Working PaperPDF Available

English Translation of the German Road Traffic Act Amendment Regulating the Use of “Motor Vehicles with Highly or Fully Automated Driving Function” from July 17, 2017

Authors:
Krzysztof Czarnecki at University of Waterloo
Krzysztof Czarnecki
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation
Content uploaded by Krzysztof Czarnecki
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Krzysztof Czarnecki on Nov 03, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
!
"!
English(Translation(of(the(German(Road(Traffic(Act(Amendment(Regulating(
the(Use(of(“Motor(Vehicles(with(Highly(or(Fully(Automated(Driving(Function”(
from(July(17,(2017(
!
#$%&!'()*+,-.!/0(1%',&!2!.02-&32.%(-!(4!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!.(!.$,!5,0+2-!6(2'!#0244%)!
7).! 8! 9.02:,-1,0;,$0&<,&,.=! >9.?5@! 8! .$2.! %-.0('*),'! 0,<*32.%(-! (4! A+(.(0!
1,$%)3,&! B%.$! $%<$3C! (0! 4*33C! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<! 4*-).%(-&D! (-! 5,0+2-! 0(2'&E! #$,!
2+,-'+,-.!.((;!,44,).!(-!F*3C!"GH!IJ"GE!9,)(-'!/20.!(4!.$,!'()*+,-.!)(++,-.&!(-!
>"@! .$,! 0,32.%(-&$%/! K,.B,,-! .$,! '0%1%-<! 2*.(+2.%(-! 4*-).%(-! ',4%-,'! %-! .$%&!
2+,-'+,-.! 2-'! .$,! 3,1,3&! (4! 2*.(+2.%(-! 2&! ',4%-,'! %-! 97L! FMJ"NO9,/.! IJ"N!
AP-.,0-2.%(-23!#2Q(-(+C!2-'! R,4%-%.%(-&!4(0!#,0+&! 6,32.,'!.(!R0%1%-<! 7*.(+2.%(-!
9C&.,+&! 4(0! S-T6(2'! U(.(0! ?,$%)3,&D! 2-'! >I@! .$,! 3%2K%3%.C! (4! 1,$%)3,&! (/,02.,'! KC!
.$%&!4*-).%(-!%-!5,0+2-CE!
!
#$,! 2+,-'+,-.H! 2&! /*K3%&$,'! %-! .$,! V*-',&<,&,.=K32..! >V5V3E@! WX,',023! Y2B!
52=,..,Z!%&!212%32K3,!40(+!.$,!/*K3%&$,0[&!B,K&%.,E!#$,!)(+/3,.,!2).!%&!212%32K3,!40(+!
.$,!B,K&%.,!(4!.$,!X,',023!U%-%&.0C!(4!F*&.%),!2-'!\(-&*+,0!]0(.,).%(-E!
!
#$,! 4*33! )%.2.%(-! (4! .$,! 2+,-','! 2).! %&! A9.02:,-1,0;,$0&<,&,.=! %-! ',0! X2&&*-<! ',0!
V,;2--.+2)$*-<!1(+!^E!U_0=!IJJM!>V5V3E!P!9E!M"JH!`"`@H!'2&!=*3,.=.!'*0)$!70.%;,3!a!
',&!5,&,.=,&! 1(+!"GE! F*3%!IJ"G!>V5V3E!P! 9E!IbI"@! <,_-',0.!B(0',-! %&.D! W%-! L-<3%&$O!
A6(2'!#0244%)!7).!2&!2+,-','!(-!^!U20)$!IJJM!>V5V3E!P! /E! M"JH! `"`@H!32&.!2+,-','!
KC!70.%)3,!a!(4!.$,!7).!(4!"G!F*3C!IJ"G!>V5V3E!P!/E!IbI"@DZE!
!
#$,! .,Q.! (-! .$,! 4(33(B%-<! /2<,&! >/E! ITN@! %-)3*',&! .$,! )(+/3,.,! .02-&32.%(-!(4! .$,!
2+,-'+,-.! 2-'! 2''%.%(-23! .,Q.! 40(+! .$,! 2).! .$2.!<%1,&!)(-.,Q.! 4(0! $(B! .$,!
2+,-'+,-.! B2&!2//3%,'! .(! .$,! (0%<%-23! 2).E! #$,! 2+,-','! .,Q.! %&! +20;,'! %-! 0,'E!
#02-&32.%(-!0,+20;&!20,!,-)3(&,'!%-!K02);,.&E!L3%','!.,Q.!%&!+20;,'!2&!WcZE!
!
X(0!2!4*33!'%&)3(&*0,H!P!*&,'!5((<3,!#02-&32.,!.(!/0,/20,!.$,!%-%.%23!'024.H!B$%)$!P!.$,-!
)(00,).,'!2-'!/(3%&$,'E!P!2+!43*,-.!K(.$!%-!5,0+2-!2-'!L-<3%&$H!2-'!P!2+!2!&*Kd,).!
+2..,0!,Q/,0.!(-!'0%1%-<! 2*.(+2.%(-! >2+(-<!(.$,0&H!P!&,01,! (-! .$,!97L!)(++%..,,!
.$2.! )0,2.,'! 2-'! +2%-.2%-&! .$,! FMJ"N! <*%'2-),@E! P! 2+! -,%.$,0!2! /0(4,&&%(-23!
.02-&32.(0!-(0!2!3,<23!,Q/,0.H!$(B,1,0E!X(0!)(++,-.&!2-'!)(00,).%(-&H!)(-.2).!+,!2.!
;)=20-,)e<&'E*B2.,03((E)2E!
!
f2.,03((H!g(1,+K,0!IJ"G!
h0=C&=.(4!\=20-,);%H!
f2.,03((!P-.,33%<,-.!9C&.,+&!L-<%-,,0%-<!Y2K!
i-%1,0&%.C!(4!f2.,03((!
! !
!
I!
I.(Traffic(regulations(
!
§(1((Registration(
WcZ!
!
§(1a((Motor(vehicles(with(highly(or(fully(automated(driving(function(
!
>"@!#$,!(/,02.%(-!(4!2!+(.(0!1,$%)3,!KC!+,2-&!(4!2!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!
4*-).%(-!%&!/,0+%&&%K3,!/0(1%','!.$,!4*-).%(-!%&!*&,'!4(0!%.&!%-.,-','!/*0/(&,E!
!
>I@! U(.(0! 1,$%)3,&! B%.$! $%<$3C! (0! 4*33C! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<! 4*-).%(-! B%.$%-! .$,!
+,2-%-<!(4!.$%&!7).!20,!.$(&,!B$%)$!$21,!.,)$-%)23!,j*%/+,-.!B$%)$!
"E %&!2K3,!.(!/,04(0+H!24.,0!2).%12.%(-H!.$,!'0%1%-<!.2&;!8!%-)3*'%-<!3(-<%.*'%-23!
2-'!32.,023!)(-.0(3!8!4(0!.$,!0,&/,).%1,!+(.(0!1,$%)3,!>1,$%)3,!)(-.0(3@H!
IE %&!2K3,!.(!)(+/3C!B%.$!.$,!.0244%)!0,<*32.%(-&!2//3%)2K3,!.(!.$,!1,$%)3,!'0%1%-<!
.2&;!'*0%-<!$%<$3C!2*.(+2.,'!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<H!
ME )2-!K,!+2-*233C!(1,00%'',-!(0!',2).%12.,'!KC!.$,!'0%1,0!2.!2-C!.%+,H!
bE %&!2K3,!.(!0,)(<-%=,!.$,!-,),&&%.C!(4!+2-*23!1,$%)3,!)(-.0(3!KC!.$,!'0%1,0H!
^E %&! 2K3,! .(!1%&*233CH! 2)(*&.%)233CH! .2).%3,3C! (0! (.$,0B%&,! /,0),%12K3C! -(.%4C! .$,!
1,$%)3,!'0%1,0! (4! .$,!0,j*%0,+,-.! .(! /2&&! 1,$%)3,! )(-.0(3! .(! .$,! '0%1,0! B%.$!
&*44%)%,-.!0,&,01,!(4!.%+,!2$,2'!(4!/2&&%-<!)(-.0(3H!2-'!
NE -(.%4%,&!(4!*&,!.$2.!%&!)(-.020C!.(!.$,!&C&.,+!',&)0%/.%(-E!
!
#$,! +2-*42).*0,0! (4! &*)$! 2! +(.(0! 1,$%)3,! +*&.! ',)320,! %-! .$,! &C&.,+! ',&)0%/.%(-!
.$2.!.$,!1,$%)3,!)(+/3%,&!B%.$!.$,!0,j*%0,+,-.&!(4!&,-.,-),!>"@E!
!
>M@! #$,! /0,),'%-<! /202<02/$&! &$233! (-3C! K,! 2//3%,'! .(! .$(&,! 1,$%)3,&! B$%)$! 20,!
2//0(1,'! %-! 2))(0'2-),! B%.$! k! "! >"@H! B$%)$! )(+/3C! B%.$! .$,! 0,j*%0,+,-.&! (4!
/202<02/$!>I@!&,-.,-),!"!2-'!B$(&,!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!4*-).%(-&!
"E 20,!',&)0%K,'!%-!%-.,0-2.%(-23!0,<*32.%(-&! 2//3%)2K3,! %-! .$,! .,00%.(0%23!,Q.,-.!
(4!.$%&!7).!2-'!)(+/3C!B%.$!.$,+!(0!
IE $21,!0,),%1,'! 2!.C/,T2//0(123!/*0&*2-.!.(!70.%)3,!IJ!(4!R%0,).%1,!IJJGlbN!l!
L\! (4! .$,! L*0(/,2-! ]203%2+,-.! 2-'! (4! .$,! \(*-)%3! (4! ^! 9,/.,+K,0! IJJG!
,&.2K3%&$%-<!2!402+,B(0;!4(0!.$,!2//0(123!(4!+(.(0!1,$%)3,&!2-'!.$,%0!.02%3,0&!
2-'!(4! &C&.,+&H! )(+/(-,-.&! 2-'! &,/202.,!.,)$-%)23! *-%.&! %-.,-','! 4(0! &*)$!
1,$%)3,&!>X02+,B(0;!R%0,).%1,@!>!SF!Y!INMH!`E"JEIJJGH!/E!"@E!
!
>b@!R0%1,0!%&!23&(!.$,!(-,!B$(!2).%12.,&!2!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!4*-).%(-!
0,4,00,'!.(!%-! /202<02/$! >I@! 2-'!*&,&!&*)$!2!4*-).%(-!4(0!1,$%)3,!)(-.0(3H!,1,-!%4!$,!
'(,&!-(.!)(-.0(3!.$,!1,$%)3,!KC!$%+&,34!B%.$%-!.$,!)(-.,Q.!(4!.$,!%-.,-','!*&,!(4!.$%&!
4*-).%(-E!
!
!
!
!
!
!
M!
!
§( 1b( Rights( and( responsibilities( of( the( driver( when( using( highly( or( fully(
automated(driving(functions(
!
>"@! #$,! '0%1,0! (4! .$,! 1,$%)3,! +2C! .*0-! 2B2C! $%&! 2..,-.%(-! 40(+! .$,! .0244%)! 2-'! .$,!
1,$%)3,!)(-.0(3!B$,-!.$,!1,$%)3,!%&!)(-.0(33,'!KC!+,2-&!(4!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!
'0%1%-<!4*-).%(-&!2))(0'%-<!.(! k! "2m!$,!+*&.! 0,+2%-! &*44%)%,-.3C!0,&/(-&%1,!.$2.!$,!
)2-!4*34%33!$%&!'*.C!*-',0!/202<02/$!>I@!2.!2-C!.%+,E!
!
>I@!#$,!'0%1,0!%&!(K3%<,'!.(!.2;,!(1,0!.$,!1,$%)3,!)(-.0(3!%++,'%2.,3CH!
"E B$,-!.$,!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!&C&.,+!2&;&!$%+!.(!'(!&(!(0!
IE %4! $,! 0,)(<-%=,&! (0H! (-! .$,! K2&%&! (4! (K1%(*&! )%0)*+&.2-),&H! 0,23%=,&! .$2.! .$,!
/0,0,j*%&%.,&! 4(0! .$,! %-.,-','! *&,! (4! .$,! $%<$3C! (0! 4*33C! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<!
4*-).%(-&!-(!3(-<,0!,Q%&.E!
!
§(1c((Evaluation(
!
#$,! X,',023! U%-%&.0C! (4! #02-&/(0.! 2-'! R%<%.23! P-402&.0*).*0,! B%33! ,123*2.,! .$,!
2//3%)2.%(-!(4! .$,! 0,<*32.%(-&!%-! 70.%)3,!PE! (4! .$,!32B! (4! "N!F*-,! IJ"G! >X,',023!Y2B!
52=,..,!P! /E!"Nba@! 24.,0!.$,! ,-'! (4! .$,! C,20! IJ"`! (-!2! &)%,-.%4%)!K2&%&E! #$,!X,',023!
5(1,0-+,-.!%-4(0+&!.$,!5,0+2-!V*-',&.2<!2K(*.!.$,!0,&*3.&!(4!.$,!,123*2.%(-E!
!
WcZ!
!
§(6((Execution(regulations(
!
>"@! #$,! X,',023! U%-%&.0C! (4! #02-&/(0.! 2-'! R%<%.23! P-402&.0*).*0,! %&! 2*.$(0%=,'! .(!
%&&*,!&.2.*.(0C!(0'%-2-),&!B%.$!.$,!)(-&,-.!(4!.$,!V*-',&02.!0,<20'%-<!
WcZ!
"b2E! .$,! ,&.2K3%&$+,-.! 2-'H! B%.$! .$,! )(-&,-.! (4! .$,! 2*.$(0%=,'! /,0&(-!.(!
'%&/(&,!(4!.$,!1,$%)3,H!.$,!*&,!(4! '0%1,03,&&! /20;%-<! &C&.,+&! 2.!3(B!&/,,'!
(-! /20;%-<! 20,2&! B$%)$! 20,! &,/202.,'! 40(+! .$,! 0,&.! (4! .$,! /*K3%)! 0(2'!
&/2),!KC!&.0*).*023! (0!(.$,0! 42)%3%.%,&! 2-'!B$%)$!)2-! (-3C!K,!0,2)$,'! 2-'!
,Q%.,'!1%2!&/,)%23!,-.02-),&!2-'!,Q%.&m!
!
WcZ!
!
W#$,! $,0,! ,3%','! /202<02/$! >"@! %.,+&! "EH! IE! (0! ME! )(-),0-H! 0,&/,).%1,3CH! '0%1,0!
3%),-&%-<H! 1,$%)3,! 3%),-&%-<H! 2-'! 0,<*32.%(-&! 0,<20'%-<! &24,.C! 2-'! (0',0! (-! &.0,,.&H!
&*)$!2&!.0244%)!/0($%K%.%(-&!%-!),0.2%-!20,2&!2-'!(-!),0.2%-!'2C&EZ!
!
WcZ!
!
>b2@!6,<*32.%(-&!0,4,00,'!.(!%-!/202<02/$!>"@!"EH!IEH!(0!ME!+2C!23&(!K,!,-2).,'H!%-&(420!
2&!%&! -,),&&20C! .(!.2;,! 2))(*-.!(4!.$,! &/,)%23!0,j*%0,+,-.&! 4(0! .$,!/20.%)%/2.%(-! (4!
+(.(0!1,$%)3,&!B%.$!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!(-!.$,!0(2'E!
!
b!
!
!
WcZ!
!
II.(Liability(
!
§(7((Liability(of(the(owner,(unauthorized(vehicle(operation(
!
>"@!P4H!'*0%-<!.$,!(/,02.%(-!(4!2!+(.(0!1,$%)3,!(0!2!.02%3,0!%-.,-','!.(!K,!)200%,'!KC!2!
+(.(0! 1,$%)3,H! 2! /,0&(-! %&! ;%33,'H! .$,! K('C! (0! $,23.$! (4! 2! /,0&(-! %&! %-d*0,'! (0! 2!
/0(/,0.C!%&!'2+2<,'H!.$,!(B-,0!&$233!K,!(K3%<,'!.(!.$,!%-d*0,'!/,0&(-!.(!0,/32),!.$,!
0,&*3.%-<!'2+2<,E!
!
>I@!\(+/,-&2.%(-!%&!,Q)3*','!%4!.$,!2))%',-.!%&!)2*&,'!KC!4(0),!+2d,*0,E!
!
>M@! P4! &(+,(-,! *&,&! .$,! 1,$%)3,! B%.$(*.! .$,! ;-(B3,'<,! 2-'! B%33! (4! .$,! 1,$%)3,!
(B-,0H! $,! %&! (K3%<,'! .(! )(+/,-&2.,! .$,! '2+2<,! %-&.,2'! (4! .$,! (B-,0m! %-! 2''%.%(-H!
.$,!$(3',0! 0,+2%-&!(K3%<,'! .(!)(+/,-&2.,! 4(0!.$,! '2+2<,!%4! .$,!*&,! (4! .$,! 1,$%)3,!
$2&!K,,-! +2',!/(&&%K3,!.$0(*<$!$%&!42*3.E!9,-.,-),!>"@!'(,&! -(.!2//3C!%4!.$,!*&,0!%&!
,+/3(C,'! KC! .$,! 1,$%)3,! (B-,0! 4(0! .$,! (/,02.%(-! (4! .$,! +(.(0! 1,$%)3,! (0! %4! .$,!
1,$%)3,!$2&!K,,-!3,4.!.(!$%+!KC!.$,!(B-,0E!9,-.,-),&!>"@!2-'!>I@!2//3C!2))(0'%-<3C!.(!
.$,!*&,!(4!2!.02%3,0E!
!
WcZ!
!
§(12((Maximum(Amounts(
!
>"@!#$,!/,0&(-!3%2K3,!.(!/2C!)(+/,-&2.%(-!%&!3%2K3,!
"E %-!.$,! ,1,-.! (4!.$,!',2.$!(0!%-d*0C!(4!(-,!(0!+(0,!/,(/3,!KC!.$,! &2+,!,1,-.H!
(-3C!*/!.(!2!.(.23!2+(*-.!(4!4%1,!+%33%(-!,*0(&H!2-'!%4!.$,!'2+2<,!%&!)2*&,'!KC!
.$,!*&,!(4!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!%-!2))(0'2-),!B%.$!k!"2H!(-3C!*/!
.(!2!.(.23!(4!.,-!+%33%(-!,*0(&m!%-!.$,!)2&,!(4!/2%'!/2&&,-<,0!.02-&/(0.H!4(0!.$,!
$(3',0! (4! .$,! .02-&/(0.%-<! +(.(0! 1,$%)3,! (0! .02%3,0! B$(! %&! 3%2K3,! .(! /2C!
)(+/,-&2.%(-! 4(0! .$,! ;%33%-<! (0! %-d*0C! (4! +(0,! .$2-! ,%<$.! /2&&,-<,0&H! .$2.!
2+(*-.!&$233!K,!%-)0,2&,'!KC!NJJ!JJJ!,*0(&!4(0!,2)$!2''%.%(-23!/,0&(-!;%33,'!
(0!%-d*0,'m!
IE %-!.$,!,1,-.!(4!'2+2<,!.(!/0(/,0.CH!,1,-!%4!&,1,023!.$%-<&!20,!'2+2<,'!KC!.$,!
&2+,!,1,-.H!(-3C!*/! .(! 2!.(.23!2+(*-.! (4! (-,!+%33%(-!,*0(&H!%4! .$,! '2+2<,!%&!
)2*&,'! KC! .$,! *&,! (4! 2! $%<$3C! (0! 4*33C! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<! 4*-).%(-! %-!
2))(0'2-),!B%.$!k!"2H!(-3C!*/!.(!2-!2+(*-.!(4!2!.(.23!(4!.B(!+%33%(-!,*0(&E!
#$,! +2Q%+*+! 2+(*-.&! 2))(0'%-<! .(! &,-.,-),! >"@! "E! 23&(! 2//3C! .(! .$,! -,.! /0,&,-.!
123*,!(4!2!/,-&%(-!.(!K,!/2%'!2&!)(+/,-&2.%(-E!
WcZ!!
!
V.((Vehicle(Register(
WcZ!
!
^!
!
§(32((Purpose(of(vehicle(registers(
!
>"@!#$,!1,$%)3,!0,<%&.,0&!20,!;,/.!4(0!&.(02<,!(4!'2.2!
"E 4(0! .$,! 0,<%&.02.%(-! 2-'! &*/,01%&%(-! (4! 1,$%)3,&! *-',0! .$%&! 7).! (0! .$,!
3,<%&32.%(-!K2&,'!.$,0,(-H!
WcZ!
GE 4(0!+,2&*0,&!.(!)200C!(*.!.$,!'2.2!/0(),&&%-<!%-!1,$%)3,&!B%.$!$%<$3C!(0!4*33C!
2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<! 4*-).%(-! *-',0! .$%&! 7).! (0! *-',0! .$,! 3,<%&32.%(-!
,&.2K3%&$,'!KC!.$%&!7).E!
!
WcZ!
!
VIa.(Data(Processing(in(the(Motor(Vehicle(
!
§( 63a( ( Data( Processing( in( Motor( Vehicles( With( Highly( or( Fully( Automated(
Driving(Function(
!
>"@! U(.(0! 1,$%)3,&! 2))(0'%-<! .(! k! "2! &.(0,! .$,! /(&%.%(-! 2-'! .%+,! %-4(0+2.%(-!
',.,0+%-,'! KC! 2! &2.,33%.,! -21%<2.%(-! &C&.,+! B$,-! 2! )$2-<,! (4! 1,$%)3,! )(-.0(3!
K,.B,,-! .$,! '0%1,0! 2-'! .$,! $%<$3C! (0! 4*33C! 2*.(+2.,'! &C&.,+! .2;,&! /32),E! 9*)$!
&.(02<,!23&(!())*0&!B$,-!.$,!'0%1,0!%&!/0(+/.,'!KC!.$,!&C&.,+!.(!.2;,!)(-.0(3!(4!.$,!
1,$%)3,!(0!2!.,)$-%)23!42%3*0,!(4!.$,!&C&.,+!())*0&E!
!
>I@!#$,!'2.2!0,)(0','!%-!2))(0'2-),!B%.$!/202<02/$!>"@!+2C!K,!.02-&+%..,'!.(!.$,!
2*.$(0%.%,&!0,&/(-&%K3,!*-',0!4,',023!&.2.,!32B!4(0!.$,!&2-).%(-%-<!(4!.0244%)!(44,-&,&!
B$,-!.$,C!0,j*,&.!.$,!'2.2E!#$,!.02-&+%..,'!'2.2!+2C!K,!&.(0,'!2-'!*&,'!KC!.$,+E!
#$,!,Q.,-.!(4!.$,! .02-&+%&&%(-! (4!'2.2!&$233!K,! 3%+%.,'! .(!B$2.!%&!-,),&&20C! 4(0! .$,!
/*0/(&,!(4!,&.2K3%&$%-<!/202<02/$!>"@!%-!.$,!)(-.,Q.!(4!.$,!)(-.0(3!/0(),'*0,&!/*.!%-!
/32),! KC! .$(&,! 2*.$(0%.%,&E! #$%&! '(,&! -(.! 244,).! .$,! <,-,023! 0*3,&! <(1,0-%-<! .$,!
/0(),&&%-<!(4!/,0&(-23!'2.2E!
!
>M@! #$,! 1,$%)3,! (B-,0! &$233! 2002-<,! 4(0! .$,! .02-&+%&&%(-! (4! .$,! '2.2! &.(0,'! %-!
2))(0'2-),!B%.$!/202<02/$!>"@!.(!.$%0'!/20.%,&H!%4O!
"E .$,! '2.2! 0,j*%0,'! .(! 2&&,0.H! &2.%&4C! (0! ',4,-'! 2<2%-&.! 3,<23! )32%+&! %-!
)(--,).%(-!B%.$!2-!,1,-.!0,<*32.,'!%-!k!G!>"@!20,!0,j*%0,'m!2-'!
IE .$,! )(00,&/(-'%-<! +(.(0! 1,$%)3,! B%.$! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<! 4*-).%(-! B2&!
%-1(31,'!%-!.$%&!,1,-.E!]202<02/$!>I@!&,-.,-),!M!2//3%,&!2))(0'%-<3CE!
!
>b@! #$,! '2.2! &.(0,'! %-! 2))(0'2-),! B%.$! /202<02/$! >"@! &$233! K,! ',3,.,'! 24.,0! &%Q!
+(-.$&H!*-3,&&!.$,!1,$%)3,!B2&!%-1(31,'!%-!2-!,1,-.!0,<*32.,'!%-!k!G!>"@m!%-!.$%&!)2&,H!
.$,!'2.2!+*&.!K,!',3,.,'!24.,0!.$0,,!C,20&E!
!
>^@!P-!)(--,).%(-!B%.$! 2-! ,1,-.!0,<*32.,'!%-! k! G!>"@H!.$,!'2.2! &.(0,'! %-!2))(0'2-),!
B%.$!/202<02/$! >"@!+2C!K,!.02-&+%..,'!.(!.$%0'!/20.%,&!%-!2-(-C+%&,'!4(0+!4(0!.$,!
/*0/(&,!(4!2))%',-.!0,&,20)$E!
!
N!
!
!
§(63b((Enabling(Provisions(
!
#$,! X,',023! U%-%&.0C! (4! #02-&/(0.! 2-'! R%<%.23! P-402&.0*).*0,! %&! 2*.$(0%=,'H! %-!
)(-&*3.2.%(-! B%.$! .$,! \(++%&&%(-,0! 4(0! R2.2! ]0(.,).%(-! 2-'! X0,,'(+! (4!
P-4(0+2.%(-H!.(!,-2).!&.2.*.(0C!(0'%-2-),&!4(0!.$,!%+/3,+,-.2.%(-!(4!9,).%(-!NM2!
"E .$,!.,)$-%)23! ',&%<-!2-'! 3()2.%(-!(4! .$,! &.(02<,! +,'%*+! 2-'!.$,! +2--,0!(4!
&.(02<,!%-!2))(0'2-),!B%.$!k!NM2!>"@m!
IE .$,!2''0,&&,,!(4!.$,!&.(02<,!(K3%<2.%(-!2))(0'%-<!.(!k!NM2!>"@H!
ME +,2&*0,&! .(! /0(.,).! .$,! &.(0,'! '2.2! 2<2%-&.! *-2*.$(0%=,'! 2)),&&! B$,-!
&,33%-<!.$,!+(.(0!1,$%)3,E!
!
Y,<23! 0,<*32.%(-&! 2))(0'%-<! .(! &,-.,-),! "! 20,! .(! K,! 4(0B20','! .(! .$,! 5,0+2-!
V*-',&.2<!K,4(0,!/*K3%)2.%(-E!
!
!
!
!
G!
Comments!
!
"@!6,32.%(-&$%/!K,.B,,-!.$,!'%1%-<!2*.(+2.%(-!4*-).%(-!',4%-,'!%-!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!
2-'!3,1,3&!(4!2*.(+2.%(-&!',4%-,'!%-!97L!FMJ"NO9,/!IJ"N!
!
#$,! (0%<%-23! 5,0+2-! .,Q.! (4! .$,! 2+,-'+,-.! 0,4,0&! .(! A$%<$3C! 2*.(+2.,'! '0%1%-<!
4*-).%(-&D!2-'!A4*33C!2*.(+2.,'!'0%1%-<!4*-).%(-&ED!#$,&,!.,0+&!)(00,&/(-'!.(!Y,1,3!
M! 2-'! Y,1,3! b! (4! 97L! FMJ"NO9,/! IJ"NH! 0,&/,).%1,3C! >&,,! #2K3,! "@E! #$,! '%1,0<%-<!
-(+,-)32.*0,!$2&!$%&.(0%)23! 0,2&(-&E! 97L!FMJ"NO9,/!IJ"N! B2&! ',1,3(/,'!K2&,'!(-!
.B(!/0,1%(*&3C!,Q%&.%-<!)32&&%4%)2.%(-&!(4!3,1,3&!(4!2*.(+2.%(-H!(-,!40(+!.$,!g2.%(-23!
n%<$B2C!#0244%)!924,.C!7'+%-%&.02.%(-!>gn#97@!%-!.$,!iE9E!2-'!2-(.$,0!(-,!40(+!.$,!
X,',023! n%<$B2C! 6,&,20)$! P-&.%.*.,! >V*-',&2-&.23.! 4o0! 9.02:,-B,&,-H! 2E;E2E! V79.@!
%-!5,0+2-CE!7&!,Q/32%-,'!%-!9,).%(-!aE^!(4!97L!FMJ"NO9,/!IJ"NH!.$,!97L!#2&;!X(0),!
+,+K,0&!/0,/20%-<!.$,!97L!<*%'2-),!',)%','!.(!K2&,!.$,!97L!.2Q(-(+C!+2%-3C!(-!
.$,! .2Q(-(+C! 40(+! V79.E! #$,! .2&;! 4(0),! %-)3*','! +,+K,0&! (4! .$,! 5,0+2-!
7&&()%2.%(-! (4! .$,! 7*.(+(.%1,! P-'*&.0C! >?,0K2-'! ',0! 7*.(+(K%3%-'*&.0%,H! 2E;E2E!
?R7@H! B$%)$! (0%<%-233C! B(0;,'! B%.$! V79.! (-! .$,! V79.! .2Q(-(+CE! 9,).%(-! aE^! 23&(!
,Q/32%-&!.$2.! .$,!97L! .2Q(-(+C! 2'','!Y,1,3! ^H!B$%)$! B2&! -(.!/0,&,-.! %-!.$,! V79.!
.2Q(-(+CH! 2-'! 0,1%&,'! .$,! -2+,&! (4! Y,1,3&! M! 2-'! b! 2))(0'%-<3CH! 2&! %33*&.02.,'! %-!
#2K3,!"E! !74.,0! .$,! /*K3%)2.%(-! (4! .$,!97L! .2Q(-(+CH!?R7! 2<0,,'!.(! 2''! Y,1,3! ^! .(!
.$,%0! 402+,B(0;H! K*.! ',)%','! .(! ;,,/! .$,! (0%<%-23! .,0+&! 40(+! .$,! V79.! IJ"I!
X02+,B(0;! B$,-! 0,4,00%-<! .(! 3,1,3&! M! 2-'! b! %-! .$,! 5,0+2-! 32-<*2<,E! #$,C! 23&(!
%-.0('*),'!2! 5,0+2-! .02-&32.%(-!4(0! Y,1,3! ^! 2&! AX2$0,03(&D!>L-<3%&$O!AR0%1,03,&&D@E!
P-.,0,&.%-<3CH! 9,).%(-! GE"! %-! 97L! FMJ"NO9,/! IJ"N! '%&)(*02<,&! .$,! *&,! (4! .$,! .,0+!
A'0%1,03,&&D!%-!.$,!L-<3%&$!32-<*2<,m!%-!42).H!2!Y,1,3!b!7R9!)2-!K,!A'0%1,03,&&DH!%-!.$,!
&,-&,! (4! K,%-<! %-&.233,'! %-! 2! 7R9TR,'%)2.,'! ?,$%)3,H! B$%)$! 0,j*%0,&! -,%.$,0!
)(-1,-.%(-23! -(0! 0,+(.,! '0%1,0H! 2-'! +2C! -(.! ,1,-! $21,! ,j*%/+,-.! .(! 0,),%1,!
$*+2-T'0%1,0!%-/*.E! 73&(! -(.,! .$2.! FMJ"N! *&,&! .$,! .,0+! A'0%1%-<!2*.(+2.%(-D! 2&! 2!
<,-,023!.,0+!4(0! 2-C! 2*.(+2.%(-!(4!'0%1%-<! 2.! Y,1,3&!"T^H!2-'!0,&,01,&! A2*.(+2.,'!
'0%1%-<D!.(!Y,1,3&!MT^E!?R7!B2&!(-,!(4!.$,!+2%-!%-43*,-),0&!(-!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!'024.H!
B$%)$!,Q/32%-&!.$,!.,0+%-(3(<C!*&,'!%-!.$,!2+,-'+,-.E!
!
Table(1!!\(00,&/(-',-),!K,.B,,-!97L!FMJ"N!2-'!V79.!-(+,-)32.*0,!(-!.$,!3,1,3&!
(4!'0%1%-<!2*.(+2.%(-!
SAE(J3016:Sep(2016(Nomenclature(
BASt(2012(Framework(Nomenclature(
Y,1,3!^O!X*33!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-!
!
Y,1,3!bO!n%<$!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-!
X*33C!7*.(+2.,'!R0%1%-<!
>A1(332*.(+2.%&%,0.,&!X2$0,-D@!
Y,1,3!MO!\(-'%.%(-23!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-!
n%<$3C!7*.(+2.,'!R0%1%-<!
>A$()$2*.(+2.%&%,0.,&!X2$0,-D@!
Y,1,3!IO!]20.%23!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-!
]20.%233C!7*.(+2.,'!R0%1%-<!
>A.,%32*.(+2.%&%,0.,&!X2$0,-D@!
Y,1,3!"O!R0%1,0!7&&%&.2-),!
R0%1,0!7&&%&.2-),!!>AX2$02&&%&.,-=D@!
Y,1,3!JO!g(!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-!
R0%1,0!(-3C!
!
!
R,&/%.,!.$,!',)3202.%(-!(4!.$,!'0%1%-<!2*.(+2.%(-! 4*-).%(-&! ',4%-,'! %-!&,).%(-&!k"2!
2-'!k"K! (4!.$,! 2+,-'+,-.! 2&! Y,1,3! M! >A$()$2*.(+2.%&%,0.,&! X2$0,-D@!2-'! Y,1,3!b!
>A1(332*.(+2.%&%,0.,&!X2$0,-D@H!.$,!',4%-%.%(-&! %-! .$,&,!&,).%(-&!)(00,&/(-'!.(! (-3C!
!
a!
97L!FMJ"N!Y,1,3!M!\(-'%.%(-23!R0%1%-<!7*.(+2.%(-H!(0!2!Y,1,3!M!7*.(+2.,'!R0%1%-<!
9C&.,+! >7R9@E! #$,! +2%-! /20.&! (4! .$,! 4*-).%(-! ',4%-%.%(-! .$2.! )(00,&/(-'! .(! .$,!
0,j*%0,+,-.&! (4! 2! Y,1,3! M! 7R9! 20,! k"2! >I@! "EH! MEH! bEH! ^E! 2-'! k"K! >"@! 2-'! >I@E!
P-.,0,&.%-<3CH!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!0,4,0&!.(!.$,!4233K2);T0,2'C!*&,0!2&!A'0%1,0D!>k"2!>b@@H!
,1,-!.$(*<$!FMJ"N!0,&,01,&!.$,!.,0+!A'0%1,0D!.(!2!*&,0!B$(!%&!%-!.$,!'0%1,0!&,2.!2-'!
/,04(0+&! .$,! 'C-2+%)! '0%1%-<! .2&;! 4*33C! (0! /20.%233CE! V*.! +(0,! %+/(0.2-.3CH! .$,!
2+,-'+,-.!'(,&! -(.! 0,43,).!.$,!+2%-!0,j*%0,+,-.!(4!2!Y,1,3!b!7R9!%-!&,).%(-&!k"2!
2-'!k"KH!B$%)$!B(*3'!K,!2!4233K2);!/,04(0+2-),!)2/2K%3%.C!KC!.$,!7R9E!P.!&,,+&!.$2.!
2! Y,1,3! b! 7R9! B(*3'! &.%33! K,! /,0+%&&%K3,! (-! 5,0+2-! 0(2'&H! 2&! 3(-<! 2&! .$,! '0%1,0!
0,+2%-&!A0,),/.%1,D!.(!.2;,!(1,0!0,j*,&.!40(+!.$,!7R9!>k"K@H!,1,-!.$(*<$!2-!2).*23!
Y,1,3!b!&C&.,+!B(*3'!-(.!0,j*%0,!2!4233K2);T0,2'C!*&,0H!B$(!B(*3'!0,&/(-'!.(!&*)$!
0,j*,&.&E!
!
P-.,0,&.%-<3CH!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!&/,)%4%,&!.B(!2''%.%(-23!0,j*%0,+,-.&O!
• k"2! >"@! IE! 0,j*%0,&! .$2.! 2-! 7R9! )(+/3%,&! B%.$! .$,! 2//3%)2K3,! .0244%)! 32B&m!
/0,&*+2K3CH!.$,!.0244%)!32B&! B0%..,-! 4(0! $*+2-! '0%1,0&!2//3C!1,0K2.%+!.(!2-!
7R9m!2-'!
• k"2! >"@! NE! 0,j*%0,&! .$2.! .$,! 7R9! -(.%4%,&! .$,! *&,0! (4! 7R9! +%&*&,m! .$%&!
0,j*%0,+,-.!%&!%+/(0.2-.!<%1,-!.$,!/(.,-.%23!)(+/3,Q%.%,&!(4!&*)$!2!&C&.,+E!
!
#$,! 2+,-'+,-.H! %-! kN! >"@! "b2H! 23&(! &.%/*32.,&! 2! &,/202.,! '0%1%-<! 2*.(+2.%(-!
4*-).%(-!4(0!/20;%-<!%-!)(-.0(33,'!2)),&&!/20;%-<!&/2),&E!P.!',&)0%K,&!.$,!4*-).%(-!2&!
2! A'0%1,03,&&! /20;%-<! &C&.,+DE! 9%-),! .$,! 4*-).%(-! %&! '0%1,03,&&H! .$,-! 2))(0'%-<! .(!
FMJ"N!%.! %&! -(.! 2! Y,1,3!M! 4*-).%(-! K*.!2! Y,1,3! b! 4*-).%(-H! B$%)$!0,j*%0,&! 2! 4233K2);!
/,04(0+2-),!)2/2K%3%.C!KC! .$,!7R9E!9*)$! 4233K2);!/,04(0+2-),!%&! -(.! +,-.%(-,'!%-!
.$,!2+,-'+,-.H!$(B,1,0E! P.!2//,20&!.$2.! .$%&! 4*-).%(-!B%33!-,,'! .(!KC!)320%4%,'! 4(0!
'0%1,03,&&! /20;%-<! %-! 2''%.%(-23! 0,<*32.%(-&H! /,0$2/&! *-',0! .$,! /0(1%&%(-&! (4! kN!
>b2@E!
!
I@!\320%4%)2.%(-!(-!3%2K%3%.C!B$,-!.$,!1,$%)3,!%&!(/,02.,'!KC!2-!7R9!
!
#$,! ,Q%&.%-<! /0(1%&%(-&! (4! .$,! 2).! /0%(0! .(! .$,! 2+,-'+,-.H! %-! /20.%)*320! k! GH!
',.,0+%-,! .$,! 3%2K%3%.C! 4(0! %-d*0%,&! 2-'! '2+2<,&! 40(+! )02&$,&! )2*&,'! KC! 2!
+234*-).%(-%-<!7R9!B$,-!%.!(/,02.,&!2!1,$%)3,E!#$2.!%&H!.$,!3%2K%3%.C!0,&%',&!B%.$!.$,!
1,$%)3,!(B-,0E!
!
#$,!K%33!/0(/(&%-<!.$,!2+,-'+,-.!)(++,-.&!(-!.$,!)(-&,j*,-),&!(4!.$%&!2//0(2)$!
>/E!"N@O!
!
A#$,!*&,!(4!.$,!1,$%)3,!(B-,0!KC!B2C!(4!&.0%).!3%2K%3%.C!B%33!0,&*3.!%-!.$,!3%2K%3%.C!
%-&*0,0!(4!.$,!1,$%)3,!(B-,0!2-'!.$,!+2-*42).*0,0[&! %-&*0,0! )320%4C%-<! 2+(-<!
.$,+&,31,&!B$(!+*&.!K,20!.$,!)(&.&!(4!.$,!2))%',-.!2&!2!0,&*3.ED!
!
#$,!K%33!%&!212%32K3,!40(+!.$,!V*-',&.2<[&!B,K&%.,E!
!
Acknowledgment:! P! B(*3'! 3%;,! .(! .$2-;! V20K202! f,-'3%-<H! .$,! \$2%0! (4! .$,! 97L!
#2&;! X(0),! 0,&/(-&%K3,! 4(0! FMJ"NH! 4(0! $,0! )(++,-.&! (-! 2-! ,203%,0! '024.! 2-'H! %-!
/20.%)*320H! 4(0! +2;%-<! +,! 2B20,! (4! .$,! $%&.(0%)23! 0,2&(-&! 4(0! .$,! .,0+%-(3(<%)23!
'%&)0,/2-)%,&! K,.B,,-! .$,! L-<3%&$! 2-'! 5,0+2-! -(+,-)32.*0,E! P! 23&(! .$2-;! 9,2-!
9,'B20'&!2-'!9.,1,-!f2&32-',0!4(0!.$,%0!,'%.(0%23!&*<<,&.%(-&E!
... Musí sa neustále učiť, pretože nábytok, predmety a domáce zvieratá menia prostredie, v ktorom poS sobí. 9 Autonómne systémy nemožno stotožňovať len s algoritmom (softvérom). 10 Autonómne systémy nie sú naprogramované len k výkonu určitých činností, ale aj k tomu, aby sa určité činnosti naučili vykonávať sami. ...
... Ako uvádza Polčák, autonómne vozidlá nemožno z pohľadu práva prirovnávať ku klasickým automobilom, a to najmä s ohľadom na skutočnosť, že autonómne vozidlá sa riadia sami. 9 Tamže. 10 Z právneho pohľadu možno softvér (počítačový program) chápať ako súbor príkazov a inštrukcií vyjadrených v akejkoľvek forme použitých priamo alebo nepriamo v počítači alebo v podobnom technickom zariadení a zároveň musí byť výsledkom tvorivej duševnej činnosti autora. ...
Čo vieš o mojom vozidle? Ochrana osobných údajov a kybernetická bezpečnosť v kontexte autonómnych vozidiel
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2020
Autori sa v článku zameriavajú na vybrané otázky toku údajov v kontexte autonómnych vozidiel. V prvých častiach príspevku sú postupne predstavené základné pojmy danej problematiky a načrtnutá právna úprava. Následne sú charakterizované prieniky s právnou úpravou kybernetickej bezpečnosti a ochrany osobných údajov. Osobitný dôraz je kladený na otázku osobnej pôsobnosti a súvisiacej zodpovednosti v oblasti ochrany osobných údajov medzi jednotlivými aktérmi spracúvania osobných údajov v autonómnom vozidle.
View
... Regulation can also introduce technical challenges for insurers and Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) of embedded telematic devices. Data transmission to authorities or third parties will be required in the event of a crash, offence, or loss of vehicle (stolen) [1,58]. Data relating to the event will need to be protected and encrypted before transmission occurs. ...
Regulatory and Technical Constraints: An Overview of the Technical Possibilities and Regulatory Limitations of Vehicle Telematic Data
Article
Full-text available
A telematics device is a vehicle instrument that comes preinstalled by the vehicle manufacturer or can be added later. The device records information about driving behavior, including speed, acceleration, and turning force. When connected to vehicle computers, the device can also provide additional information regarding the mechanical usage and condition of the vehicle. All of this information can be transmitted to a central database via mobile networks. The information provided has led to new services such as Usage Based Insurance (UBI). A range of consultants, industry commentators and academics have produced an abundance of projections on how telematics information will allow the introduction of services from personalized insurance, bespoke entertainment and advertise and vehicle energy optimization, particularly for Electric Vehicles (EVs). In this paper we examine these potential services against a backdrop of nascent regulatory limitations and against the technical capacity of the devices. Using a case study approach, we examine three applications that can use telematics information. We find that the expectations of service providers will be significantly tempered by regulatory and technical hurdles. In our discussion we detail these limitations and suggest a more realistic rollout of ancillary services.
View
... Further, in the considered target scenario of substituting the human driver with an ADS for some of the vehicles in traffic, the ADS-operated vehicles are expected to follow the same traffic rules as human drivers. This approach, which has been codified by law in some countries, such as in Germany [GA17], allows human drivers to predict the behavior of ADS-operated vehicles to the extent that they are familiar with the traffic rules. Special traffic rules for ADS-operated vehicles are likely to be introduced in future. ...
On-Road Safety of Automated Driving System (ADS) - Taxonomy and Safety Analysis Methods
Technical Report
Full-text available
  • Jul 2018
This document provides a taxonomy of on-road safety of an Automated Driving System (ADS) and describes safety analysis methods applicable at requirements and early design stage of ADS development. In particular, it covers Driving Behavior Safety Assurance, Safety of The Intended Functionality (SOTIF) Assurance, and the Hazard Analysis and Risk Assessment (HARA) part of Functional Safety, and relates the three methods to System-Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA).
View
Data Protection in the Field of Automated and Connected Vehicles
Conference Paper
  • Sep 2024
Connected and automated vehicles rely on a set of sensors and cameras as well as on connectivity to function properly and safely. On the other hand, these technologies gather large amounts of personal data. The present article analyzes the legal issues related to processing of such data, its vulnerability to cyberattacks, and the access of regulatory and law enforcement bodies to the data. A brief study of the current legislation is offered and conclusions and proposals on the regulation are made.
View
The digital development of the European Union: data governance aspects of cooperative, connected and automated mobility
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2021
This article focuses on the issue of data governance in connected vehicles. Firstly, basic notions of autonomous vehicles are analyzed, and a legal framework is introduced. The European Union aims to create cooperative, connected, and automated mobility based on the cooperation of different inter connected types of machinery. The essence of the system is data flow in connected vehicles, and the issue represents one of the heavily discussed themes in legal doctrine. Therefore, data governance is further discussed in the article. The final part of the article deals with the issue of responsibility and liability of different actors involved in the processing of personal data according to the General Data Protection Regulation applied to the environment of CAV smart infrastructure.
View
Sustainable Data Governance for Cooperative, Connected and Automated Mobility in the European Union
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2021
The article focuses on the issue of data governance in connected vehicles through a novel analysis of current legal frameworks in the European Union. The analysis of relevant legislation, judicial decisions, and doctrines is supplemented by discussions relating to associated sustainability issues. Relevant notions of autonomous vehicles are analyzed, and a respective legal framework is introduced. Although fully automated vehicles are a matter for the future, the time to regulate is now. The European Union aims to create cooperative, connected, and automated mobility based on cooperation between different interconnected types of machinery. The essence of the system is data flow, as data governance in connected vehicles is one of the most intensively discussed themes nowadays. This triggers a need to analyze relevant legal frameworks in connection with fundamental rights and freedoms. Replacing human decision-making with artificial intelligence has the capacity to erode long-held and protected social and cultural values, such as the autonomy of individuals as has already been in evidence in legislation. Finally, the article deals with the issue of responsibility and liability of different actors involved in processing personal data according to the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applied to the environment of connected and automated vehicle (CAV) smart infrastructure. Based on a definition and analysis of three model situations, we point out that in several cases of processing personal data within the CAV, it proves extremely demanding to determine the liable entity, due to the functional and relatively broad interpretation of the concept of joint controllers, in terms of the possibility of converging decisions on the purposes and means of processing within the vehicles discussed.
View
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.