force FSis applied to the stationary block and then increased until
it exceeds FTHRD, upon which the block begins to slide. After that, a
lower kinetic force FKIN is required to maintain the block’s motion3.
However, it is not clear whether these forces develop in a comparable
manner when a drop of liquid resting on a solid surface starts to
slide. This gap in our understanding is astonishing, given the fact
that liquid drops are omnipresent in our lives and their motion
is relevant for numerous applications, including microfluidics4,
printing5, condensation6,7, and water collection8,9. Hence insight on
the behaviour of drops that start sliding over solid surfaces is needed.
A sessile drop of liquid is usually in molecular contact with the
supporting solid surface. In contrast, two solid bodies are in direct
contact only at asperities owing to surface roughness10,11. Thus, the
real contact area of a solid–solid contact is much smaller than the
apparent contact area. Consequently, the sliding of drops might be
fundamentally different. However, by simply observing a drop of
water on a pivot window pane, we know that also sessile drops
start sliding when a critical tilt angle is reached—that is, when the
gravitational force acting on the drop overcomes the lateral adhesion
force12. The question may therefore be raised whether a static and
a kinetic regime are also present for sessile drops. The general
question is: How do drops start sliding over solid surfaces and how
do the forces develop while the drops slide?
Owing to higher gravitational forces, larger drops start sliding
at lower tilt angles. Sliding is opposed by capillary forces. They
are associated with a contact angle difference between the rear
and the front of the drop. Indeed, the interactions between solid
surfaces and liquids are described by the liquid–air surface tension
γand the apparent rear and front contact angles of the drop, θRear
and θFront, respectively. Thus, the surface tension, the contact angles
and the drop contact width Ldetermine the lateral adhesion force
FLA by13–17
FLA =kLγ(cosθRear −cosθFront)(1)
The dimensionless factor kaccounts for the precise shape of the
solid–liquid–air three-phase contact line of the drop. Values for k
were calculated to be between 1/2 and π/2 (refs 13,18–20).
Despite the omnipresence of drops, the onset of motion has
never been correlated with the development of lateral adhesion
forces. The lateral adhesion force has been related to external forces
that cause a drop to slide, such as gravitational21,22, centrifugal23,
magnetic24, or capillary forces25–27. The contact angles have also been
experimentally and numerically investigated for the pinned state—
that is, just before and during steady motions28,29. However, once a
drop has started to slide, the lateral adhesion force cannot be tracked
using simple techniques. Astonishingly, it is unclear how the force
develops and how it depends on sliding velocity. We will demon-
strate that, for lateral liquid–solid adhesion, we can distinguish a
static and a kinetic regime, analogous to solid–solid friction.
To measure the lateral adhesion force between a drop of liquid
and a solid substrate, a capillary is positioned in the centre of the
drop. The substrate with the drop is moved sideways against the
capillary at a constant velocity. When the capillary reaches the edge
of the drop, it sticks to the drop. Consequently the motion of the
substrate is accompanied by a deformation of the drop as well as a
deflection of the capillary. Initially, the drop remains pinned to the
substrate (Fig. 1b). Once the capillary exerts a certain critical force,
the drop overcomes the lateral adhesion and is set into translational
motion relative to the substrate—that is, the front and rear side of
the drop start moving. The deflection Dof the capillary is measured
by recording the position of a reflected laser beam with a position-
sensitive detector26. Then, the lateral adhesion force acting on the
drop can be calculated by FLA =κD, where κis the spring constant
of the capillary. Simultaneously, the drop’s shape is monitored by two
cameras, which are synchronized with the force measurement. In
this way the lateral adhesion force can be correlated with the contact
angles. Velocities ranged from 1 µm s−1to 50 mm s−1(see Methods).
As a representative example we start with a drop of an ionic
liquid placed on a fluorinated Si wafer. It forms a contact angle of
approximately 70◦. Moving the wafer laterally increased the force
(blue circles in Fig. 2a) until a maximum force of 50 µN was reached
(after 11 s). This maximum force corresponded to the threshold
force for the drop, upon which it started to slide. Then the force
1Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research, Ackermannweg 10, 55128 Mainz, Germany. 2Fudan University, 220 Handan Road, Shanghai 200433, China.
†Present address: School of Chemical Engineering & Materials Science, Chung-Ang University, 84 Heukseok-ro, Dongjak-gu, Seoul 06974, Korea.
*e-mail: nann.gao@gmail.com;berger@mpip-mainz.mpg.de
NATURE PHYSICS | VOL 14 | FEBRUARY 2018 | www.nature.com/naturephysics 191
© 2017 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.