ArticlePublisher preview available

Effect of inspection performance in smart manufacturing system based on human quality control system

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Quality control at every stage of manufacturing is a key aspect of the quality management system of any organization. Inspection at different stages of manufacturing is essential to achieve required quality of the product. This knowledge area has been studied extensively in the past with respect to inspection strategies, inspection location, and inspection intervals to minimize inspection cost. However, there is a lack of literature that examines the relationship between inspection performance and factors related to human labor and inspection time of different products. Here, offline inspection is investigated to achieve the process target values by determining the optimal number of inspectors for different products. Three skill levels for inspectors are selected on the basis of their inspection errors, inspection quantities, and inspection cost. The purpose of this study is to achieve the optimum results of objective functions that consist of inspection cost, outgoing quality, and inspection quantity by determining the optimal value of decision variables, i.e., the number of inspectors with respect to their skill. A multi-objective optimization model is developed using a stochastic approach to determine the optimal results of the objective functions and decision variables. Firstly, goal programming is employed to verify the optimization model by using numerical examples. Secondly, sensitivity analysis is considered to illustrate the effect of incoming quantity on inspection performance and optimal combination of decision variables.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Effect of inspection performance in smart manufacturing system
based on human quality control system
Chang Wook Kang
1
&Muhammad Babar Ramzan
2
&Biswajit Sarkar
1
&
Muhammad Imran
1
Received: 5 April 2017 /Accepted: 11 September 2017 /Published online: 3 October 2017
#Springer-Verlag London Ltd. 2017
Abstract Quality control at every stage of manufacturing is a
key aspect of the quality management system of any organi-
zation. Inspection at different stages of manufacturing is es-
sential to achieve required quality of the product. This knowl-
edge area has been studied extensively in the past with respect
to inspection strategies, inspection location, and inspection
intervals to minimize inspection cost. However, there is a lack
of literature that examines the relationship between inspection
performance and factors related tohuman labor and inspection
time of different products. Here, offline inspection is investi-
gated to achieve the process target values by determining the
optimal number of inspectors for different products. Three
skill levels for inspectors are selected on the basis of their
inspection errors, inspection quantities, and inspection cost.
The purpose of this study is to achieve the optimum results
of objective functions that consist of inspection cost, outgoing
quality, and inspection quantity by determining the optimal
value of decision variables, i.e., the number of inspectors with
respect to their skill. A multi-objective optimization model is
developed using a stochastic approach to determine the opti-
mal results of the objective functions and decision variables.
Firstly, goal programming is employed to verify the optimiza-
tion model by using numerical examples. Secondly, sensitivity
analysis is considered to illustrate the effect of incoming quan-
tity on inspection performance and optimal combination of
decision variables.
Keywords Quality control .Offline inspection .Inspection
performance .Inspection time .Goal programming
1 Introduction
The inspection process and skill of inspector are important for
any manufacturing system [1]. Even though, the recent ad-
vancements in manufacturing systems have been character-
ized by precision of work through automation [2]. However,
it is very difficult to automate any manufacturing system due
to budget constraints, space constrains, or lack of skilled labor.
Thus, the inspection process is controlled by human labor and
it is the necessity that the judgment of the human labor is
skilled, semi-skilled, or low-skilled inspectors. The job, in
the complex manufacturing sector, should be assigned accord-
ing to the skill of the inspector such that different skill levels
may have different inspection loads [3]. Due to the availability
of funds, the manufacturing system can be made automated in
several countries. However, for other countries, the labor cost
is much cheaper due to the availability of manpower. Thus, for
some countries, manufacturing industries prefer to use human
labor for inspection purposes with minimum cost rather than
the automated system. Therefore, the skills of those inspectors
should be judged properly before assigning any job. That ma-
jor research gap is solved by this research problem.
Two types of inspections are most commonly used during
the manufacturing process: online inspection and offline in-
spection [4]. Online inspection facilitates to monitor quality
level during the manufacturing process, while offline inspec-
tion inspects the finished products [5,6]. This study has in-
vestigated the offline inspection case, where human labor of
different skill levels performs the process of inspections.
Offline inspection has been extensively examined in past to
decrease inspection cost by considering inspection errors,
*Biswajit Sarkar
bsbiswajitsarkar@gmail.com
1
Department of Industrial and Management Engineering, Hanyang
University, Ansan, Gyeonggi-do 15588, Republic of Korea
2
Department of Garment Manufacturing, National Textile University,
Faisalabad, Pakistan
Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2018) 94:43514364
DOI 10.1007/s00170-017-1069-4
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Quality control is a vital aspect of quality management in the manufacturing industry, ensuring that products meet the required standards of quality and efficiency [40], [72], [94]. Among the essential tasks in quality control, manual visual inspection stands out as a complex and tedious process that can lead to decreased production and performance. ...
... While specific manufacturing processes may vary, the ultimate objective remains consistent: detecting and identifying defective items as early as possible to prevent their negative impact on the production system and maintain productivity [77]. Consequently, regular inspections are necessary to ensure the production of error-free products [40]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Visual inspection is a crucial aspect of maintaining product quality and preventing the distribution of faulty items in the manufacturing industry. The introduction of deep learning has brought a revolution to visual inspection by leveraging advanced neural network architectures and large datasets. These technologies enable accurate detection of defects, anomalies, and deviations in products. However, the effectiveness of deep learning models heavily relies on a significant number of training samples. To address the scarcity of real-world samples, data augmentation techniques have been suggested. These tchniques involve applying various transformations and perturbations to existing data, thereby expanding the dataset and enhancing its diversity. This thesis presents an experimental study conducted for Seal Engineering AS, a Norwegian sealing manufacturing company, with the primary objective of implementing an automatic visual inspection system to enhance the quality assurance process. A dataset consisting of 896 high-quality images captured using a digital microscope was generated for binary classification tasks. The research methodology incorporated theoretical analysis, experimental design, and data-driven analysis within a controlled industrial environment. Multiple deep learning architectures, including custom CNN, ResNet50, LSTM, CNN-LSTM, VGG19, InceptionNet, and MobileNet, were evaluated to identify the optimal model for visual inspection. Transfer learning and data augmentation techniques were employed, resulting in a validation loss of 0.0252 with ResNet50. The performance of the models was assessed using validation loss and the confusion matrix, a tool that measures the classification model’s effectiveness. The experimental results highlight the significant impact of deep learning and data augmentation in enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of visual inspection tasks. This thesis provides valuable insights into the potential of deep learning for improving inspection processes, leading to higher-quality products and increased operational efficiency for Seal Engineering AS.
... Food production is based on long and complex supply chains (Serdarasan 2013;Gunasekaran 1996;Haji et al 2020). The inspection of food packaging is a main production bottleneck (Nandakumar et al 2020) due to manual checks leading to inevitable human error and process inefficiencies (Kang et al 2018;Vergara-Villegas et al 2014). Following the Theory of Constraints, reducing or eliminating those bottlenecks strongly improves production productivity (Hoseinpour et al 2020(Hoseinpour et al , 2021. ...
Article
Full-text available
Reducing waste through automated quality control (AQC) has both positive economical and ecological effects. In order to incorporate AQC in packaging, multiple quality factor types (visual, informational, etc.) of a packaged artifact need to be evaluated. Thus, this work proposes an end-to-end quality control framework evaluating multiple quality control factors of packaged artifacts (visual, informational, etc.) to enable future industrial and scientific use cases. The framework includes an AQC architecture blueprint as well as a computer vision-based model training pipeline. The framework is designed generically, and then implemented based on a real use case from the packaging industry. As an innovate approach to quality control solution development, the data-centric artificial-intelligence (DCAI) paradigm is incorporated in the framework. The implemented use case solution is finally tested on actual data. As a result, it is shown that the framework’s implementation through a real industry use case works seamlessly and achieves superior results. The majority of packaged artifacts are correctly classified with rapid prediction speed. Deep-learning-based and traditional computer vision approaches are both integrated and benchmarked against each other. Through the measurement of a variety of performance metrics, valuable insights and key learnings for future adoptions of the framework are derived.
... Moreover, considering its position in the global clothing market, the emerging economy, and geographical position, the apparel industry of Bangladesh needs proper guidelines for quality improvement [11]. Defects that are discovered after sewing have a detrimental impact on the costs of manufacturing [12]. It has several advantages to finding an error early on, before it interferes with other procedures or makes it more challenging to remove seams and re-sew [5]. ...
Article
To increase customer satisfaction in the highly dynamic and competitive apparel industry, it is essential to manufacture garments of superior quality. The study aimed to investigate the underlying causes of sewing faults and offer solutions for enhancing quality to a 100% export-oriented knit garment industry in Bangladesh. The study employed a comprehensive approach using quantitative and qualitative research methods to evaluate garment faults systematically. The whole garment inspection procedure was done on five common garment styles to collect the quantitative data. Some novel TQM (Total Quality Management) tools, Pareto analysis, WH questionnaire, cause-effect diagram, and a highly potential focus group panel were employed. The findings indicate the most prevalent faults like an open seam, skip stitch, and label mistake, accounting for 50 per cent, 29 per cent, and 7 per cent of all observed defects, respectively, and their remedies. The research’s significance lies in its holistic approach to quality improvement in the knit garment manufacturing industries. This study provides a valuable framework for enhancing product quality and reducing rejection rates by pinpointing crucial defects, their origins, and effective remedies.
... The IQC department is responsible for testing and inspection of all incoming batches of units to assure they fall within documented design-stated specifications. It is a vital checkpoint where all individual parts are examined, in order to ensure that after assembly, the instrument performs as expected without any failures or complications (Kang et al. 2018). With the expansion of this department, an improved regulated process should be in place to ensure parts are reaching the Manufacturing department in a more timely, efficient manner, maintaining the quality, while addressing the number of incoming parts that are currently sitting in accumulation waiting to be inspected. ...
Conference Paper
Incoming quality control (IQC) is integral to quality management system of manufacturing industries. IQC plays a significant role in ensuring delivery of high standard products to the target customers and, in turn, affects the company’s reputation and their competitiveness in the industry. Presenting a case from a biotechnology company, the purpose of this research is to develop a quality control system for inspection improvement of a biotechnological device. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the IQC Department encountered inconsistencies with output rate when providing inspected parts to the Manufacturing Department: an issue that could be mitigated with a documented process that addresses the prevalent issues that plague the current unestablished IQC system. This study utilized the Lean Six Sigma Methodology to achieve improvement for the IQC Department practice for enhanced performance by identifying root causes of inconsistencies, and creating a systematic documented process for IQC department. Upon successful analysis and implementation of the new IQC inspecting system, the non-value-added time decreased by over fifty percent. While this project is the first stepping stone in improving the IQC Department, its significant results emphasizes the integral contribution of quality control and Six Sigma practices in creating a continuous improvement system which ensures consistent high-quality instruments are being produced for the customers.
... Automation of quality control has a high priority, since for any production this step is of central importance. Equally, as machine capacity increases and depending on the skill of the workforce, it is more difficult to ensure high-quality inspections (Kang et al., 2018). Human-machine collaboration offers opportunities for this: computer vision algorithms can help human workers to detect defects and anomalies in manufactured parts, thus providing high reliability of quality control. ...
Article
Full-text available
The role of quality control based on images is important in industrial production. Nevertheless, this problem has not been addressed in computer vision for a long time. In recent years, this has changed: driven by publicly available datasets, a variety of methods have been proposed for detecting anomalies and defects in workpieces. In this survey, we present more than 40 methods that promise the best results for this task. In a comprehensive benchmark, we show that more datasets and metrics are needed to move the field forward. Further, we highlight strengths and weaknesses, discuss research gaps and future research areas.
... In facing the new environment, companies are required to establish their quality foundation while applying innovative quality method [11]. Since the performance of quality system significantly affected by the skill level of the inspector [14], the issue of quality-related skill becomes important. Skillful quality engineers are needed to maintain the quality foundation. ...
Conference Paper
Since the issue of productivity is increased, Industry 4.0 also promotes the issue of quality of product, processes, and services. However, studies show that recent quality initiatives are still facing the old problem and companies cannot get benefit from industry 4.0 environment to establish better quality. This paper proposes a framework of Cloud-based Quality Analyzer (CQA) which is designed specifically to perform quality analysis by reducing the dependency to the human quality engineer with respect to faster and more accurate information. Equipped by the standard quality analysis tools and some data mining algorithms, CQA can perform a wide-range quality-related activity from simple analysis to fully automated feedback loop quality control. Moreover, by adopting Cyber Physical System (CPS) technology, CQA is also expected to be able to realize real-time online quality control. However, since this is a conceptual framework, many technical details related to the data flow, configurability, security, the quality of service, connectivity and network aspect are still required for further investigation. From a quality engineering point of view, quality analysis techniques, data modeling, formal procedure of quality analysis, and more advanced data mining algorithms for extracting quality-related information are open for further research.
Article
Full-text available
Carbon emission reduction is very crucial nowadays. Industries need to find a proper balance between use of fossil fuels and carbon emission reduction as burning fossil fuels are indispensable for industrialization. This study proposes an sustainable inventory model to control carbon emission by using green products. It involves all parameters in a framework to optimize the profit function. Product deterioration, is an important aspect for practitioner to decide how to preserve a perishable product for maximum shelf-life. Therefore, an investment in preservation technology and green technology with full and partial backorder is allowed in the system. Remembering the present global situation, the ordering cost is assumed as variable cost which contain order cancelation and reorder cost. A nonlinear model is proposed and the solution procedure is suggested. The model is solved both theoretically and analytically. A case study is introduced and provides a connection with the anticipated model with a sensitivity analysis to present the model validity and conclusions. These results prove that a sustainable model with controllable carbon emission, green technology investment and preservation technology investment, is more realistic and profitable in compared with the other existing models.
Article
Full-text available
Along with the revolution of the manufacturing world, companies face a new challenge to continuously improving their production processes to meet the escalating demand for high-quality goods in a fiercely competitive market. The previous concept of Cloud-Based Quality Analyzer (CQA) can be used as a real-time monitoring software that provides information of the on-going process. This concept can be implemented as an effort to achieve high quality manufacturing. This study aimed to develop the descriptive analysis module to realise the concept of CQA and evaluate its ability in realising online quality monitoring process. By employing the waterfall methodology, this study developed and implemented the descriptive analysis module in the CQA environment. The module was implemented in a case study in guitar manufacturing. The result showed that this module worked perfectly in displaying the multivariate process control chart and successfully gave the warning when some processes were in out-ofcontrol state. Furthermore, the user acceptance test also showed a positive response from the users. The descriptive analysis module was believed able to enhance the quality of manufacturing process while reducing the dependencies to the human quality engineers. However, more case studies in various industries were required to evaluate the benefit of implementing this module.
Article
Full-text available
In their study on how Joint Health facility Inspections (JHI) were implemented in practice with a need to identify key facilitators or barriers for regulatory policy and practice, Tama et al found that innovative regulatory reforms markedly improved inspection scores among intervention health facilities albeit with challenges. Their article makes an important contribution to the body of knowledge in as far as regulation of health facilities is concerned. In low- and middle-income countries, private health facilities are poorly regulated and yet, they purge gaps where public health facilities are inadequate as was demonstrated during the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, while regulation of public health facilities is standardized, the research by Tama and colleagues provides a unique opportunity to continue dialogue on how private health facilities can be regulated through inspection and supervision. Regulation of public and private health facilities continues to be contentious since both experience unique contextual challenges.
Article
Full-text available
This study has been aimed at developing a model to reduce inspection cost by determining the optimum number of quality inspectors with respect to their skill levels using goal programming. A mathematical model is proposed to find out the optimal combination of decision variables. It is concluded that inspection cost may be reduced by optimising the skill level of the quality inspectors. © 2016, National Institute of Science Communication and Information Resources (NISCAIR). All rights reserved.
Article
Full-text available
To ensure all products as perfect, inspection is essential, even though it is not possible to inspect all products after producing them like some special type products as plastic joint for the water pipe. In this direction, this paper develops an inventory model with lot inspection policy. With the help of lot inspection, all products need not to be verified still the retailer can decide the quality of products during inspection. If retailer founds products as imperfect quality, the products are sent back to supplier. As it is lot inspection, mis-clarification errors (Type-I error and Type-II error) are introduced to model the problem. Two possible cases are discussed for sending back products as defective lots are immediately withdrawn from the system and send back to supplier with retailer’s payment and for second case, retailer sends defective products during receiving next lot from supplier with supplier’s investment, like in food industry or in hygiene product industry. The model is solved analytically and results indicate that optimal order size and sample size are intrinsically linked and maximize the total profit. Numerical examples, graphical representations, and sensitivity analysis are given to illustrate the model. The results suggest that sending defective products maintaining the first case is the more profitable than the second case.
Article
Full-text available
This paper considers an imperfect production system with preventive maintenance to obtain the optimal buffer inventory and inspection policy for sold products with free minimal repair warranty. The production system is subject to a random movement from an in-control to an out-of-control state, where some proportion of defective items are produced by the production system during both the in-control and out-of-control states. Online inspection is continuing after a time variable during the production process. Another offline human-based inspection policy is considered at the end of the production cycle to identify the defective items. Defective items found by the inspector are salvaged at some fixed cost before being shipped and the non-inspected items are passed to the customer with free minimal repair warranty. During human-based inspection, some misclassifications may arise from the inspector’s side. Thus, two types of inspection errors (Type I and Type II) are considered to make the model more realistic rather than the existing models. A numerical example along with graphical representations are provided to illustrate the proposed model. Sensitivity analysis of the optimal solution with respect to major parameters of the system has been carried out, and the implications are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, the problem of process targeting is considered in a situation where several objectives are sought, the product quality is controlled using 100 % inspection and the inspection system is error prone. The model extends the work of the literature of Duffuaa and El-Ga’aly (Appl Math Model 37(3):1545–1552, 2013a) by incorporating measurement errors in the inspection system. The quality characteristic under consideration is normally distributed with two market specification limits. The product satisfies the first specification limit which is sold in a primary market at a regular price, and products failing the first specification limit and satisfying the second one is sold in a secondary market at a reduced price. The product is reworked if it does not satisfy both specification limits. The multi-objective optimization model consists three objective functions, which are to maximize profit, income, and product uniformity using the Taguchi quadratic function as a surrogate for product uniformity. The concept of cutoff points (the decision during inspection is based on these cutoff points rather than specification limits) is used to counter and reduce the impact of inspection errors. An algorithm is proposed to obtain and rank the set of Pareto-optimal points. An illustrative numerical example and an industrial case study are presented to demonstrate the utility of the model. A sensitivity analysis is conducted to study the effect of the error on the optimal process mean and cutoff points.
Article
Full-text available
Organizations want to focus on product quality along with productivity to get their competitive advantage in global market. In order to achieve this aim, quality management system and its different aspects are becoming more valuable than before. This study has considered quality control and its activities with specific focus on offline inspection. The objective of this study is to provide a literature review that identifies different models and methodologies, developed for offline inspection under different manufacturing and inspection conditions. This review is based on research work accepted by international journals and published in the years from 2000 to 2016. These studies are classified into six groups on the basis of their research objectives, model developed, adopted methodologies, and research outcomes. This review paper also gives а brief look at the offline inspection to propose future research opportunities and emerging trends. The proposed research directions can be helpful in developing new models or modifying the existing models to improve the performance of offline inspection.
Article
Full-text available
It is usually assumed that a quality characteristic in an item obeys a normal distribution in the case that the quality of items is evaluated based on the variable property. Then, the concept of Taguchi’s quality loss has been accepted as the evaluation measure of quality instead of the traditional attribute property such as the proportion of nonconforming items. From this viewpoint, some variable sampling plans indexed by the quality loss have been investigated before now. As a study earliest among them, the variable single sampling plan based on operating characteristics (OC) indexed by the quality loss was considered. On the other hand, the attribute repetitive group sampling plan on OC was proposed for reducing the sampling number in the inspection. Recently, the variable repetitive group sampling (VRGS) plan on OC indexed by the quality loss has been considered. By the way, the rectifying inspection is known as one of the schemes of acceptance sampling inspection. Then, Dodge-Romig single sampling plans are known as the traditional rectifying inspection based on attribute sampling plans. Dodge-Romig rectifying attribute sampling plans provide the lot tolerance percent defective (LTPD) scheme on each lot and the average outgoing quality limit (AOQL) scheme for many lots. Furthermore, the rectifying variable single sampling (RVSS) plan indexed by the quality loss was investigated. In conformity with the traditional rectifying attribute sampling plans for the LTPD and AOQL schemes, the acceptance quality loss limit (AQLL) and specified permissible average outgoing surplus quality loss limit (PAOSQLL) schemes are respectively proposed in the RVSS plans indexed by the quality loss. In this article, we suppose that the quality characteristic in an item obeys a normal distribution. Under this condition, the rectifying variable repetitive group sampling (RVRGS) plan for AQLL is considered for the purpose of reducing the average total inspection (ATI). Specifically, the design procedure for finding out the required sample size and inspection criteria for satisfying the constraint of the quality assurance is derived. Lastly, it is shown that ATI of the RVRGS plan is reduced in comparison with that of the RVSS plan under the same condition.
Article
Under the assumptions that inspections in CSP-1 are not perfect and each defective shipped to the buyer will be fined a return cost, this paper investigates a joint policy between precise inspection and CSP-1 for non-repairable products, where precise inspection is introduced to screen out the defectives for the products behind the procedure of CSP-1. By using the criterion of maximizing the unit net profit, the following five decision variables are determined: (1) the optimal clearance number, (2) the optimal sampling frequency, and (3) the proportions which should be taken precise inspection for the defectives identified by CSP-1, the non-inspected items in the procedure of CSP-1, and the non-defectives identified by CSP-1. Overall, the analytical results indicate that depending on seven parameters (Type I error, Type II error, the selling price of an item, the unit opportunity cost, the unit return cost, the unit cost of precise inspection, and the process defective fraction), two main inspection policies for CSP-1 are "Do not inspect" and "Do 100% inspection." Besides, for the defectives and the non-defectives identified in CSP-1 and the non-inspected items, two main proportions which should be performed precise inspection are: 100% and 0%.
Article
During manufacturing of products, all produced items are considered as perfect in general. This viewpoint of taking all finished products are perfect is not correct always. Defective items may occur during the production process for several reasons. This paper describes a deteriorating production process which randomly shifts to out-of-control state from in-control state. In case of full inspection policy, expected total cost together with inspection cost results higher inventory cost. Therefore, product inspection policy is better to use for reducing inspection costs. During product inspection process, inspectors may choose falsely a defective item as non-defective and vice-versa. Type I and Type II errors are incorporated in this model to make more realistic rather than existing models. This model includes a warranty policy for some fixed time periods. Some numerical examples, sensitivity analysis, and graphical representations are given to illustrate this model.
Article
This study develops a new optimisation framework for process inspection planning of a manufacturing system with multiple quality characteristics, in which the proposed framework is based on a mixed-integer mathematical programming (MILP) model. Due to the stochastic nature of production processes and since their production processes are sensitive to manufacturing variations; a proportion of products do not conform the design specifications. A common source of these variations is maladjustment of each operation that leads to a higher number of scraps. Therefore, uncertainty in maladjustment is taken into account in this study. A twofold decision is made on the subject that which quality characteristic needs what kind of inspection, and the time this inspection should be performed. To cope with the introduced uncertainty, two robust optimisation methods are developed based on Taguchi and Monte Carlo methods. Furthermore, a genetic algorithm is applied to the problem to obtain near-optimal solutions. To validate the proposed model and solution approach, several numerical experiments are done on a real industrial case. Finally, the conclusion is provided.
Article
This work studies the relationship between Yield and Flow Time (FT) in a production system monitored by in-line inspection. It originates in the known semiconductors Yield vs. FT trade-off premise, but can be adapted to other industries. We challenge the common premise, and suggest an alternate analytical model to demonstrate this relationship. The model relies on a simplified production system that represents a repetitive segment in a production line. It illustrates that rising inspection rate increases both Yield and FT while exhibiting a trade-off. However with further growing inspection rate the Yield reaches a maximum and then starts to decline, while FT continues to increase. The Yield decline is explained by longer delay of inspection results which trigger the repair of an out-of-control machine. Clearly, lower Yield performance and higher FT are undesired. Our work defines this relationship with the analytical model and validates it with simulation. The model can be embedded in a decision support tool to pre-determine the inspection policy, while simultaneously considering Yield and FT.