ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

High-intensity housing having been carried out in town's centres causes that many complex issues related to earthworks and foundations must be resolved. Project owners are required to ensure respective number of parking bays, which in turn demands 2-3 storeys of underground car parks. It is especially difficult to fulfil in dense buildings of old town areas where apart from engineering problems, very stringent requirements of heritage conservator supervision are also raised. The problems with ensuring stability of excavation sidewalls need to be, at the same time, dealt with analysis of foundations of neighbouring structures, and possible strengthening them at the stages of installing the excavation protection walls, progressing the excavations and constructing basement storeys. A separate problem refers to necessity of constructing underground storeys below the level of local groundwater. This requires long-term lowering of water table inside excavation while at possibly limited intervention in hydrological regime beyond the project in progress. In river valleys such "hoarding off" the excavation and cutting off groundwater leads to temporary or permanent disturbances of groundwater run-off and local swellings. Traditional way to protect vertical fault and simultaneously to cut-off groundwater inflow consists in application of steel sheet pilings. They enable to construct monolithic reinforced concrete structures of underground storeys thus ensuring both their tightness and high rigidity of foundation. Depending on situation, steel sheet pilings can be in retrieving or staying-in-place versions. This study deals with some selected aspects of engineering design and fabrication of sheet piling for deep excavations and underground parts of buildings.
Content may be subject to copyright.
IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering
PAPER • OPEN ACCESS
Steel Sheet Piles – Applications and Elementary
Design Issues
To cite this article: Dariusz Sobala and Jarosaw Rybak 2017 IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 245
022072
View the article online for updates and enhancements.
Related content
Strutting systems for deep excavations –
technical challenges
Hubert Szabowicz and Tomasz yrek
-
Theoretical study of short pile effect in
tunnel excavation
Xiao-yan Tian, Jing Liu, Xiao-mei Gao et
al.
-
STUDY on Quality Control of SMW
Construction Pile in Foundation Pit
Excavation of Soft Soil Foundation
Fei Cheng
-
This content was downloaded from IP address 38.145.79.77 on 07/10/2018 at 09:53
1
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
Steel Sheet Piles – Applications and Elementary Design Issues
Dariusz Sobala1, Jarosław Rybak2
1 Rzeszow University of Technology, Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering
and Architecture, al. Powstańców Warszawy 12, 35-959 Rzeszów, Poland
2 Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering
Wyb. Wyspianskiego 27, 50-370 Wrocław, Poland
d.sobala@prz.edu.pl
Abstract. High-intensity housing having been carried out in town’s centres causes that many
complex issues related to earthworks and foundations must be resolved. Project owners are
required to ensure respective number of parking bays, which in turn demands 2-3 storeys of
underground car parks. It is especially difficult to fulfil in dense buildings of old town areas
where apart from engineering problems, very stringent requirements of heritage conservator
supervision are also raised. The problems with ensuring stability of excavation sidewalls need
to be, at the same time, dealt with analysis of foundations of neighbouring structures, and
possible strengthening them at the stages of installing the excavation protection walls,
progressing the excavations and constructing basement storeys. A separate problem refers to
necessity of constructing underground storeys below the level of local groundwater. This
requires long-term lowering of water table inside excavation while at possibly limited
intervention in hydrological regime beyond the project in progress. In river valleys such
“hoarding off” the excavation and cutting off groundwater leads to temporary or permanent
disturbances of groundwater run-off and local swellings. Traditional way to protect vertical
fault and simultaneously to cut-off groundwater inflow consists in application of steel sheet
pilings. They enable to construct monolithic reinforced concrete structures of underground
storeys thus ensuring both their tightness and high rigidity of foundation. Depending on
situation, steel sheet pilings can be in retrieving or staying-in-place versions. This study deals
with some selected aspects of engineering design and fabrication of sheet piling for deep
excavations and underground parts of buildings.
1. Introduction – traditional solutions for deep excavations or trench shoring with sheet piling
Technological progress of recent years concerns both the steel sheet piles themselves („efficient”
large-width profiles Figure 1) and the methods of pushing them into ground (reducing the dynamic
effects by application of static embedding the sheet piles – Figure 2) [1]. This study deals with some
selected aspects of engineering design and fabrication of sheet piling for deep excavations and
underground parts of buildings formerly presented in work [2][1].
It is impossible to list all important implementation of deep excavations over downtown areas. It
has to be noted that construction boom from late 90-ties coincided with introducing modern methods
of steel sheet pile embedding in Poland, which allowed to run works within inner core of city centres
(Fig. 3) where the deep excavations always bring a risk of negative influence on neighbouring
structures [3], [4]. The features offered by steel sheet piles are: flexibility of design constructions, fast
execution, and in general, high profitability basing on full or partial material recovery.
2
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
Figure 1. U-profiles and Z-profiles Figure 2. Press-in method
Figure 3. Wroclaw experience – deep excavations in historical city centre
2. Modern methods of steel sheet pile applications
Though one of the main tasks of sheet piles was, is now and will be to withstand the earth pressure,
they can be also used, in some situations, to transfer vertical loads. At present an explicit trend is
observed that sheet pile walls are used as foundation elements which transfer loads from structure to
subsoil. Many bridge structures have been completed so far where the steel wall of abutment transfer
the loads from travelling beams. The methods of calculating and controlling the vertical bearing
capacity of sheet piles were developed [5].
There are some cases (which become more and more frequent) that piles and steel sheet piles are
used in other durable structures. These are, to name a few, the following:
footbridges founded on bulkheads out of flat steel sheet piles;
tunnels and semi-tunnels (Fig. 4) where steel sheet piles in a cantilever arrangement, anchored
or expanded, are the element of steel/concrete tunnel shoring united with its bottom;
tunnels and semi-tunnels where steel sheet piles in single- or double-row, of cantilever,
anchored and/or expanded arrangement are used as a permanent final shoring of
communication excavations, or at the same time as excavation shoring and support/abutment
of overbridges;
3
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
embankments of approaches to engineering structures in enclosure out of steel walls, either
cantilever or braced;
railway and road overbridges with various static schemes, which abutments and possibly the
piers are constructed out of steel sheet piles as palisades (combination of H-type profiles and
steel sheet piles – Fig. 5).
Figure 4. Railway tunnel opening in Lipsk Figure 5. Sheet piles as foundation elements –
overbridge in Swarzędz
Even more radical idea is to use sheet piling as final underground walls of buildings. Such solution
frequently used in tunnel works (entrances), now due to developments in sheet pile fabrication
technology, is used in construction of basement car parks. However, due to the pushback of design
engineers, there are a small number of such implementations, nevertheless the facilities completed so
far behave well and they do not give rise to any objections and are a good reference and a source of
inspiration for the future.
Walls out of steel sheet piles as permanent shoring and for foundations of various structures are
generally much more used over the world than in Poland. It is greatly dependent on local tradition. For
example:
steel sheet pilings are used as a shoring for most excavations in Holland, Germany and
Denmark, i.e. in countries which also lead in development of design methods for such type of
construction,
pressed-in steel sheet piles are used on a massive scale (much higher than that in Europe) in
Japan – the country haunted by earthquakes where impact and vibrating methods for sheet pile
seating are not socially acceptable.
The above, inevitable very short, presentation clearly shows the potential still existing in Poland for
wide and various applications of steel sheet pilings as walls and foundations of permanent structures,
especially in areas of limited access, so mainly in urban conditions.
Table 1. Thickness reduction in steel profiles, in mm acc. to Tables 4.1 and 4.2, EN 1993-5 (2003).
Design time of structure usage [years] 5 25 50 75 100
Thickness reduction of steel profiles
[mm]
Undisturbed natural soils (sands, clays) 0.00 0.30 0.60 0.90 1.20
Normal fresh water: water table line 0.15 0.55 0.90 1.15 1.40
Sea water: full submersion & rippling zone 0.25 0.90 1.75 2.60 3.50
Sea water: splashing and low water level zone 0.55 1.90 3.75 5.60 7.50
4
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
In relation to steel walls as the permanent construction elements, often the problem of sheet pile
durability is raised. In general, durability is affected by environmental conditions (corrosion-related),
which need to be reviewed as compared with design durability of the whole structure.
Figure 6. Steel sheet piles in foundation of a bridge in Poland (beginning of XX century structure)
As early as at design stage, it is possible to envisage: zinc coatings; paint coats; „duplex” coating, and
use corrosion-resistant steels or to provide respective allowance for possible corrosion. Existing
structures are properly maintained, at accessible areas by maintenance operations such as sealing,
coatings. Corrosion losses in natural soils are negligible and corrosion of steel submersed in sweat
water is at low level (Fig. 6). The issues can be with steel corrosion in sea water, especially in variable
water level zone, however such phenomenon is absent in deep excavations.
3. Main design issues
This text of limited volume is just an introduction to the subject dealing with application of steel walls
in town centre areas, hence the most difficult problems related to design work will be barely
mentioned and shortly commented basing on experience. In order to design sheet pile walls we need to
determine the necessary depth of penetration, maximum bending moment (i.e. to select proper profile
of steel sheet pile) and to calculate the forces in anchorages or struts, in so far as they are present. The
known and common methods used to calculate pressure on retaining structures fixed in soil are based
on vary different assumptions and usually lead to divergent results. For example, in traditional design
methods for sheet pilings, generally no their distortion is analysed, neither the effect of excavation on
surroundings. Numerical methods provide better overview of soil-structure interaction. Already the
first computer programs based on solutions of beams on elastic supports enabled to estimate horizontal
displacements of walls. Further on, specialist geotechnical software based on Finite Element Method
(FEM) and other ones (like MEB, MRS) enabled full analysis of excavation shoring distortion and the
land surface behind retaining wall [6]. For various reasons, these are however not in common use
because advanced calculation procedure does not provide results of higher credibility level than the
data applied. Hence, designing the excavation shoring with sheet piling needs experience while
a series of risk factors causes that current coordination is needed for work execution so as possibly
changes can be introduced to design documentation.
There is now a separate group of methods supporting design work like so called observation
method [7]. It consists in application of quite simple solutions and models, which however are
accompanying by current correction of design assumptions basing on deformation observed during
project progressing [7]. In this way we avoid dramatic discrepancies between forecast and real
behaviour of the structure. This design method is also not free of disadvantages. Due to unforeseen
situation, planning and arranging the building process are here hindered, e.g. preparing the reliable
time and payment schedule, not to mention the procedural requirements of construction law.
5
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
In each case, a continued communication between supervision, management at site and design
agency is necessary to allow current updating the project assumptions. In case of large geotechnical
contracts, the best solution is to make use of a design team of experienced contractor (design-and-
construct system). The competence injunctions are thus reduced and the responsibility clearly
established. It is of great importance as there are no design (calculation) standards for sheet pile
shoring. Excavation safety, at design stage, depends on the following:
proper selection of static scheme and determination of the excavation affected zone,
properly determination of geotechnical characteristics used to calculate earth pressures and
passive pressures, and safe estimation of surcharge load from construction site arrangement or
from adjacent buildings,
proper selection of shoring elements (indicators, steel grades, type of sheet piles) – due to their
loading capacity (also in vertical direction), flexibility, expected deformations (including
possible slip on interlocking joints) and chance to be built-in.
forecast of short and long-term phenomena related to works progressed and ultimately
related to presence of the building under design.
Hereunder, there are some detailed notes dealing with aforementioned issues.
3.1. Static schemes of sheet pilings
Depending on excavation depth, possible immersion of the wall below the designed bottom of
excavation, possibility of using struts of anchorages, assumed limitations as concerns wall
displacements and, finally, the necessity to cut off water inflow into excavations, various static
schemes are assumed (Figure 7). In case of cantilever scheme, we always must expect that the wall
must be embedded deeply below final bottom of excavation. Cantilever walls subject to strong
bending and are experienced by considerable horizontal displacements, hence they are rarely used
close to other structures or installations. For the sake of operating principle, they are extremely
sensitive to their insufficient embedding (when it is impossible to immerse the sheet piles to the
required depth) or to excessive depth of excavation. These two situations result in reduction of fixing
depth being the only factor which makes the wall stable.
Publications often provide experience that cantilever walls or cantilever stages of walls, which
finally are anchored or provided with struts, suffer breakdowns. In case of cantilever walls, the
preliminary excavations and temporary earth slopes inside the excavation are often used. Such
solutions can be used only when the work progressing is ensured strictly in line with the design
(phased execution, geometry of slopes). Unfortunately, there are numerous cases of failures when
earth works inside excavation are run inconsistently with design (reduction of earth slopes, steep and
loaded slopes of preliminary excavations).
Cantilever scheme
– wall secured in soil
Single anchorage or strut (various levels
of immersion D below excavation bottom)
Walls with multiple
anchorages or struts
Figure 7. Static schemes of sheet pile walls
Pile or anchoring
plate
Ground ancho
r
struts
Ground anchors
H
D DD
6
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
Figure 8. Steel walls with single strut (final wall of tunnel) and anchored (excavation shoring)
Single anchored or strut walls (Figure 8) are designed by calculating the necessary depth below
excavation bottom, required strength of sheet pile to bending force and the forces in anchors or struts.
Traditional approach to designing the sheet pilings, not covered by any standard, provides a difficult-
to-read picture of static calculations and the scale of simplifications made. The reason is the change of
physical quantities – more or less subjective:
reduction of passive earth pressure,
neglecting the friction at wall-to-earth contact,
increasing the depth of wall embedding,
assuming the force in anchorage higher than that resulting from calculations.
Furthermore, we need to take into account the fact that quantities given for execution are frequently
much higher than those calculated. This can result from:
extending the wall below excavation bottom forced by necessity to limit water inflow under
the wall and to eliminate depression around the excavation,
application of steel profile which is dependent of embedding it to the design depth but not the
bending strength,
application of steel with relatively low strength, which forces that higher bending factor need
to be assumed and also ensures higher rigidity of wall (it is not “economical” approach but
light sheet piles out of good steel may lead to excessive wall deformation),
application of struts or anchorages with strength much higher than those from calculations (to
reduce displacements).
Designing the walls with multiple anchors or struts requires specialist software, experience and a
skill of evaluating the safety of excavation shoring at all stages of execution. In case of walls with
multiple anchorages, the conditions of total stability and schemes of soil displacement at excavation
bottom are of large importance.
3.2. Data for static calculations of shoring out of sheet pile walls.
Static calculations of sheet pilings are run basing on values of pressure and passive earth pressure
depending on geotechnical characteristics, wall geometry and surcharge loading conditions. Thus,
proper geotechnical identification is a key factor for safety of calculations. The purposes of
geotechnical investigations specify how accurate they should be. The range of identification was
regulated by ordinance of the Minister of Internal Affairs and Administration (1998) which introduced
the notion of geotechnical category. In case of deep excavations this is most often the second (or third)
category. Paradoxically, the full range of identification cannot be determined prior initial
determination of the scope of protecting works (wall depth, locations of anchorages). Therefore,
subsoil identification works are made in stages. Initial testing is to determine the static scheme and
conception of wall-relate and anchorage-related works. Detailed testing is crucial for designing the
7
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
foundation for the structure and for selecting the method of execution (machines to be used).
Unfortunately, geotechnical documentation to be used in design of excavation protection wall is often
excluded from the responsibility of structural engineer and entrusted to geologists. This leads to a
series of errors in programming the subsoil investigations. The most flagrant deficiencies are:
restricting the scope of field works to the minimum, which leads to over-interpreting the
information gained and to geotechnical omissions,
large number of shallow holes on the object projection (useless for designing the shoring),
bad arrangement of holes over the object projection (e.g. omission the area beyond foundation
contour, in the zone where earth anchorages will be made),
omitting in laboratory testing the soils regarded as weak, for which no detailed description is
provided and no geotechnical characteristic are determined (such soils are indeed removed
from excavation, but remain behind the wall and give pressure which are difficult to estimate).
Errors in carrying out field testing are generally the following:
clutching tightly the scope of work as contracted, which often restricts the chance to determine
accurately the reach of weak soils both in plane and in depth,
finishing drilling in weak soils, thus making the investigations useless in designing or leads to
considerable over-dimensioning for the foundation elements,
improper execution of boreholes – making the boring without piping, which gives a false
image of water relations and condition of soils (especially cohesive ones).
Errors occurring at the stage of laboratory testing and workshop work result from:
executing laboratory tests which do not correspond to the needs of standards,
omitting determination the features of soils recognized as weak: fills, silts, peats, which makes
impossible to design their strengthening and to calculate the earth pressures.
3.3. Considering the influence of wall flexibility.
Extensive review and discussion about various designing methods for sheet pile walls, considering
their flexibility, was published by Bjerrum, Frimann-Clausen and Duncan over 40 years ago [9]. It was
a presentation of history and current status of knowledge in this field. They draw attention to large
discrepancies between bending moments calculated by commonly used methods due to assuming
extremely different design assumptions. Model testing shows occurrence of so called spanning –
concentrations of pressures at points of anchorages and below excavation bottom while simultaneously
the pressure is reduced along wall length, where its deflection is possible.
effect of
surcharge q
earth pr essur es
for q = 0
level of strutting
(anchoring)
excavation -6,00 m
effect of q
q = 30 kPa
Figure 9. Concentration of soil pressures at the
level of strutting or anchorage specific for walls
with low rigidity (sheet pilings).
Figure 10. Reduction factor Rm
for moments from soil pressures.
8
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
Model tests show reduction of bending moment, which can be as low as 30% of the value
calculated on the basis of limiting pressures. What need to be stressed, possible reduction of bending
moment can be accompanied by essential growth of force in anchorage and therefore in economic
terms – they should be jointly examined. The discussion about the effect of wall stiffness on
determined bending moments (so consequently on the protection costs) was given in publications of
Rowe [10] who dealt with single-anchored walls. The measure of wall rigidness is log(
), where the
parameter
= H4/EI is expressed in m3/kN (H wall length). The moment which is considered in
calculations of necessary wall factor is M=RmMmax. For the most frequent values of parameter
log
= log(H4/EI) equal from -0.5 to 1.3 (in International System of Units, where H [m],
EI [kNm2/m]), the reduction of wall bending moments with respect Mmax (for the scheme with wall not
fixed in soil) can be estimated to 25-70%. Example of the diagram for reduction factor Rm for
pressures from non-cohesive soils is given in the figure 10.
In case of cohesive soils, such redistribution of pressures on flexible structures leads to reduction of
bending moment by up to 40%. Reduction refers to the moments from soil pressure only (pressures
from water are not reduced). If wall flexibility is taken into account during calculations, more accurate
determination is possible for bending moments and designing process is more cost-effective.
3.4. Selecting the sheet piles – problem of low rigidity of sheet piles out of high-strength steel.
A successive way to reduce the cost of shoring composed of sheet pilings is to use the sheet piles
made of higher-strength steel. They allow to use lighter profiles. However, each time they should be
examined for possible embedding and estimated for deformations of unearthed wall (also as concerns
redistribution of soil pressures towards struts and anchorages.
3.5. Calculating and verifying the bearing capacity to pressing.
Vertical load bearing capacity of sheet piling (to pressing) depends on resistances generated at the
basis and on the side surface of sheet piles. Here, we need to mention that the soil ground cork is
created between arms of sheet piles immersed. For this reason, type Z sheet piles should be immersed
with hammer or vibrating hammer in pairs. This is clearly shown in figure from „Fascicule 62 Titre V”
– the publication of LCPC in Paris.
Figure 11. Surface area of base A and side surface P (measured along the circumference)
assumed for calculations, sheet piles type U in upper row and type U in lower row
An important factor affecting the piling capacity is the embedding technology. Coefficients
considered in calculating the vertical capacity given in French recommendations were determined for
walls immersed with pile-driver as this document is the result of correlation between trial loads of so
immersed sheet piles and in-situ tests made at point of immersion. In 2002, trial loads were carried out
for walls being vibration-immersed and driven. The largest differences of vertical capacity were about
50% in favour of driving method. Hence, proposal was made to reduce the bearing capacity for base
and side surface of vibration-immersed sheet piles calculated on the basis of „Fascicule” by 50% and
30% respectively. The vertical bearing capacity of sheet piles embedded by means of vibrating
hammer can be increased by driving them in for the last 2 or 3 metres of the pile. Worth mentioning is
that the sheet piles immersed by means of static pressing have the vertical capacity comparable with
that of being driven in. This is the result of mobilizing friction at side surface during pressing in the
9
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
sheet piles. The most credible way to estimate the vertical bearing capacity of vertical sheet pilings is
to carry out trial load. It should be borne in mind to load the sheet piles which are not connected with
adjacent ones via interlocking joints. The point is that the effect of friction in interlocking joint of
loaded and unloaded sheet piles does not affect the results of trial loading. Hence, it is recommended
to immerse additional sheet piles at the same soil conditions, i.e. close to the wall which will be a part
of the structure under construction. The other solution (which is a little more complicated in technical
aspects) is to tear out the adjacent sheet piles for the time of trial loading, and the re-immerse them
again after trial load testing.
Testing the vertical bearing capacity of sheet piles, type AZ37-700 D, in construction of retain wall
RC21 at construction site of the S8 throughway, Armia Krajowa Route, in Warsaw. The trial load of
the separate sheet pile, type AZ37-700D, gave the design capacity for pressing of 1212 kN what
means that the admissible load for pressing in the sheet piling is about 866 kN/m. In fact, the bearing
capacity of continuous wall is higher due to higher capacity of the base (soil spanning). The settlement
corresponding to the design vertical capacity of paired sheet pile was 2.80 mm.
4. Summary: Advantages and limitations of sheet pile walls.
Steel sheet piles are commonly used to protect deep excavations. Modern methods of designing and
monitoring the quality of works are available now. The advantages of steel sheet piles worth to
emphasise are as follows:
they can be easily transported and installed using up-to-date and highly efficient equipment
for driving them in, vibration pressing and pressing; (reduction of work scope at foundation
construction area – starting from the moment when material unloading is completed, the
construction site is occupied just by pile driver or pressing machine with a crane which handle
the sheet piles;
sheet pilings have quite flexible work schedule – there is no risk related unplanned downtime;
sheet piles can be pulled out and driven in again;
when the steel sheet piles can be retrieved, the costs are substantially reduced and the project
impact on environment is limited as the water relations can be regenerated totally or to
considerable extent (limitation of damming);
they can be easily joint together; the profiles, length, level of wall crown and the shape of
footprint of future excavation can be flexibly selected;
when transfer of vertical forces is planned, they have high bearing capacity at low settlement;
after they are driven in immediate loads can be applied;
they have high durability, proved in practice, also under severe conditions of use; observations
made for over a hundred-year-old embankments or equally old communication structures
allow to say that steel elements in soil ensure sufficient durability in adverse environmental
conditions, often without proper maintenance;
they ensure clean site area, and – what is important – limit traffic of heavy vehicles (concrete
mixer vehicles) because steel sheet piles are delivered with one transport.
Application of steel sheet piles have also some constraints:
Steel sheet piles have limited length, which results both from transportation reasons and from
limited height of pile-driver masts. In special cases, this may cause necessity to “lengthen” the
wall of sheet piles by means of palisade of injection piles. Such solutions have already been
successfully implemented.
Occasionally, it is impossible to immerse the sheet piles with conventional methods. Then,
drilling or water jetting is necessary to assist in immersing. Such actions reduce soil strength
at contact with the wall and can cause higher pressures than those in design assumptions.
Steel sheet piles can, when they encounter obstacles in soil, be destroyed or partially
disconnected in interlocking joints. When the wall shall pay the role of sheet piling, a
“window” is then created and the ground water will flow into the excavation.
10
1234567890
WMCAUS IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 245 (2017) 022072 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/245/2/022072
In congested housing, deep excavations may adversely affect close surroundings by:
lowering the land adjacent to excavation and settlement resulted from possible depression
cone when walls protecting deep excavation did not reach non-permeable layers (affected are
buildings and infrastructure),
dynamic effects transmitted to neighbourhood during works,
soil distressing due to unloading the excavation bottom level.
These last phenomena are described in detail in Polish ITB Instruction No. 376/2002 [10]. All
available techniques of steel piles and sheet piles embedding in towns (also by means of driving in and
vibration driving) are possible provided the surroundings subjects to continuous monitoring referring
the impact of the works, and provided the project progressed is accompanied by a proper information
action. Commonly available measuring instruments with recorders and fast analysing method for
measurement results enable to run measurements continuously, and they frequently allow to ensure
automatic work suspension if the acceptable vibration level is exceeded. The aforementioned issues do
not fully exhaust the subject of designing and executing steel sheet pile walls. The author is going to
provide a review of problems, which need to be taken into account by a cognizant design engineer
dealing with shoring of deep excavations.
References
[1] D. Sobala, K. Sahajda, “Metoda statycznego wciskania grodzic stalowych. Zalety, przykłady
i warunki stosowania”, Press-in method of sheet pile driving advantages, examples and
conditions of applications. Geoinżynieria. Drogi, mosty, tunele, [in Polish], 01/2006
[2] Cz. Rybak, J. Rybak, D. Sobala, “O zastosowaniu stalowych wciskanych ścianek szczelnych”
Applications of pressed-in steel sheet piles, Inżynieria i Budownictwo, No 12, pp. 709-712,
[in Polish], 2001
[3] A. Siemińska-Lewandowska, M. Mitew-Czajewska, “The effect of deep excavation on
surrounding ground and nearby structures”, Geotechnical Aspects of Underground
Construction in Soft Ground - Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium,
IS-SHANGHAI 2008, pp. 201-206, 2009
[4] Cz. Rybak, J. Rybak, K. Sahajda, “Zagrożenia konstrukcji obiektów istniejących związane
z realizacją głębokich wykopów”. Major threats for the buildings in vicinity of deep
excavations, Inżynieria i Budownictwo, Vol. 6, pp. 318-321, [in Polish], 2004
[5] M. Bustamante, L. Gianeselli, Predicting the bearing capacity of sheet piles under vertical load;
Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Piling and Deep Foundations, Stresa
(Italy), 7 – 12 April 1991.
[6] M. Mitew-Czajewska, “Numerical analysis of a 36m deep diaphragm wall - Parametric study”,
Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground - Proceedings of the
8th Int. Symposium on Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground,
TC204 ISSMGE - IS-SEOUL 2014, pp. 257-262. 2014
[7] K. Gorska, Z. Muszyński, J. Rybak, “Displacement monitoring and sensitivity analysis in the
observational method”, Studia Geotechnica et Mechanica, Vol. 35, No 3, pp. 25-43, 2013
[8] K. Gorska, M. Wyjadłowski, “An analysis of excavation support safety based on experimental
studies”, Studia Geotechnica et Mechanica, Vol. 37, No 3, pp. 19-29, 2015
[9] L. Bjerrum, C.J. Friman Clausen, J.M. Duncan, “Earth pressures on flexible structures”.
Proceedings of the 5th European Conf. on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Eng. Madrid,
1972
[10] D.P. Rowe, “Theoretical and experimental analysis of sheet pile walls”, Inst. Civ. Eng. London,
Proc. Vol 4, pp. 32-64, 1955
[11] W. Kotlicki, L. Wysokiński, „Ochrona zabudowy w sąsiedztwie głębokich wykopów”,
Protection of buildings adjacent to deep excavations, Instruction ITB 376/2002, Warszawa,
[in Polish], 2002
... The U-type steel sheet pile is often used in construction as a temporary supporting structure for excavation work due to its flexibility of design constructions, fast execution, and high profitability based on full or partial material recovery [40]. On the other hand, the soil in coastal areas normally consists of high content of sand [32], complicating the situation and necessitating a different approach. ...
... Furthermore, the sheet pile is used in the coastal area to control and to delay the seepage as well as the transportation of contaminants through soil [5]. It is also often used as a part of earth retaining structure at the water-front structure, with its advantages such that dewatering at the site is not compulsory, and often an ideal option or choice at the sites with groundwater tables or soils with lower bearing capacity [40]. For example, it can be used in the construction of harbor or port, by aligning the sheet pile in the way of connecting to major structures like locks and dams [22]. ...
Article
It is often challenging to construct temporary work structures for excavation work with temporary structures at coastal areas with soft soil properties and high-water tables. In this project, we simulated the behaviour of soil movements and stresses by finite element analysis method (using PLAXIS 2D) under different types of U- type steel sheet piles. The outcome result is then presented in the form of a table in this paper, for comparison and reference, which promotes better workmanship and quality in selecting the suitable sheet pile used for temporary work structures for excavation purposes at the coastal area. Deformed mesh, Horizontal Displacement, Horizontal Incremental Displacement, Safety Factor, Total Displacement, Total Incremental Displacement, Vertical Displacement as well as Vertical Incremental Displacement for both with groundwater and without groundwater conditions of each option are included in the result and analysis section. In conclusion, the analysis serves as an important guideline and reference before the commencement of work, which is important in the decision-making of future work, especially during excavation.
... The U-type steel sheet pile is often used in construction as a temporary supporting structure for excavation work due to its flexibility of design constructions, fast execution, and high profitability based on full or partial material recovery [40]. On the other hand, the soil in coastal areas normally consists of high content of sand [32], complicating the situation and necessitating a different approach. ...
... Furthermore, the sheet pile is used in the coastal area to control and to delay the seepage as well as the transportation of contaminants through soil [5]. It is also often used as a part of earth retaining structure at the water-front structure, with its advantages such that dewatering at the site is not compulsory, and often an ideal option or choice at the sites with groundwater tables or soils with lower bearing capacity [40]. For example, it can be used in the construction of harbor or port, by aligning the sheet pile in the way of connecting to major structures like locks and dams [22]. ...
Article
It is often challenging to construct temporary work structures for excavation work with temporary structures at coastal areas with soft soil properties and high-water tables. In this project, we simulated the behaviour of soil movements and stresses by finite element analysis method (using PLAXIS 2D) under different types of U- type steel sheet piles. The outcome result is then presented in the form of a table in this paper, for comparison and reference, which promotes better workmanship and quality in selecting the suitable sheet pile used for temporary work structures for excavation purposes at the coastal area. Deformed mesh, Horizontal Displacement, Horizontal Incremental Displacement, Safety Factor, Total Displacement, Total Incremental Displacement, Vertical Displacement as well as Vertical Incremental Displacement for both with groundwater and without groundwater conditions of each option are included in the result and analysis section. In conclusion, the analysis serves as an important guideline and reference before the commencement of work, which is important in the decision-making of future work, especially during excavation.
... During the design phase, one can consider various options such as zinc coatings, paint layers, "duplex" coating, and the use of corrosion-resistant steel. It is also possible to incorporate appropriate measures to account for potential corrosion (Sobala & Rybak, 2017). The maximum thickness reduction for the steel sheet pile is shown in Table 6. ...
Article
Full-text available
Seepage is one of the main causes of dams and some other hydraulic structures' failure. Water movement beneath the dam’s base creates piping and uplift pressure under the structure, potentially leading to improper dam operation. This current study focuses on the utilization of a special technique to restrict the transfer of movement water via soil which includes sheet piles under the dam foundation. Sheet pile walls are interlocking pile segments that are embedded in soil to resist horizontal pressure, classified as a flexible retaining system, and capable of tolerating relatively large deformations. Sheet piles are made of various materials, such as wood, concrete, steel, and aluminum, which are suitable for different applications. The role of seepage can be affected by the cutoff utilization. In this study, some Iraqi dam issues due to seepage are explained, also the geological stratum beneath the dam is briefly discussed. the potential use of sheet piles with different configurations has been reviewed to detect the optimum situation for seepage parameters reduction based on their numbers, interval distances, inclinations, and places. Keywords: Seepage, sheet piles, impermeable foundation, Iraqi dams’ issues, and geological stratum.
... It was found that generally the system stability could be amended by truncating the trench length and incrementally increasing the pile offset distance from the trench (Simpson, 1992;Bloodworth and Bloodworth, 2002;Gourvenec et al., 2002). A study also describes the effect of the construction stage on the retaining wall on the nearby structures, displacements, and bending moment (Hamza et al., 1999;Mohamed et al., 2013;Ghazaly et al., 2017;Sobala and Rybak, 2017). With the help of finite-element analysis, PLAXIS2D, and 3D software, it is possible to forecast how a diaphragm wall will behave under different loading situations and about soil deformation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Due to the soil’s low strength and high sensitivity to deterioration, designing and building in soft soil is extremely challenging and can result in structural damage. Insufficient space in urban areas has presented a challenge to excavate deep into the earth, and it is increasing the required area for the provision of public services. The function of the diaphragm wall and supporting strut member was modeled in this study using a 2D Finite element model developed with PLAXIS2D software. The excavation was designed to stabilize and limit aging due to excavation at acceptable levels nearby buildings. The analysis took into account the soil’s indirect conduct using the Mohr-coulomb failure method. Results of the study show that up to the depth of 8 m the ground surface can be safely excavated without any structural support. Beyond this limit, soil failure occurs due to the release of vertical stress and loss of lateral support. The diaphragm wall with two strut systems is sufficient to restrict ground movement under structure loading by providing lateral stability to excavation sides. The performance of the diaphragm wall is independent of the cross-sectional shape of strut members. However, the I section is more economical.
... In contrast, while soil nail walls and soil mixing walls have high construction efficiency and low costs, they exhibit weak deformation resistance. Steel sheet pile walls also have a weakness in their deformation resistance as well as leakage at the joints [18], despite the fact that they can be recycled and reused. In recent years, there has been growing concern about the environmental impact of infrastructure development, including carbon dioxide emissions and waste generation [19][20][21]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Excavations for underground structures, such as working shafts, underground grain silos, and parking garages, are characterized by uniformity, consistent dimensions, large quantities, and strict timelines. Prefabricated recyclable supporting structures (PRSS) are gaining attention over traditional retaining structures due to their standardized design, efficient construction, and reusability, which suit such excavations better. To validate their performance, full-scale tests are conducted to analyze the deformation and stress characteristics of PRSS. The results show that the average maximum lateral displacement of supporting pile is 0.07% of the excavation depth (He), roughly half that of steel plate. Differences in ground surface settlement behind steel plates and the supporting piles are not as significant as those in their lateral displacements. While the displacement of the supporting piles is insufficient to induce soil movement into the active limit state on the non-excavation side, the circular excavation’s arching effect reduces the earth pressure on this side of the supporting piles below the active earth pressure limit. Furthermore, the earth pressure acting on the steel plates is lower than that acting on the supporting piles, suggesting the presence of a soil arching effect between two adjacent piles. These findings offer valuable insights for guiding the construction of PRSS.
Article
Full-text available
The usage of “sheet pile wall” is very common solution in Denmark due to the geographic situation of the country – low sea level, a significant part of the state border is sea, high groundwater level, poor geotechnical conditions. The “sheet pile wall” is used for strengthening of embankments, reclaim marine territories and as a supporting walls of railway lines and roads. As a consequence of this, a very common solution is to use the sheet pile walls as a part of the substructure of bridges – overpasses of railway lines and roads when the alignment is in excavation. From one side, the “sheet pile wall” are used as wing walls of the bridge and they support the road embankment. From another side, it is used as an abutment walls of the bridge. The part of the wall acting as a bridge support is design with some concrete “hammer beam”. The “hammer” in some cases is connected to the bridge deck by means of concrete hinges. Very often, “sheet pile wall” in the zone of the wing walls is combined with anchors in order to take increased section forces. Common variants in Denmark practice for connection of the bridge superstructure and sheet pile substructure are presented and analysed in the paper.
Article
Full-text available
Based on the site conditions and lateral earth pressure of soil plays important role in the selection of sheet pile wall. In the present day different types of sheet pile wall present in the market like as steel sheet pile wall , concrete sheet pile wall and timber etc. Concrete sheet pile walls are common in use. Modification in the properties of the concrete sheet piles is easier making it more economical as the utility of the section can be considerably increased according to projects requirement. Sheet pile wall deformation is dependent on the materials properties. Consequently, it is essential to research how different material types and properties affect the deformation and stress distribution of cantilever concrete sheet pile walls. A parametric analysis was carried out numerically using a case study that makes use of a base model to determine how long a sheet pile wall should be at the bottom of an embankment with various material types for ditch with a depth of 3m, 5m and 7m.to safeguard and improve the stability of the embankment , a sheet pile wall was temporarily constructed near the toe of the embankment. Analysing simulation data was completed with the aid of GE05FINE. The analysis findings revealed that when subjected to the same loading situation, bending moment and shear force varies with the material properties. Therefore, it is wise to carefully select the sheet pile wall materials in accordance with the projects requirements.
Article
Full-text available
W artykule przedstawiono ogólny opis, zalety i warunki stosowania metody statycznego wciskania grodzic stalowych. Podjęto także próbę wyjaśnienia niektórych wątpliwości związanych z wpływem opisywanej technologii i zabiegów ją wspomagających na wytrzymałość i odkształcalność podłoża gruntowego. Omówiono także wybrane przykłady instalacji grodzic stalowych metodą wciskania statycznego spośród blisko trzydziestu tego typu realizacji firmy Aarsleff Sp. z o.o., wykonanych w latach 2000-2006. Z doświadczeń autorów wynika, że metoda wciskania statycznego grodzic jest w Polsce wciąż mało popularna i pomimo swoich niewątpliwych zalet nie jest wykorzystywana nawet w sytuacjach, wydawałoby się, oczywistych. Można wskazać na kilka przyczyn takiego stanu rzeczy, z których najważniejsze wydają się: - brak informacji na temat rzeczywistych możliwości metody wciskania statycznego (m.in. brak publikacji na ten temat), - fakt, że niewielka grupa wykonawców oferuje w Polsce tego typu usługi.
Article
Full-text available
The article presents the results of inclinometric measurements and numerical analyses of soldier-pile wall displacements. The excavation under investigation was made in cohesive soils. The measurements were conducted at points located at the edge of the cantilever excavation support system. The displacements of the excavation support observed over the period of three years demonstrated the pattern of steady growth over the first two months, followed by a gradual levelling out to a final plateau. The numerical analyses were conducted based on 3D FEM models. The numerical analysis of the problem comprise calculations of the global structural safety factor depending on the displacement of the chosen points in the lagging and conducted by means of the φ/c reduction procedure. The adopted graphical method of safety estimation is very conservative in the sense that it recognizes stability loss quite early, when one could further load the medium or weaken it by further strength reduction. The values of the M
Article
Full-text available
This work discusses the fundamentals of designing deep excavation support by means of observational method. The effective tools for optimum designing with the use of the observational method are both inclinometric and geodetic monitoring, which provide data for the systematically updated calibration of the numerical computational model. The analysis included methods for selecting data for the design (by choosing the basic random variables), as well as methods for an on-going verification of the results of numeric calculations (e.g., MES) by way of measuring the structure displacement using geodetic and inclinometric techniques. The presented example shows the sensitivity analysis of the calculation model for a cantilever wall in non-cohesive soil; that analysis makes it possible to select the data to be later subject to calibration. The paper presents the results of measurements of a sheet pile wall displacement, carried out by means of inclinometric method and, simultaneously, two geodetic methods, successively with the deepening of the excavation. This work includes also critical comments regarding the usefulness of the obtained data, as well as practical aspects of taking measurement in the conditions of on-going construction works.
Article
PL Opisano przypadki szkodliwych oddziaływań dynamicznych na obiekty budowlane usytuowane w bezpośrednim sąsiedztwie głębokich wykopów. Podano zalecenia praktyczne. EN The examples of damaging dynamic influence of deep excavation on close located building objects are presented. Some practical guidelines concerning realization of deep foundation, are also given.
Article
Omówiono przykłady zastosowania stalowych ścianek szczelnych wciskanych do zabezpieczenia głębokich wykopów i zapewnienia stateczności skarp i nasypów. Wskazano na zalety tego rodzaju ścianek i możliwości ich szerszego wykorzystania w praktyce.
Conference Paper
Last year a deep excavation for the construction of a metro station in Warsaw was executed in complex geotechnical conditions. In the first stage of the investment process the primary soil investigation was performed. Basing on the results of this investigation calculations of supporting system and the design of casing were carried out. In the subsequent investment stages complementary soil investigations were performed and the results were taken into account in the final analysis, design and dimensioning. Significant differences were observed in the results of analysis made at each investment stage. In the paper, description of the case and multiple numerical analysis of the case with variation of soil parameters are presented. The discussion of calculation results in relation to the changing geotechnical data is presented. At the end comparison of theoretical displacements and the displacements of the wall measured on site is given and final conclusions are provided.
Article
THE VARIATION OF THE MAXIMUM BENDING MOMENT ON SHEET-PILE WALLS WITH PILE FLEXIBILITY AND SOIL STIFFNESS IS CALCULATED FOR THE CASES OF CANTILEVERED PILING AND ANCHORED PILING, ASSUMING A MODULUS OF SUBGRADE REACTION WHICH INCREASES LINEARLY WITH DEPTH AND DEFLECTION. THIS MATHEMATICAL ANALYSIS LEADS TO MOMENT FLEXIBILITY CURVES IN CLOSE AGREEMENT WITH THOSE OBSERVED. THE POSITION OF THE MOMENT/ FLEXIBILITY CURVE IS DETERMINED BY THE VALUE OF THE SOIL STIFFNESS MODULUS. THIS MAY BE ESTIMATED BY COMPARING THE RECORDS OF PENETRATION TESTS IN THE ACTUAL SOIL WITH THAT IN ARTIFICIAL BEDS OF SOIL IN A LABORATORY. SEEPAGE MAY INCREASE THE BENDING MOMENT ON COFFERDAM WALLS BY DECREASING FIXITY. THE INFLUENCE OF SEEPAGE FORCES AND MORE COMPRESSIBLE SUBSOILS THAN LOOSE SAND ON THE STABILITY OF SHEET-PILING IS READILY ESTIMATED FROM OBSERVATIONS OF THEIR INFLUENCE ON THE SOIL MODULUS. PREVIOUS WORK IS EXTENDED TO COVER CANTILEVERED PILING AND ALL RANGES OF COHESIONLESS SUBSOILS.
2001 O zastosowaniu stalowych wciskanych scianek szczelnych Applications of pressed-in steel sheet piles, Inzynieria i Budownictwo 709-712 in Polish
  • Rybak Cz
  • J Rybak
  • D Sobala
The effect of deep excavation on surrounding ground and nearby structures
  • A Siemińska-Lewandowska
  • M Mitew-Czajewska
A. Siemińska-Lewandowska, M. Mitew-Czajewska, "The effect of deep excavation on surrounding ground and nearby structures", Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground -Proceedings of the 6 th International Symposium, IS-SHANGHAI 2008, pp. 201-206, 2009
2014 Numerical analysis of a 36m deep diaphragm wall-Parametric study Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground
  • M Mitew-Czajewska