ArticlePDF Available

Authors:
Article

A Large-Scale Emulation System for Realistic Three-Dimensional (3-D) Forest Simulation

Abstract and Figures

The realistic reconstruction and radiometric simulation of a large-scale three-dimensional (3-D) forest scene have potential applications in remote sensing. Although many 3-D radiative transfer models concerning forest canopy have been developed, they mainly focused on homogeneous or relatively small heterogeneous scenes, which are not compatible with the coarse-resolution remote sensing observations. Due to the huge complexity of forests and the inefficiency of collecting precise 3-D data of large areas, realistic simulation over large-scale forest area remains challenging, especially in regions of complex terrain. In this study, a large-scale emulation system for realistic 3-D forest Simulation is proposed. The 3-D forest scene is constructed from a representative single tree database (SDB) and airborne laser scanning (ALS) data. ALS data are used to extract tree height, crown diameter and position, which are linked to the individual trees in SDB. To simulate the radiometric properties of the reconstructed scene, a radiative transfer model based on a parallelized ray-tracing code was developed. This model has been validated with an abstract and an actual 3-D scene from the radiation transfer model intercomparison website and it showed comparable results with other models. Finally, a 1 km $\times$ 1 km scene with more than 100 000 realistic individual trees was reconstructed and a Landsat-like reflectance image was simulated, which kept the same spatial pattern as the actual Landsat 8 image.
Content may be subject to copyright.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING 1
A Large-Scale Emulation System for Realistic
Three-Dimensional (3-D) Forest Simulation
Jianbo Qi, Donghui Xie, Dashuai Guo, and Guangjian Yan
Abstract—The realistic reconstruction and radiometric simula-
tion of a large-scale three-dimensional (3-D) forest scene have po-
tential applications in remote sensing. Although many 3-D radia-
tive transfer models concerning forest canopy have been developed,
they mainly focused on homogeneous or relatively small heteroge-
neous scenes, which are not compatible with the coarse-resolution
remote sensing observations. Due to the huge complexity of forests
and the inefﬁciency of collecting precise 3-D data of large areas, re-
alistic simulation over large-scale forest area remains challenging,
especially in regions of complex terrain. In this study, a large-scale
emulation system for realistic 3-D forest Simulation is proposed.
The 3-D forest scene is constructed from a representative single tree
database (SDB) and airborne laser scanning (ALS) data. ALS data
are used to extract tree height, crown diameter and position, which
are linked to the individual trees in SDB. To simulate the radio-
metric properties of the reconstructed scene, a radiative transfer
model based on a parallelized ray-tracing code was developed. This
model has been validated with an abstract and an actual 3-D scene
from the radiation transfer model intercomparison website and it
showed comparable results with other models. Finally, a 1 km ×
1 km scene with more than 100 000 realistic individual trees was
reconstructed and a Landsat-like reﬂectance image was simulated,
which kept the same spatial pattern as the actual Landsat 8 image.
Index Terms—Airborne laser scanning (ALS), three-dimen-
sional (3-D) forest reconstruction, 3-D simulation, forest.
I. INTRODUCTION
FORESTS cover approximately 31%of the land surface
across the globe and play a prominent role in the global car-
bon cycle [1]. Forests are highly complex and dynamic ecosys-
tems that comprise various species and a large number of in-
dividual trees. They are important and also widely managed
for biodiversity protection, wildlife habitat conservation, forest
products, and recreation [2]. Modeling the forest [3], [4] is an es-
sential step to assist management decisions [5]. However, most
of these models, such as the whole-stand model [6], rely on ab-
stract, conceptual, and two-dimensional (2-D) representations
of the forest canopy, which are rarely presented in a coherent
Manuscript received November 20, 2016; revised March 5, 2017 and May
2, 2017; accepted June 2, 2017. This work was supported by the National
Natural Science Foundation of China programs under Grant 41331171 and
Grant 41571341 and the National Basic Research Program of China under
Grant 2013CB733402. (Corresponding author: Donghui Xie.)
The authors are with the College of Remote Science and Engineering, Faculty
of Geographical Science, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China
(e-mail: qijb@mail.bnu.edu.cn; xiedonghui@bnu.edu.cn; 1130219602@qq.
com; gjyan@bnu.edu.cn).
Color versions of one or more of the ﬁgures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identiﬁer 10.1109/JSTARS.2017.2714423
and stimulating manner, and also complicate the translation of
this information into landscape images [7]. Consequently, new
powerful tools, such as precise 3-D landscape and forest models,
are required to model precise landscapes and environments [8].
In the remote sensing community, various methods have been
developed to extract forest parameters from remotely sensed
data [9]. However, most of these methods based on direct ﬁeld
measurements are not completely and comprehensively vali-
dated due to the complexity of forest canopies and inhomo-
geneity of land surfaces [10], [11]. Thus, simulated datasets
resulting from radiative transfer models are widely used to vali-
date and analyze retrieval methods, and this simulation enables
us to precisely control the composition and spatial arrange-
ment of stand structures. It can help to understand the physical
process of interactions between the incoming solar radiation
and plants within the canopy, and it is also used to study
the radiative properties (scattering, absorption, and emission,
etc.) of speciﬁc land cover types [12] or to develop parametric
models [13].
To fully describe the scattering of radiation by vegetation
canopies, a number of 3-D radiative transfer models have been
developed [14], such as DART [15], [16] (discrete-ordinate ray
tracing), FLIGHT [17] (Monte Carlo ray tracing), and RGM
[18] (radiosity). All of them have been successfully applied to
the study of canopy properties. In [11], the DART model was
parameterized using airborne laser scanning (ALS) data and in
situ measurements to simulate the at-sensor spectral radiances,
and the results were compared with measurements of Airborne
Prism Experiment (APEX) [19]. In [20], a radiosity model, Ra-
diosity Applicable to Porous IndiviDual objects (RAPID), was
introduced for 3-D radiative transfer simulation over large-scale
heterogeneous areas. This method parameterized the single tree
crown into porous individual objects to achieve a better balance
between computing efﬁciency and accuracy. In order to obtain
the explicitly described 3-D structures of forest canopy, which
are the input for most 3-D models, individual tree architecture
(from leaf to crown), tree position, and tree species in a forest
area need to be predetermined.
A persistent and signiﬁcant challenge in 3-D models is always
about precisely reconstructing the complex forest, which usually
contains plenty of trees, and each individual tree is constructed
with millions of leaves and branches. Thus, it is impractical to
directly reconstruct the structures of all the trees and branches.
Fortunately, a number of site- and species-speciﬁc allometric
equations which connect biomass and leaf area (LA) to diame-
ter at breast height (DBH) or tree height have been established
1939-1404 © 2017 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
2 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
[21], [22]. These equations enable us to populate the leaf area
index (LAI) measured at plot scale to each individual tree with
the aid of ﬁeld-inventory data (DBH, crown diameter and tree
height). With these parameters available, we can generate a se-
ries of individual tree models that have different DBHs by some
well-developed tree modeling packages [23]–[25]. For the tree
positions, they can be manually measured using a global po-
sition system (GPS). However, it is labor-intensive and time
consuming, notably impossible in large and dangerous areas.
Recently, airborne laser scanning (ALS) has been widely used
to study the structure of forests [26], [27]. It provides a promis-
ing alternative to acquire large-scale 3-D structure and spatial
distribution data of individual trees in a relatively short time.
In this paper, we presented a so-called large-scale emulation
system (LESS) for realistic 3-D forest simulation which can
rapidly generate virtual forest with explicitly described individ-
ual tree models. In addition, a radiative transfer model based on a
parallelized ray-tracing code was developed and validated. This
system can simulate visible images, multispectral images, and
bidirectional reﬂectance factor (BRF) for different research pur-
poses. The entire simulation process is mostly automatic with
only a few parameters to be set by the user, and this signiﬁcantly
speeds up the emulation process.
II. MATERIAL
A. Study Area
The study area is located in the Genhe Forestry Reserve
(Genhe) (12012to 12255E, 5020to 5230N), Greater
Khingan of Inner Mongolia, Northeastern China. It has a hilly
terrain with 75%forest cover, which is mainly composed of
Dahurian Larch (Larix gmelinii) and White Birch (Betula platy-
phylla Suk.). Nine forest plots (labeled as L1 L9) with the
area of 45 m ×45 m were established with their locations shown
in Fig. 1.
The leaf area index (LAI) of each plot was measured with a
TRAC (Tracing Radiation and Architecture of Canopies) instru-
ment (Third Wave Engineering, ON, Canada) in August 2013.
For each plot, the positions of four corners were measured by
a differential global positioning system (DGPS) device. Each
plot was divided into 3 ×3 subplots. In these subplots, the tree
height, tree position, crown diameter, and DBH were manually
measured. The position of each individual tree was obtained by
measuring the relative distances to the plot corners. Field data
are shown in Table I.
B. Spectral Data
The spectral reﬂectance and transmittance of white birch
leaves were measured by a ﬁeld spectroradiometer (ASD Field-
Spec 3, Analytical Spectral Devices, USA) equipped with an in-
tegrating sphere in August 2013. Some of the white birch leaves
became yellow, so both green and yellow leaves were selected
for our measurements. The barks of white birch and larch were
also collected and their reﬂectance spectra were obtained. The
reﬂectance and transmittance spectra of needles were simulated
by LIBERTY [28] and the parameters used in LIBERTY were
Fig. 1. Locations of forest plots and the DEM of the Genhe Forestry Reserve.
TAB L E I
PLOTS IN THE STUDY AREA
Plot Birch
(number)
Larch
(number)
Mean height
(m)
Mean DBH
(cm)
LAI
L1 131 220 8.4 9.9 2.52
L2 111 467 9.1 8.8 3.06
L3 11 71 7.9 7.7 2.57
L4 294 79 11.7 11.5 4.51
L5 1 327 12.7 12.9 2.96
L6 0 173 17.3 22.3 2.3
L7 18 112 10.2 13.1 1.49
L8 63 118 13.3 15.6 2.44
L9 1 585 8.4 8.7 3.16
Fig. 2. Optical properties of the larch, soil background (left) and white birch
(right).
adopted from [29], which were retrieved based on the measured
reﬂectance of larch needles in the Great Xingan Mountain,
Inner Mongolia, very near to our study area. All the spectral
data were resampled from 400 to 1000 nm with a step of 1 nm
(see Fig. 2).
The canopy background (the underlying soil) reﬂectance was
obtained by comparing the measurements of the ground with
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
QI et al.: LARGE-SCALE EMULATION SYSTEM FOR REALISTIC THREE-DIMENSIONAL (3-D) FOREST SIMULATION 3
Fig. 3. Overview of the simulation system.
measurements of an ideal and diffuse standard surface in the
same observation geometry with an ASD FieldSpec instrument.
To obtain representative spectra of the ground, we averaged
50 ASD measurements that were uniformly distributed in the
plot. The type of ground was bare earth.
C. ALS and CCD Data
Data acquisition ﬂights with an onboard LIDAR (Leica
ALS60, Leica Geosystem AG, Heerbrugg, Switzerland) and
a charge-coupled device (CCD-Leica RCD105, Leica Geosys-
tem AG, Heerbrugg, Switzerland) were performed from Au-
gust to September 2012 above the Genhe study Area, covering
approximately 230 km2. The ﬂight height was about 1.8 km
above ground level. This measurement used a rotation scanning
system with an angle range of ±30. The wavelength of the air-
borne laser sensor was 1064 nm, and the laser beam divergence
was 0.3 mrad. The vertical accuracy of the acquired ALS data
was within 0.15 m. This LIDAR+CCD mission acquired point
cloud data with an average density of 8.0 points/m2and CCD
image with 0.5 m spatial resolution.
III. METHOD
The proposed system (LESS) mainly consists of four main
modules (see Fig. 3):
1) individual tree generation;
2) individual tree detection;
3) virtual forest scene generation;
A. 3-D Scene Reconstruction
1) Individual Tree Generation: It is usually difﬁcult to pre-
cisely reconstruct each individual tree in a forest, especially for
larch, which has very small needle-like leaves. In this study, 3-D
structures of individual tree were generated from the OnyxTREE
software (www.onyxtree.com). This software can generate re-
alistic 3-D trees from a variety of parameters which deﬁne the
Fig. 4. Generated trees: (a) white birch tree; (b) larch tree.
architectures of the tree. Since DBH is an important parame-
ter which is usually related to other parameters, 20 birch and
20 larch trees with different DBHs were generated. To match
them to the real trees in this study area, the tree height, tree
crown diameter, and under branch height were obtained from
ﬁeld measurements. Among all the parameters, the LA of an
individual tree was the most difﬁcult parameter to be retrieved.
To get the LA, we used allometric-based method to populate the
plot LAI to individual tree LA as presented in [30]. For com-
pleteness, we summarized the main idea of this method here.
The relationship between DBH and LA can be expressed as:
where aand bare parameters which need to be determined for
different species. For a forest plot, the LA of the whole plot is
the sum of all the individual trees. Thus,
Splot ·LAI =
N
i
LAi=a
N
i
DBHib(2)
where Splot is the area of the plot. LAiis the LA of individual
tree. Nis total number of trees in the plot. Using plot L5 and
L9, aand bof white birch were estimated as 0.746 and 1.235,
respectively. The parameters of larch were a=0.06 and b=2.36
(using plot L1 and L4). It should be noted that L1 and L4
were mixed plots with white birches and larches, the LA of
white birches in these plots were calculated by the relationship
established by L5 and L9. Some representatives of the generated
trees for the SDB are shown in Fig. 4.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
4 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
Fig. 5. Generated 3-D forest, which is a part of a 1 km ×1 km forest scene
with more than 100 000 instanced trees from SDB.
2) Individual Tree Detection: Individual trees were ex-
tracted from the canopy height model (CHM) by a watershed
algorithm, which was also presented in [30]. The CHM used in
this study was obtained by subtracting a digital elevation model
(DEM) from a digital surface model (DSM). The DSM was
directly derived from ALS ﬁrst returns, while the DEM was ex-
tracted by using an easy-to-use airborne lidar ﬁltering algorithm
[31], which was based on cloth simulation. The ﬁnal resolution
of the CHM map was 0.5 m. As no multispectral data were
collected in this area, the CCD image was used to distinguish
tree species. This image was obtained in September 2012 when
the leaves of white birch became slightly yellow while larch re-
mained green. We used a statistical histogram of CIELAB color
to separate birch from larch [30].
3) 3-D Forest Generation: 3-D forest scene of this study
area was generated by choosing a proper individual tree model
from SDB, and placing it on the DEM map according to the
detected parameters of individual trees from the CHM. Thus,
a similarity factor (SF) was deﬁned to describe the selection
criteria:
SF =w|HdHm|
Hm
+(1w)|CdCm|
Cm
(3)
where Hd(Cd) is the tree height (crown diameter) of a de-
tected tree from CHM map. Hm(Cm) is the tree height (crown
diameter) of a model from SDB, wis a weight parameter that
lies between [0,1]. By default, it is set to 0.5. To generate forest,
the model with the smallest SF is selected. As the number of
individual trees in SDB is limited, a tree model may be used
multiple times. Thus, an ”instance” mechanism is adopted. If
a tree model has already been selected before the current se-
lection, an instance or reference of that model is created. This
mechanism can reduce the memory usage, especially when there
are millions of individual trees. Fig. 5 shows a generated 3-D
virtual forest, which contains more than 100 000 trees.
Fig. 6. Path tracing algorithm.
B. Reﬂectance Image Simulation
1) Simulation Fundamentals: The simulation system in this
study uses physically based ray-tracing as the basis to calculate
the radiances at the top of canopy (TOC). Rays are traced from
the virtual sensor into the virtual scene, and the intersections
between rays and objects in the scene are tested. The rays are
deﬁned to be launched in parallel within a ﬁeld of view (ortho-
graphic projection) that covers the whole scene. At each inter-
section point, the bidirectional reﬂectance distribution function
(BRDF) is used to determine the incoming direction of the ray
that is reﬂected toward the sensor. By this way, the contributions
and attenuations along the tracing path are summed to calculate
the radiance that light sources scatter into the sensor. For an
arbitrary point pin the scene, the reﬂected outgoing radiance
along direction ωocan be expressed as [32],
Lo(p, ωo)=2π
fr(p, ωi
o)Li(p, ωi)|cos θi|i(4)
where Lo(p, ωo)is the outgoing radiance along direction ωoat
point p,fr(p, ωi
o)is BRDF, Li(p, ωi)is the incident radiance
from direction ωi, it includes both direct illumination as well
as indirect illumination (i.e., multiple scattering). Usually, ωiis
considered as a differential solid angle. θiis the angle between
the incident radiance direction ωiand surface normal at point
p. The integration is applied to the upper hemisphere space at
point p. If transmittance exists, fr(p, ωi
o)is simply replaced
by a bidirectional transmittance distribution function (BTDF)
ft(p, ωi
o), then the incident direction ωiand ωowill be in the
different hemispheres. For convenience, BRDF and BTDF can
be combined together as f(p, ωi
o), which is called bidirec-
tional scattering distribution function (BSDF). Then, the equa-
tion which considers both reﬂectance and transmittance will be
(5), the integration is now applied to the 4πspace at point p.
Lo(p, ωo)=4π
f(p, ωi
o)Li(p, ωi)|cosθi|i.(5)
This equation is solved by a path tracing algorithm [32],
which is illustrated in Fig. 6. Assuming a ray is traced from the
sensor and the ﬁrst intersection point is p. At point p, the direct
can be calculated with the BSDF of point p, this is called ﬁrst
scattering. To calculate outgoing radiance induced by multiple
scattering, a new ray originated at pis traced, the direction is
determined by the BSDF of point p. If this new ray intersects
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
QI et al.: LARGE-SCALE EMULATION SYSTEM FOR REALISTIC THREE-DIMENSIONAL (3-D) FOREST SIMULATION 5
with the scene (e.g., leaves and branches) at point p1, we execute
the same operation as at point p(evaluate sun radiation and
multiple scattering), the outgoing radiation of p1is the incident
radiation of p. This process is recursively performed until it
reaches the maximum scattering order speciﬁed by the user or
when the contribution of multiple scattering is below a small
threshold. Through this way, a path between sun and sensor can
be found, which determines the amount of radiation scattered
from sun to sensor. For each pixel, many sensor rays are traced
to get an average value. It should be noted that although the
image is simulated pixel by pixel, the neighbor objects are still
considered, because the rays are allowed to traverse through the
whole scene. To implement this simulation system, a ray tracer,
named Mitsuba [33], was modiﬁed to calculate the TOC spectral
Compared to forward tracking methods (tracing rays from sun
to sensor), this backward tracking method has a few advantages
when simulating at-sensor images: 1) it only needs to calculate
the radiation which exactly goes to the sensor, avoiding a lot of
useless computations for radiation which goes out of the scene;
2) The number of rays of each pixel is conﬁgurable, which
means that a low value (e.g., rays =2) can make the simulation
very fast with a relatively low quality. However, this mechanism
makes it possible to have a quick preview of the result to check
the correctness of parameter conﬁgurations, especially when
simulating large areas. In addition, the proposed system can
run on high-performance computing clusters with hundreds of
processing cores. This scalability also enables LESS to simulate
much larger scenes (e.g., >5km).
2) Model Intercomparison: Before applying this system to
realistic forest simulation, we ﬁrst tested it with some exist-
ing models from RAMI [34], which proposes a mechanism
to benchmark various radiative transfer models by using some
well-controlled experimental conditions. A homogeneous ab-
stract canopy with two layers (HOM28 in RAMI-IV) and a
heterogeneous actual canopy (HET07_JPS_SUM in RAMI-IV)
were chosen as the testing scenes. The detailed optical and struc-
tural properties can be found at [35].
The leaf shape is deﬁned as a disk in HOM28, we converted
it into a rectangle with the same LA, and each leaf was then
represented by two triangles only. For HET07_JPS_SUM, the
needle shape of J¨
arvselja Scots Pine is described by a scaled
sphere. In our simulation, this scaled sphere is represented as
a hexagonal prism, which keeps the same total area and needle
length with RAMI deﬁnitions. LESS treats leaves and breaches
as facet, which do not have thickness, so it is impossible to
input transmittance of needle directly, because needles are usu-
ally like cylinders. To maximumly imitate the behavior of needle
transmittance, we set outside reﬂectance of facets (ρout) equal to
ρneedle, which is given by RAMI (see Fig. 7). For transmittance,
both sides of the facet are set to τneedle, and the inside re-
ﬂectance (ρin) is 0, so there will be no multiple scattering within
the needle, then the total transmittance (τtotal) is exactly τneedle ,
which is the transmittance of a needle.
To compare with RAMI, BRF in principal plane from the
scene of HOM28 was simulated in RED and near infrared (NIR)
bands, and the scene of HET07_JPS_SUM was simulated with
Fig. 7. Structural and optical properties of needle and shoot.
Fig. 8. Comparison between measured LAI and predicted LAI.
19 bands. The observation zenith angles range from 1to 75
withastepof2
. The BRF was ﬁnally compared with results
3) Realistic Forest Simulation: A large plot (LPLOT) with
1km×1 km (red rectangle in Fig. 1) in our study area was
reconstructed. It contains 152 848 larch trees and 9433 birch
trees. The terrain of LPLOT has a minimum elevation of 857
m, and a maximum elevation of 958 m. Each component (i.e.,
leaf, truck, and soil background) was assigned with different
optical property that was obtained in the ﬁeld measurements,
and all facets in this scene were assumed to be Lambertian.
Based on this virtual scene, a Landsat-like reﬂectance image
was simulated in RED (from 625 to 690 nm), and NIR (from
830 to 901 nm) bands with 1 nm spectral resolution and 30
m spatial resolution. The sun direction was calculated by the
overpass time of Landsat 8 and geographical location of the
study area. The ﬁnal image was simulated under nadir direction
with an orthographic camera. The spectral response function
of Landsat 8 was then applied to the multispectral images to
get broadband images in RED and NIR. Finally, the normal-
ized difference vegetation index (NDVI) was calculated. The
land surface reﬂectance of Landsat 8 was obtained by the Fast
Line-of-sight Atmospheric Analysis of Hypercubes (FLAASH)
atmospheric correction model in ENVI 5.1. Since our study area
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
6 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
Fig. 9. Comparison with RAMI for an abstract two layers case: (a) NIR BRF. (b) RED BRF. (The ﬁgures of other models are originally from RAMI website.)
Fig. 10. Comparison with RAMI for a heterogeneous case, two bands were chosen from the simulation results: (a) band9 with a needle reﬂectance around 0.056.
(b) band17 with a needle reﬂectance around 0.52. (The ﬁgures of other models are originally from RAMI website.)
was covered by clouds during the whole summer of 2013. The
date of Landsat 8 data used in our study is May 24, 2014.
IV. RESULTS
A. Allometric Relationship
Allometric relationships between DBH and LA for larch and
white birch were established by using ﬁeld inventory data of L1,
L4, L5, and L9. We then used these relationships to predict the
LAI of other plots. We found that L3 and L8 had similar LAI,
DBH distribution, and tree height distribution, but the number
of individual trees in L3 (82) was much lower than that in
L8 (181). Therefore, we inferred that the ﬁeld measurement of
L3 was incorrect, and excluded it from the following analysis.
Fig. 8 shows the comparison between predicted LAI and ﬁeld-
measured LAI for L2, L6, L7, and L8. The root-mean-square
error (RSME) between the predicted LAI and measured LAI is
0.42.
B. Model Intercomparison
The ray-tracing-based radiative transfer simulation was vali-
dated with other models on the RAMI website. Fig. 9 presents
the results of HOM28. It shows a relatively accurate result for
both NIR and RED BRF, since it is inconsistent with most of
the existing models. Fig. 10 shows the principal BRF of the
heterogeneous actual canopy. It can be observed that the dif-
ferences between different models are relatively large. Among
them, our model is at the middle position. BRF near hotspot of
our model is in good agreement with several other 3-D mod-
els, such as librat. However, the inconsistence also can be seen
when the zenith angles are larger than 20. Our BRF has a
more obvious bowl shape than other models. Although similar
ray-tracing theory has been used in other simulation models
(i.e., pbrt), the representations of 3-D scene are different. RAMI
provides a standard description of the a 3-D scene, but some
models still have simpliﬁcations due to the complex structure of
canopy, especially for the representations of needles and shoots.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
QI et al.: LARGE-SCALE EMULATION SYSTEM FOR REALISTIC THREE-DIMENSIONAL (3-D) FOREST SIMULATION 7
Fig. 11. Comparison between CCD image and generated visible image: (a) CCD image; (b) generated image.
Fig. 12. Comparison between NDVIL8and NDVIS: (a) NDVIL8; (b) NDVIS; (c) Horizontal proﬁle 1 (P1_L8 and P1_LESS); (d) Horizontal proﬁle 2 (P2_L8
and P2_LESS).
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
8 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
Fig. 13. Difference between simulated NDVI and Landsat 8 NDVI: (a) NDVI
difference distribution. (b) Histogram of NDVI difference.
These simpliﬁcations can result in inconsistencies between dif-
ferent models.
C. Image Simulation
Fig. 11 shows the computer-generated image of LPLOT.
Compared with the CCD image, the main distribution of in-
dividual trees in this plot is consistent with the real world, as
seen in the CCD image, especially for the isolated trees which
are easier to be segmented from CHM map. In the subplot (red
rectangle), the shadow of trees is also comparable with the CCD
image. In this virtual scene, there is a small valley around the
green rectangle in Fig. 11. The shadow produced by this valley
is well preserved. However, the classiﬁcation of tree species is
not very accurate, because no multispectral data were available,
and the quality of CCD image is relatively low.
D. Spectral Simulation
Landsat-like land surface reﬂectance images in NIR and
RED were simulated by LESS, and NDVI from simulation
data (NDVIS) were calculated and compared with the observed
Landsat 8 NDVI (NDVIL8) (see Fig. 12). Overall, the distribu-
tion pattern of NDVISis similar to NDVIL8, both of them show
a relatively high value in areas with dense vegetation. Two hori-
zontal proﬁles across different places of the image were chosen
and illustrated in Fig. 12(c) and (d). It can be seen that the trends
are quite consistent. Fig. 13 illustrates the distribution of the dif-
ference between NDVISand NDVIL8. The mean value is 0.17
with a standard deviation of 0.08. The distribution of the differ-
ence showed that NDVISwas slightly larger than NDVIL8.A
possible reason is that most of the predicted LAIs based on the
allometric relationship in this study area are also overestimated
(see Fig. 8), which would result in a larger NDVIS.Themain
differences locate at areas with relatively sparse trees coverage
(the bottom of the image) and area of the valley, while in areas
with bare earth and dense vegetation, the differences are smaller,
because these areas are more homogeneous.
V. D ISCUSSION
A. 3-D Scene Generation
In this study, we used a well-established plant software pack-
age (OnyxTREE) to generate a series of individual trees, for
which the parameters were obtained by ﬁeld measurements.
Fig. 14. A 30 m ×30 m forest scene: (a) RGB image, (b) NIR image. This
scene contains 30 birch trees, which are made from three single tree objects
with random translations and rotations.
However, the highest uncertainty is the LA of individual tree,
this uncertainty is produced either by the effective LAI mea-
surements or allometric relationships used in this study. In the
future, terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) may be a good alternative
to estimate LA of both individual tree and plot [36]. More im-
portantly, TLS can obtain very accurate 3-D branch structures
of trees. In this way, we can generate a virtual tree which is
almost identical to real trees.
B. Spectral Simulation
The absolute values of NDVISand NDVIL8show an apparent
offset. This may be caused by a number of reasons. Since we
only used a limited number of individual tree models and the
regenerated 3-D forest was not really identical to the real one,
and this structural difference may produce the gap between
NDVISand NDVIL8. Another reason was that the selection of
individual trees from SDB was only based on the tree height
and crown diameter, but LA, which is a very important factor
that inﬂuences NDVI, was not considered currently. In fact, the
predicted LAIs in most plots, excluding L8, were overestimated,
which means that the produced individual tree model may have
higher LA than a real tree and in turn produced a higher NDVI.
Additionally, the Landsat data were obtained in May, but the
scene in August was reconstructed, the LAI in May was lower
than the LAI in August, which caused that NDVISwas larger
than NDVIL8. However, the simulation is still useful because
we have predetermined all the “ground truth” (such as LAI)
of the regenerated scene, which is important to support some
quantitative remote sensing studies, such as the validation of
land surface parameter retrieval algorithms.
C. Ray-Tracing Sampling
Since ray-tracing mainly relies on random sampling of image
plane; thus, the sampling count (SC) per square meter may have
a large inﬂuence on the simulation accuracy, especially in highly
heterogeneous areas. To study the inﬂuences of SC, we simu-
lated the nadir BRF in NIR band of a 30 m ×30 m scene (see
Fig. 14) under different SC values, which range from 20m2to
2Nm2(N=0, 1,..., 10). For each SC, the simulations were
carried out 50 times. The mean, minimum, maximum value,
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
QI et al.: LARGE-SCALE EMULATION SYSTEM FOR REALISTIC THREE-DIMENSIONAL (3-D) FOREST SIMULATION 9
Fig. 15. Inﬂuence of sampling count (SC): (a) Simulation accuracy under different SC, BFRmean, BRFmin, BRFmax represents the mean, minimum, and maximum
value of the 50 simulations for each SC, 95%CI is the conﬁdence interval that indicates each simulated BRF has a possibility of 0.95 to lie in this interval.
(b) Simulation time of ﬁrst-scattering and multi-scattering under different SC (excluding the time for reading and writing ﬁles).
and 95%conﬁdence interval (CI) are shown in Fig. 15, which
also shows the corresponding simulation time (under a laptop
with 8 cores and 16 GB memory). It can be observed that BRF
tends to be stable while SC increases, however, the difference
is only 0.1% between SC =64 and SC =1024. This means
that the accuracy of SC =64 is comparable with higher SC, but
the simulation time is signiﬁcantly reduced (from 23.1 to 1.5 s).
Although BRFmin and BRFmax have a signiﬁcant difference un-
der very low SC, the 95%CI is relatively small, i.e., there is
a possibility of 95%that the simulated BRF value will lie in a
small interval, which becomes smaller when SC increases.
This ﬁgure also indicates that the simulation of multiscatter-
ing takes up most of the computing resources, because vegeta-
tion usually has very complex foliage structures and relatively
high reﬂectance in NIR band. If the reﬂectance is low (e.g.,
RED band), we can set the tracing paths shorter to reduce the
scattering times, which will in turn reduce multiscattering and
increase computing efﬁciency.
VI. CONCLUSION
In this study, we proposed a large-scale emulation system
to generate 3-D forest scene with explicitly described individ-
ual trees and simulate reﬂectance images. Allometric equations
were used to populate plot LAI to individual tree LA. With these
parameters, we constructed a SDB which contained a series of
individual trees. This SDB can be reused to build a larger forest
scene and can be used in the remote sensing and forest manage-
ment research. We also developed a parallelized radiative trans-
fer model based on ray-tracing techniques, and it provided a
relatively efﬁcient way to simulate images of large and complex
scene. This model has been validated with other 3-D radiative
transfer models from RAMI, and a high consistency with most
of them proved the model’s feasibility. Moreover, we have re-
leased LESS to the public and it has an easy-to-use graphic user
interface (GUI) [37]. This software can simulate multispectral,
multiangle, and multiresolution images. We hope this software
can help remote sensing researchers to better understand the
complex interactions between vegetation and radiation, and also
possibly ease their modeling and validation work.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors would like to thank K. Yan and Y. Chen for
providing us with ﬁeld measurement data. Special thanks also to
Dr. T. Yin and Prof. J.-P. Gastellu-Etchegorry, for their valuable
REFERENCES
[1] J. K. Winjum, R. K. Dixon, and P. E. Schroeder, “Estimating the global
potential of forest and agroforest management practices to sequester car-
bon,” in Natural Sinks CO2, J. Wisniewski and A. E. Lugo, Eds. The
Netherlands: Springer, 1992, pp. 213–227.
[2] M. J. Twery and A. R. Weiskittel, “Forest-m modelling,” in Environmental
Modelling: Finding Simplicity Complexity, 2nd ed. Hoboken, NJ, USA:
Wiley, 2013, pp. 379–398.
[3] D. Alder, “Growth modelling for mixed tropical forests,Tropi-
cal Forestry Papers (United Kingdom), 1995. [Online]. Available:
http://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=GB9618283
[4] M. Battaglia, P.J. Sands, and S. G. Candy, “Hybrid growth model to predict
height and volume growth in young Eucalyptus globulus plantations,
Forest Ecol. Manag., vol. 120, no. 1, pp. 193–201, 1999.
[5] J. K. Vanclay, Modelling Forest Growth and Yield: Applications to Mixed
Tropical Forests. Wallingford, U.K.: CAB Int., 1994.
[6] R. O. Curtis, G. W. Clendenen, D. J. DeMars, and P. N. Forest, ANew
Stand Simulator for Coast Douglas-Fir: DFSIM User’s Guide. U.S. Dept.
Agriculture, Forest Service, Paciﬁc Northwest Forest and Range Experi-
ment Station, Portland, 1981.
[7] P. Paar, “Landscape visualizations: Applications and requirements of 3D
visualization software for environmental planning,Comput., Environ-
ment Urban Syst., vol. 30, no. 6, pp. 815–839, Nov. 2006. [Online]. Avail-
[8] S. R. Sheppard, “Guidance for crystal ball gazers: Developing a code of
ethics for landscape visualization,” Landscape Urban Plann., vol. 54, no.
1, pp. 183–199, 2001.
[9] G. Zheng and L. M. Moskal, “Retrieving leaf area index (LAI)
using remote sensing: Theories, methods and sensors,” Sensors,
vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 2719–2745, Apr. 2009. [Online]. Available:
http://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/9/4/2719/
[10] M. B´
eland, J.-L. Widlowski, R. A. Fournier, J.-F. Cˆ
ot´
e, and M. M.
Verstraete, “Estimating leaf area distribution in savanna trees from terres-
trial lidar measurements,” Agricultural Forest Meteorol., vol. 151, no. 9,
pp. 1252–1266, 2011.
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
10 IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATIONS AND REMOTE SENSING
[11] F. D. Schneider et al., “Simulating imaging spectrometer data: 3D for-
est modeling based on LiDAR and in situ data,Remote Sens. Environ.,
vol. 152, pp. 235–250, 2014.
[12] J.-L. Widlowski, J.-F. Cˆ
ot´
e, and M. B´
eland, “Abstract tree crowns in 3d
radiative transfer models: Impact on simulated open-canopy reﬂectances,
Remote Sens. Environ., vol. 142, pp. 155–175, 2014.
[13] R. Darvishzadeh, A. Skidmore, M. Schlerf, and C. Atzberger, “Inversion of
a radiative transfer model for estimating vegetation LAI and chlorophyll
in a heterogeneous grassland,” Remote Sens. Environ., vol. 112, no. 5,
pp. 2592–2604, 2008.
[14] M. I. Disney, P. Lewis, and P. North, “Monte Carlo ray tracing in opti-
cal canopy reﬂectance modelling,” Remote Sens. Rev., vol. 18, no. 2–4,
pp. 163–196, 2000.
[15] J.-P. Gastellu-Etchegorry, V. Demarez, V. Pinel, and F. Zagolski, “Model-
ing radiative transfer in heterogeneous 3D vegetation canopies,” in Satel-
lite Remote Sensing (ser. Satellite Remote Sensing). International Society
for Optics and Photonics, 1995, pp. 38–49.
[16] J.-P. Gastellu-Etchegorry et al., “Discrete anisotropic radiative transfer
(dart 5) for modeling airborne and satellite spectroradiometer and lidar
acquisitions of natural and urban landscapes,” Remote Sens., vol. 7, no. 2,
pp. 1667–1701, 2015.
[17] P. R. J. North, “Three-dimensional forest light interaction model using a
Monte Carlo method,” IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote Sens., vol. 34, no. 4,
pp. 946–956, Jul. 1996.
[18] W. Qin and S. A. Gerstl, “3-D scene modeling of semidesert vegetation
cover and its radiation regime,Remote Sens. Environ., vol. 74, no. 1,
pp. 145–162, 2000.
science applications with the airborne prism experiment (apex),” Remote
Sens. Environ., vol. 158, pp. 207–219, 2015.
[20] H. Huang, W. Qin, and Q. Liu, “RAPID: A radiosity ap-
plicable to porous indiviDual objects for directional re-
ﬂectance over complex vegetated scenes,Remote Sens. En-
viron., vol. 132, pp. 221–237, May 2013. [Online]. Available:
[21] A. Komiyama, J. E. Ong, and S. Poungparn, “Allometry, biomass, and pro-
ductivity of mangrove forests: A review,Aquatic Botany, vol. 89, no. 2,
pp. 128–137, Aug. 2008. [Online]. Available: http://www.sciencedirect.
com/science/article/pii/S0304377007001829
[22] D. P. Turner, S. A. Acker, J. E. Means, and S. L. Garman, “As-
sessing alternative allometric algorithms for estimating leaf area of
Douglas-ﬁr trees and stands,” Forest Ecol. Manage., vol. 126, no. 1,
pp. 61–76, Feb. 2000. [Online]. Available: http://www.sciencedirect.
com/science/article/pii/S0378112799000833
[23] J.-F. Barczi et al., “Amapsim: A structural whole-plant simulator based
on botanical knowledge and designed to host external functional models,
Ann. Botany, vol. 101, no. 8, pp. 1125–1138, 2008.
[24] S. Griffon and F. de Coligny, “AMAPstudio: An editing and sim-
ulation software suite for plants architecture modelling,” Ecologi-
cal Modelling, vol. 290, pp. 3–10, Oct. 2014. [Online]. Available:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030438001300536X
[25] J. Weber and J. Penn, “Creation and rendering of realistic trees,” in Proc.
22nd Annu. Comput. Graph. Interactive Techn., 1995, pp. 119–128. [On-
line]. Available: http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/218380.218427
[26] K. Lim, P. Treitz, M. Wulder, B. St-Onge, and M. Flood, “LiDAR remote
sensing of forest structure,” Progress Phys. Geography, vol. 27, no. 1,
pp. 88–106, 2003.
[27] M. Van Leeuwen and M. Nieuwenhuis, “Retrieval of forest structural
parameters using LiDAR remote sensing,Eur. J. Forest Res., vol. 129,
no. 4, pp. 749–770, 2010.
[28] T. P. Dawson, P. J. Curran, and S. E. Plummer, “LIBERTY-Modeling the
effects of leaf biochemical concentration on reﬂectance spectra,Remote
Sens. Environ., vol. 65, no. 1, pp. 50–60, 1998.
[29] L. Wang et al., “Reﬂectance features of water stressed Larix gmelinii
needles,” Forestry Studies China, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 28–33, 2009.
[30] J. Qi, D. Xie, and G. Yan, “Realistic 3D-simulation of large-scale
forest scene based on individual tree detection,” in Proc. IEEE Int.
Geosci. Remote Sens. Symp., Jul. 2016, pp. 728–731. [Online]. Available:
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7729183/
[31] W. Zhang et al., “An easy-to-use airborne lidar data ﬁltering method
based on cloth simulation,” Remote Sens., vol. 8, no. 6, 2016,Art. no. 501.
[Online]. Available: http://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/8/6/501
[32] J. T. Kajiya, “The rendering equation,” in ACM SIGGRAPH Comput.
Graph., vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 143–150, 1986.
[33] W. Jakob, “Mitsuba physically based renderer. mitsuba-renderer.org,
2010.
[34] J. L. Widlowski et al., “Third radiation transfer model intercomparison
(RAMI) exercise: Documenting progress in canopy reﬂectance models,
J. Geophys. Res., Atmospheres (1984-2012), vol. 112, no. D9, 2007.
[35] “RAMI, RAMI-IV - EXPERIMENTS - European Commission.”
2017. [Online]. Available: http://rami-benchmark.jrc.ec.europa.
eu/HTML/RAMI-IV/RAMI-IV.php. Accessed on: Sep. 27, 2017.
[36] W. Yan, D. Xie, X. Wang, Q. I. Jianbo, W. Zhang, and G. Yan, “Simulation
and analysis of point clouds from a terrestrial laser scanner,” J. Remote
Sens., vol. 19, no. s1, pp. 391–399, 2015.
[37] J. Qi, “Home—LESS Documentation,” Mar. 2017. [Online]. Available:
http://ramm.bnu.edu.cn/projects/less/
Jianbo Qi is currently working toward the Ph.D. de-
gree in cartography and geographic information sys-
tem at Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
He is also a joint Ph.D. student at CESBIO Labora-
tory,Paul Sabatier University, France.
His research interests include 3-D radiative trans-
fer modeling, realistic forest scene simulation, and
vegetation parameter retrieval.
Donghui Xie received the Ph.D. degree in remote
sensing and geographic information systems from
Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China, in 2005.
From 2005 to 2007, she was a Postdoctoral Re-
search Associate with Beijing Normal University. She
is currently with the State Key Laboratory of Remote
Sensing Science, School of Geography, Beijing Nor-
mal University. Her research interests include canopy
radiative transfer modeling and biophysical parame-
ter retrieval of vegetation.
Dashuai Guo is currently working toward the Mas-
ter’s degree in cartography and geographic informa-
tion system at Beijing Normal University, Beijing,
China.
His research interests are mainly in individual trees
modeling and realistic forest scene simulation.
Guangjian Yan received the Ph.D. degree in carto-
graphy and geographic information system from the
Institute of Remote Sensing Applications, Chinese
Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China, in 1999.
He is currently a Professor with the State Key Lab-
oratory of Remote Sensing Science, School of Geog-
raphy, Beijing Normal University, Beijing. He has
published more than 160 papers. His main research
interests are multiangular remote sensing, vegetation
remote sensing, radiation budget, scale effect, and
scale correction of remote sensing.
... Collecting sufficient real data is challenging mainly due to the UAV jitter and cost, which limits the exploration of the effect of different scanning angles on the direct DBH measurement. To overcome this limitation, the LESS model [31,32] (http://lessrt.org/, accessed on 14 April 2022) established by Jianbo Qi's team at Beijing Forestry University was used to generate simulated UAV LiDAR data in this study. ...
... In this paper, the influence of the scanning angles and scanning modes on trunk point extraction and DBH measurement were analyzed on the UAV LiDAR data. We employed the LESS [31,32] ...
... In this paper, the influence of the scanning angles and scanning modes on trunk point extraction and DBH measurement were analyzed on the UAV Li-DAR data. We employed the LESS [31,32] model to simulate UAV LiDAR data for multiple routes with a scanning angle range of 45-90 degrees (interval of 5 degrees). Table 4 shows the accuracies of trunk point extraction and DBH measurement based on all routes of real and simulated UAV LiDAR data. ...
Article
Full-text available
The accurate measurement of diameter at breast height (DBH) is one of the essential tasks for biomass estimation at an individual tree scale. This paper aims to explore the potential of unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) based light detection and ranging (LiDAR) for trunk point extraction and direct DBH measurement. First, the trunk point cloud for each tree is extracted based on UAV LiDAR data by the multiscale cylindrical detection method. Then, the DBH is directly measured from the point cloud via the multiscale ring fitting. Lastly, we analyze the influence of scanning angle and mode on trunk point extraction and DBH measurement. The results show that the proposed method can obtain high accuracy of trunk point extraction and DBH measurement with real (R2 = 0.708) and simulated (R2 = 0.882) UAV LiDAR data. It proves that the UAV LiDAR data is feasible to directly measure the DBH. The highest accuracy was obtained with the scanning angles ranging from 50 to 65 degrees. Additionally, as the number of routes increases, the accuracy increases. This paper demonstrates that the UAV LiDAR can be used to directly measure the DBH, providing the scientific guidance for UAV path planning and LiDAR scanning design.
... Urban trees play one of the most significant roles in regulating the urban microclimate, along with bushes and green spaces, which can be taken as a simpler form of "trees" in the reconstruction process. However, the association of urban microclimate simulation and tree reconstruction has hardly been considered comprehensively in prior studies, although some tree models have been used for a particular part of the microclimate, e.g., radiative transfer modeling [39][40][41][42], transpiration simulation [43], shadow effect evaluation [44], etc. ...
... Some studies used digital photos of trees as supplementary data when reconstructing trees from LiDAR point clouds. Instead of addressing the 3D structure of trees, these images are used to extract individual trees, separate foliage and woody components [110], refine in-crown structure [42,111,112] or identify tree species [41]. There is still a focus on processing LiDAR points to reconstruct trees. ...
... Terrestrial photogrammetry Photogrammetric point cloud [115][116][117][118][119][120][121][122][123] Aerial photogrammetry UAV sequence images [124] Photogrammetric point cloud [125][126][127][128][129] Aerial laser scanning LiDAR point clouds [130] Terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) LiDAR point clouds [39,40,43,44,[131][132][133][134][135][136][137][138][139][140][141][142] Mobile laser scanning (MLS) LiDAR point clouds [143,144] Aerial laser scanning (ALS) & aerial photography LiDAR point clouds & images identifying tree species [41] Terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) & terrestrial photography ...
Article
Full-text available
The negative climate change induced by rapid urbanization has become a global environmental issue. Numerous studies have been devoted to the microclimate regulation functions performed by urban vegetation. Digital city information modeling provides a powerful tool for various simula-tions and data analytics for the sustainable development of urban areas. However, the method reconstructing urban trees is still in its early stage compared to the relatively mature building modeling. Most prior studies on tree reconstruction focused on retrieving geometric features, while other factors related to urban microclimate simulation were rarely addressed. This paper presents a comprehensive literature review and in-depth analysis covering two distinct research directions in relation to urban microclimate simulation. The first one is set on the identification of key factors related to trees’ impact on urban microclimate. The second one is dedicated to approaches for three-dimensional (3D) tree reconstruction. Based on the findings, the paper identifies information including trees’ geometric, physiological characteristics and relation to the surroundings required for 3D tree reconstruction in the context of urban microclimate simulation, and further assesses the potential of the 3D tree reconstruction approaches to accommodate these pieces of information. An appropriate 3D tree reconstruction approach, which allows for the supply of the required infor-mation for urban microclimate simulation, is recommended.
... To assemble 3D virtual forest scenes, 3D models of trees are needed. Qi et al. (2017) presented a system to reconstruct a large 3D forest scene (1 km × 1 km) by combining a database of representative computer-generated tree models with ALS data of a forest plot. A related approach to generate synthetic forestry data was suggested by Fassnacht et al. (2018) and Schäfer et al. (2019), where tree positions and characteristics are determined using a forest growth simulator and forests are then built by voxelising real 3D point clouds of trees with matching characteristics, stored in a tree database. ...
... A further option is to use very detailed synthetic 3D mesh models generated by computer algorithms included in software such as Arbaro (Weber and Penn, 1995), OnyxTREE (Onyx Computing, 2020) or AMAPstudio (Griffon and de Coligny, 2014). Such models have often been applied for virtual laser scanning (Hämmerle et al., 2017;Qi et al., 2017;Qin et al., 2017;Roberts et al., 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
Virtual laser scanning (VLS), the simulation of laser scanning in a computer environment, is a useful tool for field campaign planning, acquisition optimisation, and development and sensitivity analyses of algorithms in various disciplines including forestry research. One key to meaningful VLS is a suitable 3D representation of the objects of interest. For VLS of forests, the way trees are constructed influences both the performance and the realism of the simulations. In this contribution, we analyse how well VLS can reproduce scans of individual trees in a forest. Specifically, we examine how different voxel sizes used to create a virtual forest affect point cloud metrics (e.g., height percentiles) and tree metrics (e.g., tree height and crown base height) derived from simulated point clouds. The level of detail in the voxelisation is dependent on the voxel size, which influences the number of voxel cells of the model. A smaller voxel size (i.e., more voxels) increases the computational cost of laser scanning simulations but allows for more detail in the object representation. We present a method that decouples voxel grid resolution from final voxel cube size by scaling voxels to smaller cubes, whose surface area is proportional to estimated normalised local plant area density. Voxel models are created from terrestrial laser scanning point clouds and then virtually scanned in one airborne and one UAV-borne simulation scenario. Using a comprehensive dataset of spatially overlapping terrestrial, UAV-borne and airborne laser scanning field data, we compare metrics derived from simulated point clouds and from real reference point clouds. Compared to voxel cubes of fixed size with the same base grid size, using scaled voxels greatly improves the agreement of simulated and real point cloud metrics and tree metrics. This can be largely attributed to reduced artificial occlusion effects. The scaled voxels better represent gaps in the canopy, allowing for higher and more realistic crown penetration. Similarly high accuracy in the derived metrics can be achieved using regular fixed-sized voxel models with notably finer resolution, e.g., 0.02 m. But this can pose a computational limitation for running simulations over large forest plots due to the ca. 50 times higher number of filled voxels. We conclude that opaque scaled voxel models enable realistic laser scanning simulations in forests and avoid the high computational cost of small fixed-sized voxels.
... (4) Evaluation using simulated images A simulation method that only uses DEM data, which can eliminate the errors caused by the assumptions using remote sensing images, was adopted (e.g., the sunlit and the shady areas have the same reflectance characteristics). LESS (LargE-Scale remote Sensing data and image simulation framework) is a ray-tracing-based 3D radiative transfer model which can simulate large-scale satellite images and solar radiation over rugged terrain [46,59]. In LESS simulation, the "orthographic" sensor type was selected, and 50% diffuse irradiance (SKY_TO_TOTAL) was set. ...
Article
Full-text available
Topographic effects in medium and high spatial resolution remote sensing images greatly limit the application of quantitative parameter retrieval and analysis in mountainous areas. Many topographic correction methods have been proposed to reduce such effects. Comparative analyses on topographic correction algorithms have been carried out, some of which drew different or even contradictory conclusions. Performances of these algorithms over different terrain and surface cover conditions remain largely unknown. In this paper, we intercompared ten widely used topographic correction algorithms by adopting multi-criteria evaluation methods using Landsat images under various terrain and surface cover conditions as well as images simulated by a 3D radiative transfer model. Based on comprehensive analysis, we found that the Teillet regression-based models had the overall best performance in terms of topographic effects’ reduction and overcorrection; however, correction bias may be introduced by Teillet regression models when surface reflectance in the uncorrected images do not follow a normal distribution. We recommend including more simulated images for a more in-depth evaluation. We also recommend that the pros and cons of topographic correction methods reported in this paper should be carefully considered for surface parameters retrieval and applications in mountain regions.
... LESS, as a 3D radiative transfer model, can accurately and efficiently simulate spectral reflectance and images of vegetation scenes from the visible to thermal infrared domains (Qi et al., 2017(Qi et al., , 2019. The BRF simulated by LESS is consistent with those of other classic models (e.g., the DART model) applying the RAMI exercise under different forest scenarios. ...
Article
Full-text available
The canopy bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) plays a pivotal role in estimating the biophysical parameters of plants, whereas soil background anisotropy creates challenges for their retrieval. Soil optical properties affect canopy anisotropic characteristics, especially in open-canopy areas. However, the remote sensing of background anisotropy is challenging due to the difficulties of information extraction in complex forest ecosystems and varying illumination conditions. This study develops an efficient photogrammetric technique to extract the background soil bidirectional reflectance factor (BRF) from unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-based multiangular images and to verify the need for accurate soil anisotropy information in canopy radiative transfer modeling. Soil BRF profiles were measured over three open-canopy sample plots from multiangular remotely sensed multispectral images collected with a hexacopter. As validation, reference soil BRF profiles were synchronously acquired by a ground-based multiangular imaging system. A high level of consistency between the ground- and UAV-measured soil BRF was observed with an RMSE of less than 0.012. Uncertainty analysis of the measured soil BRF showed that multiple scattering between sunlit soil in large sunflecks and foliage elements contributed less than 5%. Both results demonstrated that soil anisotropy can be accurately extracted from UAV multiangular measurements. To explicitly demonstrate that the use of soil anisotropy can reduce uncertainties in canopy radiative transfer simulations, we simulated the canopy BRF with Lambertian soil and with anisotropic soil using a three-dimensional (3D) radiative transfer model under different soil moisture content (SMC) levels, canopy cover (CC) levels and solar zenith angles (SZAs) with simulated realistic forest scenes. We found that less CC, lower SZAs and less SMC lead to a more significant influence of soil anisotropy on canopy reflectance; e.g., the reflectance bias reaches up to 0.3 in the hotspot direction. This illustrates that neglecting soil anisotropy can cause considerable errors in the modeling of the canopy BRF of open forests (i.e., CC levels of less than 0.5). The proposed technique facilitates the characterization of anisotropic forest background soil, which is important for advancing canopy radiative transfer modeling and validation and for the retrieval of vegetation parameters.
... A LargE-Scale remote sensing data and image Simulation framework (LESS) is a ray-tracing based 3-D RT model, which has the advantage of high computational efficiency in 3-D RT modeling (Qi et al., 2017(Qi et al., , 2019. It employs forward photon tracing mode to simulate downwelling and upwelling radiation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Terrain reflected solar radiation in snow‐covered mountains is nonnegligible in investigations of the energy budget. However, it has so far not been investigated thoroughly, especially with regard to the influence of snow cover. Several parameterization approaches have been raised but not yet evaluated in a more uniform and quantitative manner. Based on the three‐dimensional (3‐D) ray‐tracing simulation, we explored the temporal and spatial characteristics of the terrain reflected radiation in 15 domains on the southeastern Tibetan Plateau, and comprehensively evaluated different parameterization approaches. The results indicate that the ratio of reflected radiation to total daily radiation ranges from 0.25% to 10.85% at the scale of 5 × 5 km² in a winter clear day, and it is 57% higher at noon in spring and autumn due to the higher snow cover fraction. Snow cover not only enhances the magnitude of reflected radiation by increasing surface albedo but also changes the spatial distribution pattern of radiation in partial snow‐covered mountains, causing more snow‐reflected radiation to be received by the surrounding surfaces. Three forms of terrain configuration factors in common parameterization approaches were evaluated by the ray‐tracing model. The complementary of sky view factor shows good consistency with ray‐tracing model at domain‐averaged scales, with a root mean square error (RMSE) of 2.55 (14%) W/m², while the other two both underestimate the radiation. The parameterization approach involving the multi‐reflection shows better performance with the normalized RMSE decreasing by 5%. However, the uncertainty of it increases with the surface spatial heterogeneity caused by the partial snow cover, especially at high resolution.
... (3) Contribution of the prior information: the plot measurement was used to limit the parameter bounds and distribution, and the tree allometric equations were applied to derive reasonable relationships among the canopy structure parameters of tree crowns. The latter has been well recognized in many studies (Korpela and Tokola 2006;Qi et al. 2017;Verma et al. 2014). These strategies helped to generate more reasonable LUT values and obtain more uniform parameters inversion (Fig. 13). ...
Article
As a significant forest disturbance factor, pine shoot beetles (PSB) have caused widespread tree mortality in Yunnan pine forests over southwestern China. Due to significant vertical heterogeneity of tree crowns, empirical remote sensing methods or one-dimensional (1D) radiative transfer (RT) models are not qualified enough to accurately retrieve the damage level of PSB damage. Therefore, three-dimensional (3D) RT models which have the ability to describe vertically complex heterogeneous canopies are more suitable for the damaged forests. In this study, shoot dieback ratio (SDR) was used to parameterize the Radiosity Applicable to Porous IndiviDual Objects (RAPID) model, in order to accurately estimate the PSB damage. Specifically, the vertically heterogeneous characteristics of the biophysical and optical properties within the canopy were carefully considered. First, we developed an approach to reconstruct damaged forest scenes through individual tree segmentation from UAV-lidar data and in situ measurements. Second, the simulated reflectance of forest scenes was compared with the actual hyperspectral and Sentinel-2 (S2) reflectance data to evaluate the performance of the parameterized RAPID. Then, the parameterized RAPID model was used to create a look-up table (LUT) containing the leaf chlorophyll content (Cab), effective leaf area index (LAIe), SDR, and dead needles LAIe (LAIdead, LAIe × SDR) as well as the corresponding simulated canopy reflectance. Furthermore, tree allometric equations were used to regularize the LUT with the intention to improve the estimation accuracy. Good agreement (RMSE: 0.015-0.031, index of agreement: 0.97-0.99) was found between the simulated reflectance and the remote sensing observations. The retrieval accuracy of the biochemical and biophysical parameters using S2 data yielded R² = 0.55 (normalized RMSE (NRMSE) = 19%) for Cab, R² = 0.70 (NRMSE = 15%) for the LAIe, R² = 0.66 (NRMSE = 25%) for SDR, and R² = 0.82 (NRMSE = 18%) for LAIdead. Using hyperspectral data with higher spatial and spectral resolution yielded better retrieval performance. This study demonstrated that 3D models (such as RAPID) have great potential to accurately invert SDR and LAIdead to assess PSB damage for the forests.
... The LESS model can synergistically use spectral and angular information to simulate the radiation properties of complex realistic landscapes, which can be used for simulating datasets of 3D landscapes [45]. The outputs of LESS can serve as benchmarks for retrieval algorithm evaluation since it has a solid theoretical foundation and its accuracy has already been well-assessed by comparison with other models of radiation transfer model intercomparison (RAMI) [35] and field measurements [46]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Uncertainty assessment of the moderate resolution imaging spectroradiometer (MODIS) leaf area index (LAI) and the fraction of photosynthetically active radiation absorbed by vegetation (FPAR) retrieval algorithm can provide a scientific basis for the usage and improvement of this widely-used product. Previous evaluations generally depended on the intercomparison with other datasets as well as direct validation using ground measurements, which mix the uncertainties from the model, inputs, and assessment method. In this study, we adopted the evaluation method based on three-dimensional radiative transfer model (3D RTM) simulations, which helps to separate model uncertainty and other factors. We used the well-validated 3D RTM LESS (large-scale remote sensing data and image simulation framework) for a grassland scene simulation and calculated bidirectional reflectance factors (BRFs) as inputs for the LAI/FPAR retrieval. The dependency between LAI/FPAR truth and model estimation serves as the algorithm uncertainty indicator. This paper analyzed the LAI/FPAR uncertainty caused by inherent model uncertainty, input uncertainty (BRF and biome classification), clumping effect, and scale dependency. We found that the uncertainties of different algorithm paths vary greatly (−6.61% and +84.85% bias for main and backup algorithm, respectively) and the “hotspot” geometry results in greatest retrieval uncertainty. For the input uncertainty, the BRF of the near-infrared (NIR) band has greater impacts than that of the red band, and the biome misclassification also leads to nonnegligible LAI/FPAR bias. Moreover, the clumping effect leads to a significant LAI underestimation (−0.846 and −0.525 LAI difference for two clumping types), but the scale dependency (pixel size ranges from 100 m to 1000 m) has little impact on LAI/FPAR uncertainty. Overall, this study provides a new perspective on the evaluation of LAI/FPAR retrieval algorithms.
Thesis
Les forêts tropicales, représentant 6,4% de la surface terrestre, abritent la plus grande biodiversité des écosystèmes terrestres et jouent un rôle fondamental dans le cycle du carbone à l'échelle mondiale. La durabilité de l'exploitation des forêts tropicales est un enjeu fondamental tant du point de vue de la conservation de la biodiversité que de la réduction des émissions liées à la déforestation et à la dégradation des forêts (REDD +). L'Office National des Forêts (ONF) est chargé de la conservation et de la gestion de 6 millions d'hectares de forêts privé en Guyane française. La possibilité de cartographier les espèces dans la canopée par télédétection est d'un intérêt évident, tant appliquées que scientifique.Les inventaires spatialisés à l'échelle du paysage contribueraient à faire progresser les connaissances fondamentales de ce biome complexe et menacé et aiderait à sa gestion durable. Les cartes de distribution d’espèces peuvent être croisées avec les facteurs environnementaux et fournir ainsi des clés d’interprétation des schémas d’organisation des peuplements forestiers. Du point de vue de la gestion, les cartes de distribution des espèces offre une rationalisation de l'exploitation forestière. La cartographie des espèces commerciales pourrait favoriser des pratiques forestières minimisant l'impact environnemental de l'exploitation. L'identification des espèces permettrait de prioriser les zones particulièrement riches en espèces commerciales, tout en évitant d'ouvrir des pistes d'exploitation dans les zones à faible niveau de ressources exploitables. La télédétection offre également la possibilité de surveiller l’extension des espèces proliférantes, telles que les lianes.Des capteurs hyperspectraux et LiDAR ont été utilisés à bord d’un avion pour identifier les espèces dans les forêts tropicales guyanaises. Une large gamme spectrale issue des capteurs hyperspectraux (400–2500 nm) est mesurée permettant d'avoir de nombreux descripteurs. Le LiDAR embarqué offre une description fine de la structure du couvert, facilitant la segmentation des houppiers. La fusion de ces deux informations améliore la caractérisation de la ressource.Afin de tirer le meilleur parti des données hyperspectrales, différents prétraitements radiométriques ont été évalués. Le lissage spatial et le filtrage des ombres sont les principaux facteurs qui améliorent la discrimination des espèces. L'utilisation de la gamme spectrale complète est également bénéfique. Ces résultats de classification ont été obtenus sur un groupe 20 espèces abondantes. L’identification de ces mêmes espèces en mélange au sein d’un peuplement hyperdivers a constitué la deuxième étape de ce travail.Nous avons évalué le niveau d'information nécessaire et le degré de confusion tolérable dans les données d’apprentissage afin de retrouver une espèce cible dans une canopée hyperdiverse. Une méthode de classification spécifique a été mise en œuvre pour être insensible à la contamination entre classes focales/non focales. Même dans le cas où la classe non focale contient jusqu’à 5% de pixels de la classe focale (espèce à identifier), les classifieurs se sont révélés efficaces.La troisème étape aborde le problème de la transposabilité des classifieurs d’une acquisition à une autre. La caractérisation des conditions d’acquisition et la prise en compte de leurs effets sont nécessaires pour convertir les données de radiance en réflectance de surface. Cependant cette opération de standardisation reste une étape extrêmement délicate au vue des nombreuses sources de variabilité : état de l’atmosphère, géométrie soleil-capteur et conditions d'éclairement. Nous évaluons en comparant des vols répétés sur le même site, la contribution des diverses caractéristiques d’acquisition à la divergence spectrale entre dates. Ce travail vise à proposer des pistes pour développer des méthodes de reconnaissance d'espèces qui soient plus robustes aux variations des caractéristiques d'acquisition.
Article
Optical remote sensing allows to efficiently monitor forest ecosystems at regional and global scales. However, most of the widely used optical forward models and backward estimation methods are only suitable for forest canopies in flat areas. To evaluate the recent progress in forest remote sensing over complex terrain, a satellite-airborne-ground synchronous Fine scale Optical Remote sensing Experiment of mixed Stand over complex Terrain (FOREST) was conducted over a 1 km×1 km key experiment area (KEA) located in the Genhe Reserve Areain 2016. Twenty 30 m×30 m elementary sampling units (ESUs) were established to represent the spatiotemporal variations of the KEA. Structural and spectral parameters were simultaneously measured for each ESU. As a case study, we first built two 3D scenes of the KEA with individual-tree and voxel-based approaches, and then simulated the canopy reflectance using the LargE-Scale remote sensing data and image Simulation framework over heterogeneous 3D scenes (LESS). The correlation coefficient between the LESS-simulated reflectance and the airborne-measured reflectance reaches 0.68–0.73 in the red band and 0.56–0.59 in the near-infrared band, indicating a good quality of the experiment dataset. More validation studies of the related forward models and retrieval methods will be done.
Article
Full-text available
Separating point clouds into ground and non-ground measurements is an essential step to generate digital terrain models (DTMs) from airborne LiDAR (light detection and ranging) data. However, most filtering algorithms need to carefully set up a number of complicated parameters to achieve high accuracy. In this paper, we present a new filtering method which only needs a few easy-to-set integer and Boolean parameters. Within the proposed approach, a LiDAR point cloud is inverted, and then a rigid cloth is used to cover the inverted surface. By analyzing the interactions between the cloth nodes and the corresponding LiDAR points, the locations of the cloth nodes can be determined to generate an approximation of the ground surface. Finally, the ground points can be extracted from the LiDAR point cloud by comparing the original LiDAR points and the generated surface. Benchmark datasets provided by ISPRS (International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing) working Group III/3 are used to validate the proposed filtering method, and the experimental results yield an average total error of 4.58%, which is comparable with most of the state-of-the-art filtering algorithms. The proposed easy-to-use filtering method may help the users without much experience to use LiDAR data and related technology in their own applications more easily.
Article
Full-text available
Terrestrial Laser Scanner (TLS) technology can quickly acquire three-dimensional information of targets with high precision. Given that TLS is a new data collection technique, it has been gradually applied to characterize the structural attributes of forest canopy. However, the inversion accuracy of Leaf Area Index (LAI) is highly dependent on the intrinsic configuration of the sensor, such as beam size and echo detection energy. In this paper, a computer simulation model was proposed to simulate point clouds from TLS and to analyze quantitatively the influence of beam characteristic on LAI inverted from TLS data. A realistic tree was generated with OnyxTREE BROADLEAF software. Moreover, a computer model was proposed to simulate the interactions of lasers with a single tree and to acquire the point clouds from a TLS Riegl VZ-1000 based on the ray tracing algorithm. This model consisted of the ray intersection with triangular patches of photorealistic trees, the coordinate system conversion, and the acceleration of the algorithm. The beam size at exit, beam divergence, and echo detection algorithm were considered in the computer simulation method. One laser beam was divided into multiple bins, and each bin was treated as a separate pulse with its location, propagation direction, and an initial energy changing into a Gaussian shape. We inverted the crown-level Leaf Area Index (LAI) by using gap fraction analysis with the simulated point clouds, and the influence of beam characteristics (such as beam diameter and minimum echo detection intensity) on the LAI inversion was analyzed. Finally, we conducted the validation with the measured points of a birch tree located in Root River. We analyzed the influences of beam characteristics, such as beam size, beam divergence, and echo detection energy, on LAI inversion. The inversion results indicate that beam size and detection limit greatly influence LAI inversion. The points are increased with the decrease of the corresponding gap fraction because several points can be returned from one beam when the beam width and divergence were considered, particularly when significant differences are achieved at the edge of leaves. A larger beam size means that components in the edge portion are intercepted more easily. Thus, the deviation of LAI inversion would be greater. When the detection intensity threshold was small, echo information could be returned even if only part of the spot edge was intercepted. Thus, gap fraction is undervalued. However, when the energy threshold setting was large, the returned energy may be below the threshold value and cannot be recorded, thereby resulting in overestimation of the gap fraction and underestimation of LAI. Therefore, the points caused by beam size and echo detection must be filtered, and suitable points must be chosen before inverting LAI with the gap fraction model. The simulation model based on the ray tracing algorithm was presented to explore the laser beam interceptions with an individual tree generated by using OnyxTree software. The LAI was retrieved via gap fraction analysis with zenith slicing method. The beam characteristics, such as beam size, echo detection energy, and beam divergence, were considered. The simulation model enables efficient and cost-effective research that can avoid environmental and instrumental error. This model contributes to an improved understanding of the intersections of laser beams with the tree crown well, and the LAI inversion of an individual tree is facilitated.
Article
Full-text available
We present the Airborne Prism Experiment (APEX), its calibration and subsequent radiometric measurements as well as Earth science applications derived from this data. APEX is a dispersive pushbroom imaging spectrometer covering the solar reflected wavelength range between 372 and 2540 nm with nominal 312 (max. 532) spectral bands. APEX is calibrated using a combination of laboratory, in-flight and vicarious calibration approaches. These are complemented by using a forward and inverse radiative transfer modeling approach, suitable to further validate APEX data. We establish traceability of APEX radiances to a primary calibration standard, including uncertainty analysis. We also discuss the instrument simulation process ranging from initial specifications to performance validation. In a second part, we present Earth science applications using APEX. They include geometric and atmospheric compensated as well as reflectance anisotropy minimized Level 2 data. Further, we discuss retrieval of aerosol optical depth as well as vertical column density of NOx, a radiance data-based coupled canopy-atmosphere model, and finally measuring sun-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (Fs) and infer plant pigment content. The results report on all APEX specifications including validation. APEX radiances are traceable to a primary standard with < 4% uncertainty and with an average SNR of > 625 for all spectral bands. Radiance based vicarious calibration is traceable to a secondary standard with ≤ 6.5% uncertainty. Except for inferring plant pigment content, all applications are validated using in-situ measurement approaches and modeling. Even relatively broad APEX bands (FWHM of 6 nm at 760 nm) can assess Fs with modeling agreements as high as R2 = 0.87 (relative RMSE = 27.76%). We conclude on the use of high resolution imaging spectrometers and suggest further development of imaging spectrometers supporting science grade spectroscopy measurements.
Chapter
Forests play a prominent role in the global C cycle. Occupying one-third of the earth’s land area, forest vegetation and soils contain about 60% of the total terrestrial C. Forest biomass productivity can be enhanced by management practices, which suggests that, by this means, forests could store more C globally and thereby slow the increase in atmospheric CO2. The question is how much C can be sequestered by forest and agroforest management practices. To address the question, a global database of information was compiled to assess quantitatively the potential of forestry practices to sequester C. The database presently has information for 94 forested nations that represent the boreal, temperate and tropical latitudes. Results indicate that the most promising management practices are reforestation in the temperate and tropical latitudes, afforestation in the temperate regions, and agroforestry and natural reforestation in the tropics. Across all practices, the median of the mean C storage values for the boreal latitudes is 16 tCha-1 (n=46) while in the temperate and tropical latitudes the median values are 71 tCha-1 (n=401) and 66 tCha-1 (n=170), respectively. Preliminary projections are that if these practices were implemented on 0.6 to 1.2 × 109 ha of available land over a 50-yr period, approximately 50 to 100 GtC could be sequestered.
Article
Satellite and airborne optical sensors are increasingly used by scientists, and policy makers, and managers for studying and managing forests, agriculture crops, and urban areas. Their data acquired with given instrumental specifications (spectral resolution, viewing direction, sensor field-of-view, etc.) and for a specific experimental configuration (surface and atmosphere conditions, sun direction, etc.) are commonly translated into qualitative and quantitative Earth surface parameters. However, atmosphere properties and Earth surface 3D architecture often confound their interpretation. Radiative transfer models capable of simulating the Earth and atmosphere complexity are, therefore, ideal tools for linking remotely sensed data to the surface parameters. Still, many existing models are oversimplifying the Earth-atmosphere system interactions and their parameterization of sensor specifications is often neglected or poorly considered. The Discrete Anisotropic Radiative Transfer (DART) model is one of the most comprehensive physically based 3D models simulating the Earth-atmosphere radiation interaction from visible to thermal infrared wavelengths. It has been developed since 1992. It models optical signals at the entrance of imaging radiometers and laser scanners on board of satellites and airplanes, as well as the 3D radiative budget, of urban and natural landscapes for any experimental configuration and instrumental specification. It is freely distributed for research and teaching activities. This paper presents DART physical bases and its latest functionality for simulating imaging spectroscopy of natural and urban landscapes with atmosphere, including the perspective projection of airborne acquisitions and LIght Detection And Ranging (LIDAR) waveform and photon counting signals.
Article
AMAPstudio is a software suite dedicated to plants architecture modelling, designed for botanists and agronomists, providing features to edit, visualise, explore and simulate multi-scale plant descriptions. AMAPstudio is based on the multi-scale tree graph (MTG) data structure, which is commonly used to represent plant topology. The user can explore and edit the topology and the geometry of one or several plants. Specific data can be extracted with combinations of criteria and can be visualised in tables and graphs. Simple analysis functions can be run and data can be exported to external tools, e.g. R or any other statistical computing environment, for more specific analyses. AMAPstudio is also a framework in which modellers can integrate their own plant simulation models to build plant growth or scene dynamics scenarios and explore the results. Models can be of different kinds, they can address more or less functioning and interaction with other plants or with the environment, possibly enabling to run ecological studies. AMAPstudio is an open software built according to the Capsis methodology. It is scenario oriented and brings particularly interactive editors easing the daily work and knowledge transfer. It is a free open-source software (LGPL) available on all Java compatible operating systems and it can be downloaded on http://amapstudio.cirad.fr.
Article
Remote sensing offers the potential to study forest ecosystems by providing spatially and temporally distributed information on key biophysical and biochemical variables. The estimation of biochemical constituents of leaves from remotely sensed data is of high interest revealing insight on photosynthetic processes, plant health, plant functional types, and species composition. However, upscaling leaf level observations to canopy level is not a trivial task, in particular due to the inherent structural complexity of forests. A common solution for scaling spectral information is the use of physically-based radiative transfer models. We parameterize the Discrete Anisotropic Radiative Transfer (DART) model based on airborne and in situ measurements. At-sensor radiances were simulated and compared with measurements of the Airborne Prism Experiment (APEX) imaging spectrometer. The study was performed on the Laegern site (47°28′43.0 N, 8°21′53.2 E, Switzerland), a temperate mixed forest characterized by steep slopes, a heterogeneous spectral background, and a high species diversity. Particularly the accurate 3D modeling of the complex canopy architecture is crucial to understand the interaction of photons with the vegetation canopy and its background. Two turbid medium based forest reconstruction approaches were developed and compared; namely based on a voxel grid and based on individual tree detection. Our study shows that the voxel grid based reconstruction yields better results. When using a pixel-wise comparison with the imaging spectrometer data, the voxel grid approach performed better (R2 = 0.48, λ780 nm) than the individual tree approach (R2 = 0.34, λ780 nm). Spatial patterns as compared to APEX data were similar, whereas absolute radiance values differed slightly, depending on wavelength. We provide a successful representation of a 3D radiative regime of a temperate mixed forest, suitable to simulate most spectral and spatial features of imaging spectrometer data. Limitations of the approach include the high spectral variability of leaf optical properties between and within species, which will be further addressed. The results also reveal the need of more accurate parameterizations of small-scale structures, such as needle clumping at shoot level as well as leaf angle.
Article
Three-dimensional (3D) radiatives transfer models of vegetation canopies are increasingly used to study the reflective properties of specific land cover types and to interpret satellite-based remote sensing observations of such environments. In doing so, most 3D canopy reflectance models simplify the structural representation of individual tree crowns, for example, by using a single ellipsoidal envelope or a series of cubic volumes (known as voxels) to approximate the actual crown shape and the 3D distribution of scatterers therein. Often these tree abstractions ignore or simplify the woody architecture as well. Focusing on broad-leaved Savanna trees, this study investigates the impact that architectural simplifications may have on the fidelity of simulated satellite observations at the bottom of the atmosphere for a variety of spatial resolutions, spectral bands, as well as viewing and illumination geometries. The typical uncertainty associated with vicarious calibration efforts, i.e., 5%, is used as the quality objective for the simulated bidirectional reflectance factors (BRFs). Our results indicate that the size of the voxel as well as the spectral, viewing, and illumination conditions drive the BRF bias at a given spatial resolution. The simulation of remote sensing data at medium spatial resolution is not affected by canopy abstractions except in the near-infrared (NIR) for cases where woody structures are omitted. Here, the BRF simulations of the abstract tree crowns exceeded the 5% tolerance limit even at spatial resolutions coarser than 125 m. For high-resolution satellite imagery, i.e., for nominal pixel sizes of 1 × 1 m2 or finer, local BRF biases can be 10 times greater than the 5% tolerance criterion. Both positive and negative local biases are possible depending on the relative weights of the single-collided, single-uncollided, and multiple-collided BRF components.