Content uploaded by Leighton Andrews
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Leighton Andrews on Sep 29, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
The walled garden, the lter bubble and the public sphere: can news
speak truth to power without regulaon of the internet intermediaries?
Leighton Andrews
Cardi Business School
WORKING DOCUMENT – not for cing with permission
Abstract
!" # $
% &'(%)
% %"%%*
&%"&+%,& "'
"%" #%%$%&
&-&."&)%
&#/"&*$)
"0%" %%* %
"#%%$1'%
%,& %) &%%)&&*)%"%
&%."#$2%)%&&
" %#%$
'(%&" )
&*0"%%,&)
% "%,&
3& % %)concept %
%%*%%)
"&&.&
&)&%&")
*%&!
%")!& %*
&4%%*)
%*%-
&"&
Keywords:')&)%)%
%)%%)&%"
Introducon
%"%%* & &
&&"&055)& 6%
66)789) -
%&&%.*%%%0
%%%
&$/"%&* &
% 7&!&&*)
&%%%%
%*"&&%
)&)&%)
2"%0%
%%%7&055):&&%%*
%%7*%*)%*4&0
6;68<)=*&%. &
>!%*&%0
&;?)@=
4*) %%"
&>A,%-)&.9&)4%%
-&%)*% 7**
%*& "
"0%%')*
%%%%;)=
& % %)"%%*&%)
";2)=
B%* -** )%
6%66;10)=) %*
&% %;0'-)=)
+%;&)CA="%
&".6%66&*
* )%%."#%$
*%2%)# $
1-4&*;1%%)CD$)
CD)=0
&;8&ED)= /"
&) %&
&/";6)=)&
";A)C2*)= %%
%#$;2%%)F=
6%** )%
&%%#%*$?G
7?8)&H
"0)%%*%&!
"4-%%*
- 7%%%&%
&&")
%%* %*4 %%
')& /%%%*(%%%
Facebook – the new walled garden
7"%%55
%& 2H
:;A;555=
)4I
*2H:)%%
&&%* &
4*'#&%*
&."%$;A%%)=)%%
)0 &%**."
&&*'%6)7&
2'%JKKF%%;)
=
'$%&&&%7
&%*
& "7/"& &
&%)*%%%*%&
&&"%") &"
0L&&D";')=
'&*." !%
"%%;9%"%)=4
%%) )"%%**
&)%)
%%$% &%%%
M%&%%%%
%%)*/"
N)"%%
%%*)%
%& %%;3%%)F=?
%M*)- %&%-
%& &"$ )
;4&)=
'$L:%& ))
&*$&#%%
&&*%%$;O)=
8&" %,&$
%*:%'
&+0%" %"&%,&
# $ %%?89"%%""%
'%)
%0&%%7
&&&%&""&"*
# $;6%%%)=L&&*
" &"&"L%
%.
;7)CA)K=2*%&&")
6%0)%,&)%" "
6%)&&"
%;3*/L%)=7)%&%%*)
%*'"%)%#&"-
"" %&&"$;B&)@=
3)/" %* '
%%%*0 ""> &&%&"
")%*%;8%&%)=)
-&)&%.;9%%)
C4%)=7%,& "
&&%)'$
*&%%%
;'8*)=4
" %*%%%%" &
"*;3%)C2)C4&%)
CL%%)C3%)=4 %
?G &"*?G7 &"
L&&;1)=4% %&
&%* M -&%)
'% K0%"&;4 )
F=
'%%0
." &&*%%
2%*)L:-"
&*;())C7&='&
%*&)(%)&%*
%&%";)C2)=
Filter bubbles, echo chambers and fake news – a distracon?
8?G &?&&?89"%
%"% -#
$P&; " )6%)
=6%&
* %&&
%" %)
%&%&%%*.#%%$
-&;9)C4 )=)
%%)#&$
;8)=)% &")
"%) "4%%
))6%%8<%%
"%%?8%
'A';68<)=
'$A' %&
*>&"&)%&%*
&%*$ ;2)='$
%0 )%&&%%%)
%*;B)C9))IA)F=
')% %
&%%*;B)=>
&'A') "
%)&*;3)=;'%*
&=
7%*')"%%*
&) %" 'A)
/) )
%&&")%* 'A
"%,&;1%%)CG.)CA
%)C4&)=7)& &
' &&%;8%&)
=
#-*$&&%&
%*;A%)555CA%G)@C3%
%)F=G%%;=# $/
& %"
&2%* &&&
%% )"%%*
' )&")")
-&%)'% &"C
%$0-"%"%% )
%"%%& &
&% )%&
& ;3&%)C%%/%)
=B*'%A%;=
#%& &Q$7)
B$%&*&
- ;A%)=;=
&*%'#
"&$
%%*#$"/&%":
?8%")"%&%%
%"*";9/)=
4 P")
I%;=#P "
&$B;D/%)=
&%&)#
)&%%-)
*$7)%
)* 3 L&&L%)2
88%L&&/;L&%%)C)=)&*
&%&>
')&% )
%)H%%%*$
)-;)=
The public sphere ideal and its persistence.
D&*%&)
&" & )
"* 1%
&&"0&)%&
%" &)!&%%*
#$'&%
)%"&%*%""
7& &"%
3&$;5= %%
&&" &"
"&&;(&)5R@=
8%;=*>
%*%%*&"
- "%+&)")%)
%.)%)%%"&
&&/ %
6%-%*". &%";L%)55C
8%)555CG%RC)@=
#%$%)&)
%% %";(&)55C
L%%55@C2R=7)-%%*
&%&;)55F=%$
%*&%;11L)55F>) =
7);=%*3&
%* ?G"%):'L:2
*%.%% #%$
;*)=G%;R=#%
"%"- %*
$B&;@= &%
#%%%,& %"%0&$)
# *" &%%"%""S
%&" $
8&"&)#&"%&%$
;8)=7&*%
# &"&*$;2)=%')&"
% %"%%*%*0
- %%)&%%
M%&&&%
'
Regulang internet intermediaries: the academic debate
2%%;F=& &&"%*
&%"%L
&-&%;4&)C
(%%)C9!%)F=)&%;1%%)CI)=
%*;L&&TLU)FC
3 )= %%*
H?89"%%" 9%%*)
-& &"""0%*
;B4%)@CL*%)=)&%%&
*;3%%)K)FC2)C4&
)=)%&%*;D%)K)FC
(%%)KC4 )F=)&""
;:LD)C4=
D* )&&&.>
4&" %)"%%*&%)"*
'(%)&
&")"%%*)
4% * "&&
"";')
=
7P* )&
%&"
4% & %*1
D%"" 0&
'(%
4V%* &)
0!%*
&
4%*&%%
*&") &""
4%*%&
&
L0%,& &
4%*% %)
-&%
4 ".)")&
&&&*
&%%%/"%"
4V%* & -"
4* &&
4/%0%
*&)"%%*&&
&
%&*)
&% %$
4& &%*%"%%*
;(%%)=
2*&&&""&"&
%%*&%-4%V%* "%
&""%*)&")
#.$)&"%%**
/";:LD)=L*%;=*
#& %H&"""&
!"$)%"%"0%
%%# &$%,&
&8&!* &""% %
" *%*!"*'(%%
%%"&)%%
&"";4&)C4%)=
L&"""" %*&%-%0
&;')=A& &"%
& &%%*;4&)F=1'
;=2%%;F=&&%*
"%&""%*%* %%
&&"%*%G;=
"%"0%)%?8-)
%*%"*4
%% * )%
;L*%)=) %&";4&)C
9!%)FCD%)K)FC(%%)K=
8%.;=&)V"
%*"0"4&;=
% &"%**
%%*"# %%%*
*%* &$4*
&potenal to
in)uence
W%&%"%-
P
4%%&& *%)
,%%*>)%*&
%%*&%% &"&
%)%*
(%)*)';3 )=C)
"% %*"&*&%*%*
%" %&"%& &%
*)&"&C) -"
%*%*)&""%*)
&"&%
&&"&%)%&
&&0%&C ) %
&:'L:2 -"B
#$ %*&
%*;B)K=
The dynamics of the regulatory debate in 2017
4 &"&%'(%
%%)%*L&&;L
=1 %*"
6%"%"%%%
#%*$;G)5RK=)*%*
*A%) &%!"
&"&?G*7%%%*
%%>
-4"*"
-2&$"
-9%"% &*%"
-(
4"*%" &"
&4*L 1:V
9(&%<*7""
1%#* %$
;A)=4 3 L&&8%L&&/
L%28)D&L%%29)%
%"*)%%*
-&% "
:- 2L";L&%%)=
'"% %%"
&)%+&%%#%*"$*
'&.;7&)=D%" )
*)"&J%%)&"&
;)=
2&*%"'
&"&7**;9)
=&%-* &&$%"
'B"*
&%
&;9)C1%%%)=B*A%
(;=%&."
%%* '"%
1%%%;=)*';=)8%I%%*
#0+%&$7 &%&+&
%*?G)%%&#$
$*%
%**'$&3)
&&"
9(./&%%#%*$
;9 )=7?G)A2"%%
L&""2* %"
&?G '(%
;8)CA2)=4Guardian;I)=The Times
;="%%*& %*
")&;(2()C
4&)=1&
"%% %**
&7?8) -" AN
4&# %"&+$
;2*)=)A2%% %
"0-&"%%"
"%%"%*%*"0
;8%)=) "&
'(%"%;'%)C')
C3/)C2)CA)CB)=
7& %" &"&)
%"%%*%&
%-&))
&%"*%*)&V
&%4&?G"%
;L"9*)=*(%%
;B*)=:%&
% %*&%%%&%;L%%)=4
&% &"&
&&"&)%%%
%" &&"%"?G)0
L&&%"?5555R&&"
%%"?8"%%* &"
&%"%*D)" %%
)%&%&"
&N %%- &%%-
-&4#&"$%*
&&""%&%%
"N)*(%)"%;D
%)C2)C2%)C8%)C4)
=8&")I )
*%%";9&)='$
%%%)%%)
%*%.%*""
-%Sunday Times;1)=
(;6)K=%%*
%& "&*
&%&%
:*)& *
%:'L:2&* &
+"%" &&
%%* !&7%)
:'L:2$ -"%:'L:2%
%4/)'(%;A&)=1*'*
:'L:212&%&"
'(%&%"#$
%%%H%"%*&%%
&)&/ &&
;)=:- 2L"))
:'L:2$ -" &
%* %%&&)%
%*";)=(%%
!%%4L&""
2*)"8*
7 &"L&&%%"7)
7 &"L&&%%*
'6;D&)=>
7&$%*)
$ *!&*&&$
7$
&"'%
&")7$6%
& &"7%%%
% &")+
@*
4*! '"
%" &&%" %%
L&&7%%*%% 0%
"&%)%*&
%"%";4&%)=)%&
&"*' &&
-";)=
B"*&"""
?&""%"0%
?8M?(%D9"
B%";8/)F=%*.&
%% &?8
%"4 "0
"*?8;D&)=)%
(%$%%A&'"$:
2&&;L".2%*)C4)
=4%%&;A)=
%%"&+*3)%
%*&?8)%*")
&";B&&)C8)=
Regulang Facebook as a media company?
L%*"
'&&*;) -&%)B+)C9)
='$ %*)%>
' %,&7$"%
%*&*7$"%&&*
;L")=
7)O "&'#%
"%*$;B)5=& )
#% $;O)=%4
'&&&
&* " &&*1%
O'%"%*
& % ?"%")H%%)%
;*)=M"% ;99)=
7)%% &
*% *) &%)
-&)
%";3 L&&)=
8&%#%&%$
;2.)F=)'#%%**%
&*"?G%%*
#"% %*$$)&%%%
&%*3)*) &
& "L%*)2%%
;F=)*%&&
4*%')
&(%)&
&&"%%")';=%%#
& *$ %* &)
%#$ %'$%)
*& &%)%-
%" 0&
")"&&&&)
&&&) "
& &*"*
3)%%
%%"% &) -&%)
2B &L%";=) %*"
%&)%""
%)"%*
74I&%*L%'8KL
554"%" A&
"* %%-&%;2)
=
Conclusion
4#%*$ "
&*4!"
&*)%
".) %
&&"%"&&" 4
&%* 4*
%%% 0%*""%
)*)&%)-&"
:"&&"%" &%
H4%%*&&
References
Journal of Economic Perspectives !" #
$%&'$(House of Commons Culture,
Media and Sport Committee Inquiry into Fake News,
http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidenc
edocument/culture-media-and-sport-committee/fake-news/written/
48139.pdf
Andrews L (2017b) Four ideas to tackle Fake News, Nesta blog, 7 July
http://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/four-ideas-tackle-fake-news
$%&)*+,-)$-$!../
0$)1$,$,"2$200$3Paper
presented at the Nordic Political Science Association’s (NoPSA) XVIII Political
Science Congress450*#
)&6)$20!0$72$
20$Political Communication
.5&Post-truth: how bullshit conquered the world%!.7
../889Extending Choice in Europe../
.&7:($-$-*$;0($
)$<9*
)!==#,#$-=7-=-+$-=)#2,=27++($-+
$-*+$+;0+($++)$
.7-$
)!==#>$#$-=*=27??,#))&$
.46.$@0/A,&The Platform Press:
how Silicon Valley re-engineered journalism, 6/$2$B-50$,
/0,750$,)$#
.$$+%6&6-7)7<$0$$#$:
*CObserver$
.A&<;0$*0$--21D($$0-
,Guardian&*
.*B70*E0-$-0
)!==#)$#$-=0-=$(==9=9=27+++
0*+0+-+$-0#,9*
7*B$$@07!22$
B*,<,)@)$FA Networked SelfA0-#
/$/&6$.$.$GA77$*Observer&*
/0/88/#/0#Habermas and the public sphere/,7$-!
6<6@$#
/,)7%&,220Television)$
/-)*&-:7(
)!==-,)*#$-=
/A88 @07$(($0,$*$!$2
$$*77$-)*1DScreen H
/B&)7*B,/@4G2$/(
7*0$I$#
/$((@$*&The Conservative Party Manifesto
)!==#$((#,=,2
/5F0$7$-,)7,,)*>0J
$,,)*K6$0B,7$
)!==$0#,====27=
/*BB-,$)0,)0$#Financial
Times8$#(7!
)!==7-#2#,=+G-== =8=-+,$+)+
-+2$+,)+0$=850&#
/*B7-,2)2$,!)*$$-#
6002,'$-@)$#(7!
)!==7$0-#$-=)+=0)===)2$,?*#)2
850&#
B:&Post-truth: the new war on truth and how to fight back,
%!70$*@$
B(& Post-truth: why we have reached peak bullshit and what to do
about it%!%.$#
B,$&A Better Deal6B,$@$*
)!==#,$$#-(=)+=0)=&=&=+.$+
B++/,)++/#)2
B,<2$,/,,$0)'))=7
(-</47-&(,7$
)!==7-#$-#0===&=2$,+,,$+0)+
+))+27+(-=
B)$,2$/00$889$@)$
.$-$#
B)0#H-$,07*A)$-!
(-2..G/0,750$,#
B)0#9#-$,07*#Digital Journalism !
8I+H9#
B0B&.)0-$($(
Sunday Times8$
Dutton, WH. Reisdorf, BC, Dubois E & Blank, G (2017) Search and Politics: The
Uses and Impacts of Search in Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Spain, and the
United States Quello Center Working Paper No. 5-1-17. Available at SSRN:
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2960697
,'L)$36,G)
)!==#,#,=7-=,+G)===,+
G)+(,7$
$*1D-2$+I!$-700(
-$#A)$(,7$#(7!
)!==#$*#,==)07=0+-++2$+
+I+$-+0(+-$50&#
0$)/,,9!/,,02$,/,,
0$)@$,/060$),
/,,/,,2A-B--$$-*2$
0$)0$)/,,/4982#.$0#
0$)/,,&L$-$!/,,27M
,2$)$(-,-2$,70'))($#
(7!)!==0$)#0=$)=)$+$?<@+&+ 8?#,
I50&#
0$)/,,&7$0!/,,2-M#H7
2$70-,$-7*-(--(-
,)$))-$(#(7!)!==0$)#0=$)=)$+
$?<@+&+&IH?#,I50&#
70$*&<,)$(,)$--$*2(*
7
)!==#27#,==27+0$*=,)$(,++
)$-++-$*+2+(*++27=9H 98&=
)$
$AAD$0$-*2$-,3$+
*2$+)2$,02$-,
0)Journal of Communication&
$&'N*($>0$,The Atlantic
),7$)!==##,=,-=$(=&=8=+
+(*++($+>0$,=9 H89=
$A@0$*B-'$A0$<02$0*
250$,#50*#
$&',,$30$):0)2$2-The Times
50*
$,8I Public Service versus the market$9
$,886,)07)$/#/0#Habermas
and the public sphere/,7$-!6<6@$#
77$F0$7$-))$2*,7,
,)*Guardian B,7$
)66)2)2$,New Media and Society
)6#H!L6$(2-$,:Media Technologies: Essays on
Communication, Materiality, and Society6$)@75#
.D$##/,7$-!<6@$#
0$$0)&Written evidence submitted by Guardian
News & Media (FNW0096), House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport
Committee Inquiry into Fake News.
http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidenc
edocument/culture-media-and-sport-committee/fake-news/written/
48259.html
7$,58The structural transformation of the public sphere: an inquiry
into a category of bourgeois society..@$#
)$&07O$A(2.I
50I
,)D$-)7,-72$6$0,):
The Hill. (,7$#(7!)!==#,=7-=)0+
7-=)$+,)-= &H I+)+7,-+27+2$+$0,)+
+ H50*&#
7$-$D+(DP-PD($AH/($-
2$,$,$,)0$,+,))--
,0+;0#Institute for Information Law (IViR).
(7!
)!==#($#=)07==<2$,?$,$??,
?)0$,#)2950*&#
7$-$D+(DP-PD($A9A-0-
2$,$,$-)$22$,($*<nfo&
!9+&#
$7Q722-# Guardian9
(,7$)!==#-0$#,=-*==(=9=27+
2++2-+,$+0$7$-H50*&#
$@&6$(07-Prospec*
*0//022B602'-0-7
Information, Communication and Society
02/,,&,22$/,,!$,!70
G$,,HA)$2+&9)$/8
02%$0$)1/,,!4@2$,
B--$A)$29+#)$%@)$8
0'&$2*$-$0)(0)$,*2
7-3Observer,$#
<-$,$:*7:$)$-,,$Fortune8
B,7$
<-$,7$F0$7$-*,7<
/,)*Fortune B,7$
<2@6@07)$$@07$(
Information, Communication and SocietyH9
D%&,:$0@$GYale Law Journal#
D$70)7:2#
Buzzfeed#(7!)!==#702#,=G$=+
+7+0)++27+230,?$,R#;%*$S#B7NG4
H50*&#
D$A+5D'7B>$.&,7$
$$2$*,7European Journal of
Communication
D$)D(5I7$,022@
/,,0Javnost – The Public9
D-5'8IH= Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies%!
%-,
%$5&O0$)$0London Review of Books&0-0
%+G&6-*,$(:,,$Guardian
)$
%-'-$DH-!-
-($$,$()The Governance Report
2014$2($4G2$!41@#
%0@%(- 0:2)2
)07)$!$$2,$--7Media, Culture and
Society 9
Lunt P and Livingstone S (2012) Media Regulation,
A96@07:<$<$,$ Info&
$)A&N*:)07,*0,7$WIRED)$
A2$,/0))$)$($((*-
-# (,7$#(7!
)!==#,$2$,#$-#0=7-=0))$+++)$($+(+(*+
-+-950*&#
$&<$6$&"//2$Kleiner Perkins&
*)!==#)7#,=$+$I50*&#
IB,-0)07)$!2$)07
$(,Media, Culture and Society
&0$-,($*)0$*$*%
@*@$>.-
)!==7-###0=,)*)$>=&=H==0$-+,+
($*++)0$*++$*=
$6-()$$2$0*2,#
/,,0@$D-:/-%#(7!
)!==###0=))=)*+0=,)=+-++(+
)$#)2950*&#
$77/$((A$4)
1D@T0$$*I& 50*
$(9$UNew Left Review57
$$*.&6O$6,/42-($-!
L-,$>:Digiday, 850#(7!
)!==-*#,=,=+*$+,+++-+($-+
-,$+>=950*&#
$.0-7$22$*0#8507#
(7!)!==$,#27#,====70-++7$++
2+2$+*0=
H50*&#
$0&($--$)-$,($G$,(
The Times I$#
0$-'$$.BO007$(00$$2$))$
-G$,(Financial Times&$
)@888B$0-B($*@$)Journal of
Communication H8H
)@D$)D 6$-($*$-($
$*I
H6;02>72$,!2,$0$
*27@-**$,Proceedings of the fourth
international conference on communication and media studies/$2A$
/,,02$@$$$1($*@$&
0-5&6,*0$Observer,8$
0-5&7'*,$2$:7-7*
Observer ),7$
225&@6B-/1)%*BA02$-
6@#Advertising Age#850$*#(7!
)!==-#,=$=,=)+-++)$$++-+-$+0)++
$0= &&H=I50&#
&6)$
)!==##$-#0=&+)$=)$50$*
,42,0-($*Television47$
5$,B-7,
#(7!)!==#>#,=$=--+)0++7+
($+2++++7+H&898I&H50*&#
AD&'$))-$30, *
)!==,0,#,=G2$+0($*=$++))+-+$++
II9
AD$&B--$,$!0*
2$7)07$)2$,New Media and Society&#
AD/$D-$)0Challenges and Opoortunities
for news media and journalism in an increasingly digital, mobile, and social media
environment/020$)=A0$<02$0*250$,#
&'$(House of Commons Culture, Media and
Sport Committee Inquiry into Fake News
http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidenc
edocument/culture-media-and-sport-committee/fake-news/written/
48244.pdf
(.888L6--070-(3.$--
0$)/A-02$,-:/$$
2N$0Convergence in European Digital TV Regulation.
4/BEBig Data – bringing competition policy to the digital era
.-$07*$$8+ (,7$#
@-,A&N2)0($2$,2The Times&
50
@$$The Filter Bubble, %!N-#
@;09The Black Box Society#/,7$-!$($1($*
@$#
@67+A)0!:,)
<),7$
@)/D7$.&7)07$0$2,-$The Times
90-0
Patterson, TE. (2016), News Coverage of the 2016 General Election: How the Press
Failed the Voters (December 1, 2016). HKS Working Paper No. RWP16-052.
Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2884837 or
http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2884837
@A$/$0$,)2$,#
A)$*#(7!)!==#>0$,#$-==9==+
0+$++,+)2$,+850&#
@A$/$& ))$:$0$(0,7*
(($-
/>WWW 0WWWW%"000
%%0 00*WHX0F0FXX@W *
@5+/%-/$@(-/<2$$00$0
,)2$,0-2-7New Media and Society
+I
@2$B&@$0LB0)*:,)-)-
7$*->0$,Press Gazette )$#(7!
)!==#)$-##0=)$+-+0+0)*+,)-++
)+--++27+$*-+>0$,=H50*&#
@5&61$-770,$2:)$
0--Guardian*
@0$(&,2$-Television*&#
A>7!$,,)*+$739
B,7$)!==#77##0==$,+$+ I H8
A,06 <$+7,0$)))07
)$Media, Culture and Society, 9
A*$&*0))$2&-,:$G$,,
Daily Telegraph&*
A-86(027:,,47$($#,
)!==7$($#,=8=&=+(0+2+27+,+,=
50*
A0$<02$0*250$,B-A)$#
(7!)!==$0$0#)#G##0=)07=-++
$)$+H50*&#
A$H02%$/,,/,,04+22
(A$0--2G0(24/4#
)!==#)$,#0=0,=$+,,=,,0=
?A$?IH=0/,,(IH42,A$#)2 I(,7$
AV&6,)$20,.$0New Statesman H+50*
A5+/6$5 @2$,/,)+,$
50$20$),))88+8
A,,6&/-$>0($)*//$0)$*0$
$)$(*RecodeI$#
-$@888/--)2@/,,0!2
0$)1@/,,0
-$@&/,)6,)European Journal of
CommunicationH
90$)))$(60-B@$A0New York
Times9B,7$
$&Calls to investigate Google and Facebook’s role in fake news
digital advertising, https://inews.co.uk/essentials/calls-investigate-google-facebooks-
role-fake-news-digital-advertising/
),6B0&.$(-L-0-:-Sunday Times
$#
($,/6*N$$
40)$2$,A47(,7$
)!==#702#,=$-($,=($+2+++
0)$2$,+$+++2730,?$,R#-78N&FS#>)9V@(8H
($,/%*(*5N%6-$+N5&<)$2-
2$*0$2
)!==#702#,=$-($,=++)$+2-+2$+*0$+
+230,?$,R#*9 '.AS#0A,I0-0
$&//(($0$0$*USA TodayI*
4&-Q7!O0607,($-$
$1#Observer9$#
-%&))$77*2$$0G,)7-
7-#(7!
)!==#7>0$#,=>==&=&==))$+77*+
$0+27+27+--+--#,H50*&#
$<&-!-(Sunday Times 50*
0/&#republic@$!@$1($*@$
)$/6-7)07)$A/
HThe Television Studies Reader%!A0-
6,7B&($-202%@*@$>
.-#(7!)!==7-###0=,)*)$>=&==H=+
($-+20+2+=H50*&#
6,7B%7B-$,$1D!,)2$
)0$*.infoIH#
6,7B%7,$&6),)--
%@*@$>@*.$28#
6)5&Move fast and break things%!%.$
60F&-,-2$$,>0$,#<:
,),Washington Post 0-0
66,&$$)!==#,##0=)+
G+*=&+ +=,,=$+,+,-$2 $
6,).&2)Stratechery Blog#(7!
)!==$$*#,=&=,2++,)= H50*
&#
6,A&B-B0)*Wall Street JournalH
)$
)!==#>#,=$=2++++-+0)*+
H8 9
60&B-,-+6$0G--Wired, H50#
(7!)!==#$#,=&==$0+-+*+7-+
+,)*+=950*&#
48*2E(<;=L%%"(%
-4E8/2;='B11L9%:
7""7L%8-7&)New York Times,
/>WW*"&&WW@W5WW&W0 0%0-0
%&%52
602F9L-$,$,7*7-!,$-
-2,)0-*:#Colorado Technology Law Journal #
602F#$-,0,,$,$,)$#6
6#A$(2$,
)!==##,==*)?02?,?-?,?0,
?,$?,$?,)$
602F77:-$,0))$/B($*
*2A0O0$W/#(7!
)!==#--##0=$3;R602XFXXX7
YYIY88X-$,X0))$X/XB($*$R//.?+
..&.&;R602XFXXX7
YYIY88X-$,X0))$X/XB($*;R$,##89&#
I >>&0$R$,R16+I
17$B -2,!0,2$,$
2-IndependentH50$*
N97/0.--6$226)
@07$/>WW%%*WWRFFW 0"000%00
0V000%WKD&
N$-/50%,&6-+-)$22!
7-*2,)2$,HNew Media
and Society
N$D-*$0)$0Guardian
)!==#-0$#,=,==>0==+-*+$0)+
+$050*
'$50$AOL’s ‘Walled Garden’, H),7$
https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB968104011203980910
'$50$&.0A#(7!
)!==-$)#>#,=70+2+$+2=I50&#
'$/&!<:,)#(7!
)!==2$$2#,=2++,)= H50*&
'A-B$,%6A(27$$
@$)(@*-&
'06The Attention Merchants#2$#D)2#
F0$7$-&.0-7/,,0*
)!==#27#,==,$+0$7$-=70-+-7+
,,0*=9H9HH8I H7$0$*